Mineral Deposit of Sulawesi_Theo M. Van Leeuwen and Peter E. Pieters

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 7/22/2019 Mineral Deposit of Sulawesi_Theo M. Van Leeuwen and Peter E. Pieters

    1/130

    PROCEEDINGSOFTHESULAWESIMINERALRESOURCES2011SEMINARMGEIIAGI

    2829November2011,Manado,NorthSulawesi,Indonesia

    1

    MineralDepositsofSulawesi

    TheoM.vanLeeuwenandPeterE.Pieters

    ABSTRACT

    Sulawesi can be divided into three geologicalmetallogenic provinces: 1) Northern Sulawesi, which consists of

    series of Late Cenozoic calcalkaline magmatic arcs built on a basement of Early Cenozoic tholeiitic basaltic

    volcanicsunderlainbyoceaniccrust;itcontainsnumerousmineraldepositsandoccurrencesofpredominantlyLate

    MiocenePlioceneage, includingporphyryCuAuMo,high, intermediate,and lowsulphidationepithermalAu

    Ag, sedimenthosted Au, intrusionrelated base metalAu, skarn, and VMS styles of mineralization; 2) Western

    Sulawesi,composedofLateCenozoichighKcalcalkalinetoultrapotassicigneoussuitesoverlyingaseriesofEarly

    Cenozoic sedimentary rocks and subordinate calcalkaline volcanics deposited on a basement of metamorphic

    complexes and Late Cretaceous flysch deposits; mineralization styles include porphyry Mo, porphyry CuAu,

    intrusionrelated(?)Au,intrusionrelatedbasemetalAu,andVMS;and3)EasternSulawesi,comprisingawestern

    metamorphicbeltandeasternophiolitebelt,whichare interthrustedwithMesozoicEarlyCenozoicsedimentary

    rocks and unconformably overlain by Late Cenozoic postorogenic sequences; weathering of the ophiolite has

    givenrisetoanumberofNiandFelateritedeposits,andchromitebeachsands;goldmineralizationofuncertain

    originislocallyhostedbymetamorphicandpostorogenicsedimentaryrocks.

    MineralexplorationandminingactivitieshavebeenundertakeninSulawesisincetheturnofthe19thcentury,but

    byworldstandardslargepartsoftheregionremainunderexplored.Todateonlytwocommoditieshavebeenmined

    onasignificantscale,viz.goldwithatotalproductionofabout90t(excludingartisanalmining),andnickeltotaling

    about4.8Mt. Golddepositsfoundtodateareofsmalltomodestsize(

  • 7/22/2019 Mineral Deposit of Sulawesi_Theo M. Van Leeuwen and Peter E. Pieters

    2/130

    2

    Table1.MaingeologicalandmetalogeniccharacteristicsofNorthern,WesternandEasternSulawesi

    NORTHERNSULAWESI WESTERNSULAWESI EASTERNSULAWESI

    Tectonicsetting IslandArc Continentalmargin Suture

    Basement Oceanic(backarc)crust Continental fragments;

    accretionary

    rocks/mlange; overlain

    byLateCretaceousflysch

    deposits.

    Continental fragments;

    accretionary

    rocks/mlange;

    ophiolites; Mesozoic

    Paleogene sedimentary

    terranes.

    Paleogene

    magmatism

    LowK tholeiitic, bimodal

    (basalticfelsic);

    submarine; intense,

    widespread.

    Calcalkaline:

    intermittent and

    localized.

    Neogenemagmatism MediumK calcalkaline,

    predominantly andesitic;

    also bimodal during

    latest PliocenePleistocene.

    Voluminous highK calc

    alkaline (mostly

    granitoids); and

    shoshonitic to ultrapotassic.

    Minor,localized.

    Paleogene

    sedimentation

    Minor;deepsea. Synrift siliciclastics

    overlain by platform and

    deeper marine

    carbonates; pelitic

    sedimentsinthenorth.

    Neogene

    sedimentation

    Siliciclastics in isolated

    basins, including Plio

    Pleistocene Celebes

    Molasse.

    Marine sediments and

    volcaniclastics; Plio

    Pleistocene Celebes

    Molasse.

    Widespread deposition

    ofCelebesMolasse.

    Main mineralization

    types

    Porphyry CuAu; high,

    intermediate, and low

    sulphidationepithermal

    AuAg; sedimenthosted

    Au.

    PorphyryMo; intrusion

    relatedAu.

    LateriticNi&Fe.

    Otherstyles VMS; intrusionrelated

    base metal Au;

    FeAuskarn alluvial Au;

    Febeachsands.

    VMS; intrusionrelated

    base metal Au;

    FeAuskarn; Mn

    ironstones.

    Primary and secondary

    chromite; alluvial Au;

    epithermalAu,Sb.

  • 7/22/2019 Mineral Deposit of Sulawesi_Theo M. Van Leeuwen and Peter E. Pieters

    3/130

    3

    Figure1.RegionaltectonicsettingofSulawesi(afterWilsonandMoss,1999)

    Figure2.DigitalterrainmodelSulawesi

  • 7/22/2019 Mineral Deposit of Sulawesi_Theo M. Van Leeuwen and Peter E. Pieters

    4/130

    4

    areaof172,000km2. It is themostmountainous

    of the larger islands within the Indonesian

    archipelago. Withtheexceptionofsomenarrow

    stretches of coastal lowland and intermontane

    plains, the terrain consists entirely of mountain

    rangeswith thehighestpeaksbeing inexcessof

    3000m (Figure 2). Unlike the other larger

    islands/island groups in Indonesia, which are

    partlyborderedbyextensiveshallowshelfareas,

    the seabottomoff theSulawesi coastsdrops in

    mostplacesrapidlybelow100m,andthe1000m

    bathymetriclineislocatedatadistanceofonlya

    few10sofkilometersorlessfromthecoast.

    TheislandhasapeculiarKshape,consistingof

    four peninsular known as Arms, which are

    separated by deep gulfs and united in central

    Sulawesi(Figure3A). ThenarrownorthtrendingpartoftheNorthArm,iscommonlyreferredtoas

    theNeck.

    The Sulawesi region can be divided into four

    distinct geological and metallogenic provinces,

    namedhere (modifiedafterSukamto,1978),the

    Northern, Western and Eastern Sulawesi

    ProvincesandBanggaiSulaProvince (Figure3B).

    As the latter province does not contain any

    significantknownmineralization, ithasnotbeen

    included

    in

    this

    review.

    The

    main

    geological

    and

    metallogenic features of the other three

    provincesareshowninTable1.

    Thepresentpaperconsistsoffourparts. Thefirst

    partdescribes thehistoryofmineralexploration

    and mining in Sulawesi. It is followed by an

    overviewoftheregionalgeology. Themainpart

    of thepaper comprisesadetailed reviewof the

    various mineral deposit types found in each of

    the three provinces together with some

    additional exploration history data. In the last

    section we discuss how the various deposit

    typesaredistributedinspaceandtime,whenand

    howtheywerediscovered,andhowtheyfeature

    in Sulawesis mining industry. It also briefly

    addressespastandpresentexplorationtrends.

    Anumberofsourcesofinformationareavailable

    for the history of exploration and mining in

    Sulawesi,andtheregionsmineralresources. For

    the Dutch colonial era these include the

    Jaarboek van het Mijnwezen (Mining

    Yearbook), ter Braake (1944), van der Ploeg

    (1944), and van Bemmelens (1949) Economic

    Geology of Indonesia. A publication by the

    Indonesian Mining Association and Mining and

    Metal Agency of Japan (IMAMMAJ, 1995), the

    anually published Register of Indonesian

    Gold/RegistrerofIndoPacificMining,andvarious

    trade journals record mineral exploration

    activities post1967. Several review papers on

    thecopperandgoldmineralizationofNorthern(+

    Western) Sulawesi have been published (Carlile

    et al., 1990; Kavalieris et al., 1992; Soeria

    Atmadja et al, 1999; Pearson and Caira, 1999).

    Paperson individualdepositsandprospects can

    be found in various proceedings and journals.

    Mostoftheseareincludedinthereferencelistof

    thepresentpaper. MoredetailedinformationiscontainedinCOWcompanyreports,whicharean

    open file in the library of Pusat Sumber Daya

    Geologi (PSDG). Unfortunately a number of

    reports are missing,often the more informative

    ones, and the quality of the reports is rather

    variable (some discuss at great length weather

    conditions, topography, etc but give little

    geological information). Websites of foreign

    junior companies are another source of

    information, although they tend to focus on

    trench

    and

    drill

    results.

    Recently Pusat Sumber Daya Geologil published

    two geochemical atlases covering the northern

    and southern halfs of Sulawesi, which include

    mapsforthefollowingelements: As,Co,Cr,Cu,

    Fe,K,Li,Mn,Ni,PbandZn (PSDG,2008). They

    also compiled a mineral resources atlas for

    Sulawesi as part of a series of atlases for the

    entire country (PSDG, 2010). It comprises a

    series of maps for each Kabupaten

    (administrative district), including geology and

    minerallocationsmaps,andalistofmetallicand

    nonmetallicmineralresources(nameofdeposit,

    coordinatesand resource figure). Nogeological

    information or references are given, limiting

    somewhat its usefulness for mineral

    explorationists.

    Forthisreviewwehavemadeextensiveuseofa

    GIS databasecalledIndonesianMineral Deposit

    Database(IMDD),thatwehavebeencompiling

  • 7/22/2019 Mineral Deposit of Sulawesi_Theo M. Van Leeuwen and Peter E. Pieters

    5/130

    5

    Figure3.Sulawesi. (A)Geographicdivision;(B)Geologicalmetallogenicprovinces

    Figure 4. Simplified geological map of Sulawesi (modified after

    Sukamto,1975b;Hamilton,1979;Silveretal.,1983;Parkinson,1991)

  • 7/22/2019 Mineral Deposit of Sulawesi_Theo M. Van Leeuwen and Peter E. Pieters

    6/130

    6

    Table2.HighlightshistoryofmineralexplorationandmininginSulawesi

    Year Results

    18961908 SmallquantitiesofAuproducedatSumalata.

    18961929 Palelehmine; 6.2tAu,5tAg,550tPb.

    1900 G.Panidiscovered.

    19001921 Totokmine;3.7tAu.

    1911 AbendanonrecognizesNiFelateritepotentialofESulawesi.

    19131931 ThreeminesinBolaangMongondowdistrict;5tAu,4tAg.

    19161919 SeveralNiandFelateritedepositsfound,includingPomalaaandSoroako.

    1938 NilateriteminingstartsatPomalaa.

    1968 Large2ndgenerationCOWareaawardedtoPTInco.

    1969 SasakporphyryCuAuprospectidentified.

    1970 SecondgenerationCOWawardedtoEndeavourResources;BahodopiNilaterite

    depositdiscovered.

    19721973 TapadaaandTombulilatoporphyryCudistrictsidentified.

    19741975 Discovery of the Cabang Kiri, Cabang Kanan and Kayubulan Ridge porphyry

    prospects.

    1976 Commercial ferronickel production starts at Pomalaa; Malala porphyry Mo

    discovered.

    1977 3rdgenerationcontractsignedbyRioTinto.

    1978 CommencementofnickelmatteproductionatSoroako.

    19801982 Drill testing of Cabang Kiri, Cabang Kanan, Kayubulan Ridge and Sungai Mak;

    [email protected]%Cu,0.47g/tAu.

    19831984 Motombotohighsulphidationsystemdrilled.

    19861987 Twentytwo4th

    generationCOWssigned.

    1987 Severaldiscoveriesmade, includingBulagidun(porphyryCuAu),Binabase(HS),

    andTototopo,Anggrek,Tanoyan(IS).

    1988 MiningofchromitebeachsandscommencesinESulawesi

    1989 MeselandAwakMasdiscovered.

    1994 TokaTindungandPoboya discovered.

    19941997 115th7

    thgenerationCOWssigned.

    1998 RiskaandMasabofound

    1999 Palopodistrictdiscovered.

    2004 MiningstartsatRiska;annualproductionca50.000ozAu.

    2008 GoldrushatBombanainvolving>20,000localminers.

    2011 FirstgoldpouredatTokaTindung;annualproductionca160,000ozAueq.

  • 7/22/2019 Mineral Deposit of Sulawesi_Theo M. Van Leeuwen and Peter E. Pieters

    7/130

    7

    since 2005 (van LeeuwenandPieters,2011). It

    contains all available relevant descriptive

    information about deposits and prospects,

    including location details, commodity, deposit

    type, host rock, mineralization, alteration,

    structure, resourcedata,explorationhistoryetc.

    Most of the data in IMDD are derived from

    sources mentioned above and unpublished

    companyreportts.

    Thepresentpaperisaimedprimarilyatgeologists

    engaged in mineral exploration in Sulawesi and

    those who wish to assess its mineral potential.

    The focus is on providing descriptions of the

    more significant mineralizing districts and

    individualdeposits.

    2.0 HistoryofMineralExplorationandMining

    inSulawesi

    The documented history of mineral exploration

    andmining in Sulawesi spans aperiodofabout

    125 years, but traces of iron slag with a Ni

    content of 12% found at an archeological site

    near Lake Montano suggests there was already

    someminingactivity more than1000 yearsago

    (Bulbecks, 2000, in Rafianto, 2011). The

    highlights

    of

    the

    past

    125

    years

    are

    summarized

    in Table 2 and discussed below in some more

    detail.

    Local gold mining activity in Northern Sulawesi

    wasrecordedasearlyas1813andhascontinued

    uptothepresentday,itsintensitydependingon

    the price of gold and economic conditions.

    BritishmapsofSulawesipublished in1885show

    agoldmine intheRatatotokdistrict,namedMt.

    Tottik. Mining there was done by local people

    from the neighbouring province of Bolaang

    Mongondowtoprovidegoldfortheirchief.

    In1848,thegovernmentoftheNetherlandsEast

    Indiesdecidedtoinvestigatethemineralrichesof

    thearchipelago. Itwas thought that sixmining

    engineers would be sufficient to carry out the

    task. Theywereemployedby HetMijnwezen

    (BureauofMines),founded in1852,thattwenty

    years later began to publish Jaarboek van het

    Mijwezen (MiningYearbook). Initiallythefocus

    wasonJava,SumatraandBorneo. Investigations

    inSulawesistartedmuchlater,aroundtheendof

    the 19th century.The reason for this was

    threefold: i)Sulawesiwashighly inaccessible; ii)

    theislandhadnotyetbeenpacified;andiii)very

    little was known about its mineral endowment

    (Rutten,1927).

    The first government mining engineer to

    investigate some of the gold deposits known at

    that time in Northern Sulawesi was van Schelle

    (1889). Private enterprise soon followed,

    prompted by historical reports of artisan gold

    mining in the region. Between 1896 and 1929

    fourundergroundmineswereoperated(Table2)

    and in the Ratatotok district elluvial deposits

    were also exploited using hydraulic mining

    methods. Inadditiontwounsuccessfulattemptswere made to carry out underground mining at

    G. Pani between 1900 and 1910. Mining of

    nearbyalluvialsproducedonlymarginallybetter

    results. Also not overly impressive were the

    results of alluvial mining at Tapaibekin in the

    Doup district. When more than 50 years later

    geologists of Endeavour Resources undertook a

    mineral survey in the central part of the North

    Arm they observed short trial adits in even the

    mostremotepartsoftheregion,suggestingthat

    it

    had

    been

    thoroughly

    covered

    by

    the

    early

    gold

    prospectors(Trailetal.,1974).

    Truscott (1901) published a description of gold

    minesandprospects intheNorthArmknownat

    the time, presenting highly optimistic

    evaluations. Healsonotedthatcopperdeposits

    in the hinterland of Gorontalo were being

    developed,butno further recordsareavailable.

    Attempts toproduce copperatBuhu,Molosipat

    andBukalintheearly1900sallfailed.Twoofthe

    gold mines in Northern Sulawesi were

    investigated in some detail by government

    engineers and geologists, namely Sumalata

    (Molengraaff, 1902) and Totok (Ratatotok)

    (Koperberg,1900;Hirsh,1911). Theoriginofthe

    goldmineralizationatTotok,which ishostedby

    limestone,wasexplainedintwoways: i)thegold

    wasoriginallyderivedfromrocks locatedfurther

    inland and transported by the Totok river at a

    timethatitslevelwasseveralhundredsofmeter

    higherthanatpresent. Goldandsilicawerethen

  • 7/22/2019 Mineral Deposit of Sulawesi_Theo M. Van Leeuwen and Peter E. Pieters

    8/130

    8

    dissolvedanddepositedfromdescendingfluidsin

    fracturesand cavities in the limestone,believed

    to be younger than underlying andesite, and ii)

    the limestonewas intrudedby theandesiteand

    gold deposited from associated hydrothermal

    fluids.

    During the early part of the 20th century

    government geologists discovered several

    preciousmetal,basemetaland ironoccurrences

    in central Western Sulawesi, including at Sasak,

    which more recently has been explored for its

    porphyry copper potential. A rather curious

    copper occurrencewas found in the Latimojong

    Mountains,wheresmallpocketsofnativecopper

    arepresentinslates,thesocalledKoperLeienor

    CopperSlates(vanBemmelen,1949),thesedays

    knownas ToradjaFormation.

    Far more important (from a presentday

    perspective) was the work done in Eastern

    Sulawesi. Abendanon (191517), who

    investigated the region in 1909/10 was the first

    to observe the presence of extensive ultramafic

    rocksandtheirlateriticweatheringproducts. He

    wasconvincedthatironandnickeloreswouldbe

    found in this part of the island. Following his

    recommendation,amore systematicsurveywas

    initiated

    in

    1915,

    and

    in

    a

    relatively

    short

    period

    of time significant iron and nickel laterite

    resourceshadbeenoutlined. Oneof these, the

    Larona Fe laterite deposit was explored in

    considerable detail outlining proven reserves of

    370Mt (airdried)averaging49%Fe (Dieckmann

    and Julius, 1925). Extensive studies were

    undertakenintheensuingyearsonthepossibility

    of establishing an iron and steel industry in

    Sulawesi, butwithout much success, one of the

    reasons being the lack of known coking coal

    depositsinIndonesia.Theoutlookfordeveloping

    the more Nirich laterite deposits was equally

    discouragingbecauseofthelowNicontents(0.50

    1.15%), whereas at the time grades of 3.5

    4.0% were required. Using the rich nickel

    deposits of New Caledonia as a model efforts

    were subsequently directed towards finding

    highergradegarnierite(Nisilicate)ore. Afteran

    extensivesearch thistypeoforewasdiscovered

    inthehillssouthofLakeMantanoatSoroakoand

    near Malili (Pomalaa). In 1934, two private

    companiesweregiventherighttofurtherexplore

    and develop these deposits. By applying a

    method of selective mining, which involved

    careful stripping of overburden and removing

    peridotite boulders, dry ore of 3.5% Ni was

    producedatPomalaa,andshipped to Japanand

    Germany, starting in 1937. By 1940, a

    government engineer had succeeded in

    developing a new process for the treatment of

    theseNisilicateoresonsite,butbefore itcould

    beappliedJapaneseforcesinvadedIndonesia. By

    that time a totalofabout150.000 tof ore had

    beenexported(Darmono,2009).

    Before the outbreak of the Pacific War the

    Japanese had obtained nickel ore from Canada

    andNewCaledonia,butthesesourceswerenow

    cut off. Sulawesi became an important newsource to supply their war industry. The Dutch

    miningoperationsweretakenoverbySumitomo

    Metal Mining, which built a smelting plant to

    produceNimatte,butbeforeitwascompletedit

    was destroyed by the allied forces. Between

    1942and1945a totalof184.000tofnickelore

    was produced (Darmono, 2009). The Japanese

    alsocarriedoutlimitedminingforbasemetalsat

    SangkaropiincentralSulawesi.

    After

    the

    Dutch

    returned

    in

    1946

    they

    resumed

    nickel mining, but only for three years. Eight

    years later NV Perto (Pertambangan Toraja)

    shipped nickel ore still remaining in stock piles

    fromtheJapaneseoccupationtoJapan. In1961,

    it became PT Pertambangan Nickel Indonesia, a

    stateownedenterprise,whichthenmergedwith

    several other stateowned mining companies to

    become PT Aneka Tambang (Antam). This

    company has been operating thePomalaamine

    since 1968. In the central part of Eastern

    Sulawesi, including the Soroako area, all

    explorationactivitiesweresuspendeduntil1965

    becauseoflocalinsurgency.

    Following the promulgation of new foreign

    investment and mining laws in 1967, Indonesia

    offered for tender several areas with known tin

    and nickel laterite potential, including a large

    block in Eastern Sulawesi. This concession was

    awardedin1968toaconsortiumheadedbyINCO

    (International Nickel Cooperation) of Canada.

  • 7/22/2019 Mineral Deposit of Sulawesi_Theo M. Van Leeuwen and Peter E. Pieters

    9/130

    9

    The consortium company, which includes

    Sumitomo Metal Mining as a shareholder, is

    usuallyreferredtoasPTINCO. Intheearlyyears

    the company carried out extensive exploration

    with the assistance of the Geological Survey of

    Indonesia(GSI) and about 40 geology students

    from the Institute Teknologi Bandung (ITB).

    Initiallytheexploration focuswason thecoastal

    areas, but in mid1969 it shifted to Soroako,

    wherefouryearslaterminedevelopmentbegan.

    Soon afterwards oil prices escalated and the

    international nickel market deteriorated. In

    ordertocounterthesenegativedevelopmentsPT

    INCO built a hydroelectric plant and tripled

    annual production capacity to 45,000 tonnes of

    nickel matte, but it had to wait until 1988,

    following an improvement in the nickel market,

    to see its operations become profitable (vanLeeuwen,1994).

    The first company to carry our gold and base

    metal exploration in Sulawesi was Newmont,

    which between 1967 and 1969 undertook

    reconnaissanceandlimitedfollowupworkinthe

    NorthArmwithporphyrycopperdepositsasthe

    main target. They examined recorded

    mineralizationanddiorite rockseasilyaccessible

    from the north and south coast, and in the

    hinterland

    of

    Gorontalo

    and

    the

    Bone

    Valley,

    and

    made more detailed investigations around the

    abandonedG.Panigoldmine,andatafewother

    localities,includingtheBuhucopperprospect.

    Intheearly1970stwoothercompaniesinitiated

    porphyry copper searches, namely Endeavour

    Resources,ajuniorAustraliancompany,andRio

    Tinto. The former obtained a 2nd generation

    ContractofWork(COW),knownasBlockII,which

    coveredanareaof12,000km2inthecentralpart

    oftheNorthArm. Theirobjectivewastotestthe

    hypothesis that thePhilippines porphyry copper

    belt might extend into northern Sulawesi, an

    initiative thatwas rewardedby thediscoveryof

    porphyryCu stylemineralization in theTapadaa

    andTombuililatodistricts. Followinga literature

    study and the second years survey work that

    revealedthatgoldmineralizationwaswidespread

    inBlockII,thescopeofthesurveywasextended

    toincludealluvialandhardrockgoldtargets.

    The two porphyry districts were investigated in

    moredetailinjointventurewithKennecottfrom

    1973 to1976. In1980,Utah International took

    controlofEndeavourslocalcompanyandcarried

    out an intensive exploration campaign in the

    Tombuililato district until 1982. Together these

    efforts resulted in the discovery of three

    porphyry prospects in the Tapadaa district and

    five porphyry prospects in the Tombuililato

    district, including Cabang Kiri, Kayubulan Ridge

    andSungaiMakwithacombinedresourceof296

    Mt @ 0.57% and 0.47 g/t Au (van Leeuwen,

    1994). In addition high sulphidation AuCu

    mineralizationwasfoundatMotomboto.

    RioTintoappliedfora largeCOWarea,Block III,

    located to the west of block II and covering an

    areaof17,200km2in1973,whichwasgranted in1977. In the intervening years reconnaissance

    geochemical sampling identified 18 anomalous

    areas,followupofwhich ledtothediscoveryof

    the Malala (Anomaly B) porphyry molybdenum

    deposit in theTolitolidistrict. Drillingbetween

    1978 and 1982, partly in JV with SANTOS of

    Australia,outlineda [email protected]

    MoS2, which was not economically viable at

    prevailingmolybdenumprices.

    Further

    south,

    GIS

    carried

    out

    reconnaissance

    geochemical surveys in the late 1960searly

    1970s, outlining three areas anomalous in base

    metals, i.e. Sasak, Seko and Sangkaropi. These

    were subsequently investigated together with

    Antam, and drilled. Porphyry Cu mineralization

    was found in the former two locations, but

    appearedtobeoflowgrade(0.3 0.4%Cu)andof

    limited extent. In the Sangkaropi area, three

    VMS deposits were subjected to detailed

    exploration that failed to outline an economic

    resource.

    Inthoseearlyyearsexplorationwasoftencarried

    out under conditions reminiscent of the Dutch

    days, requiring a true pioneering spirit. This is

    exemplified by the story of the Kuda mati

    berdiri(standingdeadhorses)(Geomin,2010). In

    1975, Antam decided to drill test Seko, located

    200km to thenorthofSangkaropiatanaltitude

    of 1000m, which could for the most part be

    reached only on foot. The party included 30

  • 7/22/2019 Mineral Deposit of Sulawesi_Theo M. Van Leeuwen and Peter E. Pieters

    10/130

    10

    porters and 70 horses. As the track followed

    mostly mountain ridges grass and water were

    very scarce. After 10 days one of the horses

    refusedtomoveevenaftersomeof its loadhad

    been decreased. It took a while to realize that

    the poor animal was already dead, probably

    because of dehydration. A number of other

    horses died the same way without falling over.

    Thelocationwasfinallyreachedafter30days.

    By the mid1980s the porphyry search was

    virtually over and the focus shifted to gold. In

    Northern Sulawesi the gold search was

    spearheadedbyBHPMinerals (whichhad taken

    over Utah in 1984), soon to be joined by

    Newmont,Ashton,PlacerDome,andNewHope

    Colliers. A total of thirteen 4th generation

    COWsweresignedinthelate1986and1987.

    The gold exploration undertaken during the

    second half of the 1980s and early 1990si

    Northern Sulawesi was quite successful.

    Newmont discovered a sedimenthosted gold

    district in an area of old Dutch workings

    (Ratatotokdistrict). Itsubsequentlydevelopeda

    mine (Mesel), which between 1996 and 2004

    produced1.9MozAu. Anothergolddistrictwas

    identified by Ashton at the northern tip of the

    North

    Arm

    centred

    on

    Toka

    Tindung.

    This

    company was also involved in the discovery of

    high sulphidation gold mineralization in the

    BinabaseBawone area on Sangihe island. BHP

    drilledfivegoldprospects,includingMotomboto.

    In addition, a high resolution aeromagnetic

    survey identified several targets, only some of

    which were followed up. A reevaluation of the

    Tombuililato district resulted in a geological

    resource estimate of up to 356 Mt @ 0.6% Cu,

    0.37 g/t Au, including a mining reserve of

    [email protected]%Cu,0.43g/tAuand118

    Mt @ 0.94% Cu, 0.40 g/t Au at a strip ratio of

    ~2.75:1 (BHP Minerals Sulawesi, 1997). Finally,

    New Hope Colliers geochemical sampling

    identified a number of gold anomalies which

    were subsequently followed up by Newcrest,

    resulting in the discovery of gold mineralization

    atTototopoandPetulis.

    Concurrentlywiththesigningofthe13COWs in

    Northern Sulawesi, nine 4th generation COW

    agreements were entered into for areas in

    Western Sulawesi, but serious exploration was

    carried out only by Aberfoyle Resources, which

    held a block containing Sasak and Sangkaropi

    (relinquished in 1994), and new Hope Colliers,

    which discovered the Awak Mas deposit in the

    LatimojongMountains.

    In Eastern Sulawesi PT Palmabim commenced

    exploration for chromite beach sands in the

    Bungkuareawhereitoutlined700,000tonnesof

    recoverable chromite. The deposit was put into

    operationin1988.Ithassincebeencloseddown

    (yearnotknown).

    The 1990s witnessed the signing of one 5th

    generation Cow by Newcrest covering most of

    the old Endeavour Block II, and two 6thgeneration COWs, also located in Northern

    Sulawesi (Newmont in the Bolaang Mongondow

    district, and Aurora Gold, which had acquired

    Ashtons areas in 1993,in an area adjacent to

    their Toka Tindung COW), and eight 7th

    generationCOWs,allbutonelocatedinWestern

    Sulawesi, including twoblocksheldbyRioTinto

    andonebyNorthLtd). The lattercompanyhad

    selected a large block in central Western

    Sulawesi, which based on the widespread

    occurrence

    of

    potassic

    alkaline

    volcanic

    and

    intrusive rocks combined with the presence of

    known porphyry mineralization (Sasak) was

    believed to have good potential for finding

    Parkestype porphyry copper deposits. (The

    Parkesmine inAustraliawasoperatedbyNorth

    at the time). Arguably themostcomprehensive

    investigations were carried out by Newcrest,

    which between 1993 and 1998 covered their

    entire COW area in Northern Sulawesi with

    drainage reconnaissance sampling, resulting ina

    largenumberofanomalies. Manyofthesewere

    investigatedin1996/97. Atotalof168prospects

    were identified (including previously known

    ones),twelveofwhichweredrilltested, inmost

    casesdowngradingtheireconomicpotential.

    The highlights of the 1990s include Newmonts

    discovery of the Northern Lanut trend, which

    contains several styles of mineralization,

    including highsulphidation epithermal gold

    mineralization. Work by Aurora outlined a

  • 7/22/2019 Mineral Deposit of Sulawesi_Theo M. Van Leeuwen and Peter E. Pieters

    11/130

    11

    mineraldistrictaroundTokaTindung,containing

    seven epithermal gold systems. In Western

    Sulawesi, Rio Tinto discovered the Masabo

    porphyry copper and the Poboya gold deposits.

    Rather surprisingly the latter deposit was

    previouslynotknowndespitebeing locatedonly

    7km from the provincial capital Palu and next

    doortoPoboyavillage,formingadistinctoutcrop

    withhighgoldgrades. RioTintoalsodiscovered

    towards the end of the decade the La Sampala

    laterite deposit in Eastern Sulawesi, believed to

    beoneofthe largestundevelopednickellaterite

    resources in the world. Around the same time

    Antam found several new gold prospects near

    Palopo Sulawesi.Thecompanyalso initiatedan

    intensive exploration programme in Eastern

    Sulawesi with the objective to find additional

    nickel laterite resources to supply theirferronickelplantatPomalaa. Severalprospective

    areaswereoutlined.

    As elsewhere in Indonesia, the combined effect

    of the Busang scandal (the largest fraud in the

    history of mining, which was committed in East

    Kalimantan), the Asian economic crisis, and

    domestic political instability that took place

    towardstheendofthe20thcenturyhadasevere

    impact on the mineral exploration activities in

    Sulawesi

    (and

    elsewhere

    in

    Indonesia).

    Most

    foreigncompanies,bothbigandsmall,withdrew

    fromtheregionorcurtailedtheiractivities.

    The first decade of the 21st century saw some

    important new developments: 1) regional

    autonomy gave the local government of

    Kabupaten(Districts,subdivisionsofProvinces)a

    significant direct say in mining and related

    matters ;2)anewmining lawwaspromulgated

    in 2009, which among other initiatives

    introduced a tender system for new areas,

    abolishedtheCOWsystem,whichuptothenhad

    been the cornerstone of Indonesias modern

    miningindustry,andpromotedprocessingofore

    toatleastasemifinishedstatewithinIndonesia;

    3)commoditypricesstartedtorisearound2004,

    which spurred an increase in domestic

    involvement in exploration and mining,

    particularly of nickel laterites; and 4) the

    explorationfocuswasonknown,moreadvanced

    prospects.

    Some of the highlights of the decade include

    commencementofgoldproductionatRiskaand

    Toka Tindung, and revisiting of some old tired

    prospects. At Riska, which was discovered by

    Newmont in 1988, Avocet Mining started

    productionin2006withanannualproductionof

    about50,000ounces. TokaTindungwasbought

    by Archipelago Resources in 2002; after long

    delays the first goldwaspoured in2011 witha

    forecastedannualproductionof160,000ounces.

    Gunung Pani (looked at by 7 companies since

    1967) and Awak Mas (investigated by 5

    companies since 1988) are presently under

    detailed investigations by One Asia Resources

    Ltd. The Tombulilato porphyry Cu and Malala

    porphyry Mo deposits, discovered in the mid

    1970s, are being reinvestigated by BumiResources and Victory Moly West respectively.

    The former company also acquired the Poboya

    golddeposit,butuptillnowhasbeenprevented

    from carrying out exploration because of illegal

    mining activities.The latter company has

    expanded its activities into nickel laterite and

    base metal explorations in central Sulawesi.

    Antam started exploration at Esang, which had

    been discovered during North Ltd regional

    exploration programme in central Western

    Sulawesi

    a

    decade

    earlier.

    A

    new

    arrival

    on

    the

    scene isGoldenPeaksResourceswhich recently

    acquired the Palopo gold property in Western

    Sulawesi and the Tanoyan and Anggrek gold

    prospects in Northern Sulawesi. And finally, in

    2008 seven domestic companies started nickel

    laterite production, all being relatively small

    operations.

    Theonly importantnewdiscoverythathasbeen

    reported since 2000 is the rich alluvial gold

    depositatBombanainSESulawesifoundbylocal

    villagers in2008. It is the first indicationof the

    presence of potentially significant gold

    mineralizationinEasternSulawesi.

    In summary, thedocumentedhistoryofmineral

    explorationandmininginSulawesicanbedivided

    intosixstages:

    1) 1813 1888. Local gold mining activities in

    various parts of Northern Sulawesi, which

  • 7/22/2019 Mineral Deposit of Sulawesi_Theo M. Van Leeuwen and Peter E. Pieters

    12/130

    12

    have continued intermittently until the

    presentday.

    2) 1889 1941. Exploration by the Netherlands

    EastIndiesgovernmentandprivateenterprise

    that resulted in the development of several

    goldandnickellateritemines.

    3) 19421967. Relatively small scale nickel

    laterite mining by Japanese, Dutch and

    IndonesianStatecompanies.

    4) 1968 1984. Exploration with the main focus

    on nickel laterite and porphyry copper

    deposits; initially reconnaissance surveys of

    largetractsofland,followedbymoredetailed

    investigations of selected areas; mine

    developmentatSoroako.

    5) 1985 1999. Focus shifts to gold; 23 COWs

    signed; exploration mix of regional surveys

    and prospect evaluation; several significant

    gold discoveries made, one of which (Mesel)

    wasdevelopedintoamine(nowclosed).

    6) 2000 present. Activities that began to

    decrease sharply in the late 1990s pick up

    again around 2004/5 with increased

    involvement

    of

    domestic

    companies,

    mainly

    in

    nickel laterite exploration and mining; focus

    on known gold and nickel laterite

    deposits/districts; two gold mines developed

    (RiskaandTokaTindung).

    3.0 Geology

    Inthischapterwebrieflydescribethegeologyof

    the Northern, Western and Eastern Provinces.

    Theformertwoprovincesareoftentreatedasa

    single tectonostratigraphic unit, referred to as

    theWestSulawesiPlutonVolcanicArc (WSPVA),

    whereas the Eastern Sulawesi Province is

    commonly divided into a western Central

    Sulawesi Metamorphic Belt and an Eastern

    OphioliteSulawesiBelt.

    SeparatingtheWSPVAintotwodifferententities,

    as first proposed by Taylor and van Leeuwen

    (1980), isbasedon therecognitionofsignificant

    differences intectonicsetting,ageandcharacter

    of rockunits (Table1).The tectonic relationship

    between the two domains is not clear. They

    probably formedamoreor less continuousbelt

    throughout the Cenozoic, but were definitely

    connectednot laterthantheEarlyMiocene (van

    Leeuwen and Muhardjo, 2005). A simplified

    geologicalmapofSulawesiisshowninFigure4.

    3.1 NorthernSulawesiProvince

    TheNorthernSulawesiProvinceoccupiesa large

    part of the North Arm and the row of islands

    extending to the north as far as Sangihe Island

    (Figure 3B). The EW part of the North Arm,

    referred to as the Gorontalo section (van

    Bemmelen, 1949), is made up of Cenozoic arc

    volcanics and associated sedimentary rocks.TowardstheeasttheNorthArmbendssharplyto

    aNEtrendandthisregion,theMinahasasection,

    islargelycoveredbyPliocenetoRecentvolcanics.

    The young volcanic arc continues northwards

    through the Sangihe Island group and is often

    referred toas the SangiheArc. Like the restof

    Sulawesi, Northern Sulawesi consists of

    mountainous terrain, although rarely reaching

    altitudes higher than 2000m. The landscape of

    thenorthernpartoftheprovinceisdominatedby

    the

    presence

    of

    (partly

    eroded)

    volcanic

    cones,

    someofwhicharestillactive,likeLokonVolcano,

    which erupted as recently as October 2011.

    Several grabenlike depressions occupy the

    centralpartoftheGorontalosection.

    The rock sequences that make up Northern

    Sulawesicanbedividedbroadlyintothreegroups

    thatareseparatedbyregionalunconformities. In

    thispaper theyare informallyreferred toas the

    Early,Mid andLateCenozoicgroups.

    TheoldestgroupconsistsofathickpileofMiddle

    EoceneLate Miocene submarine oceanic arc

    volcanics,namedPapayatoVolcanics(Trailetal.,

    1974;vanLeeuwenandMuhardjo,2005),which

    arewidely exposed in the southwestern part of

    theGorontalosectionforminga275kmlongbelt,

    andarefoundfurthereastassmallerexposures.

    This unit consists of a thick series of basaltic

    volcanics that occur in bimodal association with

    much less voluminous felsic rocks. It contains

  • 7/22/2019 Mineral Deposit of Sulawesi_Theo M. Van Leeuwen and Peter E. Pieters

    13/130

    13

    subordinate intercalations of red calcareous

    mudstone, red limestone, greywacke, and

    radiolarian chert, and is intruded by basaltic

    dykes, locally occurring as dyke swarms, and

    stocks of gabbro and diorite. The basaltic

    volcanics include massive, autobrecciated or

    pillowed lava flows, and volcanic breccia. The

    bulk of the mafic and felsic rocks have

    geochemicalcompositionsthataretypicaloflow

    K tholeiitic island arc (IAT) volcanics, but some,

    thought to have been produced late in the

    evolutionofthevolcanicarc,showahighKcalc

    alkalineaffinity(Elburgetal.,2003;vanLeeuwen

    and Muhardjo, 2005), and contain small

    volcanogenicmassivesulphidedeposits.

    Near Labanuki on the north coast of the

    Gorontalo section, the Papayato Volcanics areunderlain by basalts, which show geochemical

    similaritieswithbasalts that form thebasement

    of the Celebes Sea and are interpreted to

    represent backarc basalts (Priadi et al., 1997).

    Bothbasaltsequencesareoverlainbygreenand

    blackmudstone. These similarities suggest that

    the Labanuki basalts formed as part of the

    CelebesSeacrust(Ranginetal.,1997). Anumber

    ofauthorshavesuggestedthatmostoftheNorth

    Arm isunderlainbysimilarcrust (e.g.Taylorand

    van

    Leeuwen,

    1980;

    Kavalieris

    et

    al.,

    1992;

    Rangin

    etal.,1997).

    TheEarlyCenozoicrockscommonlydisplaysteep

    dips, and in places are highly deformed

    (Koperberg,1929;Trailetal.,1974;Kavalieriset

    al.,1992). This,togetherwiththepresenceofa

    regional unconformity separating the unit from

    the MidCenozoic group (Koperberg, 1929;

    Ratman, 1976; Carlile et al., 1990; Pearson and

    Caira, 1999) indicate that a significant tectonic

    eventtook place in the Early Miocene (van

    LeeuwenandMuhardjo,2005). Thecauseofthis

    eventisnotcertain. Ithasbeensuggestedthatit

    may be related to the collision between the

    North Arm and either a small continental

    fragment or the Sula Spur (van Leeuwen and

    Muhardjo,2005;SpakmanandHall,2010).Inthe

    latter scenario the Sula Spur was subsequently

    fragmented during extension caused by

    subductionrollbackindeBandaregion.

    TheMidCenozoicgroupoccupiesa largepartof

    the Gorontalo section, and is locally exposed in

    the southern part of the Minahasa section. It

    consists of a predominantly volcanic unit

    (Bilungala Volcanics), a mixed sedimentary

    volcanic unit (Dolokopa Formation), and several

    sedimentary units, including the Ratatotok

    Limestone, which hosts Mesel and associated

    gold deposits. The volcanic rocks consist

    predominantly of andesitic lava flows and

    pyroclastics, debris flows, and related

    volcaniclastics,markingmultipleperiodsofuplift

    anderosionduringthedevelopmentofthemid

    Cenozoicvolcanicarc (PearsonandCaira,1999).

    Felsicrocksarecommonlypresentinsomeareas,

    includingtheTombulilatodistrict(Perello,1994).

    The base of the MidCenozoic group has beenobservedonlyinafewlocalities,whereitconsists

    of chaotic masses of Papayato Volcanics

    fragments or poorly sorted conglomerates (Trail

    etal.,1974;vanLeeuwenandMuhardjo,2005).

    Thesequenceisintrudedbycomagmaticbodies,

    varying in size from dykes and stocks to

    batholiths of diorite, quartzdiorite and

    granodiorite (e.g.Trailetal.,1974;Pearsonand

    Caira, 1999). Limited radiometric age dating

    results (Lowder and Dow, 1978; Polv et al.,

    1997;

    Pearson

    and

    Caira,

    1999)

    suggest

    that

    batholithsizedbodieswereemplacedduringthe

    EarlyMiddleMiocene(1612Ma),irregularstock

    and dykelike intrusions of diorite and

    monzodiorite composition during MiddleLate

    Miocene times, and small stocks and plugs of

    quartz diorite composition during the latest

    Miocene (85 Ma). According to Pearson and

    Caira (1999) the batholiths were probably

    exposedbyoneormoreperiodsofintraMiocene

    erosion. Published geochemical data for the

    volcanicandplutonicsuitessuggestthattheMid

    Cenozoic was dominated by mediumK calc

    alkalinemagmatism(Polvetal,1997). Porphyry

    CuAuMo and intrusionrelated base metal Au

    mineralization is commonly associated with the

    MiddleLate Miocene suites. However, most

    depositsaresmalland/oroflowmetaltenor.

    ThestructureoftheMidCenozoicrockshasbeen

    studiedinmostdetail intheTombulilatodistrict,

    where several periods of lowangle thrusting

  • 7/22/2019 Mineral Deposit of Sulawesi_Theo M. Van Leeuwen and Peter E. Pieters

    14/130

    14

    were followed by development of highangle

    northerly trending faults, which was succeeded

    by several stages of easttrending block faulting

    (Perello, 1994). A regional unconformity

    between theMid and LateCenozoic sequences

    marks a major tectonic event that is generally

    believed to be related to the collision of the

    BanggaiSulacontinental fragmentwithSulawesi

    (e.g.Perello,1994;PearsonandCaira,1999).

    The Late Cenozoic, which was the most

    productivemineralizing period, witnessed

    widespread and intensive volcanism. The Early

    Pliocene Wobudu Breccia, exposed along the

    north coast of the Gorontalo section, is

    composedalmostentirelyofbasaltictoandesitic

    agglomerates, breccias, pyroclastics, and lava

    flows(Trailetal.,1974). Alongthesouthcoast,aseries of dominantly dacitic volcanics and co

    magmatic highlevel intrusions are exposed,

    named Pani Volcanics (Trail et al., 1974). They

    form major caldera complexes that have

    developed within the SW corners of large arc

    parallel and arcnormal fault rhombs, and host

    significant gold mineralization (Pearson and

    Caira, 1999). Similar rocks are found in the

    Tombulilato district, where they have been

    named Motomboto Volcanics by Perello (1994).

    K/Ar

    dating

    suggests

    the

    two

    units

    were

    formed

    between5.3and2.0Ma (Perello,1994;Polvet

    al., 1997; Pearson and Caira, 1999). Significant

    porphyryCuAuandepithermalAumineralization

    isassociatedwiththismagmaticevent.

    ThePinogoVolcanics(Trailetal.,1972)constitute

    a volcanicsedimentary succession that occurs

    overadistanceof170kmalong thesouthcoast,

    from40kmwestofTototopotomorethan60km

    eastofTombulilato,whereitisupto300mthick.

    Isolatedremnantsarepresentwithinthecentral

    LimbotoBone riftvalley,andup to40km to the

    north. The unit is thought to have formed in

    latest PliocenePleistocene times, a period

    dominated by explosive volcanism (Kavalieris et

    al.,1992;Perello,1994;PearsonandCaira,1999).

    Thevolcanicsarecharacterized,atleastinpart,by

    a bimodal association of basaltic andesite and

    rhyolite(Kavalierisetal.,1992). Throughoutthe

    Gorontalo section diatreme and irregular

    magmatichydrothermalbrecciabodiesappearto

    postdate and intrude the Pani Volcanics. They

    include postmineralization diatreme breccias at

    theCabangKiriandSungaiMakporphyrycopper

    deposits(CarlileandKirkegaard,1985).

    Volcanic units in the Minahasa section include

    the locally named Maen Volcanics and Toka

    Tindung Breccia (Wake et al., 1996), which are

    contemporaneouswiththegoldmineralizationin

    the Toka Tindung district and of Late Pliocene

    age, and the Tondano Tuff of Effendi (1976),

    whichare the resultofexplosiveeruptions from

    the Tondano caldera, now occupied by the

    Tondano Lake. Quaternary to Recent volcanics

    maskmostof theolderrocks in theSangiheArc

    (i.e. northern Minahasa section to Sangihe

    Island).

    The Late Cenozoic units are mostly flat lying to

    gently dipping. Significant subrecent vertical

    movements in the Gorontalo section are

    evidenced by the elevation of young coral

    limestone up to height of 5501000m, and the

    formationofbroaddepressions(Rutten,1927).

    The Gorontalo section is dominated by three

    structural elements: i)long ESE trending fault

    corridors, which are arcparallel structures; ii)

    regularly

    spaced

    NW

    NNW

    arc

    normal

    fault

    zones;andiii)shortNEENEarcnormalconjugate

    faults (Carlileetal.,1990;Kavalierisetal.,1992;

    Pearson and Caira, 1999). Carlile and al. (1990)

    andKavalierisetall.(1992)observethatmuchof

    the most recent faulting along the arcparallel

    structures comprisenormal verticalmovements,

    resulting in uplifted EW trending mountain

    chainsandgraben.IntheMinahassasectiontwo

    fault sets dominate: i) NE, showing vertical

    movement,andii)NW,whichprobablycomprises

    an orthogonal tensional fracture system

    comparable to the Gorontalo section (Carlile et

    al.,1990).

    3.2 WesternSulawesiProvince

    IntermsofgeomorphologyandgeologyWestern

    Sulawesi can be divided into three parts:

    Southwest (SW), Central West (CW) and

    Northwest (NW) Sulawesi (Figure 3B). SW

    Sulawesi is geomorphologically separated from

  • 7/22/2019 Mineral Deposit of Sulawesi_Theo M. Van Leeuwen and Peter E. Pieters

    15/130

    15

    CWSulawesibyaNW trendingdepression filled

    with Quaternary sediments, which may mask a

    major structure. It differs from the rest of the

    province inbeing less tectonicallydeformedand

    less mountainous, lacking large Neogene

    granitoid bodies, and having Neogene volcanics

    with isotopic and trace element characteristics

    that are different from those found in CWNW

    Sulawesi(e.g.ElburgandFoden,1999). Themain

    differencesbetweenCWandNWSulawesiarein

    the nature of Late EoceneEarly Miocene

    sedimentation (dominantly carbonate and

    dominantly siliclastic respectively) and the

    relative scarcityofNeogene volcanicdeposits in

    thelatterarea. CWSulawesihasthemostrugged

    terrain, with many mountain ridges between

    20003000m altitudes reaching a maximum

    heightof3495m.

    Western Sulawesi contains an almost complete

    stratigraphic sequence ranging between Late

    Cretaceous and Recent, which developed on a

    basement of continental fragment and

    accretionary/mlange rocks. It represents

    severalmajorperiodsofsedimentation,including

    Late Cretaceous flysch, Eocene synrift

    siliciclastics, Late EoceneMiddle Miocene

    platformanddeepermarine carbonates,Middle

    Miocene

    Early

    Pliocene

    shallow

    marine

    deposits,

    and latest Cenozoic synorogenicsedimentary

    successions. The sedimentation cycles were

    accompaniedorinterruptedbyseveralmagmatic

    eventsthattookplaceduringthePaleocene,mid

    Eocene to midOligocene, Early Miocene, and

    Middle Miocene to Pliocene, locally continuing

    into the Quaternary (e.g. van Leeuwen and

    Muhardjo,2005;vanLeeuwenetal.,2010).

    PreTertiaryaccretionary/mlangecomplexesare

    exposed in theBantimalaandBarrublocks inSW

    Sulawesi and in the Latimojong Complex in SW

    Sulawesi. They consist of imbricated tectonic

    slices of both continental and oceanic rocks,

    whichhavebeenmetamorphosedtogreenschist

    amphibolite and blueschist facies (Sukamto,

    1986;Wakitaetal.,1996;Maulanaetal.,2010).

    The complexes have been interpreted by

    Parkinson et al. (1998) to belong to a

    dismembered midCretaceous accretionary/

    subduction zone that extended from central

    Eastern Sulawesi through southern Western

    SulawesiandSEKalimantantocentralJava.

    Three metamorphic complexes are exposed in

    NW Sulawesi, i.e. the Palu, Karossa and Malino

    MetamorphicComplexes,whicharecomposedof

    continental fragments derived from the

    AustralianNewGuineamargin,andinthecaseof

    theformer twocomplexes,alsocontainslicesof

    oceaniccrust(vanLeeuwenandMuhardjo,2005;

    vanLeeuwenetal.,2007). ThePaluMetamorphic

    Complex hosts a gold deposit named Poboya,

    which is of uncertain origin. The metamorphic

    complexes are believed to form part of asingle

    large fragment (or composite fragment) that

    underlies most of Western Sulawesi, the

    MakassarStraits,JavaSeaandEastJava,andhas

    been named the East JavaWest Sulawesi Blockby Hall (2009). This author interprets the

    fragment(s) to have been separated from NW

    Australia in the Jurassic and accreted to the SE

    SundalandmargininthemidCretaceous.

    The basement complexes are unconformably

    overlain by weakly metamorphosed Late

    Cretaceous flysch deposits, which occur

    widespread throughout the province and in CW

    Sulawesi host significant gold mineralization.No

    mineralization,

    other

    than

    minor

    sediment

    hostedCuoccurrences,hasbeenfoundtodatein

    the unconformably overlying siliciclastics and

    carbonate sequences which were deposited in

    midEocene to midMiocene times. Volcanism

    thattookplaceduringthisperiodappeartohave

    been intermittent and localized, as a result of

    which no major continuous volcanic arc

    developed (van Leeuwen and Muhardjo, 2005;

    van Leeuwen et al., 2010). The volcanic rocks

    arecalcalkaline in composition and generally

    believed tobe related toactive subduction (e.g.

    Yuwono et al., 1986, 1988; Elburg et al., 2002,

    2003). The only mineralization known to be

    associated with the Early Tertiary volcanism is

    Kurokotype VMS near Sangkaropi in CW

    Sulawesi.

    A major tectonic event took place in the early

    MiddleMioceneunderextensionalconditions. It

    wascharacterizedbyblockfaultingthatresulted

    inlocalunconformitiesand developmentofa

  • 7/22/2019 Mineral Deposit of Sulawesi_Theo M. Van Leeuwen and Peter E. Pieters

    16/130

    16

    Table 3 SelectedfeaturesofporphyryCuAuMosystemsinNorthernSulawes

    Prospect

    Name

    Hostrocks Alteration Mineralization Vertic

    exten

    (cm

    Type Mineralogy

    Bulagidun hydrothermal collapse

    bx associated with

    diorite &qtz diorite

    stocks

    (upper)muscchlorthqtzillkaol;

    (inner)btqtzmgt

    (outer)chlepi.

    sulphide

    cement

    fillingbx

    cpypymgt;Auwith

    cpy and in native

    form

    500

    Dunu diorite porphyry &

    tourmalinebx

    (inner)btqtzalb

    (outer)chlactepi

    stk&bxfilling cpypo(pymo); Au

    withCp

    Tapadaa qtz diorite; andesite

    volcanics

    (early)qtzchlbtanhalbmgt

    (late)ser+qtzdiaspandpyroph.

    stk&dissem pycpybo; chalc

    blanket up to 40m

    thick

    100

    CabangKiri qtz diorite stock;

    (andesitevolcanics)

    1.(top)kaoldiaspal2.clayserchlmgt3.chlmgt4.(bottom)qtzseralbchlmgt

    bt

    stk&dissem cpypybomgt,

    chalccovpy

    400

    Kayubulan

    Ridge

    pipelike breccia

    complex

    qtzmgtbt overprintedby serill

    chl

    Stk&dissem cpypybo 150

    SungaiMak diorite porphyry, sill

    like

    qtzmgtbt overprinted by serill

    chlvuggysialkaol

    Stk&dissem chalcblanket,upto

    176m;+pycp

    200

    Source: vanLeeuwenandPieters(2011)

    Abbreviations(Tables35): A=alteration;act=actinolite; al=alunite;alb=albite;ad=adularia;and=andalusite;anh=a

    ba=barite;bo=bornite;bt=biotite;bx=breccias;carb=carbonate;chalc=chalcocite;chald=chalcedony;chl=chlorite;

    =

    diaspore;

    dissem

    =

    disseminations;

    en

    =

    enargite;

    epi

    =

    epidote;

    ga

    =

    galena;

    HR

    =

    host

    rock;

    ill

    =

    illite;

    kaol

    =

    kaolinitemolybdenite;musc=muscovite;orth=orthoclase;py=pyrite;pyroph=pyrophyllite;po=pyrrhotite;qtz=quartz;ser=se

    stibnite;stk=stockwork;

  • 7/22/2019 Mineral Deposit of Sulawesi_Theo M. Van Leeuwen and Peter E. Pieters

    17/130

    17

    major strikeslip fault in SW Sulawesi (Walanae

    FaultZone),alongwhichanoceanicfragmentwas

    emplaced (van Leeuwen et al., 2010). Another

    oceanic fragment exposed further north, the

    LamasiOphioliteComplex,mayhaveaccretedto

    theWesternSulawesicontinentalmarginaround

    thesametime.

    Thetectoniceventheraldedtheonsetofaperiod

    of widespread shoshonitic to ultrapotassic

    magmatismthatlastedtotheEarlyPliocene,and

    locally continued into the Quaternary

    (Lompobatang Volcano). Over 5000m thick

    deposits of volcanic, comagmatic intrusive,

    volcaniclastics and intercalated sedimentary

    rocks cover large parts of SW and CW Sulawesi

    (e.g. Sukamto, 1982; Bergman et al., 1996). In

    NWSulawesi,theirdistributionismorerestricted(Elburg et al., 2003). The potassicultrapotassic

    suiteshavebeenreferredtoasHKseriesbyPolv

    et al. (1997).In CW and NW Sulawesi, the HK

    seriesmagmatismwasaccompaniedbyadistinct

    magmatic event that started around the

    beginning of the Late Miocene and produced

    large volumes of granitoids and subordinate

    amounts of tuffs that were exclusively felsic in

    nature and of highK calcalkaline composition,

    theCAKseriesofPolvetal. (1997). Thisevent

    lasted

    until

    the

    Pleistocene,

    making

    the

    granites

    oneoftheyoungestintheworld.

    Most of the mineral deposits and occurrences

    found inWesternSulawesiarerelatedtotheHK

    andCAKmagmatism. TheyincludeporphyryMo,

    porphyryCuAu,intrusionrelatedbasemetalAu,

    and probably also the Awak Mas and Poboya

    golddeposits,andothersfoundinthesamebelt,

    which in this paper we refer to as intrusion

    relatedAudeposits.

    Synorogenicsedimentary deposits of Plio

    Pleistocene age, collectively known as Celebes

    Molasse (Sarasin and Sarasin, 1901) occur

    widespread throughoutWesternSulawesi. They

    reflect a major tectonic event, involving rapid

    uplift, folding and thrusting (? gravity sliding) in

    CWandNWSulawesi. Thiseventhaspreviously

    beenattributedtocollisionbetweentheBanggai

    Sula microcontinent and the East Arm (e.g.

    Bergman et al., 1996; Hall and Wilson, 2000).

    However,thereisincreasingevidencetosuggest

    that the CWNW SulawesiNorth ArmGorontalo

    Bayregionhasbeen inextensionsince theEarly

    Pliocene,whichmayhavebeendrivenbyrollback

    of the subduction hinge at the North Sulawesi

    Trench (Cottam et al., 2011). However, the

    extremelyrapidratesandlargeamountsofuplift

    andsubsidence in the region (ca3kmand>2km

    respectively) suggest that significant flow of

    lower crust, from beneath basins towards

    topographically elevated areas, may also have

    beenacontributingfactor(Hall,2011).

    3.3 EasternSulawesiProvince

    TheeasternSulawesiProvincecomprisestheEast

    andSoutheastArms, theeasternpartof central

    Sulawesi,andthe islandofButon. Theterrain isinmanyplacesveryrugged. This,combinedwith

    thehighlytectonizednatureoftheregion,means

    thatitsgeologyisstillpoorlyunderstood.

    As discussed by Hamilton (1979), the province

    consists of several quasicentric arcuate belts,

    which are composed of, from west to east: 1)

    shearedmetamorphicrocks,2)highly tectonized

    mlange of ophiolitic, metamorphic, and

    MesozoicPaleogene rocks; the latter also

    occuring

    as

    more

    coherent

    masses;

    and

    3)

    predominantlyophioliticrocks. Afourthzoneof

    imbricated Mesozoic and Paleogene rocks that

    fringes the southeast margin of the East Arm

    belongs to theBanggaiSulaProvinceandmarks

    the collision zone between the BanggaiSula

    continentalfragmentandtheophioliteterraneof

    theEastArm. Therocksthatconstitutethefour

    zonesareunconformablyoverlainbysyntopost

    orogenic sedimentary deposits (Celebes

    Molasse).

    Metamorphic rocks form a 460km long, 80km

    wide zone, including the Pompangeo

    Metamorphic Complex in central Eastern

    Sulawesi (Parkinson, 1991; 1998), and the

    MehonggaandTeimosiMetamorphicComplexes

    in the SE Arm (Rusmana and Sukarna, 1985).

    Severalsmallermassesoccuratthesouthendof

    the SE Arm and on Kabaena Island. In central

    Sulawesi,themetamrphicbeltisboundedonthe

    west by a profound tectonic dislocation, the

  • 7/22/2019 Mineral Deposit of Sulawesi_Theo M. Van Leeuwen and Peter E. Pieters

    18/130

    18

    Median Line (Brouwer, 1947), against Western

    Sulawesi,andtotheeastitgradesintoatectonic

    mlange. In the SE Arm, the southwestern

    boundaryofthemetamorphiczoneismarkedby

    a narrow strip of ophiolite, whereas a major

    strikeslip fault (Lawanopo Fault) forms the

    northeastern boundary, separating the

    metamorphiczonefromtheophiolitezone.

    The metamorphic rocks include both blueschist

    and greenschistamphibolite facies (e.g.

    Parkinson,1998;Helmersetal.,1989;1990). In

    central Eastern Sulawesi an increase in the

    degreeofmetamorphiccrystallizationisapparent

    fromeasttowest(Brouwer,1947). Thistogether

    withthestyleofdeformationofthePompangeo

    Schists is consistent with successive

    underthrustingofslicesofdowngoingmaterialina westdipping subduction, which based on

    limited K/Ar dating of the schists probably took

    place during the midCretaceous (Parkinson,

    1991;1998). Parkinson (1998)suggeststhatthe

    protolithsofthemetamorphicsconsistsinpartof

    Jurassic sedimentary rocks, similar to the ones

    exposed in small terranes to the east. Until the

    recent discovery of gold in metamorphic rocks

    near Bombana in the SE Arm the metamorphic

    complexeswereconsideredtohavelittlemineral

    potential.

    The contact zone between the metamorphic

    rocks and the ophiolite is marked by a tectonic

    mlange in central Eastern Sulawesi, which is

    composed of a highly complex mosaic of

    tectonized and metamorphosed ophiolite

    fragments, schist fragments and variably

    disruptedMesozoicsedimentaryrocks.K/Arages

    of 2832 Ma suggest that the mlange was

    formed during the middle to late Oligocene,

    possibly as the result of eastward subduction

    beneath the ophiolite terrane, that was

    subsequently thrusted westward over the

    metamorphicbasement(Parkinson,1996).

    Largeophiolitemassesaredistributedovermost

    of the East Arm and the northwest part of the

    Southeast Arm, and on the adjacent islands of

    ButonandKabaena. Theycoverover15,000km2

    andareknownas theEastSulawesiOphioliteor

    ESO (Simandjuntak, 1986). From an economic

    pointofviewthisisthemostimportantrockunit

    in Eastern Sulawesi, as it has given rise to

    extensiveNilateritedepositsandchromitebeach

    sandsdeposits.

    A complete, but highly imbricated ophiolite

    sequence has only been observed in the East

    Arm, whereas elsewhere only the lower,

    ultramafic portion of the sequence is present.

    Theageoftheophioliteispoorlyconstrained. A

    widerangeofK/Arageshavebeenobtainedfrom

    ESO rocks, varying from Cretaceous to Miocene

    (Mubroto et al., 1994; Monnier et al., 1994;

    Simandjuntak, 1986), which are difficult to

    interpret. IthasbeensuggestedthatCretaceous

    deepmarinepelagicsedimentaryrockswhichare

    spatiallyassociatedinseveralplaceswiththeESO

    may represent the uppermost part of thesequence(e.g.Kndig,1956). Variousoriginsand

    timingofemplacementhavebeenproposed for

    theESO. It is likely,however, that theESO isa

    compositeterranewithmorethanoneoriginand

    ofdifferentages(HallandWilson,2000).

    MesozoicPaleogene sedimentary rocks are

    mostlyinterthrustorininterminablefaultcontact

    with the metamorphic basement and ophiolite

    sequencesthroughoutEasternSulawesi. Broadly

    speaking,

    they

    consist

    of

    fluvial

    to

    shallow

    marine

    siliciclastics and subordinate carbonates of late

    TriassicJurassicage thatwere formedalong the

    Australian continental margin, and Cretaceous

    Oligocene deep marine, pelagic sedimentary

    rocks,whichwere laiddownonfragmentsrifted

    from the margin and transported westwards to

    theSulawesiregion(e.g.PigramandPanggabean,

    1984;Villeneuveetal.,2001;Surono,2008).

    Synto postorogenic deposits are widely

    distributed throughout Eastern Sulawesi. They

    can be divided into clastic and carbonate

    sequenceswith coarsegrained clastic sediments

    dominating (Surono, 2008). Deposition started

    earlier in the southern part of the province

    (around the Early Miocene) than further north

    (MiddleLateMiocene).

  • 7/22/2019 Mineral Deposit of Sulawesi_Theo M. Van Leeuwen and Peter E. Pieters

    19/130

    19

    4.0 Mineraldeposits

    Inthischapterwepresentareviewofthevarious

    mineralization styles thatareknown tooccur in

    the Northern, Western and Eastern Sulawesi

    Provinces.Examplesofeachtypearedescribedin

    some detail as either individual deposits or

    mineral districts, for which a brief summary of

    their exploration history is also given. We have

    assignedthemto17categories,whichareshown

    in Figure5 togetherwith theirmap symbols for

    Figures 6, 25 and 35. In this paper we have

    adopted the most widely used nomenclature.

    The reader will be familiar with most of the

    terms,butafewneedfurtherexplanation.

    1) High, intermediate and lowsulphidation

    epithermalAu

    Ag.Thisbroadgroupofepithermal

    mineral deposits has been subjected to over a

    dozenclassificationschemessincethelate1970s,

    which in part reflects the wide range of

    characteristic features displayed by orebodies

    belonging to this group (Simmons et al., 2005).

    The currently most widely used terminology of

    high, intermediate and lowsulphidation, terms

    introducedbyHedenquist (1987),Hedenquistet

    al(2000)andEinaudietal (2003), isbasedupon

    the sulphidation state (or sulphur fugacity) of

    sulphur

    bearing

    minerals

    that

    occur

    in

    the

    epithermal mineral assemblage. Intermediate

    sulphidation isarelativelynew term,whichwas

    previously included in the lowsulphidation

    category. Sillitoe and Hedenquist (2003)

    emphasize the linkage between sulphidation

    types and volcanotectonic settings; most high

    sulphidation deposits are generated in calc

    alkalineandesiticdaciticarcsunderneutralstress

    state or mild extension conditions, and

    commonly show a close connection with

    porphyry Cu deposits; intermediatesulphidation

    deposits occur in a broadly similar environment

    but lack such close relationship; and most low

    sulphidation deposits are associated with

    volcanicsuitesinabroadspectrumofextensional

    settings.

    Corbett and Leach (1998) divided the low

    intermediate sulphidation deposits into two

    broad groups. The first group dominates in

    magmatic arcs and displays an association with

    intrusionsgradingawayfromtheintrusionsource

    as; quartzsulphideAu+/Cu, carbonatebase

    metalAu and epithemal AuAg. The second

    group,termedadulariasericiteepithermalAuAg,

    dominates in rift settings. Corbett (2007)

    subsequentlyrenamed the lattergroupbanded

    chalcedonyginguro epithermal veins. Where

    appropriatewerefertothisclassificationscheme

    inthetext.

    2)IntrusionrelatedbasemetalAu. Thiscategory

    includes vein deposits which usually contain

    significantamountsofbasemetal sulphidesand

    show,orareinferredtohave,acloseassociation

    with (porphyry) intrusions. It overlaps with the

    quartzsulphideAu+/CucategoryofCorbettand

    Leach(1998).

    3)Intrusionrelated Au. This category has been

    assigned toa fewdeposits inWesternSulawesi,

    includingAwakMas,MangkalukuandPoboya.As

    discussed below, the origin and classification of

    thesedepositsisproblematic.Wedescribethem

    in4.2.4under the (moreneutral)heading Gold

    inmetamorphicterrains

    Asformanymineraldepositsandoccurrences in

    Sulawesi there is no detailed information

    available,

    assigning

    them

    to

    a

    particular

    category

    can be quite subjective. In a few cases where

    therewastoolittletogoby,oranoccurrencedid

    notseemtofitanyofthecategories,weassigned

    themtothenotclassifiedcategory.

    For each of the three provinces we have

    prepared a map showing mineral localities and

    the names of deposits/prospects or mineral

    districts mentioned in the text. The maps were

    compiled from the Indonesian Mineral Deposit

    DataBase(vanLeeuwenandPieters(2011).

    4.1 NorthernSulawesiProvince

    Northern Sulawesi is relatively well endowed

    with mineral deposits and prospects (Figure 6).

    Asdiscussedearlieritisaregionofbothpastand

    presentgoldminingactivity.Anumberofmineral

    styles have been recognized todate. These are

    porphyryCuAuMo,high,intermediate and

  • 7/22/2019 Mineral Deposit of Sulawesi_Theo M. Van Leeuwen and Peter E. Pieters

    20/130

    20

    Figure5.MineralizationtypesfoundinSulawesiandtheirsymbolsusedinFigures6,25and35

    Figure 6. Northern Sulawesi. Distribution of mineralization types, and location of prospects and

    mineralizeddistrictsmentionedinthetext;forsymbolsseeFigure5

  • 7/22/2019 Mineral Deposit of Sulawesi_Theo M. Van Leeuwen and Peter E. Pieters

    21/130

    21

    lowsulphidation epithermal AuAg, sediment

    hosted Au, brecciahosted base metalAu

    mineralization, intrusionrelated base metalAu

    veins, FeAu skarns, and CuPbZn volcanogenic

    massive sulphides (VMS). The VMS

    mineralizationistheonlystyleassociatedwiththe

    Paleogenevolcanicactivity. All theotherswere

    formed during the Miocene and particularly

    Pliocenemagmaticepochs. Tables3and4show

    selected features of the more significant

    Northern Sulawesis porphyry copper and

    preciousmetalsystemsrespectively.

    4.1.1 PorphyryCuAuMomineralization

    More than 40 porphyrystyle deposits and

    occurrences have been identified, which

    commonlyoccurinclusters. Theycanbedividedinto two groups, Late Miocene and Pliocene.

    Their main features have been described by

    PearsonandCaira(1990).

    The Late Miocene group (e.g. Bahumbang, and

    Dunu)arehostedby irregulardykelikebodiesof

    dioritetoquartzdioritecompositionintrudedinto

    comagmatic basaltic andesite andesite

    volcanics. A central quartzbiotitemagnetite

    zonegradesoutwards to chloriteepidotecalcite

    alteration,

    and

    upwards

    to

    quartz

    sericite

    carbonateclayassemblages. Albite ispresent in

    someprospects. Advancedargillic lithocaps are

    absent. In some deposits sheeted quartz veins

    are well developed (e.g. Petulu) but most are

    characterized by quartz stockworks. The

    porphyry systems are poorly mineralized,

    showing the following zonation: central

    chalcopyrite+molybdenite pyrite+chalcopyrite

    pyrite leadzinc. Gold is associated with

    chalcopyrite. Molybdenite commonly occurs in

    earlyveins. RatherunusualisBulagidun(4.1.1.2)

    whereCuAumineralization ishostedbyaseries

    ofhydrothermalbrecciasdevelopedperipheralto

    a biotite altered, but unmineralized diorite

    complex.

    ThePliocenesystemsshowbothsimilaritiesand

    differenceswiththeMiocenesystems. Examples

    include the Tapadaa district (4.1.1.3) and

    Tombulilato district (4.1.1.4) and Taware on

    Sangihe Island (4.1.1.5). With a few exceptions

    (e.g. Taware) the Pliocene systems are better

    mineralized. They are centred on multiphase

    cylindricalstocksanddykesshowingfractionation

    to more felsic endmembers (quartz diorite to

    dacite porphyry) that are associated with co

    magmatic volcanics of dacite composition.

    Diatreme breccias are commonly present.

    Alteration zonation consists of a central quartz

    albitemagnetitebiotitechlorite core, an outer

    chloriteactinolitemagnetite zone,andanupper

    sericitekaolinitealunitediaspore zone. Quartz

    sulphide stockworks are well developed. Higher

    gold grades show a strong association with

    bornite,magnetiteandchalcopyriteinthecentral

    zone thatgradeoutwards toa pyrite zone with

    supergenechalcocite. Au:Curatiosarerelatively

    high.

    4.1.1.1 Bahumbung

    Bahumbung is the only Miocene porphyry Cu

    prospect thathasbeendescribed insomedetail

    (Lubis et al., 2011). It consists of several

    mineralizedcentresupto500x400mindiameter.

    The area was identified during Newcrests

    regionalexplorationprogrammeinthelate1990s

    asaCuAuanomaly. Itwasinvestigatedinmore

    detail by Ivanhoe Mines Ltd in the late 2000s,

    including

    groundmagnetics

    and

    drilling

    of

    3

    deep

    holes(1,544m)and13shallowholes(561m).

    The prospect area is underlain largely by

    andesitic lava, tuff and volcanic breccias

    belonging to theBilungalaVolcanics. Theseare

    accompanied by minor dacitic volcanics and

    intruded by multiple intrusives ranging in

    compositionfromdioritetoaplite. Threediorite

    units have been recognized, referred to as Old,

    IntermediateandYoungDiorite.

    TheOldDiorite (onlydetected intwodrillholes)

    ischaracterizedbystrongalteration(potassicand

    pale green mica), moderate to high density

    quartz stockwork, and moderate copper grades

    (0.3%0.4%). The Intermediate Diorite has a

    lowerdensityofquartzstockwork(upto3%)and

    lower copper grades (0.10.3%), and is

    moderately altered (PMG). The Young Diorite

    occurs as latemineral dykes with low sulphide

    andCucontents,

  • 7/22/2019 Mineral Deposit of Sulawesi_Theo M. Van Leeuwen and Peter E. Pieters

    22/130

    22

    Potassicalterationhasaffectedmoststronglythe

    Old Diorite and andesitic wall rocks. Very fine

    grained secondary biotite and magnetite

    completely replace mafic minerals, and are

    intergrown with actinolite in veinlets. The

    alteration is associated with quartz stockwork

    zones, varying in intensity from 3 to 10%, and

    0.4%)havebeenobtainedfromstronglyaltered

    andesiticwall rocks adjacent to the Old Diorite.

    Palegreenmicaalterationischaracterizedbythe

    presence of shreddy chlorite and green sericite,

    which replace earlier secondary biotite and

    primary feldspar. In rocks that are not tooweathered chalcopyrite and pyrite can be

    observed.

    Sericitechloritemagnetite alteration is

    associated with the Young Diorite. Mafics are

    replacedbychloriteandmagnetiteaccompanied

    byvariousamountsofpyrite. Primary feldspars

    are partially or totally altered to sericite. This

    alterationassemblage isprominent inore zones

    ofanumberofmajorPhilippineporphyryCuAg

    deposits

    (Sillitoe

    and

    Gappe,

    1984),

    but

    at

    Bahumbung contains only very little

    chalcopyrite.Molybdenite appears to be mostly

    associated with sericitechloriteclay alteration

    overprintingpotassicalteration.

    4.1.1.2 Bulagidundistrict(Figure7)

    This district is located 170km WNW from

    Gorontaloand10kminlandfromthenorthcoast.

    It is the largest known Miocene system in

    Northern Sulawesi, covering an area of 50km2,

    and encompassing five separate prospects of

    porphyry, vein and skarn styles, of which the

    largest known is the Bulagidun prospect. The

    districtisoutlinedbya790ppmCu80#stream

    sediment anomaly, while Au anomalism is

    centredonBulagidun,andPbandZnanomalies

    are related to peripheral vein systems. It is

    coveredbydense tropical rain forestwith steep

    relief(500to1700m).

    Thedistrictwas identified in1987byBHPduring

    followup of stream sediment and panned

    concentrategeochemicalanomalies. Systematic

    exploration until 1991, including ~8000m of

    drillingoutlinedageologicalresourceof14.4Mt

    @ 0.68 g/t Au and 0.61% Cu in three separate

    breccia bodies. Further investigations were

    carried out by Newcrest and Cyprus in 199697

    involving detailed surface work and drilling

    (Bulagidun,2793m;Matinan9,760m;Matinan6,

    1484m). The results of the two campaigns are

    discussed by Lubis et al. (1994), PT Newcrest

    Nusa Sulawesi (1999) and Pearson and Caira

    (1999).

    ThegeologycomprisesadeeplyerodedMiocene

    volcanic centre within a sequence of

    volcaniclastics and immature sediments coveredby andesite lava, which in turn is overlain by

    andesite pyroclastics and volcanogenic

    conglomerates. Two samples of unaltered

    andesitelavayieldedKArwholerockagesof9.4

    Ma. The sequence is intruded by a sequential

    fractionation intrusive suite consisting of seven

    partially superimposed plutons that range in

    composition from pyroxenebiotite diorite to

    quartzbiotite feldspar porphyry and aplite.

    Limited whole rock analyses presented by Lubis

    et

    al.

    (1994)

    suggest

    that

    the

    igneous

    rocks

    in

    the

    BulagidunareabelongtothemediumandhighK

    calcalkalineseries.

    A regional scale NNWtrending arc normal

    structurepassesthroughthewesternpartofthe

    system. A setofNEtrending faultsbracket this

    system linking it across to another arc normal

    structure, 20km to the east. Intrusive bodies

    forming aligned circular features, 2 to 4km in

    diameter, are centred on the Bulagidun and

    Matinan prospect areas, suggesting a collapsed

    magma chamber at depth. Mineralization is

    strongly controlled by EW structures and

    intersections with crosscutting NS structures.

    This pattern is consistent with dextral

    transpressuring of the arc normal structures.

    Twelve breccia pipes have been mapped in the

    system.

    The Bulagidun/Matinan alteration system

    extendsover7k min an EN Edirectionwitha

  • 7/22/2019 Mineral Deposit of Sulawesi_Theo M. Van Leeuwen and Peter E. Pieters

    23/130

    23

    Figure7.SimplifiedgeologicalmapofBulagidundistrictandprospect locations (modifiedafterPT

    Newcrest

    Nusa

    Sulawesi,

    1999)

    Figure 8. Simplified geological map of Tapadaa district and prospect locations (modified after PT

    NewcrestNusaSulawesi,1999)

  • 7/22/2019 Mineral Deposit of Sulawesi_Theo M. Van Leeuwen and Peter E. Pieters

    24/130

    24

    Figure9.SimplifiedgeologicalmapofTombulilatodistrictandprospect locations

    (modifiedafterPerello,1994)

    Figure10.CartoonshowingporphyryCudepositstylesintheTombulilatodistrict

  • 7/22/2019 Mineral Deposit of Sulawesi_Theo M. Van Leeuwen and Peter E. Pieters

    25/130

    25

    width of 3km. It is concentrically zoned with a

    biotite core (2000mx300m) surrounded by an

    albitemagnetite zone thatgradesoutwards into

    an albitesericitepyrite assemblage. Another

    shell of epidotechloritecalcite surrounds these

    assemblages. Sericiteclay

    chloritequartzcarbonate alteration, both

    pervasiveandstructurallycontrolled,crosscutall

    theearlyassemblages. WholerockKArdatingof

    thisassemblageyieldedanageof8.75Ma. Late

    stage claypyrite alteration occurs as narrow

    zones along faults and fractures. Disseminated

    blebs and fracture fillings of radiating black

    tourmaline are found in biotite magnetite and

    sericiteclaychlorite altered rocks. It typically

    constitutes 12% of the rocks, but locally may

    attainvaluesof1020%.

    StylesofhypogeneCuAumineralization include

    a porphyryrelated collapsedrawing down

    brecciainfillinatleast7brecciapipes(Bulagidun)

    and disseminated mineralization controlled by

    microlitic cavities in the causative intrusions,

    representing orthomagmatic mineralization

    (Matinan9). Drillingofthemainbrecciapipehas

    demonstratedthatthemineralizationextendsto

    greater than 500m depth. The dominant

    sulphides are chalcopyrite and pyrite (largely in

    veinlets

    and

    breccia

    matrix).

    Molybdenite

    is

    locally abundant, whereas bornite, galena and

    sphalerite are rare. Gold is associated with

    chalcopyrite and pyrite in solid solution or as

    minuteintergrowths.

    Breccias are fragment supported with angular

    fragments ranging in size from cm to 10s of m

    withlittleornorockflourmatrixandnoevidence

    ofhydrothermalstreamingorfragmentedmilling.

    The breccia void spaces are filled with coarse

    grained, pegmatitic, hydrothermal minerals,

    whichhavea remarkably consistentparagenesis

    across the system, from earliest to latest;

    magnetite (replaced by specularite in places),

    apatite, biotite (partly replaced by chlorite),

    molybdenite, quartz, tourmaline, chalcopyrite,

    galena, pyrite, ankerite. A characteristic of the

    Bulagidun district is the apparent lack of quartz

    stockworkdevelopmentassociatedwithzonesof

    CuAu mineralization. Preliminary fluid inclusion

    studiesshowawiderangeofhomogenenization

    temperatures (180oC to 700oC) and salinities,

    suggesting multiple separate stages of

    hydrothermal fluid and mixing between saline

    magmaticanddilutemeteoricfluids.

    Quartz veins,partly sheeted,occuradjacent (up

    to 500m lateral distance) to the mineralized

    breccias. They are up to 2m thick and contain

    minorsphaleriteandgalena. Inexcessof10g/t

    Auwas recorded in surface samples,but indrill

    holesonly0.52g/tAuwasobtained. Insome

    placesmeterwidezonesofabundanttourmaline

    occurincloseproximity.

    A large tabular body of magnetiteepidote

    garnetpyrrhotite skarn (Matinan6) is found

    within the propylitic zone, 2km to the NNW of

    thecentralCuAuzoneatBulagidun. Itcontainspatchygoldmineralizationinnativeform.

    4.1.1.3 Tapadaadistrict(Figure8)

    Discovered in1971byEndeavourResources,the

    district was investigated in some detail by

    Kennecott between 1972 and 1974, including

    1,222mofdiamonddrilling. Four smallsystems

    were outlined (Tapadaa South, Central and

    North, and Mogi Wapo), each containing

    between

    2

    and

    15

    Mt

    @

    0.2

    0.4%

    Cu

    in

    primary

    ore and a total of 20 Mt @ 0.61.0% Cu in

    supergeneenrichedore(vanLeeuwen,1994). In

    1994,NewcrestobtainedalargeCOWareawhich

    included the Tapadaa district. It undertook

    regionaltoprospectscalesurfacework,whichled

    tothediscoveryofafifthsystem,TapadaaWest.

    The best result obtained was 252m of chip

    sampling averaging 0.39% Cu and 0.13 g/t at

    TapadaaSouth.

    LiteratureontheTapadaadistrict inludespapers

    byLowderandDow(1977;1978)andareportby

    PTNewcrestNusaSulawesi(1999).

    ThedistrictgeologyconsistsofMioceneBilungala

    Volcanics, which are primarily andesitic to lithic

    tuffs. They have been intruded by a series of

    porphyritic diorite stocks and dykes on the

    western margin of the Miocene Bone batholith.

    These have been subdivided into premineral

    weakly porphyritic diorites, synmineral quartz

  • 7/22/2019 Mineral Deposit of Sulawesi_Theo M. Van Leeuwen and Peter E. Pieters

    26/130

    26

    diorite plugs and quartzdacite porphyry dykes,

    and postmineral andesite porphyry dykes.

    Pleistocene Pinogu dacite tuffs (some with

    mineralized clasts) unconformably overlie much

    ofthearea,includingpartofthemineralizationat

    TapadaaNorthandCentral.

    TheTapadaaprospectsliewithina>90mppmCu

    elliptical halo defined by stream sediment

    sampling. Internal to this isa>4ppmMohalo,

    thatonly includes Mogi Wapo. PlotsofCuand

    Au in rock show small Au bull eyes (>0.1 ppm)

    within largerCu (>500ppm) zones. AtTapadaa

    West the largest Au anomaly measures

    460mx400m. Porphyry mineralization appears

    almost continuous from Tapadaa South through

    to Tapadaa North, except where obscured by

    postmineral Pinogu Volcanics over an area of100300m by 3000m. Mogi Wapo measures

    about200mx1000m, andTapadaaWest has the

    smallest exposure (200x400m). Mapping by

    Newcrest has shown that the Tapadaa West

    mineralization is hosted by the Bilungala

    Volcanics,andnotbydioriteintrusiveasthought

    by previous explorers. This introduces the

    possibilityofa largerconcealed intrusivehosted

    system.

    The

    porphyry

    prospects

    occur

    in

    a

    NW

    trending

    structurally controlled blocks. Copper

    mineralization isassociatedwithearlyalteration

    consisting predominantly of quartzchlorite

    biotiteanhydrite, and in areas of better grades

    (0.20.4%)alsogreensericiteandalbitetogether

    withalbitequartzandmagnetitequartzveinlets.

    TwosecondarybiotitesamplesyieldedKArages

    of5and2.5Ma. Sulphidecontents(chalcopyrite,

    bornite,pyrite)are typically low. Sulphidesand

    magnetite are present mostly as fracture infill,

    andalsoasdisseminationsandinquartzveinlets.

    There appears to be a positive correlation

    between primary Cu grades and magnetite

    concentrations.

    The early alterationmineralization assemblages

    areoverprintedbysericite+quartzorclay,quartz

    sericitediaspore, and/or andalusitepyrophyllite

    assemblages. Corundum and specularite are

    associatedwithhighpyritecontents. Supergene

    blankets,up to30m thick,are locallydeveloped

    underlying of strongly leached pyritic zones in

    advancedargillicrock.

    4.1.1.4 Tombulilatodistrict(Figure9)

    TheTombulilatodistricthasbeenanexploration

    teaserformanyyears. Followingitsdiscoveryin

    1971byEndeavourResources,Kennecottcarried

    out exploration between 1972 and 1975 which

    ledtothediscoveryofCabangKiriwhere1,070m

    [email protected]%Cu

    and 0.75 g/t Au, Kayubulan Ridge with an

    estimated [email protected]%

    Cuand 0.35 g/tAubased on surface data only,

    and Cabang Kanan. Following Kennecotts

    withdrawal in1976,Endeavourdrilled6holesat

    Kayubulan Ridge, one of which intersected

    significant mineralization. Between 1980 and1982 Utah International embarked on a major

    exploration programme involving 5 drilling rigs

    and2helicopters. Thethreeknowndepositsplus

    a new discovery, Sungai Mak, were drill tested

    (~1600m)outliningacombinedresourcesof296

    Mt @ 0.57% Cu and 0.47 g/t Au. The original

    Endeavour COW was terminated in 1986. Two

    years later BHP entered into a JV with Antam

    whichobtainedtwosocalledsuperKPsoverthe

    district. In 1991, a national park was declared

    over

    the

    area

    and

    all

    work

    ceased.

    After

    a

    2

    year

    exploration permit was obtained from the

    MinisterofForestry in1996BHPembarkedona

    heliborne magnetic survey, which identified a

    numberofanomalies,twoofwhichappeared to

    beassociatedwithpreviouslyunknownporphyry

    stylemineralization,i.e.GunungLintahandWest

    Kayubulan Ridge. Because of uncertainties

    pertainingtothenationalparkandotherreasons

    BHPwithdrewinlate1997. Recentlythedistrict

    was excised from the park and exploration title

    wasawardedtoBumiResources.

    TheTombulilatodistrict(LowderandDow,1978;

    CarlileandKirkegaard,1985;Carlileetal.,1990;

    Perello, 1994; BHP Minerals Sulawesi, 1997) is

    composed of a >3400m thick volcano

    sedimentary sequence in which three main

    stratigraphic units are recognized: i) Bilungala

    Volcanics (Upper Miocene base Pliocene)

    divided intoa LowerMember (tholeiiticbasaltic

    and spilitic volcanics), Middle Member

  • 7/22/2019 Mineral Deposit of Sulawesi_Theo M. Van Leeuwen and Peter E. Pieters

    27/130

    27

    (alternating andesitic and felsic volcanics with

    minor sedimentary intercalations), and Upper

    Member (subaerial andesitic fragmental

    volcanics); ii) Motomboto Volcanics (Upper

    Pliocene), which consists of subaerial felsic to

    intermediatevolcanic rocks; iii)PinoguVolcanics

    (Pleistocene), characterized by poorly

    consolidated, subaerial bimodal volcanics.The

    sequence is intruded by strongly porphyritic

    bodies of andesitic to dacitic composition, and

    equigranular bodies of granodioritic to dioritic

    composition. Field relationshipsand twowhole

    rocksKAragesof2.35and2.05Ma suggests a

    LatePlioceneagefortheseintrusions. Afoliated

    granodioriteexposedintheNEpartofthedistrict

    isprobablyMiddleMiocene(orolder).

    The structure of the Tombulilato district ischaracterized by northerly striking highangle

    faults, normally a few metres wide and

    containing