Midland vs. Madden Amicus Brief by Solicitor General

8/16/2019 Midland vs. Madden Amicus Brief by Solicitor General

1/25

!"# %&'(%)

!" $%& '()*&+& ,-(*$ -. $%& /">$&5 '$6$&4

"#$%&'$ ()'$#'*+ %%,+ -. &%/+ >-.#.#5'-64

!"

4 &%#


2/25

0#9

26-,/! ;+--4

;=:8=:N 8=: 'E8FDLEO 1ELC &A8+ BK )/4/,/ B 3: 03Q"+ G=FA= @N::I@8M M8E8: JMJNH OEGM N:^JOE8FL^ 8=: FL8:NU:M8 E LE8FDLEO VELC IEH A=EN^: DL E ODEL+ ADL8FLJ:M 8D=ET: @N::I@8FT: :\\:A8 E\8:N 8=: LE8FDLEO VELC =EM

MDO_ DN D8=:NGFM: EMMF^L:_ 8=: ODEL 8D ELD8=:N :L8F8H/


3/25

0###9

>?*7- /. 1/!>-!><

>E^:

#L8:N:M8 D\ 8=: )LF8:_ 48E8:M/////////////////////////////////////////////////////// B48E8:I:L8 ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// B$FMAJMMFDL ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// S

,DLAOJMFDL /////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// KB

>?*7- /. ?6>5/+,>,-<

,EM:MQ

^LN73:: ^L7R 21 [LN?27 .7:8"F $"," T/ $39027+SBR )/4/ KS 0B[[W9 /////////////////////////////////////////////////// BP+ BB+ BY

^3731?E?L9 $L:W9 ^L7R T/ ,7@3N027+ SY[ )/4/ B 0KPPY9 //////// K

*5). T/ 4L::?O2N3 4L7@ .2N="+ WSW (/K_ BY[0S8= ,FN/ B[]B9 ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// BZ+ BW+ BR

GL?:


4/25

#7

48E8J8:M EL_ N:^JOE8FDLMn,DL8FLJ:_Q >E^:

$D__U(NELC ;EOO 48N::8 6:\DNI EL_ ,DLMJI:N>ND8:A8FDL &A8+ >JV/ %/ 'D/ BBBUKPY+ X BPZZ0\

9+

BKZ 48E8/ KPBR 0AD_F\F:_ E8 BK )/4/,/ KSV0\ 99 //////////////////// BB(EFN $:V8 ,DOO:A8FDL >NEA8FA:M &A8+ BS )/4/,/ BW[K

3: 03Q" """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" Y

'E8FDLEO 1ELC &A8+ BK )/4/,/ B 3: 03Q" ////////////////////////////////// B

BK )/4/,/ KZ04:T:L8=9 ///////////////////////////////////// W+ BB+ BY+ B[

BK )/4/,/ KSV0\

9 /////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// BB

BK )/4/,/ ]S ///////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// =L00?O

BK )/4/,/ ]W //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// K+ Z+ R

'/?/ 1ELCFL^ %EG X BZUE0B9 0"A3FLL:H KPBY9 ///////////////////// Y

'/?/ *:L/ 5VOF^/ %EG X SUSPB 0"A3FLL:H KPBK9 /////////////////// Y

'/?/ >:LEO %EG X B[P/ZP 0"A3FLL:H KPBP9 /////////////////////////// YBK ,/(/6/Q

4:A8FDL R/ZPPB0E9 //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// R

4:A8FDL R/ZPPB0V9 //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// R

4:A8FDL R/ZPP] ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// BB


5/25

0B9

" $%& '()*&+& ,-(*$ -. $%& /">$&5 '$6$&4

'D/ BSUWBP

"#$%&'$ ()'$#'*+ %%,+ -. &%/+ >-.#.#5'-64

!"

4 &%#


6/25

K

8=: OEGM D\ 8=: 48E8:+ .:NNF8DNH+ DN $FM8NFA8 G=:N: 8=:VELC FM ODAE8:_+l DN E NE8: E8 DL: @:NA:L8 EVDT: 8=:(:_:NEO 6:M:NT: _FMADJL8 NE8:+ G=FA=:T:N FM =F^=:N+dEL_ LD IDN:/l .=FM @NDTFMFDL EOODGM E LE8FDLEO VELC8=E8 D@:NE8:M FL IELH 48E8:M 8D A=EN^: FL8:N:M8 FL EOOD\ 8=DM: 48E8:M J@ 8D 8=: NE8: @:NIF88:_ VH 8=: VELCeM=DI: 48E8:/ 4:A8FDL ]W @NDTF_:M EL :fAOJMFT: \:_:NEOAEJM: D\ EA8FDL \DN CLDGFL^OH d8ECFL^+ N:A:FTFL^+ N:UM:NTFL^+ DN A=EN^FL^ E NE8: D\ FL8:N:M8 ^N:E8:N 8=EL FMEOODG:_ VH M:A8FDL ]S/l BK )/4/,/ ]Wo M:: ^3731?E?L9

$L:W9 ^L7R T/ ,7@3N027+ SY[ )/4/ B+ BPUBB 0KPPY9 0=DO_UFL^ 8=E8 4:A8FDL ]W ADI@O:8:OH @N::I@8M M8E8: JMJNHOEG9/

K/ #L KPPS+ N:M@DL_:L8+ G=D OFT:_ FL ':G ?DNC+

D@:L:_ E AN:_F8 AEN_ EAADJL8 GF8= 1ELC D\ &I:NFAE+E LE8FDLEO VELC/ >:8/ &@@/ YE/ #L KPPW+ 1ELC D\ &I:NUFAEeM AN:_F8UAEN_ @ND^NEI GEM ADLMDOF_E8:_ FL8D (#&,EN_ 4:NTFA:M+ '/&/ 0(#&9+ E LE8FDLEO VELC EL_ G=DOOHUDGL:_ MJVMF_FENH D\ 1ELC D\ &I:NFAE/ )@" E8 YE+ KZE/

;=:L 8=: ODEL GEM 8NELM\:NN:_+ (#& EI:L_:_ 8=:EAADJL8eM 8:NIM EL_ ADL_F8FDLM/ )@" E8 YE/ (DN @JN@DM:MD\ 4:A8FDL ]S+ (#& FM ODAE8:_ FL $:OEGEN:+ M:: >:8/ Ro1N/ FL 5@@/ Z+ EL_ 8=: EI:L_:_ E^N::I:L8 FLAOJ_:_ E$:OEGEN: A=DFA:UD\UOEG AOEJM:+ >:8/ &@@/ YE+ BZE c L/Z"

6:M@DL_:L8 MJVM:aJ:L8OH _:\EJO8:_ DL =:N (#&

AN:_F8UAEN_ EAADJL8+ DGFL^ E@@NDfFIE8:OH bSYPP/ >:8/ &@@/ YE+ KSE/ (#& GND8: D\\ 8=: _:V8 EM JLADOO:A8EVO:EL_ MDO_ 8=: _:V8 8D @:8F8FDL:N "F_OEL_ (JL_FL^+ %%,/

)@" E8 YE/ >:8F8FDL:N "F_OEL_ ,N:_F8 "ELE^:I:L8+ #LA/+M:NTFA:M "F_OEL_ (JL_FL^eM EAADJL8M/ )Z?@" ':F8=:N@:8F8FDL:N FM E LE8FDLEO VELC/ )Z?@"

#L KPBP+ "F_OEL_ ,N:_F8 "ELE^:I:L8 M:L8 N:UM@DL_:L8 E O:88:N M::CFL^ 8D ADOO:A8 @EHI:L8 DL 8=:AN:_F8UAEN_ _:V8/ >:8/ &@@/ ZE/ .=: O:88:N M8E8:_ 8=E8


7/25

Y

E KRk FL8:N:M8 NE8: E@@OF:_ 8D 8=: _:V8/ )@" E8 ZE+ KSE/ & KRk FL8:N:M8 NE8: FM @:NIF88:_ JL_:N $:OEGEN: OEG+VJ8 FM JMJNFDJM JL_:N ':G ?DNC OEG/ )@" E8 BSE+ KSEoM:: '/?/ *:L/ 5VOF^/ %EG X SUSPB 0"A3FLL:H KPBK90M:88FL^ Wk FL8:N:M8 NE8: dJLO:MM E _F\\:N:L8 NE8: FM@N:MANFV:_ FL M:A8FDL \DJN8::LUE D\ 8=: VELCFL^ OEGl9o'/?/ 1ELCFL^ %EG X BZUE0B9 0"A3FLL:H KPBY9 0M:88FLÎEfFIJI @:NIFMMFVO: FL8:N:M8 NE8: E8 BWk9o M:: EOMD'/?/ >:LEO %EG X B[P/ZP 0"A3FLL:H KPBP9 0N:A:FTFL^FL8:N:M8 E8 NE8: :fA::_FL^ KSk FM ANFIFLEO JMJNH9/

Y/ 6:M@DL_:L8 MJ:_ @:8F8FDL:NM FL \:_:NEO _FM8NFA8ADJN8/ 6:M@DL_:L8 EOO:^:_ 8=E8 @:8F8FDL:NMe E88:I@8 8DA=EN^: KRk FL8:N:M8 DL 8=: _:V8 \DN 8=: @:NFD_ E\8:N F8

GEM EMMF^L:_ VH (#& TFDOE8:_ ':G ?DNCeM AFTFO EL_

ANFIFLEO JMJNH OEGM EL_ 8=: (EFN $:V8 ,DOO:A8FDL>NEA8FA:M &A8 0($,>&9+ BS )/4/,/ BW[K 3: 03Q" >:8/ &@@/ ZE/ >:8F8FDL:NM MDJ^=8 MJIIENH gJ_Î:L8 DL 8=:^NDJL_ 8=E8 8=: '1& @N::I@8M N:M@DL_:L8eM M8E8:UOEGJMJNH AOEFI 0EL_ =:N ($,>& AOEFI 8D 8=: :f8:L8 8=E8F8 _:@:L_M DL 8=: EOO:^:_ M8E8:UOEG TFDOE8FDL9/ )@" E8BEUKE/

.=: _FM8NFA8 ADJN8 ^NEL8:_ MJIIENH gJ_Î:L8 8D@:8F8FDL:NM+ =DO_FL^ 8=E8 N:M@DL_:L8eM AOEFIM G:N:@N::I@8:_ VH 8=: '1&/ >:8/ &@@/ KE/B .=: ADJN8 _:U8:NIFL:_ 8=E8+ dV:AEJM: (#& FM E LE8FDLEO VELC :L8FU

8O:_ 8D :f:I@8FDL \NDI M8E8: JMJNH OEGM+ `@:8F8FDL:NMiEN: :L8F8O:_ 8D 8=: MEI: F\ 8=:H EN: (#&eM EMMF^L::M/l

)@" E8 K]E/ .D N:EA= 8=E8 ADLAOJMFDL+ 8=: ADJN8 N:OF:_

B ;=:L 8=: _FM8NFA8 ADJN8 _:AF_:_ 8=: @N::I@8FDL aJ:M8FDL FL@:8F8FDL:NMe \ETDN+ F8 FLF8FEOOH =:O_ 8=E8 _FM@J8:_ \EA8JEO FMMJ:M@N:AOJ_:_ E N̂EL8 D\ MJIIENH gJ_Î:L8/ 4:: >:8/ &@@/ K]E+ YREUY]E+ Z[EUSPE/ .=: @EN8F:M 8=:L :L8:N:_ FL8D E M8F@JOE8FDL N:ÊN_FL^8=DM: \EA8M+ EL_ 8=: _FM8NFA8 ADJN8 :L8:N:_ gJ_Î:L8 \DN @:8F8FDL:NM/ )@" E8 SBEUSSE/


8/25

Z

DL _:AFMFDLM MJA= EM &


9/25

S

EIDJL8 E LE8FDLEO VELC ADJO_ A=EN^: \DN F8M ADLMJI:N_:V8 FL A:N8EFL M8E8:M+l MJA= EL :\\:A8 dGDJO_ LD8 jMF^ULF\FAEL8OH FL8:N\:N:e GF8= 8=: :f:NAFM: D\ E LE8FDLEOVELC @DG:N/l )@" E8 BPEUBBE/ .=: ADJN8 \JN8=:N =:O_8=E8 F8 GDJO_ V: EL dDT:NOH VNDE_ E@@OFAE8FDL D\ 8=:'1&l 8D d:f8:L_`i `F8Mi @ND8:A8FDLMl 8D dLDLULE8FDLEOVELC :L8F8F:M 8=E8 EN: LD8 EA8FL^ DL V:=EO\ D\ E LE8FDLUEO VELC/l )@" E8 BBE/

(FLEOOH+ 8=: ADJN8 _FM8FL^JFM=:_ ]N?0=?7+ 0;=NL+EL_ &


10/25

W

OH @ND=FVF8 E LE8FDLEO VELCeM EMMF^L:: \NDI :L\DNAFL^8=: FL8:N:M8UNE8: 8:NI D\ E _:V8 E^N::I:L8 8=E8 GEM

TEOF_ JL_:N 8=: OEG D\ 8=: 48E8: FL G=FA= 8=: LE8FDLEOVELC FM ODAE8:_/ 1J8 8=:N: FM LD AFNAJF8 M@OF8 DL 8=:aJ:M8FDL @N:M:L8:_o 8=: @EN8F:M _F_ LD8 @N:M:L8 C:HEM@:A8M D\ 8=: @N::I@8FDL ELEOHMFM 8D 8=: ADJN8M V:UODGo EL_ @:8F8FDL:NM IEH M8FOO @N:TEFO DL N:IEL_ _:UM@F8: 8=: :NNDN FL 8=: ADJN8 D\ E@@:EOMe FL8:NODAJ8DNH_:AFMFDL/ (DN EOO D\ 8=DM: N:EMDLM+ \JN8=:N N:TF:G FMLD8 GENNEL8:_/

B/ .=: ADJN8 D\ E@@:EOMe _:AFMFDL FM FLADNN:A8/>ND@:NOH JL_:NM8DD_+ E LE8FDLEO VELCeM 4:A8FDL ]SEJ8=DNF8H 8D A=EN^: FL8:N:M8 J@ 8D 8=: IEfFIJI @:NUIF88:_ VH F8M =DI: 48E8: :LADI@EMM:M 8=: @DG:N 8D

ADLT:H 8D EL EMMF^L:: 8=: NF^=8 8D :L\DNA: 8=: FL8:N:M8UNE8: 8:NI D\ 8=: E^N::I:L8/ .=E8 JL_:NM8EL_FL^ FMN:FL\DNA:_ VH BK )/4/,/ KZ04:T:L8=9+ G=FA= F_:L8F\F:M8=: @DG:N 8D M:OO ODELM EM EL E__F8FDLEO @DG:N D\ LEU8FDLEO VELCM/ .=: ADJN8 D\ E@@:EOM E@@:EN:_ 8D ADLUAOJ_: 8=E8+ MD ODL^ EM E@@OFAE8FDL D\ ':G ?DNC JMJNHOEG 8D @:8F8FDL:NMe ADOO:A8FDL EA8FTF8F:M GDJO_ LD8 :LU8FN:OH @N:T:L8 LE8FDLEO VELCM \NDI M:OOFL^ ADLMJI:N_:V8+ M8E8: OEG FM LD8 @N::I@8:_/ 4:: >:8/ &@@/ BPEUBBE/ .=E8 ELEOHMFM N:\O:A8M E IFMJL_:NM8EL_FL^ D\4:A8FDL ]S EL_ D\ 8=FM ,DJN8eM @N:A:_:L8M/

E/ .=: '1& @N:MANFV:M 8=: FL8:N:M8 NE8: 8=E8 E LEU8FDLEO VELC IEH A=EN^: F8M ODEL AJM8DI:NM EL_ :M8EVUOFM=:M EL :fAOJMFT: \:_:NEO AEJM: D\ EA8FDL \DN JMJNH/#L @EN8FAJOEN+ 4:A8FDL ]S @:NIF8M EL dEMMDAFE8FDL+l ?"3"+E LE8FDLEO VELC+ 8D dA=EN^: DL ELH ODEL h h h FLU8:N:M8 E8 8=: NE8: EOODG:_ VH 8=: OEGM D\ 8=: 48E8:+.:NNF8DNH+ DN $FM8NFA8 G=:N: 8=: VELC FM ODAE8:_+l DN ENE8: DL: @:NA:L8 EVDT: 8=: (:_:NEO 6:M:NT: _FMADJL8NE8:+ G=FA=:T:N FM =F^=:N+ dEL_ LD IDN:/l BK )/4/,/


11/25

R

]S/ K 4:A8FDL ]W :M8EVOFM=:M EL :fAOJMFT: \:_:NEO AEJM:D\ EA8FDL+ EL_ M@:AF\F:M 8=: E@@OFAEVO: @:LEO8F:M+ \DN 8=:ADOO:A8FDL D\ FL8:N:M8 ^N:E8:N 8=EL 8=E8 EOODG:_ VH4:A8FDL ]S/ 4:: BK )/4/,/ ]W 0CLDGFL^OH A=EN^FL^FL8:N:M8 EVDT: 8=: NE8: @:NIF88:_ VH 4:A8FDL ]S dM=EOOV: _::I:_ E \DN\:F8JN: D\ 8=: :L8FN: FL8:N:M8 G=FA= 8=:LD8:+ VFOO+ DN D8=:N :TF_:LA: D\ _:V8 AENNF:M GF8= F8+lEL_ 8=: _:V8DN IEH N:ADT:N \NDI 8=: LE8FDLEO VELCd8GFA: 8=: EIDJL8 D\ 8=: FL8:N:M8 8=JM @EF_l9/

.=: :\\:A8 D\ 8=:M: @NDTFMFDLM FM 8D M:8 E IEfFIJIFL8:N:M8 NE8: 8=E8 E LE8FDLEO VELC IEH A=EN^: 08=: NE8:EOODG:_ VH F8M =DI: 48E8:9 EL_ 8D @N:AOJ_: ELH 48E8:D8=:N 8=EL 8=: DL: G=:N: 8=: LE8FDLEO VELC FM ODAE8:_\NDI FI@DMFL^ E ODG:N IEfFIJI FL8:N:M8 NE8:/ 4::

[LNQ;3::3 $L:W9 ^L7R 21 [?773L=29?0 T/ *?N0: 21 #OHL


12/25

]

M:OO ODELM GEM E dL:A:MMENFOH FI@OF:_l ADNDOOENH D\ 8=:@DG:N 8D DNF^FLE8: ODELM/ &9L7:3N0W ^L7R 21 [?00" T/

6


13/25

[

V/ 6:M@DL_:L8eM M8E8:UOEG JMJNH AOEFI FM @N::I@8U:_ VH 4:A8FDL ]S V:AEJM: F8 _FN:A8OH FL8:N\:N:M GF8= ELE8FDLEO VELCeM EJ8=DNF8H 8D IEC: EL_ 8NELM\:N ODELME8 8=: @:NIF88:_ NE8: D\ FL8:N:M8/ .=: AN:_F8UAEN_ _:V8E8 FMMJ: FL 8=FM AEM: GEM DNF^FLE8:_ VH (#&+ E LE8FDLEOVELC 8=E8 FM ODAE8:_ FL $:OEGEN:/ Y (#&eM ADL8NEA8 GF8=N:M@DL_:L8 M@:AF\F:_ E KRk NE8: D\ FL8:N:M8+ G=FA= 8=:@EN8F:M E^N:: GEM @:NIFMMFVO: JL_:N $:OEGEN: OEG/>:8/ &@@/ BSE/ &AADN_FLÔH+ DLA: N:M@DL_:L8 _:\EJO8U:_ DL 8=: _:V8+ (#& GEM :L8F8O:_ 8D A=EN^: KRk FL8:NU:M8 ^DFL^ \DNGEN_ DL 8=: EAAJIJOE8:_ VEOELA:/

#LM8:E_ D\ ADL8FLJFL^ 8D E88:I@8 8D ADOO:A8 DL 8=:_:V8+ (#& MDO_ 8=: _:V8 8D @:8F8FDL:NM/ &M (#&eM EMUMF^L::M+ @:8F8FDL:NM G:N: :L8F8O:_ 8D A=EN^: 8=: MEI:

FL8:N:M8 NE8: 8=E8 (#& ADJO_ =ET: A=EN^:_ JL_:N 8=:AN:_F8UAEN_ E^N::I:L8 EL_ $:OEGEN: OEG/ .D 8=: :fU8:L8 8=E8 ':G ?DNC OEG :M8EVOFM=:M E ODG:N IEfFIJIFL8:N:M8 NE8:+ E@@OFAE8FDL D\ 8=E8 OFIF8 8D (#&eM EMMF^LU::M GDJO_ FI@EFN 8=: LE8FDLEO VELCeM \:_:NEOOH N:ADÛLFm:_ EJ8=DNF8H 8D DNF^FLE8: EL_ 8NELM\:N ODELM E8 8=:NE8: @:NIF88:_ VH 8=: '1&/ &L_+ FL 8=: E^^N:Ê8:+8=: IENC:8EVFOF8H 0EL_ 8=:N:\DN: 8=: TEOJ:9 D\ E LEU8FDLEO VELCeM ODEL @DN8\DOFD ADJO_ V: MF^LF\FAEL8OH _FUIFLFM=:_ F\ 8=: LE8FDLEO VELC ADJO_ LD8 8NELM\:N 8DEMMF^L::M 8=: NF^=8 8D A=EN^: 8=: MEI: NE8: D\ FL8:N:M8

8=E8 8=: LE8FDLEO VELC F8M:O\ ADJO_ A=EN^:/4:A8FDL ]S EJ8=DNFm:M :EA= LE8FDLEO VELC 8D A=EN^:

FL8:N:M8 J@ 8D 8=: IEfFIJI NE8: EOODG:_ VH 8=: VELCeM=DI: 48E8:/ ,DL^N:MMeM ADL\:NNEO D\ 8=E8 \:_:NEO NF^=8

Y &O8=DJ^= N:M@DL_:L8 \FNM8 DV8EFL:_ =:N AN:_F8UAEN_ EAADJL8\NDI 1ELC D\ &I:NFAE+ 8=: @EN8F:M EL_ 8=: ADJN8M V:ODG EMMJI:_8=E8 1ELC D\ &I:NFAEeM ADLMDOF_E8FDL D\ F8M AN:_F8UAEN_ EAADJL8M FL(#& AN:E8:_ E L:G EAADJL8+ IECFL^ (#& 8=: LE8FDLEO VELC 8=E8DNF^FLE8:_ 8=: ODEL E8 FMMJ:/ 4:: >:8/ &@@/ YE+ SE+ YWEUYRE/


14/25

BP

M=DJO_ V: JL_:NM8DD_ 8D FLADN@DNE8: 8=: JL_:NM8EL_UFL^M 8=E8 0E9 MEO: D\ ODELM FM EL FL8:^NEO EM@:A8 D\ JMJEOVELCFL^ @NEA8FA:+ EL_ 0V9 E ODEL 8=E8 GEM TEOF_ G=:LIE_: GFOO LD8 V: N:L_:N:_ JMJNFDJM VH 8=: 8NELM\:N/.D 8=: :f8:L8 8=E8 E@@OFAE8FDL D\ ':G ?DNC JMJNH OEG

GDJO_ @N:T:L8 (#& \NDI \JOOH :f:NAFMFL^ 8=: @DG:NMADL\:NN:_ VH 4:A8FDL ]S+ M8E8: OEG FM @N::I@8:_/ 4::

^LN73:: ^L7R 21 [LN?27 .7:8"F $"," T/ $39027+ SBR)/4/ KS+ K]UK[+ YRUY] 0B[[W9 0=DO_FL^ 8=E8+ V:AEJM: 8=:'1& EJ8=DNFm:M LE8FDLEO VELCM 8D M:OO FLMJNELA: FLMIEOO 8DGLM+ E M8E8: OEG @N:T:L8FL^ LE8FDLEO VELCM\NDI M:OOFL^ IDM8 CFL_M D\ FLMJNELA: FM @N::I@8:_9/>J8 ELD8=:N GEH+ 8=:N: FM EL dFNN:ADLAFOEVO: ADL\OFA8l0?@" E8 YB9 V:8G::L 8=: '1& 0M@:AF\FAEOOH+ BK )/4/,/

]S9 EL_ ELH M8E8: OEG 8=E8 GDJO_ @N:AOJ_: (#&eM EMUMF^L::M \NDI A=EN^FL^ 8=: \JOO EIDJL8 D\ FL8:N:M8 8=E8FM @:NIF88:_ VH 8=: OEGM D\ (#&eM =DI: 48E8:/

A/ ,DL^N:MM ADJO_ =ET: :I@DG:N:_ LE8FDLEO VELCM8D A=EN^: A:N8EFL NE8:M D\ FL8:N:M8 0EM F8 _F_ FL 4:A8FDL]S9+ G=FO: :f@N:MMOH EJ8=DNFmFL^ 48E8:M 8D N:^JOE8: 8=:8:NIM DL G=FA= ODELM DNF^FLE8:_ VH LE8FDLEO VELCM ADJO_V: EMMF^L:_ 8D D8=:N :L8F8F:M/ 4:: ^LN73:: ^L7R+ SBR)/4/ E8 YZ 0AF8FL^ '1& @NDTFMFDLM 8=E8 dEAADI@ELH E^NEL8 D\ EL :f@OFAF8 @DG:N GF8= EL :f@OFAF8 M8E8:I:L88=E8 8=: :f:NAFM: D\ 8=E8 @DG:N FM MJVg:A8 8D M8E8: OEGl9/

#\ ,DL^N:MM =E_ :LEA8:_ MJA= E @NDTFMFDL+ F8 GDJO_N:VJ8 8=: FL\:N:LA: 8=E8 E LE8FDLEO VELCeM \:_:NEO NF^=88D DNF^FLE8: ODELM E8 8=: IEfFIJI FL8:N:M8 NE8: EOUODG:_ VH F8M =DI: 48E8: FLAOJ_:M 8=: @DG:N 8D EMMF^L8=E8 NF^=8 8D D8=:NM/ 1J8 LD8=FL^ FL 8=: '1& MJ^^:M8M8=E8 ,DL^N:MM FL8:L_:_ 8D OFIF8 8=: LE8FDLEO VELCeM@DG:N FL 8=E8 GEH/

.D 8=: ADL8NENH+ FL E__F8FDL 8D M@:AF\HFL^ 8=: NE8:D\ FL8:N:M8 8=E8 E LE8FDLEO VELC IEH A=EN^:+ 8=:


15/25

BB

'1& :f@N:MMOH EJ8=DNFm:M LE8FDLEO VELCM 8D AENNH DL8=: VJMFL:MM D\ VELCFL^ VH d_FMADJL8FL^ EL_ L:^D8FE8UFL^ @NDIFMMDNH LD8:M+ _NE\8M+ VFOOM D\ :fA=EL^:+ EL_D8=:N :TF_:LA:M D\ _:V8/l BK )/4/,/ KZ04:T:L8=9/ .=E8@DG:N FLAOJ_:M 8=: @DG:N 8D M:OO ODEL ADL8NEA8M/ 4::BK ,/(/6/ R/ZPP] 0d& LE8FDLEO VELC IEH IEC:+ M:OO+@JNA=EM:+ @EN8FAF@E8: FL+ DN D8=:NGFM: _:EO FL ODELMh h h MJVg:A8 8D MJA= 8:NIM+ ADL_F8FDLM+ EL_ OFIF8EU8FDLM @N:MANFV:_ VH 8=: ,DI@8NDOO:N D\ 8=: ,JNN:LUAH EL_ ELH D8=:N E@@OFAEVO: (:_:NEO OEG/l9/ 4:A8FDLKZ04:T:L8=9+ VH F_:L8F\HFL^ 8=: @DG:N 8D M:OO ODELM EMEL E__F8FDLEO :LJI:NE8:_ @DG:N D\ LE8FDLEO VELCM+N:FL\DNA:M 8=: ODL^M8EL_FL^ JL_:NM8EL_FL^ 8=E8 ELE8FDLEO VELCeM 4:A8FDL ]S @DG:NM FLAOJ_: 8=: @DG:N 8D

8NELM\:N ODELM 8D D8=:N :L8F8F:M+ G=FA= IEH ADL8FLJ: 8DA=EN^: FL8:N:M8 E8 8=: DNF^FLEO NE8:/ Z &@@OFAE8FDL D\M8E8: JMJNH OEG =:N: GDJO_ d@N:T:L8 DN MF^LF\FAEL8OHFL8:N\:N: GF8= 8=: LE8FDLEO VELCeM :f:NAFM: D\ `8=DM:i@DG:NM+l ^LN73:: ^L7R + SBR )/4/ E8 YY+ EL_ F8 8=:N:U\DN: FM @N::I@8:_/

_/ #L =DO_FL^ 8=E8 E@@OFAE8FDL D\ ':G ?DNC JMJNHOEG 8D @:8F8FDL:NMe ADOO:A8FDL EA8FTF8F:M FM LD8 @N::I@8U:_ =:N:+ 8=: ADJN8 D\ E@@:EOM :NN:_ FL 8=N:: @NFLAF@EON:M@:A8M/ (FNM8+ 8=: ADJN8 \EFO:_ 8D N:AD^LFm: 8=E8 ELE8FDLEO VELCeM 4:A8FDL ]S @DG:N 8D A=EN^: A:N8EFL

FL8:N:M8 NE8:M AENNF:M GF8= F8 8=: @DG:N 8D EMMF^L 8DD8=:NM 8=: NF̂ =8 8D A=EN^: 8=: MEI: NE8:M/ .=: ADJN8LD8:_ 8=E8 8=: _FM8NFA8 ADJN8 EL_ D8=:N ADJN8M D\ E@U@:EOM =ET: N:OF:_ DL 8=: TEOF_UG=:LUIE_: @NFLAF@O:+>:8/ &@@/ BKE L/K+ BYE+ VJ8 F8 \EFO:_ 8D E@@N:AFE8: 8=:

Z ,DL^N:MM =EM ADL8FLJ:_ 8D N:AD^LFm: EL_ N:E\\FNI 8=: @N::I@U8FT: :\\:A8 D\ 4:A8FDL ]S/ 4:: $D__U(NELC ;EOO 48N::8 6:\DNI EL_,DLMJI:N >ND8:A8FDL &A8+ >JV/ %/ 'D/ BBBUKPY+ X BPZZ0\ 9+ BKZ 48E8/KPBR 0AD_F\F:_ E8 BK )/4/,/ KSV0\ 99/


16/25

BK

MF^LF\FAELA: D\ 8=E8 @NFLAF@O: FL 8=FM AEM:/ 1:AEJM: 8=:ADJN8 D\ E@@:EOM ADLMF_:N:_ DLOH @EN8 D\ E LE8FDLEOVELCeM 4:A8FDL ]S @DG:NM+ F8 \EFO:_ 8D JL_:NM8EL_ =DGE@@OFAE8FDL D\ M8E8: JMJNH OEG 8D @:8F8FDL:NM GDJO_FI@EFN 8=: VELCeM :f:NAFM: D\ 8=DM: @DG:NM/

4:ADL_+ 8=: ADJN8 D\ E@@:EOM V:OF:T:_ 8=E8+ V:AEJM:(#& =E_ EMMF^L:_ N:M@DL_:L8eM _:V8 DJ8NF^=8 EL_ N:U8EFL:_ LD ADL8NDO DT:N 0DN \FLELAFEO M8EC: FL9 @:8F8FDLU:NMe :\\DN8M 8D ADOO:A8 8=E8 _:V8+ E@@OFAE8FDL D\ M8E8:JMJNH OEG GDJO_ dOFIF8 `i DLOH EA8FTF8F:M D\ l @:8F8FDLU:NM+ EL_ LD8 D\ 8=: LE8FDLEO VELC F8M:O\/ >:8/ &@@/ [EUBPE 0AF8E8FDL DIF88:_o VNEAC:8M FL DNF^FLEO9o M:: ?@" E8KE+ BBE/ .=E8 ELEOHMFM FM IFMADLA:FT:_/ .D 8=: :f8:L88=E8 ':G ?DNC OEG @ND=FVF8M @:8F8FDL:NM \NDI A=EN^U

FL^ 8=: \JOO EIDJL8 D\ FL8:N:M8 8=E8 (#& F8M:O\ ADJO_=ET: A=EN^:_+ 8=E8 OEG @N:T:L8M (#& \NDI \JOOH :f:NUAFMFL^ F8M \:_:NEO NF^=8 8D DNF^FLE8: ODELM E8 8=: FL8:NU:M8 NE8: EOODG:_ VH $:OEGEN: OEG+ G=FA= FLAOJ_:M 8=:NF^=8 8D M:OO 8=DM: ODELM 8D D8=:NM/ (DN @N::I@8FDL@JN@DM:M+ MJA= M8E8:UOEG FL8:N:M8UNE8: N:M8NFA8FDLM DL@:8F8FDL:NM EA8FL^ EM (#&eM EMMF^L::M EN: LD _F\\:N:L8\NDI :f@OFAF8 M8E8:UOEG N:M8NFA8FDLM DL 8=: LE8FDLEOVELCeM :f:NAFM: D\ F8M EMMF^LI:L8 @DG:N/

.=FN_+ 8=: ADJN8 D\ E@@:EOM N:OF:_ DL EL JL_JOH LENUNDG ADLA:@8FDL D\ ADL\OFA8 @N::I@8FDL/ .=: ADJN8 EAU

CLDGO:_^:_ 8=E8 E@@OFAE8FDL D\ M8E8: JMJNH OEG 8D ELE8FDLEO VELCeM EMMF^L::M dIF^=8 _:AN:EM: 8=: EIDJL8E LE8FDLEO VELC ADJO_ A=EN^: \DN F8M ADLMJI:N _:V8 FLA:N8EFL M8E8:M/l >:8/ &@@/ BBE/ .=: ADJN8 M8E8:_+ =DGU:T:N+ 8=E8 V:AEJM: dM8E8: JMJNH OEGM GDJO_ LD8 =N3!37: ADLMJI:N _:V8 MEO:M VH LE8FDLEO VELCM 8D 8=FN_ @ENU8F:M+l 8=E8 MDN8 D\ @NFA: :\\:A8 dGDJO_ LD8 jMF^LF\FAEL8OHFL8:N\:N:e GF8= 8=: :f:NAFM: D\ E LE8FDLEO VELC @DG:N/l

)@/ E8 BPUBBE 0:I@=EMFM E__:_9/ .=: F8EOFAFm:_ GDN_


17/25

BY

MJ^^:M8M 8=E8+ MD ODL^ EM 8=: E@@OFAE8FDL D\ ':G ?DNCJMJNH OEG GDJO_ LD8 N:L_:N LE8FDLEOUVELC ODELM JLUMEO:EVO:+ M8E8: OEG FM LD8 @N::I@8:_/

.=E8 ELEOHMFM N:\O:A8M EL JL_JOH ANEVV:_ ADLA:@U8FDL D\ '1& @N::I@8FDL+ EL_ D\ FI@OF:_UADL\OFA8 @N:U:I@8FDL ^:L:NEOOH/ ;=:L \:_:NEO OEG d:f@OFAF8OH ^NEL8ME LE8FDLEO VELC EL EJ8=DNFmE8FDL+ @:NIFMMFDL+ DN @DGU:N+l EL_ _D:M LD8 d:f@OFAF8ÒHi M8E8:ì 8=E8 8=: :f:NAFM:D\ 8=E8 @DG:N FM MJVg:A8 8D M8E8: OEG+l M8E8: OEG FM@N::I@8:_ 8D 8=: :f8:L8 8=E8 F8 N:M8NFA8M 8=E8 @DG:N/

^LN73:: ^L7R + SBR )/4/ E8 YZ/ #\ ':G ?DNC =E_ E8U8:I@8:_ 8D N:^JOE8: 8=: FL8:N:M8 8=E8 (#& F8M:O\ ADJO_A=EN^: ':G ?DNC N:MF_:L8M+ M8E8: OEG GDJO_ AO:ENOH=ET: V::L @N::I@8:_ VH 4:A8FDL ]S+ GF8=DJ8 N:ÊN_ 8D

8=: _:^N:: D\ @NEA8FAEO =ENI 8D 8=: LE8FDLEO VELC 8=E8':G ?DNC JMJNH OEG GDJO_ :L8EFO/ 4:: [LNQ;3::3 $L:W9 ^L7R + ZY[ )/4/ E8 YBZUYBS/ 1:AEJM: 8=: \:_:NEO@DG:N ADL\:NN:_ VH 4:A8FDL ]S 0N:FL\DNA:_ VH 4:A8FDLKZ04:T:L8=99 FLAOJ_:M 8=: @DG:N 8D ADLT:H 8D EL EMUMF^L:: 8=: NF^=8 8D A=EN^: 8=: IEfFIJI FL8:N:M8 EOUODG:_ VH 8=: LE8FDLEO VELCeM =DI: 48E8:+ E M8E8: OEG8=E8 @N:AOJ_:M 8=: LE8FDLEO VELC \NDI \JOOH :f:NAFMFL^8=E8 @DG:N FM MFIFOENOH @N::I@8:_/ >N::I@8FDL FL8=:M: AFNAJIM8ELA:M _D:M LD8 N:aJFN: E M=DGFL^ 8=E8M8E8: JMJNH OEG GDJO_ N:_JA: 8=: @NFA: (#& ADJO_

DV8EFL \DN ELH @EN8FAJOEN ODEL DN AE8:^DNH D\ ODELM+ O:8EODL: E M=DGFL^ 8=E8 M8E8: OEG GDJO_ d@N:T:L8 ADLUMJI:N _:V8 MEO:M VH LE8FDLEO VELCM 8D 8=FN_ @EN8F:M/l>:8/ &@@/ BPEUBBE/

K/ &O8=DJ^= 8=: _:AFMFDL V:ODG FM FLADNN:A8+ 8=:N: FMLD ADL\OFA8 EIDL^ 8=: AFNAJF8M DL 8=: aJ:M8FDL @N:UM:L8:_ =:N:/ >:8F8FDL:NM ADL8:L_ 0>:8/ BBUBZ9 8=E8 8=:_:AFMFDL V:ODG ADL\OFA8M GF8= 8=: _:AFMFDLM FL &


18/25

BZ

53=LN:O37: 6:2N30 .2"+ KB] (/Y_ [B[ 0]8= ,FN/ KPPP9+EL_ *5). T/ 4L::?O2N3 4L7@ .2N="+ WSW (/K_ BY[ 0S8=,FN/ B[]B9 0 4L::?O2N39/ 1:AEJM: 8=: aJ:M8FDLM @N:M:L8U:_ FL 8=DM: AEM:M G:N: MF^LF\FAEL8OH _F\\:N:L8 \NDI 8=:aJ:M8FDL @N:M:L8:_ =:N:+ 8=DM: _:AFMFDLM _D LD8 ADLU\OFA8 GF8= 8=: NJOFL^ V:ODG/

E/ .=: _FM@J8:_ aJ:M8FDL FL &


19/25

BS

8=: A=EN^:M E8 FMMJ: G:N: FI@DM:_ VH 8=: LE8FDLEOVELC F8M:O\ E8 8=: 8FI: F8 IE_: 8=: ODELM/ &O8=DJ^= 8=:@OEFL8F\\M FL &


20/25

BW

.=: -F^=8= ,FNAJF8eM ADI@O:8:U@N::I@8FDL =DO_FL^FL ]N?0=?7 N:M8:_ DL 8=: ADJN8eM _:8:NIFLE8FDL 8=E88=: LE8FDLEO VELC FL 8=E8 AEM: GEM 8=: dN:EO @EN8H FLFL8:N:M8l GF8= N:M@:A8 8D 8=: @OEFL8F\\Me AN:_F8UAEN_ EAUADJL8/ .=E8 _:8:NIFLE8FDL N:M8:_ DL 8=: \EA8 8=E8+_:M@F8: 8=: VELCeM _EFOH MEO: D\ F8M N:A:FTEVO:M 8D 8=:M8DN:+ 8=: VELC IEFL8EFL:_ EL DL^DFL^ AN:_F8 N:OE8FDLUM=F@ GF8= :EA= EAADJL8 =DO_:N/ #L 8=FM AEM:+ VH ADLU8NEM8+ (#&eM MEO: D\ N:M@DL_:L8eM _:V8 8D @:8F8FDL:NM:L8FN:OH 8:NIFLE8:_ 8=: AN:_F8 N:OE8FDLM=F@ V:8G::LN:M@DL_:L8 EL_ 8=: LE8FDLEO VELC/ (#& MDO_ N:M@DL_U:L8eM _:V8 DJ8NF^=8o F8 N:8EFL:_ LD ADL8FLJFL^ NDO: FLE_IFLFM8:NFL^ =:N EAADJL8 EL_ LD ADL8FLJFL^ NF^=8 8DELH FL8:N:M8 8=E8 @:8F8FDL:NM IF^=8 V: EVO: 8D ADOO:A8/

4:: >:8/ &@@/ BYE 0_FM8FL^JFM=FL^ ]N?0=?7 DL 8=E8VEMFM9/A/ 4L::?O2N3 FLTDOT:_ E ODEL 8=E8 GEM DNF^FLE8:_ VH


21/25

BR

DNF^FLEOOH V::L IE_: VH EL :L8F8H 8=E8 GEM LD8 E LEU8FDLEO VELC+ 8=: ADJN8 TF:G:_ M8E8: JMJNH OEG+ NE8=:N8=EL 4:A8FDL ]S+ EM ADL8NDOOFL^ 8=: _:8:NIFLE8FDL

G=:8=:N 8=: FL8:N:M8 A=EN^:_ GEM OEG\JO/ 4:: ?@" E8BZRUBSP/

.=: ADJN8 FL 4L::?O2N3 _F_ LD8 E__N:MM 8=: aJ:MU8FDL @N:M:L8:_ =:N:/ 4L::?O2N3 FLTDOT:_ E ODEL 8NELMU\:NN:_ 1N2O E M8E8:UN:^JOE8:_ :L8F8H :2 E LE8FDLEO VELC+LD8 E ODEL DNF^FLE8:_ EL_ MJVM:aJ:L8OH EMMF^L:_ Z8 ELE8FDLEO VELC/ &O8=DJ^= 8=: ADJN8 FL 4L::?O2N3 E@@OF:_8=: TEOF_UG=:LUIE_: NJO:+ EL_ 8=: 4:ADL_ ,FNAJF8 FL8=FM AEM: DT:NODDC:_ 8=E8 @NFLAF@O:+ 8=: ADJN8M G:N: ADLUMF_:NFL^ _F\\:N:L8 FMMJ:M/ .D V: MJN:+ 8=:N: FM EL E@U@:EOFL^ MHII:8NH 8D 8=: F_:E 8=E8+ F\ 8=: OEG 8=E8

^DT:NLM 8=: DNF^FLE8FL^ :L8F8H ADL8FLJ:M 8D E@@OH E\8:NDL: MDN8 D\ 8NELM\:N+ F8 M=DJO_ OFC:GFM: E@@OH G=:L 8=:EMMF^LI:L8 NJLM FL 8=: D@@DMF8: _FN:A8FDL/ 4:: >:8/BYUBZ/ .=:N: FM+ =DG:T:N+ LD O:^EO DN OD^FAEO N:EMDL 8DADLAOJ_: 8=E8 8=: (F\8= ,FNAJF8eM ELEOHMFM FL 4L::?O2N3 0:T:L EMMJIFL^ F8 FM ADNN:A89 O;0: ADL8NDO FL 8=: MF8JEU8FDL @N:M:L8:_ =:N:/

Y/ (DN 8GD E__F8FDLEO N:EMDLM+ 8=FM AEM: GDJO_ V: E@DDN T:=FAO: \DN N:MDOJ8FDL D\ 8=: aJ:M8FDL @N:M:L8:_/

E/ .=: _:\FAF:LAF:M FL 8=: ADJN8 D\ E@@:EOMe @N::I@U8FDL ELEOHMFM IEH V: E88NFVJ8EVO: FL @EN8 8D 8=: @ENU

8F:Me \EFOJN: 8D @N:M:L8 8=: \JOO NEL^: D\ @N::I@8FDLEN^JI:L8M V:ODG/

#L 8=: _FM8NFA8 ADJN8+ @:8F8FDL:NM EN^J:_ 8=E8 N:UM@DL_:L8eM AOEFIM dEN: :f@N:MMOH @N:U:I@8:_ VH \:_U:NEO OEGl V:AEJM: dXX ]S EL_ ]W `D\ .F8O: BKi @NDTF_:8=: :fAOJMFT: AEJM: D\ EA8FDL \DN MJA= AOEFIM/l >:8M/":I/ D\ %EG FL 4J@@DN8 D\ "D8/ \DN 4JII/ 2/ Y 02EL/KS+ KPBY9 0$/ ,8/ $DA/ YK9 0AF8E8FDL DIF88:_9/ .=: @ENU8F:Me _FM@J8: A:L8:N:_ DL G=:8=:N E LE8FDLEO VELC


22/25

B]

IJM8 N:8EFL EL FL8:N:M8 FL E ODEL F8 8NELM\:NM FL DN_:N\DN 8=: 8NELM\:N:: 8D TEOF_OH FLTDC: '1& @N::I@8FDL/,DI@EN: ?@" E8 Y+ RU] 0@:8F8FDL:NM EN^JFL^ 8=E8@N::I@8FDL E@@OF:M 8D dVD8= LE8FDLEO VELCM EL_ EMUMF^L::M D\ 8=:FN N:A:FTEVO:Ml9 0:I@=EMFM DIF88:_9+ GF8=6:M@/ ":I/ D\ %EG FL 5@@/ 8D "D8/ \DN 4JII/ 2/ Y+ BWUKZ 0"EN/ Z+ KPBY9 0$/ ,8/ $DA/ ZK9 0N:M@DL_:L8 EN^JFL^8=E8 dE LDLULE8FDLEO VELC EMMF^L:: `IEHi :LgDH 8=:V:L:\F8 D\ 8=: 'E8FDLEO 1ELC &A8 :f:I@8FDL `DLOHi

G=:N: 8=: LE8FDLEO VELC EMMF^LDN N:8EFLM E AD^LFmEVO:+MJVM8EL8FT: FL8:N:M8 FL 8=: _:V8 ^DFL^ \DNGEN_l9/ .=:@EN8F:Me VNF:\M _F_ LD8 _FM8FL^JFM= V:8G::L _F\\:N:L88H@:M D\ @N::I@8FDL DN E__N:MM G=:8=:N E@@OFAE8FDL D\M8E8: JMJNH OEG GDJO_ FL8:N\:N: GF8= 8=: LE8FDLEO

VELCeM :f:NAFM: D\ F8M @DG:NM/#L 8=: ADJN8 D\ E@@:EOM+ 8=: @EN8F:Me EN^JI:L8MM=F\8:_/ 6:M@DL_:L8 EN^J:_+ ?7:3N L9?L+ 8=E8 @:8F8FDLU:NM IJM8 :M8EVOFM= 8=E8 E@@OFAE8FDL D\ M8E8: OEG GDJO_dMF^LF\FAEL8OH FL8:N\:N: GF8= 8=: LE8FDLEO VELCeM :f:NUAFM: D\ F8M @DG:NM/l 6:M@/ ,/&/ 1N/ BZ 0AF8E8FDLM DIF8U8:_9o M:: ?@" E8 BKUBZ/ >:8F8FDL:NMe VNF:\ EN^J:_ \DN '1&@N::I@8FDL VJ8 _F_ LD8 M@:AF\H =DG 8=: @N::I@8FDLELEOHMFM M=DJO_ GDNC EL_ _F_ LD8 AF8: 4:A8FDL ]S :T:LDLA:/ .=: VNF:\ M8E8:_ 8=E8 @:8F8FDL:NM =E_ dLD VJN_:L

G=E8MD:T:N 8D M=DG EL FL8:N\:N:LA: GF8= E LE8FDLEO

VELCeM :f:NAFM: D\ @DG:NM+l >:8M/ ,/&/ 1N/ KY+ G=FA=MJ^^:M8M 8=E8 @:8F8FDL:NM G:N: E88:I@8FL^ 8D _FMETDG EADL\OFA8U@N::I@8FDL EN^JI:L8/ 1J8 8=: VNF:\ EOMD M8E8:_8=E8 8=: _FM8NFA8 ADJN8eM FLTDAE8FDL D\ 8=: TEOF_UG=:LUIE_: NJO: dGEM LD8 A:L8NEO 8D 8=: `_FM8NFA8 ADJN8eMi `_i:UAFMFDL EL_ _D:M LD8 A=EL^: 8=: ELEOHMFM E8 EOO/l )@" E8 BW/

&M E N:MJO8+ 8=: ADJN8 D\ E@@:EOM :f@N:MM:_ JLA:NU8EFL8H EVDJ8 8=: @N:AFM: LE8JN: D\ @:8F8FDL:NMe @N::I@U


23/25

B[

8FDL 8=:DNH+ M:: >:8/ &@@/ RE 0M8E8FL^ 8=E8 @:8F8FDL:NMdE@@:EN 8D MJ^^:M8 8=E8 8=FM AEM: FLTDOT:M jADL\OFA8@N::I@8FDLel9+ EL_ E88:I@8:_ 8D OFIF8 F8M =DO_FL^ 8D8=: EN^JI:L8M @N:M:L8:_ VH 8=: @EN8F:M+ ?@" E8 [E 0M8E8UFL^ 8=E8 dLD D8=:N I:A=ELFMI E@@:ENM DL 8=:M: \EA8Ml8D :M8EVOFM= 8=E8 E@@OFAE8FDL D\ M8E8: JMJNH OEG GDJO_MF^LF\FAEL8OH FL8:N\:N: GF8= E LE8FDLEO VELCeM :f:NAFM:D\ F8M @DG:NM9/ .=: ADJN8 D\ E@@:EOMe \EFOJN: 8D N:AD^ULFm: 8=: \JOO MAD@: D\ @DG:NM ^NEL8:_ 8D LE8FDLEO VELCMJL_:N 4:A8FDLM ]S EL_ KZ04:T:L8=9+ EL_ 8=: ADJN8eM\EFOJN: 8D E@@N:AFE8: 8=: @D8:L8FEO MF^LF\FAELA: D\ 8=:

TEOF_UG=:LUIE_: NJO:+ IEH V: E88NFVJ8EVO: E8 O:EM8 FL@EN8 8D 8=: OEAC D\ AOENF8H FL 8=: VNF:\FL /̂ 1:AEJM: 8=:VNF:\ FL^ FL 8=: ADJN8 D\ E@@:EOM \EFO:_ 8D E__N:MM C:H

ADI@DL:L8M D\ 8=: @N::I@8FDL ELEOHMFM+ 8=FM FM ELJLE88NEA8FT: AEM: \DN \JN8=:N N:TF:G/V/ .=: _:AFMFDL V:ODG FM FL8:NODAJ8DNH+ EL_ N:MDOJU

8FDL D\ 8=: aJ:M8FDL @N:M:L8:_ IF^=8 LD8 E\\:A8 8=:DJ8ADI: D\ 8=FM AEM:/ >:8F8FDL:NM EN^J:_ FL 8=: ADJN8D\ E@@:EOM 8=E8+ :T:L F\ N:M@DL_:L8eM AOEFIM EN: LD8@N::I@8:_ VH 8=: '1&+ N:M@DL_:L8eM AN:_F8UAEN_ E^N::UI:L8 GF8= (#& ADL8EFLM E A=DFA:UD\UOEG @NDTFMFDL 8=E8IEL_E8:M 8=: E@@OFAE8FDL D\ $:OEGEN: OEG/ >:8/ &@@/BEUKE/ .=: ADJN8 D\ E@@:EOM _F_ LD8 _:AF_: 8=E8 FMMJ:+VJ8 FLM8:E_ N:IEL_:_ \DN 8=: _FM8NFA8 ADJN8 8D ADLMF_:N

8=: :\\:A8 D\ 8=: A=DFA:UD\UOEG AOEJM:/ )@" E8 BZEUBSE/1:AEJM: 8=: @EN8F:M dE@@:EN 8D E^N:: 8=E8 F\ $:OEGEN:OEG E@@OF:M+ 8=: NE8: `@:8F8FDL:NMi A=EN^:_ `N:M@DL_U:L8i GEM @:NIFMMFVO:+l ?@" E8 BSE+ @:8F8FDL:NM GFOO OFC:OH@N:TEFO DL N:IEL_ F\ 8=: _FM8NFA8 ADJN8 EAA:@8M 8=:FNN:E_FL^ D\ 8=: AN:_F8UAEN_ E^N::I:L8/

-T:L F\ 8=: _FM8NFA8 ADJN8 _:8:NIFL:M 8=E8 ':G ?DNC OEG 0NE8=:N 8=EL $:OEGEN: OEG9 E@@OF:M+ @:8F8FDLU:NM ADJO_ @N:TEFO DL N:IEL_ F\ ':G ?DNC JMJNH OEG


24/25

KP

F8M:O\ FLADN@DNE8:M 8=: TEOF_UG=:LUIE_: @NFLAF@O: 0EMUMJIFL^ 8=E8 @:8F8FDL:NM =ET: @N:M:NT:_ MJA= EL EN^JUI:L89/ .=: EN^JI:L8 8=E8 ':G ?DNC OEG FLADN@DNE8:M8=FM @NFLAF@O: GDJO_ V: E LE8JNEO ADNDOOENH 8D @:8F8FDLU:NMe _:MANF@8FDL D\ 8=: TEOF_UG=:LUIE_: NJO: EM E d\JLU_EI:L8EO @NFLAF@O: D\ JMJNH OEG/l >:8/ BSo M:: ,O:ENUFL^


25/25

KB

1/!176

Documents

Midland vs. Madden Amicus Brief by Solicitor General