Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    1/232

    5

    6

    7

    . 8

    11

    :13

    1-14 2-38

    :56 1- 57 2- 71

    :82 1- 83 2- 88

    :91

    1- 92

    2- 96

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    2/232

    :98 1-99 2

    - 106 :110

    1-111 2- 116

    :119

    :127

    - :

    " " 142

    -: 1947

    181 187

    222

    - 223 - 229 - 232

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    3/232

    6

    / .

    .

    .

    /

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    4/232

    -

    7

    /1940.

    ..

    . .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    5/232

    8

    *

    1993

    ...

    !!! .

    .*

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    6/232

    -

    9

    ..

    .

    "."

    .

    ......

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    7/232

    10

    .

    .

    ..

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    8/232

    -

    11

    .

    . .

    . .

    .

    .

    .

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    9/232

    12

    ..:

    181.

    181

    .

    / 8/7/2010

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    10/232

    -

    13

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    11/232

    14

    -1-

    .

    . . !

    1-

    .

    . 1. 2-

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    12/232

    -

    15

    . .

    . . .

    ..( ).

    .

    .

    2. 3-

    ..

    .1948

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    13/232

    16

    . .

    . " ".

    .

    .

    .

    .

    .

    .""

    ." "

    . .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    14/232

    -

    17

    .

    3. 4-

    . .

    1967.

    .

    .

    4.

    1996

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    15/232

    18

    .5.

    .

    .

    .5-

    .

    ..

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    16/232

    -

    19

    6-

    (" " )....6.

    .

    " ". .

    ..

    .1(

    2( 3(

    . .

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    17/232

    20

    7.

    )(.

    :- :

    " "

    .

    . :""

    .:

    .:

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    18/232

    -

    21

    .

    ..

    : .

    .

    :

    .

    .:

    .!!.

    8.7- 9

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    19/232

    22

    .

    .

    -

    . .

    .

    . -

    .

    .

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    20/232

    -

    23

    - .

    ..

    .

    .

    -

    .

    )(.

    .

    .-

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    21/232

    24

    ( ).

    .

    ).(-

    . .

    ..

    . .

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    22/232

    -

    25

    : 1-

    ." "

    10. 2-

    .

    .

    .

    /

    . .

    ..

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    23/232

    26

    3-

    . . )WMD(

    .4-

    " ")(

    .

    .

    .5-

    )ACRS.( .

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    24/232

    -

    27

    .

    .

    :1

    - . 2-

    .3-

    .

    .

    ....

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    25/232

    28

    11.

    ." ".

    ."

    " " "

    .

    /.

    : .

    . . .

    . .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    26/232

    -

    29

    " ". )

    ("" .

    )MERSC.(

    .

    .

    : .

    . .

    . .

    ( ).

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    27/232

    30

    .

    . . .

    .

    .

    .

    ..

    .

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    28/232

    -

    31

    .

    ..

    )ACRS( .

    :. . . .

    . ( )

    .

    . ...

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    29/232

    32

    1-

    . ...

    )DMZ( .

    .2- /.

    )DMZ.( .

    3-

    .- )(. - ." "

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    30/232

    -

    33

    4--

    . - ).(

    5- -

    .

    -)JMC( .

    )CBMs.(

    ).(

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    31/232

    34

    !!

    !

    ) (!

    . )

    (.)(

    )ACRS(.

    .)(

    .

    1967

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    32/232

    -

    35

    .

    .

    . 12 1-

    .

    .

    .2-

    ..

    .13 1973

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    33/232

    36

    .

    2009. 3- 14

    .

    .

    .)

    ( "

    .". :- - . -.

    1967

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    34/232

    -

    37

    .

    !

    .

    .

    ! .!!

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    35/232

    38

    -2-

    1948

    . 1967 .

    1811947

    1948.1967

    .

    .

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    36/232

    -

    39

    .

    .. .

    ( ))Citizens(

    )Residents(. )Further redeployment(

    85%

    .

    1948 1(

    .2(

    .3(

    .

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    37/232

    40

    .

    .

    . :

    1967 .

    . ....

    1- .

    15.

    ..

    . 2-

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    38/232

    -

    41

    16.

    .3-

    .

    ..

    !

    4-

    .17

    .-:

    :

    .

    1941948.

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    39/232

    42

    1967

    .

    .

    1811947

    .

    18: 1(

    1999

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    40/232

    -

    43

    2(

    )Bantustans( . 3(

    1948 . 1967

    .4(

    (

    .

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    41/232

    44

    ....

    (

    ...

    .(

    . 5(

    .19.

    6(

    . 7(

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    42/232

    -

    45

    .. 8( 20

    .: ( ( ) ( /

    9(

    1948

    1976.

    13 2000

    .

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    43/232

    46

    . -:

    1. )ACRS( .

    1993 1996...

    .2. :. .

    . .

    . .21

    .3.

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    44/232

    -

    47

    . :

    - .

    - .

    - ) (.

    4.

    22

    ..

    5. (IGCC) (UCSD)

    . .

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    45/232

    48

    6.

    .

    .7.

    (CBM).

    .

    . :

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    46/232

    -

    49

    - - .- .- .- .

    :

    ( .

    (

    ( 23.

    1-

    .2

    - . 3- .

    4- .

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    47/232

    50

    5- .

    .6-

    .7-

    .

    1- .

    2- .

    3- : -) ( ..

    .-

    . .

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    48/232

    -

    51

    .

    .

    .

    : 1-

    ... 1948.

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    49/232

    52

    .2-

    . 2500-7000

    .3-

    .4-

    .5-

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    50/232

    -

    53

    ).( ..

    24.

    : 1(

    ) (.

    .2(

    ...

    .

    . 25.

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    51/232

    54

    3( .

    .

    .4(

    .

    .

    .

    .

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    52/232

    -

    55

    ( )

    . .

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    53/232

    56

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    54/232

    -

    57

    -1-

    .

    .

    .

    .

    .) 1923. (

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    55/232

    58

    .

    ..

    .

    181

    ..

    .

    .

    . 1948 .

    .1967

    .181

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    56/232

    -

    59

    .

    .. .

    1948 .

    . )

    ( ) 1999. . .23261999(.

    .

    . .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    57/232

    60

    20 1999 :1-242

    242 . "

    ".242

    "." .

    242. 271967.

    2-

    " "

    1967. )terra nullius(

    . "

    ."

    "181"

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    58/232

    -

    61

    !!28.

    3-181 291947

    181

    " "

    1948 181!!

    4-

    .

    .:-

    ." ".

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    59/232

    62

    !!29.

    .

    .:-

    " "

    .12 .

    . -

    ..-

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    60/232

    -

    63

    .

    Daniel Reisner- .

    :

    1- 242 """ "

    " "30.2- 1967

    .( ).

    181 14 186 1949

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    61/232

    64

    181291947!!

    3-

    . :

    1-

    .: ( 15-25 .

    ( . ( 31.

    2-+

    40-50% 3-

    +

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    62/232

    -

    65

    4-

    12% 5-8

    . 5- 5%

    32.6- 33:

    13% 600

    2

    + )

    (. 5% .

    7- 34:

    :(

    1.9% (

    7.03%

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    63/232

    66

    (

    :4.3%

    4% 3.4%.

    !

    .

    . )Bantustans( ..

    9( )2004.

    )Fait accompli(

    ...

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    64/232

    -

    67

    )In loco(

    35.

    ]

    [.

    .

    . .

    1947

    36.

    1967 .

    ..

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    65/232

    68

    1811947.

    .!!

    . .

    . .

    .1952

    ..

    1967

    37

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    66/232

    -

    69

    242

    " "1967

    .

    ( ).

    ." " .242

    .

    .38

    .

    ..

    22%.181.

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    67/232

    70

    ! . .

    .

    1967

    .

    100 40 40239.

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    68/232

    -

    71

    -2-

    1-

    83,794

    757,182 1922. "

    " 1923

    ..

    .

    .192919331936-1939.

    2-

    ..

    .1923-1948..

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    69/232

    72

    ..

    3-

    291947 45%

    55% 15( )1948

    .

    .

    .( )

    .4- 1949

    ..

    . .1964 .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    70/232

    -

    73

    5-. .1964 .

    6-. . .

    1967 1968

    5/3/401971. 7-

    .

    ..

    .8-( )1973

    .1974

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    71/232

    74

    - 242. ..

    . . .-

    .

    29 1947 181.

    !! -. .

    .- . .

    41.9

    - 22/

    11/

    19733236 421973.

    . .

    - -

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    72/232

    -

    75

    -

    .10-131988. .

    : -. .

    242328

    .

    18160460560760825244646532363237

    -. .

    .

    .11- 1988

    :-

    181 1947.

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    73/232

    76

    - 242338

    43.

    41967

    44.

    :

    : -

    . 1811947 242338 .

    1967 1967

    ..

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    74/232

    -

    77

    ...

    .- :

    1- :

    " "

    ..

    _ _ _

    ..

    .

    27%.

    )Militaryinstallation(.

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    75/232

    78

    _

    :

    * A.

    . * B

    .* C

    .75%.

    .* )

    (. *

    . * 12 20

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    76/232

    -

    79

    2- :

    BC

    A. 18

    B A C A.

    ..

    H1H2 B A A+B 40% .

    .

    .3- :

    ..( )4-6%94-96%

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    77/232

    80

    .

    .

    .4-

    . .

    .

    ...

    .

    ...

    .

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    78/232

    -

    81

    .

    .

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    79/232

    82

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    80/232

    -

    83

    -1-

    -

    . .....

    45.

    ..

    ..

    .

    1967 46)

    (!

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    81/232

    84

    .

    ..

    .

    !

    " ".

    .

    ..

    .

    .

    )( .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    82/232

    -

    85

    .

    .47.

    " " 48 .

    1990"

    """49.

    - -.

    .

    " ".

    .1871 8 26

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    83/232

    86

    )1920-1948( .

    .1945-501946.

    .

    1948

    . ..

    .1947

    .51.

    20%

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    84/232

    -

    87

    50.%

    1967.

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    85/232

    88

    -2-

    11

    194 .

    .

    .

    1947 .52.

    . .1964.1968 9

    53.

    ..

    1974

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    86/232

    -

    89

    .

    194 11/12/1948 11"

    "54.

    .. .

    .1974 . .

    323622 1974.

    .

    55. 3376"

    1975

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    87/232

    90

    .

    1811947 194 11/12/1948

    ..

    1947 194 56.

    . .

    194

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    88/232

    -

    91

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    89/232

    92

    -1-

    .

    .1967 ..

    57. 60% .

    .

    ."2"

    70-80 .

    58:

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    90/232

    -

    93

    1-.2-0.5.

    3-.4- 0.6

    .5- 1.40

    .6- 5.

    .17

    ..

    59. !! )JWC(

    GAC

    .

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    91/232

    94

    .

    .

    .

    .

    . 60 .

    .

    .

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    92/232

    -

    95

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    93/232

    96

    -2-

    .1966

    .

    .

    .. ..

    60% .

    :1-

    . 1966

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    94/232

    -

    97

    .2-

    .

    .3-

    ..

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    95/232

    98

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    96/232

    -

    99

    -1-

    -

    .

    . .

    .

    1897

    .

    61.

    . " ".

    "

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    97/232

    100

    " ""."

    ..

    62.

    ..

    1967.

    . )

    (63.

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    98/232

    -

    101

    64.

    ..

    .

    9/8/1948

    ..

    .3/4/1949

    65.

    29/11/194711/12/1948

    .13/12/1949

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    99/232

    102

    .)14( .

    261949 14( )1948.

    1967.

    .

    .

    1967 .

    66 :

    1-:

    . .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    100/232

    -

    103

    .

    2-:.3-:

    .4-:

    - .

    ( ).

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    101/232

    104

    .

    .

    .. ...

    67.

    68.

    .199326

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    102/232

    -

    105

    .

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    103/232

    106

    -2-

    .

    . .

    ." "

    69.

    .242

    181..

    242 1967

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    104/232

    -

    107

    .

    . ( )"

    70.

    "

    .

    . .

    "71.

    " "

    181242 181 1947

    242

    72.

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    105/232

    108

    181 1967

    .1947.

    73.

    .

    . .

    .

    1967 242 181

    .181.

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    106/232

    -

    109

    242338 1967

    181194.

    !

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    107/232

    110

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    108/232

    -

    111

    -1-

    1967

    ..

    ..

    )terra nullius(" "

    ..

    ..

    )Bantustans(.

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    109/232

    112

    74. .

    : . --.

    -1948 .

    - .-

    :-

    .-

    .- .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    110/232

    -

    113

    .75.

    7/6/1967 3

    12

    )(1949. .

    ..

    76.

    .

    .

    .364.

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    111/232

    114

    . .

    77.

    ..

    .

    .

    .

    78. " ".

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    112/232

    -

    115

    ..

    ..

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    113/232

    116

    -2-

    1967

    1967 1967

    .

    .1967

    1967. .

    )Bantustan( 79.

    1967

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    114/232

    -

    117

    .

    .80.

    .. .

    .

    3.4%4%4.3%81.

    .

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    115/232

    118

    .

    ...

    .

    .

    . 82.

    ..

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    116/232

    -

    119

    " ".

    .

    . . .

    1967 )terra nullius( 22%

    . 1811947.

    . .

    12%." "

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    117/232

    120

    .

    .) .Bantustans(

    . .)Fait

    accompl( 83

    . 1967 .

    .1967.

    .

    .

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    118/232

    -

    121

    ..

    ) .(

    . .

    !!

    .)CB( A 84.

    ..

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    119/232

    122

    .

    .

    ..!!

    !!.

    1967 .

    . .1964.

    .

    ... .

    :

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    120/232

    -

    123

    ..

    .!!.!

    .

    ..

    ..

    . )( .

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    121/232

    124

    .85.

    .

    .

    .

    .)

    (.

    .. . !

    1988 242338

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    122/232

    -

    125

    .

    .1967

    ." "

    .

    .

    .

    . .

    .

    ..

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    123/232

    126

    1948.

    . .

    . .

    .

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    124/232

    -

    127

    ..

    .

    .

    ..

    1811947 .1967

    .22%!!1949

    .

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    125/232

    128

    ..

    86. .

    ..1- 1917

    ..

    ." "

    """

    .87.

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    126/232

    -

    129

    "

    !!"

    ."

    " " ".) . .Anthony H.

    Crodsman(

    .

    .162010 )Andrew J. Shapiro(

    .

    ""Preserving Israel's

    Qualitative Military Edge.20 " "Israel Asset or Liability

    .

    Strategic Bonanza

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    127/232

    130

    .

    .

    .

    .

    .

    .2008 :

    46% 30%

    6% 88.

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    128/232

    -

    131

    2009

    68% 11%

    89.

    .") "Post

    American world. (

    ."

    )Zero-sum("90. 2006"

    ."

    . . )The Size of crisis("

    /2009" "

    ".

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    129/232

    132

    " .

    2008"91. ."Hu Jintao"

    "".

    )SCO(. 92

    .

    "" .

    .

    .

    20-30. .

    ...

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    130/232

    -

    133

    2- - "" 93.

    ..

    .

    1914."

    . .

    .

    . .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    131/232

    134

    .:

    .""

    ..

    ..

    .

    .

    .94.

    1967

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    132/232

    -

    135

    .

    .) ()300 400(

    (.(.

    :

    !!

    .

    )Bantustan(

    .

    .

    ..

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    133/232

    136

    ..

    . . 6002

    " ". :

    .

    ..

    .

    ...

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    134/232

    -

    137

    ..

    .

    .

    . . "Anthony .H. Cordsman"2000 20142020

    . .

    ..

    .5-

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    135/232

    138

    1967. .

    .

    .

    .

    . .

    .

    .. .

    1967.

    )de facto(.

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    136/232

    -

    139

    181

    .

    .

    !

    .

    . . 20-30.

    .

    192919351936193819481965

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    137/232

    140

    .

    .

    .

    .( )

    .

    .

    .

    .( )

    95.

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    138/232

    -

    141

    "

    " 1811947..

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    139/232

    142

    " "

    1967

    . -. .

    .

    .

    .""

    : . .- "

    ". -

    -.

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    140/232

    -

    143

    ) .2003( ."

    .

    ..

    ""One man one vote.

    ) .2002(

    "

    " "1967

    ......22% 78% 22. %

    ")Gass 2002.155(.

    . .2001

    "-" "Palestine Israel An Alternative

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    141/232

    144

    configuration". .

    .-.

    ..

    . ..

    96

    :

    .

    -

    .

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    142/232

    -

    145

    .

    .

    .

    ..

    .

    .

    .

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    143/232

    146

    .

    .

    ..

    .

    .1:

    : -:

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    144/232

    -

    147

    .

    -:

    .

    .-:

    .

    .

    .-:( )

    .

    ..

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    145/232

    148

    -:

    ..

    . -:

    .

    ..

    .2:

    - Statehood:

    .

    .( )

    " .Statehood" .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    146/232

    -

    149

    -:.

    1948. 4.5.

    -:

    1967

    .

    "."

    .-

    1948...

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    147/232

    150

    ..

    1976.

    2000.

    .13

    2000 .

    .

    .-:

    1948..3000

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    148/232

    -

    151

    ..

    -:

    ..

    1967.

    ..

    .

    .

    .3 :

    . .1978.

    1993. 1967

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    149/232

    152

    .

    "" ." "

    ." ".

    -: .

    .

    .-:

    .

    .-:

    ..

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    150/232

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    151/232

    154

    ..

    ..

    1967.

    1947...

    .

    . .

    . .

    .

    ..

    "."

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    152/232

    -

    155

    4:

    ..

    .

    .

    ..

    . .

    ...

    . . .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    153/232

    156

    ..

    .

    ..

    .

    .

    .

    .

    25% .

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    154/232

    -

    157

    .

    ...

    . 62

    ..

    . .

    ..

    .

    ..

    .

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    155/232

    158

    " "

    . " " " "..

    .1948

    .

    !!.

    . .( )

    .25%)-

    (.

    ..

    1948

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    156/232

    -

    159

    .

    .

    .

    ..

    ..

    ..

    .

    ..

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    157/232

    160

    Statehood

    .

    . ..

    .

    .-

    .

    ..

    .

    .32

    ..

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    158/232

    -

    161

    1996

    .

    ..

    .

    . . .

    ..

    ..5:

    .

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    159/232

    162

    .

    .

    . .

    .4.5

    ..

    .

    -. -.

    . :

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    160/232

    -

    163

    .

    ..

    .

    .

    . -

    .

    .. .

    .

    .

    .

    )

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    161/232

    164

    . (

    . 6

    -.

    -.( )

    .

    ..

    -.

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    162/232

    -

    165

    . .

    .

    . .

    .-.

    ..

    . 7:

    .-:

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    163/232

    166

    25. %

    20 20 .

    ..-:

    . .

    -:.

    :1-:

    .2-:

    . .

    3-:

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    164/232

    -

    167

    .

    .4-:

    .5-:

    .6-:

    ..

    .

    .7-:

    .8-:

    . .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    165/232

    168

    9-: .

    10-:.11-:

    .8:

    1-: .

    .2-:

    . 3-: :

    .4-:

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    166/232

    -

    169

    5-::

    -:--.

    6-:

    .7-:

    .

    8-:.

    .9-:

    .10-:

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    167/232

    170

    8-:( )

    1948 .

    -:.

    -:

    .- :

    . - :

    .

    - : .- :

    .-

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    168/232

    -

    171

    - :

    .9:

    1948.

    .

    .( )

    .

    ..

    .

    ..

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    169/232

    172

    .

    .

    .

    " .."

    .1-

    .2-

    .3-

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    170/232

    -

    173

    4- :

    . .

    .

    242338

    .181

    29( )1947

    . .....

    .181 .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    171/232

    174

    :

    .

    -.

    .194755%

    45. %.

    .

    :

    . .

    :-

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    172/232

    -

    175

    - .- .

    - .( )

    ( ).

    :-.

    -.-.- .

    -

    .

    ..

    1967 .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    173/232

    176

    --- - - - - -

    .

    181 1948.62

    .-:

    4002.

    11002. 181.

    ..

    . ..

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    174/232

    -

    177

    .

    .471.10033.991

    .2001 505.91 93.3%

    6.7. %33 .-:

    .32%

    3.368.

    .4.660.

    1948 .

    -:

    1002.

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    175/232

    178

    .

    .

    .1948.

    .

    . . .

    2202. 8.104

    2343. 78%.

    14 .

    -:2002

    . ..

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    176/232

    -

    179

    .1949 .

    .

    1947...

    .

    )652.(

    .657635802.966. 54%.

    -:

    :1- .2-

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    177/232

    180

    . 1-:

    .

    .

    103.86399.232 4.635 5% 95. %

    .

    2-:

    .-

    1947 1947. .

    - .-

    1947. 652 .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    178/232

    -

    181

    100%

    77.440.

    - ::1-

    .2-.3- .

    1-: 1.9002

    1947.102 )

    .(

    . ..

    2-:

    . .

    1947.

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    179/232

    182

    .602.

    3-:

    202 . . 1947

    ..

    30002

    . . ..

    .6502.

    -. .

    ..

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    180/232

    -

    183

    - : 1947

    ..

    ..

    1948.

    .

    36% 64%

    30002..

    : 1948-1951

    471.100 33.991 001.060 02.308

    8.104 2.343 3.580 2.996

    99.232 4.635

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    181/232

    184

    77.240 0 27.340 4.403

    687.656 50.376

    : 31/12/1998 1998.

    :687.656 93.2% 50.376 6.8%

    738.032

    :( )181

    25 1947..

    .

    .181

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    182/232

    -

    185

    .

    ..

    " ".

    .-.

    .

    -

    ..

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    183/232

    186

    ." "

    .

    . .

    . .

    .. .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    184/232

    -

    187

    1947

    181

    ..

    1947 19481967.

    1949 .

    ..

    1947 .

    . .

    )terra nullius.(

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    185/232

    188

    181 97.

    181194. 181 194.

    70. %.

    .194 181.

    70% 181 .

    400 .!!

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    186/232

    -

    189

    -. .181.

    .." "

    . . .

    1811947. .

    ..

    1967 1948.

    .181.

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    187/232

    190

    181194.

    .1947. .

    . ) 181(

    : ( )

    1/1948

    ::

    .: -

    - .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    188/232

    -

    191

    -

    )3941(-.

    :

    )39(. : :

    . :

    .:

    ) ( )1 (

    .( )

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    189/232

    192

    :: :

    : : :

    1/1948. :

    1/1948.

    1/

    1948. :

    1/1948.

    .:

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    190/232

    -

    193

    :: .

    . :

    .

    .

    .

    . :

    .

    .:

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    191/232

    194

    1/1948( )

    . :

    - - .

    : .

    :

    .: - -

    .-

    -.

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    192/232

    -

    195

    : ""

    .

    .( )

    ( )

    .

    . .

    .:

    .

    : ( )

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    193/232

    196

    :( )

    .:( )

    . :( )

    .:( )

    . :( )

    .:

    . ( ):

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    194/232

    -

    197

    . :

    - -

    - -

    . :.

    - -.

    . :

    .:

    :

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    195/232

    198

    :

    .: :

    :( ) .

    :( )

    . .

    :( ) .

    ..

    :( ) .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    196/232

    -

    199

    . :( )

    .

    . : :

    ( ): .

    :( ) .

    :( ) .

    :( ) .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    197/232

    200

    :( )

    .:( )

    .

    ..

    :( )

    .:( )

    .

    .: :

    :( )Citizenship:

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    198/232

    -

    201

    . .

    .: :(

    )a:( .

    .)b:(

    . : :( )

    )a:(

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    199/232

    202

    .

    )B

    :( .

    )C:( ) " "Court of Claims(

    .)D:(

    .: :

    :( ) .

    . :( )

    -- .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    200/232

    -

    203

    :

    :( )

    .( ) )1( ) (.

    /1948.

    :

    : :( ) .

    .

    .

    .

    .

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    201/232

    204

    .

    .

    .

    .- -

    .

    . -)2( ) (-

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    202/232

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    203/232

    206

    )a. :( )b :(

    )3

    . ( 5%

    10%

    ..

    .

    .

    .:

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    204/232

    -

    207

    :

    ..

    --

    .:

    :( )

    ) ( )1(.

    :( )

    .-

    -

    ) 4. (

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    205/232

    208

    :: A: :

    .

    . /.

    / /

    / /

    - /

    .230

    .

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    206/232

    -

    209

    /

    ./

    .

    . // /

    .

    /

    ./

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    207/232

    210

    /

    .

    /.

    / / /

    / /

    )(

    .

    /

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    208/232

    -

    211

    .

    ./

    .

    /

    ./

    / ..150160.

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    209/232

    212

    .

    ..

    .

    100

    .90 70

    /

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    210/232

    -

    213

    .

    //

    .- -

    .:

    ( ).

    ..

    .

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    211/232

    214

    :

    ) ..( : :: :( )

    )Corpus Aeparatum(

    .

    : :( )

    . .

    : :( )

    : )a. :(

    ::( )

    -

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    212/232

    -

    215

    - - -.

    :( )

    .)b(:

    -

    .

    )100(

    ..)c: (

    :( ) ( )

    :( )

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    213/232

    216

    .

    )d: (

    :( ) .

    :( )

    .

    :( )

    .)e: (

    .

    VETO

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    214/232

    -

    217

    )f : (

    < )g(:

    .

    .)h(TRANSIT:

    .

    .)k: (

    .) j: (

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    215/232

    218

    )l: (

    )9( ) (.

    )n: (

    :( - -

    .:( )

    . :( )

    . :( )

    .:( )

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    216/232

    -

    219

    :( ) .

    - -.

    .:( )

    .)m: (

    :( .

    :( )

    . :( )

    ..

    . :( )

    ( )

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    217/232

    220

    .)o(

    :

    .

    - -

    .

    .

    .:

    - -/1948

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    218/232

    -

    221

    ..

    : :

    .

    )128(23 1310: ( ) :

    .:

    .:

    .

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    219/232

    222

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    220/232

    -

    223

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    221/232

    224

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    222/232

    -

    225

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    223/232

    226

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    224/232

    -

    227

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    225/232

    228

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    226/232

    -

    229

    : 1-FAPS Negotiation: Presentation to the Palestinian Delegation

    From Israeli Delegation, 22 November 1999 Re: Israeli securityconcerns

    2-. 3-. 4-. 5-. 6-Israel National security concerns and Threat Perceptions.

    Presented by Israeli Delegation to IGCC workshop on Arms Controland security Improvement in the middle East. February 21-24-2000

    Nicosia Cyprus. (M. General Dan Halots)7-. 8-. 9-.

    10-. 11-. 12- - 1999- /

    127.13-. 14-. 15-The Palestinian vision of Peace and security 22 November

    1999. FAPS Negotiation: Presentation to Israeli Delegation.

    16-. 17-. 18-Palestinian security concerns Fifth Workshop no Arms control

    and security Improvement in the Middle East IGCC of Universityof California. Nicosia Cyprus 2124 February 2000 (M. General

    Omar Ashour)19-. 20-. 21-Multilateral Negotiation. Arms Corral and Regional Security

    workshops. 22-. 23- -. 24

    -. 25-.

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    227/232

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    228/232

    -

    231

    60 -. . 61 . " " 62 . 63 . 64

    - 6/7 /2007. 65 66 67 . 68 . . 69 -. 70 71 72 73 74 - -1995.75 76 77 78 79 80 81 . 82 -. 83 -. 84 -. 85 . 86 / - 87 . 88 Middle East Papers. Middle East strategy At Harvard89 90 Post-American WorldFareed Zakaria 91-The size of crisis , Dr.Samir Ameen92 93 94 Haman Rights in Palestinian and other occupied Arab Territories Goldston

    Mission on the Gaza conflict95 -. 96 Palestine-Israel, An alternative configuration D. Nasser Abu Farha97 . 98- . 1934 1974 . .

    .97.

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    229/232

    232

    1- FAPS Negotiation: Presentation to the PalestinianDelegation From Israeli Delegation, 22 November 1999Re: Israeli security concerns ( )

    2- Israel National security concerns and Threat Perceptions.Presented by Israeli Delegation to IGCC workshop onArms Control and security Improvement in the middleEast. February 21-24-2000 Nicosia Cyprus. (M. GeneralDan Halots) ( )

    3- - 1999- / 127.

    ) 5( 4- The Palestinian vision of Peace and security 22 November

    1999. FAPS Negotiation: Presentation to IsraeliDelegation. ( )

    5- Palestinian security concerns Fifth Workshop no Armscontrol and security Improvement in the Middle EastIGCC of University of California. Nicosia Cyprus 21

    24 February 2000 (M. General Omar Ashour) ( )6- Multilateral Negotiation. Arms Control and Regional

    Security workshops ( )7- /

    - :

    ) (1995

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    230/232

    -

    233

    8- Permanent Status Negotiation: Special Session on Border

    Issues. Report Prepared by the legal unit of P.L.ONegotiation affairs Department 23-12-1999 ( )

    9- /

    ) 2(. . ( ) 1999.

    10- . /

    2010 11- Getting to Territorial End game of on IsraeliPalestinail.

    Peace settlement special Report by Israeli Palestinianworkshop of Baker institute's conflict Resolution Forum.http://www.bakerinstitute.org/publications/BI-pub-IPTerritorialEndgame-020210.pdf

    12- International Court of Justice Press Release 2004/289July2004 legal consequences of construction of a wall inoccupied Palestinian Territory http://www.icj-cij.org/presscom/index.php?pr=71&pt=1&p1=6&p2=1

    13- / ) 3 (

    . 1999 14- -

    1991 15- -

    1989 16- . . 194

    11/12/1948 17-

    . 1995

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    231/232

    234

    18- . .

    2003

    19- 1995 20- " "

    21- --

    6-7 /2007

    22- JMCC - 1995

    23- 1964 24- Middle East Papers. Middle East strategy At Harvard,

    http://blogs.law.harvard.edu/mesh/

    25- Post-American WorldFareed Zakariahttp://www.cnl.com/documents/Post-American%20World.pdf

    26- The size of crisis , Dr.Samir Amin,http://www.ahewar.org/eng/show.art.asp?aid=805

    27- Human Rights in Palestinian and other occupied Arab

    Territories Goldston Mission on the Gaza conflict,http://www2.ohchr.org/english/bodies/hrcouncil/specialsession/9/factfindingmission.htm

    28- Alternative Palestinian Agenda Proposal for an Alternativeconfiguration in Palestine-Israel Nasser Abufarha, August2001 www.ap-agenda.org

    29- 1923

    30- Hani Albasoos (2005) The security and policing of

    Palestine, PhD Thesis. University of Bradford, UK

  • 7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives

    232/232

    -

    31- The OBAMA administration's approach to U.S-Israel's

    qualitative military Edge The Brookings InstitutionWashington, D.C Friday, July 16, 2010,

    http://www.brookings.edu/events/2010/0716_us_israel_security.aspx

    32- Remarks by Robert satloff from the Nixon Center Debate"Israel: Asset or Liability?" July 20, 2010, Jerusalem Post,August 1, 2010

    33- - 19471974