233

Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

A Dec. 20, 2011 initial determination written by Administrative Law Judge Theodore R. Essex in the Microsoft-Motorola case. (337-TA-744)

Citation preview

Page 1: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 2: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 3: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 4: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 5: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 6: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 7: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 8: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 9: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 10: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 11: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 12: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 13: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 14: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 15: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 16: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 17: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 18: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 19: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 20: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 21: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 22: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 23: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 24: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 25: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 26: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 27: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 28: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 29: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 30: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 31: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 32: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 33: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 34: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 35: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 36: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 37: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 38: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 39: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 40: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 41: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 42: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 43: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 44: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 45: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 46: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 47: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 48: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 49: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 50: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 51: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 52: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 53: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 54: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 55: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 56: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 57: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 58: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 59: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 60: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 61: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 62: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 63: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 64: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 65: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 66: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 67: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 68: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 69: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 70: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 71: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 72: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 73: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 74: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 75: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 76: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 77: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 78: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 79: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 80: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 81: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 82: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 83: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 84: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 85: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 86: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 87: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 88: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 89: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 90: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 91: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 92: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 93: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 94: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 95: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 96: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 97: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 98: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 99: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 100: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 101: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 102: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 103: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 104: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 105: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 106: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 107: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 108: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 109: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 110: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 111: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 112: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 113: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 114: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 115: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 116: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 117: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 118: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 119: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 120: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 121: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 122: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 123: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 124: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 125: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 126: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 127: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 128: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 129: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 130: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 131: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 132: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 133: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 134: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 135: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 136: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 137: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 138: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 139: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 140: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 141: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 142: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 143: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 144: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 145: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 146: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 147: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 148: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 149: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 150: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 151: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 152: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 153: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 154: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 155: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 156: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 157: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 158: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 159: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 160: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 161: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 162: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 163: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 164: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 165: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 166: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 167: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 168: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 169: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 170: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 171: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 172: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 173: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 174: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 175: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 176: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 177: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 178: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 179: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 180: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 181: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 182: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 183: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 184: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 185: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 186: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 187: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 188: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 189: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 190: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 191: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 192: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 193: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 194: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 195: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 196: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 197: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 198: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 199: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 200: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 201: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 202: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 203: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 204: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 205: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 206: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 207: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 208: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 209: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 210: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 211: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 212: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 213: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 214: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 215: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 216: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 217: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 218: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 219: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 220: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 221: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 222: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 223: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 224: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 225: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 226: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 227: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 228: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 229: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 230: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 231: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 232: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination
Page 233: Microsoft - Motorola ITC Initial Determination

MOTOROLA SOLUTIONS Motorola Solutions Germany Gmb Am ... · MOTOROLA SOLUTIONS Motorola Solutions Germany Gmb Am Borsigturm 130, D-13507 Berlim Germany Document Keeper: Motorola Solutions

MOTOROLA SOLUTIONS Motorola Solutions Germany Gmb Am ... · MOTOROLA SOLUTIONS Motorola Solutions Germany Gmb Am Borsigturm 130, D-13507 Berlim Germany Document Keeper: Motorola Solutions

Documents
Motorola DSP Assembler Reference Manual · MOTOROLA DIGITAL SIGNAL PROCESSING DEVELOPMENT SOFTWARE MOTOROLA DSP ASSEMBLER REFERENCE MANUAL Motorola, Incorporated Semiconductor Products

Motorola DSP Assembler Reference Manual · MOTOROLA DIGITAL SIGNAL PROCESSING DEVELOPMENT SOFTWARE MOTOROLA DSP ASSEMBLER REFERENCE MANUAL Motorola, Incorporated Semiconductor Products

Documents
2010-01-11 Agenda...2010/01/11  · Page 3 - 9. AGENDA - January 11, 2010 Motorola Walkie Talkie Motorola Walkie Talkie Motorola Walkie Talkie Motorola Walkie Talkie Motorola Walkie

2010-01-11 Agenda...2010/01/11  · Page 3 - 9. AGENDA - January 11, 2010 Motorola Walkie Talkie Motorola Walkie Talkie Motorola Walkie Talkie Motorola Walkie Talkie Motorola Walkie

Documents
ITC and ITC sunfeast indepth

ITC and ITC sunfeast indepth

Documents
DBA ITC LTD ITC

DBA ITC LTD ITC

Documents
Presentation on Salient Features of Model GST Law (MGL) · –ITC of CGST as ITC of CGST or IGST; –ITC of SGST as ITC of SGST or IGST; –ITC of IGST as ITC of IGST or CGST. ITC

Presentation on Salient Features of Model GST Law (MGL) · –ITC of CGST as ITC of CGST or IGST; –ITC of SGST as ITC of SGST or IGST; –ITC of IGST as ITC of IGST or CGST. ITC

Documents
ITC-2, ITC-4 et ITC-6--ENG2 · 2015-07-21 · Title: ITC-2, ITC-4 et ITC-6--ENG2.pdf Author: PIRIS Created Date: 4/21/2015 2:32:12 PM Keywords ()

ITC-2, ITC-4 et ITC-6--ENG2 · 2015-07-21 · Title: ITC-2, ITC-4 et ITC-6--ENG2.pdf Author: PIRIS Created Date: 4/21/2015 2:32:12 PM Keywords ()

Documents
Motorola TeTra Solutionstetraforum.pl/produkty-tetra/Motorola/CEP400/Motorola-TETRA-CEP400... · Localised systems Motorola have delivered more TETRA infrastructure than anyone else

Motorola TeTra Solutionstetraforum.pl/produkty-tetra/Motorola/CEP400/Motorola-TETRA-CEP400... · Localised systems Motorola have delivered more TETRA infrastructure than anyone else

Documents
Motorola Confidential Restricted MOTOROLA, MOTO, MOTOROLA SOLUTIONS and the Stylized M Logo are trademarks or registered trademarks of Motorola Trademark

Motorola Confidential Restricted MOTOROLA, MOTO, MOTOROLA SOLUTIONS and the Stylized M Logo are trademarks or registered trademarks of Motorola Trademark

Documents
13-04-25 Microsoft-Motorola FRAND Rate Determination

13-04-25 Microsoft-Motorola FRAND Rate Determination

Documents
12-03-30 ITC Initial Determination Denying Apple Summary Determination Against Samsung

12-03-30 ITC Initial Determination Denying Apple Summary Determination Against Samsung

Documents
Motorola 680x0 aka Motorola 68k Family

Motorola 680x0 aka Motorola 68k Family

Documents
Motorola Embedded Software Version 9.1.0 Motorola …setuprouter.com/router/motorola/nvg589/manual-1741.pdf · b Motorola ® NVG589 VDSL2 Gateway Motorola ® Embedded Software Version

Motorola Embedded Software Version 9.1.0 Motorola …setuprouter.com/router/motorola/nvg589/manual-1741.pdf · b Motorola ® NVG589 VDSL2 Gateway Motorola ® Embedded Software Version

Documents
Soehnle Connect-App compatibility list · 2018-10-12 · Motorola Moto E4/E4plus Motorola Moto G6 Motorola Moto z force Motorola Moto z Play 2 Motorola Moto z3play Motorola Moto G

Soehnle Connect-App compatibility list · 2018-10-12 · Motorola Moto E4/E4plus Motorola Moto G6 Motorola Moto z force Motorola Moto z Play 2 Motorola Moto z3play Motorola Moto G

Documents
Microsoft v Motorola ITC '762 Patent Claim Chart

Microsoft v Motorola ITC '762 Patent Claim Chart

Documents
Www.itcsoftware.com ITC Software ITC AUTOMATION TESTING SERVICES

Www.itcsoftware.com ITC Software ITC AUTOMATION TESTING SERVICES

Documents
13-09-06 Motorola Petition for Rehearing (Apple ITC Appeal)

13-09-06 Motorola Petition for Rehearing (Apple ITC Appeal)

Documents
Itc-impact of Itc on Fmcg Sector

Itc-impact of Itc on Fmcg Sector

Documents
MK500 Micro Kiosk - Motorola Solutions Homepage - Motorola

MK500 Micro Kiosk - Motorola Solutions Homepage - Motorola

Documents
Itc Enhancing Rural Marketing an Itc Perspective

Itc Enhancing Rural Marketing an Itc Perspective

Documents
ITC ruling reviving Apple's multitouch patent case against Motorola

ITC ruling reviving Apple's multitouch patent case against Motorola

Documents
ITC (ITC IN)

ITC (ITC IN)

Documents
MOTOROLA INC. 1989 Annual Report - Motorola Solutions

MOTOROLA INC. 1989 Annual Report - Motorola Solutions

Documents
MOTOROLA · MOTOROLA ... motorola

MOTOROLA · MOTOROLA ... motorola

Documents
| GDS BOOKING …download.intercomtraining.com/starwoodprolearning/docs/...HOTEL ITC Mughal, Agra ITC Maurya, New Delhi ITC Kakatiya, Hyderabad ITC Windsor, Bangalore ITC Maratha,

| GDS BOOKING …download.intercomtraining.com/starwoodprolearning/docs/...HOTEL ITC Mughal, Agra ITC Maurya, New Delhi ITC Kakatiya, Hyderabad ITC Windsor, Bangalore ITC Maratha,

Documents
Microsoft v Motorola ITC '376 Patent Claim Chart

Microsoft v Motorola ITC '376 Patent Claim Chart

Documents
Motorola Embedded Software Version 9.1.0 Motorola NVG589

Motorola Embedded Software Version 9.1.0 Motorola NVG589

Documents
ITC INDUCTION ITC MELTING and HEATING

ITC INDUCTION ITC MELTING and HEATING

Documents
ITC exclusion order on Motorola smartphones

ITC exclusion order on Motorola smartphones

Documents
Www.itcsoftware.com ITC Software ITC SOFTWARE TESTING SERVICES

Www.itcsoftware.com ITC Software ITC SOFTWARE TESTING SERVICES

Documents