METHODS OF TREATING OFFENDERS

TOKEN ECONOMIESANGER MANAGEMENT

THE TREATMENT OF OFFENDERS AND PREVENTION OF CRIME.

• The criminal justice system has many punishments at its disposal. It can sentence offenders to a period of imprisonment or it can use more lenient deterrents such as a suspended sentence, a period of probation, community service or a fine. • Once offenders are imprisoned, some of them will be

part of a treatment programme aimed at improving heir immediate behaviour and reducing their chances of reoffending.• Behaviour modification in the form of token

economies and anger management are the 2 that we will describe and assess.

THE SYLLABUS - WHAT DOES IT SAY?

• Describe and evaluate two ways of treating offenders including:

- the token economy programme and one other.

• Suitable examples:- punishment- anger management- social skills training.

ANGER MANAGEMENT• Offenders can be treated using anger

management programmes, which focus on people with aggressive behaviour that needs to be controlled. • Anger management in general uses strategies

such as identifying what triggers anger and learning to control those triggers.• Proper eating regimes are suggested as well as

relaxation techniques.• Learning to cope with different opinions from

others is also important in the programme.

• Anger is considered a normal healthy response, but if it develops into rage that takes a person over, it is not healthy but puts a strain on the body.• Anger can trigger aggressive outburts which may

lead to harming someone else.• Some offenders are put on anger management

programmes as part of their treatment, because of the nature of the offence or because of personal characteristics.

• The theory of anger as an outburst links to Freud’s ideas of negative emotions being locked away in the unconscious, only to burst out later. • Freud believed sport and other energetic

activities could release such emotions. • Currently there is more focus on what triggers

the outburst of anger or aggression and how that trigger, often based on thought processes, can be changed.• Such anger is thought of as inappropriate

thought patterns and reactions rather than outbursts.

• TASK ... Using your textbook and any other suitable sources, make notes on Novaco’s approach to anger including the 3 steps involved in an anger management programme.• Using the internet and other appropriate

sources, find out what sorts of skills you would need to acquire during the skill acquisition stage of an anger management programme. • Spend a little time searching on the internet for

actual anger management programmes – where have they been used? On whom? Were they successful?

Studies evaluating anger management programmes

• Watt et al (1999) - Western AustraliaViolent male adult offenders on an anger management programme were compared with offenders on a waiting list, who acted as a control. Two groups were measured in terms of anger knowledge, anger expression, observed aggressive behaviour and misconduct in prison.The study found no special gain for the offenders on the AMP compared with the controls, suggesting such programmes have no value for violent offenders.

• TASK ... Use your textbook to make notes on the study by Loza and Loza – Fanous (1999) and Ireland (2004) • What do these studies tell us about the

effectiveness of anger management programmes? • Can you think of any problems with using self

report data such as that used by Ireland (2004)?• How else can we evaluate anger management

programmes? Are there any ethical/moral problems?

Strengths of anger management programmes

• Studies show the success of anger management programmes from self report data, which are likely to be valid as they come from prisoners themselves.• The programmes focus on learning about

triggers from angry episodes and give people the tools to control their anger in the future, so they should have long term benefits.

Weaknesses of Anger Management • The programmes do not include a discussion of

morality or understanding from a victim’s point of view, which has been said to limit their success.• It has been claimed that they turn physical

aggression into other ways of expressing aggression, such as verbal or emotional abuse.• Studies claiming success of the programmes use self

report data, where prisoners might want to look good and say the groups were useful, or they might simply have enjoyed the sessions as a break from routine.• Many studies do not look further into the future to

predict recidivism rates.

Possible exam questions1. Outline one way of treating offender behaviour (3

marks) 2. The probation service is looking into ways to treat

offenders and reduce recidivism. They are using token economies but realise this treatment programme is limited in the extent to which they rehabilitate offenders and lower recidivism. Describe another way of treating prisoners and evaluate the usefulness of this programme. (12 marks)

3. Evaluate the use of one method of reducing offending behaviour other than token economies. (5 marks)