27
1 Methanol – An Emerging Clean- Burning Marine Fuel September 24, 2014 Jason Chesko, Senior Manager, Global Market Development

Methanol An Emerging Clean- Burning Marine Fuel

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    6

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Methanol An Emerging Clean- Burning Marine Fuel

1

Methanol – An Emerging Clean-Burning Marine Fuel

September 24, 2014

Jason Chesko, Senior Manager, Global Market Development

Page 2: Methanol An Emerging Clean- Burning Marine Fuel

2

Overview

• Methanex

• Methanol Industry

• Methanol – An Emerging Marine Fuel

• Regulations driving change

• Options

• Commercial developments

• Stena case study

Page 3: Methanol An Emerging Clean- Burning Marine Fuel

3 3

Methanol / Methanex Overview

Page 4: Methanol An Emerging Clean- Burning Marine Fuel

4 4

About Methanex

• Largest supplier of methanol in all major markets: ~18% overall merchant market share1

• Production capacity: ~9 million tonnes

• ~$7 Billion Enterprise Value / $3 Billion Revenue (2013)

• Wholly-owned Waterfront Shipping subsidiary

• A Responsible Care® company

• Approximately 1,100 dedicated employees globally

• A publicly traded company:

• NASDAQ Global Market (“MEOH”)

• TSX (“MX”)

1 Merchant market share represents share of total sales to non-integrated consumers of methanol. Source: Methanex

Page 5: Methanol An Emerging Clean- Burning Marine Fuel

5

Methanex’s Global Operations

Page 6: Methanol An Emerging Clean- Burning Marine Fuel

7 7

Methanol

• Has diversified end uses

Formaldehyde Acetic Acid Wood Industry, Pharmaceuticals, Automotive Fleece, Adhesives, Paints

Methyl Methacrylate Methyl Chloride PMMA- LCD screens, automotive Silicones

Energy & MTO

(40% of Demand; High Growth) Traditional Uses (60% of Demand)

Fuel Blending

MTO Methanol-to-

Olefins

Marine Fuels

DME (di-methyl-ether)

MTBE

Page 7: Methanol An Emerging Clean- Burning Marine Fuel

8 8

0

10,000

20,000

30,000

40,000

50,000

60,000

70,000

80,000

2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013E 2014E 2015E 2016E 2017E

Chemical MTBE/TAME Fuel DME MTO/MTP (Merchant)

Methanol Demand Growth

• Projected 8.2% CAGR, led by energy applications

(000s tonnes)

2003 – 2013 CAGR: Energy: 11.0%

Total: 6.1%

2013 – 2017 CAGR: Energy: 12.8%

Total: 8.2%

Source: IHS Chemical 2014 Update, July, 2014. Excludes integrated methanol demand for methanol to olefins and propylene

Page 8: Methanol An Emerging Clean- Burning Marine Fuel

9 9

Methanol Energy Applications - Growth Drivers

• Economics • Lower energy cost

• Liquid fuel – low infrastructure costs, easy to transport

• Clean-burning / meets more stringent environmental regulations

• Energy security

• A safe fuel which biodegrades quickly (compared to petroleum fuels) in case of a spill

• Renewable Options

Source: Historical data and forecast from IHS Chemical, July 2014

Page 9: Methanol An Emerging Clean- Burning Marine Fuel

10 10

Methanol – An Emerging Clean-Burning Marine Fuel

Page 10: Methanol An Emerging Clean- Burning Marine Fuel

11 11

Marine Fuel Regulations Driving Change

• Regulations – shift from Heavy Fuel Oil (HFO) to lower sulphur alternatives

• SECA / ECA target 0.1% by 2015

• IMO global target 0.5% by 2020

Global Emission Control Areas (ECA’s)

HFO

Page 11: Methanol An Emerging Clean- Burning Marine Fuel

12 12

• Regulations to meet Tier III NOx emissions in North America ECA for new build vessels 2016+

• Potentially expanding to other regions

NOx Emissions Regulations

Page 12: Methanol An Emerging Clean- Burning Marine Fuel

13 13

Alternatives

• HFO (Heavy fuel oil) with scrubbers

• Marine Diesel Oil (MDO) / Marine Gas Oil (MGO)

• LNG

• Methanol

HFO

+ Aftertreatment

MGO

(Low Sulphur fuel)

as fuel

GAS

as fuel

Methanol

as fuel

Relative benefits will vary with circumstances (ie; % of time in ECA’s)

13

Page 13: Methanol An Emerging Clean- Burning Marine Fuel

14 14

Environmental Impact

Methanol: • Achieves International Maritime Organization (IMO) targets • Achieves lower NOx, CO2, and PM emissions than other alternatives

Source: Stena (4-stroke engine testing)

Page 14: Methanol An Emerging Clean- Burning Marine Fuel

15 15

MGO

Benefits • Straight forward alternative

• Minor engine modification from HFO (limited to no conversion costs)

• Bunkering system in place

Disadvantages/Risks • No flex-fuel options

• Fuel Price – high historically & risk of demand pull from new regulations in 2015+

• Does not help with NOx for newbuilds 2016+

Energy Price Comparison | MGO vs Methanol (mmbtu basis, LHV)

* Calculated as the average of Singapore 0.5% MGO, San Francisco 0.5% MGO, and Rotterdam MDO pricing (LQM)

when data i s ava i lable. Source: Bloomberg & LQM

^ Simple average of NE China Spot, USGC Spot, and Rotterdam T2 Spot prices from CMAI.

10.0

12.0

14.0

16.0

18.0

20.0

22.0

24.0

2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013

$/m

mb

tu

MGO Price * Global Avg. Methanol Price ^

Source: Morgan Stanley, Gemanischer Lloyd

Page 15: Methanol An Emerging Clean- Burning Marine Fuel

16 16

HFO with Scrubbers

Disadvantages/Risks • Added weight & loss of onboard space;

may cause vessel imbalance

• Disposal of byproduct

• Limited renewable options to produce fuel

• Only benefits addresses SOx/Particulates, more capital may be required as regulations tighten

• Technology uncertainty

• No flex fuel option

Benefits

• Can be cost effective solution 1

• No engine or fuel system modification

• Retrofit process can be easier than other options

1 Morgan Stanley report (2013) cited $5.84 million as example of scrubber capex cost

Page 16: Methanol An Emerging Clean- Burning Marine Fuel

17 17

LNG

Disadvantages/Risks • Conversion expensive (requires engine

replacement)

• Capital intensive infrastructure

• Lack of refueling infrastructure & standards

• Loss of onboard space

• Methane leakage concerns

• Price transparency

Benefits

• Fuel price potentially cheaper where infrastructure exists

• Flex-fuel option

• Environmental benefits (lower SOx, Particulates, NOx)

Page 17: Methanol An Emerging Clean- Burning Marine Fuel

18 18

Methanol

Benefits

• Modest conversion & infrastructure cost

• Existing fueling infrastructure can be utilized

• Minor modifications (fuel system)

• Competitive fuel cost

• Flex-fuel option

• Renewable feedstock (low GHG potential)

• Environmental benefits (lower SOx, Particulates, NOx)

Disadvantages/Risks

• Fuel price uncertainty

• While modest, incremental conversion & infrastructure cost

Page 18: Methanol An Emerging Clean- Burning Marine Fuel

19 19

Methanol Fuel Costs

• Methanol flex fuel engine allows you to switch between cheapest fuel (MGO/MDO or methanol)

• Example: US$21 million savings 2009-2013 (~1-2 year payback period)

Page 19: Methanol An Emerging Clean- Burning Marine Fuel

20 20

Methanol Infrastructure

* Terminal locations are representative based on available information and is not a complete list

• Extensive existing terminal infrastructure + modest cost to build new terminal capacity; ability to use existing diesel infrastructure

Page 20: Methanol An Emerging Clean- Burning Marine Fuel

21 21

Methanol Modifications Minor

On-engine scope is limited to exchange of cylinder heads, fuel injectors and fuel plungers in existing fuel pumps. A common rail system for methanol injection will be added on the engine. In addition to the Engine related conversion includes the conversion kit a stand-alone high pressure methanol pump with belonging oil unit for supply of sealing oil and control oil to the fuel injectors.

Source: Wartsila

Page 21: Methanol An Emerging Clean- Burning Marine Fuel

22 22

Methanol Commercialization

• SPIRETH Project – technology confirmation

• Engine manufacturers developing methanol compatible engines

• MAN – 2 stroke low speed engines

• Wartsila – 4 stroke medium speed engines

• Projects being proposed for smaller high speed engines (e.g. barges)

• Standards and regulations under development

• Risk Classification Societies – DNV, Lloyd’s Register

• Marine fuels regulations being updated for methanol

Page 22: Methanol An Emerging Clean- Burning Marine Fuel

23 23

Methanol as a Marine Fuel – Commercial Developments

• Stena converting Germanica (2015) and potentially up to 25 ferries to methanol in Northern Europe

• Methanex (Waterfront Shipping) taking delivery of seven new methanol flex-fuel engine ships in 2016 (MAN’s ME-LGI flex fuel engine)

• Significant interest developing in Europe, North America & Asia

Page 23: Methanol An Emerging Clean- Burning Marine Fuel

24 24

Case Study: Stena/Effship Project

• Converting ferries to run on methanol (ECA 100% of time)

• Stena Germanica 2015 (potentially up to 25 vessels)

Page 24: Methanol An Emerging Clean- Burning Marine Fuel

25 25

Case Study: Infrastructure Investment

Cost Methanol (flex fuel engine)

LNG MGO Scrubber

Terminal Build $7,100,000 $71,000,000 - -

Bunker Vessel Conversion

$2,100,000 - - -

Bunker Vessel Build

- $42,900,000 - -

Feeder Boat Build - $71,400,000 - -

Total Infrastructure

$9,200,000* $185,300,000* minimal minimal

Source: Stena (25MW ferry conversion example) * Costs in € converted to US$ at 1.428571

• Methanol infrastructure significantly lower cost than LNG

Page 25: Methanol An Emerging Clean- Burning Marine Fuel

26 26

Case Study: Conversion and Fuel Comparison

Source: Effship Project Summary Report, 2013 (* Costs do not include infrastructure development). Fuel cost based on market price 2012. Conversion based on 5 years pay-back and 6% interest

Page 26: Methanol An Emerging Clean- Burning Marine Fuel

27 27

Methanol – An Emerging Marine Fuel Alternative

Clean Burning

Economical Fuel Cost

Modest Investment Cost

Existing Infrastructure

Fuel Flexibility

Renewable Options

Page 27: Methanol An Emerging Clean- Burning Marine Fuel

Thank You

Contact Information: Methanex Corporation Jason Chesko Senior Manager, Global Market Development (604) 661-2680 [email protected]