63
!"#$%&’$"#%&()"* ,-./$0-(- %)1 #$" 2)-%)(#. 3"4")/" !"#$% ’#()*+, -./#(0 ! )#**%.1+1#2( *345#11%) #( 6+.1#+" 73"7#""5%(1 27 18% )%0.%% 27 9+$8%"2. 27 ’+:* ;<2(23.*= +1 18% >(#/%.*#1, 27 ?1+02 @ A% B8+.% B+(+(0+ 2 ?1+02C ?$124%. DEEF

Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/"

!"#$%&'#()*+,&-./#(0

!&)#**%.1+1#2(&*345#11%)&#(&6+.1#+"&73"7#""5%(1&27&18%&)%0.%%&27&9+$8%"2.&27&'+:*&;<2(23.*=+1&18%&>(#/%.*#1,&27&?1+02&@&A%&B8+.%&B+(+(0+&2&?1+02C

?$124%.&DEEF

Page 2: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/"+ !

"#$%&'()*+,)%-.

5,6%(-"+#$"+70618+9(:"+#$%);-+#0+#$"+7061*+406+$"+(-+<0018+=06+$(-+>0:"+")1?6"-+406":"6@A

B0+&.+-?'"6:(-06+C0$)+3%D-0)*+406+.0?6+'%#(")/"*+")/0?6%<"&")#*+-$%6'+"."+406+1"#%(>*+%)1+D(>>()<)"--+#0+6"%1+>%#" +16%4#-+D$(>"+()+2#%>.E

#0+F#?%6#+G)1"6-0)*+406+.0?6+<")"60?-+-?''06#+#$60?<$0?#+&.+>%D+1"<6""E

#0+H":()+3%D;()-*+406+4(">1()<+I?"-#(0)-+%)1+'0()#()<+&"+#0+?-"4?>+6"-0?6/"-E

#0+H%#"*+406+.0?6+'6"/(0?-+46(")1-$('E+%)1

#0+!?&+%)1+3%1*+406+.0?6+>0:"@

+

Page 3: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/"+ !!

!"#$%#$&'

!()*$%+,-#%',.#$+"/01$2"#"########################################################################################################### $

!()*$%+,34"',5%$()6*(%$)62#%78%9)$%/,:&;1("&2&,########################################################## %

&#$ '("!()*+,-.)!+(")+"/0)12/310)2/!(0"####################################################################### %

&#& 410"(2)-*0"+5"/0)12/310)2/!(06*072)0,"389.1+8!8"################################################ :

&#% 410"3*0;270(.0"+5"/0)12/310)2/!(06*072)0,"389.1+8!8"######################################### <

&#: =+(.7-8!+("###################################################################################################################### >

!()*$%+,3(+%%',.#$"<21)$2"#=,.#&)#2$;,)#/,>0$"6)$2&6"##################################################### ?

%#$ @()+A!.2)!+("##################################################################################################################### ?

%#& @(82(!)9"############################################################################################################################ $$

%#% '-)+/2)!8/"#################################################################################################################### $%

%#: '337!.2)!+(")+"/0)12/310)2/!(06*072)0,"389.1+8!8".2808"##################################### $:

%#< B0()0(.!(C"2(,",!83+8!)!+("########################################################################################### $<

%#D =+(.7-8!+("###################################################################################################################### $>

!()*$%+,?"0+',3(%,!0++%#$,>**+")1(,$",@2&%)&%,"A,$(%,52#/"########################################## $E

:#$ F!80280"+5")10"/!(,"####################################################################################################### $E

:#& 410"*0.-**!(C",2(C0*")10+*9"######################################################################################## &G

:#% 410"!()0*(27".2-80")10+*9"############################################################################################## &&

:#: '337!.2)!+("!(".2808"+5"!()+A!.2)!+("############################################################################ &D

:#:#$ =2808"+5"389.1+8!8",-*!(C"!()+A!.2)!+("############################################################ &>

:#:#& =2808"+5"3*060A!8)!(C"/0()27",!8+*,0*"2(,"!()+A!.2)!+("################################ &E

:#< =+(.7-8!+("###################################################################################################################### &?

!()*$%+,?2B%',>,C"92&$21,>**+")1(,$",@2&%)&%,"A,$(%,52#/"############################################### %$

<#$ '"1+7!8)!."233*+2.1")+",!80280"+5")10"/!(,"############################################################### %$

<#& H070;2()"52.)+*8"############################################################################################################## %&

<#&#$ I-J7!."3*+)0.)!+("################################################################################################# %&

<#&#& 410"(00,"5+*"2(,"233*+3*!2)0(088"+5")*02)/0()"############################################ %%

<#&#% 410"*0.-**!(C",2(C0*"52.)+*"############################################################################## %:

<#&#: 410"!()0*(27".2-80"52.)+*"#################################################################################### %<

<#% @**070;2()"52.)+*8"############################################################################################################ %D

<#%#$ =*0,!J!7!)9"+5")10"K-8)!.0"898)0/"######################################################################## %D

<#%#& I*!+*"52-7)"+5")10"2..-80,"################################################################################### %E

<#: H+708"+5"K-,C0"2(,"K-*9"################################################################################################# %?

<#< =*!)!.27"288088/0()"+5")10"1+7!8)!."233*+2.1"############################################################## :G

<#D =+(.7-8!+("###################################################################################################################### :%

Page 4: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/"+ !!!

!"#$%&'()*+,(-$$./*01(%"&(23.*4%*5(-$$'3#5"(%3(!#4&4(36(7&%"#8$"&%#8*0&9:&.#%&;(<4/5"34*4("""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" ##

$"% &'())*+(,-.)/01!2*203)3""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" ##

$"4 5++.!201!,6*1,*203)*,6)7*+382',1!2*,6.8*9'!.)*!61,:!201);*"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" #<

$"= 5++.!201!,6*1,*203)*19,7*+(,6)*1,*>?.03'-02@3A*"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" #B

$"# 5++.!201!,6*1,*203)*1'())7*.,6CD1)(/*+382',1!2*;!3,(;)(*""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" #E

$"< F,62.G3!,6*"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" <H

!"#$%&'()&=&0,(!305.>4*30*""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" <4

?*@.*31'#$"/*"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" <<

Page 5: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !

!"#$%&'()*&+(,*%'-./0%1-*

"#$%&'($)*)+,$"$-'..$/0#('1+,$%&+$*)).'/*%'0#$02$%&+$'#(*#'%3$1+2+#/+$%0$022+#1+,($-&0$-+,+$0#$

4+%&*4)&+%*4'#+$564+%&78$*#1$-+,+$)(3/&0%'/$*%$%&+$%'4+$02$022+#1'#9: $;&+$&'9&$),+<*.+#/+$02$

4+%&$=(+$*#1$*((0/'*%+1$/,'4+$'#$>?$4*@+($%&'($*$),+(('#9$'((=+:

A4)&+%*4'#+$*#1$4+%&$=(+$'#$B/+*#'*$'($%&+$&'9&+(%$)+,$/*)'%*$02$*#3$,+9'0#$'#$%&+$-0,.1C$

-'%&$*##=*.$),+<*.+#/+$,*%+($*.40(%$%-'/+$%&*%$20=#1$'#$>0,%&$A4+,'/*C$*#1$0<+,$20=,$%'4+($%&*%$'#$

D=,0)+:!$E+(+*,/&$(=99+(%($%&*%$=)$%0$0#+$F=*,%+,$02$2,+F=+#%$4+%&$=(+,($(=22+,$2,04$)(3/&0('($'#$

*#3$9'<+#$3+*,:G$E+/+#%$'#%+,<'+-($-'%&$!HI$2,+F=+#%$4+%&$=(+,($'#$>?$20=#1$%&*%$'#$%&+$.*(%$40#%&$

GJK$&*1$/044'%%+1$*$),0)+,%3$/,'4+C$$HGK$&*1$(0.1$1,=9(C$*#1$LK$&*1$/044'%%+1$*$<'0.+#%$/,'4+:H$

>=4+,0=($'#%+,#*%'0#*.$(%=1'+($&*<+$+(%*M.'(&+1$*$.'#@$M+%-++#$4+%&$=(+$*#1$<'0.+#%$/,'4+:N$;&'($

,+.*%'0#(&') $4*@+( $ '% $ '#+<'%*M.+ $ %&*% $>?$/0=,%( $-'.. $M+ $ 2*/+1 $-'%& $<'0.+#% $022+#1+,( $-&0$-+,+$

'#%0O'/*%+1$-'%&$4+%&C$*#1$)0%+#%'*..3$(=22+,'#9$2,04$)(3/&0('($*%$%&+$%'4+$02$022+#1'#9:

P+%&Q,+.*%+1$)(3/&0('($02%+#$'#<0.<+($&*..=/'#*%'0#($*#1$)*,*#0'1$1+.=('0#(C$-&'/&$4*3$,0M$

022+#1+,( $ 02 $ %&+ $ *M'.'%3 $ %0 $ *)),+/'*%+ $ %&*% $ %&+', $ */%( $ *,+ $40,*..3 $-,0#9: $ R0, $ (04+ $022+#1+,(C$

)(3/&0('($4*3$('4).3$M+$.'#@+1$%0$'#%0O'/*%'0#C$/+*('#9$-&+#$%&+3$/04+$/.+*#:$R0,$0%&+,(C$)(3/&0('($

4*3$)+,('(%$M+30#1$'#%0O'/*%'0#:$;&'($/*#$,+),+(+#%$+O*/+,M*%'0#$02$*$),+Q+O'(%'#9$4+#%*.$'..#+((C$%&+$

,+*.'(*%'0#$02$*$),+1'()0('%'0#$%0$'..#+((C$0,$*))*,+#%.3$'#+O).'/*M.+$M*1$.=/@:$"#$*#3$9'<+#$/*(+$%&+$

4+#%*.$(%*%+$02$%&+$022+#1+,$4*3$M+$=#/.+*,C$-'%&$=#/+,%*'#%3$).*9='#9$'1+#%'2'/*%'0#$02$%&+$/*=(+$02$

)(3/&0('(C $ /=,,+#% $ 1'*9#0('( $ *#1 $ 2=%=,+ $ ),09#0('(: $ ;&'( $ ,*'(+( $ ),0M.+4( $ 20, $ %&+ $ /,'4'#*. $ .*-:$

S=+(%'0#($*,'(+$*($%0$-&+%&+,$*#$022+#1+,$'#$%&+(+$/',/=4(%*#/+($(&0=.1$M+$/0#('1+,+1$,+()0#('M.+$

! "%$'($+(%'4*%+1$%&*%$G:LK$02$%&+$%0%*.$B/+*#'*$)0)=.*%'0#$=(+1$*4)&+%*4'#+$0,$4+%&*4)&+%*4'#+$'#$GTTI:$;&'($/*#$M+$/0#%,*(%+1$-'%&$%&+$*##=*.$),+<*.+#/+$,*%+($'#$>0,%&$A4+,'/*$02$!:NK$*#1$'#$D=,0)+$02$T:NQT:LKU$V#'%+1$>*%'0#($B22'/+$0#$W,=9($*#1$X,'4+$6Y0,.1$W,=9$E+)0,%$GTTZ7$5GTTZ8$V#'%+1$>*%'0#($B22'/+$0#$W,=9($*#1$X,'4+$---:=#01/:0,9$5*//+((+1$0#$!T$[=#+$GTTZ8$*%$!NJ:

G \++$X&*)%+,$;-0$]G:H^:

" X$Y'.@'#(C$E$_,'22'%&($*#1$`$\-++%(=,$6E+/+#%$;,+#1($'#$"..+9*.$W,=9$V(+$'#$>+-$?+*.*#1C$GTTLQGTTaU$R'#1'#9($2,04$%&+$"..'/'%$W,=9$P0#'%0,'#9$\3(%+4$5"WP\87$5GTTZ8$X+#%,+$20,$\0/'*.$*#1$b+*.%&$B=%/04+($E+(+*,/&$*#1$D<*.=*%'0#C$P*((+3$V#'<+,('%3$---:(&0,+:*/:#c$5*//+((+1$0#$!T$[=#+$GTTZ8$*%$!aG:

N \++$\&*#+$W*,@+C$\&*,.+#+$d*3+C$E+M+//*$P/d+%'#$*#1$[0&*#$W=2.0=$6P*e0,$)&3('/*.$*#1$)(3/&0.09'/*.$&*,4($02$4+%&*4)&+%*4'#+$=(+7$5GTTa8$!I$W,=9$*#1$A./0&0.$E+<'+-$GJH$*%$GJaQGJZ:

Page 6: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !

"#$%&'()$%*+&)#,-.%/#&)#,-%#"%$(-0#,-)1)2)&3%+*,%+#,"2)+&%4)&'%+#,+($,-%"#$%0$#&(+&)#,%#"%&'(%0512)+.%

6)*7,#-&)+%5,+($&*),&3%'()7'&(,-%&'(-(%8)"")+52&)(-.%95$&'($:%8)-0#-)&)#,%$*)-(-%(&')+*2%8)2(;;*-:%4)&'%

+#,+($,-%*1#5&%&'(%*00$#0$)*&(%5-(%#"%"#$(,-)+%0-3+')*&$)+%4*$8-%*,8%&'(%$#2(%#"%0-3+')*&$)-&-%*-%

<*)2($-.%=22%#"%&'(-(%)--5(-%+#;(%&#%*%'(*8%),%&'(%*002)+*&)#,%#"%&'(%),-*,)&3%8("(,+(:%-(&%#5&%),%-(+&)#,%

!>%#"%&'(%?$);(-%=+&%@AB@:%&#%+*-(-%),C#2C),7%;(&'%*,8%0-3+'#-)-.%D0(+)")+*223:%&'(%),&($0$(&*&)#,%#"%

&'(%8)-(*-(%#"%&'(%;),8%EF6GHIJK%(2(;(,&%#"%-(+&)#,%!>%)-%+(,&$*2%&#%8(&($;),),7%4'(&'($%;(&'L

),&#M)+*&(8%#""(,8($-%+*,%$(23%#,%&'(%),-*,)&3%8("(,+(.

H')-%0*0($%4)22%0$#C)8(%&'(%1*-)-%"#$%*,%),"#$;(8%*,8%0$),+)02(8%*002)+*&)#,%#"%&'(%),-*,)&3%

8("(,+(%&#%+*-(-%),C#2C),7%;(&'%*,8%0-3+'#-)-.%N(+(,&%-+)(,&)")+%$(-(*$+'%4)22%1(%-5;;*$)-(8%*,8%

2),O(8%&#%*,%(M*;),*&)#,%#"%&'(%6GHI%(2(;(,&%#"%&'(%),-*,)&3%8("(,+(.%H')-%4)22%(,*12(%&'(%;#-&%

0$#12(;*&)+%+*-(-%*,8%&'(%,*&5$(%#"%&'(%8)"")+52&)(-%0#-(8%&#%1(%+2(*$23%)8(,&)")(8.%=%-#25&)#,%&#%&'(-(%

+*-(-%4)22%&'(,%1(%0$#0#-(8.%H')-%4)22%&*O(%&'(%"#$;%#"%*%'#2)-&)+%*00$#*+'%&#%&'(%6GHI%),P5)$3:%

4')+'%4)22%1(%-(&%#5&:%*8C#+*&(8:%*,8%&'(,%*002)(8%&#%&'(%0$#12(;*&)+%+*-(-.%GC($*22:%Q%*);%&#%;*O(%*%

0$*+&)+*2%+#,&$)15&)#,%&#%-+'#2*$-')0%),%&')-%*$(*:%(,+#5$*7),7%*%$(*-#,(8%*,8%&$*,-0*$(,&%*00$#*+'%

&#%&'(%;5+'%0512)+)R(8%)--5(%#"%;(&'L$(2*&(8%0-3+'#-)-S%),%&'(%+#,&(M&%#"%+$);),*2%#""(,8),7.

S FI(&'L$(2*&(8%0-3+'#-)-J%)-%5-(8%&'$#57'#5&%&')-%0*0($:%*-%#00#-(8%&#%F;(&'L),85+(8%0-3+'#-)-J.%H')-%$("2(+&-%&'(%8)*7,#-&)+%5,+($&*),&3%#"&(,%0$(-(,&%4'(,%8(&($;),),7%&'(%+*5-(%#"%0-3+'#-)-%(M0($)(,+(8%),%&'(%+#,&(M&%#"%;(&'L),&#M)+*&)#,.

Page 7: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !

!"#$%&'()*+,(-&%"#.$"&%#./0&12&3#%&4(5678"+6/6

" # $%&'&()% # (*+,'-$.*+/*) # &0 # 1,$%2',3.$,+ # 4-56%&-/- # /- # ',7(/',+ # /0 # .* # /*0&'1,+#

6&*-/+,'.$/&*#&0#$%,#.443/6.$/&*#&0#$%,#/*-.*/$5#+,0,*6,#/*#4'&83,1.$/6#6.-,-#/-#$&#8,#(*+,'$.9,*:#

;*0&'$(*.$,35<#=(-$#.-#1,$%2',3.$,+#4-56%&-/-#6.(-,-#4'&83,1-#0&'#3.>5,'-<#-&#$&&#/$#6.(-,-#.#%&-$#&0#

4'&83,1- # 0&' #4-56%/.$'/-$-: #?('',*$ # ',-,.'6% #&* #1,$%2',3.$,+ #4-56%&-/- #4'&@/+,- # .* # /*6&143,$,#

4/6$(',: #A/.)*&-/- #&0#4.$/,*$- #>%&#(-, #1,$%#.*+#,B4,'/,*6,#4-56%&-/- #%.- #8,,*#+,-6'/8,+#.- #.#

C6&*(*+'(1D:E#F%/-#0.'#0'&1#63,.'#6($#+/.)*&-$/6#4/6$(',#%.-#/143/6.$/&*-#0&'#$%,#.443/6.$/&*#&0#$%,#

/*-.*/$5#+,0,*6,:

G*#$%/-#6%.4$,'#G#>/33#4'&@/+,#.#8'/,0#/*$'&+(6$/&*#$&#1,$%:#G#>/33#$%,*#-(11.'/-,#.#*(18,'#&0#

',6,*$#-$(+/,-#&*#1,$%2',3.$,+#4-56%&-/-<#/+,*$/05/*)#>%.$#6.*#8,#9*&>*#>/$%#',3.$/@,#6,'$./*$5<#.-#

>,33#.-#).4-#/*#9*&>3,+),:

H:I## ######### "*#/*$'&+(6$/&*#$&#1,$%.14%,$.1/*,##

J,$%#/-#.#-5*$%,$/6#+'()#>%/6%#0(*6$/&*-#.-#.#6,*$'.3#*,'@&(-#-5-$,1#-$/1(3.*$:K#F%,#1&-$#

4&$,*$#0&'1#&0#1,$%#/-#6'5-$.3#1,$%<#>%/6%#/-#6&11&*35#9*&>*#.-##C/6,D<#C)3.--D<#C4(',D#.*+#CLD:M#

N@,* # /* # ',3.$/@,35 # 3&> # +&-,-< #1,$% # 6.(-,- # 0,,3/*)- # &0 # ,(4%&'/.< # /*6',.-,+ # ,*,')5< # %,/)%$,*,+#

6&*0/+,*6,<#)',.$,'#.$$,*$/@,*,--<#.*+#O/*/$/.335P#.#-,*-,#&0#>,338,/*):Q#R/)%#+&-,-#&0#1,$%#6.*#',-(3$#

/*#/14./',+#6&)*/$/@,#.*+#1&$&'#4,'0&'1.*6,<#6&*0(-/&*<#.)/$.$/&*<#.))',--/@,*,--<#4.'.*&/.<#.*+#

4-56%&-/-:IS#T&*)#$,'1#(-,'-#.',#&0$,*#+,4,*+,*$<#.*+#1.5#-1&9,#1,$%#-,@,'.3#$/1,-#.#>,,9<#&'#

E U$,@,#J.$%/.-<#A.*#T(81.*#.*+#T,.**,#R/+,-#CU(8-$.*6,2G*+(6,+#L-56%&-/-V#"#A/.)*&-$/6#?&*(*+'(1D#OHSSMP#EQ#W#?3/*#L-56%/.$'5#!XM#.$#!XM:

K ?%.'3,-#J,',+/$%<#?'./)#W.00,<#Y.$%3,,*#"*)2T,,#.*+#"*+',>#U.B&*#CG143/6.$/&*-#&0#?%'&*/6#J,$%.14%,$.1/*,#;-,V#"#T/$,'.$(',#Z,@/,>D#OHSSXP#I!#R.'@#Z,@#L-56%/.$'5#I[H#.$#I[!:

M W.*,#\(B$&*#.*+#].&1/#A&@,#CF%,#8('+,*#.*+#1.*.),1,*$#&0#6'5-$.3#1,$%#(-,D#OHSSMP#IKM#?J"W#IX!K#.$#IX!K:

! ]#T,,<#T#W&%*-<#Z#W,*9/*-&*<#W#W&%*-$&*<#Y#?&**&335<#Y#R.33#.*+#Z#?.-%#C?3/*/6.3#F',.$1,*$#^(/+,3/*,-#0&'#"36&%&3#.*+#A'()#?3/*/6/.*-:#]&#I[V#J,$%.14%,$.1/*,#+,4,*+,*6,#.*+#$',.$1,*$D#OHSSKP#F('*/*)#L&/*$#"36&%&3#.*+#A'()#?,*$',#G*6#_/$`'&5#a/6$&'/.#>>>:%,.3$%:@/6:)&@:.(#O.66,--,+#&*#IS#W(*,#HSSQP#.$#Hb#J,',+/$%<#W.00,<#"*)2T,,#.*+#U.B&*<#.8&@,#*#K<#I[!b#\(B$&*#.*+#A&@,<#.8&@,#*#M<#IX!K:

IS T,,<#W&%*-<#W,*9/*-&*<#W&%*-$&*<#?&**&335<#R.33#.*+#?.-%<#.8&@,#*#Q<#H:

Page 8: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !

"#$%$" & '# &('#$"'#$ & )"))'*#) & )"+%,%-". & (/ &+",'*.) & *0 & %()-'#"#1"233& 45"/ &6'77 & ."8"7*+ & '#1,"%)".&

-*7",%#1"&-*&-5"&.,9$: &,";9','#$& 7%,$",&%#.&<*,"&0,";9"#-&.*)")& '#&*,.",& -*&%15'"8"&-5"&.")',".&

"00"1-23=& >*#$ & -",<&9)" & 1%# & ,")97- & '# &<"<*,/ & 7*)): &+**, &1*#1"#-,%-'*#: & "?-,"<" &<**.& )6'#$):&

%#?'"-/ &.')*,.",): & ."+,"))'*#: &+%,%#*'%: &+)/15*)'): & %#. & 15,*#'1 & )7""+'#$ &+,*(7"<)23@& A'-5.,%6%7&

)/<+-*<)&)900",".&(/&."+"#."#-&9)",)&'#179."&'#-"#)"&1,%8'#$)&0*,&-5"&.,9$:&8'8'.&%#.&9#+7"%)%#-&

.,"%<):&+%,%#*'%:&%$$,"))'8"#")):&%#.&+)/15*<*-*,&%$'-%-'*#23!

=2=&&& &&&&&&&& 45"&#%-9,"&*0&<"-5%<+5"-%<'#"B,"7%-".&+)/15*)')&&

C"-5B,"7%-".&+)/15*)')&1%#&*119,&65","&5'$5&.*)")&%,"&%.<'#')-",".:&%#.&65","&-5","&5%)&

(""# & 7*#$ & -",< & 9)"23D& 45') & +)/15*)') & ') & -/+'1%77/ & <%,E". & 6'-5 & +",)"19-*,/ & ."79)'*#) & %#.&

5%7791'#%-'*#): & %#. & 17*)"7/ & ,")"<(7") & -5%- & )900",". & (/ & +%,%#*'. & )15'F*+5,"#'1)23G& H",)"19-*,/&

."79)'*#) & 1*#)')- &*0 & 0%7)" & ("7'"0): &65'15 & 1"#-," & %,*9#. &("'#$ & %--%1E".: & 5%,%))".: & +",)"19-". &*,&

1*#)+',".&%$%'#)-2&45')&<%/&,")97-&'#&0"%,:&%$'-%-'*#&%#.&."0"#)'8"&("5%8'*9,2&I"79)'*#%7&("7'"0)&%,"&

0',<7/ &<%'#-%'#".: & "8"# & '# & -5" & 0%1" &*0 & 17"%, &"8'."#1" &"?+*)'#$ & -5"', & %()9,.'-/23J& K%7791'#%-'*#)&

'#8*78"&0%7)"&)"#)*,/&"?+",'"#1"):&65'15&)""<&-*&("&1%9)".&(/&"?-",#%7&)-'<97%-'*#&65"#&'#&0%1-&

-5","& ')&#*&"?-",#%7&1%9)"2&K%7791'#%-'*#)&1%#&*119,& '#&,"7%-'*#&-*&%#/&*0&-5"&)"#)")23L&K*6"8",:&

-5*)"&<*)-&1*<<*#&'#&<"-5B,"7%-".&+)/15*)')&%,"&%9.'-*,/&%#.&8')9%7&5%7791'#%-'*#)23M& N9.'-*,/&

5%7791'#%-'*#)&'#8*78"&-5"&0%7)"&+",1"+-'*#&*0&)*9#.:&<*)-&1*<<*#7/&8*'1")2=O&P')9%7&5%7791'#%-'*#)&

'#8*78"&-5"&0%7)"&+",1"+-'*#&*0&"'-5",&0*,<".&'<%$")&Q"2$2:&+"*+7"R&*,&9#0*,<".&'<%$")&Q"2$2:&07%)5")&

*0&7'$5-R2=3&

33 >"":&S*5#):&S"#E'#)*#:&S*5#)-*#:&T*##*77/:&K%77&%#.&T%)5:&%(*8"&#&M:&!BD23= U9?-*#&%#.&I*8":&%(*8"&#&L:&3D@J23@ >"":&S*5#):&S"#E'#)*#:&S*5#)-*#:&T*##*77/:&K%77&%#.&T%)5:&%(*8"&#&M:&@23! V('.:&G23D V('.:&=B@23G W7"#/)&I*,"&%#.&C"7'#.%&X6""-'#$&YI,9$B'#.91".&+)/15*)')&%))*1'%-".&6'-5&1,/)-%77'#"&<"-5%<+5"-%<'#"Z&Q=OOGR&3!&N9)-,%7%)'%#&H)/15'%-,/&LG&%-&LG[&I%,E":&\%/":&C1\"-'#&%#.&I907*9:&%(*8"&#&!:&=DJ2

3J N<",'1%#&H)/15'%-,'1&N))*1'%-'*#&3(%5)0-#(/+%)1+6#%#(-#(/%7+!%)8%7+04+!")#%7+3(-091"9-:+36!;2<;=>+Q!-5&".&4"?-&]"8')'*#&N<",'1%#&H)/15'%-,'1&N))*1'%-'*#&A%)5'#$-*#&IT&=OOOR&%-&L=3BL==2

3L V('.:&L=@BL=!23M I%,E":&\%/":&C1\"-'#&%#.&I907*9:&%(*8"&#&!:&=DJ2=O N<",'1%#&H)/15'%-,'1&N))*1'%-'*#:&%(*8"&#&3J:&L=@2=3 V('.:&L=!2

Page 9: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !

"#$%&%'(#&)$*#&*+,-'#*&'%%,*+.$+#&+/#&0$+,.#&1(&2#+/3.#%$+#-&4*5)/1*'*&'0&$&21.#&+$06'7%#&8$59&

:$;#<&(1.&#=$24%#<&+/#&)$*#&1(&$&>?35#$.31%-&2$%#&8'+/&$&/'*+1.5&1(&4*5)/'$+.')&'%%0#**&$0-&-.,6&$7,*#<&

4.'2$.'%5 &8'+/ & $24/#+$2'0#*9 & :/# & -#%,*'10* & /# & *,((#.#- & '0)%,-#- & 4#.*#),+1.5 & 7#%'#(* & +/$+ & /'*&

#0#2'#*&8#.#&#0+#.'06&/'*&/1,*#&$+&0'6/+&$0-&.$4'06&/'2&'0&/'*&*%##49&@0&.#*410*#&/#&/$-&'0*+$%%#-&$&

*#.'#*&1(&#%$71.$+#&%1);*&10&/'*&-11.<&$0-&*%#4+&8'+/&$&6,0&,0-#.&/'*&7#-&$0-&$&;0'(#&75&/'*&*'-#9&A#&

$44#$.#-&+1&7#&*,((#.'06&(.12&$,-'+1.5&/$%%,)'0$+'10*<&$*&/#&8$*&1(+#0&/#$.-&+$%;'06&+1&/'2*#%(9&

B#-')$+'10&8$*&$7%# & +1&$%%#C'$+# &/'* &-#%,*'10*&$0-&/$%%,)'0$+'10*9 &A18#C#.< &8/'%# &2#-')$+#-&/#&

*##2#-&4#.2$0#0+%5&$0/#-10')9&D++#24+*&+1&.#-,)#&2#-')$+'10&%#-&+1&$&.#%$4*#&1(&4*5)/1*'*&$0-&

8#.#&+/#.#(1.#&$7$0-10#-9EE&

D01+/#.&)$*#&*+,-5&(#$+,.#-&$&FF35#$.31%-&(#2$%#&2#+/&,*#.9&G/#&7#%'#C#-&+/$+&/#.&4$.+0#.&

8$*&'0H#)+'06&/#.&8'+/&-.,6*<&+/$+&*/#&/$-&7##0&.$4#-<&$0-&+/$+&+/#.#&8#.#&)$2#.$*&4%$0+#-&'0&/#.&

/1,*#9&G/#&*,((#.#-&C'*,$%&/$%%,)'0$+'10*&'0&+/#&(1.2&1(&4#.*#),+1.5&2#**$6#*&8.'++#0&10&17H#)+*&

$.1,0-&/#.&$0-&/#.&180&*;'09&:/#*#&2#**$6#*&'0)%,-#-&+/.#$+*&+/$+&/#.&)/'%-.#0&81,%-&7#&*#=,$%%5&

/$.2#-9&@0&.#*410*#&+1&+/'*&*/#&+.'#-&+1&*).$4#&+/#&8.'+'06&1((&/#.&*;'0&8'+/&$&;0'(#9&G/#&$%*1&*%#4+&

8'+/&$&*).#8-.'C#.&$0-&*8'+)/7%$-#&,0-#.&/#.&7#-9&G/#&.#41.+#-&+/1,6/+*&1(&8$0+'06&+1&/$.2&/#.&

4$.+0#.9 & I410 & )#$*'06 & 2#+/ & ,*# & $0- & 8'+/ & 1061'06 & 2#-')$+'10< & 4*5)/1+') & *524+12* & 8#.#&

*,))#**(,%%5 & )10+.1%%#-9 & A18#C#.< & $ & *2$%% & -1*# & 1( &2#+/ & 81,%- & )$,*# & $ & .#%$4*# & 1( & 4*5)/1+')&

*524+12*9E>

:/#*#&)$*#&*+,-'#*&6.$4/')$%%5&'%%,*+.$+#&+/#&-'*+.#**'06&0$+,.#&1(&2#+/3.#%$+#-&4*5)/1*'*<&$0-&

4.1C'-#&'0*'6/+&'0+1&8/5&*,((#.#.*&1(&4*5)/1*'*&2$5&)122'+&C'1%#0+&).'2#*9

E9>&& &&&&&&&&& :/#&4.#C$%#0)#&1(&2#+/$24/#+$2'0#3.#%$+#-&4*5)/1*'*&&

:/#&.$+#&1(&4*5)/1*'*&$2106*+&2#+/&,*#.*&'*&$%$.2'06%5&/'6/9&D&.#)#0+&D,*+.$%'$0&*+,-5&1(&

,*#.*&8/1&+11;&2#+/&$+&%#$*+&10)#&210+/%5&.#41.+#-&+/$+&E>J&/$-&#=4#.'#0)#-&)%'0')$%%5&*'60'(')$0+&

EE B')/$#%&K%$,2&$0-&G,*$0&G)/,%+L&MN/#0&-1#*&$24/#+$2'0#3'0-,)#-&4*5)/1*'*&7#)12#&*)/'L14/.#0'$OP&QRSS?T&R!>&:/#&D2#.')$0&U1,.0$%&1(&V*5)/'$+.5&WRE9

E> X1.#&$0-&G8##+'06<&$71C#&0&R?9

Page 10: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !

"#$$%&'(#)'*(+, -+%+.'&'*%+(/++-*0-%(%+%#$-)"*%1")+- '(-)"/-.#+)-2/#03 -4%0)"/0,-567-*8-.#0)'&'.#()+-

+&0//(/9-.*+')':/-8*0-#-.+2&"*)'&-9'+*09/0,-8/#)%0'(1-.0*;'(/()-"#$$%&'(#)'*(+-*0-9/$%+'*(+3-<"'+-0#)/-

*8 - .+2&"*+'+ -=#+ - 55 - )';/+ -"'1"/0 - )"#( - #;*(1 - )"/ - 1/(/0#$ ->%+)0#$'#( -.*.%$#)'*(3 -4%0)"/0, - )"/-

.0/:#$/(&/-*8-.+2&"*+'+-=#+-"'1"-/:/(-#;*(1+)-)"*+/-.#0)'&'.#()+-="*-"#9-(*-?(*=(-"'+)*02-*8-

+&"'@*."0/('#-*0-*)"/0-.+2&"*)'&-9'+*09/03AB->(*)"/0->%+)0#$'#(-+)%92-0/.*0)/9-)"#)-#0*%(9-"#$8-*8-

)"/-;/)"-%+/0+-+)%9'/9-"#9-/C./0'/(&/9-&$'('&#$$2-+'1('8'&#()-"#$$%&'(#)'*(+-*0-8//$'(1+-*8-./0+/&%)'*(-

+'(&/ - %+'(1 - ;/)"3AD- E'1" - 0#)/+ - *8 - .+2&"*+'+ - #;*(1+) - ;/)" - %+/0+ - "#+ - #$+* - F//( - 0/.*0)/9-

'()/0(#)'*(#$$23A!

G/)"H0/$#)/9-.+2&"*+'+-'+-(*0;#$$2-)0#(+'/(),-0/+*$:'(1-=')"'(-9#2+-)*-#-;*()"-#8)/0-;/)"-%+/-

&/#+/+3 - E*=/:/0, - '( - # - +;#$$ - .0*.*0)'*( - *8 - &#+/+ - .+2&"*+'+ - ='$$ - F/ - /(9%0'(1, - +%11/+)'(1 - )"/-

9/:/$*.;/()-*8-#-;*0/-&"0*('&-.+2&"*)'&-&*(9')'*(3AI->:#'$#F$/-9#)#-0/1#09'(1-)"/-.0/:#$/(&/-*8-

&"0*('&-9'+*09/0+-#;*(1+)-;/)"-%+/0+-'+-:#0'#F$/3-J(/-+)%92-+%11/+)/9-)"#)-#(2="/0/-F/)=//(-57-

#(9-5D7-*8 - )"*+/-="*-+%88/0 -+)';%$#()H0/$#)/9-.+2&"*+'+ -='$$ -;#'()#'(-+*;/-+2;.)*;+-#8)/0 -#-

;*()"-*8 -#F+)'(/(&/3AK- >(*)"/0 - +)%92- 8*%(9- )"#) -AI7-*8 -.+2&"*)'& -;/)"-%+/0+ -"#9-+2;.)*;+-

$#+)'(1-;*0/-)"#(-#-;*()",-9/+.')/-#F+)'(/(&/-#(9-)0/#);/(),-=')"-5I7-"#:'(1-+2;.)*;+-$#+)'(1-

;*0/-)"#(-)"0//-;*()"+3AL-J)"/0-+)%9'/+-"#:/-0/.*0)/9-)"#)-#0*%(9-5D7-*8-.+2&"*)'&-.#)'/()+-)#?/-

8':/-2/#0+-*0-;*0/-)*-0/&*:/0,-'(-)"/-#F+/(&/-*8-*(1*'(1-;/)"-%+/36M-

<"/+/ - /;.'0'&#$ - 0/+%$)+ -.#'() - # - &*;.$'&#)/9 -.'&)%0/3 - N) - '+ - &/0)#'( - )"#) - +*;/ -;/)" -%+/0+-

9/:/$*.-$*(1/0H)/0;-.+2&"*)'&-9'+*09/0+3-E*=/:/0,-)"/-.0/:#$/(&/-*8-)"/+/-9'+*09/0+-#(9-)"/'0-$'?/$2-

9%0#)'*(-'+-8#0-80*;-&$/#03-N)-&#(-#$+*-F/-%(&$/#0-="/)"/0-*(1*'(1-.0*F$/;+-0/.0/+/()-)"/-/;/01/(&/-

*8-+&"'@*."0/('#,-*0-#$)/0(#)':/$2-+*;/-8*0;-*8-.0*)0#&)/9-90%1H'(9%&/9-.+2&"*+'+-#+-2/)-(*)-8%$$2-

AB O/F/&&#-G&P/)'(,-Q/(('8/0-G&R#0/(,-S#(-R%F;#(-#(9-R/#((/-E'9/+-T<"/-.0/:#$/(&/-*8-.+2&"*)'&-+2;.)*;+-#;*(1-;/)"#;."/)#;'(/-%+/0+U-VAMM!W-5M5->99'&)'*(-5BI6-#)-5BI63

AD X#2(/-E#$$,-Q%$'/-E#(9*,-Y"#(/-S#0?/-#(9-Q*#((/-O*++-TZ+2&"*$*1'&#$-;*0F'9')2-#(9-0*%)/-*8-#9;'('+)0#)'*(-#;*(1-#;."/)#;'(/-%+/0+-'(-Y29(/2,->%+)0#$'#U-V5LL!W-L5->99'&)'*(-K5-#)-K53

A! S#0?/,-P#2/,-G&P/)'(-#(9-S%8$*%,-#F*:/-(-B,-ADI3AI G#0&-Y&"%&?')-T[*;*0F'9')2-F/)=//(-+%F+)#(&/-%+/-9'+*09/0+-#(9-.+2&"'#)0'&-&*(9')'*(+U-VAMM!W-5M5->99'&)'*(-I!-#)-IL3

AK NF'9,-IL3AL Y//-G#)"'#+,-R%F;#(-#(9-E'9/+,-#F*:/-(-!,-6!636M Y//-4$#%;-#(9-Y&"$%)@,-#F*:/-(-AA,-K5D3

Page 11: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !

"#$%&'())$*+,- .( - /' - 0%#%&1223 - 144%5(%$ - (61( - (6)'% -7/(6 - 1# - "#$%&23/#0 - 8"2#%&19/2/(3 - () - 5'346)(/4-

$/')&$%&':-%8/$%#4%$-;)&-%<1=52%-93-1--;1=/23-6/'()&3-);-'46/>)56&%#/1:-1&%-=)&%-2/?%23-()-$%8%2)5-1-

46&)#/4-$/')&$%&*+@- .(- /'-12')-42%1&-(61(-=%(6-"'%: -%8%#-/#-2)7-$)'%': -41#-%<14%&91(%-5&%A%</'(/#0-

5'346)(/4-$/')&$%&'*++-B)7%8%&:-/#-&1&%-41'%'-"'%&'-7/(6-#)-1551&%#(-5&%$/'5)'/(/)#-()-=%#(12-6%12(6-

5&)92%=' -$%8%2)5 - 2)#0A(%&=-$/')&$%&'*+C- D6% - &%21(/)#'6/5 -9%(7%%# -=%(6 - 1#$ - 46&)#/4 -5'346)(/4-

$/')&$%&'-/'-"#4%&(1/#*-

E("$/%' - () -$1(% - $) - 42%1&23 - %'(192/'6 - (61( - F'%#'/(/>1(/)#G - 41# -)44"& - /# - ')=% -=%(6 -"'%&':-

12(6)"06-(6/'-$)%'-#)(-H"12/;3-1'-1-46&)#/4-5'346)(/4-$/')&$%&*+I-E%#'/(/>1(/)#-/'-76%&%-1-=%(6-"'%&:-

76)-61'-%<5%&/%#4%$-1-5'346)(/4-%5/')$%:-$%8%2)5'-1#-)#0)/#0-5&)5%#'/(3-()-'";;%&-'5)#(1#%)"'-

&%4"&&%#4%'-);-5'346)'/':-)&-F;21'6914?'G*-D6%'%-41#-9%-(&/00%&%$-93-&%21(/8%23-2)7-$)'%'-);-=%(6*-

D6%3-=13-12')-9%-(&/00%&%$-/#-19'(/#%#(-/#$/8/$"12'-93-=/2$23-'(&%'';"2-'/("1(/)#':-'"46-1'-;%1&-);-

4)#;2/4(-7/(6-1#)(6%&-5%&')#-)&-%8%#-(6%-;%1&-);-%=/((/#0-9)$3-)$)"&*+J-K#%-'("$3-);-,,J-19'(/#%#(-

'"9L%4(': - 76) - 61$ - 5&%8/)"'23 - %<5%&/%#4%$ - =%(6A&%21(%$ - 5'346)'/': - ;)"#$ - (61( - 1&)"#$ - +,M-

%<5%&/%#4%$-;21'6914?'-$"&/#0-1-,I-()-@N-=)#(6-5%&/)$*+!-O21'6914?'-%#$"&%$-1#376%&%-9%(7%%#-@-

() -@P@ -$13': - 1#$ - 0%#%&1223 - /#8)28%$ - (6% - '1=% -$%2"'/)#' - 1#$ -6122"4/#1(/)#' - %<5%&/%#4%$ -93 - (6%-

'"9L%4(' -76/2% -)#-=%(6*+P- B)7%8%&: - '"9L%4(' - &%("&#%$- () -1 - ()(1223 -#)&=12 - '(1(% - 1;(%& - ;21'6914?'-

51''%$* - O"&(6%&: - 1#(/A5'346)(/4 - $&"0' - 7%&% - '6)7# - () - 9% - %;;%4(/8% - /# - (&%1(/#0 - 1#$ - 5&%8%#(/#0-

;21'6914?'*+Q

@*C-- --------- R)#42"'/)#--

D6% -5&%812%#4% -); -5'346)'/' - 1=)#0'( -=%(6 -"'%&' -=1?%' - (6% -1552/41(/)# -); - (6% - /#'1#/(3-

+, O21"=-1#$-E462"(>:-19)8%-#-@@:-P,CAP,I*+@ S1&?%:-T13%:-U4T%(/#-1#$-S";2)":-19)8%-#-C:-@I!*++ S)&%-1#$-E7%%(/#0:-19)8%-#-,J:-PP*+C .9/$:-PPV-T"#/)-W"/:-D1?%)-.'6/0"&):-T/=/6/?)-X)()-1#$-E6/0%#)&/-.?%=)()-FY&%4/5/(1(/#0-;14()&'-/#-'5)#(1#%)"'-&%4"&&%#4%-);-=%(61=56%(1=/#%-5'346)'/'G-Z,QQ![-,+C-Y61&=14)2)03-+N+-1(-+NCV-E46"4?/(:-19)8%-#-@!:-!Q*

+I W"/:-.'6/0"&):-X)()-1#$-.?%=)():-19)8%-#-+C:-+NC*+J .9/$:-+N+*+! .9/$:-+NC*+P .9/$:-+NI*+Q .9/$:-+NI*

Page 12: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !

"#$#%&# ' () '*#(+,-%().-&/(#" ' )$$#%"#01 ' /% ' -*2)0(/%( ' -113#4 '5#(+,0#6/(#" ' 217&+)1-1 '*/7 ' 0#%"#0'

-%"-8-"3/61'*)0/667' -00#12)%1-96#'$)0'(+#-0'&)%"3&(:'/1'+/663&-%/(-)%1'/%"'"#631-)%1'20#8#%('(+#*'

$0)*'0#/6-1-%;'(+#-0'&)%"3&('-1'<0)%;4'=)<#8#0:'-('-1'3%&6#/0'<+#(+#0'(+#1#'-%"-8-"3/61'1+)36"'9#'

&)%1-"#0#"'6#;/667'-00#12)%1-96#4'>+#'%/(30#')$'*#(+,0#6/(#"'217&+)1-1'?-%&63"-%;'(+#'2)(#%(-/6'$)0'

1#%1-(-@/(-)%'/%"'"#8#6)2*#%(')$'/'&+0)%-&'217&+)(-&'"-1)0"#0A'-1'0#6#8/%('<+#%'/11#11-%;'<+#(+#0'

*#(+,0#6/(#"'217&+)1-1'&/%'1322)0('/'"#$#%&#'/('6/<4'B%'C+/2(#0'>+0##'B'<-66'&)%1-"#0'(+#'"-$$#0#%('

6-%#1')$'"#$#%&#'<+-&+'*/7'9#'0#6-#"'32)%'97'/%'/&&31#"'<+)'</1'*#(+,-%().-&/(#"'<+#%')$$#%"-%;4'

B%'C+/2(#01'D)30'()'E-.'B'<-66'#.2/%"')%'(+#'/226-&/(-)%')$'(+#'-%1/%-(7'"#$#%&#'-%'&/1#1')$'*#(+,

0#6/(#"'217&+)1-14

Page 13: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !

!"#$%&'()"'&&*(+,%-./0#%/-,1(+,2#,/%3(#,4(56%-7#%/27

"#$%$&'(&'))*+$,&-'+&.(&'&+$/$%$01&,.+2*%3$,&4$(2'0&+2'2$&'++5).'2$,&-.2#&4$2#&*+$&'2&2#$&

2.4$ & 56 & 566$(,.(78 & 2#%$$ & 4'.( & 0.($+ & 56 & ,$6$()$ & 4'1 & 3$ & %$0$/'(29 & .(25:.)'2.5(8 & .(+'(.21 & '(,&

'*254'2.+4;&<(&'))*+$,&-.00&3$&6*001&')=*.22$,&.6&65*(,&25&0')>&&")-+5"%8&5%&25&#'/$&3$$(&')2.(7&.(&'&

+2'2$&56&'*254'2.+4;&?6&65*(,&(52&7*.021&31&%$'+5(&56&.(+'(.218&'&=*'0.6.$,&')=*.22'0&-.00&$(+*$;&@#$&

'))*+$,&)5*0,&2#$(&3$&2%$'2$,&.(&'&4$(2'0&#$'02#&.(+2.2*2.5(A&#5-$/$%8&#$BC&)5*0,&(52&3$&,$2'.($,&.(&

D%.+5(;&<02$%('2./$018&.6&'00&0.($+&56&,$6$()$&'%$&*(+*))$++6*08&#$&+#5*0,&3$&)5(/.)2$,&'(,&+$(2$()$,;&

E(&+$(2$().(7&'&2#$%'D$*2.)&5%,$%&)5*0,&3$&.4D5+$,8&-#.)#&-5*0,&'005-&65%&2%'(+6$%&3$2-$$(&D%.+5(&

'(,&#5+D.2'0&'+&%$=*.%$,;&

?( & 2#.+ & )#'D2$% & ? &-.00 &D%5/.,$ &' &3%.$6 &5/$%/.$-&56 & 2#$ & 0'- &56 & .(25:.)'2.5(8 & .(+'(.21 & '(,&

'*254'2.+48&2#$&+$(2$().(7&'(,&,.+D5+.2.5(&5D2.5(+8&'(,&2#$&'DD0.)'2.5(&56&2#.+&0'-&25&)'+$+&56&4$2#F

%$0'2$,&D+1)#5+.+;

G;H&& &&&&&&&&& ?(25:.)'2.5(&&

?(25:.)'2.5(&.+&(52&'&,$6$()$&25&'&)%.4.('0&)#'%7$ &'"5+-";&I5-$/$%8&'(&'))*+$,&4'1&%$01&5(&

.(25:.)'2.5(&25&+*DD5%2&'&)0'.4&2#'2&#$&,.,&(52&D5++$++&2#$&4$(2'0&+2'2$&%$=*.%$,&31&2#$&566$()$&-.2#&

-#.)#&#$&.+&)#'%7$,;BH&J5%&$:'4D0$8&.6&'(&'))*+$,&.+&)#'%7$,&-.2#&'++'*02&-.2#&.(2$(2&25&.(K*%$8BL&#$&

4'1&+*34.2&2#'2&#$&,.,&(52&.(2$(,&25&.(K*%$&2#$&/.)2.48&566$%.(7&$/.,$()$&56&.(25:.)'2.5(&25&+*DD5%2&

2#.+; & ?(25:.)'2.5( &-.00 & 3$ & 5($ & )5(+.,$%'2.5( & '45(7+2 &4'(1 & 2'>$( & .(25 & '))5*(2 & 31 & 2#$ & K*%1 & .(&

,$2$%4.(.(7&-#$2#$%&2#$&'))*+$,&#',&2#$&%$=*.+.2$&.(2$(2;&?(&M$-&N$'0'(,8&$/.,$()$&56&.(25:.)'2.5(&

.+&%$0$/'(2&.(&'++$++.(7&2#$&D%$+$()$&56&'(1&4$(2'0&+2'2$&%$=*.%$,&31&'(&566$()$8&.()0*,.(7&.(2$(2.5(8&

>(5-0$,7$8&%$)>0$++($++8&'(,&2#$&%$=*.%$4$(2&2#'2&)5(,*)2&3$&/50*(2'%1;BG&?4D5%2'(2018&2#$&5(*+&56&

BC ?&-.00&*+$&O#$P&2#%5*7#5*2&2#.+&D'D$%&-#$(&%$6$%%.(7&25&'(&'))*+$,&-#5&-'+&+*66$%.(7&6%54&4$2#F%$0'2$,&D+1)#5+.+&'2&2#$&2.4$&56&566$(,.(7;&@#.+&.+&(52&+.4D01&65%&$'+$&56&$:D%$++.5(8&3*2&'0+5&%$60$)2+&2#'2&'%5*(,&QRS&56&MN&4$2#&*+$%+&'%$&4'0$9&".0>.(+8&T%.66.2#+&'(,&U-$$2+*%8&'35/$&(&G8&LV;

BH 6+7+8%&('"9(+WH!QRX&L&MNYZ&[HC&\]<^&'2&[H[;BL ]%.4$+&<)2&H![H8&+&H!G;BG 6+7+8%&('"9(8&'35/$&(&BH8+[HB;&@#$&_(70.+#&'DD%5')#8&+$2&5*2&.(&3(5"/#05+04+,:;9(/+,50-"/:#(0)-+7+!%<"=->(&WH!QQX&<]&BBG&

Page 14: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !"

#$%&'()*+,-*$-./'0'+-*1-(+23 *0+2+-*$-0+0*%(*+,-*#$%0-4/+'%(566* 7,-$-8%$-9 * '+ *:'33 *0/88'4-*+%*-042#-*

4%(&'4+'%(*'8*+,-*;/$<*'0*3-8+*:'+,*2*$-20%(2=3-*>%/=+*2=%/+*+,-*244/0->?0*1-(+23*0+2+-*2+*+,-*+'1-*%8*

%88-(>'()5*@-20%(2=3-*>%/=+*12<*-A'0+*'(*420-0*:,-$-*+,-*244/0->9*23+,%/),*'(+%A'42+->9*:20*0+'33*

2=3-*+%*8%$1*+,-*$-./'0'+-*1-(+23*0+2+-9*=/+*12<*(%+*,2&-*>%(-*0%5*7,-*12++-$*%8*'(./'$<*'0*B+,-*824+*

%8*'(+-(+*$2+,-$*+,2(*+,-*42#24'+<*8%$*'(+-(+C56D*7,-$-8%$-9*23+,%/),*-&'>-(4-*+,-*244/0->*:20*+%+233<*

/(2=3-*+%*8%$1*+,-*$-./'0'+-*1-(+23*0+2+-*:%/3>*8%/(>*2*0+$%()*>-8-(4-*420-9*'+*'0*(%+*(-4-002$<*+%*

-042#-*4%(&'4+'%(5*E8*+,-*;/$<*8'(>0*+,2+*+,-*244/0->*>'>*,2&-*+,-*$-./'0'+-*1-(+23*0+2+-9*+,-*824+*+,2+*

,-*:%/3>*(%+*,2&-*8%$1->*+,2+*'(+-(+*'8*,-*:-$-*0%=-$*'0*(%+*2*>-8-(4-5*F*>$/(G-(*'(+-(+*'0*0+'33*2(*

'(+-(+56H*7,-*021-*2##$%24,*'0*+2G-(*+%*'(+%A'42+'%(*2$'0'()*8$%1*>$/)*/0-56I

F3+,%/),*'(+%A'42+'%(*12<*=-*2*824+%$*3-2>'()*+%*2(*244/0->?0*24./'++23*%(*%(-*4,2$)-9*+,'0*

>%-0*(%+*1-2(*,-*:'33 *(-4-002$'3<*-042#-*#/('0,1-(+5 *E(+%A'42+'%(*12<*#$-&-(+*+,-*#$%0-4/+'%(*

8$%1*#$%&'()*2*4,2$)-*:,'4,*$-./'$-0*2*&-$<*0#-4'8'4*1-(+23*0+2+-5*J-&-$+,-3-009*+,-<*12<*#$%&-*2*

3-00-$ *%88-(4-9 *:'+, *2 * 0'1#3-$ *1-(+23 * -3-1-(+5 *K%$ *-A21#3-9 * +,- *#$%0-4/+'%(*12< *(%+ * 0-4/$- *2*

1/$>-$*4%(&'4+'%(*'8*+,-<*2$-*/(2=3-*+%*#$%&-*+,2+*+,-*244/0->*1-2(+*+%*42/0-*>-2+,9*%$*+%*42/0-*

=%>'3< * '(;/$< *,- *G(-:*:20 * 3'G-3< * +% * 42/0- *>-2+,9 *=-'() * $-4G3-00 * 20 * +% *:,-+,-$ *>-2+, * -(0/->56L*

M%:-&-$9*12(032/),+-$*12<*=-*#$%&-(*=<*-&'>-(4-*+,2+*+,-*244/0->*2##3'->*8%$4-*+%*+,-*&'4+'19*+,2+*

,-*'(+-(>->*+%*2##3<*8%$4-9*2(>*+,2+*+,'0*24+*42/0->*+,-*&'4+'1?0*>-2+,56N*F(*'(+%A'42+->*%88-(>-$*'0*

/(3'G-3<*+%*2&%'>*2*4%(&'4+'%(*-(+'$-3<5*E+*'0*'1#$%=2=3-*2(*244/0->*:'33*0/44-008/33<*420+*>%/=+*%(*+,-*

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`$-00*^A8%$>*W""HQ*2+*IH"X*a2&'>*^$1-$%>*C&(#$+%)1+D0E%)+@=(&()%;+A%6+O!W+,*->*^A8%$>*_('&-$0'+<*`$-00*^A8%$>*W""LQ*2+*\"NX*b32(&'33-*c'33'210*F"G#H007+04+@=(&()%;+A%6+OZ+-&-(0*P%(>%(*!NILQ*2+*6I!d6IH*5

66 8+9+>%&('";(9+2=%&-*(*6!9*H!H56D E='>9*H!H56H ?##0=)".I<")"=%;+40=+J0=#$"=)+2=";%)1+9+<%;;%E$"=+U!NH\V*FS*\6N*OMPQ*2+*\L"X*8+9+C$""$%)+U!NIDV*!*cP@*I\N*OSFQ*2+*I66X*8+9+>()E-#0)+U!NNDV*W*FS*\DD*OMPQ*2+*\HN5

6I 8+9+A('&%)+U!NI"V*!*e[*!DW*OSFQ*2+*!DH56L S$'1-0*F4+*!NH!9*0*!HI56N S$'1-0*F4+*!NH!9*00*!H"OWQO2Q9*!I!*2(>*!NH5

Page 15: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !!

"#$%$&'$()* (+,%-' (.$&/,0 ($0$.$&/% ( 1%2'3(,% (4)02&/,#-&$%%56 (,&7( /3$#$ (8-00 (9$&$#,00: (+$ (, ('3,#9$(

,4,-0,+0$(83$#$("#))*()*(/3-%(8-00(%2**-'$;<=

>;?(( ((((((((( @&%,&-/:((

A3$(-&%,&-/:(7$*$&'$(-%(%$/()2/(-&(%$'/-)&(?>()*(/3$(B#-.$%(C'/(!DE!;(@/(9)4$#&%(/3$(&,##)8(

'-#'2.%/,&'$% ( -& (83-'3(.$&/,0 (,+&)#.,0-/: (',& (#$&7$# (,&(,''2%$7('#-.-&,00: ( -##$%")&%-+0$; (A3$(

"#)4-%-)&(#$,7%(,%(*)00)8%F

!" #$%&$'()

(1!5 G4$#:()&$(%3,00(+$("#$%2.$7(/)(+$(%,&$(,/(/3$(/-.$()*(7)-&9()#().-//-&9(,&:(,'/(2&/-0(/3$(

')&/#,#:(-%("#)4$7;(

(1?5 H)("$#%)&(%3,00(+$(')&4-'/$7()*(,&()**$&'$(+:(#$,%)&()*(,&(,'/(7)&$()#().-//$7(+:(3-.(

83$&(0,+)2#-&9(2&7$#(&,/2#,0(-.+$'-0-/:()#(7-%$,%$()*(/3$(.-&7(/)(%2'3(,&($I/$&/(,%(/)(

#$&7$#(3-.(-&',",+0$(J((

1,5 K*(2&7$#%/,&7-&9(/3$(&,/2#$(,&7(L2,0-/:()*(/3$(,'/()#().-%%-)&6()#(

1+5 K*(M&)8-&9(/3,/(/3$(,'/()#().-%%-)&(8,%(.)#,00:(8#)&9N(3,4-&9(#$9,#7(/)(/3$(

')..)&0:(,''$"/$7(%/,&7,#7%()*(#-93/(,&7(8#)&9;

A3$ ("#$%2."/-)&()* ( %,&-/: ( -& ( %2+%$'/-)& ( 1!5 (.$,&% ( /3,/ ( /3$ (,''2%$7 (+$,#% ( /3$ ()&2% ()*(

"#)4-&9(-&%,&-/:N()&(/3$(+,0,&'$()*("#)+,+-0-/-$%;<!(@&(%).$(',%$%(/3$(O279$(.,:(0$,4$(-&%,&-/:(/)(/3$(

O2#:($4$&(/3)293(/3$(,''2%$7(7-%,4)8%(/3$(7$*$&'$;(A3-%(')207()''2#(83$#$(/3$(,''2%$7(,772'$%(

$4-7$&'$()*(.$/3P#$0,/$7("%:'3)%-%(-&()#7$#(/)(&$9,/$(,(.$&/,0($0$.$&/()#(/)("0$,7(,2/).,/-%.N(,&7(

<= B)&'$#&(3,7(+$$&($I"#$%%$7(/3,/(,00)8-&9(')&%-7$#,/-)&()*(-&/)I-',/-)&(-&(#$0,/-)&(/)(,00(/:"$%()*(.$&/,0(%/,/$N(-&'027-&9(#$'M0$%%&$%%(,&7(4)0-/-)&N(8)207(0$,7(/)(3-93(#,/$%()*(,'L2-//,0(,&7(,&($#)%-)&()*(/3$(O2%/-'$(%:%/$.Q%('#$7-+-0-/:;(R)8$4$#N(/3$%$(')&'$#&%(3,4$("#)4$&(/)(+$(2&*)2&7$7F(B,#7N(,+)4$(&(S>N(TE=6(K#.$#)7N(,+)4$(&(S>N(>=D;

<! 5006&()7#0)+8+3(9"/#09+04+,:;6(/+,90-"/:#(0)-+U!D><V(CB(SE?(1RW56(<+8+=0##6"+U!D<XV(HYWZ(DDD(1BC5(,/(!=!SN(!=??(,&7(!=>!;

Page 16: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !"

#$%&%'()*+#,)#$%-&),./-#()-/)-,,+%01"

23& ) ./ ) -/,./-#( ) 4%5%/6% ) #3 ) ,+66%%47 ) -# )8+,# ) 5-&,# ) '% ) %,#.'9-,$%4 ) #$.# ) #$% ) .66+,%4 ):.,)

;9.'3+&-/<)+/4%&)/.#+&.9)-8'%6-9-#()3&)4-,%.,%)35)#$%)8-/4=).#)#$%)#-8%)35)#$%).99%<%4)355%/4-/<0)

>.#+&.9)-8'%6-9-#()$.,)'%%/)%?+.#%4):-#$),+'/3&8.9-#(7)8%/#.9)&%#.&4.#-3/7)./4)-/#%99%6#+.9)4-,.'-9-#(0)

@#)63A%&,)'3#$)63/<%/-#.9)4%5%6#,7)./4)4%5%6#,)4%A%93*%4)9.#%&)-/)9-5%)4+%)#3)/.#+&.9)4%6.(01B)CDEF)

-,).)#%&8):$-6$);4%5-%,)*&%6-,%)4%5-/-#-3/)./4):$-6$)6./)638*&%$%/4)8%/#.9)4%&./<%8%/#)-/)#$%)

:-4%,#),%/,%=01G) @#)-,).)9%<.97)/3#)8%4-6.97)63/6%*#0)E$%&%53&%7):$%#$%&)./()63/4-#-3/)?+.9-5-%,).,).)

CDEF):-99)'%)4%#%&8-/%4)'()#$%)H+4<%).,).)8.##%&)35)9.:011)@):-99)5+&#$%&)%I*93&%)#$-,)*&3'9%8.#-6)

%9%8%/#)35)#$%)-/,./-#()4%5%/6%)-/)J$.*#%&,)23+&)./4)2-A%0

@5).)/.#+&.9)-8'%6-9-#()3&)CDEF)-,)%,#.'9-,$%47)-#)8+,#)#$%/)'%),$3:/)#$.#)#$%).66+,%4):.,)

-/6.*.6-#.#%4).#)#$%)#-8%)35)355%/4-/<)-/)3/%)35)#$%),#.#%4):.(,0)2-&,#7)-#)8.()'%),$3:/)#$.#)#$%)

.66+,%4 ) 4-4 ) /3# ) +/4%&,#./4 ) #$% ) *$(,-6.9 ) ;/.#+&% ) ./4 ) ?+.9-#(= ) 35 ) $-, ) 63/4+6#01K) E$-, ) 63A%&,)

6-&6+8,#./6%, ):$%&% ) #$% ) .66+,%4 ):., )/3# ) 63/,6-3+, )35 ) .6#-/< ) L%0<07 ) 4+&-/< ) . )4-,,36-.#-A% ) ,#.#%)

53993:-/<)./)%*-9%*#-6),%-M+&%N71O)3&)8-,.**&%$%/4%4)%/#-&%9():$.#)#$%():%&%)43-/<)L%0<07)#$%()#$3+<$#)

#$%():%&%)6+##-/<)'&%.4)'+#)-/)5.6#)6+#).)*%&,3/P,)#$&3.#N01Q)R9#%&/.#-A%9(7)./)-/,./-#()4%5%/6%)6./)

,+66%%4)-5 )./).66+,%4)4-4)/3#)S/3:)$-,)63/4+6#):.,)83&.99():&3/<0)E$-,)63A%&,)6-&6+8,#./6%,)

:$%&%)#$%).66+,%4):.,)+/.'9%)#3)#$-/S)&.#-3/.99().'3+#)#$%)83&.9)?+.9-#()35)$-,)63/4+6#71T)3&):$%&%)

#$%).66+,%4)S/%:)*%3*9%):3+94)&%<.&4)$-,)63/4+6#).,):&3/<7)'+#)'%9-%A%4)$-8,%95)#3)'%).'3A%)

H+4<8%/#)3/)83&.9),#./4.&4,0KU)V$-6$%A%&)53&8)35)-/6.*.6-#.#-3/)-,)&%9-%4)+*3/7)-#)8+,#)'%),$3:/)

1" J&-8-/.9)W&36%4+&%)LF%/#.99()@8*.-&%4)W%&,3/,N)R6#)"UUB7),)"ULGN0)E$%)H+4<%).9,3)$.,)#$%)*3:%&)#3)&%?+-&%).)8%4-6.9)&%*3&#)#3)'%)*&%*.&%4)53&)#$%)*+&*3,%)35).,,-,#-/<)#$%)63+&#)#3)4%#%&8-/%):$%#$%&)#$%).66+,%4):.,)-/,./%X)J&-8-/.9)W&36%4+&%)LF%/#.99()@8*.-&%4)W%&,3/,N)R6#)"UUB7),)BQ0)

1B Y3'%&#,3/)L%4N7).'3A%)/)GB7)ZJR"B0UG[\)V.&&%/)]&33S'./S,)./4)^./4()^-8*,3/)L%4,N),-./$(%#5.+%)1+#$"+6%7+L_%I-,>%I-,)V%99-/<#3/)"UUON).#)!BG0

1G 8+9+:0##;"7).'3A%)/)1!7)!U!!011 @'-47)!"UQ\)<5%##.+9+=##05)".>?")"5%;+405+@05#$"5)+25";%)1+Z!TKB[)RJ)BQK)L`_N).#)G!"01K E$%),#.#+#3&()9./<+.<%),+<<%,#,)#$.#)#$%).66+,%4)8+,#)'%);-/6.*.'9%=)35)+/4%&,#./4-/<)#$%)/.#+&%)./4)?+.9-#()35)$-,)63/4+6#0)`3:%A%&7)#$%)536+,)35)-/?+-&(),$3+94)/3#)'%)#$%)6.*.6-#()35)#$%).66+,%4)#3)+/4%&,#./47)'+#)#$%)%I-,#%/6%)3&)/3/a%I-,#%/6%)35)#$-,)+/4%&,#./4-/<0)E$%),.8%).**&3.6$).**9-%,):$%/)63/,-4%&-/<):$%#$%&)#$%).66+,%4)S/%:)$-,)63/4+6#):.,)83&.99():&3/<X)8+9+!%/&(;;%)+Z!TKK[)>b_Y)K!K)LJRN).#)K"!\)8+9+3(A0)+Z"UUO[)>bJR)BTQ\)Z"UUQ[)")>b_Y)K!O)LJRN).#)ZB"[0

1O 8+9+BC;;(9%)+Z!TQG[)RJ)!1K)L`_N).#)!OB\)8+9+:0##;"7).'3A%)/)1!7)!UUT01Q 3(5"/#05+04+,CD;(/+,50-"/C#(0)-+9+<"%51+Z!T"U[)RJ)GOT)L`_N).#)GQU01T 8+9+,05#"5+L!TBBN)11)J_Y)!Q")L`JRN).#)!QTa!TU\)8+9+!%/&(;;%)7).'3A%)/)1K7)K!T0KU 8+9+!%/&(;;%)7)).'3A%)/)1K7)K"U)./4)K""0

Page 17: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !"

#$%#&#$'(&)%(&*%+(,-&./&#$,&0%#+1%2&'3.,*'2'#/&41&5678&91,:'4+(2/&,(#%.2'($,-;&

<=&#$,&>+1/&'(&(%#'(=',-?&40&#$,&.%2%0*,&4=&914.%.'2'#',(?&#$%#&#$,(,&1,@+'1,3,0#(&$%:,&.,,0&3,#?&

#$,/&($4+2-&-,2':,1&%&:,1-'*#&4=&A04#&B+'2#/&40&%**4+0#&4=&$'(&'0(%0'#/C;D!

";"&& &&&&&&&&& E+#43%#'(3&&

74&(,*+1,&% &*40:'*#'40&=41&34(# &4==,0*,(? & #$,&914(,*+#'40&3+(# &914:,& #$%# & #$,&%*# &)%(&

*%11',-&4+#&./&#$,&%**+(,-&)'#$&*40(*'4+(&:42'#'40;DF& <0&4#$,1&)41-(?&#$,/&3+(#&($4)&#$%#&#$,&%*#&

)%(&%&)'22,-&.4-'2/&34:,3,0#;D"&<=&#$,&%*#&)%(&+0)'22,-?&+0*40(*'4+(?&41&'0:42+0#%1/&#$,&%**+(,-&$%(&

%&-,=,0*,&4=&%+#43%#'(3;&G'H,&#$,&#,13&5678?&%+#43%#'(3&$%(&%&2,B%2&3,%0'0B&)$'*$&-4,(&04#&

%2'B0&-'1,*#2/&)'#$&%0/&3,-'*%2 &-,='0'#'40;DI& E+#43%#'(3&%#& 2%)&,J#,0-(&#4&*4:,1&%*#(&*433'##,-&

)$'2,&(2,,9)%2H'0BDK&%0-&-+1'0B&%0&,9'2,9#'*&='#;DD&<#&%2(4&*4:,1(&2,((,1&(#%#,(&4=&-'((4*'%#'40&*%+(,-&./&

*40*+(('40?DL&$/9,1B2/*%,3'%?DM&$/94B2/*%,3'%?DN&%0-&O*40#14:,1('%22/P&%&9(/*$424B'*%2&.24);LQ

&<0&#$,&%.(,0*,&4=&,:'-,0*,&#4&#$,&*40#1%1/?&'#&)'22&.,&'0=,11,-&#$%#&%0&%**+(,-R(&*40-+*#&)%(&

:42'#'40%2;&7$,1,=41,?&'0&41-,1&#4&1%'(,&#$'(&-,=,0*,&#$,&%**+(,-&3+(#&-'(*$%1B,&%0&,:'-,0#'%2&40+(&./&

%--+*'0B &,:'-,0*, & #$%# &B':,( &$'( & *2%'3&4= &%+#43%#'(3&%0&%'1 &4= & 1,%2'#/;L!& &SJ9,1# & ,:'-,0*,&)'22&

B,0,1%22/ &., & 1,@+'1,- & #4 & %*$',:, & #$'(;LF& 60*, & #$'( & ,:'-,0#'%2 &.+1-,0 & '( &-'(*$%1B,-? & '# & '( & =41 & #$,&

914(,*+#'40&#4&,J*2+-,&1,%(40%.2,&-4+.#(&9,1#%'0'0B&#4&%+#43%#'(3;L"

T$,1,&%+#43%#'(3&'(&%**,9#,-&./&#$,&>+1/? &#$,1,&%1,&#)4&94(('.2,&4+#*43,(U& '0&*%(,(&4=&

A(%0,V%+#43%#'(3C&#$,&%**+(,-&)'22&1,*,':,&%0&4+#1'B$#&%*@+'##%2W&'0&*%(,(&4=&A'0(%0,V%+#43%#'(3C&%&

D! X1'3'0%2&Y14*,-+1,&O8,0#%22/&<39%'1,-&Y,1(40(P&E*#&FQQ"?&(&FQ;DF 5+6+70##8"?&%.4:,&0&K!?&!QQL;D" T'22'%3(?&%.4:,&0&I"?&!IMW&Z,41B,&[2,#*$,1&&9%-(/+70)/"'#-+04+7:(&()%8+;%<+O6J=41-&\0':,1('#/&Y1,((&],)&^41H&!NNMP&%#&II;

DI ,08(/"+6+9%))()+_!NN!`&F&]aGb&F"L&OcXP&%#&FI!;DK d,,&5+6+,%:=-+!K&Xb&OI#$P&FMN&OdXXPW&5+6+9>:?"--+_!NN!`&F&ef&NF&OXEP;DD d,,&5+6+@>88(6%)?&%.4:,&0&KLW&9:%##.+6+A##0:)".BC")":%8+40:+D0:#$":)+2:"8%)1?&%.4:,&0&KKW&5+6+!"11()?-+_!NDD`&gb&"QD&OdXP;DL d,,&700'":+6+!/E"))%+_!NDQ`&e-&b&IQD&OdXP;+DM d,,&5+6+F"))"--.+_!NMN`&!&TGb&FML&OXEP;DN d,,&5+6+G>(/=+_!NL"`&!&ef&N!Q&OXEP;LQ d,,&5+6+5%H".+_!NMQ`&F&dXb&K!"&OdXXP;&<0&#$%#&*%(,&#$,&%**+(,-&%##%*H,-&%&=,3%2,&=1',0-&%=#,1&(+==,1'0B&%&9(/*$424B'*%2&.24)U&='0-'0B&4+#&#$%#&($,&*40('-,1,-&$'3&A%&04#$'0BC;&d,,&%2(4&5+6+I"-8":+_FQQL`&!&]aGb&FIQ&OcXPW&5+6+@#0)"&_!NNN`&F&dXb&FNQ&OdXXP;

L! 5+6+J%8/0)":+O!NNQP&!L!&XGb&!"Q&OcXEP&%#&I";LF 5+6+5%H".?&%.4:,&0&LQ?&KKF;L" 5+6+J%8/0)":?&%.4:,&0&L!?+I";

Page 18: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !"

#$%&'()*+,*-+)*./'0)1*+-*2((+/-)*+,*'-32-')1*4'00*5$*%$(+%&$&6*7-32-$82/)+92)'39*4'00*5$*,+/-&*4:$%$*

):$*02(;*+,*(+-3('+/3*#+0')'+-*423*(2/3$&*51*2*-2)/%20*'95$('0')1*+%*<=>?6*@3*&'3(/33$&*25+#$A*):$*

'33/$*+,*'-32-')1*4'00*5$*&$)$%9'-$&*51*):$*B/%1*+-*):$*5202-($*+,*C%+525'0')'$36

D6"** ********* @CC0'(2)'+-*)+*(23$3*+,*9$):29C:$)29'-$8%$02)$&*C31(:+3'3**

>:$*+/)(+9$*+,*(23$3*'-#+0#'-.*9$):8%$02)$&*C31(:+3'3*4'00*&$C$-&*:$2#'01*/C+-*4:$):$%*

):$*2((/3$&E3*(+-&')'+-*2)*):$*)'9$*+,*+,,$-&'-.*'3*)%$2)$&*23*2*<=>?A*+%*9$%$01*23*2*,$2)/%$*+,*

'-)+F'(2)'+-6

7,*9$):8%$02)$&*C31(:+3'3*'3*2*,$2)/%$*+,*'-)+F'(2)'+-A*):$-*')3*%$0$#2-($*'3*0'9')$&6*G#'&$-($*

+,*C31(:+3'3*921*3/CC+%)*2*&$,$-($*):2)*):$*%$H/'3')$*9$-)20*3)2)$*:23*-+)*5$$-*C%+#$-A*+%*):2)*):$*

2((/3$&*423*2()'-.*'-*2-*2/)+92)'(*3)2)$6*G#'&$-($*+,*&$0/3'+-3*2-&I+%*:200/('-2)'+-3*2)*):$*)'9$*+,*

+,,$-&'-.*921*%2'3$*2*%$23+-250$*&+/5)*23*)+*):$*2((/3$&E3*9$-)20*3)2)$6*>:$%$,+%$A*9$):8%$02)$&*

C31(:+3'3*(+/0&*0$2&*)+*2(H/'))20*,+%*+,,$-($3*'-#+0#'-.*(+9C0$F*9$-)20*$0$9$-)3A*3/(:*23*9/%&$%6*

J+-#'()'+-3*2%$*9+%$*0';$01*)+*5$*3$(/%$&*,+%*+,,$-($3*4'):*%$02)'#$01*3'9C0$*9$-)20*$0$9$-)3A*3/(:*

23*92-302/.:)$%6 *7) * '3 */-0';$01*):2) *9$):8%$02)$&*C31(:+3'3*4+/0&*3/CC+%) *2*C0$2*+,*2/)+92)'396*

K$-$%2001*3C$2;'-.A*9$):8%$02)$&*C31(:+3'3*&+$3*-+)*'-#+0#$*2*0+33*+,*(+-3('+/3*#+0')'+-6*L+4$#$%A*

', *2/)+92)'39*'3 *$3)250'3:$&A *2-&*):$*9$):8%$02)$&*C31(:+3'3*):2) *:23*(2/3$&*):'3* '3 *)%$2)$&*23*2*

,$2)/%$*+,*'-)+F'(2)'+-A*):'3*4'00*0$2&*)+*2-*+/)%'.:)*2(H/'))206

7,*9$):8%$02)$&*C31(:+3'3*'3*)%$2)$&*23*2*<=>?A*')*(2-*,+%9*):$*523'3*+,*2-*'-32-')1*C0$26*M+%*

):$*'-32-')1*&$,$-($*)+*3/(($$&A*):$*C31(:+3'3*9/3)*:2#$*'-(2C2(')2)$&*):$*2((/3$&*'-*2*%$0$#2-)*4216*

M+%*$F29C0$A*2-*2((/3$&*3/,,$%'-.*,%+9*:200/('-2)'+-3*2-&I+%*&$0/3'+-3*921*-+)*:2#$*;-+4-*):$*

-2)/%$*+%*H/20')1*+,*:'3*2()A*+%*):2)*:'3*(+-&/()*423*9+%2001*4%+-.6*7,A*'-*3/(:*2*(23$A*):$*'-32-')1*

&$,$-($*'3*92&$*+/)A*2*H/20','$&*2(H/'))20*4'00 *,+00+46 *7,*') * '3*-+)*92&$*+/)A*):$*2((/3$&*921*5$*

2(H/'))$&*+/)%'.:)*+%*(+-#'()$&6*@*,/00*2(H/'))20*921*+((/%*4:$%$*$#'&$-($*+,*):$*2((/3$&E3*9$):8

%$02)$&*C31(:+3'3*0$2#$3*):$*B/%1*4'):*2*%$23+-250$*&+/5)*23*)+*):$*C%$3$-($*+,*):$*%$H/'3')$*9$-)20*

Page 19: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !"

#$%$&'()*+(,-.&/&0+(1-(0&%#-1%23&(4-52$(0&6%71#($,&(8509(#,-534(:-1/7:$';<(=#(47#:5##&4(%2-/&+(71(

:%#&#(-*(6&$,>0&3%$&4(?#9:,-#7#(:-1/7:$7-1#(%0&(#$733(37@&39($-(2&(#&:50&4(*-0(-**&1:&#(.7$,(0&3%$7/&39(

#76?3&(6&1$%3(&3&6&1$#'

A'"(( ((((((((( B&1$&1:71C(%14(D7#?-#7$7-1((

)1(6&$,(:%#&#(71/-3/71C(?#9:,-#7#($,&0&(%0&($,0&&(?-##723&(/&047:$#E(C573$9+(1-$(C573$9+(%14(1-$(

C573$9(-1(%::-51$(-*(71#%17$9'(F-33-.71C(%(1-$(C573$9(/&047:$($,&(%::5#&4(7#(&1$7$3&4($-(%1(-5$07C,$(

%:G57$$%3'(B-6&(6&%#50&(-*(:-1$0-3(-/&0($,&(%::5#&4(6%9(2&(6%71$%71&4($,0-5C,(%(:7/73(:-6?53#-09(

$0&%$6&1$(-04&0'(H-.&/&0+(%1(%:G57$$&4(?&0#-1(.733(2&(%##&##&4(%14($0&%$&4(-1($,&(#%6&(2%#7#(%#(%19(

-$,&0(?&0#-1';"(

)*($,&(%::5#&4(7#(*-514(C573$9+(,&(.733(2&(#&1$&1:&4(71(%::-04%1:&(.7$,($,&(B&1$&1:71C(=:$(

IJJI(%14($,&(K07671%3(L0-:&450&(MN&1$%339()6?%70&4(L&0#-1#O(=:$(IJJI'(P,&(#&1$&1:71C(854C&(7#(

&Q?0&##39 ( ?0-,727$&4 ( *0-6 ( $%@71C ( 71$- ( %::-51$ ( 71$-Q7:%$7-1 ( %# ( % (67$7C%$71C ( *%:$-0';R( H-.&/&0+(

476717#,&4( 71$&33&:$5%3(:%?%:7$9(-0(514&0#$%1471C+ (1-$(:%5#&4(29(/-351$%09( 71$-Q7:%$7-1+ (65#$ (2&(

$%@&1(71$-(%::-51$';;(=::-0471C39+(6&1$%3(47#-04&0(6%9(2&(%(67$7C%$71C(-0(%CC0%/%$71C(*%:$-0E(7$(:%1(

67$7C%$& (.,&0& ( $,& ( -**&14&0 ( 7# ( :-1#74&0&4 ( 3&## ( :53?%23&+;S( -0 ( 7# ( 37@&39 ( $- ( &Q?&07&1:& ( % ( C0&%$&0(

#528&:$7/& ( 76?%:$ ( *0-6 ( % ( ?&1%3$9T;U( :-1/&0#&39+ ( 6&1$%3 ( 47#-04&0 ( .,7:, ( 71:0&%#&# ( $,& ( 07#@ ( -*(

0&-**&1471C(6%9(2&(%1(%CC0%/%$71C(*%:$-0'SJ()1(:%#&#(71/-3/71C(2-$,(71$-Q7:%$7-1(%14(6&1$%3(7331&##+(

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

;S B&1$&1:71C(=:$(IJJI+(#(SM%OT(5+6+K9(L$#+VIJJ!W(A(^_`X(II(MK=O(%$(VIIWT(5+6+D(8--0)(K=(""IaUU(I;(b539(IJJJ(%$(V!JW';U B&1$&1:71C(=:$(IJJI+(#(SM,OT(5+6+K9(L$#+(%2-/&(1(;S+(VIIWT+5+6+D(8--0)+(%2-/&(1(;S+(V!JW'SJ B&1$&1:71C(=:$(IJJI+(#(;M!OMCOT(5+6+K9(L$#+(%2-/&(1(;S+(VIIW'(

Page 20: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !"

#$%&'%(#%()*(+&,-.+%&/-'#&.*'#*(+-*'$&0%#1%%(&23)#45'&)4(#5*0-#*(+&#4&422%(.*(+6&'4/%&/*#*+3#*(+&

3(.&'4/%&(4(7/*#*+3#*(+89!&:%(#%()*(+&42&/%(#3;;<&*;;&422%(.%5'&$3'&0%%(&.%')5*0%.&3'&=4(%&42&#$%&

/4'# & .*22*)-;# & #3'>' & 3 & ?-.+% & /3< & 0% & )3;;%. & -@4( & #4 & @%5245/A69B& 3' & )4(2;*)#*(+ & @-5@4'%' & 42&

5%$30*;*#3#*4(&3(.&@-0;*)&@54#%)#*4(&/-'#&0%&03;3()%.8

C2&#$%&'%(#%()*(+&,-.+%&*'&'3#*'2*%.&#$3#&#$%&422%(.%5&*'&=/%(#3;;<&.*'45.%5%.A&3(.&5%D-*5%'&

)4/@-;'45<&#5%3#/%(#69E&#$%<&$3F%&#$%&4@#*4(&42&/3>*(+&3&#$%53@%-#*)&45.%5G&245&%H3/@;%6&#$%&,-.+%&

/3<&*/@4'%&3&$<05*.&45.%56&1$%5%&3&'%(#%()%&42&*/@5*'4(/%(#&*'&$3(.%.&.41(&*(&#3(.%/&1*#$&3(&

45.%5&245&.%#%(#*4(&3'&3&'@%)*3;&@3#*%(#89I&J$*'&/%3('&#$%&422%(.%5&1*;;&0%&)4//*##%.&#4&$4'@*#3;6&0-#&

)3(&0%&#53('2%55%.&#4&3(.&254/&@5*'4(&.-5*(+&#$%&.-53#*4(&42&$*'&'%(#%()%89K&C2&#$%&422%(.%5&*'&'#*;;&*(&

$4'@*#3;&1$%(&$*'&'%(#%()%&%(.'6&$%&1*;;&0%&.%%/%.&#4&0%&3&)*F*;&@3#*%(#89"&L;#%5(3#*F%;<6&#$%&,-.+%&

/3<&5%253*(&254/&@3''*(+&'%(#%()%&%(#*5%;<6&3(.&*('#%3.&.*5%)#&#$%&422%(.%5&#4&0%&#5%3#%.&3'&3&)*F*;&

@3#*%(#89M&N*F*;&@3#*%(#'&35%&'-0,%)#&#4&)4/@-;'45<&#5%3#/%(#&45.%5'6&3(.&/-'#&0%&5%;%3'%.&4()%&#$%<&

35%&(4&;4(+%5&.*'45.%5%.899&OF%(&*2&3(&422%(.%5&*'&'%(#%()%.&#4&3&(45/3;&'%(#%()%&42&*/@5*'4(/%(#6&

3(&3@@;*)3#*4(&)3(&'-0'%D-%(#;<&0%&/3.%&245&#53('2%5&254/&@5*'4(&#4&$4'@*#3;89P

C2&#$%&3))-'%.&*'&24-(.&(4#&+-*;#<&0<&5%3'4(&42&*('3(*#<6&#$%&,-.+%&/3<&45.%5&.%#%(#*4(&3'&3&

'@%)*3;&@3#*%(#6&#5%3#/%(#&3'&3&)*F*;&@3#*%(#6&45&*//%.*3#%&5%;%3'%8PQ&J$%5%&*'&(4&@5%'-/@#*4(&3&'@%)*3;&

@3#*%(#&45.%5&1*;;&0%&/3.%6P!&0-#&#$%&,-.+%&/-'#&)4('*.%5&1$%#$%5&#$*'&*'&(%)%''35<&#4&@54#%)#&#$%&

@-0;*)8PB&C2&3&'@%)*3;&@3#*%(#&45.%5&*'&/3.%6&#$%&3))-'%.&1*;;&0%&$%;.&*(.%2*(*#%;<8&J$%<&1*;;&0%&'-0,%)#&

9! :%%&5+6+718%91-6&304F%&(&MM6&RBKS89B T355%(&3(.&:*/@'4(6&304F%&(&KB6&BBK89E J$%&,-.+%&/-'#&0%&'3#*'2*%.&#$3#&#$%&422%(.%5&5%D-*5%'&)4/@-;'45<&#5%3#/%(#6&245&#$%&422%(.%5U'&41(&'3>%&45&245&#$%&'32%#<&42&#$%&@-0;*)&45&3&@%5'4(&45&);3''&42&@%5'4(8&V%(#3;&.*'45.%5&3(.&#$%&(%%.&245&#5%3#/%(#&/-'#&0%&%'#30;*'$%.&4(&#$%&%F*.%()%&42&4(%&45&/45%&=$%3;#$&3''%''45'AG&N5*/*(3;&W54)%.-5%&XV%(#3;;<&C/@3*5%.&W%5'4('Y&L)#&BQQE6&''&EIXBY&3(.&EIXEY8

9I N5*/*(3;&W54)%.-5%&XV%(#3;;<&C/@3*5%.&W%5'4('Y&L)#&BQQE6&''&EIX!YX3YX*Y6&EIXBY&3(.&EIXEY89K C0*.6&'&I9XBY89" C0*.6&'&I9XEYX03Y89M C0*.6&''&EIX!YX0YX*Y6&EIXBY6&EIXEY&3(.&E"899 C0*.6&'&EK89P V%(#3;&Z%3;#$&XN4/@-;'45<&L''%''/%(#&3(.&J5%3#/%(#Y&L)#&!PPB6&''&IK7IM8PQ N5*/*(3;&W54)%.-5%&XV%(#3;;<&C/@3*5%.&W%5'4('Y&L)#&BQQE6&''&BI&[&B"8&P! 5+6+:%.4091+ZN&W3;/%5'#4(&\45#$&N]C&BQQI7BKI7PM6&P&^%)%/0%5&BQQI&3#&RB!S8PB N5*/*(3;&W54)%.-5%&XV%(#3;;<&C/@3*5%.&W%5'4('Y&L)#&BQQE6&'&BI8

Page 21: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !"

#$%&'()(&*'%+,-(,./%,-,+0%/(1%2$)#3/456%*)7%#+(89)*'%+,-(,./%9:$)%*::'(&*#($);5<%=$.,-,+4%(#%(/%>$+%#3,%

?()(/#,+%$>%=,*'#3%#$%7,&(7,%.3,#3,+%&$)#()9,7%7,#,)#($)%*/%*%/:,&(*'%:*#(,)#%(/%),&,//*+04%()%#3,%

()#,+,/#/%$>%#3,%:*#(,)#%$+%:98'(&%/*>,#0;%@>%#3,%?()(/#,+%/,,/%>(#4%3,5A% &*)%7(/&3*+B,%#3,%:*#(,)#4%$+%

+,&'*//(>0%3(2%*/%*%&(-('%:*#(,)#;5C%D3,%?()(/#,+%&*))$#%$+7,+%#+*)/>,+%$>%#3,%:*#(,)#%#$%:+(/$);%

E%&,)#+*'%:$()#%+,B*+7()B%/,)#,)&()B%*)7%7(/:$/(#($)%(/4%#3,+,>$+,4%#3*#%.3(',%*%:,+/$)%>$9)7%

B9('#0%*)7%(2:+(/$),7%&*)%'*#,+%8,%#+*)/>,++,7%#$%3$/:(#*'%>$+%:/0&3(*#+(&%#+,*#2,)#4%*%:,+/$)%>$9)7%

)$#%B9('#0%80%+,*/$)%$>%()/*)(#0%*)7%$+7,+,7%#$%3$/:(#*'%&*))$#%8,%#+*)/>,++,7%#$%:+(/$);%D3(/%2,*)/%

#3*#%#3$/,%>$9)7%()/*),%*+,%#3,%/$',%+,/:$)/(8('(#0%$>%#3,%2,)#*'%3,*'#3%/0/#,24%,-,)%(>%#3,(+%2,)#*'%

&$)7(#($)%(2:+$-,/%F9(&G'0%*)7%)$%>9+#3,+%#+,*#2,)#%(/%+,F9(+,7;

6;C%% %%%%%%%%% H$)&'9/($)%%

D3,%$9#&$2,%$>%*%:+$/,&9#($)%()-$'-()B%2,#3I+,'*#,7%:/0&3$/(/%.(''%#9+)%'*+B,'0%$)%.3,#3,+%

#3(/ %:/0&3$/(/ % (/ % #+,*#,7%*/ %* %JKD?4%$+ %*/ %* % >,*#9+, %$>% ()#$1(&*#($); %D3(/ %&3*+*&#,+(L*#($)%.(''%

7,#,+2(),%#3,%*-*('*8('(#0%$>%#3,%7,>,)&,%$>%()/*)(#04%*)7%#3,%,1#,)#%#$%.3(&3%#3,%:/0&3$/(/%&*)%8,%

+,'(,7%9:$)%#$%),B*#,%&")-+5"%%$+%>$9)7%*%&'*(2%$>%*9#$2*#(/2;%@#%.(''4%#3,+,>$+,4%7(&#*#,%.3,#3,+%*)%

*&&9/,7%$9B3#% #$%8,%&$)-(&#,74 %*&F9(##,7%$9#+(B3#4 %$+%>$9)7% ()/*),%*)7%:$#,)#(*''0 %/98M,&#,7%#$%

()7,>()(#,%7,#,)#($)%()%3$/:(#*';%N3(',%()%*)0%B(-,)%&*/,%#3,%/9&&,//%$>%*%7,>,)&,%.(''%8,%*%2*##,+%$>%

>*&#4%%(#%29/#%>(+/#%8,%7,#,+2(),7%*#%'*.%.3(&3%7,>,)&,/%*+,%*-*('*8',%#$%#3,%*&&9/,7;%=,+,4%#3,%&+(#(&*'%

(//9,%(/%'(G,'0%#$%8,%.3,#3,+%2,#3I+,'*#,7%:/0&3$/(/%.(''%8,%#+,*#,7%*/%*%JKD?;

56 ?,)#*'%=,*'#3%OH$2:9'/$+0%E//,//2,)#%*)7%D+,*#2,)#P%E&#%!55Q4%/%""O!P;%5< @8(74%/%RSO!P;5A D3,%&9++,)#%?()(/#,+%$>%=,*'#3%(/%#3,%=$)%D$)0%T0*'';5C H+(2()*'%U+$&,79+,%O?,)#*''0%@2:*(+,7%U,+/$)/P%E&#%QSS64%/%66;

Page 22: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !"

!"#$%&'()*+',(-"&(!+''&.%(/$$'*#0"(%*(123&#3&(*4(%"&(52.6

#$%&$%'()'(*)&(+%&$,'%-.&%/(0123$)141(41(.(5678(9)'(&$%(0:'0)1%1()9(&$%(4*1.*4&2(/%9%*3%(

$.1(14;*4943.*&(4+0-43.&4)*1(9)'(&$%(/410)14&4)*()9()99%*/%'1<(=*9)'&:*.&%-2>(5678(41(.*(4--,/%94*%/(

-%;.-(&%'+(?4&$(:*3%'&.4*(.00-43.&4)*<(@*(&$41(3$.0&%'(@(?4--():&-4*%()'&$)/)A(1&.&%+%*&1()9(?$.&(

B:.-494%1(.1(.(5678>(.*/(/413:11(&?)(&$%)'4%1(3:''%*&-2(%+0-)2%/(4*(C)'/%'-4*%(3.1%1(&)(/%&%'+4*%(

?$%&$%'(4&(41(0'%1%*&D(&$.&()9('%3:''4*;(/.*;%'>(.*/(&$.&()9(4*&%'*.-(3.:1%<(E4*.--2>(@(?4--(/413:11(&$%(

1$)'&3)+4*;1()9(&$%1%(&$%)'4%1(?$%*(.00-4%/(4*(&$%(3)*&%A&()9(4*&)A43.&4)*<

F<!(( ((((((((( 541%.1%()9(&$%(+4*/((

5678(41(.(-%;.->(*)&(+%/43.->(&%'+<GH( @&(41(9)'(&$%(I:/;%(&)(/%&%'+4*%(?$%&$%'(&$%(.--%;%/(

+%*&.-(1&.&%()9(&$%(.33:1%/>(.1(/%13'4C%/(4*(%A0%'&(%J4/%*3%>(3):-/(B:.-492(.1(.(5678(.*/(&)(/4'%3&(

&$%(I:'2(.33)'/4*;-2<G"(@*(3.1%1(?$%'%(&$%(%J4/%*3%()9(&$%(.33:1%/K1(+%*&.-(1&.&%(41(3)*&%1&%/>(4&(41(9)'(

&$%(I:'2(&)(/%&%'+4*%(?$43$(%J4/%*3%(&)(.33%0&<(L%J%'&$%-%11>(&$%2(+:1&(.00-2(&$%(-%;.-(+%.*4*;()9(

5678>(.1(1%&():&(9)'(&$%+(C2(&$%(I:/;%>(&)(&$%4'(9.3&:.-(94*/4*;1<

@* ( .&&'4C:&4*; ( +%.*4*; ( &) ( &$% ( &%'+ (5678> ( I:/;%1 ( 4* ( %99%3& ( /%&%'+4*% ( ?$) ( 3.* ( C%(

3)*14/%'%/(3'4+4*.--2(4''%10)*14C-%>GG(.*/($)?(&$%(0:C-43(1$):-/(C%(1.9%;:.'/%/(.;.4*1&(+%*&.--2(4--(

)99%*/%'1<!MM( 7$41 ( /499%'1 ( 9')+ ( &$% ( 9)3:1 ( )9 ( &$% ( +%/43.- ( 0')9%114)*> ( ?$) ( .'% ( 0'%/)+4*.*&-2(

3)*3%'*%/(?4&$(4/%*&4924*;(/41%.1%(4*()'/%'(&)(0')J4/%(&'%.&+%*&<!M!(N33)'/4*;-2>(?$4-%(&$%(3):'&1(

?4--(3)*14/%'(+%/43.-(%J4/%*3%>(&$%2(?4--(*)&(.33)'/(/%3414J%(?%4;$&(&)(4&<!MO(#$.&(&$%(-.?('%;.'/1(.1(.(

5678(3.*(.&(&4+%1(C%(9.'('%+)J%/(9')+(+%/43.-(:*/%'1&.*/4*;<!MP(7$41(3'%.&%1(&%*14)*>(?4&$(1)+%(

I:/;%1(%A0'%114*;(3)*3%'*(&$.&(&$%(-%;.-(.00').3$(&)(5678(41(Q'%;.'/%/(?4&$(4*3'%/:-4&2():&14/%()9(

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

!MP5+6+=>9?"-->(.C)J%(*(TR>(GH<

Page 23: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !"

#$%&'()!*+,-%&'./&0,#$1'21%213,4/'/1'2$1,$5,216712'8,7#9%2''//6,21,:/1'7;,216'2'%'2$160,<./1,:/42#7;,

/=>/&'6,4$,1$',#$1624/&,'./:,'$,?/,:/1'7;;8,2;;0,:78,?&/7#.,5%147:/1'7;,.%:71,&23.'6(!*@,A/6>2'/,

'.260, B%43/6,6'2;;,7''7#.,#$1624/&7?;/,</23.','$,>$;2#8,#$1624/&7'2$16(,C.26,#71,;/74,'$,&/6%;'6,'.7',

7>>/7&,21#$13&%$%6,'$,:/42#7;,>&$5/662$17;6,714,;78,>/$>;/,7;2D/(!*E

FG/1,'.$%3.,'./,B%42#27&8,.7G/,21626'/4,$1,4/521213,AHCI0,'./8,.7G/,572;/4,'$,>&$G24/,7,

#;/7& , 6'7'/:/1' ,$5 ,<.7' , 2' ,:/716( , J1 , !"@K0 , './ ,L/<,M/7;714 ,N$%&' ,$5 ,O>>/7; , 6'7'/4 , '.7' , 71,

7%'.$&2'7'2G/,>&$1$%1#/:/1',$1,'./,:7''/&,<$%;4,?/,4/62&7?;/(!*P, Q%#.,3%2471#/,26 ,6'2;; ,7<72'/4(,

L/G/&'./;/660,6$:/,#$&/,>&$>$62'2$16,#71,?/,3;/71/4,5&$:,'./,#76/,;7<(,-2&6'0,5$&,7,AHCI,'$,?/,

>&/6/1'0 , './&/ , :%6' , ?/ , 6$:/ , 2:>72&:/1' , $5 , './ , :/1'7; , 57#%;'2/6 , $5 , &/76$10 , :/:$&8 , $&,

%14/&6'714213(,O,>.862#7;,#7%6/,$5,2:>72&:/1',1//4,1$',?/,24/1'252/4,5$&,7,AHCI,'$,?/,5$%14(!*K,

Q/#$140,1$',/G/&8,426'%&?71#/,$5,'./,:/1'7;,57#%;'2/6,<2;;,?/,7,AHCI(!*",I7B$&,:/1'7;,2;;1/66/60,

6%#.,76,6#.2R$>.&/1270,#;/7&;8,9%7;258(!!*,J1,#$1'&76'0,'./,S:/&/,/=#2'7?2;2'8,$5,7,1$&:7;,:710,>7662$10,

/G/1,6'%>242'80,$?'%6/1/660,;7#D,$5,6/;5,#$1'&$;0,714,2:>%;62G/1/66),7&/,1$',426/76/6,$5,'./,:214(!!!,

L$&,7&/,>766213,6'7'/6,$5,2:>72&:/1'0,#7%6/4,?8,4&%1D/11/660,7,?;$<,'$,'./,./740,$&,.8>1$'26:(!!T,

U$</G/&0,7,AHCI,:78,&/6%;',5&$:,7;#$.$;2#,/=#/66,V/(3(0,4/;2&2%:,'&/:/16W,$&,5&$:,7,?;$<(!!X,

Y/8$14,'./6/,#;/7&,#76/60,'./,B%42#27&8,.7G/,6'&%33;/4,'$,7&'2#%;7'/,<./1,7,:/1'7;,2:>72&:/1',

<2;;,?/,7,AHCI(,O''/:>'6,7',3/1/&7;,6'7'/:/1'6,.7G/,?//1,:74/(,U$</G/&0,'./6/,.7G/,>&$G/1,

;7&3/;8,%1./;>5%;( ,C7D/,5$&,/=7:>;/,'./,.$>/;/66;8,'7%'$;$3$%6,4/5212'2$1,6/',$%',?8,'./,F13;26.,

N$%&' ,$5 ,O>>/7; , 21 ,56(/7Z!!+, 7 ,AHCI, 26 , 7 , S:/1'7; , #$142'2$1 , ['.7' , #71\ ,?/ , 572&;8 , &/37&4/4 , 76,

!*+8+9+56(/70,,7?$G/,1,E"0,"!"(!*@Y&$$D?71D6,714,Q2:>6$10,7?$G/,1,@X0,!*P]!*K(,Q//,7;6$,:()#";<";'+9+=$"+>"#$";?%)1-+V!"P"W,T,FU^^,XKP,VFNU^W(!*E8+9+@6??(9%)0,7?$G/,@P0,!PX,V71,/>2;/>'2#,<76,5$%14,'$,?/,21671/W_,8+9+A6;B"--0,7?$G/,1,E@0,!*T,V7,6;//><7;D/&,<76,5$%14,'$,?/,21671/W(

!*P8+9+C0##?"0,7?$G/,1,@!0,!*TT(!*K8+9+D"&'+[!"@P\,!,`Y,X"",VNOW,7',+*P_,8+9+C0##?"0,7?$G/,1,@!0,!*!!_,8+9+E"))"--.0,7?$G/,1,EK0,T"T_,8+9+@6??(9%)0,7?$G/,1,@P0+!PT_,8+9+,0;#";0,7?$G/,1,@"0+!K"(

!*"8+9+C0##?"0,7?$G/,1,@!0,!*!!0,!*TE,714,!*XT_,8+9+56(/70,7?$G/,1,E"0,"T*(!!*A;%##.+9+F##0;)".GH")";%?+40;+>0;#$";)+2;"?%)10,7?$G/,1,@@0,+!T(!!!8+9+,0;#";0,7?$G/,1,@"0,!KK(!!T8+9+C0##?"0,7?$G/,1,@!0+!*!!,714,!*XT(!!XJ?240,!*XT_,F##0;)".GH")";%?,40;+>0#$";)+2;"?%)1+9+H%??%B$";0,7?$G/,1,+E0,XK!_,3(;"/#0;+04+,6I?(/+,;0-"/6#(0)-+9+A"%;10,7?$G/,1,@K0,@**_,8+9+3%9(-+V!KK!W,!+,N$=,NN,@EX,VO66W(

!!+8+9+56(/70,7?$G/,1,E"(

Page 24: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !"

#$%&'()'* + (% + %, + -,%.&/)'* + # + .010/( + %1 + ,0#2%' + 1,%$ + .)20#20 + %1 + (30 + $)'.45667+ 8'%(30,+

-,%'%&'/0$0'( + /%$$%'9: + ,010,,0. + (% + 1%, + *&).#'/0 + )2 + ;%,. +<0=9)'>2 + 2(#(0$0'( + )' +5"&'?66@+ )'+

.0(0,$)')'*+A30(30, +# +<BCD+)2 +-,020'(E + )( +$#((0,2 +'%( +A30(30, + (30+/%'.)()%'+%1 + (30+$)'.+ )2+

/&,#F90+%,+)'/&,#F90E+(,#'2)(%,:+%,+-0,$#'0'(566G+C3)2+2(#(0$0'(+3#2+F00'+/,)()/)H0.+#2+*)=)'*+<BCD+

(%% + F,%#. + #' + #--9)/#()%'566I+ D%,0 + 2&//0221&9 + J&.)/)#9 + #((0$-(2 + (% + .0$#,/#(0 + (30 +F%&'.#,)02 + %1+

<BCD+3#=0+*0'0,#99:+(#K0'+(A%+1%,$2?+(30+,0/&,,)'*+.#'*0,+(30%,:+#'.+(30+)'(0,'#9+/#&20+(30%,:566L+

M+A)99+.)2/&22+0#/3+%1+(3020+)'+(&,'5

N5!++ +++++++++ C30+,0/&,,)'*+.#'*0,+(30%,:++

C30 + ,0/&,,)'* +.#'*0, + (30%,: +3#2 + )(2 +*0'02)2 + )' + (30+ J&.*$0'(2 +%1 +;%,.+<0=9)' + )' +6(77 + 8 +

9%:#";6!"+ #'. +%1 +;%,. +<0'')'* + )' +9;%##. + 8 +<##0;)".=>")";%7 + 40; +?0;#$";) + 2;"7%)1@6!6+ ;%,.+<0'')'*>2+

1%,$&9#()%'+)2+$%2(+%1(0'+/)(0.+#'.+2(#(02+(3#(+O#':+.)2%,.0,+A3)/3+3#2+$#')102(0.+)(2091+)'+=)%90'/0+

#'.+)2+-,%'0+(%+,0/&,+)2+#+.)20#20+%1+(30+$)'.456!!+C30+,#()%'#90+1%,+(3)2+#--,%#/3+)2+(3#(+-&F9)/+2#10(:+

,0P&),02+(30+.0(0'()%'+%1+)'.)=).&#92+A)(3+,0/&,,)'*+$0'(#9+.)2%,.0,256!Q+R&,(30,E+3%2-)(#9+.0(0'()%'+

A%&9. + F0 + )'#--,%-,)#(0 + )1 + (30 + .)2%,.0, + )2 + '%( + ,0/&,,)'*E + #2 + )( +A%&9. + 0$F#,,#22 +$0'(#9 + 30#9(3+

#&(3%,)()0256!N+C30,01%,0E+#+,0/&,,)'*+.)2%,.0,+)2+'0/022#,:+(%+A#,,#'(+#'+)'2#')(:+1)'.)'*5

C3)2+#--,%#/3+3#2+1%&'.+2&--%,(+)'+(30+S)*3+T%&,(+%1+8&2(,#9)#E6!7+F&(+3#2+#92%+F00'+A).09:+

667A+8+BC(/DE+#F%=0+'+@LE+L!!5+;%,.+U&2()/0+;#A(%'+-&,-%,(2+(%+,02(#(0+#+(02(+02(#F9)230.+F:+V,02).0'(+W,022%'+%1+(30+X0A+Y0#9#'.+T%&,(+%1+8--0#9+)'+A+8+E0##7"?+#F%=0+'+76E+6"665+C30+A%,.2+1)Z#(0.+&-%'+F:+;%,.+U&2()/0+;#A(%'+A0,0+%,)*)'#99:+&20.+)'+,09#()%'+(%+/),/&$2(#'/02+A30,0+#'+0Z(0,'#9+1#/(%,+#/(2+&-%'+#+-0,2%'E+/#&2)'*+#+(,#'2)0'(+$0'(#9+)$-#),$0'(5+V,02).0'(+W,022%'+/%'/9&.0.+(3#(+2&/3+#+(,#'2)0'(+0110/(+/%&9.+'%(+1#),9:+F0+.02/,)F0.+#2+#+<BCD5+[)(3+,02-0/(E+V,02).0'(+W,022%'+.).+'%(+#--0#,+(%+F0+-,%-%&'.)'*+#+(02(+1%,+*0'0,#9+#--9)/#()%'5+

66@A+8+5"&'E+#F%=0+'+6"I566GMF).E+N"G\+A+8+FC77(8%)E+#F%=0+'+7GE+6G!566IA+8+G%7/0)";E+#F%=0+'+G6E+7N\+[)99)#$2E+#F%=0+'+NQE+@IN566LC30+9#'*&#*0+%1+O(30%,)024+)2+'%(+*0'0,#99:+&20.+F:+(30+/%&,(25+S%A0=0,E+(30+(A%+K0:+#--,%#/302+#--#,0'(+)'+/#20+9#A+A0,0+.02/,)F0.+)'+(3)2+A#:+F:+;#+R%,02(+U+%1+(30+]&-,0$0+T%&,(+%1+T#'#.#?+A+8+,%;D-E+#F%=0+'+@7E+^L_5

6!"6(77+8+9%:#";+^6L7I_+6+`a+!GG+bT8c+#(+!I756!69;%##.+8+<##0;)".=>")";%7+40;+?0;#$";)+2;"7%)1E+#F%=0+'+77E+N6!56!!MF).E+N6!56!QMF).E+N6"56!NA+8+A%140;1+b6LI7c+N!+]8]d+!@@+b]Tc+#(+!G@\+[)99)#$2E+#F%=0+'+NQE+@G@56!7A+8+G%7/0)";E+#F%=0+'+G6E+7N5+S%A0=0,E+)(+)2+'%(0.+(3#(+)'+G%7/0)";+/%$$0'(2+#F%&(+(30+'0/022)(:+%1+,0/&,,0'/0+A0,0+$#.0+)'+(30+/%'(0Z(+%1+#+J&.*$0'(+A3)/3+#92%+0'.%,20.+(30+)'(0,'#9+1#/(%,+(30%,:5+]00+#92%+(30+J&.*$0'(2+%1+]3%99+U+%1+(30+]&-,0$0+T%&,(+%1+e)/(%,)#+)'+A3)/3+(30+)$-%,(#'/0+%1+,0/&,,0'/0+)2+0$-3#2)20.?+A+8+!"11()H-E+#F%=0+'+@@\+A+8+E%;#";+^6L7L_+ed+6"7+b]Tc5

Page 25: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !"

#$%&%#%'()*+,--.%()+'&$%#&./0+12$)+3(44%456'+'&7&(8(4&+92:.)+%4#.:)(+2;;(4)($'+9<2+7$5:7=./+2:5<&+

42&+=(+#24'%)($()+%4'74(*+>2$+(?78-.(0+7+-($'24+9<2+8:'&+=(+747(&<(&%'()+$(5:.7$./+9<(4+@%'%&%45+

&<(+)(4&%'&0+74)+%'+-$24(+&2+.7'<+2:&+9<(4+$(#2@($%45+;$28+74+747('&<(&%#+):(+&2+7+=2)%./+)%'2$)($+

92:.) +<7@( +7 +3ABC*"!D+ E24@($'(./0 + &<%' + &<(2$/ +-$(#.:)(' +2;;(4)($' +9<2+7$( +7$5:7=./ +82$7../+

%$$('-24'%=.(+;$28+$(./%45+:-24+&<(+%4'74%&/+)(;(4#(*+,4+2;;(4)($+87/+42&+<7@(+:4)($'&22)+&<7&+

9<7&+&<(/+9($(+)2%45+97'+9$245+):(+&2+7+'(@($(+8(4&7.+)%'2$)($0+=:&+%;+&<%'+%'+:4.%F(./+&2+$(#:$+&<(/+

9%..+42&+<7@(+7+G:7.%;/%45+3ABC*"!H+

B<( + $7&%247.( + ;2$ + &<( + $(#:$$%45 + )745($ + &<(2$/ + <7' + 7.'2 + #28( + :4)($ + 7&&7#F* + >%$'&0 + %& + %'+

#24&(4)()+&<7&+&<(+-:=.%#+#74+=(+-$2&(#&()+;$28+$(#:$$%45+)745($+&<$2:5<+8(74'+2&<($+&<74+74+

%4'74%&/+)%'-2'%&%24*+I4+'28(+#7'('0+$(J(#&%24+2;+74+%4'74%&/+)(;(4#(+92:.)+.(7)+&2+&<(+#24@%#&%24+74)+

%8-$%'248(4& +2; + &<(+7##:'()* + I4 +#7'(' +9<($( + ;7%.:$( +2; + &<( + %4'74%&/ +)(;(4#( +92:.) + .(7) + &2 +74+

2:&$%5<& + 7#G:%&&7. + K(*5*0 + 7:&287&%'8 + #7'('L0 + &<( + 7##:'() +87/ + '&%.. + =( + ':=J(#&() + &2 + #28-:.'2$/+

&$(7&8(4&+:4)($+#%@%.+8(4&7.+<(7.&<+-$2#():$('*"!M+B<($(;2$(0+&<(+$%'F+2;+$(#:$$%45+)745($+'"5+-"+)2('+

42&+ J:'&%;/+7+#24#.:'%24+&<7&+74+ %4'74%&/+;%4)%45+ %' +4(()()+&2+-$2&(#&+ &<(+-:=.%#*"!N+ O(#24)0+ %& + %'+

)%'-:&()+&<7&+74+%4'74%&/+@($)%#&+9<($(+74+7##:'()6'+)%'2$)($+%'+:4.%F(./+&2+$(#:$+92:.)+$(':.&+%4+

%47--$2-$%7&(+<2'-%&7. +)(&(4&%24*+I& + %' +42&+874)7&2$/+&<7& +74+%4'74%&/+7#G:%&&((+=(+)(&7%4()+ %4+7+

8(4&7.+<2'-%&7.*+B<(+J:)5(+#2:.)+%88()%7&(./+$(.(7'(+&<(+7#G:%&&((0+2$+2$)($+&<7&+&<(/+=(+&$(7&()+7'+7+

#%@%. +-7&%(4&*"PQ+ B<($(;2$(0 + %4+#7'(' +9<($(+&<($(+ %' +42+$%'F+2;+$(#:$$(4#(0 + &<(+ %4'74%&/+)%'-2'%&%24+

$(5%8(+#2:.)+-$2@%)(+;2$+74+7--$2-$%7&(+2:&#28(*"P"+

,+;%47.+2=J(#&%24+&2+&<%'+&<(2$/+<%5<.%5<&'+&<(+)%;;%#:.&/+2;+-$()%#&%45+$(#:$$(4#(+$7&('*"P!+ I&+

'((8'+ %8-$2-($ + &<7&0 +)('-%&( +-2&(4&%7. + %47##:$7#/0 +-(2-.( +7$( +#.7''()+7' +'74( +2$ + %4'74( +24+ &<%'+

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`+KW7-($+-$('(4&()+7&+I4'&%&:&(+2;+^:)%#%7.+O&:)%('+U%5<+E2:$&+_-)7&(0+C(4&7.+U(7.&<+I'':('0+a(..%45&24b,:#F.74)0+c2@(8=($+!QQRL+7&+SDT*

Page 26: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !!

"#$%$&'((

)*+ ,-#./0 , .12%3%#4 , 0+$5/*$+ , 6/ , 67+$+ , 2%88%3146%+$ , 7#$ , "++* , 6/ ,-#9+ , 0+3100+*3+ , # , */*:

2+6+0-%*#6%;+,8#36/0,%*,67+,<)=>,%*?1%0@&,A7%+8,B1$6%3+,C/02,C#*+D,%*,67+,E*F4%$7,A/106,/8,G55+#4D,

$6#6+2,67#6,0+3100+*3+,H#$,-+0+4@,I#*,#22+2,0+#$/*,8/0,3#6+F/0%$%*F,J#K,3/*2%6%/*,#$,#,2%$+#$+,/8,67+,

-%*2&L'(M,=7+0+8/0+D,#,-+*6#4,2%$/02+0,*++2,*/6,0+310,6/,?1#4%8@,#$,#,<)=>&,,=7+,$#-+,#550/#37,

7#$ , "++* , 6#9+* , "@ , 67+ , N150+-+ , A/106 , /8 , A#*#2#'(O, #*2 , 67+ ,P/1$+ , /8 , C/02$&'(Q, =7%$ , */*:

2+6+0-%*#6%;+,#550/#37,6/,0+3100+*3+,#4%F*$,H%67,67+,R+H,S+#4#*2,A/106,/8,G55+#4T$,$6#6+-+*6,67#6,

67+,I%*$#*%6@,50/;%$%/*$,#554@&&&,6/,#,3/*2%6%/*,/8,6+-5/0#0@,%*$#*%6@D,H7+67+0,0+3100+*6,/0,*/6&L'(U

M&(,, ,,,,,,,,, =7+,%*6+0*#4,3#1$+,67+/0@,,

=7+ , %*6+0*#4 , 3#1$+ , 67+/0@ ,H#$ ,2+;+4/5+2, %* , 0+$5/*$+ , 6/ , 67+ ,5+03+%;+2, $7/063/-%*F$ ,/8,

8/31$%*F , $/4+4@ ,/*, 0+3100%*F ,2#*F+0&'(V, W* ,56(/7'(X+ C/02 , B1$6%3+ ,C#H6/* ,*/6+2, 67#6 , +-57#$%$%*F,

0+3100+*3+,#4/*+,-+#*6,67+,3#1$+,/8,-+*6#4,2%$/02+0$,H#$,%F*/0+2&,W*,$/-+,3#$+$,67%$,H/142,4+#2,6/,

#"$102 , 0+$146$& , Y/0 , +Z#-54+D , 67+ , 2+*6#4 , 5#6%+*6 , H%67 , # , $+*$%6%;%6@ , 6/ , #*#+$67+6%3$D , 2+$30%"+2,

50+;%/1$4@D,H/142,"+,8/1*2,6/,7#;+,#,<)=>&'M[,)*,67%$,"#$%$,67+,C/02,B1$6%3+,3/*3412+2,67#6,I#,

-#481*36%/*%*F,/8, 67+,-%*2,/8, 60#*$%6/0@,+88+36 ,3#1$+2,"@,67+,#554%3#6%/*,6/,67+,"/2@,/8,$/-+,

+Z6+0*#4 , 8#36/0 , $137 , #$ ,;%/4+*3+D , 201F$D , %*3412%*F , #*#+$67+6%3$D , #43/7/4 , #*2 ,7@5*/6%3 , %*841+*3+$,

3#**/6,8#%04@,"+,$#%2,6/,"+,21+,6/,2%$+#$+L&'M'

'((>%37#+4,B+88+0$/*,89(&()%:+;%<+\O67,+2,C/*F-#*,P#04/H,E*F4#*2,![['],#6,(MX&'(M=+>+?69@"--D,#"/;+,*,QOD,XX&'(O=+>+=%A".D,#"/;+,*,U[D+O((,#*2,OO'^,=+>+,%97-D,#"/;+,*,QOD,J'MK^,=+>+B#0)"D,#"/;+,*,U[D+J!'!K:J!'(K&'(QN++,=+>+B6::(>%)D,#"/;+,*,OUD,'U!&,=7+,.12F-+*6,/8,C/02,<%54/39,%$,*/6,+*6%0+4@,34+#0&,P/H+;+0D,67+,8/44/H%*F,5#$$#F+,$1FF+$6$,67#6,7+,3/*$%2+0$,0+3100+*3+,6/,"+,#,0+4+;#*6D,"16,*/6,2+3%$%;+D,8#36/0,%*,67+,<)=>,%*?1%0@_,I=7+,210#6%/*,/8,#,6+-5/0#0@,$1$5+*$%/*,/8,67+,-+*6#4,8#3146%+$,/8,0+#$/*D,-+-/0@,#*2,1*2+0$6#*2%*FD,5#06%314#04@,%8&&&,%6,%$,0+3100+*6D,3#**/6,/*,#*@,0#6%/*#4,F0/1*2,"+,0+4+;#*6,6/,67+,#554%3#6%/*,"@,67+,3/106$,/8,67+,>TR#F76+*,`14+$L_,W"%2D,'U!&,C/02,<%54/39,%$,20#H%*F,#,2%$6%*36%/*,"+6H++*,67+,210#6%/*,/8,#,-+*6#4,%-5#%0-+*6D,#*2,67+,4%9+4%7//2,67#6,67%$,%-5#%0-+*6,H%44,0+310&,P+,$6#6+$,67#6,67+,210#6%/*,/8,#,-+*6#4,%-5#%0-+*6,%$,*/6,0+4+;#*6,6/,H7+67+0,#*,#331$+2,3#*,#;#%4,7%-$+48,/8,67+,%*$#*%6@,2+8+*3+&,Y1067+0D,67#6,%*,3#$+$,H7+0+,#*,%-5#%0-+*6,%$,4%9+4@,6/,0+310D,%6,%$,5#06%314#04@,34+#0,67#6,210#6%/*,%$,%00+4+;#*6&,=7+,%-54%3#6%/*,%$,67#6,H7%4+,0+3100+*3+,-%F76,50/;%2+,#*,#22%6%/*#4,0+#$/*,8/0,8%*2%*F,#,<)=>D,%6,%$,*/6,*+3+$$#0@,6/,$137,#,8%*2%*F&

'(U=+>+80##:"D,#"/;+,*,O'D,'[('&'(V=+>+56(/7D,#"/;+,*,QXD,X'V&'(XW"%2&'M[W"%2D,X'V&'M'W"%2D,X!!&

Page 27: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !"

#$%&'()*+,-.'#/0+$12*'*+/+.3.1+'0/*'-$14.%+.&',1+$'/1'/55%$/-6'7$%'5$*,+,4.89',&.1+,79,1:'/'

;<=>',1'+6.'-$1+.?+'$7'/)+$3/+,*3'-/*.*',14$84,1:'5*9-6$8$:,-/8'@8$0*A'+6/+',*B'+6.'/@*.1-.'$7'/'

*)77,-,.1+89'*.4.%.'.?+.%1/8'7/-+$%'0,88'*)55$%+'/1',17.%.1-.'$7'/';<=>',1'+6.*.'-/*.*C

D1'5*9-6$8$:,-/8'@8$0'-/*.*'+6.'/--)*.&'-$1+.1&*'6.'0/*'/-+,1:',14$8)1+/%,89'/+'+6.'+,3.'$7'

$77.1&,1:B'/*'/'5*9-6$8$:,-/8'@8$0'-/)*.&'6,3'+$'.1+.%'/'&,**$-,/+,4.'*+/+.CEF!'=6.'-$)%+*'%./*$1.&'

+6/+'1$'&,*+,1-+,$1'-$)8&'@.'3/&.'@.+0..1'569*,-/8'/1&'5*9-6$8$:,-/8'@8$0*'8./&,1:'+$'/)+$3/+,*3C'

=6.%.7$%.B'G)*+'/*'569*,-/8'-/)*.*'H.C:CB'&%):*'$%'/'@8$0'+$'+6.'6./&I'/%.'+%./+.&'/*'7/-+$%*'.?+.%1/8'+$'

+6.'/--)*.&B'5*9-6$8$:,-/8'@8$0*'3)*+'/8*$'@.'+%./+.&'/*'.?+.%1/8'+$'+6.'/--)*.&C'<1'+6,*'@/*,*',+'0/*'

-$1-8)&.&'+6/+'/'+%/1*,+$%9'*+/+.'$7'&,**$-,/+,$1'-/)*.&'@9'/'5*9-6$8$:,-/8'@8$0'0$)8&'1$+'@.'/'

;<=>B'/*',+'0/*'-/)*.&'J@9'+6.'/558,-/+,$1'$7'*$3.'.?+.%1/8'7/-+$%KCEF"

L$0.4.%B'/'7)%+6.%'5%[email protected]'/%$*.',1'*)-6'-/*.*A',+',*'&,77,-)8+'+$'&.+.%3,1.'06.+6.%'+6.'-/)*.'

$7'&,**$-,/+,$1'0/*'+6.'5*9-6$8$:,-/8'@8$0B'$%'0/*'*$3.',17,%3,+9',1+.%1/8'+$'+6.'/--)*.&'+%,::.%.&'

@9 ' +6.'-,%-)3*+/1-.*C ' D1 ' %.*5$1*. ' +$ ' +6,* '&,77,-)8+9B ' +6.'J-$1+.?+)/8 '[email protected]+,4.KEFF' /55%$/-6'0/*'

7$%3)8/+.&C'=6,*',14$84.*'-$35/%,1:'+6.'/--)*.&2*'%.*5$1*.'+$'+6.'5*9-6$8$:,-/8'@8$0'/:/,1*+'+6.'

695$+6.+,-/8 ' %.*5$1*.'$7'/1'$%&,1/%9'5.%*$1'58/-.&' ,1'+6.'/--)*.&2* '-,%-)3*+/1-.*CEFM' N$% '+6.*.'

5)%5$*.*B ' +6. ' $%&,1/%9 ' 5.%*$1 ' ,* ' /**)3.& ' +$ ' @. ' $7 ' 1$%3/8 ' +.35.%/3.1+ ' /1& ' *.87O-$1+%$8P ' *$'

.4,&.1-.'$7'+6.'/--)*.&2*'3.1+/8'*+/+.'H.C:CB ' +6.,%'&.5%.**,$1I'0,88 '@.',%%.8.4/1+CEFQ' D7'/1'$%&,1/%9'

5.%*$1 ' ,1 ' +6.*. ' -,%-)3*+/1-.* '0$)8& ' 1$+ ' 6/4. ' .1+.%.& ' / ' &,**$-,/+,4. ' *+/+.B ' +6.1 '@9 '1.-.**/%9'

,17.%.1-.'*$3.+6,1:',1+.%1/8'+$'+6.'/--)*.&'3)*+'6/4.'-/)*.&'+6,*'*+/+.C'=6,*'0,88'@.'*)77,-,.1+'+$'

*)55$%+ ' / ' 7,1&,1: ' $7 ' / ';<=>B ' ' .4.1 ' ,7 ' 1$ ' ,1+.%1/8 ' ,17,%3,+9 ' -/1 ' @. ' ,&.1+,7,.& ' @9 '3.&,-/8'

5%$7.**,$1/8*CEFR' D1'$+6.%'0$%&*B',7'+6.'5*9-6$8$:,-/8'@8$0'&$.*'1$+'.?-..&'J+6.'$%&,1/%9'*+%.**.*'

/1&'&,*/55$,1+3.1+*'$7'8,7.'06,-6'/%.'/'-$33$1'8$+'$7'3/1S,1&KEFT'@)+'+6.'/--)*.&'6/*'*+,88'.1+.%.&'

EF!N$%'.?/358.B'-$1*,&.%'+6.'-/*.'$7'/'9$)1:'3/1'06$'/88.:.&89'.1+.%.&'/'&,**$-,/+,4.'*+/+.'/7+.%'8./%1,1:'+6.'[email protected]+'$7'6,*'/77.-+,$1'+6$):6+'8,++8.'$7'6,3A'5+6+5%7".B'/@$4.'1'RUC

EF"5+6+89(/:B'/@$4.'1'QVB'V!!CEFF5+6+;#0)"B'/@$4.'1'RUB'W!EUXCEFM5+6+<%=/0)">B'/@$4.'1'REB'MM'/1&'MTP'5+6+5%7".B'/@$4.'1'RUB'WTXOWVXCEFQ5+6+;#0)"B'/@$4.'1'RUB'W!UVXP'5+6+<%=/0)">B'/@$4.'1'REB'MTCEFR5+6+5%7".B'/@$4.'1'RUB'WTXCEFTD@,&B'WVXC

Page 28: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !"

#$%&''()&#*&+,$'*#*,$*-,.$#$/012$3&44$5,$6(7.%8$

1-,$9#*&(.#4,$6(9$*-&'$#::9(#)-$&'$*3(6(4%;$*-,$:9,',.),$(6$#.$&.*,9.#4$3,#<.,''$&.)9,#','$*-,$

4&<,4&-((%$(6$9,)799,.*$%&''()&#*&(.$3-&)-$*-,$:754&)$'-(74%$5,$:9(*,)*,%$69(=>?"@$ #.%$#.$&.*,9.#4$

3,#<.,''$=#<,'$*9,#*=,.*$#::9(:9&#*,8?AB

1-, $ &.*,9.#4 $ )#7', $ *-,(9C $ -#' $ D#&.,% $ # $ ),9*#&. $ #'),.%#.)C $ &. $ E#.#%&#. $ #.% $ F.D4&'-$

G79&':97%,.),8?A?$H(3,+,9>$&*$-#'$#4'($5,,.$*-,$*#9D,*$(6$',+,9,$)9&*&)&'=8$I*$&'$#9D7,%$*-#*$*-,$*-,(9C$

%(,'$.(*$',9+,$*-,$:(4&)C$)(.),9.'$5C$3-&)-$&*$)4#&='$*($5,$&447=&.#*,%8?A!$1-,9,$=#C$5,$.($=,%&)#4$

,+&%,.),$(6$#$=,.*#4$%&'(9%,9$3-&)-$&'$4&<,4C$*($9,)79>$(9$3-&)-$9,J7&9,'$*9,#*=,.*8$K,+,9*-,4,''>$&.$

*-,$#5',.),$(6$#$'766&)&,.*4C$',+,9,$,L*,9.#4$6#)*(9$*($,L:4#&.$*-,$#))7',%M'$9,#)*&(.$#$/012$3&44$5,$

&.6,99,%8$N))(9%&.D$*($&.*,9.#*&(.#4$-7=#.$9&D-*'$G79&':97%,.),>$%,*,.*&(.$&.$'7)-$)&9)7='*#.),'$

=#C$5,$#$59,#)-$(6$9&D-*'8?AO$P79*-,9>$&.6,99&.D$#$/012$&.$*-&'$3#C$',,='$:9(54,=#*&)$&.$4&D-*$(6$

*-,$:9,'7=:*&(.$(6$'#.&*C8?A"

Q*9&)*$#::4&)#*&(.$(6$*-,$&.*,9.#4$)#7',$*-,(9C$4,#%'$*($#5'79%$9,'74*'8$1#<,>$6(9$,L#=:4,>$*-,$

)#','$(6$56(/7?AA+#.%$8"))"--.8?AR$I.$56(/7>$*-,$#))7',%$3#'$&.$#$-C:(DC4)#,=&)$'*#*,$#*$*-,$*&=,$(6$

(66,.%&.D>$3-&)-$9,.%,9,%$-&'$)(.%7)*$&.+(47.*#9C8$1-,$-C:(D4C)#,=&#$#9(',$#6*,9$*-,$#))7',%>$#$

%&#5,*&)>$*((<$&.'74&.$57*$6#&4,%$*($,#*$,.(7D-8$1-,$F.D4&'-$E(79*$(6$N::,#4$%,*,9=&.,%$*-#*$*-,$

%&''()&#*&+, $ '*#*, $3#' $)#7',%$5C $#. $,L*,9.#4 $ 6#)*(9> $.#=,4C $ &.'74&.8 $ I. $)(.*9#'*> $ &. $8"))"--. +*-,$

#))7',%>$#.(*-,9$%&#5,*&)>$3#'$&.$#$-C:,9D4C)#,=&)$'*#*,8$H,$-#%$.(*$*#<,.$&.'74&.$(9$6((%$:9&(9$*($

*-,$(66,.%&.D8$1-,$F.D4&'-$E(79*$(6$N::,#4$)(.)47%,%$*-#*$*-,$%&''()&#*&+,$'*#*,$3#'$)#7',%$5C$#.$

&.*,9.#4$6#)*(9>$.#=,4C$%&#5,*,'8$1-,$#::4&)#*&(.$(6$*-,$&.*,9.#4$)#7',$*-,(9C$&.$*-,',$)#','$)#..(*$5,$

&=:7D.,%8$H(3,+,9>$'*9&)*$#::4&)#*&(.$(6$*-,$*-,(9C$9,'74*,%$&.$#$%&'*&.)*&(.$5,&.D$%9#3.$5,*3,,.$

*3($%&#5,*&)$(66,.%,9'$3-&)-$#::,#9'$*($5,$7.6(7.%,%$(.$:(4&)C$D9(7.%'8$1-&'$%&'*&.)*&(.$-#'$5,,.$

?"@,09(/"+:+;%))()>$#5(+,$.$R">$!"!S$<+:+,%=7->$#5(+,$.$RA>+T@U8?AB,09(/"+:+;%))()>$#5(+,$.$R">$!"!8?A?<+:+,%=7->$#5(+,$.$RA>+T@U8$Q,,$<+:+56(/7>$#5(+,$.$R@S+<+:+8"))"--.>$#5(+,$.$RVS$<+:+<%>".>$#5(+,$.$WB8?A!09=,9(%>$#5(+,$.$"O>$!V!8?AOX9((<5#.<'$#.%$Q&=:'(.>$#5(+,$.$AO>$?BWY?BV8$Q,,$#4'($?()#"=@"='+:+A$"+B"#$"=9%)1->$#5(+,$.$?BA8?A"E9&=,'$N)*$?@R?>$'$!OZ?[S$<+:+<%>".>$#5(+,$.$WB>$T@?U$:,9$/&)<'(.$\$%&'',.*&.D8?AA<+:+56(/7>$#5(+,$.$R@8?AR<+:+8"))"--.>$#5(+,$.$RV8

Page 29: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !"

#$%&'()*+$,$*$-&%.)/0%)#/1)%&1*+$2&%)2()3'/04$''&)5$''$/61)/1)7$++/,$80/'9:;"<

=,+$*,)/>>'$*/,$80)8?),@&)$0,&+0/')*/A1&),@&8+()/'18)'&/%1),8)+&1A',1)#@$*@)/+&)$0*801$1,&0,)#$,@)

#&''B&1,/2'$1@&%)'$0&1)8?)/A,@8+$,(:)C8+)&D/6>'&.)1'&&>#/'E$0F)@/1),+/%$,$80/''()2&&0)*$,&%)/1)/)*'&/+)

$01,/0*&)8?)080B$01/0&)/A,86/,$16:;"G)H8#&4&+.)IA%F&1)@/4&)1$0*&)/*E08#'&%F&%),@/,)$,)1&&61),8)2&)

*/A1&%)2()/ )>+&%$1>81$,$80)$0,&+0/' ) ,8),@&)/**A1&%)/0%),@&+&?8+&. )/**8+%$0F),8),@$1),@&8+(. )2()/)

JKLM:;"N) )O0)+&1>801&),8),@$1)%$??$*A',(.)$,)@/1)2&&0)/+FA&%),@/,)1'&&>#/'E$0F)$1)*/A1&%)2()&D,&+0/')

?/*,8+1)P&:F:.)&D*&11$4&)&D&+*$1&.)1'&&>)%&>+$4/,$80.)1A%%&0)08$1&1)$0),@&)0$F@,Q:;RS) O,)@/1)&4&0)2&&0)

>+8>81&%),@/,)$,)$1)*/A1&%)2()1'&&>.)/)0/,A+/')&D,&+0/')*/A1&:;R;)L@&1&)1AFF&1,$801)/>>&/+)/+,$?$*$/')/0%)

%&6801,+/,&)@8#),@&)$0,&+0/'T&D,&+0/')%$1,$0*,$80)*/0)2&)6/0$>A'/,&%:)='&&>#/'E$0F)$1)/0)&D/6>'&)

8?)/)*80%$,$80)08,)#&'')1A$,&%),8)/0/'(1$1)A0%&+),@&)$0,&+0/')*/A1&),@&8+(:;R!

U)?$0/')82I&*,$80)$1),@/,),@&),@&8+()%+/#1)/0)A0#/++/0,&%)%$1,$0*,$80)2&,#&&0)>@(1$*/')/0%)

>1(*@8'8F$*/')2'8#1:)L@&)$6>/*,)8?)/)>@(1$*/')2'8#)#$'')2&)1A2I&*,$4&'()/11&11&%:)L@$1)6&/01),@&)

*8A+,1)#$'')08,)*86>/+&),@&)+&/*,$80)8?),@&)/**A1&%),8),@&)2'8#)#$,@),@/,)8?)/0)8+%$0/+()>&+180.)08+)

#$''),@&()$0?&+)/)JKLM)80),@&)2/1$1),@/,),@&)/**A1&%)+&1>80%&%)/208+6/''(:)U)JKLM)#$'')80'()2&)

?8A0%)$?),@&+&)$1)&4$%&0*&)8?)/)6&0,/')%$18+%&+)#@$*@),@&)>@(1$*/')2'8#)@/1)$0,&+/*,&%)#$,@:)C8+)

&D/6>'&.)/)>&+180)#@8)1A??&+1)/)6$08+)2'8#),8),@&)@&/%.)/0%)2&*86&1)*80*A11&%)2&*/A1&),@&()@/4&)

/),@$0)1EA'')#$'')08,)@/4&)/)JKLM:)V$E&#$1&.)08)JKLM)#$'')2&)?8A0%)#@&+&)/)>&+180)@/1)/0)

/208+6/' )6&,/28'$16 ) 1A*@ ) ,@/, ) *801A6>,$80 )8? ) /'*8@8' ) &??&*,1 ) ,@&6 )68+& ) ,@/0 ) ,@& )8+%$0/+()

>&+180:)O0)*80,+/1,.)/0)82I&*,$4&)/>>+8/*@)$1),/E&0),8)>1(*@8'8F$*/')2'8#1:)L@&)/**A1&%)$1)*86>/+&%)

#$,@)/0)8+%$0/+()>&+180.)/0%)$?),@&$+)+&1>801&)%$??&+1)?+86),@/,)8?)/0)8+%$0/+()>&+180)/)JKLM)$1)

$0?&++&%:)C8+)&D/6>'&.)/)>&+180)#@8)&D>&+$&0*&1)/0)8+%$0/+()1,+&11)8?)'$?&)/0%)%$118*$/,&1)2&*/A1&)8?)

;"<5$''$/61.)/284&)0)WX.)RGW:)=&&)/'18)Y&??&+180.)/284&)0);XX.)XWW:;"G5+6+708-0)+P;GGNQ)!X)Z[J);RG)P\UQ)/,);G<])5+6+90##8".)/284&)0)";.);S!R])5+6+:%8/0)";.)/284&)0)<;.)<W:;"NL@&)%$??$*A',()$0)1'&&>#/'E$0F)*/1&1)#/1)>A,)/>,'()2()['/0*@/+%)Y)$0)<;;(/-0)+6+,08(/")P;NNXQ);S)\^_`);;S)PH\Q)/,);;<a)7H8#:::)*/0)/A,86/,$16)$0),@&)?8+6)8?)1'&&>B#/'E$0F)2&)/,,+$2A,&%),8)/0)&D,&+0/')*/A1&.)(&,)$,)A1A/''()$1)*'&/+'()080)$01/0&)2&@/4$8A+b9)=&&)/'18)5+6+="-8";.)/284&)0)<S.)c!Gd])5+6++:%8/0)";.)/284&)0)<;.)<"])5+6+,%;>-.)/284&)0)R".)c;Sd)/0%)c;!d])5+6+?#0)".)/284&)0)<S.)c"Wd)>&+)[$00$&)Y)%$11&0,$0F:)\86>/+&)5+6+@A;B"--.)/284&)0)R")$0)#@$*@)/)1'&&>#/'E&+)#/1)?8A0%),8)2&)$01/0&

;RS5+6+,%;>-.)/284&)0)R".)c;!d:;R;Y&??&+180.)/284&)0);XX.)XWW:)L@&)/A,@8+)1,/,&%),@&)%&*$1$80)$0),%;>-)#/1)+&/*@&%)80),@$1)2/1$1:)H8#&4&+.),@$1)$0,&+>+&,/,$80)8?),%;>-+$1)eA&1,$80/2'&:

;R!5+6+,%;>-.)/284&)0)R".)c;Sd)/0%)c;!d])5$''$/61.)/284&)0)WX.)R<":

Page 30: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !"

#$%&' ( '%)*#&+%), (-%*. ( /$*'*/#%' (-&)) ( $*+% ( * (01234 ( 567% ( 89:;%< ( *';9% ( #$*# ( #$&< ( :&<#&=/#&6= ( &<(

9=89<#&>&%:4?"@

A6-%+%'B(-&#$('%<C%/#B(#$&<(&<(=6#(%=#&'%),(/6''%/#4(2$%(0123(&=D9&',(&<(=6#(/6=/%'=%:(-&#$(

C$,<&/*)(:%>%/#<B(E9#(-&#$(#$%(7%=#*)(>*/9)#&%<(6>('%*<6=B(7%76',(*=:(9=:%'<#*=:&=;4?"F( G#(7*.%<(

<%=<%(#$*#(*=(*//9<%:H<(#$&=(<.9))B(6'('*C&:(7%#*E6)&<7(&<(=6#('%)%+*=#(#6(#$&<(&=D9&',B(*<(#$&<(&<(=6#(*(

>%*#9'%(6>(#$%(7&=:4(A6-%+%'B(*CC*'%=#(%76#&6=*)(-%*.=%<<(&<('%)%+*=#(#6(#$%(0123(&=D9&',B(*<(&#(

7*,()%;&#&7*#%),('%>)%/#(9C6=(#$%(<#*#%(6>(#$%(*//9<%:H<(7%=#*)(>*/9)#&%<(6>('%*<6=(*=:(9=:%'<#*=:&=;4(

I%+%'#$%)%<<B ( *=(6E8%/#&6= (/*= (E%(7*:%( #6( #$% (:'*-&=;(6> (* ( )&=% (<#'&/#), (E%#-%%=(C$,<&/*) (*=:(

C<,/$6)6;&/*)(%J#%'=*)(>*/#6'<4(567%(C$,<&/*)(>*/#6'<B(<9/$(*<(:'9;<B(/*=(&=#%'*/#(-&#$(#$%(9=:%'),&=;(

7%=#*)(-%*.=%<<(6>(*=(&=:&+&:9*)(#6(E'&=;(*E69#(*(<#*#%(6>(&7C*&'7%=#4(G=(#$%<%(/&'/97<#*=/%<B(#$%(

&=#%'=*)(-%*.=%<<(&<(6>(*(#,C%(-$&/$(&<('%)%+*=#(#6(#$%(0123(&=D9&',4(2$%'%>6'%B(&#(&<(*';9*E)%(*=(

6E8%/#&+%(*<<%<<7%=# (<$69):( )&.%-&<%(E%(#*.%=( #6( #$%<%(/*<%<4 (2$%( &=#%'=*) (/*9<%( #$%6',(>*&)< ( #6(

C'6+&:%(>6'(#$%<%(=9*=/%<4

K<(-&#$('%/9''%=/%B(#$%(89:&/&*)('%<C6=<%(#6(#$%<%(:&>>&/9)#&%<($*<(E%%=(#6(#'%*#(#$%(&=#%'=*)(

/*9<%(#$%6',(*<(6=%(*=*),#&/*)(#66)(9<%:(&=(#$%(0123(&=D9&',L(&#(-&))(=6#(E%(:%/&<&+%B(*=:(&#(-&))(=6#(

E%(*CC)&%:(-$%'%(#$&<(-69):(9=:%'7&=%(C6)&/,(6E8%/#&+%<4?"M(K(<7*))(=97E%'(6>(89:;%<($*+%('%8%/#%:(

#$%(&=#%'=*)(/*9<%(#$%6',(69#'&;$#B(*';9&=;(#$*#(,69(/*==6#(>&=:(*(0123(-&#$69#(C6<&#&+%(%+&:%=/%(

6>(*(7%=#*)(:&<6':%'4?""

F4F(( ((((((((( KCC)&/*#&6=(&=(/*<%<(6>(&=#6J&/*#&6=((

2$%('%/9''&=;(:*=;%'(*=:(&=#%'=*)(>*/#6'(#$%6'&%<($*+%(C'6+%=(#6(E%(C*'#&/9)*'),(:%>&/&%=#(&=(

/*<%<(&=+6)+&=;(&=#6J&/*#&6=4(G#(&<(/)%*'(#$*#(*(C*<<&=;(<#*#%(6>(&=#6J&/*#&6=(&<(=6#(*(01234(A6-%+%'B(

?"@5+6+5%7".B(*E6+%(=(NOB(PQFRSPQ"R(C%'(0&/.<6=(T(:&<<%=#&=;4?"F5+6+8"&'B(*E6+%(=(?OUB(FONV(5+6+90##:"B(*E6+%(=(M?B(?O??V(5+6+;"))"--.B(*E6+%(=("UB(!Q!V(5+6+<=::(6%)B(*E6+%(=(MNB+?N!V(5+6+,0>#">B(*E6+%(=(MQB+?UQ4

?"M5+6+,%>?-B(*E6+%(=("MB(P??R4(W$&)%(>%-(/*<%<(%JC'%<<),(*/.=6-)%:;%(#$%(:6-=;'*:&=;(6>(#$%(&=#%'=*)(/*9<%(#$%6',(#6(*=(*=*),#&/*)S#66)B(#$&<(&7C)&/&#),(6//9'<(-$%=%+%'(#$%(#$%6',(&<(=6#(*CC)&%:(#6(:%#%'7&=%(#$%(0123(&=D9&',4(2$%(&=#%'=*)(/*9<%(#$%6',(&<(=6#(&=(>*/#(9#&)&<%:(E,(#$%(/69'#<(*<(*=(*))S%=/67C*<<&=;(7%#$6:6)6;,4

?""5+6+5%7".B(*E6+%(=(NOB(PQ?R(C%'(0&/.<6=(T(:&<<%=#&=;V(5+6+@%:/0)">B(*E6+%(=(N?B(NMSN"4(5%%(*)<6(W&))&*7<B(*E6+%(=(F@B("NM4

Page 31: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !"

#$%&'(&)*($%&'+,%-,$*#.'-%$/0$'./'(#)*-$#/.'-$1#0$2.#3&40$-5-)$&4 $ &( $ &' $(-16+,#,0$7-898: $%-3&,&.1$

(,-1-)';8<="$>)4+,(.)#(-30:$(?-$%&'(&)*(&+)$/-(@--)$(-16+,#,0$&)'#)&(0$*#.'-%$/0$%,&)A$#)%$%,.9':$

#)%$'&163-$&)(+B&*#(&+)$&'$%&44&*.3($(+$1#A-8<=C$ D.,(?-,$%&44&*.3(&-'$#,&'-$@?-,-$&)(+B&*#(&+)$+**.,'$

*+)*.,,-)(30$@&(?$#)$.)%-,30&)9$1-)(#3$%&'+,%-,8<=E

56567+8%-"-+04+'-./$0-(-+19:();+()#0<(/%#(0)

F&'6#,#(-$+.(*+1-'$?#5-$/--)$,-#*?-%$&)$*#'-'$@?-,-$6'0*?+'&'$+**.,,-%$%.,&)9$'./'(#)*-$

.'-:$/.($*-#'-%$+)*-$(?-$%,.9$@#'$1-(#/+3&'-%8$G?-$H-@$I-#3#)%$J+.,($+4$K66-#3$?#'$?-3%$(?#($

6'0*?+'&'$&)%.*-%$/0$-&(?-,$(?-$*+1/&)-%$-44-*('$+4$#3*+?+3$#)%$93.-:$+,$1-(?$&'$'&163-$&)(+B&*#(&+):$

#)%$*#))+($4+.)%$#)$&)'#)&(0$63-#8<"L$M&1&3#,30:$(?-$M.6,-1-$J+.,($+4$N&*(+,&#$?-3%$*#))#/&'O&)%.*-%$

6'0*?+'&'$@#'$)+($#$FPGQ:<"<$ #)% $(?-$R)93&'?$J+.,($+4$K66-#3$,-4.'-%$(+$#33+@$?#33.*&)#(&+)'$

-B6-,&-)*-%$%.,&)9$(?-$*+.,'-$+4$#)$SMF$(,&6$(+$2.#3&408<"!$P)$(?-$+(?-,$?#)%:$(?-$M.6,-1-$J+.,($+4$

J#)#%# $ ?-3% $ (?#( $ -5&%-)*- $ +4 $ #$ 6'0*?+(&* $ '(#(- $ *#.'-% $ /0 $ *#))#/&' $ *+.3% $ 4+.)% $ #) $ &)'#)&(0$

%-4-)*-8<"T$U)$)+)-$+4$(?-'-$*#'-'$@-,-$6,&)*&63-%$,-#'+)'$9&5-)8

G?-$,-*.,,&)9$%#)9-,$(?-+,0$1#0$V.'(&40$-B*3.%&)9$(?-$&)'#)&(0$%-4-)*-$&)$(?-'-$#)%$+(?-,$

*#'-'8$W'0*?+'&'$@&33$)+($,-*.,$&)$(?-$#/'-)*-$+4$'./'(#)*-$.'-X$(?-,-4+,-:$#)$&)'#)&(0$%&'6+'&(&+)$(+$

?+'6&(#3$&'$#,9.#/30$&)#66,+6,&#(-8$Y+@-5-,:$&($'--1'$6,+/3-1#(&*$(?#($#$6-,'+)$@?+$%&%$)+($A)+@$

@?#($(?-0$@-,-$%+&)9$'?+.3%$/-$*+)5&*(-%:$'&1630$/-*#.'-$(?-$1-)(#3$&16#&,1-)($4,+1$@?&*?$(?-0$

'.44-,-%$&'$.)3&A-30$(+$,-*.,8$K,9.#/30:$(?-0$'?+.3%$/-$-)(&(3-%$(+$#5#&3$(?-1'-35-'$+4$(?-$&)'#)&(0$

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`'$,+3-:$'.99-'(&)9$(?#($(?-$V.,0$'?+.3%$@-&9?$*+16-(&)9$6+3&*0$4#*(+,'$&)$+,%-,$(+$%-(-,1&)-$(?-$FPGQ$&)2.&,0_$U/&%:$]C=^O]CC^8$G?&'$1#0$-B63#&)$(?-$@&33&)9)-''$+4$(?-$M.6,-1-$J+.,($(+$3-#5-$&)'#)&(0$(+$(?-$V.,08$K,9.#/30:$(?-0$?#%$&)$-44-*($-B(-)%-%$(?-$V.,0`'$,+3-$/-0+)%$4&)%&)9$4#*('$(+$&)*3.%-$%-(-,1&)&)9$(?-$3-9#3$1-#)&)9$+4$FPGQ8$G?#($&':$(?-0$@-,-$)+($,-*+9)&'&)9$%,.9O&)%.*-%$6'0*?+'&'$#'$#$FPGQ:$/.($@-,-$&)'(-#%$3-#5&)9$&($(+$(?-$V.,0$(+$%-*&%-$@?-(?-,$'.*?$6'0*?+'&'$*+.3%$/-$#$FPGQ8

Page 32: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !"

#$%$&'$()&#*(+%(,-./+0)1(#$0$&0+-&(2-31#(&-0(4$()//5-/5+)0$*(0,$6(.,-31#(4$(5$1$).$#7(830(0,+.(0--(

')3.$.(#+%%+'310+$.*().(0,$6(9)6():)+&(3.$(#53:.*(05+::$5+&:()(#)&:$5-3.(/.6',-0+'($/+.-#$7(

;10$5&)0+<$16* (0,$(+&0$5&)1(')3.$(0,$-56('-31#($=/1)+&($='13.+-&(-%(0,$(+&.)&+06(#$%$&'$(+&(

0,$.$(').$.7(;.(.-9$(#53:.(+&0$5)'0(2+0,(0,$(9$&0)1(2$)>&$..(-%(3.$5.*(+0(+.()5:3)41$()&(-4?$'0+<$(

)..$..9$&0(-%(0,$+5($%%$'0.(.,-31#(4$(3&#$50)>$&7(@,+.()//5-)',(2-31#(4)5(0,$(+&.)&+06(#$%$&'$(+&(

').$.(+&<-1<+&:(#53:.(1+>$(ABC7(;&(-5#+&)56(/$5.-&(2,-(0)>$.(ABC(2+11($=/$5+$&'$(,)113'+&)0+-&.7(

@,$5$%-5$*(0,$.$(,)113'+&)0+-&.()5$(')3.$#(46()&($=0$5&)1(%)'0-5*(&-0()(CD@E7(F-2$<$5*(2,$5$(0,$(

#53:(+&(G3$.0+-&(#-$.(&-0(+&#3'$(/.6',-.+.(+&(0,$()<$5):$(3.$5(H$7:7*(9$0,)9/,$0)9+&$*(')&&)4+.I(

)&#( 0,$()''3.$#(#+#(4$'-9$(/.6',-0+'* ()&(-4?$'0+<$()..$..9$&0 (2-31#( 1$)#(0-() (CD@E(4$+&:(

+&%$55$#7(J0(+.(3&'1$)5(,-2('-99-&(/.6',-.+.(2-31#(,)<$(0-(4$(%-5(+0(0-(4$(05$)0$#().()(%$)035$(-%(

+&0-=+')0+-&($=/$5+$&'$#(46(0,$(-5#+&)56(/$5.-&*().(-//-.$#(0-()(CD@E7(

K$+0,$5(0,$(5$'355+&:(#)&:$5(&-0(0,$(+&0$5&)1(')3.$(0,$-56(/5-<+#$()('1$)5()&.2$5(+&(').$.(-%(

#53:L+&#3'$#(/.6',-.+.7

56567+8%-"-+04+'9":";(-#()<+&")#%=+1(-091"9+%)1+()#0;(/%#(0)

M-&%3.+-&(,).()1.-()5+.$&(+&(').$.(2,$5$(0,$5$(+.()(/5$L$=+.0+&:(9$&0)1(#+.-5#$5(/)+5$#(2+0,(

+&0-=+')0+-&()0(0,$(0+9$(-%(-%%$&#+&:7(N-5($=)9/1$*('-&.+#$5()&()''3.$#(2+0,()(2$11(#-'39$&0$#(

/$5.-&)1+06(#+.-5#$5(2,-(-%%$&#.(2,+1$(+&0-=+')0$#7OPQ(J&(0,$.$(').$.*(4-0,(0,$(+&0$5&)1(#+.-5#$5()&#(

0,$($=0$5&)1(.34.0)&'$(2+11(,)<$('-94+&$#(0-(+9/)+5(0,$(9$&0)1(%)'310+$.7(@,$5$%-5$*(+0(+.(3&'1$)5(

2,$0,$5(0,$()''3.$#(.,-31#(4$(05$)0$#().(+&.)&$(-5().()(#53&>)5#7(B-9$(').$.(.3::$.0(0,)0(+%(0,$(

/5$.$&'$(-%()&(3&#$516+&:(#+.-5#$5(2).(&$'$..)56(%-5(+9/)+59$&0(0-(-''35*(0,$&()&(+&.)&+06(#$%$&'$(

')&(4$(.3//-50$#7(@,$(+9/1+')0+-&(+.(0,)0(+0(#-$.(&-0(9)00$5(2,$0,$5(0,$(3&#$516+&:(#+.-5#$5(2).(0,$(

/5$#-9+&)&0(')3.$7OPR(D0,$5(').$.(.3::$.0(0,)0(+%()&($=0$5&)1(05+::$5(+.(5$G3+5$#(%-5()(#+.-5#$5(0-(

9)&+%$.0*(0,+.(05+::$5(+.(0,$(5$1$<)&0(')3.$7(@,$5$%-5$*(0-(%-3&#()&(+&.)&+06('1)+9(+0(93.0(4$(.,-2&(

OPQB$$(>##09)".:?")"9%=(409+@0#$"9)+29"=%)1+A+?%==%<$"9*()4-<$(&(QS7OPRB"1"='$+A+C+TOU"VW(@).(X(!Y(HMM;I()0(!PZ(!"11()<-*()4-<$(&(SS*(YOV7

Page 33: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !"

#$%#&'()%'*(+,#&-./01&$%2+&.33/**+1&*+4%*10+55&.6&',#.7'3%#'.,89:;&<$+5+&#-.&%))*.%3$+5&%*+&2%5#0=&

1'66+*+,#8 & <$+ &>,'#+1 &?',41.( &@%- &A.(('55'., & $%5 & 5/44+5#+1 & % &(.*+ & )*%4(%#'3 & %))*.%3$&

-$+*+B= & #$+ &(.5# &5'4,'6'3%,# &3%/5+ &.6 & '()%'*(+,# & '5 & '1+,#'6'+18 & C6 & #$'5 & '5 & %,&/,1+*0=',4&(+,#%0&

1'5.*1+*D & #$+, & %, & ',5%,'#= & 1+6+,3+ & 3%, & 5/33++18 &A.,2+*5+0=D & '6 & #$+ &(.5# & 5'4,'6'3%,# & 3%/5+ &-%5&

3.,5/()#'.,&.6&%&1*/4D&#$+&1+6+,3+&-'00&6%'089::&E.-+2+*D&%))0=',4&#$'5&5'()0+&#+5#&',2.02+5&%&1'66'3/0#&

6%3#/%0 & ',F/'*=D &%,1&.,+&1.(',%,#&3%/5+&(%=&,.# &B+&%))%*+,#8 &<$+& ',#+*,%0G+7#+*,%0 &1'5#',3#'.,&

1*%-,&B=&#$+&3./*#5&B*+%H5&1.-,&',&#$+5+&3'*3/(5#%,3+58&

<$+&*+3/**',4&1%,4+*&#$+.*=&%05.&6%0#+*5&',&3%5+5&',2.02',4&)*+I+7'5#',4&(+,#%0&1'5.*1+*&%,1&

',#.7'3%#'.,8&C6&#$+&'()%'*(+,#&*+3/*5&',1+)+,1+,#0=&.6&1*/4&/5+D&#$'5&1.+5&5/44+5#&#$+&3%/5+&'5&%&

JK<L8&E.-+2+*D&-$+*+&'()%'*(+,#&.,0=&*+3/*5&',&#$+&3.,#+7#&.6&',#.7'3%#'.,D&#$+&3+,#*%0&)*.B0+(&

.6 & 3%/5%#'., & *+(%',58 & C# &(/5# & 6'*5# &B+ &1+#+*(',+1 &-$+#$+* & #$+ &,+3+55'#= &.6 & %, & +7#+*,%0 & #*'44+*&

)*+30/1+5&%,&',5%,'#=&)0+%8&C6&,.#D& #$+&)*.B0+(&'5&%4%',&$.-&#$+&*+0+2%,#&3%/5+&.6&+%3$&+)'5.1+&

5$./01&B+&1+#+*(',+18!C,&+66+3#D&#$+&)*.B0+(&'5&.,+&.6&',#+*%3#'.,8

M8N&& &&&&&&&&& A.,30/5'.,&&

O/1'3'%0&3.,#*.0&.2+*&#$+&(+%,',4&.6&JK<L&(%=&B+&P/5#'6'+1&.,&).0'3=&4*./,158&E.-+2+*D&

#$+&6%'0/*+&.6&#$+&P/1'3'%*=&#.&)*.2'1+&#$+&#+*(&-'#$&%&30+%*&(+%,',4&'5&$'4$0=&)*.B0+(%#'38&K*#$.1.7&

5#%#+(+,#5&.6&#$+&(+%,',4&.6&JK<L&%*+&6*%/4$#&-'#$&#%/#.0.4'+58&Q##+()#5&#.&)*.2'1+&%&)*',3')0+1&

%))*.%3$D & ', & #$+ & 6.*(&.6 & #$+ & *+3/**',4 &1%,4+* & %,1 & ',#+*,%0 & 3%/5+ & #$+.*'+5D & 6%'0 & #. &)*.2'1+ & %00I

+,3.()%55',4&(+#$.1.0.4'+58&C,&3%5+5&-$+*+&',#.7'3%#'.,&'5&)*+5+,#&#$+5+&#$+.*'+5&%*+&)%*#'3/0%*0=&

',%1+F/%#+8&<$+*+6.*+D&#$+&3/**+,#&%))*.%3$&'5&3$%*%3#+*'5+1&B=&/,3+*#%',#=&%,1&3.,5'1+*%B0+&P/1'3'%0&

1'53*+#'.,8&O/14+5&(%=&)'3H&%&)%*#'3/0%*&5#%#+(+,#&.6&-$%#&3.,5#'#/#+5&%&JK<LD&.*&%&)%*#'3/0%*&

#$+.*=D&-'#$./#&+7)0%',',4&-$=&#$'5&%))*.%3$&$%5&B++,&)*+6+**+18&R/*#$+*D&',&%))0'3%#'.,D&P/14+5&(%=&

.B53/*+&#$+'*&*+%5.,',4&-'#$&#%/#.0.4'+5D &.*&(%,')/0%#+&P/1'3'%00=&3*+%#+1&3%#+4.*'5%#'.,5&#.&B*',4&

9:;5+6+789)-+S9":MT&NU&A*&Q))&V&W;MD&W:MIW:N8&<$'5&1+3'5'.,&$%5&B++,&1+53*'B+1&B=&#$+&>,'#+1&?',41.(&@%-&A.(('55'.,&%5&%,&X%BB+**%#'.,Y&#$%#&5$./01&,.#&B+&6.00.-+1Z&>,'#+1&?',41.(&@%-&A.(('55'.,&2)#0:(/%#(0)+%)1+;9(&()%<+=(%>(<(#.+S>?@A&VW9M&![["T&%#&NN8

9::>,'#+1&?',41.(&@%-&A.(('55'.,D&%B.2+&,&9:;D&NN8

Page 34: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !"

#$%&'(')*(+*,-.*+(.*,&/'0(1%/-23(.#')*.(')#4(5.-42-5/*(-46%.7,(')*,*(+*2-,-%4,8(#/')%&9)(')-,(-,(4%'(

*:5.*,,*+0(;)-,(2%46&,-%4(#4+(73,'-6-2#'-%4(-,(4%'(+*,-.#$/*8(#,(')*(5.*,*42*(%.(#$,*42*(%6(#(<=;>(

2#4(7*#4(')*(+-66*.*42*($*'?**4(2%4@-2'-%4(#4+(#2A&-''#/8 (A&#/-6-*+(%.(%&'.-9)'0(B4(*:5.*,,(#4+(

5.-42-5/*+(#55.%#2)('%(')*(<=;>(-4A&-.3(-,(.*A&-.*+0(C4(')*(4*:'(2)#5'*.(C(?-//(5.%5%,*(,&2)(#4(

#55.%#2)0

Page 35: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !"

!"#$%&'()*+&,(-(./0*1%*2(-$$'/#2"(%/(3*1&#1&(/4(%"&(5*67

#$%&'&() * +,-.-$.'/0/.12 * 1- * %(1/ * 3(4/ * .-1 * +,-4&%/% * ( * 2521/0(1&' * (++,-('3 * 1- * 13/*

&%/.1&6&'(1&-. *-6 *( *789:*13(1 *'(.*;/*(++)&/%*<&13 *'/,1(&.15 * &.*0(,=&.() *'(2/2> *?/4/,13/)/22@ *(*

.$0;/, *-6*6('1-,2 *,/)/4(.1 * 1-*13/*789:*&.A$&,5*3(4/*;//.* &%/.1&6&/%> *93/*B$+,/0/*C-$,1*-6*

C(.(%(*,/'/.1)5*%,/<*13/2/*6('1-,2*1-=/13/,@*+,-+-2&.=*(*3-)&21&'*(++,-('3*1-*13/*&.A$&,5>"DE*F.*13&2*

'3(+1/,*F*<&))*-$1)&./*(.*(++,-('3*;(2/%*-.*13/*C(.(%&(.*0-%/)@*(.%*(%4-'(1/*&12*(%-+1&-.*&.*?/<*

G/()(.%>

H>"** ********* I*3-)&21&'*(++,-('3*1-*789:**

93/ *3-)&21&' * (++,-('3*+,-'//%2 *-.* 13/ *;(2&2 * 13(1 *789:*&2 * ( *'-.'/+1 *'-.1(&.&.= *;-13*

0/%&'() *(.%*+-)&'5*'-0+-./.12>"DJ* 93/*0/%&'() *'-0+-./.1 *'-.2&212 *-6* 13/*/4&%/.'/*-6*0/%&'()*

/K+/,12*=&4/.*(1*1,&()>"EL*M-</4/,@*13/*0/%&'()*/4&%/.'/*&2*.-1*%/1/,0&.(1&4/>*F1*&2*21&))*6-,*13/*N$%=/*1-*

%/'&%/*<3/13/,*13/*/4&%/.'/*'(.*2$++-,1*(*6&.%&.=*-6*789:*(1*)(<>"E"*93&2*%/1/,0&.(1&-.*&2*%,&4/.*

;5*13/*+-)&'5*'-0+-./.1*-6*13/*789:*&.A$&,5>

93&2*'-0+-./.1 * &.4-)4/2*'-.2&%/,(1&-.*-6*(*.$0;/,*-6* &.1/,,/)(1/%*6('1-,2@ * 13/*'3&/6*-6*

<3&'3* &2 *+,-1/'1&-.*-6* 13/*+$;)&' *6,-0*%(.=/,>"EO* P/)/4(.1 *+-)&'5 *'-.2&%/,(1&-.2*3(4/*.-1 *;//.*

/K3($21&4/)5*%/6&./%*;5*13/*'-$,12>"E!*M-</4/,@*6('1-,2*(%%&1&-.()*1-*+$;)&'*+,-1/'1&-.*&.')$%/*13/*

.//%*6-,*(.%*(++,-+,&(1/./22*-6*1,/(10/.1@"EQ* (.%*13/*',/%&;&)&15*-6*13/*N$21&'/*2521/0>"EH* R('3*-6*

13/2/*6('1-,2*&2*1-*;/*'-.2&%/,/%@*(''-,%/%*(++,-+,&(1/*</&=31@*(.%*;/(,2*-.*13/*789:*&.A$&,5>"ES*

93/*-4/,(,'3&.=*&22$/*1-*;/*(%%,/22/%*<3/.*'-.2&%/,&.=*13/2/*+-)&'5*6('1-,2*&2*<3/13/,*(*0-,())5*

"DE5+6+7#0)"@*(;-4/*.*DL>*93/*C-$,1*<(2*2+)&1*HTQ@*<&13*13/*)/(%&.=*N$%=0/.1*%/)&4/,/%*;5*U(21(,('3/*#>"DJF;&%@*V"DSW>"EL93&2*/4&%/.'/*23-$)%*,/6)/'1*13/*'$,,/.1*21(1/*-6*0/%&'()*X.-<)/%=/@*13/,/;5*/.(;)&.=*13/*789:*&.A$&,5*1-*;/*&.6-,0/%*;5*$+*1-*%(1/*2'&/.1&6&'*$.%/,21(.%&.=2Y*F;&%@*V"DSW>

"E"B//*C3(+1/,*Z&4/*VH>QW*6-,*(*6$))/,*/K+)(.(1&-.*-6*13/*,-)/2*-6*N$%=/*(.%*N$,5>"EO5+6+7#0)"@*(;-4/*.*DL@*VO"OW*(.%*VO"EW[*5+6+,%89-@*(;-4/*.*SH@*VJW[*5+6+5%:".@*(;-4/*.*DL@*V"DW>"E!5+6+7#0)"@*(;-4/*.*DL@*VO"EW>"EQ5+6+7#0)"@*(;-4/*.*DL@*VOL!W[*5+6+,%89-@*(;-4/*.*SH@+VJW[*5+6*5%:".@*(;-4/*.*DL@*VQSW>"EH5+6+7#0)"@*(;-4/*.*DL@*V"DSW[*5+6+,%89-@*(;-4/*.*SH@*V"SW[*5+6*5%:".@*(;-4/*.*DL@*VEEW>"ES5+6+7#0)"@*(;-4/*.*DL@*VO"EW>

Page 36: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !"

#$$%&'$()*&&+,'-./0),1%+2-)3'),+34'&('-)(%)(1')#$,*$#(5)-#,6%,#(#%$)7'8#9':)

;$ )<%79+2*(#$8 )(1')1%2#,(#& )*667%*&1= ) (1')>+67'9')?%+7( )%< )?*$*-* )7'&%8$#,'-) (1*( ) (1')

7'&+77#$8)-*$8'7)*$-)#$('7$*2)&*+,')(1'%7#',)&%+2-)67%@#-')+,'<+2)8+#-*$&')#$),%9')&*,',=)*2(1%+81)

(1'5)1*-)<*#2'-)*,)*22A'$&%96*,,#$8)9'(1%-%2%8#',:)B1'7'<%7'=)(1',')(1'%7#',)C'7')7'2'8*('-)(%)(1')

,(*(+, ) %< ) D<*&(%7,E ) (% ) 3' ) &%$,#-'7'- ) #<= ) *$- ) %$25 ) #<= ) (1'5 ) ,1'- ) 2#81( ) %$ ) 37%*-'7 ) 6%2#&5)

&%$,#-'7*(#%$,:.//)F%7)'G*962'=)(1')7'&+77#$8)-*$8'7)<*&(%7)9#81()3')7'2'@*$()(%)*,,',,#$8)1%C)6+32#&)

67%('&(#%$ ) ,1%+2- ) 3' ) ,'&+7'-: ) H%C'@'7= ) #< ) &2'*7 ) '@#-'$&' ) %< ) (1' ) 2#I'2#1%%- ) %< ) 7'&+77'$&' ) #,)

+$*@*#2*32')#(),1%+2-)3')-#,7'8*7-'-:

B1'7'<%7'=)(1')1%2#,(#&)*667%*&1)#,)9+2(#A<*&(%7#*2)#$)$*(+7'=)*$-)#$@%2@',)(1')'G62#&#()'G'7&#,')

%<)-#,&7'(#%$:)J'-#&*2)'@#-'$&')#,)&%$,#-'7'-)#$)2#81()%<)*)7*$8')%<)6%2#&5)<*&(%7,:)B1',')<*&(%7,)*7')

3*2*$&'-)#$)%7-'7)(%)7'*&1)*)<#$*2)-'('79#$*(#%$:)B1#,)#,)(%)3')&%$(7*,('-)C#(1)67'@#%+,)*667%*&1',=)

C1#&1)*(('96('-)(%)&*('8%7#,')&%$-#(#%$,)*,)*)KLBJ)%7)%(1'7C#,')%$)(1')3*,#,)%<)*),#$82')@*7#*32')

M':8:=)7'&+77'$&')%<)-*$8'7=)#$('7$*2)&*+,'N:)

;)C#22)$%C)-#,&+,,)'*&1)%<)(1')7'2'@*$()<*&(%7,)#$)9%7')-'(*#2= ) #$-#&*(#$8)(1')C'#81()'*&1)

<*&(%7),1%+2-)3'*7:);)C#22)(1'$)-#,&+,,)(C%)6%,,#32')<*&(%7,);)C%+2-)'G&2+-')<7%9)(1')#$O+#75=)*$-)

'G62*#$)C15:)F#$*225=);)C#22)%+(2#$')(1')7%2',)%<)4+-8')*$-)4+75)#$)*6625#$8)(1')1%2#,(#&)*667%*&1:

P:")) ))))))))) Q'2'@*$()<*&(%7,))

56768 ,9:;(/+'<0#"/#(0)

B1')2#$I)3'(C''$)KLBJ)*$-)6+32#&),*<'(5)C*,)&2'*725)'G67',,'-)35)R+,(#&')K'@2#$)#$)=(;;+> +

?%@#"<S./T))D#<)-#,'*,')#,)67','$(=)(1'),*9')(1#$8)9*5)1*66'$)*8*#$=)*$-)(1'7'<%7'=),#$&')./UU=)(1')2*C)

1*,)67%@#-'-)(1*()6'7,%$,)*&O+#(('-)%$)*&&%+$()%<)(1#,)87%+$-),1%+2-)3'),+34'&()(%)7',(7*#$(:E ).TU)

B1')#96%7(*$&')%<)6+32#&)67%('&(#%$)1*,)3''$)'961*,#,'-)#$)$+9'7%+,)&*,',:.T.)V'@'7(1'2',,=)(1')

./0W,,+9#$8)(1*()(1')*&&+,'-),+&&',,<+225)',(*32#,1',)(1'),'&%$-)7'O+#7'9'$()%<)(1')#$,*$#(5)-'<'$&'S)(1*()(1'5)-#-)$%()I$%C)(1')$*(+7')*$-)O+*2#(5)%7)(1'#7)*&(=)%7)-#-)$%()I$%C)(1*()(1'#7)&%$-+&()C*,)C7%$8:

.//A+>+B#0)"=)*3%@')$)0U=)X"UYZ=)X"..Z)*$-)X".!Z:

./T=(;;+>+?%@#"<=)*3%@')$)."U:

.TU);3#-=+"/PA"/Y:

.T.A+>+B9;;(>%)=)*3%@')$)P0=).0"[)?<%##.+>+C##0<)".DE")"<%;+40<+F0<#$"<)+2<";%)1=)*3%@')$)PP=)\.U[)A+>+G"&'=)*3%@')$).U/=+\U![)

Page 37: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !!

"#$%&'()**+,-#-('+('&$.(/+0$*1(*+2.$-#,)'$+2($.(*+2'#3'(-#/#2-#2'4(

( 52 ( *).#. (+6 ( )7'+8)'$.89 ( '&# (/+'#2'$)0 (+7'*+8#. ( ),# ( )2 (+7',$%&' ( +, (:7)0$6$#- ( )*:7$'')04(

;&#,#6+,#9()2($2.)2$'1(<#,-$*'(/,+<$-#.('&#(+201(")1(6+,($88#-$)'#(*+2',+0('+(=#(#3#,*$.#-(+<#,('&#(

)**7.#-(<$)( '&#(*,$8$2)0( 0)"4(56 ( '&#,#( $. (*+2*#,2()=+7'(+2%+$2%(-)2%#,9 (*+2.$-#,)'$+2(+6(/7=0$*(

/,+'#*'$+2(8)1("#$%&(&#)<$01($2(6)<+7,(+6(6$2-$2%()(>?;@4(A+"#<#,9'&$.(#8/&).$.(+2(/7=0$*(.)6#'1(

&). (=##2(*,$'$*$B#-(+2( '&# (=).$. ( '&)' (/7=0$* (/,+'#*'$+2(*)2(=# (.#*7,#-(7.$2%(*$<$09 (2+' (*,$8$2)0(

/,+*#-7,#.4CDE( F7'( '&$.(*,$'$*$.8(*)2(=#($2*+,/+,)'#-("$'&$2('&#(870'$G6)*'+,$)0 ()//,+)*&H( '&)'( $.9(

"&#'&#,('&#(/7=0$*(*+70-(=#()-#:7)'#01(.)6#%7),-#-(=1(7.#(+6(*$<$0(/,+*#-7,#.("+70-(=#(+2#(8+,#(

6)*'+,('+(=#(*+2.$-#,#-4(I#<#,'&#0#..9($2(.+8#(*).#.()2($2.)2$'1(6$2-$2%(8)1(=#('&#(+201(8#)2.(=1(

"&$*&('+(/,+'#*'('&#(/7=0$*4((J+,(#3)8/0#9()(/#,.+2("$'&(/+.'G',)78)'$*(.',#..(-$.+,-#,("&+(#2'#,.()(

<$+0#2'(-$..+*$)'$<#(.')'#( $2(,#./+2.#('+(*#,')$2(#2<$,+28#2')0(',$%%#,.(*+70-(2+'(=#(-#')$2#-(6+,(

/,+0+2%#- (/#,$+-. ( $2 ( $2/)'$#2' (*),# (72-#, ( '&# (*$<$0 (8#2')0 (&#)0'& ( ,#%$8#9 (=7' (8)1 ( ,#/,#.#2' ( )(

.$%2$6$*)2'(+2%+$2%(,$.K('+('&#(*+8872$'14

52(2+2G)7'+8)'$.8(*).#.('&#(/+'#2'$)0(+7'*+8#.(),#()(:7)0$6$#-()*:7$'')09(+,(*+2<$*'$+2()2-(

.#2'#2*$2%4(F+'&(+7'*+8#.(*)2(/,+<$-#(6+,(-#'#2'$+2(+6('&#()**7.#-4(;&#,#6+,#9($2('&#.#(*).#.('&#(

2##-('+(/,+'#*'('&#(/7=0$*(8)1(2+'(*),,1().(87*&("#$%&'4(I#<#,'&#0#..9($'(*)2(.'$00(=#(,#0#<)2'4(52()(

*).#( $2<+0<$2%( 0+"G0#<#0 (+66#2-$2%9 (*+2<$*'$+2(8)1( 0#)-('+() (.&+,' (/#,$+-(+6(-#'#2'$+2(+2014 (52(

*+2',).'9(-#'#2'$+2().()(./#*$)0(/)'$#2'(*)2(=#($2-#6$2$'#9()2-('&$.(8)1(=#(*+2.$-#,#-(-#.$,)=0#4

56767 8$"+)""1+409+%)1+%''90'9(%#")"--+04+#9"%#&")#

( ;&#(2##-(6+,(',#)'8#2'($.()(L/,$2*$/)0(,#).+2M(6+,(*+26$2#8#2'(+6(8#2')001($00(+66#2-#,.4CD!(

:+;+<"-="99()=+<#(2(NO9+PQORS(:+;+>0##="9(2(TC9(COED()2-(CO!!S(:+;+?%=/0)"99()=+<#(2(NC9+TT()2-(UNS(:+;+@A(/B9()=+<#(2(UD9(DCDS(:+;(:%C".9()=+<#(2(NO9(PCNRS(:+;+,%9B-9()=+<#(2(UT9(PDR4

CDEV$8#.'#,()2-(V700$<)29()=+<#(2(CED9(UQD4(V##()0.+(:+;+?%=/0)"99()=+<#(2(NC9(U!H(>#)2#()2-(>)".+2(WW(2+'#-('&)'($6('&#(*7,,#2'()//,+)*&('+()7'+8)'$.8(8#)2'('&)'(.+8#(/+'#2'$)001(<$+0#2'(+66#2-#,.("#,#(,#0#).#-(+7',$%&'9('&$.(&)-('+(=#()**#/'#-4(X21(*+2*#,2.()=+7'(.)6#'1("+70-(=#(L)(8)''#,('+(=#(-#)0'("$'&(=1('&#(8#)2.(+'&#,"$.#()<)$0)=0#(6+,(/,+'#*'$2%('&#(*+8872$'1(6,+8(.7*&(/#,.+2.()2-9($6('&+.#(8#)2.(),#('&+7%&'('+(=#($2)-#:7)'#9(=1(0#%$.0)'$<#($2'#,<#2'$+24M

CD!:+;(:%C".9()=+<#(2(NO9(PQUR4

Page 38: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !"

#$%&'(%)*%(+,&'(,-..%*.%/-&(0(11,*2,1(03/04,-0,*22(03(%,&*,-,)(0&-5,'*1./&-5,/1,%(5(6-0&789", :2,&'(,

*22(03(%,1$22(%1,2%*),-,;*03/&/*0,&'-&,/1,$05/<(5=,&*,%(;$%+,*%,/1,0*&,-,)(0&-5,/550(11,-)(0->5(,&*,

&%(-&)(0&+,&'(0,/&,)-=,0*&,>(,-..%*.%/-&(,&*,3(&-/0,'/),/0,-,)(0&-5,'*1./&-57,?$;',3(&(0&/*0,@*$53,

/0,(22(;&,)-<(,)(0&-5,'(-5&',.%-;&/&/*0(%1,A-/5(%1+,.5-;/04,&'(),/0,-,3/22/;$5&,-03,()>-%%-11/04,(&'/;-5,

.*1/&/*0789B

C*@(6(%+,&'(,25(D/>/5/&=,.%*6/3(3,/0,1(0&(0;/04,-03,3/1.*1/&/*0,)(-01,&'-&,;*01/3(%-&/*0,*2,

&'(,0((3,2*%,-03,-..%*.%/-&(0(11,*2,&%(-&)(0&,)-=,0*&,;-%%=,3(;/1/6(,@(/4'&7,E,.(%1*0,-;F$/&&(3,*0,

4%*$031,*2,/01-0/&=,0((3,0*&,>(,3(&-/0(3,/2,&'/1,/1,/0-..%*.%/-&(789G,H'(=,)-=,/01&(-3,>(,/))(3/-&(5=,

%(5(-1(3+,;*))/&&(3,-1,-,;/6/5,.-&/(0&+,*%,%(5(-1(3,2%*),1.(;/-5,.-&/(0&,1&-&$1789I,J*06(%1(5=+,-,0((3,

2*% , &%(-&)(0& ,;-00*& ,3(&(%)/0( , &'( ,)-&&(% , /0 , 2-6*$% ,*2 , /01-0/&=+ , -1 , &'(%-.($&/; ,*%3(%1 , -%( , 1&/55,

-6-/5->5(,2*55*@/04,-,;*06/;&/*0789K,

L(6(%&'(5(11+,;*06/;&/*0,-03,F$-5/2/(3,-;F$/&&-5,;-0,1&/55,5(-3,&*,3/22(%(0&,*$&;*)(17,E,.(%1*0,

2*$03,/01-0(,;-0,0(6(%,>(,'(53,/0,.%/1*07,:0,;*0&%-1&+,-,.(%1*0,;*06/;&(3,)-=,>(,'(53,/0,.%/1*0+,/0,-,

)(0&-5,'*1./&-5+,*%,)-=,>(,&%-012(%%(3,>(&@((0,&'(,&@*7,H'/1,3/22(%(0;(,/0,3/1.*1/&/*0,*.&/*01,@/55,

>(,%(5(6-0&,&*,&'(,MNHO,/0F$/%=7,#*%,(D-).5(+,;*01/3(%,-0,-;;$1(3,@'*,1$22(%1,2%*),*;;-1/*0-5,

.1=;'*&/; ,(./1*3(1+ ,>$& ,-& ,*&'(% , &/)(1 , /1 ,*2 , 1*$03,)/037 ,#*% , 1$;',-0,-;;$1(3+ ,- ,'=>%/3 ,*%3(%,

2*55*@/04,;*06/;&/*0,)-=,>(,)*1&,-..%*.%/-&(7 ,H'/1,@*$53,.(%)/&,2*%,&%-012(%,&*,'*1./&-5 ,@'(0,

.1=;'*&/;,(./1*3(1,*;;$%+,-03,3(&(0&/*0,/0,.%/1*0,@'(0,&'(,-;;$1(3,/1,0*&,/0,0((3,*2,&%(-&)(0&7,E,

.%(2(%(0;(,2*%,-,'=>%/3,*%3(%,@*$53,)/5/&-&(,-4-/01&,-,2/03/04,*2,MNHO7

56768 9$"+:"/;::()<+1%)<":+4%/#0:

H'/1,2-;&*%,/06*56(1,;*01/3(%-&/*0,*2,&'(,5/<(5/'**3,&'-&,&'(,-55(4(3,;*03/&/*0,@/55,%(;$%7,:2,-,

3/1*%3(%,/1,5/<(5=,&*,%(;$%+,&'/1,)-=,/03/;-&(,&'-&,&%(-&)(0&,/1,0(;(11-%=,-03,-..%*.%/-&(7,#$%&'(%+,/&,

89"=+>+=%140:1+,->*6(,0,8P"+,PIGQ,=+>+?;(/@++->*6(,0,G9++98KQ,R/55/-)1+,->*6(,0,"!+,"GG789B=+>+=%140:1+,->*6(,0,8P"+,PIG7,?((,-51*,R/55/-)1+,->*6(,0,"!+,GIG789G=+>+?;(/@+,->*6(,0,G9+,98KQ,=+>,=%A".+,->*6(,0,IS+,T8PUQ,=+>+B0##C"+,->*6(,0,B8+,8SPK789IJ%/)/0-5,V%*;(3$%(,WO(0&-55=,:).-/%(3,V(%1*01X,E;&,PSS!+,11,P"YPG,-03,!!789K:>/3+,1,!"7

Page 39: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !"

#$%&'(&)(*(+$,-&.,&/(-()#.,.,0&12$-&.3&)(45.)(/&-6&3(75)(&85'*.7&3$9(-%:&;9&-2()(&.3&,6&76,-.,5.,0&

/$,0()< &261(+()< & -2.3&1.** &,6-&$5-6#$-.7$**% &8)(7*5/(&$& 9.,/.,0&69&$ &=>?@:ABB& ;,&$33(33.,0&-2(&

*.C(*.266/&$&/.36)/()&1.**&)(75)<&-2(&83%72.$-).7&2.3-6)%&69&-2(&$7753(/<&$,/&-2(&*.C(*%&)(75))(,7(&69&

$,%&(D-(),$*&-).00()&1.**&'(&)(*(+$,-:EFF& ?2(&)(75)).,0&/$,0()&9$7-6)&#$%&'(&69&*.#.-(/&53(&12()(&

(+./(,7(&$3&-6&95-5)(&)(75))(,7(&.3&(45.+67$*:

56768 9$"+()#":)%;+/%<-"+4%/#0:

?2( & .,-(),$* & 7$53( & 9$7-6) & )(*$-(3 & -6 &12(-2() & -2( & $**(0(/ & .#8$.)#(,- &1$3 & 7$53(/ &'% & -2(&

83%726*60.7$*&6)&(#6-.6,$*&#$C(58&69&-2(&$7753(/<&6)&-2(&(99(7-3&69&36#(&(D-(),$*&9$7-6):&;9&-2(&

7$53(&.3&.,-(),$*<&-2.3&#$%&3500(3-&$&,((/&96)&-)($-#(,-<&6)&$&*.C(*.266/&69&)(75))(,7(&12.72&85-3&-2(&

85'*.7&$-&).3C:

;,&7$3(3&12()(&.-&.3&/.99.75*-&-6&5,-$,0*(&-2(&.,-(),$*&$,/&(D-(),$*&7$53(3&69&.#8$.)#(,-<&-2(&

76,-(D-5$*&6'G(7-.+(&$88)6$72&/(37).'(/&.,&H2$8-()&I65)&#$%&'(&(#8*6%(/J&-2$-&.3<&-2(&)(386,3(&69&

-2(&$7753(/&-6&-2(&(D-(),$*&9$7-6)&1.**&'(&76#8$)(/&1.-2&-2$-&69&$,&6)/.,$)%&8()36,&8*$7(/&.,&-2(&

$7753(/K3&7.)75#3-$,7(3&.,&6)/()&-6&/(-()#.,(&12(-2()&36#(&$',6)#$*.-%&.,-(),$*&-6&-2(&$7753(/&2$3&

7$53(/&-2(&.#8$.)#(,-:&?2.3&$88)6$72&1.**&'(&$88)68).$-(&.,&7$3(3&12()(&-2(&(D-(),$*&9$7-6)&.3&*.C(*%&

-6 & .,-()$7- & 1.-2 & 6) & (D$7()'$-( & $, & 5,/()*%.,0 & #(,-$* & .,9.)#.-%: & I6) & (D$#8*(< & -2( & (99(7- & 69 & $&

83%726*60.7$*&'*61&#$%&'(&76,-.,0(,-&586,&-2(&#(,-$*&3-$-(&69&-2(&.,/.+./5$*:&L.#.*$)*%<&-2(&(99(7-&

69 & $ & /)50 &12.72 & 7$, & 7$53( &83%7263.3 &#$% &'( & 76,-.,0(,- & 586, & -2( &8)(3(,7( &69 & $, & 5,/()*%.,0&

+5*,()$'.*.-%&-6&83%7263.3:&;,&-2(3(&7$3(3<&-2(&76,-(D-5$*&6'G(7-.+(&$88)6$72&1.**&8)6+./(&.,3.02-&.,-6&

-2(&#(,-$*&3-$-(&69&-2(&$7753(/:&;,&76,-)$3-<&-2(&(99(7-&69&$&'*61&-6&-2(&2($/&/6(3&,6-&0(,()$**%&

/(8(,/&586,&-2(&8)(M(D.3-.,0&3-$-(&69&#.,/&69&-2(&.,/.+./5$*:&N776)/.,0*%<&-2(&76,-(D-5$*&6'G(7-.+(&

$88)6$72&3265*/&,6-&'(&$88*.(/:

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

Page 40: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !"

#$ % &'()( % *$+,-+*$. % ' % $/01)2 % ,3 % &'/()(4 % *5 % 6*-- % 1) % $)&)(('27 % 5, % &,$(*8)2 % 59) % 2)-'5*+)%

&,$52*1/5*,$%,3%)'&9%&'/()%5,%59)%0)$5'-%*0:'*20)$5%/-5*0'5)-7%(/33)2)8;%#$%(,0)%&'()(4%*5%6*--%1)%

&-)'2%59'5%59)%8,0*$'$5%&'/()%6'(%,$)%*$5)2$'-%5,%59)%'&&/()8;%<,6)+)24%*$%,59)2%&'()(%*5%0'7%1)%

8*33*&/-5%5,%*(,-'5)%,$)%0'*$%&'/();%#$%59)()%&'()(4%59)%/5*-*57%,3%59)%*$5)2$'-=)>5)2$'-%8*&9,5,07%0'7%

1)%-*0*5)8;%

?;!%% %%%%%%%%% #22)-)+'$5%3'&5,2(%%

56768 9:"1(;(<(#.+04+#$"+=>-#(/"+-.-#"&

@$,59)2%:,-*&7%&,$(*8)2'5*,$%9*.9-*.95)8%17%59)%&,/25(%*(%59)%$))8%5,%0'*$5'*$%59)%&2)8*1*-*57%

,3%59)%A/(5*&)%(7(5)0;BCD%E,$&)2$%9'(%1))$%)>:2)(()8%59'5%59)%-).'-%0)'$*$.%,3%FGHI%(9,/-8%$,5%1)%

2).'28)8 %6*59 % *$&2)8/-*57 % ,/5(*8) %,3 % 59) % &,/25(;BCB% J/259)24 %*$ % &'()( %69)2) % ('$) % '/5,0'5*(0 % *(%

:-)'8)84%'%(:)&*3*& %&,$&)2$% *( %59'5 %59)%A/(5*&)%(7(5)0K(%&2)8*1*-*57 %6*-- %1)%L()+)2)-7 %(52'*$)8M%*3 %'%

+*,-)$5%,33)$8)2%2)&)*+)(%'$%'1(,-/5)%'&N/*55'-;BC!% H9*(%*(%-*$O)8%5,%3)'2(%59'5%'/5,0'5*(0%0'7%1)%

3)*.$)84%'$8%59'5%*3%:-)'(%,3%('$)%'/5,0'5*(0%'2)%5,,%2)'8*-7%'&&):5)8%59)2)%6*--%1)%'$%*$&2)'()%*$%

/$0)2*5,2*,/(%8)3)$&)(;BCP% <,6)+)24 %# %&,$5)$8%59'5 % 59)()%&,$&)2$(%,+)2%&2)8*1*-*57 %&'$$,5%&'227%

0/&94%*3%'$74%6)*.95%*$%59)%FGHI%*$N/*27;%

E,$(*8)2*$. % 3*2(5 % 59) %&,$&)2$% 59'5 % 59) % -).'- % '::2,'&9% 5, %FGHI%0'7%1) % 2).'28)8 %6*59%

*$&2)8/-*574%Q,28%F*:-,&O%*$ %?><<(@%)BC?+ (5'5)8%59'5% *$('$*57% *(%'%5)&9$*&'-% -).'-%5)20;%H9)2)3,2)4% *5%

(9,/-8%1)%'::-*)8%*$%&'()(%69)2)%59)%-).'-%2)N/*2)0)$5(%,3%59)%*$('$*57%8)3)$&)%'2)%0)54%)+)$%*3%59*(%

'::)'2(%(52'$.)%5,%59,()%,/5(*8)%59)%&,/25(;%<)%&,$&-/8)8%59'5%*3%-).'-%/()%,3%59)%-'1)-%L*$('$*57M%6'(%

&,$(*8)2)8 % :2,1-)0'5*&4 % R'2-*'0)$5 % &,/-8 % &9'$.) % 59) % -'1)-;BC"% H9*( % 9'( % ,&&/22)8 % *$ % ,59)2%

A/2*(8*&5*,$(4%(/&9%'(%E'$'8'4%69)2)%59)%8)3)$&)%*(%0,2)%&-)'2-7%8)(&2*1)8%'(%59)%L8)3)$&)%,3%0)$5'-%

BCDA+@+B>(/C4+'1,+)%$%"S4+SDST%A+@+D"-<":4%'1,+)%$%UC4+VPCWT%A+@+?#0)"4%'1,+)%$%UC4%VDU"WT%A+@%A%;".4%'1,+)%$%UC4%VXXW%:)2%F*&O(,$%Y%8*(()$5*$.T%%A+@+,%:C-4%'1,+)%$%"?4%VD?W;

BCBA+@+B>(/C4+'1,+)%$%"S4%SDS;BC!A+@+?#0)"4%'1,+)%$%UC4%VDU"WT%A+@+,%:C-4%'1,+)%$%"?4%VD?WT%A+@%A%;".4%'1,+)%$%UC4%VXXW%:)2%F*&O(,$%Y%8*(()$5*$.%;BCPA+@+?#0)"4%'1,+)%$%UC4%VDU"WT%A+@+,%:C-4%'1,+)%$%"?4%VD"WT%A+@%A%;".4%'1,+)%$%UC4%VXXW%:)2%F*&O(,$%Y%8*(()$5*$.;BC?A+@+?><<(@%)4%'1,+)%$%?U;BC"#1*84%DU!;

Page 41: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !"

#$%&'#(')*+,"- . -/0'((-1$23-4&'#-5$67&89*+,:- .2 -1&;7#-<(-$=/66'&6'$/2(->&'- 23(-?&;'2% -2&-#(>(' -2&-

6;<7$8-&6$=$&=@-/%-$=%/=$2A-8/%(%-&>2(=-(B&9(-%2'&=0-(C&2$&=/7-'(%6&=%(%-13$83-C/A-#$%2'/82->'&C-

6('2$=(=2-8&=%$#('/2$&=%*-D;'23('@-23(-8&;'2%-C;%2-2/9(-/-#$>>('(=2-/66'&/83-2&-5EFG-23/=-23(-

C(#$8/7 -6'&>(%%$&=* -F3(-8&;'2%-/'(-2/%9(#-1$23-#(2('C$=$=0- $%%;(%-&>-8'$C$=/7-'(%6&=%$<$7$2A-/=#-

6;<7$8-6'&2(82$&=@-=&2-1$23-6'&B$#$=0-2'(/2C(=2*+,H-F3$%-$=(B$2/<7A-/72('%-23(-8&=2(I2-$=-13$83-23(-

C(/=$=0-&>-23(-2('C-$%-2&-<(-%(227(#*-J##$2$&=/[email protected]&=2(=#-23/2-/667$8/2$&=-&>-23(-3&7$%2$8-/66'&/83-

1$77-'(#;8(-23(-=;C<('-&>-8/%(%-$=-13$83-/-5EFG->$=#$=0-1$77-/66(/'-$=8&=0';&;%-2&-23(-6;<7$8*+K,-

?&=8('=%-23/2-23(-#(>(=8(-&>-%/=(-/;2&C/2$%C-1$77-<(-C$%;%(#-/'(-/7%&-;=1/''/=2(#*-.-/0'((-

1$23-L$==$(-M@-#$%%(=2$=0-$= -5#0)"@+KK- $=-23$%-'(0/'#*-N(-/'0;(#-23/2-O23(-P;'A-/'(-/%-1(77-67/8(#-/%-

/=A&=(-$=-23(-P;%2$8(-%A%2(C-2&-;63&7#-$2%-8'(#$<$7$2A*-F3(-<&22&C-7$=(-$%@-/>2('-/77@-23/2-23(-2/%9-&>-

1($03$=0-23(-8'(#$<$7$2A-&>-%;83-#(>(=8(%-1/%-8&=>$=(#-<A-Q/'7$/C(=2-2&-23(-P;'A*)+K+-F3('(>&'(@-/-

P;#0(-13&-1$233&7#%-23(-#(>(=8(-&>-%/=(-/;2&C/2$%C->'&C-23(-P;'A-<(8/;%(-&>-#&;<2-/<&;2- $2%-

8'(#$<$7$2A-;%;'6%-23(-P;'AR%-'&7(-/%->/82->$=#('*-D(/'-23/2-23(-P;'A-C/A->/77-$=2&-(''&'-8/==&2-P;%2$>A-

23$%*+K!-JB/$7/<7(-(B$#(=8(-%;00(%2%-23/2-/77&1$=0-%/=(-/;2&C/2$%C-#(>(=8(%-2&-<(-/%%(%%(#-<A-23(-P;'A-

1$77 - =&2 - '(%;72 - $= - / - >7&&# - &> - ;=1/''/=2(# - /8S;$22/7%*+KT- U(B('23(7(%%@ - %3&;7# - /= - $=8'(/%( - $=-

;=C('$2&'$&;%-#(>(=8(%-&88;'@-23(-/66'&6'$/2(-'(%6&=%(-1&;7#-<(-7(0$%7/2$B(-$=2('B(=2$&=@-%;83-/%-

%3$>2$=0-23(-6('%;/%$B(-<;'#(=-&=-2&-23(-/88;%(#@-=&2-(I2(=%$&=-&>-23(-2('C-5EFG*+KV-

+,"?'$C$=/7-?&#(-WX?-KH:V-8-?YTZ@-%-KZ*+,:.-#&-=&2-/0'((-1$23-23(-'(%;72-$=-5677(8%)[-/<&B(-=-V"*-N&1(B('@-23$%-$%-=&2-<(8/;%(-.-23$=9-23/2-6;<7$8-#$%2/%2(-2&1/'#-/667$8/2$&=-&>-23(-O$=%/=$2A)-7/<(7-%3&;7#-8/''A-#(8$%$B(-1($032*-.=%2(/#@-.-8&=%$#('-23/2-4&'#-5$67&89-(''(#-$=-/667A$=0-23(-/66'&/83-2&-5EFG-7/$#-#&1=-$=-9"&'[-/<&B(-=-K,:*

+,H:+8+,0;#";@-/<&B(-=-VH@-K:Z*+K,F3(->7(I$<$7$2A-&>-23(-3&7$%2$8-/66'&/83-(=%;'(%-23/2-23(-5EFG-$=S;$'A-8/=-<(-#(2('C$=(#-$=-/88&'#/=8(-1$23-6&7$8A-/=#-8&CC&=-%(=%(*-J<%;'#-'(%;72%-/'$%$=0->'&C-23(-%2'$82-/667$8/2$&=-&>-8/2(0&'$8/7-2(%2%-1$77-=&-7&=0('-/'$%(*-D;'23('C&'(@-/%-6&7$8A-#(7$<('/2$&=-$%-C/#(-(I67$8$2-;=#('-23(-3&7$%2$8-/66'&/83@-23(-6;<7$8-1$77-3/B(-/88(%%-2&-P;#$8$/7-'(/%&=$=0->&'-83/'/82('$\/2$&=-&>-/-#$%&'#('-$=-/-8('2/$=-1/A*

+KK:+8+5#0)"@-/<&B(-=-",*+K+.<$#@-]"T^-6('-L$==$(-M-#$%%(=2$=0*+K!.<$#@-]+H^-/=#-]::^-6('-L$==$(-M-#$%%(=2$=0*+KTX((-X2;/'2@-/<&B(-=-"T@-K+V[-OX$=8(-,%;<-+<;2-6'$&'-2&-5#0)"+%/=(-/;2&C/2$%C-87/$C%-1('(-'(P(82(#-$=-=";>%&()+_KHHZ`-!-?W-_V23`-KT,-_J72/-?J`-/=#-!/?6%;;("+_KHH:`-K+"-???-_!#`-+:+-_J72/-?J`*)

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

Page 42: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !"

56768 ,9(09+4%:;#+04+#$"+%//:-"1

#$%&''()*+%,&)%-./0.%1&(23%4,*$%3,*5%10.6%&$%/$3*$3%30%'066/3%&%'./6*%-./0.%30%7*33/$7%

/$308/'&3*+9%3,*$%:*'06*%/$308/'&3*+%&$+%'066/3%3,*%'./6*;%#$%&''()*+%6&5%&2)0%,&<*%-./0.%1&(23%/1%

3,*5%',00)*%30%3&=*%&%+.(7%=$04/$7%3,&3%3,/)%4/22%6&=*%3,*6%+&$7*.0()%&$+%/6-(2)/<*9%&$+%3,*$%

:*'06*%+&$7*.0()%&$+%'066/3%&%'./6*;%>&)*)%30%+&3*%)(77*)3%3,&3%3,*%-.*)*$'*%01%-./0.%1&(23%,&)%

/6-2/'&3/0$)%10.%3,*%&--2/'&3/0$%01%3,*%/$)&$/35%+*1*$'*;?@A

B$%<##09)".=>")"9%;+409+?09#$"9)+29";%)1+@+>%;;%A$"9?@C%3,*%&''()*+%4&)%&$%&77.*))/<*%-)5',0-&3,9%

4,0%4&)%-.0$*%30%*8-20)/<*%0(3:(.)3)%4,*$%/$308/'&3*+;%D*%10.6*+%3,*%/$3*$3/0$%30%=/22%,/)%4/1*%

4,/2*%)0:*.%&$+%/$%,/)%./7,3%6/$+;%D*%3,*$%0:3&/$*+%&%=$/1*%10.%3,/)%-(.-0)*9%703%+.($=9%&$+%'&../*+%

0(3%,/)%-2&$;%B$%.*E*'3/$7%&$%/$)&$/35%+*1*$'*9%F0.+%G*$$/$7%'0$'2(+*+%3,&3%HI3J,*%4/'=*+$*))%01%,/)%

6/$+%:*10.*%,*%703%+.($=%/)%*$0(7,%30%'0$+*6$%,/69%'0(-2*+%4/3,%3,*%&'3%4,/',%,*%/$3*$+*+%30%+0%

&$+%+/+%+0;K?@"%

L/6/2&.259%/$%B(&&-+@+,0;(/"?@M+3,*%&''()*+%=$*4%3,&3%)(:)3&$'*%()*%'0(2+%3./77*.%,*.%($+*.25/$7%

6*$3&2%+/)0.+*.9%&$+%3,&3%3,/)%'0(2+%.*)(23%/$%'./6/$&2%011*$+/$7;%L,*%$*<*.3,*2*))%',0)*%30%:*'06*%

/$308/'&3*+9%&$+%011*$+*+;%N22/)%O%)(77*)3*+9%4/3,0(3%+*'/+/$7%3,*%6&33*.9%3,&3%3,*%&''()*+P)%10.*)/7,3%

01%011*$+/$7%6/7,3%-.*<*$3%,*.%1.06%.*25/$7%0$%3,*%/$)&$/35%+*1*$'*;??Q

R,*)*%'&)*)%)(77*)3%3,&3%3,*%-.*)*$'*%01%-./0.%1&(23%'&$%:*%1&3&2%30%3,*%/$)&$/35%+*1*$'*;%R,/)%

/)%:*'&()*9%&)%F0.+%G*$$/$7%-(3%/39%3,*%H4/'=*+$*))%01%I&$%&''()*+P)J%6/$+%:*10.*%,*%703%+.($=%/)%

*$0(7,%30%'0$+*6$%,/6K;%R,&3%/)9%/$%'&)*)%01%<02($3&.5%/$308/'&3/0$9%3,*%6*$3&2%)3&3*%01%3,*%&''()*+%

6&5%:*%&))*))*+%-./0.%30%3,*/.%/$308/'&3/0$;??@%B1%3,*%&''()*+%/$3*$+*+%&3%3,&3%3/6*%30%+0%&$%&'3%,*%

=$*4%30%:*%4.0$7%S/;*;9%,*%4&)%4/'=*+T9%3,*$%,*%'&$$03%.*25%2&3*.%0$%3,*%/$)&$/35%+*1*$'*;%R,/)%40(2+%

?@A<##09)".=>")"9%;%409+?0#$"9)+29";%)1+@+>%;;%A$"99%&:0<*%$%UAV%C+@+D:(/E9+&:0<*%$%AMV+C+@+F%(;".+I@M"!J%NW>#%>./6%?V%B(&&-%@+,0;(/"+D>%W*22/$730$%#X%"YMC9%?C%Z&.',%@MMC;

?@C<##09)".=>")"9%;%409+?0#$"9)+29";%)1+@+>%;;%A$"99%&:0<*%$%UA;?@"B:/+9%!"?;%%R,*%03,*.%6*6:*.)%01%3,*%D0()*%01%F0.+)%+*3*.6/$*+%3,*%6&33*.%0$%&$%&23*.$&3/<*%:&)/)[%3,*%&''()*+%,&+%$03%),04$%3,&3%,/)%+/)0.+*.%.*$+*.*+%,/6%($&:2*%30%=$04%3,*%$&3(.*9%\(&2/35%0.%4.0$7$*))%01%,/)%&'3);%]*<*.3,*2*))9%F0.+%G*$$/$7P)%&--.0&',%S)06*3/6*)%+*)'./:*+%&)%3,*%HG(3',%'0(.&7*%.(2*KT%,&)%.*'*/<*+%)(--0.3;%!"#$

?@MB(&&-%@+,0;(/"9%&:0<*%$%?@A;??QB:/+9%M;??@R,/)%),/13%/$%3,*%3/6*%01%&))*))/$7%3,*%6*$3&2%)3&3*%01%3,*%&''()*+%/)%&.7(&:25%E()3/1/*+%0$%-02/'5%7.0($+);

Page 43: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !"

#$%&'$%()*$%$+$,%-.%)&%&'$%&-/$%'$%0$1.21/$3%&'$%)(&%'$%3-3%,2&%4,25%'-*%)(&%5)*%512,67%891&'$1:%&'$%

2#-&$1 % *&)&$/$,&* %2.%;<<-* % = % *966$*& % &')& % 1$(4<$**,$**%)* % &2%2..$,3-,6: %)& %) %01-21 % &-/$%5'$,%&'$%

)((9*$3%4,$5%1-6'&%.12/%512,6:%/)>%#$%.)&)<%&2%),%-,*),-&>%3$.$,($7

?25$+$1: %5'-<$%01-21%.)9<& %/)>%')+$%&'-*%$..$(&: % &'-*% -* %,2&: %@ %529<3%*966$*&: %#$()9*$% -&%

01$+$,&*%)%.-,3-,6%&')&%&'$%)((9*$3%')3%)%ABCD7%E%F9)<-.>-,6%/$,&)<%3-*213$1%/)>%#$%01$*$,&:%),3%

$+$, % -. % &'-* % -* % &1-66$1$3 % 21 % $G)($1#)&$3 % #> % +2<9,&)1> % -,&2G-()&-2,: % -& % 5-<< % *&-<< % #$ % ) %ABCD7HHH%

I$+$1&'$<$**:%&'$%)((9*$3%/)>%,2&%#$%(2,*-3$1$3%&2%*)&-*.>%&'$%*$(2,3%*&)6$%2.%&'$%-,*),-&>%-,F9-1>J%

&')&%-*:%&'$>%5-<<%,2&%#$%)#<$%&2%*)>%&')&%&'$>%3-3%,2&%4,25%&'$-1%)(&%5)*%/21)<<>%512,67%@&%-*%-,%&'-*%

/),,$1%&')&%01-21%.)9<&%(),%01$(<93$%),%-,*),-&>%3$.$,($7%C'$1$.21$:%$+$,%&'296'%01-21%.)9<&%/)>%#$%

1$<$+),&% &2%&'$%)00<-()&-2,%2.%&'$%-,*),-&>%3$.$,($%)*%)%5'2<$:% -& % -* %,2&%)%.)(&21%1$<$+),&%&2%&'$%

ABCD%-,F9-1>7HH!

K7L%% %%%%%%%%% M2<$*%2.%N936$%),3%N91>%%

C'$%ABCD%-,F9-1>%-,+2<+$*%F9$*&-2,*%2.%<)5%),3%.)(&7HHL%C'$1$.21$:%#2&'%&'$%N936$%),3%&'$%

N91>%')+$%(19(-)<%12<$*%&2%0<)>%-,%3$&$1/-,-,6%5'$&'$1%)%ABCD%-*%01$*$,&7%@&%-*%.21%&'$%N936$%&2%

3$&$1/-,$%5'$&'$1%)%1$)*2,)#<$% N91>%0120$1<>%-,*&19(&$3%(29<3%.-,3%)%ABCD:%*9('%&')&% -,*),-&>%

*'29<3%#$%<$.&%&2%&'$%N91>7HHK%C'$%N936$%/9*&%)<*2%3-1$(&%&'$%N91>%)*%&2%&'$%<$6)<%/$),-,6%2.%ABCD7%

C'$%N91>O*%12<$%-*%&2%3$&$1/-,$%5'$&'$1%&2%)(($0&%&'$%$G0$1&%),3%2&'$1%$+-3$,($%2..$1$3%)&%&1-)<%-,%

*90021&%2.%),%-,*),-&>%3$.$,($:%),3%&2%)00<>%&'$%<)5%&2%&'$-1%.-,3-,6*7

@, %50)#%()":HHP% 8-*'%=%*&)&$3%-,%2#-&$1%&')&%&'$%'2<-*&-(%)0012)('%*$&%29&%-, %6#0)" +*'29<3%#$%

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

HH!C'$%$G&$,&%&2%5'-('%01-21%.)9<&%/)>%01$+$,&%),%)((9*$3%.12/%$*&)#<-*'-,6%&'$%*$(2,3%<-/#%2.%&'$%-,*),-&>%3$.$,($%-*%(2,&12+$1*-)<7%C'$%IS%(291&*:%-.%.)($3%5-&'%&'$%/)&&$1:%/-6'&%&)4$%)%3-..$1$,&%)0012)('%&2%&'$%;,6<-*'%(291&*7%C'$%1$<$+),($%2.%+2<9,&)1>%-,&2G-()&-2,%&2%&'$%01$*$,($%2.%&")-+9"%%-*%(911$,&<>%&1$)&$3%3-..$1$,&<>%-,%&'$*$%N91-*3-(&-2,*J%*$$%T')0&$1%C'1$$%.,%L!7%E%.9<<%3-*(9**-2,%2.%&'-*%-**9$%-*%#$>2,3%&'$%*(20$%2.%&'-*%0)0$17

HHL7+8+6#0)":%)#2+$%,%UV:%WQ"UX7HHK7+8+50)#%()":%)#2+$%,%QU!:+WKUX7HHP@#-37

Page 44: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !"

#$%&%'()*+,*$-(* .#/,* $0*)($(/1%2(*$-(*3456*%27#%/,899:* ;0<(=(/>*$-%'*?@220$*+(*?0//(?$*@'* $-%'*

<0#&)*/(7#%/(*$-(*.#/,*$0*+@&@2?(*?01A($%2B*A0&%?,*C@?$0/'8*5-(*.#/,*@/(*C@?$*C%2)(/'>*20$*A0&%?,*

@2@&,'$'8*D2*@AA&,%2B*$-(*-0&%'$%?*@AA/0@?-*%$*%'*C0/*$-(*.#)B(*$0*<(%B-*$-(*A0&%?,*?02?(/2'8*D2*?@'('*

<-(/(*$-(/(*%'*?01A($%2B*(=%)(2?(*@'*$0*$-(*@??#'()E'*1(2$@&*'$@$(>*$-(*.#)B(*<%&&*2(()*$0*(2B@B(*%2*@*

?0#2$(/FC@?$#@& * %27#%/,8 *5-(*.#)B(*'-0#&)*?02'%)(/*-0<*$-(*A0&%?,*C@?$0/' *<0#&)*+(*+@&@2?()*%C*

@??0#2$*G*0C*$-(*@??#'()E'*1(2$@&*'$@$(*<(/(*@??(A$()*+,*$-(*.#/,8*;(*'-0#&)*@&'0*?02'%)(/*$-(*

+@&@2?(*'$/#?H*%C*@??0#2$*I*<(/(*@??(A$()>*@2)*'0*C0/$-8*;@=%2B*)($(/1%2()*$-%'>*$-(*.#)B(*1@,*$-(2*

%2'$/#?$*$-(*.#/,*$-@$*@*C%2)%2B*0C*G*<%&&*&(@)*$0*=(/)%?$*J>*<-(/(@'*@*C%2)%2B*0C*I*<%&&*&(@)*$0*=(/)%?$*

K8*L0/*(M@1A&(>*@*.#)B(*1@,*)($(/1%2(*$-@$*$-(*<-0&(*3456*%27#%/,*<%&&*$#/2*02*<-($-(/*$-(*

)%'0/)(/*-@)*@2*%2$(/2@&*?@#'(8*5-(/(C0/(>*$-(*.#)B(*#'%2B*'#%$@+&(*&@2B#@B(*<0#&)*%2'$/#?$*$-(*.#/,*

$0*@AA&,*$-(*?02$(M$#@&*0+.(?$%=(*@AA/0@?-*$0*)($(/1%2(*<-($-(/*$-(*?@#'(*<@'*%2$(/2@&*0/*(M$(/2@&8*

;(*<0#&)*C#/$-(/*%2'$/#?$*$-@$*C%2)%2B*@2*%2$(/2@&*?@#'(*(2$@%&'*C%2)%2B*@*3456>*<-(/(@'*C%2)%2B*@2*

(M$(/2@&*?@#'(*<%&&*1(@2*/(.(?$%2B*$-(*%2'@2%$,*)(C(2?(8

5-%' * )%=%'%02 * 0C * &@+0#/ * <0#&) * /(2)(/ * %1A0$(2$ * 02( * 0C * $-( * 0+.(?$%02' * $0 * $-( * -0&%'$%?*

@AA/0@?-8*5-%'*0+.(?$%02*'$@$('*$-@$*$-(*A0&%?,*?01A02(2$*0C*$-(*@AA/0@?-*1(@2'*$-@$*.#)%?%@&*@2)*

1()%?@&*?02?(A$%02'*0C*3456*?@2*+(*'%B2%C%?@2$&,*)%CC(/(2$8*5-%'*%'*A/0+&(1@$%?>*@'*%$*1@,*?02C#'(*

$-(* .#/,899N* ;0<(=(/>*20*?02C#'%02*?@2*@/%'(* %C*$-(*.#)B(*)%/(?$'*$-(*.#/,* $0*$-(*/(&(=@2$*C@?$#@&*

%27#%/%('*@2)*%2'$/#?$'*$-(1*@'*$0*$-(*&(B@&*?02'(7#(2?('*0C*$-(%/*C@?$#@&*C%2)%2B'8*DC*$-('(*/0&('*@/(*

@)-(/()*$0>*$-(*?02C&@$%02*0C*1()%?@&*@2)*&(B@&*?02?(A$%02'*0C*3456*'-0#&)*20$*0??#/8

O8O** ********* P/%$%?@&*@''(''1(2$*0C*$-(*-0&%'$%?*@AA/0@?-**

P/%$%?%'1*0C*$-(*-0&%'$%?*@AA/0@?-*'($*0#$*%2 *5#0)" +-@'*$@H(2*$<0*H(,*C0/1'Q*$-(*@AA/0@?-*

1@H('*%$*$00*)%CC%?#&$*$0*('$@+&%'-*@*)(C(2?(*0C*'@2(*@#$01@$%'1>99R*@2)*$-(*?02'%)(/@$%02*0C*=@B#(*

99:6+7+80)#%()">*@+0=(*2*S:T>+UNVW*X*UNNW899NY@?%0??0>*@+0=(*2*9""899RD+%)Z*[&(2*\#$-(/*@2)*6@2'C%(&)*6(&@*]5-(*50A*5(2*D''#('*%2*\@<*@2)*Y',?-%@$/,^*_9""V`*VR*aJab\c(=*!"S*@$*!9S8

Page 45: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !"

#$%&'()*+',$-.)$/*0.'+,1.),21),1-3)456789:;)<1&,21-)$*),21.1)$/=1',&$>.)+-1)#1-.0+.&?18

621)*&-.,)$/=1',&$>),$)5#0)"+30.,)/1)+..1..1@)&>)%&A2,)$*)'-&,&'&.3.),2+,)3+()/1)3+@1)$*)$,21-)

+.#1',.)$*),21)@1'&.&$>8)621)3+=$-&,()&>)5#0)"++%,1-1@),21)1?&@1>,&+%)+>@)#1-.0+.&?1)/0-@1>.)&>)'+.1.)

$*).+>1)+0,$3+,&.3B)+.)C1%%)+.)*$-30%+,&>A),21)2$%&.,&')+##-$+'28)D,)&.),21)'$3/&>+,&$>)$*),21.1)

'2+>A1.),2+,)-1.,-&',.),21)+?+&%+/&%&,()$*).+>1)+0,$3+,&.38)D)+A-11),2+,),21)+##-$+'2),+E1>)/(),21)

3+=$-&,(),$)/0-@1>.)$*)#-$$*)&.)0>@1.&-+/%18)F$C1?1-B)D)@$)>$,)+A-11),2+,),21)2$%&.,&')+##-$+'2)&,.1%*)

&.)#-$/%13+,&')&>)'+.1.)$*).+>1)+0,$3+,&.38

G$31)'-&,&'.)+-A01),2+,),21)2$%&.,&')+##-$+'2)#%+'1.)>031-$0.)20-@%1.)&>),21)C+()$*)+).+>1)

+0,$3+,&.3)@1*1>'1B)+>@)&.),21-1*$-1)$?1-%()-1.,-&',&?18)621()'$>,1>@),2+,)&>)$-@1-),$).0''11@),21)

+''0.1@)30.,).2$C)/$,2),2+,),21&-)@&.$-@1-)C+.)'+0.1@)/()+>)1H,1->+%)*+',$-B)+>@),2+,)&,)&.)0>%&E1%()

,$)-1'0-89:")I&,2)-1.#1',B),2&.)+-A031>,)3&.-1#-1.1>,.),21)2$%&.,&')+##-$+'28)621)3+=$-&,()&> )5#0)" +

1H#-1..%()+'E>$C%1@A1@),2+,)J&>)+>()A&?1)'+.1B)+),-&+%)=0@A1)3+()*&>@)$>1B),21)$,21-)$-)/$,2)$*)K,21)

&>,1->+%)'+0.1)+>@)-1'0--&>A)@+>A1-L)+##-$+'21.)$*)+..&.,+>'18M9:9)621-1*$-1B),21)=0@A1)@$1.)>$,)2+?1)

+)'21'E%&.,),21)+''0.1@)30.,).+,&.*(8 )621)+##%&'+/&%&,()$*),21)&>,1->+%)'+0.1)+>@)-1'0--&>A)@+>A1-)

*+',$-.)&.)'$>,1H,)@1#1>@1>,8

5,21- )'-&,&'. )+-A01) ,2+, ) ,21 )2$%&.,&' )+##-$+'2) &%%1A&,&3+,1%( ) %&3&,. )+?+&%+/&%&,( )$* ) ,21 ).+>1)

+0,$3+,&.3)@1*1>'1)/()$?1-N13#2+.&.&>A)#0/%&')#-$,1',&$>89::)F$C1?1-B),2&.)'-&,&'&.3)&.)%1?1%1@)+,)

,21)C1&A2,)+,,+'21@),$)$>1)*+',$-)'$>.&@1-1@)&>),21)+##-$+'28)D,)&.)>$,)+)'-&,&'&.3)$*),21)2$%&.,&')

+##-$+'2)'"6+-"8)O)=0@A1)3+()*+%%)&>,$)1--$-)&>)+,,+'2&>A)C1&A2,),$)+>()A&?1>)*+',$-8)F$C1?1-B),2&.)

@$1.)>$,)-1>@1-),21)$?1-+%%)+>+%(,&'+%)*-+31C$-E)0.1%1..8

621).1'$>@)A1>1-+%)$/=1',&$>),$),21)2$%&.,&')+##-$+'2B),2+,)&,)$/*0.'+,1.),21)31+>&>A)$*)

4567)/()&>,-$@0'&>A)#$%&'()*+',$-.B)&.)+%.$)&%%N*$0>@1@8)621)'$>.&@1-+,&$>)$*)#$%&'()*+',$-.)&>),21)

4567)&>P0&-() &.)&>1?&,+/%18 )Q-1?&$0.)+##-$+'21.),$)4567)@&@)>$,)1H'%0@1)#$%&'()*+',$-.B)/0,)

9:;R0,21-)+>@)71%+B)+/$?1)>)99SB)!9"T)U1->+@1,,1)7'G21--()J7+8+5#0)"+K"SSSL)9)GVW)9S;X)V+.1)V$331>,+-(M)Y9;;;Z)[)Q.('2&+,-()Q.('2$%)\)R)9[S)+,)9]:T)^+31.)R&?&>A.,$>)+>@)G&3$>)_1-@0>N^$>1.)JG&@1/+-)Q.('2$%$A(X)4&.'0..&>A)+>@)V2+%%1>A&>A),21)41*1>'1)$*)Q.('2$%$A&'+%)U%$C)O0,$3+,&.3M)Y9;;9Z)![)V-&3)R`)[S)+,)S[8

9:"R0,21-)+>@)71%+B)+/$?1)>)99SB)!9"89:97+8+5#0)"B)+/$?1)>)[;B)K9":L89::Q+'&$''$B)+/$?1)>)9;;8

Page 46: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !"

#$%&'()*(++,-')*.,/*&0'#/*1,$%#)'/(&#,$*&,*2'*,2%13/')4*5,/*'6(78+'9*(*:3);'*(88+<#$;*&0'*#$&'/$(+*

1(3%'*&0',/<*1,3+)*7($#83+(&'*&0'*#$&'/$(+='6&'/$(+*)#10,&,7<*#$*,/)'/*&,*2/#$;*(2,3&*&0'*/'%3+&*0'*

1,$%#)'/')*&,*2'*1,$%#%&'$&*-#&0*8,+#1<4*>0'*0,+#%&#1*(88/,(10*0(%*&0'*2'$'.#&*,.*7(?#$;*'68+#1#&*&0'*

'6'/1#%'*,.*)#%1/'&#,$*($)*1,$%#)'/(&#,$*,.*8,+#1<*#$0'/'$&*#$*&0'*@A>B*#$C3#/<4*>0#%*#%*)'%#/(2+'9*

(%*#&*8(D'%*&0'*-(<*.,/*(*2,)<*,.*1(%'*+(-*())/'%%#$;*1,78'&#$;*8,+#1<*1,$1'/$%*($)*&0'*2(+($1'*&,*

2' * %&/31? *2'&-''$* &0'74 *>0#% *-#++ *8/,D#)' * .,/ *;/'(&'/ *1+(/#&< * &0($ * &0' *8/'D#,3% *(88/,(10'% * &,*

@A>B9*-0#10*&3/$')*,$*&(3&,+,;#'%*($)*8/,2+'7(&#1*)#%&#$1&#,$%4

E$*1,$&/(%&9*&0'*0,+#%&#1*(88/,(10*0(%*2''$*0(#+')*2<*,&0'/*1,77'$&(&,/%*(%*(*8/(;7(&#1*

7'&0,)*.,/*)'&'/7#$#$;*&0'*@A>B*#$C3#/<4"F!* E&*0(%*8/,D'$*#78,%%#2+'*&,*+(<*),-$*(*1(&';,/#1(+*

%&(&'7'$& *,. *-0(& *-#++ * 1,$%&#&3&' *( *@A>B4 *G*73+&#H.(1&,/#(+ * (88/,(10*8/,D#)'% * .,/ * &0' *7310*

$'')')*.+'6#2#+#&<*#$*)'&'/7#$#$;*&0#%*#$C3#/<9"FI*-0#+'*(+%,*,..'/#$;*($*($(+<&#1(+*./(7'-,/?4*53/&0'/9*

#&*'$1,3/(;'%*:3)#1#(+*,8'$$'%%4*>0#%*'$(2+'%*;/'(&'/*1+(/#&<9*($)*(#)%*832+#1*3$)'/%&($)#$;*,.*&0'*

:3)#1#(+*(88/,(10*&,*@A>B4**E*:,#$*-#&0*&0'*1,77'$&(&,/%*-0,*.(D,3/*&0'*0,+#%&#1*(88/,(109*($)*

1,$&'$)*&0(&*#&*%0,3+)*2'*(),8&')*#$*J'-*K'(+($)4*>0'*(88/,(10*0(%*(+/'()<*2''$*(88+#')*,$1'9*2<*

L($;*M * #$*&0'*J'-*K'(+($)*N#;0*O,3/&4"FP* E&% *-0,+'%(+'*(),8&#,$*-,3+)*8/,D#)'*7310*$'')')*

;3#)($1'*#$*&0#%*QC3(;7#/'*,.*+(-R4"FS

>0' * 0,+#%&#1 * (88/,(10 * -(% * .,/73+(&') * .,/ * (88+#1(&#,$ * #$ * Q1(%'% * #$D,+D#$; * 1+(#7% * ,.*

(3&,7(&#%74R"FT*J'D'/&0'+'%%9*E*1,$&'$)*#&*%0,3+)*2'*(88+#')*&,*(++*1(%'%*-0'/'*&0'*8/'%'$1'*,.*(*

@A>B*#%*(&*#%%3'4*>0'*(88/,(10*#%*%3..#1#'$&+<*.+'6#2+'*&,*(11,3$&*.,/*1,$&'6&3(+*D(/#(&#,$4*U#7#+(/*

8,+#1<*1,$%#)'/(&#,$%*(/'*/(#%')*#$*1(%'%*-0'/'*#$%($#&<*#%*8+'()')9*(%*#$*(3&,7(&#%7*1(%'%4*>0'%'*

8,+#1<*.(1&,/%*-#++*%#78+<*1(//<*)#..'/#$;*-'#;0&9*)'8'$)#$;*38,$*&0'*1,$&'6&4

"F!V*B(1?(<*($)*W*B#&10'++*QU+''8-(+?#$;9*G3&,7(&#%7*($)*E$%($#&<R*X"YYPZ*O/#7*LV*[Y\*(&*[YI]!U&($+'<*^',*QO+(/#.<#$;*G3&,7(&#%7R*_"YY"`*"I*E$&*M*,.*L(-*a%<10#(&/<*!!I*(&*!!I4

"FIB(1?(<*($)*B#&10'++9*(2,D'*$*"F!9*[YI4"FP5+6+7"-8"99*(2,D'*$*SY4"FS5+6+:;(/<9+(2,D'*$*P[9*[""4"FT5+6+=#0)"9*(2,D'*$*SY9*X\PFZ4

Page 47: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !"

#$%&& &&&&&&&&& '()*+,-.()&&

/01&0(+.-2.*&3445(3*0&51*(6).-1-&2032&201&78/9&.):,.5;&.)<(+<1-&=(20&>1?.*3+&3)?&4(+.*;&

*(>4()1)2-$&/01&>1?.*3+&1<.?1)*1&(@&1A4152-&32&25.3+&.-&*5,*.3+$&B(C1<15D&.2&.-&201&E,?61&C0(&C.++&

?1215>.)1&C012015&20.-&1<.?1)*1&*3)&-,44(52&3&78/9&@.)?.)6$&F)&>3G.)6&20.-&?1215>.)32.()&201&

E,?61&-0(,+?&*()-.?15&3)?&C1.60&3&),>=15&(@&4(+.*;&*()-.?1532.()-D&.)*+,?.)6&201&45(21*2.()&(@&201&

4,=+.*D&3)?&201&)11?&@(5&3)?&3445(45.321)1--&(@&25132>1)2$&/01&51*,55.)6&?3)615&@3*2(5&3)?&.)215)3+&

*3,-1& @3*2(5&>3;&3.?& .)&3--1--.)6&201-1&4(+.*;&*()*15)-$ &/01&(<1535*0.)6& .--,1&@(5& 201& E,?61& .-&

C012015&201&3**,-1?&-0(,+?&=1&-,=E1*21?&2(&201&.)-3).2;&?.-4(-.2.()&516.>1$&F@&()&()1&3**(,)2&(@&201&

3**,-1?H-&>1)23+&-2321&20.-&C(,+?&=1&3445(45.321D&201)&3&78/9&>3;&=1&@(,)?$&I**(5?.)6+;D&201&

1<.?1)*1&(@&201&3**,-1?H-&>1)23+&-2321&-0(,+?&=1&+1@2&2(&201&E,5;&@(5&?1215>.)32.()$

/01&0(+.-2.*&3445(3*0&45(<.?1-&3&*+135&3)3+;2.*3+ & @53>1C(5G&@(5&?1215>.).)6&201&78/9&

.):,.5;&.)&3++&*3-1-&C0151&201&.--,1&.-&53.-1?$&F)&201&)1A2&*034215&F&C.++&*()-.?15&.2-&344+.*32.()&2(&

45(=+1>32.*&*3-1-&.)<(+<.)6&>120&,-1&3)?&4-;*0(-.-$

Page 48: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !!

!"#$%&'()*+,(-$$./*01(%"&(23.*4%*5(-$$'3#5"(%3(!#4&4(36(

7&%"#8$"&%#8*0&9:&.#%&;(<4/5"34*4

"#$%&'()#*+(#(,,%)-'#*+./%#()#0%1+#2)-#'3,,%&.)4#$'56+('.'#025#&%13&)#1(#2)#(&-.)2&5#'121%#

(,#0.)-7#-%8%/($#2#&%63&&%)1#$'56+(1.6#-.'(&-%&7#(&#'3,,%&#.)1%&0.11%)1#,/2'+926:';#<+%'%#82&.21.()'#

+28% # .0$/.621.()' # ,(& # 1+% # 2$$/.621.() # (, # 1+% # +(/.'1.6 # 2$$&(26+7 # 2)- # 6()'%=3%)1/5 # ,(& # 1+%#

-%1%&0.)21.()#(,#1+%#>?<@#.)=3.&5;#A)#1+.'#6+2$1%&#A#*.//#(31/.)%#1+&%%#$&(9/%021.6#62'%'#.)8(/8.)4#

0%1+B.)1(C.621.() # 2)- # $'56+('.' #*+.6+ #025 # 6(0% # 9%,(&% # 1+% # 6(3&1'; # A #*.// # 2$$/5 # 1+% # +(/.'1.6#

2$$&(26+#1(#%26+7#&%26+.)4#2#6()6/3'.()#2'#1(#*+%1+%&#2#>?<@#(34+1#1(#9%#,(3)-;#A#*.//#2/'(#

+.4+/.4+1#6()1.)4%)6.%'#*+.6+#025#2/1%&#1+%#2$$/.621.()#(,#1+%#+(/.'1.6#2$$&(26+7#&%6(4).'.)4#1+21#1+.'#

2$$&(26+#.'#'%)'.1.8%#1(#62'%B95B62'%#82&.21.()';#

D;E## ######### <+&%%#$&(9/%021.6#62'%'##

F+%&%#2#$%&'()#+2'#'3,,%&%-#$'56+('.'#*+./%#.)1(C.621%-#95#0%1+7#1+.'#025#&%$&%'%)1#()%#(,#

1+&%%#-.,,%&%)1#'6%)2&.(';#<+%#,.&'1#'6%)2&.(7#2)-#1+%#0('1#6(00()7#.'#1+21#1+%#3'%&#.'#$'56+(1.6#

*+./%#0%1+#$%&'.'1'#.)#1+%.&#9(-5;#G(*%8%&7#$'56+('.'#6%2'%'#3$()#0%129(/.'0#(,#1+%#-&34#2)-#*.//#

)(1#&%63&#*.1+(31#-&34#3'%; #H%)%&2//57 #2#+.4+#-('%#(,#0%1+#*.// #9%#&%=3.&%-#1(# .)-36%#2)(1+%&#

$'56+(1.6#%$.'(-%;#I''%)1.2//57#1+%#3'%&#.'#$'56+(1.6#()/5#*+./%#.)1(C.621%-;##

<+%#'%6()-#'6%)2&.( # .' # 1+21 # 1+%#3'%& #'3,,%&' #$'56+('.' #-3&.)4# .)1(C.621.()7 #*+.6+#6%2'%'#

*+%)#1+%#-&34#6/%2&'# 1+%.&#9(-5; #G(*%8%&7#2/1+(34+#1+%#3'%& #&%13&)'#1(#2#)(&02/#0%)12/ #'121%7#

$'56+('.'#62)#&%2-./5#9%#1&.44%&%-#1+%&%2,1%&#95#/(*#-('%'#(,#0%1+7#(&#95#6%&12.)#'1&%'',3/#'.1321.()';#

<+%#3'%&#.'#$'56+(1.6#*+./%#.)1(C.621%-#2)-#2/'(#$&()%#1(#J,/2'+926:'K;

<+%#,.)2/#'6%)2&.(#.'#1+21#1+%#3'%&#.'#$'56+(1.6#-3&.)4#0%1+#3'%7#2)-#1+.'#$'56+('.'#6()1.)3%'#

%8%)#*+%)#1+%#3'%&#29'12.)'#,&(0#1+%#-&34;#<+%5#025#9%#-.24)('%-#*.1+#'6+.L($+&%).27#(&#*.1+#

'(0%#,(&0#(,#$&(1&261%-#-&34B.)-36%-#$'56+('.'; #<+%#3'%& # .' #$'56+(1.6#-3&.)4# .)1(C.621.()#2)-#

Page 49: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !"

#$%&'($)$*#+,$)$-$.

/)-')0*+1&'*(2*-'+$+*3,(14*&1-+5(,)+$*-'+,+*1,+*$63-7+*81,)1-)(0$*9')&'*:1%*3+1,*(0*-'+*

;<=>*)0?6),%.*@+8+,-'+7+$$A*1##7%)05*-'+*'(7)$-)&*1##,(1&'*-(*-'+$+*5+0+,17)$+4*&1-+5(,)+$*9)77*'+7#*

4+-+,:)0+*-'+*#,(#+,*(6-&(:+*(2*-'+*;<=>*)0?6),%*)0*&1$+$*)08(78)05*:+-'*6$+*104*#$%&'($)$.

B0*+1&'*&1$+*B*9)77*&(0$)4+,*9'1-*:1%*3+*,+?6),+4*)0*-'+*)0-+,+$-$*(2*#637)&*#,(-+&-)(0A*104*

9'+-'+,*-,+1-:+0-*)$*0++4+4*104*1##,(#,)1-+.*B*9)77*6-)7)$+*-'+*,+&6,,)05*4105+,*104*)0-+,017*&16$+*

21&-(,$*-(*1)4*-'+$+*)0?6),)+$A*9'+,+*1##,(#,)1-+.*C)0177%A*B*9)77*:1D+*1*5+0+,17*,+&(::+041-)(0*1$*-(*

9'+-'+,*1*;<=>*$'(674*3+*2(604.*>%*1$$+$$:+0-$*9)77*#,(&++4*(0*-'+*31$)$*-'1-*)0$10)-%*)$*3+)05*

#7+14+4A*0(-*)0$10+E16-(:1-)$:.*=')$*)$*3+&16$+*:+-'*9)77*8+,%*,1,+7%*)046&+*10*16-(:1-)&*$-1-+.

F.G** ********* H##7)&1-)(0*-(*&1$+*(0+I*#$%&'(-)&*(07%*9')7+*)0-(J)&1-+4**

B0 * (,4+, * -( * 1$$+$$ *9'1- *:1% * 3+ * ,+?6),+4 * -( * $12+561,4 * #637)& * #,(-+&-)(0A * 104 *9'+-'+,*

-,+1-:+0-*)$*,+?6),+4A**3(-'*-'+*,+&6,,)05*4105+,*104*)0-+,017*&16$+*21&-(,$*:1%*3+*(2*6$+.*

H##7%)05*-'+*,+&6,,)05*4105+,*21&-(,A*)-*9)77*3+*,+7+810-*-(*&(0$)4+,*3(-'*-'+*7)D+7)'((4*-'1-*

-'+*-,)55+,*(2*#$%&'($)$*K).+.A*:+-'*6$+L*9)77*,+&6,A*104*-'+*#,+8)(6$*:+0-17*'+17-'*')$-(,%*(2*-'+*

1&&6$+4.*<38)(6$7%A*3(-'*9)77*81,%*2,(:*&1$+*-(*&1$+.*M(9+8+,A*B*9)77*1$$6:+*-'1-*-'+*1&&6$+4*'1$*

0(*#,)(,*')$-(,%*(2*#$%&'(-)&*4)$(,4+,$.GNO*=')$*9)77*#,(3137%*3+*-%#)&17*(2*-'($+*2177)05*)0-(*&1$+*(0+A*

1$*6$+,$*9)-'*1*#,)(,*')$-(,%*(2*#$%&'($)$*9)77*5+0+,177%*-,)55+,*1*7(05E-+,:*4)$(,4+,*1$*#+,*&1$+*-',++.*

B*9)77*17$(*1$$6:+*-'1-*-'+,+*)$*1*7)D+7)'((4*(2*(05()05*4,65*6$+A*1$*#$%&'($)$*)$*:(,+*&(::(07%*

+J#+,)+0&+4*1:(05$-*2,+?6+0-*6$+,$.*P+1,)05*-'+$+*1$$6:#-)(0$*)0*:)04A*)-*)$*7)D+7%*#$%&'($)$*9)77*

,+&6,* )2 * -'+*1&&6$+4*'1$ *1&&+$$ * -(*:+-'. *='+,+2(,+A * -( *#,(-+&- * -'+*#637)& * -'+*1&&6$+4*:6$- *3+*

#,+8+0-+4*2,(:*6$)05*:+-'.*=')$*&(674*(&&6,*3%*#71&)05*-'+*1&&6$+4*)0*1*$+&6,+*+08),(0:+0-A*+)-'+,*

#,)$(0*(,*1*'($#)-17.*B2*-'+*1&&6$+4*)$*1*4,65*144)&-A*#637)&*#,(-+&-)(0*)0*-'+*7(05*-+,:*&(674*3+*

$+&6,+4*3%* -,+1-)05*-')$ *144)&-)(0. *H44)&-)(0* -,+1-:+0-*&(674*3+*:14+*181)7137+* )0*#,)$(0*(,* )0*

GNOH*#,)(,*')$-(,%*(2*10(-'+,*:+0-17*4)$(,4+,A*$6&'*1$*4+#,+$$)(0A*:1%*3+*(2*$(:+*,+7+810&+.*C(,*+J1:#7+A*(05()05*4+#,+$$)(0*:1%*:1D+*)-*:(,+*7)D+7%*2(,*-'+*1&&6$+4*-(*&(0-)06+*6$)05*4,65$.*M(9+8+,A*:+0-17*4)$(,4+,$*0(-*)08(78)05*#$%&'($)$*9)77*0(-*3+1,*4),+&-7%*(0*-'+*7)D+7)'((4*(2*,+&6,,+0&+.

Page 50: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !"

#$%&'()*+,!-

.&&*/'012(#32'0(340)*25)6%327)5($42 '02(#'%25)%32'%2&4$8*39)('5:2835)6%3293(#2'%2;0$<02($2

'0(34)5(2<'(#260=34*/'012930()*2>6*034)8'*'('3%2'026%34%2($284'012)8$6(2930()*2='%$4=34+2?#3437$43:2($2

'=30('7/2(#3243*3>)0(25)6%32$72&%/5#$%'%:2(#32$8@35('>325$0(3A(6)*2)&&4$)5#2%#$6*=28326('*'%3=+2B(2'%2

0353%%)4/ 2 ($ 2 5$0%'=34 2<#3(#34 2 )0 2$4='0)4/ 2 &34%$0 26%'01 293(# 2<$6*= 2 %67734 2 (#'% 2 &%/5#$%'%: 2 $42

<#3(#342&%/5#$%'%2#)%2)4'%302835)6%32$72%$932'0(340)*2>6*034)8'*'(/2$72(#32)556%3=+2.4$60=2)2C6)4(342

$72743C630(293(#26%34%2<'**23A&34'30532&%/5#$%'%+2D#'*32(#'%2<'**29$4325$99$0*/28323A&34'3053=2

)9$01%(2(#$%32<'(#2)2&43='%&$%'('$02($2&%/5#$%'%:2&%/5#$%'%2)*%$2$5564%2)(2)2#'1#24)(32'02&43>'$6%*/2

#3)*(#/26%34%+2.%2'(2'%2C6'(32&$%%'8*32(#)(2)2#3)*(#/2&34%$025$6*=2%677342&%/5#$%'%:2)416)8*/2)02'0(340)*2

5)6%3 2 $61#( 2 0$( 2 83 2 )%%693=+ 2 E$0>34%3*/: 2 835)6%3 2 (#3 29)@$4'(/ 2 $7 293(# 2 6%34% 2 =$ 2 0$( 2 %677342

&%/5#$%'%: 2 '( 2 '% 2 )416)8*3 2 (#)( 2 )0 2$4='0)4/ 2 &34%$0 2<$6*= 20$( 2 835$93 2&%/5#$('5 2 )0= 2 (#)( 2 %$932

<3);03%%2'0(340)*2($2(#32)556%3=2%#$6*=2832'073443=2'72&%/5#$%'%2#)%2$556443=+2F$<3>34:23>302'72)02

'0(340)* 25)6%3 2 '% 2 '073443=: 2 '( 2 '% 260*';3*/ 2 (#)( 2 (#'% 2<$6*= 2832 (43)(3=2)% 2 (#3 2&43=$9'0)0( 25)6%3 2$72

&%/5#$%'%+2?#3437$43:2'(25)028325$05*6=3=2(#32%$*3:2$42)(2*3)%(2(#32&43=$9'0)0(25)6%32$72&%/5#$%'%2'%2

3A(340)* 2 ($2 (#32)556%3=+ 2B( 2 '% 260*';3*/ 2&%/5#$%'% 2<'** 2 435642 '0=3&30=30(*/ 2$72 (#'%23A(340)* 2 7)5($4+2

G68*'52&4$(35('$02%'9&*/2=39)0=%23A5*6%'$02$72(#32)556%3=274$92=46126%3+

E$0%'=34'012(#32033=27$42)0=2)&&4$&4')(303%%2$72(43)(930(:2'(2#)%2)*43)=/2833023%()8*'%#3=2

(#)(2(#32$0*/2$01$'012='%$4=342(#)(29)/243C6'432(43)(930(2'%2=4612)=='5('$0+2H'>302(#'%:2)02'0%)0'(/2

='%&$%'('$02%339%2'0)&&4$&4')(3+2B(2<$6*=2832#3)>/2#)0=3=2($2%30=2)02)556%3=2($2)2#$%&'()*27$42(#32

54'9'0)**/2'0%)032'02$4=342($2(43)(2)02)=='5('$0+2?#32$(#342)*(340)('>327$**$<'012)02'0%)0'(/27'0='012

<$6*=2832($25$99'(2(#32)556%3=2)%2)25'>'*2&)('30(+2F$<3>34:2(#'%2<$6*=20$(2&349'(2(#32)556%3=2($2832

=3()'03=2($24353'>32(43)(930(27$42)=='5('$0+,!I2B025$0(4)%(:2=64'012=3(30('$02'02&4'%$02(43)(930(27$42

=4612)=='5('$029)/2832)=9'0'%(343=+,!,2?#3437$43:2)0/2033=27$42(43)(930(25$6*=28329$%(2)=3C6)(3*/2

,!-J332K3&)4(930(2$72E$4435('$0%2L.006)*2M3&$4(N2I2O6*/2,--PQR-2O6032,--ST2U,--SV2K3&)4(930(2$72E$4435('$0%2<<<+5$4435('$0%+1$>(+0W2U)553%%3=2$02IX2J3&(398342,--XV2)(2IRIQIR,2)0=2IY!QI"-+

,!IJ332Z30()*2F3)*(#2UE$9&6*%$4/2.%%3%%930(2)0=2?43)(930(V2.5(2IXX,+,!,B(2'%20$(3=2(#)(2)2&4'%$03425)00$(2832$4=343=2($2)((30=2=4612)0=2)*5$#$*2(43)(930(:286(29)/2)((30=2&4$14)993%29)=32)>)'*)8*32'02&4'%$02$02)2>$*60()4/28)%'%+2F$<3>34:2(#32'0)8'*'(/2($2$4=342)=='5('$02(43)(930(2'%20$(2&4$8*39)('5+2Z$%(2(43)(930(%2)432$0*/237735('>32<#302(#32&34%$02<'**'01*/2301)13%2(#32(43)(930(+2?#3437$43:2'725$64(2$4=343=2(43)(930(2

Page 51: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !"

#$%&'())(*+,-&.(,/+.%+(,0

1$+-2+,-&%2$3$&4()+.5&'6.%(73&%(-$%2$78&6&9:;<&32(=)>&,(%&?$&'(=,>0&@=?)+.&47(%$.%+(,&.6,&

?$&3$.=7$>&6>$A=6%$)5&+'&%2$&6..=3$>&+3&.(,/+.%$>8&633=#+,-&6&3$,%$,.$&('&+#47+3(,#$,%&('&#(7$&

%26,&,$-)+-+?)$&)$,-%2&+3&+#4(3$>0&;2$&,$$>&'(7&%7$6%#$,%&.6,&?$&#$%&/+6&47(-76##$3&>$)+/$7$>&+,&

47+3(,0&B2(=)>&435.2(3+3&=,$C4$.%$>)5&7$.=78&%2$7$&+3&%2$&4(33+?+)+%5&('&%76,3'$7&+,%(&6&#$,%6)&2$6)%2&

2(34+%6)0 & D, &.(,%763%8 & %2$& +,36,+%5 &>+34(3+%+(, & 7$-+#$&*(=)>&?$& +))E3=+%$> & +, & %2$3$ &.+7.=#3%6,.$30&

D,>$'+,+%$&>$%$,%+(,&63&6&34$.+6)&46%+$,%&+3&,(%&*6776,%$>&6,>&.+/+)&.(##+%#$,%&*(=)>&,(%&3=''+.$0

F0G&& &&&&&&&&& H44)+.6%+(,&%(&.63$&%*(I&47(,$&%(&J')632?6.K3L&&

;2+3&.63$&$33$,%+6))5&76+3$3&%2$&36#$&+33=$3&63&.63$&(,$8&*+%2&6&3+,-)$&/67+6%+(,I&435.2(3+3&.6,&

,(*&?$&%7+--$7$>&?5&)(*&>(3$3&('&#$%28&(7&?5&3%7$33'=)&3+%=6%+(,3&+,&6?3%+,$,%&+,>+/+>=6)30&D%&.6,&

6-6+,&?$&633=#$>&%26%&6&4$73(,&'6))+,-&+,%(&%2+3&.6%$-(75&*(=)>&?$&6&'7$A=$,%&=3$78&*+%2&,(&47+(7&

2+3%(75&('&435.2(%+.&>+3(7>$730

<(7$&#65&?$&7$A=+7$>&%(&3$.=7$&4=?)+.&36'$%5&+,&%2+3&.63$&%26,&+,&.63$&(,$0&;2+3&+3&?$.6=3$8&

.(,3+>$7+,-&%2$&7$.=77+,-&>6,-$7&'6.%(78&%2$&%7+--$7&*2+.2&.6=3$3&435.2(3+3&+3&,(*&#(7$&)+K$)5&%(&

(..=70&M(*$7&>(3$3&('&#$%2&*+))&3=''+.$&6,>8&+,&3(#$&+,3%6,.$38&3(&%((&*+))&7$)6%+/$)5&.(##(,&3(.+6)&

3%7$33(730 &D' &3(.+6)&3%7$33(73&6.%&63&6&%7+--$78&%2$,&$C.)=>+,-&%2$&6..=3$>&'7(#&#$%2&=3$&*+)) &,(%&

,$.$3367+)5&$,3=7$&4=?)+.&36'$%50&N=7%2$7#(7$8&.(,3+>$7+,-&%2$&+,%$7,6)&.6=3$&'6.%(78&+,&%2+3&.63$&+%&+3&

.)$67&%26%&3(#$&+,%$7,6)&/=),$76?+)+%5&('&%2$&6..=3$>&+3&6&3+-,+'+.6,%&.6=3$&('&435.2(3+30&H,&(7>+,675&

4$73(,&*2(&%((K&6&)(*&>(3$&('&#$%28&(7&*63&$C4(3$>&%(&6&.(##(,&3(.+6)&3%7$33(78&*(=)>&,(%&$,%$7&

6&435.2(%+.&3%6%$0&;2$&47$3$,.$&('&6&3+-,+'+.6,%&+,%$7,6)&.6=3$&7$+,'(7.$3&%2$&)+K$)+2((>&('&7$.=77$,.$&

6,>&%2$&,$$>&'(7&3%$43&%(&?$&%6K$,&%(&3$.=7$&4=?)+.&47(%$.%+(,0&;2$7$'(7$8&3(#$&'(7#&('&>$%$,%+(,&+3&

7$A=+7$>8&*2$%2$7&%26%&?$&+,&6&47+3(,&(7&6&2(34+%6)0

;2$&+,%$7,6)&.6=3$&('&')632?6.K3&6)3(&3=--$3%3&%2$7$&+3&6&,$$>&'(7&%7$6%#$,%0&D,&'6.%8&435.2(%+.&

')632?6.K3 &.6,&?$ &$''$.%+/$)5 &47$/$,%$>&(78 & +' & %2$5 &26/$&(..=77$>8 & 7$3()/$>&=3+,- &6,%+E435.2(%+.&

*$7$&6/6+)6?)$&+%&*(=)>&)+K$)5&?$&+,$''$.%+/$I&3$$&1+))+6#38&6?(/$&,&!G8&!FF0

Page 52: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !"

#$%&'()&*+,-.*/$0$12-&+-)3$4$-'(4$4-)3$-(''54$%-/&66-7$-*8-4*5+%-#&+%-$9'$:)-/3$+-$9:$1&$+'&+;-

86(437('<4,-=3$1$8*1$2-&+-7$)/$$+-86(437('<4-)3$1$-&4-+*-+$$%-8*1-3*4:&)(6-)1$()#$+),-=3&4-45;;$4)4-

)3()-(-4:$'&(6-:()&$+)-*1%$1-#(>-7$-&+(::1*:1&()$2-(4-)3&4-/*56%-6$(%-)*-(-:$14*+-/3*-/(4-*8)$+-&+-

4*5+%-#&+%-7$&+;-%$)(&+$%-&+-(-#$+)(6-3*4:&)(6,-?*+0$14$6>2-'&0&6-'*##&)#$+)-/*56%-7$-5+6&<$6>-)*-

4588&'$-&+-)3$4$-'&1'5#4)(+'$4,-@3&6$-)3$-(''54$%-'*56%-7$-%$)(&+$%-/3&6$-:4>'3*)&'2-)3$1$-/*56%-7$-

6&#&)$% -:*/$1 - )* -%$)(&+ -3&#-*)3$1/&4$, -A$0$1)3$6$442 - 4*#$ - 8*1#-*8 -*0$14&;3) -/3$+ -3$ - &4 -+*)-

:4>'3*)&'-#(>-7$-%$4&1(76$2- &+-*1%$1-)*-:1$0$+)-%(+;$1*54-86(437('<4-7>-$+451&+;-(+)&B:4>'3*)&'-

#$%&'()&*+-&4-)(<$+-(+%-#$)3-54$-&4-'51)(&6$%,-C$)$+)&*+-&+-:1&4*+-/*56%-$+(76$-(''$44-)*-(%%&')&*+-

)1$()#$+)-(+%-#*+&)*1&+;-*8-#$%&'()&*+-54$,-D8-)3$-(''54$%-7$'(#$-:4>'3*)&'-/3&6$-&+-:1&4*+2-3$-

'*56%-7$-)1(+48$11$%-)*-(-3*4:&)(6,-E-3>71&%-*1%$1-#(>-7$-:(1)&'56(16>-(::1*:1&()$-&+-45'3-'(4$42-

$+(76&+;-)1(+48$1-)*-7$-#*1$-1$(%&6>-$88$')$%-/3$+-+$'$44(1>,

=3$1$8*1$2 -'*+4&%$1&+;- )3$-:*6&'> - 8(')*14 -(+- &+4(+&)> -%&4:*4&)&*+ - &4 -+*) - 1$F5&1$%- &+- )3$4$-

'&1'5#4)(+'$4,-G576&'-4(8$)>-'(+-7$-#*4)-(%$F5()$6>-4$'51$%-)31*5;3-&#:1&4*+#$+),-=3$-)1$()#$+)-

1$F5&1$%-'(+-7$-4$'51$%-&+-:1&4*+2-*1-)31*5;3-)1(+48$1-)*-(+%-81*#-3*4:&)(6-&+-(''*1%(+'$-/&)3-(-

3>71&%-*1%$1,-C$)$+)&*+-(4-(-4:$'&(6-:()&$+)-8*66*/&+;-(+-&+4(+&)>-8&+%&+;-/*56%-7$-&+(::1*:1&()$2-

(+%-)1$()#$+)-(4-(-'&0&6-:()&$+)-/*56%-7$-&+(%$F5()$,-=3$1$8*1$2-(-CH=I-43*56%-+*)-7$-8*5+%,

J,!-- --------- E::6&'()&*+-)*-'(4$-)31$$K-6*+;B)$1#-:4>'3*)&'-%&4*1%$1--

=3$-8&+(6 -'(4$- &4 - )3() - &+-/3&'3-(-1$'511&+;-:4>'3*)&'-%&4*1%$1 -3(4- 8*66*/$%- &+)*9&'()&*+,-

D+%&0&%5(64 - 8(66&+; - /&)3&+ - )3&4 - '()$;*1> -/&66 - *8)$+ - 3(0$ - ( - :$14*+(6 - 3&4)*1> - *8 -#$+)(6 - %&4*1%$1-

&+0*60&+;-:4>'3*4&42-45'3-(4-4'3&L*:31$+&(,-I$)3-54$-&+-)3$4$-'(4$4-#(>-3(0$-$9('$17()$%-(-#$+)(6-

%&4*1%$1-)3()-/(4-(61$(%>-:1$4$+),-E6)$1+()&0$6>2-&+%&0&%5(64-#(>-3(0$-(-8(#&6>-3&4)*1>-*8-45'3-#$+)(6-

%&4*1%$142-(+%-#$)3-#(>-3(0$-)1&;;$1$%-(-056+$1(7&6&)>,-M&+(66>2-(-4#(66-:1*:*1)&*+-*8-&+%&0&%5(64-

/3*-%$0$6*:-(-6*+;-)$1#-#$+)(6-%&4*1%$1-/&66-3(0$-+*-:$14*+(6-*1-8(#&6>-3&4)*1>-*8-&66B3$(6)3,-D+-

)3$4$-'(4$42-#$)3-&4-)3$-*+6>-(::(1$+)-'(54$-*8-)3$-*+;*&+;-%&4*1%$1,-I*4)-&+%&0&%5(64-/3*-%$0$6*:-

Page 53: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !"

#$%&'()*+,-./$*-)*/,0*),1*)23)%(,3/)*/4

5$%/.-)*.%&,(6),%))-,($,/)73*),839#.7,8*$()7(.$%:,.%,0##,$1,(6),;0*.0(.$%/,$1,(6./,1.%0#,70/),

(6)*),./,#.<)#.6$$-,$1,*)73**)%7),=6.76,8$/)/,0,*./<,($,(6),7$++3%.(>4,?6./,*)73**)%7),$1,8/>76$/./,

=.##,$773*,);)%,=6)%,(6),.%-.;.-30#,./,09/(.%)%(:,0#(6$3&6,$%&$.%&,-*3&,3/),+0>,+0<),8/>76$(.7,

)8./$-)/ ,+$*) , 1*)23)%(4 ,?6)*)1$*): , /)73*.%& ,839#.7 , /01)(> ,=.## , *)23.*) ,+$*) , (60% , )@7#3-.%& , 0%,

0773/)-,1*$+,+)(6,3/)4,A%,70/)/,=6)*),(6)*),./,0,8*.$*,6./($*>,$*,0,10+.#>,6./($*>,$1,+)%(0#,.##%)//:,

(6),#.<)#.6$$-,$1,*)73**)%7),=.## ,9),+$*),*)0-.#>,0//)//)-4,B$=);)*:,.%, .%-.;.-30#/,$1,8*);.$3/#>,

&$$-,6)0#(6:,(6),13(3*),7$3*/),$1,(6),-./$*-)*,+0>,9),3%7)*(0.%4,A%,/$+),-$73+)%()-,70/)/:,+)(6'

.%-37)-,8/>76$/./,60/,8)*/./()-,1$*,$%),$*,(=$,>)0*/,0%-,(6)%,090()-4,C*3&,3/),+0>,(6)%,703/),.(,($,

*)73*4,A%,(6)/),70/)/:,(6),#.<)#.6$$-,$1,$%&$.%&,-*3&,3/),+0>,9),6.&6#>,*)#);0%(,($,0//)//.%&,(6),

-)&*)),$1,*./<,8$/)-,9>,(6),0773/)-4

D88#>.%& , (6) , .%()*%0# , 703/) , 107($* , .% , (6)/) , 70/)/ , 0#/$ , #)0-/ , ($ , 0 , 7$%7#3/.$% , (6)*) , ./ , 0,

#.<)#.6$$-,$1,*)73**)%7),0%-,0,%))-,($,8*$()7(,(6),839#.74,E6.#),+)(6,3/),./,0,703/),$1,(6),8/>76$/./:,

(6),8)*/./()%7),$1,8/>76$/./,9)>$%-,.%([email protected](.$%,.%-.70()/,/$+)(6.%&,.%()*%0#,($,(6),0773/)-,./,0(,

8#0>4,A(,+0>,9),.%1)**)-,(60(,(6./,.%()*%0#,107($*,./,(6),8*)-$+.%0%(,703/),$1,8/>76$/./:,0/,8/>76$/./,

7$%(.%3)/,.%,(6),09/)%7),$1,+)(6,3/)4

?6)*)1$*):,.%,0##,70/)/,$1,8)*/./(.%&,8/>76$/./,-)()%(.$%,./,.++)-.0()#>,%)7)//0*>,($,8*$()7(,

(6),839#.74,B$=);)*:, .%,70/)/,=6)*),(6)*),./,%$,8)*/$%0#,$*,10+.#>,6./($*>,$1,+)%(0#, .##%)//,(6),

-./$*-)*,+0>,*)/$#;),23.7<#>:,*)%-)*.%&,#$%&'()*+,(*)0(+)%(,3%%)7)//0*>4,F);)*(6)#)//:,(6)*),7$3#-,

9),0%,$%&$.%&,*./<,$1,*)73**)%7):,80*(.73#0*#>,=6)*),(6),.%-.;.-30#,./,#.<)#>,($,*)(3*%,($,-*3&,3/)4,A%,

(6)/),3%7)*(0.%,70/)/,0,/8)7.0#,80(.)%(,$*-)*,/))+/,.%088*$8*.0()4,A1,(6),.%-.;.-30#,./,-)(0.%)-,0/,0,

/8)7.0#,80(.)%(,0%-,(6).*,-./$*-)*,*)/$#;)/,(6)>,+0>,9),*)#)0/)-4,B$=);)*:,(6./,7$3#-,8$/),0,*./<,($,

(6),7$++3%.(>,.1,(6).*,-./$*-)*,#0()*,*)73*/,.%,(6),7$%()@(,$1,-*3&,3/)4,D,6>9*.-,$*-)*,+.&6(,.%/()0-,

9) ,088*$8*.0()4 ,G%-)* , (6./ ,$*-)* , (6) ,$11)%-)* ,=$3#- ,9) , /)%( , ($ ,6$/8.(0# , 1$##$=.%& , /)%()%7.%&4,

B$=);)*:,.1,6./,-./$*-)*,*)/$#;)/:,6),7$3#-,9),(*0%/1)**)-,907<,($,8*./$%,($,=0.(,$3(,(6),*)/(,$1,0,

Page 54: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !"

#$%&'()'*&+%*,(-&$-#.'/0*1$'*-'+%*,(-'0$'2(314'%$2$*5$'#%$6#&$-#')(%'644*2#*(-7'#0$%$89'&*#*:6#*-:'

#0$'%*,;'()')3#3%$'4%3:'3,$'263,*-:'6'%$23%%$-2$'()'#0$'4*,(%4$%.

<(-,*4$%*-:'#0$'-$$4')(%'#%$6#&$-#7'*-'26,$,'=0$%$'#0$%$'*,'6'+$%,(-61'(%')6&*19'0*,#(%9'()'

4*,(%4$% ' #0$%$ ' *, ' 1*;$19 ' #( '8$ ' 6- '(-:(*-: '-$$4 ' )(% ' #%$6#&$-# ' *- ' 6 '&$-#61 ' 0(,+*#61. '>0$%$)(%$7'

4$#$-#*(-'6, ' 6 ' ,+$2*61 '+6#*$-# ' *, ' 1*;$19 ' #( '8$ '6++%(+%*6#$. '>0$'-$$4' )(% '6-4 '6++%(+%*6#$-$,, '()'

#%$6#&$-# ' *, '&(%$'4*))*231# ' #( '6,,$,, '=0$%$' #0$' *-4*5*4361 '06, '-('+$%,(-61 '(% ' )6&*19 '0*,#(%9 '()'

4*,(%4$%. ' >0$ ' 2(3%,$ ' () ' #0$*% ' 23%%$-# ' +,920(#*2 ' 4*,(%4$% ' *, ' 1*;$19 ' #( ' 8$ ' 3-+%$4*2#681$. '/0*1$'

#%$6#&$-#'*-'6'&$4*261'0(,+*#61'*,'*&&$4*6#$19'%$?3*%$47'#0$'4*,(%4$%'&69'%$,(15$'*#,$1)'*-'6'9$6%'(%'

#=(.'@)',+$2*61'+6#*$-#',#6#3,'*,'*&+(,$4'6-4'#0$'4*,(%4$%'%$,(15$,7'83#'#0$'+6#*$-#'*,'-(#'%$1$6,$4'

8$263,$'()'2(-2$%-,'68(3#'%$23%%$-2$7'#0$'&$-#61'0$61#0'63#0(%*#*$,'&$%$19'+%(5*4$',$23%$'26%$.'>0*,'

,3::$,#,'#06#'6',+$2*61'+6#*$-#'(%4$%'=(314'-(#'8$'6++%(+%*6#$'*-'#0$,$'26,$,.'A'098%*4'(%4$%'=(314'

*-,#$64'$-681$'#0$'6223,$4'#('8$'#%6-,)$%%$4')%(&'0(,+*#61'#('+%*,(-'=0$-'#%$6#&$-#'*-'6'&$-#61'

0(,+*#61'*,'-('1(-:$%'-$2$,,6%9.

>0$%$)(%$7'*-'26,$,'=0$%$'+$%,*,#*-:'+,920(,*,'06,')(11(=$4'&$#0'3,$7'6'BC>D')*-4*-:'=*11'

1*;$19'8$'6++%(+%*6#$'*-'26,$,'=0$%$'#0$'6223,$4'06,'6'+$%,(-61'(%')6&*19'0*,#(%9'()'&$-#61'*11-$,,.'@-'

26,$,'=0$%$'-(',320'0*,#(%9'$E*,#,7'3-2$%#6*-#9',3%%(3-4*-:'#0$')3#3%$'2(3%,$'()'#0$'4*,(%4$%'&69'

&$6-'6'BC>D')*-4*-:' *, ' *-6++%(+%*6#$. '/0$#0$%' #0*, ' *, ' #0$'26,$'=*11 '31#*&6#$19 ' #3%-'3+(-'#0$'

$5*4$-2$'+%$,$-#$4'6#'#%*61.'@)'#0$'$E+$%#,'26-',69'=*#0',(&$'2$%#6*-#9'#06#'#0$'4*,(%4$%'*,'3-1*;$19'#('

686#$'*-'#0$'-$6%')3#3%$7'#0$-'6'BC>D')*-4*-:'&69'8$'6++%(+%*6#$.

F.!'' ''''''''' <(-213,*(-''

>0$ '0(1*,#*2 ' 6++%(620 '+%(5*4$, '6 '+%6:&6#*2 '&6--$% ' *- '=0*20 ' #( '4$#$%&*-$ ' #0$ 'BC>D'

*-?3*%9' *-'26,$,' *-5(15*-:'&$#0'3,$'6-4'+,920(,*,.'@-'26,$,'=0$%$'+,920(,*,'(-19'(223%,'43%*-:'

*-#(E*26#*(-7'6'BC>D'=*11'-(#'8$')(3-4.'G('#(('6'BC>D'*,'3-1*;$19'#('8$')(3-4'*-'26,$,'=0$%$'

&$#0'3,$'06,'263,$4'6-'*-4*5*4361'#('4$5$1(+'6'531-$%68*1*#97',320'#06#'+,920(,*,'*,'#%*::$%$4'89'1(='

Page 55: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !"

#$%&%'$(')&*+'$,'-.'%$/012'%*,&%%$,%3'45'/$5*,1%*6'7+&,&'15'$58$058'9%./+$*0/'#0%$,#&,'+1%'-&&5'

*,088&,&# ' $, ' &:1/&,-1*&# ' -. ')&*+ ' ;%&6 ' 1 '<=>?' (05#058 '7022 ' -& ' 20@&2.3 'A$7&B&,6 ' ;5/&,*105*.'

%;,,$;5#058 ' #0185$%0% ' 05 ' %$)& ' /1%&% ' $( ' $58$058 ' 9%./+$%0% ')1. ' *09 ' *+& ' -1215/& ' 05 ' (1B$;, ' $('

/$5B0/*0$5'15#'0)9$%0*0$5'$('1'+.-,0#'$,#&,3'>+&%&'$;*/$)&%'1//$,#'70*+'9$20/.'$-C&/*0B&%'15#'70*+'

/$))$5'%&5%&3 'D;,*+&,6 '*+&',&1%$5%'($,'*+&%&'$;*/$)&%'1,&' 210#'-1,&'#;,058'19920/1*0$5'$(' *+&'

+$20%*0/'199,$1/+3'>+0%'0%'*$'-&'/$5*,1%*&#'70*+'*+&'/$5(;%0$5'7+0/+'/$;2#'1,0%&'7+&5'*,.058'*$'1992.'

*+&'9,&B0$;%'199,$1/+&%'E%;/+'1%'*+&'05*&,512'/1;%&'*+&$,.F'*$'*+&%&'9,$-2&)1*0/'/1%&%3

Page 56: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !"

!"#$%&'()&*&+,(!-+./012-+

#$%&'(%)*+%,-%&./&0%1$&23%&4,&567&*,8&1$%&(%+*14.,3$4'&9%1:%%,&41&*,8&-(40%&0%*,&56&

-.2(13&:4++&-.,14,2%&1.&9%&/*-%8&:41$&.//%,8%(3&:$.&:%(%&0%1$;4,1.<4-*1%8&*1&1$%&140%&./&.//%,84,=>&

?2(1$%(0.(%7&=4)%,&1$%&$4=$&(*1%3&./&'3@-$.343&%<'%(4%,-%8&9@&0%1$&23%(37&*&34=,4/4-*,1&'(.'.(14.,&

./&1$%3%&.//%,8%(3&:4++&$*)%&9%%,&'3@-$.14-&*1&1$%&140%&./&.//%,84,=>&#$%&*''+4-*14.,&./&1$%&4,3*,41@&

8%/%,-%&4,&1$%3%&-*3%3& 43&*& +4)%& 4332%>&A.:%)%(7&:$%1$%(&0%1$;(%+*1%8&'3@-$.343&-*,&B2*+4/@&*3&*&

CD#E&/.(&1$43&'2('.3%&43&2,-+%*(>&#$43&2,-%(1*4,1@&43&'(.9+%0*14-7&*3&8%1%(04,*14.,&./&1$%&CD#E&

4,B24(@&$*3&34=,4/4-*,1&40'+4-*14.,3&/.(&*,&.//%,8%(F3&/*1%G&41&0*@&8%1%(04,%&1$%&*''+4-*14.,&./&1$%&+*:&

./&4,1.<4-*14.,7&*21.0*1430&*,8&4,3*,41@7&1$%&)%(84-13&%,1%(%87&*,8&1$%&843'.3414.,&.(&3%,1%,-4,=&./&

1$%&.//%,8%(>&#$43&43&:$@&1$43&'*'%(&$*3&/.-23%8&.,&1$%&-(414-*+&+%=*+&1%(0&CD#E>

#$% & -2((%,1 & H284-4*+ & *''(.*-$ & 1. &CD#E& 43 & 2,3*143/*-1.(@> &C%/4,414.,3 & ./ & 41 & *(% & ./1%,&

1*21.+.=.23&*,8&H284-4*+&1$%.(4%3&:$4-$&1(@&1.&/4<&413&9.2,8*(4%37&32-$&*3&1$%&(%-2((4,=&8*,=%(&*,8&

4,1%(,*+&-*23%&1$%.(4%37&$*)%&/*4+%8&1.&'(.)48%&*,&*++;%,-.0'*334,=&0%1$.8.+.=@>&#$%&-2((%,1&+*:&43&

2,-%(1*4,7&*,8&1$43&'%(0413&H28=%3&1.&.93-2(%&1$%4(&'.+4-@&8%+49%(*14.,3&9%$4,8&1*21.+.=4%3&*,8&1$%&

3%+%-14)%&23%&./&1$%3%&1$%.(4%3>&I4)%,&1$%&34=,4/4-*,-%&./&1$%&CD#E&4,B24(@7&1$43&2,-%(1*4,1@&*,8&

0@314/4-*14.,&43&2,8%34(*9+%>

J&$.+4314-&*''(.*-$&1.&1$43&4,B24(@&-*,&'(.)48%&*&3.+214.,&1.&1$%3%&84//4-2+14%3>&#$43&*''(.*-$&

43&02+14;/*-1.(4*+> &K1&4,).+)%3&.)%(1&(%/%(%,-%&1.&'.+4-@&*,8&1$%&1(*,3'*(%,1&%<%(-43%&./&843-(%14.,>&

L,8%(&1$43&*''(.*-$7&*&H28=%&:.2+8&-.,348%(&1$%&0%84-*+&%)48%,-%&9%/.(%&1$%&-.2(1&*+.,=&:41$&*&

,209%( & ./ & '.+4-@ & /*-1.(3 & 1. & 8%1%(04,% &:$%1$%( & *, & *--23%8 & 3$.2+8 & 9% & 329H%-1 & 1. & *, & 4,3*,41@&

843'.3414.,>&M'%-4/4-*++@7&1$%&H28=%&:.2+8&-.,348%(&:$%1$%(&1$%&%)48%,-%&32==%31%8&1$*1&1$%&'29+4-&

,%%8%8&'(.1%-14.,&/(.0&1$%&*--23%87&.(&1$*1&1$%&*--23%8&,%%8%8&'3@-$4*1(4-&1(%*10%,1>&K,&*88414.,7&

1$%&H28=%&0*@&=*4,&*33431*,-%&/(.0&1$%&4,1%(,*+&-*23%&*,8&(%-2((4,=&8*,=%(&*''(.*-$%3>&K/7&/.++.:4,=&

1$*1&4,B24(@7&1$%&H28=%&8%1%(04,%8&.,&'.+4-@&=(.2,83&1$*1&*,&4,3*,41@&843'.3414.,&:.2+8&9%&8%34(*9+%7&

Page 57: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !"

#$%&'(')*+,'-./01'2%'3./&14

+$%'/5%3/0&%55'.3'#$65'(778.(9$'65'1%:.&5#8(#%1'-$%&'6#' 65'(7706%1'#.'78.20%:(#69'9(5%5'

6&;.0;6&< ':%#$=8%0(#%1'75>9$.5654 '?&1%8 ' #$65 ' (778.(9$' #$%'90(556369(#6.& '.3 '75>9$.565 '-./01'&.'

0.&<%8'#/8&'.&'56&<0%'3(9#.85@'5/9$'(5'#$%'06A%06$..1'.3'8%9/88%&9%'.8'-$%#$%8'#$%'78%1.:6&(&#'9(/5%'

-(5'6&#%8&(0'#.'#$%'(99/5%14'+$65'-./01'2%'('1%568(20%'9$(&<%@'(5'(55%556&<'#$%'3/#/8%'9./85%@'.8'

9(/5%'.3'#$%'8%0%;(&#'165.81%8'-6#$'(&>'1%<8%%'.3'9%8#(6&#>'$(5'.3#%&'78.;%1'163369/0#4'B&5#%(1@'#$%'

:/0#6=3(9#.86(0'&(#/8%'.3'#$%'$.065#69'(778.(9$'B'(:'(1;.9(#6&<'-./01'%&(20%'#$%'(;(60(20%'%;61%&9%'

(&1'#$%'8%0%;(&#'7.069>'3(9#.85'#.'2%'9.&561%8%1'6&'#$%'8./&14'

?&1%8 ' #$65 ' (778.(9$@ ' ( ')*+,'-./01 '<%&%8(00> '2% ' 3./&1'-$%8% ':%#$=6&#.C69(#6.& '$(1'

#86<<%8%1'.8'%C(9%82(#%1'(&'.&<.6&<'75>9$.#69'165.81%84'D.&;%85%0>@'(')*+,'-./01'&.#'/5/(00>'2%'

3./&1'-$%8%'75>9$.565'-(5'78%5%&#'1/86&<'6&#.C69(#6.&'(0.&%@'.8'1/86&<'('E30(5$2(9AF4',.8%.;%8@'

-$%& ' #$% ' 9(/5% ' .3 ' ( ' 75>9$.#69 ' %765.1%@ ' .8 ' #$% ' 06A%06$..1 ' .3 ' 6#5 ' 8%9/88%&9% '-%8% ' /&90%(8@ ' #$%'

-%6<$#6&<'<6;%&' #.';(86./5'7.069> ' 3(9#.85 ' 6& ' #$%')*+,'6&G/68> '9./01'8%30%9# ' #$(#4 '+$%'$.065#69'

(778.(9$'65'30%C620%'6&'#$65'3(5$6.&@'#$%8%2>'%&5/86&<'#$%'(778.786(#%'1%#%8:6&(#6.&'65':(1%@'(&1'#$(#'

6&H/5#69%5'(8%'(;.61%1'#$(#'9(&'3.00.-'38.:'#$%'(77069(#6.&'.3'86<61'9(#%<.86%5'#.'(00'9(5%54'I6&(00>@'#$%'

$.065#69'(778.(9$'%&5/8%5'#$(#'#$%'7.069>'8%(5.&6&<'65':(1%'%C70696#'6&'#$%5%'163369/0#'9(5%54'+$65'-600'

%&$(&9%'7/2069'/&1%85#(&16&<'.3'#$%'0%<(0'(778.(9$'#(A%&'#.':%#$=8%0(#%1'75>9$.565@'(&1'78.;61%'

<8%(#%8'90(86#>'6&'#$%'0(-4

+$%'$.065#69'(778.(9$'9./01'2%'(7706%1'#.'.#$%8'9(5%5'-$%8%'6&5(&6#>'65'6&'655/%@'(7(8#'38.:'

#$.5%' 6&;.0;6&< ':%#$=8%0(#%1'75>9$.5654 '+$%'5(:%'7.069> ' 3(9#.85 '-./01'2%'8%0%;(&#@ '%;%&' 63 ' #$%'

-%6<$#'(##(9$%1'#.'#$%:':6<$#'1633%84'B&'#$65':(&&%8@'#$%'$.065#69'(778.(9$'9./01'78.;61%'(&'(00=

%&9.:7(556&<':%#$.1.0.<>'3.8'#$%')*+,'6&G/68>4'B#'5$./01'#$%8%3.8%'2%'(1.7#%1'2>'JK'9./8#5'(5'

#$%'78%3%88%1'(778.(9$'#.'61%&#6369(#6.&'.3'(')*+,4' 'B#'78.;61%5'#$%'&%9%55(8>'30%C62606#>'-6#$6&'

90%(8'7(8(:%#%85@'-$60%'%&5/86&<'#8(&57(8%&9>'6&'1%9656.&':(A6&<4'I/8#$%8@'#(A6&<'('56&<0%'(778.(9$'

#.' #$65' 6&G/68>'-./01'%&5/8%'( ':%(5/8%'.3' H/1696(0 '9.&565#%&9>@ '(&1'-./01'78%;%&#' H/1<%5' 38.:'

Page 58: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !"

#$%&$'()*'+)%,--.$'()/01200')1,0)*3*$4*/40)*##5-*%,0.)2$1,-61)*51$%64*1$'()1,0$5)50*.-'.7)81)2-64+)

$9#5-30)1,0)%6550'14:)%-';6.0+)*'+)#$0%090*4 ).1*10)-;) 1,0) 4*2< ) 40*3$'()1,0)%-651. )2$1,)*)%40*5<)

#5$'%$#40+<)*'+)0;;0%1$30)*##5-*%,)1-)$+0'1$;:$'()*44);-59.)-;)=>?@7

Page 59: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !!

!"#$"%&'()*+,

-'".('+/0%1'234

"#$%&'()%*+,-./

01%2#&-34)-56758

01%2%+('-91*4#:;1#-<=#+)(''>-?2@(%1#:-9#1&*+&A-34)-BCCD8

=#+)('-E#(')F-<0*2@;'&*1>-3&&#&&2#+)-(+:-G1#()2#+)A-34)-566B8

H#+)#+4%+$-34)-BCCB8

"#$%&'()%*+,-0(+(:(

01%2%+('-0*:#-IH0-56J!-4-0KL78

0(&#&,-./

566(/-0)+7+,08(/"-<566DA-5C-0I./-55C-<E0A8

,08(/"+7+9%))()+M5665N-B-./"I-BDO-<E0A8

:+7+9%.4061+E0-9('2#1&)*+-.*1)F-0I?-BCCLKB!LK6OP-6-Q#4#2R#1-BCCL8

:+7+;0##8"+M56!JN-./"I-666-<03A8

:+7+3(<0)+MBCCON-./03-D6JS-MBCCJN-B-./"I-75O-<03A8

:+7+51=%61-+MBCCON-./03-DJB8

:+7+>6(/"+M56O!N-5-./"I-O7C-<03A8-

:+7+?%&('"8(+M56O!N-B-./"I-75C-<03A8

:+7+!/@88(-#"6+<56JLA-5-0I./-BLJ-<03A8

:+7+!%/&(88%)+M5677N-./"I-757-<03A8

:+7+A(8--0)+03-!!BT66-BO-U;'>-BCCC8

:+7+:0B8-#0)-M56O7N-B-./"I-7LL-<03A8-:+7+C6(D$#-MBCC5N-D-./"I-BB-<03A8

:+7+E"-8"6+MBCCON-5-./"I-BLC-<E0A8-

Page 60: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !"

5(&&-+6+,07(/"+#$%&'(()*+,-*%./%01234%53%6789:%;223<

$7='=>%.?=,87()7

800'"9+6+!/:"))%;+"<+'%9#"+800'"9+@;2"AB%CD%E%FA"%GH$I<+

=+6+>"1"7'$+@;20AB%J7=%E%5K%G$$.I<

=+6+8%9#"9+@;2!2B%LE%;A!%GH$I<

=+6+?%7/0)"9+G;22AI%;3;%$ME%;KA%G#$.I<

=+6+!%9#()+@A0+BC+G5AA!I%;!2%.%$8)N%E%K;F%GLH$I<

=+6+!"11()D-+@;2""B%LE%KA"%GH$I<

=+6+,09#"9+G;2KKI%!!%$ME%;05%G#$.I<

=+6+=%14091+G;20!I%F5%H.HE%5""%GH$I<

$7='=>%$7*7D7

=+6+>"9D%&()+G;22"I%K%$E%G!,:I%;FA%G.(,7%$.I<

=+6+?0)#%()"+5AAF%H$$%53O%@5AAFB%;%H$E%3A5<

=+6+!%/10)%71+G;23"I%52%$$$%G5DI%5!3%GH$$I<

=+6+!/EF%99("+G;220I%;53%$$$%GKDI%505%G.(,7%$.I<

=+6+!09"+@;2"KB%H$E%!55%GH$$I<

=+6+,%9G-+;!%$<E<%GF,:I%502%GH$$I<

=+6+=%H".+@;20AB%5%H$E%!;K%GH$$I<

=+6+5#0)"%@;222B%5%H$E%52A%GH$$I<

=+6+5I%()+G;22;I%!%$E%GF,:I%5!K%GH$$I<

$7='=>%P*+(7*D

J##09)".KL")"9%7+409+A09#$"9)+29"7%)1+6+L%77%D$"9%@;2"KB%.$%KF2%G#MI<

J##09)".KL")"9%7M-+="4"9")/"+@A0+N+04+BOOPC+@;222B%K%.((%PE%FA%G$.I<

>9%##.+6+J##09)".KL")"9%7+409+A09#$"9)+29"7%)1+@;2"KB%.$%K0"%G#MI<

Page 61: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !"

3(5"/#05+04+,678(/+,50-"/6#(0)-+9+:"%51+#$%&'()*+),"%)-./01

3(5"/#05+04+,678(/+,50-"/6#(0)-+9+!%;"<-=(+#$%""()*+),,2)-./01

>+9+:%(8".+#$%32()45+*)+678)&1

>+9+:65?"--)#$%%$()&)9:)%&)-+*01

>+9+@"))"--.+#$%3%()$)5/;)&3")-+*01

>+9+A()?-#0)+#$%%!()&)*+)2!!)-./01

>+9+B('&%))#$%"'()$)9:)$!&)-+*01

>+9+C6(/=+#$%"2()$)9:)%$')-+*01

>+9+D$""$%)+#$%"!()$)5/;)"2%)-+*01

>+9+D688(9%)+#$%3,()*+)$!<)-./01

>+9+E08-0)+-$33%0)&2)9:=)$<3)-+*01

F008&()?#0)+9+3(5"/#05+04+,678(/+,50-"/6#(0)-+#$%2!()*+),<&)-./01)

+>?@?A)BCD@6C>D7EC>F

F()#"5<"5'+9+E$"+G"#$"58%)1-+-$%"%0)&)4.;;)23")-4+.;01

/>G)+E887??7EC);@HE6D?

IC7D@J)K7CLJE8)/>G)+E887??7EC)BCDEM7N>D7EC)>CJ)+6787C>F)/7>O7F7DP)-IK/+);2$,)&''%01

!"#$%&'()*!$+(#",

:EEQ?

*8@67N>C)R?PNS7>D67N)*??EN7>D7EC)3(%?)0-#(/+%)1+D#%#(-#(/%8+!%)6%8+04+!")#%8+3(-051"5-H+3D!I2JIE>+-,DS)

@J)T@MD);@U7?7EC)*8@67N>C)R?PNS7>D67N)*??EN7>D7EC)5>?S7CLDEC)=+)&'''01

:6EEQO>CQ?V)51)>CJ)W78H?ECV)W1)-@J?0),-./$(%#5.+%)1+#$"+B%<+-/@M7?X@M7?)5@FF7CLDEC)&''"01

+>6JV);1)K%51*+K50--+%)1+L0)"-+K5(&()%8+B%<)-$"DS)@J)YMZE6J)IC7U@6?7DP)R6@??)YMZE6J)&''<01

[F@DNS@6V)\1):%-(/+K0)/"'#-+04+K5(&()%8+B%<+-YMZE6J)IC7U@6?7DP)R6@??)X@G)]E6Q)$%%301

^@ZZ@6?ECV)_1)K5(&()%8+B%<+-!DS)@J)/ECL8>C).>6FEG)4CLF>CJ)&''$01

Page 62: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !"

#$%&$'()*+,*5&(#$+%)1+607%)+89(&()%:+;%<+-./01*&(*#23'$(*4567&$8609*:$&88*#23'$(*/;;"<,

=6%&80&$)*>,*?5(*=@AA67?5)*B,*89(&()%:+;%<=+>$"09.+%)1+30/#9()"+-C$(*&(*:'$0A?5(*#23'$(*/;;D<,

=0@?$0)*+,*8%)%1(%)+89(&()%:+;%<=+?+>9"%#(-"+-E01*&(*F?$8G&AA*=H?$I'$'@J1*#50?$6'*/;;.<,

K6AA6?%8)*B,*>"@#A00B+04+89(&()%:+;%<+-=0&7&58*L'5('5*.MD"<,

N'@$5?A*?$06HA&8

O@20'5)*N,*?5(*+'7&)*P,*QR1&*I@$(&5*?5(*%?5?J&%&50*'3*H$980?A*%&01*@8&S*-/;;"<*.D"*FT>N*.!CDU.!CM,

+?$V&)*=,)*W?9&)*=,)*THW&065)*X,*?5(*+@3A'@)*N,*QT?Y'$*Z1986H?A*?5(*Z89H1'A'J6H?A*1?$%8*'3*%&01?%Z1&0?%65&*@8&S*-/;;"<*.D*+$@J*?5(*>AH'1'A*X&76&G*/!CU/[/,

+'$&)*B,*?5(*=G&&065J)*T,*Q+$@JU65(@H&(*Z89H1'868*?88'H6?0&(*G601*H$980?AA65&*%&01?%Z1&0?%65&S*-/;;[<*.E*>@80$?A?86?5*:89H16?0$9*"[U"M,

\A?@%)*T,*?5(*=H1@A0])*=,*QK1&5*('&8*?%Z1&0?%65&U65(@H&(*Z89H1'868*I&H'%&*8H16]'Z1$&56?^S*-.MM[<*.!C*R1&*>%&$6H?5*N'@$5?A*'3*:89H16?0$9*"./U".!,

_?AA)*K,)*_?5(')*N,)*+?$V&)*=,*?5(*X'88)*N,*Q:89H1'A'J6H?A*%'$I6(609*?5(*$'@0&*'3*?(%65680$?06'5*?%'5J*?%Z1&0?%65&*@8&$8*65*=9(5&9)*>@80$?A6?S*-.MM[<*M.*>((6H06'5*".U"D,

L6765J80'5)*N,*?5(*`&$(@5UN'5&8)*=,*Q=6(&I?$*:89H1'A'J9a*+68H@8865J*?5(*F1?AA&5J65J*01&*+&3&5H&*'3*:89H1'A'J6H?A*OA'G*>@0'%?068%S*-/;;/<*ED*F$6%*Lb*DMU..;,

L@01&$)*B,*?5(*T&A?)*T,*QR1&*R'Z*R&5*c88@&8*65*L?G*?5(*:89H16?0$9S*-/;;[<*[M*=>=WLX&7*E;.UEE;,

T?HV?9)*X,*?5(*T60H1&AA)*O,*Q=A&&ZG?AV65J)*>@0'%?068%*?5(*c58?5609S*d/;;[e*F$6%*LX*M;.UM;!,

TH=1&$$9)*O,*QC+D+5#0)"+d.MMMe*/*=FX*/M;a*F?8&*F'%%&50?$9S*-/;;;<*D*:89H16?0$9*:89H1'A,*f*L*/DMU/"C,

T?016?8)*=,)*L@I%?5)*+,*?5(*_6(&8)*L,*Q=@I80?5H&Uc5(@H&(*:89H1'868a*>*+6?J5'806H*F'5@5($@%S*-/;;"<*[MaC*N*FA65*:89H16?0$9*C!"UC[D,

T&$&(601)*F,)*N?33&)*F,)*>5JUL&&)*W,*?5(*=?2'5)*>,*Qc%ZA6H?06'58*'3*F1$'56H*T&01?%Z1&0?%65&*48&a*>*L60&$?0@$&*X&76&GS*-/;;!<*.C*_?$7*X&7*:89H16?0$9*.E/U.!E,

:?H6'HH')*+,*Q+&?01*I9*=0'5&U65Ja*R1&*+&%68&*'3*01&*+&3&5H&*'3*=6%ZA&*>@0'%?068%S*-.MMM<*/[*FX*-!01<*/DCU/"!,

g&')*=,*QFA?$63965J*>@0'%?068%S*-/;;/<*/!*c50*N*'3*L?G*:89H16?0$9*EE!UE!",

THW&065)*X,)*THL?$&5)*N,)*L@I%?5)*+,*?5(*_6(&8)*L,*QR1&*Z$&7?A&5H&*'3*Z89H1'06H*89%Z0'%8*

Page 63: Methamphetamine, Psychosis and the Insanity Defence

!"#$%&'$"#%&()"*+,-./$0-(-+%)1+#$"+2)-%)(#.+3"4")/" !"

#$%&'($)*+#$,+)*#$-&)(./)0/1(234456(747(899-:*-%&(7;<=>7;<?@

A.-B(C@B(D/+-'.0%B(E@B(F%*%B(C@(#&9(DG)$%*%B(H@(IJ0):-,-*#*-&'(K#:*%0/(-&(/,%&*#&)%./(0):.00)&:)(%K($)*+#$,+)*#$-&)(,/L:+%/-/1(27""<6(7=;(J+#0$#:%M%'L(=4=>=4?@

N%%/)M)#K/

O%P)0*/%&B(Q@(2)96(51%&-+0)+67(&()%8+9%:+2%&M-&)(M%%/)M)#K()96(2#::)//)9(=(R#0:+(344"6@

S*+)0

T),#0*$)&*(%K(U%00):*-%&/(I8&&.#M(O),%0*V(7(W.ML(344<>=4(W.&)(344?1(2344?6(T),#0*$)&*(%K(U%00):*-%&/(XXX@:%00):*-%&/@'%Y*@&Z(2#::)//)9(%&(7"(H),*)$P)0(344"6@

N))B([@B(W%+&/B(N@B(W)&G-&/%&B(O@B(W%+&/*%&B(W@B(U%&&%MMLB(C@B(\#MMB(C@(#&9(U#/+B(O@(IUM-&-:#M(E0)#*$)&*(F.-9)M-&)/(K%0(8M:%+%M(#&9(T0.'(UM-&-:-#&/@([%(7;V(R)*+#$,+)*#$-&)(9),)&9)&:)(#&9(*0)#*$)&*1(2344<6(E.0&-&'(J%-&*(8M:%+%M(#&9(T0.'(U)&*0)(D&:(]-*Z0%L(^-:*%0-#(XXX@+)#M*+@Y-:@'%Y@#.(2#::)//)9(%&(74(W.&)(344"6@

E#,/)MMB(O@(I]%0)&/-:(J/L:+-#*0L(#&9(*+)(N#XV(8(W.9-:-#M(_,9#*)1(2J#,)0(,0)/)&*)9(#*(D&/*-*.*)(%K(W.9-:-#M(H*.9-)/(\-'+(U%.0*(_,9#*)B(R)&*#M(\)#M*+(D//.)/B(`)MM-&'*%&a8.:GM#&9B([%Y)$P)0(344!6@

_&-*)9([#*-%&/(SKK-:)(%&(T0.'/(#&9(U0-$)(I`%0M9(T0.'(O),%0*(344"1(2344"6(_&-*)9([#*-%&/(SKK-:)(%&(T0.'/(#&9(U0-$)(XXX@.&%9:@%0'(2#::)//)9(%&(74(W.&)(344"6@

`-MG-&/B(U@B(F0-KK-*+/B(O@(#&9(HX))*/.0B(J@(IO):)&*(E0)&9/(-&(DMM)'#M(T0.'(_/)(-&([)X(b)#M#&9B(3445>344?V(]-&9-&'/(K0%$(*+)(DMM-:-*(T0.'(R%&-*%0-&'(HL/*)$(2DTRH61(2344"6(U)&*0)(K%0(H%:-#M(#&9(\)#M*+(S.*:%$)/(O)/)#0:+(#&9(cY#M.#*-%&B(R#//)L(_&-Y)0/-*L(XXX@/+%0)@#:@&Z(2#::)//)9(%&(74(W.&)(344"6@