Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Page 1
Meeting Agenda
ContentsMeeting Agenda..........................................................................................................................................1
Discussion Items......................................................................................................................................1
Reports....................................................................................................................................................1
Publicity: Paul/Chan.............................................................................................................................1
Boot Camp Report - Herb....................................................................................................................1
SCL Group: Christoph...........................................................................................................................1
Time Sync: Bernhard............................................................................................................................2
R-GOOSE: Herb....................................................................................................................................2
Security: Herb......................................................................................................................................3
Integrated Application and Test Cases................................................................................................3
High Level Use cases and Abstract Test Cases (coordinated by Joel)...................................................4
Logistics.......................................................................................................................................................6
Known Participants and Witness.................................................................................................................9
Page 2
Discussion Items
Statistics on IOP
158 attendees currently (still Growing)17 new witnessing companies (total of 43)“7” new participating companies (total of 36)
Need to update website with new participating companies.
Need to update mailing lists, etc. Kay – need everyone’s email.
Will be putting out additional weekly meeting notices? Use GotoWebinar
Invoice discussion – Who hasn’t received their invoices?o Triangleo SELo Toshibao CYGo GE – individual issue o NIST – Eugene Song (send email to [email protected] and copy [email protected])
Areas of Participation form review (only 2 vendors have filled it in)?
Due 2017-09-08 Spreadsheet to be updated with number of devices, equipment type, and power
requirements – posted. Due 2017-09-08
Hotel rooms – Kay – still open Some rooms available, but OK to book elsewhere because some nights are not available. Dean – RTDS needs invitation – Kay to provide this week. Entergy to coordinate with Kay. Shipping information needed. Herb to verify
Page 3
ICD Files Due 2017-09-08 Each vendor to create folder under http://iec61850.ucaiug.org/2017IOP-NOrleans/IOP
%20Documents/Forms/AllItems.aspx?RootFolder=%2f2017IOP%2dNOrleans%2fIOP%20Documents%2fVendor%20ICD%20Files&FolderCTID=&View=%7b206D92CC%2dA596%2d437A%2d9092%2d153EDDF0F32C%7d Any additional product documentation can be added to that folder.
Failure of application on GPS. Will bring splitter and this requires the equivalent L1 GPS inputs (this includes PTP Master clocks). Need to know how many inputs to feed. Need to bring N Male connector cables in order to connect to the splitter.
Reports
Publicity: Paul/Chan
In EPRI Publicity – Paul to follow-up. Will be pushed to LinkedIn, Ensto-e Friday Roundup, Karlheinz, PES, PSRC, T&D World, PACWorld.
Boot Camp Report - Herb
Brochure is complete. Link on the website.
Presentations to be provided for review and approval first week in October.
Infrastructure
a. Connections between switches will be 1 G copper.b. Connections between IEDs, Routers, and Switches 100M copper.
i. Switches should be capable of auto-negotiationc. Infrastructure vendors should bring “sparse” capability for optical LCST
Page 4
SCL Group: Christoph
Need ICT vendors to participate in this group. No Update
Herb will be chatting with with Christoph.
ICD files needed ASAP
R-GOOSE Configuration will be done
SED exchange ED.1/ED.2 Exchanges Later Binding tests may not be possible since IED. Decision: IEDs will have unique names throughout the IOP system.
Time Sync: Bernhard
Current Status:
Have an agreed upon set of test cases Will be working on a test plan. NIST will bring a splitter with loads. Need to add a column for equipment draws. Next meeting in 2 weeks.
From previous meetings
Topics discussed for testingo GPS Security (Spoofing, Jamming)o HSR & PRP in combination with PTPo GLONASS simulationo Leap second handling in IEC 61850 ED 2.1 – Move to integrated application testingo GPS Repeater may need to be over coax.
Equipment – still in need for suppliers for transparent clocks Agreement reached that everybody submits what equipment will brought to IOP – Bernhard to
send out questionnaire Key finding: October is closer than one might think
Page 5
R-GOOSE: Herb
Participants: Triangle, SISCO, GE, CISCO, Vizimax, Moxa, Belden, CISCO, Helinks
Preliminary R-GOOSE test cases posted. Need Firewall vendor input (CISCO, Palo Alto, Beldin will provide).
SCL testing will become part of the test campaign.
R-GOOSE ICDs due to be posted 2017-09-25.
Security: Herb Final Meetings calendared in Sept
Added new potential test cases:o GOOSE Replay based upon the draft 62351-6 documento DOS tests (Dean and Herb still working on this).
Integrated Application and Test CasesFinal Meetings calendared in Sept
o SCT Vendors need to get together to divide responsibilities. Grid Software SSD will be the start.
o Simulations vendor’s will be meeting this Monday to divide simulation responsibilities.o GE has a digital disturbance recorder (transmission level). Jun to help with the
placement. Where to put?o Herb will start assigning IP addresses.o Need more definition from simulation/test group regarding transients and latencies of
transformer protection connected to 2 merging units.o Discuss remote file access purposes (security related)o Settings Group Test cases – Fred (OMICRON) will coordinate with Juno Resiliency of GOOSE publishers (maybe from SCADA publisher)oo Comments on Integrated Application set-up to Jun by 2017-04-24.
1 SCT vendor per bay. SCT vendors will provide a resource to perform the bay/substation engineering task in advance of the IOP and during the IOP.
Page 6
Grid Software – will generate SSD for the Integrated Application Helinks Kalkitech
Page 7
Software has been developed to allow exchange of GOOSE over the Internet. The software has been posted at: http://iec61850.ucaiug.org/2017IOP-NOrleans/IOP%20Documents/GOOSE%20to%20GOOGLE%20Bridge%20(AS-IS%20Software)/XMPPBridge.zip
GoogleTalk was found to have performance problems and OOD packet delivery (non-conformant to XMPP). New software being tested using MQTT. May be looking for somebody to host the MQTT broker. Triangle Microworks has set up hosting but performance issues are still being evaluated. Initial latency measurements are worse than GOOGLETalk, but has no dropped messages.
Decision: Since GOOGLE Talk has service drop outs, the MQTT version should be used. Instructions and revised software is posted. Triangle Microworks has
provided a publically available MQTT broker located at: 45.20.211.173
High Level Use cases and Abstract Test Cases (coordinated by Joel)
See the following folder: http://iec61850.ucaiug.org/2017IOP-NOrleans/IOP%20Documents/General%20Integrated%20Demo%20Information/Test%20procedure%20drafts
Joel will put together a matrix of the ACSI services tested.
Item Responsible People Estimated Comp “Submitted”IED Isolation for maintenance and testing in the field
Herb FalkAndreas Klien
Yes
IED Replacement Bruce Muschlitz 10-03-2017 YesIED Addition to Bay Vladen 17-03-2017 YesIED Failure/power down Michael Haecker 10-03-2017 YesClock Failure – Station Bus Peter Pfisterer (TUV-
SUD)Yes
Network Failure Bruce Muschlitz 10-03-2017 YesMerging Unit Failure Dean 31-03-2017 YesEAP/Failure Herb, Chan/IT 17-03-2017 YesClock Failure – Process Bus Peter Pfisterer YesCyber Intrusion of GOOSE Herb Falk 17-03-2017 YesReporting to SCADA Masters Mark and Ursla – 12-04-2017 Yes
Page 8
CopadataSOE Testing (Logging) Vladan 12-04-2017 YesSecurity Event Monitoring (Syslog, SNMP, IEC 62351-7)
Frances, Herb 12-04-2017 In progress as part of security test cases
Secure IEC 61850 MMS Joel, Ralph, Herb 12-04-2017 In progress as part of security test cases
Leap Second Test (Based upon 2.1)PTP and SNTP
Herb ,Joel, jean-sebastian, Eric, Vinoo
Jean-Sebastian working on it.
Clock/GPS Time Discontinuity Herb and JoelSettings GroupMatrix of ACSI Services Covered – email: [email protected]
Joel Ongoing until all test cases are complete.
Infrastructure team
Meeting held 17-07-2017 Participants:
o GEo Moxao Siemens/Ruggedcommo CISCOo Beldeno SEL will be joining next meeting
Accomplished/Decisions:o Tentative IP addressing (using class B address spaces)
Control center: 10.10.0.1 Substation 1: 10.11.0.1 Substation 2: 10.12.0.1
o All connections to IEDs are being planned as 100M Coppero Sparse optical connection capability to IEDs will be providedo DAN PRP “red-box” functionality will need to be provided by individual IED vendors or
IEDs will be connected as a SAN.o Switches will be PTP capable.o VLAN assignments:
Switch Management: VLAN 1 GOOSE VLAN 2 SV: VLAN 3
o PTP Grandmasters: Currently Siemens/RuggedComm and GE will be providing.
Page 9
Page 10
Logistics
URL for IOP Site: http://iec61850.ucaiug.org/2017IOP-NOrleans/default.aspx
Email Exploder: [email protected]
Boot Camp: October 13-14
IOP: Setup: October 14, Testing October 15-19
Hotel: New Orleans Downtown Marriot at the Convention Center 859 Convention Center Blvd New Orleans, LA 70130 Phone: 504-613-2888
web: http://www.marriott.com/hotels/fact-sheet/travel/msymc-new-orleans-downtown-marriott-at-the-convention-center/
IOP Reservation Link: https://aws.passkey.com/go/UCAIOP (room rate $189 + tax/night)
Page 11
Please note that the IOP Hotel is approximately a 20 minute walk from the WG10 meeting site.
WG10 Meetings will be held at Entergy (October 23-27). Entergy is located at:
Entergy639 Loyola AveNew Orleans, LA 70113
There are two hotels that are connected to the Entergy building (there are no official hotels for the IOP):
Hyatt Regency New Orleans601 Loyola AvenueNew Orleans, Louisiana, USA, 70113
Hyatt House New Orleans/Downtown1250 Poydras StNew Orleans, Louisiana, USA, 70113
Participation fees:
UCA Members (USD)
Non-member(USD)
Comments
Participating Company $ 6,500 $ 8,000 Includes one Individual if staying at the IOP hotel
Individual Staying at the IOP Hotel
$ 1,000 $ 1,350 For non-members, the fee includes UCA membership.
Individual not staying at the IOP Hotel
$ 2,000 $ 2,350 For non-members, the fee includes UCA membership.
Participation fees are due by July 1st.
Individual fees can vary after.
Kay will check on hotel cut-off - June.
Boot Camp fees and logistics:
The Boot Camp has the ability to provide training for 30-40 people. Reservations are first come and will be based upon payment of a registration fee of $250.
Page 12
WG10 Meetings will be held at Entergy (October 23-27). Entergy is located at:
Entergy639 Loyola AveNew Orleans, LA 70113
Page 13
Known Participants and Witness
Participating Companies1 ABB2 Belden3 CISCO4 Copadata5 Doble6 GE-Alstom7 Grid Software8 Kalkitech9 Meinberg10 Moxa11 NovaTech12 NREC13 OMICRON14 OPAL-RT15 OSIsoft16 Palo Alto17 Reinhausen18 RTDS19 Schweitzer20 Siemens21 SISCO22 Sprecher-automation23 Subnet Solutions24 Toshiba25 Triangle Microworks26 Vizimax27 CYG28 DoWoo digitech29 Helinks30 SAC China31 SystemCORP Embedded
Technology32 Wago33 ErlPhase34 KEPCO
Witnessing Companies1 Amprion
Page 14
2 BPA3 CenterPoint Energy4 CEPRI5 ComEd6 ConEd7 DNV/GL8 Eandis9 EDF10 Entergy11 Entso-e/Elia12 EPRI13 Hydro Quebec14 It4power15 National Grid16 NERC17 NIST18 NYPA19 PNNL20 Reliability First21 SCE22 SWECO23 Tesco24 TÜV SÜD
25 UCA26 Dominion27 Cyber Sciences28 EANDIS29 EC Source Services30 Groupe Conseil PM
SCADA Inc.31 Joulz Energy Solutions32 KERI33 KETOP34 NuGrid Power Corp35 SGEPRI36 Solutil37 SRP38 TECNALIA39 Tekron International Ltd.40 TUV Sud41 Tuv Rhineland42 XELAS Energy43 Xuchang Ketop Testing
Technolo
Page 15
![I G D I T IEC 61850-9-2iec61850.ucaiug.org/Implementation Guidelines/DigIF_spec_9-2LE_R2-1...7.2.4 Calculations to be done in the Merging Unit ... [7-4] IEC 61850-7-4: Communication](https://img.pdfslide.us/doc/110x75/5a6fb6137f8b9ac0538b5374/pdfi-g-d-i-t-iec-61850-9-2iec61850ucaiugorgimplementation-guidelinesdigifspec9-2ler2-1724.jpg)
