May 15 Senate impeachment court record

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    1/68

    YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735 3

    Uawqedof bh yka Wkodowwomav

    Vamcya

    Uafbui bh yka VamcyaVoyyomn Cv Cm Olwacfklamy Fbquy

    Yqavic$ Lc 31$ 5735

    Wcvc Foy

    CY 5:37 W-L-$ YKA WUAVOIOMN BHHOFAU$ VAMCYA WUAVOIAMY JQCM WBMFA AMUODA$

    FCDDAI YKA OLWACFKLAMY YUOCD BH VQWUALA FBQUY FKOAH JQVYOFA UAMCYB F-

    FBUBMC YB BUIAU-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau-Yka fbmyomqcyobm bh yka olwacfklamy yuocd bh yka Kbm- Fkoah Jqvyofa Uamcyb

    F- Fbubmc bh yka Vqwuala Fbquy ov kauae fcddai yb buiau-

    ^a vkcdd ea dai om wucau e Vam- Hucmfov M- Wcmnodomcm-

    Vamcybu Wcmnodomcm-

    Cdlonky Hcykau cmi Kacxamd @omn$ cv ~a macu yka ami bh ykov kovybuof olwacfklamy yuocd $ cv

    Vamcybu,Jqinav$ ~a kqled vaa` _bqu omhomoya ~ovibl$ _bqu ebqmidavv fbqucna$ cmi ollacvquceda

    vyuamnyk cv ~a hqdhodd bqu fbmvyoyqyobmcd iqy yb uamiau olwcuyocd jqvyofa om ykava wubfaaiomnv-

    ^a ykcm` _bq$ B Dbui$ ykcy chyau macud vo{ lbmykv$ ~a kcxa fbla ykov hcu om vacufk bh yka yuqyk

    cmi om yka wquvqoy bh jqvyofa-

    ^a ykcm` _bq$ Kacxamd @omn$ hbu ebyk yka Wubvafqyobm cmi yka Iahamva ~kb kcxa amiacxbuai

    lonkyod yb wquvqa ykaou uavwafyoxa fcqvav-

    ^a ykcm` _bq hbu bqu Wuavoiomn Bhhofau$ bqu Vamcya Wuavoiamy$ hbu kov ualcu`ceda vyclomc cmi

    qmwcucddadai omfovoxamavv om yka vyaauomn bh ykava wubfaaiomnv-

    ^a kqled cv` _bq yb edavv$ yb nqoia$ cmi yb vkawkaui cdd wcuyoav om ykava wubfaaiomnv$ omfdqiomn

    yka uavwbmiamy Fkoah Jqvyofa cmi kov hclod-

    Cmi cy ykcy wbomy$ ~kam c iafovobm e ykov Fbquy ov lcia$ uancuidavv bh yka bqyfbla$ ~a wuc ykcy

    _bq cddb~ yka kacdomn bh yka mcyobm yb fbllamfa-

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    2/68

    5 YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735

    Nceccm Lb Wb `clo$ Wcmnombbmn Lc`cwcmncuokcm$ vc clomn kcmncuom mc lcoycnqbi

    cmn `cycuqmncm cy `cybybkcmcm vc wcndodoyov mc oyb- Mc~c lcmnoecec~ cmn kqvyovc wcuc

    vc dckcy-

    Homcdd$ ~a cv` _bq$ B Dbui$ yb edavv bqu eadbxai mcyobm cmi bqu wabwda$ cmi ykcy om yka ami$ oy

    ov kau omyauavy cmi ykcy bh kau foyozamv$ yka Hodowomb wabwda cdbma$ ~kb cua eavy vauxai e yka xauiofy bh

    ykov Fbquy-

    Ykava ~a cv` om yka Mcla bh Javqv$

    Clam-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Clam-

    Yka Vafuaycu ~odd mb~ wdacva fcdd yka ubdd bh Vamcybuv-

    Yka Vafuaycu$ uaciomn:

    Vamcybu Aincuib J- Cmncuc --------------------------------------------------------------- Wuavamy

    Vamcybu Jb`au W- Cuubb ------------------------------------------------------------------- Wuavamy*Vamcybu Cdcm Wayau Fblwcaub V- Fcaycmb --------------------------------- Wuavamy*

    Vamcybu Woc V- Fcaycmb ------------------------------------------------------------------- Wuavamy*

    Vamcybu Louocl Iahamvbu Vcmyocnb ---------------------------------------------------- Wuavamy

    Vamcybu Hucm`dom L- Iuodbm ---------------------------------------------------------------- Wuavamy

    Vamcybu Jomnnb Ajaufoyb Avyucic ------------------------------------------------------- Wuavamy

    Vamcybu Hucmfov N- Avfqiaub ------------------------------------------------------------- Wuavamy

    Vamcybu Yabhovyb D- Nqomnbmc OOO ------------------------------------------------------- Wuavamy

    Vamcybu Nuanbuob E- Kbmcvcm OO-------------------------------------------------------- Wuavamy

    Vamcybu Wcmhodb L- Dcfvbm ---------------------------------------------------------------- Wuavamy

    Vamcybu Lcmqad Doyb L- Dcwoi ------------------------------------------------------- WuavamyVamcybu Dbuam D- Dancuic ----------------------------------------------------------------- Wuavamy*

    Vamcybu Hauiomcmi Ebmnebmn U- Lcufbv Ju- ---------------------------------- Wuavamy

    Vamcybu Vaunob U- Bvlac OOO ----------------------------------------------------------- Wuavamy*

    Vamcybu Hucmfov M- Wcmnodomcm ------------------------------------------------------------ Wuavamy

    Vamcybu Csqodomb Wolamyad OOO ------------------------------------------------------------- Wuavamy

    Vamcybu Ucdwk N- Uafyb -------------------------------------------------------------------- Wuavamy

    Vamcybu Uclbm Ebmn Uaxoddc Ju- ----------------------------------------------------- Wuavamy

    Vamcybu Xofamya F- Vbyyb OOO ------------------------------------------------------------- Wuavamy

    Vamcybu Cmybmob Vbmm H- Yuoddcmav OX ------------------------------------------- Wuavamy

    Vamcybu Lcmm Xoddcu ------------------------------------------------------------------------- Cevamy**

    Yka Wuavoiamy---------------- --------------------------------------------------------------------- Wuavamy

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- ^oyk 3> Vamcybu,Jqinav wuavamy$ yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau iafdcuav yka

    wuavamfa bh c sqbuql-

    Yka Hdbbu Daciau ov uafbnmozai-

    Vamcybu Vbyyb- Lu- Wuavoiamy$ lc O cv` yka Vaunacmy,cy,Culv yb lc`a yka wubfdclcyobm-

    RRRRRRRRRRRRRR* Cuuoxai chyau yka ubdd fcdd

    **Bm bhhofocd lovvobm

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    3/68

    YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735 6

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Yka Vaunacmy,cy,Culv ov iouafyai yb lc`a yka wubfdclcyobm-

    Yka Vaunacmy,cy,Culv- Cdd wauvbmv cua fbllcmiai yb `aaw vodamy qmiau wcom bh wamcdy ~koda

    yka Vamcya ov voyyomn om yuocd bm yka Cuyofdav bh Olwacfklamy cncomvy Fkoah Jqvyofa Uamcyb F- Fbubmc-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Yka Hdbbu Daciau-

    Vamcybu Vbyyb- Lu- Wuavoiamy$ O lbxa ykcy ~a iovwamva ~oyk yka uaciomn bh yka Lc 39$ 5735Jbqumcd bh yka Vamcya voyyomn cv cm Olwacfklamy Fbquy cmi fbmvoiau oy cwwubxai-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Ov ykaua cm bejafyobm PVodamfa\ Ykaua eaomn mbma$ yka Lc 39$ 5735

    Jbqumcd bh yka Vamcya voyyomn cv cm Olwacfklamy Fbquy ov kauae cwwubxai-

    Yka Vafuaycu ~odd wdacva fcdd yka fcva eahbua yka Vamcya cv cm Olwacfklamy Fbquy-

    Yka Fdau` bh Fbquy- Fcva Mb- 775,5733$ Om yka Lcyyau bh yka Olwacfklamy Yuocd bh Kbm- Fkoah

    Jqvyofa Uamcyb F- Fbubmc-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Yka Hdbbu Daciau ov uafbnmozai-

    Vamcybu Vbyyb- Lu- Wuavoiamy$ lc ~a cv` yka wcuyoav cmi"bu ykaou uavwafyoxa Fbqmvad yb amyauykaou cwwacucmfav-

    Uawuavamycyoxa Yqwcv- Lu- Wuavoiamy$ nbbi chyaumbbm-

    Hbu yka Kbqva bh Uawuavamycyoxav Wubvafqyobm wcmad$ vcla cwwacucmfa- ^a cua uaci$ _bqu

    Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Mbyai-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _bqu Kbmbu$ hbu yka Iahamva$ yka vcla cwwacucmfa- ^a cua cdvb uaci-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Mbyai- Yka Hdbbu Daciau ov uafbnmozai-

    Vamcybu Vbyyb- Eahbua yka eqvomavv hbu yka ic$ O lbxa ykcy ~a cddb~ Vam- Louocl Iahamvbu

    Vcmyocnb hbu c lcmohavycyobm-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Yka dci Vamcybu hubl Odbodb kcv yka hdbbu-

    Vamcybu Iahamvbu Vcmyocnb- O kcxa lcia c uavauxcyobm hbu sqavyobmomn yka ~oymavv bm yka vycmi

    eqy ykov ov mby yka yola- Ykov yola ov hbu la yb lc`a yka hbddb~omn lcmohavycyobm-

    _avyauic$ yka Bleqivlcmv Wb~auWbomy wuavamycyobm omiofcyai ykcy Iahamicmy kcv ;5 ibddcu

    cffbqmyv om yka hbddb~omn ecm` eucmfkav: EWO,Cfubwbdov Eucmfk$ ;0 EWO,Ycmicmn Vbuc$ 3;0 EWO,Iad

    Lbmya$ Sqazbm Foy$ 690 EWO Omxavylamy Fbuw-$ 30 WVE,Fcomyc$ ;0 WVE,@cyowqmcm$ 80 Cddoai Ecm`$

    90 Iaqyvfka Ecm`$ 50 Foyoecm`$ 3-

    Eafcqva bh konk,yafk ecm`omn wucfyofav ybic$ cm omhbulcyobm cebqy c ecm` cffbqmy ~odd iawami

    qwbm yka vvyal cibwyai e c wcuyofqdcu ecm`- Hbu a{clwda$ yka ecm` fbqdi hbddb~ yka fqvyblau

    yucmvcfyobm vvyal bu yka ecm` yucmvcfyobm vvyal- Kamfa$ oy fbqdi ea wbvvoeda ykcy yka vomnda vql bh

    lbma fbqdi ea uawuavamyai om c ibqeda amyu- Bma amyu ~bqdi ea lcia om yka fuaioy fbdqlm cmi

    cmbykau amyu ~bqdi ea lcia om yka iaeoy fbdqlm$ cdykbqnk ebyk amyuoav fbqdi iacd ~oyk bma cmi yka

    vcla clbqmy bh lbma-

    Hquykaulbua$ c fdoamy fbqdi iawbvoy cmi ~oykiuc~ yka vcla clbqmy ~oykom c vomnda ic bu ~oykom c

    ha~ icv bh acfk bykau oh ka amncnav om ibddcu yuciomn- C fdoamy ~kb lcomycomv c hbuaonm fquuamf iawbvoy

    ov mby uasqouai yb cfsqoua c dofamva hbu ykov wquwbva- Kb~axau$ yb amncna om ibddcu yuciomn y~b +5/ bu

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    4/68

    9 YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735

    ykuaa +6/ cffbqmyv cua vqhhofoamy- Oy ~bqdi ea qmmafavvcu yb lcomycom cdd bh ;5 cffbqmyv- Yka vycmicui

    wucfyofa om yka ecm`omn fbllqmoy ov yb ucova yka eaddv cmi ~kovydav ~kam bma fdoamy vaa`v yb `aaw lbua

    ykcm y~b +5/ bu ykuaa +6/ cffbqmyv- Yb cddana ykcy yka Iahamicmy kci$ hbu a{clwda$ 69 cffbqmyv om EWO,

    Iad Lbmya$ yc{av yka fuaiqdoy bh ecm`auv-

    Ykauahbua$ O kqled wubwbva$ oh ykaua ov mb bejafyobm hubl bqu fbddacnqav$ ykcy yka Vamcya Wuavoiamy

    vkbqdi vqewbamc yka lcmcnauv bh cdd moma +?/ ecm` eucmfkav ykcy O kcxa jqvy amqlaucyai- Yka lbvy`mb~dainaceda bhhofocd cebqy c wauvbmv ecm` cffbqmy ov yka eucmfk lcmcnau- Yka eucmfk lcmcnau ov

    uasqouai e dc~ cmi e vycmicui ecm`omn wbdof yb vaa` cmi uafbui iaycodv cebqy yka fdoamy-

    Lu- Wuavoiamy$ hbu bqu fbmvoiaucyobm- Ykcm` bq-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Yka Hdbbu Daciau ov uafbnmozai-

    Vamcybu Vbyyb- Lu- Wuavoiamy$ oh yka bykau Laleauv bh yka Fbquy ~bqdi do`a yb yc`a ykcy qw$ ~a

    lc ea ceda yb yc`a qw yka lbyobm bh Vamcybu Vcmyocnb iquomn yka fcqfqv bm Lbmic-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Day qv kbdi om ceacmfa yka fbmvoiaucyobm bh yka lbyobm bh yka dci

    Vamcybu hubl Odbodb cmi iovfqvv oy om bqu fcqfqv bm Lbmic$ cmi ykam ~a ~odd cfy bm yka lbyobm-Vamcybu Vbyyb- _av$ Lu- Wuavoiamy-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- ^kcy ov yka vycyqv bh yka kacuomn mb~2

    Vamcybu Vbyyb- Mb~$ ~a cua uaci hbu yka fbmyomqcyobm bh yka wuavamycyobm bh axoiamfa e yka

    Iahamva-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Mb$ O ykom` yka fubvv,a{clomcyobm e yka Wubvafqyobm kcv mby eaam

    yaulomcyai-

    Vamcybu Vbyyb- Fbuuafy$ Lu- Wuavoiamy

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykcy ov fbuuafy$ _bqu Kbmbu- Yka ~oymavv bm yka vycmi ov yka Kbmbuceda

    Bleqivlcm$ _bqu Kbmbu- Vka eannai yb ea a{fqvai hubl fbmyomqomn ~oyk yka fubvv,a{clomcyobm

    cddanaid hbu eaomn youai cmi hcyonqai$ _bqu Kbmbu- Cmi yka Fkcoulcm bh yka cqioyomn bhhofa bh yka

    Uawqedof ybb` kau wdcfa omvyaci- ^a bejafyai yb vqfk `omi bh c wubfaiqua eafcqva ~a ib mby `mb~

    ~kbva ~oymavv ov ykov Fbllovvobmau bh yka Cqioyomn Bhhofa$ _bqu Kbmbu- Cmi ~a ~aua vqvycomai e

    yka Fbquy- Vb$ yka cnamic hbu ybic vkbqdi nb bu vkbqdi wubfaai ~oyk yka fubvv,a{clomcyobm bh yka

    Kbmbuceda Bleqivlcm-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Ykcy ov ~kcy O cl daciomn yb$ Fbqmvad- Ykcy ov ~kaua O cl nbomn-

    Wuafovad$ O cl cv`omn yka Wubvafqyobm yb fbmyomqa ~oyk ykaou fubvv,a{clomcyobm bh yka Bleqivlcm

    eafcqva avyauic yka Bleqivlcm amiai chyau vka lcia c Wb~auWbomy wuavamycyobm cmi vka ~cmyaiyka wuavamycyobm yb ea fbmyomqai e yka Fbllovvobm bm Cqioy$ Lv- Kaoio Lamibzc-

    Eqy ykam ykaua ~cv cm bejafyobm$ cmi wubwaud vb$ e yka Iahamva- Cmi vb yka Fkcou iovlovvai yka

    vqevyoyqya wuavamybu bh yka Wb~auWbomy wuavamycyobm eafcqva vka ~cv mby fbmyomqomn ~oyk yka Wb~auWbomy

    wuavamycyobm eqy ucykau ~cv yavyohomn cmi$ yuqd$ bq ucovai yka bejafyobm ~kbva ~oymavv ov ykov wauvbm

    bm yka ~oymavv vycmi- Ykcy ov ~k yka Fkcou iovlovvai kau- Vb$ ~a cua cy ykcy wbomy ~kaua yka

    Bleqivlcm ~odd kcxa yb fbmyomqa kau yavyolbm cmi day yka Wubvafqyobm iafoia ~kaykau yka ~odd

    fbmyomqa yka fubvv,a{clomcyobm-

    Vb$ lc O mb~ uasqavy vblabma yb fcdd yka iovyomnqovkai Bleqivlcm$ oh vka ov om yka Fbquy$ cmi

    euomn kau yb yka ~oymavv vycmi hbu yka fbmyomqcyobm bh kau fubvv,a{clomcyobm e yka Wubvafqyobm-

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    5/68

    YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735 1

    Vamcybu Vbyyb- Lu- Wuavoiamy-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- _av-

    Vamcybu Vbyyb- ^koda ~a cua ~coyomn hbu yka ~oymavv$ Vamcybu Wolamyad ~cv acudoau cv`omn oh oy ~bqdi

    ea wubwau hbu qv yb vyuo`a bqy yka vycyalamyv lcia e yka cqioybu bu yka fbllovvobmau eafcqva oy ~cv

    ouuanqdcu$ bu day oy ualcom om yka uafbuiv- Ykcy ~cv yka sqavyobm ykcy ~cv cv`ai e Vamcybu Wolamyad-Lu- Fqaxcv- Oh$ _bqu Kbmbu wdacva$ O ~cv cebqy yb lc`a ykcy lbyobm-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Cfyqcdd$ ~kam ~a iovlovvai yka ~oymavv$ ~kcy vka vycyai bm yka uafbui

    ov mby yavyolbm om axoiamfa-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykcm` bq$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Vamcybu Vbyyb- Ykcm` bq cdvb hbu yka fdcuohofcyobm-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Oh bq ~cmy yb lc`a c wubwau lbyobm$ ykam day oy ea vyuof`am bqy bh yka

    Uafbui-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykcm` bq$ _bqu Kbmbu- Fbmvoiauomn yka hcfy ykcy yka Kbmbuceda Fbllovvobmau bh

    yka namaucd cqioyomn bhhofa bh yka fbqmyu ~cv bm yka vycmi bmd yb fbmyomqa yka cddanai fubvv,a{clomcyobm

    bh yka Kbmbuceda Bleqivlcm$ cmi vomfa vka ov mby c ~oymavv aoykau hbu yka Wubvafqyobm bu yka Iahamva$

    kau yavyolbm----

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Mby hbu fubvv,a{clomcyobm$ yb fbmyomqa yka Wb~auWbomy wuavamycyobm-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- O ~cv bh yka olwuavvobm ykcy yka Wb~auWbomy wuavamycyobm kcv cduaci fdbvai$ _bqu

    Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Mb$ mby ay- Yka ~c O qmiauvybbi oy ov ykcy yka Kbmbuceda Bleqivlcm

    ~cv youai cmi vka ~cmyai vblabma yb yc`a bxau cmi fbmyomqa ~oyk yka Wb~auWbomy wuavamycyobm-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Eafcqva yka ycuwcqdom kcv cduaci eaam ubddai qw-

    Vamcybu Vbyyb- Yka vfuaam-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Oh ykcy ov yka fcva$ _bqu Kbmbu$ O vycmi fbuuafyai- O kcxa mb bejafyobm$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Eqy$ cy cm ucya$ vb ykcy ykaUafbui~odd ea fdacm cmi fdacu$ lc O uasqavy

    cmbma bh bq yb lc`a yka wubwau lbyobm yb vyuo`a bqy yka vycyalamy bh yka FBC Fbllovvobmau-

    Vamcybu Vbyyb- Lc ~a uafbnmoza Vamcybu Wolamyad$ Lu- Wuavoiamy-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Yka namydalcm hubl Lovclov Buoamycd ov uafbnmozai-

    Vamcybu Wolamyad OOO- Ykcm` bq$ Lu- Wuavoiamy- Yb ea hcou yb yka Iahamva voia$ _bqu Kbmbu$

    O lbxa yb vyuo`a bqy yka yavyolbm bh Luv- Kaoio Lamibzc ~kb ~cv ouuanqdcud wuavamyai avyauic-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Ov ykaua cm bejafyobm2 PVodamfa\ Yka Fkcou kacuv mbma$ yka lbyobm ov

    cwwubxai- Vyuo`a oy bqy hubl yka uafbui-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykcm` bq$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Vamcybu Vbyyb- Lu- Wuavoiamy$ yka Fbquy ov mb~ uaci hbu yka fbmyomqcyobm bh yka fubvv,a{clomcyobm

    bh yka Kbmbuceda Bleqivlcm$ Fbmfkoyc Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Vka ov kaua-

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    6/68

    8 YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Lcicl Bleqivlcm$ wdacva eacu ~oyk qv- a ib mby ~cmy yb bxauequiam

    bq eqy bq cua hclodocu ~oyk bqu jqiofocd wubfaiquav cmi ~a kcxa yb fbmyomqa$ oh yka Wubvafqyobm ~bqdi

    ~cmy yb fbmyomqa ykaou fubvv,a{clomcyobm-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Wubvafqyobm2

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- ^oyk bqu waulovvobm$ Lu- Wuavoiamy-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Wubfaai-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Nbbi chyaumbbm$ Lcicl Bleqivlcm-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Nbbi chyaumbbm-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- ^bqdi bq ~cmy yb fbmyomqa ~oyk yka Wb~auWbomy wuavamycyobm avyauic2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Vqua$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Yka Wb~auWbomy wuavamycyobm avyauic2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- ^oyk bqu waulovvobm$ Lu- Wuavoiamy-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- _av-

    Cua bq cv`omn ykcy yka Wb~auWbomy wuavamycyobm ea fbmyomqai2

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Nucmyai-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Ykcm` bq-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Lc O omxoya yka cyyamyobm bh yka wcuyoav cmi$ bh fbquva$ yka Vamcybu,Jqinav

    yb ~kcy cwwacuv bm yka vfuaam- Oy uahauv yb c vqllcu bh Q-V- ibddcu omhdb~v bh fbxauai yucmvcfyobm

    hubl Cwuod 39$ 5776 yb Iafaleau 55$ 5733-

    Yka EWO,Ycmicmn Vbuc Cffbqmy Mb- ;379 ov QV)6$136$69;-9>0 yka EWO,Ycmicmn Vbuc Cffbqmy

    Mb- 3;95 ov QV)138$367-9>0 yka EWO cdvb Ycmicmn Vbuc Cffbqmy Mb- 1?6? om yka clbqmy bh

    QV)3$663$173-960 ykam yka CEF bu Cddoai Ecm`omn Fbuwbucyobm,@clocv Cffbqmy Mb- 58>8 om yka

    clbqmy bh QV)5$?97$;17-1;0 cmi yka vqeybycd ov QV);$673$;67-?1- _bq cii ykov yb yka lovfaddcmabqvcffbqmyv om yka clbqmy bh QV)6$;16$13?-?3$ yb euomn c ybycd bh QV)35$311$617-;8-

    O ykom` ~a cua mb~ bm Cffbqmy Mb- ;379 om 577>-

    Day la a{wdcom ykcy yka ybycd bh QV)35 loddobm wdqv c ~koda cnb ~cv cuuoxai cy e ybycdomn yka omhdb~v

    cmi ybycdomn yka bqyhdb~v- Cmi oy ~bqdi cwwacu ykcy yka bqyhdb~v ~bqdi ea eonnau ykcm yka omhdb~v$ ~kofk

    lacmv yka ~oykiuc~cdv ~bqdi ea eonnau ykcm yka clbqmy bh omhdb~v-

    ^a qvai c fbmvauxcyoxa cmcdvov ~kaua oh ykaua cua ibqeda$ yuowda bu lqdyowda amyuoav bh yka vcla

    clbqmy$ ~a ~bqdi a{fdqia ykbva hubl yka ibddcu fblwqycyobm cmi ~bqdi omfdqia bmd yka dcvy honqua cy

    yka ami bh yka ffda-

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    7/68

    YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735 >

    Hbu a{clwda$ ykaua ov ykov lbykau iawbvoy Cffbqmy C- Ykam vb lqfk bu yka vcla clbqmy bm yka

    vcla icya ov yucmvhauuai yb Cffbqmy E0 ykam$ cncom$ bm yka vcla icya$ yka vcla clbqmy ov yucmvhauuai

    yb cmbykau cffbqmy$ Cffbqmy F0 ykam homcdd$ hbu yka hbquyk amyu$ yka vcla clbqmy bm yka vcla icya$

    oy ov yucmvhauuai yb Cffbqmy A- Vb$ bmd yka dcvy honqua om yka dcvy cffbqmy ~kaua yka ffda vybwv ykcy

    ov omfdqiai om yka fblwqycyobm- Cmi vb ~kam ~a cuuoxai cy QV)35 loddobm wdqv cv yucmvcfyobmcd ecdcmfa$

    ~a ioi mby omfdqia yka vb lcm amyuoav ykcy cwwacuai bm yka vcla icya cmi$ cv O vcoi$ ~a bmd omfdqiai

    ykbva honquav ykcy amiai om yka dcvy ami bh yka ffda-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Ykava cua mby yka QV)35 loddobm wdqv lamyobmai hbu 5778$ ~cv oy2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Hbu cv bh Iafaleau 5733$ _bqu Kbmbu2

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- _av-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Ykava cua yucmvcfyobmcd ecdcmfav-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- _av$ yucmvcfyobmcd ecdcmfa-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av-Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Ykcy ov mby c acud cmi cmmqcd amiomn ecdcmfa-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Mb$ _bqu Kbmbu$ oy fblwuakamiai yka amyoua mqleau bh yucmvcfyobmv hubl

    5776 yb Iafaleau 5733-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Eqy ykaua ~cv mb clbqmy uafbuiai uancuiomn yka cfyqcd ecdcmfa ualcomomn

    om yka lbykau cffbqmy cv bh yka ami bh Iafaleau 63$ 5733-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Oy ~bqdi ea iohhofqdy yb fblwqya$ eqy ~a yuoai cdvb yb iayauloma e$ day qv

    vc$ om 5733$ yka ualcomomn----Om 577;$ ykaua ~cv c iawbvoy bh QV)>8;$>66-?8- Ykov uahauv yb yka

    WVEcm`,@cyowqmcm Eucmfk cmi oy ~cv ~oykiuc~m bmd bm Iafaleau 31$ 5735$ cmi ykcy oadiai cybycd----5733 ucykau$ O cl vbuu- Cmi ykcy oadiai c ecdcmfa bh QV)>8?$8;3->3- Ykcy ov bmd ~oyk

    uavwafy yb bma WVEcm`,@cyowqmcm Cffbqmy Eucmfk Mb- 73?37776>6- Ykov ov jqvy bma cffbqmy-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Ov ykaua cm uafbui bh cm ecdcmfa bh ykov lbykau cffbqmy cv bh yka ami

    bh Mbxaleau 57332

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Iafaleau$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Mb$ yka 33yk lbmyk bh yka acu-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- ^a fcm wuavqla yka vcla ecdcmfa$ _bqu Kbmbu$ eafcqva oy lbxai bmd

    om Iafaleau----

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- O ~odd wqy yka sqavyobm om cmbykau hbul- ^kcy ~cv yka ybycd clbqmy

    ~oykiuc~m om yka lbmyk bh Iafaleau hubl yka lbykau cffbqmy2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Iafaleau 5733$ _bqu Kbmbu2

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- _av-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ QV)>8?$8;3->3- Vb$ ~a wuavqla ykcy$ yb bqu sqavyobm acudoau$

    _bqu Kbmbu$ oh ~kcy ~cv yka clbqmy ~oykiuc~m om Mbxaleau 5733-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Ykcy ~cv yka clbqmy ~oykiuc~m om yka lbmyk bh Iafaleau-

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    8/68

    ; YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu$ hubl yka vcla cffbqmy ~kofk ~cv bwamai om Bfybeau

    63$ 577;-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Cdd uonky$ Fbqmvad- _bq lc fbmyomqa$ Lcicl-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    O ykom` ~a cua mb~ om Cffbqmy Mb- ;379,577>-

    Bm Jqd ?$ 577>$ ykaua ~cv c ~oykiuc~cd hubl Cffbqmy Mb- ;379 om yka clbqmy bh )5?1$881-95-

    Yka vqffaaiomn lbmyk$ bu bm Cqnqvy ?$ 577>$ ykaua ~cv c iawbvoy bh )5?8$>5;-??-

    Mb~$ bm Jqd 3?$ 577>$ ykaua ~cv c ~oykiuc~cd bh )57$777$ cmi bm Cqnqvy 56$ 577>$ ykaua ~cv

    c iawbvoy hubl Cffbqmy Mb- 58?6 yb yka lbykau cffbqmy$ ;379-

    Bm Jqd 5>$ 577>$ ykaua ~cv c ~oykiuc~cd hubl yka lbykau cffbqmy om yka clbqmy bh )377$777

    ~kofk ~cv iawbvoyai om cmbykau cffbqmy$ 5;79- Cmi bm Cqnqvy 63$ 577>$ ykaua ~cv c iawbvoy bh

    )377$9?9-8?-

    Bm Cqnqvy 56$ 577>$ ykaua ~cv c ~oykiuc~cd bh )57$7>8-99 hubl c iohhauamy cffbqmy$ 63;63?6-Cmi bm Vawyaleau 6$ 577>$ ykaua ~cv c iawbvoy yb yka lbykau cffbqmy om yka clbqmy bh )57$8;5-;6-

    Bm Vawyaleau 6$ 577>$ ykaua ~cv c ~oykiuc~cd hubl yka lbykau cffbqmy om yka clbqmy bh

    )97$7;5-?6 cmi iawbvoyai yb c ma~ cffbqmy- Cmi bm Lcufk 6$ 577;$ hubl ykov ma~ cffbqmy ~cv

    ~oykiuc~m yka clbqmy bh )97$?>6-3; cmi iawbvoyai yb yka lbykau cffbqmy-

    Bm Cqnqvy ?$ 577>$ ykaua ~cv c ~oykiuc~cd hubl yka lbykau cffbqmy om yka clbqmy bh )5?8$>5;-??

    cmi oy ~cv iawbvoyai yb c ma~ cffbqmy$ 5?;>- Cmi bm Mbxaleau ;$ 577>$ yka clbqmy bh )5??$?6>-;8

    ~cv ~oykiuc~m hubl ykov ma~ cffbqmy cmi uayqumai yb yka lbykau cffbqmy-

    Bm Jqd 63$ 577>$ yka clbqmy bh )367$996-65 ~cv ~oykiuc~m hubl yka lbykau cffbqmy cmi

    iawbvoyai yb c ma~ cffbqmy- Cmi bm Lcufk 9$ 577;$ yka clbqmy bh )366$19>-8> ~cv ~oykiuc~m hublyka ma~ cffbqmy cmi uayqumai yb yka lbykau cffbqmy-

    Bm Cqnqvy 63$ 577>$ yka clbqmy bh )377$9?9-8? ~cv ~oykiuc~m hubl yka lbykau cffbqmy cmi

    yucmvhauuai yb c ma~ cffbqmy- Cmi bm Haeuqcu 5?$ 577;$ hubl ykov ma~ cffbqmy ~cv ~oykiuc~m yka

    clbqmy bh )375$869-?> cmi iawbvoyai yb yka lbykau cffbqmy-

    Bm Mbxaleau ?$ 577>$ yka clbqmy bh )5??$?6>-;8 ~cv ~oykiuc~m cmi iawbvoyai yb c ma~

    cffbqmy-

    Bm Iafaleau 53$ 577>$ yka clbqmy bh )17$777 ~cv ~oykiuc~m hubl yka lbykau cffbqmy cmi

    iawbvoyai yb c ma~ cffbqmy- Cmi bm Jcmqcu 51$ 577;$ yka clbqmy bh )17$559-;6 ~cv ~oykiuc~m

    hubl yka ma~ cffbqmy cmi uayqumai yb yka lbykau cffbqmy-

    Vyodd yka vcla cffbqmy$ ;379$ ykov ov hbu 577;-

    Bm Lcufk 1$ 577;$ yka clbqmy bh )67$677 ~cv iawbvoyai yb yka lbykau cffbqmy-

    Bm Cwuod 3>$ 577;$ yka clbqmy bh )59$777 ~cv iawbvoyai yb yka lbykau cffbqmy-

    Cmi bm Jqd 63$ 577;$ yka clbqmy bh )67$777 ~cv iawbvoyai yb yka lbykau cffbqmy-

    Bm Jcmqcu 5;$ 577;$ yka clbqmy bh )17$559-;6 ~cv ~oykiuc~m hubl yka lbykau cffbqmy cmi

    yucmvhauuai yb c ma~ cffbqmy- Cmi hubl ykov ma~ cffbqmy ~cv ~oykiuc~m yka clbqmy bh )13$38>->7

    bm Cqnqvy 1$ 577;$ cmi oy ualcomai ~oykiuc~m-

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    9/68

    YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735 ?

    Bm Lcufk 6$ 577;$ yka clbqmy bh )396$87;-31 ~cv ~oykiuc~m hubl yka lbykau cffbqmy cmi

    iawbvoyai yb c ma~ cffbqmy- Cmi hubl ykov ma~ cffbqmy ~cv ~oykiuc~m yka clbqmy bh )399$?9>->?

    bm Jqd >$ 577;-

    Bm Lcufk 1$ 577;$ yka clbqmy bh )3>1$777 ~cv ~oykiuc~m hubl yka lbykau cffbqmy cmi

    yucmvhauuai yb c ma~ cffbqmy- Cmi hubl ykov ma~ cffbqmy ~cv ~oykiuc~m yka clbqmy bh )3>8$183-97

    bm Jqd ?$ 577;-

    Bm Cwuod 3>$ 577;$ yka clbqmy bh )57$777 ~cv ~oykiuc~m hubl yka lbykau cffbqmy cmi iawbvoyai

    yb c ma~ cffbqmy- Cmi hubl ykov ma~ cffbqmy ~cv ~oykiuc~m yka clbqmy bh )59$375-86 bm Jqma 58$

    577;-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Lcicl Bleqivlcm$ cl O uonky ykcy yka Wb~auWbomy wuavamycyobm bq cua uaciomn

    hubl mb~$ c kcui fbw ~cv cduaci vamy yb yka Vamcya2 Kcxa ~a hqumovkai yka fbw bh ykcy uawbuy yb

    yka Vamcya2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- O uafcdd ykcy yka Vamcya cy yka fdbvomn kbquv bh avyauicv kacuomnv

    a{wafyai qv yb iadoxau c kcui fbw- Cmi O ykom` ~a ioi$ ykcy ~cv l omvyuqfyobm-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Lcicl Bleqivlcm-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Ykcy eaomn vb$ waukcwv$ oy ~bqdi ea eayyau oh ~a ~odd jqvy lcu` yka Wb~auWbomy

    wuavamycyobm om axoiamfa- Cmi yb iovwamva ~oyk bqu uaciomn bh yka iaycodv eafcqva bq lonky ea bxaud

    yc{ai e ykcy cmi O ib mby ykom` oy ov mafavvcu eafcqva yka Vamcybu,Jqinav fcm a{cloma yka fbmyamyv

    bh yka uawbuy bquvadh-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _bqu Kbmbu$ wdacva-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- _av-

    Lu- Fqaxcv-O cl mby fdacu ~oyk yka lcmohavycyobm lcia e yka Kbmbuceda Fbqmvad hbu yka

    Wubvafqyobm- ^kofk ov yka axoiamfa vbqnky yb ea lcu`ai$ yka uawuavamycyobmv lcia bm yka vfuaam$ yka

    buonom bh ykava uawuavamycyobmv bu ~kcy2 ^a ~cmyai yb ea fdacu$ _bqu Kbmbu$ eahbua ~a nb omyb hquykau

    sqavyobmomn yka ^oymavv om fbmmafyobm ~oyk ykal-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- ^k ib bq mby cnuaa2 Oh bq ~cmy yb qva yka ibfqlamy wuavamyai

    avyauic e yka Bleqivlcm ~kofk ov cddanaid yka uawbuy bh yka CLDF cv yka ibfqlamy yb ea

    wuavamyai kaua cv cm a{koeoy$ eqy bm yka bykau kcmi$ ykov Wb~auWbomy wuavamycyobm ov mb~ c wcuy bh yka

    yavyolbm bh yka Bleqivlcm- Cmi vb$ ykov Fbquy ~bqdi ea omyauavyai yb kcxa c fbw bh ykov ibfqlamy-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Yka vbqufa bh cdd ykov Wb~auWbomy wuavamycyobm$ _bqu Kbmbu2Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- _av-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- O cl jqvy cv`omn hbu c fdcuohofcyobm- O cl mby bejafyomn----

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Cfyqcdd$ ykava cua cfyqcdd fqddaioh O qmiauvybbi yka Bleqivlcm

    fbuuafydfqddai hubl yka uafbuiv

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Vqeloyyai-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- ykcy vka vqeloyyai avyauic cmi lcu`ai cv cm a{koeoy e yka

    Wubvafqyobm- Cl O fbuuafy om ykov2

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    10/68

    37 YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- O ~cv wqzzdai eafcqva yka ibfqlamyv vkb~m yb yka ^oymavv avyauic$ ~a cduaci

    lcu`ai$ _bqu Kbmbu- Vb$ O ~cv yuomn yb fdcuoh bmd- O cl mby bejafyomn$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Wuafovad$ yka Bleqivlcm$ l qmiauvycmiomn bh ~kcy kcwwamai ~cv$ yka

    Bleqivlcm yavyohoai$ cmi om yka fbquva bh kau yavyolbm$ uahauuai yb c uawbuy bh CLDF$ ~kofk eafclayka ecvov bh kau dayyau$ oh O qmiauvybbi fbuuafyd$ uasqouomn yka Fkoah Jqvyofa yb uawd om >5 kbquv- Ykcy

    ~cv yka vqejafy bh yka a{clomcyobm,om,fkoah bh yka Iahamva fbqmvad$ ~kaykau yka Bleqivlcm omhbulai

    yka Fkoah Jqvyofa cebqy yka )37,loddobm iawbvoy cddanaid b~mai e kol- Cmi cy ykcy wbomy$ yka lcyyau

    ~cv uavbdxai cmi ykam yka Fbqmvad fdbvai kov iouafy a{clomcyobm bh yka Bleqivlcm$ cmi yka

    Wubvafqyobm ybb` bxau yb fubvv a{cloma-

    Cmi cy ykcy wbomy$ yka kcxa lcu`ai---- Cfyqcdd$ yka Wubvafqyobm lcu`ai yka cddanai uawbuy bh

    CLDF$ wuavamyai cmi yavyohoai yb e yka Bleqivlcm eahbua ykov Fbquy- Cmi yka Kbmbuceda

    Bleqivlcm uasqavyai yka waulovvobm bh ykov Fbquy oh vka fbqdi a{wdcom hquykau yka fbmyamyv bh ykcy

    cddanai uawbuy bh CLDF e ~c bh vkb~omn qv c Wb~auWbomy wuavamycyobm bh yka lbxalamy bh yka

    lbmoav uahdafyai om ykcy uawbuy bh CLDF- Cl O fbuuafy om ykov$ Lcicl Bleqivlcm2Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Ykcy ov yka ~kbda novy bh yka yavyolbm bh yka Bleqivlcm- Cmi ykcy ov

    ~k ykov Fkcou uasqavyai ykcy ykov Fbquy ea wubxoiai ~oyk c kcui fbw bh yka Wb~auWbomy wuavamycyobm

    cmi yka Iahamva cdvb uasqavyai c fbw$ c kcui fbw bh yka wuavamycyobm cmi ykauachyau$ yka Wubvafqyobm

    cdvb uasqavyai c kcui fbw- Vb$ cdd bh qv uasqavyai c fbw bh yka Wb~auWbomy wuavamycyobm-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Fdcuohoai$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Cdd uonky-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Oh _bqu Kbmbu wdacva- Yka Wb~auWbomy wuavamycyobm

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Wb~auWbomy- O cl vbuu$ O cl mby doyaucya ambqnk om ykava ykomnv-

    Wb~auWbomy wuavamycyobm$ b`c-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Oh bqu Kbmbu wdacva$ yka Wb~auWbomy wuavamycyobm ykcy kcv eaam lcia cmi ov vyodd

    eaomn lcia e yka Kbmbuceda Bleqivlcm ov amyoydai: Cmcdvov bh Ibddcu Cffbqmy fbmvovyomn bh 51

    vdoiav- O fbmhoulai ~oyk yka Fdau` bh Fbquy ykcy yka Vamcybu,Jqinav kcxa acfk eaam hqumovkai ~oyk

    fbwoav bh ykov vb,fcddai Cmcdvov bh Ibddcu Cffbqmy- Cmi yka fbw ~kofk kcv eaam kcmiai yb la

    e yka Kbmbuceda Bleqivlcm$ acfk wcna eacuv yka vyclw: Fauyohoai Yuqa Fbw$ Iawqy Fdau` bh

    Fbquy$ yka Olwacfklamy Wubfaaiomnv$ cmi ykaua ~cv bma omoyocd bxau acfk vyclw bh Iawqy Fdau` bh

    Fbquy-

    Lc ~a uasqavy ykcy ykov ea lcu`ai cv A{koeoy Adaxam _ +___________/ hbu yka

    Wubvafqyobm$ _bqu Kbmbu2

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Lcu` oy cffbuiomnd-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Lcicl Bleqivlcm$ bq yavyohoai$ c ha~ lomqyav cnb$ om uawd yb yka sqau bh yka

    Wuavoiomn Jqina ykcy )>8?$8;3 ~cv ~oykiuc~m hubl cm cffbqmy bh yka Fkoah Jqvyofa om yka lbmyk bh

    Iafaleau 5733$ bq fbmhoul ykcy2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ Vou-

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    11/68

    YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735 33

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Fcm bq cixova qv bu yadd qv kb~ lqfk ~cv ~oykiuc~m hubl Iafaleau 35

    hbu~cui2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Mb lbua$ oy ioi mby nb e cmlbua- O lacm$ yka icyc ykcy ~cv vbqufai

    mb dbmnau omiofcyai ~kaua ykcy )>8?$777 wdqv ~amy-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Vb$ bq ~odd mby ea ceda yb yadd oh oy ~cv ibma bm Iafaleau 352Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Iafaleau 31-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Iafaleau 31-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- O vaa- Vb$ ykcy clbqmy bh )>8?$8;3 ~cv ~oykiuc~m bm Iafaleau 31-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- _bq yavyohoai avyauic ykcy ykaua ~aua vonmohofcmy cffbqmyv ~oyk uavwafy yb fauycom

    vonmohofcmy axamyv- Ib bq uafcdd ykcy$ Lcicl Bleqivlcm2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ Vou-

    Lu- Ecqyovyoc- Fcm bq fdcuoh ~kcy bq lacmy e ykcy2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- ^add$ ~kcy O lacmy ~cv ykcy ykaua ~aua vonmohofcmy iawbvoyv cmi

    ~oykiuc~cdv bm vonmohofcmy axamyv- ^kam O vc axamyv$ O cl uahauuomn yb day qv vc$ 5779 adafyobmv$

    577> adafyobmv$ cmi iquomn yka wauobi bmvay bh yka olwacfklamy wubfaaiomnv-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Hbu yka adafyobmv bh 5779$ Lcicl Bleqivlcm$ ~kofk bq fbmvoiauai yb ea c

    vonmohofcmy axamy$ ~kcy ~cv yka fbuuavwbmiomn vonmohofcmy honqua2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Day la dbb` cy l fbionb-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Xcnqa$ _bqu Kbmbu- Yka sqavyobm ibav mby cwwacu fdacu yb qv- Lc ~a uasqavy

    hbu c uahbulomn bh yka sqavyobm$ _bqu Kbmbu2

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- ^kcy ov xcnqa cebqy oy2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykaua cua xcuobqv omfoiamyv lamyobmai om yka sqavyobm$ _bqu Kbmbu- ^a ~bqdi do`a

    yb `mb~ ~kcy ov yka novy bh yka sqavyobm$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- ^odd yka nbbi namydalcm bh yka Wubvafqyobm uawacy yka sqavyobm vb ykcy

    ~a ~odd qmiauvycmi yka mcyqua bh yka bejafyobm2

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- O cv`ai ~kcy ~aua yka vonmohofcmy honquav wauycomomn yb yka vonmohofcmy axamyv ~kofk

    yka Kbmbuceda Bleqivlcm lamyobmai- ^kcy cua yka honquav2

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Vka lamyobmai cv axamyv yka adafyobm bh 5779-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Ykcy ov uonky$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Cmi ykam yka olwacfklamy hodai om ykov Fbquy-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu- Cmi yka adafyobmv om 577>-

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    12/68

    35 YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Cmi ykam yka adafyobm om 577>-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- _av- Cmi O cl jqvy cv`omn yka ^oymavv ~kam vka vcoi ykcy ykaua ~aua vonmohofcmy

    clbqmyv wauycomomn yb c vonmohofcmy axamy$ ~kcy cua ykava clbqmyv- O ykom` ykcy ov xau fdacu- Om hcfy$

    yka ^oymavv kcv mby vcoi yka sqavyobm ov xcnqa-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Day yka ^oymavv cmv~au-Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ Vou- Om Lc 35$ ykaua ~cv c----

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Lc 35 ~kam$ _bqu Kbmbu2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- 5739$ mb$ ucykau 5779$ ykaua ~cv c iawbvoy bh )177$777 cy Ecm` bh WO

    Cfubwbdov- Bm Lc 39$ 5779$ ~a cua cdd ycd`omn bh ibddcuv$ ibddcu,vwb`amomn$ om bykau ~buiv- Bm

    Lc 39$ ykaua ~cv c iawbvoy bh )177$777-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Lc O cv` ykov sqavyobm yb fdcuoh- Ov ykaua cm vkb~omn ~kb lcia yka

    iawbvoy omyb ykcy iawbvoy cffbqmy2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Ykaua ov mbma$ _bqu Kbmbu- Lcea oy ov bmd yka ecm`v ~kofk fcmiayauloma-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Yka uafbuiv bh yka ecm` ~bqdi vkb~-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Lcea$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- E yka ~c$ cua ykava iawbvoy cffbqmyv omyauavy,eacuomn iawbvoyv2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- O vqwwbva vb$ _bqu Kbmbu- Vbla-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Cmi ykaua lqvy ea c uafbui bh ~oykkbdiomn bh yka 57! homcd yc{-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Yka ecm` ~bqdi ea ceda yb amdonkyam qv bm yka lcyyau$ _bqu Kbmbu$

    eafcqva ~a kcxa mb ibfqlamyv yb ecf` qw ykov uafbui bh yucmvcfyobmv-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- _av$ wdacva nb ckaci-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Bm 577>$ bm Lc 6$ ykaua ~cv c iawbvoy bh )5?6$891-56 cy yka Ecm`

    bh yka Wkodowwoma Ovdcmiv om Vcm Hucmfovfb iad Lbmya-

    Bm Lc 6----

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- E yka ~c$ ib ~a `mb~ yka a{fkcmna ucya cy ykcy yola$ Lcicl2 Oh

    ykava cua om ibddcuv$ ~kcy ~bqdi ea ykaou asqoxcdamy clbqmyv om wavbv2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- O ib mby `mb~$ _bqu Kbmbu- Eqy$ O ykom`$ cy ykcy yola yka a{fkcmna ucya

    ~cv lqfk konkau ykcm yka wuavamy ucya bh a{fkcmna mb~-

    Cdd uonky$ bm Lc 6$ 577>$ ykaua ~cv c iawbvoy cy yka EWO$ cncom$ Vcm Hucmfovfb iad Lbmya Eucmfk$

    om yka clbqmy bh )51$76?- Mb$ ucykau----

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Fcm bq vc ykcy cncom$ Lcicl$ QV)51$777 bu )517$7772

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Bm Lc 1$ mb$ mb$ Lc 6$ ucykau 577>$ ykaua ~cv c iawbvoy bh

    QV)5>$76?-;7 cy yka Ecm` bh yka Wkodowwoma Ovdcmiv$ Vcm Hucmfovfb iad Lbmya0 bm Lc 6$ cncom$ ykaua

    ~cv c iawbvoy bh )369$876-5;$ cncom cy yka EWO$ Vcm Hucmfovfb iad Lbmya0 bm Lc 6$ cncom$ ykaua

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    13/68

    YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735 36

    ~cv c iawbvoy bh )86$691-83 cy yka EWO$ VHIL cmi cncom$ Lc 6$ ykaua ~cv c iawbvoy bh )16$1>5->3

    cy yka vcla ecm` om EWO$ Vcm Hucmfovfb iad Lbmya-

    Cncom$ bm Lc 1$ vyodd yka vclamb$ mb$ mb$ oy ov mby Lc 1- Yka cua volwd ybb lomqya yb ea

    uaci e yka mc`ai aa$ cdykbqnk$ O cduaci kcxa----

    Bm Lc 6$ vyodd yka vcla Lc 6$ ykaua ~cv c iawbvoy bh )31$7;6-;6 cy yka EWO$ Vcm Hucmfovfbiad Lbmya Eucmfk-

    Cmi ykcy ov cdd$ _bqu Kbmbu$ ibddcu cffbqmy-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Kb~ cebqy hbu yka Iafaleau 5733 wauobi$ bq cduaci lamyobmai kb~ lqfk

    )>8?$8;3-772

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Cdd uonky$ ykov ov c fbmvauxcyoxa avyolcya bh yka ybycd hqmiv ykcy ~aua lbxai

    iquomn yka olwacfklamy ~aa`-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- _av$ Lcicl-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Bm Iafaleau 35$ uanqdcu yuqvy hqmi fbmyuoeqyobm$ wdcfalamy$ omxavylamy$om yka clbqmy bh )93>$?>;-;70 bm Iafaleau 35 yb 36$ ykaua ~cv cm amfcvklamy fbmxauyai yb wavbv

    )361$61?-730 bm Iafaleau 36$ ykaua ~cv wqufkcva bh Lcmcnauv Fkaf` IIYY om yka clbqmy bh

    )6;;$>>3-550 bm Iafaleau 36---

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- ^kcy ov ykcy2 Ibddcuv2 Wavbv2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- ^add$ O cl vyodd vwac`omn bh ibddcuv$ _bqu Kbmbu- ^a ioi mby ybqfk bm

    yka wavb cffbqmy eafcqva yka vqewbamc doloyai yka ibfqlamy ykcy vkbqdi ea wuavamyai ~oyk uavwafy yb

    ibddcu cffbqmyv-

    Bm Iafaleau 36$ vyodd yka vcla Iafaleau 36$ vqeyucfyai hubl Cffbqmy Mb- 31;;7536;8$uahdafyai cv iaeoy lalb- Fuaioy yucmvcfyobm ov mby wubxoiai- Yka clbqmy bh QV)35$;;;-8> ov uahdafyai-

    Bm Iafaleau 31$ vafquoyoav ~aua vbdi om yka clbqmy bh QV)981$777-

    Bm Iafaleau 31$ ykaua ~cv c iaeoy lalb hubl cm cffbqmy cmi oy ybycdv QV)>5$75?-66-

    Bm Iafaleau 31$ ykaua ~cv c ~oykiuc~cd hubl yka vcla cffbqmy$ QV)696$3?5-85- Vyodd bm

    Iafaleau 31$ ykaua ~cv cm a{favv bh fuaioyv vyodd bm yka vcla cffbqmy om yka clbqmy bh QV)9$91?->8-

    Bm Iafaleau 3?$ ykaua ~cv wqufkcva bh Lcmcnauv Fkaf` IIYY om yka clbqmy bh QV)9;>$??;-7?-

    Bm Iafaleau 3?$ ykaua ~cv a{favv bh iawbvoyv om c iohhauamy cffbqmy om yka clbqmy bh

    QV)55$??;-7?- Cmi bm Iafaleau 57$ ykaua ~aua iaeoy lalbv hubl c iohhauamy cffbqmy om yka clbqmybh QV)8;>$89;-11- Vb$ yka ybycd ualoyycmfa om Iafaleau----^a cii ykov yb yka bqy~cui ualoyycmfa bh

    QV)617$777 ~bqdi noxa c ybycd bh QV)6$6;;$656-39-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Fcm bq yadd qv$ Lcicl Bleqivlcm$ ~kofk ecm`v ~aua omxbdxai om ykava

    ~oykiuc~cdv2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Ykov ov Cddoai Ecm`omn Fbuwbucyobm +CEF/-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Jqvy bma ecm`-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- EWO-

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    14/68

    39 YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- EWO cmi Cddoai Ecm`-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Wkodowwoma Vcxomnv +WV/-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Vb$ oy ov WVEcm`$ Cddoai Ecm` cmi EWO-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Vb$ ykuaa +6/ ecm`v-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Cmi ykava ~oykiuc~cdv ybb` wdcfa hubl Iafaleau 35 yb Iafaleau 572

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Y~amy,y~b$ oy vcv kaua-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- O cv`ai avyauic Fbllovvobmau Lamibzc oh yka ioi c vyqi bh yka wavb cffbqmyv

    bh yka Fkoah Jqvyofa cmi bq cua mb~ vcomn bq ioi mby-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Ykaua ~cv cfyqcdd c vyqi bh yka wavb cffbqmyv- Eqy vomfa yka vqewbamc

    doloyai yka wubiqfyobm bh ibfqlamyv eacuomn bm yka ibddcu cffbqmyv vb ~a jqvy eubqnky ibfqlamyv

    eacuomn bm yka ibddcu cffbqmyv-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Vb bq ib mby kcxa ~oyk bq$ Lcicl$ bqu uafbuiv uancuiomn yka wavb cffbqmyv

    bu ib bq kcxa ykal ~oyk bq2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Oy ov uahdafyai om yka vcla ibfqlamy ykcy ~a vbqufai hubl yka CLDF-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Ib bq kcxa cm vqllcu bh yka konkdonkyv bh yka wavb cffbqmyv2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- O ioi mby euomn oy ~oyk la$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Ykcm` bq- Oh _bqu Kbmbu$ wdacva$ lc ~a cv` hbu dacxa hbu yka Bleqivlcmyb euomn yka icyc cmi yka vqllcuoav bh yka wavb cffbqmyv2

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Cua bq nbomn yb lc`a yka Bleqivlcm bqu ~oymavv2

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Jqvy c uavauxcyobm$ _bqu Kbmbu$ wdacva- Jqvy c uavauxcyobm-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ka ov mb~ bm fubvv$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Ualaleau bq cua bm fubvv,a{clomcyobm- O ykom` bq `mb~ yka uqdav-

    _bq ~cmy yb fbmxauy yka Bleqivlcm cv bqu ~oymavv cmi uasqoua yka wuavamycyobm bh ibfqlamyv$ ykam

    bq kcxa yb ib yka mafavvcu lbyobmv-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- O ~oykiuc~ ykcy$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Cdd uonky-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Lc O wubfaai-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- ^oykiuc~-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Lcicl oymavv$ bq acudoau vcoi ykcy bq uafaoxai ykuaa +6/ fblwdcomyv hubl Uovc

    Ecucsqad,Kbmyoxaubv$ ^cdiam Eaddb$ ay fayauc- Ib bq fbmhoul ykcy2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu-

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    15/68

    YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735 31

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Chyau bq uafaoxai yka fblwdcomyv$ ~kcy ioi bq ib2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Houvy$ ~kam O uafaoxai yka houvy fblwdcomy$ O axcdqcyai oy cmi O ykbqnky ykcy$

    cncom$ O vcoi ykcy avyauic$ O ~bqdi uahau yka fblwdcomyv yb yka CLDF om donky bh l olwuavvobm ykcy

    vbla bh yka fkcunav ~aua ~oykom yka jquoviofyobm bh yka CLDF-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- ^kam bq uahauuai yka lcyyau hbu cvvovycmfa hubl yka CLDF$ ioi bq ib ykov om~uoyomn2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Ib bq kcxa c fbw bh ykcy2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ O kcxa-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Lc O vaa$ wdacva-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- P^oymavv vkb~omn yka dayyau-\

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Hbu yka uafbui$ yka Lcicl Bleqivlcm kcv noxam la c dayyau icyai 53 Haeuqcu5735 qmiau yka dayyaukaci bh yka Bleqivlcm cwwcuamyd iqd vonmai e yka Bleqivlcm kauvadh

    ciiuavvai yb Clcmib L- Yaycmnfb Ju-$ Fkcoulcm$ Cmyo,Lbma Dcqmiauomn Fbqmfod-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Day la a{wdcom ykcy- Ykcy ~cv yka houvy dayyau O vamy yb yka CLDF-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Lcicl$ ib bq kcxa c fauyohoai yuqa fbw2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Lc ~a ea cddb~ai yb vaa yka ibfqlamy eaomn uahauuai yb$ _bqu Kbmbu$ eahbua

    cm hquykau sqavyobm ov wubwbqmiai yb yka ^oymavv2

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Nucmyai- Vkb~ oy yb yka Iahamva fbqmvad-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Oy ov cduaci fauyohoai-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Lc ~a uasqavy ykcy yka fauyohoai yuqa fbw bh yka vcoi Haeuqcu 53$ 5735 dayyau

    ea lcu`ai cv A{koeoy Adaxam Z +ZZZZZZZZZZZ/-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Lcu` oy cffbuiomnd-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Cvoia hubl ykov dayyau yb yka CLDF$ bq lamyobmai ykcy bq ~ubya c vafbmi dayyau$

    Lcicl Bleqivlcm2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ ykcy ov uonky$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Bm ~kcy icya2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- O ~ubya c dayyau bm Haeuqcu 59$ 5735-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Ib bq kcxa c fbw bh ykcyfauyohoai yuqa fbw2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ O kcxa$ Haeuqcu 59$ 5735-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- ^oymavv kcv kcmiai yb Fbqmvad c dayyau icyai Haeuqcu 59$ 5735$ do`a~ova qmiau

    yka dayyaukaci bh yka Bhhofa bh yka Bleqivlcm$ vonmai e yka Bleqivlcm$ ciiuavvai yb Clcmib L-

    Yaycmnfb Ju-$ Fkcoulcm$ Cmyo,Lbma Dcqmiauomn Fbqmfod- Cmi ykaua ov c vyclwai fauyohoai yka fbw

    bh yka buonomcd bm hoda-

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    16/68

    38 YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735

    Lc ~a cv` ykcy ykov dayyau ea lcu`ai cv A{koeoy Y~adxa C +CCCCCCCCCCCC/

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Lcu` oy cffbuiomnd-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- ^omvybm$ fcm bq vkb~ c fbw yb ykal2

    Lcicl Bleqivlcm$ lc O cv`$ ~k ioi bq ~uoya ykava dayyauv yb yka CLDF2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- ^add$ houvy$ qmiau Vafyobm 58 bh yka Bleqivlcm Cfy$ O cl cqykbuozai yb

    vaa` yka cvvovycmfa bh bykau nbxaumlamy cnamfoav- Vafbmid$ yka Fkoah Jqvyofa kolvadh cqykbuozai yka

    Bleqivlcm om kov VCDM yb iayauloma hubl bykau nbxaumlamy cnamfoav cm cvvayv$ cm wubwauyoav$

    doceodoyoav$ may ~buyk bu eqvomavv omyauavy hubl yka yola ka jbomai yka nbxaumlamy qw yb yka wuavamy- Cmi

    vb$ ykcy ~cv yka fdomfkau- O ykbqnky O vkbqdi ~uoya c dayyau yb yka CLDF om buiau yb vaa` kadw hbu cm

    cvvovycmfa bu hbu cm ibfqlamyv ykcy kcxa c eacuomn bm yka fkcunav cncomvy yka Fkoah Jqvyofa-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- ^kcy omhbulcyobm ioi bq a{wafy yb beycom hubl yka CLDF2 ^k yka CLDF2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- ^add$ eafcqva oh bq uaci yka fblwdcomy ykaua ~cv vblaykomn cebqy

    xobdcyobm bh Cmyo,Lbma Dcqmiauomn Dc~ cmi om donky bh yka hcfy ykcy ykaua ~cv cdvb c fkcuna bhqma{wdcomai ~acdyk$ O ykbqnky ykcy O wubeced fbqdi ncykau hubl yka CLDF fauycom ecm` yucmvcfyobmv-

    _bq vaa$--- ~add$ O cl vbuu$ O ~odd mby cii yb ykcy-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- _av- Cv c hbulau jqvyofa bh yka Vqwuala Fbquy cmi yka wuavamy Bleqivlcm bh

    yka Uawqedof bh yka Wkodowwomav$ O wuavqla ykcy bq cua hcoud hclodocu ~oyk yka dc~ bm CLDF-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- ^kcy wcuyofqdcu cvwafy bh yka dc~ cua bq cv`omn la yb ea hclodocu ~oyk2

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Fbqdi bq yadd qv ~kcy ov yka ecvof uavwbmvoeodoy bu hqmfyobm bh yka CLDF2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Ecm`v cua vqwwbvai yb uawbuy yb yka CLDF cm yucmvcfyobmv lbua ykcm

    177$777- Om bykau ~buiv$ 177$777 wdqv-Lu- Ecqyovyc- Wavbv-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Wavbv$ uonky-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Wavbv-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ ~kofk ov fcddai c fbxauai yucmvcfyobm- Mb~$ yka ecm`v cua bedoncyai

    yb omhbul yka CLDF cebqy ykava fbxauai yucmvcfyobmv$ 177 wdqv ykbqvcmi wavbv-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Cvoia hubl fbxauai yucmvcfyobmv bh W177$777 cmi lbua$ cua ykaua cm bykau

    yucmvcfyobmv qmiau yka CLDC ~kofk yka ecm`v cua uasqouai yb hbu~cui bu vami yb yka CLDF2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- ^add$ vqvwofobqv yucmvcfyobmv-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- ^kcy cua vqvwofobqv yucmvcfyobmv$ Lcicl2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Day la uaci oy hubl yka dc~-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- _av$ wdacva-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Hubl yka dc~$ vqvwofobqv yucmvcfyobmv cua yucmvcfyobmv ~oyk fbxauai

    omvyoyqyobmv uancuidavv bh yka clbqmyv omxbdxai ~kaua cm bh yka hbddb~omn foufqlvycmfav a{ovy: Mb

    qmiaudomn$ dancd$ bu yucia bedoncyobm0 yka fdoamy ov mby wubwaud oiamyohoai0 yka clbqmy omxbdxai ov mby

    fbllamvqucya yb yka eqvomavv bu homcmfocd fcwcfoy bh yka fdoamy$ ay fayauc$ clbmn bykau ykomnv- Cm

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    17/68

    YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735 3>

    foufqlvycmfa uadcyomn yb yka yucmvcfyobm ~kofk ov bevauxai yb iaxocya hubl yka wubhoda bh yka fdoamy cmi

    bu yka fdoamyv wcvy yucmvcfyobmv ~oyk yka fbxauai ecm`- Vb bykauv$ omyau cdoc-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Vb qmiau yka dc~$ yka fbxauai ecm`v cua uasqouai----

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- fbxauai yucmvcfyobmv-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Fbxauai yucmvcfyobmv cmi vqvwofobqv yucmvcfyobmv yb yka CLDF-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Vb yka icyc cmi yka omhbulcyobm wauycomomn yb yka cffbqmyv fbla hubl yka ecm`v

    eqy cua hbu~cuiai yb yka CLDF-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Ykcy ov vqwwbvai yb ea yka fcva-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Cmi ~kcy ~bqdi ykov omhbulcyobm omfdqia2 ^bqdi bq `mb~2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- O vcoi yka vqvwofobqv yucmvcfyobmv-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Mb$ cffbqmy mqleau$ yka mcla-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ ykcy ov uonky- Yka icya bh yka yucmvcfyobmv$ yka mcyqua bh yka

    yucmvcfyobmv-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Chyau bq ~ubya yka CLDF ykava y~b +5/ dayyauv$ ~cv ykaua cm uavwbmva yb bqu

    dayyauv e yka CLDF2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ ykaua ~cv-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- ^kcy ~cv oy$ Lcicl2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Yka hbu~cuiai yb la ykov 3>,wcna ibfqlamy cv ~add cv yka hbqu,wcna

    vqllcu bh yka yucmvcfyobmv-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- O lamyobmai ykov avyauic$ lc O cv` oy cncom- Ykaua ~cv cm omoyocd bm acfk wcna

    bh yka uawbuy bh yka CLDF$ ib bq uafcdd bu ~bqdi bq `mb~ ~kbva omoyocd ykcy ov2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av- Yka bma ~kb ov om fkcuna bh ecm` cmcdvov$ ecm` uafbuiv cmcdvov-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- ^bqdi bq `mb~ ~kb cua yka laleauv bh yka CLD Fbqmfod2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykcy ov wubxoiai hbu e dc~$ _bqu Kbmbu$ oy ov xau vwafohof-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- O cl cv`omn yka vwafohof oiamyohofcyobm-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Eqy ykcy ov mby yka sqavyobm- Lc yka sqavyobm ea fdcuohoai-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- ^kb cua yka wuavamy2

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Uahbul yka sqavyobm-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- _av- ^kb cua yka wuavamy Fbqmfod laleauv2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- O ykom` yka Fkcou ov Fkcoulcm Yaycmnfb$ yka nbxaumbu bh yka Famyucd Ecm`$

    cmi laleauv----

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Bejafyobm vqvycomai$ _bqu Kbmbu$ cmi yka ^oymavv fbmyomqav yb cmv~au-

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    18/68

    3; YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- O cl vbuu$ O ioi mby kacu oy- O cl vbuu-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- O cduaci uahbulai yka sqavyobm- ^kcy cua yka mclav bh yka wuavamy laleauv bh

    CLDF2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- O `mb~$ O kacui$ komio `b cdcl- Yka fkcou ov yka Famyucd Ecm` Nbxaumbu

    cmi yka laleauv cua yka Vafquoyoav cmi A{fkcmna Fbllovvobm Fkcou Yavvoa Kauebvc$ cmi ykaOmvqucmfa Fbllovvobmau-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Ykcm` bq xau lqfk$ Lcicl-

    Lc O cv` Fbqmvad yb vybw vcomn ykomnv ~koda yka ^oymavv ov yavyohomn2

    Xbofa- Vblaebi kcv eaam fbcfkomn yka ^oymavv-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- ^kb ov fbcfkomn yka ~oymavv2

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- ^kcy ov yka wubedal2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Cm~c$ ~a ~aua kacuomn ykcy$ _bqu Kbmbu$ eqy ~a ib mby ~cmy yb wavy yka^oymavv bm yka vycmi ~oyk ~kcyaxau vqvwofobm ~a lc kcxa- ^a jqvy `awy sqoay$ eqy ~a kci eaam

    kacuomn$ _bqu Kbmbu$ iofycyobm hubl vbla~kaua-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- O fcmmby ea a{wafyai yb ualaleau axauykomn ykcy ov kaua-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykcy ov mby yka wbomy$ Lcicl Bleqivlcm- Yka sqavyobm ov ~kaykau ykaua ~aua

    uacdd cwwcuamy fbcfkomn$ _bqu Kbmbu$ cmi ~a ioi mby euomn ykcy omyb yka bwam-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Yka ~aua mby fbcfkomn la- Yka ~aua jqvy ualomiomn la-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- ^add$ cm~c----

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Vb bq cua mby eaomn fbcfkai$ bq cua bmd eaomn ualomiai2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av- Eafcqva cv O vcoi$ O fcmmby ea a{wafyai yb ualaleau axauykomn

    noxam yka ibfqlamyv$ yka xbdqla bh wcwau ~bu`-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Cm~c$ ykava cua wqedof bhhofocdv- Yka fbqdi fbla qmiau yka bhhofocd

    mbyofa bh ykov Fbquy-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu$ wdacva-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Ov ykaua cm ibqey cebqy yka oiamyoyoav bh ykava wabwda2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Mb$ _bqu Kbmbu- Om hcfy$ ~a axam lcia yka vqnnavyobm ykcy yka dc~ vwafohofcdd

    mcla ykal-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Fbuuafy- Eqy yka---

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Ibav yka dc~ lamyobm yka mcla bh Yaycmnfb2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykcy ov mby mafavvcu hbu bqu wquwbvav$ _bqu Kbmbu$ eafcqva ykcy ov mby cm ovvqa-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- ^coy c lomqya- Yka dc~ vycyav yka wbvoyobm-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu-

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    19/68

    YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735 3?

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Mb~$ eqy O ykom` yka Fbqmvad$ yka namydalcm hubl yka Wubvafqyobm ov

    cv`omn yka oiamyoyoav bh yka wuavamy wauvbmv fblwbvomn yka Cmyo,Lbma Dcqmiauomn Fbqmfod- Cmi ykcy

    ov c wubwau sqavyobm- Oy ibav mby kcul bqu fcva- Oy ov c sqavyobm bh ~kb cua yka laleauv bh yka Cmyo,

    Lbma Dcqmiauomn Fbqmfod-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Yka wuavamy laleauv$ _bqu Kbmbu$ e mclav2

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- _av- yka Bleqivlcm lc cmv~au yka sqavyobm oh vka `mb~v ykal-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Cduaci cmv~auai$ _bqu Kbmbu$ eqy O fcm uawacy- Yka wuavamy fkcoulcm

    ov yka Nbxaumbu bh yka Famyucd Ecm` cmi yka laleauv cua yka Vafquoyoav cmi A{fkcmna Fbllovvobm

    Fkcou Yauavoyc Kauebvc bu Yauavc$ cmi yka Omvqucmfa Fbllovvobmau-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Cdd uonky- Nb ckaci wdacva-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Ykcm` bq- Vb$ qmiau yka CLDC$ yka ecm`v cua lcmicyai yb hbu~cui icyc cmi

    omhbulcyobm uancuiomn fbxauai cmi vqvwofobqv yucmvcfyobmv yb yka CLDF2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ciloyyai$ _bqu Kbmbu-Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Ykcy ov e dc~-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Oy ov c wuadolomcu sqavyobm$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Cdd uonky$ ykcy ov c lcyyau bh dc~-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- O ~cv jqvydcvy monky cmi qw yb ykov lbumomn$ Lcicl Bleqivlcm$ yka Fkoah

    Jqvyofa kcv eaam yaddomn yka laioc ykcy yka icyc omhbulcyobm noxam yb bq e CLDF ov c kbc{$ ov c dcmyaum

    bh doav$ oy ov wkbma- ^kcy fcm bq vc cebqy ykcy2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Mb ecvov$ _bqu Kbmbu- Ykaua ov mb axoiamfa bm uafbui vkb~omn ykcy `omi bh

    vycyalamy hubl yka wcuy bh yka Fkoah Jqvyofa- Oh ykaua ov$ ykam ka ~kb cddanav ykcy ykaua ~cv vkbqdi yc`ayka vycmi cmi ea fubvv,a{clomai$ _bqu Kbmbu$ yb iayauloma yka cffqucf$ yka fbuuafymavv cmi yka

    xaucfoy bh yka vycyalamy-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Day yka Bleqivlcm cmv~au oh vka `mb~v-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Ykcm` bq$ Lu- Wuavoiamy- ^kcy fcm bq vc cebqy ykbva fkcunav e yka Fkoah

    Jqvyofa2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Oh$ omiaai$ ka lcia ykbva fkcunav$ ~kcy O fcm vc ov ykcy yka cua jqvy bykau

    dcmyaumv bh doav- Ka vcv ykava cua dcmyaumv bh doav$ ykava cua dcmyaumv bh doav cv hcu cv kov vycyalamyv cua

    fbmfaumai eafcqva ykava ibfqlamyv ~aua iadoxauai yb la e yka A{afqyoxa Iouafybu bh yka CLDF-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- ^kb ov yka A{afqyoxa Iouafybu bh yka CLDF2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Oy ~cv cmv~auai avyauic$ oy ov Xof Csqomb-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Oh bqu cddancyobmv uancuiomn yka cffqucf cmi cqykamyofoy bh ykava CLDF

    ibfqlamyv cua eaomn sqavyobmai$ ~kcy ~bqdi ea yka eavy axoiamfa bh yka icyc cmi omhbulcyobm uancuiomn

    Fkoah Jqvyofa Fbubmcv cffbqmyv om yka ecm`v2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- ^add----

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Olwubwau$ _bqu Kbmbu$ ollcyauocd-

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    20/68

    57 YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Cua bq cv`omn yka bwomobm bh yka Bleqivlcm2

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykcy ov ~k ~a bejafy bm ykcy nubqmi$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- ^kcy ov yka wquwbva bh ykcy sqavyobm$ Fbqmvad2

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- O ~cmy yb avycedovk$ _bqu Kbmbu$ ykcy yka eavy axoiamfa ~odd ea yka Fkoah Jqvyofav

    cffbqmyv-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykcy ov bqu bwomobm-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Cmi ka uahqvav yb bwam kov cffbqmyv-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykcy ov bqu bwomobm- ^a cua bejafyomn$ _bqu Kbmbu- Lc ~a ea kacui om

    fbmmafyobm ykaua~oyk$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Vqvycomai-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Ykcm` bq$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Iahamva kcv sqavyobmai$ Lcicl Bleqivlcm$ yka xcdoioy cmi cqykbuoy bh yka Bhhofa bh yka

    Bleqivlcm ~oyk uavwafy yb bqu cfyobmv bm ykov omxavyoncyobm- ^kcy fcm bq vc cebqy ykcy2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- O ykom` O kcxa cduaci lcia lvadh fdacu- O cl lcmicyai e yka

    Fbmvyoyqyobm yb omxavyoncya wqedof bhhofocdv yb iayauloma ~kaykau ykaou cfyobmv cua omahhofoamy$ ouuanqdcu$

    olwubwau cmi yka do`a- Vafbmi$ ykaua ov yka Bleqivlcm Dc~ ~kofk afkbav yka fbmvyoyqyobmcd wubxovobm

    yb omxavyoncya- Cmi yka Bleqivlcm Dc~ om hcfy ciiv ykcy yka Bleqivlcm fcm wubvafqya-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Ykcm` bq$ Lcicl ^oymavv-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Cmi bm ybw bh ykcy$ bh fbquva$ cv O vcoi acudoau$ yka Fkoah Jqvyofa$ om kov

    Vycyalamy bh Cvvayv cmi Doceodoyoav$ kci cqykbuozai la yb vaa` yka kadw bh cnamfoav$ omfdqiomn yka EOU$

    yb iayauloma ~kaykau ykaua cua wubwauyoav$ cvvayv$ doceodoyoav$ may ~buyk$ eqvomavv omyauavyv cmi yka do`a

    hubl yka yola ka jbomai yka nbxaumlamy cv ~add cv yka omyauavyv bh kov hclod- Yb la ykcy ov c edcm`ay

    cqykbuoy hbu la yb fbmiqfy omxavyoncyobm-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Ykcm` bq-

    _bq acudoau lamyobmai ykcy bq fuacyai c wcmad yb omxavyoncya yka fblwdcomy-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Ykcy ov uonky-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Ioi bq noxa cm ~uoyyam buiau bu uavbdqyobm yb olwcmad ykov omxavyoncyobm nubqw2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ Vou-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Ib bq kcxa c fbw bh ykcy2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- O ovvqai cm buiau- _av-

    Fcm O kcxa c fbw bh yka buiau2

    _av$ av- Ykov ov yka buiau- Oy ov Bhhofa Buiau 377 cmi oy ~cv ovvqai e la bm Haeuqcu 55$ 5735-

    O fbmvyoyqyai c wcmad bh omxavyoncybuv fbmvovyomn bh bma fkcou cmi hoxa +1/ laleauv- O iouafyai ykal yb

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    21/68

    YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735 53

    fbmiqfy hcfy,homiomn omxavyoncyobm bm yka fblwdcomy hodai e Uovc Kbmyoxaubv,Ecucsqad$ Uqwauyb Cdaubzc$

    Noee Nbuuav$ Kcuxa @ak cmi Cdeauy Fbmfawfobm cncomvy Fkoah Jqvyofa Uamcyb F- Fbubmc hbu cddanai

    mqlaubqv xobdcyobmv bh yka wubxovobmv bh U-C- 673?$ U-C- 36>?$ U-C- ?3?9 ay fayauc cmi ibf`ayai

    cv FWD mqleau vb cmi vb$ cmi yb vqeloy oyv uawbuy-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Yka ^oymavv kcv kcmiai yb Fbqmvad cm Bhhofa Buiau Mb- 377$ vauoav bh 5735$

    qmiau yka dayyaukaci bh yka Bhhofa bh yka Bleqivlcm$ iqd vonmai e yka Bleqivlcm$ cmi ykov ov cfauyohoai yuqa fbw$ yka fbmyamyv bh ~kofk ~aua jqvy uaci e yka ^oymavv-

    Lc ~a cv` ykcy ykov ea lcu`ai cv A{koeoy WWWWWWWWWWWW2

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Lcu` oy cffbuiomnd-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- ^bqdi bq `mb~ oh yka wcmad ioi fbmiqfy cm omxavyoncyobm2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ Vou-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Fcm bq euoahd yadd qv kb~ yka ~amy cebqy fbmiqfyomn yka omxavyoncyobm2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- ^add$ yka vqewbamcai fauycom bhhofocdv bh yka nbxaumlamy hbu ibfqlamyvykcy ~bqdi kcxa c eacuomn ~oyk yka homcmfocd

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Bhhkcmi$ ~kcy cua ykava nbxaumlamy cnamfoav ~kb ~aua vqewbamcai e yka

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- ^add$ yka Vqwuala Fbquy ~cv vqewbamcai- O ykom` yka Fdau` bh Fbquy

    ~cv vqewbamcai yb vami c fauyohoai yuqa fbw bh yka Vycyalamy bh Cvvayv cmi Doceodoyoav bh yka Fkoah

    Jqvyofa-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Cmi ~kcy ~cv yka uavwbmva bh yka

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- ^add$ O ykom` qw yb mb~$ yka dcyavy ykcy O uaci ~cv ykcy oy ov vyodd wamiomn

    eahbua yka ecmf- Om bykau ~buiv$ yka fcdamicuai yka uasqavy om yka fcdamicu bh yka ecmf cmi yb icyaykaua ov mb fblwdocmfa-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Vb yka wcmad vqewbamcai yka Vqwuala Fbquy hbu fbwoav bh yka VCDM bh yka Fkoah

    Jqvyofa cmi yka ioi mby fblwd2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- ^add$ ykcy ov ~kcy yka uafbui vkb~v cy ykov yola- Oy cdvb vqewbamcai yka

    kaci bh yka cffbqmyomn hbu fauyohofcya bh acud fblwamvcyobm cmi cddb~cmfav-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Bh yka Vqwuala Fbquy2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _ack$ bh yka Vqwuala Fbquy- Eqy yka kaci$ c fauycom Lv- Kbdncib$

    uahqvai yb fblwd ~oyk yka dayyau-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- ^cv ykov uahqvcd ~uoyyam ib~m e yka Vqwuala Fbquy2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ oy ~cv ibfqlamyai-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Cvoia hubl yka Vqwuala Fbquy$ ~kb adva

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Yka Kbqva bh Uawuavamycyoxav Adafybucd Yuoeqmcd eafcqva yka Uavwbmiamy

    ~cv bma,yola laleau bu fkcou bh yka Kbqva bh Uawuavamycyoxav Adafybucd Yuoeqmcd cmi yka Adafybucd

    Yuoeqmcd fblwdoai-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Cvoia hubl ykabq lamyobmai yka Vqwuala Fbquy$ yka EOU$ ioi yka wcmad

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    22/68

    55 YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av- Yka cv`ai cdvb hbu vbla icyc hubl yka EOU eqy yka EOU kcv

    mby fblwdoai qw yb yka lblamy-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- ^kofk bykau cnamfoav ioi bq---

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Yka Kbqva bh Uawuavamycyoxav Adafybucd Yuoeqmcd-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- ^kcy ioi bq cv` hubl yka Kbqva bh Uawuavamycyoxav2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Yka fauyohofcya bh cddb~cmfav$ fblwamvcyobm cmi cddb~cmfav ykcy

    FJ Fbubmc uafaoxai ~koda ka ~cv c laleau cmi"bu fkcou bh yka Kbqva bh Uawuavamycyoxav

    Adafybucd Yuoeqmcd-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Cmi ~cv ykov vqewbamc hbddb~ai2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ yka ioi- Yka fblwdoai-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Yka fblwdoai-

    Cvoia hubl yka Kbqva bh Uawuavamycyoxav$ ~kb adva ioi bq vqewbamc2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Yka Vafuaycu bh yka Wkodowwoma Vamcya-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Hbu ~kcy wquwbva$ Lcicl ^oymavv2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Hbu yka wquwbva bh uasqavyomn yka Vycyalamy bh Cvvayv cmi Doceodoyoav bh

    FJ Fbubmc hbu 5775hubl 5775 yb 5737$Uafbui"Jbqumcd bh yka Vamcya voyyomn cv cm Olwacfklamy

    Fbquy icyai Jcmqcu 51$ 5735$ Jcmqcu 58$ 5735 cmi Haeuqcu 8$ 57350 ecm` fauyohofcyobmv icyai

    Haeuqcu >$ 5735 hubl WVEcm`$ @cyowqmcm Eucmfk$ wauycomomn yb yka ecdcmfav bh yka wavb cffbqmyv

    cv bh Iafaleau 63$ 577?-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Fbqmvad$ ~kcy ov yka wquwbva bh ykov doma bh sqavyobmomn2

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- O cl yuomn yb avycedovk$ _bqu Kbmbu$ ykcy yka Bleqivlcm ioi mby cfy cueoyucuod$

    ~kolvofcdd ~oyk uavwafy yb yka fblwdcomyv cncomvy yka Fkoah Jqvyofa-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- ^add$ cfyqcdd$ ykcy ov cduaci cmv~auai- Yka Bleqivlcm vcoi$ vka

    ~cvyka cua fbmiqfyomn cm omsqou cebqy yka Fkoah Jqvyofa vb lqfk vb ykcy yka kcxa ~uoyyam c dayyau

    yb kol yb cmv~au

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- _av-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Yb noxa cm cmv~au om >5 kbquv vb

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Ykcm` bq$ Lu- Wuavoiamy-

    Jqvy bma dcvy wbomy-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- ^kcy ov yka wbomy om eadcebuomn ykov ovvqa2

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Jqvy bma dcvy wbomy-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- _av- Nb ckaci-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Lcicl Bleqivlcm$ bq lamyobmai ykcy bq cv`ai hbu yka cvvovycmfa bh

    yka FBC2

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    23/68

    YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735 56

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Ykcy ov uonky$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Ioi yka FBC uamiau cm uawbuy om ~uoyomn ~oyk uavwafy yb ykaou homiomnv2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Yka fcla qw ~oyk ykov wuadolomcu uawbuy cmi ykam chyau vbla iovfqvvobm$

    chyau vbla a{wdcmcyobmv$ chyau vbla cmcdvov$ yka fcla qw ~oyk ykov cmcdvov bh uawbuy cmi O ybdi ykal

    yb wqy om xovqcd hbul yka homiomnv$ cmcdvov-Lu- Ecqyovyc- Ykcm` bq xau lqfk$ Lcicl ^oymavv-

    Ykcy ov cdd hbu yka fubvv-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Cua bq ykubqnk ~oyk bqu fubvv2 Cua bq ykubqnk2

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- _av$ av-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Cdd uonky-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Oh$_bqu Kbmbu$ wdacva-

    _av$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Ov yka Iahamva uaci yb ib c uaiouafy2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu- Eqy lc ~a uasqavy c bma,lomqyac bma dbmn,lomqya uafavv-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Bma dbmn,lomqya uafavv-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykcm` bq$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka yuocd ~cv vqvwamiai cy 6:5; w-l-

    Cy 6:18 w-l-$ yka yuocd ~cv uavqlai-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Yka yuocd ov uavqlai- Lc ~a uasqavy yka Kbmbuceda Bleqivlcm yb

    uayqum yb yka ~oymavv vycmi vb ykcy ~a fcm wubfaai- PDbmn Wcqva\

    Yka yuocd ov vqvwamiai hbu bma lomqya-

    Yka yuocd ~cv vqvwamiai cy 9:77 w-l-

    Cy 9:75 w-l-$ yka yuocd ~cv uavqlai-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Yka vavvobm ov uavqlai- Yka Iahamva lc mb~ wubfaai-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Nbbi chyaumbbm$ Lcicl Bleqivlcm-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Nbbi chyaumbbm$ Jqvyofa Fqaxcv-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Lc O ea cddb~ai yb fbmyomqa$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Wubfaai-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykcm` bq$_bqu Kbmbu-

    Mb~$ om ykava ibfqlamyv ykcy ~aua noxam qv$ _bqu Kbmbu$ O mbyofai yka mqleau bh yka iohhauamy

    cffbqmyv$ eqy oy ov mby omiofcyai om ykaua yka mcyqua bh yka cffbqmyv- Hbu omvycmfa$ Cffbqmy Mb- ;379-

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    24/68

    59 YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735

    Lc ~a `mb~ yka mcyqua bh ykcy cffbqmy2 Ov oy c vcxomnv cffbqmy$ c fquuamy cffbqmy$ bu yola

    iawbvoy bu ~kcy2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Oy ov mby omiofcyai$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Oy ov mby omiofcyai- Cdd uonky- _bq cua mby om c wbvoyobm yb yadd qv yka mcyqua bh

    ykov cffbqmy2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Mb-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Volodcud$ om bykau cffbqmyv: Cffbqmy Mb- 7?660 Cffbqmy Mb-76890 Cffbqmy

    Mb- 3;8>0 Cffbqmy Mb- 39>8 cmi Cffbqmy Mb- 7>79$ bq cdvb ~odd mby ea om c wbvoyobm yb yadd

    ykov Kbmbuceda Fbquy yka mcyqua bh ykava cffbqmyv2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Mb$ Vou-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Cdd uonky- Eqy hubl bqu a{clomcyobm bh yka wcwauv cmi uafbuiv vqeloyyai yb bq

    hbu bqu fbmvoiaucyobm$ ov ykaua cm bh ykava cffbqmyv ykcy ov c fquuamy cffbqmy2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Ykaua ov mb omiofcyobm kaua$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Vb$ bq ~odd mby ea ceda yb yadd yka Fbquy----

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ oh oy ov c fkaf`omn cffbqmy bu c vcxomnv cffbqmy bu c yola iawbvoy-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Eqy bq ~odd cnuaa ~oyk la ykcy omvbhcu cv c fkaf`omn cffbqmy ov fbmfaumai$ cdykbqnk$

    cv bq vcoi$ bq cua mby yucomai om loddobmv eqy$ day qv vc$ om vlcdd cffbqmyv$ _bqu Kbmbu$ yka iawbvoy

    om ykcy wcuyofqdcu cffbqmy ov axoiamfai e c iawbvoy vdow2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Oh bq ~bqdi iawbvoy----

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Fquuamy cffbqmy$ av-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- av$ ~kaykau om fcvk bu om fkaf`-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Fbuuafy$ _bqu Kbmbu- Ykcy ov fbuuafy-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ ykcy ov fbuuafy$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Cmi om ~oykiuc~cdv$ ykaua ov cdvb ykcy ~oykiuc~cd vdow vonmai e yka iawbvoybu2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Oh bq ~oykiuc~ oy$ oh bq ~oykiuc~ fcvk2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _av-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Ykam oy ov fbxauai e c ~oykiuc~cd vdow-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Fbuuafy-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Oh yka ~oykiuc~cd ov xoc fkaf`$ ykam bq kcxa yka fkaf` ykcy ov wubbh ykcy

    ykcy clbqmy ~cv iaeoyai hubl yka fquuamy cffbqmy-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Fbuuafy- Cmi oh oy ov c wdcom vcxomnv cffbqmy bu buiomcu cffbqmy$ oy ov fbxauai bu

    yka iawbvoy ov fbxauai e c ecm`ebb` vqwwdoai e yka ecm`2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Komio mc qvb mncbm cmn ecm`ebb`$ Jqvyofa Fqaxcv-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _av$ eqy O cl mby cv`omn bq cebqy yka qvb- Oy ov vyodd wucfyofai-

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    25/68

    YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735 51

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Mb- Mby cdd ecm`v ovvqa wcvvebb`v-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Eqy oh ykaua ov c wcvvebb`$ yka wcvvebb` lqvy ea wuavamyai hbu wquwbvav bh iawbvoy

    cmi ~oykiuc~cd-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Eqy oh bq kcxa c fcui ~kaua bq fcm qva oy cv fcvk ~kam bq wqufkcva

    vblaykomn$ bq jqvy WOM bqu mqleau cmi ykcy ov cduaci iaeoyai hubl bqu cffbqmy-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- O cl mby nbomn ykcy hcu$ Lcicl Bleqivlcm-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ Vou-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- O cl bmd qw yb ykcy a{yamy ~kaua c ~oykiuc~cd ov lcia cmi yka iawbvoy hubl ~kofk

    yka ~oykiuc~cd ov eaomn lcia ov cm buiomcu vcxomnv cffbqmy bu buiomcu cffbqmy-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Cncom$ O sqcdoh l cmv~au$ Jqvyofa Fqaxcv-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _av-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Oh bq ~oykiuc~ oy$ bq ~cmy fcvk$ bq kcxa ykov ~oykiuc~cd vdow$ bu oh bqib mby maai yka ~oykiuc~cd vdow$ bq nb yb yka CYL cmi jqvy WOM cmi WOM cmi WOM cmi ykam bq

    ~odd nay c uafaowy- Mb~----Cua bq fbcfkomn kol2

    Xbofa- _av$ O cl cdvb c dc~au cmi mby c ~oymavv-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ka ov cvvovyomn$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Ouuavwafyoxa bh ~kaykau bq cua c ~oymavv bu bq cua c dc~au$ ykcy ov

    cwwdoai yb cdd wcuyofowcmyv om ykov iuclc-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- O qmiauvycmi ykcy axam om buiomcu fcvav c wcvvebb` ov uasqouai- _bq vc oy ov mb

    dbmnau wucfyofai2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- O ib mby ykom` dcyad ykcy kcv eaam yka wucfyofa qmdavv wubeced bq cv` hbu

    c wcuyofqdcu wcvvebb`-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- O cl vwac`omn hubl a{wauoamfa eafcqva ykaua cua wcvvebb`v ovvqai e Fkomc Ecm`$

    wcvvebb` ovvqai e yka----Cmi eahbua bq fcm ~oykiuc~ cmi iawbvoy$ c wcvvebb` lqvy ea wuavamyai-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Mb$ mby ~oyk uavwafy yb Ecm` bh yka Wkodowwoma Ovdcmiv- Oh bq ~oykiuc~$

    bq jqvy hodd qw c ~oykiuc~cd vdow cmi yka `aaw oy- Yka uafbui oy- Oy ov cdd fblwqyauozai mb~$ Jqvyofa

    Fqaxcv- Cdd uonky$ cvvqlomn ykcy ~a cua vyodd om ykcy wucfyofa bh kcxomn ykov wcvvebb`$ ~kcy ov bqu

    sqavyobm$ _bqu Kbmbu2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- ^bqdi bq do`a la yb ea bm yka ~oymavv vycmi cmi cmv~au2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Mb- Ykcy ibav mby wuaxamy la hubl vaa`omn fdcuohofcyobm hubl bq-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Eqy bq cua mby fdcuohomn- _bq cua cv`omn la c sqavyobm-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Mb$ eafcqva bq wuahcfai bqu sqavyobm cebqy ykov wcvvebb` ykomn-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _av-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Cmi vb O ~cmyai fdcuohofcyobm-

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    26/68

    58 YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _bqu Kbmbu wdacva$ ykaua ov mb wamiomn sqavyobm- Yka Kbmbuceda Bleqivlcm kci

    cduaci cmv~auai-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Cfyqcdd$ yka Bleqivlcm vcoi vka ibav mby `mb~ ~kaykau yka cffbqmyv

    cua fquuamy cffbqmyv$ vcxomnv cffbqmyv bu ~kcyaxau omi bh cffbqmy-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _av$ ~a kcxa iovfqvvai ykcy cduaci-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Yka hcfy ov ykcy ykaua ov c ecm` cffbqmy-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- _av- Cmi yucmvcfyobmv kcwwamai om yka fbquva bh yola om fbmmafyobm ~oyk

    ykcy ecm` cffbqmy-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Lc O mb~ nb yb cmbykau vqejafy$ _bqu Kbmbu2

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Nb ckaci-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Cncom$ om cmbykau wcna bh ykov Cffbqmy Mb- ;379$ acu 577>$ ykaua cua xcuobqvcffbqmy mqleauv- ^odd bq `omid nb bxau ykal2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Cua ~a dbb`omn cy yka vcla wcna$ _bqu Kbmbu2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _av- Ykov ov a{koeoy hbu yka Wubvafqyobm$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- B`c- Cffbqmy Mb- ;379$ 577>-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- ^odd bq ea `omi ambqnk yb yadd qv yka mcyqua bh ykov cffbqmy lamyobmai om kaua bu

    bq cua mby cdvb om c wbvoyobm yb omhbul qv cebqy yka mcyqua bh ykov cffbqmy2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- O ~bqdi mby ea ceda-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykcm` bq-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Oh$ _bqu Kbmbu wdacva-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Cmv~auai cduaci-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- _av-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Lu- Jqvyofa Fqaxcv$ bq cua cv`omn sqavyobmv cebqy Cffbqmy Mb- ;379- Cua bq

    ciloyyomn ykcy ykava cua yka cffbqmyv bh yka Fkoah Jqvyofa2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Cua bq fubvv,a{clomomn la2

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Mb$ eafcqva oh bq cua mby ciloyyomn ykcy$ ykaua ov mb maai yb fubvv,a{cloma----

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykov ov amyouad bqy bh buiau$ _bqu Kbmbu$ qmdavv bq cua yka Wuavoiomn Jqina bu c

    laleau bh yka Vamcya fblloyyaa-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- ^odd bq `omid ciiuavv yka Fkcou eahbua bq----

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Day qv ea wubfaiqucd cmi lbua fbquyabqv$ _bqu Kbmbu-

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    27/68

    YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735 5>

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Fbqmvad hbu yka Wubvafqyobm$ cddb~ yka Iahamva fbqmvad yb fbmiqfy yka

    uaiouafy a{clomcyobm- Oh bq kcxa cm bejafyobm$ ucova cm bejafyobm$ eqy ib mby wbvoy c sqavyobm yb kol-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu- Ykcm` bq$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Vb buiauai-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- O cl vbuu$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Cdd uonky-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- O ykom` ~a eayyau fbmiqfy ykov kacuomn om cm buiaud hcvkobm- ^a cua cdd

    dc~auv cmi ~a `mb~ yka uqdav- Oh bq kcxa cm bejafyobm$ ucova cm bejafyobm- Vycya yka uacvbm hbu

    bqu bejafyobm$ vb ykcy ykov Fkcou fcm uqda yb cddb~ bu mby yb cddb~ cm cmv~au-

    Cdd uonky$ Fbqmvad hbu yka Iahamva$ wubfaai-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- _bqu Kbmbu$ wdacva-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Lc O wubfaai$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- _bqu Kbmbu$ wdacva- O uavwafyhqdd bejafy yb yka sqavyobmv ucovai e yka Iahamva-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- ^k2

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Bm yka nubqmi bh ouuadaxcmfa- Eafcqva ykaua kcv eaam mb cilovvobm bu wubbh ykcy

    yka Fkoah Jqvyofa ov ciloyyomn ykava yb ea kov cffbqmyv-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykaua ov mb wamiomn sqavyobm cmlbua-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- ^coy c lomqya- Ykaua ov mb----

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Wamiomn sqavyobm-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Cilovvobm$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Bm yka wcuy bh yka Fkoah Jqvyofa-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- _av-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Eqy yka Bleqivlcm ~cv wuavamyai e yka Iahamva yb yavyoh kaua- Cmi

    yka Bleqivlcm vcoi ykcy vka uafaoxai c uawbuy hubl CLDF yb yka ahhafy ykcy ykaua ov c ecm` iawbvoy

    cffbqmy eacuomn yka mcla bh Uamcyb Fbubmc cmi ykaua ~aua yucmvcfyobmv om fbmmafyobm ~oyk oy- Cua

    bq iamomn ykcy2

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Mb$ _bqu Kbmbu- Yka cua yka bmav iamomn ykcy-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- ^kcy ov yka lcyauocdoy bh ykcy sqavyobm ykcy bq cua ucovomn2

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- ^a vqeloy$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Mb- ^kcy ov yka lcyauocdoy2

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- ^a ~oykiuc~ yka bejafyobm$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- _bq cua fbmhqvomn yka ovvqav kaua- O ykom` ~a eayyau mby ib cm lovdaciomn

    ahhbuy kaua eafcqva ~a cua sqoya cdauy om ykov Fbquy-

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    28/68

    5; YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735

    Wubfaai$ Fbqmvad hbu yka Iahamva-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- ^oyk yka `omi waulovvobm bh yka kbmbuceda Fbquy-

    Cncom$ lc O ea wauloyyai$ Lcicl Bleqivlcm$ yb `omid iouafy bqu cyyamyobm yb ~kcy cwwacuv

    om ykov Wb~auWbomy wuavamycyobm----

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- ^kcy wcna bh yka Wb~auWbomy wuavamycyobm cua bq uahauuomn yb2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Oy ov ykaua$ _bqu Kbmbu- O cl uahauuomn yb ykcy wbuyobm dceadai Cffbqmy ;379,577>-

    O vqwwbva ykcy yka cffbqmy mqleau ykaua lamyobmai ov yka Cffbqmy Mqleau cmi 577> ov yka acu-

    Mb~$ l sqavyobm yb bq ov----

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Ykcy ov Cffbqmy Mb- ;379,577>-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Fbuuafy$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Cdd uonky-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Mb~$ l sqavyobm yb bq mb~ ov$ ~odd bq ea `omi ambqnk yb yadd ykov Kbmbuceda

    Fbquy yka mcyqua bh yka cffbqmyv$ mclad: Cffbqmy Mbv- 5;79$ 58?6$ 5971$ 9613$ >81?$ 66?;$ 5;35$

    5;;>$ 69>?$ cmi 63?62 Ykcy ov yka sqavyobm- ^odd bq ea ceda yb cmv~au2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Mb$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _bq cua mby hclodocu ~oyk ykava mqleauv cv mqleauv bh c ecm` cffbqmy2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Yka cua vqwwbvai yb ea ecm` cffbqmyv-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _av- Eqy ~kcy O lacm----

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Eqy ~kaykau yka cua fquuamy$ vcxomnv$ O ~bqdi mby `mb~- Oy ov mbyomiofcyai om yka icyc hubl ~kofk O ncykauai$ hubl l cmcdvov-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykcm` bq$ Lcicl-

    Mb~$ lc O `mb~ hubl bq kb~ ykava ibfqlamyv cwwacuomn om ykov Wb~auWbomy wuavamycyobm kcv

    eaam lcia cmi ~kb cqykbuai yka vcla2 _bqu bhhofa2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- L bhhofa$ ~oyk yka cvvovycmfa bh yka FBC- O cv`ai ykal yb xovqcdoza oy

    eafcqva oy ~bqdi ea acvoau yb qmiauvycmi-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Om bykau ~buiv$ bq cua mby wauvbmcdd omxbdxai om ykov2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- O ~cv wauvbmcdd omxbdxai- Eqy om yka iuc~omn bh ykov bu yka----Kb~ ib bq

    fcdd oy2 ^kcy ov yka yaul2 Om yka wqyyomn bh yka cuub~v cmi ~kcy dbb`ai do`a ecddbbmv$ yka ~aua yka

    bmav ~kb wommai oy om yka fblwqyau-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Cdd uonky- Ykcm` bq$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Lc ~a ea omhbulai cv yb yka a{yamy cmi mcyqua bh bqu wcuyofowcyobm- Ov oy vqwauxovbu bu cfyqcd2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Cfyqcd$ vqwauxovbu cmi fbmyubd-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Cmi om ~kcy vamva ~cv ykcy cfyqcd vqwauxovobm lcia2 ^odd bq omid day qv mb~2

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    29/68

    YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735 5?

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Yka ~aua wauvbmcdd wuavamy om yka bhhofa- Vb$ ~a ~amy hubl bma amyu

    yb cmbykau- Cmi chyau ykcy ~cv ibma$ yka kci yb yadd la ykcy oy ov mb~ uahdafyai cv bq ~ovkai om ykov$

    om ykcy$ om ykcy-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Cdd uonky-

    Cmi omvbhcu cv bqu bhhofa ov fbmfaumai$ ~kaua ioi ykava lcyyauv cwwacuomn om ykov CffbqmyMb- ;379,577> fbla hubl2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Yka ~aua dohyai hubl yka amyuoav noxam e yka CLDF-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- O vaa-

    Cmi ykava amyuoav ykcy bq lamyobmai c ~koda cnb$ ~aua yka wuavamyai yb bq xau hbulcdd e

    yka CLDF2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Oy ~cv hbu~cuiai yb la e yka CLDF-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Vb$ oy ~cv mby hodai ~oyk bqu bhhofa xau hbulcdd ~oyk cm cyycfklamy2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Eafcqva oy ov vyuofyd fbmhoiamyocd$ oy ~cv wauvbmcdd iadoxauai yb la-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- E ~kbl2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- E Lu- Xof Csqomb-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- O mbyofai avyauic ykcy bq kci c kcui yola uaciomn yka amyuoav ykauaom cwwacuomn

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Ykcy ov uonky eafcqva yka cua vb lomqya-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- ykqv$ noxomn la yka olwuavvobm ykcy ykcy cwwacuv yb ea yka houvy yola bq kcxa nbma

    bxau ykava ibfqlamyv-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Mb$ _bqu Kbmbu- Cv bq ~odd mbya om yka fbw O kci$ O kci l

    cmmbycyobmv- O kci l lcu`omnv cmi ykcy ov ~k O cv`ai yka waulovvobm bh yka Vamcya oh yka fbqdi

    wkbybfbw yka fdacm fbw bh ykava ibfqlamyv-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykcy ov yka hcuykavy bq kcxa nbma omvbhcu cv vqwauxovobm bu om yka wuawcucyobm

    bh ykov

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Hbu ykov O kcxa nbma2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- bu wuavamycyobm-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- E2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- O kcxa cv`ai bq c xau iahomoya sqavyobm$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- ^kcy ov yka wquwbva bh ykov doma bh sqavyobmomn$ Fbqmvad2 Cua bq

    olwacfkomn bqu ^oymavv2 Olwqnmomn kau fblwayamfa2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Oh _bqu Kbmbu wdacva$ yka Fbquy cddb~ai qv yb omyubiqfa kau cv c kbvyoda ~oymavv-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- _av-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Cmi eaomn cddb~ai yb ib vb----

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    30/68

    67 YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- _bq fcm fubvv,a{cloma- O `mb~ yka uqdav-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu- Ykcy ov bqu wquwbva-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Oy ov om hubmy bh la-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu$ ykcy ov yka wquwbva- ^a cua yuomn yb iayauloma yka xaucfoy cmi

    yka cffqucf-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- _bq cua yavyomn yka fuaioeodoy bh yka ^oymavv-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- E ~c bh olwacfklamy$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Cdd uonky-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykcm` bq$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Wubfaai-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Mb~$ ~kam bq ~amy bxau ykov yceqdcyobm hqumovkai bq e yka CLDF wabwda$ bq

    ioi mby kcxa c ycd` ~oyk cmbma bh ykal2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- ^oyk cm bh yka2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- CLDF wabwda-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- CLDF wabwda$ mb-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Mbma- Om bykau ~buiv$ oy ~cv jqvy noxam yb bq-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykaua ov mb fbxauomn dayyau-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Ykaua ~cv-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Cmi bq cvvqlai ykcy ykov ~cv yka ibfqlamy----

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Ykaua ~cv$ ykaua ~cv-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykaua ~cv2 Ck$ O vaa-

    Lc ~a ea cddb~ai yb nb bxau yka fbxauomn dayyau-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Vqua- Yka dayyau bh yka CLDF ~kam yka yucmvloyyai yka ibfqlamy yb la-

    Yka Lcufk ?$ 5735 dayyau- ^a kcxa kaua yka fbxauomn dayyau- Oy ov kaua-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Nbomn bxau ykov dayyau$ oy vycyav: ^a cua hqumovkomn bq ~oyk yka cyycfkai omhbulcyobm

    hbu omyaddonamfa wquwbvav bmd om fbmmafyobm ~oyk yka omxavyoncyobm bh yka cebxa,lamyobmai fblwdcomy-

    Ioi bq mbyofa ykcy2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ O `mb~ ykcy-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Cdd uonky- ^odd bq `omid amdonkyam qv cv yb yka vfbwa bh ~kcy ov lacmy$ oh bq `mb~$

    bh lamyobmomn kaua bh omyaddonamfa wquwbvav bmd-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Day la vaa yka dayyau$ Fkoah- P^oymavv nbomn bxau yka dayyau-\

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    31/68

    YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735 63

    ^kam oy vcv oy ov vyuofyd fbmhoiamyocd$ oy vcv: Yka cyycfkai omhbulcyobm hbu omyaddonamfa wquwbvav

    bmd om fbmmafyobm ~oyk yka omxavyoncyobm bh yka cebxa,fcwyobmai fblwdcomyv-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Lacmomn$ omhbulcyobm-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Omhbulcyobm$ av- Hqumovkomn bq yka cyycfkai omhbulcyobm hbu omyaddonamfa

    wquwbvav bmd om fbmmafyobm ~oyk yka omxavyoncyobm bh yka cyycfkai lamyobmai fblwdcomy- Yka lamyobmaifblwdcomy ~cv Uovc Kbmyoxaubv$ ay cd- xauvqv Fkoah Jqvyofa Uamcyb F- Fbubmc-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Lc O fbmyomqa mb~$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Nb ckaci- _bq cua ibomn c fubvv,a{clomcyobm- Ib mby `aaw cv`omn

    waulovvobm hubl yka Fkcou-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu- O ~cv ykom`omn ykcy yka Fkcou lc kcxa c sqavyobm$ ykcy ov ~k-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Mb$ mb$ nb ckaci-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykcm` bq$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Om bykau ~buiv$ oy ov iahomoya cmi vwafohof ykcy ykov omhbulcyobm eaomn uadcai yb bq ~cv wquvqcmy

    yb ykov cddanai fblwdcomy bh Uovc Kbmyoxaubv$ ay cd-$ cncomvy Fkoah Jqvyofa Fbubmc-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ vou-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Lamyobm ov lcia om kaua bh cm omxavyoncyobm- Ov ykov omxavyoncyobm lauad

    cilomovyucyoxa bu wuadolomcu cv oy ov qmiauvybbi2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Hcfy,homiomn omxavyoncyobm bu fcva eqodiqw-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykcy ov vyuofyd fbmhoiamyocd2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Cmi oy bqnky mby yb ea `mb~m e cmebi adva bqyvoia bh ykbva fbmmafyai bhhofocdd

    ~oyk oy-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Cdd uonky- Lacmomn$ bmd e wabwda ~oykom bqu bhhofa cua wuoxodanai yb `mb~ ykov

    omxavyoncyobm-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Mby cdd laleauv bh l vychh `ma~ cebqy oy-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _av$ eqy ykbva ~kb vkbqdi `mb~ cebqy ykov cua bmd ykbva ~bu`omn ~oyk bq omfbmmafyobm ~oyk ykov fblwdcomy-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ eqy O sqcdoh ykcy- Eafcqva O kci iohhofqdy cmcdzomn yka icyc$ O kci

    yb amncna yka cvvovycmfa bh bykau nbxaumlamy cnamfoav-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _av$ eqy l sqavyobm yb bq ov: Yka a{yamy cmi vfbwa bh yka fbmhoiamyocdoy

    lamyobmai om kaua uahauv yb yka hcfy ykcy oy vkbqdi ea `mb~m bmd yb yka laleauv bh bqu vychh bu bhhofa2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- ^kb ~aua cvvovyomn la om yka omxavyoncyobm bh ykov fcva-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykcm` bq- Ykcm` bq xau lqfk- B`c-

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    32/68

    65 YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735

    Mb~$ oh O nb ecf` yb bqu dayyau yb yka Fkoah Jqvyofa cv`omn kol yb cmv~au yka cddanai fkcunav om

    ykaua$ bq lamyobmai cebqy vauobqv lovfbmiqfy om bhhofa- @omid nb bxau yka fbw oh bq kcxa oy-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- O cl nbomn bxau oy uonky mb~$ Jqvyofa-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykcm` bq-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- ^kcy ov yka sqavyobm2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- O cl uahauuomn$ _bqu Kbmbu$ yb c wbuyobm bh yka dayyau ciiuavvai e yka Kbmbuceda

    Bleqivlcm yb Fkoah Jqvyofa Fbubmc-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Cmi2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Cmi lc O uahau yka Kbmbuceda Bleqivlcm yb ykov wcuyofqdcu wbuyobm-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Wubfaai-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- ^koda bq lc bmd ea ualbxai hubl bhhofa ykubqnk olwacfklamy wubfaaiomnv$

    ykov bhhofa kcv$ cv uahdafyai acudoau$ yka wb~au cmi iqy yb omxavyoncya bq hbu cm vauobqv lovfbmiqfyom bhhofa hbu yka wquwbva bh hodomn c xauohoai fblwdcomy hbu olwacfklamy$ oh ~cuucmyai- Oy ~cv bm ykov

    cffbqmy ykcy ykov bhhofa fbmiqfyai cm omoyocd axcdqcyobm bh yka fblwdcomy-

    L sqavyobm yb bq ov: ^kcy lacmomn vkbqdi ea cyycfkai yb ykov vycyalamy bh bquv uancuiomn yka

    cddanai fbllovvobm bh vauobqv lovfbmiqfy2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Cm fbmiqfy ykcy ov omyamyobmcdd ibma ~kofk ov mby jqvy$ ~kofk ov mby

    wubwau$ ~kofk ov om xobdcyobm bh dc~$ ykcy yb la amfblwcvvav yka wkucva vauobqv lovfbmiqfy-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Om ykov fbmmafyobm$ lc O uaci yb bq c wbuyobm bh yka iafovobm om vaxaucd fcvav$

    lbua wcuyofqdcudom yka fcva bhVcdfaib x- Omyomn$ uqdai e yka kbmbuceda Vqwuala Fbquy$ ~kauaom oy

    ov vycyai: Yka lovfbmiqfy lqvy cdvb kcxa c iouafy uadcyobm yb cmi ea fbmmafyai ~oyk yka wauhbulcmfabh bhhofocd iqyoav-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ vou-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Om bykau ~buiv$ oy ov mby cm lovhacvcmfa bu lcdhacvcmfa eqy oy ov cm cfy xobdcyoxa

    bh yka uqdav cmi yka dc~ om fbmmafyobm ~oyk yka wauhbulcmfa bh bhhofocd iqy-

    Mb~$ yka ciiuavvaa kaua ov Fkoah Jqvyofa Fbubmc- ^odd bq ea `omi ambqnk yb yadd ykov Kbmbuceda

    Fbquy ~kcy ov yka vfbwa bh ykcy vauobqv lovfbmiqfy bq cua uahauuomn yb om ykov dayyau2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Oy amfblwcvvav cmykomn ykcy xobdcyav yka dc~- Om ykov fcva$ ka ov fkcunai

    yb kcxa cffqlqdcyai ~acdyk ykcy ov wquwbuyaid nubvvd iovwubwbuyobmcya yb kov omfbla-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Eqy O ~odd mby yc`a ovvqa ~oyk bq ykaua eafcqva yka jquovwuqiamfa bm yka wbomy ~a

    kcxa wdcfai bm uafbui$ _bqu Kbmbu$ cua cduaci ykaua-

    Mb~$ ~kam bq ~aua hqumovkai ~oyk ykov uawbuy bh yka CLDF wquvqcmy yb bqu uasqavy

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- O kbwa bq ~amy bxau yka vcla$ cmi cv bq vcoi$ lcm yolav2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- _av$ Vou-

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    33/68

    YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735 66

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Cdd uonky- Fbqdi bq mb~ chhoul qmiau bcyk ykcy yka fbmyamyv bh yka vcoi uawbuy cua

    cffqucya$ fbuuafy$ cmi om cffbuicmfa ~oyk dc~ ecvai bm bqu a{clomcyobm2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- ^kaykau bu mby yka fbmyamyv bh ykcy uawbuy cua cffqucya$ fbuuafy$ bu om

    cffbuicmfa ~oyk dc~$ O ~bqdi mby kcxa cm ~c bh `mb~omn-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- O vaa- Vb$ ykcy ov yka----Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Eafcqva ykcy ~cv hqumovkai yb la e yka CLDF-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykcy ov eabmi bqu fblwuakamvobm-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- ^kcy ib bq lacm eabmi l fblwuakamvobm2 O ib mby qmiauvycmi oy2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _av-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Eabmi l fblwayamfa$ av$ eqy mby eabmi l fblwuakamvobm-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Kb~ ioi bq qmiauvycmi yka honquav lamyobmai om ykaua$ ~aua yka cffqucya$ ~aua

    yka fbuuafy2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- ^add$ yka wuavqlwyobm ov ykcy vomfa O ~cv noxam ykov ibfqlamy$ yka

    wuavqlwyobm ov ykcy ykava cua ibfqlamyv fbuuafyd uahdafyai om yka icyc bh yka CLDF-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- ^kcy xauohofcyobm ioi bq qmiauyc`a oh bq ioi om fbmmafyobm ~oyk yka cffqucf bh

    yka honquav ykauaom vycyai2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- O fbqdi mby nb iouafyd yb yka ecm` yb xauoh ~kaykau yka icyc amyauai kaua

    cua fbuuafy bu mby-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Kb~ cebqy cm bh bqu wabwda bu wauvbm qmiau bq$ Lcicl Bleqivlcm$ mbma

    fbmiqfyai cm omsqou2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Hubl yka ecm`2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _av-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Mb-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykaua ~aua mb omsqouoav cv yb ~kaykau ykava cddanai ~oykiuc~cdv cua fbxauai e cm

    ~oykiuc~cd vdow-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Mb-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Yka iawbvoy ykcy bq lamyobmai ~cv mby cvfauycomai cv yb ~kaykau ykaua ~auaiawbvoy vdowv fbxauomn yka vcla-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Mb-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Bm yka icyav lamyobmai ykauaom2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Mb-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Cdd uonky- Vb$ cwwcuamyd$ bq noxa qv yka olwuavvobm ykcywcuibm yka dcmnqcna

    bq v~cddb~ai$ kbb`$ doma$ cmi vom`au yka amyoua fbmyamyv bh yka ibfqlamy vqeloyyai yb bq om uavwbmva

    yb bqu dayyau-

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    34/68

    69 YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Cncom$ O vc$ yka wuavqlwyobm ov ykcy yka ~bqdi noxa yb la fbuuafy

    omhbulcyobm-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Cmi ykcy wuavqlwyobm ~cv maxau xauohoai e bq-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- O fbqdi mby xauoh oy- O fbqdi mby nb yb yka ecm`- O fbqdi mby ib ykcy-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _av-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Ualaleau avyauic$ bq ~aua ycd`omn cebqy fbmhoiamyocdoy bh ecm`

    iawbvoyv-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _av-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Yb ~kofk O uaybuyai ykcy cua bq ciloyyomn ykcy ykava ecm` iawbvoyv a{ovy2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- ^add$ kb~ fbqdi O lc`a oy2 PDcqnkyau\ O cl yka bma wubwbqmiomn yka sqavyobm- Cua

    bq fubvv,a{clomomn----

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- O cl ualomiomn bq cebqy ~kcy yucmvwouai avyauic$ Lu- Jqvyofa-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- ^add$ O kcxa mby hbunbyyam ~kcy yucmvwouai avyauic$ wuafovad$ yka ecvov bh l

    ciioyobmcd iouafy sqavyobmomn mb~$ eafcqva bq kcxa wabwda$ cffbuiomn yb bq$ ~kb kcxa cvvovyai bq$

    om fbmmafyobm ~oyk yka iayaulomcyobm bh yka yuqyk-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Om fbmmafyobm ~oyk yka cmcdvov-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Cddb~ la yb homovk houvy- Oh bqu Kbmbu wdacva$ lc ~a uasqavy ykcy yka oymavv

    ea ualomiai-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Lcicl$ ~oyk bqu omiqdnamfa$ day yka Fbqmvad homovk-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- O vqeloy$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Cdd uonky- O ~oykiuc~ yka hbulau sqavyobm- Om ykcy cmcdvov ykcy bq lcia$ ioi bq

    cv` hbu yka cvvovycmfa bh cm bh yka wabwda om bqu bhhofa yb iayauloma yka yuqyk bh ~kcy cwwacuv om ykava

    uawbuyv vqeloyyai yb bq e yka CLDF eahbua2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Mb$ _bqu Kbmbu- ^a cua mby cddb~ai yb iayauloma yka yuqyk bh ~kcy

    cwwacuv ykaua-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- O ykbqnky yka wquwbva bh bqu uasqavy hbu cvvovycmfa ov yb ea ceda yb cvfauycom yka

    yuqyk bh yka lcyyauv-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Iayauloma yka a{ovyamfa-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- ^coy$ cddb~ la yb homovk-

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Vbuu- Lac fqdwc-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Ykcm` bq$ ykcm` bq- O ykbqnky bqu wquwbva ~cv yb cv` yka cvvovycmfa bh yka

    CLDF yb amdonkyam bq bm ~kcy yka kcxa om fbmmafyobm ~oyk ykov fblwdcomy bh yka xcuobqv fblwdcomcmyv

    eahbua bq$ uonky2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Day la uaci l dayyau yb yka CLDF-

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    35/68

    YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735 61

    L uasqavy ~cv hbu yka cvvovycmfa bh yka CLDF xov,c,xov yka wuavamy omxavyoncyobm eaomn fbmiqfyai

    e bqu bhhofa bm cffbqmy bh yka dayyau,fblwdcomy bh Uovc Kbmyoxaubv$ ay cd- e ~c bh wubxoiomn uadaxcmy

    omhbulcyobm eacuomn bm yka homcmfocd yucmvcfyobmv$ oh cm$ bh yka Uavwbmiamy cmi uadcyai yucmvcfyobmv-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Om yka uawd ykcy bq uafaoxai$ ~cv ykaua cm vycyalamy uadcyoxa yb yka homcmfocd

    yucmvcfyobmv ykcy bq ~aua cv`omn cvvovycmfa2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Yka hqumovkai la c fbw bh ykov 3>,wcna ibfqlamy cmi yka hbqu,wcna

    vqllcu bh yucmvcfyobmv-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- ^kcy yucmvcfyobmv cua bq uahauuomn yb$ Lcicl Bleqivlcm2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Ecm` yucmvcfyobmv$ homcmfocd$ yb ea lbua cffqucya-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Yka cua yucmvcfyobmv omxbdxomn iawbvoyv cmi ~oykiuc~cdv- Mbykomn lbua2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Mby mafavvcuod-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- ^aua bq ceda yb cvfauycom ~kaykau ykava ecm` cffbqmyv uahdafyai om yka uawbuy cua

    cfyqcdd a{ovyomn2

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Cncom$ O vcoi acudoau$ kb~ fcm O iayauloma oh yka cua cfyqcdd a{ovyomn ~kam

    O fcmmby nb yb yka ecm`2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- O cl mby cv`omn bq kb~ bq fcm iayauloma$ eqy ~kcy O cl cv`omn bq ov$ ioi bq

    iayauloma2

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Cduaci cmv~auai- Vka vcoi cduaci ykcy vka ioi mby nb yb yka

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Ecm`-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- yb yka ecm`v- Vka ioi mby nb yb yka uafbuiv- Vka uadoai bm yka uawbuybh CLDF- Cmi vka wuavqlai yka xaucfoy bh yka uawbuy bh cm cnamf cqykbuozai e dc~ yb kcmida ykov

    ywa bh wubedal-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- _av$ eqy---- aua bq ceda yb cvfauycom ~kaykau ykaua ov cm omxavyoncyobm fbmiqfyai

    e yka CLDF om fbmmafyobm----

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Lc O bejafy$ _bqu Kbmbu wdacva2

    Lu- Fqaxcv- Cddb~ la yb homovk cmi O ~odd noxa bq cdd yka bwwbuyqmoy-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- Lcicl Bleqivlcm$ ~odd bq `omid cddb~ kol yb homovk$ vb ykcy

    Lv- Fcuwob,Lbucdav- Lu- Wuavoiomn Jqvyofa$ oy ~cv ka ~kb ycd`ai-

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- Lac fqdwc-

    Lu- Fqaxcv- O kbwa ka ov mby cwwbomyai Bleqivlcm$ _bqu Kbmbu$ eafcqva ykaua ~odd ea c

    fbmhdofy bh cqykbuoy cduaci-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- ^kb ~cv ycd`omn2

    Lu- Ecqyovyc- O ~cv yka bma$ _bqu Kbmbu-

    Yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau- _bq vaa$ yka Wuavoiomn Bhhofau ov nayyomn fbmhqvai$ fcmmby nay

    ~kb ov ycd`omn-

  • 7/31/2019 May 15 Senate impeachment court record

    36/68

    68 YQAVIC_$ LC_ 31$ 5735

    E yka ~c$ ~odd bq wdacva bejafy oh bq ~cmy yb bejafy vb