81
Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications Based on: M. Cheng, X. Dong, J. Duncan, S. Harrison, S. Kachru, TW to appear N. Paquette, TW to appear TW 1402.2973 M. Cheng, X. Dong, J. Duncan, J. Harvey, S. Kachru, TW 1306.4981 Texas A&M April 30, 2014 Timm Wrase

Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Based on: M. Cheng, X. Dong, J. Duncan, S. Harrison, S. Kachru, TW to appear N. Paquette, TW to appear

TW 1402.2973 M. Cheng, X. Dong, J. Duncan, J. Harvey, S. Kachru, TW 1306.4981

Texas A&M April 30, 2014

Timm Wrase

Page 2: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Outline

• Introduction to moonshine

• Mathieu Moonshine and

string compactifications

• Physical implications

• A new moonshine phenomena 2

Page 3: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Finite simple groups

There are 18 infinite families, e.g.

• Alternating group of n elements An

e.g. A3: (123) ↔ (231) ↔ (312)

• Cyclic groups of prime order Cp

e.g.: Cp = p = < 2π /p >

3

Page 4: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Finite simple groups

There are also 26 so called sporadic groups that do not come in

infinite families:

4

the largest group

subgroups

Page 5: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Finite simple groups

There are also 26 so called sporadic groups that do not come in

infinite families:

5

|Monster| 8 x 1053

Page 6: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Finite simple groups

There are also 26 so called sporadic groups that do not come in

infinite families:

6

|Monster| 8 x 1053

Largest Mathieu group 2 x 109

Conway group 4 x 1018

|M22| = 443, 520

Page 7: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Modular Forms

Modular function of weight k

),2(,)( ZSL

dc

bafdc

dc

baf k

7

Page 8: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Modular Forms

Modular function of weight k

Jacobi form of weight k and index m

),2(,)( ZSLdc

bafdc

dc

baf k

Z

,,,,

,)(,

)(2

2

2

2

zfezf

zfedcdc

z

dc

baf

zmi

dc

zcmi

k

8

Page 9: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Modular Forms

Modular function of weight k

Jacobi form of weight k and index m

Can Fourier expand

),2(,)( ZSLdc

bafdc

dc

baf k

Z

,,,,

,)(,

)(2

2

2

2

zfezf

zfedcdc

z

dc

baf

zmi

dc

zcmi

k

0 42

),(]2exp[],2exp[,n mnr

rn yqrncziyiqfzf

9

Page 10: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Monstrous Moonshine

• The irreducible representations of the Monster group have dimensions 1, 196 883, 21 296 876, …

• The J-function, that appears in many places in string theory, enjoys the expansion

10

...760493218841961

)( 2 qqq

qJ

Page 11: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Monstrous Moonshine

• The irreducible representations of the Monster group have dimensions 1, 196 883, 21 296 876, …

• The J-function, that appears in many places in string theory, enjoys the expansion

• as observed by John McKay

11

876296218831961 8831961

...760493218841961

)( 2 qqq

qJ

Page 12: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Monstrous Moonshine

1. foolish talk or ideas.

Page 13: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Monstrous Moonshine

1. foolish talk or ideas. 2. NORTH AMERICAN illicitly distilled or smuggled liquor.

Page 14: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Monstrous Moonshine

This surprising connection can be explained by string theory:

• The (left-moving) bosonic string compactified on a 2 orbifold of R24/Λ with Λ the Leech lattice has as its 1-loop partition function the J(q)-function

14

...760493218841961

)(Tr)( 2

H240

qq

qqJqqZ

cL

Page 15: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Monstrous Moonshine

This surprising connection can be explained by string theory:

• The (left-moving) bosonic string compactified on a 2 orbifold of R24/Λ with Λ the Leech lattice has as its 1-loop partition function the J(q)-function

15

tachyon of the bosonic string

no massless q0 states

supermassive string states

...760493218841961

)(Tr)( 2

H240

qq

qqJqqZ

cL

Page 16: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Monstrous Moonshine

This surprising connection can be explained by string theory:

• The (left-moving) bosonic string compactified on a 2 orbifold of R24/Λ with Λ the Leech lattice has as its 1-loop partition function the J(q)-function

• The symmetry group of the compactification space R24/Λ/ 2 is the Monster group.

16

...760493218841961

)(Tr)( 2

H240

qq

qqJqqZ

cL

Page 17: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Monstrous Moonshine

Since we have a Virasoro algebra we can expand the J(q)-function

in terms of Virasoro characters (traces of Verma modules)

17

...)(ch87629621)(ch883196)(ch1

...760493218841961

)(

320

2

qqq

qqq

qJ

)1()(ch,

)1()(ch

1

24/

2

24/

0h n

n

ch

hn

n

c

q

qq

q

qq

Page 18: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

18

Complex Analysis Number Theory

(mock) modular forms, Jacobi forms

Group Theory Representation Theory

finite (sporadic) groups String Theory

Monstrous Moonshine

Page 19: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

19

Complex Analysis Number Theory

(mock) modular forms, Jacobi forms

Group Theory Representation Theory

finite (sporadic) groups String Theory

Monstrous Moonshine

Very interesting for mathematicians!

Page 20: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Monstrous Moonshine

Compactification of the bosonic string:

we have a tachyon (instability)

spacetime theory has no fermions

Additionally

• Only two spacetime dimensions are non-compact

20

Page 21: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Monstrous Moonshine

Compactification of the bosonic string:

we have a tachyon (instability)

spacetime theory has no fermions

Additionally

• Only two spacetime dimensions are non-compact

21

Not so interesting for physicists!

Page 22: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Mathieu Moonshine

• In 2010 Eguchi, Ooguri and Tachikawa discovered a new moonshine phenomenon that connects K3 to the largest Mathieu group M24

Eguchi, Ooguri, Tachikawa 1004.0956

• They considered a N=(4,4) SCFT with K3 target and calculate an index that is called elliptic genus

22

Page 23: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Mathieu Moonshine

23

2400240 )1()1(Tr),( RRelliptic

cR

cL

LFJLFqyqyqZ

Witten index: No dependence on q

Chemical potential for U(1) in left-moving N=2 theory

Page 24: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Mathieu Moonshine

T. Eguchi, H. Ooguri, A. Taormina, S. -K. Yang Nucl. Phys. B 315, 193 (1989)

We have N=(4,4) world sheet supersymmetry

expand in N=4 Virasoro characters

24

2

4

2

4

2

3

2

3

2

2

2

2K3

)1,(

),(

)1,(

),(

)1,(

),(8),(

elliptic q

yq

q

yq

q

yqyqZ

Page 25: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Mathieu Moonshine

T. Eguchi, H. Ooguri, A. Taormina, S. -K. Yang Nucl. Phys. B 315, 193 (1989)

We have N=(4,4) world sheet supersymmetry

expand in N=4 Virasoro characters

N=4 Virasoro characters are defined by the trace over the

highest weight state and all its descendants

For the case h=c/24 there are short BPS multiplets

25

2

4

2

4

2

3

2

3

2

2

2

2K3

)1,(

),(

)1,(

),(

)1,(

),(8),(

elliptic q

yq

q

yq

q

yqyqZ

0240Tr),(ch lh,

JLyqyq

c

Page 26: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Mathieu Moonshine

T. Eguchi, H. Ooguri, A. Taormina, S. -K. Yang Nucl. Phys. B 315, 193 (1989)

We have N=(4,4) world sheet supersymmetry

expand in N=4 Virasoro characters T. Eguchi, K. Hikami 0904.0911

26

2

4

2

4

2

3

2

3

2

2

2

2K3

)1,(

),(

)1,(

),(

)1,(

),(8),(

elliptic q

yq

q

yq

q

yqyqZ

long

,1

long

,

short

0,

K3

21

41

21

41

41

ellipticchch2ch24

lnhn

nlhlhAZ

...},1440,462,90{nA

Page 27: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Mathieu Moonshine

T. Eguchi, H. Ooguri, A. Taormina, S. -K. Yang Nucl. Phys. B 315, 193 (1989)

We have N=(4,4) world sheet supersymmetry

expand in N=4 Virasoro characters T. Eguchi, K. Hikami 0904.0911

T. Eguchi, H. Ooguri, Y. Tachikawa 1004.0956

27

2

4

2

4

2

3

2

3

2

2

2

2K3

)1,(

),(

)1,(

),(

)1,(

),(8),(

elliptic q

yq

q

yq

q

yqyqZ

...},770770,231231,4545{ nADimensions of Irreps of M24

123

long

,1

long

,

short

0,

K3

21

41

21

41

41

ellipticchch2ch24

lnhn

nlhlhAZ

Page 28: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Mathieu Moonshine

Does this imply a connection between M24 and K3?

• The geometric symmetries of K3 are contained in M23 M24

Mukai, Kondo 1988, 1998

28

Page 29: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Mathieu Moonshine

Does this imply a connection between M24 and K3?

• The geometric symmetries of K3 are contained in M23 M24

Mukai, Kondo 1988, 1998

• The symmetry groups of N=(4,4) SCFT with K3 target are never M24 and for some points in moduli space do not even fit into M24

Gaberdiel, Hohenegger, Volpato 1106.4315

29

Page 30: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Mathieu Moonshine

Does this imply a connection between M24 and K3?

• The geometric symmetries of K3 are contained in M23 M24

Mukai, Kondo 1988, 1998

• The symmetry groups of N=(4,4) SCFT with K3 target are never M24 and for some points in moduli space do not even fit into M24

Gaberdiel, Hohenegger, Volpato 1106.4315

• However, all coefficients are positive sums of dimensions of M24

Gannon 1211.5531

30

K3

ellipticZ

Page 31: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Mathieu Moonshine

• K3 has played a central role in string compactifications and string dualities

• What are implications we can derive from Mathieu moonshine for string compactifications?

• Has the elliptic genus of K3 already appeared in the string theory literature?

31

Page 32: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Mathieu Moonshine

• K3 has played a central role in string compactifications and string dualities

• What are implications we can derive from Mathieu moonshine for string compactifications?

• Has the elliptic genus of K3 already appeared in the string theory literature?

32

YES!

Page 33: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Heterotic String Theory

• Consider the heterotic E8 x E8 string theory compactified on K3 x T2

• We need to embed 24 instantons into E8 x E8 (12+n,12-n) n = 0,1,…,12 to satisfy the Bianchi identity for H3

33

Page 34: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Heterotic String Theory

• Consider the heterotic E8 x E8 string theory compactified on K3 x T2

• We need to embed 24 instantons into E8 x E8 (12+n,12-n) n = 0,1,…,12 to satisfy the Bianchi identity for H3

• The resulting four dimensional theories preserves N=2 spacetime supersymmetry

• The 1-loop corrections to the prepotential are related to the new supersymmetric index Znew

Dixon, Kaplunovsky, Louis, de Wit, Lüst, Stieberger, Antoniadis, Narain, Taylor, Gava,

Kiritsis, Kounnas, Harvey, Moore, ….

34 )(),,( 21tree Siloop eOhhUTSh

Page 35: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

• The new supersymmetric index is defined as

• The trace is over our internal (22,9) conformal field theory for the heterotic E8xE8 string theory compactified on K3 x T2

2402400)1(Tr 0Rnew

cc LLJqqJZ

Heterotic String Theory

35

Page 36: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

• The new supersymmetric index is defined as

• The trace is over our internal (22,9) conformal field theory for the heterotic E8xE8 string theory compactified on K3 x T2

• We have a right moving N=2 SCFT from the T2 and we denote its U(1) generator J(1)

• For the K3 we have an N=4 SCFT with a level one SU(2). We define J(2) = 2 J3 where J3 is the SU(2) Cartan current

• Then J = J(1) + J(2)

2402400)1(Tr 0Rnew

cc LLJqqJZ

Heterotic String Theory

36

Page 37: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

• The new supersymmetric index is defined as

240)2(

0240)1(

0

240240)2(

0)1(

0

240240)2(

0)1(

0

)1()1(Tr

)1(Tr

)1()(Tr

)2(

0R

)1(

0R

)2(

0

)1(

0Rnew

cc

cc

cc

LJLJ

LLJJ

LLJJ

qJq

qqJ

qqJJZ

Heterotic String Theory

37

Page 38: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

• The new supersymmetric index is defined as

For SU(2) representations eigenvalues of J(2) come in opposite pairs

Heterotic String Theory

38

0)[...])1()1((

)1(Tr 240)2(

0)2(

0K3

n

n

n

LJ

nn

qJc

Z

240)2(

0240)1(

0

240240)2(

0)1(

0

240240)2(

0)1(

0

)1()1(Tr

)1(Tr

)1()(Tr

)2(

0R

)1(

0R

)2(

0

)1(

0Rnew

cc

cc

cc

LJLJ

LLJJ

LLJJ

qJq

qqJ

qqJJZ

Page 39: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

• The new supersymmetric index is defined as

Heterotic String Theory

39

0

240)2(

0240)1(

0

240240)2(

0)1(

0

240240)2(

0)1(

0

)1()1(Tr

)1(Tr

)1()(Tr

)2(

0R

)1(

0R

)2(

0

)1(

0Rnew

cc

cc

cc

LJLJ

LLJJ

LLJJ

qJq

qqJ

qqJJZ

Page 40: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

• The new supersymmetric index is defined as

• Now we calculate it for the standard embedding SU(2) E8 for a compactification on K3 x T2

240)2(

0)1(

0240

240)2(

0240)1(

0

240240)2(

0)1(

0

240240)2(

0)1(

0

)1(Tr

)1()1(Tr

)1(Tr

)1()(Tr

)1(

0R

)2(

0R

)1(

0R

)2(

0

)1(

0Rnew

cc

cc

cc

cc

LJJL

LJLJ

LLJJ

LLJJ

qJq

qJq

qqJ

qqJJZ

Heterotic String Theory

40

0

Page 41: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

For K3 x T2 compactifications we have for the standard embedding

that preserves N=(4,4)

Compare to

We will get contributions from at different y-values

240)2(

0)1(

0240 )1(Tr )1(

0Rnew

cc LJJLqJqZ

Heterotic String Theory

41

Witten index

2400240 )1()1(Tr),( RRelliptic

cR

cL

LFJLFqyqyqZ

),(K3

ellipticyqZ

Page 42: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

For K3 x T2 compactifications we have for the standard embedding

that preserves N=(4,4)

Harvey, Moore hep-th/9510182

T is the complexified Kähler modulus, U the complex structure

modulus of the T2

),()(

)(),(

)(

)(

)1,()(

)(

(q)

(q)E

)(

),(

2),;(

21

41

21

41

2,2

K3

elliptic

6

4K3

elliptic

6

3

K3

elliptic

6

2

8

4

4new

qqZqq

qqqZq

q

q

qZq

q

q

UTiUTqZ

Heterotic String Theory

42

SO(12) characters

SO(12) characters

Affine E8

Page 43: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

For K3 x T2 compactifications we have for the standard embedding

that preserves N=(4,4)

Harvey, Moore hep-th/9510182

So in particular the […] part has an “SO(12)xM24”-expansion:

exactly the same M24 as in Mathieu Moonshine due to N=(4,4)

Heterotic String Theory

43

SO(12) characters

SO(12) characters

Affine E8

),()(

)(),(

)(

)(

)1,()(

)(

(q)

(q)E

)(

),(

2),;(

21

41

21

41

2,2

K3

elliptic

6

4K3

elliptic

6

3

K3

elliptic

6

2

8

4

4new

qqZqq

qqqZq

q

q

qZq

q

q

UTiUTqZ

Page 44: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

For K3 x T2 compactifications we have for the standard embedding

that preserves N=(4,4)

n

n

nlhlhlh

lhlhlh

lhlhlh

qAqq

qqqq

q

qq

q

q

qqqq

qqqq

q

qq

q

q

qqqq

qqqq

q

qq

q

q

q

UTiUTqZ

1

long

,

6

4long

,

6

3long

,

6

2

short

,

6

4short

,

6

3short

,

6

2

short

0,

6

4short

0,

6

3short

0,

6

2

8

4

4new

21

41

41

21

21

41

41

21

41

21

21

41

41

21

21

41

41

21

41

21

41

41

21

41

41

41

2,2

ch)(

)(),(ch

)(

)()1,(ch

)(

)(

),(ch)(

)(),(ch

)(

)()1,(ch

)(

)(2

),(ch)(

)(),(ch

)(

)()1,(ch

)(

)(24

(q)

(q)E

)(

),(

2),;(

Heterotic String Theory

44 ...},770770,231231,4545{ nADimensions of Irreps of M24

Page 45: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

For K3 x T2 compactifications we have for the standard (24,0)

instanton embedding

Harvey, Moore hep-th/9510182

So in particular the E6(q) has an “SO(12)xM24”-expansion

24

64

12

6

8

4

4new(q)

(q)(q)EE),(

2(q)

(q)E

(q)

(q)E

)(

),(

2),;( 2,22,2

UTi

q

UTiUTqZ

Heterotic String Theory

45

Affine E8

Page 46: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

For K3 x T2 compactifications we have for the standard embedding

that preserves N=(4,4)

T is the complexified Kähler modulus, U the complex structure

modulus of the T2

Heterotic String Theory

46

Take away message:

Znew depends on T and U and is connected

to Zelliptic and therefore to M24

Page 47: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Heterotic String Theory

The 1-loop correction to the prepotential is roughly determined

by

and knows about M24 since Znew does

M. Cheng, X. Dong, J. Duncan, J. Harvey, S. Kachru, TW 1306.4981

47

)(),;(),(28

122

new

2

2

QUTeqZ

dUT i

Page 48: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Heterotic String Theory

The 1-loop correction to the prepotential is roughly determined

by

and knows about M24 since Znew does

M. Cheng, X. Dong, J. Duncan, J. Harvey, S. Kachru, TW 1306.4981

The modular invariance of actually tells us that

there is a unique solution. So for all instanton embeddings

(12+n,12-n) the answer is the same. Kiritsis, Kounnas, Petropoulos, Rizos hep-th/9608034

Henningson, Moore hep-th/9608145

48

)(),;(),(28

122

new

2

2

QUTeqZ

dUT i

)(28

12

new2 QZ

Page 49: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Heterotic String Theory

The 1-loop correction to the prepotential is roughly determined

by

and knows about M24 since Znew does

M. Cheng, X. Dong, J. Duncan, J. Harvey, S. Kachru, TW 1306.4981

We have to solve the following second order differential equation Harvey, Moore hep-th/9510182

49

)])()(Re(log[4]2(log[2

)()()(),;(

2

1

)])()(Re(log[1

)1(1

Re

118

8812

2

2

1

11

11

1

28iUiTUT

EbEbQUTqiZ

d

iUJiTJhUTUT

h

Enew

loop

UT

loop

UT

)(),;(),(28

122

new

2

2

QUTeqZ

dUT i

Page 50: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Heterotic String Theory

The solution is given by

where the polylogarithm is given by

50

lk

lUkTiloop eLiklcCUh,

)(2

3

3

311 )()(

1

33 )(n

n

n

xxLi

Page 51: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Heterotic String Theory

The solution is given by

where

51

lk

lUkTiloop eLiklcCUh,

)(2

3

3

311 )()(

Dimensions of M24

1

new )(),(2

),;(2,2

m

mqmcUTi

UTqZ

The solution is given by

where the polylogarithm is given by and the expansion coefficients are the same as in our index (they go along for the ride when integrating)

1

33 )(n

n

n

xxLi

Page 52: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Heterotic String Theory

The solution is given by

where

52

lk

lUkTiloop eLiklcCUh,

)(2

3

3

311 )()(

Dimensions of M24

1

new )(),(2

),;(2,2

m

mqmcUTi

UTqZ

The solution is given by

where the polylogarithm is given by and the expansion coefficients are the same as in our index (they go along for the ride when integrating)

1

33 )(n

n

n

xxLi

Dimensions of M24 (appearing in a spacetime quantity)

Page 53: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Type IIA on CY3

Type IIA string theory

on elliptic fibrations

over Fn (Hirzebruch

surface)

53

Heterotic string

on K3 x T2 with

instanton embedding

(12+n,12-n)

String duality

Page 54: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Type IIA on CY3

Type IIA string theory

on elliptic fibrations

over Fn (Hirzebruch

surface)

Fn

Size of base S2

54

Heterotic string

on K3 x T2 with

instanton embedding

(12+n,12-n)

dilaton S

String duality

Page 55: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Type IIA string theory on elliptic fibrations over Fn:

• Prepotential receives instanton corrections

• These are determined by the Gromow-Witten invariants curve counting (S2, T2, …)

Type IIA on CY3

55

Page 56: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Type IIA string theory on elliptic fibrations over Fn:

• Prepotential receives instanton corrections

• These are determined by the Gromow-Witten invariants curve counting (S2, T2, …)

M. Cheng, X. Dong, J. Duncan, J. Harvey, S. Kachru, TW 1306.4981

M. Alim, E. Scheidegger 1205.1784 A. Klemm, J. Manschot, T. Wotschke 1205.1795

Type IIA on CY3

56

)()()(),,( 2

,

)(2

3

3

31 iS

lk

lUkTi eOeLiklcCUSTUUTSh

Dimensions of M24 (appearing in a spacetime quantity)

Page 57: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Type IIB on CY3

Type IIB string theory

on mirror manifold

57

Type IIA string theory

on elliptic fibrations over

Fn (Hirzebruch surface)

String duality

Page 58: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Type IIB on CY3

Type IIB string theory

on mirror manifold

CY3 manifold Yn

Periods of the holo-morphic 3-form

58

Type IIA string theory

on elliptic fibrations over

Fn (Hirzebruch surface)

CY3 manifold Xn

Gromov-Witten invariants

String duality

Page 59: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Complex Analysis Number Theory

(mock) modular forms, Jacobi forms

(Algebraic) Geometry periods of Calabi-Yau manifolds, Gromov-Witten invariants, elliptic genus, …

Cool new math connections!

Group Theory Representation Theory

finite (sporadic) groups

N E W

String Theory

59

Page 60: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Moonshine and physics

“I have a sneaking hope, a hope unsupported by any facts or any evidence, that sometime in the twenty-first century physicists will stumble upon the Monster group, built in some unsuspected way into the structure of the Universe.”

– Freeman Dyson (1983)

60

Page 61: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Moonshine and physics

For the K3xT2 compactifications, the 1-loop prepotential

controls the 1-loop corrections to the gauge couplings in

the N=2 spacetime theory

61

Page 62: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Moonshine and physics

For the K3xT2 compactifications, the 1-loop prepotential

controls the 1-loop corrections to the gauge couplings in

the N=2 spacetime theory

For four dimensional N=1 models obtained from orbifold

compactifications of the heterotic E8 x E8 string theory:

62

)(),(),,( 2loop1 SieOUTfSUTSf

Page 63: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Moonshine and physics

For the K3xT2 compactifications, the 1-loop prepotential

controls the 1-loop corrections to the gauge couplings in

the N=2 spacetime theory

For four dimensional N=1 models obtained from orbifold

compactifications of the heterotic E8 x E8 string theory:

The (bulk) moduli dependent 1-loop correction to the gauge

kinetic function arises only from N=2 subsectors! Dixon, Louis, Kaplunovsky Nuclear Physics B 355 (1991)

63

)(),(),,( 2loop1 SieOUTfSUTSf

Page 64: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Moonshine and physics

Example T6/Z6-II = T2 x T2 x T2/Z6-II :

64

),,(),,(:, 32

3/2

1

3/

3216 zzezezzzgg ii

II

Z

Page 65: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Moonshine and physics

Example T6/Z6-II = T2 x T2 x T2/Z6-II :

has two N=2 subsector

65

),,(),,(:, 32

3/2

1

3/

3216 zzezezzzgg ii

II

Z

),,(),,(:},,1{

),,(),,(:},,,1{

321321

33

2

32

3/4

1

3/2

321

242

3

zzzzzzgg

zzezezzzggg ii

Z

Z

Page 66: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Moonshine and physics

Example T6/Z6-II = T2 x T2 x T2/Z6-II :

has two N=2 subsector

For which the internal space is T4/Z3 x T2 or T4/Z2 x T2

respectively and therefore an orbifold limit of T2 x K3.

66

),,(),,(:, 32

3/2

1

3/

3216 zzezezzzgg ii

II

Z

),,(),,(:},,1{

),,(),,(:},,,1{

321321

33

2

32

3/4

1

3/2

321

242

3

zzzzzzgg

zzezezzzggg ii

Z

Z

Page 67: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Moonshine and physics

N=2 sectors lead to 1-loop corrections

67

)])()((log[4

)()(log[8

1

),(2

1

||

|'|),(

2

2

,

2

1

3,2,1

loop1

ii

N

i

ii

ii

loop

iUT

i

i

iUiTb

iUJiTJ

UThG

GUTf

ii

N=1 gauge kinetic coupling

N=2 prepotential

Page 68: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Moonshine and physics

N=2 sectors lead to 1-loop corrections

where the prepotential was calculated above

68

)])()((log[4

)()(log[8

1

),(2

1

||

|'|),(

2

2

,

2

1

3,2,1

loop1

ii

N

i

ii

ii

loop

iUT

i

i

iUiTb

iUJiTJ

UThG

GUTf

ii

lk

lUkTiloop eLiklcCUUTh,

)(2

3

3

311 )()(),(

Dimensions of M24

N=1 gauge kinetic coupling

N=2 prepotential

Page 69: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Moonshine and physics

69

No N=2 sectors

Page 70: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Moonshine and physics

70

Page 71: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Moonshine and physics

Four dimensional N=1 models obtained from orbifold

compactifications of the heterotic E8 x E8 string theory

receive universal 1-loop corrections to their gauge

kinetic functions that are related to M24 TW 1402.2973

71

Page 72: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Moonshine and physics

Four dimensional N=1 models obtained from orbifold

compactifications of the heterotic E8 x E8 string theory

receive universal 1-loop corrections to their gauge

kinetic functions that are related to M24 TW 1402.2973

For all T6/ZN, N3,7, and all T6/ZNxZM

72

)(...)()(),,( 2

,

)(2

3

iS

lk

lUkTi

UT eOeLiklcSUTSf

Dimensions of M24

Page 73: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Moonshine and physics

N. Paquette, TW work in progress:

• The holomorphic 3-form plays a role in flux compactifications

Gukov, Vafa, Witten hep-th/9906070 Giddings, Kachru, Polchinski hep-th/0105097

73

... HW

Page 74: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Moonshine and physics

N. Paquette, TW work in progress:

• The holomorphic 3-form plays a role in flux compactifications

Gukov, Vafa, Witten hep-th/9906070 Giddings, Kachru, Polchinski hep-th/0105097

74

... HW

Flux vacua might have large symmetry groups: |M24| 2 x 109

Page 75: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Moonshine and physics

N. Paquette, TW work in progress:

• The holomorphic 3-form plays a role in flux compactifications

Gukov, Vafa, Witten hep-th/9906070 Giddings, Kachru, Polchinski hep-th/0105097

• The Yukawa couplings in heterotic models are given by the third derivative of with respect to the moduli Hosono, Klemm, Theisen, Yau hep-th/9308122

75

... HW

),,( UTShY KJIIJK

Page 76: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

New Moonshine phenomena

Consider eight (left-moving) bosons and fermions

compactified on the orbifold T8/ 2 = R8/ΛE8 / 2

The partition function in the NS sector is Frenkel, Lepowsky, Meurman 1985

Duncan math/0502267

76

...1120220482761

)( 23

qqqq

qZ

Sums of dimensions of Conway group

Page 77: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

New Moonshine phenomena

Consider eight (left-moving) bosons and fermions

compactified on the orbifold T8/ 2 = R8/ΛE8 / 2

Tensor left- and right movers together in an

asymmetric orbifold where we act with one 2 on

the left and with another one only on the right:

The asymmetric orbifold preserves N=(4,4) symmetry

77

)()(),(partition qZqZqqZ

Page 78: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

New Moonshine phenomena

Asymmetric orbifold T8/ 2 x 2 = R8/ΛE8 / 2 x 2

Calculate the elliptic genus and expand in N=4 characters:

Two infinite series, coefficients unrelated to Conway

78

...ch4444ch210

...ch8470ch560

chch21

long

1,

long

1,

long

,

long

,

short

1,

short

0,

25

23

21

25

21

23

21

21

elliptic

lhlh

lhlh

lhlhZ

Page 79: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

New Moonshine phenomena

Asymmetric orbifold T8/ 2 x 2 = R8/ΛE8 / 2 x 2

Calculate the elliptic genus and expand in N=4 characters:

All coefficients are dimensions of the Mathieu group M22!

Checks all work and one can see M22 Co preserving N=4 M. Cheng, X. Dong, J. Duncan, S. Harrison, S. Kachru, TW to appear

79

...ch4444ch210

...ch8470ch560

chch21

long

1,

long

1,

long

,

long

,

short

1,

short

0,

25

23

21

25

21

23

21

21

elliptic

lhlh

lhlh

lhlhZ

Page 80: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Conclusion

• Mathieu Moonshine involves K3 that has played a crucial role in superstring compactifications and string dualities

• Certain CY3 manifolds are now also implicated in Mathieu Moonshine

• This leads to a variety of intriguing implications for physically interesting string compactifications

• Much more to come!

80

Page 81: Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactificationsmi.physics.tamu.edu/docs/mifpa/meetings/heterotic-strings/Timm_Wrase.pdf · Mathieu Moonshine and Heterotic String Compactifications

Conclusion

• Mathieu Moonshine involves K3 that has played a crucial role in superstring compactifications and string dualities

• Certain CY3 manifolds are now also implicated in Mathieu Moonshine

• This leads to a variety of intriguing implications for physically interesting string compactifications

• Much more to come!

THANK YOU! 81