67
Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors Master Thesis Christopher S. Buehler !""#$%&'($ *+&,-%#&$. !"#$$% $' ()*+,-** .,/ 0"$,$1+"* 2..*34+"#35 6#- 7-3#-4%.,/* 89 :-;4).4< =>88 /"0-" ?#4+*3$@#-4 !A ()-#%-4 1$23." B,3-4,.3+$,.% ()*+,-** 45'2#" !34.3-C< .,/ B,,$D.3+$, 126-%,&#5%" E4A F,+3. D., G+%*

Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

!!!

Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of

directors !!

Master Thesis Christopher S. Buehler

!""#$%&'($)*+&,-%#&$.))!"#$$%&$'&()*+,-**&.,/&0"$,$1+"*&&2..*34+"#35&6#-&7-3#-4%.,/*&&&&89&:-;4).4<&=>88&!/"0-"!?#4+*3$@#-4&!A&()-#%-4!1$23."!B,3-4,.3+$,.%&()*+,-**!45'2#"!!34.3-C<&.,/&B,,$D.3+$,!126-%,&#5%"!E4A&F,+3.&D.,&G+%*!!!!!!!

Page 2: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!2!

789/:;<=>?=!=/@1)

!3!4.*'0!5*+6!'&7-!6.!6$7-!68&+!.99./6*,&6(!6.!68$,7!$!,*%:-/!.;!&,0&<&0*$'+!$,0!./=$,&>$6&.,+!;./!68-&/!

$++&+6$,?-! $,0! +*99./6! 0*/&,=! 68-! ?.,+6/*?6&.,! .;! 68&+! 68-+&+@! #&/+6! $,0! ;./-%.+6A! 3! 4.*'0! '&7-! 6.!

-B6-,0! %(! =/$?&.*+! +*99./6! 6.! 68-! ./=$,&>$6&.,+! 68$6! .;;-/-0! *9! 68-&/! <$'*$:'-! 6&%-! 6.! 9/.<&0-!

&,6-/<&-4+@!C&68.*6! 68-!4&''&,=,-++!.;! 68-+-!,*%-/.*+! ;$%&'(!:*+&,-++-+A!,.,-!.;! 68&+!4.*'0!8$<-!

:--,!9.++&:'-@!3!4.*'0!$'+.!'&7-!6.!68$,7!68-!;.''.4&,=!&,0&<&0*$'+!;./!68-&/!+*99./6"!

!

>%A)7+&$"),"+)?&B#A!D/.;-++./!$6!E$$+6/&?86!F,&<-/+&6(!$,0!+*9-/<&+./!.;!68&+!68-+&+A!;./!8-/!?.,6&,*-0!

$++&+6$,?-!68/.*=8.*6!68-!-,6&/-!4/&6&,=!9/.?-++G!

)

C%-+$)D"$05#A!.4,-/!.;!D-/9-6*$'!H-<-'.9%-,6A! ;./!8&+! 6&%-A! +*==-+6&.,+A!$,0!<$/&.*+!0.?*%-,6+!

+*//.*,0&,=!8&+!:.$/0!%-%:-/!:-,?8%$/7&,=!$,0!$++-++%-,6!9/.=/$%+G!

)

>%A) E5(+);"%3A! D/.;-++./! $6! 68-! I-''.==! J?8..'! .;!E$,$=-%-,6A! ;./! 8&+! $&0! &,! 9/.<&0&,=! <$'*$:'-!

&,;./%$6&.,!;./!68-!?.,6-,6!.;!%(!68-+&+G!

!

4%&-+3#) "+3) F"0&B.! ;./! 68-&/! *,/-'-,6&,=! +*99./6! 0*/&,=! ,.6! .,'(! 68-! 68-+&+! 4/&6&,=! 9/.?-++A! :*6!

68/.*=8.*6!%(!-,6&/-!+6*0(!9-/&.0!$6!E$$+6/&?86!F,&<-/+&6(@!

!

K8/&+6.98-/!J@!)*-8'-/!

E$+6-/!+6*0-,6A!EJ?!3,6-/,$6&.,$'!)*+&,-++!

E$$+6/&?86!F,&<-/+&6(A!2LMLN2LMM!

Page 3: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!O!

7C1@G78@)

#$%&'(! :*+&,-++-+! 8$<-! $'4$(+! :--,! $! 8.6! 6.9&?! &,! 68-! $?$0-%&?! ?.%%*,&6(@! E./-! /-?-,6'(A!

8.4-<-/A! ;.?*+! 8$+! 6*/,-0! 6.! 68-! ;$%&'(! :*+&,-++! :.$/0/..%! $,0! 68-! -<-,6+! .??*//&,=! 4&68&,@!

P8-./&-+! ?.,6&,*-! 6.! +4&/'! $/.*,0! :.$/0/..%! $?6&<&6&-+A! &,?'*0&,=! 0&/-?6./! %.6&<$6&.,+A! 0-?&+&.,+A!

$,0!$?6&.,+A!$+!+?8.'$/+!$66-%96!6.!-B9'$&,!68-!&,6-/,$'!4./7&,=+!.;!+*?8!./=$,&>$6&.,$'!+6/*?6*/-+@!Q+!

?.%9-6&6&.,! &,?/-$+-+A! =-,-/$6&.,+! 9/.=/-++A! $,0! ;$%&'(! :*+&,-++-+! +--7! ,-4! $<-,*-+! 6.! +*??--0A!

0&+?*++&.,+!.;! &,0-9-,0-,6!:.$/0!%-%:-/+!.,! ;$%&'(!:*+&,-++!:.$/0+!.;!0&/-?6./+!8$<-! +6$/6-0! 6.!

-,6-/! 68-! $?$0-%&?! $,0! :*+&,-++! +9.6'&=86+@! Q+! ;$%&'(! :*+&,-++-+! +6/&<-! 6.! 6$?7'-! 68-! &++*-! .;!

/-?/*&6&,=! &,0-9-,0-,6!:.$/0!%-%:-/+A! +.!0.! +?8.'$/+! &,!$,!$66-%96! 6.!*,0-/+6$,0! 68-!9/.?-++-+!

:-8&,0!+*?8!$,!&%9./6$,6!-<-,6@!Q+!$!/-+*'6A!68-!$&%!.;!68&+!/-+-$/?8!&+!6.!-B$%&,-!$,0!$0<$,?-!68-!

*,0-/+6$,0&,=! :-8&,0! +-'-?6&.,! 9/.?-++-+! ;./! &,0-9-,0-,6! 0&/-?6./+! .,! 9/&<$6-A! ;$%&'(! :*+&,-++!

:.$/0+!.;!0&/-?6./+@!

!

P8&+! +6*0(! +*/<-(+! 68-! +-'-?6&.,! 9/.?-0*/-+! ;./! -&=86! 9/&<$6-! ;$%&'(! :*+&,-++! ?./9./$6&.,+! &,! 68-!

F,&6-0! J6$6-+@! 3,6-/<&-4+! ?.,0*?6-0! 4&68! ;$%&'(! -B-?*6&<-+! ?'.+-! 6.! 68-&/! /-+9-?6&<-! ?.%9$,(R+!

9/.?-++! 8-'9-0! 6.! /-<-$'! 68-! &,,-/! 0(,$%&?+A! %.6&<$6&.,+A! 0-+&/-+A! $,0! .68-/! -'-%-,6+! .;! +*?8!

?.%9'-B!0-?&+&.,+@!#*/68-/%./-A!68-!+6*0(!$'+.!&,<-+6&=$6-0!+.%-!9.+6N+-'-?6&.,!?.,+&0-/$6&.,+!68$6!

$99-$/! &,! ?*//-,6!$?$0-%&?! '&6-/$6*/-! /-=$/0&,=! ;$%&'(!:*+&,-++!:.$/0+@!Q'68.*=8! 68-! &,6-,6!.;! 68-!

+6*0(!4$+!,.6!6.!0-6-/%&,-!68-!-;;-?6&<-,-++!.;!.,-!9$/6&?*'$/!%-68.0!.<-/!$,.68-/A!&6!0.-+!/-<-$'!$!

,*%:-/!.;!&,+&=86;*'!0-6$&'+@!

!

P8-!;.''.4&,=!/-+-$/?8!/-+*'6+!-B8&:&6! 64.!%$&,! &,0-9-,0-,6!0&/-?6./!+-'-?6&.,!9$68+"! &,;./%$'!$,0!

;./%$'@!Q'68.*=8!:.68!$/-!$++*%-0!6.!/-$?8!68-!+$%-!=.$'A!68-!+-'-?6&.,!/.*6-+!68-%+-'<-+!$/-!S*&6-!

0&;;-/-,6@! C&68! $=-,?(! 68-./(! $,0! +6-4$/0+8&9! 68-./(! 9'$(&,=! $! +&=,&;&?$,6! /.'-! 68/.*=8.*6! 68-!

+-'-?6&.,! -<-,6+A! 68-! /-+*'6+! ?.,6&,*-! 6.! +8-0! '&=86! .,! 68-! %-68.0+! &,! 48&?8! 68-+-! 68-./&-+!

?.,6/&:*6-!./!9.++&:'(!8&,0-/!68-!$:&'&6(!.;!;$%&'(!:.$/0+!6.!%$7-!.:5-?6&<-!0-?&+&.,+!$,0!*'6&%$6-'(!

+-'-?6!.*6+&0-!0&/-?6./+!68$6!+-/<-!&,!68-!:-+6!&,6-/-+6!.;!68-&/!/-+9-?6&<-!;$%&'(N.4,-0!./=$,&>$6&.,+@!

!!!!!!!!!!!

Page 4: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!T!

@7C<=):4)8:/@=/@1)

M@!3UPVWHFKP3WU!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!X!

2@!#QE3YZ!)FJ3U[JJ!)WQVHJ!N!Y3P[VQPFV[!V[\3[C!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!]!

2@M!#$%&'(!:*+&,-++!:.$/0+!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!]!

2@M@M!#$%&'(!:*+&,-++!:.$/0!+6/*?6*/-!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!ML!

2@M@2!K.,<-/=&,=!68-./&-+!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!MO!

2@M@O!P$+7+!$,0!?.%9.+&6&.,+!.;!+*9-/<&+./(!$,0!$0<&+./(!:.$/0+!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!MT!

2@M@T!K*//-,6!%.0-'+!&,!9'$?-!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!M]!

2@2!3,0&<&0*$'!:.$/0!%-%:-/+!$,0!68-!+-'-?6&.,!9/.?-++!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!2L!

2@2@M!3,6-/,$'!<+@!-B6-/,$'!0&/-?6./+!$,0!<$'*-!?/-$6&.,!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!2L!

2@2@2!K.,+&0-/$6&.,+!.;!-B6-/,$'!:.$/0!%-%:-/+!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!2M!

2@2@O!)*+&,-++!,--0+!<-/+*+!9/-;-/-,?-+!.;!9-/+.,$'&6(!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!22!

2@2@T!J*%%$/(!.;!68-!'&6-/$6*/-!.,!68-!+-'-?6&.,!9/.?-++!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!2O!

2@2@^!Y&%&6$6&.,+!.,!+-'-?6&.,!9/.?-++!$,0!/-+-$/?8!S*-+6&.,!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!2T!

O@!E[P_WHWYW`Z!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!2a!

O@M!V-+-$/?8!;./%$6!$,0!+6*0(!0-+&=,!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!2a!

O@2!J$%9'-!.;!;$%&'(!;&/%+!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!2b!

O@O!H$6$!?.''-?6&.,!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!2b!

T@!V[JFYPJ!QUH!H3JKFJJ3WU!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!OM!

T@M!#$%&'(!:*+&,-++!?$+-+"!$,!.<-/<&-4!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!OM!

T@2!3,&6&$'!0-+&/-+!;./!&,0-9-,0-,6!0&/-?6./+!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!OO!

T@2@M!H-;&,&,=!68-!&,0-9-,0-,6!0&/-?6./R+!/.'-!.,!68-!;$%&'(!:.$/0!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!O^!

T@O!F,0-/+6$,0&,=!68-!+-'-?6&.,!9/.?-++!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!O^!

T@O@M!3,&6&$'!+-$/?8!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!OX!

T@O@2!J-$/?8!$,0!/-+.*/?-!?.,+&0-/$6&.,+!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!TL!

T@O@O!#&,$'!?.,+&0-/$6&.,+!9/&./!6.!?$,0&0$6-!+-'-?6&.,!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!T2!

T@^!D.+6N+-'-?6&.,!?.,+&0-/$6&.,+"!0&/-?6./!6-/%+!.;!+-/<&?-!$,0!:.$/0!-<$'*$6&.,+!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!TT!

T@X!H&+?*++&.,!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!Ta!

^@!KWUKYFJ3WUJ!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!̂ M!

^@M!K.,?'*+&.,!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!̂ M!

^@2!E$,$=-/&$'!&%9'&?$6&.,+!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!̂ 2!

^@O!Y&%&6$6&.,+!$,0!0&/-?6&.,+!;./!;*6*/-!/-+-$/?8!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!̂ O!

X@!V[#[V[UK[J!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!̂ ^!

QDD[UH3c!Q"!J6*0(!/-+*'6+!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!̂ ]!

QDD[UH3c!)"!)-,?8%$/7!$++-++%-,6+!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!X2!

QDD[UH3c!K"!3,6-/<&-4!S*-+6&.,,$&/-!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!XX!

Page 5: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!^!

@7C<=):4)4H?*G=1)

#&=*/-!M"!#$%&'(!:*+&,-++!:.$/0!.;!0&/-?6./+!+6/*?6*/-!$,0!&,;'*-,?-+!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!MM!

#&=*/-!2"!).$/0!.;!0&/-?6./+!;/$%-4./7!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!M]!

#&=*/-!O"!J&B!0-=/--+!.;!:.$/0!.;!0&/-?6./+!&,<.'<-%-,6!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!Mb!

#&=*/-!T"!V.'-!.;!68-!+*9-/<&+./(!:.$/0!%-%:-/!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!2L!

#&=*/-!^"!J*%%$/(!.;!'&6-/$6*/-!.,!+-'-?6&.,!9/.?-++!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!2O!

#&=*/-!X"!Y&,-$/!9/.?-++!;./!?$+-!+6*0(!/-+-$/?8!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!2a!

#&=*/-!a"!J$%9'-!.;!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++!;&/%+!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!2b!

#&=*/-!]"!`-,-/$'!?'$++&;&?$6&.,!$,0!.<-/<&-4!.;!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++-+!&,6-/<&-4-0!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!O2!

#&=*/-!b"!3,;./%$'!$,0!;./%$'!+-$/?8!9/.?-++-+!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!Ob!

#&=*/-!ML"!Q00&6&.,$'!+-'-?6&.,!9/.?-++!?.,+&0-/$6&.,+!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!TT!

#&=*/-!MM"!P-/%+!$,0!6-/%!'&%&6+!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!T^!

!

7DD=/>HI)4H?*G=1)

Q99-,0&B!#&=*/-!M"!`-,-/$'!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++!?'$++&;&?$6&.,!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!̂ ]!

Q99-,0&B!#&=*/-!2"!3,&6&$'!0-+&/-+!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!̂ ]!

Q99-,0&B!#&=*/-!O"!3,&6&$'!+-$/?8!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!̂ b!

Q99-,0&B!#&=*/-!T"!J-$/?8!$,0!/-+.*/?-!?.,+&0-/$6&.,+!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!XL!

Q99-,0&B!#&=*/-!^"!Q00&6&.,$'!?$,0&0$6-!+-'-?6&.,!?.,+&0-/$6&.,+!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!XM!

Q99-,0&B!#&=*/-!X"!D.+6N+-'-?6&.,!?.,+&0-/$6&.,+!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!XM!

Q99-,0&B!#&=*/-!a"!)-,?8%$/7!$++-++%-,6+!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!X2!

Q99-,0&B!#&=*/-!]"![B$%9'-!;'.4!?8$/6!;./!-B6-/,$'!:.$/0!%-%:-/!d[)Ee!+-'-?6&.,!@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@!X^!

! !

Page 6: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!X!

JA)H/@G:>*8@H:/)

#$%&'(!:*+&,-++-+! &,!=-,-/$'!8$<-!:--,!$,$'(>-0!&,6-,+-'(!;./!%$,(!(-$/+@!`&<-,!68-!?.%9'-B&6(!.;!

+*?8!;/$=&'-!:*+&,-++!+(+6-%+A!&6!&+!8$/0'(!$!%(+6-/(!$+!6.!48(!+6*0&-+!?.,6&,*-!6.!0-'<-!0--9-/!&,6.!

68-! +--%&,='(! ?.*,6'-++! ;$%&'(! :*+&,-++! 6.9&?+@! E./-! /-?-,6'(A! 8.4-<-/A! &,?/-$+-0! $66-,6&.,! 8$+!

;.?*+-0! .,! ;$%&'(! :*+&,-++! :.$/0+! .;! 0&/-?6./+! &,! 9$/6&?*'$/@! W;! ?.*/+-A! ;$%&'(! ./=$,&>$6&.,+! 9.+-!

*,&S*-!?8$''-,=-+!4&68&,!68-!:*+&,-++!4./'0A!4&68!?.%9'&?$6&.,+!.;!;$%&'(!$,0!:*+&,-++!&,6-/N64&,&,=!

&,!68-!.<-/$''!=.<-/,$,?-!9/.?-++@!P8&+!?.,;'&?6!8$+!'-0!%$,(!/-+-$/?8-/+!6.4$/0!68-!-B9'./$6&.,!.;!

;$%&'(! :*+&,-++! :.$/0! ?.%9.+&6&.,! $,0! 68-! $99$/-,6! ?8$''-,=-+! .;! ?.%:&,&,=! ;$%&'(! 0&/-?6./+! $,0!

&,0-9-,0-,6!0&/-?6./+!.,!$!+&,='-!;$%&'(!;&/%!:.$/0!dK./:-66$!f!J$'<$6.A!2LLTG!g.8$,,&++.,!f!_*+-A!

2LLLG!Y$,-A!Q+6/$?8-,A!I-(6A!f!E?E&''$,A!2LLXG!W+&A!2LLbe@!

!

Q'68.*=8!68-!&0-$!.;!&,<&6&,=!&,0-9-,0-,6!0&/-?6./+!.,6.!$!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++!:.$/0!%$(!+--%!+&%9'-!$6!

;&/+6A!68-!9/.?-++!&+!/&00'-0!4&68!?.%9'&?$6&.,+A!+.%-!.;!48&?8!/-'$6-!0&/-?6'(!6.!$?$0-%&?!68-./(!$,0!

.68-/+! 68$6! 9-/6$&,! 6.! &0-$+! ,.6! (-6! ;*''(! *,0-/+6..0! :(! +?8.'$/+@! U-<-/68-'-++A! ?.%9-6&6&.,!

?.,6&,*-+! 6.! &,?/-$+-!$,0! ;$%&'(!:*+&,-++-+!9-/9-6*$''(! +--7!4$(+! 6.! /-%$&,!.,! 6.9@! 3,0-9-,0-,6!

0&/-?6./+!9/.<&0-!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++!4&68!$!+.*/?-!.;!h.:5-?6&<&6(!ijk!6.!-,+*/-!68$6!0&;;&?*'6!6.9&?+!$/-!

$00/-++-0! &,! $! %$,,-/! 68$6! 9/.6-?6+! '.,=N6-/%! <&$:&'&6(! .;! 68-! :*+&,-++A! $+! 4-''! $+! 68-! ;$%&'(!

/-'$6&.,+8&9+! 68$6!%$(!:-!0&/-?6'(! ./! &,0&/-?6'(! &%9$?6-0l! dC$/0A! 2LMLA! 9@! T^e@!C&68! +*?8! $! ?/&6&?$'!

/.'-!&,!68-!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++A!?.%9$,&-+!.;6-,!?/-$6-!0-6$&'-0!+-'-?6&.,!9/.?-++-+!6.!;&-'0!?$,0&0$6-+!&,!

$! +(+6-%$6&?! $,0! +6/*?6*/-0! 9/.?-++@! C8&'-! $! ,*%:-/! +?8.'$/+! 8$<-! 4/&66-,! $:.*6! 68-! .<-/$''!

+-'-?6&.,! 9/.?-++! d)$%%-,+A! \../0-?7-/+A! f! `&'+A! 2LMLG! K./:-66$! f! J$'<$6.A! 2LLTG! _*+-A! 2LLLG!

g.8$,,&++.,!f!_*+-A!2LLLG!Y$,-!-6!$'@A!2LLXG!W+&A!2LLbeA!&,?'*0&,=!&0-$'!?.,+&0-/$6&.,+!dC$/0A!2LMLeA!

;-4! 8$<-! 9-/;./%-0! +6*0&-+! .,! 68-! $?6*$'! 9/.?-++-+! ?*//-,6'(! *6&'&>-0! $,0! 68-! +*:+-S*-,6!

?.,+&0-/$6&.,+!.;!+*?8!9/.?-++-+!:(!;$%&'(!;&/%+@!

!

P8&+! /-+-$/?8!4&''! 6$7-! $&%! $6! 68-! -B$?6! 9/.?-++-+! :(!48&?8! &,0-9-,0-,6! 0&/-?6./+! $/-! +-'-?6-0! 6.!

+-/<-! .,! 9/&<$6-A! ;$%&'(! :*+&,-++! :.$/0+! .;! 0&/-?6./+@! )-?$*+-! .;! 68-! *,&S*-! ,$6*/-! .;! ;$%&'(!

:*+&,-++-+! ?.%9$/-0! 6.! 68-&/! 9*:'&?! ?./9./$6&.,! ?.*,6-/9$/6+A! 68-! /-+-$/?8! :-=&,+! 4&68! $! ?'-$/!

0&+6&,?6&.,!:-64--,!68-!64.!:*+&,-++!%.0-'+!$,0!?.,6&,*-+!6.!;.?*+!.,!68-!+9-?&;&?!&++*-+!/-'$6&,=!6.!

;$%&'(!:*+&,-++!:.$/0+!.;!0&/-?6./+@!U*%-/.*+!+?8.'$/+! ;.?*+!.,!68-!68-./(!:-8&,0!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++!

:.$/0+! $,0! 68-! /-+*'6&,=! -;;-?6+! .,! +*?8! ./=$,&>$6&.,+! dK./:-66$! f! J$'<$6.A! 2LLTG! g.8$,,&++.,! f!

_*+-A!2LLLG!Y$,-!-6!$'@A!2LLXe@!Q00&6&.,$''(A!$?$0-%&?!'&6-/$6*/-!$'+.!9/-+-,6+!&0-$'!?.,+&0-/$6&.,+!;./!

68-!+-'-?6&.,!.,! &,0-9-,0-,6!%-%:-/+!.,!;$%&'(!:.$/0+!d_*+-A!2LLaG!W+&A!2LLbG!C$/0A!2LMLe@!P8&+!

/-+-$/?8! $+9&/-+! 6.! :/&0=-! 68-! =$9! :-64--,! 68-! 64.! $,0! -B9.+-! 68-! 9/.?-++-+! :(! 48&?8! 68-+-!

+-'-?6&.,+!6$7-!9'$?-@!

Page 7: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!a!

!

#*/68-/%./-A! $00&6&.,$'! ?.,+&0-/$6&.,+! ;./! &,0-9-,0-,6! 0&/-?6./! ?$,0&0$6-+! 4&''! :-! -B$%&,-0@! )(!

?.%:&,&,=!68-+-! &0-$+!4&68!68.+-!.;! 68-!$?6*$'!+-'-?6&.,!9/.?-++A! 68&+!+6*0(!$'+.! &,6-,0+!6.!-B9.+-!

-'-%-,6+! .;! 68-! 9/.?-++! 68$6! $/-! '-$+6! *,0-/+6..0@! P8/.*=8! $! ?.%9$/$6&<-! -B$%&,$6&.,! .;! -&=86!

?./9./$6&.,+A! $! :&=! 9&?6*/-! <&-4! .;! 68-! +-'-?6&.,! 9/.?-++! 4&''! :-! 0-<-'.9-0! $,0! $,$'(>-0! $=$&,+6!

?*//-,6! 68-./&-+! $,0! $?$0-%&?! '&6-/$6*/-! &,! 68-! 8.9-+! .;! ?.,+6/*?6&,=! $! :-66-/! ;.*,0$6&.,! .;!

*,0-/+6$,0&,=!;./!68-!$?$0-%&?!$,0!:*+&,-++!?.%%*,&6&-+@!

!

#&,$''(A! 68-! =.$'! .;! 68&+! /-+-$/?8! &+! ,.6! 6.! 0-6-/%&,-! $! +&,='-A! +*9-/&./! +-'-?6&.,! 9/.?-++A! ,./! &+! &6!

&,6-,0-0! 6.! 0-6-/%&,-! 68-! :-+6! ?.,+&0-/$6&.,+@! V$68-/A! 68-! ;.?*+! &+! 6.! *,?.<-/! 68-! ?*//-,6!

9/.?-0*/-+!*6&'&>-0!:(!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++-+!$,0!/-9./6!68-+-!;&,0&,=+!&,!$,!./=$,&>-0!$,0!?.,+.'&0$6-0!

%$,,-/@!

!

Page 8: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!]!

KA)47!H<L)C*1H/=11)C:7G>1)M)<H@=G7@*G=)G=NH=;)

P8-! ;.''.4&,=! '&6-/$6*/-! /-<&-4! ;.?*+-+! *9.,! -B&+6&,=! /-+-$/?8! $,0! +6*0&-+! .,! 6.9&?+! $,0! &++*-+!

+*//.*,0&,=! ;$%&'(!:*+&,-++!:.$/0+!.;!0&/-?6./+@!P8-!/-<&-4!4&''!:-=&,!4&68!$,!.<-/<&-4!.;!=-,-/$'!

;$%&'(! :*+&,-++! ?.,;'&?6! $+! &6! /-'$6-+! 6.! 68-! ;$%&'(! :*+&,-++! :.$/0@! ).68! 68-! ?.,6/.'! $,0! %$/7-6!

%.0-'+!4&''! :-!0&+?*++-0! &,!./0-/! 6.!*,0-/+6$,0! 68-!0&;;-/-,?-+! &,! ?./9./$6-!=.<-/,$,?-!:-64--,!

9/&<$6-! ;$%&'(! :*+&,-++! $,0! 9*:'&?! ?./9./$6&.,+@! U-B6A! ;$%&'(! :*+&,-++! :.$/0! +6/*?6*/-! 4&''! :-!

-B9'./-0! ;.''.4-0! :(! $! /-<&-4! .;! $=-,?(! $,0! +6-4$/0+8&9! 68-./&-+@! P8-+-! 68-./&-+! 4&''! :-! 9*6!

68/.*=8!;*/68-/!$,$'(+&+!4&68!$!0&+?*++&.,!.,!:.$/0!6$+7+!$,0!/-+9.,+&:&'&6&-+!:-;./-!6$7&,=!$!'..7!$6!

?*//-,6!%.0-'+! 0-<-'.9-0! /-=$/0&,=! ;$%&'(! :.$/0+@! Y$+6'(A! $! 68./.*=8! $++-++%-,6! .;! '&6-/$6*/-! .,!

&,0&<&0*$'!:.$/0!%-%:-/+A!0&/-?6./! 6$+7+A!$,0! '&%&6$6&.,+!.;! '&6-/$6*/-!.,!68-!+-'-?6&.,!9/.?-++!4&''!

:-!9/-+-,6-0@!!

!

Q00&6&.,$''(A! &6! &+! &%9./6$,6! 6.! *,0-/+6$,0! 68-! ;.?*+! .;! 68-! ;.''.4&,=! '&6-/$6*/-! /-<&-4! $,0!

+*:+-S*-,6! /-+-$/?8@! Q'68.*=8! &6! +6$,0+! 6/*-! 68$6! 9/&<$6-A! ,.,N;$%&'(! :*+&,-++-+!%$(! ;$''! &,6.! 68-!

+$%-! ?'$++&;&?$6&.,! $+! 9/&<$6-A! ;$%&'(N.4,-0! ?./9./$6&.,+!48-,! ?.%9$/-0! 6.! 68-&/! 9*:'&?'(! 6/$0-0!

?.*,6-/9$/6+A!%$,(!.;!68-!+&%&'$/&6&-+!0.A!&,!;$?6A!-,0!68-/-@!Q+!4&''!:-!9/-+-,6-0!'$6-/!&,!68&+!/-<&-4A!

.,-!4&''!S*&?7'(!*,0-/+6$,0!68-!*,&S*-!9/.:'-%+!$++.?&$6-0!4&68!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++!.9-/$6&.,+!68$6!$/-!

,.6!,-?-++$/&'(!+--,! &,!9/&<$6-A!,.,N;$%&'(!?.%9$,&-+@!Q'68.*=8! &6! &+!,.6!/$6&.,$'! 6.!:-'&-<-!68$6!$''!

;$%&'(! :*+&,-++-+! -B9-/&-,?-! 68-! &0-,6&?$'! 9/.:'-%+! $'.,=! 68-!4$(A! 0-?&+&.,N%$7&,=!9/.?-++-+! $/-!

*,0.*:6-0'(!?8$''-,=-0!&,!4$(+!68$6!+&%9'(!0.!,.6!9/-+-,6!68-%+-'<-+!&,!,.,N;$%&'(!:*+&,-++-+!0*-!

6.!68-!$:+-,?-!.;!;$%&'(!?8-%&+6/(!&,!+*?8!./=$,&>$6&.,+@!Q+!$!/-+*'6A!68-!;.''.4&,=!/-+-$/?8!4&''!;.?*+!

9/&%$/&'(! .,! ;$%&'(N.4,-0! :*+&,-++-+A! ?.%9$/&,=! 68-%! 6.! 9*:'&?'(! 6/$0-0! ?.%9$,&-+! 48-,!

,-?-++$/(!;./!$!?'-$/-/!*,0-/+6$,0&,=!

!"#$%&'()*$+,-(./--$+0&12-$

P8-! <$+6! 0&;;-/-,?-+! :-64--,! 68-! ?.%9'-B! +6/*?6*/-+! .;! :.68! 9/&<$6-! ;$%&'(! $,0! 9*:'&?! :*+&,-++!

;./%+!?$,!:-!+--,!-<-/(48-/-!;/.%!68-!.*6-/!+8-''!.;!.9-/$6&.,+!$''!68-!4$(!&,6.!68-!<-/(!?./-!.;!68-!

?.%9$,&-+R!:.$/0+!.;!0&/-?6./+@![B$%&,&,=!?./9./$6-!=.<-/,$,?-!0&;;-/-,?-+! 68/.*=8! 68-! '-,+-+!.;!

:.68!%$/7-6!$,0!?.,6/.'!%.0-'+A!$!%./-!0-;&,&6&<-!68-./-6&?$'! '&,-!?$,!:-!0/$4,!:-64--,!68-!64.!

:*+&,-++!=.<-/,$,?-!;./%+@!!

!

P8-! %$/7-6! %.0-'! &+! %.+6! 9/-<$'-,6! &,! 8&=8'(! '&S*&0! %$/7-6+! +*?8! $+! 68.+-! +9-?&;&?$''(! '.?$6-0!

68/.*=8.*6!68-!F,&6-0!J6$6-+!$,0!F,&6-0!I&,=0.%@!P8-!%.0-'!&+!?8$/$?6-/&>-0!:(!$!+6/.,=!;.?*+!.,!

:.$/0! .:5-?6&<&6(! $,0! &,0-9-,0-,?-A! $! 6-,0-,?(! 6.! ;.?*+! .,! +8./6N6-/%! 9-/;./%$,?-A! $,0!

/-S*&/-%-,6+!.;!9*:'&?!;&,$,?&$'!0&+?'.+*/-+!dY$,-!-6!$'@A!2LLXG!W+&A!2LLbe@!Q00&6&.,$''(A!$!'$/=-!:$+-!.;!

Page 9: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!b!

9/-<&.*+'(! *,/-'$6-0! +8$/-8.'0-/+! 9*:'&?'(! 6/$0&,=! +6.?7! 68/.*=8! ;./%$'! +6.?7! -B?8$,=-+! &+!

?*+6.%$/(! .;! 68&+! :*+&,-++! %.0-'@! #*/68-/%./-A! -B6-/,$'! :.$/0! %-%:-/+! $/-! *+*$''(! 68-! ,./%A!

/$68-/!68$,!68-!-B?-96&.,A!$,0!$!+6/&?6!0&<&+&.,!:-64--,!.4,-/+8&9!$,0!%$,$=-%-,6!&+!$'+.!-B8&:&6-0!

dW+&A!2LLbe@!Q??./0&,=!6.!Y$,-!-6!$'@!d2LLXeA!%$/7-6!%.0-'+!-++-,6&$''(!$66-%96!6.!9*/=-!68-!:*+&,-++!

.;!$,(!h?.,;'&?6+!.;!&,6-/-+6l!:-64--,!%$,$=-%-,6!$,0!.4,-/+8&9@!

!

K.,<-/+-'(A! 68-! ?.,6/.'! %.0-'! &+! 9/-<$'-,6! &,! %*?8! .;! 68-! ='.:$'! :*+&,-++! 4./'0! $,0! &+! =-,-/$''(!

+(,.,(%.*+! 4&68! ;$%&'(! :*+&,-++-+A! 48-/-! ?'-$/! 0&<&+&.,+! .;! .4,-/+8&9! $,0! ?.,6/.'! $/-! '$?7&,=@!

Q00&6&.,$''(A! .4,-/+8&9! ;/-S*-,6'(! 9'$(+! $! ?.%%$,0&,=! /.'-A! ;*/68-/! :'*//&,=! 68-! '&,-+! :-64--,!

&,0-9-,0-,?-! $,0! .:5-?6&<&6(A! *'6&%$6-'(! ?/-$6&,=! 9/-<$'-,6! ?.,;'&?6+! .;! &,6-/-+6@! V$68-/! 68$,!

-'&%&,$6&,=!68-!?.,;'&?6A!8.4-<-/A!68-!?.,6/.'!%.0-'!$&%+!6.!$??-96!:*6!.99/-++!68-!9/.:'-%A!'&%&6&,=!

&6+!-;;-?6+!6.!68-!./=$,&>$6&.,@!J8$/-8.'0-/+R!'.,=N6-/%!.*6'..7!;./!;&/%!8-$'68!$,0!;$%&'(!+*??-++&.,!

$+!4-''!$+!+&=,&;&?$,6!;$%&'(!9/-+-,?-!.,!68-!/-+9-?6&<-!?.%9$,(!:.$/0!&+!$'+.!$!:$+&+!.;!68&+!%.0-'@!

P8.*=8!+.%-!'$/=-/!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++-+!$/-!%.<&,=!?'.+-/!6.!$!%$/7-6!%.0-'A!%.+6!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++-+!

/-+&0-! *,0-/! 68-! ?.,6/.'! %.0-'! *%:/-''$! dY$,-! -6! $'@A! 2LLXe@! W;! ?.*/+-A! 68-+-! 64.! %.0-'+! .,'(!

+?/$6?8!68-!+*/;$?-!.;!68-!/$68-/!;*,0$%-,6$'!0&;;-/-,?-+!:-64--,!68-!64.!=.<-/,$,?-!;./%+@!

!

P8-! *,&S*-! 0&;;-/-,?-+! :-64--,! ;$%&'(! :*+&,-++-+! $,0! 9*:'&?! ?./9./$6&.,+! 8$<-! $'+.! '-0! 6.! $,!

-B6-,+&<-!$//$(!.;!/-+-$/?8!;.?*+-0!+9-?&;&?$''(!.,!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++!:.$/0+!.;!0&/-?6./+!.<-/!68-!(-$/+!

d)$%%-,+! -6! $'@A! 2LMLG! _*+-A! 2LLLG! m$8/$! f! J8$/%$A! 2LLTe@! Q+! ,.6-0! -$/'&-/A! ;$%&'(! :*+&,-++!

=.<-/,$,?-! .;6-,! /-;'-?6+! 8-$<(! ;$%&'(!%-%:-/! &,;'*-,?-A! $+! .4,-/+8&9A!%$,$=-/&$'A! $,0! 0&/-?6./!

/.'-+!$/-!;/-S*-,6'(!;&''-0!:(!%$,(!.;!68-!+$%-!&,0&<&0*$'+@!W;!?.*/+-A!;$%&'(!<$'*-+A!+*/<&<$'!.;!68-!

:*+&,-++! ;./! +*:+-S*-,6! =-,-/$6&.,+A! $,0! 68-! .<-/$''! 0-+&/-! ;./! ?.,6/.'! .;! .,-R+! .4,! :*+&,-++A! $''!

9'$(!$!?.%%$,0&,=!/.'-!dY$,-!-6!$'@A!2LLXG!W+&A!2LLbe@!3,!;$?6A!-B6-/,$'!,.,N;$%&'(!/-9/-+-,6$6&.,!.,!

;$%&'(! :*+&,-++! :.$/0+! .;! 0&/-?6./+! /-%$&,+! $! /-'$6&<-'(! /$/-! .??*//-,?-! 6.0$(@! 3,! $! +*/<-(! .;! OXL!

;$%&'(!:*+&,-++-+A!?.,0*?6-0!.,!:-8$';!.;! g.8,!C$/0!d2LMLeA!.,'(!68&/6(!9-/?-,6!.;! ;$%&'(!:*+&,-++!

:.$/0+! &,0&?$6-0! 8$<&,=! 64.! ./! %./-! &,0-9-,0-,6! 0&/-?6./+! .,! 68-! :.$/0@! 3,! 6.6$'A! .,'(! ;&;6--,!

9-/?-,6!.;!/-+9.,0-,6+!&,0&?$6-0!9.++-++&.,!.;!$!%$5./&6(!&,0-9-,0-,6!:.$/0@!Q00&6&.,$''(A!/-+-$/?8!

:(!)$%%-,+!-6! $'@! d2LL]e! +*==-+6+! 68$6! 68-! ?$''! ;./! $00&6&.,$'! ;$%&'(!:.$/0!%-%:-/+! ?.,6&,*-+! 6.!

&,?/-$+-!4&68!=-,-/$6&.,$'!+*??-++&.,+@!K.%9$/-!68&+!6.!68-!6(9&?$'!9*:'&?'(!8-'0!?./9./$6&.,!68$6!&+!

*+*$''(! ?.,6/.''-0! :(! $,! -'-?6-0! :.$/0! .;! 0&/-?6./+A! *9! 6.! bLn! .;! 48.%! $/-! &,0-9-,0-,6! .;! 68-!

?.%9$,(A!$,0!68-!0&+6&,?6&.,+!:-64--,!9*:'&?!$,0!;$%&'(!:.$/0+!:-?.%-+!?'-$/-/!dW+&A!2LLbe@!!

!

F,0-/+6$,0&,=! 68-! 68-./-6&?$'! 0&;;-/-,?-+! :-64--,! 9/&<$6-! ;$%&'(! :*+&,-++! ;&/%+! $,0! 9*:'&?!

?./9./$6&.,+! 8-'9+! 9/.<&0-! $! +.'&0! ;.*,0$6&.,! ;./! $! %./-! 0-6$&'-0! =.<-/,$,?-! $,$'(+&+! .;! +*?8!

Page 10: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!ML!

./=$,&>$6&.,$'!+6/*?6*/-+@!)*&'0&,=!*9.,!68-!9/-<&.*+'(!0&+?*++-0!&0-$+A!68-!;.''.4&,=!+-?6&.,+!'-$0!6.!

;*/68-/!-B$%&,$6&.,!/-=$/0&,=!+9-?&;&?!:.$/0!+6/*?6*/-+!$,0!?.,<-/=&,=!68-./&-+!9-/6$&,&,=!6.!;$%&'(!

:*+&,-++! .9-/$6&.,+A! 68-! /-+9-?6&<-! ;$%&'(! %$,$=-%-,6A! $,0! 68-! &,;*+&.,! .;! &,0-9-,0-,6! :.$/0!

%-%:-/+!;./!-&68-/!.<-/+&=86!./!?.%9'-%-,6$/(!/-+.*/?-!/.'-+@!

!"#"#$%&'()*$+,-(./--$+0&12$-31,43,1/$

F,0-/+6$,0&,=! :.$/0! +6/*?6*/-!4&68&,! ;$%&'(! .9-/$6&.,+! &+! ?/&6&?$'! &,! '$(&,=! $! ;.*,0$6&.,! ;./! :.$/0!

%-%:-/!+-'-?6&.,G!&6!9$<-+!$,!*,0-/+6$,0&,=!;./!68-!?$9$?&6&-+!&,!48&?8!&,0-9-,0-,6!%-%:-/+!?$,!

:-+6!+-/<-!&,!68&+!*,&S*-!-,<&/.,%-,6@!P8.*=8!$''!F@J@!:*+&,-++-+!$/-!/-S*&/-0!6.!0-?'$/-!$,0!/-6$&,!

$,!.;;&?&$'! :.$/0!.;! 0&/-?6./+A! +.%-![*/.9-$,! '$4+!-<-,! =.! $+! ;$/! $+! 6.! /-S*&/-! ;*/68-/! +-9$/$6&.,!

:-64--,!%$,$=-%-,6!$,0!:.$/0+!.;!0&/-?6./+!68/.*=8!$!64.N6&-/!=.<-/,&,=!+6/*?6*/-!d_*+-A!2LLaG!

C$/0A! 2LMLe@! U.,-68-'-++A! :-?$*+-! 68-! ;.?*+! .,! F@J@! ;$%&'(! ?./9./$6&.,+! &+! 68-! ?-,6-/! .;! 68&+!

9$/6&?*'$/!/-+-$/?8A!68&+!+-?6&.,!4&''!?.,6&,*-!6.!+9.6'&=86!.,!68-!+&,='-N6&-/!:.$/0!?.,;&=*/$6&.,@!

!

P8-!%.+6! ?.%%.,! 6.9&?+! /-=$/0&,=! :.$/0! +6/*?6*/-! $/-! hK[W!0*$'&6(A! :.$/0! ?.%%&66--+A! 68-! K[W!

4./7! 0-+?/&96&.,A! :.$/0! &,+6/*?6&.,+! $,0! <$/&.*+! :.$/0! %$&,6-,$,?-! $?6&<&6&-+l! d_*+-A! 2LLae@! Q+!

-B8&:&6-0! &,! '+C)4-& 8A! K./:-66$! $,0! J$'<$6.! d2LLTe! 0-<-'.9-0! $! %.0-'! /-9/-+-,6&,=! 68-! 0&<-/+-!

?.%9.,-,6+!6.!68-!;$%&'(!:.$/0!+6/*?6*/-!$,0!68-!&,;'*-,?&,=!-'-%-,6+!.;!+*?8!./=$,&>$6&.,!d9@!M2ae@!

Q+!&,!68-!%$5./&6(!.;!./=$,&>$6&.,+A!68-!K[W!9'$(+!$!?/&6&?$'!/.'-!&,!68-!'-$0-/+8&9!$,0!0&/-?6&.,!.;!68-!

?.%9$,(! $,0! ;$%&'(! :*+&,-++-+! $/-! .;6-,! 8$/0'(! 68-! -B?-96&.,@! _.4-<-/A! :-?$*+-! ;$%&'(! ;&/%+!

8$:&6*$''(!8$<-!$!8&=8!'-<-'!.;!;$%&'(!?.,6/.'!d&@-@!48.''(N.4,-0eA!K./:-66$!$,0!J$'<$6.!d2LLTe!+*==-+6!

68-/-!&+!$,!-'-<$6-0!'-<-'!.;!0-9-,0-,?-!.,!&,+&0-!0&/-?6./+@!Q+!+*?8A!68-!K[W!?.%%.,'(!+-/<-+!&,!$!

0*$'! ?$9$?&6(! $+! 68$6! .;! ?8$&/9-/+.,A! $+! 4-''! dC$/0A! 2LMLe@! P8.*=8! %$,(! &,0&<&0*$'+! ?$''! ;./!

+-9$/$6&.,! .;! 68-! 64.! 0*6&-+! &,! ?./9./$6-! =.<-/,$,?-! d_*+-A! 2LLaeA! &6! $99-$/+! 68-! ;$%&'(!

-,<&/.,%-,6! .;6-,! ?.,<-(+! 68-! .99.+&,=! +?-,$/&.@! F'6&%$6-'(! +-9$/$6&,=! 68-+-! 0*6&-+! $,0! 9*''&,=!

/-+.*/?-+! ;/.%! .*6+&0-! 68-! ./=$,&>$6&.,! $,0! ;$%&'(! ?$,! $'6-/! 68-! 0-9-,0-,?-! .,! &,0-9-,0-,6!

0&/-?6./+!$,0!.<-/+&=86!.;!$! ;$%&'(! ?.%9$,(! d68-!9.6-,6&$'! &,;'*-,?-+!$/-!0-9&?6-0!$+!:.68! h;$%&'(!

9.4-/l!$,0!h:.$/0!0-9-,0-,?-l!&,!'+C)4-&8e@!

!

Page 11: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!MM!

!4&O2%-)JP)4"0&B.)Q2#&+-##)Q5"%3)5F)3&%-'$5%#)#$%2'$2%-)"+3)&+FB2-+'-#)!)-(.,0!68-!K[WA!68-!/-%$&,&,=!8&-/$/?8(!.;!0&/-?6./+!&,!$!6(9&?$'!?./9./$6&.,!+-/<-+!.,!<$/&.*+!:.$/0!

?.%%&66--+!6.!%./-!?'.+-'(!-B$%&,-!+9-?&;&?!$+9-?6+!.;!:*+&,-++!.9-/$6&.,+@![<-,!;./!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++!

:.$/0+! 68$6! $/-! '$/=-! -,.*=8! 6.! +*+6$&,! ?.%%&66--+A! 68-! 0&<-/+&6(! .;! %-%:-/+! $99-$/+! S*&6-!

/-+6/&?6-0@!J6-%%&,=! ;/.%!C$/0R+!2LML!+*/<-(A! +-<-,6(!9-/?-,6!.;!:*+&,-++! /-+9.,0-,6+! &,0&?$6-0!

,.! 9/-+-,?-! .;! &,0-9-,0-,6! :.$/0!%-%:-/+! .,! 68-&/! /-+9-?6&<-! :.$/0+! .;! 0&/-?6./+@! Q00&6&.,$''(A!

+&B6(N+&B! 9-/?-,6! .;! /-+9.,0-,6+! /-9./6-0! 8$<&,=! ,.! ?.%%&66--+! 4&68&,! 68-&/! :.$/0! .;! 0&/-?6./+!

dC$/0A!2LMLe@!`&<-,!:.68!'&%&6-0!.*6+&0-/!/-9/-+-,6$6&.,!$,0!?.%%&66--!-B&+6-,?-!.,!;$%&'(!:.$/0+A!

0&/-?6./+! $/-! $'+.! '&7-'(! +-/<&,=! %*'6&9'-! /.'-+! .;! .<-/+&=86! $,0! $*0&6A! $+! 4-''! $+! -B-?*6&<-!

%$,$=-%-,6!0-?&+&.,+@!P8&+!4.*'0!$'+.!:-!/-9/-+-,6-0!:(!h;$%&'(!9.4-/l&&,!'+C)4-&8@!

!

\&6$'! 6.! :.$/0! +6/*?6*/-! &+! .<-/$''! :.$/0! %$&,6-,$,?-A! &,?'*0&,=! 68-! -0*?$6&.,! .;! ?*//-,6! $,0!

&,?.%&,=! 0&/-?6./+A! 6-$%! :*&'0&,=A! $,0! -<$'*$6&.,@! Q00&6&.,$''(A! 9/&./! +6*0&-+A! &,?'*0&,=! 68.+-!

+9$,,&,=!&,6-/,$6&.,$'!:./0-/+A!/-<-$'!68$6!68-+-!6.9&?+!?.,6&,*-!6.!:-!+.%-!.;!68-!%.+6!0.%&,$6&,=!

=.<-/,$,?-!+6/*?6*/-!&++*-+!dH-%:!f!U-*:$*-/A!Mbb2G!\$,!0-,!)-/=8-!f!Y-</$*A!2LLTG!C$/0A!2LMLe@!

#.?*+&,=!*9.,!68-!?.8-+&<-,-++!.;!68-!?./9./$6-!:.$/0!.;!0&/-?6./+!&+!7-(!6.!-,+*/&,=!:.$/0!0-?&+&.,!

-;;-?6&<-,-++!$,0!&0-$!-B?8$,=-@!J*/<-(+!.;!:.68!9*:'&?!$,0!9/&<$6-!d;$%&'(e!?./9./$6&.,+!/-<-$'!68$6!

6-$%! :*&'0&,=! &+! $,! &,?/-$+&,='(! &%9./6$,6! $+9-?6! 6.! :.$/0! +6/*?6*/-! $,0! .9-/$6&.,A! 4&68! $,!

$:*,0$,?-!.;!?.%9$,&-+!&,+6&6*6&,=!-B-?*6&<-!/-6/-$6+!$&%-0!$6!:*&'0&,=!:.$/0!%-%:-/!/-'$6&.,+8&9+!

d\$,! 0-,! )-/=8-! f! Y-</$*A! 2LLTG! C$/0A! 2LMLe@! D./6/$(-0! $+! 68-! h?*'6*/-l! -'-%-,6! &,! '+C)4-& 8A!

K./:-66$!$,0!J$'<$6.!d2LLTe!$'+.!?.%%&6!68-%+-'<-+!6.!&6+!+&=,&;&?$,?-@!

!

).$/0! &,+6/*?6&.,+A! $+! .*6'&,-0! :(! _*+-! d2LLaeA! $99-$/! ?/&6&?$'! 6.! :.$/0+! .;! 0&/-?6./+@! 36! ,.6! .,'(!

.*6'&,-+! +9-?&;&?! /.'-+! .;! :.$/0! %-%:-/+! $,0! 8-'9+! -+6$:'&+8! 68-%! $+! 68-! 6.9! 0-?&+&.,N%$7&,=!

Page 12: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!M2!

$*68./&6(A!:*6!$'+.!&,?'*0-+!68-!h=/.*,0!/*'-+l!.;!68-!=.<-/,&,=!$*68./&6(!d?8-?7+!$,0!:$'$,?-+!.;!68-!

K[W!$,0!.68-/!0&/-?6./+A!%--6&,=! ;/-S*-,?(A! <.6&,=A!:.$/0!?.%9.+&6&.,A!-6?@e@! [%$,$6&,=! ;/.%!68-!

$;./-%-,6&.,-0! +*/<-(A! %.+6! :.$/0+! +*/<-(-0! %--6! :-64--,! ;.*/! $,0! ;&<-! 6&%-+! 9-/! (-$/@!

#*/68-/%./-A! ,&,-6(N68/--! 9-/?-,6! .;! /-+9.,0-,6+! &,0&?$6-0! ,.! +9-?&;&?! 6-/%! '&%&6+! .;! &,0&<&0*$'!

0&/-?6./+@!#.''.4&,=!$!2LL2&F1-4+".,&:.1+%<&()*+,-**&H-*-.4"#! +*/<-(! dg*/&,+7&!f!m4&?7A!2LL2e!$,0!

;*/68-/!&,<-+6&=$6&.,!:(!W+&!d2LLbeA!68-!$*68./!+*==-+6+!68-!&0-$'!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++!:.$/0!?.%9/&+-+!$!

%&B!.;!,.!%./-!68$,!64-'<-!;$%&'(!$,0!-B6-/,$'!:.$/0!%-%:-/+!?.%:&,-0A!4&68!6-/%!'&%&6+!.;!.,-!6.!

68/--! (-$/+G! 68.*=8A! ?*//-,6! +*/<-(+! &%9'(! 68&+! &+! ,.6! 68-! /-$'&6(! 4&68! %.+6! ;$%&'(! ?./9./$6&.,+@!

W<-/$''A!-$?8!.;!68-+-!68/--!$66/&:*6-+!d:.$/0!%--6&,=!;/-S*-,?(A!6-/%+!$,0!6-/%!'&%&6+A!$,0!:.$/0!

+&>-e!8-'9+!0-;&,-!.<-/$''! :.$/0!$?6&<&+%!$,0!=-,-/$'! ?.%9.+&6&.,@!P8-+-!$66/&:*6-+!$/-! ?.''-?6&<-'(!

.*6'&,-0!$+!h:.$/0!?$9&6$'l!&,!'+C)4-&8A!!J*//.*,0&,=!:.$/0!?.%9.+&6&.,!&+!68-!9.6-,6&$'!-;;-?6!.;!68-!

:*+&,-++!9/.;&?&-,?(!:/.*=86!6.!68-!6$:'-!:(!&,<.'<-0!;$%&'(!%-%:-/+@!K.%9'&%-,6!68-+-!+7&''+!4&68!

68.+-! .;! 68-! :.$/0! .;! 0&/-?6./+! $,0! 68-! 9.6-,6&$'! 6.! $;;-?6! :*+&,-++! 9/.;&6$:&'&6(! $,0! .<-/$''!

9-/;./%$,?-!-B&+6+@!

!

V-?-,6'(A!:.$/0!-<$'*$6&.,!8$+!$'+.!:--,!/-?.=,&>-0!$+!$!?/&6&?$'!?.%9.,-,6!6.!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++!:.$/0!

+6/*?6*/-@!C&68! $! +-<-/-! '$?7! .;! :.$/0! -<$'*$6&.,! 9/.?-0*/-+! &,! 9'$?-! ;./!%$,(! ;$%&'(! :*+&,-++-+A!

-&=86(!9-/?-,6!&,!+.%-!?$+-+!dC$/0A!2LMLeA!&%9/.<-%-,6+!?'-$/'(!+6$,0!6.!:-!%$0-@!K$''+!;./!:.$/0!

.;! 0&/-?6./! -<$'*$6&.,+! -B&+6! $6! $''! '-<-'+! .;! :*+&,-++A! 4&68! 9$/6&?*'$/! ;.?*+! .,! ;$%&'(! :*+&,-++-+A!

9/&%$/&'(!0*-!6.!$!;./%$'!-<$'*$6&.,R+!$:&'&6(!6.!*,-$/68!;$%&'(!0&/-?6./!9-/;./%$,?-!dW+&A!2LLbG!\$,!

0-,!)-/=8-!f!Y-</$*A!2LLTG!C$/0A!2LMLe@!P8.*=8!-<$'*$6&.,!?$,!:-!?.%9'&?$6-0!&,!68-!;$%&'(!;&/%A!&6!

+8.*'0!:-!?.,+6/*-0!$+!$!,-?-++$/(!?.%9.,-,6!.;!68-!?./9./$6-!+6/*?6*/-@!P8/.*=8!;$%&'(!-B-?*6&<-!

&,6-/<&-4+A! C$/0! d2LMLe! *+-+! 68&+! $+! $! :$+&+! ;./! -B-%9'&;(&,=! 68-! &0-$'! %.0-'! .;! ;$%&'(! ;&/%!

=.<-/,$,?-! +6/*?6*/-+! ?*//-,6'(! &,! -B&+6-,?-! ;./! .,'(! $! 8$,0;*'! .;! ;$%&'(! ;&/%+@! W,-! $,.,(%.*+!

;$%&'(! :*+&,-++! &,6-/<&-4--! -B9/-++-0! 8&+! 0-+&/-! ;./! 0&/-?6./! -<$'*$6&.,+! 68/.*=8! 68-! ;.''.4&,=!

S*.6-"!!

!

0D-4<& <-.4& I-& -%-"3& $)4& '.1+%<& /+4-"3$4*& 3$& 3#-& ;$.4/A& J#.3& +'& $,-& +*& ,$3&

@-4'$41+,C& I-%%K& L$I& I$)%/& I-& M,$IK& B& ),/-4*3.,/& I-& /$,N3& I.,3& 3$&

-1;.44.**&'.1+%<&/+4-"3$4*&I#$&.4-&),/-4@-4'$41+,C5&;)3&#$I&".,&I-&-D-4&*$%D-&

3#-&@4$;%-1&+'&I-&"$,3+,)-&3$&-%-"3&3#$*-&/+4-"3$4*K&OJ.4/5&=>8>5&@A&=8PQA)

!

W:<&.*+'(A! 68-! =$9! :-64--,! 68-! &0-$'! ;$%&'(! :.$/0! .;! 0&/-?6./+! +6/*?6*/-! $,0! 68-! /-$'&6(! .;!

=.<-/,$,?-! &,! %.+6! ;$%&'(! :.$/0+! 6.0$(! &+! +*:+6$,6&$''(! 4&0-! ;./! $! %$5./&6(! .;! 68-! ?.%%*,&6(@!

P8-./&-+! -B9'$&,&,=! ,.6! .,'(! 68-+-! =$9+! :*6! $'+.! 0&;;&?*'6&-+! ./&=&,$6&,=! ;/.%! 68-! $;./-%-,6&.,-0!

Page 13: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!MO!

0&+9$/&6&-+! :-64--,! ;$%&'(! $,0! 9*:'&?A! ,.,N;$%&'(! ./=$,&>$6&.,+! 4&''! :-! ;*/68-/! 0&+?*++-0! &,! 68-!

;.''.4&,=!+-?6&.,+@!

!"#"!$50.6/17(.7$38/01(/-$

P4.!?.%9-6&,=!68-./&-+!-%-/=-!48-,!-B$%&,&,=!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++!:.$/0+!.;!0&/-?6./+!$,0!+*:+-S*-,6!

/$6&.,$'-!:-8&,0!$,!&,;*+&.,!.;!,.,N;$%&'(A!-B6-/,$'!0&/-?6./+!6.!68-!;$%&'(!:.$/0@!P8-!64.!68-./&-+!

$/-!%.+6!?.%%.,'(!/-;-//-0!6.!$+! 68-!$=-,?(!68-./(!$,0!68-!+6-4$/0+8&9!68-./(@!P8.*=8!68-!/.'-!

68$6! ;$%&'(! :.$/0+! 9'$(! *,0-/! -$?8! 68-./(! 4&''! :-! :/&-;'(! %-,6&.,-0! 8-/-A! 68-+-! &0-$+! 4&''! :-!

-B9$,0-0!*9.,!&,!+*:+-S*-,6!+-?6&.,+@!

!

Q=-,?(!68-./(!9./6/$(+!68-!&0-$!68$6!?.,;'&?6+!9/-<$&'!:-64--,!68$6!.;!68-!9/&,?&9$'+!d68-!.4,-/+e!$,0!

68-!$=-,6+!d68-!%$,$=-%-,6e@!J&%9'(!+6$6-0A!&6!&+!68-!?.,;'&?6+!.;!&,6-/-+6!68$6!+6-%!;/.%!?.,6/.'!$,0!

.4,-/+8&9!4&68&,!$!?./9./$6&.,!$,0!68-!%./$'!8$>$/0!68$6!-B&+6+!:-64--,!68-!64.!9$/6&-+!dK./:-66$!

f! J$'<$6.A! 2LLTG! g.8$,,&++.,!f!_*+-A! 2LLLG!W+&A! 2LLbe@! P8&+! 0&<-/=-,?-! &+! .;! 9$/6&?*'$/! &,6-/-+6! 6.!

;$%&'(!:*+&,-++!:.$/0+A!4&68!68-!9.6-,6&$'!;./!?.,;'&?6!:-64--,!.4,-/+8&9!$,0!%$,$=-%-,6!+6$,0&,=!

8&=8A!$+!68-!64.!9'$(-/+!$/-!6(9&?$''(!.,-!&,!68-!+$%-@!!

!

Q+!9/-<&.*+'(!0&+?*++-0A!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++-+!$/-!$*6.%$6&?$''(!9'$=*-0!4&68!$!9.6-,6&$'! ;./!9/.:'-%+@!

P8-+-!0&'-%%$+!%$(!:-!-B$?-/:$6-0!48-,!;$%&'(!.4,-/+!$'+.!8$<-!$!8$,0!&,!%$,$=-%-,6!$?6&<&6&-+A!

'-$<&,=! '&66'-! +-9$/$6&.,! $,0! %.,&6./&,=! $:&'&6(! :-64--,! 68-! 64.! $?6&<&6&-+@! C8-,! $99'&-0! 6.! 68-!

?.,6-B6! .;! $! ;$%&'(! :.$/0A! 68&+! 68-./(! 9-/+9-?6&<-! $++*%-+! 68$6! 68-! &,6-/-+6+! .;! 68-! .4,-/+!

,-?-++&6$6-!9/.6-?6&.,!;/.%!68-!&,6-/-+6+!.;!68-!%$,$=-%-,6!=/.*9@!Q+!+*?8A!68-!:.$/0!.;!0&/-?6./+!

$++*%-+!$!+*9-/<&+./(!/.'-!&,!48&?8!:*+&,-++!$?6&<&6&-+!$/-!?'.+-'(!%.,&6./-0!$,0!?$/-;*''(!-B$%&,-0!

;./!%./$'!8$>$/0!dK./:-66$!f!J$'<$6.A!2LLTG!W+&A!2LLbe@!3,!-++-,?-A!68-!:.$/0R+!/.'-!*,0-/!68-!$=-,?(!

*%:/-''$!-,6$&'+!$!h9$/-,6&,=!$99/.$?8l!6.!68-!./=$,&>$6&.,!&,!68-!+-,+-!68$6!&6!9/.<&0-+!68-!4$6?8;*'!

-(-!$,0!,-?-++$/(!0&+?&9'&,-!6.!7--9!&,6-/-+6+!$,0!$?6&.,+!$'&=,-0@!

!

Q=-,?(!68-./(!$00&6&.,$''(!$++*%-+!68-!?.%9.+&6&.,!.;!68-!:.$/0!.;!0&/-?6./+!?$,!+*+6$&,!64.!?/&6&?$'!

/-S*&/-%-,6+@!Q??./0&,=! 6.! g.8$,,&++.,!$,0!_*+-! d2LLLeA! 68-!9/.9-/! +-9$/$6&.,!.;!.4,-/+8&9!$,0!

%$,$=-%-,6! /-S*&/-+! 68$6! h9/.+9-?6&<-! :.$/0! %-%:-/+! $/-! ;&,$,?&$''(! $,0! 9+(?8.'.=&?$''(!

&,0-9-,0-,6!.;!68-!-B-?*6&<-!%$,$=-%-,6A!$,0!4&''!*+-!68&+!&,6-=/&6(!6.!%.,&6./!68-!%$,$=-/+l!d9@!

O^Xe@! J-?.,0'(A! 68-! $*68./+! $0<&+-! h68$6! 68-! :.$/0! $+! $! ?.''-?6&<-! 8$+! +*;;&?&-,6! ?.%9-6-,?&-+! 6.!

%.,&6./!%$,$=-%-,6l!d9@!O^Xe@!Q!:/&-;!'..7!$6!68-!+6-4$/0+8&9!68-./(!4&''A!8.4-<-/A!9/-+-,6!$!<-/(!

0&;;-/-,6!<&-4!6.!68-!.4,-/N%$,$=-%-,6!/-'$6&.,+8&9@!

!

Page 14: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!MT!

J6-4$/0+8&9!68-./(!+6/-++-+!68-!?.,?-96!.;!-68&?$'A!?./9./$6-N0/&<-,!<$'*-+!.<-/!68.+-!.;!9-/+.,$'A!

+-';N$0<$,?&,=! &,6-/-+6+@!E./-! +9-?&;&?$''(A! 68-! =.$'+! $,0! <$'*-+!8-'0!:(! 68.+-!.;! 68-!%$,$=-%-,6!

6-$%! $,0! :.$/0! .;! 0&/-?6./+! $/-! h&,! 6*,-l! 4&68! 68.+-! .;! 68-! .<-/$''! '.,=N6-/%! 8-$'68A! =.$'+A! $,0!

.*6'..7! .;! 68-! ?./9./$6&.,! $,0! &6+! +6$7-8.'0-/+! dW+&A! 2LLbe@! 3,! $00&6&.,A! $! ;.?*+! .,! :*+&,-++!

/-9*6$6&.,A! '.,=N6-/%! 9-/;./%$,?-! dK./:-66$! f! J$'<$6.A! 2LLTeA! -%9.4-/%-,6A! $,0! 6/$,+9$/-,?(!

dW+&A!2LLbe!$/-!9&<.6$'!6.!+6-4$/0+8&9@!!

!

F,'&7-! 68-! :.$/0! .;! 0&/-?6./R+! /.'-! .;! .<-/+&=86! $,0! 0&+?&9'&,$/(! $?6&.,! 4&68! $=-,?(! 68-./(A!

+6-4$/0+8&9!68-./(!+*==-+6+!68$6!68-!:.$/0!.;!0&/-?6./+!-B&+6! &,!$,!$0<&+./(!?$9$?&6(!6.!68-!;&/%@! 3,!

+*?8!$,!-,<&/.,%-,6A! &,0&<&0*$'!0&/-?6./+!$/-!?8$/$?6-/&>-0!$+!h9-.9'-!.,!48.%!%$,$=-%-,6!?$,!

/-'(A!$,0!ijk!8$<-!68-!,--0-0!9/.;-++&.,$'!?.%9-6-,?&-+l!dg.8$,,&++.,!f!_*+-A!2LLLA!9@!O^Xe@!P8-!

7-(!?.%9-6-,?&-+!&,?'*0-!7,.4'-0=-!$,0!-B9-/&-,?-!,--0-0!6.!9/.<&0-!+.*,0!$0<&?-!$,0!=*&0$,?-A!

?/-0&:&'&6(A!$,0!.<-/$''!+*99./6!6.!8&=8-/N'-<-'!:*+&,-++!0-?&+&.,+!dg.8$,,&++.,!f!_*+-A!2LLLe@!

!

K./:-66$!$,0!J$'<$6.!d2LLTe!$?7,.4'-0=-!68$6A!&,!+6-4$/0+8&9!-,<&/.,%-,6+A!K[W+!$,0!%$,$=-%-,6!

6(9&?$''(!-B8&:&6!$!+6/.,=!9-/+.,$'!?.%%&6%-,6!6.!68-!?./9./$6&.,A!48-/-!+-';N&,6-/-+6+!$/-!+&0-'&,-0!

$,0!?.''-?6&<-!%$,$=-%-,6!=.$'+!$/-!?.%%.,'(!$'&=,-0!4&68!68.+-!.;!68-!.4,-/+A!68-!:*+&,-++A!$,0!

&6+! .<-/$''! +*??-++@! #*/68-/%./-A! 68-! $*68./+! &%9'(! 68$6! +6-4$/0+8&9! 68-./(! 6(9&?$''(! &,0&?$6-+! $!

?'.+-'(N7,&6! :.$/0! .;! 0&/-?6./+A! ;/-S*-,6'(! ?.%9.+-0! .;! $! %$5./&6(! .;! ;$%&'(! %-%:-/+! 4&68! 68-!

/-%$&,&,=! +-$6+! ;&''-0! :(! ;$%&'&$/! 9/.;-++&.,$'! $,0! 9-/+.,$'! ,-64./7! $?S*$&,6$,?-+@! K.,+-S*-,6'(A!

W+&!d2LLbe!+*==-+6+!68$6!+6-4$/0+8&9!68-./(!&+!%.+6!+(,.,(%.*+!4&68!68-!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++!%.0-'!0*-!

6.!68-!?.''-?6&<-!=.$'!$'&=,%-,6!.;!.4,-/+A!%$,$=-%-,6A!$,0!.*6'(&,=!+6$7-8.'0-/+@!

!

P8-! 68-./-6&?$'! ?8$/$?6-/&+6&?+! .;! $=-,?(! $,0! +6-4$/0+8&9! +6/-6?8! %*?8! ;*/68-/! &,6.! $! :.$/0! .;!

0&/-?6./+! 68$6! 5*+6! +&%9'(! .<-/+&=86! ./! ?.*,+-'@! P8-(! $;;-?6! 68-! <-/(! ;.*,0$6&.,! .;! &,0-9-,0-,6!

0&/-?6./+! 68/.*=8!0&;;-/-,6! /.'-+! $,0! /-+9.,+&:&'&6&-+A! +*:+-S*-,6! :*+&,-++! 0-?&+&.,+A! $,0! -<-,! 68-!

/-'$6&.,+8&9+! 68-(!%$&,6$&,!4&68!%$,$=-%-,6! $,0! .4,-/+@! P8-+-!4&''! ,.4! :-! -B9'./-0! &,! ;*/68-/!

0-6$&'@!

!"#"9$:&-;-$&.2$40'<0-(3(0.-$0=$-,</16(-01*$&.2$&26(-01*$+0&12-$

)(!$99'(&,=! 68-!?.,<-/=&,=! 68-./&-+!.;!$=-,?(!$,0!+6-4$/0+8&9A!$!%./-!?.%9/-8-,+&<-! 68-./-6&?$'!

*,0-/+6$,0&,=!.;!:.$/0!6$+7!$,0!?.%9.+&6&.,!?$,!:-!0-/&<-0!;/.%!9/-<&.*+!/-+-$/?8@!P8.*=8!$=-,?(!

68-./(! &+!?.,+&0-/-0!68-!%.+6! &,;'*-,6&$'!$+9-?6!.;!:.$/0!?.,6/.'! &,!$!?./9./$6&.,!d)$%%-,+!-6!$'@A!

2LMLeA! /-+-$/?8! .,! :.68! /-+9-?6&<-! 68-./&-+! 8$+! '-0! 6.! $! =/-$6-/! *,0-/+6$,0&,=! .;! :.$/0! $?6&.,+A!

/.'-+A! $,0! ?.%9.+&6&.,! d)$%%-,+! -6! $'@A! 2LL]A! 2LMLG! K./:-66$! f! J$'<$6.A! 2LLTG! _*+-A! 2LLLG! W+&A!

2LLbG!\$,!0-,!)-/=8-!f!Y-</$*A!2LLTe@!P8-!;.''.4&,=!&,;./%$6&.,!4&''!-B9'./-!64.!:.$/0!=.<-/,$,?-!

Page 15: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!M^!

+6/*?6*/-+A! +*9-/<&+./(! :.$/0+! $,0! $0<&+./(! :.$/0+A! $,0! 68-! 6$+7+! 68$6! +-6! 68-%! :.68! $9$/6@! 36! &+!

&%9./6$,6! 6.! /-?.=,&>-A! 8.4-<-/A! 68$6! %$,(! .;! 68-! 6$+7+! ;./! -$?8! $//$,=-%-,6! +8.*'0! ,.6! :-!

?.,+&0-/-0!%*6*$''(!-B?'*+&<-A!$+!=.<-/,$,?-!$,0!$0<&+./(!/.'-+!0.!9/-+-,6!68-%+-'<-+!68/.*=8.*6!

:.68!=.<-/,$,?-!+6/*?6*/-+@!!

!

J*9-/<&+./(!:.$/0+!8$<-!:--,!&,!68-!+9.6'&=86!.;!+-<-/$'![*/.9-$,!$,0!K8&,-+-!&,+6&6*6&.,+!;./!(-$/+A!

.??$+&.,$''(! 68/.*=8! 68-! *+-! .;! 68-! 64.N6&/-0!%$,$=-%-,6! +(+6-%!%-,6&.,-0! 9/-<&.*+'(@! P8.*=8!

F@J@! /-=*'$6&.,+!0.!,.6! /-S*&/-!*+$=-!.;! +*?8!0&<&0-0!=.<-/,$,?-! +6/*?6*/-+A!:.$/0! &,0-9-,0-,?-A!

4&68&,!68-!?.,6-B6!.;!$!+*9-/<&+./(!:.$/0A!8$+!/-?-&<-0!=/.4&,=!+*99./6!0*-!6.!,*%-/.*+!?./9./$6-!

+?$,0$'+! &,! /-?-,6! (-$/+! d_*+-A! 2LLaG! c&$.A! H$8($A! f! Y&,A! 2LLTe@! 3,! 68&+! :.$/0! +6/*?6*/-A! 0&/-?6./+!

$++*%-!$,!.<-/+&=86!/.'-A!%.,&6./&,=A!?.,6/.''&,=A!$,0!/-9/&%$,0&,=!68.+-!$?6&.,+!68$6!0-;-?6!;/.%!

$??-96$:'-! %./$'+! $,0! ?./9./$6-! =.$'+@! [,+*/&,=! 68-! -,=$=-%-,6! .;! $?6&<&6&-+! :(! %$,$=-%-,6!

/-+*'6+! &,! 68-! :-+6! &,6-/-+6! .;! +8$/-8.'0-/+! &+! .;! <&6$'! &,6-/-+6! 6.! $! +*9-/<&+./(! :.$/0! dK./:-66$! f!

J$'<$6.A!2LLTG!#./:-+!f!E&''&7-,A!Mbbbe@!3,&6&$''(A!68&+!&+!0.,-!68/.*=8!K[W!+-'-?6&.,A!%.,&6./&,=A!$,0!

+*??-++&.,! dK./:-66$! f! J$'<$6.A! 2LLTe@! 3,! ;$?6A! $=-,?(! 68-./(! +*99./6-/+! 8$:&6*$''(! 9/.9.+-! $!

+-9$/$6&.,!.;!K[W!$,0!:.$/0!?8$&/%$,!/.'-+A!$+!68&+!0&<&+&.,!?$,!;$?&'&6$6-!+*99/-++&.,!.;!68-!K[WR+!

9.4-/! &,;'*-,?-! d\$,! 0-,! )-/=8-! f! Y-</$*A! 2LLTe@! #*/68-/! +*9-/<&+./(! /.'-+! &,?'*0-! 0-+&=,&,=!

;&,$,?&$'!9$?7$=-+!.;!6.9!-B-?*6&<-+A!.<-/+&=86!.;!?./9./$6-!+6/$6-=&-+A!?.,6&,*.*+!:.$/0!-<$'*$6&.,A!

$,0! -,+*/&,=! ?.%9'&$,?-! 4&68! $99'&?$6&.,! '$4+! d&@-@! J[K! $,0! 3VJe! dK./:-66$! f! J$'<$6.A! 2LLTG! W+&A!

2LLbe@! Q00&6&.,$''(A! c&$.! -6! $'@! d2LLTe! +*==-+6! 68$6! :-(.,0! 68-! '-=$'! $,0! ?.,6/.'! ?$9$?&6&-+! .;!

+*9-/<&+./(! 0&/-?6./+A! %&,./&6(! /.'-+! &,! +*99'(&,=! $0<&?-! 6.! 68-! :.$/0! $,0! /-?.%%-,0$6&.,+! 6.!

+8$/-8.'0-/+!$'+.!-B&+6@!

!

J*9-/<&+./(!:.$/0! +6/*?6*/-! &+! 6(9&?$''(!-<$'*$6-0! 68/.*=8! 68-!-(-+!.;!9*:'&?! ?./9./$6&.,+A! $+! 68-&/!

%$/7-6!%.0-'R+!0-%$,0+!.;!:.$/0!.:5-?6&<&6(!$,0!&,;./%$6&.,!0&+?'.+*/-!?.,5*/-!*9!?$''+!;./!:.$/0!

&,0-9-,0-,?-@!Q00&6&.,$''(A!:.$/0! &,0-9-,0-,?-! /-9/-+-,6+!$!?./,-/+6.,-!.;!$=-,?(! 68-./(! &,! 68-!

?.%9.+&6&.,!.;!+*9-/<&+./(!:.$/0+@!Q??./0&,=!6.!K./:-66$!$,0!J$'<$6.!d2LLTeA!$,!&,0-9-,0-,6!:.$/0!

?$,!:-!h0-;&,-0!$+!&,0-9-,0-,6!48-,!&,+&0-/+!ijk!$,0!.*6+&0-/+!48.!$/-!,.6!&,0-9-,0-,6!.;!?*//-,6!

%$,$=-%-,6!./!68-!;&/%!ijk!0.!,.6!0.%&,$6-!68-!:.$/0l!d9@!M2Xe@!Q?$0-%&?!'&6-/$6*/-!+*==-+6+!68$6!

&,0-9-,0-,?-!&+!:-+6!$?8&-<-0!68/.*=8!$!%$5./&6(!.;!-B6-/,$'!:.$/0!%-%:-/+!?$9$:'-!.;!%$&,6$&,&,=!

$! 0&<&+&.,! :-64--,! %$,$=-%-,6! +-';N&,6-/-+6! $,0! ?./9./$6-! 0-?&+&.,! %$7&,=! d\$,! 0-,! )-/=8-! f!

Y-</$*A!2LLTe@!Q!+*/<-(!.;!H*6?8!?./9./$6&.,+!4&68!64.N6&/-0!=.<-/,$,?-!+(+6-%+!/-<-$'-0!68$6!68-!

%.+6!-B6/-%-!+*9-/<&+./(!:.$/0+!$/-!<&/6*$''(!+-9$/$6-!.;!%$,$=-%-,6!:.0&-+A!?.%9.+-0!-,6&/-'(!.;!

,.,N-B-?*6&<-! 0&/-?6./+! 68$6! $/-! ;/--! 6.!%$7-! 0-?&+&.,+!4&68.*6! /-=$/0! 6.! -B-?*6&<-!%$,$=-%-,6!

0-?&+&.,+!$,0!&,;'*-,?-@!E./-.<-/A!68-!/-+-$/?8!&,0&?$6-+!+*9-/<&+./(!0&/-?6./+!$/-!+-'-?6-0!:(!9--/!

Page 16: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!MX!

0&/-?6./+!.;!68-!+*9-/<&+./(!:.$/0A!;*/68-/!-'&%&,$6&,=!&,;'*-,6&$'!0-?&+&.,+!;/.%!%$,$=&,=!0&/-?6./+!

$,0! .68-/! +8$/-8.'0-/+! dE$$++-,! f! ).+?8A! Mbbbe@! 3,! 68-! ?.,6-B6! .;! ;$%&'(! :*+&,-++-+A! -%9&/&?$'!

;&,0&,=+! 8$<-! 9/.0*?-0!%&B-0! /-+*'6+! .,! +*9-/<&+./(! :.$/0+A! /-9-$6-0'(! ?&6&,=! ?.,;'&?6&,=! ;&,$,?&$'!

9-/;./%$,?-! &,!$?$0-%&?!+6*0&-+@!U*%-/.*+!+6*0&-+A!8.4-<-/A!0.! &,0&?$6-! 68$6!+*9-/<&+./(!:.$/0+!

;/-S*-,6'(! -B&+6! &,! ;$%&'(! :*+&,-++-+! 0*-! 6.! ,.,N;$%&'(! +6$7-8.'0-/! 9/-++*/-+A!%*'6&9'-! =-,-/$6&.,!

&,<.'<-%-,6!d&,?/-$+-0!;$%&'(!?.,;'&?6eA!$,0!%./$'!8$>$/0!$,0!-B9/.9/&$6&.,!;-$/+! d)$%%-,+!-6!$'@A!

2LMLe@!

!

3,!?.,6/$+6A!$0<&+./(!:.$/0+!?.%9'-6-'(!6/$,+;./%!68-!=.<-/,$,?-!/.'-!.;!68-!:.$/0!;/.%!68$6!.;!$,!

.<-/+&=86! =/.*9! 6.! .,-! .;! $! ?.%9'-%-,6$/(! /.'-!48-/-! $0<&?-A! ?.*,+-'A! $,0! .<-/$''!%$,$=-%-,6!

+*99./6! $/-! 9/.<&0-0! dK./:-66$! f! J$'<$6.A! 2LLTe@! J6-4$/0+8&9A! -;;-?6&<-'(! 68-! 68-./-6&?$'! ;./?-!

:-8&,0!$,!$0<&+./(!:.$/0!.;!0&/-?6./+A!-%98$+&>-+!$!=/-$6-/!?..9-/$6&.,!4&68!?./9./$6-!%$,$=-/+!

$,0! h.9-/$6-+! 4&68! 68-! $++*%96&.,! 68$6! %$,$=-/+! $/-! $:'-! 6.! 9-/+.,$''(! &0-,6&;(! 4&68! 68-! ;&/%A!

&,6-/,$'&>-!&6+!%&++&.,A!$,0!.:6$&,!+$6&+;$?6&.,!;/.%!&,6/&,+&?!%.6&<$6&.,l!dY$,-!-6!$'@A!2LLXA!9@!M^Le@!Q+!

.99.+-0!6.!68-!.<-/+&=86!-'-%-,6!.;!+*9-/<&+./(!:.$/0+A!$0<&+./(!:.$/0+!8-'9!&,+6&''!$!+-,+-!.;!6/*+6!

$,0! ?.%%&6%-,6! &,! %$,$=-%-,6! 68/.*=8! %$,$=-/&$'! -%9.4-/%-,6! dY$,-! -6! $'@A! 2LLXe@! Q'+.A!

$0<&+./(!:.$/0+!8$<-!9/.<-,!6.!:-!$!=..0!+6-9!;./!%$,(!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++-+A!$+!&6!+6&''!$''.4+!68-!;$%&'(!

6.!+*%%.,!.*6+&0-!$0<&?-!$,0!+7&''+!4&68.*6!68-!;-$/!.;!/-'&,S*&+8&,=!?.,6/.'!6.!$!+*9-/<&+./(!:.$/0@!

Q'68.*=8! $0<&+./(! :.$/0+! 9/.%.6-! &,0-9-,0-,6! &,9*6! .,! =.<-/,$,?-! $,0! ?.,6/.'! &6-%+! +&%&'$/! 6.!

68.+-!4/-+6'-0!:(!$!+*9-/<&+./(!:.$/0A!68-!$0<&?-!.;!$0<&+./(!:.$/0!0&/-?6./+!&+!,.,N:&,0&,=!$,0!68-!

$0<&+./(!:.$/0!$+!$!48.'-!8$+!,.!;&,$'!0-?&+&.,!%$7&,=!?$9$:&'&6&-+!dC$/0A!2LMLe@![++-,6&$''(A!$0<&+./(!

:.$/0+! 8-'9! ?.$?8! $,0! 0&/-?6! ;$%&'(! :*+&,-++! -B-?*6&<-+! .,!%$,(! .;! 68-! +$%-! $=-,?(! 68-./(! $,0!

?.,6/.'!&++*-+!=/$99'-0!:(!+*9-/<&+./(!:.$/0+A!$,0!*'6&%$6-'(A!0-?&+&.,+!$/-!8$,0-0!6.!68-!;$%&'(!&,!

68-!;./%!.;!+*==-+6&.,+!/$68-/!68$,!;./?-;*'!&%9'-%-,6$6&.,+@!

!

P8-!$0<&+./(! /.'-! &+! +*99'-%-,6-0!:(! 64.!$00&6&.,$'! -'-%-,6+!.;! +6-4$/0+8&9"! 68-! /-+.*/?-N:$+-0!

<&-4!$,0!+6$7-8.'0-/!68-./(!d)$%%-,+!-6!$'@A!2LMLe@!3,!=-,-/$'A!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++!%$,$=-/+!9.++-++!$!

*,&S*-! +7&''! +-6! 9-/6$&,&,=! 6.! ;&/%N+9-?&;&?! 7,.4'-0=-A! =$&,-0! &,! 9$/6! ;/.%! 68-! -B9-/&-,?-! .;!

.9-/$6&,=! 68-! ;$%&'(! :*+&,-++G! 8.4-<-/A! $6! 6&%-+! 68-+-! %$,$=-/+! '$?7! 68-! =-,-/$'! :*+&,-++!

7,.4'-0=-! 0-+&/-0! .;! ?.%9$/$:'-! ,.,N;$%&'(! :*+&,-++! 9.+&6&.,+@! P8-! 0-%$,0! ;./! .*6+&0-! :.$/0!

$0<&+./+!:-?.%-+!,-?-++$/(!;/.%!$!/-+.*/?-N:$+-0!9-/+9-?6&<-A!$+!:*+&,-++!.4,-/+!?$,!?$''!.,!68-!

$0<&?-! $,0! +*:+-S*-,6! :*+&,-++! +7&''+! .;! -B6-/,$'! &,0&<&0*$'+! 6.! +*99'(! 68-! %&++&,=! 9&-?-+! .;! $,!

.68-/4&+-!?.%9-6-,6!:.$/0!d)$%%-,+!-6!$'@A!2LMLG!C$/0A!2LMLe@!Q00&6&.,$''(A!K./:-66$!$,0!J$'<$6.!

d2LLTe!&0-,6&;(!;.*/!/-+.*/?-!?$6-=./&-+!-,8$,?-0!:(!$0<&+./(!:.$/0+"!9/.<&0&,=!-B9-/6&+-!$,0!$0<&?-!

6.! %$,$=-%-,6A! ;$?&'&6$6&,=! .9-,! ?.%%*,&?$6&.,! :-64--,! &,6-/,$'! $,0! -B6-/,$'! /-+.*/?-+A!

Page 17: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!Ma!

-,8$,?&,=!:*+&,-++!?/-0&:&'&6(A!$,0!+-?*/&,=!9/&<&'-=-0!$??-++!6.!-B6-/,$'!/-+.*/?-+@!Q??./0&,=!6.!68-!

$*68./+A! -$?8! .;! 68-+-! $0<&+./(! :.$/0! /.'-+! &+! ;$?&'&6$6-0! 68/.*=8! ,-64./7! ?.,,-?6&.,+! 4&68&,!

9-/+.,$'! $,0! :*+&,-++! -,<&/.,%-,6+! .;! 68-! :.$/0!%-%:-/+! 68-%+-'<-+@! #/.%! 68-! 9-/+9-?6&<-! .;!

+6$7-8.'0-/! 68-./(A! 68-!,--0! ;./!$0<&+./(!:.$/0!%-%:-/+! 6.! h;&''! 68-!%&++&,=!?.%9-6-,?(!=$9+l! &+!

$'+.! ?/&6&?$'! 6.! :$'$,?&,=! 68-! &,6-/-+6+! .;! $''! 9$/6&-+! 4&68&,! 68-! ?./9./$6&.,R+! +6$7-8.'0-/! $/-,$!

d)$%%-,+!-6!$'@A!2LMLe@!

!

Y$+6'(A! ,*%-/.*+! +?8.'$/+! d)$%%-,+! -6! $'@A! 2LL]A! 2LMLG! K./:-66$! f! J$'<$6.A! 2LLTG! W+&A! 2LLbe!

/-?.=,&>-!68$6!%-0&$6&,=!$,0!%&,&%&>&,=!?.,;'&?6!:-64--,!;$%&'(!%-%:-/+!&+!$,.68-/!/.'-!.;!$0<&+./(!

:.$/0!%-%:-/+@!C&68! ?.,;'&?6+! ?.%%.,'(! -/*96&,=! :-64--,! ;$%&'(! &++*-+! $,0! :*+&,-++! =.$'+A! 68-!

0-%$,0! ;./!$,!.:5-?6&<-! 68&/0!9$/6(!?$,!9'$(!$!?/&6&?$'! /.'-! dY$,-!-6!$'@A!2LLXe@!F'6&%$6-'(A!$0<&+./(!

:.$/0!%-%:-/+!.;;-/!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++!-B-?*6&<-+!$!68&/0!9$/6(!9-/+9-?6&<-!48&'-!+-<-/-'(!'&%&6&,=!68-!

68/-$6!6.!;$%&'(!0-?&+&.,!%$7&,=!68$6!%$(!:-!9/-+-,6!4&68!$!+*9-/<&+./(!:.$/0!dW+&A!2LLbe@!

!

C&68&,!68-!?.,6-B6!.;!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++-+A!68-!-B?'*+&<-!*+-!.;!-&68-/!$!+*9-/<&+./(!:.$/0!./!$!=-,-/$'!

$0<&+./(!:.$/0!&+!,.6!,-?-++$/&'(!?.,6&,*$''(!-,0./+-0@!V$68-/A!$!?.%:&,$6&.,!.;!68-!64.!=.<-/,$,?-!

+6/*?6*/-+! %$(! :-! 68-! %./-! $99/.9/&$6-! ;./%$6! &,! ,*%-/.*+! ;$%&'(! :*+&,-++! ?&/?*%+6$,?-+!

d)$%%-,+!-6!$'@A!2LL]G!K./:-66$!f!J$'<$6.A!2LLTG!H$<&+A!J?8../%$,A!f!H.,$'0+.,A!MbbaG!Y$,-!-6!$'@A!

2LLXG!W+&A! 2LLbG!C$/0A!2LMLe@! J9-?&;&?$''(A!C$/0! d2LMLe! $00/-++-+! ?.%9'&?$6&.,+!.;!%$&,6$&,&,=!$,!

$0<&+./(! :.$/0! 0*-! 6.! ?.%9-6&,=! /.'-+! $,0! :'*//-0! /-+9.,+&:&'&6&-+! 4&68! 68-! :.$/0! .;! 0&/-?6./+@!

Q00&6&.,$''(A!;.?*+-0!$66-,6&.,!9/&%$/&'(!.,!68-!:*+&,-++!&,6-/-+6+!d+*9-/<&+./(!:.$/0e!./!68-!;$%&'(!

&,6-/-+6+!d$0<&+./(!:.$/0e!48-,!&6!?.%-+!6.!0-?&+&.,!%$7&,=!%$(!/-+*'6!&,!*,0-+&/$:'-!?&/?*%+6$,?-+"!

!

RSD-4&3+1-5&-+3#-4&.&T;)*+,-**&'+4*3N&$4&T'.1+%<&'+4*3N&1$/-&$'&[email protected]+$,&".,&".)*-&

*-4+$)*&@4$;%-1*A&F& T;)*+,-**& '+4*3N&@-4*@-"3+D-&.%%$I*& '.1+%<&"$,"-4,*& 3$& '-*3-4&

.,/& -4)@3& +,3$& "%.*#-*& 3#.3& ".,& 3#4-.3-,& 3#-& ')3)4-& $'& 3#-& ;)*+,-**A& F& T'.1+%<&

'+4*3N& D+-I& ".,& /+*34."3& .,/& /4.+,& 1.,.C-1-,3& .,/& ),/-41+,-& 3#-&

"$1@-3+3+D-,-**&$'&3#-&;)*+,-**A&0+3#-4&*#.4@%<&+,"4-.*-*&3#-&%+M-%+#$$/&$'&"$,'%+"3&

;-3I--,&1.,.C-4*&.,/&*#.4-#$%/-4*U&OF4$,$''&V&J.4/5&8WWX5&@A&YQA$

!

V-=$/0'-++A!;$%&'(!?.,6/.'!&+!?'-$/'(!&%9./6$,6!6.!%.+6!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++-+A!$,0!:.68!Y$,-!-6!$'@!d2LLXe!

$,0! C$/0! d2LMLe! 8&=8'&=86! 68-! &%9./6$,?-! .;! -B6-/,$'! 0&/-?6./+! +-/<&,=! &,! :.68! $0<&+./(! $,0!

+*9-/<&+./(!/.'-+!;./!&,?/-$+-0!0&<-/+&6(A!?.,;'&?6!%$,$=-%-,6A!?/-0&:&'&6(A!$??.*,6$:&'&6(A!$,0!.<-/$''!

$0<$,?-%-,6!.;!68-!./=$,&>$6&.,@!!

!

Page 18: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!M]!

K'-$/'(A! $=-,?(! $,0! +6-4$/0+8&9! ;*,?6&.,+! 9'$(! $! ?.%%$,0&,=! /.'-! &,! ;$%&'(! :*+&,-++! =.<-/,$,?-@!

C&68!.<-/+&=86!$,0!$0<&?-!.;6-,!%-/=&,=!;./!$!?.%:&,-0!/.'-!.;!&,0-9-,0-,6!0&/-?6./+!&,!68-!;$%&'(!

;&/%A! 68-! $%:&6&.,+! .;! $! ?.%9$,(! 6.! +-'-?6! -B6-/,$'! 0&/-?6./+! $,0! 68-! -B$?6! &,;'*-,?-+! 9*+8&,=!

$=$&,+6!68-!:.$/0!.;!0&/-?6./+!?$,!:-?.%-!?'.*0-0!:-64--,!68-!64.!0&;;-/-,6!.:5-?6&<-+@!P8/.*=8!$!

:/&-;! .<-/<&-4A! 68-! ;.''.4&,=! %.0-'+! 4&''! 8-'9! 9'$?-! 68-! 0&+?*++&.,! &,6.! $! =/$98&?! 0-9&?6&.,! $,0!

+*%%$6&.,!.;!68-!<$/&.*+!6$+7+!$,0!&,;'*-,?-+!/-'$6&,=!6.!&,0-9-,0-,6!0&/-?6./+@!

!"#">$5,11/.3$'02/)-$(.$<)&4/$

K.,?/-6-!%.0-'+! ;./! ;$%&'(!:*+&,-++!:.$/0+!$,0! 68-! +-'-?6&.,!.;! &,0&<&0*$'!0&/-?6./+! $/-! '&%&6-0! &,!

,*%:-/+!$,0!?.,6-,6@!V-=$/0'-++A!$!/-<&-4!.;!$<$&'$:'-!%.0-'+!4&''!:-!9-/;./%-0A!:-=&,,&,=!4&68!68-!

=-,-/$'!:.$/0!?.,?-96!$,0!?.,?'*0&,=!4&68!$!;.?*+!.,!&,0&<&0*$'!:.$/0!%-%:-/+@!

!

P8/.*=8! $! ?.%:&,$6&.,! .;! $?$0-%&?! 9$9-/! /-<&-4+A! _*+-! d2LLLe! 0-<-'.9-0! $! :&=! 9&?6*/-! <&-4! .;!

:.$/0+! .;! 0&/-?6./+! .9-/$6&.,+! $,0! &,;'*-,?-+! d+--! '+C)4-& =e@! K&6&,=! 68-! ,--0! ;./! $! :-66-/!

*,0-/+6$,0&,=!.;!-$?8!.;!68-!&,0&<&0*$'!?.,?-96+!:-&,=!$99'&-0!&,!68-!%.0-'A!_*+-!d2LLLe!,.6-+!68-!

&%9./6$,?-! .;! 68-! =-,-/$'! =/$98&?$'! %.0-'! ;./! ?.,6&,*-0! -B9'./$6&.,! &,6.! 68-! &,;'*-,?-+! .;! 68-!

0&+6&,?6&<-!;*,?6&.,+@!

!4&O2%-)KP)C5"%3)5F)3&%-'$5%#)F%"0-R5%S)!Q+! -<&0-,?-0! :(! '+C)4-& =A! :.$/0! &,;'*-,?-! &+! 0-/&<-0! ;/.%! $! 0&<-/+-! $++./6%-,6! .;! &,6-/,$'! $,0!

-B6-/,$'!;$?6./+@!H&+?*++-0!-$/'&-/! &+!68-!&%9$?6!68$6!-B6-/,$'!+6$7-8.'0-/!$,0!+8$/-8.'0-/!&,6-/-+6+!

9'$(!,.6!.,'(! &,! 68-! /.'-!.;! :.$/0!%-%:-/! +-'-?6&.,A! :*6! $'+.! &,! 68-!0-?&+&.,!%$7&,=!.;! &,0&<&0*$'!

0&/-?6./+@! P8&+! &+! 0-9&?6-0! &,!_*+-R+!%.0-'! 68/.*=8! -'-%-,6! ,*%:-/+! 2A! OA! XA! $,0! ]@! #*/68-/%./-A!

:.$/0! ?.%9.+&6&.,! $,0! +6/*?6*/-! dae! 0&/-?6'(! /-'$6-! 6.! .<-/$''! =.<-/,$,?-! 68/.*=8! :.68! $=-,?(!

Page 19: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!Mb!

68-./(!$,0!+6-4$/0+8&9!68-./(!$,0!68-&/!/-+9-?6&<-!+*9-/<&+./(!:.$/0!$,0!$0<&+./(!:.$/0!+6/*?6*/-+!

-B&+6&,=! 4&68&,! :.$/0/..%+@! ).$/0! 6$+7! 9-/;./%$,?-! d^e! 0&+?*++-0! $,0! /-;'-?6-0! -$/'&-/! &,! :.$/0!

%-%:-/!-<$'*$6&.,+!&+!$;;-?6-0!:(!68-!$;./-%-,6&.,-0!;$?6./+@!Y$+6'(A!_*+-R+!%.0-'!0-9&?6+!$,!-,0!

/-+*'6!-<$'*$6-0!:(!?.%9$,(!9-/;./%$,?-!dTe@!

!

C8--'-,! $,0! _*,=-/! d2LMLe! .*6'&,-! +&B! 0-=/--+! .;! :.$/0! .;! 0&/-?6./+! &,<.'<-%-,6! 4&68&,! $!

?./9./$6&.,A!$+!9/-+-,6-0!:-'.4!&,!'+C)4-&Z@!P8&+!?$,!+-/<-!$+!$!*+-;*'!0&/-?6&<-!&,!*,0-/+6$,0&,=!68-!

%$=,&6*0-!6.!48&?8!$!:.$/0!.;!0&/-?6./+!-%:-0+!&6+-';!&,6.!68-!+6/$6-=&?!%$,$=-%-,6!9/.?-++!:$+-0!

*9.,! 68/--! :$+&?! 6$+7+"! %.,&6./&,=A! -<$'*$6&.,! 68/.*=8! $0<&?-A! $,0! +6/$6-=&?! 0-?&+&.,! %$7&,=!

dC8--'-,!f!_*,=-/A! 2LMLe@!F'6&%$6-'(A! &6! 9/.<&0-+! $! /.$0%$9! ;./!:.$/0+! +--7&,=! 6.! &,?/-$+-! 68-&/!

/.'-!4&68&,! ./=$,&>$6&.,+@!C&68! :.$/0+! .;! 0&/-?6./+! 6$7&,=! &,?/-$+&,='(! $?6&<-! /.'-+!4&68&,! :*+&,-++!

.9-/$6&.,+!68/.*=8.*6!/-?-,6!(-$/+!dC8--'-,!f!_*,=-/A!2LMLeA!Y$,-!-6!$'@!d2LLXe!+*==-+6!68$6!;$%&'(!

:.$/0+! %*+6! 6$7-! $! %./-! 0(,$%&?! /.'-! 48&'-! -B-/?&+&,=! ?$/-! 6.! 9/.<&0-! 68-! ,-?-++$/(! ?/-0&:&'&6(!

4&68.*6!*,0-/%&,&,=!?./9./$6-!%$,$=-%-,6@!!

!<5R) TMM))C5"%3)H+,5B,-0-+$))MMU) V&O()D("+$50) G2QQ-%)1$"06) !&+&0"B)

G-,&-R)/50&+"B)D"%$&'&6"$&5+)

7'$&,-)D"%$&'&6"$&5+)

8"$"B.#$)

U-<-/!7,.4+!48$6!6.!0.A!&;!$,(68&,=@!U.!0-=/--!.;!&,<.'<-%-,6@!

D-/%&6+!.;;&?-/+!6.!%$7-!$''!0-?&+&.,+@!36!<.6-+!$+!68-!.;;&?-/+!/-?.%%-,0!.,!$?6&.,!&++*-+@!

#./%$''(!/-<&-4+!+-'-?6-0!&++*-+!68$6!.;;&?-/+!:/&,=!6.!&6+!$66-,6&.,@!

3,<.'<-0!6.!$!'&%&6-0!0-=/--!&,!68-!9-/;./%$,?-!./!/-<&-4!.;!+-'-?6-0!7-(!0-?&+&.,+A!&,0&?$6./+A!./!9/.=/$%+!.;!%$,$=-%-,6@!

Q99/.<-+A!S*-+6&.,+A!$,0!%$7-+!;&,$'!0-?&+&.,+!.,!%&++&.,A!+6/$6-=(A!9.'&?&-+A!$,0!.:5-?6&<-+@!_$+!$?6&<-!:.$/0!?.%%&66--+@!D-/;./%+!;&+?$'!$,0!%$,$=-%-,6!$*0&6+@!

P$7-+!68-!'-$0&,=!/.'-!&,!-+6$:'&+8&,=!$,0!%.0&;(&,=!68-!%&++&.,A!.:5-?6&<-+A!+6/$6-=(A!$,0!9.'&?&-+@!36!8$+!$!<-/(!$?6&<-!+6/$6-=(!?.%%&66--@!

4&O2%-)WP)1&X)3-O%--#)5F)Q5"%3)5F)3&%-'$5%#)&+,5B,-0-+$)!Y$+6'(A!'+C)4-&PA!&,6/.0*?-0!:(!c&$.!-6!$'@!d2LLTeA!0-'<-+!0--9-/!&,6.!68-!+*9-/<&+./(!:.$/0!+9-?&;&?$''(A!

-++-,6&$''(! .*6'&,&,=! &,0&<&0*$'! :.$/0! %-%:-/! /.'-+@! Q'68.*=8! 68-! %.0-'! &+! ,.6! ;$%&'(! :*+&,-++!

+9-?&;&?A! &6! +6&''! 9/.<&0-+! <$'*$:'-! &,+&=86! ;./! 68&+! 9$9-/@! )-?$*+-! .*6+&0-! :.$/0! %-%:-/+! .;6-,!

$++*%-!$!+*9-/<&+./(!/.'-!4&68&,!68-!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++!:.$/0A!68-!;.''.4&,=!;&=*/-!0-9&?6+!$!68./.*=8!

*,0-/+6$,0&,=! .;! $,! &,0&<&0*$'! %-%:-/R+! &,<.'<-%-,6! 9-/6$&,&,=! 6.! +*?8! .<-/+&=86! 9.+&6&.,+@!

F'6&%$6-'(A! 68&+! %.0-'! 4&''! :-?.%-! *+-;*'! &,! 0-<-'.9&,=! $! ;*/68-/! ?.%9/-8-,+&.,! .;! 68-! .*6+&0-!

:.$/0!%-%:-/!+-'-?6&.,!9/.?-++-+!?.,?-/,&,=!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++!:.$/0+@!

!

Page 20: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!2L!

!4&O2%-)YP)G5B-)5F)$(-)#26-%,&#5%.)Q5"%3)0-0Q-%)!

C&68! $,! *,0-/+6$,0&,=! .;! =-,-/$'! :.$/0! &,;'*-,?-+A! '-<-'! .;! :.$/0! &,<.'<-%-,6A! $,0! &,0&<&0*$'!

0&/-?6./!6$+7+A!$!,$6*/$'!9/.=/-++&.,!6.! &,0&<&0*$'!:.$/0!%-%:-/!?.,+&0-/$6&.,+!$,0!68-&/!+-'-?6&.,!

9/.?-++! ?$,! 6$7-! 9'$?-@! P8-! ;.''.4&,=! &,;./%$6&.,! 4&''! 8-'9! 6.! :*&'0! *9.,! '+C)4-& P! :(! -B9'./&,=!

+9-?&;&?!?.,+&0-/$6&.,+!;./!68-!+-'-?6&.,!.;!-B6-/,$'!:.$/0!%-%:-/+!&,!:.68!$,!$0<&+./(!$,0!.<-/+&=86!

?$9$?&6(@!

!"!$?.2(6(2,&)$+0&12$'/'+/1-$&.2$38/$-/)/43(0.$<104/--$

H&+?*++&.,!.;!&,0&<&0*$'!:.$/0!%-%:-/+!&+!.,-!68$6!%.<-+!:-(.,0!68$6!.;!=-,-/$'!:.$/0!?.%9.+&6&.,!

$,0!/.'-+A!$,0!;.?*+-+!%./-!.,!68-!+9-?&;&?!6$+7+!9-/;./%-0!$,0!&,;'*-,?-+!.;;-/-0!:(!-$?8!$?6./!.,!

68-!:.$/0@!_*+-!d2LLLe!&0-,6&;&-+!:.68!$!0-%$,0!$,0!+*99'(!+&0-!.;!0&/-?6./!+-'-?6&.,@!U.6!.,'(!$/-!

?./9./$6&.,+! +--7&,=! 6.! -+6$:'&+8! $! +6/.,=!:.$/0!.;! 0&/-?6./+!4&68!-B6-/,$'! 0&/-?6./! /-9/-+-,6$6&.,!

d0-%$,0eA!:*6!9.6-,6&$'!0&/-?6./+!$/-!$'+.! &,!+-$/?8!.;!+6/.,=!?.%9$,&-+!4&68! &,,.<$6&<-! &0-$+!$,0!

9/.%&+&,=! ;*6*/-+! d+*99'(e@! J&%&'$/! 6.!_*+-R+! $/=*%-,6A! 68&+! /-<&-4!4&''! ;.?*+!.,! 68-!0-%$,0! +&0-A!

+&,?-!68&+!9$9-/!$&%+!6.!*,0-/+6$,0!68-!+-'-?6&.,!9/.?-++!:(!?./9./$6&.,+@!

!"!"#$?.3/1.&)$6-"$/@3/1.&)$2(1/4301-$&.2$6&),/$41/&3(0.$

P8.*=8! 68-! :$+&?! ?.,?-96! .;! &,+&0-! $,0! .*6+&0-! 0&/-?6./+! %$(! $99-$/! .:<&.*+A! $! ;./%$'!

*,0-/+6$,0&,=! .;! 68-! 0&;;-/-,?-! :-64--,! 68-! 64.! &+! ,-?-++$/(@! F6&'&>&,=! 68-! 0-;&,&6&.,! .;!

)$/68.'.%-*+>!$,0!P$,-4+7&!d2LLXeA!$,! &,+&0-/! &+!+&%9'(!h$!0&/-?6./!48.!&+!$!;*''N6&%-!-%9'.(--!.;!

Page 21: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!2M!

68-!?.%9$,(l!d9@!2^Oe@!3,!68-!?.,6-B6!.;!;$%&'(!;&/%+A!68&+!&,?'*0-+!68.+-!;$%&'(!%-%:-/+!+-/<&,=!.,!

68-!:.$/0!&,!48&?8!68-(!8$<-!0&/-?6!.9-/$6&.,$'!6&-+!4&68!68-!:*+&,-++!d&@-@!K[W!$,0!D/-+&0-,6e!dW+&A!

2LLbe@!

!

_*+-! d2LLae!-%9'.(+! 64.!0-;&,&6&.,+!.;! &,0-9-,0-,6!0&/-?6./+!0-9-,0&,=!.,!=.<-/,$,?-! +6/*?6*/-!

d$=-,?(!68-./(!./!+6-4$/0+8&9!68-./(e@!`&<-,!68$6!68-!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++!&+!?*+6.%$/&'(!.9-/$6&,=!4&68!$!

?.%:&,$6&.,! .;! 68-! 64.! 68-./&-+! $,0! :*&'0&,=! *9.,! 0-;&,&6&.,+! .;! .68-/! +?8.'$/+A! $,! &,0-9-,0-,6!

0&/-?6./! ?$,! :-! 0-;&,-0! $+! $,! hj-B9-/&-,?-0! ,.,N;$%&'(! 9-/+.,! &,! 48.%! 68-! 0.%&,$6&,=! ;$%&'(!

%-%:-/+!6/*+6l!d_*+-A!2LLaA!9@!M2TeA!8$+!,.!0&/-?6!/-'$6&.,+8&9!6&-+!6.!68-!:*+&,-++!d&@-@!-%9'.(--+A!

+*99'&-/+A! :$,7-/+!4&68! ;&,$,?&$'! 6&-+e! dW+&A! 2LLbeA! $,0! :*&'0+! ?/-0&:&'&6(!4&68! -B6-/,$'! +6$7-8.'0-/+!

dY$,-!-6!$'@A!2LLXe@!

!

[B&+6&,=!/-+-$/?8!&,0&?$6-+!$!%&B-0!/-<&-4!/-=$/0&,=!68-!/-'$6&.,+8&9!:-64--,!&,0-9-,0-,6!0&/-?6./+!

$,0!<$'*-!?/-$6&.,A!9$/6&?*'$/'(!;/.%!$!;&,$,?&$'!9-/+9-?6&<-!d)./.78.<&?8A!D$//&,.A!f!P/$9$,&A!MbbXG!

)./.78.<&?8A!D$//&,.A!f!P/$9&,&A!MbbXG!K.'-+A!H$,&-'A!f!U$<--,A!2LL]G!_*$,=A!_+*A!I8$,A!f!Z*A!2LL]e@!

_.4-<-/A! 68-/-! $/-! .68-/! ?.,+&0-/$6&.,+! ;./! <$'*-! ?/-$6&.,! .;! &,0-9-,0-,6! 0&/-?6./+@! E.,7+! $,0!

E&,.4!d2LL]e! &,0&?$6-! 68$6! &6! &+!.;6-,! 68-!hj?/-$6&<-! 6-,+&.,!:-64--,!68-! &,;./%-0A! &,<.'<-0A!$,0!

-%9.4-/-0!%.,&6./+jl! d9@!TOe! 68$6!$''.4+! ;./!%./-!-;;-?6&<-!?./9./$6-!=.<-/,$,?-@! 36! &+! /-=*'$/'(!

68-! &,+&0-/! 0&/-?6./! 68$6! &+! %./-! '&7-'(! 6.! $'&=,! $,0! :-;/&-,0! 68-! K[WA! ?/-$6&,=! 0&;;&?*'6&-+! ;./!

.:5-?6&<-,-++!$,0!6/*'(!-;;-?6&<-!=.<-/,$,?-!dE.,7+!f!E&,.4A!2LL]e@!P8&+!4.*'0!+*==-+6!&%%-0&$6-!

<$'*-! ;/.%! &,0-9-,0-,6! 0&/-?6./+@! Q00&6&.,$''(A! &,0-9-,0-,6! 0&/-?6./+! ?*/6$&'! +.%-! &,;./%$6&.,!

&%:$'$,?-+!$+!4-''!$+!9/.<&0-!?/&6&?$'!/-+.*/?-+!6.!;&/%+A!&,?'*0&,=!-B6-/,$'!,-64./7&,=!?.,,-?6&.,+A!

?.%9'-%-,6$/(! +7&''+A! $,0! -B6-/,$'! :*+&,-++! 7,.4'-0=-! $,0! -B9-/&-,?-! 68$6! %$(! 8-'9! 6.! 9$6?8!

/-+.*/?-!=$9+!4&68&,!68-!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++!d_*+-A!2LLae@!

!

C$/0!d2LMLe!.*6'&,-+!$!,*%:-/!.;!$00&6&.,$'!*,&S*-!?$9$?&6&-+!&,!48&?8!68-!&,0-9-,0-,6!0&/-?6./!?$,!

9/.<-!*+-;*'!.,!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++!:.$/0+@!#*6*/-!K[W!+*??-++&.,!9'$,+!d&,?'*0&,=!+*??-++./!9/-9$/$6&.,!

$,0! 9/.?-++!%.,&6./&,=eA! ?.%9'&?$6-0! :*+&,-++! ;&,$,?&$'! 0-?&+&.,+! d&,?'*0&,=! ;$%&'(! ?.%9-,+$6&.,A!

0&<&0-,0+A!$,0!:-,-;&6+eA!$,0!;$%&'(!%-%:-/!-<$'*$6&.,+!$/-!$''!9$/6&?*'$/!/.'-+!&,!48&?8!$,!-B6-/,$'!

0&/-?6./! ?$,! +-/<-@! F,'&7-! 9*:'&?A! ,.,N;$%&'(! :*+&,-++-+A! 68-! &,0-9-,0-,6! 0&/-?6./! &,! 68-! ;$%&'(!

+-66&,=! +&%9'(! ;$?&'&6$6-+! $!%.0-/$6&,=! $,0! h+6$:&'&>&,=! &,;'*-,?-l! :-64--,! ;$%&'(! &,6-/$?6&.,+! $,0!

:*+&,-++!.9-/$6&.,+!dC$/0A!2LMLe@!

!"!"!$50.-(2/1&3(0.-$0=$/@3/1.&)$+0&12$'/'+/1-$

C$/0! d2LMLe! .*6'&,-+! $! +-/&-+! .;! ?.,+&0-/$6&.,+! ;./! &,0&<&0*$'! 0&/-?6./! +-'-?6&.,! :$+-0! *9.,! 68/--!

=-,-/$'! S*-+6&.,+! 68-! ?./9./$6&.,! +8.*'0! $+7! 68-%+-'<-+"! hC8$6! -B9-/6&+-! $/-! (.*! +--7&,=! &,!

Page 22: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!22!

0&/-?6./+ol! d9@!bLeG! hC8$6!9-/+.,$'!S*$'&6&-+!0.!(.*!4$,6! &,!0&/-?6./+ol! d9@!bOeG!Q,0!h_.4!4&''! 68-!

:.$/0! :-! +6/*?6*/-0ol! d9@! bTe@! #*/68-/%./-A! _*+-! d2LLLe! ?.,0*?6-0! $! ?$+-! +6*0(! .;! :.68! $! ,-4!

-,6/-9/-,-*/&$'! +6$/6N*9! $+!4-''! $+! $,! -+6$:'&+8-0! ;$%&'(! ;&/%@! )-(.,0! 68-! &,&6&$'! ?.,+&0-/$6&.,+! .;!

48-68-/! 68-! ,-4! 0&/-?6./! 4.*'0! +-/<&?-! &,! $,! $=-,?(! ./! +6-4$/0+8&9! 68-./(! ?$9$?&6(A! _*+-!

0&+?.<-/-0! $! <$/&-6(! .;! ?.,+&0-/$6&.,+! &,! :.$/0! %-%:-/! +-'-?6&.,A! &,?'*0&,="! ;./%$'! <+@! &,;./%$'!

+-$/?8! 9/.?-0*/-+A! ?.%9$,(! 9-/;./%$,?-! =.$'+A! ?.%9'-%-,6$/(! /-+.*/?-N:$+-0! ,--0+A! $,0!

9/-++*/-+! ;/.%!-B6-/,$'! +6$7-8.'0-/+! d_*+-A!2LLLe@!Q00&6&.,$''(A! $! +6*0(!:(!)$%%-,+!-6!$'@! d2LL]e!

&,0&?$6-0! 68$6! =-,-/$6&.,$'! +*??-++&.,+! $/-! $,! $00&6&.,$'! ;$?6./! &,! &,0&<&0*$'! 0&/-?6./! +-'-?6&.,!

9/.?-++-+@! Y$+6'(A!C$/0! d2LMLe!%-,6&.,+! 68$6! 68-!+8--/!,*%:-/!.;! &,0-9-,0-,6!:.$/0!%-%:-/+! &+!

$'+.!$,!&,&6&$'!?.,+&0-/$6&.,@!).$/0!?.%9.+&6&.,!+8.*'0!?.,+&+6!.;!$6!'-$+6!64.!.*6+&0-!0&/-?6./+!.,!$,!

$<-/$=-!:.$/0!.;!-&=86!$0<&+./+@!W68-/4&+-A!68-&/!&,0&<&0*$'!-;;-?6&<-,-++!$+!$,!h&,0-9-,0-,6l!68&/0!

9$/6(!?$,!:-?.%-!h$!9-/+.,$'&6(!/$68-/!68$,!$!<.&?-l!d9@!]Xe@!

!"!"9$A,-(./--$.//2-$6/1-,-$<1/=/1/.4/-$0=$</1-0.&)(3*$

3,! /-;-/-,?-! 6.!:.$/0!%-%:-/! +-'-?6&.,A! $,!$00&6&.,$'! ?.,?-/,! &+! 68-!S*$'&;&?$6&.,+!$,0!?/&6-/&$!:(!

48&?8! &,0&<&0*$'+! $/-! ;&-'0-0! 6.! +-/<-! &,! $!:.$/0!.;!0&/-?6./! ?$9$?&6(@! 3,0&<&0*$'+!9.++-++! $!,$6*/$'!

6-,0-,?(! 6.! :-! $66/$?6-0! 6.! .68-/+! 4&68! +&%&'$/! <&-4+! $,0! 9-/+.,$'&6(! ?8$/$?6-/&+6&?+A! $,0! 68&+! &+!

?-/6$&,'(! ,.! -B?-96&.,! &,! 68-! ?./9./$6-! +-66&,=! d_*+-A! 2LLaG! I8*/$,$A! 2LLMG! D&++$/&+A!C-&,+6-&,A!f!

J6-98$,A! 2LMLe@! 36! +6$,0+! 6.! /-$+.,! 68$6A! 48-,! =&<-,! 68-! ?8.&?-A! ;$%&'(! ;&/%+! =-,-/$''(! %&=/$6-!

6.4$/0!:.$/0!%-%:-/+!.;!?.%9$/$:'-!?8$/$?6-/&+6&?+!&,!./0-/!6.!$<.&0!0-?&+&.,!?.,;'&?6+!d)$%%-,+!

-6!$'@A!2LMLG!Y$,-!-6!$'@A!2LLXG!W+&A!2LLbe@!#./!-B$%9'-A!$,!-%9&/&?$'!+6*0(!:(!J8&<0$+$,&!$,0!Z-/%$?7!

dMbbbe!;.*,0!68$6!K[W+!&,!9$/6&?*'$/!$/-!9$/6&$'!6.!+-'-?6&,=!=/$(!0&/-?6./+!4&68!$!'.4-/!'&7-'&8..0!.;!

$==/-++&<-! ?./9./$6-! $?6&<&6(! %.,&6./&,=! $,0! +?/*6&,&>&,=@! P8-+-! /-+*'6+! +*==-+6! 68$6! K[W+! &,!

9$/6&?*'$/! $/-! +*==-+6&,=! 0&/-?6./+! <&$! $! :&$+-0! $,0! 9-/+.,$''(! ;$<./$:'-! .9&,&.,! 68/.*=8.*6! 68-!

+-'-?6&.,!9/.?-0*/-A! /$68-/! 68$,! 6$7&,=!$!%./-!.:5-?6&<-A! /-+.*/?-N:$+-0!<&-4!0*/&,=! 68-!9/.?-++@!

J&%9'(! 9*6! :(!_*+-! d2LLaeA! h68-!:.$/0!%-%:-/+!1)*3! :-!S*$'&;&-0l! d9@! aOeA!4&68! ?.%9-6-,?(! $,0!

7,.4'-0=-!.;!?$,0&0$6-+!$6!68-!;./-;/.,6@!

!

Q??./0&,=! 6.!C$/0! d2LMLeA! :.$/0! .;! 0&/-?6./+!%*+6! :-! ?8.+-,!4&68! 68-! ;*''! &,6-,6! hj6.!%--6! 68-!

,--0+!.;! 68-!?.%9$,(!$,0! 68-!.4,-/+A!$,0! 6.! +*99./6! 68-!,--0+!.;! 68-!:*+&,-++R+! '-$0-/+8&9l! d9@!

ML^e@! [++-,6&$''(A! &,0-9-,0-,6!0&/-?6./+!.*=86! 6.!:-!8$,09&?7-0!:$+-0!.,! 68-&/! ?.%9-6-,?&-+A! 68-!

,--0+! .;! 68-! :*+&,-++! ;/.%! $! /-+.*/?-N0-9-,0-,?(! 9-/+9-?6&<-A! $,0! 68-! -B9-/&-,?-! &,0&<&0*$'!

0&/-?6./+! 9.++-++! 6.! ;&''! 7,.4'-0=-! =$9+! 4&68&,! ;$%&'(! :*+&,-++! .9-/$6&.,+@! E$&,6$&,&,=! .:5-?6&<-!

<&-4+! 68/.*=8.*6! 68-! 9/.?-++! ?$,! :-! $! ?8$''-,=&,=! 6$+7! $,0! ,*%-/.*+! 68-./&-+! $/-! +*==-+6-0! ;./!

.96&%*%! +-'-?6&.,! 9/$?6&?-+@! P8-! 2LML! +*/<-(! :(!C$/0! d2LMLe! /-<-$'-0! 68$6! Mbn! .;! ;&/%+! *+-! $,!

.*6+&0-! +-$/?8! ;&/%@! W68-/! ;$%&'(! ./=$,&>$6&.,+! =/$<&6$6-! 6.4$/0! 68-! *+-! .;! ?.,+*'6$,6+! ./! +-$/?8!

Page 23: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!2O!

?.%%&66--+A! 48&'-! +.%-! -'-?6! 6.! ?8..+-! :$+-0! .,! -&68-/! 68-! :*+&,-++! ,-64./7&,=! ?$9$:&'&6&-+! .;!

?*//-,6!0&/-?6./+!./! +&%9'(! 68-!h?.%;./6! '-<-'l!.;!9-/+.,$'!,-64./7&,=!?.,6$?6+!$,0! 68-! /-+9-?6&<-!

?$,0&0$6-R+!$:&'&6(!6.!&,6-/$?6!4-''!4&68!?*//-,6!:.$/0!%-%:-/+!dg.8$,,&++.,!f!_*+-A!2LLLG!I8*/$,$A!

2LLMG! C$/0A! 2LMLe@! V-=$/0'-++A! -B&+6&,=! /-+-$/?8! 0.-+! ,.6! $99-$/! 6.! /-<-$'! $,(! ;*/68-/! +9-?&;&?+!

/-=$/0&,=!68-!$?6*$'!+-'-?6&.,!9/.?-++!:-(.,0!68-!+--%&,='(!<$=*-!0-+?/&96&.,+!'&+6-0!$:.<-@!

!"!">$B,''&1*$0=$38/$)(3/1&3,1/$0.$38/$-/)/43(0.$<104/--$

Q!:/&-;!+*%%$/(A!$+!0&+9'$(-0!&,!'+C)4-&95!4&''!8-'9!9/.<&0-!$!+&%9'-!*,0-/+6$,0&,=!.;!68-!'&6-/$6*/-!

.,!68-!+-'-?6&.,!9/.?-++!.;!0&/-?6./+!68*+!;$/@!Q!S*&?7!.<-/<&-4!:-'.4!+8$''!+-/<-!$+!68-!;.*,0$6&.,!.;!

68-!;.''.4&,=!+-?6&.,!9-/6$&,&,=!6.!'&%&6$6&.,+!$,0!68-!/-+-$/?8!9/.9.+&6&.,@!

!

!4&O2%-)ZP)1200"%.)5F)B&$-%"$2%-)5+)#-B-'$&5+)6%5'-##)!P8&+! ;&=*/-! ?.%:&,-+! :.68! 68-! 68-./-6&?$'! $+9-?6+! 9/.<&0-0A! $+! 4-''! &0-$'! :.$/0! ?.,+&0-/$6&.,+!

;*/,&+8-0!&,!68-!'&6-/$6*/-!:(!+?8.'$/+!9/-<&.*+'(!%-,6&.,-0@!P8-!%-68.0!=-,-/$''(!;'.4+!;/.%!'-;6!6.!

/&=86! 4&68! 68-! ;&/+6! 64.! :'.?7+! 9-/6$&,&,=! 6.! &,6-/,$'! ;&/%! 68.*=86+! /-=$/0&,=! 68-! ,--0! ;./!

&,0-9-,0-,6! 0&/-?6&.,+@! P8-! h3,&6&$'! +-$/?8l! :'.?7! /-;-/+! 6.! 68-! %-68.0! &,! 48&?8! ?$,0&0$6-+! $/-!

;&-'0-0! ;./! ?.,+&0-/$6&.,@! hJ-$/?8! ?.,+&0-/$6&.,+l! $,0! h/-+.*/?-! ?.,+&0-/$6&.,+l! =-,-/$''(! &,<.'<-!

68-! ?.%9-6-,?(! $,0! 6/*+6! ?.,+&0-/$6&.,+!.;! &0-,6&;&-0! ?$,0&0$6-+@! Y$+6'(A! hK$,0&0$6-! +-'-?6&.,lA! .;!

48&?8! 68-! '-$+6!$%.*,6!.;!$?$0-%&?! '&6-/$6*/-! &+!9*:'&+8-0A! &0-,6&;&-+!$00&6&.,$'! ?.,+&0-/$6&.,+! ;./!

68-!+-'-?6&.,!.;!;&,$'!?$,0&0$6-+@!K'-$/'(A!8.4-<-/A!68&+!&,;./%$6&.,!&+!'&%&6-0!48&?8!/-<-$'+!68-!,--0!

;./!$00&6&.,$'!/-+-$/?8@!

3,&p$'!0-+&/-!;./!.*6+&0-/d+e!q [B6-/,$'!9/-++*/-+o!

q 3,6-/,$'!%.p<$p.,+o!

q V-9'$?-!;$%&'(!0&/-?6./!./!$00!-B6/$!0&/-?6./o!

K$9$?&6(!&,!48&?8!.*6+&0-/!+-/<-+!q Q=-,?(!d.<-/+&=86e!

q J6-4$/0+8&9!d$0<&+./(e!

q K.%:&,$p.,!

3,&p$'!+-$/?8!q #./%$'!<+@!&,;./%$'!

q K.%%&r--A!K.,+*'6$,6!

q D-/+.,$'s9/.;-++&.,$'!,-64./7+!

J-$/?8!?.,+&0-/$p.,+!q D-/+.,$'&6(!<+@!?.%9-6-,?(!

q P/*+6s/-'&$,?-!.;!.*6+&0-/!

V-+.*/?-!?.,+&0-/$p.,+!q [B9-/p+-!:-&,=!+.*=86!

q Y-<-'!.;!?.%9-6-,?(!$,0!7,.4'-0=-!:$+-0!

K$,0&0$6-!+-'-?p.,!q D/-<&.*+!:.$/0!-B9-/&-,?-!

q K/.++N?8-?7&,=!q [68&?+s./=$,&>$p.,$'!t6!d;.''.4&,=!?.%9-6-,?(e!

Page 24: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!2T!

!"!"C$D('(3&3(0.-$0.$-/)/43(0.$<104/--$&.2$1/-/&148$E,/-3(0.$

Y&6-/$6*/-! -,?.%9$++&,=! 68-! ?.,?-96! .;! &,0-9-,0-,6! :.$/0! .;! 0&/-?6./! +-'-?6&.,! &+! $:*,0$,6A!

8.4-<-/A! '&6-/$6*/-! 0-6$&'&,=! 68-! $?6*$'! +-'-?6&.,! 9/.?-++! &6+-';! &+! ,.6&?-$:'(! $:+-,6! ;/.%! ?*//-,6!

9*:'&?$6&.,+@! Q'68.*=8! &6! &+! &%9./6$,6! 6.! ,.6-! 68$6! +?8.'$/+! 8$<-! 4/&66-,! ,*%-/.*+! /-<&-4+! $,0!

/-+-$/?8! 9$9-/+! /-=$/0&,=! K[W! +-'-?6&.,! ?.,+&0-/$6&.,+! $,0! 9/.?-++-+! d)./.78.<&?8A! D$//&,.A! f!

P/$9$,&A!MbbXG!`.-'!f!P8$7./A!2LL]G!_.;;%$,A!J?8,&-0-/5$,+A!f!J-:./$A!2LLTG!I8*/$,$A!2LLMG!D&++$/&+!

-6!$'@A!2LMLeA!68-(A!6..A!+6.9!+8./6!.;!+*==-+6&,=!+-'-?6&.,!9/.?-++-+!:-(.,0!68&+!6.9!9.+&6&.,!$,0!0.!

,.6!$99-$/!6.!&%9'(!68-&/!/-+*'6+!:-!=-,-/$'&>-0!:-(.,0!+*?8!9.+&6&.,+@!K[W!+-'-?6&.,A!48&'-!&,!+.%-!

$+9-?6+!9.++-++-+!+&%&'$/&6&-+!4&68!&,0-9-,0-,6!0&/-?6./!+-'-?6&.,!9/.?-++!d-+9-?&$''(!=&<-,!68$6!68-!

K[W! &+!.;6-,!$!:.$/0!%-%:-/eA! 68-! +?.9-!.;! +*?8! +-'-?6&.,!9/.?-++-+! ;./! 68-!*,&S*-!K[W!9.+&6&.,!

+6--/!6..!;$/!;/.%!68-!&,6-,6!.;!68-!/-+-$/?8!9/-+-,6-0!8-/-@!

!

C8&'-!9$9-/+!+*?8!$+!68.+-!$*68./-0!:(!Y$,-!-6!$'@!d2LLXe!$,0!K./:-66$!$,0!J$'<$6.!d2LLTe!$/-!S*&?7!

6.! 9.&,6! .*6! 68-! =-,-/$'! 0&;;-/-,?-+! :-64--,! ,.,N;$%&'(! :.$/0+! $,0! ;$%&'(! :.$/0+A! &,?'*0&,=! 68-!

9$/6&?*'$/! +6/*=='-+! 68$6! ;$%&'(! :.$/0+! ;$?-! d$+! 68-(! /-'$6-! 6.! ,*%-/.*+! =.<-/,$,?-! 68-./&-+eA! 68-!

$*68./+! ?-/6$&,'(! 9*+8! ,.! ;*/68-/! 68$,! 6.! .;;-/! <-/(! =-,-/$'! :.$/0! ?.%9.+&6&.,! $,0! ;*,?6&.,!

$66/&:*6-+@! g.8$,,&++.,! $,0! _*+-! d2LLLe! ?'-$/'(! %.<-! .,-! +6-9! ;*/68-/! 6.! 0&+?*++! .*6+&0-! :.$/0!

%-%:-/+!$,0!68-!?8$''-,=-+!$++.?&$6-0!4&68!9/.9-/!+-'-?6&.,!.;!+*?8!0&/-?6./+! 68/.*=8!S*$'&6$6&<-!

+6*0&-+@!C$/0! d2LMLe! $0<$,?-+! 68-! 6./?8! ;*/68-/! 68$,! $,(!.68-/! '&6-/$6*/-!0&+?.<-/-0! 68/.*=8! 68&+!

/-<&-4! :(! +*==-+6&,=! +9-?&;&?! ?.,+&0-/$6&.,+! /-=$/0&,=! &,0-9-,0-,6! 0&/-?6./! +-'-?6&.,A! &,?'*0&,=!

;&''&,=! /-+.*/?-! =$9+A! +.*/?-!.;! ?$,0&0$6-+A! +-$/?8!%-?8$,&+%+A! $,0! ;$?6./+! 6.! ?.,6-%9'$6-!0*/&,=!

0&+?*++&.,+!4&68!9.6-,6&$'!?$,0&0$6-+@!P8-+-!68.*=86+A!8.4-<-/A!$/-!+&%9'(!h&0-$'!?.,+&0-/$6&.,+l!;./!

:.$/0+!.;!0&/-?6./+!$,0!0.!,.6!$99-$/!6.!:-!:$+-0!*9.,!+9-?&;&?!+6*0&-+@!Q+!$!/-+*'6A!$,!$?6*$'!9&?6*/-!

.;! /-$'&6(! $%.,=+6! ;&/%+! 4&68! /-+9-?6! 6.! +-'-?6&.,! 9/.?-0*/-+! &+! +--%&,='(! '$?7&,=@! )(! ?.%:&,&,=!

68-./&-+!$,0!&0-$'!?.,+&0-/$6&.,+!4&68!$?6*$'!9/.?-++-+!6$7&,=!9'$?-!&,!68-!?./9./$6-!-,<&/.,%-,6A!&6!

$99-$/+!;-$+&:'-!68$6!$!%./-!/.*,0-0!*,0-/+6$,0&,=!?$,!:-!;./%*'$6-0@!

!

Q+! $! /-+*'6! .;! 68-! $;./-%-,6&.,-0! '&6-/$6*/-! /-+-$/?8! =$9A! 68-! ;.''.4&,=! /-+-$/?8! S*-+6&.,! &+!

9/-+-,6-0"!

!

FGH$I8&3$&1/$38/$4,11/.3$<104/--/-$+*$J8(48$'/2(,'$30$)&17/$<1(6&3/)*$0J./2$=&'()*$+,-(./--/-$

-/)/43$/@3/1.&)K$.0.L=&'()*$+0&12$'/'+/1-M)

!

Q00&6&.,$''(A! $! +-/&-+! .;! +*:NS*-+6&.,+!4&''! :-! 9/-+-,6-0! 6.! 8-'9! =*&0-! 68-! /-+-$/?8@! Q+! 9/-<&.*+'(!

.*6'&,-0A! $! ,*%:-/! .;! %.6&<$6&.,+! ?.,6/&:*6-! 6.! 68-! &,&6&$'! 0-?&+&.,! ;./! 68-! $00&6&.,! .;! .*6+&0-!

Page 25: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!2^!

0&/-?6./+!.,!$!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++!:.$/0@!Q'68.*=8!68-!&0-$'!?&/?*%+6$,?-+!'&7-'(!&,<.'<-!&,6-/,$'!0-+&/-+!

6.! ;&''! 7,.4'-0=-! $,0! -B9-/&-,?-! 0-;&?&-,?&-+A! 9/-<&.*+! /-+-$/?8! $'+.! 9.&,6+! 6.! <$/&.*+! -B6-/,$'!

+6$7-8.'0-/! 9/-++*/-+! ;./! 68-! &,<-+6%-,6! .;! $! %./-! &,0-9-,0-,6! :.$/0! .;! 0&/-?6./+@! #&-'0&,=!

+*:+-S*-,6!&,;./%$6&.,!&,6.!68-!%.6&<$6&.,+!:-8&,0!68-!&,;*+&.,!.;!.*6+&0-!0&/-?6./+!4&''!;$?&'&6$6-!&,!

9/.<&0&,=!$!+6/.,=-/!;.*,0$6&.,!6.!68-!+-'-?6&.,!9/.?-++@!P8*+"!

!

B,+$ G,/-3(0.#H$ I8&3$ &1/$ 38/$ '03(6&3(0.-$ +/8(.2$ 38/$ (.(3(&)$ 2/4(-(0.$ 30$ =(/)2$ 4&.2(2&3/-$ =01$ &.$

(.2/</.2/.3$+0&12$'/'+/1$<0-(3(0.$0.$38/$=&'()*$+0&12$0=$2(1/4301-M)

!

Q=-,?(! 68-./(!$,0! +6-4$/0+8&9! 68-./(!*,S*-+6&.,$:'(!9'$(!$!9/.%&,-,6! /.'-! &,!.*6+&0-/! +-'-?6&.,@!

_.4! 0.! 68-+-! 68-./&-+! $?6*$''(! 4./7! &,6.! 68-! ?.,+&0-/$6&.,+! :-&,=! %$0-! :(! 68-! +-'-?6&.,! 6-$%o!

Q=-,?(!68-./(!9.&,6+!6.!$,!.<-/+&=86!9.+&6&.,!&,!48&?8!+.%-!?.,6/.'! &+!,.6&?-$:'(!/-'&,S*&+8-0!6.!$!

%-%:-/!.*6+&0-! 68-! ;$%&'(!.4,-/+8&9! ?&/?'-@! )-?$*+-! 68-./(! +$(+! 68$6! 68&+! &+! ./0&,$/&'(! +.%-68&,=!

<-/(! 0&;;&?*'6! ;./! %$,(! ;$%&'(! :*+&,-++! .4,-/+! 6.! +*//-,0-/! d&;! -<-,! .,'(! $! 9./6&.,! .;! ?.,6/.'eA! &6!

4.*'0! :-! &,+&=86;*'! 6.! *,0-/+6$,0! 8.4! 68&+! 0-?&+&.,! &+! $?6*$''(! :-&,=! ;./%*'$6-0@! K.,<-/+-'(A!

+6-4$/0+8&9!68-./(!+--7+!6.!-B6/$?6!?.*,+-'!$,0!.9-/$6&.,$'!7,.4'-0=-!;/.%!&,0-9-,0-,6!0&/-?6./+!

6.! ?.%9'-%-,6! ;$%&'(!0&/-?6./+@! 3;! $,!$0<&+./(!0&/-?6./! &+!:-&,=! +.*=86A! $! ?'-$/-/!*,0-/+6$,0&,=!.;!

68-!0-?&+&.,+!'-$0&,=!6.!48&?8!$0<&+./(!/.'-+!d$,0!6.!48$6!-B6-,6e!68-!0&/-?6./!4.*'0!9.6-,6&$''(!;&''!

4.*'0!$++&+6!&,!:/&0=&,=!68-./(!4&68!9/$?6&?$'!$99'&?$6&.,+@!P8*+"!

!

B,+$ G,/-3(0.!H$ N0$ -/<&1&3/$ -/)/43(0.$ <104/--/-$ /@(-3$ =01$ +038$ &7/.4*$ 38/01*$ 1/-0),3(0.$ &.2$

-3/J&12-8(<$38/01*$70&)-$0=$38/$+,-(./--M)

&

B,+$G,/-3(0.9H$O0J$ (-$ 38/$ 10)/$ 0=$ 38/$ (.2/</.2/.3$ 2(1/4301$ 2/3/1'(./2$ P40.310)$ 6-"$ -3/J&12-8(<Q$

&.2$80J$(-$38/$4&<&4(3*$0=$38&3$10)/$2/4(2/2$,<0.M)

!

K.%:&,&,=!68-!?$''+!.;!$!,*%:-/!.;!+?8.'$/+!;./!68-!0&+6&,?6&.,!:-64--,!9-/+.,$'&6(!9/-;-/-,?-+!$,0!

+-'-?6&.,!:$+-0!.,!%-/&6A!$! ;*/68-/! &,<-+6&=$6&.,! &,6.! 68&+! ;$?-6! &+!4$//$,6-0@![%9&/&?$'! +6*0&-+!$'+.!

-+6$:'&+8! -<&0-,?-! 68$6! +-'-?6&.,! 9/.?-0*/-+! ;/-S*-,6'(! <--/! 6.4$/0! 9-/+.,$'&6(! 9/-;-/-,?-+! $,0!

9-/+.,$'! $+9&/$6&.,+! /$68-/! 68$,! 68-! /-S*&/-%-,6+! ,-?-++&6$6-0! :(! 68-! :*+&,-++! &6+-';@! P8.*=8! 68-!

?$,0&0$6-! +*/-'(!%*+6! ;&6! 68-! ?*'6*/-A! 9-/+.,$'&6&-+A! $,0! 9-/+.,$'! -68&?+! .;! 68-! :.$/0! $+! $! 48.'-A!

+?8.'$/+! 0-+&=,$6-! 68&+! $+! $! ?'-$/! +-?.,0$/(! ?.,+&0-/$6&.,! 6.4$/0! 68-! -,0! .;! 68-! 9/.?-++! $;6-/!

?.%9-6-,?&-+!$/-!0-6-/%&,-0@!P8*+"!

!

Page 26: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!2X!

B,+$ G,/-3(0.>H$ R1/$ 38/1/$ -(7.(=(4&.3$ 2/3/1'(.&.3-$ +/(.7$'&2/$ (.$ 38/$ -/)/43(0.$ <104/--$ +/3J//.$

</1-0.&)$48&1&43/1(-3(4-$&.2$<10=/--(0.&)$40'</3/.4(/-$0=$4&.2(2&3/-K$&.2$(=$-0K$80J$&.2$&3$J8&3$

-3&7/$(.$38/$<104/--M)

!

B,+$ G,/-3(0.CH$ O0J$ (-$ (3$ 2/3/1'(./2$ 38&3$ 4&.2(2&3/-S$ /38(4-$ &.2$ </1-0.&)$ 48&1&43/1(-3(4-$ J())$

<0-(3(6/)*$'/.2$J(38$38/$/38(4-$&.2$017&.(T&3(0.&)$-31,43,1/$0=$38/$=&'()*$+,-(./--$(3-/)=M)

!

Y$+6'(A! C$/0! d2LMLe! %$7-+! %-,6&.,! .;! h6-/%+! .;! +-/<&?-l! '&%&6+! $,0! :.$/0! -<$'*$6&.,! $+! ?/*?&$'!

-'-%-,6+!6.!$!/.:*+6!:.$/0!.;!0&/-?6./+! &,!68-!;$%&'(!;&/%@!)-?$*+-!?.%9$,(!+6/$6-=(!$,0!:*+&,-++!

=.$'+!%./98!.<-/!6&%-A!&,+6&6*6&,=!$!/.6$6&,=!:.$/0!.;!0&/-?6./+!?$,!8-'9!6.!9/.%.6-!,-4!%-%:-/+A!

h48&?8!-,+*/-+!,-4!:'..0A!,-4!&0-$+A!$,0!$!;/-+8!9-/+9-?6&<-l!d9@!b^e@![<-,!4&68!/-;-/-,?-!6.!+*?8!

'&%&6+A! C$/0! ;$&'+! 6.! .;;-/! 9/-?&+-! 6-/%! 9-/&.0+! 48&'-! W+&! d2LLbe! +&%9'(! .;;-/+! ?$+*$'!

/-?.%%-,0$6&.,+! .;! .,-! 6.! 68/--! (-$/+@! K.%:&,-0! 4&68!C$/0R+! 2LML! +*/<-(! &,0&?$6&,=! 68$6! .,'(!

+-<-,!9-/?-,6!.;!/-+9.,0-,6+!8$<-!6-/%!'&%&6+!&,!9'$?-A!&6!&+!.:<&.*+!68$6!-%9&/&?$'!/-+-$/?8!%*+6!:-!

9-/;./%-0! ;./! $! =/-$6-/! *,0-/+6$,0&,=! .;! -B$?6! 6-/%+! $,0! 6-/%! '&%&6+! 9/-+-,6! .,! ;$%&'(! :*+&,-++!

:.$/0+@!P8*+"!

!

B,+$G,/-3(0.UH$O0J$&1/$3/1'-$&.2$3/1'$ )('(3-$/-3&+)(-8/2$=01$ =&'()*$+,-(./--$+0&12-$0=$2(1/4301-$

&.2$J8&3$&1/$38/$3*<(4&)$)/.738-$0=$-,48$3/1'-M)

!

Q??./0&,=!6.!C$/0!d2LMLeA!6-/%!'&%&6+!%$(!$'+.!%.6&<$6-!68-!:.$/0!./!.4,-/+8&9!=/.*9!6.!-<$'*$6-!

&,0&<&0*$'! :.$/0! %-%:-/+! .,! $! %./-! ?.,+&+6-,6! +?8-0*'-@! Q+! :.$/0+! $+9&/-! 6.! =$&,! =/-$6-/!

&,0-9-,0-,?-A!?$''+!;./!:.$/0!-<$'*$6&.,+!$%.,=!;$%&'(!$,0!.*6+&0-/!0&/-?6./+!&,?/-$+-A!9$/6&?*'$/'(!

;/.%!$,!$=-,?(!68-./(!9-/+9-?6&<-@!P8-!-<$'*$6&.,!6-?8,&S*-!;.?*+-+!.,!?*'6*/-A!:.$/0!9/.?-++A!$,0!

?.%9.+&6&.,A! 9/.<&0&,=! $! 4$(! 6.! 0-6-/%&,-A! .,! $! /-=*'$/! :$+&+A! 68-! -;;-?6&<-,-++! '-<-'! .;! :.68!

&,0&<&0*$'!:.$/0!%-%:-/+!$,0!68-!:.$/0!$+!$!48.'-!dC$/0A!2LMLe@!P8.*=8!'&66'-!0&+$=/--%-,6!-B&+6+!

&,!68-!?$''!;./!-<$'*$6&.,+A!;-4!-%9&/&?$'!0-6$&'+!-%-/=-!/-=$/0&,=!&%9'-%-,6$6&.,!$,0!-<.'*6&.,!.;!

+*?8!9/.?-++-+@!P8*+"!!!

!

B,+$ G,/-3(0.VH$ O0J$ &1/$ +0&12$ /6&),&3(0.$ <104/--/-$ -31,43,1/2K$ ('<)/'/.3/2K$ &.2$ 40.2,43/2$

J(38(.$&$=&'()*$+,-(./--$+0&12$0=$2(1/4301-M)

!

`$68-/&,=!$,+4-/+! 6.! 68-!$:.<-!/-+-$/?8!S*-+6&.,!$,0!/-+9-?6&<-!+*:!S*-+6&.,+!4&''!:-!$66-%96-0!

68/.*=8!68-!?.%9'-6&.,!.;!$!/-+-$/?8!+6*0(!.*6'&,-0!$,0!9/-+-,6-0!&,!68-!;.''.4&,=!+-?6&.,+@! !

Page 27: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!2a!

WA)!=@V:>:<:?L)

P8-! ;.''.4&,=! &,;./%$6&.,! 4&''! 0-6$&'! 68-! %-68.0! &,! 48&?8! 68&+! +6*0(! 4$+! ?.,0*?6-0@! #&/+6A! 68-!

/-+-$/?8! ;./%$6!4&''!:-!0&+?*++-0! ;.''.4-0!:(!$,!.*6'&,-!.;! 68-!+$%9'-!*6&'&>-0! ;./!0$6$!?.''-?6&.,@!

U-B6A! $! %./-! 0-6$&'-0! -B9'$,$6&.,! .;! 68-! /-+-$/?8! 9/.?-++! 4&''! :-! 9/-+-,6-0@! Y$+6'(A! &,;./%$6&.,!

/-=$/0&,=!$,$'(+&+!.;!68-!?.''-?6-0!0$6$!4&''!:-!-B9'$&,-0@!

9"#$F/-/&148$=01'&3$&.2$-3,2*$2/-(7.$

C8-,!$66-%96&,=!6.!*,0-/+6$,0!68-!h8.4l!$,0!h48(l!.;!$!9$/6&?*'$/!+&6*$6&.,A!-B9'$,$6./(!/-+-$/?8!

&+! .;6-,6&%-+! 68-! %.+6! $99/.9/&$6-! ;./%$6A! $+! &6! ?$,! 9/.<&0-! 68-! ,-?-++$/(! 0-6$&'-0! &,;./%$6&.,!

*,$:'-!6.!:-!.:6$&,-0!;/.%!:$+&?!+*/<-(!./!.68-/!S*$,6&6$6&<-!%-68.0+!dZ&,A!2LLbe@!K.,+-S*-,6'(A!$!

S*$'&6$6&<-!/-+-$/?8!;./%$6!4$+!?8.+-,!;./!68&+!+6*0(@!P8-!;./%$6!$''.4+!;./!?$+-!+6*0(!/-+-$/?8!68$6!

9/.<&0-+!$!%./-!68./.*=8!*,0-/+6$,0&,=!.;!+*?8!$!0(,$%&?!9/.?-++!dE-/-0&68A!Mbb]e@!

!

V.:-/6! Z&,! d2LLbe! 0-<-'.9-0! $! +&%9'-! $,0! '.=&?$'! 9/.?-++! ;./! ?$+-! +6*0(! /-+-$/?8@! P8&+! '&,-$/!

$99/.$?8!?.,+&+6&,=!.;!+&B!;$?-6+!d'+C)4-&XQ!9/.<&0-0!68-!,-?-++$/(!+*99'-%-,6+!6.!-,+*/-!+6/.,=!?$+-!

+6*0(! -B9'./$6&.,@! [$?8! .;! 68-+-! ;$?-6+! 4$+! $! ?.,+&0-/$6&.,! ,.6! .,'(! &,! 68-! 0-<-'.9%-,6! .;! 68-!

/-+-$/?8!S*-+6&.,+A!:*6! $'+.! 68-! ?$/-;*'! +-'-?6&.,!.;! ?$+-+!$,0! +*:+-S*-,6!0-+&=,!.;! 68-! &,6-/<&-4!

S*-+6&.,,$&/-! 6.! -,+*/-! 68-! 9/.9-/! &,;./%$6&.,! ?.*'0! :-! -B6/$?6-0! ;/.%! -$?8! ?.%9$,(R+!

&,0-9-,0-,6!0&/-?6./!+-'-?6&.,!9/.?-++@!

!4&O2%-)[P)<&+-"%)6%5'-##)F5%)'"#-)#$23.)%-#-"%'()!P8-!+6*0(!4$+!0-+&=,-0!$/.*,0!68-!?$+-!+6*0(!?.,?-96!0*-!6.!68-!$99$/-,6!'$?7!.;!68-./-6&?$'!$,0!

-%9&/&?$'! &,;./%$6&.,! ?.,?-/,&,=! 68-! 0(,$%&?! +-'-?6&.,! 9/.?-++! .;! &,0-9-,0-,6! :.$/0! %-%:-/+@!

Page 28: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!2]!

)-;./-! +-'-?6&,=! 68-! $99/.9/&$6-! ;&/%+! ;./! 68-! +6*0(A! 8.4-<-/A! $! ;-4!9$/$%-6-/+!4-/-!.*6'&,-0! 6.!

-,+*/-!$!%./-!?.,+&+6-,6!+$%9'-@!

!

P8-!F@J@!`.<-/,%-,6R+!J%$''!)*+&,-++!Q++.?&$6&.,! dJ)Qe!=-,-/$''(! ?'$++&;&-+! +%$''!:*+&,-++-+!:$+-0!

.,! +$'-+! ;&=*/-+! ./! -%9'.(--! ?.*,6A! 4&68! &,0*+6/&-+! 6(9&?$''(! :-&,=! ?$99-0! $6! ^LL! -%9'.(--+! ;./!

9*/9.+-+!.;!J)Q!'-,0&,=!9/.=/$%+!d2LLae@!Q'+.A!68-/-!$/-!=-,-/$''(!$??-96-0!F@J@!0-;&,&6&.,+!.;!+%$''N!

d*9! 6.!MLL!-%9'.(--+e!$,0! '$/=-!:*+&,-++-+! d.<-/!^LL!-%9'.(--+e@!_.4-<-/A!9/-<&.*+! /-+-$/?8!.,!

;$%&'(!:*+&,-++!:.$/0+!?.%%.,'(!+8&-+!$4$(!;/.%!;.?*+&,=!.,!68-!+&>-!.;!68-!:*+&,-++@!Q+!&,0&?$6-0!

:(!C$/0! d2LMLeA!:*+&,-++-+!.;!,-$/'(!$,(!+&>-!?$,!9.++-++!$,!$?6&<-!:.$/0!.;!0&/-?6./+!$,0!:-,-;&6!

;/.%! 68-! &,6/.0*?6&.,!.;! &,0-9-,0-,6! 0&/-?6./+! .,! 68-!:.$/0@!_.4-<-/A! &6! &+! $'+.! :-'&-<-0! 68$6A! &,!

=-,-/$'A! 68-! '$/=-/! 68-! :*+&,-++! d,*%:-/! .;! -%9'.(--+! $,0! $,,*$'! +$'-+eA! 68-! =/-$6-/! 68-! ?8$,?-!

-B&+6+!68$6!&,0-9-,0-,6!%-%:-/+!+-/<-!.,!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++!:.$/0+!.;!0&/-?6./+!dC$/0A!2LMLe@!)-?$*+-!

&6!&+!/.*6&,-!68$6!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++-+!$/-!8-+&6$,6!6.!0&+?'.+-!+$'-+!;&=*/-+A!-%9'.(--!?.*,6!/-%$&,+!68-!

:-+6!0-6-/%&,$,6!;./!68&+!+6*0(@!Q!9/-'&%&,$/(!+?$,!.;!:*+&,-++-+!+&0-0!4&68!C$/0R+!$;./-%-,6&.,-0!

:-'&-;! $,0! &,0&?$6-0!.;6-,6&%-+! 68-!<-/(! +%$''A! -$/'&-/! =-,-/$6&.,! ;$%&'(!:*+&,-++-+!8$<-!-&68-/!$,!

&,$?6&<-!:.$/0!d0&+?*++-0! '$6-/e!./!,.! &,0-9-,0-,6!%-%:-/+!.,!$,!$?6&<-!:.$/0@!Q+!$!/-+*'6A! &6!4$+!

0-6-/%&,-0!6.!&,?'*0-!&,!68&+!+6*0(!.,'(!68.+-!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++-+!4&68!$6!'-$+6!;&;6(!-%9'.(--+@!

!

Q00&6&.,$''(A!-$/'&-/!+6*0&-+!8$<-!/-?.=,&>-0!68$6!;$%&'(!;&/%+!?$,!:-!?'$++&;&-0!:(!;$%&'(!.4,-/+8&9!

9-/?-,6$=-!<$'*-+!d)$%%-,+!-6!$'@A!2LL]e@!W;!;*/68-/!?.,+&0-/$6&.,!&+!MLLnA!./!48.''(!.4,-0A!;$%&'(!

:*+&,-++-+@! )-?$*+-! ?*//-,6'(! /-+-$/?8-0! '&6-/$6*/-! ;.?*+-+! .,!%$5./&6(N.4,-0! ;$%&'(! :*+&,-++-+A!

68&+!'&6-/$6*/-!4&''!:-!$!/-;'-?6&.,!.;!68.+-!0-;&,&6&.,+@!Q'68.*=8!MLLn!.4,-/+8&9!&+!+.%-48$6!/$/-!&,!

'$/=-/! ;$%&'(! :*+&,-++-+A! 68&+! +6*0(!4&''! =.! .,-! +6-9! ;*/68-/! 6.! +.'&?&6! &,6-/<&-4+! ;/.%!MLLn! ;$%&'(!

.4,-/+8&9! 48-,-<-/! 9.++&:'-@! Q00&6&.,$''(A! 68-! 0&+6&,?6&.,! :-64--,! 9*:'&?'(N! $,0! 9/&<$6-'(N8-'0!

:*+&,-++! $,0! 68-&/! 0&;;-/&,=! -;;-?6+! .,! :.$/0+! .;! 0&/-?6./+! 4$+! -B$%&,-0! $:.<-@! P8-/-;./-A! .,'(!

9/&<$6-'(N8-'0! d?.%9$,&-+! ,.6! '&+6-0! .,! $! 9*:'&?! +6.?7! -B?8$,=-! $,0! 48-/-! ;$%&'(! .4,-/+8&9! &+!

=/-$6-/!68$,!^Lne!$/-!?.,+&0-/-0@!

!

E./-.<-/A! 68-! &,;./%$6&.,! /-+-$/?8-0! 9-/6$&,+! 6.! $?6&<-! :.$/0+! .;! 0&/-?6./+@! 3,! 68-!F,&6-0! J6$6-+!

+9-?&;&?$''(A!$''!?./9./$6&.,+!$/-!/-S*&/-0!6.!0-?'$/-!$,!.;;&?&$'!:.$/0!.;!0&/-?6./+A!68.*=8!:*+&,-++-+!

$/-! ,.6! ,-?-++$/&'(! /-S*&/-0! 6.! +*+6$&,! $,! $?6&<-! :.$/0! .;! 0&/-?6./+@! P8-! -B6-,6! 6.! 48&?8! -$?8!

?.%9$,(! ?8..+-+! 6.! -B6/$?6! <$'*-! ;/.%! &6+! /-+9-?6&<-! :.$/0! .;! 0&/-?6./+! &+! $,! &,0&<&0*$'! :*+&,-++!

0-?&+&.,!dC$/0A!2LMLe@!P8-!/-+-$/?8!?.,0*?6-0!8-/-!4&''!;.?*+!*9.,!$?6&<-!:.$/0+!68$6!$/-!=-,-/$''(!

?.,+&0-/-0!:(!-$?8!/-+9-?6&<-!?.%9$,(!6.!$00!<$'*-!6.!.<-/$''!:*+&,-++!.9-/$6&.,+!.,!.,-!'-<-'!./!

$,.68-/@!!

Page 29: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!2b!

9"!$B&'<)/$0=$=&'()*$=(1'-$

[&+-,8$/06!dMb]be!$,0!Z&,!d2LLbe!9/.9.+-!*+&,=!;.*/!6.!6-,!?$+-+!$,0!+&B!6.!6-,!?$+-+A!/-+9-?6&<-'(@!

)-(.,0!6-,!?$+-+A!&6!:-?.%-+!&,?/-$+&,='(!0&;;&?*'6!6.!5*=='-!68-!;'.4!$,0!./=$,&>$6&.,!.;!&,;./%$6&.,!

9/.9-/'(! d[&+-,8$/06A! Mb]be@! P8-/-;./-A! $! ?.,<-,&-,?-! +$%9'-! .;! -&=86! ;&/%+!4$+! *+-0@! P8-! *+-! .;!

%*'6&9'-! ?$+-+! $;;./0+! /-+-$/?8-/+! 68-! $:&'&6(! 6.! ;.''.4! h/-9'&?$6&.,! '.=&?l! .<-/! 68-! ?.*/+-! .;! 68-!

+6*0&-+!68/.*=8!$!?$/-;*'!+-'-?6&.,!.;!/-'$6-0!+&6*$6&.,+!dZ&,A!2LLbe@!#*/68-/%./-A!Z&,!dMb]be!+*==-+6+!

68$6! $! +-/&-+! .;! +-<-,! 6.! 6-,! ?$+-+! /-+*'6&,=! &,! 9/-0&?6$:'-! .*6?.%-+! ?$,! 9/.<&0-! ,.6! .,'(! h'&6-/$'!

/-9'&?$6&.,l! :*6! $'+.! 68$6! .;! h68-./-6&?$'! /-9'&?$6&.,lA! 9/.0*?&,=! 9.6-,6&$''(! +6/.,=! /-+*'6+! ;./! 68-!

9/-?-0&,=!9/.9.+&6&.,+@!P8-/-;./-A!68-!+-'-?6&.,!.;!-&=86!/-'$6-0!?$+-+!+8.*'0!$++&+6!4&68!68-!.<-/$''!

+6/-,=68!.;!68-!/-+-$/?8@!Q!=-,-/$'!0-+?/&96&.,!.;!68-!;$%&'(!;&/%+!?$,!:-!+--,!:-'.4!&,!'+C)4-&Y@!

!

)\) H+32#$%.)5F)

'506"+.)H+$-%,&-R--)65#&$&5+)

766%5X&0"$-)+20Q-%)5F)-06B5.--#)

82%%-+$)O-+-%"$&5+)56-%"$&+O)Q2#&+-##)

J) E$,*;$?6*/&,=! K8$&/%$,sK[W! OLL! O/0!K) V-6$&'!`/.?-/(! \D!W9-/$6&.,+! 2A^XT! O/0!W) D$?7$=-0!#..0+! K8$&/%$,! aLL! T68!Y) H$&/(!D/.?-++&,=! D/-+&0-,6! ^LL! O/0!Z) H$&/(!D/.?-++&,=! D/-+&0-,6sK[W! 2^L! O/0![) V$,?8&,=sY&<-+6.?7! K8$&/%$,! ^L! 2,0sO/0!]) D.*'6/(!D/.?-++&,=! D/-+&0-,6sK[W! O2L! O/0!^) V-6$&'A!K$6$'.=! K8$&/%$,sK[W! M2L! 2,0!

4&O2%-)]P)1"06B-)5F)F"0&B.)Q2#&+-##)F&%0#)!Q'68.*=8!68-!,$6*/-!.;!-$?8!:*+&,-++R!9/.0*?6!.;;-/&,=+!0&;;-/+A!-<-/(!;&/%!+-'-?6-0!&+!8-$0S*$/6-/-0!

4&68&,!68-!F,&6-0!J6$6-+@!Q00&6&.,$''(A!68-!+-'-?6&.,!9/.?-++!.;!&,0-9-,0-,6!0&/-?6./+!$+!4-''!$+!68-!

:.$/0!%--6&,=+!68-%+-'<-+!.??*/+!4&68&,!68-!F,&6-0!J6$6-+A!8-'9&,=!6.!-'&%&,$6-!$,(!?/.++N?*'6*/$'!

0&;;-/-,?-+!&,!+-'-?6&.,!9/.?-++-+!$,0!:.$/0!.9-/$6&.,+@!!

9"9$N&3&$40))/43(0.$

D-/+.,$'A!;.?*+-0!&,6-/<&-4+!4-/-!$//$,=-0!4&68!-$?8!.;!68-!-&=86!?.%9$,&-+!&,<.'<-0!&,!68-!+6*0(@!

3,!-$?8!+&6*$6&.,A!68-!%.+6!+-,&./!'-<-'!-B-?*6&<-!;$%&'&$/!4&68!68-&/!/-+9-?6&<-!?.%9$,(R+!+-'-?6&.,!

9/.?-++! ;./! &,0-9-,0-,6! :.$/0! 0&/-?6./+! 4$+! &,6-/<&-4-0@! [$?8! &,6-/<&-4! ?.,+&+6-0! .;! $! +-/&-+! .;!

68&/6(N68/--!+&,='-!$,0!%*'6&N9$/6!S*-+6&.,+@!E$,(!.;!68-!S*-+6&.,+!4-/-!0-+&=,-0!$+!.9-,N-,0-0!6.!

$''.4!68-!&,6-/<&-4--!$!?8$,?-!6.!-B9$,0!$,0!:*&'0!*9.,!$,+4-/+!;./!$!%./-!?.%9/-8-,+&<-!/-+*'6@!

!

[$?8! +-6! .;! &,6-/<&-4! S*-+6&.,+! 4$+! 0&<&0-0! &,6.! ;.*/! =-,-/$'! ?$6-=./&-+"! dMe! ?.%9$,(! 9/.;&'-!

&,;./%$6&.,! d+-<-,!S*-+6&.,+eA! d2e! =-,-/$'! :.$/0!.;! 0&/-?6./+! &,;./%$6&.,! d+&B! S*-+6&.,+eA! dOe! +-%&N

Page 30: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!OL!

+6/*?6*/-0! S*-+6&.,+! .,! +-'-?6&.,! 9/.?-++! d+&B6--,! S*-+6&.,+eA! dTe! $00&6&.,$'! &,;./%$6&.,! d68/--!

S*-+6&.,+e@! [$?8! ?$6-=./(! 4$+! 0-+&=,-0! 6.! $,+4-/! $! +9-?&;&?! +-6! .;! &++*-+! -%$,$6&,=! ;/.%! 68-!

9/-?-0&,=! 68-./-6&?$'! $,0! $?$0-%&?! &,;./%$6&.,! +*//.*,0&,=! 68-! $;./-%-,6&.,-0! /-+-$/?8!

9/.9.+&6&.,+@!

!

P8-!;&/+6!?$6-=./(!4$+!0-+&=,-0!6.!8-'9!?'$++&;(!68-!?.%9$,(!$+!$!48.'-A!-,+*/&,=!68-!:*+&,-++!%-6!

68-!=-,-/$'!?/&6-/&$!.*6'&,-0!$:.<-!;./!9*/9.+-+!.;!68-!+6*0(@!Q00&6&.,$''(A!68-!&,;./%$6&.,!4$+!*+-0!

6.!?.%9$/-!-$?8!?./9./$6&.,!.,!$!<-/(!:$+&?!'-<-'@!P8-!+-?.,0!?$6-=./(!4$+!&,6-,0-0!6.!0-6-/%&,-!

68-! 9/-+-,?-! .;! $,! $?6&<-! :.$/0! $,0! =-,-/$'! ?.%9.+&6&.,! .;! -$?8! ./=$,&>$6&.,R+! :.$/0! ;./!

?'$++&;&?$6&.,!$,0!?.%9$/&+.,!9*/9.+-+@!P8-!68&/0!?$6-=./(!4$+!68-!%.+6!?.%9/-8-,+&<-!+-?6&.,!$,0!

4$+!&,6-,0-0!6.!$,+4-/!$!%$5./&6(!.;!68-!/-+-$/?8!9/.9.+&6&.,+!/-=$/0&,=!:.$/0!+-'-?6&.,@!E$,(!.;!

68-!S*-+6&.,+!4-/-!0-/&<-0!;/.%!68-./-6&?$'!&0-$+!9/-+-,6-0!-$/'&-/!$+!4-''!$+!68-!$99$/-,6!=$9+!&,!

9/$?6&?$'A!0-6$&'-0!7,.4'-0=-!?.,?-/,&,=!68-!<$/&.*+!+6$=-+!.;!68-!+-'-?6&.,!9/.?-++!&6+-';!$+!.*6'&,-0!

:(!C$/0!d2LMLe@!#&,$''(A!68-!;.*/68!?$6-=./(!.;!S*-+6&.,+!4$+!&,6-,0-0!6.!6$/=-6!<$/&.*+!;$?-6+!.;!68-!

:.$/0! .;! 0&/-?6./+! $;6-/! 68-! +-'-?6&.,! 9/.?-++! ?.,?-/,&,=! 68-! -B&+6-,?-! .;! 6-/%! '&%&6+! $,0! .<-/$''!

:.$/0!-<$'*$6&.,!$+!4$+!0&+?*++-0!-$/'&-/@!

!

P8-! &,6-/<&-4! S*-+6&.,,$&/-! *6&'&>-0! ;./! -$?8! .;! 68-! -&=86! &,6-/<&-4+! &+! 9/-+-,6-0! &,! F@@-,/+[& ?\&

B,3-4D+-I&])-*3+$,,.+4-@!

!

! !

Page 31: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!OM!

YA)G=1*<@1)7/>)>H18*11H:/)

#.''.4&,=!$! +-/&-+!.;!-&=86! +-%&N+6/*?6*/-0! &,6-/<&-4+!4&68! ;$%&'(!:*+&,-++!./=$,&>$6&.,+A!0$6$!4$+!

?.%9&'-0! ;/.%!-$?8! ?$+-! 6.! $66$&,! =/-$6-/! 9-/+9-?6&<-! .,! 68-! +-'-?6&.,! 9/.?-++-+! 6$7&,=! 9'$?-! ;./!

&,0-9-,0-,6!:.$/0!%-%:-/+!.,!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++!:.$/0+@! 3,!$,!$66-%96!6.!+8-0!'&=86!.,!68&+!+6*0(R+!

/-+-$/?8! S*-+6&.,A! 68-! &,<-+6&=$6&.,! /-$?8-0! &,6.! 6.9&?+! ?.,?-/,&,=! 68-! &,&6&$'! 0-+&/-+! ;./!

&,0-9-,0-,6!%-%:-/+A!.<-/+&=86!$,0!$0<&+./(!?.,+&0-/$6&.,+A!$+!4-''!$+!=-,-/$'!+-'-?6&.,!9/.?-++-+!

$,0! 0-6$&'-0! +-$/?8! %-?8$,&+%+A! $=-,?(! $,0! +6-4$/0+8&9! 68-./(! ?.,?-/,+A! $,0! .68-/! +9-?&;&?!

?.,+&0-/$6&.,+!68$6!-+6$:'&+8!-$?8!0-?&+&.,@!Q00&6&.,$''(A!;*/68-/!?.,+&0-/$6&.,+!/-=$/0&,=!6-/%!'&%&6+!

$,0! :.$/0! -<$'*$6&.,+! 4-/-! $'+.! -B9'./-0! 68/.*=8.*6! $''! -&=86! &,6-/<&-4+@! P8-! /-+*'6+! .;! -$?8! .;!

68-+-!&,<-+6&=$6-0!6.9&?+!4&''!,.4!:-!9/-+-,6-0!&,!68-!;.''.4&,=!+-?6&.,+@!Q!0-6$&'-0!'&+6!.;!68-!/-+*'6+!

?$,!:-!+--,!&,!F@@-,/+[&F\&!3)/<&4-*)%3*@!

>"#$%&'()*$+,-(./--$4&-/-H$&.$06/16(/J$

P8-! -&=86! &,6-/<&-4+A! ?.,0*?6-0! .<-/! $! 9-/&.0! .;! .,-! %.,68A! .??*//-0! 4&68&,! $! 4&0-! /$,=-! .;!

&,0*+6/&-+! $,0! :*+&,-++! -B9-/&-,?-! '-<-'+@! Q00&6&.,$''(A! ?.''-?6-0! 0$6$! /-<-$'-0! $! <$/&-6(! .;!

&,0-9-,0-,6!0&/-?6./!-B9-/&-,?-!$+!4-''! $+!%$5./&6(!$,0!%&,./&6(! &,0-9-,0-,6!:.$/0+!.;!0&/-?6./+!

$%.,=! 68-! ;$%&'(! :*+&,-++-+@! P8-! &,;./%$6&.,! &,! '+C)4-& ^! 0&+9'$(+! $,! .<-/<&-4! .;! 68-! -&=86!

?.%9$,&-+A! .;;-/&,=! ?.%9$/&+.,+! .,! -&=86! '-<-'+! d+--! F@@-,/+[& F\& !3)/<& 4-*)%3*! ;./! 68-! ?.%9'-6-!

?8$/6e@!P8-!;&=*/-+!-B8&:&6!$!+.'&0!/$,=-!.;!<$'*-+!&,!+-<-/$'!?$6-=./&-+A!+9-?&;&?$''(!h[%9'.(--+l!$,0!

hU*%:-/! .;! (-$/+! .;! &,0-9-,0-,6! 0&/-?6./+u@! W;! 9$/6&?*'$/! &,6-/-+6! &+! 68-! -B9-/&-,?-! 4&68!

&,0-9-,0-,6! 0&/-?6./! :.$/0+!4&68! /-+9-?6! 6.! ?.%9$,(! v]@! Q'68.*=8! 68-! 6$:'-! &,0&?$6-+! 64-,6(N+&B!

(-$/+! .;! &,0-9-,0-,6! -B9-/&-,?-A! 68-/-! 4-/-! 6&%-+! 48-,! 68-! :.$/0! ?.,+&+6-0! .,'(! .;! ;$%&'(!

%-%:-/+@!U-$/'(!+&B!(-$/+!$=.A!$!68&/0!=-,-/$6&.,!;$%&'(!%-%:-/!=$&,-0!%$,$=-%-,6!?.,6/.'!.;!68-!

?.%9$,(!$,0!/-./=$,&>-0!68-!:.$/0!.;!0&/-?6./+@!J&,?-!/-./=$,&>$6&.,A!68/--!&,0-9-,0-,6!%-%:-/+!

8$<-! :--,! $00-0@! Q+! $! /-+*'6A! 68&+! 9$/6&?*'$/! ?.%9$,(! :/&,=+! ,.6! .,'(! '.,=N6-/%! 7,.4'-0=-! .;!

.*6+&0-!:.$/0!%-%:-/+A!:*6!$'+.!%./-!/-?-,6'(!*90$6-0!9/.?-++-+!0*-!6.!68-!&,;*+&.,!.;!$!(.*,=-/!

%$,$=-%-,6! =-,-/$6&.,@! P8-+-! -B9-/&-,?-+! $,0! 9/.?-++-+! 4&''! :-! &,6-=/$6-0! &,6.! +*:+-S*-,6!

+-?6&.,+@!

!

Page 32: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!O2!

K.%9$,(! [%9'.(--+! U*%:-/!.;!(-$/+!4&68!

&,0-9-,0-,6!0&/-?6./+!

#$%&'(!.4,-/+8&9!

Z.*,=-+6!.9-/$6&,=!=-,-/$6&.,!

Z.*,=-+6!.4,-/+8&9!=-,-/$6&.,!

P.6$'!,*%:-/!

.;!0&/-?6./+!

U*%:-/!.;!&,0-9-,0-,6!0&/-?6./+!

D-/?-,6$=-!.;!&,0-9-,0-,6!0&/-?6./+!.,!

:.$/0!

J) OLL! OL! b^n! 2,0! O/0! ]! X! a^n!K) 2A^XT! wM! MLLn! O/0! T68! ML! O! OLn!W) aL^! Mb! MLLn! T68! X68! MM! X! ^^n!Y) ^LL! M^! bLn! O/0! O/0! b! T! TTn!Z) 2^L! 2^! MLLn! O/0! ^68! X! O! ^Ln![) ^L! M2! MLLn! O/0! T68! ML! T! TLn!]) O2L! !!2Xx! bTn! O/0! T68! X! O! ^Ln!^) M^L! ]! MLLn! 2,0! 2,0! X! O! ^Ln!

) ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !7N?) XL^! MO@X! ban! O/0! T68! ]! T! Tbn!

_4"0&B.) Q2#&+-##) R-+$) $(%52O() %-B"$&,-B.) Q%&-F) 6-%&53) R&$(52$) &+3-6-+3-+$) Q5"%3)3&%-'$5%#A!

!!

4&O2%-)^P)?-+-%"B)'B"##&F&'"$&5+)"+3)5,-%,&-R)5F)F"0&B.)Q2#&+-##-#)&+$-%,&-R-3)!P8-! 9-/?-,6$=-! .;! &,0-9-,0-,6! 0&/-?6./+! +-/<&,=! .,! 68-+-! +9-?&;&-0! :.$/0+! $99-$/+! 6.! :-! /$68-/!

?.,+&+6-,6A!+*==-+6&,=!68$6!68-!,*%:-/!.;!.*6+&0-/+!&+!+.%-48$6!0-9-,0-,6!.,!68-!6.6$'!,*%:-/!.;!

0&/-?6./+!.,!68-!:.$/0@!!P8-!.,'(!,.6&?-$:'-!.*6'&-/+!d?.%9$,&-+!vM!$,0!v2e!.;;-/-0!/$6&.,$'&>$6&.,+!

68$6!9$/6&$''(!-B9'$&,!68-&/!0-<&$6&.,+@!K.%9$,(!vM! &,0&?$6-0!68$6A!4&68!68-!-B?-96&.,!.;!64.!;$%&'(!

:.$/0!9.+&6&.,+A! $! ;*''(! &,0-9-,0-,6!:.$/0!8$0!:--,!$!=.$'!.;! 68-! ?*//-,6! ;$%&'(!K[W!+&,?-! 6$7&,=!

?.,6/.'!.;!68-!?.%9$,(@!Q00&6&.,$''(A!?.%9$,(!vM!9.++-++-+!$!=/-$6-/!'-,=68!.;!.*6+&0-/!-B9-/&-,?-A!

48&?8! %$(! +*==-+6! $,! &,?/-$+-0! '-<-'! .;! ?.%;./6! /-=$/0&,=! 68-! ,*%:-/! .;! 0&/-?6./+@! K.,<-/+-'(A!

?.%9$,(! v2A! :-&,=! $! ,-4! -,6/$,6! &,6.! 68-! /-$'%! .;! .*6+&0-! 0&/-?6./+A! .;;-/-0! $,! -B9'$,$6&.,! .;!

8-+&6$6&.,! ;./! 68-&/! '&%&6-0!,*%:-/!.;! &,0-9-,0-,6+@! 3,! ;$?6A! 68-!?.%9$,(!./&=&,$''(!$&%-0!;./!.,'(!

.,-!.*6+&0-/!&,!68-!&,&6&$'!+6$=-+@!_.4-<-/A!9$/$''-'!6.!68-./&-+!9/-+-,6-0!:(!C$/0!d2LMLeA!?.,?-/,+!

.;! &,0-9-,0-,6! 0&/-?6./! &+.'$6&.,! d68-! ;$%&'(! $=$&,+6! $! +&,='-! .*6+&0-/e! $/.+-! $,0! S*&?7'(! 9.&,6-0!

6.4$/0! 68-! ,--0! ;./! $! +-?.,0! .*6+&0-/@! [<-,6*$''(A! 68-! 0-?&+&.,! 4$+! %$0-! 6.! &,6/.0*?-! $! 68&/0!

&,0-9-,0-,6! 0&/-?6./! 4&68&,! 68-! +$%-! 6&%-! ;/$%-@! P.! -$+-! 68-! 8-+&6$6&.,+! $,0! ?.,?-/,+A! &6! 4$+!

0-6-/%&,-0!68$6!68-!68&/0!.*6+&0-/!4.*'0!:-!$,!&,0&<&0*$'!;$%&'&$/!4&68!68-!:*+&,-++!d$!/-?-,6!/-6&/--!

.;!68-!./=$,&>$6&.,e!$,0!&,&6&$''(!+-/<-!;./!,.!%./-!68$,!.,-!(-$/@!E./-.<-/A!'&%&6&,=!68-!&,&6&$'!4$<-!

.;! &,0-9-,0-,6+! 6.! 68/--! 4.*'0! 8-'9! -$+-! 68-! 6/$,+&6&.,! $,0! 9.6-,6&$'! +8.?7! 6.! 68-! 8&+6./&?$''(!

&,+&0-/N.,'(!:.$/0@!

!

Q'68.*=8! 68-! /-%$&,&,=! ?.%9$,(! :.$/0! 9/.;&'-! &,;./%$6&.,! /-%$&,+! /-'$6&<-'(! ?.,+&+6-,6A! 68-!

%.6&<$6&.,+A! 9/.?-++-+A! $,0! 9/.?-0*/-+! :(! 48&?8! &,0-9-,0-,6! 0&/-?6./+! $/-! +-'-?6-0! ;./! ;$%&'(!

:*+&,-++!:.$/0+!.;!0&/-?6./+!-B8&:&6+!$!%*?8!%./-!-B9$,+&<-!/$,=-!.;!/-+*'6+@!P8-+-!.*6?.%-+!4&''!:-!

-B9'./-0! &,! +*:+-S*-,6! +-?6&.,+! 6.! ;$?&'&6$6-! =/-$6-/! *,0-/+6$,0&,=! .;! 68-+-! /-+9-?6&<-! +-'-?6&.,!

9/.?-++-+@!

Page 33: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!OO!

>"!$?.(3(&)$2/-(1/-$=01$(.2/</.2/.3$2(1/4301-$

[$?8!.;!68-!&,6-/<&-4--+!4$+!S*-+6&.,-0!/-=$/0&,=!68-!./&=&,$'!%.6&<$6&.,+!:-8&,0!68-!&,6/.0*?6&.,!

.;! &,0-9-,0-,6! :.$/0! %-%:-/+! d!);& _)-*3+$,8e@! 36! 4$+! :-'&-<-0! 68$6! :(! *,0-/+6$,0&,=! -$?8!

./=$,&>$6&.,R+! ./&=&,! ;./! 68-! &0-$! .;! .*6+&0-! 0&/-?6./+A! '&=86! ?.*'0! :-! +8-0! .,! 68-./&-+! /-'$6-0! 6.!

-B6-/,$'! $,0! &,6-/,$'!9/-++*/-+!9*+8&,=! ;./! 68-!,--0!.;! +*?8!.:5-?6&<-! 68&/0!9$/6&-+@! P8-! ;.''.4&,=!

S*-+6&.,+!4-/-!$+7-0"!

!

M@ _.4!4$+!68-!&,&6&$'!&0-$!.;!&,0-9-,0-,6!:.$/0!%-%:-/+!?.,?-&<-0o!#/.%!48-/-!0&0!68-!&0-$!

./&=&,$6-o!

2@ C-/-!68-/-!$,(! &,6-/,$'!./!-B6-/,$'!9/-++*/-+! ;./! 68-! &,;*+&.,!.;! &,0-9-,0-,6!0&/-?6./+o! 3+!

68-/-! -<-/! ;$%&'(! %-%:-/! /-+&+6$,?-o! 3;! ;$%&'(! /-+&+6$,?-A! 48$6! $/-! 68-! 6(9&?$'! ?.,?-/,+!

:/.*=86!6.!68-!6$:'-o!

!

#.*/! .;! 68-! -&=86! &,6-/<&-4--+! &,0&?$6-0! 68$6! $! 0-+&/-! ;./! ;/-+8! &0-$+! 4&68! .:5-?6&<-! <&-4+! 4$+!

/-?.=,&>-0!$+!$!6.9!9/&./&6(!;./!;&-'0&,=!.*6+&0-!0&/-?6./+@!36!4$+!,.6-0!68$6!/-$'&=,%-,6!.;!+6/$6-=&?!

0&/-?6&.,A!$+9&/$6&.,+!;./!$!:/.$0-/!9-/+9-?6&<-A!$,0!68-!$:&'&6(!6.!9*+8!68-!?.%9$,(!6.!$!8&=8-/!'-<-'!

4-/-!$''! ;$?6./+! &,! 68-! ;$%&'(!0-?&+&.,! ;./!=/-$6-/!:.$/0! &,0-9-,0-,?-@!Q??./0&,=! 6.!.,-!-B-?*6&<-!

;/.%!?.%9$,(!v^"!

!

RB'&+3N*&C$+,C&3$&;-&.&4-.%&;$.4/5&%-3N*&,$3&#.D-&<-3&.,$3#-4&+,3-4,.%&1--3+,C&I+3#&

.& /+''-4-,3& ,.1-A& B& I.*& 3+4-/& $'& #.D+,C& 3#-& T*.1-& $%/& ;$.4/& 1--3+,C*N& I+3#&

'.1+%<&3#.3&/+/,N3&.@@-.4&3$&;-&C$+,C&D-4<&'.4A&B&I.,3-/&'4-*#&+/-.*&3$&`)1@*3.43&

3#-&;$.4/&.,/&1.M-&+3&T*$1-3#+,C&1$4-NAU&

!

Q00&6&.,$''(A! +*??-++&.,! ?.,?-/,+! -%$,$6-0! ;/.%! $! ,*%:-/! .;! ;$%&'&-+! $+! 68-&/! ./=$,&>$6&.,+!

?.,6&,*-0! 6.! =/.4@! P8/--! .;! 68-! -&=86! ?.%9$,&-+! &,0&?$6-0! $! ,--0! ;./! +*??-++&.,! 9'$,,&,=!

-B9-/&-,?-!.,! 68-&/! /-+9-?6&<-! :.$/0+! .;! 0&/-?6./+! y! $! 6/$&6! 68-(! 0&0! ,.6! 9.++-++!4&68&,! 68-! ;$%&'(!

+7&''+-6@!#.''.4&,=!68-!9$++&,=!.;!$!;$%&'(!%-%:-/!&,<.'<-0!4&68!68-!:*+&,-++A!?.%9$,(!vM!&,0&?$6-0!

+*??-++&.,!$+!68-&/!,*%:-/!.,-!/-$+.,!;./!$,!&,0-9-,0-,6!:.$/0@!V-?.=,&>&,=!68$6!$!0-9-,0-,?-!.,!

;$%&'(!;./!+*??-++&.,!%$(!,.6!:-!8-$'68(!;./!68-!?.%9$,(!&,!68-!'.,=!6-/%A!&6!4$+!0-?&0-0!68-!6&%-!

4$+! /&9-! ;./! +.%-! .*6+&0-! 9-/+9-?6&<-+@! Y$+6'(A! $00&6&.,$'!%.6&<$6&.,+! &,?'*0-0! +&%9'-! 7,.4'-0=-!

0&<-/+&;&?$6&.,A! &,?/-$+-0! :*+&,-++! ?.%9-6&6&.,A! $,0! 8&+6./&?$'! ;$%&'(! ?*'6*/-! $,0! -B9-/&-,?-! 4&68!

9/-<&.*+!./=$,&>$6&.,+!?.,6$&,&,=!&,0-9-,0-,6!:.$/0+@!

!

Page 34: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!OT!

U.,-! .;! 68-! -&=86! ./=$,&>$6&.,+! +*==-+6-0! 68$6! $,(! +&=,&;&?$,6! -B6-/,$'! 9/-++*/-+! 9/.%96-0! 68-!

0-+&/-!;./!-B6-/,$'!:.$/0!%-%:-/+@!3,6-/,$'!9/-++*/-+A!.,!68-!.68-/!8$,0A!-B&+6-0!4&68!$6!'-$+6!8$';!

.;!68-!:*+&,-++-+@!K.%9$,&-+!v2A!vOA!vTA!$,0!vX!&,0&?$6-0!$6!'-$+6!+.%-!;./%!.;!&,6-/,$'!9/-++*/-!;./!

&,0-9-,0-,6! :.$/0! %-%:-/+@! P8&+! ./&=&,$6-0! ;/.%! ;-''.4! ;$%&'(! %-%:-/+A! &,6-/,$'! -%9'.(--+!

$0<.?$6&,=!=/-$6-/!.:5-?6&<&6(!.,!68-!:.$/0A!$,0!+&%9'-!;$%&'(!?*'6*/-!$,0!-B9-?6$6&.,+@!K.%9$,&-+!

v^!$,0!va!/-9./6-0!'&66'-!6.!,.!&,6-/,$'!9/-++*/-@!K.%9$,&-+!vM!$,0!v]!8$0!,.!&,6-/,$'!;./?-+!:-(.,0!

+-';N%.6&<$6-0!9/-++*/-!;./!$,!&,0-9-,0-,6!:.$/0@!!

!

P8-! .99.+&,=! ;./?-! .;! &,6-/,$'! ;$%&'(! 9/-++*/-+! 6.4$/0! .*6+&0-/+! &+! 68-! /-+&+6$,?-! 6.! &,0-9-,0-,6!

:.$/0! %-%:-/+@! _$';! .;! 68-! :*+&,-++-+! &,6-/<&-4-0! &,0&?$6-0! $! 9/-+-,?-! .;! ;$%&'(! /-+&+6$,?-@!

V-9./6+! .;! ;$%&'(! .99.+&6&.,! &,?'*0-0! ?.%9$,&-+! vMA! v2A! vOA! $,0! v]@! K.%9$,(! vO! 0-+?/&:-0! 68-!

/-+&+6$,?-! 9.+6-0! :(! $! ,*%:-/! .;! +8$/-8.'0&,=! ?.*+&,+! -B9/-++&,=! +6/.,=! ?.,?-/,+! /-=$/0&,=! $!

9.++&:'-!'.++!.;!?.,6/.'!d9$/6&?*'$/'(!0*-!6.!$!;--'&,=!.;!-,6&6'-%-,6!6.!68-!:.$/0e!$+!4-''!$+!$!;-$/!.;!

'.+&,=! <$'*$:'-! +6.?7! 0&<&0-,0+@! K.%9$,(! v2A! .,! 68-! .68-/! 8$,0A! 0-+?/&:-0! 68-! +&6*$6&.,! %*?8!

0&;;-/-,6'("!

!

RB&I$)%/&/-*"4+;-& +3&.*& '.1+%<&1-1;-4&#-*+3.3+$,5&,$3& 4-*+*3.,"-A&7$3&-D-4<$,-&

*#$I-/& 3#-&*.1-& '--%+,C*& a*)@@$43+,C&$)3*+/-&;$.4/&1-1;-4*bA& B3&I.*&/+''+")%3&

3$& 1.M-& *)CC-*3+$,*& 3$& "#.,C-& 3#-& ;$.4/& *34)"3)4-& $)3& $'& 4-*@-"3& '$4& 3#-&

@4-D+$)*&C-,-4.3+$,N*&$4C.,+c.3+$,&-''$43*AU&

!

K.%9$,(! v]!4&6,-++-0! +&>-$:'-! 9*+8:$?7! ;/.%! ;$%&'(!%-%:-/+! ;-$/&,=! $! '.++! .;! ?.,6/.'! $,0! <-/(!

+6/.,=!.99.+&6&.,!;/.%!68.+-!&,<.'<-0!&,!68-!%$,$=-%-,6!6-$%@!K.%9$,(!vM!/-9./6-0!.,'(!$!+%$''!

0-=/--!.;!/-+&+6$,?-@!W<-/$''A!8.4-<-/A!-$?8!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++!8$,0'-0!68-!+&6*$6&.,!&,!+&%&'$/!;$+8&.,!

4&68!$99$/-,6!+*??-++@!K.%9$,&-+!vMA!v2A!$,0!vO!*6&'&>-0!?.,+*'6$,6+!./!$0<&+./+!6.!8-'9!%-0&$6-!68-!

+&6*$6&.,!$,0!-$+-! 68-! ;$%&'(! &,6.! 68-!9/.?-++@!P8-!K[W!.;!?.%9$,(!v]! 6..7! 68&+! /.'-! &,6.!8&+!.4,!

8$,0+! 68/.*=8!0&+?*++&.,+!4&68! 68-! ;$%&'(A!9/.<&0&,=! 68-%!4&68!%*?8!?.,6/.'!$,0!0-?&+&.,N%$7&,=!

.<-/!68-!+-'-?6&.,!.;!&,0&<&0*$'!.*6+&0-!0&/-?6./+@!!

!

RB& 4-%+*#& 3#-& "#.,C-& .,/& "#.%%-,C-*& $)3*+/-& /+4-"3$4*& ;4+,Cd& B& /$,N3& *--& +3& a3#-&

"#.%%-,C-b&.*&.&3#4-.3A&&&&e&B,3-4D+-I--5&?$1@.,<&f8&

!

P8-+-!/-+*'6+!+*==-+6!68$6!&,!+&6*$6&.,+!.;!;$%&'(!/-+&+6$,?-A!+8$/-8.'0-/!-0*?$6&.,!$,0!&,<.'<-%-,6!

&,!68-!6/$,+&6&.,!$,0!0&/-?6./!+-'-?6&.,!9/.?-++-+!%$(!=.!$!'.,=!4$(!&,!8-'9&,=!68-%!*,0-/+6$,0&,=!

Page 35: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!O^!

68-!9.6-,6&$'! :-,-;&6+! $,0! /$6&.,$'-d+e! :-8&,0! +*?8! ?/&6&?$'! 0-?&+&.,+@!Q00&6&.,$''(A! 68-! &,&6&$'! 0-+&/-!

;./!&,0-9-,0-,6+!6.!+-/<-!&,!+6-4$/0+8&9!/.'-+!$'+.!'&7-'(!+-/<-0!6.!%.0-/$6-!68&+!-;;-?6A!$+!4-''@!

>"!"#$N/=(.(.7$38/$(.2/</.2/.3$2(1/4301S-$10)/$0.$38/$=&'()*$+0&12$

P.!*,0-/+6$,0!8.4!;$%&'(!:.$/0+!0-;&,-!68-!/.'-!.;!68-!&,0-9-,0-,6!0&/-?6./!$,0!68-&/!;&6!4&68&,!68-!

.<-/$''!:.$/0A!68-!;.''.4&,=!S*-+6&.,+!4-/-!9/.9.+-0"!

!

M@ C$+!68-!0-+&/-! ;./!-B6-/,$'!0&/-?6./+!+--,!6.4$/0!$,!.<-/+&=86!9.+&6&.,!./!.,-!.;! /-+.*/?-!

,--0s+*99'-%-,6$6&.,o!_.4!4$+!68-!,--0-0!/.'-!0-6-/%&,-0o!

2@ 3;!.<-/+&=86"!!Q,(!9$/6&?*'$/!.<-/+&=86+!&,&6&$''(!6$/=-6-0o!

O@ 3;!+6-4$/0+8&9"!C8(!$!/-+.*/?-!,--0!$,0!48$6!4-/-!68-!/-+.*/?-+!:-&,=!+.*=86o!

!

J-<-,!.;!68-!-&=86!?./9./$6&.,+!/-9./6-0!68-&/!&,&6&$'!0-+&/-+!;.?*+-0!6.4$/0!.*6+&0-/+!6.!:-!68$6!.;!

$,! $0<&+./(! $,0! +6-4$/0+8&9! ?$9$?&6(A! 68.*=8! +.%-! %./-! 68$,! .68-/+@! K*//-,6'(A! +&B! .;! 68-!

?.%9$,&-+! +6&''! 9*/+*-! .*6+&0-! 0&/-?6./+! 9/&%$/&'(! ;./! /-+.*/?-! 9*/9.+-+@! P4.N68&/0+! .;! 68-+-!

/-+9.,0-,6+! $0%&66-0! 6.! +.%-! ?.%:&,-0! .<-/+&=86! ;*,?6&.,+! ./! $,! &,6-/-+6! 6.! %.<-! 6.4$/0!

.<-/+&=86! &,! 68-! '.,=N6-/%@! P4.! .;! 68-! &,6-/<&-4--+! ?.,+&0-/! 68-&/! .*6+&0-/+! 6.! +-/<-! 9/&%$/&'(! &,!

.<-/+&=86! ?$9$?&6&-+!4&68! $0<&+./(! +7&''+! +6$,0&,=! +-?.,0$/(! 6.! 0&/-?6./+R! 9/&%$/(! 6$+7+@! Y$+6'(A! ;-4!

0-6$&'+! 4-/-! 9/.<&0-0! &,! $,(! .;! 68-! &,6-/<&-4+! /-=$/0&,=! +9-?&;&?! .<-/+&=86+! ./! /-+.*/?-+! 6$/=-6-0!

:-(.,0!%-%:-/+! 68$6! ?.*'0! 8-'9! 68-! :.$/0! +--!%./-! .;! $! h:&=! 9&?6*/-! <&-4l! $,0! 8-'9! 6.! h68&,7!

.*6+&0-!68-!:.B@l!

!

P8-+-! &,&6&$'! 0-+&/-+! $,0! +*:+-S*-,6! ?.,?-/,+! $/-! .,'(! 68-! :-=&,,&,=! .;! $! 9/.?-++! 68$6! ?.,+*%-+!

%*?8!6&%-!$,0!-;;./6!.,!68-!9$/6!.;!-B-?*6&<-+A!0&/-?6./+A!$,0!68-!;$%&'(!.<-/$''@!F,0-/+6$,0&,=!68-!

/.*6-! &,! 48&?8! 68-+-! 0-+&/-+! 6/$,+'$6-! &,6.! ?.,?/-6-! +-'-?6&.,! 0-?&+&.,+! &+! ?/&6&?$'@! P8-! 0-6$&'+!

/-=$/0&,=! 68-! -&=86! ;$%&'(! :*+&,-++R! +-'-?6&.,! 9/.?-++-+! 4&''! :-! 9/-+-,6-0! &,! $! ?.,+.'&0$6-0! $,0!

'.=&?$'!%$,,-/!&,!68-!;.''.4&,=!+-?6&.,+@!

>"9$W.2/1-3&.2(.7$38/$-/)/43(0.$<104/--$

P8-!+-'-?6&.,!9/.?-++!;./!&,0-9-,0-,6!:.$/0+!.;!0&/-?6./+!$99-$/+!6.!:-!S*&6-!+6/$&=86;./4$/0!.,!68-!

+*/;$?-@!F,0-/+6$,0&,=!68-!0-6$&'-0!%-?8$,&+%+!:(!48&?8!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++-+!+-'-?6!68-+-!&,0&<&0*$'+A!

8.4-<-/A! &+! 68-! =/-$6-/! 6$+7@! P8/.*=8! $! +-/&-+! .;! ?.%9/-8-,+&<-! S*-+6&.,+A! -$?8! .;! 68-! -&=86!

-B-?*6&<-+!&,6-/<&-4-0!4$+!$+7-0!6.!:/-$7!0.4,!68-&/!+-'-?6&.,!9/.?-++-+!.,!$!,*%:-/!.;!0&;;-/-,6!

'-<-'+@! P.9&?+! /$,=&,=! ;/.%! 0-;&,&,=! 68-! /.''! .;! 68-! .*6+&0-/! $,0! 68-! &,&6&$'! +-$/?8! 9/.?-0*/-A! 6.!

Page 36: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!OX!

.*6+&0-/!?.,6/.'A!/-+.*/?-!?.,+&0-/$6&.,+A!$,0!+9-?&;&?!?$,0&0$6-!+-'-?6&.,!-'-%-,6+!4-/-!0&+?*++-0@!

P8-!/-+*'6+!$/-!9/-+-,6-0!:-'.4@!

>"9"#$?.(3(&)$-/&148$

P8-!;.''.4&,=!S*-+6&.,+!4-/-!9/.9.+-0!6.!$++&+6!&,!?.%9/-8-,+&.,!.;!&,&6&$'!+-$/?8!9/.?-++!$,0!68-!

$<-,*-+!:(!48&?8!-$?8!?./9./$6&.,!+--7+!&,0-9-,0-,6!0&/-?6./!?$,0&0$6-+@!

!

M@ K$,! (.*! 9/.<&0-! $! =-,-/$'! &0-$! .;! 68-! +-'-?6&.,! 9/.?-++! *+-0! :(! (.*/! ./=$,&>$6&.,! ;./!

&,0-9-,0-,6!0&/-?6./!+-'-?6&.,o!

2@ _.4! 0.! (.*! 7&?7! .;;! 68-! &,&6&$'! +-$/?8! 6.! &0-,6&;(! 9.6-,6&$'! ?$,0&0$6-+o! 3+! &6! $! ;./%$'! ./!

&,;./%$'!9/.?-++o!

O@ C8$6!&+!(.*/!9/&%$/(!+-$/?8!%-?8$,&+%!d+-$/?8!?.%%&66--A!?.,+*'6$,6A!-6?@eo!

T@ _.4!0.!(.*/!+-$/?8!9/.?-++-+!0&;;-/A!&;!$6!$''A!48-,!+--7&,=!?$,0&0$6-+!;./!-&68-/!.<-/+&=86!./!

+6-4$/0+8&9o!

!

[$?8! ?.%9$,(A!4&68!,.!-B?-96&.,A!:-=&,+! 68-! +-$/?8!9/.?-++! <&$! $!0&+?*++&.,!$%.,=+6! 68-! ?*//-,6!

:.$/0! .;! 0&/-?6./+@! 36! &+! :-(.,0! 68&+! 9.&,6A! 8.4-<-/A! 68$6! +-$/?8! 9/.?-0*/-+! 4&68&,! 68-! -&=86!

?./9./$6&.,+!0&;;-/@!K.%9$,&-+!vMA!v^A!vXA!$,0!v]!&,0&?$6-0!$!?.,6&,*.*+!h9$++&<-!+-$/?8l!%.0-!;./!

9.6-,6&$'! &,0-9-,0-,6! 0&/-?6./! ?$,0&0$6-+@! K.%9$,&-+! v2! $,0! vaA! 8.4-<-/A! 0-+?/&:-0! $,! h$?6&<-!

+-$/?8l@!Q00&6&.,$''(A! &6!4$+!$'+.! 68-+-!+$%-!64.!?.%9$,&-+! 68$6! /-9./6-0!$!%./-!h;./%$'l!+-$/?8!

9/.?-++@![$?8!.;!68-!.68-/!+&B!?./9./$6&.,+!?8$/$?6-/&>-0!68-&/!9/.?-++-+!$+!=-,-/$''(!h&,;./%$'l!4&68!

+.%-!$&%&,=!6.4$/0!;./%$'&>$6&.,!&,!68-!,-$/!;*6*/-@!36!$?6*$''(!:-?.%-+!68&+!'-<-'!.;!;./%$'&>$6&.,!

68$6!9/.<&0-+!$00&6&.,$'!7-(!0&;;-/-,?-+!:-64--,!68-!-&=86!;&/%+A!$+!4&''!:-!0&+?*++-0!+8./6'(@!

!

Q'68.*=8!-$?8!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++!/-9./6-0!+.%-!*,&S*-!h9/&%$/(!+-$/?8!%-?8$,&+%+lA!$''!-&=86!4-/-!&,!

$=/--%-,6! 68$6! :*+&,-++! ,-64./7&,=! &+! .;! ?/*?&$'! &%9./6$,?-@! Q! <$+6! %$5./&6(! .;! 68-! ?.%9$,&-+!

*6&'&>-0!?'.+-'(!/-'$6-0!/-+.*/?-+A!&,?'*0&,=!?*//-,6!:.$/0!%-%:-/+!$,0!+-,&./!%$,$=-%-,6A!$+!4-''!

$+! 9/-<&.*+'(! 8&/-0! $??.*,6&,=! $,0! '$4! ;&/%+! ;/.%! 48&?8! 6.! ;&-'0! ?$,0&0$6-! ,$%-+@! F+-! .;! 6/$0-!

$++.?&$6&.,+! 4$+! $'+.! /-9./6-0! :(! ;.*/! .;! 68-! :*+&,-++-+@! P4.! ?.%9$,&-+! /-<-$'-0! 68-! *+-! .;! $!

9/.;-++&.,$'! $0<&+./! ;./! +--7&,=! .*6! 9.6-,6&$'! ?$,0&0$6-+@! V-%$/7$:'(A! 8.4-<-/A! ,.,-! .;! 68-!

&,6-/<&-4--+!&,0&?$6-0!68-!*+-!.;!+-$/?8!?.%%&66--+@!3,!;$?6A!64.!?.%9$,&-+!dvT!$,0!vXe!+9-?&;&?$''(!

0&+?'.+-0! 68-(!$?6&<-'(! +6/$(!$4$(! ;/.%!+*?8!9/$?6&?-+@!K.%9$,(!vXA! &,!9$/6&?*'$/A!,.6-0! 68$6! 68-&/!

./=$,&>$6&.,! ;.*,0! +-$/?8! ?.%%&66--+! 6.!:-! &,-;;-?6&<-! ;./! 68-!*,&S*-!,--0+!.;! $! ;$%&'(!:*+&,-++@!

P8-+-! /-+*'6+! +*==-+6! 68$6! +-$/?8! ?.%%&66--+! %$(! :-! :-66-/! /-+-/<-0! ;./! 9*:'&?A! ,.,N;$%&'(!

?./9./$6&.,+@! Q00&6&.,$''(A! :-?$*+-! $! %$5./&6(! .;! 68-+-! ./=$,&>$6&.,+! ?.,6&,*-! 6.! +-$/?8! ;./!

&,0-9-,0-,6!0&/-?6./+!;./!+6-4$/0+8&9!9*/9.+-+A!?'.+-!,-64./7!?.,6$?6+!%$(!8-'9!/-0*?-!68-!<-66&,=!

Page 37: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!Oa!

9/.?-++! .;! ,-4! 0&/-?6./+A! 9$/6&?*'$/'(! =&<-,! 68-! '&%&6-0! :.$/0! /-+.*/?-+! .;! %$,(! +%$''-/! ;$%&'(!

:*+&,-++-+@!

!

#.''.4&,=!68-!&,&6&$6&.,!.;!?$,0&0$6-!-B9'./$6&.,!<&$!68-!9/&%$/(!+-$/?8!%-?8$,&+%+!'&+6-0!$:.<-A!68-!

-&=86!./=$,&>$6&.,+!+9'&6! &,6.!64.!0&/-?6&.,+!.;!9*/+*&6!:$+-0!.,!68-!d&,e;./%$'&6(!.;!68-&/!/-+9-?6&<-!

9/.?-++-+@! 3,! =-,-/$'A! .,?-! ?$,0&0$6-+! $/-! &0-,6&;&-0A! 68-! &,;./%$'! 9/.?-++! :-=&,+! 4&68! &,&6&$'!

?.,<-/+$6&.,+! :-64--,! 68-! ?$,0&0$6-! $,0! ?./9./$6&.,! 6.! ?.,;&/%! ./! 0-,(! ?$,0&0$6-! &,6-/-+6+! &,!

+-/<&,=! $+! $,! .*6+&0-! :.$/0! %-%:-/@! #*/68-/A! 68-! &,;./%$'! 9/.?-++! $?6+! +&%&'$/! 6.! $,! &,6-/<&-4!

48-/-:(! $! 64.N4$(! -,=$=-%-,6! 6$7-+! 9'$?-! 6.! :-66-/! *,0-/+6$,0! 68-! ?$,0&0$6-R+! S*$'&;&?$6&.,+A!

:$?7=/.*,0A! $,0! %.6&<$6&.,+A! $+! 4-''! $+! 6.! /-'$(! 68-! /-+9-?6&<-! ?./9./$6&.,R+! =.$'+A! <$'*-+A! $,0!

0&/-?6./!-B9-?6$6&.,+!6.!68-!?$,0&0$6-@!Q+!4$+!0-+?/&:-0!:(!?.%9$,(!vMA!&6!&+!$+!%*?8!68-!?$,0&0$6-!

-<$'*$6&,=! 68-&/! ;&6!4&68! 68-! ?.%9$,(! $+! &6! &+! 68-! ?.%9$,(! -<$'*$6&,=! 68-&/! ;&6!4&68! 68-! ?$,0&0$6-@!

F'6&%$6-'(A! 68&+! 8-'9+! 6.! 0-6-/%&,-! $'&=,%-,6! .;! 4$,6+! $,0! ,--0+! ;./! :.68! 68-! ?.%9$,(! $,0!

?$,0&0$6-d+e@!Q!,*%:-/!.;!&,6-/<&-4--+!&,0&?$6-0!68-(!9/-;-/!6.!4./7!$'.,=+&0-!?$,0&0$6-+!&,!+.%-!

9/.;-++&.,$'! ?$9$?&6(! ;./! $! =&<-,! 9-/&.0! .;! 6&%-! 6.! :-66-/! *,0-/+6$,0! 48.! 68-(! $/-! $+! $! 9-/+.,A!

:*+&,-++!'-$0-/A!$,0!9.6-,6&$'!:.$/0!%-%:-/@!#*/68-/%./-A!?.%9$,(!vX!+6/.,='(!$<.&0+!+--7&,=!.*6!

?.%9'-6-! h+6/$,=-/+l! 6.! 68-!?.%9$,(A!9/-;-//&,=! ?$,0&0$6-+!$'/-$0(! ;$%&'&$/! 6.! 68-! ;$%&'(!$,0! 68-!

:*+&,-++@!K./9./$6&.,+!vX!$,0!v]!&,0&?$6-!68-!&%9./6$,?-!.;!+-'-?6&,=!:.$/0!?$,0&0$6-+!68$6!/-+9-?6!

68-!*,&S*-!+&6*$6&.,+!:/.*=86!6.!68-!6$:'-!:(!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++-+!$,0!?$,!6/*'(!$99/-?&$6-!68-!<$'*-!.;!

+-/<&,=!4&68&,!+*?8!0&+6&,?6&<-!?$9$?&6&-+@!

!

[$?8! .;! 68-! +&B! ?.%9$,&-+! *+&,=! $,! &,;./%$'! +-'-?6&.,! 9/.?-++! &,0&?$6-0! 68$6! ?$,0&0$6-+! 4-/-!

=-,-/$''(!;$%&'&$/!4&68!68-!+-'-?6&,=!?./9./$6&.,R+!=-,-/$'!:*+&,-++!9/&./!6.!:-&,=!?.,+&0-/-0!;./!68-!

9.+&6&.,@! U-<-/68-'-++A! ?$,0&0$6-+! 4-/-! $'4$(+! ;./%$''(! &,6/.0*?-0! 6.! -$?8! ?.%9$,(R+! &,6-/,$'!

9/.?-++-+!$,0!?*'6*/-!68/.*=8!6.*/+A!9/-+-,6$6&.,+A!$,0!?'.+-!&,6-/$?6&.,+!h.,N+&6-l@!Q!4&0-!/$,=-!.;!

/-+9.,+-+! 4$+! /-?-&<-0A! &,?'*0&,=! &,6/.0*?6&.,+! &,<.'<&,=! %*'6&N0$(! .,N+&6-! &,6-/$?6&.,+! 6.! +&%9'-!

64.N8.*/!?./9./$6-!6.*/+!$,0!9/-+-,6$6&.,+!;./!68-!?$,0&0$6-+@! 3,!=-,-/$'A! 68-+-! &,6-/$?6&.,+!4-/-!

*6&'&>-0! ;./! ?./9./$6-! :-8$<&./$'! ;&6! 0-6-/%&,$6&.,+@! #.''.4&,=! ?.,;&/%$6&.,! .;! ?.,6&,*-0! &,6-/-+6!

4&68!68-!?$,0&0$6-!$,0!$'&=,%-,6!4&68!68-!?.%9$,(A!6(9&?$'!S*$'&;&?$6&.,!?/.++N?8-?7+!4-/-!$'%.+6!

$'4$(+!9-/;./%-0!<&$!/-;-/-,?-!?8-?7+! &,!+.%-!?$9$?&6(@!Y$+6'(A! ;&,$'!0&+?*++&.,+!$6!68-!:.$/0! '-<-'!

6$7-!9'$?-!:-;./-!?$,0&0$6-+!$/-!.;;-/-0!68-!9.+&6&.,@!Q00&6&.,$'!0-6$&'+!?$,!:-!;.*,0!&,!F@@-,/+[&F\&

!3)/<&4-*)%3*@!

!

P8-!;./%$'!+-$/?8!9/.?-++A!8.4-<-/A!6$7-+!$!%*?8!%./-!+6/*?6*/-0!$99/.$?8!6.!?$,0&0$6-!+-'-?6&.,@!

K.%9$,&-+! v2! $,0! va! $99-$/-0! 6.! $&%! 8-$<&'(! 6.4$/0! :-8$<&./$'A! ?*'6*/$'A! $,0! <$'*-! $'&=,%-,6@!

Page 38: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!O]!

#.''.4&,=!68-!$?6&<$6&.,!.;!&,&6&$'!+-$/?8!%-?8$,&+%+!$,0!&0-,6&;&?$6&.,!.;!9.6-,6&$'!.*6+&0-!0&/-?6./!

?$,0&0$6-+A! 68-! 9/.?-0*/-+! &%%-0&$6-'(! +8&;6! 6.4$/0! $! 8&-/$/?8(! .;! 4-''N+6/*?6*/-0! +6$=-N=$6-+@!

D.6-,6&$'! .*6+&0-/! :.$/0! %-%:-/+! $/-! 9'$?-0! 68/.*=8! $,! .,'&,-! $++-++%-,6! 6-+6! 0-+&=,-0! 6.!

0-6-/%&,-!$'&=,%-,6+!:-64--,!7-(!:-,?8%$/7+!0-6-/%&,-0!:(! 68-!?.%9$,(!$+!4-''!$+!:-8$<&./$'!

$'&=,%-,6+! 4&68! ?*//-,6! 0&/-?6./+! .;! 68-! :.$/0@! 3,6-/-+6&,='(A! ?.%9$,(! va! -B9'$&,-0! 68-&/! &,&6&$'!

4.//&-+! +6-%%&,=! ;/.%! $++-++%-,6+@! D*66&,=! 9/.+9-?6&<-! :.$/0! %-%:-/+! 68/.*=8! $++-++%-,6+A!

%$,(! .;! 48.%! $/-! -B9-/6+! 4&68&,! 68-&/! ;&-'0+A! 4$+! +'&=86'(! 4.//&+.%-@! 36! 4$+! ,.68&,=! 68-+-!

?$,0&0$6-+! 8$0! -<-/! -B9-/&-,?-0! :-;./-@!_.4-<-/A! 68-(!4-/-! $''! <-/(!4&''&,=! 6.! 9$/6&?&9$6-! &,! 68&+!

+--%&,='(! ,.<-'! ?.,?-96@!C8-,! $+7-0! $:.*6! 68-! *'6&%$6-! .9&,&.,! .;! 68-! :-,?8%$/7! $++-++%-,6+!

*+-0!;./!68-&/!?$,0&0$6-+A!68-!&,6-/<&-4--!.;!?.%9$,(!va!-B9'$&,-0"!

!

RB& #.D-& ;--,& D-4<& D-4<& @%-.*-/&I+3#& 3#-& .**-**1-,3*A& B& ".,N3& ;-%+-D-&I-& #+4-/&

a@4-D+$)*%<b&I+3#$)3&3#-1g&6$&.@@%<&+3&3$&3#-&;$.4/&a".,/+/.3-*b&I.*&,.3)4.%A&J-&

#.D-&;--,&D-4<&*)""-**')%&I+3#&+3A&B&.;*$%)3-%<&/$&,$3&#+4-&I+3#$)3&+3&,$IgU&

!

3;! &6! &+! 0-6-/%&,-0! 68$6! 68-! ?$,0&0$6-+! 0.! ,.6! $'&=,! 4-''! -,.*=8! 4&68! 68-! ?.%9$,(A! ,.! ;*/68-/!

-B9'./$6./(! $?6&.,+! $/-! 6$7-,! 4&68! 68-! &,0&<&0*$'@! _.4-<-/A! &;! $'&=,%-,6+! 0.! 9/.<-! ;$<./$:'-A!

$++-++%-,6+!$/-!=-,-/$''(!/-<&-4-0!4&68!68-!?$,0&0$6-!&,!;*/68-/!0&+?*++&.,+@!36!&+!$6!68&+!9.&,6!68$6!

$00&6&.,$'!9-/+.,$'!$,0!9/.;-++&.,$'!&,;./%$6&.,!$/-!.:6$&,-0!$,0!/-;-/-,?-!?8-?7+!9-/;./%-0@!36!&+!

.,'(!$;6-/!68&+!+6-9!68$6!?$,0&0$6-+!$/-!&,<&6-0!6.!$,!&,6-,+&<-!&,6-/<&-4!$,0!64.N4$(!&,6-/$?6&.,!4&68!

68-!?.%9$,(A!$6!48&?8!9.&,6!68-!?$,0&0$6-!&+!;*/68-/!&,6/.0*?-0!6.!?./9./$6-!<$'*-+A!?*'6*/$'!;$?-6+A!

$,0!.<-/$''!?.%9$,(!.9-/$6&.,+@!P8&+!+6$=-!$'+.!9/.<&0-+! 68-!=/-$6-+6!$%.*,6!.;!+.?&$'! &,6-/$?6&.,!

4&68! 68-! ?$,0&0$6-! $,0! ?*//-,6! 0&/-?6./+@! H-0&?$6-0! S*-+6&.,! $,0! $,+4-/! +-++&.,+! $''.4! 68-!

?$,0&0$6-! $,! -,8$,?-0! .99./6*,&6(! 6.! $+7! ;*/68-/! S*-+6&.,+! $,0! 0-6-/%&,-! 68-&/! ;&6! 4&68&,! 68-!

./=$,&>$6&.,A! $+! 4-''@! K.%9$,(! v2! /-9./6-0! 68-! -,6&/-! 9/.?-++! =-,-/$''(! -,?.%9$++-+! $! 8$';N0$(!

+-++&.,!$6!%.+6@! P8&+! ?.,6/$+6+!4&68! 68-! &,;./%$'!%-68.0!9/-<&.*+'(!%-,6&.,-0! &,!48&?8! &,6-,+&<-!

64.N4$(!&,6-/$?6&.,+!$99-$/!6.!6$7-!9'$?-!%*?8!-$/'&-/!&,!68-!+-'-?6&.,!9/.?-++!$,0!.;6-,!;./!'.,=-/!

9-/&.0+!.;!6&%-@!P8-!;&,$'!+6-9A!,./%$''(!&,6-=/$6-0!4&68!68-!9/-<&.*+!+6-9R+!8$';N0$(!+-++&.,A!-,6$&'+!$!

;&,$'!:.$/0!0&+?*++&.,!$,0!4/&66-,!?$,0&0$6-!/-?.%%-,0$6&.,!6.!68-!:.$/0@!

!

H-+?/&96&.,+!.;!:.68!9/.?-++-+!d&,;./%$'!$,0!;./%$'e!$/-!9/-+-,6-0!&,!'+C)4-&WA&8-'9&,=!6.!9/.<&0-!$!

<&+*$'!/-;-/-,?-!6.!+.%-!.;!68-!+6$/7!0&;;-/-,?-+!&,!9/.?-0*/-+@!&

! !

Page 39: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!Ob!

!!!!!!!! !!!!!!! !))))

))

)4&O2%-)`P)H+F5%0"B)"+3)F5%0"B)#-"%'()6%5'-##-#)

#./%$'!+-$/?8!9/.?-++!

3,;./%$'!+-$/?8!9/.?-++!

3,&p$'!?$,0&0$6-!?.,<-/+$p.,+!

q 3,6/.0*?p.,!.;!?.%9$,(!6.!?$,0&0$6- !!q E*6*$'!&,6-/-+6!?.,t/%-0!:(!?$,0&0$6-!

P4.N4$(!-,=$=-%-,6!

q F,0-/+6$,0!?$,0&0$6-!S*$'&t?$p.,+A!:$?7=/.*,0A!<$'*-+!q V-'$(!?./9./$6-!=.$'+A!<$'*-+A!-B9-?6$p.,+!q F,0-/+6$,0!?.%%&r%-,6!6.!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++A!*,&S*-!?8$''-,=-+!

3,N0-968!&,6-/$?p.,!!

q J.%-!9/-<&.*+!;$%&'&$/&6(!0-+&/-0!q 3,6/.0*?p.,!6.!&,6-/,$'!.9-/$p.,+A!?*'6*/-!q W,N+&6-!&,6-/$?p.,+!4&68!+-,&./!%$,$=-%-,6A!0&/-?6./+A!;$%&'(!q P4.!8.*/+!6.!%*'pN0$(!&,6-/$?p.,!!

V-?.,t/%$p.,!.;!&,6-/-+6!

q K$,0&0$6-!?.,t/%+!?.,p,*-0!&,6-/-+6!&,!9.+&p.,!q K$,0&0$6-!0-,&-+!?.,p,*-0!&,6-/-+6!&,!9.+&p.,!

K/.++N?8-?7+!

q V-;-/-,?-!?8-?7+!q #*/68-/!?8-?7+!4&68!9/&./s?*//-,6!?.''-$=*-+A!+*9-/&./+A!.68-/+!&,!?$,0&0$6-z+!&,0*+6/(!

#&,$'!:.$/0!0&+?*++&.,!

q ).$/0!$=/--%-,6!$,0!;./%$'!/-?.%%-,0$p.,!q K$,0&0$6-!.{?&$''(!.|-/-0!9.+&p.,!

H-t,-0!+7&''!+-6!

q E$6?8!0-t,-0!+7&''!+-6!4&68!+-'-?6-0!?$,0&0$6-+!q K$,0&0$6-!$0<$,?-+!0-9-,0&,=!.,!0-=/--!.;!%$6?8!

3,&p$'!?$,0&0$6-!?.,<-/+$p.,!

q D/-+-,6$p.,!.;!:.$/0!%-%:-/!7-(!$??.*,6$:&'&p-+!q K.,t/%!%*6*$'!&,6-/-+6!

)-,?8%$/7!$++-++%-,6+!

q K$,0&0$6-!6$7-+!.,'&,-!$++-++%-,6!q H-6-/%&,-!?$,0&0$6-!$'&=,%-,6!4&68!0-t,-0!:-,?8%$/7+!q K$,0&0$6-!$0<$,?-%-,6!0-9-,0&,=!.,!/-+*'6+!

Q++-++%-,6!?.%9$/&+.,!

q H-6-/%&,-!:-8$<&./$'!$++-++%-,6!$'&=,%-,6!4&68!?*//-,6!:.$/0!%-%:-/+!q K$,0&0$6-!$0<$,?-%-,6!0-9-,0&,=!.,!/-+*'6+!

3,N0-968!&,6-/<&-4!

q 3,6/.0*?p.,!6.!&,6-/,$'!.9-/$p.,+A!?*'6*/-!q W,N+&6-!&,6-/$?p.,+!4&68!+-,&./!%$,$=-%-,6A!0&/-?6./+A!;$%&'(!q _$';N0$(!+-++&.,!d=-,-/$''(e!q V-?.,t/%$p.,!.;!?.,t/%-0!&,6-/-+6!

#&,$'!:.$/0!0&+?*++&.,!

q ).$/0!0&+?*++&.,A!/-?.%%-,0$p.,A!$,0!<.6-!q K$,0&0$6-!.{?&$''(!.|-/-0!9.+&p.,!q K$,0&0$6-!?.,t/%+!./!0-,&-+!.|-/!

3,&p$'!0&+?*++&.,!4&68&,!:.$/0!

q U--0!;./!&,0-9-,0-,6!0&/-?6./!q 30-,p;(!?$9$?&6(!&,!48&?8!?$,0&0$6-!4.*'0!+-/<-!q K.,+&0-/!.68-/!9$/p-+!$|-?6-0!:(!0-?&+&.,@!H&+?*++&.,!4$//$,6-0!4&68!68-+-!=/.*9+o!

D/&%$/(!+-$/?8!%-?8$,&+%+!

q D$++&<-!<+@!$?p<-!+-$/?8!q )*+&,-++!,-64./7+!q K'.+-'(!/-'$6-0!/-+.*/?-+!d$??.*,6$,6+A!'$4!t/%+e!q D/.;-++&.,$'!$0<&+./+A!6/$0-!$++.?&$p.,+!

Page 40: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!TL!

>"9"!$B/&148$&.2$1/-0,14/$40.-(2/1&3(0.-$

C8-,! +-'-?6&,=! ?$,0&0$6-+! ;./! .*6+&0-! 0&/-?6./! 9.+&6&.,+A! 48-68-/! &,! $! +6-4$/0+8&9! ./! .<-/+&=86!

9.+&6&.,A!68-!$:&'&6(!6.!6/*+6!68-!-B9-/6&+-!$,0!%.6&<$6&.,+!.;!$,! &,0&<&0*$'! &+!?/*?&$'@!Q00&6&.,$''(A!$!

,*%:-/!.;!+?8.'$/+!+6/-++!68-!&%9./6$,?-!.;!9'$?&,=!?$,0&0$6-!?.%9-6-,?(!$,0!7,.4'-0=-!$8-$0!.;!

68-!9/-;-/-,?-! ;./!9-/+.,$'&6(!?8$/$?6-/&+6&?+@! 3,!$,!-;;./6! 6.!*,0-/+6$,0!8.4!68-+-!64.!$+9-?6+!.;!

0&/-?6./!+-'-?6&.,!$/-!:-&,=!?.,+&0-/-0A!68-!;.''.4&,=!S*-+6&.,+!4-/-!9/-+-,6-0"!

!

M@ P/*+6!&+!$!7-(!-'-%-,6@!_.4!0.!(.*!+--7!+.%-.,-!68$6!(.*!?$,!6/*+6o!

2@ _.4!0.!(.*!-,+*/-!68$6!?$,0&0$6-+!$/-!;*''(!S*$'&;&-0!$,0!68$6!68-/-!&+!$!?'-$/!+-9$/$6&.,!.;!

9-/+.,$'&6(!9/-;-/-,?-+!$,0!?.%9-6-,?(sS*$'&;&?$6&.,+!68/.*=8.*6!68-!+-'-?6&.,!9/.?-++o!

!

K.%9$,&-+! vMA! v2A! vTA! v^A! $,0! v]! ?.''-?6&<-'(! -B9/-++-0! $! 0-+&/-! 6.! :*&'0! /-'$6&.,+8&9+! .<-/! $,!

-B6-,0-0!9-/&.0!.;!6&%-@!Q'68.*=8!68-!.*6+&0-!0&/-?6./!+-$/?8!&+!$!/-'$6&<-'(!+8./6N'&<-0!9/.?-++A!68-!

/-'$6&.,+8&9+! 0-<-'.9-0! 4&68! 9.6-,6&$'! ?$,0&0$6-+! ;./! 68-! 9.+&6&.,! /-9./6-0'(! 0-<-'.9! .<-/! %*?8!

'.,=-/! 9-/&.0+@! K.%9$,(! v^! 9/-;-/+! 6.! 4./7+! 4&68! ?$,0&0$6-+! ;./! $! h=..0! $%.*,6! .;! 6&%-l! .,! $!

9/.;-++&.,$'! '-<-'! 6.! =/$+9! $! :-66-/! *,0-/+6$,0&,=! .;! 68-&/! <$'*-+A! ?$9$:&'&6&-+A! $,0! 9.++&:'-!

?.,6/&:*6&.,+@!K.%9$,&-+!vX!$,0!v]!$=/--!68$6!=..0!;$%&'(!?.,,-?6&.,+! 6.! &,0&<&0*$'+!4&68!9/.<-,!

6/$?7!/-?./0+!$/-!+.%-!.;!68-!:-+6!4$(+!6.!-,+*/-!$!?.%;./6$:'-!'-<-'!.;!6/*+6@!_.4-<-/A!68-/-!&+!$!

'&%&6!6.!68-!6/*+6!(.*!?$,!=$&,A!-B9/-++-+!?.%9$,(!vTR+!D/-+&0-,6"!hP8-/-!&+!.,'(!+.!%*?8!6/*+6!6.!:-!

=$&,-0!9/&./!6.!$00&,=!68-%!6.!68-!:.$/0G!%*?8!.;!68-!6/*+6! &+!:*&'6!$;6-/!:/&,=&,=!68-%!.,!i6.!68-!

:.$/0k@l!P8-!\&?-!D/-+&0-,6!.;!?.%9$,(!v2!4.*'0!$=/--"!

!

RB'&<$)N4-&C$+,C&3$&1$D-&.#-./&+,&;)*+,-**5&.3&*$1-&@$+,3&<$)&`)*3&#.D-&3$&*3$@&

;-+,C&*$%-&[email protected]$4*&.,/&;-&-,34-@4-,-)4*&e&.""-@3&*$1-&),"-43.+,3<A&J-&#.D-&

3$& 4-1-1;-4& 3#.3& 3#-& 4+*M*& $'& "#$$*+,C& 3#-&I4$,C& ;$.4/&1-1;-4& .4-& ,$3& 3#-&

C4-.3-*3&"$,"-4,5&-*@-"+.%%<&I#-,&"[email protected]/&3$&3#-&'+,.,"+.%&4+*M*&$'&*$1-3#+,C&

%+M-&;)*+,-**&-[@.,*+$,AU&

!

).68! ?.%9$,&-+! v2! $,0! va! $66/&:*6-0! +.%-! .;! 68-&/! 6/*+6! &,! 68-! $:&'&6(! .;! 68-! :-,?8%$/7! $,0!

:-8$<&./$'!$++-++%-,6+!6.!9/.<&0-!+.%-!/-$++*/$,?-!68-&/!0-?&+&.,+!$/-!68-!:-+6!68$6!?.*'0!:-!%$0-!

4&68!68-!$<$&'$:'-!&,;./%$6&.,@!C&68!68-!0-+&/-!.;!+.%-!.;!68-!/-+9.,0-,6+!6.!%.<-!68-&/!+-'-?6&.,!

9/.?-++-+!6.!$!;./%$'!;./%$6!.<-/!6&%-A!68-+-!:-,?8%$/7+!%$(!9/.<&0-!$00&6&.,$'!/-+.*/?-+!6.!:..+6!

?.,;&0-,?-!$,0!9.++&:'(!.9-,!*9!=/-$6-/!9.6-,6&$'!?$,0&0$6-!+-'-?6&.,!9..'+!=&<-,!68-!$00-0!'$(-/!.;!

?.%;./6!/-9./6-0'(!9/.<&0-0!:(!68-+-!$'&=,%-,6!6-+6+@!Y$+6'(A!64.!/-+9.,0-,6+!dvO!$,0!vXe!-B9/-++-0!

68-&/! 0-+&/-! 6.! +--7! 8&=8N9/.;&'-! &,0&<&0*$'+! 48-,! 9.++&:'-@! Q'68.*=8! 68&+! %$(! 9/.<&0-! /-9*6$:'-!

Page 41: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!TM!

7,.4'-0=-A! 68&+! +6&''!:/&,=+! &,6.!S*-+6&.,! 68-!-'-%-,6!.;! 6/*+6!48-,! &6! ?.%-+! 6.! 68-!*,0-/+6$,0&,=!

$,0! /-+9-?6! 0-%$,0-0! :(! 68-! *,&S*-! -,<&/.,%-,6! .;! $! ;$%&'(! :*+&,-++@! W<-/$''A! 8.4-<-/A! %$,(!

/-+9.,0-,6+! &,0&?$6-0! 68-&/! %$5./&6(! ;$%&'(! .4,-/+8&9! dMLLn! &,! %$,(! ?$+-+e! 9/.<&0-0! $00&6&.,$'!

0-?&+&.,N%$7&,=!9/.6-?6&.,@!Q00&6&.,$''(A!=&<-,!68$6!%.+6!?.%9$,&-+!+--7!$0<&+./(!/.'-+!;./!.*6+&0-!

0&/-?6./+A! 68-! ;&,$'!0-?&+&.,! +6&''! /-+6+!4&68! 68-! ;$%&'(@![<-,! +.A!,*%-/.*+! /-+9.,0-,6+!9.&,6-0!.*6!

68$6!68&+!$66&6*0-!?$,!-,?.*,6-/!68&,!&?-!$,0!%*+6!:-!8$,0'-0!?$/-;*''(A!$+!&=,./&,=!.*6+&0-/!0&/-?6./!

/-?.%%-,0$6&.,+!$,0!+*==-+6&.,+!%$(!'-$0!6.!$!;--'&,=!.;!&+.'$6&.,!$,0!-<-,6*$'!/-+&=,$6&.,!.;!68-!

&,0-9-,0-,6!0&/-?6./@!

!

C8-,!&6!?.%-+!6.!?$,0&0$6-!?.%9-6-,?(!<-/+*+!9-/+.,$'&6(!9/-;-/-,?-+A!68-!/-+9.,+-+!4-/-!5*+6!$+!

0-?./$6-0!$,0!0&<-/+-@!_.4-<-/A!$,!.<-/$''!=-,-/$'!?.,+-,+*+!9/-<$&'-0!y!68-!0&+6&,?6&.,A!68.*=8!,.6!

$'4$(+! ?'-$/! $6! 6&%-+A! +6-%+! ;/.%! 68-&/! /-+9-?6&<-! +-$/?8! $,0! +-'-?6&.,! 9/.?-0*/-+@! _$';! .;! 68-!

/-+9.,0-,6+! &,0&?$6-0! 68-&/! 0-+&/-+! ;./! &,0-9-,0-,6!%-%:-/+! 68$6! ?8$''-,=-! 68-! ;$%&'(! $,0! K[WA!

+.%-.,-!+6/.,=!-,.*=8!6.!9*+8!:$?7!.,!:.$/0!$?6&.,+A!4$,6+A!$,0!0-+&/-+@!h3!4$,6!&,0&<&0*$'+!68$6!

4&''!9*+8!:$?7!.,!9/.9.+-0!0-?&+&.,+!y!+.%-.,-!6.!+$(A!hC8(!68-!8-?7!4.*'0!(.*!4$,6!6.!0.!68$6ol!

d?.%9$,(! v]e@! K.%9$,&-+! vTA! v^A! vaA! $,0! v]! +8(! $4$(! ;/.%!9-/+.,$'! ,-64./7+! $,0! ?'.+-! ;/&-,0+A!

48&'-!?.%9$,(!vMR+!K[W!&,0&?$6-+!$!9/-;-/-,?-!;./!&,0&<&0*$'+!68$6!4&''!8.'0!8&%!6.!$!8&=8-/!+6$,0$/0!

$,0! +-6! $! =..0! -B$%9'-! ;./! .68-/+@! C8&'-! 68-! ;$%&'(! -B-?*6&<-! ;/.%! ?.%9$,(! vX! ?'$&%+! 68$6!

9-/+.,$'&6(!6/$&6+!$/-!5*+6!$+!&%9./6$,6!$+!S*$'&;&?$6&.,+!+&,?-!68-!:.$/0!%*+6!:-!$:'-!6.!;*,?6&.,!$+!

$,! -;;-?6&<-A! /-+9-?6;*'A! $,0! ?.8-+&<-! 6-$%A! 68-! &,6-/<&-4--! &+! S*&?7! 6.! ,.6-! h68-! ?$,0&0$6-!%*+6!

8$<-!$!9/.<-,!6/$?7!/-?./0A!9'$&,!$,0!+&%9'-@l!Q00&6&.,$''(A!?.%9$,(!v^!$0%&66-0!6.!$!'$?7!.;!;./%$'!

9/.?-++-+!;./!?'-$/!+-9$/$6&.,"!hW*/!%&,0+-6!&,!48&?8!68-!?$,0&0$6-!+-$/?8!&+!?.,0*?6-0!8$+!9/.<-,!

4-''! 68*+! ;$/l@! 3,! 9/-0&?6$:'-! ;$+8&.,A! ?.%9$,&-+! v2! $,0! va! 0-;-,0-0! 68-&/! ;./%$'! 9/.?-++-+! .;!

0-<-'.9&,=! $,0! :-,?8%$/7&,=! $=$&,+6! 9/-N0-6-/%&,-0! 7-(! $??.*,6$:&'&6&-+! $,0! 0-;&,-0! +7&''+-6+@!

\-/&;(&,=! 68-! ,--0+! .;! 68-! ?.%9$,(! :(! ;&/+6! +-'-?6&,=! $/-$+! .;! -B9-/6&+-! +.*=86! 9/&./! 6.! $,(!

?.,<-/+$6&.,+! 4&68! 9$/6&?*'$/! ?$,0&0$6-+! $''.4+! ;./! $! +.'&0! 0&<&+&.,! :-64--,! ?.%9-6-,?(! $,0!

9-/+.,$'&6(!9/-;-/-,?-+@!!

!

Q'68.*=8!,-&68-/! 68-! ;./%$'!,./! 68-! &,;./%$'!9/.?-++!0-+?/&96&.,+!4-/-!0-6-/%&,-0!6.!:-!%./-!./!

'-++! -;;-?6&<-! 68$,! 68-! .68-/A! 68-/-! $/-! ?'-$/'(! 64.! 9-/+9-?6&<-+! ;./! /-$?8&,=! 68-! +$%-! =.$'@!

K.%9$,&-+!4&68! &,;./%$'! 9/.?-++-+! 9-/+9&?*.*+'(! 0&+6&,=*&+8! :-64--,! 68-! 64.! $66/&:*6-+! 68/.*=8!

%./-!.;!$!h48$6!;--'+!/&=86l!$66&6*0-A!48&'-!68-!64.!?.%9$,&-+!9.++-++&,=!;./%$'!9/.?-0*/-+!8$<-!

%./-!+(+6-%$6&?!9/.?-++-+!&,!9'$?-@!Q??./0&,=!6.!68-!/-+9.,0-,6+A!68-&/!/-+9-?6&<-!9/.?-++-+!$99-$/!

6.!+-/<-! 68-%!4-''! 68*+! ;$/@!_.4-<-/A! 68-!K[W!.;!?.%9$,(!vM!?$*6&.,+A!hC-!0.,R6!7,.4!48$6!4-!

0.,R6!7,.4@l!

Page 42: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!T2!

!

Q!=/$98&?$'!+*%%$/(!.;!68-!&,;./%$6&.,!9/-+-,6-0!&,!68&+!+-?6&.,!?$,!:-!<&-4-0!&,!'+C)4-&8>&$6!68-!

?.,?'*+&.,!.;!68-!;.''.4&,=!+-?6&.,@!

>"9"9$%(.&)$40.-(2/1&3(0.-$<1(01$30$4&.2(2&3/$-/)/43(0.$

3,! $,! $66-%96! 6.! 0&+?.<-/! +.%-! ;&,$'! 0-6$&'+! /-=$/0&,=! ?$,0&0$6-! +-'-?6&.,A! $! ;-4! S*-+6&.,+! 4-/-!

&,6/.0*?-0@!P8-!68/--!/-%$&,&,=!S*-+6&.,+!9/-+-,6-0!6.!68-!&,6-/<&-4--+!4&68!/-+*'6+!0&+?*++-0!8-/-!

$/-!$+!;.''.4+"!

!

M@ 36! &+! +*==-+6-0! 68$6! ?$,0&0$6-+!%*+6!%-,0!4-''! 4&68! 68-! -68&?+! $,0! .<-/$''! ./=$,&>$6&.,$'!

+6/*?6*/-!.;!68-!:*+&,-++@!_.4!&+!68&+!0-6-/%&,-0!0*/&,=!68-!+-'-?6&.,!9/.?-++o!

2@ C8-,! &6! ?.%-+! 6.! ;&,$'! +-'-?6&.,!.;! ?$,0&0$6-+A!8.4! &%9./6$,6! &+! h9/&./!:.$/0!-B9-/&-,?-l!

$,0!8.4!&+!68&+!;$?6./-0!&,6.!68-!0-?&+&.,!9/.?-++o!

O@ C8-,! &6! ?.%-+! 6.! ?/.++N?8-?7&,=! ?$,0&0$6-! S*$'&;&?$6&.,+A! 8.4! 0.-+! (.*/! ./=$,&>$6&.,!

=-,-/$''(!9-/;./%!68&+!6$+7o!

!

\-/(! '&66'-! &,;./%$6&.,! &+! $<$&'$:'-! &,! $?$0-%&?! '&6-/$6*/-! 9-/6$&,&,=! 6.! ./=$,&>$6&.,$'! ;&6! 48-,! &6!

?.%-+! 6.! -68&?+! $,0! <$'*-+@! K.,+-S*-,6'(A! &,6-/<&-4--+! 4-/-! $+7-0! 6.! /-<-$'! 68-&/! +-$/?8! 6$?6&?+!

/-=$/0&,=!68&+!&++*-@!Q'68.*=8!68-!/-+9.,+-+!<$/&-0!=/-$6'(A!?.%9$,&-+!vMA!vOA!v^A!$,0!va!0-+?/&:-0!

$,! &,6-,+&<-!64.N4$(!-<$'*$6&.,!9/.?-++!48-/-:(!$!=/-$6!$%.*,6!.;! 6&%-! &+!+9-,6! &,6-/$?6&,=!4&68!

?$,0&0$6-+! -&68-/! 9/&./! 6.! 68-! +-'-?6&.,! 9/.?-++! .,! $! '.,=N6-/%! :$+&+! ./! 0*/&,=! 68-! 9/.?-++! &6+-';!

68/.*=8! %*'6&N0$(! .,N+&6-! <&+&6+A! &,6-/$?6&.,! 4&68! 0&/-?6./+A! ;$%&'(A! $,0! +-,&./! %$,$=-%-,6A! $,0!

0&+?*++&.,+! /-=$/0&,=! ?*'6*/-!$,0!<$'*-+@!K.%9$,&-+!v2!$,0!vT! 6..7!$! +8./6-/! $99/.$?8A! +9-,0&,=!

'-++! 6&%-! d=-,-/$''(! 8.*/+A! ,.6! 0$(+e! 0&+?*++&,=! <$'*-+! $,0! ?*'6*/-! 4&68! 9.6-,6&$'! ?$,0&0$6-+! :*6!

$=/--0!68$6! &6!4$+!+6&''!<-/(! &%9./6$,6!;./!68-!6.9&?+!6.!:-!0&+?*++-0!&,!$!%-$,&,=;*'!$,0!&%9$?6&,=!

%$,,-/@!Q00&6&.,$''(A!?.%9$,&-+!v2!$,0!va!0-;-,0-0!68-&/!:-,?8%$/7+!$+!$,!-B6/$!'-<-'!-68&?+!$,0!

<$'*-+!$'&=,%-,6@!K.%9$,(!vX! +&%9'(! /-'&-+!.,!9/-<&.*+'(! +6/.,=! ;$%&'(! 6&-+!$,0! 68.+-! 68$6!8$<-!$!

+6/.,=!;$%&'&$/&6(!4&68!68-&/!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++A!68-!?$66'-!$,0!/$,?8&,=!&,0*+6/(A!./!:.68@!!

!

g.8,!C$/0!d2LMLe!&,0&?$6-+!68-!&%9./6$,?-!.;!h9/&./!:.$/0!-B9-/&-,?-l!4&68!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++!0&/-?6./!

?$,0&0$6-+@!Q+!$! /-+*'6A!-$?8! &,6-/<&-4--!4$+!$+7-0!$:.*6!+*?8!-B9-/&-,?-!$,0!8.4! &6! ;$?6./+! &,6.!

68-&/! ?.%9$,(R+! +-'-?6&.,!9/.?-++@! J*/9/&+&,='(A! /-+*'6+!4-/-!?.,6/$/(! 6.!C$/0R+! ?'$&%+@!K.%9$,&-+!

vM!$,0!vO! &,0&?$6-0!9/&./!:.$/0!-B9-/&-,?-!$+!:-&,=! h,.6! &%9./6$,6!$6!$''l@!K.%9$,&-+!vTA!v^A!vaA!

$,0! v]! &,0&?$6-0! 68$6A! $'68.*=8! &6!%$(! :-! $! ?.,+&0-/$6&.,A! &6! &+! /-$''(! ,.6! .;! $,(! 9$/6&?*'$/! <$'*-@!

K.%9$,(!vX!&,0&?$6-0!-B9-/&-,?-!$+!h,.6!$!:&=!?.,?-/,l!$,0!?.%9$,(!v2!4$+!68-!.,'(!./=$,&>$6&.,!

&,0&?$6&,=!:.$/0!-B9-/&-,?-!$+!+&=,&;&?$,6!6.!68-!0-?&+&.,@!

Page 43: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!TO!

!

Rh4+$4&;$.4/&-[@-4+-,"-&+*&,$3&D-4<&+1@$43.,3A&SD-4.%%5&B&I.,3&.&C$$/&"$,34+;)3$4&

3#.3& "$1-*& I+3#& *$%+/& ;)*+,-**& M,$I%-/C-A& B& /$& ,$3& I.,3& @4$'-**+$,.%& ;$.4/&

1-1;-4*d&B&I.,3&34)-&;)*+,-**&[email protected]+$,&-[@-4+-,"-&e&@-$@%-&T+,&3#-&3#+"M&$'&+3NAU&&&&&

& e&B,3-4D+-I--5&?$1@.,<&fP&

!

3,0--0A! ,-$/'(! $''! /-+9.,0-,6+! &,0&?$6-0! 68$6! 9/&./! :*+&,-++! -B9-/&-,?-! 4$+!%./-! ?/&6&?$'! 6.! 68-&/!

+-'-?6&.,!9/.?-++!68$,!9/&./!:.$/0!-B9-/&-,?-@!E.+6!?.%9$,&-+!$/-!?.,?-/,-0!4&68!?$,0&0$6-+!68$6!

-B-?*6-! +6/.,=!0&+?*++&.,+!:$+-0!.,! 68-&/!:$?7=/.*,0!-B9-/&-,?-!$,0!7,.4'-0=-! /$68-/! 68$,!8.4!

4-''!68-(!&,6-/$?6-0!&,!$!:.$/0!$6%.+98-/-@!Q??./0&,=!6.!&,6-/<&-4--!vMA!-<-,!4&68.*6!9/&./!:.$/0!

-B9-/&-,?-A!&6!&+!$!<-/(!-$+(!$05*+6%-,6!6.!%$7-!;./!,-4!0&/-?6./+@!W,-!68-!.68-/!8$,0A!&,6-/<&-4--!

vX!-B9/-++-0! 68$6! &;! 68-! ?$,0&0$6-!8$+!$! +-/&.*+! '-$0-/+8&9!$,0!-B9-/&-,?-!:$?7=/.*,0A! 68-,! 68-(!

%.+6!'&7-'(!8$<-!9/&./!:.$/0!-B9-/&-,?-A!$,(4$(@!!

!

Y$+6'(A!/-+9.,+-+!4-/-!;&-'0-0!;/.%!-$?8!.;!68-!-&=86!?.%9$,&-+!?.,?-/,&,=!/-=$/0&,=!S*$'&;&?$6&.,!

?/.++N?8-?7+@! Q'68.*=8! -$?8! ?.%9$,(! /-9./6-0! 68-&/! .4,! +6('-! .;! ?.,;&/%&,=! ?$,0&0$6-!

S*$'&;&?$6&.,+A! +&%&'$/&6&-+! 0&0! 9/-<$&'@! [$?8! :*+&,-++! /-9./6-0! $! <$/&-6(! .;! ?/.++N?8-?7&,=!%-68.0+A!

8.4-<-/A! 68-!%.+6! 9/.%&,-,6!%-68.0+! $/-! $+! ;.''.4+"! ,-$/'(! $''! ?.%9$,&-+! +.*/?-0! .9&,&.,+! $,0!

/-;-/-,?-+! ;/.%! 68-&/!.4,!:*+&,-++!,-64./7+A! &,?'*0&,=! &,0&<&0*$'+!4&68&,! 68-! ?$,0&0$6-R+! &,0*+6/(!

68$6! $/-! ;$%&'&$/! 4&68! 68-&/! 4./7! -68&?A! -B9-/&-,?-A! $,0! 9-/+.,$'! $66/&:*6-+@! Q00&6&.,$''(A! 64.!

./=$,&>$6&.,+! dvM!$,0!vXe!9/-;-/! 6.!$66/$?6!4-''N/-+9-?6-0!$,0!8&=8-/N9/.;&'-! &,0&<&0*$'+A!*'6&%$6-'(!

'&%&6&,=!68-!,--0!;./!-B6-,+&<-!?/.++N?8-?7+@!Y$+6'(A!64.!?.%9$,&-+!dv2!$,0!v]e!$'+.!/-'(!8-$<&'(!.,!

/-;-/-,?-+! 9/.<&0-0! :(! 68-! ?$,0&0$6-+! 68-%+-'<-+@! Q'68.*=8! 68-+-! /-+*'6+! $/-! ,.6! ?/&6&?$'! 6.! 68-!

/-+-$/?8!:-&,=!9-/;./%-0A!68-(!0.!9/.<&0-!+'&=86'(!%./-!&,+&=86! &,6.!68-!?.%9'-B!+-'-?6&.,!9/.?-++!

;./!.*6+&0-!:.$/0!%-%:-/+@!

!

Q!=/$98&?$'!+*%%$/(!.;!68-!&,;./%$6&.,!9/-+-,6-0!&,!68&+!+-?6&.,!&,!-<&0-,?-0!&,!'+C)4-&8>@!

!

Page 44: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!TT!

!4&O2%-)JaP)733&$&5+"B)#-B-'$&5+)6%5'-##)'5+#&3-%"$&5+#)

>"C$X0-3L-/)/43(0.$40.-(2/1&3(0.-H$2(1/4301$3/1'-$0=$-/16(4/$&.2$+0&12$/6&),&3(0.-$

Q'68.*=8! 68-! +-'-?6&.,! 9/.?-++! &6+-';! 6-?8,&?$''(! -,0+! .,?-! 68-! &,0-9-,0-,6! 0&/-?6./! 8$+! :--,!

$99/.<-0! $,0! $??-96+! 68-! 9.+&6&.,A! 68-/-! $/-! 64.! $00&6&.,$'! ?.,+&0-/$6&.,+! 9.+6-0! &,! $?$0-%&?!

'&6-/$6*/-! 68$6! 4-/-! -B9'./-0! 4&68&,! 68&+! /-+-$/?8! y! 6-/%+! .;! +-/<&?-! $,0! :.$/0! -<$'*$6&.,+@!!

V-+9.,0-,6+!4-/-!$+7-0!68-!;.''.4&,=!S*-+6&.,+"!

!

M@ H.!6-/%!'&%&6+!<$/(!;./!;$%&'(!$,0!&,0-9-,0-,6!0&/-?6./+o!

2@ C8$6! $/-! 68-! 6-/%! '-,=68+! $,0!8.4!$/-! 68-(!0-6-/%&,-0! ;./! 68-! &,0-9-,0-,6! 0&/-?6./o! 3;!

68-(!0&;;-/!;/.%!68-!;$%&'(A!48(o!

!

733&b5+"B)#-B-'b5+)

'5+#&3-%"b5+#)P/*+6!q K.,+6/*?6!'.,=N6-/%!/-'$p.,+8&9+!q J.'&0!;$%&'(!?.,,-?p.,+!q _&=8!9/.t'-!?$,0&0$6-+A!9/.<-,!6/$?7!/-?./0+!q )-,?8%$/7!$++-++%-,6+!d:-8$<&./$'e!

K.%9-6-,?(!<+@!9-/+.,$'&6(!q 3,0&<&0*$'+!68$6!?8$''-,=-!;$%&'(!$,0!K[W!4$,6+A!$?p.,+!q 3,0&<&0*$'+!68$6!8.'0!K[W!6.!8&=8-/!+6$,0$/0!q J8(!$4$(!;/.%!9-/+.,$'!,-64./7+A!;/&-,0+!q )-,?8%$/7!$=$&,+6!7-(!$??.*,6$:&'&p-+A!0-t,-0!+7&''+-6+!

[68&?+!f!<$'*-+!q 3,6-,+&<-!64.N4$(!-<$'*$p.,!9/.?-++!d'.,=N6-/%e!q 3,6-,+&<-!64.N4$(!-<$'*$p.,!9/.?-++!d+8./6N6-/%e!q )-,?8%$/7+!d-B6/$!u?.%;./6u!'-<-'e!q J6/.,=!;$%&'(!p-+A!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++!;$%&'&$/&6(!

D/&./!:.$/0!-B9-/&-,?-!q K.,+&0-/$p.,A!:*6!,.6!$!6.9!9/&./&6(G!,.!:-,?8%$/7+!q D/&./!:*+&,-++!-B9-/&-,?-!&+!.;!=/-$6-/!&%9./6$,?-!q J-/&.*+!'-$0-/+8&9A!:*+&,-++!-B9-/&-,?-!%$(!$'+.!&,0&?$6-!:.$/0!-B9-/&-,?-!$,(4$(!

K/.++!?8-?7+!q J.*/?-!.9&,&.,+A!/-;-/-,?-+!;/.%!?.%9$,(z+!,-64./7+A!9-.9'-!;$%&'&$/!4&68!?$,0&0$6-!q Qr/$?6!8&=8-/N9/.t'-!?$,0&0$6-+!4&68!/-9*6$p.,!6.!8-'9!'&%&6!S*$'&t?$p.,!?/.++N?8-?7&,=!,--0+!

Page 45: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!T^!

V-+9.,+-+! 4-/-! +9'&6! -<-,'(! 0.4,! 68-! %&00'-! /-=$/0&,=! 68-! -B&+6-,?-! .;! <$/(&,=! 6-/%! '&%&6+! ;./!

;$%&'(!$,0! &,0-9-,0-,6!0&/-?6./+@!)-?$*+-!.;! 68-!4&0-!<$/&$,?-! &,! 6-/%+!$,0! 6-/%! '&%&6+A! 68-(!$/-!

9/-+-,6-0!&,!'+C)4-&88!:(!?.%9$,(!,*%:-/@!P8-/-!$/-!$!;-4!,.6$:'-!?.%%-,6+!/-=$/0&,=!68-!/-+*'6+@!

W68-/! 68$,! 68-! '$?7! .;! 6-/%+! $,0! 6-/%! '&%&6+! ;./! $''! :.$/0! %-%:-/+! 4&68&,! ?.%9$,(! v^A! 68-!

/-%$&,&,=!+-<-,!./=$,&>$6&.,+!4-/-!&,!'&,-!4&68!68-!+*==-+6&.,+!9/-+-,6-0!:(!W+&!d2LLbeA!&,0&?$6&,=!

-&68-/!.,-! (-$/!./! 68/--! (-$/! 6-/%+! ;./!.*6+&0-/+@! )-?$*+-! &,0-9-,0-,6+! $/-!,-4! 6.! ?.%9$,(!v2A!

6-/%+!$/-!?*//-,6'(!.,-!(-$/A!64.!(-$/+A!$,0!68/--!(-$/+!;./!-$?8!.;!68-!68/--!0&/-?6./+!&,!./0-/!;./!

68-!:.$/0!6.!-+6$:'&+8!$!/.6$6&,=!./!+6$==-/-0!.*6+&0-!0&/-?6./!6-/%!-B9&/$6&.,!+?8-0*'-!&,!68-!'.,=N

6-/%@! P-/%+! $/-! '&7-'(! 6.! 6/$,+&6&.,! 6.4$/0! 68/--! (-$/+! $+! ?.%9$,(! v2! -+6$:'&+8-+! 68&+! /.6$6&,=!

;./%$6! +&%&'$/! 6.! ,-$/'(! $''! .68-/! /-+9.,0-,6+@! W,'(! ?.%9$,(! vO! /-9./6-0! 6-/%! '&%&6+! ;./!

&,0-9-,0-,6+A!48&'-!?.%9$,(!vX!-B9'$&,-0!68$6!0&/-?6./!$=-!'&%&6+A!/$68-/!68$,!6-/%!'&%&6+A!/-%$&,!&,!

9'$?-!;./!68-&/!.*6+&0-!:.$/0!%-%:-/+@!

!8506"+.) @-%0)B&0&$#)

,"%.)F5%)&+3-6-+3-+$#)"+3)F"0&B.c)

@-%0#d$-%0)B&0&$#)

&+3-6-+3-+$#)

@-%0#d$-%0)B&0&$#)F"0&B.)

J) UW! O!(/+@!s!,.,-! O!(/+@!s!,.,-!K) Z[J! MA2AO!(/+@!s!,.,-! ,.,-!s!,.,-!W) Z[J! M!(/@!s!^!(/+@! ,.,-!s!,.,-!Y) UW! M!(/@!s!,.,-! M!(/@!s!,.,-!Z) UW! ,.,-!s!,.,-! ,.,-!s!,.,-![) Z[J! O!(/+@!s!,.,-! 2,0!`-,"!,.,-!s!,.,-!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

O/0!`-,"!O!(/+@!s!O!(/+@!]) UW! M!(/@!s!,.,-! M!(/@!s!,.,-!^) Z[J! O!(/+@!s!,.,-! ,.,-!s!,.,-!

4&O2%-)JJP)@-%0#)"+3)$-%0)B&0&$#)!P-/%+!;./!;$%&'(!0&/-?6./+!/$,=-0!;/.%!,.,-!6.!68/--!(-$/+!4&68!.,'(!.,-!?.%9$,(!&,0&?$6&,=!6-/%!

'&%&6+! ;./! ;$%&'(@! [$?8! .;! 68-! ;.*/! ?.%9$,&-+! 4&68.*6! 6-/%+! $,0! 6-/%! '&%&6+! ;./! ;$%&'(! %-%:-/+!

&,0&?$6-0! 68$6! 0&+?*++&.,+! $/-! ?*//-,6'(! 6$7&,=! 9'$?-! 6.! -+6$:'&+8! +*?8! '&%&6+! ;./! 68-! ;$%&'(@!!

V-+9.,0-,6+!.;;-/-0!;-4!-B9'$,$6&.,+!;./!68-!<$/&-0!;$%&'(!6-/%+!$,0!'$?7!.;!6-/%!'&%&6+@!!K.%9$,(!

v2!-B9'$&,-0!68$6!&,6/.0*?&,=!&,0-9-,0-,6!0&/-?6./+!$,0!-+6$:'&+8&,=!6-/%!'&%&6+!;./!;$%&'(!%-%:-/+!

4$+!6..!0&+/*96&<-!6.!0.!+&%*'6$,-.*+'(@!!

!

Y$+6'(A! -$?8! .;! 68-! -&=86! &,6-/<&-4--+! 4$+! $+7-0! S*-+6&.,+! /-=$/0&,=! :.$/0! 9-/;./%$,?-! $,0!

-<$'*$6&.,@!P8-!S*-+6&.,+!4-/-!$+!;.''.4+"!

!

Page 46: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!TX!

M@ _.4!&+!68-!/-'$6&.,+8&9!:-64--,!?.%9$,(!9-/;./%$,?-!$,0!:.$/0!.;!0&/-?6./!9-/;./%$,?-!

0-6-/%&,-0o!!

2@ Q/-!9-/&.0&?!0&/-?6./!-<$'*$6&.,+!$!9$/6!.;!(.*/!?.%9$,(R+!:.$/0!.;!0&/-?6./+o!

!

U.,-!.;!68-!-&=86!/-+9.,0-,6+!&,0&?$6-0!68$6!:.$/0!9-/;./%$,?-!4$+!6&-0!6.!?.%9$,(!9-/;./%$,?-!

0&/-?6'(!?&6&,=!68-!0&;;&?*'6(!.;!+*?8!$!6$+7@!E.+6! &,6-/<&-4--+!%&//./-0!68-!/-+9.,+-!;/.%!?.%9$,(!

vX"!

!

RJ-& #.D-& ,-D-4& 34+-/& 3$& *<*3-1.3+".%%<& 1-.*)4-& 3#-& 4-%.3+$,*#+@& ;-3I--,&

-''-"3+D-,-**&$'&3#-&;$.4/&.,/&@4$'+3.;+%+3<A&6#-4-&.4-&*$&1.,<&3#+,C*&3#.3&.''-"3&

@4$'+3.;+%+3<& +,& .& ;)*+,-**& .,/& +3& ;-"$1-*& D-4<& /+''+")%3& 3$& .334+;)3-& ;$.4/&

@-4'$41.,"-&I+3#&@4$'+3.;+%+3<&$D-4.%%AU&

!

C8-,! $+7-0! $:.*6! :.$/0! -<$'*$6&.,+A! 8.4-<-/A! 68/--! :*+&,-++-+! &,0&?$6-0! 68$6! -<$'*$6&.,+! $/-!

9-/;./%-0@! K.%9$,&-+! vO! $,0! vX! 9-/;./%! -<$'*$6&.,+! <&$! $! ?.%%&66--! 4&68&,! 68-! :.$/0! $,0!

?.%9$,(!v^!+6/*?6*/-+!-<$'*$6&.,+!?'.+-/!6.!$!9--/N.,N9--/!-<$'*$6&.,!$//$,=-%-,6@![<$'*$6&.,+!$/-!

=-,-/$''(!9-/;./%-0!.,!$,!$,,*$'!:$+&+!4&68! 68-!-B?-96&.,!.;! ?.%9$,(!vOA!$+! 68-(!4&''!%.<-! 6.!$!

+-%&N$,,*$'!:$+&+!68&+!(-$/@!K.%9$,(!va!8$+!$'+.!&,0&?$6-0!68$6A!$'68.*=8!:.$/0!-<$'*$6&.,+!$/-!,.6!

9$/6!.;!68-&/!./=$,&>$6&.,A!68-(!4&''!+..,!:-!&%9'-%-,6-0!.,!$,!$,,*$'!:$+&+@!K.%9$,(!v]!&,0&?$6-0!

68$6!:.$/0!-<$'*$6&.,+!$/-! &,!68-!:.$/0!?8$/6-/!:*6!$/-!,.6!?*//-,6'(!:-&,=!9-/;./%-0!0*-!6.!6&%-!

?.,+6/$&,6+@!K.%9$,(!vM!$'+.!$66/&:*6-0!6&%-!?.,+6/$&,6+!6.!68-&/! '$?7!.;!/-=*'$/!:.$/0!-<$'*$6&.,+@!

W<-/$''A!8.4-<-/A!;&/%+!vMA!v2A!$,0!vT!&,0&?$6-0!68$6!68-&/!/-+9-?6&<-!:.$/0+!8$<-!:--,!&,!0&+?*++&.,+!

/-=$/0&,=! -<$'*$6&.,! &%9'-%-,6$6&.,! &,! 68-! ;*6*/-@! #*/68-/%./-A! 8$';! .;! 68-! /-+9.,0-,6+! $/-!

?*//-,6'(!?.,0*?6&,=A!./!9'$,!6.!&%9'-%-,6A!:.$/0!-<$'*$6&.,+!.,!$!/-=*'$/!:$+&+@!

!

R6#-4-& .4-& C-,-4.%%<& ,$& T0)4-M.gN& +/-.*& '4$1& 3#-& ;$.4/5& ;)3& +3& a+,/-@-,/-,3&

;$.4/b& "#.%%-,C-*& 1.,.C-1-,3& 3$& [email protected]& .3& 1)"#& #+C#-4& %-D-%*A& 6#-<& .4-&

+,D.%).;%-&4-*$)4"-*&$'&3+1-&.,/&1$,-<&e&1$4-&*$&3#-&3+1-&e&;)3&3#-&@.<;."M&+*&

+,-D+3.;%<&C4-.3AU&&&&e&B,3-4D+-I--5&?$1@.,<&f8&

!

`&<-,!68$6!68-!/-+9.,0-,6+!$=/--0!68$6!&6!'&7-'(!&+!,.6!$99/.9/&$6-!6.!0&/-?6'(!6&-!:.$/0!9-/;./%$,?-!

6.! ;&,$,?&$'! 9-/;./%$,?-! .;! 68-! ?.%9$,(A! -$?8! 4$+! $+7-0! 6.! 0-+?/&:-A! &,! 6-/%+! .;! .<-/$''! <$'*-!

?/-$6&.,A! 68-! -;;-?6&<-,-++! .;! 68-&/! :.$/0+! 0*-! 6.! 68-! $00&6&.,! .;! &,0-9-,0-,6! :.$/0! %-%:-/+@!

Q'68.*=8! $''! &,0&<&0*$'+! .;;-/-0! $! +'&=86! <$/&$6&.,! .;! 68-! +$%-! /-+9.,+-A! -<-/(! /-+9.,0-,6! 4$+! &,!

.<-/48-'%&,=! $=/--%-,6! 68$6! -$?8! .;! 68-&/! /-+9-?6&<-! :.$/0+! .;! 0&/-?6./+! d$,0! +*:+-S*-,6!

Page 47: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!Ta!

./=$,&>$6&.,+e! &+! *,0.*:6-0'(! %./-! -;;-?6&<-! +&,?-! &,+6&6*6&,=! 68-! ?.,?-96! .;! &,0-9-,0-,6! :.$/0!

%-%:-/+@!!

>"U$N(-4,--(0.$

P8-!/-+-$/?8!9/-+-,6-0!$:.<-!4$+!$&%-0!$6!0-6-/%&,&,=!R3#-&")44-,3&@4$"-**-*&;<&I#+"#&1-/+)1&3$&

%.4C-&@4+D.3-%<i$I,-/& '.1+%<& ;)*+,-**-*& *-%-"3& -[3-4,.%5& ,$,i'.1+%<& ;$.4/&1-1;-4*UA! 3,! $00&6&.,A! $!

+-/&-+! .;! +*:! S*-+6&.,+! 4$+! 9/-+-,6-0! 6.! 8-'9! =*&0-! 68-! /-+-$/?8! &,! 68-! $99/.9/&$6-! 0&/-?6&.,@!

#.''.4&,=! 9/-+-,6$6&.,! .;! 68&+! +6*0(R+! /-+*'6+A! $! ,*%:-/! .;! &%9./6$,6! /-'$6&.,+8&9+!4&68! $?$0-%&?!

'&6-/$6*/-!$/&+-@!

!

P8-!9/.%&,-,6!/.'-+!.;!:.68!$=-,?(!68-./(!$,0!+6-4$/0+8&9!68-./(!4&68!/-+9-?6!6.!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++!

:.$/0+!8$<-!:--,!+6/-++-0!:(!$!,*%:-/!.;!$?$0-%&?!+?8.'$/+!dK./:-66$!f!J$'<$6.A!2LLTG!g.8$,,&++.,!

f! _*+-A! 2LLLG! W+&A! 2LLbe@! P8-! /-+*'6+! .;! 68&+! +6*0(! 9/.<&0-! +*99./6A! $6! '-$+6! &,! 9$/6A! ;./! 68-+-!

9.6-,6&$''(! &,;'*-,6&$'! 68-./-6&?$'! -;;-?6+@!Q+!,.6-0!9/-<&.*+'(A! 68-./(! +6$6-+! 68$6!:.68! &,6-/,$'! $,0!

-B6-/,$'! ;./?-+! %$(! -<.'<-! $%.,=+6! 68-! ;$%&'(! :*+&,-++A! =-,-/$6&,=! 9/-++*/-+! ;/.%! $! ,*%:-/! .;!

+.*/?-+!;./!68-!&,?'*+&.,!.;!.*6+&0-!:.$/0!%-%:-/+!.,!;$%&'(!:.$/0+!d)$%%-,+!-6!$'@A!2LMLG!_*+-A!

2LLLe@! J&=,&;&?$,6! &,6-/,$'! 9/-++*/-!4$+! 9/-<$'-,6! &,! $! ,*%:-/! .;! ?&/?*%+6$,?-+A! &,?'*0&,="! ;$%&'(!

%-%:-/! ?.,?-/,+! .;! ?.,6/.'! '.++A! '.++! .;! 0&<&0-,0! &,?.%-A! $,0! ;-$/! .;! 0&+/-+9-?6! 6.! 9/-<&.*+!

=-,-/$6&.,$'!0-?&+&.,+@![$?8!.;! 68-+-!./=$,&>$6&.,R+!.4,!-B9-/&-,?-+!4&68! ;$%&'(!9*+8:$?7!$/-!,.6!

+*/9/&+&,=A!8.4-<-/A!$+! 68-(!?.,;&/%!?'$++&?!$66/&:*6-+!.;!$=-,?(!68-./(!:-64--,!0-?&+&.,+! ;./!h68-!

=..0!.;!68-!;$%&'(l!$,0!h68-!=..0!.;!68-!:*+&,-++l!$+!4-''!$+!$?$0-%&?!'&6-/$6*/-!0&+?*++&,=!9.6-,6&$'!

;$%&'(! ;-$/+! /-=$/0&,=! '.++!.;! ?.,6/.'@! [B6-/,$'! ;./?-+A!8.4-<-/A!4-/-! <&/6*$''(!,.,N-B&+6-,6@! P8&+! &+!

,.6! $,! -,6&/-'(! +*/9/&+&,=! 0&+?.<-/(! 48-,! ?.,+&0-/&,=! 68-! +9-?&;&?+! .;! 68-! +$%9'-! +&>-@! Q?$0-%&?!

'&6-/$6*/-! 9.&,6+! 6.! -B6-/,$'! 9/-++*/-+! :-&,=! $! 0/&<&,=! ;./?-! :-8&,0! +*9-/<&+./(s.<-/+&=86! :.$/0+@!

W,'(!64.!.;!68-!-&=86!;$%&'(!./=$,&>$6&.,+!?.,+&0-/-0!68-&/!&,0-9-,0-,6!%-%:-/+!6.!+-/<-!&,!/.'-+!.;!

.<-/+&=86@! K.%9$,(! vM! :-=$,! 6$/=-6&,=! .*6+&0-/+! ;./! $0<&+./(! ;*,?6&.,+! :-;./-! =/$0*$''(! %.<&,=!

6.4$/0!.<-/+&=86!&,!$,!-;;./6!6.!%--6!68-!9-/+.,$'!=.$'+!.;!68-!K[W!;./!$,!&,0-9-,0-,6!+*9-/<&+./(!

:.$/0@!Q00&6&.,$''(A!$'68.*=8!?.%9$,(!vX!+-$/?8-+!;./!.*6+&0-!%-%:-/+!;./!.<-/+&=86!/.'-+!$+!4-''A!

+*?8! ?.,;&=*/$6&.,! 8$+! :--,! $! 9$/6! .;! 68-&/! ;$%&'(! :*+&,-++! ?*'6*/-! ;./! (-$/+! 68/.*=8! 9/-<&.*+!

:*+&,-++!<-,6*/-+@!

!

Q00&6&.,$''(A!68-!%.6&<$6&.,+!$,0!&,&6&$'!0-+&/-+!:-8&,0!&,0-9-,0-,6!0&/-?6./+!?$,!:-!'&,7-0!0&/-?6'(!

6.! +6-4$/0+8&9! 68-./(@! C&68! $! ,*%:-/! .;! /-+9.,0-,6+! /-9./6&,=! 68-! ,--0! ;./! ;/-+8! &0-$+A! ,-4!

9-/+9-?6&<-+A! $,0! %./-! .:5-?6&<-! <&-4+A! 68-! /-+.*/?-! 68-./(! '&,7! :-?.%-+! ?'-$/@! Q00&6&.,$''(A!

&,6-/<&-4--+! ,.6-0! 68-! ,--0! 6.! ;&''! -B9-/&-,?-! =$9+! /-'$6-0! 6.! +*??-++&.,! 9'$,,&,=! $+! :*+&,-++!

Page 48: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!T]!

?.%9'-B&6(! -B9$,0+@! P8&+! 9$/6&?*'$/! /-+.*/?-! ,--0! &+! 64.N;.'0! 48-,! ?.%9$/-0! 4&68! $?$0-%&?!

'&6-/$6*/-@!W,!68-!.,-!8$,0A!&6!%&//./+!$?$0-%&?!+?8.'$/+!0-+?/&:&,=!$!,--0!;./!.*6+&0-!0&/-?6./+!6.!;&''!

?.%9-6-,?(! $,0!-B9-/6&+-! =$9+! &,! 68-! ;$%&'(! :*+&,-++! d)$%%-,+!-6! $'@A! 2LMLG! K./:-66$!f! J$'<$6.A!

2LLTG!C$/0A!2LMLeA!9$/6&?*'$/'(!4&68!+*??-++&.,!9'$,,&,=!dC$/0A!2LMLe@!W,!68-!.68-/!8$,0A!$!0&/-?6!

'&,7! 6.! $=-,?(! 68-./(! $,0! +6$7-8.'0-/! 68-./(! ?$,! :-! 0/$4,A! $+! +*??-++&.,! 9'$,,&,=! ;/.%! $,!

&,0-9-,0-,6!68&/0!9$/6(!%$(!8-'9!-'&%&,$6-!;$%&'(!%-%:-/!:&$+!$,0!+*??-++&.,!?.,;'&?6+!dY$,-!-6!$'@A!

2LLXG!W+&A!2LLbe!48&'-!9/.%.6&,=!68-!&,6-/-+6+!.;!$''!+6$7-8.'0-/+!d)$%%-,+!-6!$'@A!2LMLe@!

!

J?8.'$/+! Y$,-! -6! $'@! d2LLXe! $,0! C$/0! d2LMLe! %-,6&.,! 68-! 9-/?-&<-0! &%9./6$,?-! .;! 68-! :$'$,?-!

:-64--,!$0<&+./(!$,0!+*9-/<&+./(!/.'-+!.,!68-!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++!:.$/0A!-++-,6&$''(!+*==-+6&,=!$!+6/.,=!

?.%:&,-0! &,;'*-,?-! .;! :.68! $=-,?(! 68-./(! $,0! +6-4$/0+8&9! 68-./(@! P8-! /-+*'6+! .;! 68&+! /-+-$/?8!

+*99./6!68&+!$?$0-%&?!?'$&%@!P8-!+6*0(!/-<-$'-0!68$6!$'68.*=8!$!<$+6!%$5./&6(!.;!/-+9.,0-,6+!d+-<-,!

.;! -&=86e! &,0&?$6-0! $,! &,&6&$'! 0-+&/-! ;./! &,0-9-,0-,6! 0&/-?6./+! &,! $,! h$0<&+./(! .,'(l! ?$9$?&6(A! +.%-!

.<-/+&=86!6$+7+!$/-!+-?.,0$/(!6.!68-&/!/-+9-?6&<-!+6-4$/0+8&9!6$+7+@!Q00&6&.,$''(A!$'68.*=8!.,'(!64.!

./=$,&>$6&.,+! ?*//-,6'(! +--7!.*6+&0-!0&/-?6./+!9/&%$/&'(! ;./!.<-/+&=86! 6$+7+A!%.+6!.;! 68-!:*+&,-++-+!

&,0&?$6-0!$!0-+&/-!6.!%.<-!&,!68&+!0&/-?6&.,!68/.*=8!68-!'.,=N6-/%@!P8-+-!'.9+&0-0!/-+*'6+!+8.*'0!:-!

-B9-?6-0A! 8.4-<-/A! $+! 9/-<&.*+! ?.,?-/,+! $/&+&,=! &,! $?$0-%&?! '&6-/$6*/-! $,0! &,6-/<&-4! /-+9.,+-+!

/-=$/0&,=! ;$%&'(! ?.,6/.'! -B8&:&6! ?'-$/! $99/-8-,+&.,! 6.! /-'&,S*&+8! ?.,6/.'! 6.! .*6+&0-A! ,.,N;$%&'(!

0&/-?6./+@! J6&''A! 68-+-! /-+9.,+-+! 0.! ?.,;&/%! 68-./-6&?$'! '&6-/$6*/-! ;/.%!$! ,*%:-/! .;! +?8.'$/+! ,.6-0!

9/-<&.*+'(! 68$6! ;$%&'(! :*+&,-++! :.$/0+! $/-! '&7-'(! ?.%9.+-0! .;! $! ?.%:&,$6&.,! .;! $0<&+./(! $,0!

+*9-/<&+./(!+7&''+!$,0!.,-!;./%$6!&+!,.6!,-?-++$/&'(!*+-0!-B?'*+&<-'(!.<-/!68-!.68-/@!

!

U.6-4./68(!0-6$&'+!-%-/=-0!;/.%!68-!?.''-?6-0!&,;./%$6&.,!.,!68-!+-'-?6&.,!9/.?-++!&6+-';@!#&/+6A!68-!

9/-+-,6-0! +6-9+! &,! -$?8! .;! 68-! 64.! 9/.?-++-+! /-;'-?6! %$,(! .;! 68-! :-+6! 9/$?6&?-+! $,0! 68-./-6&?$'!

?.,+&0-/$6&.,+! %-,6&.,-0! :(! $?$0-%&?! +?8.'$/+! _*+-! d2LLLe! $,0! C$/0! d2LMLeA! &,?'*0&,=! ;./%$'!

<-/+*+!&,;./%$'!9/.?-++-+A!+-'-?6&,=!?$,0&0$6-+!:$+-0!.,!4-''N0-;&,-0!:*+&,-++!,--0+A!$,0!;.?*+&,=!

.,! .:5-?6&<&6(! +.! $+! 6.! $<.&0! $=-,?(! 9/.:'-%+@! Q00&6&.,$''(A! 68-! 64.! ?.%9$,&-+! .96&,=! ;./! ;./%$'!

9/.?-++-+! $/-! $'+.! 68-! +$%-! =-,-/$6&.,! .;! &,0&<&0*$'+! 4&68! 68-! '-$+6! $%.*,6! .;! -B9-/&-,?-!

?.,?-/,&,=! -B6-/,$'! :.$/0+@! Q'68.*=8! ?.%9$,(! va! /-9./6+! 64-,6(N+&B! (-$/+! .;! -B9-/&-,?-! 4&68!

&,0-9-,0-,6!0&/-?6./+A! 68-! ?*//-,6!.9-/$6&,=!=-,-/$6&.,! &+! /-'$6&<-'(!,-4! 6.! 68-! +-'-?6&.,!9/.?-++@!

P8&+!%$(! +*==-+6! 68$6! ;$%&'(! :*+&,-++-+! '..7&,=! 6.! -$+-! &,6.! 68-! 6/$,+&6&.,! 6.! &,0-9-,0-,6! :.$/0!

%-%:-/+!%$(!4$,6! 6.! ?.,+&0-/! $!%./-! ;./%$'! +-'-?6&.,! 9/.?-++@! P8&+! &+! ,.6! 6.! +$(! 68$6! &,;./%$'!

%-68.0+!$/-! &,?.//-?6A!$+! 68-&/! /-+9-?6&<-!*+-/+!8$<-! /-9./6-0!=/-$6! +*??-++@!_.4-<-/A! 68-! ;./%$'!

9/.?-++-+! %$(! 9/.<&0-! ;./! =/-$6-/! $++*/$,?-! $,0! ?.,;&0-,?-! &,! $! 0-6$&'-0! +(+6-%! 4&68! ;-4-/!

$%:&=*&6&-+@! Q00&6&.,$''(A! 68-! &,;./%$'! 9/.?-++-+! .;6-,! 0.! ,.6! 9/.<&0-! ?'-$/! :.*,0$/&-+! :-64--,!

Page 49: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!Tb!

.:5-?6&<-! <&-4+! $,0! +*:5-?6&<-! 9/-;-/-,?-+! &,! 68-! +-'-?6&.,! 9/.?-++A! $! ?.,?-/,! -?8.-0! $%.,=! 68-!

$?$0-%&?!?.%%*,&6(!d)$%%-,+!-6!$'@A!2LMLG!Y$,-!-6!$'@A!2LLXG!W+&A!2LLbG!C$/0A!2LMLe@! 36!+6$,0+!6.!

/-$+.,!68$6!68-!;./%$'!$99/.$?8!4&68!.:5-?6&<-!$++-++%-,6+!%$(!9/.<&0-!$!%./-!+.*,0!;.*,0$6&.,!

;./! '-++!-B9-/&-,?-0!$,0!8-+&6$,6! ;$%&'(!:*+&,-++-+@! 36! +8.*'0!:-! +6/-++-0! 68$6!S*-+6&.,+! /-=$/0&,=!

68-!&,&6&$'!+-$/?8!9/.?-++!4-/-!$'+.!&,6-,0-0!6.!0-6-/%&,-!48-68-/!+-9$/$6-!9/.?-0*/-+!-B&+6-0!;./!

+6-4$/0+8&9! $,0! .<-/+&=86! 9.+&6&.,+! d!);& _)-*3+$,=e@! _.4-<-/A! 68-! ;-4! ?.%9$,&-+! *+&,=!

&,0-9-,0-,6! %-%:-/+! &,! .<-/+&=86! 9.+&6&.,+! 0&0! ,.6! $99-$/! 6.! 9/.<&0-! 0/$+6&?$''(! 0&;;-/-,6!

0-+?/&96&.,+! .,! 68&+! 6.9&?@! )-(.,0! 68-! :$+&?! S*$'&;&?$6&.,+! $,0! 0&/-?6./! $??.*,6$:&'&6&-+! 68$6! 4-/-!

0-;&,-0!&,!68-!+-$/?8A!68-!.<-/$''!+-$/?8!9/.?-++-+!/-%$&,-0!*,?8$,=-0@&

!

36! &+! <&6$'! 6.! /-?.=,&>-! 68$6! $?$0-%&?! '&6-/$6*/-! 0.-+! ,.6! (-6! $99-$/! 6.! ?.<-/! $''! $+9-?6+! .;! 68-!

+-'-?6&.,!9/.?-++@!P8&+!:.0-+!-+9-?&$''(!6/*-!;./!68-!9./6&.,+!.;!68&+!+6*0(!9-/6$&,&,=!6.!hQ00&6&.,$'!

+-'-?6&.,! ?.,+&0-/$6&.,+l! d'+C)4-& 8>Q& $+!4-''! $+! :.$/0! -<$'*$6&.,+! $,0! 9-/;./%$,?-@! U-<-/68-'-++A!

68&+! +6*0(! 0.-+! /-<-$'! +.%-! $00&6&.,$'! ;&,0&,=+! 68$6! ?.,6/&:*6-! 6.! ?*//-,6! '&6-/$6*/-@! W;! 9$/6&?*'$/!

&,6-/-+6! $/-! 68-! /-+9.,+-+! /-'$6&,=! 6.! $,! .:<&.*+! 0&<&+&.,! :-64--,! ?.%9-6-,?(! $,0! 9-/+.,$'&6(!

9/-;-/-,?-+@! Q''! .;! 68-! /-+9.,0-,6+! &,0&?$6-0A! $6!%&,&%*%A! 68-&/! 0-+&/-! 6.! -,+*/-! $! ?'-$/! 0&<&+&.,A!

*'6&%$6-'(!/-;'-?6&,=!?$''+!;/.%!$?$0-%&?!+?8.'$/+!6.!+-'-?6!?$,0&0$6-+!.:5-?6&<&6(@!_.4-<-/A!.,'(!64.!

?.%9$,&-+! ?.*'0! 9/.<&0-! ?.,?/-6-! -<&0-,?-! .;! $,! .:5-?6&<-! 9/.?-++! d:-,?8%$/7! $++-++%-,6+e! ;./!

+-9$/$6&.,! .;! 68-! 64.! $66/&:*6-+@! 3,! 68-! +$%-!%$,,-/! 68$6!C$/0! d2LMLe! 9/.<&0-+! $! +-/&-+! .;! &0-$'!

?.,+&0-/$6&.,+!;./!+-9$/$6&,=!68-!64.!-'-%-,6+A!68-!.68-/!+&B!?.%9$,&-+!$'+.!$99-$/!6.!9/.<&0-!&0-$+!

.,!8.4!68-(!9-/?-&<-!68-%+-'<-+!$,0!68-&/!:.$/0!6.!:-!.:5-?6&<-!68/.*=8.*6!68-!9/.?-++@!_.4-<-/A!

5*+6!$+!$?$0-%&?! '&6-/$6*/-!4$/,+A!$! '$/=-!0-=/--!.;!:&$+!%$(!/-%$&,!$%.,=!-<-,!68.+-! &,0&<&0*$'+!

4&68! 68-! :-+6! .;! .:5-?6&<-! &,6-,+&.,+@! Q+! $! /-+*'6A! 68&+! 9/.%96-0! ;*/68-/! /-+-$/?8! <&$! $,! &,6-/<&-4!

4&68!)/-,6!D$6%.+A!$,!$0<&+./!$,0!;$?&'&6$6./!.;!.:5-?6&<-!:-,?8%$/7!$++-++%-,6+!;./!68-!+-'-?6&.,!.;!

-B6-/,$'!:.$/0!%-%:-/+@!#*/68-/!0-6$&'+!;/.%!68-!&,6-/<&-4!$/-!9/.<&0-0!&,!F@@-,/+[&(\&(-,"#1.4M&

.**-**1-,3*A&

!

[,+*/&,=!$'&=,%-,6!.;!-68&?+! $,0!<$'*-+!:-64--,! 68-! ?$,0&0$6-!$,0! 68-! ?.%9$,(A! $+!4-''! $+!9/&./!

:.$/0!-B9-/&-,?-!$/-!$'+.!.*6'&,-0!&,!$?$0-%&?!'&6-/$6*/-!$+!6.9&?+!.;!?.,+&0-/$6&.,@!Q'68.*=8!68-/-!

&+! <-/(! '&66'-! 68-./-6&?! '&6-/$6*/-! 6.! 6&-! 6.! /-+9.,+-+! /-=$/0&,=! -68&?+! $,0! <$'*-! $'&=,%-,6A! 68-(! 0.!

9/.<&0-!;*/68-/!&,+&=86!&,6.!&,0-9-,0-,6!0&/-?6./!+-'-?6&.,!9/.?-++-+@!P8-+-!0-6$&'+!$99-$/!6.!-B8&:&6!

$!%./-!;./%$'&>-0!9/.?-++!;./!%$,(!.;!68-!?.%9$,&-+!48-,!;$?-0!4&68!$'&=,&,=!-68&?+!$,0!<$'*-+!.;!

68-!?.%9$,(@!P8&+!%$(!/-;'-?6!68-!?'.+-N7,&6!$,0!9/.6-?6&<-!,$6*/-!.;!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++-+!$,0!%$(!:-!

$,! &,8-/-,6! 0-;-,+-! .;! 68-+-! *,&S*-! ./=$,&>$6&.,+! 6.! +8&-'0! $=$&,+6! 0&+/*96&.,+! 6.! ;$%&'(! ?.,6/.'A!

0&+$=/--%-,6+A!$,0!.<-/$''! +8.?7! 6.! 68-!:*+&,-++!$,0! ;$%&'(@!P8-! ;$%&'(!:*+&,-++! &+!*,0.*:6-0'(!$!

Page 50: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!^L!

;/$=&'-!./=$,&>$6&.,!68$6!/-S*&/-+!?$/-;*'!,*/6*/&,=!$'.,=!68-!4$(G!68&+!%$(!:-!.,-!$00&6&.,$'!=*$/0!

$=$&,+6!68/-$6+!6.!+*?8!0-'&?$6-!:*+&,-++!-,<&/.,%-,6+@!!

!

D/&./! :.$/0! -B9-/&-,?-A! .,! 68-! .68-/! 8$,0A! 9/.<&0-0! +.%-! +*/9/&+&,=! /-+*'6+@!C8-,! ?.%9$/-0! 6.!

$?$0-%&?!'&6-/$6*/-A!68-!?.,6/$+6&,=!/-+*'6+!$/-!/$68-/!*,-B9-?6-0!+6$,0&,=!?.,6/$/(!6.!68-!?'$&%+!:(!

C$/0! d2LMLe! 68$6! 9/&./! :.$/0! -B9-/&-,?-! &+! $,! &%9./6$,6! ?.,+&0-/$6&.,! ;./! $,! -;;-?6&<-! :.$/0@!

C8-68-/! 68&+! &+! $! ?$+-! .;! /-$'&6(! +&%9'(! ,.6! 9$/$''-'&,=! 68-./(! ./!48-68-/! ;$%&'(! :.$/0+!4.*'0! :-!

%./-!-;;-?6&<-!;.''.4&,=!$?$0-%&?!+*==-+6&.,+! &+!(-6!6.!:-!0-6-/%&,-0@!_.4-<-/A!?'*-+!%$(!/-+6! &,!

68-! &,&6&$'! 0-+&/-+! 68-! ?.%9$,&-+! &,! 68&+! +6*0(! 8$<-! ;./! .*6+&0-! :.$/0! 0&/-?6./+@! P8-! ./=$,&>$6&.,+!

+--7&,=! .*6+&0-/+! 9/&%$/&'(! ;./! +6-4$/0+8&9! 9*/9.+-+! 8$<-! ?'-$/! =.$'+! .;! /-?/*&6%-,6! ;./! 6$/=-6-0!

:*+&,-++! 7,.4'-0=-! /$68-/! 68$,! 9$/6&?*'$/! :.$/0/..%! +7&''+@! Q'68.*=8! &,6-/<&-4--+! $''*0-0! 6.! 68-!

&0-$! 68$6! &,0-9-,0-,6! %-%:-/+! 4&68! 7-(! :*+&,-++! -B9-/&-,?-! 4.*'0! &,8-/-,6'(! ?/-$6-! $! %./-!

-;;-?6&<-! :.$/0! .;! 0&/-?6./+A! 68&+! 4$+! .,'(! $,! $++*%-0! /-+*'6! .;! 68-! &,&6&$'! &,6-,6&.,! ;./! :*+&,-++N

+9-?&;&?! +7&''+@! [++-,6&$''(A! ;/.%! 68-! 9-/+9-?6&<-! .;! ;$%&'(! ;&/%+A! &6! $99-$/+! 6.! :-! $! ?$*+-! d:*+&,-++!

+7&''+e!$,0!-;;-?6!d-;;&?&-,6!:.$/0!.9-/$6&.,e!$++*%96&.,@!

!

C&68!/-+9-?6!6.!6-/%+!$,0!6-/%!'&%&6+A!-B9'$,$6&.,+!;./!68-! '$?7!.;! ;$%&'(!%-%:-/!6-/%+!$,0!6-/%!

'&%&6+!%$(!/-+6!9$/6'(!&,!$=-,?(!68-./(@!3,+6&''&,=!6-/%!'&%&6$6&.,+!.,!&,0-9-,0-,6!0&/-?6./+!%$(!:-!$,!

-$+&-/!6$+7A!,.6!5*+6!:-?$*+-!&,0-9-,0-,6+!$99-$/!6.!$//&<-!'$6-/!&,!68-!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++!6&%-'&,-A!:*6!

$'+.!:-?$*+-!&,0-9-,0-,6+!$/-!,.6!9$/6!.;!68-!;$%&'(@!C8-,!;$%&'(!%-%:-/+!:-=&,!6.!9'$?-!'&%&6+!.,!

.68-/! ;$%&'(! %-%:-/+A! $':-&6! ?.''-?6&<-'(! 68/.*=8! $! :.$/0! <.6-A! &6! %$(! ?/-$6-! 6-,+-! +&6*$6&.,+!

:-64--,!+*?8!&,0&<&0*$'+@!Q+!$!/-+*'6A!68&+!%$(!-B9'$&,!48(!+.%-!.;!68-!:*+&,-++-+!&,6-/<&-4-0!$/-!

9'$?&,=! '&%&6+! .,! +*:+-S*-,6! =-,-/$6&.,+! ./! $/-! ?*//-,6'(! &,! 6$'7+! /-=$/0&,=! 68-! &++*-@! g*+6! $+! &6! &+!

9/.:$:'(! -$+(! 6.! 9'$?-! '&%&6+! .,! &,0-9-,0-,6!%-%:-/+A! &6!%$(! $'+.! :-! -$+&-/! 6.! 9'$?-! '&%&6+! .,! $!

=-,-/$6&.,! ,.6! (-6! 8-$<&'(! &,<.'<-0! &,! 68-! :*+&,-++! /$68-/! 68$,! '&%&6&,=! ?*//-,6! ;$%&'(! :.$/0!

%-%:-/+@!!

!

Y$+6'(A! 68-! /-+*'6+! &,0&?$6&,=! $! '$?7! .;! ?.,+&+6-,6! :.$/0! -<$'*$6&.,+! $%.,=! /-+9.,0-,6+! $/-! ,.6!

+*/9/&+&,=A!-+9-?&$''(!=&<-,!68-! '.4!9$/6&?&9$6&.,!/$6-!.;!+*?8!$?6&<&6&-+! &,! 68-!$;./-%-,6&.,-0!2LML!

+*/<-(!?.%9'-6-0!.,!:-8$';!.;!C$/0!d2LMLe@!V-+9.,0-,6+!*,$,&%.*+'(!$=/--0A!8.4-<-/A!68$6!6(&,=!

:.$/0!9-/;./%$,?-!6.!?.%9$,(!;&,$,?&$'!9-/;./%$,?-!&+! '&7-'(!,.6!$,!$99/.9/&$6-!?.,,-?6&.,!=&<-,!

68-!<$+6!$%.*,6!.;!;$?6./+!68$6!%*+6!:-!?.,+&0-/-0@!P8-!%$(!8-'9!6.!-B9'$&,!48(!9/-<&.*+!-%9&/&?$'!

+6*0&-+! 8$<-! -,0-0! &,! %&B-0! /-+*'6+! 48-,! $66-%96&,=! 6.! 6&-! :.$/0! 9-/;./%$,?-! 6.! ;&,$,?&$'!

9-/;./%$,?-!d)./.78.<&?8A!D$//&,.A!f!P/$9$,&A!MbbXG!K.'-+!-6!$'@A!2LL]G!_*$,=!-6!$'@A!2LL]e@! !

Page 51: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!^M!

!

ZA)8:/8<*1H:/1)

C"#$50.4),-(0.$

P8&+! +6*0(! +-6! .*6! 6.!0-6-/%&,-! 68-! +-'-?6&.,!9/.?-++!.;! &,0-9-,0-,6!0&/-?6./+! .,! ;$%&'(! :*+&,-++!

:.$/0+!.;!0&/-?6./+@!C8&'-!9/-<&.*+!+6*0&-+!$,0!$?$0-%&?! '&6-/$6*/-!9/.<&0-!$!:/.$0!9-/+9-?6&<-!.,!

68-!6.9&?A!%*?8!.;!68-!/-+-$/?8!;$&'-0!6.!0-'<-!0--9-/!&,6.!68-!$?6*$'!9/.?-++-+!6$7&,=!9'$?-!$%.,=!

;$%&'(!:*+&,-++-+!6.0$(@!Q!,*%:-/!.;!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++!:.$/0!$66/&:*6-+!$/-!0&+?*++-0!&,!68-!'&6-/$6*/-!

/-<&-4A! &,?'*0&,=! $! 0-6$&'-0! -%98$+&+! .,! 68-! &,;'*-,?-+! .;! :.68! $=-,?(! 68-./(! $,0! +6-4$/0+8&9!

68-./(@! #*/68-/%./-A! 68-! /-<&-4! 8&=8'&=86+! $,! $//$(! .;! &,0-9-,0-,6! :.$/0! %-%:-/! ?$,0&0$6-!

?.,+&0-/$6&.,+@! P8/.*=8! $! +-/&-+! .;! &,6-/<&-4+! 4&68! %-0&*%! $,0! '$/=-! ;$%&'(! :*+&,-++! -B-?*6&<-+!

?'.+-!6.!68-&/!/-+9-?6&<-!?.%9$,(R+!&,0-9-,0-,6!0&/-?6./!+-'-?6&.,!9/.?-++A!$00&6&.,$'!&,+&=86+!4-/-!

.:6$&,-0!$,0!$,$'(>-0!$=$&,+6!?*//-,6!'&6-/$6*/-@!

!

P8-!/-+-$/?8!0&+?.<-/-0!64.!=-,-/$'!9$68+!6$7-,!:(!;$%&'(!:.$/0+!.;!0&/-?6./+!0*/&,=!68-&/!+-'-?6&.,!

9/.?-++-+"!&,;./%$'!$,0!;./%$'@&C8&'-!68-!64.!+-'-?6&.,!%-68.0+!8$<-!68-!+$%-!=.$'!.;!+-'-?6&,=!68-!

:-+6!.*6+&0-!0&/-?6./!;./!-$?8!/-+9-?6&<-!?.%9$,(A!68-!%$,,-/!&,!48&?8!-$?8!&+!9-/;./%-0!<$/&-+!&,!$!

;-4!?.,+&0-/$:'-!4$(+@!P8-!&,;./%$'!9$68!$&%+!$6!+-'-?6&,=!?$,0&0$6-+!:$+-0!.,!$<$&'$:'-!,-64./7&,=!

&,;./%$6&.,A! &,6-,+-!64.N4$(!?$,0&0$6-!-,=$=-%-,6!&,6-/<&-4+!$,0!&,N0-968!&,6-/$?6&.,!6.!&,+6&''!$!

+-,+-!.;!?.,;&0-,?-!$,0!6/*+6!&,!+-'-?6&,=!68-!?.//-?6!&,0&<&0*$'+@!P8-!;./%$'!9$68A!.,!68-!.68-/!8$,0A!

;.?*+-+!.,!$!+(+6-%$6&?!$99/.$?8!:$+-0!.,!-+6$:'&+8-0!7-(!:.$/0!%-%:-/!$??.*,6$:&'&6&-+A!0-;&,-0!

+7&''! +-6+A! $,0! :-,?8%$/7! $++-++%-,6+! 0-+&=,-0! 6.! 0-6-/%&,-! ?$,0&0$6-! :-8$<&./$'A! ?*'6*/$'A! $,0!

$66/&:*6-!$'&=,%-,6!6.!68-!+-'-?6&,=!?./9./$6&.,@!C8&'-!,-&68-/!68-!&,;./%$'!,./!68-!;./%$'!9/.?-++!

4$+!0-6-/%&,-0!6.!:-!+*9-/&./!.<-/!68-!.68-/A!-$?8!0&+9'$(+!$,!&,6-/-+6&,=!&,+&=86!&,6.!68-!+-'-?6&.,!

9/.?-++!.;!&,0-9-,0-,6!0&/-?6./+@!

!

#*/68-/%./-A! $00&6&.,$'! $66/&:*6-+! .;! ?$,0&0$6-! +-'-?6&.,! 4-/-! .:6$&,-0! $,0! +*:+-S*-,6'(!

9/-+-,6-0A!&,?'*0&,=!68-!$+9-?6!.;!6/*+6A!-68&?+A!$,0!<$'*-!$'&=,%-,6+!:-64--,!68-!?$,0&0$6-!$,0!68-!

;$%&'(!;&/%A!$+!4-''!$+!-,+*/&,=!$!?'-$/!+-9$/$6&.,!:-64--,!?$,0&0$6-!+-'-?6&.,!:$+-0!.,!?.%9-6-,?(!

$,0!+-'-?6&.,!:$+-0!.,!9-/+.,$'&6(!9/-;-/-,?-+@!Q!,*%:-/!.;!-,'&=86-,&,=!/-+9.,+-+!8-'9-0!?/-$6-!$!

0--9-/! *,0-/+6$,0&,=! .;! +-'-?6&.,! 9/.?-0*/-+!48&'-! $00&,=! <$'*$:'-! 0-6$&'! 6.! 9*:'&+8-0! $?$0-%&?!

'&6-/$6*/-@!C8&'-!/-+9.,+-+!'&,7&,=!9/.?-++!0-?&+&.,+!6.!$?$0-%&?!68-./(!?.,;&/%-0!$,!$99$/-,6!'$?7!

.;! .:5-?6&<&6(! &,! $/-$+! +*?8! $+! +-'-?6&.,! :$+-0! .,! ?.%9-6-,?(! <-/+*+! 9-/+.,$'&6(A! .68-/! /-+9.,+-+!

9/.0*?-0!&,+&=86;*'!&,;./%$6&.,!.,!6/*+6A!-68&?+A!$,0!<$'*-A!$+!4-''!$+!+*/9/&+&,=!/-+*'6+!/-=$/0&,=!68-!

$99$/-,6!'$?7!.;!&%9./6$,?-!9'$?-0!.,!$!?$,0&0$6-R+!9/&./!:.$/0!-B9-/&-,?-@!

Page 52: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!^2!

!

Y$+6'(A! 68&+! +6*0(! -B$%&,-0! 9.+6N+-'-?6&.,! 9/.?-++-+A! &,?'*0&,=! 6-/%! '&%&6+! $,0! :.$/0! -<$'*$6&.,+@!

H*-! 6.! $! '$?7! .;! 0-6$&'-0! $?$0-%&?! /-+-$/?8! .,! 6-/%+! $,0! 6-/%! '&%&6+A! 68&+! /-+-$/?8! -B9.+-+!

$00&6&.,$'! 9$/6&?*'$/+! 6.! +*99./6! $?$0-%&?! '&6-/$6*/-! +*==-+6&.,+! .,! +*?8! $66/&:*6-+@! Q00&6&.,$''(A!

/-+9.,0-,6+! 9/.<&0-0! ,.6-4./68(! $+9-?6+! /-=$/0&,=! :.$/0! -<$'*$6&.,+A! *'6&%$6-'(! ?.,;&/%&,=!

9.+&6&<-!'.,=N6-/%!&,6-,+&.,+!:*6!$0%&66&,=!'&%&6-0!+8./6N6-/%!$?6&.,+!.,!+*?8!$?6&<&6&-+@!!

!

P8-!;.''.4&,=!64.!+-?6&.,+!4&''!-B$%&,-!:.68!68-!&%9'&?$6&.,+!68&+!/-+-$/?8!%$(!8$<-!.,!%$,$=-/&$'!

?.,+&0-/$6&.,+!$+!4-''!$+!'&%&6$6&.,+!.;!68&+!+6*0(!$,0!9.6-,6&$'!0&/-?6&.,+!;./!;*6*/-!/-+-$/?8!.,!68-!

6.9&?!.;!&,0-9-,0-,6!:.$/0!%-%:-/!+-'-?6&.,@!

C"!$Y&.&7/1(&)$('<)(4&3(0.-$

P8&+! /-+-$/?8! -B9.+-+! -'-%-,6+! .;! &,0-9-,0-,6! 0&/-?6./! +-'-?6&.,! 68$6! 8$<-! :--,! 9/-0.%&,$,6'(!

-%:-00-0! 4&68&,! $?$0-%&?! '&6-/$6*/-@! P8-! +6*0(! 9/.<&0-+! $,! .99./6*,&6(! ;./! ?*//-,6! ;$%&'(!

:*+&,-++-+!4&68!&,0-9-,0-,6!0&/-?6./+!6.!/--<$'*$6-!68-&/!+-'-?6&.,!9/.?-++-+!$,0!?.%9$/-!4&68!68-!

9*:'&+8-0!/-+*'6+@!U.6!.,'(!?$,!&6!9/.<&0-!$,!.99./6*,&6(!;./!;$%&'(!:.$/0+!6.!-,8$,?-!68-&/!+-'-?6&.,!

9/.?-++-+!68/.*=8!68-! &%9'-%-,6$6&.,!.;!,-4! &0-$+A!:*6! &6!%$(!$'+.! &,0&?$6-!$/-$+!.;!4-$7,-++!./!

0&+?.,,-?6+! :-64--,! 68-&/! /-+9-?6&<-! %-68.0+! $,0! 68.+-! 9/-+-,6-0! &,! 68&+! 9$9-/@! Q+! :*+&,-++-+!

4./7! 6.! ;&,-N6*,-! 68-&/! +-'-?6&.,! 9/.?-++-+A! %./-! -;;-?6&<-! %-68.0+! %$(! 9/-<$&'A! 9/-+*%$:'(!

/-+*'6&,=!&,!&,0-9-,0-,6!0&/-?6./+!68$6!$/-!:-66-/!$'&=,-0!4&68!68-!<$'*-+A!-68&?+A!$,0!+7&''+!+.*=86!:(!

68-!?./9./$6&.,@!#*/68-/%./-A! 68-!+-'-?6&.,!9/.?-++!?.,+*%-+!$!?.,+&0-/$:'-!$%.*,6!.;! /-+.*/?-+!

&,?'*0&,=!6&%-!$,0!%.,-(@!K8..+&,=!68-!9/.9-/!.*6+&0-!:.$/0!%-%:-/+!&,!68-!%.+6!-;;&?&-,6!%$,,-/!

9.++&:'-! &+! ?/&6&?$'@! )(! =$&,&,=! $! ?'-$/-/! *,0-/+6$,0&,=! .;! -;;-?6&<-! +-'-?6&.,! 9/.?-++-+A! ;$%&'(!

:*+&,-++-+!4&''!8$<-!$00&6&.,$'!/-+.*/?-+!6.!;*/68-/!9/.9-'!68-&/!0-+&/-!;./!.*6+&0-/+!.,!68-&/!:.$/0+!

.;!0&/-?6./+@!

!

Y&7-4&+-A! 68&+! /-+-$/?8! $'+.! 9/-+-,6+! .99./6*,&6&-+! ;./! ;$%&'(! ;&/%+!4&+8&,=! 6.! $66/$?6! &,0-9-,0-,6!

:.$/0!0&/-?6./+!;./!68-!;&/+6!6&%-@!P8-!/-+*'6+!9/-+-,6!64.!9$68+!.;!+-'-?6&.,!9/.?-0*/-+A!&,;./%$'!$,0!

;./%$'A! $,0! &%%-0&$6-'(! .;;-/! .96&.,+! ;./! ,-4?.%-/+! 6.! 68-! ?.,?-96@! D-/;./%&,=! 68-! +-'-?6&.,!

9/.?-++!?.//-?6'(! 68-!;&/+6! 6&%-!%$(!8-'9!$<.&0!+6--9! '-$/,&,=!?*/<-+A!?.+6'(!%&+6$7-+A!$,0!;*%:'-0!

&,<-+6%-,6+!4&68!&,&6&$'!-B6-/,$'!:.$/0!%-%:-/+@!

!

Y$+6'(A! 68-!9/-+-,6$6&.,!.;! $00&6&.,$'! ?.,+&0-/$6&.,+! $+!4-''! $+! $+9-?6+! .;! 9.+6N+-'-?6&.,!%$(!.;;-/!

$00-0!=*&0$,?-!;./!&,0-9-,0-,6!0&/-?6./!?.,+&0-/$6&.,+!$,0!8-'9!6.!.9-,!,-4!0../+!.;!.99./6*,&6(!

68$6!-<-,!68-!%.+6!+-$+.,-0!.;!&,0-9-,0-,6!:.$/0+!%$(!8$<-!.<-/'..7-0@!C8-68-/!$!:*+&,-++!&+!$!

Page 53: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!^O!

<-6-/$,! 6.! .*6+&0-! 0&/-?6./! +-'-?6&.,! ./! ;$?&,=! 68-! &++*-! ;./! 68-! ;&/+6! 6&%-A! ,.! 64.! 9/.?-++-+! $/-!

&0-,6&?$'! $,0! ,.! 9/.?-++! &+! 9-/;-?6@! P8-! 9/-+-,6$6&.,! .;! 68-+-! /-+*'6+!%$(! $?6! $+! $! +*99'-%-,6! 6.!

?*//-,6!$?$0-%&?!'&6-/$6*/-!$,0!+6*0&-+!$,0!9.++&:'(!'-$0!6.!,-4!&0-$+!$,0!?.,+&0-/$6&.,+!;./!;$%&'(!

:*+&,-++!:.$/0+!.;!0&/-?6./+@!

C"9$D('(3&3(0.-$&.2$2(1/43(0.-$=01$=,3,1/$1/-/&148$

Y&%&6$6&.,+! $/-! $! 9$/6! .;! <&/6*$''(! -<-/(! $?$0-%&?! +6*0(! $,0! 68&+! /-+-$/?8! &+! ,.! -B?-96&.,@! P8/--!

'&%&6$6&.,+!$/-!9/-+-,6-0@!

!

#&/+6'(A!68&+!+6*0(!&+!$!?.,<-,&-,?-!+$%9'-!.;!-&=86!;$%&'(N.4,-0!;&/%+@!Q'68.*=8!68-!+$%9'-!+&>-!4$+!

?.%9.+-0!.;!0&<-/+-!&,0*+6/&-+!&,!,*%-/.*+!'.?$6&.,+!$/.*,0!68-!F,&6-0!J6$6-+A!68-!=-,-/$'&>$:&'&6(!

.;! 68-! /-+*'6+! .:6$&,-0! &,! 68&+! /-+-$/?8!%$(!:-! '&%&6-0@! 36! ?$,,.6! ,-?-++$/&'(! :-! $++*%-0! 68$6! 68-!

+-$/?8! 9/.?-++-+! 9/-+-,6-0! $/-! <$'&0! $?/.++! ?.*,6/(! :./0-/+! ./! -<-,! $?/.++! $''! ;$%&'(! :*+&,-++-+@!

K*'6*/$'! 0&;;-/-,?-+A! ?.*,6/(N+9-?&;&?! '$4+A! $,0! .68-/! ?/.++N:.$/0-/! $:,./%$'&6&-+! %$(! ?$*+-!

?.%9'-6-'(!0&;;-/-,6!/-+*'6+@!Q00&6&.,$''(A! &6! &+!9.++&:'-!68$6! &,0*+6/&-+!,.6!/-9/-+-,6-0! &,!68&+!+6*0(!

%$(!?$*+-!0&;;-/-,6!.*6?.%-+A!$+!4-''@!

!

J-?.,0'(A!68-!+$%9'-!+&>-!?.,6$&,+!$!%$5./&6(!.;!4-''N-B9-/&-,?-0!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++-+!4&68!/-+9-?6!6.!

68-&/! &,<.'<-%-,6! 4&68! &,0-9-,0-,6! :.$/0!%-%:-/+@! Q! %./-! :$'$,?-0! +6*0(! .;! -B9-/&-,?-0! $,0!

&,-B9-/&-,?-0! :.$/0+! .;! 0&/-?6./+! 4&68! /-+9-?6! 6.! +-'-?6&,=! &,0-9-,0-,6! :.$/0! %-%:-/+! %$(!

-,?.*/$=-!0&;;-/-,6!/-+*'6+@!

!

P8&/0'(A! $! %$5./&6(! .;! 68-! :.$/0+! &,! 68&+! +6*0(! +--7! &,0-9-,0-,6! %-%:-/+! d9/-0.%&,$,6'(e! ;./!

+6-4$/0+8&9!9*/9.+-+@!W,'(! 64.!.;! 68-! &,6-/<&-4-0!?.%9$,&-+!9.++-++!.<-/+&=86!:.$/0+!$,0! 68.+-!

4-/-!0*-!6.!-&68-/!68-!9-/+.,$'!=.$'+!.;!68-!K[W!./!68-!;$%&'(!?*'6*/-!$,0!-B9-/&-,?-!4&68!.<-/+&=86!

:.$/0+!&,!.68-/!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++!<-,6*/-+@!Q!%./-!:$'$,?-0!+$%9'-!%$(!=-,-/$6-!0&;;-/-,6!/-+*'6+@!

!

Q00&6&.,$''(A!.99./6*,&6&-+!-B&+6!;./!;*/68-/!/-+-$/?8!:-(.,0!48$6!&+!9/-+-,6-0!8-/-@!D/.9.+&6&.,+!;./!

;*/68-/!/-+-$/?8!$/-!$+!;.''.4+"!

!

M@ Q'68.*=8!:.68!&,;./%$'!$,0!;./%$'!+-$/?8!%-68.0+!4-/-!-B9.+-0!&,!68-!/-+*'6+!.;!68&+!9$9-/A!

68-! /-+-$/?8! 0.-+! ,.6! =.! $+! ;$/! $+! 6.! 0-6-/%&,-! 68-! -;;-?6&<-,-++! .;! -&68-/! .,-@! #*6*/-!

+6*0&-+!?.*'0!-B$%&,-!68-!+*??-++!+6-%%&,=!;/.%!-$?8!9/.?-++!6.!0-6-/%&,-!&;!.,-!%-68.0!

/-&,+!+*9-/&./!.<-/!68-!.68-/@!

Page 54: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!^T!

2@ E$,(! .;! 68-! /-+9.,0-,6+! &,0&?$6-0! 68-! 0-+&/-! 6.! %.<-! 68-&/! /-+9-?6&<-! +-'-?6&.,! 9/.?-++!

6.4$/0! =/-$6-/! ;./%$'&6(A! 8.4-<-/A! ,.,-! .;! 68-! &,6-/<&-4--+! 0-+?/&:-0! -B$?6'(! 48$6! 68$6!

%.<-!4.*'0!-,6$&'@! 36!%$(!:-! &,6/&=*&,=!6.!+--!48-68-/!68-+-!+--%&,='(!?$+*$'!h48$6! ;--'+!

/&=86l! $66&6*0-+! %.<-! 6.4$/0! $! %./-! +(+6-%$6&?! $99/.$?8! d+*?8! $+! :-,?8%$/7&,=!

$++-++%-,6+e!$+!68-(!6/$,+&6&.,!6.!%./-!;./%$'!9/.?-0*/-+@!

!

O@ P8-! ?.,?-96! .;! ;./%$'! :-,?8%$/7&,=! $,0! $++-++%-,6+! $99-$/! +.%-48$6! ,-4! 6.! 68-!

:.$/0/..%@!#*/68-/!/-+-$/?8!.,!68-+-!9/.?-++-+!$,0!68-!'-<-'!.;!+*??-++!-,0*/-0!$+!$!/-+*'6!

.;!68-&/!*+-!%$(!:-!&,+&=86;*'@!

!

T@ W<-/$''A!;&,$'!:.$/0!%-%:-/!?.,+&0-/$6&.,+!d-68&?+s<$'*-+A!9/&./!:.$/0!-B9-/&-,?-A!$,0!?/.++N

?8-?7&,=! 6-?8,&S*-+e! $;;./0! $00&6&.,$'! 9$/6&?*'$/+! 4&68&,! $/-$+! 68$6! 8$<-! /$/-'(! :--,!

$00/-++-0!&,!$?$0-%&?!'&6-/$6*/-@!P8&+!&,;./%$6&.,!%$(!$++&+6!&,!.9-,&,=!;*/68-/!&,+&=86+!&,6.!

-$?8!/-+9-?6&<-!$/-$!$,0!%$(!9/.<&0-!;./!$00&6&.,$'!/-+-$/?8!.99./6*,&6&-+@!!

!

^@ Q+!,.6-0! &,! 68-! /-+-$/?8!$:.<-! /-=$/0&,=!:.$/0!-<$'*$6&.,+A! 68-! /-+9.,0-,6+!*,$,&%.*+'(!

$=/--0!68$6!&6!4$+!'&7-'(!,.6!$99/.9/&$6-!6.!6&-!:.$/0!9-/;./%$,?-!0&/-?6'(!6.!68-!/-+9-?6&<-!

?.%9$,(R+!;&,$,?&$'!+*??-++@!Q00&6&.,$'!/-+-$/?8!%-$+*/&,=!$!%*'6&6*0-!.;!.68-/!;$?6./+!%$(!

9/.<-!6.!:-!$!<$'*$:'-!/-+-$/?8!$<-,*-@!

!

P8&+! +6*0(! 9/.<&0-+! $! +.'&0! ;.*,0$6&.,! ;./! /-<-$'&,=! 0-6$&'+! /-=$/0&,=! 68-! +-'-?6&.,! 9/.?-++! .;!

&,0-9-,0-,6!:.$/0!0&/-?6./+!.,!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++!:.$/0+!.;!0&/-?6./+@!K.,+-S*-,6'(A!&6!$'+.!9/.<&0-+!$!

'$*,?8!9$0!;./!$00&6&.,$'!/-+-$/?8!.99./6*,&6&-+!.,!68-!6.9&?!$+!$?$0-%&?!+6*0&-+!?.,6&,*-!6.!9/.9-'!

68-!+*:5-?6!%$66-/!;./4$/0@!

Page 55: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!^^!

[A)G=4=G=/8=1)

Q/.,.;;A! K@! [@A! f!C$/0A! g@! Y@! dMbbXe@! #$%&'(! )*+&,-++! `.<-/,$,?-"!E$B&%&>&,=! #$%&'(! $,0! )*+&,-++!

D.6-,6&$'@!E$/&-66$"!#$%&'(![,6-/9/&+-!D*:'&+8-/+@!

)$%%-,+A!Z@A!\../0-?7-/+A!C@A!f!`&'+A!Q@!\@!d2LL]e@!).$/0+!.;!0&/-?6./+!&,!;$%&'(!;&/%+"!$!=-,-/$6&.,$'!

9-/+9-?6&<-@!!1.%%&()*+,-**&0"$,$1+"*5&Z8A!MXONM]L@!

)$%%-,+A! Z@A! \../0-?7-/+A! C@A! f! `&'+A! Q@! \@! d2LMLe@! ).$/0+! .;! H&/-?6./+! &,! #$%&'(! )*+&,-++-+"! Q!

Y&6-/$6*/-!V-<&-4!$,0!V-+-$/?8!Q=-,0$@! B,3-4,.3+$,.%&j$)4,.%&$'&2.,.C-1-,3&H-D+-I*5&8=A!

MNMb@!

)$/68.'.%-*+>A!J@A!f!P$,-4+7&A!`@!Q@!d2LLXe@!P8-!V-'$6&.,+8&9!:-64--,!#$%&'(!#&/%+!$,0!K./9./$6-!

`.<-/,$,?-@!j$)4,.%&$'&!1.%%&()*+,-**&2.,.C-1-,35&PPd2eA!2T^N2Xa@!

)./.78.<&?8A!I@!Q@A!D$//&,.A!V@A!f!P/$9$,&A!P@!dMbbXe@!W*6+&0-!H&/-?6./+!$,0!K[W!J-'-?6&.,@!j$)4,.%&$'&

:+,.,"+.%&.,/&_).,3+3.3+D-&F,.%<*+*5&Z8dOeA!OOaNO^^@!

)./.78.<&?8A!I@!Q@A!D$//&,.A!V@A!f!P/$9&,&A!P@!dMbbXe@!W*6+&0-!H&/-?6./+!$,0!K[W!J-'-?6&.,@!j$)4,.%&$'&

:B,.,"+.%&.,/&_).,3+3.3+D-&F,.%<*+*5&Z8dOeA!OOaNO^^@!

K.'-+A! g@! Y@A! H$,&-'A! U@! H@A! f! U$<--,A! Y@! d2LL]e@! ).$/0+"! H.-+! .,-! +&>-! ;&6! $''@! j$)4,.%& $'& :+,.,"+.%&

0"$,$1+"*5&^Yd2eA!O2bNO^X@!

K./:-66$A!`@A!f!J$'<$6.A!K@!Q@!d2LLTe@!P8-!).$/0!.;!H&/-?6./+!&,!#$%&'(!#&/%+"!W,-!J&>-!#&6+!Q''o!:.1+%<&

()*+,-**&H-D+-I5&8YA!MMbNMOT@!

H$<&+A!g@!_@A!J?8../%$,A!#@!H@A!f!H.,$'0+.,A!Y@!dMbbae@!P.4$/0!Q!J6-4$/0+8&9!P8-./(!.;!E$,$=-%-,6@!

F"./-1<&$'&2.,.C-1-,3&H-D+-I5&==dMeA!2LNTa@!

H-%:A!Q@A!f!U-*:$*-/A! #@! #@! dMbb2e@!P8-!K./9./$6-!).$/0"!K.,;/.,6&,=! 68-!D$/$0.B-+@!k$,C&H.,C-&

h%.,,+,C5&=9A!bN2L@!

[&+-,8$/06A! I@! E@! dMb]be@! )*&'0&,=! P8-./&-+! ;/.%! K$+-! J6*0(! V-+-$/?8@! F"./-1<& $'& 2.,.C-1-,3&

H-D+-I5&8PdTeA!^O2N^^L@!

#./:-+A!H@!D@A!f!E&''&7-,A!#@!g@!dMbbbe@!K.=,&6&.,!$,0!K./9./$6-!`.<-/,$,?-"!F,0-/+6$,0&,=!).$/0+!.;!

H&/-?6./+!$+!J6/$6-=&?!H-?&+&.,NE$7&,=!`/.*9+@!F"./-1<&$'&2.,.C-1-,3&H-D+-I5&=PdOeA!T]bN

^L^@!

Page 56: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!^X!

`.-'A!Q@!E@A!f!P8$7./A!Q@!\@!d2LL]e@!W<-/?.,;&0-,?-A!K[W!J-'-?6&.,A!$,0!K./9./$6-!`.<-/,$,?-@!6#-&

j$)4,.%&$'&:+,.,"-5&XZdXeA!2aOaN2a]T@!

_.;;%$,A! g@! g@A! J?8,&-0-/5$,+A! E@! g@A! f! J-:./$A! P@! K@! d2LLTe@! Q! E*'6&NW:5-?6&<-! Q99/.$?8! 6.! K[W!

J-'-?6&.,@!B,'$41.3+$,&!<*3-1*&.,/&[email protected]+$,.%&H-*-.4"#5&P=dTeA!2OaN2^^@!

_*$,=A!_@!_@A!_+*A!D@A!I8$,A!_@!Q@A!f!Z*A!Z@!Y@! d2LL]e@!H.-+!68-!Q99.&,6%-,6!.;!$,!W*6+&0-!H&/-?6./!

3,?/-$+-!#&/%!\$'*-o![<&0-,?-! ;/.%!P$&4$,@!01-4C+,C&2.4M-3*&:+,.,"-&V&64./-5&PPdOeA!XXN

]L@!

_*+-A!E@! d2LLLe@!).$/0+!.;!0&/-?6./+! &,!JE[+"!$!/-<&-4!$,0!/-+-$/?8!$=-,0$@!0,34-@4-,-)4*#+@&.,/&

H-C+$,.%&E-D-%$@1-,35&8=A!2aMN2bL@!

_*+-A!E@!d2LLae@!).$/0+A!`.<-/,$,?-!$,0!\$'*-!K/-$6&.,@!K$%:/&0=-"!K$%:/&0=-!F,&<-/+&6(!D/-++@!

g.8$,,&++.,A!)@A!f!_*+-A!E@!d2LLLe@!V-?/*&6&,=!.*6+&0-!:.$/0!%-%:-/+!&,!68-!+%$''!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++"!

$,!&0-.'.=&?$'!?8$''-,=-@!0,34-@4-,-)4*#+@&.,/&H-C+$,.%&E-D-%$@1-,35&8=A!O^ONOa]@!

g*/&,+7&A! g@! g@A! f! m4&?7A! `@! Q@! d2LL2e@! P/$,+;-//&,=! 3,6-/-+6+! &,! 68-! K'.+-'(! _-'0! #$%&'(! )*+&,-++@!

D8&'$0-'98&$"! Q%-/&?$,! Y$4! 3,+6&6*6-NQ%-/&?$,! )$/! Q++.?&$6&.,! K.%%&66--! .,! K.,6&,*&,=!

D/.;-++&.,$'![0*?$6&.,@!

I8*/$,$A! V@! d2LLMe@! #&,0&,=! 68-! V&=86! K[W"! C8(! ).$/0+! W;6-,! E$7-! D../! K8.&?-+@! 2B6& !%$.,&

2.,.C-1-,3&H-D+-I5&PZdMeA!bMNb^@!

Y$,-A! J@A! Q+6/$?8-,A! g@A! I-(6A! Q@A! f! E?E&''$,A! I@! d2LLXe@! `*&0-'&,-+! ;./! #$%&'(! )*+&,-++! ).$/0+! .;!

H&/-?6./+@!:.1+%<&()*+,-**&H-D+-I5&8WA!MTaNMXa@!

E$$++-,A! `@! #@A! f! ).+?8A! #@! Q@! g@! <@! 0@! dMbbbe@! W,! 68-! J*99.+-0! 3,0-9-,0-?-! .;! P4.NP&-/! ).$/0+"!

;./%$'!+6/*?6*/-!$,0!/-$'&6(!&,!68-!U-68-/'$,0+@!?$4@$4.3-&G$D-4,.,"-5&YdMeA!OMNOa@!

E-/-0&68A!g@!dMbb]e@!)*&'0&,=!.9-/$6&.,+!%$,$=-%-,6!68-./(!68/.*=8!?$+-!$,0!;&-'0!/-+-$/?8@!j$)4,.%&

$'&[email protected]+$,*&2.,.C-1-,35&8XA!TTMNT^T@!

E.,7+A!V@!Q@!`@A!f!E&,.4A!U@!d2LL]e@!K./9./$6-!`.<-/,$,?-@!C-+6!J*++-B"!g.8,!C&'-(!f!J.,+A!Y60@!

W+&A! K@! d2LLbe@! #$%&'(! )*+&,-++! `.<-/,$,?-! $,0! 3,0-9-,0-,6! H&/-?6./+"! P8-! K8$''-,=-+! #$?&,=! $,!

3,0-9-,0-,6! #$%&'(! )*+&,-++! ).$/0@! l,+D-4*+3<& $'& h-,,*<%D.,+.& j$)4,.%& $'& ()*+,-**& k.I5&

8=dMeA!M]MN2OO@!

Page 57: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!^a!

D&++$/&+A!J@A!C-&,+6-&,A!E@A!f!J6-98$,A! g@! d2LMLe@!P8-! 3,;'*-,?-!.;!K.=,&6&<-!J&%9'&;&?$6&.,!D/.?-++-+!

.,!68-!K[W!J*??-++&.,!H-?&+&.,@!j$)4,.%&$'&2.,.C-1-,3&H-*-.4"#5&8>d2eA!aMN]X@!

J)Q@! d2LLae@!F@J@! J%$''! )*+&,-++!Q0%&,&+6/$6&.,"! P$:'-!.;! J%$''! )*+&,-++! J&>-! J6$,0$/0+@! 3,"!F,&6-0!

J6$6-+!J%$''!)*+&,-++!Q0%&,&+6/$6&.,@!

J8&<0$+$,&A!Q@A!f!Z-/%$?7A!H@!dMbbbe@!K[W!3,<.'<-%-,6!&,!68-!J-'-?6&.,!.;!U-4!).$/0!E-%:-/+"!Q,!

[%9&/&?$'!Q,$'(+&+@!6#-&j$)4,.%&$'&:+,.,"-5&9Pd^eA!M]2bNM]^O@!

\$,!0-,!)-/=8-A!Y@!Q@!Q@A!f!Y-</$*A!Q@!d2LLTe@![<$'*$6&,=!).$/0+!.;!H&-?6./+"!48$6!?.,+6&6*6-+!$!=..0!

?./9./$6-!:.$/0o!?$4@$4.3-&G$D-4,.,"-\&F,&B,3-4,.3+$,.%&H-D+-I5&8=dTeA!TXMNTa]@!

C$/0A! g@! Y@! d2LMLe@! K/-$6&,=! [;;-?6&<-! ).$/0+! ;./! D/&<$6-! [,6-/9/&+-+@! K8&?$=."! U./684-+6-/,!

F,&<-/+&6(@!

C8--'-,A! P@! Y@A! f! _*,=-/A! g@! H@! d2LMLe@! J6/$6-=&?! E$,$=-%-,6! $,0! )*+&,-++! D.'&?("! Q?8&-<&,=!

J*+6$&,$:&'&6(@!F99-/!J$00'-!V&<-/"!D-$/+.,![0*?$6&.,A!3,?@!

c&$.A! g@!m@A!H$8($A! g@A!f!Y&,A!m@! d2LLTe@!Q!`/.*,0-0!P8-./(![B9.+&6&.,!.;! 68-!V.'-!.;! 68-!J*9-/<&+./(!

).$/0!&,!K8&,$@!(4+3+*#&j$)4,.%&$'&2.,.C-1-,35&89A!ObN^^@!

Z&,A!V@!I@!dMb]be@!K$+-!J6*0(!V-+-$/?8"!H-+&=,!$,0!E-68.0+@!Y.,0.,"!JQ`[@!

Z&,A!V@!I@!d2LLbe@!K$+-!J6*0(!V-+-$/?8"!H-+&=,!$,0!E-68.0+@!P8.*+$,0!W$7+"!JQ`[@!

m$8/$A!J@!Q@A!f!J8$/%$A!D@! d2LLTe@!#$%&'(!)*+&,-++!V-+-$/?8"!Q!J6/$6-=&?!V-;'-?6&.,@!:.1+%<&()*+,-**&

H-D+-I5&8YdTeA!OOMNOTX@!

!

Page 58: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!^]!

7DD=/>HI)7P)1$23.)%-#2B$#)

!"#$%&'()#*+,-".-+#$/"'++0

1+%,0-2345-3&6+$+&6+&40

7%#3/'-"2&+,053$

1")&8+04-"$+,%43&8-8+&+,%43"&

1")&8+04-"2&+,053$-8+&+,%43"&

9++43&80-$+,-'+%,

:"4%/-63,+;4",0<&6+$+&6+&4-63,+;",0

=+,;+&4%8+-".-3&6+$+&6+&4

>//-"2&+,0-034-"&-*"%,6?

@ !"" !" #$% &'( !)( * + , -$% ./

A &$,* 01 1""% !)( *23 * 1" ! !"% ./

B -"$ 1# 1""% *23 ,23 * 11 , $$% ./

C $"" 1$ #"% !)( !)( * # * **% ./

D &$" &$ 1""% !)( $23 1& , ! $"% ./

E $" 1& 1""% !)( *23 * 1" * *"% ./

F !&" 44&,5 #*% !)( *23 * , ! $"% ./

G 1$" + 1""% &'( &'( * , ! $"% ./

>HIJ>KI ,"$ 1!6, #-% ! * $ + * *#%

5789:;<4=>?:'@??4A@'2423)B>C34=):@D4E@):B(4A:23B>24:'(@E@'(@'24=B8)(4(:)@F2B)?G !766-+3&X)4&O2%-)JP)?-+-%"B)F"0&B.)Q2#&+-##)'B"##&F&'"$&5+)!!!"#$%&' (&)*)%+,-./)0. (&*.0&%+1.2*.0&%+,$0.//30. 45.0/)67*,"0,0./"308.,&..- 9"%0-,.2$%&/)"&:

;

!"#$%&'()*++&%(*,*-.(/"$/&'$+("0(+#//&++1"$2(3"#4%$56(%&)&$%("$(0*714-(0"'(+#//&++1"$(88($"6(9&*469-(0"'(:#+1$&++(6"(*++#7&(0*714-(,144(6*;&("<&'2(

="(&>6&'$*4?(1$6&'$*4("$4-(0'"7(+&40(88()&'+"$*44-(,*$6&%(@""%.(+"41%(:#+1$&++(1$)#6(6"(@'",(/"7)*$-2(A1664&(0*714-()'&++#'&(88(,"';&%(,169(*$(*/*%&71$/(+/9"4*'(6"(9&4)(41716(0*714-(/"$/&'$+2

B6*'6&%(,169('&+"#'/&()&'+)&/61<&(C)&+"$*4(@"*4D(69&$(7"<&%(6"("<&'+1@962(="(:*$;&'+.(4*,-&'+.(*$-"$&(&4+&(-"#5'&(*4'&*%-()*-1$@(0"'(*%<1/&2(!1$%("69&'+(69*6(-"#(,"#4%$56("69&',1+&(@&6(*%<1/&(0'"72

E$161*44-(&>)*$%&%("<&'(617&2(=",(01>&%(*6(F2

<

B&&;1$@(%1<&'+101/*61"$.(,*$6&%(6"(:'*$/9(0'"7(/"'&(:#+1$&++(7"'&2(G#1/;4-('&*41H&%(%1<&'+101/*61"$(,*+(*$(&$%(@"*4.($"6(69&(1++#&2(I"*'%(1+(69&(@#1%1$@(6""4("0(:#+1$&++(C*$%(1++#&(*6(9*$%D(8(%&/1%&%(6"(+6*'6(9&'&2

="(&>6&'$*4?(1$6&'$*4(0'"7(+"7&(0*714-(7&7:&'+(0"'("#6+1%&(%1'&/6"'+2(J<&'*44(0*714-(7&7:&'(9&+1+6*61"$(C$"6('&+1+6&$/&D("#6("0('&+)&/6(0"'()'&<1"#+(@&$&'*61"$5+(:"*'%(/"$+6'#/61"$2

K%<1+"'-L'&+"#'/&($&&%2(B17)4-(4"";1$@(0"'(7&7:&'+(69*6(/*$(9&4)(#+(+&&(69&(M:1@@&'M()1/6#'&2(N"++1:4&("<&'+1@96(1$(4"$@8'#$2

E$161*4(:"*'%(&>)*$+1"$(6"(41716(%1+'#)61"$(C12&2(0*714-(7&7:&'(&4171$*61"$D2(O#+6(:&(*(6'*$+161"$()9*+&2

=

P'*$+161"$L+#//&++1"$(1++#&+2(M!'&+9&$(#)M(:"*'%.(@'&*6&'()&'+)&/61<&2(Q1'&%(/"$+#46*$6(6"(9&4)(,169(6'*$+161"$()9*+&?(1$%&)&$%&$6(%1'&/6"'(1%&*(/'"))&%(#)(R#1/;4-2

="(&>6&'$*4?(E$6&'$*4(0'"7(0*714-(7&7:&'+2(3"#+1$+(0&46(&$6164&7&$6(6"(:"*'%(0"44",1$@()*'&$6+2(B"7&(0*714-(/"$/&'$+('&@*'%1$@(%1<1%&$%+(*$%(4"+1$@(/"$6'"42

K%<1+"'-L'&+"#'/&($&&%(C@&$&'*44-D?("$&(1$%&)&$%&$6(%1'&/6"'("<&'+1@96('"4&2(N"++1:4&("<&'+1@96(1$(4"$@8'#$2

E$161*4(&>)*$+1"$2(I"*'%(6"6*4($",(04#/6#*6&+(8(69&('1@96()&")4&(%"$56(*4,*-+(/"7&(*4"$@(*6()&'0&/6(617&(+"(04#/6#*61"$()&'7166&%2(K17(0"'(S(%1'&/6"'+2

>

P1'&%("0(9*<1$@(M+*7&("4%M(:"*'%(7&&61$@+(69*6(%1%$56(@&6(*$-,9&'&2(T&+1'&(0"'(0'&+9(1%&*+.($&,(1$)#6(6"(U#7)+6*'6(:"*'%.(7*;&(16(M+"7&691$@(7"'&M.(6*;&(16(6"(69&(M$&>6(4&<&4M2(V*$6&%(":U&/61<&(<1&,(0'"7()&")4&($"6('&/&1<1$@(*()*-/9&/;(0'"7(69&(/"7)*$-2

="(&>6&'$*4?(B"7&(!"#$%& (1$6&'$*4()'&++#'&+(:-(/"$6'"44&'L6'&*+#'&'(8(%&+1'&(0"'("#6+1%&'(,169(7"'&(":U&/61<&(<1&,

K17(0"'('&+"#'/&($&&%(*$%(6'-(6"(+9-(*,*-(0'"7("<&'+1@96.(69"#@9(+"7&617&+(69&('"4&+(*'&(/"7:1$&%(1$(+"7&(*+)&/6+2(A"";(0"'(1$1%1<1%#*4+(6"()'"<1%&(M:1@()1/6#'&M(<1&,2

E$161*4(:"*'%(&>)*$+1"$2(I"*'%($",(+6*$%+(01'74-(*6(S2

?

3"7)*$-(@'&,(7"'&(/"7)4&>2(A"";1$@(0"'($&,(,*-(6"(4&*%(:#+1$&++2(=&&%&%()&")4&(69*6(/"#4%()'"<1%&((69&(M@""%.(:*%.(#@4-M($&,+(*+(:#+1$&++(&$6&'&%(7*';&6+(,169(7#/9(4*'@&'(/"7)&616"'+2

="(&>6&'$*4?(="(1$6&'$*42(!*714-(#$%&'+6""%($&&%("0("#6+1%&(9&4)2(3"7)*$-(0#44("0(*@@'&++1<&(&$6'&)'&$&#'+(69*6(#$%&'+6*$%('&R#1'&7&$6+(6"(7"<&(:#+1$&++(0"',*'%2

N#'&4-(*+('&+"#'/&($&&%2(="("<&'+1@962

3#''&$64-(4"";(*6(:"*'%(&>)*$+1"$(%#&(6"(+7*44(:"*'%(+1H&2

@

E$%&)&$%&$6(:"*'%(*4,*-+(:&&$()*'6("0(0*714-(/#46#'&(0'"7("69&'(0*714-(:#+1$&++(<&$6#'&+2(B#//&++1"$(1++#&+2(V*$6&%(9&4)(,169(+6'*6&@1/(*$%(+#//&++1"$()4*$$1$@(*$%(7"'&(1$6&$61"$*4(@"<&'$*$/&()'"/&++2

="(&>6&'$*4?(E$6&'$*4()'&++#'&(0'"7(0*714-(/#46#'&(6"(/"$61$#"#+4-(17)'"<&2(!*714-(#$%&'+6""%()'"/&++(0'"7()'1"'(0*714-(<&$6#'&+2(P'*%161"$+(:&/"7&(9*:16+(*$%(%&<&4")(1$6"(/#46#'&+2

N'17*'14-(+&&;(0"'("<&'+1@96(C0*714-(/#46#'&D2(Q1'&(/"$+#46*$6+(C*$%(69&(41;&D(0"'(*%<1/&2(K%<1/&(1+("$4-(+&/"$%*'-(,169("#6+1%&'(%1'&/6"'+2

E$(@&$&'*4.(&>)*$+1"$2(I#6(9*<&($",('&*/9&%(1%&*4(+1H&?(7*-('&%#/&(:-("$&(7&7:&'(1$(0#6#'&2

A

V&$6(69'"#@9()&'1"%("0($"6(6'#4-(;$",1$@(/#''&$6(:#+1$&++2(!*714-(;$&,(:*+1/(")&'*61"$+(:#6($"6(0'"7(M/"')"'*6&M(+6*$%)"1$62(Q1'&%(1$%1<1%#*4(,169(M&>6&'$*4(*%<1/&M(6"(9&4)('&*41@$(/"7)*$-2(V*$6&%(%1'&/6"'+(,169("#6+1%&'()&'+)&/61<&(6"(9&4)('&*41@$(/"7)*$-2

="(&>6&'$*4?(41664&(1$6&'$*4(8(0*714-(#$%&'+6""%(,9*6(9*%(6"(:&(%"$&(6"(/*''-(:#+1$&++(0"',*'%2(!*714-(9*%(&>)&'1&$/&(,169(&>6&'$*4(%1'&/6"'+(1$()*+6(:&0"'&(:"*'%(*@*1$(:&/*7&(1$6&'$*42(K(/"#)4&(-&*'+(*@".(6'*$+161"$(:*/;(6"(1$%&)&$%&$6(%1'&/6"'+(6"";()4*/&2

K%<1+"'-L'&+"#'/&($&&%2I&@*$(*+('&)4*/&7&$6(*$%(7"<&%(6",*'%(&>)*$+1"$2

BB#@@&+6&%(:-(416&'*6#'&(*$%(0*714-(/"$+#46*$62

="(&>6&'$*4("69&'(69*$(0'"7(0*714-(/"$+#46*$6?(J$4-(1$6&'$*4()'&++#'&(,*+(0'"7(+&402(O#/9(0*714-()#+9:*/;2

K%<1+"'-L'&+"#'/&($&&%(C@&$&'*44-D?(69&'&(1+(+"7&("<&'+1@96(69*6(6*;&+()4*/&2

W&$&'*44-('&)4*/&7&$62(E%&*4(+1H&(,"#4%(:&($"(7"'&(69*$(S(1$(69&(0#6#'&2

!766-+3&X)4&O2%-)KP)H+&$&"B)3-#&%-#)!

Page 59: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!^b!

!!"#$%&' ()&)*%+,-)+)./0"&,$*".)-- 1"*#%+20&3"*#%+ 4*0#%*',-)%*.5,#).5%&0-#

6

!""#$%&'"$(")"'*+,$-&+./,$&0"'*++$12-.)"--$#)&3+"/("4"56"'.")7"8$9'":"'$*$0"';$/.0"'-"$1&*'/8$<)/")=.:;$7*)/./*="-$0.*$6'.%*';$-"*'7>$%"7>*).-%?$<).=.*++;$.)0&+0"-$*$=3&@3*;$/.-72--.&)$3.=>$7*)/./*="8$A";&)/$.).=.*+$.)="'"-=$/.-72--.&)-,$7*)/./*="$1'&2(>=$=&$7&%6*);$=&$-""$.)="')*+$3&'#.)(-,$("=$*$:""+$:&'$6"'-&)*+$:.=$&:$7&%6*);$*)/$.=-$&6"'*=.&)-8$B*)/./*="$.)='&/27"/$=&$1&*'/,$->*'">&+/"'-,$*)/$:*%.+;$6'.&'$=&$-"+"7=.&)8$C"*0;$"%6>*-.-$6+*7"/$&)$=3&@3*;$"0*+2*=.&)$1"=3"")$7*)/./*="$*)/$7&%6*);8

!&%"3>*=$.):&'%*+$@@D$%&0.)($=&3*'/$:&'%*+

9*--.0"$-"*'7>8$<)=")-"$12-.)"--$)"=3&'#.)($3.=>$&=>"'$.)/.0./2*+-8$A&*'/$%"%1"'$)"=3&'#.)(8$E'*/"$*--&7.*=.&)-8

7

!"*'7>$6'&7"--$.-$)"3$/2"$=&$.)/"6")/")=$1&*'/$%"%1"'$7&)7"6=$1".)($)"3$=&$7&%6*);8$C*0"$*$/":.)"/$-#.++$-"=$:&'$6&=")=.*+$7*)/./*="-$*)/$=*'("=$=&3*'/$=>"-"$.)/.0./2*+-8$</")=.:;$7*)/./*="-$0.*$6'.%*';$-"*'7>$%"7>*).-%?$F2=2*+$/.-72--.&)$3.=>$7*)/./*="-$*)/$.)='&/27=.&)$=&$#";$*77&2)=*1.+.=."-8$A")7>%*'#$*--"--%")=$*)/$'"-2+=-$7&%6*'.-&)$3.=>$72''")=$1&*'/8$<:$*--"--%")=$6*--"-,$.)@/"6=>$.)="'*7=.&)4.)="'0."3,$7*)/./*="$'"7&%%")/*=.&),$>.'"$1&*'/$%"%1"'8

A"7&%.)($:&'%*+

F&'"$&:$*)$*7=.0"$-"*'7>8$<)=")-"$12-.)"--$)"=3&'#.)(8$B&):"'")7"-$*)/$3&'#->&6-8$G5="')*+$*/0.-&'8

8

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

<):&'%*+A&*'/$%"%1"'$)"=3&'#.)(8$!").&'$%*)*("'$7&)=*7=-8$E'*/"$*--&7.*=.&)-8

9

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

T"';$<):&'%*+

H")"'*+$)"=3&'#.)(8$<)="')*+$*2/.=&'8$!").&'$%*)*("'$7&)=*7=-8$A&*'/$%"%1"'$7&)=*7=-8$M&$='*/"$&'(*).P*=.&)-8

:

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

<):&'%*+

9*--.0"$-"*'7>8$K.-72--.&)$*%&)($72''")=$1&*'/$%"%1"'-$*)/$-"*'7>$3.=>.)$72''")=$)"=3&'#.)($7*6*1.+.=."-$I6"'-&)*+$*)/$1&*'/$)"=3&'#-$12=$)"0"'$-"*'7>$7&%%.==""-,$='*/"$&'(*).P*=.&)-,$7&)-2+=*)=-J

;

A"(.)$-"*'7>$3.=>$&0"'-.(>=$.)$%.)/,$)&=$-="3*'/->.68$Z&&#$=&$6"&6+"$=>*=$:*%.+;$*+'"*/;$>*-$-='&)($)"=3&'#.)($7&))"7=.&)-$3.=>8$Z&&#$=&$>.(>+;@'"-6"7="/$.)/.0./2*+-$3.=>$-='&)(,$6'&0")$='*7#$'"7&'/$I(")"'*++;$3.=>.)$7&%6*);L-$.)/2-=';J$*)/$6'":"'*1+;$3.=>$#)&3+"/("$&:$:*%.+;$12-.)"--$/;)*%.7-8$M"0"'$-""#$&2=$Q-='*)("'-Q$:&'$1&*'/8$!""#$.)/.0./2*+-$=>*=$#)&3$*)/$'"-6"7=$=>"$:*%.+;$*)/$.=-$12-.)"--?$-""#$=>&-"$*66'"7.*=.0"$&:$.)/"6")/")=$/.'"7=&'$'&+"8$B*)/./*="-$&:=")$:*%.+.*'$3.=>$12-.)"--$*)/$)""/$+.==+"$.)='&/27=.&)8$["+*=.0"+;$-.%6+"$-"+"7=.&)$6'&7"--8

<):&'%*+

9*--.0"$-"*'7>8$!"*'7>$3.=>.)$&2'$"-=*1+.->"/$)"=3&'#-8$!"*'7>$7&%%.==""-$3"'"$)&=$"::"7=.0"$")&2(>8

<

</")=.:;$-6"7.:.7$)""/-$1":&'"$./")=.:;.)($7*)/./*="-?$./"):.=;$7*)/./*="-$0.*$6'.%*';$-"*'7>$%"7>*).-%?$>*0"$%2=2*+$/.-72--.&)$3.=>$7*)/./*="-$'"(*'/.)($#";$*77&2)=*1.+.=."-$&:$6&-.=.&)8$<:$.)="'"-=S$7*)/./*="-$62=$=>'&2(>$1")7>%*'#$*--"--%")=-8$\&++&3.)($*--"--%")=-,$.)=")-.0"$.)="'*7=.&)$1"=3"")$7&%6*);$*)/$7*)/./*="$I=3&@3*;$.)="'*7=.&)J8$["7&%")/*=.&)-$%*/"$:&'$7*)/./*="$-"+"7=.&)8

\&'%*+

F&'"$&:$*)$*7=.0"$-"*'7>8$9"'-&)*+$*)/$12-.)"--$)"=3&'#.)(8$Y--&7.*="/$'"-&2'7"-$I+*3$:.'%,$*77&2)=*)=$:&'$7&)=*7=$./"*-J

=

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

<):&'%*+

9*--.0"$-"*'7>8$A2-.)"--$)"=3&'#.)($3.=>$&=>"'$.)/.0./2*+-8$Y--&7.*="/$'"-&2'7"-$I7&%6*);L-$*77&2)=.)($*)/$+*3$:.'%-,$:*%.+;$*/0.-&'J8$!&%"$='*/"$&'(*).P*=.&)$)"=3&'#.)(8

!766-+3&X)4&O2%-)WP)H+&$&"B)#-"%'()!!

Page 60: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!XL!

!!"#$%&' ()*&+',-.*"/'0,1%#23',%&4,3"55,"1,+"&-/"3 6-*7%/45.2$0,-/85- !"#$*-*&+',95:,$*/5"&%32-'

;

!"#$%&'(&)*#$'(&+,-.$'/0'$)1#*/-2/*$/#3%4/5-*#/-2+3432+32*/0$&'+/6$'7&*-$2/8/#3%43+/%-7-*/6&7-%9/73703'/'3.-.*32"3(4).#80&":/09/#3%4-21/6&7-%9/)2+3'.*&2+/4'$"3../&2+/233+;/<$/633%-21/$6/6&7-%9/"$2*'$%/'3%-2=)-.#3+;/>?/'3%-.#/*#3/"#&213/-*/0'-21.@/?/+$2A*/.33/-*/B*#3/"#&%%3213C/&./&/*#'3&*;>/D&7-%9/)2+3'.*$$+/5#&*/233+3+/*$/03/+$23;

E').*/'3%-.#3+/$,3'/*-73@/$6*32/&6*3'/+-'3"*$'/.3%3"*-$2;/E'9/*$/+3,3%$4/&/FGHI/.*'$21J/*5$/5&9J/7)*)&%/'3%&*-$2.#-4(0$2+/03*5332/*#3/"&2+-+&*3/&2+/$'1&2-K&*-$2;/E5$85&9/'3%&*-$2.#-4/LH?E?LMN/-2/*#-./"$74&29A./7-2+;

O).*/03/5-%%-21/*$/%3*/.$73$23/*3%%/9$)/5#&*A./03.*;/I$)/+$2A*/:2$5/5#&*/9$)/+$2A*/:2$5;/N$$:/*$/-2+-,-+)&%./*#&*/&'3/1$-21/*$/"#&%%3213/*#3/6&7-%9/&2+/LGP;/!33:./-2+-,-+)&%./*#&*/5-%%/#$%+/LGP/*$/&/#-1#3'/.*&2+&'+/&2+/.3*/1$$+/3Q&74%3/6$'/$*#3'./88/43'.$2&%-*9/&%$23/-.2A*/1$-21/*$/+$/-*;/E#3/+-,-+.-$2/'3.*./-2/*#3/.3&'"#/4'$"3../$6/*#3/"$74&29/&2+/:39/&""$)2*&0-%-*-3./3.*&0%-.#3+/09/6&7-%9/LGP;

<L$74%3*3/.*35&'+.#-4/7$*-,&*-$2./&*/*#-./*-73@/2$/%$../$6/"$2*'$%/"$2"3'2.;

O).*/>5$':>/5-*#/.$73$23/*$/1&-2/*').*/$6*32*-73.;/?6/$23/-./1$-21/*$/7$,3/&#3&+/-2/0).-23..J/.$73*-73./#&,3/*$/.*$4/03-21/.$%3/$43'&*$'./&2+/03/32*'34'323)'./88/&""34*/.$73/)2"3'*&-2*9;/R.3/"'$..8'363'32"3./&2+/&%-12732*(032"#7&':/*3.*.@/7).*/'373703'/*#&*/*#3/'-.:./$6/"#$$.-21/*#3/5'$21/0$&'+/73703'/-./2$*/*#3/0-113.*/'-.:J/3.43"-&%%9/5#32/"$74&'3+/*$/*#3/6-2&2"-&%/'-.:./$6/0).-23../3Q4&2.-$2;

S'$"3../.34&'&*3./*#3/*5$/,3'9/53%%;/T3,3%$43+/"%3&'/0$&'+/73703'/&""$)2*&0-%-*-3./&2+/0)-%*/&/"$74'3#32.-,3/&%-12732*(032"#7&':/&..3..732*/*$/3%-7-2&*3/4$*32*-&%/.)0U3"*-,-*9/$6/-2+-,-+)&%/6&7-%9/73703'.@/L&2+-+&*3/"$743*32"9/+3*3'7-2&*-$2/&%.$/'3,-353+/*#'$)1#/&/"$77-**33/$6/*#'33/6&7-%9/0$&'+/+-'3"*$'.;

=

LGP/"3'*&-2%9/32*3'*&-23+/-+3&;/L$).-2./#&+/.*'$21/"$2"3'2.V/63%*/.32.3/$6/32*-*%3732*/*$/*#3/0$&'+J/.&5/0$&'+/$44$'*)2-*9/&./3&.9/-2"$73/5-*#/%-**%3/5$':@/&%.$/"$2"3'2./'31&'+-21/+-,-+32+./&2+/%$.-21/"$2*'$%;/?2+3432+32*/&+,-.$'/#3%43+/*$/3&.3/*'&2.-*-$2;

!33:/$)*/"$74&2-3./5-*#/$0U3"*-,3./$*#3'/*#&2/U).*/4'$6-*;/?+32*-69/"$74&2-3./3Q#-0-*-21/&44'$4'-&*3/03#&,-$'.J/3*#-".J/.$"-&%/'3.4$2.-0-%*9J/.-2"3/374%$933./$6*32/'36%3"*/&/"$74&29/88/#3%4./-2.*-%/*').*/5-*#/)26&7-%-&'/6&"3.;/M%.$/.33:/#-1#3'84'$6-%3/-2+-,-+)&%./5-*#/.$%-+/"'$..8"#3":3+/'363'32"3./*$/#3%4/3&.3/*#3/"$76$'*/%3,3%;

>?/).3/&%%/*#3/.&73/*$$%./?/).3/6$'/#-'-21;>/R.3/0'$&+/'&213/$6/3,&%)&*$'.V/+-'3"*$'.J/.32-$'/7&2&13732*J/6&7-%9/88/#3%4./"$)2*3'/.)0U3"*-,-*-9;/<$*/&/7&**3'/$6/6&7-%9/4'363'32"3.J/&./&/2)703'/$6/2$286&7-%9/&'3/-2,$%,3+/-2/$,3'&%%/."'332-21/$6/"&2+-+&*3.;

>

E#3'3/53'3/B&2+/.*-%%/&'3C/.$73/"$2"3'2./6'$7/6&7-%9/73703'./2$*/+-'3"*%9/-2,$%,3+/5-*#/*#3/0).-23..;/M%%$5-21/-2+3432+32*/73703'./*'-113'3+/'3.3',&*-$2./6$'/.$73@/#3.-.*&*-$2./7-2$'J/#$53,3'J/&2+/#&,3/2$*/03"$73/&/%&'13/-..)3/.$/6&';

P6*32/.*37./6'$7/4'-$'/43'.$2&%/'3%&*-$2./5-*#/"&2+-+&*3./-2/.$73/6&.#-$2@/7)"#/$6/*').*/-./0)-%*/&6*3'/0'-21-21/$2*$/*#3/0$&'+/88/$2%9/.$/7)"#/*').*/*$/03/1&-23+/4'-$'/*$/&++-21/*$/*#3/0$&'+/88/0)-%*/$,3'/*-73;

W&,3/23,3'/1$23/*#3/>1$$+/6'-32+>/'$)*3/88/.#9/&5&9/6'$7/"%$.3/6'-32+./&2+/$*#3'/"$2*&"*./6$'/$0U3"*-,-*9/'3&.$2.;/H3&%%9/#-*/#&'+/'31&'+-21/=)&%-6-"&*-$2.@/5&2*/&/.$%-+/"&2+-+&*3/*#&*/"&2/"#&%%3213/*#3/6&7-%9/LGP;/E#3/2&*)'3/$6/*#3/"$74&29A./:39/&""$)2*&0-%-*-3./&2+/3Q43"*&*-$2./$6/-2+3432+32*/73703'./"#&%%321-21/+3"-.-$2./&'3/*#3/6$)2+&*-$2/$6/32.)'-21/"$743*32*/$)*.-+3'.;

?P)*.-+3'./.3',3/4'-7&'-%9/-2/&+,-.$'9/'$%3;/D&7-%9/$52./XYYZ/&2+/#&./*#3/6-2&%/+3"-.-$2;/!$J/2$/633%-21/$6/&/%$../$6/"$2*'$%;

?*A./&%5&9./+-66-")%*/*$/#&,3/6)%%/*').*@/5$':/5-*#/"&2+-+&*3./6$'/1$$+/&7$)2*/$6/*-73/$2/&/4'$63..-$2&%/%3,3%/*$/)2+3'.*&2+/,&%)3.J/"&4&0-%-*-3.J/0&":1'$)2+@/*'9/*$/+3,3%$4/,3'9/.*'$21/23*5$':-21/*-3./*$/#3%4/1&-2/*').*/-2/4$*32*-&%/"&2+-+&*3./$,3'/*-73

M%5&9./.33:./&**'-0)*3./'31&'+-21/6&7-%9/0).-23..J/.$73$23/.*'$21/32$)1#/*$/4).#/0&":/$2/6&7-%9/&"*-$2.J/5&2*.J/+3.-'3./88[/7&:3/-*/,3'9/"%3&'/*#&*/-*A./23,3'/&/4$4)%&'-*9/"$2*3.*;/!33:/*')3/4'$63..-$2&%./-2/0).-23..J/.:-%%3+/&2+/#-1#%9/+3*&-%3+/5-*#/1$$+/-2*3'43'.$2&%/.:-%%./88/$6*32/+$2A*/32+/)4/03-21/"%$.3/6'-32+.;/T$2A*/#&,3/6$'7&%/4'$"3../6$'/"%3&'/.34&'&*-$2J/0)*/*#3/7-2+8.3*/-2/5#-"#/*#3/"&2+-+&*3/.3&'"#/-./"$2+)"*3+/#&./4'$,3+/53%%/*#)./6&';

@<$*/0332/&/4'$0%37/+)3/*$/6&7-%9/")%*)'3/&2+/3Q43'-32"3/5-*#/-2+3432+32*/0$&'+./-2/*#3/4&.*;

\323'&%%9/#&,3/1$$+/6&7-%9/"$223"*-$2/0)*/OR!E/#&,3/&/4'$,32/*'&":/'3"$'+/$6/&"#-3,3732*@/7).*/03/&0%3/*$/3&'2/'3.43"*/&2+/03/.)""3..6)%;/!33:/$)*/#-1#3'/4'$6-%3/-2+-,-+)&%./5-*#/.*'$21/*-3./&2+/)2+3'.*&2+-21./$6/6&7-%9/0).-23../+92&7-"./B-2/1323'&%C

O).*/#&,3/4'$,32/*'&":/'3"$'+J/4%&-2/&2+/.-74%3;/W$53,3'J/*#3/0$&'+/-./&/*3&7/&2+/-*./3663"*-,323../+3432+./$2/3,3'9$23/*$/5$':/53%%/*$13*#3';/S3'.$2&%-*9/*'&-*./&'3/3=)&%%9/-74$'*&2*/0)*/-*A./$6*32/4&'*/$6/*#3/0).-23../"$743*32"9/&2+/4'$,32/*'&":/'3"$'+/4&":&13;

A

\323'&%%9/#&,3/2$*/')2/-2*$/6&7-%9/-..)3.;/O&29/$6/*#3/-..)3./5$':3+/*#37.3%,3./$)*/5-*#/*#3/3%-7-2&*-$2/$6/6&7-%9/73703'./+)'-21/&/'3.*')"*)'-21/*-73/43'-$+/B&2+/.)0.3=)32*/3%-7-2&*-$2/$6/.$73/6&7-%9/73703'./-2/7&2&13732*/4$.-*-$2./4&'*-")%&'%9C;/M%.$J/-2+343+32*./&'3/.$)1#*/4'-7&'-%9/6$'/&+,-.$'9/4)'4$.3./$2%9;

E').*/"$73./6'$7/43'6$'7-21/+)38+-%-132"3/6'$7/*#3/,3'9/031-22-21;/M..3..732*/032"#7&':.@/0&":1'$)2+/'363''&%.J/3*";/E').*//"$73./5-*#/*-73/&2+/&**32*-$2/*$/+3*&-%/-2/*#3/.3%3"*-$2/4'$"3..;/!3',3/-2/&+,-.$'9/'$%3J/.$/-6/.$73*#-21/+$3.2A*/633%/'-1#*J/9$)/"&2/&%*3'/+3"-.-$2.;/]2$5-21/"&2+-+&*3./$2/&/4'$63..-$2&%/%3,3%/"&2/&%.$/03/:39;

F3'-69/233+./09/6-'.*/.3%3"*-21/&'3&./$6/3Q43'*-.3/.$)1#*/036$'3/&29/"$2,3'.&*-$2./5-*#/4&'*-")%&'/"&2+-+&*3./*&:3/4%&"3;/N$$:/*$5&'+/4'$63..-$2&%/23*5$':/&2+/:334/&5&9/6'$7/43'.$2&%/23*5$':.;M..3..732*./&2+/032"#7&':./&'3/"'-*-"&%V/^?/#&,3/0332/,3'9/,3'9/4%3&.3+/5-*#/*#3/&..3..732*.;/?/"&2_*/03%-3,3/53/#-'3+/`4'3,-$).%9a/5-*#$)*/*#37b/E$/&44%9/-*/*$/*#3/0$&'+/`"&2+-+&*3.a/5&./2&*)'&%;/c3/#&,3/0332/,3'9/.)""3..6)%/5-*#/-*;/?/&0.$%)*3%9/+$/2$*/#-'3/5-*#$)*/-*/2$5bd/M%.$J/6-2&%/"$26-'7&*-$2/*#'$)1#/'363''&%.;

B

?2+3432+32*/73703'./&'3/*&'13*3+/6$'/&+,-.$'9/'$%3./4'-7&'-%9;/D&7-%9/#&./"$73/*$/*3'7./$2/*#3-'/$52/5-*#/$)*.-+3/0$&'+/73703'./&2+/2$5/*$/*#3/4$-2*/$6/&%5&9./&.:-21/>53%%J/5#&*/+$3./*#3/0$&'+/*#-2:/$6/*#-.e>/E#3/4'$,32/*'&":/'3"$'+/$,3'/*#3/4&.*/635/93&'./#&./&%.$/0332/:39/-2/6&7-%9/&""34*&2"3;

LGP/+$3.2A*/&%5&9./:2$5/*#3/"&2+-+&*3./&2+/'3%-3./$2/$*#3'/0$&'+/73703'./&2+/6&7-%9/6$'/*').*/3%3732*.;/N$$:/&*/"$74&29/6'$7/5#-"#/$)*.-+3'./'34'3.32*/*$/#3%4/U)+13/"$76$'*/%3,3%;/!$73/&'3/:2$52/*#'$)1#/6&7-%9/"$223"*-$2./$'/*#'$)1#/5$'+/$6/7$)*#;/!$73/'3"$7732+3+/09/6&7-%9/&+,-.$'/&2+/$*#3'/*').*-21/-2+-,-+)&%.;/E'&+3/&..$"-&*-$2./&%.$/&..-.*/*#'$)1#/"&2+-+&*3/'34)*&*-$2./5-*#/$*#3'.;

c$2A*/3,32/"$2.-+3'/&/"&2+-+&*3/5-*#/&/4$$'/*'&":/'3"$'+;/!#9/&5&9/6'$7/6'-32+.;/M44'3"-&*3/&2+/.33:/-2+-,-+)&%./*#&*/5-%%/4).#/0&":/$2/4'$4$.3+/+3"-.-$2./&2+/.&9/>5#9/*#3/#3":/5$)%+/9$)/+$/*#&*e>/c&2*/43$4%3/*#&*/5-%%/"#&%%3213/+3"-.-$2.;/f3%-3,3/*#&*/-*A./*#3/>1-,3/&2+/*&:3>/732*&%-*9/*#&*/'3.)%*./-2/03**3'/$)*"$73.;/!-74%9/4)*V/*#3/.34&'&*-$2/-./&%%/-2/*#3/7-2+.3*/$6/*#3/.3&'"#/4'$"3..;

!766-+3&X)4&O2%-)YP)1-"%'()"+3)%-#52%'-)'5+#&3-%"$&5+#)!!

Page 61: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!XM!

!"#$%&' (#$")*%&+,-".-$)/")-0"%)1-,2$,)/,&+, !)"334+5,+6/&7-+%&1/1%*,3 8,&1/&7-9/*5-,*5/+3-%&1-")7%&/:%*/"&%;-3*)<+*<),

=

!"#$%&'"(#)*#$)#$)++,$-(%"($./0%*100$12'1(%1*31$&/34$&"(1$3(%#%3)+,$561*$7%#4"/#$'(%"($.")(8$12'1(%1*319$%#:0$61;($1)0;$)8</0#&1*#$#"$&)=1$>"($*17$8%(13#"(0,

?>#1*$01+13#$71++@(10'13#18$%*8%6%8/)+0$%*$#41%($(10'13#%61$>%1+80A$#4%0$+%&%#0$3("00@3413=%*B$3"*31(*0,$C/34$(10#0$"*$#41$#(/0#9$*1#7"(=%*B$(1+)#%"*04%'09$)*8$."*80$>"(&18$7%#4$1)34$3)*8%8)#19$')(%#3/+)(+;$8/(%*B$#41$#7"@7);$16)+/)#%"*$'("3100,

D1)6;$1&'4)0%0$"*$#7"@7);$16)+/)#%"*$'("3100A$12#1*0%61$%*#1()3#%"*,

>

-(%"($12'1(%1*31$%&'"(#)*#,$E1F/%(10$)*$%*8%6%8/)+$#"$'(101*#$%81)0$%*$)$0;0#1&)#%3$7);$#4)#$'("'1(+;$%*6"=10$#4"/B4#$)*8$8%03/00%"*$7%#4%*$.")(8$1*6%("*&1*#,$G"/+8*:#$(/+1$"/#$3)*8%8)#10$7%#4"/#$.")(8$12'1(%1*31,

E1>1(1*310$'("6%818$.;$3)*8%8)#1$)0$71++$)0$*1#7"(=%*B$3"*#)3#0$=*"7*$.;$>)&%+;$./0%*100,$G1++@=*"7*$3)*8%8)#10$4)61$)$0"+%8$H%**1(@3%(3+1H$0"$#41(1$)(1$'+1*#;$">$(1>1(1*31$0"/(310,

I"(&)+$.1*34&)(=$)00100&1*#0$)*8$3"&')(%0"*0$7%#4$3/((1*#$.")(8$&1&.1(0$)*8$"(B)*%J)#%"*)+$B")+0,$K*@81'#4$%*#1(6%170$)*8$%*#1()3#%"*09$3/+#/()+$8%03/00%"*09$0"3%)+$%*#1()3#%"*0$7%#4$1213/#%6109$.")(8$&1&.1(09$>)&%+;,

? !"#$%&'"(#)*#$)#$)++,

L01$4%B41(@'(">%+1$%*8%6%8/)+0$74%34$&)=10$%#$)$+%##+1$1)0%1($#"$(101)(34$#41%($.)3=B("/*8,$E1+;$"*$3)*8%8)#1:0$3/((1*#$1&'+";1($"($"#41($'1"'+1$%*$%*8/0#(;$74"$=*"7$3)*8%8)#1,$M+0"$0'1)=$#"$#4"01$#4)#$7"(=$7%#4$3)*8%8)#1,

-/++$3)*8%8)#10$>("&$3"&')*%10$7%#4$B""8$1#4%309$0"3%)+$(10'"*0%.%+%#;$@$1&'+";110$">#1*$(1>+13#$"(B)*%J)#%"*0,$C/34$8%03/00%"*$)*8$16)+/)#%"*$">$3)*8%8)#1$8"*1$.;$1213/#%6109$.")(89$)*8$>)&%+;,$N)*8%8)#10$.("/B4#$#"$./0%*100$>"($)$3"/'+1$8);0$#"$.1$12'"018$#"$3"&')*;$)*8$3/+#/(1$#"$41+'$81#1(&%*8$3/+#/()+O1#4%3)+$>%#,

@

$!"#$61(;$%&'"(#)*#,$G)*#$"61()++$B""8$3"*#(%./#"($)*8$#4)#$B1*1()++;$3"&10$7%#4$0"+%8$./0%*100$=*"7+18B1,$P"$*"#$7)*#$'(">100%"*)+$.")(8$&1&.1(0A$7)*#$#(/1$./0%*100$"'1()#%"*$12'1(%1*31$@$'1"'+1$%*$#41$H#4%3=$">$%#H,

K*41(1*#$%*$#41$01+13#%"*$'("3100$6%)$*1#7"(=%*B$7%#4$"#41($%*8%6%8/)+0,$D%#$4)(8$"*$3)*8%8)#1$F/)+%>%3)#%"*0$.;$0'1)=%*B$7%#4$#4"01$%*$%*8/0#(;$>)&%+%)($7%#4$#41$3)*8%8)#10$)*8$#41%($F/)+%>%3)#%"*0,

-("6%81$H0#)#1$">$#41$%*8/0#(;$)*8$3"&')*;H$'(101*#)#%"*,$Q)+=$)."/#$3/0#"&1(09$3"&'1#%#%"*9$%*8/0#(;9$3"&')*;9$B")+09$6)+/10,$G)*#$3)*8%8)#1$#"$#(/+;$/*81(0#)*8$4"7$3"&')*;$"'1()#10,$R(%*B$#41&$%*#"$"(B)*%J)#%"*$>"($.(%1>$'1(%"8$">$#%&1$0"$#41;$3)*$B1#$.)0%3$/*81(0#)*8%*B,$E1)++;$4%#$4"&1$"*$6)+/10$)*8$&%00%"*$(1B)(8%*B$3/0#"&1(09$)00"3%)#109$)*8$"7*1(0,

A

-(%"($.")(8$12'1(%1*31$)$3"*0%81()#%"*$)*8$6)+/).+1$F/)+%#;$./#$*"#$')(#%3/+)(+;$*13100)(;$.;$)*;$&1)*0,$C"0#$%&'"(#)*#+;S$011=$3)*8%8)#10$7%#4$>)&%+;$./0%*100$12'1(%1*31O)##(%./#10,

K*41(1*#$%*$#41$01+13#%"*$'("3100,$T#("*B$*1#7"(=%*BA$7"(=$7%#4$3)*8%8)#1$"*$)$'(">100%"*)+$+161+$>"($+"*B$'1(%"8$">$#%&1$#"$1*0/(1$'("'1($>%#$7%#4$3"&')*;$)*8$1*0/(1$F/)+%>%3)#%"*0$&11#$12'13#)#%"*0,$

M$>)%($)&"/*#$">$#%&1$%0$0'1*#$7%#4$3)*8%8)#1U0V$#"$/*81(0#)*8$74)#$#41;$)(1$B1##%*B$#41&01+610$%*#",$G)*#$'1"'+1$7%#4$(10'13#$>"($>)&%+;$./0%*100A$0'1*8$)$+"#$">$#%&1$7%#4$#41$3"&')*;$#"$1*0/(1$#41;$/*81(0#)*8$#41$./0%*100$)*8$%#0$/*%F/1$*1180,

B

!"#$)$.%B$3"*31(*,$K>$3)*8%8)#1$4)0$01(%"/0$./0%*100$12'1(%1*31$)*8$%0$)$+1)81(9$#41*$#41;$'(".).+;$4)61$.")(8$12'1(%1*31,$K#$">#1*$3"&10$7%#4$#41$F/)+%#%10$">$B""8$./0%*100$12'1(%1*31,

K*41(1*#$%*$#41$0#("*B$01+13#%"*$'("3100A$0"+%8$*1#7"(=%*B9$01+13#%"*$">$4%B4+;$(10'13#18$%*8%6%8/)+0$#4)#$)(1$">#1*$'(16%"/0+;$=*"7*$#"$#41$>)&%+;,

Q4(11$">$>"/($%*81'1*81*#$&1&.1(0$3)&1$(%B4#$>("&$#41$#41$()*34%*BO3)##+1$%*8/0#(;,$Q41;$3"&1$#"$3"&')*;$.13)/01$#41;$/*81(0#)*8$#41$./0%*100$)*8$"(B)*%J)#%"*,$D)6%*B$=*"7+18B1$">$>)&%+;$./0%*100$8;*)&%30$%0$%&'"(#)*#,$K>$3)*8%8)#1$8"10*:#$4)61$#41$>)&%+;$./0%*100$=*"7+17B19$#41;$&/0#$.1$7%++%*B$#"$+1)(*$)*8$&/0#9$)#$&%*%&/&9$(10'13#$#41$/*%F/1$8;*)&%30$">$0/34$"(B)*%J)#%"*0,

CN"*0%81()#%"*9$./#$*"#$)$#"'$'(%"(%#;$!"#$161*$%*$#41$.1*34&)(=$)00100&1*#,

W1*1()++;$4)61$'(%"($=*"7+18B1$">$%*8%6%8/)+0$)*8$4)61$*1#7"(=18$7%#4$3)*8%8)#10,$R")(8$B1*1()++;$=*"70$74"$#41$3)*8%8)#10$)(19$#41%($(1'/#)#%"*09$)*8$74)#$#41;$3)*$.(%*B$#"$#41$#).+1,$I%*)+$3"*>%(&)#%"*$3"&10$#4("/B4$(1>1(()+0$>("&$"#41($%*8%6%8/)+0,

M++$3)*8%8)#10$)(1$B1*1()++;$>)&%+%)($7%#4$3"&')*;,$R(%*B$#41&$%*9$04"7$#41&$#41$3"&')*;$)*8$"'1()#%"*09$&)*/>)3#/(%*B$)*8$'("3100%*B,$K*#1()3#$7%#4$#41$1213/#%61$+161+$">$&)*)B1&1*#,$T'1*8$)$+"#$">$#%&1$"*$"(B)*%J)#%"*)+$%*#1()3#%"*$)*8$&/34$">$3"*>%(&)#%"*$3"&10$>("&$.1*34&)(=$)00100&1*#0,$K#:0$/+#%&)#1+;$)$#7"@7);$16)+/)#%"*$'("31009$4"7161(9$0"$3)*8%8)#10$B1#$)$>11+$>"($4"7$#41$"(B)*%J)#%"*$3)*$>%#$7%#4$#41&9$#"",

D

N1(#)%*+;$*"#$#41$#"'$3"*31(*,$-(%&)(;$3"*31(*$(10#0$7%#4$./0%*100$12'1(%1*31$)*8$>%*8%*B$#41$(%B4#$'1"'+1$>("&$#41$(%B4#$./0%*100$7%#4$#41$(%B4#$)&"/*#$">$'("61*$./0%*100$12'1(%1*31,

E1>1(1*31$3413=0$>"($3)*8%8)#10$*"#$71++@=*"7*$#"$N5?$"($.")(8,$E1>1(1*31$3413=0$B1*1()++;$'1(>"(&18$.;$#41$N5?,

N"&')*;$#"/($B%61*$8/(%*B$#41$3)*8%8)#1$%*#1(6%17$'("3100$#"$%*#("8/31$3)*8%8)#10$#"$"(B)*%J)#%"*,$P"$*"#$4)61$&/34$">$)$'("3100$.1;"*8$#4)#,

!766-+3&X)4&O2%-)ZP)733&$&5+"B)'"+3&3"$-)#-B-'$&5+)'5+#&3-%"$&5+#)!!

!"#$%&'()*#+,-#-./+0%*'+1"*+-&2)$)&2)&./+%&2+

1%#-,'3

()*#/4.)*#+,-#-./+-&2)$)&2)&./

()*#/4.)*#+,-#-./+1%#-,'!5**)&.,'+$)*1"*#+6"%*2+)0%,5%.-"&/

7%,5)+8*)%.-"&+1*"#+-&2)$)&2)&.+#)#6)*/3

9 !" #$%&'$($)*)+ #$%&'$($)*)+$ !" ,-.: ,-. /010#$%&'$($)*)+ )*)+$($)*)+ !" ,-.; ,-. /$%&$($2$%&' )*)+$($)*)+ ,-.0$345$6*77488++ ,-.< !" /$%&$($)*)+ /$%&$($)*)+ !" ,-.= !" )*)+$($)*)+ )*)+$($)*)+ ,-.0$9++&:*):9++& ,-.

> ,-. #$%&'$($)*)+1);$<+)=$)*)+$($)*)+$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$#&;$<+)=$#$%&'$($#$%&'

,-.0$345$6*77488++ ,-.

? !" /$%&$($)*)+ /$%&$($)*)+!"0$>?8$@4AA$'**)$

479A+7+)8$*)$5))?5A$>5'4'

,-.

@ ,-. #$%&$($)*)+ )*)+$($)*)+B)$8C+$>*5&;$6C5&8+&$

>?8$5&+$)*8$9+&D*&7+;E

,-.

!766-+3&X)4&O2%-)[P)D5#$M#-B-'$&5+)'5+#&3-%"$&5+#)

Page 62: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!X2!

7DD=/>HI)CP)C-+'(0"%S)"##-##0-+$#)

P8/.*=8.*6! 68-! &,6-/<&-4! 9/.?-++A! 64.! ;$%&'(! :*+&,-++-+! 0-+?/&:-0! 68-&/! ;./%$'! 9/.?-0*/-! ;./!

&,0-9-,0-,6! :.$/0! %-%:-/! +-'-?6&.,! d?.%9$,&-+! v2! $,0! vXe@! P8-&/! %-68.0+! 4-/-! -++-,6&$''(!

0-+?/&:-0!$+!$!+-/&-+!.;!:-,?8%$/7+!$=$&,+6!48&?8!9.6-,6&$'!.*6+&0-!:.$/0!%-%:-/!?$,0&0$6-+!$/-!

%-$+*/-0@! Q++-++%-,6+A! 6$7-,! :(! ?$,0&0$6-+! 9/&./! 6.! ;*/68-/! ?.,+&0-/$6&.,A! $/-! ?.%9$/-0! $=$&,+6!

9/-N0-6-/%&,-0!h7-(!$??.*,6$:&'&6&-+l!$,0!9-/;./%$,?-!:-,?8%$/7+!&,!./0-/!6.!?$'?*'$6-!$'&=,%-,6!

4&68!0-;&,-0!$66/&:*6-+A!?$,0&0$6-!:-8$<&./+A!$,0!?./9./$6-!?*'6*/-@!)-?$*+-!68&+!$99/.$?8!$99-$/+!

+.%-48$6! ,-4! 6.! 68-! 6/$0&6&.,$'! :.$/0! +-'-?6&.,! 9/.?-++A! $,! $00&6&.,$'! &,6-/<&-4!4$+! ?.,0*?6-0!

4&68!)/-,6!D$6%.+@!)/-,6! &+! 68-!hD/&,?&9$'!f!K8&-;!P8.*=86!Y-$0-/l!.;!D-/9-6*$'!H-<-'.9%-,6A! 3,?@!

_-!$0<&+-+!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++-+!.,!&,0-9-,0-,6!:.$/0!%-%:-/!+-'-?6&.,!9/.?-++-+!$,0!8-'9+!6.!=*&0-!

68-%!68/.*=8!68-!:-,?8%$/7&,=!$,0!$++-++%-,6!9/.?-0*/-+@!

!

P8-!+(+6-%$6&?!+-'-?6&.,!9/.?-++!?-,6-/-0!.,!:-,?8%$/7!$++-++%-,6+!&+!:$+-0!.,!$!6$/=-6!0&$=/$%!

0-<-'.9-0!:(!)&''! ).,+6-66-/!.;! P$/=-6! P/$&,&,=! 3,6-/,$6&.,$'A! Y60! d.@@-,/+[& '+C)4-&Ye@! 36! 9/.<&0-+! $!

;.?*+-0!&%$=-!.;!+-<-,!$66/&:*6-+!$/.*,0!48&?8!68-!:-,?8%$/7!9/.?-0*/-!&+!0-+&=,-0@!!

!766-+3&X)4&O2%-)]P)C-+'(0"%S)"##-##0-+$#)(+%%&($,*3-33-45&6.4C-3&64.+,+,C&B,3-4,.3+$,.%5&k3/A&#33@\mmIIIA33+/+*"A"$1md&#33@\mmIIIA33+%3/A"$1m&&Q+!4$+!?'-$/'(!-<&0-,6!68/.*=8.*6!68-!9/-<&.*+'(!9/-+-,6-0!+6*0(A!68-!9.6-,6&$'! ;./!:&$+!4&68&,!68-!

+-'-?6&.,! .;! -B6-/,$'! :.$/0! %-%:-/+! &+! +6/&7&,='(! 8&=8@! Q+! $! /-+*'6A! )/-,6! 8$+! ?.%9&'-0! $! ;./%$'!

9/.?-++! 68$6!$&%+! 6.! /-%.<-! 68&+! +-'-?6&.,!:&$+! ;./!$!?.%9'-6-'(!.:5-?6&<-!<&-4!.;!?$,0&0$6-+@!P8&+!

Page 63: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!XO!

+(+6-%$6&?!9/.?-++!/-S*&/-+!?$,0&0$6-+!6.!?.%9'-6-!&,&6&$'!$++-++%-,6+@!P8-!+-'-?6&,=!?.%9$,(!68-,!

$,$'(>-+! 68-!$,+4-/+! ;/.%!68-!?$,0&0$6-R+!$++-++%-,6!$=$&,+6!9/-0-6-/%&,-0!:-,?8%$/7+@!V-+*'6+!

$/-! ;*/68-/! ?.%9$/-0! 4&68! ,$6&.,$'! +6$,0$/0+! .;! $''! /-+9.,0-,6+! 68$6! 8$<-! -<-/! ?.%9'-6-0! 68-!

+*/<-(@! 36! &+! 68-+-! ?.%9$/&+.,+! 68$6! $/-! -<-,6*$''(! *+-0! 6.! 8-'9! 0-6-/%&,-!48&?8! ?$,0&0$6-+! :-+6!

%$6?8!68-!/-S*&/-%-,6+!+-6!;./68!;./!68-!9.+&6&.,!.;!$,!-B6-/,$'s&,0-9-,0-,6!:.$/0!%-%:-/@!

!

Q'68.*=8! 68-! -,6&/-! :-,?8%$/7s$++-++%-,6! 9/.?-++! &+! S*&6-! ?.%9'-BA! &6! ?$,! =-,-/$''(! :-! :/.7-,!

0.4,!&,6.!,&,-!+6-9+"!

!

M@ hI-(!$??.*,6$:&'&6&-+l!$/-!-+6$:'&+8-0!:(! 68-!?.%9$,(! &,<.'<-0!4&68! 68-! +-'-?6&.,!9/.?-++@!

P8&+! '&+6! .;! ;&<-! 6.! +-<-,! $66/&:*6-+! '$(+! 68-! &,&6&$'! ;.*,0$6&.,! ;./! ?$,0&0$6-! +-$/?8-+@! P8-!

$66/&:*6-+!0-+?/&:-!68-!%$&,!/-S*&/-%-,6+!.;!68-!&,0-9-,0-,6!0&/-?6./!9.+&6&.,!68$6!8-'9!6.!

%--6! 68-! ,--0+! $,0! 0-;&?&-,?&-+! .;! 68-! ?*//-,6! :.$/0! .;! 0&/-?6./+@! Q! '&+6! .;! '-++! 68$,! ;&<-!

S*$'&;&?$6&.,+! 4$+! 0-6-/%&,-0! 6.! ?.,6$&,! 6..! ;-4! /-S*&/-%-,6+A! .;6-,! /-+*'6&,=! &,!

0-+?/&96&.,+! ;.*,0! 6.! :-! 6..! :/.$0@! K.,<-/+-'(A! $! '&+6! ?.%9.+-0! .;! %./-! 68$,! +-<-,!

/-S*&/-%-,6+!4$+!;.*,0!6.!-B8&:&6!%./-!.;!$!%&?/.N%$,$=&,=!?.,?-96!4&68!6..!%$,(!+%$''!

6$+7+@!

!

2@ g.:! $++-++%-,6+! $/-! 9-/;./%-0@! P8-! $++-++%-,6! :-,?8%$/7+! $/-! ?.,+6/*?6-0! <&$!

?.,6/&:*6&.,+!4&68! +*:5-?6!%$66-/! -B9-/6+! ;/.%! 68-! +-'-?6&.,! ?.%9$,(@! P8&+! 9./6&.,!.;! 68-!

$++-++%-,6!&+!?*+6.%&>-0!;./!-$?8!;$%&'(!./=$,&>$6&.,@!

!

O@ g.:N6$'-,6! ?.%9$/&+.,+! $/-! ?.,0*?6-0@! P8&+! +6-9! ;$?6./+! &,! 7-(! $??.*,6$:&'&6&-+! .;! 68-!

9.+&6&.,!$,0!$,$'(>-+!68-!&,0&<&0*$'!&,9*6!.;!68-!?$,0&0$6-+!68-%+-'<-+!;/.%!68-!9/&./!+6-9@!

!

T@ K$,0&0$6-+!$/-!$'&=,-0!6.!68-!9.+&6&.,!:$+-0!.,!68-&/!/-+*'6+@!P8&+!$'&=,%-,6!.??*/+!68/.*=8!$!

,*%:-/! .;! 0&%-,+&.,$'! &,9*6+@! )-?$*+-! ,.! ?$,0&0$6-! &+! 9-/;-?6A! 68-! &,9*6+! $/-! $'6-/-0! 6.!

$''.4!;./!$!h>.,-!/$,=-l!.;!<$'*-+@!!#&/+6A!68-!&,9*6+!$/-!;$?6./-0!;./!$,(!:&$+!68$6!%$(!-B&+6!

6.!/-+*'6!&,!$!h9-/;-?6!:-,?8%$/7l@!Q!9/-0-6-/%&,-0!$%.*,6!.;!:&$+!&+!68-,!&,6/.0*?-0!:$?7!

&,6.!68-!:-,?8%$/7!6.!$''.4!?$,0&0$6-+!6.!;$''!4&68&,!$!/$,=-!.;!$??-96$:'-!<$'*-+!d+6$,0$/0!

0-<&$6&.,+!;/.%!68-!%-$,e@!

!

^@ H&+?.,,-?6+!&,!68-!-,<&/.,%-,6!$/-!0-6-/%&,-0!:$+-0!.,!68-!9/-<&.*+!?$,0&0$6-!&,9*6+!$,0!

+6$6&+6&?$'! $,$'(+&+@! P8&+! +6-9! &+! &,6-,0-0! 6.! *,?.<-/! =$9+!4&68&,! 68-! ?$,0&0$6-+A! &,?'*0&,="!

Page 64: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!XT!

/.'-!$4$/-,-++A!+-';N0&/-?6&.,A!'-<-'!.;!+-';N$4$/-,-++A!$,0!$66/&:*6-+!+*?8!$+!.<-/N!./!*,0-/N

?.,;&0-,?-@!

!

X@ Q!+-6!.;!h?./-!+7&''+l!&+!-+6$:'&+8-0!:$+-0!.,!9/-<&.*+!$,$'(+&+!&,!./0-/!6.!:-66-/!*,0-/+6$,0!

68-!?$,0&0$6-+R!+6/-,=68+!$,0!4-$7,-++-+@!Q!6.6$'!.;!+&B6(N68/--!?./-!+7&''+!$/-!-<$'*$6-0@!

!

a@ Q!?.%9$/&+.,!$,$'(+&+!.;!68-!+&B6(N68/--!?./-!+7&''+!&+!9-/;./%-0@![$?8!&+!$++&=,-0!$!<$'*-!$,0!

68-!6.9!+7&''+!$/-!0-6-/%&,-0!d2O!$66/&:*6-+A!X!<$'*-+A!]!:-8$<&./+e@!

!

]@ #*/68-/! $,$'(+&+! ,$//.4+!0.4,! 68-! +7&''+-6! ;/.%! 68-!9/-<&.*+! +6-9! 6.! $! 6.6$'! .;! 68&/6--,! da!

$66/&:*6-+A!O!<$'*-+A!O!+7&''+e@!P8-+-!$/-!?.,+&0-/-0!68-!?$,0&0$6-R+!9/&%$/(!+7&''+@!

!

b@ P8-!7,.4'-0=-!;/.%!68-!9/-<&.*+!+6-9!&+!?.*9'-0!4&68!68-!;&-'0!.;!7,.4'-0=-!68-!?.%9$,(!

&6+-';! 8$+! $:.*6! 68-! ?$,0&0$6-@! P8&+! &,?'*0-+! &6-%+! +*?8! $+! /}+*%}+A!

/-?.%%-,0$6&.,+s/-;-//$'+A!:$?7=/.*,0!?8-?7+A!-6?@!#/.%!68&+!9.&,6A! 68-!?.%9$,(!?$,!*+-!

$''!$<$&'$:'-!&,;./%$6&.,!6.!%$7-!$!%./-!&,;./%-0!0-?&+&.,@!

!

36!&+!&%9./6$,6!6.!,.6-!68$6!)/-,6A!$+!68-!$0<&+./!$,0!$0%&,&+6/$6./!.;!68&+!9/.5-?6A!,-<-/!?.%-+!&,6.!

$,(!98(+&?$'!./!?.%%*,&?$6&<-!?.,6$?6!4&68!$,(!?$,0&0$6-+!0*/&,=!68-!+-'-?6&.,!9/.?-++A!,./!0.-+!8-!

9.++-++! $,(! &,;./%$6&.,! $:.*6! 68-! ?$,0&0$6-! d/}+*%}+A! /-?.%%-,0$6&.,+s/-;-//$'+A! :$?7=/.*,0!

?8-?7+A!-6?@e@!P8-!.,'(!&,;./%$6&.,!8-!&+!$4$/-!.;!0*/&,=!68-!9/.?-++!&+!68-!?$,0&0$6-R+!,$%-@!).68!.;!

68-+-!$?6&.,+!8-'9!6.!-,+*/-!,-$/!?.%9'-6-!.:5-?6&<&6(!68/.*=8.*6!68-!:-,?8%$/7&,=!9/.?-0*/-@!

!

#*/68-/%./-A!68-!$++-++%-,6+!$/-!,.6! 5*+6!9/.<&0-0!6.!?$,0&0$6-+@!P8-(!$/-!$'+.!9-/;./%-0!.,!68-!

-,6&/-! :.$/0! .;! 0&/-?6./+@! P8&+! 8-'9+! -+6$:'&+8! $'&=,%-,6! :-64--,! ?$,0&0$6-+! $,0! ?*//-,6! :.$/0!

%-%:-/+@! Q00&6&.,$''(A! +&BN9.&,6! '&7-/6! +?$'-+! $/-! *+-0! 6.! /-%.<-! $00&6&.,$'! :&$+! ;/.%! -B9$,0-0!

$,+4-/+@!Y$+6'(A!%*?8!.;!68-!$'&=,%-,6!9/.?-++!9-/;./%-0!68/.*=8.*6!68-!$++-++%-,6!9/.?-0*/-!&+!

:$+-0!.,!68-!4-''N7,.4,!_$/6%$,!\$'*-+!D/.;&'-A!$!;./%!.;!$B&.'.=(!*+-0!6.!0-6-/%&,-!$!,*%:-/!.;!

9-/+.,$'!?8$/$?6-/&+6&?+@!

!

)/-,6!$'+.!$0<.?$6-+!68$6!68&+!9/.?-++!8$+!68-!%$5./!$0<$,6$=-!.;!;&/+6!0-$'&,=!4&68!9.+&6&.,+!d:.$/0!

%-%:-/+! &,! 68&+! ?$+-eA! +7&''+-6+A! $,0! $??.*,6$:&'&6&-+! 9/&./! 6.! 0-$'&,=! 4&68! 9-.9'-! ;/.%! 68-! &,&6&$'!

+6$=-+@! Q??./0&,=! 6.! )/-,6A! 68&+! 9/.%.6-+! $00&6&.,$'! .:5-?6&<&6(! 68/.*=8.*6! 68-! ?.*/+-! .;! 68-!

9/.?-0*/-@!

!

Page 65: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!X^!

Y$+6'(A! 68&+! :-,?8%$/7! $++-++%-,6! 9/.?-++! &+! .,'(! .,-! 9$/6! .;! $,! -B9$,0-0! &,0-9-,0-,6! 0&/-?6./!

+-'-?6&.,!%-68.0@!F@@-,/+[& '+C)4-&^!9/.<&0-+!$!0-6$&'-0!-B$%9'-!.;!8.4!68-!,*%-/.*+!+*99./6&,=!

$+9-?6+! .;! 68-! -,6&/-! +-'-?6&.,! 9/.?-++!%-,0!4&68! :-,?8%$/7&,=! $++-++%-,6+! 6.! $''.4! ;./! $! ;'*&0A!

;./%$'!+-'-?6&.,!.;!&,0-9-,0-,6!:.$/0!%-%:-/+!.,!;$%&'(!:*+&,-++!:.$/0+!.;!0&/-?6./+@!

!

!766-+3&X)4&O2%-)^P)=X"06B-)FB5R)'("%$)F5%)-X$-%+"B)Q5"%3)0-0Q-%)e=C!f)#-B-'$&5+)?$)43-*<\&(4-,3&h.31$*5&h-4@-3).%&E-D-%$@1-,35&B,"Ad&#33@\mmIIIA@-4@-3).%/-D-%$@1-,3A"$1&&

Page 66: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!XX!

7DD=/>HI)8P)H+$-%,&-R)g2-#$&5++"&%-)

KWEDQUZ!DVW#3Y[!3U#WVEQP3WU!M@ U$%-!.;!?.%9$,(!2@ U$%-!$,0!9.+&6&.,!.;!&,6-/<&-4--!O@ H$6-!;.*,0-0!T@ J&>-!d,*%:-/!.;!-%9'.(--+!;./!?'$++&;&?$6&.,!9*/9.+-+e!^@ D/&%$/(!$,0!+-?.,0$/(!:*+&,-++!.9-/$6&.,!?$6-=./&-+!d/-6$&'A!%$,*;$?6*/&,=A!-6?@e!X@ Z.*,=-+6!=-,-/$6&.,!.;!.4,-/+8&9o!C8$6!&+!68-!?*//-,6!h.9-/$6&,=l!=-,-/$6&.,o!a@ 3+! ;$%&'(! 68-! +.'-! +8$/-8.'0-/! ./! $/-! 68-/-! .68-/! ,.,N;$%&'(! +8$/-8.'0-/+o! 3;! +.A! 48$6!

9-/?-,6$=-!&+!.*6+&0-!.;!68-!;$%&'(o!!`[U[VQY!)WQVH!W#!H3V[KPWVJ!3U#WVEQP3WU!

M@ _.4!%$,(!6&%-+!9-/!(-$/!0.-+!68-!:.$/0!%--6!d=-,-/$''(eo!2@ _.4!&,0-9-,0-,6!&+!68-!?.%9$,(R+!).$/0!.;!H&/-?6./+o!E$(:-!.,!$!+?$'-!;/.%!MNML@!M!:-&,=!

?.%9'-6-'(!0-9-,0-,6!$,0!ML!:-&,=!?.%9'-6-'(!&,0-9-,0-,6@!#*''(!&,0-9-,0-,6!./!$!8-$'68(!%&Bo!_.4!%$,(!&,0-9-,0-,6!0&/-?6./+o!3+!&6!$,!$0<&+./(A!+*9-/<&+./(A!./!?.%:&,$6&.,!.;!68-!64.o!

O@ K.%9$/-0!6.!$=-!.;!:*+&,-++A!48-,!4-/-!&,0-9-,0-,6!0&/-?6./+!;&/+6!&,6/.0*?-0o!T@ _.4!%$,(!0&/-?6./+!&,!6.6$'o!^@ _.4!%$,(!$/-!;$%&'(!0&/-?6./+o!3,6-/,$'!%$,$=-%-,6!0&/-?6./+o!X@ H.!$''!:*+&,-++!.4,-/+!+&6!.,!68-!:.$/0o!

!J[E3NJPVFKPFV[H!~F[JP3WUJ!WU!J[Y[KP3WU!DVWK[JJ!3,&6&$'!H-+&/-!$,0!K$9$?&6(!&,!C8&?8!H&/-?6./!C&''!J-/<-!

M@ _.4s48(!4$+! 68-! &,&6&$'! &0-$! .;! &,0-9-,0-,6! :.$/0!%-%:-/+! ?.,?-&<-0o! #/.%!48-/-! 0&0!68-!&0-$!./&=&,$6-o!

2@ C-/-!68-/-!$,(! &,6-/,$'!./!-B6-/,$'!9/-++*/-+! ;./! 68-! &,;*+&.,!.;! &,0-9-,0-,6!0&/-?6./+o! 3+!68-/-! -<-/! ;$%&'(! %-%:-/! /-+&+6$,?-o! 3;! ;$%&'(! /-+&+6$,?-A! 48$6! $/-! 68-! 6(9&?$'! ?.,?-/,+!:/.*=86!6.!68-!6$:'-o!

O@ C$+!68-!0-+&/-! ;./!-B6-/,$'!0&/-?6./+!+--,!6.4$/0!$,!.<-/+&=86!9.+&6&.,!./!.,-!.;! /-+.*/?-!,--0s+*99'-%-,6$6&.,o!_.4!4$+!68-!,--0-0!/.'-!0-6-/%&,-0o!d.<-/+&=86!.<-/!$0<&?-A!$,0!<&?-!<-/+$e!

T@ Q`[UKZ"!Q,(!9$/6&?*'$/!.<-/+&=86+!&,&6&$''(!6$/=-6-0o!!^@ JP[CQVHJ_3D"!C8(!$!/-+.*/?-!,--0!$,0!48$6!4-/-!68-!/-+.*/?-+!:-&,=!+.*=86o!_.4!4$+!&6!

0-6-/%&,-0!68$6!68-!/-+.*/?-!,--0+!4-/-!UWP!:-&,=!%-6!4&68&,!68-!./=$,&>$6&.,o!!X@ C8-,! $00&,=! &,0-9-,0-,6! %-%:-/+A! &+! 68-! :.$/0! +&%9'(! -B9$,0-0A! $/-! ;$%&'(! %-%:-/+!

$+7-0!6.!=&<-!*9!68-&/!+-$6A!-6?@o!_.4!&+!68&+!0-?&+&.,!%$0-o!!3,&6&$'!J-$/?8!

M@ K$,! (.*! 9/.<&0-! ;./! %-! $! =-,-/$'! &0-$! .;! 68-! 9/.?-++! *+-0! :(! (.*/! ./=$,&>$6&.,! ;./!&,0-9-,0-,6!0&/-?6./!+-'-?6&.,o!

2@ E./-! 0-6$&'-0"! _.4! 0.! (.*! 7&?7! .;;! 68-! &,&6&$'! +-$/?8! 6.! &0-,6&;(! 9.6-,6&$'! ?$,0&0$6-+o!#./%$'s&,;./%$'!9/.?-++o!

O@ C8$6! &+! (.*/! 9/&%$/(! +-$/?8! %-?8$,&+%! $,0! 8.4! $/-! 68-(! *6&'&>-0"! +-$/?8! ?.%%&66--A!?.,+*'6$,6+A!-6?@o!

T@ _.4!0.!(.*/!+-$/?8!9/.?-++-+!0&;;-/A! &;!$6!$''A!48-,!+--7&,=!?$,0&0$6-+! ;./!-&68-/!.<-/+&=86!d$=-,?(!68-./(e!./!$0<&+./(!d+6-4$/0+8&9!68-./(e!/.'-+o!

$@ _.4!0.!(.*!-,+*/-!$!,.,N:&$+-0!&,0&<&0*$'!;./!.<-/+&=86o!:@ C8$6! 7&,0! .;! +-'-?6&.,! 9..'! d+.*/?-+! .;! ?$,0&0$6-+e! &+! *6&'&>-0! ;./! +6-4$/0+8&9!

?$,0&0$6-+o!!

Page 67: Master Thesis - Selection process for independent board members on private family business boards of directors

! ! #$%&'(!)*+&,-++!).$/0+!1!Xa!

J-$/?8!$,0!V-+.*/?-!K.,+&0-/$6&.,+!M@ Q=-,?(!P8-./("!#$%&'(!?.,6/.'!/-'&,S*&+8-0o!j$,0!8.4!&+!&6!8$,0'-0o!2@ J6-4$/0+8&9"!P/*+6!&+!$!7-(!-'-%-,6@!_.4!0.!(.*!+--7!+.%-.,-!68$6!(.*!?$,!6/*+6o!O@ J?8.'$/+! +6/-++! 68$6! ?$,0&0$6-! ?.%9-6-,?(! $,0! 7,.4'-0=-! EFJP! :-! $6! 68-! ;./-;/.,6! .;!

&,0-9-,0-,6! 0&/-?6./! +-'-?6&.,! 9/.?-++-+A! ;.''.4-0! :(! 68-! 9/-;-/-,?-! .;! 9-/+.,$'!?8$/$?6-/&+6&?+!0-+&/-0@!_.4!0.!(.*!-,+*/-!68$6!?$,0&0$6-+!$/-!;*''(!S*$'&;&-0!$,0!68$6!68-/-!&+! $! ?'-$/! +-9$/$6&.,! .;! 9-/+.,$'&6(! 9/-;-/-,?-+! $,0! ?.%9-6-,?(sS*$'&;&?$6&.,+! 68/.*=8.*6!68-!+-'-?6&.,!9/.?-++o!

!K$,0&0$6-!J-'-?6&.,!

M@ C8-,! &6! ?.%-+! 6.! ;&,$'! +-'-?6&.,!.;! ?$,0&0$6-+A!8.4! &%9./6$,6! &+! h9/&./!:.$/0!-B9-/&-,?-l!$,0! 8.4! &+! 68&+! ;$?6./-0! &,6.! 68-! 0-?&+&.,! 9/.?-++o! C8$6! $:.*6! 48-,! &6! &+! ?.%9$/-0! 6.!!h.<-/$''!:*+&,-++!-B9-/&-,?-lo!

2@ C8-,! &6! ?.%-+! 6.! ?/.++N?8-?7&,=! ?$,0&0$6-! S*$'&;&?$6&.,+A! 8.4! 0.-+! (.*/! ./=$,&>$6&.,!=-,-/$''(!9-/;./%!68&+!6$+7o!

O@ 36R+! +*==-+6-0! 68$6! ?$,0&0$6-+! %*+6! %-,0! 4-''! 4&68! 68-! -68&?+! $,0! .<-/$''! ./=$,&>$6&.,$'!+6/*?6*/-!.;!68-!:*+&,-++@!_.4!&+!68&+!0-6-/%&,-0!0*/&,=!68-!+-'-?6&.,!9/.?-++o!

!QHH3P3WUQY!3U#WVEQP3WU!

M@ C8-,!&%9'-%-,6&,=!$,!&,0-9-,0-,6!0&/-?6./A!0.!6-/%!'&%&6+!<$/(!;./!;$%&'(!$,0!&,0-9-,0-,6!0&/-?6./+o!C8$6! $/-! 68-! 6-/%! '-,=68+! $,0! 8.4! $/-! 68-(! 0-6-/%&,-0! ;./! 68-! &,0-9-,0-,6!0&/-?6./o!3;!68-(!0&;;-/!;/.%!;$%&'(A!48(o!

2@ _.4!&+!68-!/-'$6&.,+8&9!:-64--,!?.%9$,(!9-/;./%$,?-!$,0!:.$/0!.;!0&/-?6./!9-/;./%$,?-!0-6-/%&,-0o!Q/-!9-/&.0&?!0&/-?6./!-<$'*$6&.,+!$/-!9$/6!(.*/!?.%9$,(R+!:.$/0!.;!0&/-?6./+o!!

$@ 3;!+.A!$/-!68-+-!-<$'*$6&.,+!9-/;./%-0!$6!$!=/.*9!./!&,0&<&0*$'!'-<-'o!!:@ _.4!$/-!&,0-9-,0-,6A!,.,N;$%&'(!0&/-?6./+!=-,-/$''(!-<$'*$6-0o!

O@ _.4! 4.*'0! (.*! 0-+?/&:-! 68-! -;;-?6&<-,-++! .;! (.*/! :.$/0! 0*-! 6.! 68-! $00&6&.,! .;! -B6-/,$'!0&/-?6./+o!3,!6-/%+!.;!<$'*-N?/-$6&.,o!

!