49
The Midnight Loop The Midnight Loop MassCon 2010 MassCon 2010 G. Heron N2APB & J. Everhart, N2CX G. Heron N2APB & J. Everhart, N2CX Magnetic Loop Cookbook G. Heron, N2APB & J. Everhart, N2CX

MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    11

  • Download
    1

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J. E

ve

rhart

, N

2C

X

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J.

Ev

erh

art

, N

2C

X

Ma

gn

eti

c

Lo

op

Co

ok

bo

ok

G. H

ero

n,

N2A

PB

&

J. E

verh

art

, N

2C

X

Page 2: MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J. E

ve

rhart

, N

2C

X

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J.

Ev

erh

art

, N

2C

X

Ov

erv

iew

Fa

scin

ation

with

ST

Ls:

“Sm

all

Tra

nsm

itting

Ante

nn

as”

• d

ire

ctivity,

se

lectivity,

no

ise

re

du

ctio

n

Com

mo

n lim

ita

tion

s t

od

ay:

• su

rfa

ce

are

a, n

arr

ow

BW

• tu

nin

g, m

ate

ria

ls &

co

nstr

uctio

n, e

ffic

ien

cy

Th

is p

rese

nta

tion

• Is

no

t a

tu

tori

al o

n “

co

nve

ntio

na

l” S

TL d

esig

n

• W

e w

ill im

media

tely

focus o

n p

roble

ms o

f curr

ent desig

ns

• A

nd

pre

se

nt e

xp

erim

en

tal m

eth

od

s fo

r

im

pro

vin

g s

tate

-of-

the

-art

ST

L a

nte

nn

as

Page 3: MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J. E

ve

rhart

, N

2C

X

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J.

Ev

erh

art

, N

2C

X

Ra

dia

tio

n P

att

ern

It’s

lik

e a

do

ug

hn

ut

• V

ert

ica

lly o

rie

nte

d lo

op

giv

es r

ad

iatio

n a

t a

ll ve

rtic

al a

ng

les, a

figure

-8 p

attern

when v

iew

ed fro

m a

bove inclu

din

g N

VIS

thro

ugh

Lo

w a

ng

le r

ad

iatio

n.

• B

est fo

r lo

w e

nd

of H

F e

ve

n w

he

n o

nly

se

ve

ral fe

et a

bo

ve

gro

un

d

• W

he

n o

rie

nte

d h

ori

zo

nta

lly it ra

dia

tes in

a c

ircle

at a

ll a

zim

uth

an

gle

s w

ith

a n

ull

at h

igh

ve

rtic

al a

ng

les.

• B

est a

t th

e u

pp

er

en

d o

f th

e H

F r

an

ge

BU

T m

ust b

e m

ou

nte

d

hig

he

r th

an

a h

alf w

ave

len

gth

ab

ove

gro

un

d.

Page 4: MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J. E

ve

rhart

, N

2C

X

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J.

Ev

erh

art

, N

2C

X

Sm

all

Lo

op

Ba

sic

s

Th

ey lo

ok e

lectr

ically

lik

e a

tu

ne

d c

ircu

it w

he

re t

he

ind

ucto

r

is a

la

rge

loo

p w

ith

a c

ircu

mfe

ren

ce

of

ab

out

1/1

0

wave

len

gth

• 4

0m

~ 4

.5' d

ia.

• 2

0m

~ 2

.2' d

ia.

• 1

0m

~ 1

.1' d

ia.

• B

ut u

p to

¼ w

ave

is u

sa

ble

• T

un

ed

by a

ca

pa

cito

r a

t th

e lo

op

en

ds

• V

ari

ab

le c

ap

use

d fo

r tu

na

bili

ty

• M

atc

hin

g m

ea

ns n

ee

de

d fo

r 5

0 o

hm

fe

ed

Page 5: MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J. E

ve

rhart

, N

2C

X

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J.

Ev

erh

art

, N

2C

X

Sm

all

Lo

op

Eq

uiv

ale

nt

Cir

cu

it

Mat

ch

RR

AD

RL

OS

S

L

C

Copper

Loop

3 F

t D

ia.

1/2

in.

tub

ing

L =

2.5

uH

C =

52

pf

RR

AD

=

.0

65

Ω

RLO

SS =

.0

Q =

810

BW

= 1

7 k

Hz

VC

AP =

94

3v @

5W

Page 6: MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J. E

ve

rhart

, N

2C

X

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J.

Ev

erh

art

, N

2C

X

Sm

all

Lo

op

De

sig

n E

qu

ati

on

s

• R

ad

iati

on

Resis

tan

ce -

oh

ms

RR

= 3

.38

x 1

0-8

x (

F2 x

A)

2 !!

!!!!

!!!!

!!!!

• L

oss R

esis

tan

ce -

oh

ms

RL

= 9

.96

x 1

0-4

x s

qrt

(F)

x S

/ D

• E

ffic

ien

cy -

%

Eff

= R

R x

10

0 /

(R

R +

RL

)

• I

nd

ucta

nce -

uH

L =

1.9

x 1

0-8

x S

x (

1.2

e-.1

36

S +

.8

1)

x (

7.3

53

x l

og

10

(9

6 x

S/(Π

x D

) –

6.3

86

0)

• Q

(lo

ad

ed

)

QL =

2 x

Π x

F /

(2 x

(R

R +

RL)

)

• B

an

dw

idth

- k

Hz

BW

= F

/ Q

L

F =

Fre

q (

MH

z), A

= L

oo

p A

rea

(ft)

, D

= C

on

d. D

ia.

(in),

Fo

r a c

ircu

lar

loo

p w

ith

a t

ub

ula

r co

pp

er

co

nd

ucto

r in

fre

e s

pace …

Page 7: MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J. E

ve

rhart

, N

2C

X

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J.

Ev

erh

art

, N

2C

X

aa5

tb_lo

op

_v

1.2

2a

.xls

Ca

lcu

lato

r

Au

tom

ate

s l

oo

p d

esig

n a

nd

“w

hat-

ifs”

Page 8: MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J. E

ve

rhart

, N

2C

X

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J.

Ev

erh

art

, N

2C

X

Min

imiz

ing

Co

nd

uc

tor

Lo

ss

Lo

ss E

ffic

ien

cy a

nd B

an

dw

idth

vs T

ub

ing

siz

e

** 3

” A

l co

nd

ucto

r o

nly

1 d

B loss

M

idnig

ht

Loop d

esig

n g

oal

C

opper

A

lum

inum

Dia

- in

R

r -

R

L -

E

ff -

%

L -

uH

B

W -

kH

z

R

r -

R

L -

E

ff -

%

L -

uH

B

W -

kH

z

0.5

64.9

71.2

48

2.5

17.3

64.9

112

36.6

2.5

22.6

1

64.9

35.1

64.9

2.1

15.2

64.9

56.1

53.6

2.1

18.4

2

64.9

17.6

78.7

1.7

15.5

64.9

28.1

69.8

1.7

17.4

3

64.9

11.7

84.7

1.5

16.6

64.9

18.7

81 *

* 1.5

17.4

4

64.9

8.8

88.1

1.3

18

64.9

14.1

82.2

1.3

19.3

Page 9: MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J. E

ve

rhart

, N

2C

X

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J.

Ev

erh

art

, N

2C

X

Oth

er

Lo

ss F

acto

rs

Con

nectio

ns n

eed

ca

refu

l a

tte

ntion

• A

ny m

ech

an

ica

l co

nn

ectio

n is lo

ssy

• J

oin

ts n

ee

d to

be

so

lde

red

or

we

lde

d

Th

e t

un

ing

ca

pacito

r is

critica

l

• R

ota

ry tu

nin

g c

ap

ne

ed

s b

est in

su

latio

n

• C

era

mic

vs p

henolic

• L

ow

est lo

ss d

iele

ctr

ic if u

se

d

• R

ota

ry jo

ints

ge

ne

rally

ba

d

• M

easure

d s

evera

l m

Ω t

o 2

0 m

Ω

• C

hanges e

ach t

ime r

etu

ned

• U

su

al ch

oic

es a

re tro

mb

on

e, sp

lit s

tato

r o

r va

cu

um

va

ria

ble

Page 10: MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J. E

ve

rhart

, N

2C

X

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J.

Ev

erh

art

, N

2C

X

Eff

icie

ncy C

on

tro

vers

y

Pro

f M

ike

Un

de

rhil

l G

3L

HZ

ha

s c

ha

llen

ged

esta

blis

he

d

loop d

esig

n t

heory

cla

imin

g v

ery

sm

all

loop e

ffic

iency is

actu

ally

ma

ny d

B g

rea

ter

tha

n c

laim

ed

(R

ef

8).

Note

d a

nte

nn

a e

xp

ert

Jo

hn

Be

lro

se

VE

2C

V h

as

counte

red w

ith N

EC

ante

nna m

odelin

g a

nd r

eal-

world

me

asu

rem

en

ts u

pho

ldin

g t

he

esta

blis

he

d m

ea

ns o

f

de

rivin

g s

ma

ll lo

op

effic

ien

cy.

H

e c

on

clu

des t

ha

t G

3L

HZ

use

d f

law

ed

exp

erim

en

tal d

ata

an

d r

ea

so

nin

g t

o u

ph

old

his

unort

hodox v

iew

s (

Ref 9,1

0).

Page 11: MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J. E

ve

rhart

, N

2C

X

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J.

Ev

erh

art

, N

2C

X

Mid

nig

ht

Lo

op

Lo

ss A

pp

roa

ch

Use a

larg

e f

lat

con

ducto

r

• A

lum

inu

m fla

sh

ing

• E

stim

ate

d lo

ss s

imila

r to

3”

tub

ing

• R

ef 7

giv

es ju

stifica

tio

n fo

r fla

t co

nd

ucto

r

Ends o

f lo

op a

re o

verlapped t

o m

ake c

apacitor

• C

om

ple

tely

jo

intle

ss c

on

str

uctio

n

• T

un

ed

by v

ary

ing

pla

te s

pa

cin

g

• A

ir d

iele

ctr

ic fo

r sm

all

C

• L

ow

loss T

eflon for

hig

her

C

Page 12: MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J. E

ve

rhart

, N

2C

X

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J.

Ev

erh

art

, N

2C

X

Mid

nig

ht

Lo

op

as

Eq

uiv

to

3 i

n d

ia.

Tu

bin

g

Page 13: MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J. E

ve

rhart

, N

2C

X

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J.

Ev

erh

art

, N

2C

X

Op

tim

um

Tu

nin

g M

eth

od

Hig

h Q

ma

ke

s t

un

ing

difficu

lt

• M

an

ua

l tu

nin

g to

uch

y

• H

an

d p

roxim

ity c

au

se

s d

etu

nin

g

Ob

vio

us s

olu

tio

n is t

o m

oto

rize

But tu

nin

g c

an s

till

be t

ouchy

• H

igh

ge

ar

ratio

ne

ed

ed

• T

un

ing

to

pe

ak n

ois

e ta

ke

s s

kill

• W

atc

hin

g S

WR

me

ter

eve

n w

ors

e

Mid

nig

ht

loo

p t

arg

et

ap

pro

ach

is a

use

r-fr

ien

dly

vis

ua

l d

ispla

y

Page 14: MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J. E

ve

rhart

, N

2C

X

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J.

Ev

erh

art

, N

2C

X

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

An E

xperim

enta

l, H

igh-e

ffic

iency,

Gra

phic

-Tunable

Magnetic L

oop

PIC

Att

en

Spot

Tra

nsceiv

er

Sp

ectr

og

rap

h

NU

E-P

SK

(or

PC

w/R

ocky)

Lo

op

Co

ntr

oller

RF

Sam

ple

r

Head

Tu

nin

g

Cap

RF

Feed

po

int

RF

Sam

plin

g

An

ten

na

(PA

C-1

2)

Inte

gra

ted in

Loop(?

)

Op

era

tin

g P

rin

cp

les

1)

While

in

Rx m

ode,

vie

w s

pectr

um

on s

pectr

ogra

phic

dis

pla

y, as d

eliv

ere

d f

rom

RF

Sam

ple

r S

DR

2)

Fin

d s

ignals

of

inte

rest

(or

quie

t are

a)

by m

ovin

g c

urs

or

alo

ng s

pectr

ogra

ph

3)

Pre

ss “

Spot”

on C

ontr

ol U

nit to k

ey X

cvr.

P

IC p

laces A

TT

EN

in

lin

e t

o d

eliv

er

QR

ppp

sig

nal to

Loop ,

whic

h is d

ete

cte

d b

y R

F S

am

ple

r S

DR

and d

eliv

ere

d b

ack t

o s

pectr

ogra

phic

dis

pla

y

to s

how

curr

ent

opera

tin

g f

requency o

f th

e L

oop

4)

PIC

drives L

oop c

apacitor

to r

e-t

une L

oop r

esonance t

o d

esired c

urs

or

location (

frequency).

5)

PIC

sw

itches A

ttenuato

r out

of

circuit, re

moves p

ow

er

from

Sam

plin

g S

DR

, drives T

ransceiv

er

to t

he

frequency o

f th

e c

urs

or

in t

he s

pectr

ogra

hic

dis

pla

y,

and u

ser

begin

s o

pera

tin

g p

er

norm

al.

PV

C

Su

pp

ort

Fra

mew

ork

10”-w

ide

Alu

min

um

Fla

sh

ing

So

ftro

ck

+ S

DR

(R

eceiv

e-o

nly

)

Up /

Dow

n

Drive

RF

Locate

CA

T

RF

Page 15: MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J. E

ve

rhart

, N

2C

X

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J.

Ev

erh

art

, N

2C

X

Lo

op

Co

ntr

oller

Page 16: MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J. E

ve

rhart

, N

2C

X

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J.

Ev

erh

art

, N

2C

X

Lo

op

Co

ntr

oller

M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p C

on

tro

lle

r c

on

sis

ts o

f …

1)

Se

lft-

co

nta

ine

d b

att

ery

fo

r p

ow

eri

ng

Lo

op

ca

pac

ito

r tu

nin

g m

oto

r;

2)

“U

p/D

ow

n” S

wit

ch

(re

d)

for

ma

nu

all

y t

un

ing

Lo

op

;

3)

Rela

y s

wit

ch

ing

in

/ou

t 7

0W

du

mm

y l

oa

d a

nd

N7V

E S

WR

In

dic

ati

on

cir

cu

it

Page 17: MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J. E

ve

rhart

, N

2C

X

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J.

Ev

erh

art

, N

2C

X

SD

R S

pectr

um

Tu

nin

g U

nit

So

ftR

ock

Receiv

er

(20m

)

+12V

PA

C-1

2

Sam

plin

g

An

ten

na

I Q

eZ

DS

P

(Dem

odula

tor)

+5V

US

B A

ud

io

to N

UE

-PS

K M

od

em

for

sp

ectr

um

dis

pla

y

of

ban

d a

cti

vit

y

Si5

70

Clo

ck G

en

era

tor

& D

isp

lay

+12V

Ro

tary

En

co

der 4x R

eceiv

er

Fre

qu

en

cy

(~56 M

Hz)

Page 18: MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J. E

ve

rhart

, N

2C

X

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J.

Ev

erh

art

, N

2C

X

SD

R S

pectr

um

Tu

nin

g U

nit

NU

E-P

SK

Dig

ital

Mo

de

m (

up

per

left

)

Sp

ectr

um

dis

pla

y o

f S

DR

ou

tpu

t u

se

d to

dis

pla

y b

an

d a

ctivity o

uts

ide

th

e n

arr

ow

ba

nd

wid

th o

ffe

red b

y t

he

mid

nig

ht L

oo

p.

SD

R T

un

ing

Co

ntr

olle

r (l

ow

er

rig

ht)

So

ftR

ock v

5.0

(le

ft)

so

ftw

are

de

fined r

eceiv

er,

eZ

DS

P s

tart

er

kit r

un

nin

g N

UE

-SD

R v

0.5

so

ftw

are

an

d

Si5

70

Con

trolle

r &

Fre

qu

en

cy G

en

era

tor

on

fro

nt p

an

el

Page 19: MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J. E

ve

rhart

, N

2C

X

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J.

Ev

erh

art

, N

2C

X

Th

e S

tati

on

Clo

ckw

ise …

Yae

su

’s F

T-8

17 Q

RP

tra

nsc

eiv

er

NU

E-P

SK

Dig

ital

Mo

de

m (

for

sp

ec

tru

m d

isp

lay)

Mid

nig

ht

Lo

op

Sp

ec

tru

m T

un

ing

Co

ntr

olle

r

Mid

nig

ht

Lo

op

Co

ntr

olle

r

Rea

r vie

w o

f s

tati

on

sh

ow

ing

ca

ble

in

terc

on

nec

ts

Page 20: MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J. E

ve

rhart

, N

2C

X

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J.

Ev

erh

art

, N

2C

X

In O

pera

tio

n

Mid

nig

ht

Lo

op

sta

nd

ing

ato

p t

hre

e-f

oo

t s

no

w in

Ma

ryla

nd

Page 21: MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J. E

ve

rhart

, N

2C

X

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J.

Ev

erh

art

, N

2C

X

In O

pera

tio

n

N2A

PB

at

the

op

era

tin

g p

osit

ion

of

the M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p s

tati

on

in

sn

ow

bo

un

d M

ary

lan

d.

Page 22: MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J. E

ve

rhart

, N

2C

X

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J.

Ev

erh

art

, N

2C

X

Co

mp

ara

tive F

ield

Testi

ng

T

esting u

nder

care

fully

contr

olle

d c

onditio

ns to c

om

pa

re the M

idnig

ht Loop to the M

FJ L

oop

Need

fla

t are

a f

ree o

f tr

ees, au

tos, fe

nces, p

eo

ple

, p

ole

s, etc

. at

least

300 f

eet

lon

g a

nd

200 f

eet

wid

e. P

refe

rab

ly, cle

ar

are

a s

ho

uld

be

mo

re t

han

tw

ice t

hese d

imen

sio

ns w

ith

no

thin

g h

igh

er

than

a c

ou

ple

of

feet

to a

vo

id u

nw

an

ted

refl

ecti

on

s o

r ab

so

rpti

on

of

RF

en

erg

y.

In a

dd

itio

n t

here

can

be n

o t

ran

sm

itte

rs, la

rge e

lectr

ic m

oto

rs, p

ow

er

su

bsta

tio

ns, p

ow

er

lin

es, o

r o

ther

RF

in

terf

ere

nce s

ou

rces w

ith

in 1

/4

mile.

Th

is t

esti

ng

in

vo

lves s

ett

ing

up

a f

lat

measu

rem

en

t are

a w

ith

no

ob

str

ucti

on

s s

uch

as t

rees, h

ou

ses, h

ills

, cars

, etc

to

do

th

e

test.

Th

e a

nte

nn

a u

nd

er

test

is s

et

at

a m

easu

red

dis

tan

ce, say 1

00

feet

fro

m a

3 f

t w

hip

ov

er

a 3

ft

gro

un

d p

late

. It

is o

rien

ted

vert

ically.

Th

e t

est

an

ten

na h

as its

base a

t ab

ou

t 3 f

t ab

ov

e g

rou

nd

wh

ile

the 1

mete

r w

hip

is a

bo

ut

4-1

/2 f

eet

ab

ov

e g

rou

nd

.

A t

ran

sm

itte

r is

co

nn

ecte

d t

o t

he a

nte

nn

a u

nd

er

test

an

d its

ou

tpu

t care

fully m

easu

red

. T

he 3

fo

ot

wh

ip is c

on

necte

d t

o a

test

receiv

er.

T

he latt

er

has t

o b

e c

ap

ab

le o

f m

easu

rin

g lo

w

sig

nal le

vels

to

wit

hin

0.5

dB

or

so

rep

eata

bly

. E

ith

er

a

sp

ectr

um

an

aly

zer

or

calib

rate

d t

est

receiv

er

is b

est.

It

may b

e

po

ssib

le t

o u

se t

he H

ayw

ard

mic

row

att

mete

r w

ith

a s

harp

ban

dp

ass f

ilte

r.

Fir

st

the M

FJ lo

op

is s

et

up

as t

he t

est

an

ten

na a

nd

th

e

tran

sm

itte

r is

en

ab

led

. T

he s

ign

al at

the 3

ft

wh

ip is m

easu

red

as t

he M

FJ lo

op

is r

ota

ted

. R

eceiv

ed

sig

nal m

easu

rem

en

ts a

re

mad

e a

90 d

eg

ree in

cre

men

ts. Id

eally 0

deg

rees w

ill b

e w

ith

the lo

op

axis

po

inte

d in

th

e d

irecti

on

of

the w

hip

.

Next

the M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p is s

et

up

as t

he a

nte

nn

a u

nd

er

test

an

d

the a

bo

ve s

eq

uen

ce o

f m

easu

rem

en

ts is r

ep

eate

d.

Fin

ally t

he M

FJ lo

op

is u

sed

fo

r a s

eco

nd

set

up

measu

rem

en

ts t

o a

ssu

re r

ep

eata

bilit

y.

All m

easu

rem

en

ts s

ho

uld

be p

erf

orm

ed

wit

hin

a c

ou

ple

ho

ur

peri

od

wit

h w

eath

er,

tem

pera

ture

, etc

. re

main

ing

rela

tiv

ely

co

nsta

nt.

To

p V

iew

:

Sid

e V

iew

:

Page 23: MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J. E

ve

rhart

, N

2C

X

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J.

Ev

erh

art

, N

2C

X

Co

mp

ara

tive F

ield

Testi

ng

T

he P

hysic

al S

etu

p

Page 24: MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J. E

ve

rhart

, N

2C

X

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J.

Ev

erh

art

, N

2C

X

Co

mp

ara

tive F

ield

Testi

ng

R

es

ult

s &

Ob

se

rva

tio

ns

Mar

8, 2010

Fo

rest

Hill, M

D

Tim

e

Fre

q

(MH

z)

SW

R

Xm

it P

wr

(Watt

s)

Batt

ery

(Vo

lts)

Rx N

ois

e

(dB

m)

Rx S

ign

al

(dB

m)

2:4

4 P

M14.0

80

1.9

0.4

12.4

-67

-24.6

2:5

7 P

M14.0

96

1.9

0.4

-64

-42.1

3:0

2 P

M14.0

96

1.9

0.4

-64

-24.6

3:2

5 P

M14.0

21.5

.3/.4

-59

-24

3:3

8 A

M14.0

46

1.5

.3/.4

12V

-60

-43

3:4

5 P

M14.1

1.8

0.4

11.5

V-6

8-2

3.1

A

ppare

nt lo

wer

transm

it p

ow

er

mig

ht yi

eld

even h

igher

eff

icie

ncy f

or

Mid

nig

ht Loop.

4. S

tronger

receiv

ed s

ignal fr

om

Mid

nig

ht Loop s

uggests

hig

her

eff

icie

ncy than the

M

FJ loop, on the o

rder

of

1 d

B.

5. M

idnig

ht Loop a

lso s

how

s d

eep n

ull

when b

roadsid

e, su

ggesting low

feedlin

e r

adia

tion.

6. T

ransm

it p

ow

er

cannot be a

ccura

tely

accounte

d f

or

sin

ce m

easure

ment re

solu

tion w

as 0

.1 W

.

No

tes:

1. A

ppro

x 4

0 d

b S

/N r

atio a

t re

ceiv

e e

nd m

eans test data

not conta

min

ate

d b

y n

ois

e

2. 17 d

B n

ull

with M

FJ loop 9

0 d

eg. tr

ansm

issio

n p

ath

indic

ate

s little o

r no loop f

eedlin

e r

adia

tion.

3. Id

entical re

ceiv

ed s

ignals

when M

FJ loop turn

ed 1

80 d

eg. S

how

s g

ood p

attern

sym

metr

y.

Test

3:

MF

J L

oop r

ota

ted 1

80 d

eg. C

W

Test

4:

Mid

nig

ht Loop o

riente

d tow

ard

receiv

e a

nte

nna

Test

5:

Mid

nig

ht Loop r

ota

ted 9

0 d

eg. C

W

Test

6:

Mid

nig

ht Loop r

ota

ted 1

80 d

eg. C

W

Co

mp

ara

tiv

e L

oo

p A

nte

nn

a T

ests

Weath

er:

cle

ar,

about 50-d

egF

sunny w

ith a

lig

ht w

ind

Test

1:

MF

J L

oop o

riente

d tow

ard

receiv

e a

nte

nna

Test

2:

MF

J L

oop r

ota

ted 9

0 d

eg. C

W

Page 25: MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J. E

ve

rhart

, N

2C

X

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J.

Ev

erh

art

, N

2C

X

Perf

orm

an

ce

MF

J L

oo

p …

. B

W ~

30

kH

z

MF

J L

oo

p

Page 26: MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J. E

ve

rhart

, N

2C

X

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J.

Ev

erh

art

, N

2C

X

Perf

orm

an

ce

Mid

nig

ht

Lo

op

…. B

W ~

50

kH

z

Mid

nig

ht

Lo

op (

gro

un

d-m

ou

nte

d)

Page 27: MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J. E

ve

rhart

, N

2C

X

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J.

Ev

erh

art

, N

2C

X

Perf

orm

an

ce

Mid

nig

ht

Lo

op

…. B

W ~

20

kH

z

Mid

nig

ht

Lo

op (

mo

un

ted

at

30

fee

t)

10 k

Hz s

can

ste

p s

ize

skip

ped

ov

er

reso

nan

ce f

req

uen

cy

Page 28: MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J. E

ve

rhart

, N

2C

X

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J.

Ev

erh

art

, N

2C

X

Perf

orm

an

ce

Mid

nig

ht

Lo

op

…. B

W ~

40

kH

z

Mid

nig

ht

Lo

op (

mo

un

ted

at

30

fee

t)

Page 29: MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J. E

ve

rhart

, N

2C

X

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J.

Ev

erh

art

, N

2C

X

Perf

orm

an

ce

Mid

nig

ht

Lo

op

…. B

W ~

20

kH

z

Mid

nig

ht

Lo

op (

mo

un

ted

at

30

fee

t)

Page 30: MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J. E

ve

rhart

, N

2C

X

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J.

Ev

erh

art

, N

2C

X

Perf

orm

an

ce

Mid

nig

ht

Lo

op

…. B

W ~

30

kH

z

Mid

nig

ht

Lo

op (

mo

un

ted

at

30

fee

t)

Page 31: MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J. E

ve

rhart

, N

2C

X

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J.

Ev

erh

art

, N

2C

X

De

mo

Liv

e D

em

o

an

d/o

r

Vid

eo

Page 32: MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J. E

ve

rhart

, N

2C

X

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J.

Ev

erh

art

, N

2C

X

Next

Ste

ps

• M

ore

fie

ld m

easure

ments

• E

mp

iric

ally

de

term

ine

RLO

SS

• T

ry c

op

pe

r in

ste

ad

of

alu

min

um

• In

tegra

te s

am

plin

g a

nte

nna

• In

teg

rate

con

tro

ller

Page 33: MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J. E

ve

rhart

, N

2C

X

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J.

Ev

erh

art

, N

2C

X

Ap

pen

dix

• B

ackg

rou

nd

Lite

ratu

re

• R

efe

ren

ce

s

• C

on

str

uctio

n D

eta

ils

Page 34: MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J. E

ve

rhart

, N

2C

X

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J.

Ev

erh

art

, N

2C

X

Lo

op

An

aly

sis

Calc

ula

tors

1)

aa

5tb

_lo

op

_v1

.22

a.x

ls c

alc

ula

tor

Go

od

ov

eral

l ca

lcu

lato

r.

Do

es n

ot

acco

un

t fo

r gro

un

d l

oss

, h

and

les

on

ly r

ou

nd l

oo

ps –

wo

rks

wit

h O

pen

Off

ice

as w

ell

as

MS

Ex

cel.

htt

p:/

/ww

w.a

a5tb

.co

m/a

a5tb

_lo

op

_v

1.2

2a.

xls

2)

KI6

GD

calc

ula

tor

Mo

re g

ener

al t

han

th

e A

A5

TB

cal

cula

tor.

htt

p:/

/ww

w.m

agn

etic

loo

pan

ten

na.

com

/lo

op

calc

.zip

3)

G4

FG

Q C

alc

ula

tors

Nu

mer

ou

s D

OS

cal

cula

tor

pro

gra

ms

incl

ud

ing s

ever

al f

or

smal

l lo

op

s. H

and

les

man

y m

ore

par

amet

ers

than

ab

ov

e

calc

ula

tors

, th

ou

gh

we

hav

e n

ot

ver

ifie

d a

ccu

racy

. h

ttp

://w

ww

.zer

ob

eat.

net

/G4

FG

Q/p

age3

.htm

l

Re

fere

nc

es

(1

of 5

)

Page 35: MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J. E

ve

rhart

, N

2C

X

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J.

Ev

erh

art

, N

2C

X

Re

fere

nc

es

(2

of 5

)

Sele

cte

d S

mall T

ran

sm

itti

ng

Lo

op

s i

n r

ad

io a

mate

ur

pu

blicati

on

s:

1)

Th

e A

rmy

Lo

op

in

Ha

m C

om

mu

nic

ati

on

, L

. M

cCo

y W

1IC

P,

QS

T M

ar

19

68

pp

17

-18

, 1

50

Lo

op

an

ten

nas

des

ign

ed f

or

NV

IS (

Nea

r V

erti

cal

Inci

den

ce S

ign

alin

g)

bu

ilt

by t

he

US

Arm

y f

or

use

in

Vie

tnam

. N

VIS

ch

arac

teri

stic

pro

vid

ed n

eed

ed c

lose

-in

co

mm

un

icat

ion

s at

th

e lo

w e

nd

of

the

HF

ban

d a

nd

av

oid

ed h

igh

sig

nal

lo

ss f

rom

ju

ngle

fo

liag

e.

AR

RL

staf

fer

du

pli

cati

on r

esult

ed i

n a

n a

dm

itte

dly

loss

y a

nte

nna

that

was

sti

ll q

uit

e usa

ble

.

2)

Sm

all

Hig

h-E

ffic

ien

cy L

oo

p A

nte

nn

as,

Ted

Ha

rt W

5Q

JR

, Q

ST

J

an

19

86

Har

t d

ocu

men

ted

th

e d

esig

n o

f m

agn

etic

lo

op

s w

ith

a s

et o

f su

ccin

ct e

qu

atio

ns

in t

his

pie

ce.

It

sh

ow

ed h

ow

su

cces

sfu

l lo

op

s co

uld

be

bu

ilt

wit

h p

red

icta

ble

, re

pea

tab

le p

erfo

rman

ce.

Mat

eria

l fr

om

th

is a

rtic

le a

lso

ap

pea

rs i

n r

ecen

t A

RR

L R

ad

io A

ma

teu

r H

an

db

oo

ks a

nd

AR

RL

An

ten

na

Bo

oks

.

3)

Lo

op

Bo

ok

, T

ed H

art

W5

QJ

R A

nte

nn

ex –

ww

w.a

nte

nn

ex.c

om

\ A

va

ila

ble

by

pu

rch

ase

on

ly

An

ex

pan

ded

tre

atm

ent

of

smal

l lo

op

an

d r

elat

ed a

nte

nn

as w

ell

wo

rth

pu

rch

asin

g b

y s

erio

us

loo

p e

xp

erim

ente

rs.

4)

Tra

nsm

itti

ng S

hort

Loop A

nte

nn

as

for

the

HF

Ban

ds,

Rob

erto

Cra

igh

ero I

1A

RZ

, C

om

mu

nic

ati

on

s Q

ua

rter

ly 1

99

3

Su

mm

er/A

utu

mn

A t

ho

rou

gh

des

crip

tio

n o

f h

ow

to

mak

e a

ver

y e

ffic

ien

t, r

emo

tely

tu

nab

le s

mal

l tr

ansm

itti

ng l

oo

p.

5)

An

Up

da

te o

n C

om

pa

ct T

ran

smit

tin

g L

oo

ps,

J.

S. B

elro

se V

E2

CV

, Q

ST

No

v 1

99

3,

pp

37

-40

Go

od

tre

atm

ent

of

loo

p a

nte

nn

as a

nd

th

eir

char

acte

rist

ics

wit

h N

EC

mo

del

ing d

ata

and

mea

sure

men

ts t

o e

val

uat

e p

erfo

rman

ce.

Bel

rose

is

an e

min

entl

y q

ual

ifie

d y

et p

ract

ical

an

ten

na

exp

ert

wh

o h

as w

ritt

en m

any c

lass

ic a

nte

nn

a ar

ticl

es i

n r

adio

am

ateu

r li

tera

ture

.

6)

Per

form

an

ce o

f E

lect

rica

lly

Sm

all

Tra

nsm

itti

ng

Lo

op

An

ten

na

s, J

. S

. B

elro

se V

E2

CV

, P

art

I, R

ad

Co

m,

pp

. 6

4-6

7,

Pa

rt I

I,

Ra

dC

om

, p

p. 88-9

8, Ju

ne/

Ju

ly 2

004

Up

dat

ed a

nd

ex

pan

ded

sm

all

tran

smit

tin

g l

oo

p d

ata

wit

h a

dd

itio

nal

NE

C m

od

elin

g a

nd

su

pp

ort

ing a

nte

nn

a ra

nge

mea

sure

men

t d

ata.

7)

Res

ista

nce

of

Fo

il C

on

du

cto

rs F

or

An

ten

na

s, R

ud

y S

ever

ns

N6

LF

, Q

EX

Ma

y/J

un

e 2

00

2 T

ech

No

tes

Just

ific

atio

n f

or

the

use

of

wid

e, t

hin

fo

ils

as l

ow

lo

ss c

on

du

cto

rs f

or

ante

nn

as.

Res

ult

s o

f co

mp

ute

r m

od

elin

g s

ho

w t

hat

“cu

rren

t

cro

wd

ing”

at t

he

edge

of

wid

e co

nd

uct

ors

off

ers

sign

ific

antl

y l

ess

loss

th

an h

as b

een

po

pu

larl

y t

ho

ugh

t.

Page 36: MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J. E

ve

rhart

, N

2C

X

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J.

Ev

erh

art

, N

2C

X

Sm

all L

oo

p A

nte

nn

a C

on

tro

vers

y

8)

Th

e T

ruth

abou

t L

oops,

Mik

e U

nd

erH

ill,

G3L

HZ

, R

SG

B I

nte

rnati

on

al A

nte

nn

a C

oll

ecti

on

, 2

00

3

In t

his

pap

er a

nd

sev

eral

oth

ers

Mik

e U

nd

erh

ill

and

Ele

ctri

cal

En

gin

eeri

ng p

rofe

sso

r cl

aim

ed t

hat

cu

rren

t th

eory

an

d d

escr

ipti

on

s o

f

the

effi

cien

cy a

nd

rad

iati

ng e

ffec

tiv

enes

s is

fla

wed

. H

e cl

aim

s th

at c

rite

ria

use

d t

o e

val

uat

e th

is t

yp

e o

f an

ten

na

is i

nco

rrec

t an

d c

an

lead

to

dis

crep

anci

es i

n e

ffic

ien

cy o

f u

p t

o 3

0 d

B.

9)

Tru

th a

nd

Un

tru

th, J

. S

. B

elro

se V

E2

CV

, P

rese

nte

d a

t th

e Q

CW

A 2

00

4 I

nte

rnat

ion

al C

on

ven

tio

n, A

mat

eur

Rad

io T

ech

nic

al

Ses

sio

n, F

rid

ay,

Oct

ob

er 1

5,

hel

d a

t th

e L

ord

Elg

in H

ote

l, O

ttaw

a, O

N C

anad

a –

av

aila

ble

at

htt

p:/

/qcw

a70

.org

/tru

th a

nd

un

tru

th.p

df

10

) C

om

pact

Loops

Re-

visi

ted,

J.

S.

Bel

rose

VE

2C

V, A

nte

nn

ex O

nli

ne

Magazi

ne,

Ma

r 2

00

1 i

ssu

e (1

3-p

ag

e a

rtic

le)

av

ail

ab

le b

y

pa

id s

ub

scri

pti

on

on

ly

No

ted

ex

per

t Ja

ck B

elro

se r

efu

tes

the

clai

ms

of

Mik

e U

nd

erh

ill

abo

ut

per

form

ance

of

smal

l lo

op

an

ten

nas

an

d p

rese

nts

cre

dib

le

mo

del

ing a

nd

tes

t d

ata

to u

ph

old

th

e tr

adit

ion

al m

eth

od

s fo

r ef

fici

ency

an

d e

ffec

tiv

enes

s ca

lcu

lati

on

s in

Ref

s 9

an

d 1

0.

Re

fere

nc

es

(3

of 5

)

Page 37: MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J. E

ve

rhart

, N

2C

X

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J.

Ev

erh

art

, N

2C

X

Co

ntr

ol, S

oft

ware

an

d E

lec

tro

nic

s

1)

An

SW

R N

ull

Met

er,

Pa

ul

Ch

rist

ense

n, W

9A

C, Q

ST

Feb

rua

ry 2

01

0,

pp

30

-32

.

Des

crib

es a

co

nv

enie

nt

tech

niq

ue

for

on

-th

e-ai

r tu

nin

g t

hat

pro

vid

es o

nly

ver

y l

ow

tra

nsm

itte

d p

ow

er l

evel

s. T

his

ap

pro

ach

was

uti

lize

d i

n t

he

Mid

nig

ht

Lo

op

Co

ntr

oll

er.

2)

N7

VE

LE

D S

WR

In

dic

ato

r

Dan

Tay

loe,

N7

VE

des

ign

ed a

sim

ple

an

d c

on

ven

ien

t ab

sorp

tiv

e S

WR

in

dic

atin

g c

ircu

it s

om

e yea

rs a

go

, u

sed

in

th

e N

orC

al B

LT

tun

er k

it (

htt

p:/

/ww

w.n

orc

alq

rp.o

rg/n

orc

al_

blt

.htm

), a

nd

oth

er p

lace

s.

We

use

d t

his

cir

cuit

in

th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p C

on

tro

ller

.

3)

So

ftR

ock

SD

R, T

on

y P

ark

s K

B9

YIG

As

a b

asis

fo

r th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p’s

“so

ftw

are

def

ined

rad

io s

amp

lin

g h

ead

”, w

e u

sed t

he

po

pu

lar

and

in

exp

ensi

ve

So

ftR

ock

SD

R

circ

uit

s d

esig

ned

an

d p

rod

uce

d b

y T

on

y P

ark

s, K

B9

YIG

. S

ee h

is w

ebsi

te (

htt

p:/

/ww

w.k

b9

yig

.co

m/)

to

vie

w h

is c

om

ple

te l

ine

of

So

ftR

ock

rec

eiv

ers,

tra

nsm

itte

rs,

tran

scei

ver

s an

d a

cces

sori

es.

4)

NU

E-S

DR

So

ftw

are

ver

sio

n 0

.5,

M.C

ram

W8

NU

E

Th

e gen

esis

of

the

stan

dal

on

e D

SP

so

ftw

are

call

ed “

NU

E-S

DR

”, d

evel

op

ed b

y M

ilt

Cra

m, W

8N

UE

, w

ritt

en f

or

the

Tex

as

Inst

rum

ents

“eZ

DS

P S

tick

” p

latf

orm

(h

ttp

://f

ocu

s.ti

.co

m/d

ocs

/to

ols

w/f

old

ers/

pri

nt/

tmd

sezd

28

12

.htm

l)

5)

NU

E-P

SK

Dig

ita

l M

od

em, M

.Cra

m W

8N

UE

an

d G

.Her

on

N2

AP

B

Th

e sp

ectr

um

dis

pla

y o

f th

e N

UE

-PS

K m

od

em w

as e

ffec

tiv

ely u

sed

in

th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p t

un

ing s

yst

em t

o d

isp

lay b

and

act

ivit

y

ou

tsid

e th

e v

iew

of

the

nar

row

-BW

lo

op

. (h

ttp

://w

ww

.nu

e-p

sk.c

om

/)

6)

Si5

70

Co

ntr

oll

er &

Fre

qu

ency

Gen

era

tor,

Kee

s T

ale

n K

5B

CQ

an

d J

oh

n F

ish

er K

5J

HF

We

use

d t

his

wo

nd

erfu

l an

d i

nex

pen

siv

e fr

equ

ency

gen

erat

or

and

dis

pla

y i

n t

he

Lo

op

’s S

pec

tru

m T

un

ing C

on

tro

ller

SD

R. I

t is

pro

du

ced

by K

5B

CQ

an

d K

5JH

F o

f th

e A

ust

in Q

RP

Clu

b (

htt

p:/

/ww

w.q

sl.n

et/k

5b

cq/k

its/

kit

s.h

tml)

Re

fere

nc

es

(4

of 5

)

Page 38: MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J. E

ve

rhart

, N

2C

X

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J.

Ev

erh

art

, N

2C

X

1

) S

teve

Ya

tes

AA

5T

B s

ite

htt

p:/

/ww

w.a

a5

tb.c

om

/lo

op

.htm

l

On

e o

f th

e bes

t over

all

refe

rence

sit

es o

n t

he

Web

\des

crib

ing t

he

theo

ry a

nd p

ract

ice

of

smal

l tr

ansm

itti

ng l

oo

p a

nte

nn

as.

Has

add

itio

nal

lin

ks

to o

ther

sit

es.

2)

KI6

GD

sit

e h

ttp

://w

ww

.ma

gn

etic

loo

pa

nte

nn

a.c

om

/

Yet

an

oth

er g

oo

d s

ite

for

the

seri

ou

s lo

op

fan

. A

lso

has

oth

er l

ink

s.

3)

W2

BR

I si

te h

ttp

://w

ww

.sta

nd

pip

e.co

m/w

2b

ri/

Ex

cell

ent

site

fo

r lo

w H

F b

and

ver

y e

ffic

ien

t tr

ansm

itti

ng l

oo

ps,

in

clu

din

g a

12

’ x

12

’ sq

uar

e lo

op

fo

r 8

0 m

eter

s

4)

MF

J s

ite

ww

w.m

jfen

terp

rise

s.co

m

MF

J se

lls

som

e p

rett

y g

oo

d H

F l

oo

ps,

pri

cey,

bu

t go

od

5)

PY

1A

HD

sit

e h

ttp

://w

ww

.ale

xlo

op

.co

m/

Ale

x G

rim

ber

g s

ells

sev

eral

var

ieti

es o

f sm

all

tran

smit

tin

g l

oop

s th

at c

an b

e q

uit

e h

and

y f

or

po

rtab

le o

r h

and

-po

rtab

le u

se.

He

des

crib

es a

nu

mb

er o

f d

iffe

ren

t co

nfi

gu

rati

on

s h

e h

as d

esig

ned

an

d s

om

e v

ideo

s o

f th

e lo

op

s in

use

on

th

e ai

r.

6)

G4

TP

H s

ite

htt

p:/

/ww

w.g

4tp

h.c

om

/

To

m B

rock

man

sel

ls s

ever

al u

niq

ue

smal

l tr

ansm

itti

ng l

oo

ps

wh

ich

bre

ak d

ow

n i

nto

sm

all

sect

ion

s fo

r ea

sy t

ran

spo

rt a

nd

set

up

for

tem

po

rary

in

stal

lati

on

s.

Re

fere

nc

es

(5

of 5

)

Web

Refe

ren

ces

Page 39: MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J. E

ve

rhart

, N

2C

X

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J.

Ev

erh

art

, N

2C

X

Milli-O

hm

mete

r

LM

317

V

in

Vo

ut

AD

J

l

l

l

l

l

6V

Io

ut

= 1

00m

A

25

15

15

15

N2C

X –

100 m

A C

on

sta

nt

Cu

rren

t S

ou

rce

Millio

hm

Measu

rem

en

ts

Ad

just

po

t fo

r 100 m

a in

to s

ho

rt c

ircu

it

Co

nn

ect

CC

S t

o r

esis

tan

ce u

nd

er

test

– u

p t

o 1

0 o

hm

s

Measu

re d

rop

acro

ss r

esis

tan

ce

Scale

facto

r 0.1

mV

= 1

millio

hm

+

-

CC

S

l

Jo

int

to

be

teste

d + -

Sen

sit

ive

DM

M

Min

imiz

ing loss r

esis

tance in s

mall

transm

itting loops is im

port

ant. A

sim

ple

consta

nt

curr

ent

sourc

e is u

sefu

l in

measuring D

C loss r

esis

tance in loop

join

ts a

nd c

onnections in tunin

g c

apacitors

.

Page 40: MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J. E

ve

rhart

, N

2C

X

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J.

Ev

erh

art

, N

2C

X

Mea

su

rin

g S

TL

Re

so

na

nt

Fre

qu

en

cy

An

ten

na

A

na

lyzer

Fig

ure

1 –

An

t A

naly

zer

“d

ipp

er”

setu

p

R

(oh

ms)

F (

kH

z)

R

(oh

ms)

F (

kH

z)

Fig

ure

3 –

R v

s F

(clo

se in

)

Page 41: MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J. E

ve

rhart

, N

2C

X

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J.

Ev

erh

art

, N

2C

X

MF

J S

up

er

Hig

h-Q

Lo

op

Ca

lcu

lati

on

s

• L

oo

p is 3

ft

dia

mad

e o

f 1.1

” d

ia a

lum

inu

m t

ub

ing

• R

em

ote

ly t

un

ed

via

co

ntr

ol sig

nals

over

co

ax f

eed

lin

e

• B

uil

t fo

r p

erm

an

en

t in

do

or/

ou

tdo

or

insta

llati

on

• B

est

of

sm

all

tra

nsm

itti

ng

lo

op

s f

or

am

ate

ur

use in

U.S

• 40m

eff

icie

ncy c

om

para

ble

to

mo

bil

e w

hip

• B

ett

er

eff

icie

ncy o

n 2

0 a

nd

30 m

.

Calc

ula

ted

Ban

d

RR -

R

L -

B

W -

kH

z

Eff

- %

40m

4.1

36

6

10

30m

17.5

43.4

9.5

29

20m

64.9

51

18

56

ww

w.m

fjen

terp

rise

s.co

m

MF

J-1

78

8

Page 42: MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J. E

ve

rhart

, N

2C

X

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J.

Ev

erh

art

, N

2C

X

PY

1A

HD

Ale

xL

oo

p C

alc

ula

tio

ns

C

alc

ula

ted

Ban

d

RR -

R

L -

B

W -

kH

z

Eff

- %

40m

5

69

8.4

6.4

30m

21

83

11.8

20

20m

76

97

19.8

44

15m

384

119

58

76

10m

1214

138

155

90

•Lo

op

is

95

cm

dia

ma

de o

f 3

.8” d

ia c

op

per

tub

ing

•Ma

nu

all

y t

un

ed

•In

ten

de

d f

or

ha

nd

-held

po

rta

ble

us

e.

•Eff

icie

ncy o

n 2

0 m

an

d a

bo

ve

sim

ila

r to

or

be

tte

r th

an

mo

bil

e w

hip

•Ap

art

men

t-b

ou

nd

PY

1A

HD

has

ma

de 1

00

’s o

f S

SB

QS

O’s

op

era

tin

g u

sin

g h

an

d-h

eld

lo

op

wit

h F

T-8

17

htt

p:/

/ww

w.a

lex

loo

p.c

om

/

Page 43: MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J. E

ve

rhart

, N

2C

X

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J.

Ev

erh

art

, N

2C

X

G4

TP

H M

L-4

0 L

oo

p C

alc

ula

tio

ns

•Lo

op

co

mp

os

ed

of

alu

min

um

str

ips

1/1

6” x

3/8

bo

lted

to

geth

er.

•Ap

pro

xim

ate

s a

cir

cle

5.0

5’ d

ia

•Ma

nu

all

y t

un

ed

•Calc

ula

tio

ns p

erf

orm

ed

usin

g a

0.2

4” t

ub

e

•As

su

me

d 1

0 m

illi

oh

ms

jo

int

los

s a

nd

10

m-o

hm

s

ca

p lo

ss

– m

inim

al

co

mp

are

d t

o c

on

du

cto

r lo

ss

.

C

alc

ula

ted

Mfr

Est.

Ban

d

RR -

R

L -

B

W -

kH

z

Eff

- %

Eff

- %

40m

33

299

19.5

9.8

24

30m

141

355

29.2

28.5

68

20m

521

414

55.1

55.7

79

•Calc

ula

tio

ns s

ho

w s

om

ew

hat

les

s t

ha

n t

he o

pti

mis

tic

ma

nu

fac

ture

r’s e

sti

ma

te h

ow

ever

they a

re in

th

e

ball

pa

rk o

f m

ost

mo

bile

an

ten

nas

an

d t

he

lo

op

is

mu

ch

mo

re c

on

ve

nie

nt

for

po

rta

ble

op

era

tio

n.

htt

p:/

/ww

w.g

4tp

h.c

om

/

Page 44: MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J. E

ve

rhart

, N

2C

X

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J.

Ev

erh

art

, N

2C

X

EN

D V

IEW

P

ER

SP

EC

TIV

E V

IEW

(Fla

sh

ing

no

t sh

ow

n)

Sh

eet

Meta

l S

cre

ws

Hold

fla

shin

g to tube

Lo

op

Co

ns

tru

cti

on

Page 45: MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J. E

ve

rhart

, N

2C

X

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J.

Ev

erh

art

, N

2C

X

PE

X t

ub

e

½”

Tie

-Wra

ps

Hold

fla

shin

g t

o t

ube

Tie

-Wra

ps

Hold

PV

C

spokes to t

ube

Fla

sh

ing

be

nd

s d

ow

n

To

form

“sta

tors

” of

tunin

g c

apacitor

Alu

min

um

Fla

sh

ing

10”

Fe

ed

er

Lo

op

Copper

Wire

12 A

WG

BN

C C

oa

xia

l F

eed

po

int

½” P

VC

“sp

ok

es”

For

support

& m

ounting

DC

Mo

tor

Tu

nin

g

Cap

acit

or

“ro

tor”

Hin

ged s

ide o

f

fla

shin

g m

oved

by m

oto

r-driven

thre

aded n

ylo

n s

haft

Tu

nin

g c

on

tro

l w

ires

Als

o s

erv

e a

s

E-p

robe a

nte

nna

Dri

ve

Inte

rface

SID

E V

IEW

Lo

op

Co

ns

tru

cti

on

Page 46: MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J. E

ve

rhart

, N

2C

X

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J.

Ev

erh

art

, N

2C

X

Lo

op

Co

ns

tru

cti

on

Page 47: MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J. E

ve

rhart

, N

2C

X

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J.

Ev

erh

art

, N

2C

X

Co

mp

ara

tive F

ield

Testi

ng

T

he P

hysic

al S

etu

p

Page 48: MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J. E

ve

rhart

, N

2C

X

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J.

Ev

erh

art

, N

2C

X

Page 49: MassCon 2010 Magnetic Loop Cookbook - aricuneo.it TECNICA/loop-magnetiche/Mag Loop Design.pdf · oop design theory claiming very small loop efficiency is actually many dB greater

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Th

e M

idn

igh

t L

oo

p

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

Ma

ss

Co

n 2

01

0

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J. E

ve

rhart

, N

2C

X

G.

He

ron

N2

AP

B

&

J.

Ev

erh

art

, N

2C

X