1

Objective

Basics

T0 concept

Micro-structures

Bainmodel

Carbonin Fe

SME

Microstructure-Properties: II Martensitic Transformations

27-302

Lecture 6

Fall, 2002

Prof. A. D. Rollett

2

Objective

Basics

T0 concept

Micro-structures

Bainmodel

Carbonin Fe

SME

Materials Tetrahedron

Microstructure Properties

ProcessingPerformance

3

Objective

Basics

T0 concept

Micro-structures

Bainmodel

Carbonin Fe

SME

Objective• The objective of this lecture is to explain the basic features of

martensitic transformations.• Martensitic transformations are the most important type of

military transformations, i.e. transformations that do not require diffusion for the change in crystal structure to occur.

• Why study martensitic transformations?! They occur in many different metal, ceramic & polymer systems, and are generally important to understand. Steels represent the classical example (and a rate case of a mechanically hard martensite). Also, there are remarkable devices that exploit the shape memory effect (a consequence of martensitic transformation) such as stents that open up once at body temperature. The martensites in this case are generally soft, mechanically speaking.

4

Objective

Basics

T0 concept

Micro-structures

Bainmodel

Carbonin Fe

SME

References• Phase transformations in metals and alloys, D.A.

Porter, & K.E. Easterling, Chapman & Hall. Porter & Easterling concentrate on the geometrical and crystallographic characteristics of Fe-based martensites.

• Materials Principles & Practice, Butterworth Heinemann, Edited by C. Newey & G. Weaver.

• Otsuka, K. and C. M. Wayman (1998). Shape Memory Materials. Cambridge, England, Cambridge University Press. This book provides a very thorough description of the scientific and technological basis for the shape memory effect.

5

Objective

Basics

T0 concept

Micro-structures

Bainmodel

Carbonin Fe

SME

Notation

T0 := Eq. Temp. for 2 phases at same composition∆T := undercooling∆S := entropy of transformation∆H := enthalpy of transformation∆G := Gibbs free energy := transformation strain := Interface energy

6

Objective

Basics

T0 concept

Micro-structures

Bainmodel

Carbonin Fe

SME

Military Transformations

• What is a martensitic transformation?• Most phase transformations studied in this course

have been diffusional transformations where long range diffusion is required for the (nucleation and) growth of the new phase(s).

• There is a whole other class of military transformations which are diffusionless transformations in which the atoms move only short distances in order to join the new phase (on the order of the interatomic spacing).

• These transformations are also subject to the constraints of nucleation and growth. They are (almost invariably) associated with allotropic transformations.

7

Objective

Basics

T0 concept

Micro-structures

Bainmodel

Carbonin Fe

SME

Massive vs. Martensitic Transformations

• There are two basic types of diffusionless transformations.• One is the massive transformation. In this type, a diffusionless

transformation takes place without a definite orientation relationship. The interphase boundary (between parent and product phases) migrates so as to allow the new phase to grow. It is, however, a civilian transformation because the atoms move individually.

• The other is the martensitic transformation. In this type, the change in phase involves a definite orientation relationship because the atoms have to move in a coordinated manner. There is always a change in shape which means that there is a strain associated with the transformation. The strain is a general one, meaning that all six (independent) coefficients can be different.

8

Objective

Basics

T0 concept

Micro-structures

Bainmodel

Carbonin Fe

SME

Classification of Transformations

Civilian Military

Diffusion Required

Precipitation, Spinodal Decomposition

?

Diffusionless Massive Transformations

Martensitic Transformations

9

Objective

Basics

T0 concept

Micro-structures

Bainmodel

Carbonin Fe

SME

Driving Forces• These transformations require larger driving forces than for

diffusional transformations.• Why? In order for a transformation to occur without long range

diffusion, it must take place without a change in composition.

• This leads to the so-called T0 concept, which is the temperature at which the new phase can appear with a net decrease in free energy at the same composition as the parent (matrix) phase.

• As the following diagram demonstrates, the temperature, T0, at which segregation-less transformation becomes possible (i.e. a decrease in free energy would occur), is always less than the solvus (liquidus) temperature.

10

Objective

Basics

T0 concept

Micro-structures

Bainmodel

Carbonin Fe

SME

Free Energy - Composition: T0

parent

product

G

X

Commontangent

∆G

∆G

T1

T2

T1>T2

Diffusionless transformation impossible at T1,Diffusionless transformation possible at T2;“T0” is defined by no difference in free energy between the phases, ∆G=0.

T2 corresponds to figure 6.3b in P&E.

11

Objective

Basics

T0 concept

Micro-structures

Bainmodel

Carbonin Fe

SME

Driving Force Estimation

• The driving force for a martensitic transformation can be estimated in exactly the same way as for other transformations such as solidification.

• Provided that an enthalpy (latent heat of transformation) is known for the transformation, the driving force can be estimated as proportional to the latent heat and the undercooling below T0.

∆G = ∆H ∆T/T0.

• Thus P&E estimate the driving force at the temperature at which martensite formation starts in Eq. 6.1 using this relationship.

12

Objective

Basics

T0 concept

Micro-structures

Bainmodel

Carbonin Fe

SME

Phase relationships

Note that the Ms

line is horizontalin the TTT diagram;also, the Mf line.

T near T0

diffusionlessequilibrium

13

Objective

Basics

T0 concept

Micro-structures

Bainmodel

Carbonin Fe

SME

Heterogeneous Nucleation

• Why does martensite not form until well below the T0 temperature? The reason is that a finite driving force is required to supply the energy needed for (a) the interfacial energy of the nucleus and (b) the elastic energy associated with the transformation strain. The former is a small quantity (estimated at 0.02 J.m-2) but the elastic strain is large (estimated at 0.2 in the Fe-C system), see section 6.3.1 for details. Therefore the following (standard) equation applies.

∆G* = 16π3 / 3(∆GV - ∆GS)2

• Why does martensite require heterogeneous nucleation? The reason is the large critical free energy for nucleation outlined above.

14

Objective

Basics

T0 concept

Micro-structures

Bainmodel

Carbonin Fe

SME

Microstructure of Martensite• The microstructural characteristics of martensite are:

- the product (martensite) phase has a well defined crystallographic relationship with the parent (matrix).- martensite forms as platelets within grains.- each platelet is accompanied by a shape change- the shape change appears to be a simple shear parallel to a habit plane (the common, coherent plane between the phases) and a uniaxial expansion (dilatation) normal to the habit plane. The habit plane in plain-carbon steels is close to (225), for example (see P&E fig. 6.11).- successive sets of platelets form, each generation forming between pairs of the previous set.- the transformation rarely goes to completion.

15

Objective

Basics

T0 concept

Micro-structures

Bainmodel

Carbonin Fe

SME

Microstructures

Martensite formationrarely goes to completion becauseof the strain associatedwith the productthat leads to back stresses in theparent phase.

16

Objective

Basics

T0 concept

Micro-structures

Bainmodel

Carbonin Fe

SME

Self-accommodation by variants

• A typical feature of martensitic transformations is that each colony of martensite laths/plates consists of a stack in which different variants alternate. This allows large shears to be accommodated with minimal macroscopic shear.

17

Objective

Basics

T0 concept

Micro-structures

Bainmodel

Carbonin Fe

SME

Mechanisms

• The mechanisms of military transformations are not entirely clear. The small length scales mean that the reactions propagate at high rates - close to the speed of sound. The high rates are possible because of the absence of long range atomic movement (via diffusion).

• Possible mechanisms for martensitic transformations include(a) dislocation based (b) shear based

• Martensitic transformations strongly constrained by crystallography of the parent and product phases.

• This is analogous to slip (dislocation glide) and twinning, especially the latter.

18

Objective

Basics

T0 concept

Micro-structures

Bainmodel

Carbonin Fe

SME

Atomic model - the Bain Model

• For the case of fcc Fe transforming to bct ferrite (Fe-C martensite), there is a basic model known as the Bain model.

• The essential point of the Bain model is that it accounts for the structural transformation with a minimum of atomic motion.

• Start with two fcc unit cells: contract by 20% in the z direction, and expand by 12% along the x and y directions.

19

Objective

Basics

T0 concept

Micro-structures

Bainmodel

Carbonin Fe

SME

Bain model

• Orientation relationships in the Bain model are:(111) <=> (011)’

[101] <=> [111]’

[110] <=> [100]’

[112] <=> [011]’

20

Objective

Basics

T0 concept

Micro-structures

Bainmodel

Carbonin Fe

SME

Crystallography, contd.

• Although the Bain model explains several basic aspects of martensite formation, additional features must be added for complete explanations (not discussed here).

• The missing component of the transformation strain is an additional shear that changes the character of the strain so that an invariant plane exists. This is explained in fig. 6.8.

21

Objective

Basics

T0 concept

Micro-structures

Bainmodel

Carbonin Fe

SME

Role of Dislocations

• Dislocations play an important, albeit hard to define role in martensitic transformations.

• Dislocations in the parent phase (austenite) clearly provide sites for heterogeneous nucleation.

• Dislocation mechanisms are thought to be important for propagation/growth of martensite platelets or laths. Unfortunately, the transformation strain (and invariant plane) does not correspond to simple lattice dislocations in the fcc phase. Instead, more complex models of interfacial dislocations are required.

22

Objective

Basics

T0 concept

Micro-structures

Bainmodel

Carbonin Fe

SME

Why tetragonal Fe-C martensite?• At this point, it is worth stopping to ask why a tetragonal

martensite forms in iron. The answer has to do with the preferred site for carbon as an interstitial impurity in bcc Fe.

• Remember: Fe-C martensites are unusual for being so strong (& brittle). Most martensites are not significantly stronger than their parent phases.

• Interstitial sites:fcc: octahedral sites radius= 0.052 nm

tetrahedral sites radius= 0.028 nmbcc: octahedral sites radius= 0.019 nm

tetrahedral sites radius= 0.036 nm• Carbon atom radius = 0.08 nm.• Surprisingly, it occupies the octahedral site in the bcc Fe

structure, despite the smaller size of this site (compared to the tetrahedral sites) presumably because of the low modulus in the <100> directions.

23

Objective

Basics

T0 concept

Micro-structures

Bainmodel

Carbonin Fe

SME

Interstitial sites for C in

Fe

fcc: carbon occupies theoctahedral sites

bcc: carbon occupies the octahedral sites

[Leslie]

24

Objective

Basics

T0 concept

Micro-structures

Bainmodel

Carbonin Fe

SME

Carbon in ferrite• One consequence of the occupation

of the octahedral site in ferrite is that the carbon atom has only two nearest neighbors.

• Each carbon atom therefore distorts the iron lattice in its vicinity.

• The distortion is a tetragonal distortion.

• If all the carbon atoms occupy the same type of site then the entire lattice becomes tetragonal, as in the martensitic structure.

• Switching of the carbon atom between adjacent sites leads to strong internal friction peaks at characteristic temperatures and frequencies.

[P&E]

25

Objective

Basics

T0 concept

Micro-structures

Bainmodel

Carbonin Fe

SME

Shape Memory Effect (SME)• General phenomenon associated with martensitic

transformations.• Characteristic feature = strain induced martensite

(SIM), capable of thermal reversion.• Ferroelasticity and Superelasticity also possible.

• Md,Af,As,Ad,Ms,Mf temperatures.

[Shape Memory Materials]

26

Objective

Basics

T0 concept

Micro-structures

Bainmodel

Carbonin Fe

SME

Temperatures

Md

T0

Ad

Mf

Af

As

Ms

The Md and Ad temperatures bracket T0 because they define the on-cooling and on-heating temperatures at which the transformation is possible with allowance for the effect of strain energy.

27

Objective

Basics

T0 concept

Micro-structures

Bainmodel

Carbonin Fe

SME

SME Definitions• Md: SIM possible below Md.

• Af: reversion of SIM complete above Af

(heating).

• As: reversion of SIM starts above As

(heating).

• Ad: formation of parent phase possible above Ad.

• Ms: martensite start temperature (cooling).

• Mf: martensite finish temperature (cooling).

28

Objective

Basics

T0 concept

Micro-structures

Bainmodel

Carbonin Fe

SME

SME, contd.• Classic alloy = Nitinol = NiTi

– alloying for control of Ms.

• Stress for SIM must be less than yield stress for plastic deformation.

• SME depends on incomplete transformation and elastic back stresses to provide memory (>MS).– SME more effective in single xtals.

• Alloying permits variations in the equilibrium transformation temperature, for example (critical for bio applications, for example). Also variations in the maximum strain that can be recovered are possible.

29

Objective

Basics

T0 concept

Micro-structures

Bainmodel

Carbonin Fe

SME

Super-elasticity

• Super-elasticity is simply reversible (therefore “elastic”) deformation over very large strain ranges (many %).

• Example: Ti-50.2%Ni.

[Shape Memory Materials]

30

Objective

Basics

T0 concept

Micro-structures

Bainmodel

Carbonin Fe

SME

Role of Ordering

• A key feature of the Ni-Ti alloys for shape memory applications is that their compositions are all in the vicinity of 50Ni-50Ti and that the high temperature phase is an ordered B2 structure. The low temperature B19’ monoclinic structure is therefore also ordered (as is the other, intermediate R phase which is trigonal).

• The ordered structure (recall the discussion of ordered particle strengthening) means that there is an appreciable resistance to dislocation motion. This is critical for favoring strain accommodation via transformation and twinning as opposed to dislocation glide.

31

Objective

Basics

T0 concept

Micro-structures

Bainmodel

Carbonin Fe

SME

Self-accommodation

• Micrograph with diagram shows how different variants of a given martensitic phase form so as to minimize macroscopic shear strains in a given region.

32

Objective

Basics

T0 concept

Micro-structures

Bainmodel

Carbonin Fe

SME

Shape Memory Effect

• Demonstration of shape memory effect (SME) in a spring

• Mechanism of SME: 1) transformation;2) martensite, self-accommodated;3) deformation by variant growth;4) heating causes re-growth of parent phase in original orientation

33

Objective

Basics

T0 concept

Micro-structures

Bainmodel

Carbonin Fe

SME

SurfaceRelief

Micrographs show a sequenceof temperatureswith surfacerelief from themartensite plates.

34

Objective

Basics

T0 concept

Micro-structures

Bainmodel

Carbonin Fe

SME

Stress versus Temperature• The stress applied to the material must be less than

the critical resolved shear stress for dislocation motion, because the latter is not recoverable;SME= Shape Memory Effect; SE = Superelasticity

Stress

Temperature

CriticalStress forMartensiteFormation

Critical Stress forSlip

Af

AsMf

Ms

SME SE

d/dT = ∆S/ = ∆H/(Te

35

Objective

Basics

T0 concept

Micro-structures

Bainmodel

Carbonin Fe

SME

Ni-Ti Alloys

X Ms Mf As Af

V > 25 < -140 < -64 > 25

Cr -100 < -180 < -58 > 25

Mn -116 < -180 < -63 > 10

Fe No information

< -180 -30 > 25

Co No information

No information

0 > 25

Cu > 25 < -100 ? > 25

TiNi0.95 70 60 108 113

TiNi 60 52 71 77

Ti0.95Ni -50 < -180 ? 20 (?)

[Wasilewski, SME in Alloys, p245]

36

Objective

Basics

T0 concept

Micro-structures

Bainmodel

Carbonin Fe

SME

SME Requirements

• For achieving a strong or technologically useful SME, the following characteristics are required.

• High resistance to dislocation slip (to avoid irreversible deformation).

• Easy twin motion in the martensitic state so that variants can exchange volume at low stresses.

• Crystallographically reversible transformation from product phase back to parent phase. Ordered structures have this property (whereas for a disordered parent phase, e.g. most Fe-alloys, multiple routes back to the parent structure exist.)

37

Objective

Basics

T0 concept

Micro-structures

Bainmodel

Carbonin Fe

SME

Photo-stimulated SME!

38

Objective

Basics

T0 concept

Micro-structures

Bainmodel

Carbonin Fe

SME

Summary

• Martensitic transformations are characterized by a diffusionless change in crystal structure.

• The lack of change in composition means that larger driving forces and undercoolings are required in order for this type of transformation to occur.

• The temperature below which a diffusionless transformation is possible is known as “T0”.

• Martensitic transformations invariably result in significant strains with well defined (if irrational, in terms of Miller indices) crystallography.

• Technological applications abound - quenched and tempered steels, Nitinol shape memory alloys etc.