Upload
castorypolux20762
View
217
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
7/27/2019 March 23 2012 Eua Warwick Adh Habe Track 2 Innovative Campus Management
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/march-23-2012-eua-warwick-adh-habe-track-2-innovative-campus-management 1/12
presentation Alexandra den Heijer & Hans
Beunderman! EUA conference - March 23, 2012
http://managingtheuniversitycampus.nl ! 1
November 2010
Challenge the future DelftUniversityof Technology
EUA University Campus Strategy IntroductionHans Beunderman TU DelftWarwick March 2012
2
Introducing the workshop
•! Workshop outline
•! The Delft University of Technology
•! The Faculty of Architecture / Real Estate & Housing
•! Research on Public RE includes “University RE”
•! TU Delft as a case on University RE strategy
•! Presentation dr. Alexandra den Heijer
Let us share aims and input!
3
Delft University of Technology
founded 1842
TU Delft
4
TU Delft Organisation:
vertical & horizontal
Technology Policy & Mgmt Architecture
Civil Engineering
& Geosciences
Electrical Engineering,Mathematics
and Computer Sciences
Industrial Design
Engineering
Aerospace Engineering
Applied Sciences
Mechanical,Maritime
and Materials
Engineering
Delft ResearchInitiatives
Researchinstitutes
Supervisory Board
Executive Board
Operational Comm. supportboards
2011 TUD Graduate School: an extra horizontal!
5
M ! , as per 2010
•! Academic staff incl 1600PhD •! Support staff •! PhD degrees•! Academic/specialist public.•! Students BSc + MSc
TU Delft Facts & FiguresStaff/output & Finance
•! Funding directly from government•! Indirect and contract funding
Fte, as per 2010
26001900333
6500/75017000
370140
TREND: more students/staff, more networks + cultures
6
The TUD Faculty of Architecture
Departments: Research & Education
•! Architecture•! Urbanism & Landscape Architecture•! Architectural Engineering + Technology•! Real Estate & Housing
Key Facts & Figures FoArchitecture
•! Students 3000 : 2000 BSc, 1000 MSc•! Staff 215 fte Academic, 65 fte Support, 200 PhD (15-20 DR/year)•! Budget /year: 30 mlnE direct funding, ca 5 mlnE indirect
Real Estate & Housing Research
•! Innovations in Management of Built Environment (incl Public RE)
•! Housing Quality
Public RE research includes University/Campus strategies
7/27/2019 March 23 2012 Eua Warwick Adh Habe Track 2 Innovative Campus Management
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/march-23-2012-eua-warwick-adh-habe-track-2-innovative-campus-management 2/12
presentation Alexandra den Heijer & Hans
Beunderman! EUA conference - March 23, 2012
http://managingtheuniversitycampus.nl ! 2
7
“U-RE” relevance in University strategy: the TU Delft case
•! NL law: Campus RE and ownership/ governance
•! TUD Real Estate Portfolio: its “SWOTs”
•! TUD “Prefered partnerships” strategy: its implications
•! The campus: part of NL-Delta region and
Delft as “Univer-city”
Case example for NL Universities
source: De Hoog / Zandbelt 2010
source: De Hoog / Zandbelt 2010
Activating the “Campus-City” Delft
1 1
3
4
1
1
52
1= housing; 2=BK-City; 3=hotel; 4= Mekelpark hotspots; 5= sports & culture
toTechno
Polis
toDelft
city
related industries
Introducing: dr Alexandra denHeijer
•! In FoA Research & Education
•! Doctorate publication: “Managing the University Campus”
•! Counseling TU Delft Board
•! Advising NL University Association
•! Focal point in European/ world wide “U-RE-web”
Presentation and discussion
Campus of the futuremodels and sustainable choices
Alexandra den Heijer, MSc PhDFaculty of Architecture,
Delft University of Technology (TU Delft), Netherlands
EUA annual conference, Warwick March 23, 2012
7/27/2019 March 23 2012 Eua Warwick Adh Habe Track 2 Innovative Campus Management
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/march-23-2012-eua-warwick-adh-habe-track-2-innovative-campus-management 3/12
presentation Alexandra den Heijer & Hans
Beunderman! EUA conference - March 23, 2012
http://managingtheuniversitycampus.nl ! 3
CONTENT
1.! Vision on managing the university campus (THEORY)
2.! Trends that shape the campus of the future (PRACTICE)
3.! Three future models for university & campus (WORKSHOP)
CONTENT
1.! Vision on managing the university campus (THEORY)
!"#$%&'$()*+,$-.'/01&+$*2$-34-+2*5-6$$
(7%$*8+&70+/-9$
$
!"#"$%&'$(%)'#*"#%+,#-,#.%/#"01."23%
%!"#$%&'#()*%#+$,(&#*-#()&#./%(#%&-(&-0&#,1#23#4,,56##
:%$0+0;&8%<$!"#$%&'$()*+,$()-$/0:4'2$*2$-34-+2*5-6$$(7%$+-8;-/1+8$*(9$
proposition (PhD defence)
Each university goal
can be frustrated by the physical campus competitiveadvantage
productivity
profitability
sustainabledevelopment
7&/1,/28-0�/*(&/*8#$-*9&/%*(3#
%0&-8/*,%:#
#
;<#*-9&%(#*-#0827$%#!#)*=)#087*(8>#0,%(%#!#8(#0,%(#,1#/&%,$/0&%#&'$08?,-#@#/&%&8/0)#
#A<#-&=>&0(#4805>,=#28*-(&-8-0&#!#7/,'$0?9*(3#>,%%#!#>,B&/#7/,.(84*>*(3#!#>,B&/#/8-5#
#
*2780(#,1#0827$%#,-#C.-8-0*8>#%$%(8*-84*>*(3D#
7/27/2019 March 23 2012 Eua Warwick Adh Habe Track 2 Innovative Campus Management
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/march-23-2012-eua-warwick-adh-habe-track-2-innovative-campus-management 4/12
presentation Alexandra den Heijer & Hans
Beunderman! EUA conference - March 23, 2012
http://managingtheuniversitycampus.nl ! 4
strategic
policy makers
functional
users
controllers
financial
technical
managers
physical
focus on university focus on real estate
s t r a t e g i c
o p e r a t i o n a l
campusdecision
Managingthe university campus
strategic
goals to support,quality ambitions
functioneel
users,satisfaction, mix of functions / spaces
costs, benefits,value
financial
m2, condition.location, quality
physical
campusmanagement
competitiveadvantage
productivity
profitability
sustainabledevelopment
7&/1,/28-0�/*(&/*8#$-*9&/%*(3#
E827$%#28-8=&2&-(#*%#84,$(#1,$/#
'*F&/&-(#7&/%7&0?9&%#
Strategic
Policymakers
universitygoals
Functional
space use
Users
Controllers
investment level
costs / m2
Financial
m2 space types
Technical managers
Physical m2
UU-4 RU-1 RUG-3 TUD-3 RUG-2 UU-5 RUG-5 EUR-2
Utrecht/ UU Nijmegen / RU G ro ni ng en / R UG D el ft / T UD G ro ni ng en / R UG U tr ec ht / U U G ro ni ng en / R UG Rotterdam/ EUR
WU-2 TUE-4 UT-1 UT-3 WU-1 EUR-1 TUD-1 TUE-2
Wageningen / WU Eindhoven / TUE Enschede/ UT Enschede/ UT Wageningen / WU Rotterdam/ EUR Delf t / TUD Eindhoven / TUE
RUG-4 LEI-1 UvA-1 TUD-2 UT-2 VU-2 RUG-6 LEI-2
G ro ni ng en / R UG L ei de n / L EI A ms te rd am / U vA D el ft / T UD E ns ch ed e / U T A ms te rd am / V U G ro ni ng en / R UG Leiden / LEI
UU-3 VU-1 UvT-1 UM-2 WU-3 EUR-3 RUG-1 UM-3
U tr ec ht / UU A ms te rd am / VU T il bu rg / U vT M aa st ri ch t / U M W ag en in ge n / W U R ot te rd am / EU R G ro ni ng en / R UG Maastricht/ UM
RU-2 UvA-2 UU-1 TUE-1 UU-2 UM-1 TUE-3 TUD-4
N ij me ge n / R U A ms te rd am / U vA U tr ec ht / U U E in dh ov en / T UE U tr ec ht / U U M aa st ri ch t / U M E in dh ov en / T UE Delft/TUD
source: Den Heijer 2011 – investment costs from 500 to 4000 euro / m2 gross floor area
23
stad stad
campus
campus
stadgebouwen
gebouwen
gebouwen
gebouwen
University campus in 2011
Bron: Managing the university campus (Den Heijer, 2011)
Decreasing public funding
Ageing campus (technically and
functionally)
More than 50 % of floor area is from
1960s and 1970s
Low occupancy and frequency rates
Sustainable campus! “greening the
campus”
Increasing costs of campus
Expanding campus! city
Problems internationally shared
7/27/2019 March 23 2012 Eua Warwick Adh Habe Track 2 Innovative Campus Management
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/march-23-2012-eua-warwick-adh-habe-track-2-innovative-campus-management 5/12
presentation Alexandra den Heijer & Hans
Beunderman! EUA conference - March 23, 2012
http://managingtheuniversitycampus.nl ! 5
Managing the European campus
country profiles
Strategic
# universitiesranking of universities
future modelsfor higher education
campus ownership
Functional
# users to accommodate-! students-! employees
-! visitors
% GDP budget for higher education
% spent on campus
economic value of presence universities
Financial
m2, condition andlocations
campuses
Physical m2
Example: France
1.! 84 universities2.! more autonomy for universities (LRU, 2007)
3.! Opération Campus: 5 billion euro in 12 campuses
4.! estimated 30% of all university buildings
is in (very) bad condition
5.! goal is to create ‘centres d’excellence’ to compete internationally
6.! financial injection represents only 1% of annual resources
7.! case Paris:
- stimulate collaboration between 8 Paris universities
- invest in student housing: add >12.000 units
- use synergy university-city: ‘univer-city’
8.! extra money for 9 more universities (260 million to share)
CONTENT
1.! Vision on managing the university campus (THEORY)
2.! Trends that shape the campus of the future (PRACTICE)
Campus of the future:- sustainable solutions-! CO2 neutral campus-! less m2, more quality(photo: Wageningen)
Campus of the future:- intensive and flexible useof high quality facilities
(BK city, Delft)
Campus of the future:- sharing laboratories andother expensive facilities
7/27/2019 March 23 2012 Eua Warwick Adh Habe Track 2 Innovative Campus Management
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/march-23-2012-eua-warwick-adh-habe-track-2-innovative-campus-management 6/12
7/27/2019 March 23 2012 Eua Warwick Adh Habe Track 2 Innovative Campus Management
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/march-23-2012-eua-warwick-adh-habe-track-2-innovative-campus-management 7/12
presentation Alexandra den Heijer & Hans
Beunderman! EUA conference - March 23, 2012
http://managingtheuniversitycampus.nl ! 7
Campus of the future:student & faculty housing
image: DUWO
photos: DUWO
E,22$-*(3#4$*>'*-=#P/*98(&#!#P$4>*0#%780&#
Campus of the future:- creating the place to meet(photo: Library TU Delft)
E827$%#,1#()$($/&:##
G#2,/&#+$8>*(3O#>&%%#+$8-?(3#
G!-&B#>*1,/#,>'#4$*>'*-=%#G! *-0/&8%&-&.(%#Q#2A#(,#0,9&/#)*=)#28*-(&-8-0�,%(#Q#2A#
G#$%&/%#800&7(#2,/&#'&1&0(%#,1#
2&8-*-=1$>O#)*%(,/*0#4$*>'*-=%#
7),(,#R88%(/*0)(#K-*9&/%*(3#
7/27/2019 March 23 2012 Eua Warwick Adh Habe Track 2 Innovative Campus Management
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/march-23-2012-eua-warwick-adh-habe-track-2-innovative-campus-management 8/12
presentation Alexandra den Heijer & Hans
Beunderman! EUA conference - March 23, 2012
http://managingtheuniversitycampus.nl ! 8
=-.'/*+8$:>6$?'($*:47&5*+8@$$
$ $ $A'0;*(%$&#$4;0/-$B*+(-7*&7$.-2*8+C$
La Chaise&Screen,
Charles&Ray Eames, 1948
Armchair, Ib Kofod-Lar-
sen, ± 1950
, , , , , ,
33
Low Table Set, Frank Gehry,
1972
LTR Table, Charles&Ray
Eames, 1950
, ,
3
, , , ,
Chair, W.H. Gispen, 1929-
1930
Metal Side Table,
Ronan&Erwan Bouroullec,
, , ,
,
, ,
EA108, Charles&Ray Eames,
1958
Folding chair Dafne, Rinaldi
Gastone, 1980
EA124, Charles&Ray Eames,
1958
Elephant Stool, Sori Yanagi,
1954
Armchair, G. Th Rietveld,
1927
Elliptical Table ETR, Charles&Ray Eames, 1951 Gueridon, Jean Prouvé, 1949 Fauteuil, N.K. Roerichl,
1904
EM Table, Jean Prouvé, 1950
F reeform Sofa, Isam u Noguchi, 19 46 Arm chair, H an Pieck, 19 46-19 48 Joyn, Ronan&Erwan B ouroullec, 200244
source: BK city guide – see http://www.bk.tudelft.nl/bkcity - photos & furniture by VITRA - http://www.vitra.com
=-.'/*+8$:>6$?'($*:47&5*+8@$$
$ $ $A'0;*(%$&#$4;0/-$B/';('70;$)-7*(08-C$
=-.'/*+8$:>6$?'($*:47&5*+8@$$
$ $ $A'0;*(%$&#$;*#-$B/0:4'2$D$/*(%C$
proposition (PhD defence)
The campus of the future is a city
FUNCTION MIX – campus of the future
ACADEMIC:EDUCATION &
RESEARCH
RETAIL &LEISURE
RELATEDBUSINESS
RESIDENTIAL
INFRASTRUCTURE
7/27/2019 March 23 2012 Eua Warwick Adh Habe Track 2 Innovative Campus Management
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/march-23-2012-eua-warwick-adh-habe-track-2-innovative-campus-management 9/12
presentation Alexandra den Heijer & Hans
Beunderman! EUA conference - March 23, 2012
http://managingtheuniversitycampus.nl ! 9
2011: “To share or not to be!”
ORGANISATIONAL LEVELS / potential partners for shared use, management and/or ownership
global continental national regional local university faculty department section individual
world Europe Netherlands region city campus building zone subzone place
PHYSICAL SCALES / resources to accommodate the required campus functions
ACADEMIC FUNCTIONS • EDUCATION & RESEARCH
RESIDENTIAL FUNCTIONS
RETAIL & LEISURE FUNCTIONS
RELATED BUSINESS FUNCTIONS
INFRASTRUCTURE FUNCTIONS m o d e l s f o r s h a r e d u s e / m a n a g e m e n t / o w n e r s h i p
w i t h i n t e r n a l p a r t n e r s o n c a m p u s
m o d e l s f o r s h a r e d u s e / m a n a g e m e n t / o w n e r s h i p
w i t h e x t e r n a l p a r t n e r s o n c a m p u s
"-(&/-8?,-8>#/&1&/&-0&%:#G!S&*'&>4&/=#G!K77%8>8#G!N,/4,--&#Q#P8/*%#G!T>8%=,B#G!T&-(#
K77%8>8O#NB&'&-#
P8/*%O#U/8-0&# S&*'&>4&/=O#T&/28-3#
T>8%=,BO#KV#
CONTENT
1.! Vision on managing the university campus (THEORY)
2.! Trends that shape the campus of the future (PRACTICE)
3.! Three future models for university & campus (WORKSHOP)
•! traditional, classical university,
academic rituals
•! condition for opportunities:
selection, exclusive, elite
•! same m2
•! same resources,
healthy, safe workplace
•! no facility sharing:
exclusive use for university
•! opportunity for more resources:
- higher tuition & alumni funding
Chapman (2006), edited by Den Heijer (2007/2009/2011)
Model A: “Traditional university”
Campus of the future:model A – traditional university
- exclusiveness, elite & large- can we still afford this?
Campus of the future:model A ‘reinvented’ – University College
small, broad,Bachelor in English, selected talent
7/27/2019 March 23 2012 Eua Warwick Adh Habe Track 2 Innovative Campus Management
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/march-23-2012-eua-warwick-adh-habe-track-2-innovative-campus-management 10/12
presentation Alexandra den Heijer & Hans
Beunderman! EUA conference - March 23, 2012
http://managingtheuniversitycampus.nl ! 10
•! more institutions thoroughly mixed
with urban fabric continued infusing
in the urban domain with all
campus space types (academic,
housing, leisure etc.)
•! focus on university-industry-
community collaboration
•! same space demand, more facility
sharing
•! sharing resources!more quality
for all stakeholders
CAMPUS IN THE CITY
Harvard Square “university-community collaboration”
Chapman (2006), edited by Den Heijer (2007/2009/2011)
Model B: “Network university”
E827$%#,1#()$($/&:#
:&.-;$E$F$+-(G&7,$'+*5-72*(%#
G#!0827$%#*%#28/5&(#7>80&#,1#5-,B>&'=&"#
G!%)8/*-=#()̻$%#G!#$-*9&/G0*(3$#
•! the physical campus is an inspiring
meeting place: !creative, stimulating
and a focus on intellectual and social
exchange"
•! virtual !back office", vital very modern
state-of-the art !front office" university
•! m2: less (clicks replace part of the m2)
•! same resources available for less m2
--> higher quality
Chapman (2006), edited by Den Heijer (2007/2009/2011)
Model C: “Virtual university”
Campus of the future:model C – virtual university
work where you want
Model ATraditionaluniversity
(= referencemodel)
Model BNetwork
university
Model C Virtual
university
Model A (2)University
college
m2 same m2 much less m2 less m2
users more users more users less users
euros more eurosavailable(from more users)
more eurosavailable(for less m2)
more eurosavailable (higheradded value)
quality per m2 higher quality higher quality higher quality
Managing the university campus ! Managing the European campus
7/27/2019 March 23 2012 Eua Warwick Adh Habe Track 2 Innovative Campus Management
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/march-23-2012-eua-warwick-adh-habe-track-2-innovative-campus-management 11/12
presentation Alexandra den Heijer & Hans
Beunderman! EUA conference - March 23, 2012
http://managingtheuniversitycampus.nl ! 11
W)8(D%#-&X(Y#
N)8/*-=#5-,B>&'=&#*-#Z$/,7&8-#-&(B,/5#
•! generate collective data & tools to support policy makers
•! many countries have informal or professional organisations
to share management information, for instance:
HIS Akademiska Hus HEFCE / AUDE ‘HOI’
collect and comparestrategic – financial - functional – physical
management information for campus decisions
! NEXT BOOK – “Managing the European campus”
Role European University AssociationEUA
•! putting campus (management) on the strategic agenda
•! gathering data in European network
•! use ‘crowd sourcing’ and ‘crowd funding’ (EU universities)
•! to generate collective management information
•! compare campus management models (campus ownership)
•! result: publications / benchmarks / tools
! supporting campus decisions of EUA members
Follow me on Twitter:@alexandra_dh
More about the book
“Managing the university campus”:
http://managingtheuniversitycampus.nl
64
META CONCLUSIONS
1.! THEORY - managing the campus is complex task - affects all university performance criteria
2.! PRACTICE- trends are international- “to share or not to be”
3.! MODELS
- align university & campus strategy- combining traditional, network & virtual campus
! Share information in European (EUA) network
65
Questions for the audience
Informative1.! Your role in campus management?
[policy maker, responsible for campus management,
researching the campus]
2.! Ownership of your campus? [university or other party]
3.! Campus strategy part of your university strategy?
For debate
4.! Your opinion about the importance of (a) the campus and (b)innovative campus management
What’s next?
5. Role EUA in researching and comparing campus management in
different countries? [would you be interested / participate?]
W)8(D%#-&X(Y#
N)8/*-=#5-,B>&'=&#*-#Z$/,7&8-#-&(B,/5#
•! generate collective data & tools to support policy makers
•! many countries have informal or professional organisations
to share management information, for instance:
HIS Akademiska Hus HEFCE / AUDE ‘HOI’
collect and comparestrategic – financial - functional – physical
management information for campus decisions
! NEXT BOOK – “Managing the European campus”
7/27/2019 March 23 2012 Eua Warwick Adh Habe Track 2 Innovative Campus Management
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/march-23-2012-eua-warwick-adh-habe-track-2-innovative-campus-management 12/12
presentation Alexandra den Heijer & Hans
Beunderman! EUA conference - March 23, 2012
http://managingtheuniversitycampus.nl ! 12
Role European University AssociationEUA
•! putting campus (management) on the strategic agenda
•! gathering data in European network
•! use ‘crowd sourcing’ and ‘crowd funding’ (EU universities)
•! to generate collective management information
•! compare campus management models (campus ownership)
•! result: publications / benchmarks / tools
! supporting campus decisions of EUA members
source: http://www.university-autonomy.eu/dimensions/financial/
Campus ownership
opportunities and threats
OPPORTUNITIES THREATS
-! autonomy to decide-! costs and benefits closely
connected-! more cost-consciousness
-! more support for culture change-! land value: relation with local
parties
-! chance to have a campus portfoliostrategy (manage a ‘city’)
-! backlog maintenance-! much higher capital costs
-! poor technical state can frustrateuniversity goals
-! resources for campus can not beinvested in education and research
-! organization not prepared for new
management tasks-! lack of management information