8/2/2019 March 12 Senate impeachment court record

1/80

EAN@D[( EDRJM 42( 2642 4

Rgvwbhkj ac pmg Vmkhkvvkngz

Zgndpg

Rgjar` ac pmg ZgndpgZkppkni Dz Dn Kevgdjmegnp Jawrp

Ean`d{( Edrjm42( 2642

Vdzd{ Jkp{

DP 2?44 V.E.( PMG VRGZK@KNI ACCKJGR( ZGNDPG VRGZK@GNP OWDN VANJG GNRKHG(

JDHHG@ PMG KEVGDJMEGNP PRKDH AC ZWVRGEG JAWRP JMKGC OWZPKJG RGNDPA J.

JARAND PA AR@GR.

Pmg Vrgzk`kni Acckjgr. Pmg janpknwdpkan ac pmg Kevgdjmegnp Prkdh ac pmg Man. Jmkgc Owzpkjg

Rgndpa J. Jarand ac pmg Zwvrgeg Jawrp kz mgrgb{ jdhhg` pa ar`gr.

Yg zmdhh bg hg` kn vrd{gr b{ Zgn. Ekrkde @gcgnzar Zdnpkdia.

Zgndpar @gcgnzar Zdnpkdia. Pgjmnkjdhh{( pmkz kz nap d vrd{gr bwp d vdzzdig crae ang ac pmg

irgdpgzp Jmrkzpkdn e{zpkjdh yrkpgrz yma yrapg wn`gr pmg ndeg ac Owhkdn ac Narykjm. Zmg kz g}vhdknkni

pmg vrabhge ac gskh kn Ia`z jrgdpg` yarh`.

An ang ajjdzkan pmg iaa` Har` zdk`( Gsgr{pmkni kz iakni pa bg dhh rkimp. An dnapmgr( [aw ykhh

zgg car {awrzghc pmdp gsgr{ zarp ac pmkniz ykhh bg dhh rkimp. Kn pmgzg pya zd{kniz( pmg zawh `kzjgrnz sdrkawz

egdnkniz? Ang kz pmdp Mg ydnpz wz pa lnay pmdp nap anh{ `agz Mg jdrg car irgdp dn` nabhg pmkniz(

bwp gtwdhh{ car hkpphg dn` zedhh( hayh{ dn` zkevhg pmkniz dz yghh. Pmkz kz Mkz egdnkni( Gsgr{pmkni ykhh

bg dhh rkimp. Yg drg pa lnay pmdp pmg hgdzp pmkni ykhh nap bg cariappgn.

Dnapmgr kz pmkz? Yg zgg `gg`z `ang pmdp drg za gskh dn` knowrkgz knchkjpg` pmdp drg za irgdp( pmdp kp

zggez pa bg twkpg kevazzkbhg pmdp dn{ iaa` jdn jaeg ac pmge. Dz yg janzk`gr pmgzg( zarraycwhh{

dn` eawrncwhh{( yg jdnnap rghd} kn pmg bhgzzg` janpgevhdpkan ac Ia` dz yg awimp. Pmkz kz jdwzg`

b{ pmg cdjp pmdp awr rgdzan kz nay za bhkn`( bdzg( dn` kinardnp pmdp yg drg wndbhg pa lnay pmdp

zwvrgeg dn` edrsghawz ykz`ae( ekimp dn` iaa`ngzz pmdp bghani pa pmg Bhgzzg` Prknkp{. Pmkz kz

pmg egdnkni ac pmg yar`z [aw ykhh zgg car {awrzghc pmdp gsgr{ zarp ac pmkni ykhh bg dhh rkimp. Kp kz

dz kc Ia` ygrg zd{kni? Bg jdrgcwh nay pa bghkgsg dn` prwzp dn` kn pmg gn` {aw ykhh zgg kp dhh kn kpz

cwhhngzz dn` oa{.

Degn.

8/2/2019 March 12 Senate impeachment court record

2/80

2 EAN@D[( EDRJM 42( 2642

QQQQQQQQQQQQQQ/Drrksg` dcpgr pmg rahh jdhh

Pmg Vrgzk`kni Acckjgr. Degn.

Pmg Zgjrgpdr{ ykhh nay jdhh pmg rahh ac Zgndparz.

Pmg Zgjrgpdr{( rgd`kni?

Zgndpar G`idr`a O. Dnidrd ............................................................... Vrgzgnp/

Zgndpar Oalgr V. Drra{a ................................................................... VrgzgnpZgndpar Dhdn Vgpgr Jaevdgra Z. Jd{gpdna ................................. Vrgzgnp

Zgndpar Vkd Z. Jd{gpdna ................................................................... Vrgzgnp

Zgndpar Ekrkde @gcgnzar Zdnpkdia .................................................... Vrgzgnp

Zgndpar Crdnlhkn E. @rkhan ................................................................ Vrgzgnp

Zgndpar Okniia{ Gogrjkpa Gzprd`d ....................................................... Vrgzgnp

Zgndpar Crdnjkz I. Gzjw`gra ............................................................. Vrgzgnp

Zgndpar Pgackzpa H. Iwkniand KKK ....................................................... Vrgzgnp

Zgndpar Irgiarka B. Mandzdn KK ........................................................ Vrgzgnp

Zgndpar Vdnckha E. Hdjzan ................................................................ Vrgzgnp

Zgndpar Ednwgh Hkpa E. Hdvk` ....................................................... VrgzgnpZgndpar Hargn Hgidr`d ...................................................................... Vrgzgnp

Zgndpar Cgr`kndn` Banibani R. Edrjaz Or ................................... Vrgzgnp

Zgndpar Zgrika R. Azegd KKK ........................................................... Vrgzgnp/

Zgndpar Crdnjkz N. Vdnikhkndn ............................................................ Vrgzgnp

Zgndpar Dtwkhkna H. Vkegnpgh KKK ........................................................ Vrgzgnp

Zgndpar Rdhvm I. Rgjpa .................................................................... Vrgzgnp

Zgndpar Rdean Bani Rgskhhd Or. ..................................................... Vrgzgnp

Zgndpar Skjgnpg J. Zappa KKK... .......... Vrgzgnp

Zgndpar Dnpanka Zann{ C. Prkhhdngz KS ........................................... Vrgzgnp/

Zgndpar Ednn{ Skhhdr ....................................................................... Vrgzgnp/

Pmg Vrgzk gnp ..................................................................................... Vrgzgnp

Pmg Vrgzk`kni Acckjgr. Ykpm 4; Zgndparz Ow`igz vrgzgnp kn pmg Jmdebgr( pmg Vrgzk`kni Acckjgr

`gjhdrgz pmg vrgzgnjg ac d twarwe.

Pmg Chaar Hgd`gr.

Zgndpar Zappa. Er. Vrgzk`gnp( ed{ K dzl pmg Zgrigdnp%dp%Drez pa edlg pmg vrajhdedpkan.

Pmg Vrgzk`kni Acckjgr. Pmg Zgrigdnp%dp%Drez kz `krgjpg` pa edlg pmg vrajhdedpkan.

Pmg Zgrigdnp%dp%Drez. Dhh vgrzanz drg jaeedn`g` pa lggv zkhgnp wn`gr vdkn ac vgndhp{ ymkhg

pmg Zgndpg kz zkppkni kn prkdh an pmg Drpkjhgz ac Kevgdjmegnp didknzp Jmkgc Owzpkjg Rgndpa J. Jarand.

Pmg Vrgzk`kni Acckjgr. Pmg Chaar Hgd`gr.

Zgndpar Zappa. Er. Vrgzk`gnp( K easg pmdp yg `kzvgnzg ykpm pmg rgd`kni ac pmg Cgbrwdr{ 2;( 2642

Oawrndh ac pmg Zgndpg zkppkni dz dn Kevgdjmegnp Jawrp( dn` janzk`gr pmg zdeg dz dvvrasg`.

Pmg Vrgzk`kni Acckjgr. Kz pmgrg dn{ abogjpkan1 \ZkhgnjgU

8/2/2019 March 12 Senate impeachment court record

3/80

EAN@D[( EDRJM 42( 2642 :

Pmgrg bgkni nang( pmg Cgbrwdr{ 2;( 2642Oawrndh ac pmg Zgndpg zkppkni dz dn Kevgdjmegnp Jawrp

kz mgrgb{ dvvrasg`.

Pmg Zgjrgpdr{ ed{ nay jdhh pmg jdzg.

Pmg Zgjrgpdr{. Jdzg Na. 662%2644( Kn pmg Edppgr ac pmg Kevgdjmegnp Prkdh ac Manardbhg Jmkgc

Owzpkjg Rgndpa J. Jarand.

Pmg Vrgzk`kni Acckjgr. Pmg Chaar Hgd`gr.

Zgndpar Zappa. Dvvgdrdnjgz( Er. Vrgzk`gnp.

Rgvrgzgnpdpksg Diidbda. Iaa` dcpgrnaan( [awr Manarz. Pmg Vrazgjwpkan kz rgd`{. Zdeg

dvvgdrdnjg( [awr Manar. Yg drg rgd`{ wnpkh 9 ajhajl( dz dirgg`( [awr Manar.

Pmg Vrgzk`kni Acckjgr. Pmdp kz napg`.

Zgndpar Zappa. Car pmg @gcgnzg( Er. Vrgzk`gnp.

Er. Jwgsdz. Car pmg @gcgnzg( [awr Manar( pmg zdeg dvvgdrdnjg. Yg drg rgd`{( [awr Manar.

Pmg Vrgzk`kni Acckjgr. Napg`.

Pmg Chaar Hgd`gr.

Zgndpar Zappa. Er. Vrgzk`gnp( Jawnzgh car Jmkgc Owzpkjg Jarand ckhg` d Eapkan pa Zwvvrgzz

Khhgidhh{ Abpdkng` Gsk`gnjg zgglkni pa g}vwnig crae pmg rgjar` dhh gsk`gnjg accgrg`( rgjgksg` dn`

vravazg` kn rghdpkan pa pmg zwbvagndz d``rgzzg` pa VZBdnl Brdnjm Edndigr( Ez. Dndbghhg Pkanizan.

Car kpz vdrp( pmg Vrazgjwpkan gnpgrg` kpz Avvazkpkan pmgrgpa.

Pmg Kevgdjmegnp Jawrp kzzwg` an Edrjm 3 kpz rwhkni an pmg Eapkan dn` pmg vdrpkgz mdsg bggn

napkckg` ac pmg rwhkni ac pmg Jawrp( Er. Vrgzk`gnp.

Pmg Vrgzk`kni Acckjgr. Pmg Eapkan pa Zwvvrgzz Khhgidhh{ Abpdkng` Gsk`gnjg `dpg`

Cgbrwdr{ 29( 2642 kz mgrgb{ `gnkg` car hdjl ac egrkp.

Pmg Jhgrl ac Jawrp kz `krgjpg` pa knjhw`g pmg gnpkrg Rgzahwpkan kn pmg rgjar` ac pmg

Kevgdjmegnp Jawrp.

QQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQ

RGVWBHKJ AC PMG VMKHKVVKNGZ

ZGNDPG

-Zkppkni dz dn Kevgdjmegnp Jawrp+

Kn pmg Edppgr ac pmg Kevgdjmegnp ac Zgndpg Kevgdjmegnp Jawrp

Jmkgc Owzpkjg Rgndpa J. Jarand Jdzg Na. 662%2644

}}

R G Z A H W P K A N

Bgcarg pmkz Jawrp kz d Eapkan pa Zwvvrgzz Khhgidhh{ Abpdkng` Gsk`gnjg `dpg` Cgbrwdr{ 22(

2642 ckhg` b{ Jmkgc Owzpkjg Rgndpa Jarand pmrawim jawnzgh( zgglkni pa zwvvrgzz( g}jhw`g dn`

g}vwnig crae pmg rgjar`z( gsk`gnjg abpdkng` kn rghdpkan pa pmg zwbvagndg `dpg` Cgbrwdr{ 3 dn`

;( 2642 d``rgzzg` pa pmg Brdnjm Edndigr ac Vmkhkvvkng Zdskniz Bdnl( Ldpkvwndn Brdnjm. Pmg

zdk` Eapkan dhhgigz pmdp? -d+ Dnng} D pa pmg Vrazgjwpkanz Zwvvhgegnpdh Rgtwgzp car Zwbvagndg

kz d cdlg< -b+ pmg zwbvagndg kzzwg` b{ pmg Jawrp janzpkpwpg` dn wnhdycwh zgdrjm dn` zgkwrg< dn`

8/2/2019 March 12 Senate impeachment court record

4/80

0 EAN@D[( EDRJM 42( 2642

-j+ pmg `ajwegnpz!gsk`gnjg abpdkng` crae pmg zwbvagndg ygrg zgjwrg` kn skahdpkan ac bdnlkni

hdyz dn` pmwz zmawh` bg g}jhw`g`.

Pmg Mawzg ac Rgvrgzgnpdpksgz( pmrawim kpz Vrazgjwparz( ckhg` an Edrjm 7( 2642( d Jaeegnp!

Avvazkpkan pa pmg Eapkan pa Zwvvrgzz Khhgidhh{ Abpdkng` Gsk`gnjg ymgrgkn pmg{ vrgzgnpg`

driwegnpz pa zd{ pmdp? -d+ pmgrg mdz bggn na ckndh `gpgrekndpkan pmdp Dnng} D kz d cdlg

`ajwegnp< -b+ pmg zwbvagndg kzzwg` b{ pmg Jawrp `agz nap janzpkpwpg dn wnrgdzandbhg zgdrjm