18
MAPPING PEDESTRIAN ACCESSIBILITY AND THE QUALITY OF WALKING IN AN AFRICAN CITY: PRAIA, CAPE VERDE Paulo Anciaes 1 , Judite Nascimento 2 and Salif Silva 3 Abstract Urban areas in lower middle-income countries face specific challenges in mobility and accessibility. As cities expand in area and income grows, centres of attraction become dispersed and dependence on motorised transport increases. In this context, walking may be regarded as a residual activity, of lower priority to urban policy. However, insufficiencies in the walking environment in some neighbourhoods may reduce physical activity and restrict the accessibility of some groups to jobs and services. Planning for walking is then an important instrument for promoting public health and social equity. This paper analyses walking conditions in the capital of Cape Verde islands. It contributes to the literature on walkability by measuring indicators relevant to cities in developing countries and to fast-growing African cities in particular. The indicators measure the availability of destinations accessible on foot and the quality of walking trips in each neighbourhood. These types of measures are a useful tool for policy-makers to identify areas with particular problems of pedestrian mobility. When analysed alongside the income level and the degree of urban consolidation of each neighbourhood, the measures also provide insights into how mobility problems relate with social exclusion and with land use policies. 1. Introduction Walking is a healthy activity, facilitates social interaction, and has a low environmental impact. The recognition of these benefits has lead policy-makers around the world to implement transport and urban policies that promote walking. The identification of the specific obstacles to walking in each location is an important component of those policies, because there is evidence that the propensity for walking is associated with the characteristics of the local built environment (Owen et al., 2004; Heath et al., 2006; Saelens and Handy, 2008). With that intent, researchers have been producing a large number of indicators of walkability, based on aspects such as accessibility to specific destinations (Kuzmyak et al., 2006; Iacono et al., 2010), land use mix (Frank et al., 2005) and street layout (Porta and Renne, 2005; Parks and Schofer, 2006; Neckerman et al., 2009). 1 . University College London, London, United Kingdom. [email protected] 2 . University of Cape Verde, Praia, Cape Verde. [email protected] 3 . University of Cape Verde, Praia, Cape Verde. [email protected]

MAPPING PEDESTRIAN ACCESSIBILITY AND THE QUALITY OF ...€¦ · implement transport and urban policies that promote walking. The identification of the specific obstacles to walking

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    3

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: MAPPING PEDESTRIAN ACCESSIBILITY AND THE QUALITY OF ...€¦ · implement transport and urban policies that promote walking. The identification of the specific obstacles to walking

MAPPING PEDESTRIAN ACCESSIBILITY AND THE QUALITY OF

WALKING IN AN AFRICAN CITY: PRAIA, CAPE VERDE

Paulo Anciaes1, Judite Nascimento2 and Salif Silva3

Abstract

Urban areas in lower middle-income countries face specific challenges in mobility and

accessibility. As cities expand in area and income grows, centres of attraction become

dispersed and dependence on motorised transport increases. In this context, walking

may be regarded as a residual activity, of lower priority to urban policy. However,

insufficiencies in the walking environment in some neighbourhoods may reduce

physical activity and restrict the accessibility of some groups to jobs and services.

Planning for walking is then an important instrument for promoting public health and

social equity. This paper analyses walking conditions in the capital of Cape Verde

islands. It contributes to the literature on walkability by measuring indicators relevant

to cities in developing countries and to fast-growing African cities in particular. The

indicators measure the availability of destinations accessible on foot and the quality of

walking trips in each neighbourhood. These types of measures are a useful tool for

policy-makers to identify areas with particular problems of pedestrian mobility. When

analysed alongside the income level and the degree of urban consolidation of each

neighbourhood, the measures also provide insights into how mobility problems relate

with social exclusion and with land use policies.

1. Introduction

Walking is a healthy activity, facilitates social interaction, and has a low environmental

impact. The recognition of these benefits has lead policy-makers around the world to

implement transport and urban policies that promote walking. The identification of the

specific obstacles to walking in each location is an important component of those

policies, because there is evidence that the propensity for walking is associated with

the characteristics of the local built environment (Owen et al., 2004; Heath et al., 2006;

Saelens and Handy, 2008). With that intent, researchers have been producing a large

number of indicators of walkability, based on aspects such as accessibility to specific

destinations (Kuzmyak et al., 2006; Iacono et al., 2010), land use mix (Frank et al.,

2005) and street layout (Porta and Renne, 2005; Parks and Schofer, 2006; Neckerman

et al., 2009).

1. University College London, London, United Kingdom. [email protected] 2. University of Cape Verde, Praia, Cape Verde. [email protected] 3. University of Cape Verde, Praia, Cape Verde. [email protected]

Page 2: MAPPING PEDESTRIAN ACCESSIBILITY AND THE QUALITY OF ...€¦ · implement transport and urban policies that promote walking. The identification of the specific obstacles to walking

To what extent are these aspects relevant to the case of a semi-arid, post-colonial,

middle-income, fast growing African city? These are the characteristics of Praia, the

capital of Cape Verde islands, which is the focus of the present study. The objective

of the paper is to specify and estimate a set of indicators of walkability adapted to the

specific context of this city and similar African cities. The paper contributes to the

walkability literature by analysing a context that is considerably different from the one

of North American cities, the object of the vast majority of the studies in this field.

Many African cities have grown from settlements established during the colonial

period, in locations that benefited the colonial political and economical structure. As

cities expanded, they started to cover nearby areas, where life in general, and mobility

in particular, are in many cases limited by the relief and environmental risk. The areas

with the most severe geographic limitations tend to be occupied informally by the

poorer households.

Urban growth in developing countries also shows a tendency to be accompanied by

rapid decentralization (Cervero, 2013). The widening of the distance between

residential areas and centres of attraction reduces the opportunities for walking. At the

same time, growing income leads to higher car ownership and usage rates. The growth

in road traffic demand is accommodated in new road infrastructure where priority is

given to motorised modes of transport (De Langen, 2005). The negative impact of road

infrastructure and traffic on pedestrians in developing countries has long been

identified (Vasconcellos, 2000) but a few recent studies have started to analyse the

impacts on specific aspects such as pedestrian movement (Bradbury, 2014; Mfinanga,

2014) and safety (Tulu et al., 2013; Amoako 2014) in African countries.

The type of destinations people access on foot is also different from the case of

developed countries. For example, (Oyeyemi et al., 2013) included access to building

materials shops, food canteens, and wells in his study of perceived walkability in

Nigeria. However, we argue that in cities in developing countries and hot climates,

where large parts of the urban space is informal, the object of analysis should go

beyond the activity of walking as movement and consider outdoor life in general. This

perspective accounts for the large proportion of people in those cities who work

outdoors (such as street vendors), and for the relevance of social interactions in public

spaces near homes and workplaces. There is also evidence that the propensity for

walking and spending time outdoors are related to social aspects such as safety from

crime (Rech et al., 2012; Villaveces et al., 2012; Oyeyemi et al., 2012).

Restrictions to walking are especially relevant in African cities, due to the overreliance

on walking and the limitations of the public transport supply. Those restrictions may

limit access to employment and services for woman (Porter, 2008) and poorer

households (Olvera et al., 2013) and have an impact on the quality of life of the elderly

(Olawole and Aloba, 2014). However, concepts used in developed countries in the

discussion of transport disadvantages may need to be adapted. Lucas (2011) argues

that concept of social exclusion discussed during the last decade in developing

Page 3: MAPPING PEDESTRIAN ACCESSIBILITY AND THE QUALITY OF ...€¦ · implement transport and urban policies that promote walking. The identification of the specific obstacles to walking

countries, needs to take into account that transport poverty in developing countries is

a problem of the majority, rather than a minority of the population. The concept of

environmental justice, understood as the fair distribution of the negative effects of

transport, also needs to be translated to the African context, as documented in a case

study in Nairobi by Becker (2012).

This paper studies walkability taking into account the specific circumstances of fast-

growing African cities and the need to produce evidence about walkability dimensions

and policy concepts that have previously been applied developed countries. The

analysis consists in the estimation of indicators at the level of the neighbourhood,

considering aspects related with the availability of destinations for pedestrians (people,

jobs, shops, services, leisure areas, and bus stops) and the quality of the walking trips

(availability of public space, formal public space, safety from crime and motorised

traffic, relief and flood risk). The indicators are analysed in relation with the average

income and the degree of urban consolidation of each neighbourhood.

The next section is a brief overview of the case study area. Section 3 describes the

methods used to estimate the indicators and Section 4 analyse their distribution across

the different neighbourhoods. Section 5 reviews the lessons learnt.

2. Praia

Praia is the largest city in Cape Verde, with 130,271 inhabitants at the time of the 2010

census, representing 26.5% of the country's population. The city has been growing

fast, increasing 2.5 times since 1980. This growth has lead to the urbanization of the

plateaus and hills surrounding the original settlement in a plateau near the port (Figure

1). Due to geographic restrictions and to the fast and haphazard growth, the urban

space is now fragmented and centres of attraction are no longer concentrated in the

original settlement but dispersed throughout the city. However, some neighbourhoods

have virtually no jobs or local services.

Transport is a pressing issue in the city. According to the 2010 population census, only

19% of the households have a private vehicle. However, the figure varies between 2%

and 89% - unsurprisingly, in the least and most affluent neighbourhood of the city

respectively. The bus network is limited and does not reach some of the poorest areas

of the city. Some neighbourhoods are at a distance of several km of the nearest bus

stop. The role of shared taxis for intra-urban travel is relatively small, unlike in cities

in low-income countries. Walking is therefore the main means of transport available

in some areas.

Page 4: MAPPING PEDESTRIAN ACCESSIBILITY AND THE QUALITY OF ...€¦ · implement transport and urban policies that promote walking. The identification of the specific obstacles to walking

Figure 1: Praia - geographic context, neighbourhoods, and built-up area

Walking is restricted by the hot, dry climate and by the location of the neighbourhoods

in hills and plateaus. There is also a general lack of formal public space in the city.

Outside the historical centre, public squares and green spaces are rare. Urban parks

make up only 1.4% of the urban space (CMP, 2013, Part B-01). Despite these

limitations, walking is an important leisure activity, shared by different age and socio-

economic groups, especially in the areas near the waterfront in the early morning and

evening.

The local government has started to implement policies to improve pedestrian mobility

during the last decade. Priority was first given to formal neighbourhoods, with projects

to repave or pedestrianise parts of the historical centre. Recent policies have also

covered informal areas, including street pavement, addition of pedestrian pavements

and crossings and provision of equipment such as outdoor sports grounds and fitness

parks. Despite the improvements, the tendency for the formalization of urban space

has led to some tensions, as it impacts on the livelihoods of groups such as informal

traders (Pólvora, 2013).

Due to the growing awareness about issues of spatial equity and the role of walking in

well-being, there is a need to identify the areas of the city at disadvantage in terms of

walking conditions. This assessment is particularly important in Praia due to the

diversity of land use patterns and socio-economic characteristics in the various

neighbourhoods, with differences between the more and less urbanized areas and

between the affluent and economically-deprived areas. The approach of this paper is

then to analyse indicators of walkability in relation to two variables: average income

and degree of urban consolidation of each neighbourhood.

Page 5: MAPPING PEDESTRIAN ACCESSIBILITY AND THE QUALITY OF ...€¦ · implement transport and urban policies that promote walking. The identification of the specific obstacles to walking

The left part of Figure 2 shows average income per neighbourhood, using data from

the 2010 census. The neighbourhoods with higher income are the historical centre and

surrounding areas and the waterfront districts in the southwest part of the city. The

neighbourhoods with the lowest income are the ones in the west and east fringes of the

city. Income levels are highly variable: the income in the richest neighbourhood is 4.4

times higher than the income in the poorest neighbourhood.

Figure 2: Income and degree of urban consolidation

Figure 3: Feasible space and urbanized space

The degree of consolidation of a neighbourhood is defined as the ratio between the

urbanized area and the area considered feasible for urbanization. Figure 3 illustrates

the distinctions between those areas. The unfeasible area was extracted from the map

of the Praia Municipal Master Plan and includes for example areas with ecological

Page 6: MAPPING PEDESTRIAN ACCESSIBILITY AND THE QUALITY OF ...€¦ · implement transport and urban policies that promote walking. The identification of the specific obstacles to walking

value or with severe environmental restrictions to man-made uses. The urbanized area

includes buildings and other types of man-made land uses. These land uses were

classified into private and public space. Buildings were identified in a geographic

dataset containing all the buildings in the city, provided by the Praia Municipal

Government. Other land uses were identified in a variety of official maps and in

orthophotos such as the one in Figure 3, also provided by the municipal government.

The map with the estimated degrees of consolidation in the right side of Fig.2 shows

that the historical city centre and the geographic centre of the city have the highest

values. The values become lower as we move towards the fringes of the city.

3. Methods

The unit of analysis is the neighbourhood ("bairro") as defined by the Cape Verde

National Statistics Office. Neighbourhoods with less than 50 people were excluded.

The remaining set includes 42 neighbourhoods. The indicators are divided into two

groups, measuring the availability of destinations for pedestrians and the quality of

walking trips.

3.1 Availability of destinations

The first indicator measures access to people. This indicator is included in the analysis

as walking and outdoor life in general have an important role in the vitality of local

social networks (Du Toit et al., 2007). Theoretically, areas with lower population

density are less attractive to walking trips to meet people. In this paper, the indicator

of access to people is the ratio between the resident population and the area occupied

with man-made land uses.

Access to jobs is the ratio between the total number of jobs and the area with man-

made land uses. The calculation of the number of jobs was based on the information

in a dataset listing all the private companies in the city, provided by the National

Statistics Office. The data does not include the number of people employed in each

company. A second dataset provided the total number of employees in each sector of

activity in the city. In a first stage, this number was divided equally by the number of

companies in that sector. Corrections were then made to account for large companies,

using local knowledge. The address of each company was linked to a neighbourhood

and the jobs in each sector were summed up. Jobs in public services were then added,

using information collected from each institution and a variety of other sources.

Access to shops is the ratio between the number of retail shops and the area with man-

made land uses. The number of shops was calculated from the private companies

dataset, considering companies in the retail sector. Branches of the largest supermarket

chain in the city were assigned a factor of 3; other supermarkets were assigned a factor

of 2. Other shops were assigned a factor of 1.

Page 7: MAPPING PEDESTRIAN ACCESSIBILITY AND THE QUALITY OF ...€¦ · implement transport and urban policies that promote walking. The identification of the specific obstacles to walking

Access to services is a composite index measuring access to three types of services:

administrative services, health and education. The locations of these services was

identified in a variety of official sources. The density of the three types of services in

each neighbourhood was first calculated. The values obtained were then used to rank

the neighbourhoods in an ordered scale. Neighbourhoods with no services were ranked

according to the decreasing order of the distance from the area with the centroid of its

built-up area and the nearest service. The positions in the three ranks were then

combined to derive an overall rank of access to services.

Access to leisure is ratio between the area of recreation places and the total area with

man-made land uses. The recreation places considered were pedestrianized streets,

squares and public gardens, green spaces, promenades along the waterfront, beaches

and outdoor sports grounds and fitness parks. The identification of these places was

based on local knowledge. Fieldwork was necessary to identify the exact areas

available to pedestrians when it was not clear from the observation of orthophotos.

This was especially the case of areas on the waterfront. Areas where pedestrians share

the same space with motorised vehicles in formal roads were excluded.

Neighbourhoods with no leisure areas were ranked according to the decreasing order

of the distance to the nearest area.

Access to bus stops is the ratio between the number of bus stops and the area with man-

made land uses. The location of bus stops was identified by fieldwork and refers to the

situation in December 2013. The ongoing re-organization of bus services may lead to

changes in the location of bus stops, as some bus lines may be added or removed from

the network. Pairs of bus stops on both sides of the road in the same location were

treated as one bus stop. Neighbourhoods with no bus stop were ranked according to

the decreasing order of the distance to the nearest bus stop.

2.2 Quality of walking

The assessment of the quality of walking includes indicators derived from the

classification of public spaces and other indicators based on data on the social and

natural environment.

Pedestrian space is defined as the share of public space that can be used as a link for

pedestrian movement or as a place for social interaction. The need to recognize these

two functions of public space has been increasingly recognised by researchers (Jones

et al., 2007). The space available to pedestrians in fast-growing cities in developing

countries is considerably higher than in cities in developed countries, as the space

occupied by unpaved streets in informal areas is shared by pedestrians and motorised

vehicles. Figure 4 illustrates the distinction between informal (unpaved) streets and

formal (paved) roads and streets, where pedestrian space is limited to pedestrian

pavements. The set of pedestrian spaces considered in the construction of the indicator

then contains streets and open spaces in informal areas and pedestrian pavements and

public squares and gardens in formal areas. The carriageway of formal roads and

streets is not considered pedestrian space. The indicator of pedestrian space is the ratio

Page 8: MAPPING PEDESTRIAN ACCESSIBILITY AND THE QUALITY OF ...€¦ · implement transport and urban policies that promote walking. The identification of the specific obstacles to walking

between the area of this space and the area with man-made land uses in the

neighbourhood.

Figure 4: Pedestrian space

Formal pedestrian space is the proportion of the areas occupied by pedestrian

pavements and public squares in the total (formal and informal) pedestrian space, as

defined in the previous paragraph.

The indicator of traffic safety is the ratio between the area of carriageways in formal

roads and area with all man-made land uses in each neighbourhood. The assumptions

are that roads create a barrier to the movement of pedestrians and that this effect

depends on the total length of the roads crossing the neighbourhood and on the width

of these roads. The barrier effect of road infrastructure and motorised traffic on

pedestrians has long been recognised (Appleyard and Lintell, 1972). A recent article

by Bradbury (2014) suggests that the effect is also relevant in the African context and

should be the object of further research and policy interventions. In the current paper,

the width of the road is treated as an indicator of the level of motorised traffic. The

widths of all roads in Levels 1 and 2 of the hierarchy defined by the municipal

government were measured individually. The widths of roads in Level 3 were

measured in a sample of roads, and the average used for all roads in this level. Only

the road sections crossing the space with man-made land uses are considered, as

defined in Section 2, as it is assumed that pedestrians do not need to cross roads in

natural areas.

The indicator of personal safety uses published crime data (CMP, 2013). The number

of crimes is divided by the residential area of the neighbourhood. The indicator is

included in the analysis because crime is an increasing concern in the city (Zoettl,

Page 9: MAPPING PEDESTRIAN ACCESSIBILITY AND THE QUALITY OF ...€¦ · implement transport and urban policies that promote walking. The identification of the specific obstacles to walking

2014) and its incidence is highly variable among neighbourhoods (Pina et al., 2011).

The set of 20 neighbourhoods with data also covers a mix of values for the two

reference variables (income levels and degrees of urban consolidation).

Terrain is an indicator of the relief, calculated as the average slope in the pedestrian

spaces of each neighbourhood. The data on slopes was provided by the municipal

government.

Safety from environmental risk is the ratio of the area of all pedestrian spaces that are

located inside regions considered as prone to flooding or landslides. These regions

were identified in the Praia municipal master plan (CMP, 2011).

4. Results

The results are analysed based on the positions of the neighbourhoods in the ranks of

the two reference variables and of the twelve indicators of walkability. The bubble

charts in Fig. 5 and Fig. 6 represent respectively the indicators of availability of

destinations for pedestrians and of quality of walking trips. In each chart, the two axes

measure the position of the neighbourhoods in the ranks of average income and degree

of consolidation. The further to the right a data point is, the higher the income; and the

further up, the higher de degree of urban consolidation. The size of the bubbles is

inversely proportional to the position of the neighbourhood in the rank of the indicator

represented. Bigger bubbles mean better conditions for walking, as measured by that

indicator.

4.1 Availability of destinations

The distribution of levels of access to people has a pattern different from the other

indicators of availability of destinations for pedestrians, as the neighbourhoods with

the best position are not the ones in the upper half of the income and urban

consolidation ranks. In this case, the neighbourhoods with the best position are those

with lower income located in more consolidated areas. This finding is consistent with

the spatial patterns found in many cities in developing countries, where populations

densities are high in low-income areas near the centre, but not in low-income areas at

the fringes of the city. The neighbourhoods with the worst position are those with

higher income in less consolidated areas. This finding reflects the low population

densities in upper-end newly urbanized areas in the western extreme of Praia, which

include some isolated gated communities.

The distribution of other pedestrian destinations follows a similar pattern. Access

tends to be higher in areas with higher income and consolidation, and lower in areas

with lower income and consolidation. The inequality between these two sets of areas

is especially visible in the case of access to jobs and to services. The distribution of

access to bus stops is the most equal, as the neighbourhoods with the best position

appear near the centre of the chart.

Page 10: MAPPING PEDESTRIAN ACCESSIBILITY AND THE QUALITY OF ...€¦ · implement transport and urban policies that promote walking. The identification of the specific obstacles to walking

The areas with higher income and lower degree of consolidation fare relatively well

in terms of access to jobs, services, and bus stops, although a few of the

neighbourhoods in these areas are near the bottom of the rank. The number of

neighbourhoods near the bottom in these areas is higher in the case of access to shops

and leisure areas. The areas with lower income and higher degree of consolidation

tend to be in the middle of the rank for all types of access.

4.2 Quality of walking

The indicator of pedestrian space shows a clear pattern where neighbourhoods with

lower income and lower degrees of consolidation come first in the rank. The rest of

the districts are ranked according to a regular order: neighbourhoods with higher

income and lower consolidation, with lower income and higher consolidation, and

finally with higher income and lower consolidation.

As expected, the indicator of formal space is higher in neighbourhoods with higher

degree of consolidation, especially the ones with higher income. A few of

neighbourhoods with the best position in the rank are low income but almost all the

neighbourhoods in the bottom of the rank are low-income.

The indicator of traffic safety shows the clearer pattern of all indicators, as the best

positions in the rank are consistently located in the lower-bottom quadrant,

representing neighbourhoods with lower income and located in areas with lower

degrees of consolidation. This pattern contradicts the results obtained in most of the

environmental justice analyses in cities in developed countries, where a link tends to

be found between the incidence of risk and nuisances from transport and other urban

activities and the levels of economic deprivation of the exposed populations (Braubach

and Fairburn, 2010; Deguen and Zmirou-Navier, 2010). The areas with the second best

position are still areas with lower-income, but located in more consolidated areas. The

neighbourhoods with higher income in less consolidated areas come next and the areas

with high income in more consolidated areas come at the bottom of the rank.

The chart for personal safety includes only the 20 neighbourhoods for which crime

data was available. The bubbles were drawn at the same scale as the ones for other

indicators, that is, the smaller and the bigger bubble have the same size as in other

charts. The distribution of the indicator does not follow a clear pattern, although the

highest positions occur in higher-income neighbourhoods.

The values of the terrain indicator also show a clear order, where higher-income areas

have better positions, regardless of the degree of consolidation. Lower-income areas

have positions near the bottom, especially in less consolidated areas. This finding is

consistent with the usual pattern of residence location of poorer households in hilly

areas in many fast-growing cities in developing countries.

On the other hand, areas with low income and lower urban consolidation have the best

positions in terms of safety from environmental risk. The worst positions in this

Page 11: MAPPING PEDESTRIAN ACCESSIBILITY AND THE QUALITY OF ...€¦ · implement transport and urban policies that promote walking. The identification of the specific obstacles to walking

ranking are nevertheless occupied by lower-income neighbourhoods located in areas

with lower degrees of consolidation.

Figure 5: Availability of pedestrian destinations, income and urban consolidation

Co

nso

lid

ati

on

Income

Access to people

Co

nso

lid

ati

on

Income

Access to jobs

Co

nso

lid

ati

on

Income

Access to shops

Co

nso

lid

ati

on

Income

Access to services

Co

nso

lid

ati

on

Income

Access to bus stops

Co

nso

lid

ati

on

Income

Access to leisure areas

Page 12: MAPPING PEDESTRIAN ACCESSIBILITY AND THE QUALITY OF ...€¦ · implement transport and urban policies that promote walking. The identification of the specific obstacles to walking

Figure 6: Quality of walking, income and urban consolidation

Co

nso

lid

ati

on

Income

Pedestrian space

Co

nso

lid

ati

on

Income

Formal spaceC

on

solid

ati

on

Income

Traffic safety

Co

nso

lid

ati

on

Income

Personal safety

Co

nso

lid

ati

on

Income

Terrain

Co

nso

lid

ati

on

Income

Safety from environmental risk

Page 13: MAPPING PEDESTRIAN ACCESSIBILITY AND THE QUALITY OF ...€¦ · implement transport and urban policies that promote walking. The identification of the specific obstacles to walking

4.3 Synthesis

The results of the twelve charts indicates that no type of neighbourhood is

systematically at disadvantage in terms of all dimensions of pedestrian mobility.

Lower-income neighbourhoods in less consolidated areas tend to occupy hilly areas

and be at disadvantage in walking access to most pedestrian destinations (jobs, shops,

services, bus stops and leisure areas). However, these areas have the highest

availability of pedestrian space and are the least affected by risk posed by motorised

traffic. Lower-income neighbourhoods in more consolidated areas are the most

affected by environmental risks but have the best access to social networks. Higher

income neighbourhoods in less consolidated areas have the worst access to social

networks but the best geographic conditions for walking, both in terms of terrain and

safety from environmental risk. Higher-income neighbourhoods in more consolidated

areas have the least availability of pedestrian space and the highest exposure to

motorised traffic, but also the best walking access to all types of destinations except

social networks.

The two maps in Fig.7 illustrate the spatial dimension of the patterns found. The maps

show the position of each neighbourhood in the combined ranks of the six indicators

of availability of destinations and the six indicators of quality of walking trips. The

availability of destinations is higher in the original settlement of the city, the

geographic centre, and residential areas in the west and east. Suburban areas at the

fringes tend to perform worse. In contrast, the quality of walking is better in the fringes

of the city. Central areas are in the middle of the scale and the areas faring the worst

are small neighbourhoods scattered across the city.

Figure 7: Neighbourhood positions in combined rank of walkability indicators

5. Conclusions

This paper assessed the availability of destinations for pedestrians and the quality of

walking trips, measured by indicators take consideration the specific context of a fast-

growing African city. The indicators were constructed based on variables of the natural

and built environment and the analysis related the indicators with income levels and

Page 14: MAPPING PEDESTRIAN ACCESSIBILITY AND THE QUALITY OF ...€¦ · implement transport and urban policies that promote walking. The identification of the specific obstacles to walking

degree of urban consolidation of the neighbourhood. The results show that walkability

is highly variable and there are no areas of the city and social groups systematically at

disadvantage. Walking access to jobs, shops, services, bus stops and leisure areas tend

to be higher in higher-income neighbourhoods in more consolidated neighbourhoods.

However, other neighbourhoods have advantages in terms of access to people,

availability of pedestrian space, and exposure to motorised traffic.

These results have implications for public policy in Praia, which can be generalized

for similar African cities. There is a clear split between the obstacles faced by

pedestrians in areas with different incomes and degrees of consolidation. Policy

interventions to remove those obstacles apply to all the neighbourhoods with similar

characteristics in terms of those two variables. For example, in neighbourhoods with

low income located in less consolidated areas, the priority is the application of

economic and land use policies to increase the number of jobs and facilities within

walking distance of residential areas. In neighbourhoods with low income located in

more consolidated areas, transport, land use, and housing policies are needed to reduce

the number of trips using routes that cross areas with environmental risk. High-income

neighbourhoods in less consolidated areas require measures to reduce the dispersion

of the population. In high-income neighbourhoods in more consolidated areas, the

measures are similar to the ones applied in similar neighbourhoods in developed

countries, such as the redesign of streets to increase the space available for walking

and outdoor life, and traffic restriction measures to reduce the risks posed by motorised

traffic.

However, the identification of the measures suitable to each place requires further

information, calling for additional research. The analysis in this paper provided a

general assessment of the relative positions of each neighbourhood in several

dimensions of walkability. This approach allows for a characterization of the

disadvantages of each neighbourhood in relation to the rest of the city. However, the

definition of policy priorities should also take into account the conditions of each

neighbourhood in relation to what society regards as minimum standards. Variations

within each neighbourhood are also relevant, as obstacles to walking may be felt only

in a small part of the neighbourhood. Finally, policy-makers must consider people's

perceptions about the different dimensions of walkability and how they relate with the

objective values measured by methods such as those recommended in this paper.

6. Acknowledgements

The authors wish to thank José Carlos Borges (National Statistics Office) and José

Constantino Veiga and (Praia Municipal Government) for providing access to some of

the data used in this study.

Page 15: MAPPING PEDESTRIAN ACCESSIBILITY AND THE QUALITY OF ...€¦ · implement transport and urban policies that promote walking. The identification of the specific obstacles to walking

7. References

Amoako, C., Cobbinah, P. B., Niminga-Beka, R., 2014. Urban Infrastructure Design

and Pedestrian Safety inthe Kumasi Central Business District, Ghana. Journal of

Transportation Safety and Security, 6 (3), pp.235-256.

Appleyard, D., Gerson M S., Lintell, M., 1981. Livable streets. London: University of

California Press.

Becker, T., 2012. Can the concept of environmental justice in transport in transport be

transferred to cities of the South? A Case study of Nairobi. Proceedings of the

CODATU XV Conference: The role of urban mobility in (re)shaping cities, 22-25

October 2012, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia. Available at <http://www.codatu.org/wp-

content/uploads/T.-Becker-ARTICLE-Codatu-XV-2012-EN.pdf> (Accessed 10

August 2014).

Bradbury, A., 2014. Understanding Community Severance and its Impact on Women’s

Access and Mobility in African Countries – Literature Review. Report for the African

Community Access Programme. Available at

<http://afcap.org/Document%20Library/Community%20Severance%20Lit%20

Review%20Report%20-%20Final.pdf> (Accessed 8 August 2014).

Braubach, M., Fairburn, J. , 2010. Social inequities in environmental risks associated

with housing and residential location – a review of evidence. European Journal of

Public Health, 20(1), pp.27-35.

Cervero, R., 2013. Linking urban transport and land use in developing countries.

Journal of Transport and Land Use, 6(1), pp.7-24.

CMP (Camâra Municipal da Praia) (Praia Municipal Council), 2011 PDM do

município da Praia - Peças desenhadas (Praia Municipal Master Plan - Maps). Praia:

CMP. Available at <https://sites.google.com/site/praiapdm/anteprojecto-pdm/pecas-

desenhadas> (Accessed 10 August 2014).

CMP (Camâra Municipal da Praia) (Praia Municipal Council), 2013 PDM do

município da Praia - Volume 1 (Praia Municipal Master Plan - Volume 1). Praia: CMP.

Available at <https://sites.google.com/site/praiapdm/anteprojecto-pdm-v2/pecas-

escritas> (Accessed 10 August 2014).

Deguen, S., Zmirou-Navier, D., 2010. Social inequalities resulting from health risks

related to ambient air quality – A European review. European Journal of Public Health,

20(1), pp.27-35.

De Langen, M., 2005. Urban road infrastructure policies in Africa: the importance of

mainstreaming pedestrian infrastructure and traffic calming facilities. World Transport

Policy and Practice, 11 (2), pp.17-32.

Page 16: MAPPING PEDESTRIAN ACCESSIBILITY AND THE QUALITY OF ...€¦ · implement transport and urban policies that promote walking. The identification of the specific obstacles to walking

DuToit, L., Cerin, E., Leslie, E., Owen, N., 2007. Does Walking in the Neighbourhood

Enhance Local Sociability? Urban Studies, 44 (9), pp. 1677-1695.

Frank, L. D., Schmid, T. L., Sallis, J. F., Chapman, J., Saelens, B. E., 2005. Linking

objectively measured physical activity with objectively measured urban form:

Findings from SMARTRAQ. American Journal of Preventive Medicine, 28(2S2),

pp.117-125.

Heath, G. W.; Brownson, R. C., Kruger, J., Miles, R., Powell, K. E., Ramsey, L. T.,

2006. The effectiveness of urban design and land use transportation policies and

practices to increase physical activity. Journal of Physical Activity and Health, 3(S1),

pp.55-76.

Iacono, M., Krizek, K. J., El-Geneidy, A., 2010. Measuring non-motorized

accessibility: issues, alternatives, and execution. Journal of Transport Geography, 18

(1), pp.133-140.

Jones, P., Boujenko, N., Marshall, S., 2007. Link and place: a guide to street planning

and design. London: Landor Press.

Kuzmyak, J. R., Baber, C., Savory, D., 2006. Use of walk opportunities index to

quantify local accessibility. Transportation Research Record, 1977, pp.145-153.

Lucas, K., 2011 Making the connections between transport disadvantage and the social

exclusion of low income populations in the Tshwane Region of South Africa. Journal

of Transport Geography, 19(6), pp.1320-1334.

Mfinanga, D. A., 2014 Implications of pedestrians' stated preference of certain

attributes of crosswalks. Transport Policy, 32, pp.156-164.

Neckerman, K. M., Lovasi, G. S., Davies, S., Purciel, M., Quinn, J., Feder, E.,

Raghunath, N., Wasserman, B, Rundle, A., 2009. Disparities in urban neighborhood

conditions: Evidence from GIS measures and field observation in New York City.

Journal of Public Health Policy, 30(S1), pp.S264–S285.

Olawole, M. O., Aloba, O., 2014. Mobility characteristics of the elderly and their

associated level of satisfaction with transport services in Osogbo, Southwestern

Nigeria. Transport Policy, 35, pp.105-116.

Olvera, L. D., Plat, D., Pochet, P., 2013. The puzzle of mobility and access to the city

in Sub-Saharan Africa. Journal of Transport Geography, 32, pp.56-64.

Owen, N., Humpel, N., Lesli, E., Bauman, A., Sallis, J. F., 2004. Understanding

environment influences on walking – Review and research agenda. American Journal

of Preventive Medicine, 27(1), pp.67-76.

Page 17: MAPPING PEDESTRIAN ACCESSIBILITY AND THE QUALITY OF ...€¦ · implement transport and urban policies that promote walking. The identification of the specific obstacles to walking

Oyeyemi, A. L., Adegoke, B. O., Sallis, J. F., Oyeyemi, A. Y., De Bourdeauduij, I.,

2013. Perceived crime and traffic safety is related to physical activity among adults in

Nigeria. BioMed Central Public Health, 12:294.

Oyeyemi, A. L., Sallis, J. F., Deforche, B., Oyeyemi, A. Y., De Bourdeauduij, I., Van

Dyck, D., 2013. Evaluation of the neighbourhood environment walkability scale in

Nigeria. International Journal of Health Geographics, 12:16.

Parks, J. R., Schofer, J. L., 2006. Characterizing neighbourhood pedestrian

environments with secondary data. Transportation Research, 11 (4), pp.250-263.

Pina, J., Correia, A., Negreiros, J., 2011. Criminal management in Praia, Cape Verde.

Proceedings of the 6th Iberian Conference on Information Systems and Technology,

15-18 June 2011, Chaves, Portugal. In Portuguese.

Pólvora, J. B., 2013. Cidades informais: o caso da cidade de Praia - Informal Cities:

The case of the city of Praia. Ciências Sociais Unisinos, 49 (1), pp.97-103. In

Portuguese.

Porta, S., Renne, J. L., 2005. Linking urban design to sustainability: formal indicators

of social urban sustainability field research in Perth, Western Australia. Urban Design

International, 10(1), pp.51-64.

Porter, G., 2008. Transport planning in sub-Saharan Africa. Putting gender into

mobility and transport planning in Africa. Progress in Development Studies 8(3),

pp.281-289.

Rech, C. R., Reis, R. S., Hino, A. A. F., Rodriguez-Añez, C. R., Fermino, R. C.,

Gonçalves, P. B., Hallal, P. C., 2012. Neighborhood safety and physical inactivity in

adults from Curitiba, Brazil. International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical

Activity, 9: 72.

Saelens, B. E., Handy, S. L., 2008. Built environment correlates of walking: a review.

Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise, 40(S7), pp.550-566.

Vasconcellos, E. A., 2001. Urban transport, environment and equity: the case for

developing countries. London: Earthscan Publications.

Tulu, G. S., Washington, S., King, M J., Haque, M M., 2013. Why are pedestrian

crashes so different in developing countries? A review of relevant factors in relation

to their impact in Ethiopia. Proceedings of the 36th Australasian Transport Research

Forum (ATRF): Transport and the New World City, 2-4 October 2013, QUT Gardens

Point, Brisbane, Australia. Available from <http://eprints.qut.edu.au/63789>

(Accessed 10 August 2014).

Page 18: MAPPING PEDESTRIAN ACCESSIBILITY AND THE QUALITY OF ...€¦ · implement transport and urban policies that promote walking. The identification of the specific obstacles to walking

Villaveces, A., Nieto, L. A., Ortega, D., Ríos, J. F., Medina, J. J., Gutiérrez, M. I.,

Rodríguez, D., 2012. Pedestrians' perceptions of walkability and safety in relation to

the built environment in Cali, Colombia, 2009-2010. Injury Prevention, Online First

article. doi:10.1136/injuryprev-2011-040223.

Zoettl, P A., 2014. Morabeza, cash or body: Prison, violence and the state in Praia,

Cape Verde. International Journal of Cultural Studies. Online First article. doi:

10.1177/1367877914528530.