9
Methodology: Mapping Environmental Justice in Victoria 1. Aim The aim of this project was to assess the spatial characteristics of Environmental Justice in Victoria. The research attempted to discover if there is a correlation between the location of toxic and/or dangerous facilities and social disadvantage. For this the project needed to map data on existing facilities in Victoria with an analysis of social advantage and disadvantage. 2. Data 2.1 Data Sources The project needed to have data on toxic/and or dangerous facilities in Victoria, as well as a socio-economic measure. Table 1 outlines the data used and the sources. The ideal data would have been a set of locations of facilities that could simply be classified as dangerous. It was found that no so dataset is available. Initial attempts at refining the search to toxic waste facilities and landfills found that there was not a large enough number to draw reliable conclusions from. The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) licenses facilities that may potentially be dangerous or polluting. Another difficulty lies in the classification of being ‘dangerous’; consider a large industrial facility immaculately maintained – it might not be dangerous at all – yet a small drycleaners may use a poisonous chemical that if not stored properly becomes very hazardous. It therefore became beyond the scope of this study to judge facilities based on their licence class. No data was available for tracking incidents of pollution. The EPA compiles complaints it receives from the public about particular facilities and reports this tally annually. While far from being the ideal dataset, this tally system does mean that the facilities included have caused pollution. The data is however reliant on public complaints and those from a lower socio-economic background are potentially less likely to lodge a complaint. These annual reports were compiled and used as the data for this project. The Australian Bureau of Statistics releases SEIFA (Socio Economic Index For Areas) based on census data. There are multiple products available, one of which is the Index of Relative Socio-economic Advantage and Disadvantage, which uses information such as low income and low education as markers of relative socio-economic disadvantage. This Index was used for the project. Table 1 - Data Sources Data Source Location of facilities EPA annual reports, 2005-06 to 2011-12 Digital Boundaries (Collection District Digital Boundaries Victoria, Statistical Division Digital Boundaries, State/Territory Digital Boundaries and Local Government Area Digital Boundaries) ABS AGSC 2006 SEIFA ABS SEIFA 2006 Railway Lines Geoscience Australia 2.2 EPA Data The tally of complaints used as the EPAs mark of top polluters included many double ups within and over the years. Overall, 269 facilities had been logged over the 7 year period. Some facilities were licensed and therefore had street addresses while some had no such information. After the removal of duplicates (141) as well as removing the 27 which could not be located, 101 facilities were able to be mapped. 2.3 SEIFA Data

Mapping Environmental Justice in Victoria · disadvantage. For this the project ... it receives from the public about particular facilities and reports this tally annually. ... Mapping

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Methodology: Mapping Environmental Justice in Victoria

1. Aim

The aim of this project was to assess the spatial characteristics of Environmental Justice in Victoria. The research attempted to discover if there is a correlation between the location of toxic and/or dangerous facilities and social disadvantage. For this the project needed to map data on existing facilities in Victoria with an analysis of social advantage and disadvantage.

2. Data

2.1 Data Sources

The project needed to have data on toxic/and or dangerous facilities in Victoria, as well as a socio-economic measure. Table 1 outlines the data used and the sources.

The ideal data would have been a set of locations of facilities that could simply be classified as dangerous. It was found that no so dataset is available. Initial attempts at refining the search to toxic waste facilities and landfills found that there was not a large enough number to draw reliable conclusions from.

The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) licenses facilities that may potentially be dangerous or polluting. Another difficulty lies in the classification of being ‘dangerous’; consider a large industrial facility immaculately maintained – it might not be dangerous at all – yet a small drycleaners may use a poisonous chemical that if not stored properly becomes very hazardous. It therefore became beyond the scope of this study to judge facilities based on their licence class.

No data was available for tracking incidents of pollution.

The EPA compiles complaints it receives from the public about particular facilities and reports this tally annually. While far from being the ideal dataset, this tally system does mean that the facilities included have caused pollution. The data is however reliant on public complaints and those from a lower socio-economic background are potentially less likely to lodge a complaint. These annual reports were compiled and used as the data for this project.

The Australian Bureau of Statistics releases SEIFA (Socio Economic Index For Areas) based on census data. There are multiple products available, one of which is the Index of Relative Socio-economic Advantage and Disadvantage, which uses information such as low income and low education as markers of relative socio-economic disadvantage. This Index was used for the project.

Table 1 - Data Sources

Data Source

Location of facilities EPA annual reports, 2005-06 to 2011-12

Digital Boundaries (Collection District Digital Boundaries Victoria, Statistical Division Digital Boundaries, State/Territory Digital Boundaries and Local Government Area Digital Boundaries)

ABS AGSC 2006

SEIFA ABS SEIFA 2006

Railway Lines Geoscience Australia

2.2 EPA Data

The tally of complaints used as the EPAs mark of top polluters included many double ups within and over the years. Overall, 269 facilities had been logged over the 7 year period. Some facilities were licensed and therefore had street addresses while some had no such information. After the removal of duplicates (141) as well as removing the 27 which could not be located, 101 facilities were able to be mapped.

2.3 SEIFA Data

The SEIFA data is a specialised and highly reliable product in ranking social disadvantage. The data was mapped by Census Collection District, a fine-grained measurement allowing close spatial analysis of the relationship with polluting facilities. The Index of Relative Socio-economic Advantage and Disadvantage benchmarks scores to 1000, with scores above being areas of advantage and scores below signify disadvantage. The scores are relative to each other, however they are ordinal values and therefore cannot be used to measure the size of the difference between areas. To demonstrate, a score of 500 does not mean it is twice as disadvantaged as a score of 1000. Similarly, the difference between scores of 900 and 1000 are not necessarily the same as the difference between 1000 and 1100.

Some areas have no score. This is usually due to a population too small to be statistically significant for the analysis. In rare cases, other factors have caused the problem.

3. Mapping and Analysis

3.1 Mapping

Using GIS software the SEIFA and EPA data were mapped. This allows visual as well as statistical analysis of the location of facilities with regard to socio-economic position. Images of this mapping are provided.

3.2 Statistical

The GIS software allowed extrapolation of the SEIFA scores of each facility. This table was used to graph the number of facilities in each band of scores (groups were in 50 from the benchmark of 1000). The graphing shows the distribution of polluting facilities across the groups of socio-economic advantage and disadvantage.

4. Results

4.1 Results

The maps show a slight clustering of facilities in Alton, Broadmeadows and the Monash/Dandenong area, although they are quite spread. As the Altona area is an industrial zone with almost no inhabitants it does not have SEIFA scores. A large number of facilities are located in Altona.

Graphing the results shows a significant skew of facilities in areas with SEIFA scores below 1000, that is, disadvantaged areas. The distribution is normal, with a large number of facilities in advantaged areas as well.

The figure below is the distribution of SEIFA scores across Australia for Census Collection Districts. The distribution is far more normal and centers around 1000 closer than the skew found in this project for facility locations.

4.2 Caveats

The principle caveat lies in the EPA data; this list of facilities is based upon public complaints. Certain lower socio-economic groups may not have as high a chance of registering a complaint and therefore such a facility may be excluded. While all the facilities have been reported as polluting, it is not a perfect list of dangerous facilities. Such a list does not exist.

The extrapolation is based upon a point location, yet some facilities may be far-spreading in their effects. Additionally, some facilities may be more dangerous than others; this could not be factored into the project.

5. Conclusion

The results indicate a relationship between the location of dangerous facilities, as given by the EPA reports, and disadvantaged communities as defined by the SEIFA. The nature of the project means there is no benchmark to compare these results with, so the strength of the results cannot be determined.

6. Sources

Australian Bureau of Statistics. (2006, July 14). 1259.0.30.002 - Statistical Geography - Australian Standard Geographical Classification (ASGC), Digital Boundaries, 2006. Retrieved November 22, 2011, from Australian Bureau of Statistics: http://www.abs.gov.au/ausstats/[email protected]/DetailsPage/1259.0.30.0022006?OpenDocument

Australian Bureau of Statistics. (2008, March 26). 2033.0.55.001 - Census of Population and Housing: Socio-Economic Indexes for Areas (SEIFA), Australia - Data only , 2006. Retrieved November 30, 2011, from http://www.abs.gov.au/ausstats/[email protected]/mf/2033.0.55.001/

Geoscience Australia. (2000, March 15). Coarse Cultural Topographic Datasets (DCW) (National Geoscience Dataset): railway network. Retrieved April 22, 2012, from https://www.ga.gov.au/products/servlet/controller?event=GEOCAT_DETAILS&catno=61305

Metropolitan Melbourne

Victoria

Altona/Broadmeadows

Dandenong/Monash

Premises EPA Licence ID Address Latitude Longitude Census Collec CCD Location CCD Population Index Score Ranking WithinRank WithinVictorian DeVictorian PeCAMPASPE SHIRE COUNCIL, HEYGARTH STREET, ECHUCA EX24336 STANHOPE STORMWATER TREATMENT LAGOONS 730 ST ‐36.44399600000 144.96582000000 2020402 Campaspe (S) ‐ South 354 963 13455 2950 4 33FANMAN P/L, ECHUCA ‐36.12954000000 144.77492000000 2020901 Campaspe (S) ‐ Echuca 729 901 5761 1198 2 14ILEOWL P/L, WODONGA EI51665 WHYTES RD (CROWN ALLOTMENT 2A PARISH OF BARAN ‐36.15415700000 146.95360900000 2030502 Wodonga (RC) 433 1037 24138 5662 7 63WODONGA RENDERING P/L, WODONGA EA31173 KELLY ST, WODONGA VIC 3690 ‐36.11167500000 146.87881400000 2030604 Wodonga (RC) 261 1019 21792 5064 6 56RIVERLAND OILSEED PROCESSORS P/L, NUMURKAH EA30800 46‐50 MCDONALD ST, NUMURKAH VIC 3636 ‐36.09336800000 145.43800300000 2031208 Moira (S) ‐ West 351 899 5544 1149 2 13BIODIESEL PRODUCERS LTD, BARNAWARTHA EA60442 1456 PLEMMINGS RD, BARNAWARTHA VIC 3688 ‐36.11911300000 146.69808900000 2031403 Indigo (S) ‐ Pt A 562 1014 21144 4913 6 55OZTEK HOLDINGS P/L, BARNAWARTHA EM28699 1456 PLEMINGS RD, BARNAWARTHA VIC 3688 ‐36.11911300000 146.69808900000 2031403 Indigo (S) ‐ Pt A 562 1014 21144 4913 6 55ALPINE MDF INDUSTRIES P/L, WANGARATTA EA29773 99 CROSHER LA, WANGARATTA NORTH VIC 3678 ‐36.33547900000 146.37184100000 2031506 Wangaratta (RC) ‐ North 437 994 18204 4207 5 47WANGARATTA RURAL CITY COUNCIL, BOWSER HS1349 BOWSER LANDFILL 5 COLEMAN RD, WANGARATTA VIC 3 ‐36.32187600000 146.37226800000 2031506 Wangaratta (RC) ‐ North 437 994 18204 4207 5 47MACKAY CASINGS P/L, WANGARATTA ES35253 GRAVEL PIT RD, WANGARATTA SOUTH VIC 3678 ‐36.38058800000 146.27795400000 2031705 Wangaratta (RC) ‐ Central 620 912 6896 1444 2 16NUPLEX INDUSTRIES (AUST) PTY LIMITED EA288 1‐5 GIBSON ST, WANGARATTA VIC 3677 ‐36.36213300000 146.30287100000 2031705 Wangaratta (RC) ‐ Central 620 912 6896 1444 2 16ESSO AUST P/L, LONGFORD EM31686 GARRETTS RD, LONGFORD VIC 3851 ‐38.22975900000 147.17559800000 2041502 Wellington (S) ‐ Rosedale 268 926 8426 1785 2 20HAZELDENES CHICKEN FARM P/L, LOCKWOOD ES386 74 HAZELDENES RD, LOCKWOOD VIC 3551 ‐36.79357900000 144.17648300000 2070504 Gr. Bendigo (C) ‐ Inner West 738 973 14892 3332 4 37FULTON HOGAN, ALLINGHAM ST KANGAROO FLAT 177‐185 allingham st ‐36.78989000000 144.25177000000 2071706 Gr. Bendigo (C) ‐ Inner East 853 902 5842 1216 2 14BENDIGO MINING LIMITED, 65 HAM STREET, KANGAROO FLAT ‐36.79537000000 144.26089000000 2071708 Gr. Bendigo (C) ‐ Inner East 190 954 12142 2609 3 29MCCAIN FOODS (AUST) P/L, WENDOUREE ‐37.52050000000 143.81350000000 2080612 Ballarat (C) ‐ Inner North 326 946 11022 2340 3 26GOLDFIELDS POULTRY PTY LTD 76 POTTS LA,  CARISBROOK ‐37.05615300000 143.78684200000 2080904 C. Goldfields (S) Bal 388 925 8321 1756 2 20MADDINGLEY BROWN COAL P/L, BACCHUS MARSH ES90 EAST MADDINGLEY RD, BACCHUS MARSH VIC 3340 ‐37.70552400000 144.43844600000 2081303 Moorabool (S) ‐ Bacchus Marsh 611 995 18390 4248 5 47BALLARAT CITY SMASH REPAIRS, 4 DAVEY STREET BALLARAT ‐37.55857800000 143.85319900000 2081511 Ballarat (C) ‐ Central 493 1020 21892 5083 6 56SOUTH WEST FIBRE (MIDWAY), ELLIS RD, MYAMYN ‐38.02002000000 141.71466000000 2091308 Glenelg (S) ‐ Heywood 343 961 13103 2858 4 32INCITEC PIVOT LTD, PORTLAND EA54 MADEIRA PACKET RD, PORTLAND VIC 3305 ‐38.35803200000 141.62304600000 2091504 Glenelg (S) ‐ Portland 527 914 7107 1500 2 17MIDFIELD MEAT PROCESSING P/L, WARRNAMBOOL EM2 LEVYS PT 165 SWINTON ST, WARRNAMBOOL VIC 3280 ‐38.37038400000 142.43562300000 2092005 Warrnambool (C) 564 1032 23571 5501 7 61GODFREY HIRST AUST P/L, GEELONG SOUTH 7 Factories Road, South Geelong ‐38.16927000000 144.36147000000 2110801 Geelong 514 1000 19030 4389 5 49AUSTRALIAN PET ESSENTAILS, HAWORTH CRT BREAK WATER ‐38.18385000000 144.38075000000 2110812 Geelong 595 861 2744 465 1 6GEELONG GALVANIZING P/L, CORIO 360 Bacchus Marsh Rd, Corio VIC 3214 ‐38.05342000000 144.35995000000 2111303 Corio ‐ Inner 461 1018 21611 5010 6 56BALABAROVA, 280 EMMERSONS RD LOVELY BANKS ‐38.05378000000 144.32540000000 2111316 Corio ‐ Inner 698 1010 20618 4785 6 53HILLVIEW COMPOST P/L, LARA ‐37.92487000000 144.40678000000 2112303 Greater Geelong (C) ‐ Pt C 597 1040 24619 5799 7 64BARRO GROUP PTY LTD, MCINTYRE ROAD, KEALBA EW26848 570 DANDOS RD, POINT WILSON VIC 3212 ‐38.06873300000 144.47952200000 2112304 Greater Geelong (C) ‐ Pt C 877 993 18036 4168 5 46CHEETHAM SALT LIMITED 10 MOORABOOL ST,  GEELONG ‐38.04258200000 144.44038900000 2112304 Greater Geelong (C) ‐ Pt C 877 993 18036 4168 5 46SHELL REFINING (AUSTRALIA) PROPRIETARY LIMITED EM30626 SHELL REFINERY, REFINERY RD, CORIO VIC 3214 ‐38.08075700000 144.37722700000 2112704 Corio ‐ Inner 572 1188 36514 8973 10 99GEELONG FABRICATIONS, MADDEN AVENUE, NORTH SHORE ‐38.08989000000 144.37509000000 2112713 Corio ‐ Inner 318 919 7663 1617 2 18NEVAS BROILER FARM, 742 GREIGS RD, ROCKBANK ‐37.74503000000 144.62620000000 2120402 Melton (S) Bal 585 954 12105 2602 3 29BPL MELBOURNE P/L, LAVERTON NORTH EA527 1‐9 MERINO ST, LAVERTON NORTH VIC 3026 ‐37.82338700000 144.81350700000 2120605 Wyndham (C) ‐ North 0 0 0 0 0 0ENVIRONMENTAL OIL AUST P/L, LAVERTON NORTH 170 Fitzgerald Rd ‐37.81895000000 144.78710000000 2120605 Wyndham (C) ‐ North 0 0 0 0 0 0AUSTRALIAN TALLOW PRODUCERS PTY LTD EA205 690 GEELONG RD, BROOKLYN VIC 3012 ‐37.81835900000 144.83653200000 2130810 Brimbank (C) ‐ Sunshine 0 0 0 0 0 0BROOKLYN MEAT PROCESSORS P/L, BROOKLYN ‐37.81434400000 144.84779500000 2130810 Brimbank (C) ‐ Sunshine 0 0 0 0 0 0SIMS GROUP AUST HOLDINGS LTD, BROOKLYN ‐37.81084000000 144.84852000000 2130810 Brimbank (C) ‐ Sunshine 0 0 0 0 0 0SWIFT AUST (SOUTHERN) P/L, BROOKLYN EA25734 30 INDUSTRY PARK DR, BROOKLYN VIC 3012 ‐37.81276700000 144.85153100000 2130810 Brimbank (C) ‐ Sunshine 0 0 0 0 0 0HUME CITY COUNCIL, CAMPBELLFIELD ES506 CNR BOLINDA RD & SYDNEY RD, CAMPBELLFIELD VIC 306 ‐37.68332600000 144.96841400000 2140704 Hume (C) ‐ Broadmeadows 836 881 4063 790 1 9INDUSTRIAL GALVANIZERS CORP P/L, PRESTON EA67686 LOT 17A/B LARA WAY, CAMPBELLFIELD VIC 3061 ‐37.65536400000 144.96505700000 2140711 Hume (C) ‐ Broadmeadows 228 782 630 82 1 1EVELYN WAY P/L, ST HELENA/MASSI, 1 EVELYN WAY, ST HELENA ‐37.69518400000 145.13144400000 2150310 Banyule (C) ‐ North 398 1065 27585 6596 8 73CONTINENTAL POULTRY (LA IONICA), 5 LIPTON DRIVE, THOMASTOWN ‐37.69092000000 144.99803000000 2160910 Whittlesea (C) ‐ South‐West 0 0 0 0 0 0WORKS INFRASTRUCTURE, 342 SETTLEMENT ROAD, THOMASTOWN ‐37.68872000000 145.02198000000 2160910 Whittlesea (C) ‐ South‐West 0 0 0 0 0 0SITA AUST P/L, EPPING EA63124 480 COOPER ST, EPPING VIC 3076 ‐37.64274200000 144.97668400000 2161401 Whittlesea (C) ‐ North 182 959 12860 2789 4 31RAVENSWOOD BAYSWATER, 74 BAYFIELD ROAD, BAYSWATER ‐37.82458600000 145.27754600000 2170716 Maroondah (C) ‐ Croydon 0 0 0 0 0 0CMA RECYCLING/UNIVERSAL METALS/SOUTHERN ROCYCLING VIC, RINGWOOD 81‐85 HEATHERDALE RD,  RINGWOOD ‐37.82495500000 145.21468900000 2170810 Maroondah (C) ‐ Ringwood 347 957 12558 2717 3 30ROSSI RECYCLING P/L, RINGWOOD ‐37.82493000000 145.21625500000 2170810 Maroondah (C) ‐ Ringwood 347 957 12558 2717 3 30SOUTHERN ROCYCLING, 59‐61 HEATHERDALE RD RINGWOOD ‐37.82499000000 145.21512000000 2170810 Maroondah (C) ‐ Ringwood 347 957 12558 2717 3 30JINDI CHEESE P/L, JINDIVICK LS55351 230‐250 OLD TELEGRAPH RD, JINDIVICK VIC 3818 ‐38.06461700000 145.85383600000 2180609 Baw Baw (S) ‐ Pt B West 640 1001 19191 4436 5 49LONGWARRY FOOD PARK PTY LTD EM32127 50 WITTON ST, LONGWARRY VIC 3816 ‐38.11277700000 145.77323900000 2180701 Baw Baw (S) ‐ Pt B West 626 891 4773 957 2 11NEW COVENANT CORPORATION PTY LTD, 60 ROBERTS ROAD LILLICO ‐38.12187000000 145.93842000000 2180804 Baw Baw (S) ‐ Pt B West 558 1006 19836 4591 6 51PAPER AUST P/L, MORWELL EM30021 MARYVALE PAPER MILL TRARALGON WEST RD, MORWEL ‐38.18170500000 146.46238700000 2181907 Latrobe (C) ‐ Traralgon 706 986 16879 3861 5 43YARRA VALLEY WATER, NELSON ROAD, LILYDALE ‐37.74792000000 145.35958000000 2190902 Yarra Ranges (S) ‐ Lilydale 954 969 14244 3155 4 35BRUNO DE INGENIIS, 13 KILLARA RD COLDSTREAM ‐37.72389000000 145.38562000000 2190904 Yarra Ranges (S) ‐ Seville 467 1044 25081 5930 7 66AUSTRALIAN NATIVE LANDSCAPES, MAROONDAH HWY,  COLDSTREAM ‐37.73554000000 145.37117000000 2190910 Yarra Ranges (S) ‐ Seville 750 969 14329 3180 4 35BURRA FOODS P/L, KORUMBURRA LW59581 47 STATION ST, KORUMBURRA VIC 3950 ‐38.42588400000 145.82228000000 2200913 South Gippsland (S) ‐ West 476 908 6439 1348 2 15BORAL RECYCLING PTY LIMITED ES37288 1100‐1152 CHRISTIES RD, RAVENHALL VIC 3030 ‐38.42948900000 145.52732800000 2201103 Bass Coast (S) Bal 714 941 10381 2195 3 25AQUASURE PTY LTD LOWER POWLETT RD,  WONTHAGGI ‐38.59264000000 145.53088900000 2201105 Bass Coast (S) Bal 323 998 18795 4339 5 48INGHAMS ENTERPRISES P/L, SOMERVILLE/BAXTER ‐38.20827500000 145.18067800000 2210703 Mornington P'sula (S) ‐ East 657 1031 23426 5466 7 61NYLEX CORP P/L, MENTONE ‐37.97718500000 145.06748800000 2230203 Kingston (C) ‐ North 430 1034 23852 5585 7 62BOLWELL 37 WELLS RD,  MORDIALLOC ‐38.01106700000 145.10272300000 2230512 Kingston (C) ‐ North 0 0 0 0 0 0

DATA USED IN MAPPING EXERCISE

METRO TRAINS MELBOURNE PTY LTD, CARRUM SIDING STATION ST CARRUM ‐38.07903000000 145.12352000000 2230607 Kingston (C) ‐ South 684 962 13288 2904 4 32ENVIROMIX SOUTHERN MELBOURNE P/L, DINGLEY VILLAGE EA63780 THE WHOLE OF LOT 1, PLAN OF SUBDIVISION PS409861R ‐37.96307300000 145.11993400000 2230807 Kingston (C) ‐ North 1079 1098 30889 7507 9 83ERNEST SMITH CONTRACTORS P/L, DINGLEY VILLAGE ES146 370‐418 OLD DANDENONG RD, DINGLEY VILLAGE VIC 317 ‐37.96481300000 145.12017800000 2230807 Kingston (C) ‐ North 1079 1098 30889 7507 9 83TRANSPACIFIC WASTE MANAGEMENT P/L, CLARINDA ES45017 CARROLL RD, CLARINDA VIC 3169 ‐37.93347900000 145.09167400000 2231002 Kingston (C) ‐ North 1187 998 18772 4333 5 48BAXTER GROUP, STH METRO EM28818 FRASER RD, CLAYTON SOUTH VIC 3169 ‐37.94771900000 145.12474000000 2231809 Kingston (C) ‐ North 380 931 9080 1912 3 22CLAYTON ROAD LANDFILL JOINT VENTURE, CLAYTON SOUTH ES20872 654‐718 CLAYTON RD,  CLAYTON SOUTH ‐37.95332700000 145.11668300000 2231809 Kingston (C) ‐ North 380 931 9080 1912 3 22HUCON AUSTRALIA P/L, WALDHEIM ROAD, BAYSWATER 9 Waldheim Rd Bayswater ‐37.84220000000 145.24869000000 2240710 Knox (C) ‐ North‐West 239 1004 19528 4528 5 50LAMINEX GROUP LTD, CHELTENHAM EA1623 332‐336 BAY RD, CHELTENHAM VIC 3192 ‐37.95824800000 145.04216000000 2273201 Bayside (C) ‐ South 683 1080 29167 7035 8 78SYMEX HOLDINGS LTD, PORT MELBOURNE EM22625 14 WOODRUFF ST, PORT MELBOURNE VIC 3207 ‐37.82939500000 144.94309900000 2281208 Port Phillip (C) ‐ West 0 0 0 0 0 0DP WORLD AUST LTD, WEST MELBOURNE EW762 DP WORLD MELBOURNE 29‐79 MACKENZIE RD, WEST M ‐37.81397600000 144.91021700000 2290917 Melbourne (C) ‐ Remainder 0 0 0 0 0 0AMCOR PACKAGING (AUST) PTY LTD CL67867 AS LISTED IN SCHEDULE 3 TO THIS LICENCE, HAWTHORN  ‐37.78257800000 145.02661200000 2291709 Yarra (C) ‐ North 581 1098 30957 7517 9 83NATIONAL BUS CO (VICTORIA) P/L, FITZROY NORTH ‐37.78256000000 144.97873000000 2292104 Yarra (C) ‐ North 316 1150 34715 8565 10 95VENTURA BUS COMPANY, SCOTCHMER STREET FITZROY ‐37.78256000000 144.97873000000 2292104 Yarra (C) ‐ North 316 1150 34715 8565 10 95ENERKA APEX BELTING PTY LTD, 268‐280 GEELONG ROAD, WEST FOOTSCRAY ‐37.80420800000 144.88109100000 2300408 Maribyrnong (C) 540 1019 21807 5070 6 56WATTYL AUST P/L, WEST FOOTSCRAY EM32305 2‐38 GRAINGERS RD, FOOTSCRAY WEST VIC 3012 ‐37.80323400000 144.87973000000 2300408 Maribyrnong (C) 540 1019 21807 5070 6 56ALTONA NORTH LANDFILL P/L, ALTONA ES26227 ALTONA NORTH LANDFILL SITE 55 MCARTHURS RD, ALTO ‐37.83937000000 144.83741700000 2301308 Hobsons Bay (C) ‐ Altona 742 921 7807 1645 2 19HYDE PARK TANK DEPOT P/L, ALTONA NORTH EM62959 49‐53 MCARTHUR RD, ALTONA NORTH VIC 3025 ‐37.83627700000 144.83866800000 2301308 Hobsons Bay (C) ‐ Altona 742 921 7807 1645 2 19QENOS P/L, ALTONA EM31466 471‐513 KOROROIT CREEK RD, ALTONA VIC 3018 ‐37.85114600000 144.80725000000 2301510 Hobsons Bay (C) ‐ Altona 0 0 0 0 0 0CITY WEST WATER LTD, ALTONA EX174 293 QUEEN ST, ALTONA MEADOWS VIC 3028 ‐37.87292400000 144.79289200000 2301514 Hobsons Bay (C) ‐ Altona 0 0 0 0 0 0MOBIL REFINING AUST P/L, ALTONA CL69816 (E38) CNR MILLERS RD & KOROROIT CREEK RD, ALTONA VIC 30 ‐37.85319100000 144.84834200000 2301713 Hobsons Bay (C) ‐ Altona 0 0 0 0 0 0CARGILL PROCESSING LTD, FOOTSCRAY WEST EA375 425 SOMERVILLE RD, TOTTENHAM VIC 3012 ‐37.81109200000 144.85778800000 2302014 Maribyrnong (C) 0 0 0 0 0 0FELTEX PTY LTD, 35‐65 PARAMOUNT ROAD, TOTTENHAM ‐37.80408000000 144.86013000000 2302014 Maribyrnong (C) 0 0 0 0 0 0CATERFARE P/L, FLEMINGTON ‐37.78410000000 144.92024000000 2311017 Moonee Valley (C) ‐ Essendon 287 967 13979 3086 4 34TOM PHAT RESTAURANT, 180 SYDNEY ROAD, BRUNSWICK ‐37.77363000000 144.96118000000 2320205 Moreland (C) ‐ Brunswick 783 1096 30690 7457 9 82ALAN BECKWITH MACBRO P/L, 1 NORRIS ST,  COBURG  VIC  3058 ‐37.72511000000 144.96091000000 2321504 Moreland (C) ‐ Coburg 265 949 11379 2421 3 27NORSTAR METAL RECYCLERS, 41‐51 BANBURY ROAD RESERVOIR ‐37.71062000000 144.98938000000 2331301 Darebin (C) ‐ Preston 478 898 5482 1131 2 13HUHTAMAKI AUST PTY LTD 77‐85 RAGLAN ST,  PRESTON ‐37.75144800000 145.02267500000 2332209 Darebin (C) ‐ Preston 0 0 0 0 0 0AUSTRALIAN BOTANICAL PRODUCTS, 39 MELVERTON DRIVE HALLAM VIC 3803 ‐38.01082000000 145.27469000000 2340212 Casey (C) ‐ Hallam 874 977 15552 3509 4 39CONSOLIDATED WASTE (VICTORIA) P/L, CRANBOURNE ‐38.11787900000 145.26899800000 2340502 Casey (C) ‐ Cranbourne 665 1029 23152 5397 6 60SITA AUST P/L, HAMPTON PARK ES33144 274 HALLAM RD, HAMPTON PARK VIC 3976 ‐38.05657500000 145.27070600000 2341611 Casey (C) ‐ Cranbourne 679 942 10483 2219 3 25SITA AUST PTY LTD ‐38.05220600000 145.26767800000 2341611 Casey (C) ‐ Cranbourne 679 942 10483 2219 3 25PINSWAN NOMINEES P/L, TOORADIN ‐38.21471600000 145.40404200000 2341908 Casey (C) ‐ South 434 1014 21103 4902 6 54TRANSPACIFIC WASTE MANAGEMENT P/L, PAKENHAM EA63108 DROVERS PL, PAKENHAM VIC 3810 ‐38.09982600000 145.49847400000 2342604 Cardinia (S) ‐ Pakenham 467 983 16565 3773 5 42DONNELLONS BODY WORKS P/L, HAWTHORN ‐37.81552700000 145.02129100000 2350608 Boroondara (C) ‐ Hawthorn 638 1169 35747 8815 10 97CAMBRIDGE CAR CARE,  720 STATION STREET, BOX HILL ‐37.81634900000 145.12439700000 2362106 Whitehorse (C) ‐ Box Hill 281 1068 27892 6682 8 74MONARCH SPAS INTERNATIONAL P/L, 4/400 PRINCES HIGHWAY, NOBLE PARK ‐37.96022000000 145.18812000000 2370207 Gr. Dandenong (C) Bal 850 904 6040 1259 2 14FLETCHER INSULATION, DANDENONG EA349 127 FRANKSTON‐DANDENONG RD, DANDENONG VIC 317 ‐38.01254200000 145.21832200000 2370801 Gr. Dandenong (C) Bal 175 849 2181 355 1 4SITA‐BFI (VICTORIA) P/L, DANDENONG SOUTH/LYNDHURST ES511 890 TAYLORS RD, LYNDHURST VIC 3975 ‐38.04360500000 145.23185700000 2370801 Gr. Dandenong (C) Bal 175 849 2181 355 1 4COLMAX GLASS P/L, DANDENONG ‐38.00748300000 145.21218900000 2370819 Gr. Dandenong (C) ‐ Dandenong 0 0 0 0 0 0MELBOURNE WATER CORP, BANGHOLME EM35642 EASTERN TREATMENT PLANT, THOMPSON RD, BANGHOL ‐38.06565400000 145.16757200000 2370904 Gr. Dandenong (C) Bal 573 1030 23269 5424 6 60