Management of Non-Performing Loans in Georgia_GEO

8/13/2019 Management of Non-Performing Loans in Georgia_GEO

1/40

1

- (EWMI) --

, (G-PAC) .

,

(USAID) .

USAID- .

bank

i


2/40


3/40

,

(USAID) .

USAID-,

EWMI- .

ekonomikuri politikis kvlevis centri

2014


4/40

.........................................................................................................................................................................5

...................................................................................................................................................................5 ..........................................................................................................................................................................................7

.................................................................................................................................................................8

...............................................................................................................................8

..................................................................................................................................................13

................................................................................................................................................................. 17

......................................................................................................................................................21

....................................................................................................................................................................................21

.............................................................................................................................. 22

............................................................................................................................................................. 23

........................................................................27

............................................................................................................................................................27

....................................................................................................................................................... 28

................................................................................................................................................. 30

(AMCs)................................................................................................................. 32

: .......................................................................33

........................................................................................................................................... 36


5/40

5

(EPRC)

- (EWMI) ,

(G-PAC) . -

(USAID).

, -

( ,

), -

.

.

10% .

;

, 124 , -

52- , ;

, -

, , , ;

- ,

. , -

6-7 , ,

;

(

, , ),

( )

, , ( -

), ;

, -

, - , ;

, -


6/40

6

, -

;

, ,

. 40%- - , 30%- ,

20%- ( ), 10%- -

. ,

(80%-) , ;

; , -

.

-

. , -

;

2009 , -

,

. -

,

, .

2014 , ,

, . , , -

,

.

2008 -

. 8%- . -

95 , - -

.

. , -

,

, .

, -

, . -

, ,

;


7/40

7

. ,

,

;

-

, .

- . . 2008

-

. -

10% ,1 2 -

;

.

/.

2013 -

, -

, -

. ,

. , ,

., ,

.

. -

.

1 (Non-Performing Loans (NPLs)) , - .

2 . - , , 2010 1 . - . , . : http://nbe.gov.ge/index.php?lang_id=ENG&sec_id=167&info_id=3390#sthash.ONEKjtUc.dpuf


8/40

8

. -

, .3 -

. (IMF) 2004 (Compilation Guide on Financial Soundness

Indicators) :

, / 90

90 , -

, . 90 ,

, . -

, .

-

, , 90-

.4

-

.

2000 29 N350 -

,5

- :1. ;

2. ;

3. ;

4. ;

5. ;

,6 -

2006 23 N.145 , ,

.

3 The Treatment of Nonperforming Loans - Eighteenth Meeting of the IMF Committee on Balance of Payments Statistics. Interna-tional Monetary Fund, 2005. Washington DC.

4 Beck, R., Jakubik, P., & Piloiu, A. (2013). Non-Performing Loans - What matters in addition to the economic cycle? Frankfurt : Eu-ropean Central Bank.

5 . http://www.nbg.gov.ge/uploads/legalacts/supervision/nbg1.4.5.1regulation_on_assetsgeo.pdf

6 . http://www.nbg.gov.ge/uploads/legalacts/supervision/nbg1.4.4.2regulation_on_transparencygeo.pdf


9/40

9

-

(LLR).

LLR (%)

2%

150 100%

:

. -

, 30 , 60 , -

, -

30 .

, , -

. -

.

-

(. 90 ), -

. : 2012 9.3% , 90

, 4% .7 -

,

. -

,

30 8. ,

, , -

. , , -

,

.

2012 -

(LLR) .

7 . 2012. http://nbg.ge/uploads/publications/annualreport/2012/annualgeo2013.pdf

8 , , 30 . . 5 35 .


10/40

10

(.)

LLR

391 4% 30%

235 3% 51%

184 2% 87%

: 8,733 100% 7%

810 9.0% 49%

:

,9 124 -

52- , .

,

,

. -

.

2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012

11.6 7.9 2.4 2.0 1.2 2.5 0.8 4.1 6.3 5.4 4.6 4.1

: , 2013.

, . - , -

. ,

.

, 2008 -

, -

. ,

2008 ( 1), ,

.

, ,

.

9 http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/FB.AST.NPER.ZS/countries?display=default


11/40

11

1: , ,www.nbg.ge

, -

. ,

6-7 , ,

( 2).

2: www.nbg.ge

.

, . -

,

( 3).

01.02

01.0

6

01.0

7

01.0

8

01.0

9

01.1

0

01.1

1

01.1

2

01.1

3

09.0

6

09.0

7

09.0

8

09.0

9

09.1

0

09.1

1

09.1

2

09.1

3

12.0

6

12.0

7

12.0

8

12.0

9

12.1

0

12.1

1

12.1

2

03.0

7

03.0

8

03.0

9

03.1

0

03.1

1

03.1

2

03.1

3

01.03 01.04 01.05 01.06 01.07 01.08 01.09 01.10 01.11 01.12 01.13


12/40

12

3: www.nbg.ge

.

. -

25%-.10 -

.

. , -

-

. , 2008

. 4 5

.

4: ( )

10 . 2001 10 N. 95 .


13/40

13

5: ( )

, -

, . , -

. , -

.11

. , , -

.

. - . -

, -

.

. -

. -

.12

.

,

, 2010 1 .

11 - - - - , , - , .

12 , https://debt.reestri.gov.ge/main.php?s=1


14/40

14

-

. ,

. , -

2010 1 .

-

300- 38-40- , -

.

-

.

.13 -

,

(), -

-

. -

.

.

(www.nbe.gov.ge) .

, -

-

. - - . 2013 -

39 , -

.14

-

. 2014 107,805 .

-

, . ,

,

, -

. 301 (1) , ,

13 , http://nbe.gov.ge/index.php?lang_id=ENG&sec_id=367#sthash.XDKGs0vV.dpuf .

14 . http://nbe.gov.ge/files/documents/kerdzo_aghmasrule-belta_reestri_31.07.2013.pdf


15/40

15

, , -

,

. , - ,

, 2009

. -

, ,

.

-

2010 ( 6, 7).

, .

6: (:

)


16/40

16

7: (: )

. . ,

, -

.

:15

-

2014 . , -

,

, , -

,

-

.16

-

15 . . www.nbe.gov.ge

16 . -https://matsne.gov.ge/index.php?option=com_ldmssearch&view=docView&id=2067676&lang=ge


17/40

17

. 2008 .

8%- .17 -

95 , -

. - - ,

.

, , . ,

2008 , -

-

. .

.

, 15%- .

3%, -

12%- . , 95 -

.

. ,

.

, -

, -

. ,

.

.18

:

( );

;

;

() ,

-

, , .

17 , 2013 20

18 European Central Bank Financial Stability Review, December 2011


18/40

18

8: , - www.nbg.ge

2003-2007 - 9.6% ( 8).

( ) . 2008-2009 -

. 2013 , - -

2-2.5% . , , -

.

- -

. , 63% , -

. -

, . -

.

2008 ,

1.44- 1.65- .

-

. , ,

1 - 2008 9 ,

. - .

. - 5%- . 60% -

, .

.

60%- -

.


19/40

19

. -

-

- .

-

:

;

.

-

. , ,

, . 2003-2007 -

. 2006-2008 - .

, .

, -

.

- -

.

. -

, -

. ,

, -

.

.

.19

19 Manove, Padilla, & Pagano. (2001)Collateral Vs. Project Screening: A Model Of Lazy Banks, CEPR Discussion Papers 2439, C.E.P.R.Discussion Papers.

2 ()

- A- 16,000 . , 17%- -

.

. . 17% 2008 .

, . A- -

. -

. 17- 30%- 10

. , 10 16,000 109,787

.

72,000 , 12,000 .


20/40

20

, . -

,

. , , -

. - .

.

-

. :

, -

. () ,

, - . , ,

.20

.

. -

, .

, -

. , -

.

-

, 2007

. , -

, . 2012

20 , 2013 23 .

3 ()

1,500 2011 6

75 . . -

. 6 10 .

. ,

83 , 2,700 -

.

, , .


21/40

21

.

, -

. , 2012 -

, .

2007 . -

() -

, . ,

, -

() ,

.

, -

. -

, -

.

,

- . 21 -

11-, - -2, 1-. ?

1. :

.22, ,

8% 12% , II- -

234% 8%- . ,

. (

BB-, ).

(ROE) .

2. : , 2012 -

6.7% ,

21 Lending Interest Rate by country. The World Bank data http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/FR.INR.LEND

22 . - N. 237 http://www.nbg.gov.ge/uploads/legalacts/supervision/nbg1.4.5.1capital_adequacy_geo.pdf

23 Basel II: Revised International Capital Framework. Bank for International Settlements http://www.bis.org/publ/bcbsca.htm


22/40

22

. ,

(- 18%).24

3. : -

. ( ).

4. : -

3.5% . 4.1%-

.

, -

22%.

, -

.

(LTV ratio)25,

(DTI)26 . 2004-2008 -

-

. 2008-2009

. ,

.

. -

. 2006 :

( 3-4%) . -

,

.

. , -

, -

.

(LTV ratio) 40%-50%-.

:27

24

25 LTV ratio - .

26 DTI ratio - .

27 . http://www.nbg.gov.ge/uploads/legalacts/kanonebi/mikro_kanoni_27_03_13.pdf


23/40

23

- -

150,000 . -

/ -

. - 30,000 -

.

- -

,

15%-.

- , , 150,000 ;

- -

,

;

- ,

( ,

).

-

. , -

. -

. ,

. ( 15-18%-

24-30%- . , - ).

.

. .. -

, . -

, ,

. -

.28

.

,

28 Pritchard, J. (2013). Collateral Loans. Retrieved November 9, 2013, from http://banking.about.com/od/businessbanking/a/collater-alloans.htm


24/40

24

, .

. ,

. -

; .

. -

.

-

, .. , ,

, .29 ,

.

,

.30

, (

, ). -

, .

,

, , -

. -

,

, . ,

-

, - .

, .

,31 40% , 30%

, , 20% -

/. 10% (. -

9). .

(80%-), . -

, . -

, 2009 61 -

.32 , .

29

30 Huang, Y., & Bonina, J. P. (2001). Dealing with the bad loans of the Chinese banks. Journal of Asian Economics , 197214.

31

32 (2010). http://transparency.ge/sites/de-fault/files/post_attachments/Plea%20Bargaining%20in%20Georgia%20-%20Negotiated%20Justice%20-%20GEO%20%282%29.pdf


25/40

25

9: . .

:

- , -

. ,

( ) -

.

, --

. .

, -

2014 . , - . , -

,

; ( 1000

), -

2.5- .

2014 1 .33

, -

, .

-, -

. , , -

, .

-

:

33 . . https://matsne.gov.ge/index.php?option=com_ldmssearch&view=docView&id=2169324&lang=ge


26/40

26

(LTV & DTI )

-

.

10: . -

61% .34, -

. -

.

,

, 30%-50%- -

.

34 : ().


27/40

27

, -,

. , -

.

. -

1- 1.5 . ,

, . , , -

-

,

.35

& 2013 -

5.6%- 2012 6.8%- .36 , 2013

- 932 . , -

12.2 7.6%- . 2014

. 5.6%- .

, . -

. -

.37

2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012

20.4 13.2 8.6 7.1 6.2 2.4 1.6 1.1 1.0 0.9

. -

.

35 Flocking to Europe.Ernst & Young 2013 Non Performing Loan Reporthttp://www.ey.com/Publication/vwLUAssets/Flocking_to_Eu-rope/$FILE/Flocking_to_Europe.pdf

36

37 . . http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/FB.AST.NPER.ZS


28/40

28

, 3.3 (400

. ) .38

- , - . -

.

( ) -

.

, - .

.

. -

(AMC). /

( )39

. , -

-

, , .

:40

- , -

;

- ;

- , ;

- /;- ;

- ;

- , ;

- .

1990- . -

,

, , -

.41

38 Shih, V. (2004). Non-Performing Loans: Political Constraints and Financial Policies in China. The China Quarterly, 922-944.

39 , ( ).

40 Bing, H., (2005). The Ways of Dealing with Non-performing Loans in China: Challenges and Problems. http://dspace.lib.niigata-u.ac.jp:8080/dspace/bitstream/10191/916/1/18_0204.pdf

41 Ashurst Germany (2012), NPL REVIVAL Acquisition of loan portfolios in Germany: recent case law and current market developments


29/40

29

-

, 2003-2007 . , -

,

. - ,

, . -

, 2012

200 . . 2013

, 183

. .42 , -

. -

.

, ,

.43

---- , [---] -

, , -

, ,

, -

.44 , ,

.

, (Landesbanken)

, III- . ,

.45

, , -

- -

, .

, -

.

42 & , 2012-2013 43 German NPL: CORPUS SIREO Expects Asset Management Market Potential From Non-Performing Real Estate Loans to Exceed

Two Billion Euros, http://www.prnewswire.co.uk/news-releases/german-npl-corpus-sireo-expects-asset-management-market-potential-from-non-performing-real-estate-loans-to-exceed-two-billion-euros-231400651.html

44 KPMG: Europes CRE non-performing loan market continues to polarise. http://costarfinance.com/2013/03/06/kpmg-eu-ropes-cre-non-performing-loan-market-continues-to-polarise/

45 Flocking to Europe.Ernst & Young 2013 Non Performing Loan Report.http://www.ey.com/Publication/vwLUAssets/Flocking_to_Eu-rope/$FILE/Flocking_to_Europe.pdf.


30/40

30

:

.

. -

. (Ausgliederung) . , , -

(Umwandlungsgesetz) (Ausgliederung).46

, , -

. -

-

. 850 -

.

. - -

.

.

- .

2003 2012 17.2%- -

. , 30% ( 11).47

, 2013 ,

490 . , -

228.7 . (311.11 . ) . ()

43.4 . , -

.48

.

.

46 NPL trading in Germany, http://www.nortonrosefulbright.com/knowledge/publications/31532/npl-trading-in-germany

47 Berenberg Partnership, Greek Banks, October 22, 2013. http://www.berenberg.de/fileadmin/user_upload/berenberg2013/02_Invest-ment_Banking/Equity_Research/2013_10_22_Greek_Banks.pdf

48 WSJ: Greeces Alpha Bank Sees Third Quarter Loss Widen. November 28, 2013 http://online.wsj.com/article/BT-CO-20131128-704427.html


31/40

31

11: . :

49

. -

, ( )

. , , -

:

. ,

.

.50

- ..

,

.

.51 .

.

, . -

. -

, -

.

49 . .

50 Piraeus Talks Greek banking Recovery. Financial News. October 10, 2013 http://www.efinancialnews.com/story/2013-10-10/pirae-us-talks-greek-banking-recovery?ea9c8a2de0ee111045601ab04d673622

51 The Window of Opportunity for Greece and Its Investors; the New York Times, Business. November 17, 2013 http://www.nytimes.com/2013/11/18/business/international/window-of-opportunity-for-greece-and-its-investors.html?_r=0


32/40

32

(AMCs)

,

. -

. - ,

. ,

- , -

. : -

, ,

.52

. ,53 10 . -

-

, .

, .54

.

. , ,

-

. 2012 TLG Immobilien1.1 . -

Lone Star Funds.

, , . -

: , -

/ .55

- , .

. ,

, , -

.

. , , -

,

52 Klingebiel, D. (2000). The Use of Asset Management Companies in the Resolution of Banking Crises Cross-Country Experiences.World Bank Policy Research Working Paper No. 2284, 1-31.

53 , , , .

54 Huang, Y., & Bonina, J. P. (2001). Dealing with the bad loans of the Chinese banks. Journal of Asian Economics, 197214.

55 Flocking to Europe.Ernst & Young 2013 Non Performing Loan Report.http://www.ey.com/Publication/vwLUAssets/Flocking_to_Eu-rope/$FILE/Flocking_to_Europe.pdf


33/40

33

.

.

-

.

,

, . -

. ,

. -

, -

.

, 20%- . -

,

.

-

.

: , -

, . -

, .

.

. -

. , , -

, -

. , -

.

.

(11-216 ), - -

(304-314 ).56 , -

. -

()

.

56 Braun, S. (2006). German Insolvency Act: Special Provisions of Consumer Insolvency Proceedings and the Discharge of ResidualDebts. GERMAN LAW JOURNAL, 59-70.


34/40

34

.

.

,

.

, -

.

-

, .

:

, -

; -

.57

,

. -

- -

.58

-

.

.

. , , , , , -

. -

.

. -

-7, -11 -13 .

7,

-7 -

. -

. , .59

57 Braun, S. (2006). German Insolvency Act: Special Provisions of Consumer Insolvency Proceedings and the Discharge of ResidualDebts. GERMAN LAW JOURNAL, 59-70.

58 .


35/40

35

, -

. -

.

, -7 .

-

. , ,

, . -

. -7

.

11,

-11 .

, -

.

.

.60-11 .

, , -

.

-11 ,

.61

,

, -7 .-11 ,

.

13,

, ,

-13 . -11 -

, -

. -13 . ,

,

.

59 Flocking to Europe.Ernst & Young 2013 Non Performing Loan Report.http://www.ey.com/Publication/vwLUAssets/Flocking_to_Eu-rope/$FILE/Flocking_to_Europe.pdf

60 Internal Revenue Service. Chapter 17. Legal Reference Guide for Revenue Officers. Retrieved October 25, 2013 http://www.irs.gov/irm/part5/irm_05-017-010.html

61 .


36/40

36

-

. ,

, -

.

, ,

. , / -

. -

,

,

. , -

.

, , -

, , -

. ,

-

.

() , -

. () -

,

.

, ,

,

,

. ,

2008 ,

, .

.

, ,

. -

,

. . , -


37/40

37

, .

()

- . -

, ,

. , -

/ ,

. , -

-

.

. -

-

, , , . , -

.

-

.

.

, , , -

-,

. , , -

, , .

, , , -

.

,

, , -

, , . -

. , , -

, .

, ,

.

, -

.


38/40

38

, .

, ,

.

, - , -

.

. -

. -

, .

-

,

.

. , -

. :

, -

, , .

.

- - . -

, .

2014 , ,

, -

,

,

-

. -

. , , ,

.

, -

, -

, .


39/40


40/40

/ . 85/24. . 0162. . .

Documents

Management of Non-Performing Loans in Georgia_GEO