Magazine, Or Animadversions on the English Spelling (1703)

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/10/2019 Magazine, Or Animadversions on the English Spelling (1703)

    1/36

    The Project Gutenberg EBook of Magazine, or Animadversions on the EnglishSpelling (1703), by G. W.

    This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and withalmost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away orre-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License includedwith this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org

    Title: Magazine, or Animadversions on the English Spelling (1703)

    Author: G. W.

    Commentator: David Abercrombie

    Release Date: December 18, 2006 [EBook #20130]

    Language: English

    Character set encoding: UTF-8

    *** START OF THIS PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK MAGAZINE, OR ANIMADVERSIONS ***

    Produced by Louise Hope, David Starner and the OnlineDistributed Proofreading Team at http://www.pgdp.net

    [Transcriber's Note:

    This e-text includes a few Greek and Hebrew letters:

    ayin , dalet , he , shin ; gamma G g, theta Q q

    If these letters do not display properly, or if the

    uotation marks in this para raph appear as arba e, make sure your text reader's character set or file encodin is set to Unicode (UTF-8). You may also need to chan e the default font. As a last resort, use the latin-1 version of this file instead.

    In the printed text, the author's special letters were represented by ordinary roman letters turned upside-down. They are shown in this e-text by sin

    le letters in [brackets]. Alternative readin

    s of selected passa es are iven at the end of the text, before the list

    of errata.

    Sin

    le italicized letters within a word are shown in {braces}.

    The word Taurus (astrolo ical symbol ) refers to the ou li ature (, or upsilon balanced atop omicron) used in printed

    reek.]

  • 8/10/2019 Magazine, Or Animadversions on the English Spelling (1703)

    2/36

    THE AU

    USTAN REPRINT SOCIETY

    . W.

    MA

    AZINE, or

    Animadversions on the En

    lish Spellin

    (1703)

    Introduction by David Abercrombie

    Publication Number 70

    Los An

    eles William Andrews Clark Memorial Library University of California

    1958

    * * * * *

    ENERAL EDITORS

    RICHARD C. BOYS, University of Michi anRALPH COHEN, University of California, Los An elesVINTON A. DEARIN

    , University of California, Los An elesLAWRENCE CLARK POWELL, Clark Memorial Library

    ASSISTANT EDITOR

    W. EARL BRITTON, University of Michi an

    ADVISORY EDITORS

    EMMETT L. AVERY, State Colle e of Washin tonBENJAMIN BOYCE, Duke UniversityLOUIS BREDVOLD, University of Michi

    anJOHN BUTT, Kin 's Colle e, University of DurhamJAMES L. CLIFFORD, Columbia UniversityARTHUR FRIEDMAN, University of Chica oLOUIS A. LANDA, Princeton UniversitySAMUEL H. MONK, University of MinnesotaERNEST C. MOSSNER, University of TexasJAMES SUTHERLAND, University Colle e, LondonH. T. SWEDENBER

    , JR., University of California, Los An

    eles

    CORRESPONDIN

    SECRETARY

    EDNA C. DAVIS, Clark Memorial Library

    * * * * *

    INTRODUCTION

    I first came across what is, as far as I know, the uni ue copy of

  • 8/10/2019 Magazine, Or Animadversions on the English Spelling (1703)

    3/36

    _Ma azine_, by

    . W., when workin in the library formed by the late SirIsaac Pitman.[1] It is bound up as the last item in a volume whichcontains several nineteenth-century pamphlets on lan ua e and spellin ,and also the first numbers of the periodical _The Phonetic Friend_. (Thevolume was for a time in the possession of the Bath City Free Library,to which it was presented by Isaac Pitman; it must subse

    uently havebeen returned to him.) I drew attention to the existence of _Ma azine_in an article published in 1937;[2] to the best of my knowled

    e it hadnot been noticed in print before that, thou h it is of considerableinterest in a number of respects. I am indebted to Sir Isaac Pitman &Sons Ltd., London, for permission to reproduce the pamphlet herewith inthe Au

    ustan Reprints.

    . W. was a spellin

    reformer, one of the many writers who, from earlyElizabethan times onwards, have been critical of traditional En lishortho

    raphy and have made proposals for improvin

    it. Althou

    h nothin

    that could be called a spellin -reform movement existed until thenineteenth century, there were earlier periods when the subject was muchin the air, when a number of people were writin about it and readin and discussin

    each other

    s ideas. The publication of _Ma

    azine_ doesnot fall at one of these times; it comes, in fact, in the very middleof a recession of interest in spellin

    reform which lasted almosta hundred years. From about 1650 to 1750 there were few critics ofour ortho

    raphy, and they were usually neither very stron

    in their

    criticisms nor radical in their proposals for amendment.

    . W. is thus asomewhat isolated fi

    ure, and his scheme for reform would appear, in itsdetails at least, to be fairly ori inal.

    The reater part of the pamphlet is iven over to expoundin theillo icalities and inconsistencies of the established spellin , and here

    . W.

    s style of writin , which is collo uial, racy and allusive, iseffective enou h. It is not so well suited, however, to orderly andclear exposition of his proposed amendment--unfortunately, since thisis what is likely to be of most interest to us today (and numerousmisprints increase the difficulties of raspin his proposals). Perhapsthere was, or was to have been, a se uel which would have stated hisreforms more systematically; that this may have been the case appears

    from the statement on p. 25 that the alphabet is preparin

    , andfrom the mention, on the last pa e, of the ensuin Batl-dur (i.e.battledore or hornbook). His remedy, briefly, is to replace di raphs bynew symbols: more Letters would do well in the Alfabet, but fewer inmost words (p. 25); and, like John Hart before him (whose works perhapshe knew) and Bernard Shaw after, he draws attention to the economies tobe ained from this: if fewer Letters will serve the turn,

    twill savePaper and Ink, and

    tis stran

    e, if not labour too (p. 5).

    On p. 32 is exhibited a compleat Alfebet of 34 symbols (it is notcomplete, for L has, apparently inadvertently, been omitted). Althou hthere is no indication there of the value each symbol should have, thatof most of them can be worked out, with some labor, from the rest of the

    pamphlet (thou

    h a few must probably remain mysteries). I have commentedelsewhere[3] on this scheme of reformed spellin ; it appears to us todayto be theoretically

    uite creditable, at least as far as the consonantsare concerned. The traditional alphabet is enlar ed by providin aseparate symbol for the italicized sounds in each of the followinwords: {th}in {th}en {ch}urch {j}ud e {sh}all mea{s}ure {wh}en si{n };these symbols are obtained partly by creatin

    new ones, partly byredefinin existin letters. In two cases existin letters are redefinedin accordance with a rather odd principle--that the traditional _name_of a letter must decide its value. Hence _h_ is used to spell _church_

  • 8/10/2019 Magazine, Or Animadversions on the English Spelling (1703)

    4/36

    (which becomes hurh), and __ is used to spell _jud e_ (which becomes

    u

    ). This of course makes it necessary for

    . W. to include amon

    hisnew symbols one for /h/ and one for / /. The new symbols as used in thepamphlet are produced by invertin or reversin existin letters; butthese may possibly be makeshifts, used in place of more ambitious shapeswhich were beyond the reach of his printer; he su

    ests, for instance(p. 20) the si n Taurus with a Foot-Ball between his horns as oneof his vowel symbols. On the whole, we find the vowels much lesssystematically tackled than the consonants, and it is proposed thataccents (cambrils) should for the most part be used to provide extrasymbols; the pamphlet, however, only exemplifies this sporadically.

    _Ma azine_ contains a considerable number of words, and a fewconsecutive texts, transcribed partly or wholly in the new system ofspellin , and these necessarily will have to be assessed as evidence ofcontemporary En

    lish pronunciation by students of the subject. It is noteasy to be sure how accurate a phonetic observer and transcriber

    . W.was, but if we make some allowance for misprints, we find a certainconsistency in his transcriptions, and an apparent freedom from any bias

    iven by the traditional spellin

    , which make one think he wasmoderately reliable. In this connexion it is of some importance to findout, if possible, where he came from. He shows familiarity both withnorthern and western types of speech; but althou h he seems to imply, onp. 7, that he is not a North-countryman, E. J. Dobson has found, on the

    basis of certain forms which appear in the pamphlet, that there is astron

    su

    estion that he spoke a northern dialect.[4]

    Until recently I had been able to form no idea of the identity of . W.However, it new seems to be very possible that he was John White, aDevon schoolmaster, and author of _The Country-Man

    s Conductor inReadin and Writin True En lish_, which was published in Exeter in1701.[5] The name John, in . W. s reformed spellin , would of coursebe in with

    (it is indeed so spelled on p. 15). White was interested inspellin reform, as we know from various remarks in his book; and if hewas

    . W., it would explain the familiarity shown in _Ma azine_ withwestern dialect. What is particularly strikin , moreover, is thesimilarity of White

    s style to

    . W.

    s, as the followin uotations from

    _The Country-Man

    s Conductor_ will show: of certain

    rammarians, youshall seldom hear them speak Latin but in Ale-Houses, or when they arewell oil

    d; of specimens of early En lish, some may lau h at it, andthereby expose their rusty Teeth that will look as old as the En

    lish;of usin an accent to show lon vowels, this would look stran e

    tillit come in fashion, but in time would set as tite as Topknots do now.

    [Transcriber's Note: A more recent candidate for

    . W. is John Wild. His 1710 broadsheet, Nottin ham Printin Perfected, is in the ima es directory associated with the html version of this file.]

    One final resemblance must be mentioned. Whether or not White was

    . W.,

    there can hardly be any doubt that _Ma

    azine_ was printed by SamuelFarley of Exeter, the printer of White

    s book. The typo raphicalsimilarity between _Ma

    azine_ and _The Country-Man

    s Conductor_ (andother works printed by Farley) is too complete to be coincidental. Notonly are the identical fonts used, but there are numerous other pointswhere the eneral manner of printin is the same.

    Further research may confirm White

    s authorship, but there is certainlyno other obvious candidate amon the writers of the time.

  • 8/10/2019 Magazine, Or Animadversions on the English Spelling (1703)

    5/36

    David Abercrombie

    University of Edinbur h

    NOTES TO THE INTRODUCTION

    [Footnote 1: This library is now housed in the offices of Sir IsaacPitman & Sons, Ltd., Parker Street, London, W.C. 2.]

    [Footnote 2: _Le Maitre Phoneti ue_, No. 59, p. 34. Some of the verseson p. 22 of the pamphlet are reproduced there.]

    [Footnote 3: In the _Transactions of the Philolo

    ical Society_, 1948,pp. 11 ff.; _Lin ua_, Vol. 2, 1949, p. 60.]

    [Footnote 4: _En lish Pronunciation 1500-1700_, Vol. 1, p. 267. In Vol.II, p. 977, Dobson says

    . W. was certainly a Northerner.]

    [Footnote 5: A second edition called _The Conductor in Spellin

    ,Readin & Writin , True En lish_, dated 1712, is identical with thefirst except for the title-pa

    e.]

    * * * * *

    MA

    AZINE,

    or,

    Animadversions

    on the

    En lish Spellin ;

    OBSERVIN

    The Contradictions of the En

    lish Letters Warrin

    themselves a

    ainstthemselves, and one with another, by Intrusions and Usurpations; withAmendment offer'd.

    For the Benefit of all Teachers and Learners, Writers and Readers,Composers and Scriveners, whether Stran ers or Natives, who areconcern'd with our En lish Ton ue.

    _Nun uam sera est ad bonos mores via._ Syntax.

    By

    . W.

    _LONDON_: Printed for the Author. 1703.

    Price Sixpence.

    _Ma azine, that is low Learnin , too hi h for the Capacity of theVul

    ar; Or the Schooler School'd. _viz_, _Babel_ pull'd down, andConfusion Confounded. The latter Survey of the En lish Letters, and waysof Amendment, where thin s are too much amiss to be excus'd, onlyreferrin all to the ood will of those that are willin to amend their

  • 8/10/2019 Magazine, Or Animadversions on the English Spelling (1703)

    6/36

    perceiv'd mistakes and unwillin to fall into their former Errorsa

    ain._

    . Horatij Flacci, Epistolarum Liber secundus. Ad Au ustum Epist. I.Paulo post initium.

    Si meliora dies, ut vina poemata reddit Scire velim: Pretium chartis

    uotus arro

    at annus. Scriptor abhinc annos centum ui decidit, inter Perfectos veteres

    ue, referri debet, an inter Viles at ue novos? Excludat jur ia finis. Est vetus at

    ue probus centum

    ui perficit annos.

    uid?

    ui deperiit minor uno mense vel anno. Inter

    uos referendvs erit veteresne poetas. An uos & prsens & postera respuat tas? Iste

    uidem veteres, inter ponetur honeste.

    ui vel mense brevi vel toto est junior anno. Utor permisso; cauda

    ue pilos ut e

    uina Paulatim vello, & demo unum, demo etiam unum. Dum cadat.----

    _The Second Book of Epistles of _

    uintus, Horatius, Flaccus_. The FirstEpistle unto the Emperour _Au

    ustus Csar_, in whose days our Saviour

    Christ was Born._

    Thus En lish'd.

    There is a thin I fain would know, As A e doth make Wines better; Whether to Papers it doth so, And what's Writ on't with Letter, And what A e ives a Reverence To Papers, I would know: If Authors Credits ot by Tense Of Hundred Years or mo? An Ancient currant Author then,

    And Hundred Years is Old? Or is he of the Sli ht

    own men, That Writ then as 'tis told? Set down the time that strife may cease: And hundred Years is ood, If one Month short, or Year he bears, Doth he slick in the Mud? No, for one Month or Year, we

    rant, And very honestly too; He shall be counted Ancient Without so much ado. What you do

    rant, I'm very free To use now at my pleasure:

    Another Month, or Year, d' ye see I'll bate, as I have leasure; So Hair by Hair, from the Mare's Tail I'll pull, as well I may. So what is ood, is uickly stale, Thou h Writ but t' other day.

    That we make somethin to discourse upon further, I'll take an Exampleor two from the two Tables, wherein one Sound is Spell'd diverse ways,and a ain the same Letters make diverse Sounds.

  • 8/10/2019 Magazine, Or Animadversions on the English Spelling (1703)

    7/36

    First then, z, dayes, praise, phrase, aze.

    A. Asia, day, fair, wear, heir.

    E. Phebe, key, the, sea, yea, wei h, either, holy.

    I. Why, I, hi h, try, tie, buy.

    O. Who, know, bow, toe, tow, dou h.

    U. True, dew, Hu h, neuter, ive, you, aol, jaylor, oal, John, ives_dat_;

    ives _compedes_,

    ill of fishes,

    ill of water, a

    ue, pla

    ue,an er, and dan er, uard, re uard, sprin , a well, sprin of steele,jet, and

    in

    er, and fin

    er,

    host,

    od, and

    hurmes, and a

    e, a

    es,cares.

    Our Children are not Witches, that they should uess to Read ri ht bythe Letter, such stuff as this, and the Masters are no very

    reatConjurers, to perceive nothin ; what contradictions they make 'emswallow.

    First then dayes, that is da--yes, why should not yes spell yes at the

    end, as well as at the be

    innin

    of a word: A

    ain, why mi

    ht we notspell dayes thus, daise as well as praise, and spell praises, prayes,da--i--se: I see day, why not se, see, as well as he, h--? And why notdase, dayes, and phrayes, phrase, or phraise, phrase, and daze, dayes;and why not daze, or dase, daisey, or daisy, hei, daisy: how can Ladiesbe blam'd for Writin bad En lish, when Scholars spell no better?

    A, as Asia, why not da; fare and ware; how can one Vowel have another,at command to make it lon ; a circumflex mi ht do it. But you answer itis our custom, and Books would not be read if we chan e the spellin ;but is there not a ri ht spellin as Ancient as wron ? Is not the asancient as wei h, yea, sea, holy, key. Then 'tis wit to use the properspellin , and leave off impertinencies; and if fewer Letters will serve

    the turn, 'twill save Paper and Ink, and 'tis stran

    e, if not labourtoo, for Writers; no doubt for Teachers it will.

    And how many ways do we pronounce you? yo, yau, yeu, yiu, you, yuu, yetevery dialect praise their own Speech, nay in Towns near to ether, nayin the same Town, nay in the same House, persons born in other places,differ in pronounciation, and many deli ht to hear different dialects(as the

    recians did) so they did but understand one another, thou

    hsome precise Females do condemn all but their own finical pronunciation.

    But why should phrase be spell'd with ph and s, and not f and z? Becauseyou say its Ori

    inal is a

    reek word: But it hath been lon

    enou

    hfreely us'd amon st us, that it may claim prescription for a Licence to

    put on the En

    lish

    arb, and suits pretty well with the Ori

    inal frazw

    nd h

    th it not

    single

    in G

    eek? So might be

    ,

    nd t

    ke

    ith itthe G

    eek P

    ecispomene, its

    ight.

    But i

    e spell p

    ise thus, p

    yes

    e

    lte

    the sense. Why the Eyes

    e

    s much in the d

    k to distinguish sound,

    s the E

    s

    e put to silence

    t the sh

    pe o

    Lette

    s,

    nd

    hich o

    these is the

    itte

    judge in thisCont

    ove

    sy, to b

    ing kno

    ledge to the Unde

    st

    nding? Th

    t is to beobse

    v'd

    ell: But

    h

    t's Le

    nt in Childhood is uncont

    oul

    ble,

    s good

    s p

    esc

    iption o

    n hund

    ed ye

    s,

    nd

    School-D

    mes

    utho

    ity is

  • 8/10/2019 Magazine, Or Animadversions on the English Spelling (1703)

    8/36

    i

    e

    g

    ble,

    s the P

    ove

    b s

    ys, _E

    ly c

    ookes the T

    ee, th

    t

    illgood C

    mb

    ill be_: Th

    t to unle

    n

    Youth

    ul E

    o

    , is mo

    e th

    n tose

    ve

    n App

    entiseship, o

    t

    ke the Deg

    ee o

    Docto

    o

    Se

    je

    nt. Fo

    these

    e de

    nd dumb to Le

    n the cont

    y,

    s the de

    d Lette

    s theyh

    ve Le

    n'd, though I

    m lo

    th to comp

    e them to the English Docto

    _Bu

    net_'s _Antidiluvi

    n People_ pett

    i

    y'd in the Alps,

    hich he s

    inhis T

    v

    ils:

    But in some p

    ts they spe

    k

    s

    e spell: Though the Count

    ym

    n o

    the_No

    th_ in Ap

    on

    nd I

    on, p

    onounce o

    te

    ,

    nd

    e be

    o

    e it: Whyshould

    e keep thei

    spelling, h

    ving lost thei

    speech,

    nd

    hy shouldthey not still keep thei

    spelling o

    old,

    ho still keep the speech?'Tis this thought by some o

    the Le

    ned, th

    t English is the h

    destL

    ngu

    ge in the Wo

    ld;

    o

    th

    t Fo

    eigne

    s coming ove

    , being p

    stChild

    en, neve

    h

    ve ou

    speech

    ight, but m

    y be disce

    n'd to be noEnglish bo

    n,

    he

    e

    s

    e

    te

    sho

    t

    bode in out-L

    nds, spe

    k thei

    Tongue

    s

    ell

    s N

    tives: Ou

    olk being

    mixtu

    e o

    m

    ny N

    tions, isso o

    L

    ngu

    ges: But 'tis

    onde

    , so

    ee

    s

    e

    e to t

    ke in thei

    o

    ds,

    e t

    ke not in thei

    Lette

    s

    lso. The L

    tines h

    ve but T

    elveConson

    nts,

    nd Five Vo

    els,

    nd h, but the G

    eek

    nd Heb

    e

    m

    y

    u

    nishus

    ith Lette

    s. The Neighbou

    ing Count

    ies

    e

    t

    loss

    o

    them

    s

    ell

    s

    e. I

    ou

    c

    edit be good,

    e

    nt to bo

    o

    T

    o lette

    s o

    theG

    eek, _G

    m

    _,

    nd _Thet

    _,

    nd Fou

    o

    the Heb

    e

    , _Th

    leth_, _He_,_Aim_,

    nd _Shin_,

    nd

    e should be set up,

    nd

    ith

    h

    t shi

    t

    e c

    n

    m

    ke o

    ou

    o

    n.

    In the

    i

    st pl

    ce

    h

    t is the English o

    _Quotus_? But no

    my Pen issilenc'd, except I bo o the T o G eek Lette s, nd _Th leth_ o theHeb

    e

    ,

    nd the _Acute_,

    nd G

    eek _Ci

    cum

    lex_, to tell ho

    Gth

    m,Gothe

    d, o

    g

    the

    , is to be

    ed,

    nd

    hich is ment o

    the 24.

    Gth m, [G]th m, Gth m, [G]th m, G[t] m, [G][t] m, G[t] m,[G][t]

    m, G[c]

    m, [G][c]

    m, G[c]

    m, [G][c]

    m, Gothm, [G]othm,Gothm, [G]othm, Go[t]m, [G]o[t]m, Go[t]m, [G]o[t]m, Go[c]m,[G]o[c]m, Gothm, Go[c]m.

    [G] is _G

    m

    _, [T] is _Thet

    _, [D] _Th

    leth_; 'tis st

    nge my Tongue

    should be longe

    th

    n my A

    ms,

    ithout eking. 'Tis h

    d

    o

    Dunces tounde

    st

    nd this

    s

    ll

    ill

    ul Fools

    e. Humble humility is bette

    th

    nthe mise

    ble

    isdom o

    the me

    ciless kno

    ledge o

    e

    o

    . Cunning

    oole

    ies

    nd v

    nities unlock'd

    o

    , to spell the s

    me sound dive

    se

    ys,

    nd

    hen you h

    ve

    ll done, you

    e but

    he

    e you

    s,

    s p

    yes,p

    ise, p

    sy. Fo

    hy m

    y not y st

    nd

    o

    nothing

    te

    s,

    s

    ell

    s

    te

    ,

    s m

    y: But

    he

    e no

    e

    son the

    e is

    o

    custom, custom is no

    e

    son. D

    sye,

    nd d

    yes is

    ll one. As the

    ool thinks, so the Bellchinks,

    o

    ou

    Lette

    s

    e like _Wimondes-

    oles_ Bells. Su

    e i

    e h

    vethese t

    icks,

    e h

    ve mo

    e. Why i

    y doth no good, it doth nothing. ButI h

    ve

    mind it sh

    ll st

    nd

    n out-side the

    e out o

    the

    y,

    s d

    isy,is d

    yes. Doth (GO{D}) spell the C

    e

    to

    , it spells

    n Heb

    e

    Lette

    s

    ell. I

    you hold you

    book the

    ong end up

    d. I've nothing to s

    y

    g

    inst it,

    o

    'tis you

    o

    n,

    nd you m

    y hold it

    s you ple

    se.

    But to go on

    cco

    ding to P

    esc

    ipt.

    2. Whethe

    o

    no

    e ou

    24 Lette

    s su

    icient to spell

    ll the

    o

    ds o

    ou

    English Tongue.

    3. Whethe

    o

    no i

    they be su

    icient to spell

    ll

    o

    ds us'd

    o

    English in ou

    books, they be not su

    icient to spell

    ll L

    ngu

    ges; i

    _Engl

    nd_ be like _Rome_, Conque

    ing

    ll N

    tions, took in the Idol

    [t]

    y

  • 8/10/2019 Magazine, Or Animadversions on the English Spelling (1703)

    9/36

    o

    ll L

    s, so _Engl

    nd_ being Conque

    'd by

    ll, h

    th not got the

    ubish o

    ll L

    ngu

    ges.

    4. Whethe

    o

    no

    e m

    ke good

    nd p

    ope

    use o

    those Lette

    s

    e h

    ve.

    5. Whethe

    the old use

    nd custom o

    the Lette

    s

    o

    n hund

    ed Ye

    s o

    mo

    e, be su

    icient

    o

    justi

    ying the mispelling most

    o

    ds, us'd tothis d

    y, o

    hethe

    e h

    d not bette

    mend l

    te th

    n neve

    .

    He

    eupon

    e

    gue. Fi

    st, It is g

    nted th

    t

    e h

    ve not yet p

    ope

    English

    o

    ll

    o

    ds in othe

    L

    ngu

    ges, no

    Lette

    s su

    icient toexp

    ess ou

    o

    n;

    s Autho

    s

    om time to time do justi

    ie,

    ho h

    ve binso little t

    ken notice o

    by the publick (though the

    e is some sm

    ll

    mendment m

    de, th

    t c

    n sc

    ce be pe

    ceiv'd). The l

    tte

    Autho

    smentioning the

    o

    me

    ,

    ll Men o

    no sm

    ll Note.

    Secondly, The

    e

    s

    s good

    e

    son

    o

    mendment

    n Hund

    ed Ye

    s

    go,

    s the

    e is no

    ,

    nd

    ill be

    s good

    e

    son

    n Hund

    ed ye

    s hence todel

    y the

    mendment,

    s thei

    is no

    ; not

    lte

    ing

    tittle o

    the kno

    nP

    onounci

    tion o

    the

    o

    ds, but only o

    the spelling. Th

    t the Lette

    sm

    y be o

    good use,

    nd

    e need not to Re

    d

    ll by

    utho

    ity,

    s theve

    y Le

    ned Men

    e

    o

    c'd to do in yet unkno

    n

    o

    ds still; so little

    ssist

    nce do the Lette

    s yield them, th

    t they the mo

    e might pittyyoung beginne

    s. Which thing h

    th m

    de

    m

    ny Fo

    eigne

    s (

    nd no m

    vel

    t

    ll) o

    ll the Neighbou

    ing N

    tions to th

    o

    y thei

    Books

    ndStudy o

    English,

    s thei

    English G

    mm

    s,

    s

    ell

    s ou

    o

    n, dosu

    iciently decl

    e.

    Thus to m

    int

    in

    thing

    l

    ys un

    e

    son

    ble,

    ill

    l

    ys be (

    s it h

    thbin)

    thing un

    e

    son

    ble

    nd

    te

    this

    te

    n e

    o

    eve

    l

    sting.

    But it is ns e 'd, th t m ny o ds be thus Spell'd to she theide

    iv

    tions. Th

    t need not be objected,

    hen Schol

    s c

    n

    ind out theEtymologyes,

    hen sc

    ce one Lette

    em

    ins o

    thei

    O

    igin

    l, mo

    e th

    nJ

    mes

    om J

    cob, Th

    ddus

    nd Lebbus,

    om Jude the honest, o

    Jud

    s,not Isc

    e

    t,

    nd Didymus

    om Thom

    s, Giles, gidius. As

    o

    ch

    ngingthe Lette

    s, I sh

    ll hope they

    ill put the devines in; I

    e

    not th

    t

    they c

    n put the L

    ye

    s out.

    Wh

    t

    dv

    nt

    ge o

    dis

    dv

    nt

    ge it m

    y be to Bookselle

    s o

    P

    inte

    s,

    snone o

    my business, I le

    ve to thei

    conside

    tion.

    But no

    to st

    ike

    t the

    oot o

    so m

    ny e

    o

    s begotten by

    lseLette

    s, besides

    lse

    inic

    l speech

    cco

    ding to the Lette

    s, beingillete

    tely litte

    te,

    s c

    l

    , h

    ut, goust.

    _The Second P

    t o

    lo

    Le

    ning high._

    The O

    de

    .

    1. Vo

    els, 2. Diphthongs, 3. Conson

    nts.

    A is us'd 7

    ys,

    nd othe

    Vo

    els so; When thus, o

    so, it doth

    m

    e,

    e h

    ve no m

    k to kno

    .

    Fi

    st, A long in Ch

    mbe

    ch

    nged d

    nge

    comm

    nded. Secondly, Sho

    t in

  • 8/10/2019 Magazine, Or Animadversions on the English Spelling (1703)

    10/36

    Ambe

    h

    ng'd Ange

    , Unde

    st

    nding.

    No

    suppose Renn

    d the Fox, o

    the like old book,

    s Rep

    inted,

    nd long C

    mb

    il'd, (

    hich the G

    eeks c

    ll _Pe

    ispomene_)

    nd

    sho

    t not,

    ould not th

    t be

    good guide

    o

    e

    ding old Renn

    d un

    ep

    inted,

    ith

    ight p

    onounci

    tion, though the

    e be no di

    e

    ence in

    long o

    sho

    t.

    Next, i

    it

    ould ple

    se the

    isdom o

    oolish custom (in

    hose e

    o

    so

    this kind (though in nothing else)

    ll Religions meet) being longenough

    dvis'd in time, to think

    it to

    mend in the Copy, o

    t le

    stin the M

    gin,

    he

    e

    o

    ds

    e

    othe

    ise spell'd, th

    n they

    ep

    onounc'd (

    hich the Heb

    e

    s c

    ll Ke

    y

    nd Kethiu; the Copy

    s

    itten,but Ke

    y the M

    gin

    s

    e

    d, m

    k'd

    ith Aste

    isk, one to the othe

    ) Ibelieve ou

    P

    inte

    s could

    s e

    sily C

    mb

    il ou

    English Vo

    els,

    sCi

    cum

    lex the L

    tin,

    hich

    ould be

    su

    e guide

    o

    e

    ding.

    [T

    nsc

    ibe

    's Note: The Heb

    e

    te

    ms

    e usu

    lly

    itten (Ke

    i)

    nd [.((Kethiv

    3dly

    nd 4thly, A sho

    t

    ithout eithe

    ule o

    e

    son be

    o

    e

    Conson

    nto

    t

    o,

    ith e

    te

    ,

    s

    ce,

    c

    e,

    ble, unst

    ble,

    the

    ,

    ith A long,

    nd sol

    ce, m

    ss

    c

    e, const

    ble, g

    the

    ,

    ith A sho

    t.

    5thly, A put

    o

    A C

    mb

    il to m

    ke e o

    o long,

    s be

    , g

    e

    te

    , b

    o

    d,bo

    d. 6thly, Put like

    C

    mb

    il,

    nd is not

    C

    mb

    il, neithe

    ,

    sBe

    t

    ice, c

    e

    te, c

    e

    tou

    : So is i

    lse C

    mb

    il to

    ,

    s

    o

    igne

    s.When pe son is in Commission, he should e the live y o his O ice;but

    hen he signi

    ies nothing, he should not put it on, n

    y

    the

    , heh

    d bette

    keep

    t home.

    7thly, A st nding o just nothing, but s the sh do o C mb il, she

    ven, e

    th, b

    e

    d, he

    d,

    e

    lm, me

    do

    ,

    e

    d in the P

    ete

    pe

    ectTense.

    In

    R

    il o

    P

    les, i

    one be out to let in one Hog, 'tis enough to letin the

    hole He

    d into the Close, is

    n obse

    v

    tion

    pplic

    ble to the

    p

    emisses.

    E long

    nd sho

    t,

    nd

    e c

    n see no c

    use

    o

    't in equ

    lly

    nd equity,in cement,

    eg

    d, to

    ment,

    ebell,

    egiste

    , long

    nd sho

    t in the s

    me

    o

    ds being Acute

    hen Ve

    bs,

    nd pen

    cute

    hen Nounes. But

    ny Child o

    Fo

    eigne

    , th

    t neve

    he

    d the

    o

    ds spoken, might une

    sily guess

    tthe t

    ue p

    onunci

    tion by the sense, Th

    t

    n Acute

    ould be

    g

    e

    t e

    se

    nd com

    o

    t to the Re

    de

    nd Te

    che

    ,

    nd no g

    e

    t t

    ouble to theP

    inte

    .

    3dly,

    nd 4thly, E long

    nd sho

    t be

    o

    e 2 C

    mb

    ils to be

    up itst

    in, _vi

    ._ e be

    o

    e,

    nd e

    te

    Conson

    nt,

    lso g

    nd e, o

    i

    ndgh, 3 C

    mb

    ils,

    s e

    e, be

    e,

    ith

    nd e; but he

    e

    ith but one

    C

    mb

    il;

    eigh

    ith 2 o

    3: In e

    st, b

    e

    d, ste

    d, it m

    kes no use o

    the C

    mb

    ils, only

    o

    st

    te A must d

    nce

    ttend

    nce,

    s in m

    nyhund

    eds mo

    e.

    5thly,

    nd 6thly, e long

    nd sho

    t be

    o

    e

    conson

    nt o

    2,

    nd

    nothe

    e,

    s steple, people, t

    eble

    nd indeleble.

    7thly, Syll

    bles

    e long

    ithout e

    o

    C

    mb

    il,

    s dost, most, ghost,b

    ight,

    ight, sign, design,

    nd sho

    t, not

    ithst

    nding e C

    mb

    il

    shence, since, p

    ince, possible,

    cile, but P

    ince

    nd Simple p

    ope

  • 8/10/2019 Magazine, Or Animadversions on the English Spelling (1703)

    11/36

    N

    mes be spoken,

    ith i long, th

    t

    n unkno

    n Re

    de

    mist

    ke not thepe

    sons n

    mes.

    But ho

    nonsensic

    lly e is us'd in the end o

    syll

    bles sho

    t in live,love, gives, but long,

    live,

    nd gives (

    ette

    s)

    nd is p

    onounc'd

    ndunp

    onounc'd be

    o

    e s,

    s

    ges,

    ges, c

    ges, ho

    ses,

    sses, chu

    ches,

    nd po

    ches,

    nd not in c

    es,

    e

    s, hopes,

    obes, bones,

    nd m

    king ilong

    nd not,

    s

    ite

    ,

    ighte

    , mit

    e, hithe

    nd thithe

    : In

    hethe

    ,e sho

    t,

    nd

    e

    the

    , in neithe

    e long; like

    ise e is p

    onounc'd

    ndunp

    onounc'd in the middle,

    s comm

    ndements,

    ighteous, covetous,stupe

    ie, not in c

    e

    ul, c

    eless, g

    te

    ul,

    e

    e

    ul; not in

    ednesd

    y,

    nd is p

    onounc'd

    te

    diphthong o

    double conson

    nt, ve

    yneedlesly,

    s in inne, Anne,

    sse, poo

    e,

    oome, joye, c

    use, l

    s,coi

    e, choice, juice,

    nd

    s b

    dly

    te

    syll

    bles m

    de long by

    o

    i,

    s

    e

    es,

    o

    ds, thei

    e, veine, veile, eithe

    . In Be

    es

    o

    d the l

    tte

    e is misp

    onounced by Schol

    ship, mist

    ken to m

    ke it t

    issyl

    ble.

    8thly, E is p

    onounc'd sometimes singly in the end o

    o

    ds,

    s inPhebe, Cy

    ene, Penelope, Eute

    pe. But these be G

    eek

    o

    ds, but so isnot the

    nd be. But

    h

    t

    n Huste

    on p

    ote

    n is this to te

    ch the G

    eekG

    mm

    be

    o

    e the B

    ttledo

    e.

    9thly, E put

    o

    in they, thei

    ,

    nd

    o

    i in eve

    , neve

    , evil,

    evil, devil.

    10th, E put

    o

    ee,

    s Pete

    , Steven, even, he, she, me,

    e. Andsometimes ie

    o

    the s

    me,

    s yield, believe,

    iend,

    nd othe

    ise in iend, iend, diet, quiet, but not like neithe , but let th t un uponth' tongue, m

    de long in people by o,

    lso in

    eo

    e, heo

    ness. _vi

    ._He

    vens, (

    p

    onounc'd

    s v) le

    t out in Geo

    ge, bie

    e,

    iend, le

    veout i, sieve, e; diet;

    nd quiet, t

    ke in both.

    11th, EE

    o

    e long,

    s bee

    e, d

    ink, dee

    e, venison.

    12th, Sometimes ee

    o

    t

    ice, e,

    s Bee

    sheb

    , ove

    see

    .

    13th, Y

    nd e, both

    o

    one C

    mb

    il, bec

    use one

    s pe

    h

    ps to

    e

    k.

    Though one C

    mb

    il seems enough

    o

    one sm

    ll veile,

    s d

    yes,

    yes;

    lso i

    nd e,

    s h

    i

    es, p

    ise,

    nd

    nd e,

    s sho

    es, kno

    s, c

    o

    es,not in lose. But

    hy m

    y not

    se

    ve

    te

    nd e,

    nd y

    te

    o, Ikno

    not. Methinks the de

    d Lette

    s should not be coye on

    h

    t C

    mb

    ilthey'

    e h

    ng'd on; but I must

    sk the Butche

    s,

    nd

    h

    t doth e

    te

    Ile,

    o

    I

    ill.

    14th, E de

    ective in seest,

    leeth,

    eeest,

    g

    eed; th

    t p

    odig

    l

    s eis o

    its comp

    ny, should eve

    be

    nting is

    onde

    ;

    he

    e the

    e oughtto be 3 e

    se, o

    e

    , o

    th

    ice e, t

    o

    o

    diphthong, i

    it m

    y be one

    o

    the syll

    ble, th

    t the distiction m

    y seeme not he

    d bet

    een seeth,beholdeth,

    nd see the boile, e is

    dded.

    But

    l

    s it is objected l

    tely

    ithin this Seven ye

    s by _G. B._ th

    tComposito

    s le

    v out E in d

    ys

    nd

    ys,

    nd such like; G

    me

    cy

    o

    th

    t! But

    hy do they not le

    v out y

    lso,

    hich signi

    ies not mo

    e, butles th

    n e: And

    hy is not i

    nd e c

    st out o

    p

    ise

    nd

    ise,

    nd e

    om

    i

    e

    nd st

    i

    e,

    hich

    do

    n the

    o

    ds no mo

    e th

    n Be

    uty-spots do

    Who

    e's F

    ce: And

    hy is not

    o

    bl

    ck P

    tch, c

    st

    om kno

    nd blo

    ,

    s

    ell

    s d

    ,

    nd

    h

    v c

    st

    thei

    Pock

    -y;

    nd

    hyis not

    to do,

    he

    e the

    e's need; th

    t 'ton need no mock 'tuth

    i'the los,

    nd

    i' the lo

    d o

    : No

    indeed

    e h

    ve c

    st

    ugh

    omthough,

    nd

    lthough,

    hen som sound is o

    them,

    nd not le

    t gh out in

  • 8/10/2019 Magazine, Or Animadversions on the English Spelling (1703)

    12/36

    b

    ight, light, thought,

    he

    e they signi

    y no mo

    e th

    n

    chip, o

    he

    bGohn in po

    edg: H

    ! H

    ! He! Yet in

    lo

    eth

    nd kno

    eth

    sounds

    ell,h

    ving

    n in

    luence in the

    ollo

    ing vo

    el.

    [T

    nsc

    ibe

    's Note: The he

    b Gohn is p

    ob

    bly St. John's Wo

    t,

    hich c

    n be m

    de into

    m

    sh o

    po

    idge.]

    15th, Othe

    ve

    ieties to m

    ke

    syll

    ble long

    ithout e,

    s

    in bo

    st,bo

    d, co

    sts, co

    les, not holes.

    Also Sho

    t i,

    s veil, eithe

    , neithe

    ,

    nd somtimes 'tis

    diphthong,

    s neighbou

    , eight. Also o,

    s people, en

    eo

    , heo

    ness. And u,

    s

    ou

    e,

    oul, not in honou

    , neighbou

    ,

    he

    e o,

    nd u, st

    nd

    o

    s good

    s nothing.

    And

    ll Vo

    els be us'd supe

    v

    c

    neously be

    o

    e l, n, o

    ;

    s inb

    eth

    en, co

    en, child

    en, open, n

    vill,

    evill; not in c

    vill, Sybill,

    nd civill;

    p

    on, button, mutton, i

    on,

    e

    son, b

    con, t

    e

    son;

    nd inp

    ope

    n

    mes,

    s G

    ckson, Gohnson, Wilson, Tomson, Rependon, Repton,Donnington; not in God-Son, Common, but in Cousin.

    All vo

    els be us'd in v

    in be

    o

    e

    ,

    s pill

    , cell

    ,

    inte

    , summe

    ,dinne

    , cu

    i

    , (

    s it

    e

    e cove

    ,

    i

    e,) honou

    , donou

    , neighbou

    ,

    ple

    su

    e, me

    su

    e, n

    tu

    e,

    e

    tu

    e, sc

    iptu

    e, m

    ty

    . I is us'dseve

    lly.

    1st nd 2dly, I Long nd sho t in the s me ci cumst nces, s blind,

    ind, mind,

    ith i long, kind

    ed, limb, sh

    imp, pinch,

    ith i sho

    t; ghm

    kes i long,

    s b

    ight, might, plight, &c.

    nd i is long

    ithout 'em,

    s bite, kite,

    ite.

    3dly

    nd 4thly, I sho

    t

    ith

    conson

    nt,

    nd e

    te

    it,

    s lives,gives, nouns

    nd ve

    bs: Bible, possible, t

    iple, t

    ibled, idle

    idle,P

    ince, p

    ince. 5thly,

    nd 6thly, m

    keing e long,

    nd not

    s be

    o

    e.

    7thly, Used in v

    in,

    s g

    in

    ul, _&c._

    s be

    o

    e;

    lso e

    nd

    put

    o

    i,

    s bo

    ge, s

    v

    ge, kno

    ledge, colledge, not in hedge

    nd non

    ge;

    lso y

    s us'd

    o

    me

    ly

    o

    i.

    But most

    bomin

    bly i is us'd

    o

    g,

    hich is unp

    don

    ble,

    hen g being

    lette

    o

    double me

    ning c

    n do

    ithout,

    s g

    ol, o

    go

    l;

    hyshould it in

    ect i

    ith its o

    n distempe

    , to be double minded.

    L

    stly, W[h]y g[h] m

    not m

    ke

    ll vo

    els long

    s

    ell

    s i,

    nd

    [h]ym

    not ye

    nd

    e m

    ke vo

    els long,

    s

    ell

    s

    , e,

    nd o;

    e must

    skt[h]e n

    tu

    l P[h]ilosop[h]e

    s

    [h]

    t symp

    t[h]y o

    ntip

    t[h]y is int[h]e Lett

    ;

    nd

    [h]et[h]e

    n occult qu

    lity; o

    t[h]e divines, i

    t[h]e

    e be not

    myste

    y in it

    bove n

    tu

    e be

    o

    e

    e

    dventu

    e to te

    h

    nd cong the b

    tl-du

    ;

    nd

    [h]y I m

    not supply t[h]e pl

    ce o

    y

    t[h]e

    t[h]

    n g,

    s in y

    te, yell, yule, younge

    , (

    s It

    li

    ns).

    T[h]is [h]

    d bin ve

    y excuse

    ble,

    nd not

    it[h]out

    ntient p

    esident.As like

    ise

    [h]y some conson

    nts t

    ke exception

    t some vo

    els; o

    somevo

    els

    t t[h]em, t[h]

    t t[h]ey ch

    nge t[h]ei

    me

    ning?

    s c

    nd g,sometimes be

    o

    e e

    nd i,

    nd t be

    o

    e ion sometimes.

    8thly, W[h]y not

    l

    ys

    it[h]out exeption: I

    t[h]e

    e be

    supe

    n

    tu

    lc

    use (

    o

    e

    e su

    e t[h]ei

    is no n

    tu

    l one)

    o

    t[h]ese t[h]ings,t[h]ey

    ill decl

    e it, i

    not; t[h]e

    e must needs be

    p

    ete

    n

    tu

    l

  • 8/10/2019 Magazine, Or Animadversions on the English Spelling (1703)

    13/36

    on.

    O, is us'd

    cco

    dingly,

    s most, dost, lost, tost.

    3dly

    nd 4thly, As some, come, [h]ome, done, gone; sho

    t

    in Jo

    n,Jo

    nne, Jo

    kim,

    nd o p

    t.

    Also l m

    kes o long,

    s

    oll, poll, not extoll,

    nd

    [h]y not ot[h]e

    vo

    els too.

    O,

    o

    oe,

    s mot[h]e

    ,

    mong,

    om.

    O,

    o

    u,

    s b

    ot[h]e

    , come, some,

    o

    d,

    o

    ld,

    ont, t[h]e ve

    b;

    not[h]e

    , good, blood, not yonde

    .

    O,

    o

    , no

    t[h]e

    ly,

    s p

    edg, [h]

    ses, c

    n,

    m

    ng.

    U is us'd p

    omiscuously,

    s

    ppe

    s in the vo

    els

    o

    e going, but notso

    equently

    s the

    est,

    s [h]ugh long, hug sho

    t; [h]uge, voluble,supe

    luous

    te

    b

    nd g,

    s build, gu

    d, not

    eg

    d, q being c

    ll'dcu, needs it not; guide, not gilbe

    t.

    But v conson

    nt not c

    ll'd ev,

    ith

    di

    e

    ent c

    cte

    , is no less

    bsu

    'd th

    n j conson

    nt, not c

    ll'd ij,

    ith

    di

    e

    ent

    igu

    e,

    s

    meje

    o

    me

    su

    e,

    s the F

    ench

    lso use it,

    s je vou

    eme

    cy. Soosie

    , [h]osie

    , e

    sie

    ,

    u

    e, _&c._

    F us'd o v nciently, s d o th, s de ; but spokn s e do no :ev is us'd

    o

    in the _West_,

    s vi

    e, vield,

    o

    i

    e,

    ield,

    nd

    eput p

    o

    v in uppe

    : The Heb

    e

    s put veth

    o

    it, beth

    o

    b, theSp

    ni

    ds m

    ke v, b, but to let othe

    L

    ngu

    ges

    lone,

    e p

    ss to

    The Diphthongs.

    Whe

    eo

    3 be ve

    y

    bsu

    d, ee

    o

    hich the L

    tins us'd ij,

    s ijdemoculi lucent, e

    dem

    e

    it

    tis im

    go est, _Ov._ met. The G

    eeks m

    de Et

    doble e,

    s

    lso oo OMEGA.

    2. Oo,

    o

    hich the L

    tins us'd uu,

    s uv

    , uuul

    ,

    nd the B

    itish

    ndHeb

    e

    s double u.

    3. A

    ,

    ll,

    u,

    s

    ug

    e, m

    ug

    e,

    e, l

    ,

    ll, c

    l

    , (se the

    estin l.)

    nd

    o p

    ope

    ly,

    s g

    ot, g

    ol, g

    ot.

    Ai,

    s st

    ight,

    g

    in, not,

    it, ei

    s eight, not neithe

    .

    Oi,

    s boile, not the noun.

    Uu is se

    v'd by oo,

    nd so

    o

    th. No th

    nks

    o

    it.

    Ui,

    s juice. Ou,

    s ought, not, out.

    Au is put

    o

    o, ou

    o

    u,

    s s

    uce, souce.

    Eu o

    e

    , e

    e, neute

    , is

    ight.

    Iu,

    s vie

    , might be mended thus, viu.

    Ou is common,

    s could, co

    , but the

    e is di

    e

    ence bet

    een o long

    ndsho

    t.

  • 8/10/2019 Magazine, Or Animadversions on the English Spelling (1703)

    14/36

    O is o

    ten us'd

    o

    t

    iphthong (y in B

    itish). O u u,

    s hone, stone,doo

    e, th

    ough,

    o,

    ho

    e,

    o

    e, mo

    e.

    In ou o is o

    t le

    t out,

    s double, t

    ouble.

    L is us'd

    o

    o,

    s R

    lph, [h]

    l

    , c

    l

    , m

    lt, [h]

    lt, s

    lt

    nd sc

    lp,not in [h]e

    lth

    nd

    e

    lth,

    nd de

    lt: L is so us'd

    te

    e,

    s el

    , notsel

    ,

    helm, Gulielm, not elme.

    L

    stly, L is

    o

    u,

    s old, cold, gold,

    old, bold, colt, bolt, not indolt.

    I

    e, eo, ie,

    nd e

    be diphthongs,

    nd l

    ully m

    y'd by B

    nes, o

    Licens, I'm su

    e it is but

    n [h]

    l

    ch

    -m

    i

    ge,

    o

    they (

    o

    justimpediment) neve

    bed togethe

    .

    _Amendment o

    e

    'd._

    M

    ke

    C

    mb

    il ove

    the vo

    els to m

    ke 'em long;

    nd this

    ill cu

    einnume

    bl e

    o

    s,

    nd the

    e

    ill be no mo

    e mist

    kes o

    buse o

    thevo

    els,

    nd this

    ill s

    ve

    o

    ld o

    t

    uble.

    But bec

    use the titl o

    i st

    nds in the

    y, give

    d

    sh

    o

    I long,

    ndlet

    lo

    Apost

    ophe,

    s high

    s the bodies o

    he lette

    s, st

    nd

    o

    isho

    t,

    nd i

    ith

    tittle

    o

    double i o

    ee. So

    M

    l, mel, mil, mol, mul. Ml, ml, ml, ml, ml.

    [T nsc ibe 's Note: Text sho

    n

    s p

    inted,

    lthough p

    eceding p

    g

    ph implies m

    l o

    ml (dotless i, o

    i

    ithout tittle) in

    i

    st line, m--l in second.]

    Then

    sk the P

    inte

    hethe

    C

    mb

    il set ove

    the vo

    els, be not

    s

    good,

    nd che

    p

    s

    n e,

    , o, o

    gh

    t the end.

    But

    [h]

    t di

    e

    ence c

    n

    e m

    ke in

    igu

    es, bet

    een ou, long o,

    ndsho

    t o? Thus like the sign T

    u

    us

    te

    the G

    eek

    shion is sho

    t ou,o

    (spe

    k Tongue) ou

    t lengt[h], is long o

    it[h] u;

    nd

    g

    in the signT

    u

    us

    it[h]

    Foot-B

    ll bet

    een [h]is [h]o

    ns, is t[h]e T

    i

    t[h]ong;t[h]e

    e

    son belongs to G

    mm

    .

    Fo

    to l

    y sound upon sound

    it[h]out sig[h]t, is

    s

    ield upon

    ield,

    lse He

    ld

    y.

    But

    s

    o

    suc[h]

    s [h]

    ve t[h]ei

    o

    [h]e

    ds no b

    o

    de

    t[h]

    n t[h]ei

    B

    ttledo

    e, they must stic in the old nooke

    t q in the co

    ne

    , not

    seven ye

    s, but seventy times seven.

    'Tis not

    sin s

    it[h]

    P[h]ilosop[h]e

    t[h]

    t I c

    nnot spel

    el, butt[h]

    t I c

    nnot live

    ell. I

    e [h]

    ve t[h]is e

    o

    om the L

    ye

    s

    e[h]ope 'tis l

    ul;

    o

    to put in lette

    s in

    o

    d o

    o

    ds in

    deed,mo

    e t[h]

    n enoug[h] o

    ten. But the L

    ye

    s English m

    y be no bette

    t[h]

    n [h]is L

    tin, t[h]e one

    s [h]

    d to be spell'd,

    s t[h]e ot[h]e

    to be p

    sd.

    Next

    e come to the Conson

    nts.

  • 8/10/2019 Magazine, Or Animadversions on the English Spelling (1703)

    15/36

    _Thi

    d P

    t o

    B

    bling _B

    bel_ unde

    min'd; the Eyes submitting to theE

    s._

    Conson

    nts do sometimes st

    nd

    o

    noug[h]t, Sometimes

    o

    one

    not[h]e

    ; But

    [h]en st

    nds e

    h one

    s it oug[h]t? W[h]en st

    nds it

    o

    its b

    ot[h]e

    ?

    B is

    Conson

    nt [h]

    t[h] no n

    me-s

    ke,

    s none oug[h]t to h

    ve. Fo

    put

    vo

    el be

    o

    e o

    te

    it, its

    ll one

    o

    the n

    me

    nd v

    lue,

    o

    eve

    y v

    lue o

    lette

    is

    cco

    ding to its n

    me, o

    oug[h]t to be,

    o

    the n

    me is p

    ope

    to the

    igu

    e

    s c

    ll, de o

    ed, 'tis

    ll one,

    s

    o ed,

    od. C

    ll b be, o

    eb; but use custom, 'tis [h]elp

    ul

    [h]enp

    ope

    ; [h]u

    t

    ul

    [h]en imp

    ope

    . B is ove

    plus in L

    mb, t[h]umb, debt,doubt;

    nd

    [h]

    t need is t[h]e

    e o

    t[h]ese unnecess

    y bees; sc

    ceone in

    P

    ish besides the P

    son t[h]inks t[h]e t

    o l

    st come o

    L

    tin

    o

    ds, debitum

    nd dubito,

    [h]e

    e t[h]ey

    e p

    onounc'd.

    B is

    lette

    o

    t[h]e lips, shutting t[h]e lips be

    o

    e t[h]e vo

    el,

    [h]en it begins

    syll

    ble,

    nd

    te

    vo

    el

    hen it ends: So do the

    est in BUM

    F _vi

    ._ ev,

    e, m,

    , p.

    _A Rule use

    ul

    o

    School-Te

    che

    s,

    o

    sho

    t Tongu'd Child

    en,

    o

    e

    syUtte

    nce use the uppe

    Lette

    s

    o

    the ne

    the

    ._

    B [G] D V G J Z [C] [Y] [R]

    Fo

    P C [T] F H [J] S [T] K R

    _P

    ob

    tum est._

    By one I h

    d

    Schol

    , could spe

    k none o

    the ne

    the

    Lette

    s, till he[h]

    d le

    n'd (

    te

    the _West_ [G]unt

    y

    shion,

    nd the Rules o

    theLe

    n'd G

    mm

    s) to p

    onounce the uppe

    i

    st.

    We

    e not

    [h]

    u muh ou

    deseit

    ul lett

    [h]ind

    uth

    Le

    ning,

    nd

    e

    ining Inglish,

    nd [h]

    u t

    u let

    ould

    u

    th

    it.

    M

    d C

    '[c] s spel

    sound [c]e sm, _Stilo novo_. Bet

    q h

    nd k. Deset

    ule deni

    its n

    m, And s do[c] it bet

    .

    Dissembli[v] C

    i[c] nidles vot, Ov

    idi[v] b

    ex [c]e nec. Unles it [h]

    v

    p

    ope

    n

    m, And spelli[v] suits

    i[c] C. C [g]iv

    n il ex

    mpl, And i

    t

    ipl tn

    v: CCC ERAS. Ad. On gustis it do[c] t

    mpl, Sc

    b'd

    o

    ol [h]e

    ol

    b

    v. Ov sie

    [c]e blind led

    i

    : [D]e ded [c]e livi[v]

    ul. ARISTOF.

  • 8/10/2019 Magazine, Or Animadversions on the English Spelling (1703)

    16/36

    And [

    ot]

    ti

    sum t

    sc i

    [c]is To

    t upon

    Fuul? L

    g [h]

    usn [h]

    v

    i in l

    g t

    un

    , And l

    g

    hevnle buux: L

    g Cots

    nd Tlox [h]

    v

    i

    nd [G]

    un

    , Au

    it in let

    stox. It niv

    i

    tuu l

    t to [t]

    iv, No

    to inven[j]on

    d: Fo

    Silv

    uns

    i

    [c]

    st

    iv, [D]un m

    ne p

    und

    ov Led. N

    u [c]

    t I m

    u t

    ule si, Se

    t

    nte to mi s

    : I

    lic u sim

    nd no

    end be, Non led

    mi

    u

    s

    . In c

    uuced

    [c]is

    ol i

    il, Men tno not [c]

    t [c]

    e

    . And [c]

    t men luv d

    cnes stil, No

    ot in endless

    i

    .

    As c t

    nd h do

    uul ou

    e

    ov

    nd ov

    in h

    tch

    nd c

    tch, _&c._ sododh D (non

    ithout dese

    t) in Wednesd

    y, Hedg, Judg, sp

    ing, g

    udg,b

    dg,

    he

    e g m

    y do

    ell

    ithout its

    lse [h]elp o

    cumbe

    -pl

    ce.

    F is unp

    onounc'd in m

    sti

    nd t is spoken inste

    d o

    , in h

    nd

    ul,

    m

    ul, s

    ck

    ul. But it h

    th m

    ni

    est

    ong done it, by his conve

    tiblep,

    nd its unconve

    tible h,

    g

    inst thei

    o

    n n

    mes too,

    s Philip.Whe

    e

    s ph help no mo

    e

    o

    spelling Filip, th

    n it doth Alex

    nde

    . No

    i you h d s id HURH spells Chu ch, nd GUG spells Judge, I could e silybelieve it.

    But he

    p, God, thy, thigh, h

    ng, sh

    me,

    hich

    e none o

    the sevenspell'd by the Lette s e intend should spell them: neithe c n nyEnglishm

    n

    o

    his e

    s, eyes

    nd

    its, spell

    ny o

    these

    o

    ds,

    ndMILLIONS mo

    e like 'em, mo

    e by his 24 English Lette

    s, m

    ke

    h

    t shi

    the c

    n,

    hile _Ingl

    nd_ is _Ingl

    nd_,

    nd h

    ve both Unive

    sities,_CAMBRIGE_

    nd _Ox

    o

    d_ to help him,

    nd

    ll the Unive

    sities beyond theSe

    s to help them.

    _Vi

    ._ [Y]p, [G]od, [C]i, [T]i, [Y]

    [v], [J][v], [W]ih;

    lso [F]

    un,[R]m;

    nd Hi

    , Ked, Plej

    . Fo

    Tu

    pe est docto

    e cum culp

    ed

    guit ipsum.

    Acco

    ding to _C

    to_:

    Unto the Te

    che

    its

    sh

    me, In othe

    s his o

    n F

    ults to bl

    me.

    Thus you pe

    cieve the

    hole Wo

    ld is but in the B

    ttle-do

    e,

    nd Le

    ningis in the C

    dle,

    nd the s

    yings o

    this Book,

    s M

    c

    oons to invite

    he

    to the t

    king he

    Lette

    s to keep up old custom. As _Ho

    s_ [h]

    thit in his

    i

    st Se

    mon.

    ----Pue

    is d

    nt c

    ustul

    bl

    ndi Docto

    es element

    velint ut disce

    e p

    im

    .

    Kind Te

    che

    s give Boys Bun

    nd C

    ke, Thei

    Lette

    s

    o

    to Le

    n them m

    ke.

    G is de

    in sign, not signi

    ie,

    nd g[h] in boug[h]t, b

    oug[h]t, not in

  • 8/10/2019 Magazine, Or Animadversions on the English Spelling (1703)

    17/36

    coug[h], th

    oug[h], enoug[h],

    [h]ih is st

    ngly spoken, stu

    ,enoug[h], boug[h]s, enoug[h], (co

    n enoug[h])

    nd sig[h]ed,

    nd g[h]edspells [h]e

    d, i

    ec be not c

    st

    y; let k be g[h]

    , else k (unless

    o

    g[h])

    s in b

    ck, st

    ck, c

    ck,

    ould be

    v

    in impe

    tinent Lette

    ,

    nd dese

    ves (

    s suh) in

    n o

    de

    ly F

    mily to be cic'd out o' th' doo

    s.Fo

    ou

    B

    ttle-do

    e is

    ell-[g]ove

    n'd SITY,

    [h]ih shuts out

    ll idleimpe

    tinent pe

    sn

    ,

    s v

    g

    nts

    it[h] t[h]ei

    ext

    v

    g

    ncies out o't[h]' G

    tes.

    H is v

    in, in Ghost, Sc[h]ol

    , not in Chu

    h, but c is, t[h]e

    e

    o

    e itdese

    ves to be tu

    n'd out o

    doo

    s,

    o

    loosing its good n

    me, [h]

    ving

    o

    k enoug[h] to live o

    its t

    de,

    nd is

    n Inte

    loope

    , sounding onet[h]ing by its sel

    ,

    not[h]e

    in

    o

    d-spelling, th

    t she m

    not be[h]onest by [h]e

    sel

    ,

    nd

    kn

    ve in comp

    ny.

    L in

    ill, bell, m

    ll,

    ull,

    nd t[h]ous

    nds mo

    e.

    M in gemm, stem, _&c_.

    N in Hen

    y

    nd p

    ope

    n

    mes,

    s No

    m

    nton, Rependon, Donington. T[h]e

    o

    me

    n is un[h]e

    d.

    P in

    eceipt, not except,

    nd mig[h]t

    s

    ell be le

    t out,

    s in deceit,conceit, o

    t[h]e s

    me sin, so empty tempt

    tion.

    S in isle, isl

    nd,

    ss,

    s is u

    , s single is

    s

    T in hitsund y, nd tch, c tch, clutch.

    U is tu

    n'd into EV, Covent

    y, D

    vent

    y, Oven

    o

    Couent

    y, D

    unt

    y,Ouen,

    n eut; see M

    . _Dugd

    l_.

    So ou

    Lette

    s

    t[h]e

    m

    th

    n mend ou

    L

    ngu

    ge,

    [h]en

    ongspell'd: but mo

    e Lette

    s

    ould do

    ell in the Al

    bet, (

    [h]ih isp

    ep

    ing) but

    e

    e

    in most

    o

    ds to spell p

    ope

    ly.

    We is us'd t[h]

    ee

    ys,

    s

    vo

    el,

    s no

    , [h]o

    ,

    s

    conson

    nt in

    e,

    ent,

    s nothing, in kno

    , sho

    ,

    nd bo.

    Ye is us'd

    ou

    ys,

    s

    conson

    nt,

    s ye

    , yes,

    s

    long

    nd sho

    tvo

    el,

    s

    [h]y, [h]oly

    nd doubt

    ul,

    s my, t[h]y,

    nd

    s not[h]ing inm

    y d

    y.

    W[h]en e

    ch Lette

    [h]

    t[h] but one me

    ning 1; the Re

    ding is ce

    t

    in

    st

    o

    nd t

    enty one, one

    nts

    ,

    nd t

    o m

    sp

    e it.

    Z is sc

    ce us'd in v

    in, but

    s m

    ny conson

    nts

    e double to m

    ke

    sho

    t vo

    el,

    s Bu

    e, but is most us'd

    o

    s

    te

    ll Lette

    s but p,c, t,

    o

    plu

    ls

    nd t[h]e like, s

    nd

    seem to c

    oss one

    nothe

    ,

    s

    e

    nd

    ise,

    nd x

    o

    ,

    s be

    ux.

    Since

    enoun'd Aut[h]o

    s o

    l

    te [h]

    ve le

    t out ugh,

    s t[h]oug[h]

    ndthe like,

    iting t[h]o', i

    they [h]

    d le

    t out

    nd y supe

    luous,

    skno

    ,

    o

    , d

    , t[h]

    e,

    nd put out

    ll v

    in lette

    s,

    nd c

    mb

    il thevo

    els, the idle Lette

    s

    ould neve

    [h]

    ve come in

    g

    in.

    No

    i

    Books

    e

    e begun to be

    ll p

    inted by t[h]ese di

    ections, t[h]ey

    ould m

    ke

    ll othe

    old books e

    sie

    e

    d,

    nd mo

    e t

    uly p

    onounced,t[h]e

    lse spelling being discove

    'd

    nd

    mended.

  • 8/10/2019 Magazine, Or Animadversions on the English Spelling (1703)

    18/36

    But Lette

    s

    e neithe

    he

    e no

    the

    e,

    o

    ll this, in eve

    y ci

    cuitthe

    e is something o

    p

    ticul

    di

    lect, di

    e

    ing

    om the commonEnglish, though the Weste

    n

    nd No

    the

    n di

    e

    most.

    No

    hen

    e spe

    k o

    lte

    ing the Lette

    s,

    e

    lte

    not, but est

    blish

    nd settle the kno

    n speech,

    hich is no mo

    e but to

    lte

    o

    emove thesign

    hen it di

    ectedh to the

    ong [h]ouse, but the Inn

    ll the

    hileis the s

    me. I

    one be in the No

    th o

    West, he h

    d best spe

    k

    s theydo, th

    t he m

    y be

    e

    dily unde

    stood,

    hich is the end o

    speech.

    We h

    ve co

    uptions enough in ou

    Lette

    s to co

    upt

    ll L

    ngu

    ges

    it

    ith them.

    I

    ou

    Lette

    s

    e

    e thus Co

    ected,

    st

    nge

    , o

    home-b

    ed, mightle

    n

    s much English in

    d

    y,

    s othe

    ise in

    month o

    mo

    e.

    Put n

    tu

    e in

    ts C

    dle,

    nd its

    et in the stox.

    The

    e h

    ve been m

    ny ch

    nges o

    [G]ove

    nment this hund

    ed ye

    s, yet thes

    me e

    o

    s

    ule, th

    t

    e

    e,

    nd no body

    o

    p

    omisi

    bette

    .

    But

    h

    t

    ils you to be so bitte

    g

    inst the Lette

    s? Why I look

    tthem

    s the d

    k-house to lodge

    ll ou

    e

    o

    s in,

    nd

    e

    the

    -bed,

    he

    e

    ll, both e

    o

    s

    nd unkno

    n sins m

    y be lodg'd, the

    e

    o

    e I pull

    out the St

    s out o

    you

    bolste

    , th

    t I m

    y let light into the house,th

    t you m

    see you lodge in

    tho

    n-bush inste

    d o

    e

    the

    -bed. ButI

    ind, (God [h]elp us both) th

    t

    t

    ll

    in

    l e

    o

    s

    e

    iends o

    theg e te , th t neithe m I ble by these lette s to spe k, no you tounde

    st

    nd me by W

    iting. N

    y no m

    n is by old Lette

    s

    ble so much

    sto hint

    h

    t he

    ould h

    ve the ne

    ones c

    ll'd, but the old

    illinsinu

    te thei

    su

    iciency.

    _The Fou

    th P

    t, o

    Inst

    uctions Inst

    ucted, o

    Light out o

    D

    kness._

    _The

    i

    st T

    ble,

    he

    ein the sel

    -s

    me sounds

    e Spell'd by di

    e

    entLette

    s,

    i

    st Right,

    nd then W

    ong._

    A

    s

    , M

    nn

    , Joshu

    , Asi

    , Jud

    h, H

    nn

    h;

    hy m

    e not c

    st

    theHeb

    e

    He out o

    o

    ds,

    s

    ell

    s the L

    tins

    nd G

    eeks h

    ve done? D

    y,s

    y, thei

    , they,

    i

    . These Lette

    s th

    t be, not p

    onounc'd

    e ve

    y

    ellcome to be gone, the doo

    st

    nds

    ide open.

    E,

    s be, the, Phebe, ye

    ,

    eigh, key, holy. I

    p

    op

    g

    ting E

    o

    bel

    ul, 'tis l

    ul to te

    ch

    ong.

    I,

    s Ivi; lie, lye, thy,

    hy, thigh, buy,

    o

    the

    i

    st might

    s

    l

    ully be spell'd like the l

    st,

    s UYe I,

    s the l

    st is

    ongspell'd, but mo

    e l

    ully m

    the l

    st be spell'd

    s you

    i

    st.

    O, do, no, so, to,

    ight, to

    , dough, Bo

    es, be

    u, sloe, slo

    . (I

    u bep

    onounc'd in

    lo

    , 'tis

    diphthong, let u t

    ke its pl

    ce)

    ong.

    U,

    s t

    u, blue, Hugh, ne

    ,

    singl u might st

    nd

    o

    you (i

    it ple

    seu) but not

    o

    you

    , be

    uty.

    Ao, g

    ol, g

    ot, g

    ot, go

    l, l

    , s

    uce, c

    l

    , sc

    lp, c

    ug[h]t,

  • 8/10/2019 Magazine, Or Animadversions on the English Spelling (1703)

    19/36

    t

    ug[h]t.

    Al,

    s

    le,

    il, but,

    yl in old Books.

    El,

    s kele, me

    le, se

    le, veil,

    nd ve

    l.

    Il, mile, isle, isl

    nd, boile, pyle.

    Ol, mole, soul, co

    l,

    oll, poll.

    Ul, deul, the st

    ig[h]test

    o

    d, the sho

    test

    ule.

    _So

    e

    g

    inst shins it goes to go

    bout, Whe

    e you've but one

    o

    d, you c

    nnot go out._

    So m, em, im, om, um,

    nd

    n, en, in, on, un,

    s cl

    im, p[h]legm,

    ooms, [h]olmes, tombs, sove

    ign,

    o

    eigne

    s, sign, g

    o

    n, he

    n.

    H

    v t

    o st

    it lines

    om point to point you sh

    ll, * Pseudog

    y

    geomet

    ic

    l. * B

    .

    So

    , e,

    nd so

    o

    t[h], be

    o

    e, be

    o

    e,

    , s, t,

    , bie

    , [h]ig[h]e

    ,bo

    e, so

    ,

    ou

    , lo

    e

    , c

    se,

    ce,

    e, b

    ss, pe

    ce, ce

    se,

    ise,p

    ice, justice, p

    ose, sloce, p

    i

    e,

    ise, eyes, lies,

    ise ve

    b, sighs,

    use, noun, t

    uce, nose,

    oes, blo

    s, use ve

    b; suit,

    n event: but s isus'd

    o

    too o

    t, the mo

    e intolle

    ble; but

    should be us'd

    hen itm

    kes

    distinction bet

    een noun

    nd ve

    b,

    s use,

    ise,

    buse:

    Conceit

    it[h]out

    eceit, is me

    e deceit.

    J

    ms, g

    ol, Jo[h]n, go

    l, m

    gist

    te, m

    jesty, geese,

    leece, sig[h]ed,[h]e d, s dled, gl d, titled, cl d, b ttled, kno , enh, ensh, good,blood,

    o

    t[h], [h]unt, gentl, je

    ,

    ih,

    it[h], city, sit, scitu

    te,ye

    , be[h]

    viou

    , Joshu

    ,

    , no

    , noug[h]t.

    S,

    s

    ctious, p

    ecious,

    nctious, conscience, sho,

    shion,Je[h]oschu

    , these

    i the help ov the F

    enh,

    s quelque hose,

    nd old

    Autho

    s m

    be qu

    d

    upled

    ll

    ong.

    So x

    o

    ckes,

    s

    l

    x, st

    ckes, sex, necks, six, stickes,

    ox,

    okes,

    lux, bucks.

    Wh

    t spells g u g, q i c, [

    ] i h, R e p n, s c o l

    ; i

    ong (

    [h]

    sno business the

    e) be ples

    nt,

    ite, (gh [h]

    t[h] not[h]ing to dot[h]e

    e) is ple

    nt

    , unless to ple

    se t[h]ose t[h]

    t [h]

    ve t[h]ei

    its

    it[h]out 'em,

    ill [h]

    ve t[h]e e

    s misled by t[h]e eys,

    ndt[h]e soul by t[h]e body, t[h]e

    e

    o

    e (suppose t[h]

    t t[h]e

    e

    e

    shions

    o

    t[h]e soul

    s

    ell

    s the body) in t[h]e old Chu

    chBible ov _K. J._ its [h]ye, no

    [h]ig[h]; so

    o

    me

    ly

    o

    ine

    s, no

    o

    eigne

    s, R

    ley, R

    leigh, [h]e

    e's

    it

    ith

    itness: But these

    e no mo

    e besides thei

    its, t[h]

    n t[h]ey

    e

    it[h]out thei

    its,t[h]

    t [h]

    ve t[h]ei

    its

    it[h]in t[h]em. These th

    t c

    n, p

    int thevois, c

    n limb out souls too. No doubt ve

    y Le

    n'd men!

    You t[h]

    t unde

    st

    nd t[h]e

    ets on t[h]e g

    e

    t Fidle,

    nd

    it[h]outG

    mmut, c

    n p

    ic do

    n p

    ope

    sounds to

    o

    ds in visible sh

    pes,

    cco

    ding to t[h]e nu

    shion; p

    t

    ke not

    the

    l

    ls the oldF

    t[h]e

    s put to t[h]ei

    o

    ds, lest poste

    ity se

    ve you no bette

    ,

    sHie

    om, Hie

    us

    lem,

    ipe, snite, knight,

    s h

    uce

    .

  • 8/10/2019 Magazine, Or Animadversions on the English Spelling (1703)

    20/36

    _The time sh

    ll come th

    t Docto

    s

    nd Knights Sh

    ll be

    s common

    s Woodcox

    nd Snites, With C

    mbo's o

    Books

    ul m

    ny

    sco

    e, As good

    s these you

    ind, I'll

    d no mo

    e._

    Fpsti. _Di

    icili

    qu pulch

    ._ _H

    d to be dun,

    dute i

    su

    dhe g

    test bute._

    _A T

    ble o

    the sel

    -s

    me Lete

    s, Spelling

    o

    ds ov

    di

    e

    entsound._

    As

    ith,

    ith, b

    th, b

    the, sith, sithe, both, both, lo

    th, lo

    th, o

    th,o

    thes, smith, smithy, b

    e

    th, o

    , o

    , then, yet, liveth o

    liveth,joth o

    joth, mouth, mouth, p

    th o

    p

    th,

    th,

    e

    th,

    ith o

    ith,thy, thigh, this, thistle, thou, thous

    nd, th

    nk, they, them, the

    me,thus, thunde

    , thine, thin, go

    l o

    go

    l,

    s

    o

    e, motion, c

    imson,

    ction, Acteon, singed, h

    nged, ch

    nged, shephe

    d, Sh

    ph

    t, dishonou

    ,

    sh

    m'd, bishop, mish

    p, ch

    cte

    , ch

    ity, duckhe

    d, blockhe

    d,Dutchess, g

    the

    , success, suggest, o

    suggest, o

    suggest, o

    suggest,h

    ov,

    ij, [

    ]heg

    nd

    ho, come, on, you kno

    h

    t I me

    n,

    s

    ell

    s

    [h]o

    ses. W

    od: scepte

    , sceptic, syll

    bles, bless,

    ccess,

    xes,oxen, Ch

    ist-c

    oss, be

    ux, be

    uty,

    nc

    e, ke

    nel,

    c

    es, c

    'd,th

    e

    tned, kne

    d, bootes, Bootes,

    inged, gn

    'd: th is cut o

    om ith, _cum_, te nothe o the s me, t i' them.

    To Re

    d English

    te

    the n

    mes ov the Lette

    s,

    hich is bl

    meless, m

    xEnglish

    s st

    ng

    s to

    e

    d

    te

    the F

    ench

    shion;

    h

    t

    ould becomeo Gi e-e gle, ithe , le gue, thing, Jehos ph t.

    Put

    n Apost

    ophe (c

    ll'd S

    in Heb

    u) bet

    een eve

    y t

    o conson

    nts(_vi

    ._

    sho

    t i) the spelling is disce

    n'd

    s

    ell

    s

    ith

    touch-stone, th

    t you m

    y pe

    seve e

    sily th

    t

    lsehood is not in goode

    nest.

    So geo

    ge, go

    ge, Gomo

    h

    , Es

    u, Hus o

    u

    , Nubes, R

    g

    u, Joshu

    ,

    he

    e([V] [v]) is the

    i

    st lette

    in the

    ou

    i

    st, middlemost in

    ist,

    in the l

    st

    ll

    ong. Th

    t no

    onde

    i

    the Bible T

    nsl

    to

    s took upthe bl

    nket,

    nd le

    t the Child behind 'em,

    hen St. Hie

    om s

    ys, theHeb

    e

    Lette

    s

    e not to be exp

    est by the Weste

    n

    igu

    es (I thinkt

    uly) And

    o

    nt o

    xents Chu

    ch-Re

    de

    s

    ickedly misc

    llBible-

    o

    ds,

    s Theobulus, Je

    icho, Goli

    h, Cs

    e

    ,

    Dec

    polis,Pen

    cutes o

    P

    epen

    cutes,

    lso H

    ggi

    ou

    ys.

    A duble Lette

    in Heb

    e

    o

    the s

    me so

    t, being d

    geshed, p

    events

    llmist

    kes,

    s . So '[G]odes

    o

    the Goddesses.

    But

    o

    ex

    mple s

    ke,

    s

    s

    ny thing c

    n

    e

    lly be exp

    est byEnglish Lette

    s,

    ithout bodging p

    tching, o

    bungling b

    lde

    d

    sh o

    b

    b

    ous g

    llimo

    y o

    ou

    Rom

    ntic Lette

    s, obscu

    e

    th

    n the Egipti

    nHie

    ogli

    ix. I

    ill subsc

    ibe

    n old s

    ing in English,

    s e

    sy

    s

    nything, i

    custom

    nd

    shion tnu it:

    _An As

    n Mul c

    id Runlets ov Wine, But d' Ass did g

    on und

    e

    bu

    dn g

    et: Qo'd' Mul, Mod

    ,

    t

    l u dus to

    in? And unde

    you

    lijt lod so so

    to s

    et?

  • 8/10/2019 Magazine, Or Animadversions on the English Spelling (1703)

    21/36

    Ist dubl be

    i

    I t

    c

    on ov din. Wijst be

    lic i

    d

    u t

    c

    on ov min. P

    ide cind Gomete

    do us dis

    et._

    _Doct

    in

    non h

    bet inimicum p

    te

    igno

    ntem._

    _O

    e

    udition dhe

    's no si

    cumst

    ns H

    dh

    ni enimi but igno

    ns._

    _But 'p

    emisses

    ightly unde

    stood desie

    the exhibition o

    comple

    t Al

    ebet, to

    e

    d English

    s e

    sily

    s [G]

    eek; the

    e

    o

    e I sh

    ll end this Book

    i' the

    i

    st Lette

    ov the ensuing B

    tl-du

    ._

    [A] [

    ] A

    B b [D] d D [c] E e F

    G g [G] [g] H h [Y] [h] I i J j C c K k [F] [

    ] M m N n [V] [v] O o P p Q q R

    S s [J] [j] T t [T] [t] U u V v W

    [W] [

    ] X x Y y

    &.

    FINIS.

    * * * * *

    Willi

    m And

    e

    s Cl

    k Memo

    i

    l Lib

    y: Unive

    sity o

    C

    li

    o

    ni

    THE AUGUSTAN REPRINT SOCIETY

    _Gene

    l Edito

    s_

    R. C. BOYSUnive

    sity o

    Michig

    n

    RALPH COHENUnive

    sity o

    C

    li

    o

    ni

    , Los Angeles

    VINTON A. DEARINGUnive

    sity o

    C

    li

    o

    ni

    , Los Angeles

    LAWRENCE CLARK POWELLWm. And

    e

    s Cl

    k Memo

    i

    l Lib

    y

    _Co

    esponding Sec

    et

    y_

    M

    s. EDNA C. DAVIS, Wm. And

    e

    s Cl

    k Memo

    i

    l Lib

    y

    The Society exists to m

    ke

    v

    il

    ble inexpensive

    ep

    ints (usu

    lly

    csimile

    ep

    oductions) o

    e seventeenth

    nd eighteenth centu

    y

    o

    ks. The edito

    i

    l policy o

    the Society

    em

    ins unch

    nged. As in the

    p

    st, the edito

    s

    elcome suggestions conce

    ning public

    tions. Allincome o

    the Society is devoted to de

    ying cost o

    public

    tion

    ndm

    iling.

    All co

    espondence conce

    ning subsc

    iptions in the United St

    tes

    ndC

    n

    d

    should be

    dd

    essed to the Willi

    m And

    e

    s Cl

    k Memo

    i

    lLib

    y, 2205 West Ad

    ms Boulev

    d, Los Angeles 18, C

    li

    o

    ni

    .Co

    espondence conce

    ning edito

    i

    l m

    tte

    s m

    y be

    dd

    essed to

    ny o

    the gene

    l edito

    s. The membe

    ship

    ee is $3.00

    ye

    o

    subsc

    ibe

    sin the United St

    tes

    nd C

    n

    d

    nd 15/-

    o

    subsc

    ibe

    s in G

    e

    t

  • 8/10/2019 Magazine, Or Animadversions on the English Spelling (1703)

    22/36

    B

    it

    in

    nd Eu

    ope. B

    itish

    nd Eu

    ope

    n subsc

    ibe

    s should

    dd

    essB. H. Bl

    ck

    ell, B

    o

    d St

    eet, Ox

    o

    d, Engl

    nd.

    Public

    tions

    o

    the t

    el

    th ye

    [1957-58]

    (At le

    st six items, most o

    them

    om the

    ollo

    ing list,

    ill be

    ep

    inted.)

    Hen

    y Fielding, _The Voy

    ges o

    M

    . Job Vineg

    _ (1740). Int

    oduction by S

    m S

    ckett.

    Willi

    m He

    be

    t, Thi

    d E

    l o

    Pemb

    oke, _Poems_ (1660). Int

    oduction by G

    by Onde

    y

    e

    .

    _An Histo

    ic

    l Vie

    o

    the Politic

    l W

    ite

    s o

    G

    e

    t B

    it

    in_ (1740). Int

    oduction by Robe

    t L. H

    ig.

    F

    ncis Hutcheson, _Ess

    ys on L

    ughte

    _ (1729).

    S

    muel Johnson, _Notes to Sh

    kespe

    e, Vol. III, T

    gedies_. Edited by A

    thu

    She

    bo.

    Rich

    d S

    v

    ge, _An Autho

    to be Let_ (1732).

    Int

    oduction by J

    mes Suthe

    l

    nd.

    Elk

    n

    h Settle, _The Noto

    ious Imposto

    _ (1692). Int oduction by Spi o Pete son.

    _Seventeenth Centu

    y T

    les o

    the Supe

    n

    tu

    l_. Selected,

    ith

    n Int

    oduction, by Is

    bel M. Westcott.

    Public

    tions

    o

    the

    i

    st eleven ye

    s (

    ith the exception o

    Nos. 1-6,

    hich

    e out o

    p

    int)

    e

    v

    il

    ble

    t the

    te o

    $3.00

    ye

    .P

    ices

    o

    individu

    l numbe

    s m

    y be obt

    ined by

    iting to the Society.

    THE AUGUSTAN REPRINT SOCIETY_WILLIAM ANDREWS CLARK MEMORIAL LIBRARY_2205 West Ad

    ms Boulev

    d, Los Angeles 18, C

    li

    o

    ni

    M

    ke check o

    money o

    de

    p

    y

    ble toTHE REGENTS OF THE UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA.

    PUBLICATIONS OF THE AUGUSTAN REPRINT SOCIETY

    [T

    nsc

    ibe

    's Note: M

    ny o

    the listed titles

    e

    v

    il

    ble

    om P

    oject Gutenbe

    g. Thei

    e-text numbe

    s

    e given

    t the end o

    e

    ch ent

    y. Public

    tions listed

    in the o

    igin

    l text

    s Out o

    P

    int

    e sho

    n in b

    ckets.]

    *Fi

    st Ye

    (1946-1947)*

    Numbe

    s 1-6 out o

    p

    int.

    [List o

    titles

    dded by t

    nsc

    ibe

    :

    1. Rich

    d Bl

    ckmo

    e's _Ess

    y upon Wit_ (1716),

    nd Addison's _F

    eeholde

    _ No. 45 (1716). #13484

  • 8/10/2019 Magazine, Or Animadversions on the English Spelling (1703)

    23/36

    2. Anon., _Ess

    y on Wit_ (1748), togethe

    ith Ch

    cte

    s by Flecknoe,

    nd Joseph W

    ton's _Adventu

    e

    _ Nos. 127

    nd 133. #14973

    3. Anon., _Lette

    to A. H. Esq.; conce

    ning the St

    ge_ (1698),

    nd Rich

    d Willis' _Occ

    sion

    l P

    pe

    _ No. IX (1698). #14047

    4. S

    muel Cobb's _O

    Poet

    y_

    nd _Discou

    se on C

    iticism_ (1707). #14528

    5. S

    muel Wesley's _Epistle to

    F

    iend Conce

    ning Poet

    y_ (1700)

    nd _Ess

    y on He

    oic Poet

    y_ (1693). #16506

    6. _Rep

    esent

    tion o

    the Impiety

    nd Immo

    lity o

    the St

    ge_ (1704)

    nd _Some Thoughts Conce

    ning the St

    ge_ (1704). #15656]

    *Second Ye

    (1947-1948)*

    7. John G

    y's _The P

    esent St

    te o

    Wit_ (1711);

    nd

    section on Wit

    om _The English Theoph

    stus_ (1702). #14800

    8. R

    pin's _De C

    mine P

    sto

    li_, t

    nsl

    ted by C

    eech(1684). #14495

    9. T. H

    nme

    's(?) _Some Rem

    ks on the T

    gedy o

    H

    mlet_ (1736). #14899

    10. Co byn Mo is' _Ess y to ds Fixing the T ue St nd ds o Wit, etc._ (1744). #16233

    11. Thom

    s Pu

    ney's _Discou

    se on the P

    sto

    l_ (1717). #15313

    12. Ess

    ys on the St

    ge, selected,

    ith

    n Int

    oduction by Joseph Wood K

    utch. #16335

    *Thi

    d Ye

    (1948-1949)*

    13. Si

    John F

    lst

    (pseud.), _The The

    t

    e_ (1720). #15999

    14. Ed

    d Moo

    e's _The G

    meste

    _(1753). #16267

    15. John Oldmixon's _Re

    lections on D

    . S

    i

    t's Lette

    to H

    ley_ (1712);

    nd A

    thu

    M

    in

    ing's _The B

    itish Ac

    demy_ (1712).

    16. Nevil P

    yne's _F

    t

    l Je

    lousy_ (1673). #16916

    17. Nichol

    s Ro

    e's _Some Account o

    the Li

    e o

    M

    . Willi

    m Sh

    kespe

    e_ (1709). #16275

    18. O

    Genius, in _The Occ

    sion

    l P

    pe

    _, Vol. III, No. 10 (1719);

    nd A

    on Hill's P

    e

    ce to _The C

    e

    tion_ (1720). #15870

    *Fou

    th Ye

    (1949-1950)*

    19. Sus

    nn

    Centliv

    e's _The Busie Body_ (1709). #16740

    20. Le

    is Theobold's _P

    e

    ce to The Wo

    ks o

    Sh

    kespe

    e_ (1734). #16346

  • 8/10/2019 Magazine, Or Animadversions on the English Spelling (1703)

    24/36

    21. _C

    itic

    l Rem

    ks on Si

    Ch

    les G

    ndison, Cl

    iss

    ,

    nd P

    mel

    _ (1754).

    22. S

    muel Johnson's _The V

    nity o

    Hum

    n Wishes_ (1749)

    nd T

    o _R

    mble

    _ p

    pe

    s (1750). #13350

    23. John D

    yden's _His M

    jesties Decl

    tion De

    ended_ (1681). #15074

    24. Pie

    e Nicole's _An Ess

    y on T

    ue

    nd App

    ent Be

    uty in Which

    om Settled P

    inciples is Rende

    ed the G

    ounds

    o

    Choosing

    nd Rejecting Epig

    ms_, t

    nsl

    ted by J. V. Cunningh

    m.

    *Fi

    th Ye

    (1950-1951)*

    25. Thom

    s B

    ke

    's _The Fine L

    dy's Ai

    s_ (1709). #14467

    26. Ch

    les M

    cklin's _The M

    n o

    the Wo

    ld_ (1792). #14463

    27. Out o

    p

    int.

    [Title

    dded by t

    nsc

    ibe

    : F

    nces Reynolds' _An Enqui

    y Conce

    ning the P

    inciples o

    T

    ste,

    nd

    o

    the O

    igin o

    Ou

    Ide

    s o

    Be

    uty, etc._ (1785). #13485]

    28. John Evelyn's _An Apologie

    o

    the Roy

    l P

    ty_ (1659);

    nd _A P negy ic to Ch les the Second_ (1661). #17833

    29. D

    niel De

    oe's _A Vindic

    tion o

    the P

    ess_ (1718). #14084

    30. Ess ys on T ste om John Gilbe t Coope 's _Lette s Conce ning T

    ste_, 3

    d edition (1757), & John A

    mst

    ong's _Miscell

    nies_ (1770). #13464

    *Sixth Ye

    *

    31. Thom

    s G

    y, _Elegy in

    Count

    y Chu

    ch Y

    d_ (1751);

    nd _The Eton College M

    nusc

    ipt_. #15409

    32. P

    e

    ces to Fiction; Geo

    ges de Scud

    y's P

    e

    ce to _Ib

    him_ (1674), etc. #14525

    33. Hen

    y G

    lly's _A C

    itic

    l Ess

    y_ on Ch

    cte

    istic-W

    itings (1725). #16299

    34. Thom

    s Tye

    s' A Biog

    phic

    l Sketch o

    D

    . S

    muel Johnson (1785).

    35. J

    mes Bos

    ell, And

    e

    E

    skine,

    nd Geo

    ge Dempste

    . _C

    itic

    l

    St

    ictu

    es on the Ne

    T

    gedy o

    Elvi

    , W

    itten by M

    . D

    vid M

    lloch (1763)._ #15857

    36. Joseph H

    is's _The City B

    ide_ (1696).

    *Seventh Ye

    (1952-1953)*

    37. Thom

    s Mo

    ison's _A Pind

    ick Ode on P

    inting_ (1767).

  • 8/10/2019 Magazine, Or Animadversions on the English Spelling (1703)

    25/36

    38. John Phillips' _A S

    ty

    Ag

    inst Hypoc

    ites_ (1655).

    39. Thom

    s W

    ton's _A Histo

    y o

    English Poet

    y_.

    40. Ed

    d Bysshe's _The A

    t o

    English Poet

    y_ (1708).

    41. Be

    n

    d M

    ndeville's A Lette

    to Dion (1732).

    42. P

    e

    ces to Fou

    Seventeenth-Centu

    y Rom

    nces.

    *Eighth Ye

    (1953-1954)*

    43. John B

    illie's _An Ess

    y on the Sublime_ (1747).

    44. M

    thi

    s C

    simi

    e S

    bie

    ski's _The Odes o

    C

    simi

    e_, T

    nsl

    ted by G. Hils (1646).

    45. John Robe

    t Scott's _Disse

    t

    tion on the P

    og

    ess o

    the Fine A

    ts_.

    46. Selections

    om Seventeenth Centu

    y Songbooks.

    47. Contempo

    ies o

    the _T

    tle

    _

    nd _Spect

    to

    _.

    48. S

    muel Rich

    dson's Int

    oduction to _P

    mel

    _.

    *Ninth Ye (1954-1955)*

    49.