No. of Printed Pages : 4 UJE-~ 2018

m- II (Slfa:illl ~ ela.=tt)

LAW - II (Evidence and Procedure)

Ae1ffh1 N1P-l : ffFr 'Elrrt J

Time allowed : Three Hours J

[~: 200

f Maximum Marks : 200

;k _. ~cfit -srR r-i?§!lTJ cfiRT,:j/Rcnef ~amJP1-cit{ifR:w;:r~wt t~&Usff -e ~ "SfR cfiRT ,3/F/cit4 ~ I "¥f rffef "SfR7 -it Yrr< "##I~ w;:r -it 3rcfi ~ m1R 3ifii;a

-! I tflHffel> Reff~ -it m 3Tcn t I ~ "SlR -q; ffift mm qiT Yrf< .j-/Rci/@: [{r/i ~ WlT -;jfflf I

Note : Candidates should attempt Question No. 1 as compulsory and four more. At least one question must be attempted from each section. In all five questions are to be answered. Marks carried by each question are indicated against the question. However, all questions carry equal marks. The par,ts of same question must be answered together.

1. ~ ~ 00 ~ ~~e4fcWle1ll ~~(l<k1 it~~ 2t ~ ~ -~ ·~· cfil ~ <:R ~ - ~ ~ ~~C4~'U IC1'4 q ~-~ ~l~lql(-1 if~~~ I ~ ~~~~~~-q ~ ~~it~~ 1 ~ ~ 20 ~ , 20 10 tfil ~ ~ ~ mar-ftrffi cf;! (-1~1-! RI B ~ ~~~~ l~lffill-ftrnl~~~~~~~frftf~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~C4l ~ ch ~ $1(-1"1dl'{cfch ~~~ I~ ~00~ ~ ~ 2014

cfq) e_~{l<kl it~ I ~~ 00 ~ ~ ~ (u;ft) "chT 2013 it~~ I cJlf 2015 -qoo ~ ~~l-i l~{Ol~Tl?TT l ~ ~ ~ ~OO "cfil~~~~~, ~ ~ cit~ s_:"@ ~ I~ \ITT~ "chTllc1-a '3% ~ 6qcl~I( "ch'T cf>WJT ~ ~ ~ ~ Ci@T<TT fco "3"B ~ cft ~ ~ ~ 00 ~ u;ft (~) "chT ~ ~ I 00 ~ ~ '9"fu ~ ~ l:fR "ffi ~ ~-~~~~311Hcimu-;fi~~-~~~~~~~m-;:rr~ l

(31) 34Gc@ ~ ~ 3lTmi: "{f( ~-~-iij~ ~ ll lfi4 ch l q 00 ~ ~ 'mUT-~ %g ~ <~o~ 6fl fig~a .-4141e14 q ~ ~ I 20

(~) 34(1<:@ ~ ~ 3mm l:f1: ~ tft Hf©Q, I

~

UJE-04 1

;! I)

IP.T .O.

uq~ < 10 C1Rgcf;l~~c8~ 1.1.1 7 cfil~ ~l1f!IBD ~~~wn 1 ~ 1WT~ ~q;r~~~~~ ~ >lnl cfrt 18% ~~q;r~cnG~ 'lft~ ~ I

~1(1 iRh ~~ ~ ~ cJT9'B ~ WTT ~ 3fu_ $Bf°civ_ ~lll ~ l. l 0.18 cfiT ~ ~ ~ ~ i I

~ncf)~~~~~~WTTi IWff{cf>q{l~~~~~~~ I

~ 3ltt 3-tl cf>~ cf>~ 3ln:~cnl qHcf>(Wf~~B~~"G;T~cR I 40

Compulsory Question

Komal and Rama were studying in Zen University, Dehradoon and pursuing their M.B.A. Course and staying at their respective hostel in the University. Both after completing their studies joined in Boom Bank as officer. In the mean time they planned to marry on 20111 April, 201 O with the permission of parents. Their parents agree to it and ceremonies of Hindu marriage were performed and they start living happy married life . Komal and Rama were happy and remained in Dehradoon upto 2014. During this period Rama gave birth to baby Girl (Rani) in 2013 . In 2015 Rama transferred to Delhi. After this Komal start ignoring her which hurts Rama. When she asked Kornal for such behaviour he disclosed that he was expecting a baby boy where she delivered a baby girl (Rani). Rama consider this attitude of Komal as cruelty and planned to file a case for divorce and maintenance for Rani & her.

(A) On the basis of facts abovementioned file a divorce petition and maintenance application on behalf of Rama in appropriate court in Dehradoon.

(B) Also, write a judgement on the basis of facts as narrated above.

OR

Ram gave a loan of < 10 Lakhs to Robert vide a promissory note dated 1.1.17. Robert agreed to pay back the loan on demand and also agreed to pay an interest at 18% p.a. However Robert has not paid back the loan and hence Ram issued a legal notice dated

1.10.1 8. Till date Robert has made no reply. Ram files a suit for recovery.

Draft a plaint on behalf of Ram by framing proper issues by assuming and presuming necessary and incidental facts and circumstances. _

ls1Js- 3l

Group-A

2. ( 31) ~ I fucf> I '<'f~.fP-l I fu ch I cf;! -mn'tH ~ ~ ? .Q tfu ch I if ~ ~ ~ I 01) '~~~' Tfll@B~~~~~ I

(B) ~cfll y_:_~ icf>-1 ~~· ~~?

(a) What are pleadings and amendment of pleadings ? Explain rules relating to pleadings.

(b) Discuss law relating to place of suing in Civil Cases.

(c) What is ·Rateable distribution of assets ' ?

l ',JE-04 2

20

10

10

-' Pl) Res-judicata', "(i:.f•fo-Gi:fi Res-judicata' ~ ·Res-sub-judice' B4$il~Q, I 20

C~) fB~M ~ it BUR c:fil ~ ~ ~ ~ olll(§ql ~ I 10

(B) '91WrtcfiT~it~mm 3fu:cm:it'91Wrt~~-~~~ ~ I 10

(a) Explain ' Res-judicata', ' constructive Res-judicata' and ' Res-sub-judice'.

(b) Explain the mode of service of summons in a Civil Case.

( c) Explain rules relating to appearance of parties and consequences of non­appearance of parties in a suit.

4 . (31) ~chl~cnG~~~~fcFiBBtlfu"i:fiT~~~i ?~-q"{~ "'\"

~ I 20

0f) ¥BRIM ~ it ~ 3l$T ~it~ ~-q"{ T.fq1 ~ I 10

(B) '31zy;IB~~• ~~? ~"ff~<fm~cfiT olll(§ql ~ I 10

(a) What property can be attached by the court to satisfy the decree ? Discuss the law.

(b) Discuss the law relating to grant of temporary injunction in a Civil Suit. (c) What is 'Reference by a court' ? Explain objects and scope of such reference.

s . (31) ~ ~ fuk11q:; ~ ~ ~1fui<1 ~it~~ mm~, 190s ~ ~ 3-1Rc!l4 ~lc!!(<-li:fidl~ ~~? ~~~ 3-ljqlft-l cfiT 3lm~~? 20

(Gf) ~ ~ -q ~ 3-lt{ Sl@<:41{1 ~~it cf;1;f ~ m m r~ ? 10

(B) fBf¾M mm~' 1908 ~ ~ qfu.jqfu "B ~ ~ 3fu: ~-~ c€f fu~:IBci -q"{ ~~ I 10

(a) What are the mandatory requirements enshrined under Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 before filing a Civil Suit against the Government ? What is the effect of non-compliance with these provisions ?

(b) Who may be joined as Plaintiff and Defendant in a suit ? ( c) Discuss the provisions relating to arrest and detention of a judgement-debtor

under CPC, 1908.

@15-"if

Group-B

6. (3l) ~~, ~~ 3lt{ :tl?!cil<fl ~~ Rl~c1B.fl~a1 ~ olll&-11 3fu:~~ 1 20

01') 3llucftcfiT~~cfi"G~~~ ·~ ·m~cfil~~t? 10

CB) '1:!.' , ~ ~ , ·~• cflT ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ - "~ q:;Jfc1l-$I ~ t 3"fu: ~ ~ f ~3lfCl~"{~~ l"~~~~~cf>T>lcR~"B~~~GlT~ 7 IO

(a) Explain and discuss the credibility of a related witness, interested witness and

hostile witness . (b) Is ' conduct' a piece of evidence to hold a party guilty of committing :.m offrncc •>

(c) 'A ', a client, says to 'B·, an attorney - ''I have committed f~rgc~ and I wish you to defend me''. Will such communication be protected from bemg disclosed or not ')

l ',JE-04 3 [P.T.O

8

9.

l 31\ k\lcfil~·IWi ~ ~ ¼li_, fo if 3IB\ ~ I~~ f<".flf fa ' cf>1 q lf(i ~ q; "5llTIUT ~ ~

if 1fRT ~ "ffcfi<TT t 7 2 0

~ ) ~m~ ~ , 1872 ~~ ~<fr si 1Bfricfia1' q{~~~~ 1 10

(B) ·~ · t ~ if ~ "ER ~ ~ ~ ·, ~ gcfic_4 1 •~ • ~ fuiM l'-h ~ t ~ ~, ~ ~t~it, 'm', ~ - tftra-rc€r ~ ~ ''Q,· "ct>T~~rrmm ,~~* ~ ir "m~~-q{ ~ ~ I 10

(a) Distinguish admission from confession. Can an ·admission · be treated as substantive evidence ?

(b) Elaborate the law on · rel evancy of character· under Indian Evidence Act, 1872.

( c) ·A· sues · B · for a house in possession of · B ·. and which, as ·A' asserts, was left to ·A· b)- wi ll of ·C . ·B ' s father. Discuss the ·burden of proof in the light of the statement

(31)

0l)

(B)

(a)

(b)

(c)

(31)

~)

(B)

(a)

(b) (c)

~l~cfi 3ltt 3ifaf{<ta ~ IRl cti ~ t ~ ~~ ~ ~ I 10

:r-t~ cf>l ~4 $l l$Q. ~ ~ 41f@cf> m~ ~«i1~Jl m~~~~m~ 1 10

~ 'l:fuf ~ Sl f<!4 1~11 . ll8cfil~~ Sllfifrlcf>d l zj~cfmft~? 20

Discuss the evident iary value of j udicial and extra judicial confessions. Explain conditions under which oral evidence shall / may be excluded by documentary evidence . Does the · expectancy of death · affect the relevancy of dying declaration ?

~~~' 1973t~ •~cf;, frl(Cfalff "B~"cf>T-f1q{~~ 120

~ 3frll~ ~~ 3TI'f>~ (-14$ll$Q, I 10

"-src:R ~ ~ (fcf> ~ ~ ~ ~ I" ~ "B ~ "cf>T-f1 ~~cit I 10

Discuss the law relating to ' arrest of persons ' under Code of Criminal Procedure,

1973 . Explain Form of charges and Joinder of charges. ·'No appeal lies unless provided." Discuss the law relating to appeals.

10. (31) ~~~~(@(@lcfcf>T3TTzyl4~f?C:[RT~~~, 1973 *

~1:flfuf fcf;7.n~~ ? SIIBfrlcf> ~~~~ I 20

~ ) ~~~~B~~~&IT&l"T~I .............4----- 10

(B) ~cf>l R ci~d , ~clT@n~-tt~~-qm~ ? SIIBfrlcf> ~~'cf>T

~~~cfifi3 1R ~ ~ I JO (a) When and for whom the order of maintenance be passed by the Magis trate under

Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 ? Cite relevant case-laws. (b) Explain the law relating to Bail and Anticipatory Bail. (c) Who has the power to suspend or remit or commute the sentences? Discuss the

law citing relevant case-laws.

ll.JE-04 4