53
Campaign Finance Complaint Form Michigan Department of State '' - cl /\ !O: 2 3 This complaint form may be used to file a complaint alleging that someone violated the Michigan Campaign Finance Act (the MCFA, 1976 PA 388, as amended; MCL 169.201 et seq.). All information on the form must be provided along with an original signature and evidence. Please print or type all information. I allege that the MCFA was violated as follows· Section l;. Complainant . . · .. Your Name \-rc1nl\ LYnn I 0 rc:r:1epqn~N1b~r 8 0 6 7- Mailing Address 3 L,j Y b De.von Or. /VI::::, City V ( Cler) ~«o,ds I s 1 M I IZipY1S-4b Section 2. Alleged Violator ·.· ••• . Name Lllvre\ A-bro ham Mailing Address 110 3' Lakes,Je Or SE City &rem 0\ Kup,d.s I s'j\i\ I I Zip L-/1St>G ! Section 3. Alleged Violations (Use additional sheet if more space is needed.) Section(s) of the MC~,} violated: 'J Sec., I b '1 . 2 35 _ 3 ~, 11 Evidence that supports those allegations (attach copies of pertinent documents and other infonnation):

Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

Campaign Finance Complaint Form Michigan Department of State

''

- cl /\ !O: 2 3

This complaint form may be used to file a complaint alleging that someone violated the Michigan Campaign Finance Act (the MCFA, 1976 PA 388, as amended; MCL 169.201 et seq.). All information on the form must be provided along with an original signature and evidence. Please print or type all information.

I allege that the MCFA was violated as follows· Section l;. Complainant

. . · ..

Your Name \-rc1nl\ LYnn I 0rc:r:1epqn~N1b~r 8 0 6 7-

Mailing Address 3 L,j Y b De.von Or. /VI::::, City

V ( Cler) ~ ~«o,ds I s1M I IZipY1S-4b

Section 2. Alleged Violator ·.·

••• .

Name

Lllvre\ A-bro ham Mailing Address

110 3' Lakes,Je Or SE City

&rem 0\ Kup,d.s I s'j\i\ I I Zip L-/1St>G

! Section 3. Alleged Violations (Use additional sheet if more space is needed.)

Section(s) of the MC~,} violated: 'J Sec., I b '1 . 2 35 _ 3 ~, 11

Evidence that supports those allegations (attach copies of pertinent documents and other infonnation):

Page 2: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

I Section 4. Certification (Required)

X

I certify that to the best of my knowledge, information, and belief, formed after a reasonable inquily under the circumstances, each factual contention of this com Jaint is/su arted b evidence.

J;{ Date

Section 15(6) of the MCFA (MCL 169.215) requires that the signed certification found in section 4 of this form be included in every complaint. However, if, after a reasonable inquiry under the circumstances, you are unable to certify that certain factual contentions are supported by evidence, you may also make the following certification:

X

I certify that to the best ofmy knowledge, information, or belief, there are grounds to conclude that the following specifically identified factual contentions are likely to be supported by evidence after a reasonable opportunity for further inquiry. Those specific contentions are:

------------------Signature of Complainant Date

Section 15(8) of the MCFA provides that a person who files a complaint with a false certification is responsible for a civil violation of the MCFA. The person may be required to pay a civil fine of up to $1,000.00 and some or all of the expenses incurred by the Michigan Department of State and the alleged violator as a direct result of the filing of the complaint.

Mail or deliver the completed complaint form with an original signature and evidence to the following address:

Revised: 01/16

Michigan Department of State Bureau of Elections

Richard H. Austin Building - 1st Floor 430 West Allegan Street Lansing, Michigan 48918

· 1

Page 3: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

Section 3: Alleged Violations

Section(s) of the MCFA violated: Sec. 169.233.33,11

Explain how those sections were violated:

Candidate for Kent County Commission in the 19th district Laurel Abraham has been using campaign literature

which reads "paid for by Committee to Elect Laurel Abraham" while knocking doors in the district. She poses

with this campaign literature in a picture posted on her campaign Facebook page on July 31, 2018. However,

campaign literature is not listed as an expenditure (itemized or in-kind) on her pre-primary campaign finance

report filed July 25, 2018. Abraham also has several campaign t-shirts, a campaign banner, and a campaign car

sticker. These items were clearly on display when she and her campaign team marched in the East Grand Rapids

fourth of July Parade. Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018.

Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures on her pre-primary campaign finance

report filed July 25, 2018. Thus, her campaign literature, campaign t-shirts, a campaign banner, and a campaign

car sticker are knowingly omitted expenditures. It is likely that these items amount to over $500 of unreported

expenditures. This is a clear violation of the MCFA, specifically Sec. 169.233.33,11 (Per legislature.mi.gov­

"If a candidate, treasurer, or other individual designated as responsible for a committee's record keeping, report

preparation, or report filing knowingly omits or underreports individual contributions or individual expenditures

required to be disclosed by this act, that individual is subject to a civil fine of not more than $1,000.00 or the

amount of the contributions and expenditures omitted or underreported, whichever is greater").

Evidence that supports those allegations (attach copies of pertinent documents and other information): Each piece of evidence is numbered in black marker.

1. A piece of campaign literature signed by Laurel Abraham which includes "Paid for by CTE Laurel

Abraham."

2. Candidate Laurel Abraham posing in a picture posted on her campaign Facebook page

(https://www.facebook.com/ AbrahamforCommission/) on July 31, 2018, holding her campaign literature.

3. Candidate Laurel Abraham and her campaign posing in a picture posted on her campaign Facebook page

on July 4, 2018, with a campaign banner while her campaign team is dressed in campaign t-shirts in

front of a red convertible at the end of the East Grand Rapids July 4 Parade.

4. Members of Abraham's campaign team sit in the aforementioned red convertible and pose for a picture

with a campaign magnetic car sticker. This picture from the East Grand Rapids July 4 Parade was posted on Abraham's campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018.

5. Candidate Laurel Abraham's pre-primary campaign finance report signed by Abraham on July 25, 2018,

publicly available on the Kent County website (https://www.accesskent.com/CFPublic/search.action). As this is

Abraham's only campaign finance report to date (with the exception of her statement of organization),

all campaign expenditures to date must be listed on this report. This document does not report campaign

literature, campaign t-shitts, a campaign banner, or a campaign car sticker as expenditures though

Abraham clearly had all of them before the July 20, 2018, close of books.

6. Candidate Laurel Abraham in a picture posted on the Kent County Republican Party Twitter page on

June 28, 2018, with two pieces of campaign literature sitting a table in front of her during a fundraiser

on June 28.

7. A screenshot of the Kent County Republican Patty Twitter post to authenticate the June 28, 2018,

timestamp.

Page 4: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

0-, . er v 11 3 1, 2-o1 r 0,-l- 17.i ?,q frr1

Page 5: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

~ & ,;:r-0 0 C

::,

C"' 0

3' --;J> tr "' ') ~ JO (,,, -::::5"

3 ;t, <t r,

I" ) I:,

il S' :3 -3 ~

?: ('

j 0

-.... ;r

~ ~

Page 6: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

Cb

~ 0 ~ ., (:i :,c:;:

0 0 3 -;:I?-~ a ::::,

3 ~ f 3

-.:,

- c t:; ('Ii -(:i ::i 0 - .:,

Page 7: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

M!CI-IIOAN DEPARTMENT OF STATE BUREAU OF ELECTIONS

CANDIDATE COMMITTEE COVER PAGE

"'',Wt"'' "'it'!f, ~ %'//1""' \\j'k '111' ii/Jl,\'a'I,,"' Iha wrer (M II re keep an ca p .

1. COmmlllee I.D. Nwnber

129280 a. Comm11111e Name

Committee to Elect Laurel Abraham

6. Commllleds Malling Addreas Joo BOX 88238 (lrand Rapids, Ml 49516

ANa Code.and Phone tB16} B81"0964 lflhe atldrel!& In lllb box la different rronllhe comrnlllee malling addreu on the Statement of Olnlzallon, mall may be sent to lhfs addl'eaa by the fRlng offl •

7. Treaaurer'1 Business AddreH 7115 Burger Dr SE Grand Rapids, Ml 49546

Area Code end PltOM

9. TYPE0FSTATli.MEN'r

®

3. ThlB Statement covara From: 04126118

4. candld11le Laat Name

Kent County Cieri< Elections Division

JUL 2 '/ 2018

FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY

10 07/22/18 ,FlrelNeme M.I,

Abraham Laurel 4a. 0~ 80U9hl hlcludJng Olll!rlct#orComllll.lnily Served (If appf1¢ab[e)

County Commissioner- OJsMCI 19

4b. County of Resldenco KENT m 6. Tre11&urer'e Name & ResldenUelMdrH& JoAnn Abraham 7115 Burger Dr SE Grand Rapids, Ml 49646

Area Code & Phone {618p45-7500

8, 0e8!9na!ed R~ttf Kee~r's N11ma and Address (lflhe comm!ltee has a Dealgna!ed Reconf Keeper)

Arua Code and Phooo

I"·

fl

911, lRIPre-Erecuon OR 9b.OPost•ElecUon Required ONLY If candidate

~B-t chanklng lhls 11am WJe Derll£y any oullllandln(J deb! Is not on lhe baUolfor the CUJrent ye,ar: by e committee to thB 08lldlcl11!e or hie or her s1>9uce 15 here

PM-election or Post-Eracllon S!a!emenl relalH 10: by dlscha,~ aid forgiven! and no klnger oollactlbfe rrom OJ(jy Quartel'ly tl\&O;l/!Jmlt ee. The oomml tee hn noousltlndl119 ulffll,

~Prim•· OY/'111 oo le!ai fees or ha$ any OUsteoding deb!. 1

l:"Joenerel tJactoberQumtelly Further, lftll& dlsao!ullon csnno~llled, lhal lhlabe

Q:onven!lon oonakle1ed e tequeat fOl Ill& Re Wa!Ver,

0Spedal 9c. 0Aruiua1 Slalem~I { ) 0Sdlool Coverage Year . Etfedlve dale of dluotul!on

[]ca .... 9d D Amendment 10 Camfialan Sl•tel'llent • (Comp!&ta Item IM, b, 8C or ea to

fndlcele which Statemanlls beilg Note; Die dlap~tlon of residual funds muBI. be repoJ1ed Oil

amended,) Schewle 1B Mtl the Sin1maryPage,

Data af E.lae!lon, ConvinUon or Caueut

08/07/18

10. Verlftcallon: I\We C(lrtlfy Iha! aH reasonable dll4lance waa t111ed In th& pmparollon Of fhla elafe1119nt and ellacl'lad schedules Qf anY) and to the best of my\ou( kn~ilnd belleflh& oontoots are true, accurate and cnmp!ete,

C,rr,.ITreas"" or ;];ft, /lb ,Ji Ort ) t2,fz ~ 1/~s-/le-Designated Record keepor 0: nn r AM J r . Dale Type or Print Name .,. Sig rel,,}/ /

1 .I 111 J · u 1hsui candidllle -- ..J> , - ' Date ~peor Ptlnt Name I ./ ., nalre

Aulhorlty granled under P.A. 388 4f 1976

Page 8: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

MICHIGAN DEPARTMENT OF STATE BUREAU OF ELECTIONS

SUMMARY PAGE CANDIDATE COMMITTEE

RECEIPTS

3.Contribullon,

o. l~lmtd {Schedule 1A• COiumn 6)

b. Unllemlted {Ina than $20,01 oach - no Scnedula)

c. Subtotal of "Conlrlbullons"

4, Other Receipts {ScbedtJlo 1A-1, Column 6)

S. TOTAi. C()N'f~IBOTION$ AND OTHER RECEIPTS (Add Lino 3c + Line 4)

IN-KIND CONTRIBUTIONS & EXPENDITURES

6, In-Kind Contr!bullons (Schedule 1-!K, Column 7)

7. ln-Klrnl Expnndl1uras (Schedule 1£1-11<. Column 6)

EXPENDITURES

8. E11pa11ditU11e

a, ltemlr.ed (Sdledul& 1 B, Column 6)

b. I1'9.mlzed Gel-Oul•lhe-Vole {Schedule 18-8)

~ Unitemized {19S8 lh.an $50.01 each• no Schedule)

G, TOTAL 1:X~E.NPITURS.S (Add line Sa+ Lina 8b + Line 8c)

INCllJl;'.NTAI. EXPENSE DISBURSE!MENTS (OIIIW10l<!ei& Only)

10. D11bu1HmGnts a. llemlted (Sehedula 1C, Column 6)

b. Unkenized ~st lhan $50.01 each- no Sched11tej•

11. TOTAi. lNCJDENTAL EXPENSE DISBURSEMENTS (Add-Un& 10a + Lfne 10b)

DEBTS AND OBI.IGATIONS 12. D&bttl 11nd Oblg111lons

a, Owed bytlla coromttee(Schedule 1E)

b, Owed lo lheC0mmX1&11 (Schedule 1E)

13, En.clog Ba!ance llf lllW flport flltd (Enter:iero If no prev!oue ieporte haw bG8fl ffl@d,)

14. Amount received durl~ reporting period {l..lne5, Tol!l Ct!nlrfbut ons&Olhlll' Receipts)

1fi. SUBTOTAL Add •nu 13 and 14 16. Amowit expendad di.ring reporling period

(Addllnts98tld 11) 17. END!NO BALANCE

.{SublrtJOI Hne 18from HM 16)

1,C,m,nltt.,1.0, Numb~ .;1;;;29:.:2:.:8.:.0 _________ _

2Cmmlll ' 0 esNa.mfJI Committee to Elect Laurel Abraham

Column I Col11111nll fhlsPoriod CumulaUve thl& election cycle

(S,,).$ 7,074.90

(Sb,) $ NOT APPUCAaLE

(30) $ $0.00 (16,)$

(4,) $ $0.00 (19,)$ $0.00 (5.) $ $7,074.90 ~0.)$ $7,074.90

(6,) $ $418.90 (21,)S $418.90 ~.) s $0,00 (22,) s $0.00

(Sa,) $ $973,80 (Sb.) $ $0,00 (6'.) s $0.00 (9,) $ $973.80 (23,)$ $973,80

(10,.)$ $0.00

(10b,)$ $0.00

(11.) $ $0,00 (24,) 1 $0,00

{1'a.)$ $318,90

(12b,'$ $0,00 s ....... ~ce BTATEM!NT

(13,) s $0,00

(14.), s $7 074,90 (15,) • i $7,074,90

{1~). I $973.80

(17.) s $6,101.10 .

Page 9: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

ifi/ MICHIGAN OEPARTM!NT OF STATE ~ BUREAU OF EI..ECTIONS

ITEMIZED CONTRIBUTIONS SCHEDULE 1A

CANDIDATE COMMITTEE

1. comm,,.. t.o. Numbw _1.;.:2:;9:.;;2;..;8.;;0 _____ ~--

2. Comm\ttae Nlllli8 Commlttee to Elect Laural Abraham

Enterconlribulor's nama~nd addren, lfoontnD\IUon fa rroman Individual, enter lut name, flral name, 6.Amount 7, Curnutallve for 8eeffQn cyde,fOl'Eacb m!ddla lnttlal Chock box to lndloate If conlrlbUllon Ii from a PO!ltltil Comm!ttoo or on lndepondont

CommlttM {PAC) Report 1111. conlrlb11tl0n1 l'l!gardles8 of amount. COnlllbulor (Througl1 detBof......,fnl\

3. Con!TibuUon # 1 PACRecelpt? 1!.JYES ~o,t,orR,ootpl 04/30/18 Name&Addrno: Kent County Republican Committee 725 Lake Michigan Drtve NW ,500 ,500 Grand Rapids, Ml 49504

.

6, lfow$100.0D oumulallvc, pleate provklo: CIiek Here for Merna ltemizatlonE]

Occ\lpaliol'I Emplaye(

Btlllne89 Address

TJp, "'""'"'"'Ion, IVloi,.,, I I L0811 li'om a pefSOn I I '"'' "'"" 3, CoAfribUl!Ol'I #2 PAC Receipt? • YES 4. Oateof Aecolpt 05/1 0/18 Neme&Addre1111

Peter Sacchi a 2833 Bonnell SE s 1000 ,1000 Ea•t Grana Rapids, Ml 49506

5, lfover$10D.OO cumutallve, plelllie provide: Click Here for Memo Itemization l3 0ocu,•too CEO Employilr Sibsco

'"""'Ad'"" 220 Llon NW, STE 610, Grand Rapids, Ml 49503 TypeofCon!riblllkm: ~DlflllOt D Lo11n from o pe,son • Fund Ralw

3. CMtfibullon # 3 PAC Ree61pt?_ • YES 4. oate of Receipt Nam&&AddrMS:

Luke Arends $50 ~50 7746 Sparta Ave Sparta, Mi 49345

CIiek Here for Memo ltem!zalionl3 &. If over$100.DO oomufatlve, please provide:

0.,,,..,, Executive Director Employer Kent GOP Bua!Mn Addrew 725 Lake Michigan Drive NW, Grand Rapids, Ml 49504

TypaofContributlom lv'I Dlnlcl I I Loan from a person I I Fond Ralsar

3. COO!rlbll~On # 4 PAC Reoolp\? 0 YES 4. Date of Receipt Nam& & AddrG&S Laurel Abraham 1108 Lakeside Dr ,5 • 5 East Grand Rapids, Ml 49506

5, lfover$100,00 c:umulatlve, please provfde; CIiek Hare for Memo Itemization El Oco\lpaUon Director of Development a,,,1,,., Llbertt Justice Center

eusllle$$Addr1m 190 s. LaSalle Street, Suite 1500, Chloogo, lll!nots 60603

Type ol Conlrlbullon: 0 Olmot D Loan from a person n F11rldRa~

PaguSubto!al $1,655.00 I

e.,,_1_,, .!!_

Grand Total of All Schadulu 1A $7,074.90 (CGmplele on Int page, of SChedu'e)

Enter th!& tola1 on \Ina 3a or &Jmmary Page.

I

Page 10: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

t!if MICHIGAN DEPARTMENT OF STATE ~ BUREAU OF ELECTIONS

ITEMIZED CONTRIBUTIONS SCHEDULE 1A

CANDIDATE COMMITTEE

1. Committee I.D. Num\lllr _1.;.2:c9.:.2c;8.:.0.:__ ______ _

2, Comm1t1e~ Name Committee to Elect Laurel Abraham

Enler conlribUl0(a name and addl8U, If conlrlbullon le from an lndMdual, enter las! nlll1\&, flral name, 6.Amount 7. CUmulattve for mlddle lnlllel, Check box to !ndJQa1e If oootr!bunon 111 from a PoHUcal commllke or11n lndopendont EIIIC!lon ~elOr Eaah COMm!ttee (PAC) ~port gll conlllb1.dlOOS regerdklss of amount Conlrlbutor (~

1~ro~

dais af re@inj

s, Conlrlbutkm # 1 PACReoolpt? LJYES ,. "''"'""'"' 05/14/18 · Name & Address: Enc Larson 2215 Cascade Lakes Circle SE

,26.07 ,26.07 Grand Rapids, Ml 49546 IS, lfovu$1QD,OO i;umuhlll~ pltue Provide:

CIiek Here for Memo 1temlzat1on[:I Ocoupatlon Employer

Bu1llnm Addre&a

Typ8 of Contribution: -f.;J Direct r l Loan f'lflm a peraon I I Fund Ralaor

3, ConlrlbUllon #2 PACRe(:elpl? • YES 4,DotoofR""lpl 05/14/18 Name & Addrw

Marie Vulaj $51.84 $51.84 5759 Heritage HIii Dr

Alexandria, VA 22310 !I, If owrs100.oo cumutattvu, plea,e pr4\lfde: Click Here fof Memo ltemlzatlonE)

ocwpatlon . Employe-

Bu.ll'leas Addre"

Type,orcontribul.lon: ~Direct D Loan from a pirson D f:undRefter

3. Conlflbulion # 3 PAC Receipt? • YES 4. o,~ofR•"l>I 05/14/18 Nllllle & Addl'&&s: Wes Fisher

$26.07 $26.07 113 N Wayne SI Apt6 Arllnglon, VA 22201

CIiek Here tor' Memo ltemizatl~n l3 II, If over$1D0,00 cumulative, pl1111Be provfde:

Otoopatlon Emplo~-er

Bus1nenAddress Type tif~ntmutlon: ltll Direct D Loan rrom a p&rson 17 FUndRaJeer

3. Con!ributlon ff 4 PAC Receipt? DYES 4. Dale of-~I 05/14/18 NIIIYll'l&AddMS

Elizabeth Housemann 1332 Bucklin St .20.92 s 20.92 LaSalle, IL 61301 S, II om $100.011 cumuleUve, pl&u& provide:

CIiek Here for Memo llemlzatlonf3 ~upa.tlo- Employur

BUG!ness Mckese

Type d Conlrlbul!on: ~ Dlreot D Loan from a person I 7 Fund Re!ller

""""""""' $124.90 I

· 2 8 P11ge __ o1 __

~1~ndTolal of All Sohedul11S 1A l$7 074.90 Com t& on !HI Of Sthedukl 1 - Enter lhla total 011

lint 3a of Sl.lmmary Page,

Page 11: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

~ MICHIGAN OEPARTMENT 9F STATE ~ BURE'AU OF ELECTIONS

. ITEMIZED CONTRIBUTIONS SCHEDULE1A ,. c,mm1.., 1.o, """"" ....:.12c.9:;;2:;;8:.;0;__;_ _____ _

CANDIDATE COMMITTEE 2. Comml!{ee Name · Committee to Elect Laurel Abraham

Enter cont~bu\ota namumt 1;1ddroB11, If oonlribullon la from an tnd1vklual, enlet last name, first name, 6.Ah101Jnt 7. CumU11tlvt fur rnkfdte irllllal, Chook box \Q IOdloete lfoonlfl~lkm Is rrom a Po!Ucal Col!ml"ltee Of ilR lndepnndanl Elecllon Cydo for Each Commltlee (PAC) Report !!II. contributions regard loo a of amount. Con!rlbutor(ThrOU{lh

Aa"" of rec11fnt\ 3. Conb1bullon # 1 PAC R11celpl? LJYES 4. Dale ofReoolpt 06/03/18

Name &Aclclress: Spencer Chretien 1614 Maddux Lane

,50 ,50 McLean, VA22101 5. It ovijr$100.00cumult111v~ ploaso prwlde:

CIiek Here for Memo llemlzetionl:J OOOJpalion Employ&r

BUG!ne,;& Addren

,,.,o1ConbibU1lon: lvh,,,. I I Loan from a person I J Fund RalsBI' .

3, contrlblll!On #2 PAC Receipt? • VES •·o"'''"'"l>i 05/18/18 Nama & Addroas

Raymond Abraham s 150 1150 898 Ambarwood Court

Walnut Creek, CA 94598 5. lrover$101t,0D eumulatlve. please provide: CH.ck Here for Memo ltemlzatfonEJ "'"'p,Uon Financial Advisor .,,,,1,,,, Self-Employed

8,.,,,.,M~,., 100 Pringle Ave, STE 330, Walnut Creek, CA 94596

TypacfContrlbuHon: ~Olract 0 Loan from a per1on D Fund RalHI'

3, ConlrlbuUon # 3 PAC Raoelpt? Oves 4, DawofR@pl 05/18/18 Nllmt & Addrm::

Donljo DeJonge $250 s250 1149 Evelyn St NE Grand Rapids, Ml 49505

CIiek Here for Memo llemlzatlonl3 5. U over $100.00 oumulatlvo, plH.ll9 provide:

Oowpo.tion Professor Empt"" Grand Valley State University aua1nmAddre81 1 Campus Dr,Allenda!e, Ml 49401 Typ&ofConltlblllton: lv'I Direct I I Loan from a pe!SOn I I r-undRa!aer

3, Gonlrlbutkm # 4 PACRece!pl? Oves 4, Dole ofR.,,lpl 06/14/18 Name & Addrm

Donna Hattem 2197 Greanslone Dr SE ,20 I 20 Grand Rapids, Ml 49546 5, If ~$100.00 cumulative, plea:u, provide:

Click Here for Memo ltemizationEJ Oooupallon Employer

BU$1n&s8 Addret;8

Type of Conhlbution: ~ Direct D Loan from a person D Fund Raiser

Pag11S1Jb{o!al $470.00

OtandTOlalofAHSohedufas 1A $7 074.90 (Complete on le6ll)a:ile otSchedtlkl) '

,,..1_,,~ Enter thla total on line 3a or summary Page,

Page 12: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

~ MICHIGAN OEPARTMEN'TOF STATe ~ BUREAU OF ELECTIONS

ITEMIZED CONTRIBUTIONS SCHEOU~E 1A

CANDIDATE COMMITTEE

1.Comm•eel.0.Nwooe, _1_29_2_8_0 _______ _

2 Com I mtteeNama Committee to Elect Laurel Abraham

Enter conWbUlol's name and """ra11, If contNbulton II from an lrnlvldual, e11t&r la& name, flr&t name, mk!dh1 lnitiGI, Ohe!)l{bOx to tndlca!eltcomrlbuUon ls.from a POlltlcal Committee oran Independent

11,Arnottnt 7.CVmula!lvlJfor Eleotlon Cytle ror Each

Comm1l18e (PAC) Report!ll. oontrtbutlone regardJOS$ of amount. Contrlbvlor !~~ough dale of recel

3, Oonltlbutlon # 1 PACRecelpl? (!1YES 4.DaleofR,oolpl 06/11/20 Nema a Address: Kent County Republican Committee 726 Lake Michigan Dr NW ·

,2000 ,2500 Grand Rapids, Ml 49504 &. ff ovet $100,00 cumulatlv•, pl~~& ptov!de:

CIiek Here for Memo ltemlza.UonEJ 0CCUl)lllion Emptay,&r

Bus!nenAddren

Typeofeottlrlbullon: !Vlotreet I I Loan from a per&Oll I I Food R~aer

a, 06rt!tiblltlon #2 PAC Rec,11;1])l? • YES '·°""'"""''' 06111/20 Name & Addr&H

Terri Land ,500 1500 7955 Byron Station Ci SW

Byron Center, Ml 49315 &. rt over $100,00 cumulative, pJe.ase provide: CIiek He,e for Memo ltomlzaUonEJ Occupation Owner em,,,,., GreenlightManagement

BusrnesaAd<teH 168 Lou!$ Campay Promenade Sulla 300, Grand Raplds1 Ml 4950354

Type, of CCnlrib11Uon; • D!recl 0 lgan from a parson ~ Fund Raiser

3. CGn!tibu!lon fl 3 PAC Reoefpt? Oves 4, Date of Rocelpl Nam&&Mdreu:

Palricla Stemmler s 125 1125 1623 Spring Wind Dr SW

Byron Center, Ml 49315 CIiek Here for Memo Itemization EJ 5. If over$10D.0D cumulative, p/easa provlda:

""""""" Flight Attendant Emproyer Amway Buelnt'9Ad- 6410 44th SI SE, Grand Rapids, Ml 49512 Type of ConlrlbuOon: I I DIMct I I loan from a person lvl Fund Raiser

3. Conltlbu\lOII # 4 PAC R$08lpt? • YES 4, D•• of Reoelpl 06/28/20 Name & Add1'4'188

CTE Thomae Antor 9341 Laubach Ave ,50 , 50 Sparta, Ml 49345 ti, lfovor $100,00 cum.u!l!tlvo, pJasliB provide:

Click Here for Memo Uemlzat!onEJ Oix:upatlo· Employer

Bu11noss Address

Type of COnlrfbullon: n Direct 0 Loan rrom a petSon [ill FundRliser

Paga Subtotal $2,675.00 I GrandTota!ofAIISehlldulM 1A. $7,074.90

Complete on laat !)iga of Bdledul~) Enlt'lr this to1al on Una g~ ol SiJmmaiy Psgt.

Page 13: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

riflt MICHIGAN OEPARTMENTOF STATE ~ BUREAU OF ELECTIONS

ITEMIZED CONTRIBUTIONS SCHEDULE1A 1. Commlll,e Lo. Num..- _1.:.;2:.;9:.:2:.;8;.:0 _______ _

CANDIDATE COMMITTEE 2. CO!l'lmlttoo Name committee to Elect Laurel Abraham

Enter oonlrlbutol'e fl8fTl6 and a<klren, ff tonlribtl1Jon 1$ from an lndlvldual, 8flter last name, flrat name, 6,Arnount 7. CUmul1Uve for m,lddle ln!l!lll, Chei;k box to lnd!oale If conlt1bu!lon Is frOM II Pol!Ur.:al Committee or an Independent EJi,i;tion Cycie for Ell.di Commlttoe (PAC)R<lport!ll, t;0nlnbuUona regsrdlen of alllOIJl'tL Contribulor ~Through

3. Conlrlbuijon # 1 PAC Reoolpt? LJVES . 4.o.teofRooel~ 06/28/18 Nanie&Addre!l9l Luke Arends 7764 Sparta Ave

I 150 ,200 Sparta, Ml 49345 5. ff ov1r$100.oo cumu\1!1vO, plnse provide:

CIiek Here for Mem~ llemlzatlonl3 0.,,,,.1 .. Executive Director Employ,, Kent Gauntt GOP auotno"""""" 725 Lake Michigan Dr NW, Grand Rapids, Ml 49504 Yype of ConlrlbuUon: I I Dll&nt I I LQ.anfromapersi,n lvl Furic1 Ra1,u,

S. Cotltrtbulkm #2 PAC Receipt? • VES ,. a,~ c1 """'1 06/28/18 Name & AddrtM

Shana Shroll 1612 Woodwaro Ave SE s 100 s 100 Grand Rapids, Ml 49506

6, lfover$100,00 oumutellve-, plaast prov Id&: Click Here for Memo ltemlzaHonB)

Ocoupal!on Vice President · em,1,,., Greenllght Management

Bue!llnaAddress 168 Louis Campau Prol'nenad& Suite 300, Grand Rapids, Ml 4960354

Type Of COnltlbutiOn: D011~ 0 LoM from !I petsoo ~ Fun.!Reloor

3, ConlrlbuUon # 3 PAC Reoolpl? ~ YES •· a,,.,, """'1 06/28/18 Nema & Addren:

Kent County Republican Committee 725 Lake Michigan Dr NW ,500 13000 Grand Rapids, Ml 49503

CIiek Here for Memci 1temluiHonl3 S.. 1fe1var $100,00 cllmlllutiw, p11111.u provide:

OOClJpal!on Employer

Business Address Typa of COn'!lbU11on: 0 Dlraot I I Loan from a pernon I el I Pund Raiser

3, Donlrlbutton # 4 PAC Reoolpl? u ves ,. a,• o1 "'"l>I 06/28/18 Narne&Adtlren

Katherine Condon 2209 Elliot St SE ,75 . 75 Grand Rapids, Ml 49506-4632 &. ltover$100,0U c.umuhltlv., please provide: CIiek Here for Memo Itemization El Ocoupa!Jon l:mployar

Bu~!neaaAddl'$9$

Type ofCon1ribUUon: 0 Direct 0 Lonn from a per&On rvl Fund Raiser

Page SubloUII $625.00

Grand Total of All Sehedulea 1A $7 074.90 (Complete on laat pagi, of Schedtie) '

.. ,,_§_,,_!!_ Enterttdslolalon Hne 3a of Sumnwy P~e.

Page 14: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

ffi4_ MICHIGANDEPARTMENTOFSTA1E ~ BUREAU OFeLECTIONS

ITEMIZED CONTRIBUTIONS SCHEDULE1A

CANDIDATE COMMITTEE

1. comml"" t.o. Num,., _1.::2:::9c:2c:8c:O _______ _

2. CommJttea Name Committee to Elect Laurel Abraham

Enter conl&utor'e nami;, iind &dtlrOU, lfcoo111bullon la uam an mdlvldual, enter la&t name, fl,st name, 6.Amount r. CUmllattve ror Elcellon Cyde for l:aeh mlddle lnltkl~ Chae!\ box1o lndlcs\e If bon!rlbutlon /11 from a PolHlool CommR!eo or en lmtependslit

Committee (PAC) Report Ill conlrlbutlont regardles$ er amounl Gonll1butor (Through da!e"4 _; ...

3. Con1rlbt/Hon # 1 Nam a & Addren:

PAO-~ LJYES 4.D,toofR<colpt 06/28/18

Nicholas Culp 414 Church Street

\50 ,so St. J9aeph, Ml 49085 5. It owr$100.00 ournulaUv11, pll)ase provldo: Click Here for Memo Itemization IE] OoeupaUon Empklyer

Butlnl!!!aAa:dress

TypaofContribullon: l lo1reot I I Loan from n person lvl FlmdRat .. ,

3, COnlrlbullon #2 Name & Add'resa

. PACRecelpt? • YES 4. DalaofR,o,lpt 06/28/18

Joyce Smith ,50 ,50 2563 Pine Dunes Dr SW

Wyoming, Ml 49418 5, tr over$100.00 cumulatlve. pfsase provide: Cl!ck Here for Memo ltem!zallonE)

Ot1Cttp,!1llcn Employtr-

euah'IOGS Adcteu

1ypaofCOI\II1butlon; Doi.Rief D Loan from a parson 0 Ftr1d Raiser

3. Contribunon # a PAC Receipt? ~ YES ~ Dole ofRaoalPI 06/28/18 Nalfl& & Address:

Emily Brieve for County Commission s100 .100 7438 Missoula Dr SE caJedonia, Ml 49316

CIiek Here for Memo Itemization E] Ii, It over S10D,OO oumulatlva, pJ(laae provide:

Occupation Employer

Buelne$$Addrm Type of conlribU!lon: D Direct I I Loan fl'om a person hi I Fund Raiser

3. q)nlrlbulioo # 4 PAC R•ee!pt? ~ YES 4. Data of Racatpl 08/28/18 Name & Addraa1

Chris Afendoulls for Stale Senate Committee 240 Edgehill Ave .100 , 100 Grand Rapids, Ml 49546 S. It ovar$1DO.OO cumulaUv•, pluae provide: Click Here for Metno lt&mlzauonl2J Occupell~n E'mployer

Butlne» Addren

Type of Conlsbutlon; • DlteCl n loan from a person K?I Fund Raiser . Page Subtotal $300.00 I

GrStldTotalof.AII Schedu(&$1A $7 074.90 {Complllla en lllat pag&of Sehadu!e) 1 I

Enler this tole! on Una 2a orsumm111Y Page,

.

Page 15: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

,a MICHIGAN DEPARTMENT OF STATE ~ BUREAU OF ELECTIONS

ITEMIZED CONTRIBUTIONS SCHEDULE1A 1. Commlttaa 1.0. Number _1_2_c9;;.2;;.8;;.0;;.__.;_ ____ _

CANDIDATE COMMITTEE ' ..• commutae Name Commltte to Elect Laurel Abraham

En!Or aontdouti:irs name and addren, If conlllbullo11 le from an /~el, enter last nama. /ltil name, 11.AMOUnt I 7, Cw,,,,, ... , middle il'll'tia1, Che.ok box to lndlet1W If conMbullon I• f(Qm a Po»Ucal Co!Mllttae or an Independent Election Cyt:le for Es.ell commlllta (PAC) R$port!!,!J. con!rlbuliOnll regardlm of amount. · Contrihutor (Thf001l

d"'IO nfreoelntl S. Con1ri'b11Uon # 1 PAC Receipt? LJ VES

'·"'"''"'"''' 06/27/18 Name & Addms: David Fmy 40 PeariStNE Ste420 ,250 $250 Grand Rapkls, Ml 49503•242B II, lfovar $100.00 cunm!allvo, ple.iao provide;

Click Hare for Memo lte~lzalfonE} Ocoupatlon Retired •~oyer Retired eualnm AddrMs

Type ofOontrlbuUon: IV I Direct I I Loan from a person I I '""' ""'" 3. Contrlbullon #2 PAC Raceipl? oves 4. "'" ''"'"'~ 06/24/18 Name & Addre!IS

Anthony Abraham $ 100 $ 100 9870 Snow Ridge Dr SE

Alto, Ml 49302 s. If over $100.0D cumu1al!ve-, pleas, provldo: cnck Here for Memo ltemlzaUonlEI occupauon Marketing Associate Emplo~er Sysco

'"''"'""'"" 3700 Slsco ct SE, Grand Rapids, Ml 49512 Typ8ofContflOOtlon: ~Direct D Loan rrom a peN1on D r1.1nd Relaer

3, Conlrfbullon # a PAC Receipt? 0 Yl:S 4, o,re,r "''"'' 06/25/18 Name &Address:

La Buckley $500 $500 PO Box222 · Sublette, Illinois 61367

Cllok Here for Memo ltem.izatl~nl3 Ii, If ov11r.$1DO.QQ Clllllllallve, pleaae provide:

ocwpallon Manager Employer Production

Blllhes& Addreu Type (lfContrlbu!lon: It/I Direct 0 L'l;la11 from a pertron I I PundRalw

3. contribollon # 4 PAC Rere!pt? • YES 4. Deleo! Rtcolpt 07/18/18 Name&Adclttiia

Jim Williams 3706 Buttrick Ave NE , 100 , 100 Ada, Ml 49301 5, If ovar $1D0,QQ ctn1ulallve, p!ea111 provide:

Click Here. for Memo ·Itemization El o-••n Bus. MQt Em,r,,.er Williams Distrlbullon

'"''"'""''"" 658 Richmond St NW, Grand Raelds, Ml 49504 Type of Conlrlbu!lon: wf Direct f l Loan from 8 pmon n f1111d Ralset

Peoe Subto!al $950.00 I GrandTotalotAl!Schodufee 1A $7

1074,90

Co~lete on last page of Schedule) I

.,,,...!_ot~ Enter tfl!a tola1 on llne.3.a ofSummPry .....

Page 16: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

'(~ MICHIGAN DEPARTMENT OF STATE ~ BUREAU OF ELECTIONS

ITEMIZED CONTRIBUTIONS SCHEDULE1A 1.Comml"' 1.0. •-• _1_2_9_2_8_0 ______ _

CANDIDATE COMMITTEE 2 Comm! N uee ama Committee to Elect Laurel Abraham

enter col\ltlbulota name and addre,s, If eontrlbuUon la rrom ftll lndlvldulll, antar last narna, firal name, 6,Amoont 7, cumulative far mfdtlkl ln\Ual, Chaclt bo)( lo ln<loole Ir C()nldbutlon ts from a Polltlcal Committee or an lmlapandant ElecUon Cycle for Each commlttoe (PAC) Report all conlributlona regard leas of amount · Contribulor"~~tough

da!eofreoo 3. Contribution# 1 PAC Roc,~n LJ YES 4.DaleofRooS~ 07/18/18

Nama&Addma: Henry Fuhs Jr 3848 Leonard St NE

~50 ,so Grand Rapids, Ml 49525 Ii, If ovet$100.00 cumulatlvo, please ptovlde:

Click Here for Memo ltemlzalloril3 Occupat!on Employer

Bua!neuAddren

Typ,ofConlrlbll1iCn: I lo1recl I I Loan from II pl!r50n / -, Fond "'""

a Con11lbullon #2 PAC Receipt? • YES .4. DoloofReoelpl 07/20/18 Nama&Addreaa

Chris Afendoulis 1100 s 100 240 Edgehill Ave SE

Grand Rapids, Ml 49546 !i. If over $100.00 cumulatlvo, ploasa provide: CIiek Here for Memo UemizaUanEJ oceupallon State Represetative Employ Michigan House of Representenlallves

""""'"Ad'•" 124 N Caeilol Ave, Lansing, Ml 48909 Type of CclnlrlluUon: ~Direct D Loan 'from a perfOn • Ful!d Raiser

3, ConlllbuUon # 3 PAC Receipt? ~vs• 4, D•lo of R,o,Jpl 06/16/18 N11.1ne & Addrw,:

Nancy Steckler $25 ,25 12087 Cherry Creek Ridge Lowell, Ml 49331

CIiek Here for Memo ltemlzatioil l3 6- If ov.,$1(10.00 cumulaltvo, pl&aDb Pf()Vld~l

Oooupallon Employer

8u1JnesS Addte$e TypeofContrlOOllon: I lOlio~ I I Lo11n ftom a person 1,;1 FundRala!lf

3. Con\ribullon #14 PAC Receipt? • YES 4, Dale of R8celpt Name & Addrets

• . 5, lfover$100,00 cumul•llva, pleno proVlde:

Click Here for Memo Itemization El Oceupallo Employer

8\lalneK Adtll'e&,

Typa of Corrtfibulion: D DlreOI D Loan from a pfflon n FundRolaer

P,g• s,0•017$175.00

8 8 ... , __ .,_._ Gr.indTolalofA!lSOhedulaa 1A l$7,074.90

Co &le on IHI a of Sohadulo ( """ "' Enter tills Iola! on

Hne 3a of Sull'UMfY .....

Page 17: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

8f MIClilOAN DEPARTMl';NT0F STATE ~ SUREA.U OF ELECTIONS

ITEMIZED EXPENDITURES SCHEDULE1B

. CANDIDATE COMMITTEE a, Naml!I and addrm of peraon or vendor to whom pald

EXpendllura #1

N,me Cricket Wireless Addre0& 3195 28th St SE Unit SL022 Grand Rapids, Ml 49512.

0FtJndRl!l!aer

Expenditure #2

"'"" USPS AddreH

1451 Lake Dr SE Grand Rapids, Ml 49506

0FundRalhr

""'~""" 113 Nam, Party City Address 5114 28th St SE Grand Rapids, Ml 49512

0 1-"und Reiser

Expendllura #4

'"m• Tavern on the Square

Address 100 Ionia Ave SW Grand Rapids, Ml 49503

~Food Railer

~pendlttltfJ 115

Norn, Cricket Wireless Addro&S 3195 28th St SE Unit SL022 Grand Rapids, Ml 49512

n Fund Reiser

1 2 Page __ of __

1,Com"''"I. D. Nwnber _1_2_9_2_8_0 _______ _

"" .,,. 2 c, .,, " Committee to Elect Laurel Abraham· 4. Pu~e (Required lnfomi&tlon) I ,. Dole 6,,..,.ovnt

06/11/18 $ 35 ---

Pm,- Cell phone "''' ---Cllei< HIHe for Memo·ltemlzeUon Type

Q Check box. lflhls expllndllure la payment of I or obllgaHon reported on previous

statement

08/11/18 s130 ---Purpose; Stamps o,i. ---

CIiek Here for Memo lb.lm!ni~M Type

~hock bQx lfthla e'.xperdlluro i& paymenl of or oblgatici, r1ported on prev!oua

til&klment

06/29/18 $110.80 Purpose: Parade candy· o~,

CIiek Here ror Memo !temluttion T}'P<I

Ocheck box if thi& expenditure Is paymant of debt ot obligation tt!P0rted on previous ai11!ement

06128/18 I 652

..,_, Fundralser expenses ~

CIiek Hero for Momo ltemb:aUon TypPJ

Q Cheok box If this oxpendlQre Is payment of I orob!lga!lon reportell on prel.(ous

stal!lmenl

07/09/18 I~ .,,,.,. Cell phone ~

CIiek Here for Memo Uomb:;dion Type Q Cheek bO)( 1f this BK11endlture,1s paymenl of

t or obllgafun rnportad on prav!oua sful8manl

Sublolal this page

Gland T~lal of all $ohelniles 19 (Complete on laet paga of Schedule)

$962.80

$973.80 Enlar this tol:al onlneBaof SumMeiy Page

Page 18: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

• MICHIGAN DEPARTMENT OF STATE ~ BUREAU OF ELECTIONS

ITEMIZEO EXPENDITURES SCHEDULE 1B

CANDIDATE COMMITTEE 3, Name lltld addrHt. Df p«rson or V$1U10r IO Wllom pe!d

Expa11dlture 11

Nam, 513rd Bank AdchH

2201 Weal1hy St SE Grand Rapids, Ml 49506

0FundRtt1B81'

EKpenclilure #2

N,m,

AddreSli

n Fund Ralset

expendllµre #3

"'"' Addm,

0FundRelser

ExpendUure ft4

Nona

Add,...

DFundR:elm

EirpendHure #S

Nome

Addren

0 FW'ldR&lser

2 2 Page __ ., __

1. com,.,,.;, o, Numo,r .,.1_2_9_2_8_0 _ _.,:. _____ _ ~eo " N Committee to Elect Laurel Abraham mm ee ame

4, PUfpo!IIJ (ReqUlred lnfoml~tlon) I '·O•lo 6,AfflOWlt

07/12118 1.1.:!__ ---Purpose: ~ank FEle Dall,

Cllcl< Here{or Memo llQm!mlloo Typel3

Q Check box II Ihle expendHure is payment or I or ob8gat!on reported on previous

s!atamant

--- $

Purposo: o,. ---

C1k::k Here for Memo Uem!zal!on rypel:J Qcheek box If this expencIJure rs payment of

or /Jbllge.tloo reporled on prav!oua statement

I PurpoB&: Datu ---

Cftck Here for Memo l!Gmiullon TypeGJ Och eek box !rlhls &Xpendl!ure Is payment of debtor ob~ga!lon repQrl~d on preYlou, •"""-~

7iie $ ---Purpoaei

CJ/ck Hera for Memo Hemlmtlon Typ~l3

Q Chect box If this expentl!l.lte, Is payment of ' or obHg11t!an reported on J)re\ltOLIS

alalament

~ $ Purposa: ---

. CIiek Hero for Memo Itemization Type-El QC~ box lfth!s exp&ndllwe is payment of

t °' obtlgat!on reported oo prevlou& slalement

Sublo!&I lhls pagil

GranCITctal of ell Schedules 18 (Cotnplete on IHt page of ScheOlllt•

$11.00

$973.80 Enter lh!a total on Urie Ba of summaiyPage

Page 19: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

f~ MICHIGAN l)EPARTMENT OF STATE ~ BUREAU OF El.ECTIONS

ITEMIZED IN-KIND CONTRIBUTIONS SCHEDULE 1-IK 1.Commlttool.D.Numbo, ..::12:::9:.:2:::Sc:O ________ _

CANDIDATE co 2 Com 1tt Norn Committee to Elect Laurel Abraham MMITTEE m" ' l ••mt1,WJ.,~•i-~m•00:mfl · 4. Type ofln•Kf~ C011!11buUon (Chook appl!c9bfa box) 7,Amountor 8, Cumulallve t oon a rom an ua!, ent•t 11at

6. Date of Receipt Fair Market · for Eleolion name first. Check box lo lndlcale If oontclbullon Value Cyela (Through la from a Polltlcal Commmae or an tntlependent 6, Name & Addre&$ of Vendor rram w11om goods 01 teMC&s were data In U.11111 6) Commlltee. (Both era oommonly !Jlllad PACs), purchased Repod.§) Jn•klnd oontrlbUUOm:,

Conln'budcn # 1 PAC Recelpl? l!J Ye.I 4. O Endorsemant orGuarpn\ee of Bank Loan Nam(l&Addma: D Gootls oona{ad or l..oaned D servieee nooated g100 .100 Kent County Republican Committee

725 Lake Michigan Dr NW ~ Goods or Sarvlces Purchand by Candidate or Olhetl G,.nd Rapids, Ml 49504 • Good& or S111vlonc'PtJrohaud by Candidate or Olhet8-- LOAN

If OVK $1110.00 eiJmuletlv,, plHH provkfe: Desor!pllon Parade Fee Oocupallon:

employer NM'le Si Bl!iinss'a Addreu: ,. """°'"""~' 06/08/18 6. V&ndor Name & Address:

East. Grand Rapids Parks and Rec Dept C!k.k Here ror Memo Uemli11Uon

750 Lakeside Dr SE

D FundRalsef'Conlllbution East Grand Rapids, Ml 49506

COnt.rlblltiOn#2 PAC Racelpl? • Y~& 4. 0 Endorselffl!lnt or Gueran~ of B211'lk Loan Nam• & Address D GoodaDonat&dorL.o11118d D SaNlcMOonated Laurel Abraham 1100 1100 1108 Lakeside Dr O Goo&or SetVloeB Pi.Jrchaaed by Candidate orOthlTG

East Grand Rapids, Ml 49506 ~ Goods or Sarvio&a Purchased by Candidate orOlh&t1- LOAN

lfovor $100,001;1umulalfve, pl111at:1 pl'<lvldo: Doocriptlon Filirig Fee Oe<:upatlon: Director of Development ,. o,•or"""'" 04/23/18 Employer Mame & Addrau:

Liberty Justlca Center 6. Vendor Na.mo &Address:

190 S, LaSalle Street, Suite Kent County, Clerks Office CiC'k Here for Memo Uemtzat!Oll

1500, Chicago, Illinois 60603 300 Monroe Ave

0 Fund RilnrCOnllfbullon Grand Rapids, Ml 49504

ConMbUllon #3 PAC Recelpl? 0 Yea 4. D Endommcml orGuarar.lee of B8J'lk Loan ,268 Name & Addrvss: D Goods oon111ed or Loaned D Servlcell Donated 1 168

Laural Abraham 00ood11 or Services Purchased by Candk:lata or Others 1108 Lakeside Dr

East Grand Rapids, Ml 49506 ~Goods or Seiv!cas Purchased by Candidtlte or Olhertt• LOAN •

lf ovor$100.00 eumul11Uve, pleau provldai Oast:flptlon Website °"""""" Dlractor of Development • DalOOfRecel>J: 04/20/18 Emp!oyerName &·Addr$8a: 6. Vendor Name a Ad drew: Liberty Justice Center WIX Cltck l-lere for Memo JtemizaUon

190 S, LaSalle Street, Suite 235 West 23rd St 1500, Chicago, Illinois 60603 New York, NY D Fund Ruiter Oonlribllllon

P11ge Subtotal $368.00 Grand Total of all Sch&lllies 1°lK $418.90 (Comp~te on la$! rage of Schadule)

En!er lhls total on 1/na 6ofSumma,y

"" .... _1_ .. 2-._

Page 20: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

8 MJCHIGANDEf>AR'TME;NTOFSTATE ~ BUREAU OF ELECTIONS

ITEMIZED IN-KIND CONTRIBUTIONS SCHEDULE 1-IK 1.eomm1t•o1.o.,.,,be, ..c1:c29:c:2:c:8..:.0 _______ _

CANDIDATE COMMITTEE , <iommmeo N• Committee to Elect Laurel Abraham me

lt"""' ,:g,.,.,., "'~r.:"'~ 4. Typi,of ln-Nnd Con!rlbuliOn (Chock appl'1oa\'lleboX) 7, Amo11n1.or 6. Cumulative conlribu n IIHrotri an I oo, enter aet name first. Check box to lndlcat& If oontrlbullon &, Date of Reoolpl Fa!tMarlult for l;feclkln

I• from a PoltlceJ Commltlee or an Independent 6. Name & Addre&S or vendor from whom goOdr. or ta/V!Cfl& 1Vare Value Cycle (nlrough

Comm!tlte (80th are commonly Cfiled PAC$i puldlased _ · data In lllll!l 6)

Repo11!l! In.kind oonlrlbulion1.

Contslbullon # 1 PAC R81:flpl? LJ Yea 4. LJ Endonlement.orGuaranlee of Bank.Loan Nema & Address: D Gooda Doitated or Loaned O Servlco$ Oor,atlld .277.90 Laurel Abraham 1 9.90 1108 Lakeside Dr 0 OoodB or Services Purcl\a$ed by Cand!(late or Othera

East Grand Rapids, Ml 49506 121 Gooda or SelV!ces Porehaud b>" Cond!dali:t 01 OlhllfB• LOAN If over $100,QO cumulotlv,, plaaue provide: D!)$(1~1100 Domain name ocw,,11o"'Dlrector of Development 1:mpioyer Nam& 8 ewrness.Addren: 5, Oa~ Of-lpc 04/20/18

Liberty Justice Center 6, V11ndorName&AddN1&&:

190 S. LaSalle Street, Suite GoDaddy CHCk Hera for Memo llamtz.ati011

1500, Chicago, Illinois 60603 1 Parsons Dr

D Fund Ralatr Contribution Hiawatha, IA 52233

Conlfibulfon # 2 PAC Rec,lpt? • ye, 4, 0 Endors111Rent or GIJarsntee of Bank Loan t-lame & Alldres~ • GoGd& Donat'ed or LoanOO O 88NIOIIS Donll!ad

Laurel Abraham I 41.00 1 318.90 1108 Lakeside Dr • GoGde orS&l\'IC&II Purchased by Candidate or O!hG.'ti

East Grand Rapids, .Ml 49506 ~ Goods or Servfoes Purohaud by Cendkleta or Othelll• LOAN

lfovar $100.0D cumuJatflll,pleaco provld&: DescripGon PO Box """"""' Director of Development ;, . Doto Of Reeelpl; 04/24/18 Employer NIVll& & Adlfre»:

Liberty Justlce Center 8, Vondor Name & Addniss:

190 S. LaSalle street, Suite USPS Cl(tk Here for Memo l!Bm!Hilon

1500, Chicago, Illinois 60603 1451 Lake Dr SE

• Ful\d RlllNr ContrlbuUon

Grand Rapids, Ml 49506

Contribution #3 PAC Recelpl? D Yes 4. D EndoMement or GwmnliO ot B11nk Loan Name & Address:

!fovor $100.0D cumulallvo, ple•e provide:

OccupaUom

Employar Nome & Addteu:

Ofund RallerContrllluRon

D Goode Donated or Loan ad O S11rvlcea Donate,:! $ s 0Goods or Serv!oos Purchased by Candkfatu orOlhera

0Gooda or Services purchaosd by Csndldal& or Others- LOAN

Oesalpllon

6. Oe:le Of Receipt;

6, Vendor Name & Address: CIiek Hore ror Memo ftem!zeUon

Page Sub!Ollll

Grand Tola! otall S¢hadolaa 1-IK (CumpleWon las! paga of Schedule)

$50.90

$418.90 Enler 1h18 (otal on line 6 of summary Page

Page 21: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

f6 MICHIGAN DEPARTMENT OF STATE ~ BUREAU Of ELECT!ONS

DEBTS AND OBLIGATIONS SCHEDULE1E

CANDIDATE COMMITTEE

1, Committe11I.0. Number _1_2_9_2_8_0 ____ ~--------

2, comm1UeeN"""' Committee to Elect Laurel Abraham ThlsSctledule llemlzoi: .

a[2]oat;u and ~atlons owedlrt,or forgiven the 001M1Ktee OR b. D Debi$ and obllatlllOns OWl!d Jg_ or forghten~ lh9 comrnltle&. (Check ehlter a or b. U&e only for lhe purpose chsckd,) ·

3. Nama and Msl\1119 Adtlreu of parson, vomfor or 4. Type ofObl9aUon 7. Dale and umoootof a, Curnulalilte 9. Oulatalldlog financial lnantullon lo v.tlom deb( Is owad. (Descdpllo~ each payment pa!,Ttl&nllo Balance al close

5. lnd!oo:te ale dabl wee da!eondebl oflhll pertod Cl'Hlck bok' tc, fntllcate y,tlelher del)I 1$ ()W(!d to an IOOU('l'lld (llllm6mllll9 /OC()lf)OMled bualne&a. If debt I& a bank loan, please 6. !odtcale orig1nal amolllll ttem8) ~~vide i'lfo~n regarding ll\e endoaere or ofdGbl

UIITIRlora, If an , Deb\#1 Corp?LJYea . Owedlontby; 4. Type:

Laurel Abraham • 1108 Lakeside Dr 5, DRfeDeb1 wu 1nmud:

East Grand Rapids, Ml 49506 04/20/18 $ I 16B.00

$~ 6, OJlglnalAmounlofD•bt • '

1B8.00 . • ,o,01ve1

lfbaM loan, name of endorser or guaranM: . OllJlt EndR-ed; $

°''"' c.,,ov .. OWed to or by: 4. Typo: I

Laurel Abraham S. Rat, Dsbl ~n! ll!Sijnid: . 1108 Lakeside Dr 4/23/18 East Grand Rapids, Ml 49506 6. 1;U1!l!M-' Amounto! Dobt: I

$~ s 100.00

1 100.00 I • FORGIVEN I

II ben!c loan, name of endoraer or nuatafltor: Amount EllCIOl'.hld: ..

"'"" Corp?[]Ve& 4. 'fypo: Owed to or by: • Laurel Abraham S. llakllslilin'.ill l!!rnrred: I

1108 Lakeside Dr 4124/1B . East Grand Rapids, Ml 49506 a. Qclillnal am!!:u!lt et 121b1: $ O.r() $ 9.90

I $ 9,90 · O,oRGIVEN .

If ba~ loan, name of endorner or guarantor: Amount Endorsed: $

Page Subtotal (Ou!Slantllngdebl) $277.90

ClrandTota1or,11s..,,,~, $318 90 (Complete on tad page of Sehedlt:e shO'hng amounte owed by or to !he comm •

A debt or obligation must bo shown on this 8ohadult lttltaNI wnan olltstandlng amount owed on llatthaeroslng date of lhts Campaign stafomentor ll waa forgiven during the period eo\lOOld by 1h11 Campaign S~tement. .

,, .. _1_,r_2_

Enl8r Ulla 10111J 011 line 12a •owec1 by""or1Jnei12b •owed to" oflhe SummatyPege

Page 22: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

~ MICHIGAN Ola'AR'TMENTOF STATS ~ BUREAU OF ElECTIONS

DEBTS AND OBLIGATIONS SCHEDULE 1E

i. Commktoo I.D. """''" _1_2~9_2_8_0 _______ ~----

CANDIDATE COMMITTEE 2 C-Omm·1teeN,me Committee to Elect Laurel Abraham ' Th!s Sdledu!e Ueml:ces:

a0>eb1& and ob!lgati1J111 cwedln!,or forgiven lhc ooomttee OR b. D Dablo Sm obllgalloni ov.ecl m orfo,glven~ the t<1mmlttee. (Check &!Iller a orb, Ust orq rot tlta purpoaa checkOO.)

3. Name arid Man!ng Address of porioo, vendor or 4. TypB of ObWgallon 7. oate en~ amount of 8. CUmutaUve 9. OUlstandlff.l lnenel;llln1t11uUon lowllomdobt Is owtd, (DeSQl>t!on) each payment payment lo Balanr.e at C!Die

5. lndlcatu date debt was da!eondebl (lfl!Qpertod Ch&ek btlX IO Indicate v.fl&lh$1' debl il owad to an lm:urred {Item G m!tioc 1nco1poratad blislness. If <lebl fa a. bitnk: loan, plt11W1 Ei. lnd!oate otiginal emovnl HeJ'n8) prowla lnfotmallon regerdlr(i Ille emfmsera or of debt ftl,ar1111tora, 11 ·-·, Dabl#1 .corp?LJYes Owed to or bv: "· Typ6' •

Laurel Abraham 1108 Lakeside Dr s. Pm DOtW,1 foel![(cf • Ea.st Grand Rapids, Ml 49506 04/24/18 $ ,0l:'lL__ $~ 6. Orlglnal Amount of Debt: • ' I 41.00 • FORGIVEN . If bank IL)f!R. nerne of endorser or goarantor:

Amount Endorud: S

""""' Corp?OYe1 OWed to or by: 4. Type: I

S, Ila11'D:!bl l3!!1 Imunl: • a. Q!lglQal A1no111112( 9!ibl: • •--- •---$

$ O,oRGIVEN

I If bank roan, n11me of endonier or gu(llantor:

.

AmouAt Eodorud: • Dab1#3 """UV" Owed lo or by: 4. Type: •

$. DAie pgbtWfl1 lncµmd: • •

6. Orio!!!•! l:\!l!OUl!tsi!D!!!l:I: $ , ___

$ O,oRGIVEN $

• If bank loan, name of encror&er Qt guarantor: Amount Endorsed: $

Pa,ge Sub Iola! (Out&lendlngdebO $41.00

Grand Total ofell Behedu!n 1E $318 90 (Complete on las! pllge of Schedule shol'Ang 111110\ll!a DW!ld byor to the 90mmllfee) •

A debtorobUgaUon rnuat ba ahownon this Sohadufelftherewaa an outtt.indlng 1mo1mt owed on II "tlhe oloslng data ot this CamJ)il!gn Statoment or It WD.c: forgiven during lho porlod covered bythla Campaign statement. .

Psge_2_of_2_

Enter lln tota1 nn 11M 12a "oWed b)I'"" orun~ 12.b Dowed lo~ oft.ha Summary Page

Page 23: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

MICHIGAN DEPARTMENT OF STA't'E BUREAU OF ELECTIONS

FUND RAISER SCHEDULE 1 F I, C-tte• l,D,Mm,bo, _1_2_9_2_8_0 ______ _ CANDIDATE COMMITTEE CTE Laurel Abraham ,.comm•""'"'

• use A SEPARATE SHEET FOR EACH EVENT • 3, Dale EventWt1e Held · .4, NumberorlndMdualsAlll:indlng s. Type cf Fund RalsfngAcUvtty

or Pertlclpatrlg (wh!Ohever /a greater)

06/28/18 35 Cocktail Reception

7. Total Contribullons $1,800.00

8. Other Receipts $0.00 9. Gross Recelpta (Add lines 7 and 8) $0.00 10. TotelCostofEvent $652.00 (total COst includes In-Kind Con1rlbullons and All Expenditures Made For the Event)

11 •. 0 Check If event was a Joint fund raleer and complete the falowlng:

Co-Sponso~s) ContrlbuUon Split (%)

u 6, Address and Name (If any) oflhe place where Iha adlvlty WH Mid,

Tavern on the Square 100 lonla Ave SW, Grand

M Rap~s, Ml 49603 I lp11vataRasid8nce

Elq)Ondilure Split (%)

• The committee Is required to file a separate Fund Reiser Schedule for each fund ral$1ng event held during the. period covered by the Campaign Statement. Receipts and expe_ndltures listed on a Fund Raiser Schedule must also be reported on the Itemized Conbibullons Schedule (1A), Itemized In-Kind Con1ributions Schedule (1•IK); Itemized Expendl!ures Schedule (16) and the Summary Paga.

• Each committee that partlcipaled In a joint fund raiser must Ille a Fund Ralaer Schedule for.th~ event.

.. ,._1_.,_1 _

Page 24: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

I pledge to ... * Protect Taxpayers •

* Safeguard essential services * Prioritize infrastructure needs

Transparency I believe government should be transparent. I will hold regular meetings in the District and ensure open communication

with constitnents.

Responsibility I will vote only for balanced

budgets, make sure Kent County is investing responsibly in

infrastructnre and roads & make community safety a priority.

Effective Government I will vote only for policies that make government more

efficient, make sure we protect our AAA bond rating which saves Kent County millions of dollars a year.

LAUREL~ ABRAHAM

FOR l<ENT COUNTY COMMISSIONER

www.laurelabraham.com I 616.881.0964

Page 25: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

LAUREL~ ABRAHAM

"Nearly threey?t, ·sago, my husband Nick a 1d I cho,·p co move back to the Grand Rapia~ .trea because it is an incredible place to live, work and raise a family. Our community values safety, education and responsible

local government.

In the last two years, there have been efforts by members of the Kent aounty Commission that threatens our CD. mm unities fiscal .. responsibility. We deserve better than that.

My experience has taught me the need for efficiency, transparency and accountability in local government. As your next County Commissioner, I will work tirelessly to represent our s~aredvalues and earn your trust."

About Laurel Laurel has worked for nonprofit organizations that focus on public policies aimed at growing

r economy, protecting private property rights and making sure our government works

for its people, not politicians.

She and her husband, Nick, live in East Grand Rapids where he was born and raised.

Paid for by CTE Laurel Abraham I PO BOX 68238, Grand Rapids, Ml 49516

Page 26: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures
Page 27: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

® KENT GOP

6it JO<-"' T»l >'MTY

Kent County GOP @kentgop · Jun 28 v

Great turnout tonight at the young professional reception with [] 111• . \.braham

for Kent County Commission!

Q1 t_l, 1 Q 4 El

Page 28: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

I pledge to ... * Protect Taxpayers • * Safeguard essential services * Prioritize infrastructure needs

Transparency I believe government should be transparent. I will hold regular meetings in the District and ensure open communication

with constituents.

Responsibility I will vote only for balanced

budgets, make sure Kent County is investing responsibly in

infrastructure and roads & make community safety a priority.

Effective Government I will vote only for policies that make government more

efficient, make sure we protect our MA bond rating which saves Kent County millions of dollars a year.

LAUREL~ ABRAHAM

FOR KENT COUNTY COMMISSIONER

www.laurelabraham.com I 616.881.0964

Page 29: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

LAUREL~ ABRAHAM

"Nearly threeye1, 'Sago, my husband Nick a ,d I choc-e co move back to the Grand Rapick .trea because it is an incredible place to live1 work and raise a family. Our community values safety, education and responsible

local government.

In the last two years, there have been efforts by members of the Kent -.aunty Commission that threatens our communities 'fi_scal W responsibility. We deserve better than that.

My experience has taught me the need for efficiency, transparency and accountability in local government. As your next County Commissioner, I will work tirelessly to represent our shared values and earn your'trust.'1

About Laurel Laurel has worked for nonprofit organizations that focus on public policies aimed at growing

r economy, protecting private property rights and making sure our government works

for its people, not politicians.

She and her husband, Nick, live in East Grand Rapids where he was born and raised.

Paid for by CTE Laurel Abraham I PO BOX 68238, Grand Rapids, Ml 49516

Page 30: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

August 28, 2018

Michigan Department of State · Bureau of Elections 430 WAllegan Lansing, Ml 48918

Dear Mr. Fracassi:

.. i ,J D'1 I' l ' i ii • ~J

I am writing in response to the Campaign Finance Complaint filed by Frank Lynn with complaint number 2018-08-61-33.

Regarding the postcard, car sign, banner, and tee shirts: the invoices for these were not sent by my vendor until after the close of books had passed on 7-17-18. I paid these invoices in a timely manner, but, having paid them after the close of books, I planned to file it on the next report, the Post-Primary Report.

I have paid for these items and have attached documentation that shows this. Unless instructed otherwise, I will report these on my report due September 6. Sorry for any inconvenience this may have caused.

• Postcard and car sign: $1,935.54 - invoice #1081 dated 8/5/2018 • Banner: $100.70- invoice #22719 dated 7/30/2018 • Tee-shirt: $201.67 - invoice #112524 dated 7/18/2018

If you need to reach me, feel free to do so at 616-881-0964.

Sincerely, /'

~aurel Abraham

Page 31: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

,, Right Strategies, LLC

BILL TO

CTE Laurel Abraham

-- ----- - ----- ---

ACTIVITY -------

Graphic Design Logo Design

Printini 5/12 - aim card printing Printing 6/5 - Postcard Printing Printing 6/5 - 5-1/2 Baronial Envelope Printing Printing 6/9 - Palm card printing Printing 6/22 - Follow up postcard printing Printing 6/22 - Palm card printing

Printin~ 7 /3 - P acard printing Printing 7/3 - Palm card printing Graphic Design Yard sign and banner design Graphic Design Vector conversion Printing 7/27 6 x 11 Handout cards Printing Laurel Pre-Primary Mailer Printing Mail Processing Laurel Pre-Primary Mailer Mail Processing Postage LaurelPre-Primary lv1c1.iler Postage

- - -----------------

QTY

1

500

DATE

08/05/2018

-- ------ --- -- ---------------

/4->

2(~

t <,)

~ ,000

2,000

1,000

2

500

1

0.50

1,000

1,233

1,233

1

Invoice 1081

RATE - - --- - -------

150.00

0.18

0.20

0.22

0.145

0.09

0.145

1.00

0.18

35.00

35.00

0.22

0.21

0.1484

273.89

DUE DATE

08/05/2018

AMOUNT

150.00

90.00T

40.00T

33.00T

145.00T

180.00T

145.00T

2.00T

90.00T

35.00

17.50

220.00T

258.93T

182.98

273.89 ---------- - . - - -------- --

Please make checks out to Right Strategies, LLC and mail to 2153 Wealthy St. SE, Suite 166, East Grand Rapids, Ml 49506

Page 32: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

SUBTOTAL 1,863.30 TAX (6%) 72.24 TOTAL 1,935.54 PAYMENT 1,935.54

···- .

TOTAL DUE $0.00

THANK YOU.

Please make checks out to Right Strategies, LLC and mail to 2153 Wealthy St. SE, Suite 166, East Grand Rapids, Ml 49506

Page 33: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

The JANT Group, Inc

dba Retail Sign Systems, Inc dba Grand Rapids Looseleaf, Inc 8111 Belmont Ave. NE Belmont, Ml 49306 616-863-9422

Bill To:

Kent County GOP

P.O. Number Terms

Luke Arends

Quantity Item

Rep

1 Misc - RSS Custom 3' x 6' banner:

Michigan Sales Tax

. Ship Date

07/30/18

Description

"Laurel Abraham"

Invoice

Date Invoice No.

07/30/18 22719

Ship To

Due Date Ship Via 07/30/18 Customer Pickup

Price Each Amount

95.00 95.00T 6.00% 5.70

1 Total $100.70

Page 34: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

Promotional Adv. Group, Inc.

P. 0. Box 574 6318 Fulton St. E Ada, MI 49301 Phone: 616-676-2242 Fax: 616-676-0611

BILL TO

Abraham for commission

P.O. NO. TERMS

Luke

DESCRIPTION

White t-shirts with 2-color imprint Set-Up Charge for I-shirts Shipping and Handling Sales Tax

THANK YOU FOR YOUR ORDER. WE ARE NOW ABLE TO ACCEPT VISA, M/C, AE

DATE

7/18/2018

SHIP DATE SHIP VIA

6/1/2018 UPS

QTY

25 1

Balance Due

I INVOICE NO, I 112524

REPRESENTATIVE

RATE AMOUNT

5.92 148.00T 25.00 25.00 19.79 19.79

6.00% 8.88

$201.67

Page 35: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

STATE OF MICHIGAN

RUTH JOHNSON, SECRETARY OF STATE

DEPARTMENT OF STATE LANSING

Laurel Abraham 1108 Lakeside D1ive SE Grand Rapids, Michigan 49506

Re: Lynn v. Abraham Campaign Finance Complaint No. 2018-08-61-33

Dear Ms. Abraham:

August 14, 2018

The Department of State (Department) received a formal complaint filed by Frank Lynn against you alleging that you violated the Michigan Campaign Finance Act (MCFA or Act), 1976 PA 388, MCL 169.201 et seq. The investigation and resolution of this complaint is governed by section 15 of the Act and the co1Tesponding administrative rules, R 169.51 et seq. A copy of the complaint and supporting documentation is enclosed with this letter.

The MCFA requires candidates and committees file contributions and expenditures with the appropriate filing official by specific dates. MCL 169.233(1)-(3). The MCFA requires a committee that receives or expends more than $1,000 during any election to file campaign finance reports in compliance with the Act. MCL 169.233(6). A person who knowingly omits or unde1Teports expenditures required to be disclosed by the Act is subject to a civil fine of not more than $1,000 or the amount of the expenditures omitted or underreported, whichever is greater. MCL 169.233(11).

Mr. Lynn alleges that your committee has used campaign literature that contains the paid for by statement "Paid for by Committee to Elect Laurel Abraham" but the committee has failed to disclose any such expenditures in the pre-p1imary finance repoti.

The purpose of this letter is to inform you of the Department's examination of these matters and your right to respond to the allegations before the Department proceeds fmiher. It is important to understand that the Depmiment is neither making this complaint nor accepting the allegations as true.

If you wish to file a written response to this complaint, you are required to do so within 15 business days of the date of this letter. Your response may include any written statement or additional documentary evidence you wish to submit. All materials must be sent to the Department of State, Bureau of Elections, Richard H. Austin Building, 1st Floor, 430 West Allegan Street, Lansing, Michigan 48918. If you fail to submit a response, the Department will render a decision based on the evidence furnished by the complainant.

BUREAU OF ELECTIONS RICHARD H. AUSTIN BUILDING • 1ST FLOOR • 430 W. ALLEGAN • LANSING, MICHIGAN 48918

www.Michigan.gov/sos • (517) 373-2540

Page 36: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

Laurel Abraham August 14, 2018 Page 2

A copy of your answer will be provided to Mr. Lynn, who will have an opportunity to submit a rebuttal statement to the Department. After reviewing all of the statements and materials provided by the paiiies, the Department will determine whether "there may be reason to believe that a violation of[the MCFA] has occurred[.]" MCL 169.215(10). Note that the Depaiiment's enforcement powers include the possibility of entering a conciliation agreement, conducting an administrative hearing, or refening this matter to the Attorney General for enforcement of the penalty provided in section 33(1 I) of the Act.

If you have any questions concerning this matter, you may contact me at (517) 373-2540.

c: Frank Lynn

Sincerely,

Adam Fracassi Bureau of Elections Michigan Department of State

Page 37: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

STATE OF MICIIlGAN

RUTH JOHNSON, SECRETARY OF STATE

DEPARTMENT OF STATE LANSING

Frank Lynn 3446 Devon Drive NE Grand Rapids, Michigan 49546

Re: Lynn v. Abraham Campaign Finance Complaint No. 2018-08-61-33

Dear Mr. Lynn:

September 5, 2018

The Depaiiment of State received a response to the complaint you filed against Laurel Abraham, which concerns an alleged violation of the Michigan Campaign Finance Act (MCFA), 1976 P.A. 388, MCL 169.201 et seq. A copy of the response is provided as an enclosure with this letter.

If you elect to file a rebuttal statement, you are required to send it within IO business days of the date of this letter to the Bureau of Elections, Richard H. Austin Building, 1st Floor, 430 West Allegan Street, Lansing, Michigan 48918.

c: Laurel Abraham

Sincerely,

Adam Fracassi Bureau of Elections Michigan Department of State

BUREAU OF ELECTIONS RICHARD H. AUSTIN BUILDING • 1ST FLOOR • 430 W. ALLEGAN • LANSING, MICHIGAN 48918

www.Michigan.gov/sos • (517) 373-2540

Page 38: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

August 28, 2018

Michigan Department of State Bureau of Elections 430 WAllegan Lansing, Ml 48918

Dear Mr. Fracassi:

.. ,J • - 20 Prl I: li5

I am writing in response to the Campaign Finance Complaint filed by Frank Lynn with complaint number 2018-08-61-33.

Regarding the postcard, car sign, banner, and tee shirts: the invoices for these were not sent by my vendor until after the close of books had passed on 7-17-18. I paid these invoices in a timely manner, but, having paid them after the close of books, I planned to file it on the next report, the Post-Primary Report.

I have paid for these items and have attached documentation that shows this. Unless instructed otherwise, I will report these on my report due September 6. Sorry for any inconvenience this may have caused.

• Postcard and car sign: $1,935.54 - invoice #1081 dated 8/5/2018 • Banner: $100.70- invoice #22719 dated 7/30/2018 • Tee-shirt: $201.67 - invoice #112524 dated 7/18/2018

If you need to reach me, feel free to do so at 616-881-0964.

Sincerely, ')II I

\ _// ;,/:_···· /! ' I / / .M /~P(~ 7() f ;,Lc't/f f-7\.

~<Jurel Abraham

Page 39: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

Right Strategies, LLC

BILL TO

GTE Laurel Abraham

------------------------ -

ACTIVITY ------ _,, ____ ., ___ - -- --------- - --

Graphic Design Logo Design Printing 5/12 - Palm card printing Printing 6/5 - Postcard Printing Printing 6/5 - 5-1 /2 Baronial Envelope Printing Printing 6/9 - Palm card printing

Printin~ 6/22 - ollow up postcard printing Printing 6/22 - Palm card printing Printing 7/3 - Placard printing Printing 7/3 - Palm card printing Graphic Design Yard sign and banner design Graphic Design Vector conversion Printing 7/27 6 x 11 Handout cards Printing Laurel Pre-Primary Mailer Printing

QTY -- -- -------

1

500

DATE 08/05/2018

- -------------

~)

~~t 2,000

1,000

2

500

1

0.50

1,000

1,233

1,233 Mail Processing Laurel Pre-Primary Mailer Mail Processing Postage 1 Laurel Pre-Prin,aryMaileir Postage

-- ------------

Invoice 1 081

RATE

150.00

0.18

0.20

0.22

0.145

0.09

0.145

1.00

0.18

35.00

35.00

0.22

0.21

0.1484

273.89 - - ----------

DUE DATE 08/05/2018

--- - - ---- -- --- -

AMOUNT

150.00

90.00T

40.00T

33.00T

145.00T

180.00T

145.00T

2.00T

90.00T

35.00

17.50

220.00T

258.93T

182.98

273.89 -- - -----------

Please make checks out to Right Strategies, LLC and mail to 2153 Wealthy St. SE, Suite 166, East Grand Rapids, Ml 49506

Page 40: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

' ' SUBTOTAL 1,863.30 ,, TAX (6%) 72.24 ~#,

TOTAL 1,935.54 PAYMENT 1,935.54

TOTAL DUE $0.00

THANK YOU.

Please make checks out to Right Strategies, LLC and mail to 2153 Wealthy St. SE, Suite 166, East Grand Rapids, Ml 49506

Page 41: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

The JANT Group, Inc

dba Retail Sign Systems, Inc dba Grand Rapids Looseleaf, Inc 8111 Belmont Ave. NE Belmont, Ml 49306 616-863-9422

Bill To:

Kent County GOP

P.O. Number Terms

Luke Arends

Quantity Item

Rep

1 Misc- RSS Custom 3' x 6' banner:

Michigan Sales Tax

Ship Date

07/30/18

Description

"Laurel Abraham"

Invoice

Date Invoice No.

07/30/18 22719

Ship To

Due Date Ship Via 07/30/18 Customer Pickup

Price Each Amount

95.00 95.00T 6.00% 5.70

I Total $100.70

Page 42: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

Promotional Adv. Group, Inc.

P. 0. Box 574 6318 Fulton St. E Ada, MI 49301 Phone: 616-676-2242 Fax: 616-676-0611

BILL TO

Abraham for commission

P.O.NO. TERMS

Luke

DESCRIPTION

White t-shirts with 2-color imprint Set-Up Charge fort-shirts Shipping and Handling Sales Tax

THANK YOU FOR YOUR ORDER. WE ARE NOW ABLE TO ACCEPT VISA, MIC, AE

DATE I INVOICE NO. I 7/18/2018 1 112524

SHIP DATE SHIP VIA REPRESENTATIVE

6/1/2018 UPS

QTY RATE AMOUNT

25 5.92 148.00T I 25.00 25.00

19.79 19.79 6.00% 8.88

Balance Due $201.67

Page 43: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

~il ~

MICHIGAN DEPARTMENT OF STATE BUREAU OF ELECTIONS

CANDIDATE COMMITTEE COVER PAGE

Report must be l~lble, ttped or pgnted In rk and s!~ned by the treasurer (or eslgna ed recor keeper and can date,

1. Committee I.D. Number

I 'l. q7. 'ilO

2. Commil!ee Name

Committee to Elect Laurel Abraham 5. Committee's Malllng Address 1108 Lakeside Dr SE Grand Rapids, Ml 49506

Area Code and Pho111:1 ( ~\~ ~\ - O'\" '1 If the address In th!s box Is different from the commillee malling address on the Statement of 0rfianlzal!on, mail may be sen_! to this address by the filfng offlc al.

7. Treasurer's Business Address

1\\6 ~ ix S'i:, G,..-o1 'I¼·""· ~\ Ll%t.JG,

Area Code and Phone

9. TYPE OF STATEMENT

Kent County ClerK Elections Division

SEP O 6 1018

FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY

3. This Statement cov_ers From: 0]/.23/18 fo 08/27/18

4. Cand!da\e Last Name First Name M.1.

Abraham Laurel J 4a. Office Sought Including Dls!rictl# or Community SeNed (If appl!cabla)

Board Member~ Local

4b. County of Residence KENT El 6. Treasurer's Name & R8sldentlaIAddress

-So~Y'\ f,J,,",1'"''"" . -m,; i.,~., 'l:>o 'i>t, c,..,,.. ~,J,., ~, 4•~%

Area Code & Phone Lie\~ 1 45 - 1£oc 8, Designated Record Keeper's Name and Address (If the ·committee hes a Deslgnaled Record Keeper)

Area Code and Phone 90, Dlssolutlon of Candidate Committee

G

9a, OPre-ElecUon OR 9b.[8]Post-E!ac!lon Required ONLY if candidate Is not on Iha ballotror the gay checking !his Item I/We cerUfy any outstanding debt current year: by a committee to Iha candidate or his or her spouse is here

Pre-Elecl!on or Post-Election Statement relates to: by discharged and forgiven, and no longer collecllble from • July Quarterly lhe committee. The comm!ltee has no oustandlng assets,

2S]Primary owes no lates fees or has any oustandlng debt.

:]Genera! Ooctobar Quarterly

Further, if the dlssolullon cannot be granted, !hat this be

Oconvenl!on considered a request for the Reporting Waiver.

OspecJal Sc, OAnnua! Statement ( ___ I Oschool Coverage Year Effective date of dlssotullon

Ocaucus 9d, D Amendment to Campaign s18.tement (Comp!ate Item 9a, 9b, 9c or 9e to Jndlcate which Statement ls-being Note: The disposition of residual funds must be reported on

amended.) Schedule 1B and the Summary Page,

Dale of Election, Convention or Caucus

g/, \I~

10. Verification: I\We certify that an reasonable dll!gence was used in the preparal!on of !his statement and allached schedules (If any) and to_lhe best of my\our knowledge and belief the contents ara true, accurate and complete.

1 /;;- /;r Current Treasurer or Jl){J. A-b hC(Jf!/ ~Mj(26r~~t, Designated Record keepef-.... __ _LJ t1. __ ('0,

Type or Print Nema tgnature 'J Candldata Laurel Abraham t~!J.3 I 'Li,1,/~ ~ Date

Type or Print Name ~ature

Aulhonty granted under P.A. 388 of 1976

Page 44: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

./ii/},( MICHIGAN DEPARTMENT OF STATE /.li,-ii\ ~t.;,¥ BUREAU OF ELECTIONS

SUMMARY PAGE CANDIDATE COMMITT

RECEIPTS

3. Contributions

a, Itemized (Schedule 1A- Column 6)

EE

b. Unitemized (less than $20.01 each - no Schedule)

c. Subtotal of "Contributions"

4. Other Receipts (Schedule 1A-1, Column 6)

5, TOTAL CONTRIBUTIONS AND OTHER RECEIPTS (Add Line 3c + Line 4)

IN•KIND CONTRIBUTIONS & EXPENDITURES

6. In-Kind Contributions (Schedule 1-IK, Column 7)

7. In-Kind Expenditures (Schedule 1B-IK, Column 6)

EXPENDITURES

8. Expenditures

a. Itemized (Schedule 1B, Column 6)

b. llemlzed Get-Out-the-Vote (Schedule 18-G)

c. Uni!emized (less than $50.01 each• no Schedule)

9, TOTAL EXPENDITURES (Add Line 8a + Line 8b + Une 8c)

INCIDENTAL EXPENSE DISBURSEMENTS (Officeholders Only)

10, Dlsbursemen!s a. Itemized (Schedule 1C, Column 6)

b, Unitemized {less than $50.01 each • no Schedule)

11, TOTAL INCIDENTAL EXPENSE DISBURSEMENTS (Add Line 10a + Una 10b)

DEBTS AND OBLIGATIONS 12. Debts and Obllgal!ons

a. Owed by the Committee (Schedule 1E)

b, Owed lo the Commlllee (Schedule 1 E)

13. Ending Balance of last report filed (Enter zero if no previous reports have been filed,)

14, Amoun! received du1lng reporting period (Una 5, Total Contributions & other Receipts)

15, SUBTOTAL Add lines 13 and 14 16, Amoont expended during reporting period

(Add lines 9 and 11) 17, ENDING BALANCE

(Subtract line 16 from line 15)

1, Comm!ltee I.D. Number _1_2_9_2_8_0 ___________ _

2 c,mmm" Nam, Committee to Elect Laurel Abraham

Column I Column II This Period Cumulative th!s elec\lon cyc!e

(3a.) I 3,660.00

(3b.) $ NOT APPLICABLE

(3c.) $ (18.)$

(4.) $ $0.00 (19.) 1 $0.00

(5.) $ $3,660.00 (20.)$ $10,734.90

(6.) $ $0.00 (21.)$ $418.90

(7.) $ $0.00 (22.) s $0.00

(Ba,) $ $4,667.67

(8b.) $ $0.00

(8c,) $ $0.00

(9.) $ $4,667.67 (23.) s $5,641.47

(10a.) $ $0.00

(10b.) $ $0.00

(11.) $ $0.00 (24.) $ $0.00

(12a.) $ $318.90

(12b.)$ $0.00 BALANCE STATEMENT

(13.) $ $6,101.10

(14.), 1 $3,660.00 (15.)• $ $9,761.10

(16.)- 1 $4,667.67

(17.) I $5,093.43 .

Page 45: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

'iJtr MICHIGAN DEPARTMENT OF STATE tji BUREAU OF ELECTIONS

ITEMIZED CONTRIBUTIONS SCHEDULE 1A 1. Committee 1.0. Number __:1.:2.:9.:2.:8.:0:..._ _______ _

CANDIDATE COMMITTEE 2. Commillee Name Committee to Elect Laurel Abraham

Enler contributor's name and address. If con1ribullon Is from an Individual, enter last name, first name, middle inlllal. -Check box lo lndicala if contribution is from a Political Comml\lee or an Independent Committee (PAC) Report~ contributions regardless of amount.

.

3. Contribution# 1 PAC Receipt? O YES 4. Date of Receipt 08/05/18 Name & Address: Alan Abraham 7841 Whiteburn Dr SE Ada, Ml 49301-9398

6. If over $100.00 cumulative, please provide:

Occupation Owner Employer SAS Bosi,essAddress 4001 3 Mile Rd NW, Grand Rapids, Ml 49534 Type of Con!ributlon: [.,i'j Direct I I Loan from a person I I Fund Raiser

3, Contribution #2 PAC Receipt? DYES 4. Date of Receipt 08/05/18 Name & Address

Tracy Knapp 1206 Monroe St Mendota, IL 61342

5. If over $100,00 cumutatlve, please provide:

Occupation Farmer Employer Knapp Farms

""''""Addces, 170 E rt 52, Mendota, IL 61342 Type of Conlributlon: ~Direct D Loan from a person • Fund Raiser

3, Con!ribution # 3 PAC Receipt? Dves 4. Dale of Receipt 08/16/18 Name & Address:

Chris Beckering 7915 Loral Pines Dr SE Ada, Ml 49301

5. If over $100.00 cumulative, please provide:

Occupation Builder Employer Pioneer Construction Business Address 550 Kirtland St SW, Grand Rapids, Ml 49507 Type of Contribulion; 0 Direct r l Loan from a parson • Fund Raiser

3, Contribution# 4 PAC Receipt? 0YES 4. 0,1, of Raoelpt 08/23/18 Name & Address

Kent County Republican Committee 725 Lake Michigan Dr NW Grand Rapids, Ml 49504-5. If over $100.00 cumulatlve, please provide:

Occupation Employer

Business Address

Type of Contribution: 0 Dlrec! D Loan from a person n Fund Raiser

Page Subtotal

Grand Total of AH Schedul~s 1A (Complete on last page of Schadule)

e,,,_1_,,l___

6.Amount 7. Cumulativafor Elecllon Cycle for Each Contributor (Through date of race! ,11

11000.00 , 1000.00

Click Here for Memo Itemization El

1500.00 1 500.00

CIiek Here for Memo Itemization E)

, 100.00 , 100.00 Click Here for Memo Itemization[:)

$2000.00 I 5000.00

Click Here for Memo Itemization Ef

$3,600.00

$3,660.00 Enter this total on Hne 3a of Summary Page.

Page 46: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

MICHIGAN DEPARTMENT OF STATE BUREAU OF ELECTIONS

ITEMIZED CONTRIBUTIONS SCHEDULE1A

CANDIDATE COMMITTEE

1. Committee I.ti. Number _1_2 __ 9_2_:B __ Oc_ _______ _

2. Committee Name Committee to Elect Laurel Abraham

Enter contributor's name and address. II con!ribul!on is from an Individual, enter last name, first name, middle lniUal. Check box lo Indicate If contribullon Is from a Political Commillee or an Independent Committee (PAC) Report rut contributions regardless of amount.

.

3. Conlrlbutlon # 1 PAC Receipt? LJ YES 4. Date of Receipt 08/24/18 Name & Address: Carter Masek 2752 Maplewood Dr SE East Grand Rapids, Ml 49506

5. If over $100.00 cumulative, please provide:

Occupation Employer

Business Address

Type of Contrlbutlon: IVIDlrect I I loan from a person I I Fund Raiser

3. Contribution #2 PAC Recelp!? • YES 4. o,te of Rec,lpt 08/26/18 Name & Address

Kurt Troutman 3981 Staple Road Muskegon, Ml 49455-8503

5. If over $100.00 cumula!lve, please provide;

occupaUon Professor Employer Muskegon Community College

""''""'"'''"' 221 Quarterline Rd, Muskegon, Ml 49442 Type of Conlrlbu!lon: ~Direct D Loan from a person • Fund Raiser

3. Con!ribuUon # 3 PAC Receipt? Oves 4. Date of Receipt Nam8 & Address:

5. If over $100.00 cumulallve, please provide;

Occupation Employer

Business Address Type of Con!ribuUon: r I Direct I I loan from a person • Fund Raiser

3. Contribution# 4 PAC Receipt? DYES 4, Date of Receipt Name & Address

5. If over $100.00 cumulallve, phtase provide;

Occupation Employer

Business Address

Type of Contribution; D Dlrecl 0 Loan from a person • Fund Raiser

Page Subtotal

Grand Total of AH Schedules 1A Com !ete on last a e of Schedule pg

6. Amount 7. Cumulat!ve for Election Cycle for Each Contributor (Through date of recel ,ti

, 10.00 , 10.00

CIiek Here for Memo Itemization EJ

,50.00 1 50.00

Click Here for Memo llemizatlon EJ

$ $

Click Here for Memo Itemization[:]

' $

Click Here for Memo Itemization EJ

$60.00

$3,660.00 Enter lhla total on l!ne 3a of Summary Page.

Page 47: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

I MICHIGAN DEPARTMENT OF STATE BUREAU OF ELECTIONS -

ITEMIZED EXPENDITURES SCHEDULE1B

CANDIDATE COMMITTEE 3, Name and address of person or vendor to whom paid

Expenditure #1

Nam, Cricket Wireless Address 3195 28th St SE UnitSL022 Grand Rapids, Ml 49512

0Fund Raiser

Expenditure #2

Nam, The JANT Group

Address

8111 Belmont Ave NE Belmont, Ml 49306

D Fund Raiser

Expend!_ture #3

Nam, Right Strategies, LLC Address 2153 Wealthy St SE Suite 166 East Grand Rapids, Ml 49506

D Fund Raiser

Expenditure #4

Nam, Right Strategies, LLC

Address

2153 Wealthy St SE Suite 166 East Grand Rapids, Ml 49506

D Fund Raiser

Expenditure #5

Nam, Promotional Adv. Group, Inc. Address

6318 Fulton St E Ada, Ml 49301

D Fund Raiser

1 2 Page __ of __

1. Commllleo I, D. N,mba, _1_2_9_2_8_0_'------'------­2 C lit N omm ee ema Commitle to Elect Laurel Abraham

4, Purpose (Required !nfonnation} I 5,Dale 6, Amount

08/09/18 1 35.00 ---

e,~os, Cell phone Date ---

Click Hare for Memo Itemization Type

Ocheck box if1his expendilure Is payment of debt or obligation reported on previous statement

08/16/18 1100.70 ---Purpose: Parade banner Date ---

CIiek Here for Memo Itemization Type

Qcheck box If this expendl1ure !s payment ol tor obligation reported on previous

statement

08/16/18 11935,54 ---Purpose: Printing Dale ---

Cilek Here for Memo Itemization Type

Dcheck box if !his expenditure Is payment of debt or obliga1ion reported on previous statement

08/27/18 s 1775.19

P"''"' Football mailer Date ---

CIiek Here for Memo llemlzalion Type

Q Check box If this expenditure Is payment of tor obligaHon reported on previous

slatement

08/10/18 1201.67

Purpose: T-shirts Date ---

Click Here for Memo Itemization Type

Q Check box If thls expenditure !s payment of I or obligation reported on p_revJous

statement

Subtotal lhls page

Grand Total of all Schedules 1B (Complele on last page of Schedule)

$4,048.10

$4,667.67 Enter this total on llne8a of Summary Page

Page 48: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

MICHIGAN DEPARTMENT OF STATE BUREAU OF ELECTIONS

ITEMIZED EXPENDITURES SCHEDULE 1B

CANDIDATE COMMITTEE 3. Name and address of person or vendor to whom paid

Expenditure #1

Name Handicap Sign Inc Address 1142 Walthy St SE Grand Rapids, Ml 49506

OFund Raiser

Expenditure #2

Name

Address

0 Fund Raiser

Expandllure #3

Name

Address

D Fund Raiser

Expenditure #4

Name

Address

D Fund Raiser

Expenditure #5

Name

Address

D Fund Raiser

2 2 Page __ of __

1.Committeel.0.Nombe, 129280 ----------2. Committee Name Committee to Elect Laurel Abraham

4. Purpose (Required Information) I 5. Date 6. Amount

07/25/18 1 619.57 ---

Purpose: Yard signs Date ---

Cilek Here for Memo ltemlzallon Type

Q Check box If this expandl\ure Is payment of tor obligation reported on previous

s!atement

--- $ Date ---

Purpose:

CIiek Here for Memo llem!zalion Type

~Check box !f this expenditure Is payment of I or obllgation reported on previous

slatemenl

--- $ Date ---

Purpose:

Cilek Hare for Memo llemlza!lon Type

Ocheck box if lh!s expendllure Is payment of debt or obligation reported on previous statement

Date $ ---

Purpose:

Click Here for Memo Itemization Type

Q Check box if this expenditure !s payment of tor obligation reported on previous

statement

Dale $

Purpose: ---

Click He,e for Memo Itemization Type

Q Check box ir !his expenditure Is payment of I or obligation reported on previous

statement

Subtota! this page

Grand Total or all Schedules 1B (Complete on last paga of Schedule)

$619.57

$4,667.67 Enter this to!al on line 8aof Summary Page

Page 49: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

f~lt MICHIGAN DEPARTMENT OF STATE ~~ BUREAU OF ELECTIONS

DEBTS AND OBLIGATIONS SCHEDULE 1E

CANDIDATE COMMITTEE

1, Committee I.D. Number _1_2_9_2_8_0 _____________ _

2. commm" N,m, Committee to Elect Laurel Abraham This Schedule llemizes:

a0•eb!s and obUgatlons owed ~or forgiven the committee OR b. 0 Debts and obliga!lons owed !Q or forg!ven~ the commlllee. (Check ei!her a orb, Use only for the purpose checked,)

3, Name and Mailing Address of person, vendor or . 4. Type of Obligation 7, Date and amount of 8. Cumulative financial institution to whom debt is owed. (Description) each payment payment to

5, Indicate date debt was date on debt Check box to indicate whether debt Is owed to an Incurred Incorporated business. If debt ls a bank loan, please 6. Indicate original amount provide information regarding the endorsers or of debt

. ouarantors. If anv.

Debl#1 Corp?OYes Owed to or by: 4. Type: •

Laurel Abraham 1108 Lakeside Dr 5. Date Debt Was Jncurrcd: ' East Grand Rapids, Ml 49506 04/20/18 $ .~ 6. Orlglnal Amount of Debt:

$ $ 168.00

• If bank loan, name of endorser or guarantor:

Amount Endorsed:$ Debl#2 Corp?OYes Owed to or by: 4. Type: I

Laurel Abraham 5. Date U~ht Was Incurred:

' 1108 Lakeside Dr 4/23/18 East Grand Rapids, Ml 49506

6. Original Amount of Dt!!I: $ I 0.00

I 100.00 $

$

If bank loan, name of endorser or guarantor: Amount Endorsed: *

0ebt#3 Corp?QYes 4. Type: Owed to or by: $

Laurel Abraham 5. Dnfe Debi )Ya! Incurred: $ 1108 Lakeside Dr 4/24/18 East Grand Rapids, Ml 49506 •

6. Original AmoImt of Debt: $ 0.00

I 9.90 $

' If bank loan, name of endorser or guarantor; Amount Endorsed: $

Page Sub!o!al (Outstanding debt)

Grand Total of all Schedules 1E (Complete on last page of Schedule showing amounts owed by or to !he commiltee)

A debt or obllgallon must be shown on this Schedule lf there w~s an outstanding amount owed on II at Iha clostng date of this Campaign Statement or It was forgiven during the period covered by this Campaign Statement.

Page_1 __ or_2 __

9. Ou!standlng Balance at close of this period (llem6 minus llem8)

I 168.00

• FORGIVEN

I 100.00

• FORGIVEN

I 9.90

O,oRGIVEN

$277.90

$318.90 Enter lhls total on line 12a "owed by"' or line 12b "owed to' of the Summary Page

Page 50: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

MICHIGAN DEPARTMENT OF STATE BUREAU OF ELECTIONS

DEBTS AND OBLIGATIONS SCHEDULE1E

CANDIDATE COMMITTEE

1. Committee 1.0. Number ....:.12=-::.9.::2.::8.::0....:_ ____________ _

,. committee Nam, Committee to Elect Laurel Abraham This Schedule Itemizes:

a0Debls and obligations owedlr£.or forgiven the committee OR b. D Deb!s and obllgalions owed 12 or forgiven fil'. the committee. (Check either a orb. Use only for the purpose checked.)

3. Name and Mall!ng Address of person, vendor or 4. Type of Obligation 7. Date and amount of 8. Cumulative financial !nslilullon lo whom debt Is owed, (Description) each payment payment to

6. Indicate date debt was date on debt Check box to Indicate whe!her debt Js owed lo an incurred inccrporated business. 1f debt Is a bank loan, please 6. Indicate orlg!nal amount provide information regarding lhe endol'$ers or ;,uarantors, if anv,

of debt

Debl#1 Corp?0Yes Owed to or by: 4. Type: .

Laurel Abraham • 1108 Lakeside Dr S. Date Debt Was Incurred:

East Grand Rapids, Ml 49506 04/24/18 $ I 0.00

6. Original Amount of Debt: $

$ 41.00 . If bank loan, name of endorser or guarantor: Amount Endorsed:$

Debl#2 Corp?OYes Owed to or by: 4. Type: $

S. Dnte Debt n•as lncurre~: • 6, Or!gina1 Amount of Dabl:

$ $

$ I

$

If bank loan, name of endorser or guarantor: Amount Endorsed: "

Debi #3 Corp?0Yes Owed to or by: 4. Type: $

S, Date Debt Wes Incurred: $ . 6. Orlglnal Amount of De~j:

$ s

I •

If bank loan, name of endorser or guarantor: Amount Endorsed: $

Page Sub!olai' {Outstanding debt)

Grand Total of all Schedules 1E {Complete on last page of Schedule showing amounts owed by or lo the committee)

A debt or obllgatron must ba shown on this Schedule If there was an oulstandtng amount owed on It at !he c:toslng dale of this Campaign Statement or It was forgiven during the period covered by this Campaign Statement.

Page_2 __ of_2 __

9. Oulstanding Balance at close of this period (Item 6 minus Item SJ

s 41.00

• FORGIVEN

$

• FORGIVEN

$

• FORGIVEN

$41.00

$318.90 Enter this to!al on Hne 12a "owed by"" or line 12b "owed to' of the Summary Page

Page 51: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

'tiftt ~

MICHIGAN DEPARTMENT OF STATE BUREAU OF ELECTIONS www.Michigan.gov/sos LATE CONTRIBUTION REPORT

I. Your Committee ID#.: __ _,_\ Z.=--'l,_,'l=li'...:O,c__ ______ _

2. Your Committee Name:Committee to 'Elect Laurel Abraham

3. Date Late Contribution(s) Received:_0_8_12_8_11_8 _______ --'(Only one Date per Sheet)

• Late ContribUtion Reports are required wheii a' 0 Candidate coll11l1ittee receives a single contribution or-a cumu_lative contributi_on from the Slime contributor of .

$500.00 or mOre after the closing_ date_ of the last campaign ~ia_iement required an? _the_ 3rd daj before_ a_n election where the cliildidate is particip"ating. -S_ee Appendix·G of the" Campai$n Finnnce.Manual.

0 A com!Uitlee other than a candidate Committee (PAC, Ballot Question' pr J;>olitical Party) receives· a single contribution or a cumulative contribution fyom d1e same cQntdbtitoro:f$2,500,00 or more !l,fter.the cl9sing_date of the last carilpaigil statement requ'ired and the 3rd day before an election. see Appendix G of thO Camp.aign ·Finance Manual

• Contributions are anything of in<inetary V!J.lue including ci;mtributions of~oney, in-kind ~nd loans to the ~omrilittee . • Late. ContribUtion Reports are m:it waiy~d by the Reporting Waivef . • Late Contribution Reports that .are filed la'.te r~_ult in the committee receiving a late filing fee, _The maximum f~e is.$2,000.00

per report,

• Paper filers may file the report by any written ineans (including fax) within 48 hilur of receipt Of the contribution with your Filing Officiill.

• , Electronic Filers on the state level must file all_ _Late Contribution Report electronically . • The Late Contributiori must also be re'norted on the next Camnai 0 n Stiltement o\Ved bV the committee . .

5, Cumulative 4. Enter contributor's name and address. If contribution is from an individual, enter last name, first name, middle. Amount during initial and if the contributor is an individual, the Occupation, Employer and Business address of the contributor. LCR Period. £on!P.1fitor.~ame and Address: an, em . 7955 Byron Station Court SW

$500.00 Byron Center, Ml 49315

Of Individual, also provide:) Employer/ Business Address Greenstone Occupation Owner

3225 Walker Ave NW, Grand Rapids, Ml 49544

Contributor Name and Address:

(lflndivid11al, also provide:) Occupation Employer/ Business Address

Contributor Name and Address:

(If Individual, also provide:) Occupation Employer/ Business Address

Contributor Name and Address:

(If Individual, also provide:) Occupation Employer/ Business Address

Auihonty Granted under PA 388 of 1976 7/12

Page 52: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

STATE OF MICHIGAN

RUTI-I Jo:HNSON, SECRETARY OF STATE

Laurel Abraham 1108 Lakeside Drive SE Grand Rapids, Michigan 49506

Re: Lynn v. Abraham

DEPARTMENT OF STATE LANSING

November 27, 2018

Campaign Finance Complaint No. 2018-08-61-33

Dear Ms. Abraham:

The Depa1tment of State (Depa1tment) has concluded its investigation on the fmmal complaint filed by Frank Lynn against you alleging that you violated the Michigan Campaign Finance Act (MCFA or Act), 1976 PA 388, MCL 169.201 et seq. This letter concerns the disposition of the complaint.

Mr. Lynn filed his complaint on August 9, 2018 and alleged your committee used campaign literature that contains the paid for by statement "Paid for by Committee to Elect Laurel Abraham" but the committee has failed to disclose any such expenditures in the pre-primary finance report. Specifically, Mr. Lynn alleged that campaign literature, t-shi1ts, banners, and car stickers were knowingly omitted and were more than $500. As evidence, Mr. Lynn provided copies and/or pictures of each of the campaign materials.

By letter dated August 28, 2019, you responded and indicated that the postcard, car sign, banner, and t-shi1ts were paid for after the July 17, 2018 close of books. You stated that your vendor did. not send the invoice and you did not pay the invoice until after July 17, 2018 and planned to file the expenditure on your post-primary repmt. As evidence, you provided copies of three invoices each of which is dated after July 17, 2018. Mr. Lynn elected not to file a rebuttal.

The MCFA requires candidates and committees file contiibutions and expenditures with the approp1iate filing official by specific dates. MCL 169.233(1)- (3). The MCFA requires a committee that receives or expends more than $1,000 during any election to file campaign finance repo1ts in compliance with the Act. MCL 169.233(6). A person who knowingly omits or underrepo1ts expenditures required to be disclosed by the Act is subject to a civil fine of not more than $1,000 or the amount of the expenditures omitted or unde1Tep01ted, whichever is greater. MCL 169.233(11).

The Depaitment has reviewed all the evidence submitted by the patties and the repo1ts available tlu·ough the Kent County Clerk's Office and dete1mines that there is insufficient evidence to suppott a finding that a potential violation of the MCFA has occurred. Mr. Lynn alleges that you

BUREAU OF ELECTIONS RICHARD H. AUSTIN BUILDING • 1ST FLOOR • 430 W. ALLEGAN • LANSING, MICHIGAN 48918

www.Michigan.gov/sos • (517) 373-2540

Page 53: Lynn v. Abraham€¦ · Abraham posted pictures of these items on her campaign Facebook page on July 4, 2018. Like her literature, none of these items have been reported as expenditures

Laurel Abraham November 27, 2018 Page 2

did not file rep01is timely, but based upon the deadlines established in the Act, the rep01iing had ended prior to the invoices being sent for two of the invoices. For the August 7, 20 I 8 primary, the closing date was July 22, 2018 and statements were due by July 27, 2018. Two of the three invoices were dated after these dates. The third invoice was dated for July 18, 2018. However, the evidence shows that all invoices were paid after July 27, 2018. The date of payment is the date that is to be repo1ied on the expenditure report. Because each of the three invoices was paid after July 27, 2018, they are required to be disclosed on the Post-Election Rep01i. Upon review of your Post-Election rep01i, the rep01i contains expenditures that correspond with each invoice provided in your response. 1 Based upon this and absent evidence to the contrary, it does not appear that the rep01is have knowingly been misfiled or that expenditures have been omitted.

Therefore, the Depmiment finds that there is insufficient evidence to conclude that a violation of the MCFA has occurred. Accordingly, the complaint is dismissed, the Depmiment's file on the matter is closed, and no fmiher action will be taken.

c: Frank Lynn

Sincerely,

Adam Fracassi Bureau of Elections Michigan Depmiment of State

1 Available at https://www.accesskent.com/CFPublic/search.action