Upload
volodeatis
View
216
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
7/23/2019 Louis Boilly's Reading of the XIth and XIIth Bulletins of the Grande Arme
1/15
Deutscher Kunstverlag GmbH Munchen Berlin is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to
Zeitschrift fr Kunstgeschichte.
http://www.jstor.org
Louis Boilly's Reading of the XIth and XIIth Bulletins of the Grande ArmeAuthor(s): Albert BoimeSource: Zeitschrift fr Kunstgeschichte, 54. Bd., H. 3 (1991), pp. 374-387Published by: Deutscher Kunstverlag GmbH Munchen BerlinStable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/1482579Accessed: 19-08-2015 20:27 UTC
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at http://www.jstor.org/page/
info/about/policies/terms.jsp
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of contentin a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship.For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected].
This content downloaded from 83.137.211.198 on Wed, 19 Aug 2015 20:27:53 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/http://www.jstor.org/action/showPublisher?publisherCode=dkgmbhttp://www.jstor.org/stable/1482579http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/stable/1482579http://www.jstor.org/action/showPublisher?publisherCode=dkgmbhttp://www.jstor.org/7/23/2019 Louis Boilly's Reading of the XIth and XIIth Bulletins of the Grande Arme
2/15
Albert Boime
Louis
Boilly's Reading
of the
XIth and
XIIth
Bulletins
of
the GrandeArmre
The
little known
paintingby Louis-L6opold
Boilly
ntitled a
lecture u
Bulletin e a
Grande
Armie,
recently cquired by
the St. Louis
Art
Museum,
s one ofthe rtist's
mostunusual
works
both
for
ts
exceptional lace
n
his
repertoire
nd
for
ts
singular
ubject Fig.
)'.
Dated
1807
nd
exhibited t the Salon the
following ear,
t
pro-
vides a rare
glimpse
nto the
domestic
mpact
f
the
Napoleonic
wars.
Even more
extraordinary,
it
focuses
on
an artisanal
milieu2,
hus
telling
s
something
bout
Napoleon's
attempt
o
win the
laboring eopleto his sidedespite hefact hathis
military
ampaigns
ost heir
amilies
half
million
casualties nd forced
many
women nto
nevitable
celibacy.
Boilly's ong
life
panned
the
years
1761
-
1845,
beginning
ith
his
maturation
nder heOld
Re-
gime,
hen
his successive
xperience
f the
rauma
of the
Revolution,
he rise of
Napoleon,
the Re-
storation f the
Bourbons,
nd
finally,
evolution
again
in
1830.
These
years
witnessed drastic
changes n culturecorrespondingo the social
shifts,
nd
Boilly struggled
o
keep pace
with he
developing
aste.His
first ork nvolved senti-
mental,
moralizing,
ildly
rotic
mphasis sually
exhibiting
oignant
motional tates haracteristic
of the Old
Regime.
Eventually
e
established
is
reputation
orhis numerous
ortraits
f the
spir-
ingbourgeoisie
nd nteriorcenes f
everday
ife
done nmodest
ize,
these ast
occasionally
epre-
senting
exually uggestive
hemesbut
now in-
fluenced
y 17th-century
utch models
nd tend-
ing
toward
greater bjectivity
nd
ournalistic
e-
portage.Boilly
worked
for a
popular
market
y
ordering rints
f his
paintings
r
otherwise
l-
lowing
them o be
reproduced
nd
circulated
n
the
public
domain.
Ultimately,
hese
found heir
way
into the
humble
ottage
s well as luxurious
apartments
f
the
period.
He
produced rapidly
andprolificallyo accommodate hegrowingmar-
ket
for his
work. His
longevity
nd enormous
output
reveal the
progressive
volution
n
taste
towards realism that marks the ascendance of
the
middle class
during
he
time
of
Bonapartist
France3.
The
subject
f he t.Louis ArtMuseum's
picture
is
an
unusual alon
representation
f
thedomestic
lifeof the
working
lasses
during
he
Napoleonic
era.
n
addition
o the
theme,
he
genre
omposi-
tionuniquely resentstself s a series f ymbolic
vignettes
urrounding
central onvulsive ction
growing
ut of
family
trife.
he
majority
f the
workswith
Bonapartist
hemes
hown t
the
emi-
annual
alons,
whether
fficially
ommissionedr
independently
onceived,
end to
display
heroic
projections
of the
emperor, bigger-than-life
I want
o
express
my
gratitude
o Susan
Siegfried
nd
Judith
W. Mann fortheir
enerous elp
with
deas,
sources,
nd
photographs
n
theformationf this rti-
cle. am also
grateful
o
EdwardBerenson
orhis
n-
sightfuluggestions
n
Napoleonic
omesticife.Oth-
ers thathave made
lluminatinguggestions
re
Joni
Kinsey,Angela
Miller,
nd Lawrence
teefle,
r.
For
the
revious
iterature
n this
work
ee
H.
Harisse,
L.-L.
Boilly, eintre,
essinateur
t
ithographe:
a
vie
et
son
ceuvre
76i-I845,
aris
1898,
1,
No.
34;
A. Mabille
de
Poncheville,
oilly,
Paris
1931,
16;
M.
Delafond,
Louis
Boilly
1761-1845,
Musee
Marmottan,
aris
1984,
o8.
2
The unadorned nteriornd
rolled-up
leeves
f the
central
igure oint
unmistakably
o
an
artisanal
n-
terior.
he cream f the
working
lass
or thebottom
of the
bourgeoisie,
he killed rtisan
as a literatend
oftentimes
ntrepreneurial-minded
radesman.
He
could fford
he
heapplaster
astof
Napoleon
on the
fireplace
antle.
3
For the
two?manners
f
Boilly
eeM.
N.
Benisovitch,
>Une
autobiographie
u
peintre
ouis
Boilly,? ssays
in
Honor
of
Hans
Tietze,
88a-1954,
eds.
E.
Gombrich,
J.
S.
Held,
O.
Kurz,
Paris
958, 66;
J.
.
Hallam,
>The
Two Manners f
Louis-L6opold
Boilly
and French
Genre
Painting
n
Transition,?
he
Art
Bulletin,
ol.
63, 981, 18-633.
or
Boilly's
usiness
nterests
n a later
period
ee
S. L.
Siegfried,
>The
Artist s
Nomadic
Ca-
pitalist:
he
Case
of
Louis-L6opold
oilly,?
Art
His-
tory,
ol.
13,
December
1990,
516-541.
374
This content downloaded from 83.137.211.198 on Wed, 19 Aug 2015 20:27:53 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp7/23/2019 Louis Boilly's Reading of the XIth and XIIth Bulletins of the Grande Arme
3/15
i. Louis-L6opoldBoilly,La Lecturedu Bulletinde la GrandeArmee, 807.
The
Saint
ouis ArtMuseum.Mr. nd Mrs.
R.
Crosby
Kemper
through
he
CrosbyKemper
oundations
characterizations
estined
o awe his enemies
nd
assure
his followers.
xamples
re the
Coronation
of
the
Emperor
nd The
Baron
Gros's Battle
of
Eylau,
both of whichwere also shown
n
the
8o8
Salon. When
heoccasional cenes f domestic ife
are
depicted,
s for
example
he work of Martin
Drolling, hey
xhibit he table nvironmentnd
harmoniousnteriors f thebourgeoisie.During
the
fifteen
ears
hathe ruled
n
France,
Napoleon
held on to
his
power
by
almostcontinuouswar
with France's enemies nd he
mobilizedthe arts
to construct
self-image
f both nvincible ero
and
caring
uler.
His
centralized ontrol
over the media
predis-
posed
artists o
attempt
o
gain
recognition
nd
awards
n
the official xhibitions nown as the
salons
by
flattering
im.
Boilly
was a
politically
shrewd
painter,
who had
previously ainted
an
imageof the Triumph f Marat - the popular
Jacobin
hero
when he was at riskof
falling
ut
of favorwiththe
revolutionary
egime4.
he son
of a
carpenter
nd
baker's
daughter,
oilly
was a
4
M.
Marmottan,
e
peintre
.
Boilly,
aris
1913,
8ff.;
A.
Boime,
Art n an
Age of
Revolution,
hicago
1987,
457-458.
his
hesis
as
recently
ontested
y
Susan
Siegfried
ho
uggests
different
nterpretation
nd
amplifies
he ontext
nwhich
he
work
wasdone. ee
S.
L.
Siegfried,
>Reconsideration
u
>Marat>charming>Napoleon
decore
uatre
rtistesEmpire
franqaise,>practicalWomen,
ducation
f,?
His-
torical
ictionary fNapoleonic
rance,
o8-5II.
386
This content downloaded from 83.137.211.198 on Wed, 19 Aug 2015 20:27:53 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp7/23/2019 Louis Boilly's Reading of the XIth and XIIth Bulletins of the Grande Arme
15/15
was
a
common
practice
f
Boilly
to add animals
in
his
picture
o
complement
henarrative
motifs13.
The
Civil
Code
-
the Code
Napoleon
promulg-
ated
n
1804
-
declared
mastery
or hehead of
the
household and
accorded
nferior tatus
for
wo-
men.
The father
was
assigned
almost
despoiic
powerover thefamily.Womenhad no political
rights,
nd husbands
were bound to
carefor heir
wives'
needs.
Wives,
n
turn,
had to reside
with
theirhusbands
nd
could be forced
y
the
police
to return
home.
A wife owes
obedience to her
husband
ust
as a citizen
owes obedience
to
the
emperor.
Women's
place
was
in the
home,
where
they
wore everal ats:
wife, over,
nd
companion
to offer
dvice
and
listen;
nd
mother,
o
instill
virtues
nd raise children
orthe
progress
f the
nation.Napoleon imposedon French ocietyhis
view
that
women must
be
treated
s
irreponsible
minors
hroughout
heir ives.
He once told the
son
of
Madame
de
Stael
hat
>woman
hould
tick
to
knitting,governs
us as
a
father,