Long-Term Interim Storage and Release of Radioactive Material - Dr. H. Behrndt

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/22/2019 Long-Term Interim Storage and Release of Radioactive Material - Dr. H. Behrndt

    1/31

    InnenministeriumMecklenburg-Vorpommern

    Long-term Interim Storage and Release ofRadioactive Material

    Dr. W. Birkholz, Ministry of Interior of the Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania

    Dr. H. Behrndt, TV NORD SysTec GmbH & Co. KG

    E. Kaffka, Energiewerke Nord GmbH

    R. Meister, Ministry of Interior of the Mecklenburg-WesternPomerania

  • 8/22/2019 Long-Term Interim Storage and Release of Radioactive Material - Dr. H. Behrndt

    2/31

    InnenministeriumMecklenburg-Vorpommern

    2

    1. Introduction2. Licensing procedure and release measurements

    3. The release procedure and campaigns

    4. Mass flows of material from the Greifswald and Rheinsberg NPP and

    third parties during release in Greifswald

    5. Consequences of new release limit values: international and

    Radiation Protection Ordinance (StrlSchV)

    6. Summary and conclusions

    Content

  • 8/22/2019 Long-Term Interim Storage and Release of Radioactive Material - Dr. H. Behrndt

    3/31

    InnenministeriumMecklenburg-Vorpommern

    3

    1. Introduction

    The disposal of material resulting from the dismantling of a nuclearfacility is an important logistic task which is time-determining for the

    dismantling procedure.

  • 8/22/2019 Long-Term Interim Storage and Release of Radioactive Material - Dr. H. Behrndt

    4/31

    InnenministeriumMecklenburg-Vorpommern

    4

    The Greifswald NPP in 1995

    1. Introduction

  • 8/22/2019 Long-Term Interim Storage and Release of Radioactive Material - Dr. H. Behrndt

    5/31

    InnenministeriumMecklenburg-Vorpommern

    5

    Expected mass of radioactive material during the dismantling of the GreifswaldNPP (scheduled in 1995)

    residues to b e released

    500.000 Mg

    waste

    100.000 Mg

    without any restriction

    1.200.000 Mg

    1. Introduction

  • 8/22/2019 Long-Term Interim Storage and Release of Radioactive Material - Dr. H. Behrndt

    6/31

    InnenministeriumMecklenburg-Vorpommern

    6

    2. Licensing procedure and release measurements

    Reunification of Germany - shut down of the 5 units of the GreifswaldNPP in 1990

    Unification treaty operating licenses for nuclear power plants of theformer GDR were only valid until 30 J une 1995

    Decommissioning license - issued by the Ministry of the Interior ofMecklenburg-Western Pomerania on 30 J une 1995

    Decommissioning license - defined the regular bases fordisposal and free release measurement

  • 8/22/2019 Long-Term Interim Storage and Release of Radioactive Material - Dr. H. Behrndt

    7/31

    InnenministeriumMecklenburg-Vorpommern

    7

    Decommissioning and dismantling strategy (1995)

    Main features of the primary dismantling concept:

    2. Licensing procedure and release measurements

    dismantling and on-site cutting of components just as far as necessaryto remove them from the facility,

    establishment of separate storage, cutting, and free release measurementfacilities,

    classification of plant parts according to activity level and determination of fewcovering nuclide vectors

    decay storage (approx. 15 years) of plant parts and components for a

    simplification (under radiological aspects) of later cutting

    remote cutting of reactor pressure vessels (units 1 to 4, Rheinsberg NPP) andinternals

  • 8/22/2019 Long-Term Interim Storage and Release of Radioactive Material - Dr. H. Behrndt

    8/31

    InnenministeriumMecklenburg-Vorpommern

    8

    Remote cutting of reactor internalsInterim storage of

    dewateredwaste baskets

    2. Licensing procedure and release measurements

  • 8/22/2019 Long-Term Interim Storage and Release of Radioactive Material - Dr. H. Behrndt

    9/31

    InnenministeriumMecklenburg-Vorpommern

    9

    The modified concept:

    Remote cutting of reactors from units 1 to 4 and of reactor internalsfrom units 3 and 4 is not scheduled anymore.

    Long-term decay storage of 50 to 100 years will follow.

    Changing of the decommissioning and dismantling strategy

    (license of August 2007)

    2. Licensing procedure and release measurements

  • 8/22/2019 Long-Term Interim Storage and Release of Radioactive Material - Dr. H. Behrndt

    10/31

    InnenministeriumMecklenburg-Vorpommern

    10

    Decay storage of large components for cutting under radiologically morefavourable conditions (target value Co-60 activity < 30 Bq/g)

    Original data state2004

    Decay period for targetvalue

    Bottom plate of corebasket of unit 1

    - Co-60 4,6E+14 Bq - spec. Co-60109,1 a

    Reactor pressurevessel of unit 1

    - Co-60 1,5E+12 Bq - spec. Co-6055,9 a

    Bottom plate

    protecting tubesystem of unit 1

    - Co-60 3,4E+14 Bq -spec. Co-60

    106,4a

    2. Licensing procedure and release measurements

  • 8/22/2019 Long-Term Interim Storage and Release of Radioactive Material - Dr. H. Behrndt

    11/31

    InnenministeriumMecklenburg-Vorpommern

    11Folie: 11

    Removing a reactor pressure vessel

    2. Licensing procedure and release measurements

  • 8/22/2019 Long-Term Interim Storage and Release of Radioactive Material - Dr. H. Behrndt

    12/31

    InnenministeriumMecklenburg-Vorpommern

    12

    Removing a steam generator

    2. Licensing procedure and release measurements

  • 8/22/2019 Long-Term Interim Storage and Release of Radioactive Material - Dr. H. Behrndt

    13/31

    InnenministeriumMecklenburg-Vorpommern

    13

    Transport of a reactor pressure vessel into the Interim Storage North

    2. Licensing procedure and release measurements

  • 8/22/2019 Long-Term Interim Storage and Release of Radioactive Material - Dr. H. Behrndt

    14/31

    InnenministeriumMecklenburg-Vorpommern

    14

    Interim Storage North - Storage of large components

    2. Licensing procedure and release measurements

  • 8/22/2019 Long-Term Interim Storage and Release of Radioactive Material - Dr. H. Behrndt

    15/31

    InnenministeriumMecklenburg-Vorpommern

    15

    3. The release procedure and campaigns

    Free release limit values and release procedures were regulated by the

    decommissioning license from 1995.

    Reasons to use the free release limit values and release procedures of 29of the Radiation Protection Ordinance:

    EWN replaced the free release limit values from 1995 by theregulations of 29 of the Radiation Protection Ordinance.

    opening of a final storage not till 2013

    a modified dismantling strategy

    the license to treat and free release residues from other nuclearfacilities

  • 8/22/2019 Long-Term Interim Storage and Release of Radioactive Material - Dr. H. Behrndt

    16/31

    InnenministeriumMecklenburg-Vorpommern

    16

    Radiological categorization

    Category 1 Release without any restrict ionsno contamination - due to operation history contamination is

    not possiblerandom check measurements - supervised by an expertfrom supervisory authority

    Classification according to technological aspects and operation history

    Category 2 - Suspected materialcontamination possible - due to technological procedures

    and in comparison with similar

    facility areas contamination issuspected

    Category 3 - Contaminatedcontact with radioactive material

    3. The release procedure and campaigns

  • 8/22/2019 Long-Term Interim Storage and Release of Radioactive Material - Dr. H. Behrndt

    17/31

    InnenministeriumMecklenburg-Vorpommern

    17

    Release procedure

    A release measurement campaign comprises a certain dismantlingproject

    3. The release procedure and campaigns

    total mass, number of chargesorigin of the material

    radiological category, nuclide vectorresults of the preliminary inspectionsmethod for measuring

    A release measurement campaign is separated in charges.For every kind of material exists a separate charge.

    Application for a release measurement campaign includes

  • 8/22/2019 Long-Term Interim Storage and Release of Radioactive Material - Dr. H. Behrndt

    18/31

    InnenministeriumMecklenburg-Vorpommern

    18

    Kinds of material for release

    CST Carbon steel

    AUS Austenite

    NEM Non-ferrous metal

    ELT Electrical parts

    ELM Electric motorsKAB Cable, with and without insulation

    BET Concrete / concrete rubble, concrete parts and building structures

    SON Other (e.g. industrial safety means, waste that cannot be sorted,sweepings, rubble remains, glass and ceramics, detergents)

    ISW Insulation wool

    3. The release procedure and campaigns

  • 8/22/2019 Long-Term Interim Storage and Release of Radioactive Material - Dr. H. Behrndt

    19/31

    InnenministeriumMecklenburg-Vorpommern

    19

    Release procedure

    A release measurement campaign comprises a certain dismantlingproject

    3. The release procedure and campaigns

    total mass, number of chargesorigin of the material

    radiological category, nuclide vectorresults of the preliminary inspectionsmethod for measuring

    A release measurement campaign is separated in charges.For every kind of material exists a separate charge.

    Based on the inspection report of its expertthe supervisory authority releases free measured charge parts.

    Application for a release measurement campaign includes

  • 8/22/2019 Long-Term Interim Storage and Release of Radioactive Material - Dr. H. Behrndt

    20/31

    InnenministeriumMecklenburg-Vorpommern

    20Folie: 20

    Disposal paths

    A Unrestricted release (according to 29 clause 2.1)

    B Restricted Release (according to 29 clause 2.2)

    C Release under special conditions l icenced byauthority (according to 29 clause 4)

    D Decay storage

    3. The release procedure and campaigns

  • 8/22/2019 Long-Term Interim Storage and Release of Radioactive Material - Dr. H. Behrndt

    21/31

    InnenministeriumMecklenburg-Vorpommern

    21

    Hall with release measurements facilit ies

    3. The release procedure and campaigns

  • 8/22/2019 Long-Term Interim Storage and Release of Radioactive Material - Dr. H. Behrndt

    22/31

    InnenministeriumMecklenburg-Vorpommern

    22

    Residues released and disposed of (1995 2009)

    KGR KKR Third parties

    Dumpsite 25 582 Mg 280 Mg 7 Mg

    Scrap dealer 32 198 Mg 596 Mg 181 Mg

    Reuse of concrete 109 442 Mg

    Combustion 508 Mg 3 Mg

    Other use 3 805 Mg 1 Mg

    Buildings for reuse 5 684 Mg

    Total: 177 219 Mg 876 Mg 192 Mg

    4. Mass flows of material

  • 8/22/2019 Long-Term Interim Storage and Release of Radioactive Material - Dr. H. Behrndt

    23/31

    InnenministeriumMecklenburg-Vorpommern

    23

    Decay storage

    Objectives to be achieved by decay storage:1. Free release of a bigger amount of material

    2. Cutting of components under radiologically more favourable conditions

    3. To decrease the expenses for final storage

    4. Mass flows of material

    Consequences: Recirculation of resources into the cycle of material after

    release measurement

    Minimization of radioactive waste Avoiding remote dismantling Minimization of costs for final storage (containers, transport,

    volume)

    4 Mass flows of material

  • 8/22/2019 Long-Term Interim Storage and Release of Radioactive Material - Dr. H. Behrndt

    24/31

    InnenministeriumMecklenburg-Vorpommern

    24

    Sorting of condit ioned waste for the final storage ERAM

    Conditioned waste

    (690 Mg)

    Free releasemeasurement(270 Mg)

    Decay storage

    (150 Mg)

    Radioactive waste(270 Mg)

    4. Mass flows of material

  • 8/22/2019 Long-Term Interim Storage and Release of Radioactive Material - Dr. H. Behrndt

    25/31

    InnenministeriumMecklenburg-Vorpommern

    25Folie: 25

    Expected mass of radioactive material during the dismantling of the GreifswaldNPP (planned in 2008)

    residues to be released

    549.000 Mgwaste

    16.000 Mg

    without any restriction

    1.235.000 Mg

    4. Mass flows of material

  • 8/22/2019 Long-Term Interim Storage and Release of Radioactive Material - Dr. H. Behrndt

    26/31

    InnenministeriumMecklenburg-Vorpommern

    26

    5. Consequences of new release limit values

    Time course example of one nuclide vector

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    50

    60

    70

    80

    J ul

    95

    J ul

    96

    J ul

    97

    J ul

    98

    J ul

    99

    J ul

    00

    J ul

    01

    J ul

    02

    J ul

    03

    J ul

    04

    J ul

    05

    J ul

    06

    J ul

    07

    J ul

    08

    J ul

    09

    J ul

    10

    J ul

    11

    J ul

    12

    J ul

    13

    J ul

    14

    J ul

    15

    Period

    Percentage

    ofthe

    nuclides

    Co-60

    Ni-63

    Fe-55

    Cs-137

  • 8/22/2019 Long-Term Interim Storage and Release of Radioactive Material - Dr. H. Behrndt

    27/31

    InnenministeriumMecklenburg-Vorpommern

    27

    Comparison of current exemption quantities and release limit valueswith the scheduled IAEA values, data in Bq/g

    Co-60 Fe-55 Ni-63 Cs-137 Am-241

    Exemptionquantities 10 10.000 100.000 10 1

    Release formelting 0,6 10.000 10.000 0,6 0,3

    Unrestrictedrelease 0,1 200 300 0,5 0,05

    IAEA: RS-G-1.7 0,1 1000 100 0,1 0,1

    5. Consequences of new release limit values

  • 8/22/2019 Long-Term Interim Storage and Release of Radioactive Material - Dr. H. Behrndt

    28/31

    InnenministeriumMecklenburg-Vorpommern

    28

    6. Summary and conclusions

    - Removed material

    Category 1 86.000 Mg

    Category 2, 3 180.000 Mg

    - five covering nuclide vectors for release measurements

    - separation of dismantling and conditioning/releasein different facilities

    - building of an interim storage

  • 8/22/2019 Long-Term Interim Storage and Release of Radioactive Material - Dr. H. Behrndt

    29/31

    InnenministeriumMecklenburg-Vorpommern

    29

    6. Summary and conclusions

    Strategy of long-term decay storage of large components leads to

    - reduction of the dismantling time

    - reductionof the personnel's exposure to radiation- a considerable decrease of the volume of the radioactive waste

    supposed to be stored in a final storage

    (100.000 Mg planed in 1995 20.000 Mg planed in2008)

    - to significant cost savings

    Prerequisite for this saving

    - a final storage thatwill be open long enough

    - the adherence to the currentrelease limit values

  • 8/22/2019 Long-Term Interim Storage and Release of Radioactive Material - Dr. H. Behrndt

    30/31

    InnenministeriumMecklenburg-Vorpommern

    30

    Greifswald NPP in 2009

  • 8/22/2019 Long-Term Interim Storage and Release of Radioactive Material - Dr. H. Behrndt

    31/31

    InnenministeriumMecklenburg-Vorpommern

    Thank you for

    your attention!