Literacy Performance Taskessentialsguides.sfinstructionalresources.wikispaces.net/file/view...Literacy Performance Task 7th Grade: Learning from Tragedy ... “Titanic to Costa Concordia,

Revised Spring 2015

Literacy Performance Task

7th

Grade Learning from Tragedy

UNIT OVERVIEW The What Can We Learn from Tragedy task is embedded in a 2-3 week curricular unit on informational texts in which students read multiple sources on the subject of ocean liner disasters resulting in tragic loss of life The students complete three assessment tasks that build in complexity and are sequenced to scaffold student learning

TASK DETAILS Task Name What Can We Learn from Tragedy Grade 7 Subject English Language Arts Depth of Knowledge 3 Task Description The culminating task asks students to write an essay demonstrating the ability to examine a topic and convey ideas concepts and information through the selection organization and analysis of relevant content and textual evidence Standards RI71 Cite several pieces of textual evidence to support analysis of what the text says explicitly as well as inferences drawn from text RI73 Analyze the interactions between individuals events and ideas in a text RI78 Trace and evaluate the argument and specific claims in a text assessing whether the reasoning is sound and the evidence is relevant and sufficient to support the claims W71 Write arguments to support claims with clear reasons and relevant evidence W72 Write informatoryexplanatory texts to examine a topic and convey ideas concepts and information through the selection organization and analysis of relevant content W74 Produce clear and coherent writing in which the development organization and style are appropriate to task purpose and audience W79 Draw evidence from literary or informational texts to support analysis reflection and research L71 Demonstrate command of the conventions of standard English grammar and usage when writing or speaking SL72 Analyze the main ideas and supporting details presented in diverse media and formats and explain how the ideas clarify a topic text or issue under study

Revised Spring 2015

Resources and Materials Required Park Andy A Ship That Sailed Under a Black Cloud Traveller Sydney Morning

Herald 16 Jan 2012 Web 26 Apr 2012 lthttpmediasmhcomaunews

world-newsa-ship-that-sailed-under-a-black-cloud-2895378htmlgt

Ballard Robert D Exploring the Titanic Literature 2008 ed Evanston

McDougall Littel 2008 100-14 Print

ldquoCosta Concordia Disasterrdquo News Europe BBC 24 Jan 2012 Web 26 Apr 2012

lthttpwwwbbccouknewsworld-europe-16563562gt

Nadeau Barbie L Costa Concordia Captain Convicted on 32 Counts of

Manslaughter The Daily Beast The Daily Beast Company LLC 11 Feb 2015

Web 26 Mar 2015

lthttpwwwthedailybeastcomarticles20150211costa-concordia-captain-

convicted-on-32-counts-of-manslaughterhtmlgt

Pappas Stephanie ldquoCosta Concordia vs Titanic Do they Comparerdquo Live Science

TechMediaNetwork 18 Jan 2012 Web 26 Apr 2012

lthttpwwwlivesciencecom18004-costa-concordia-titanic-comparisonhtmlgt

Peterson Barbara One Year After Costa Concordia Has Anything Changed

Popular Mechanics Hearst Communication 29 Jan 2013 Web 23 Apr 2013

lthttpwwwpopularmechanicscomadventureoutdoorsa11921one-year-after-

costa-concordia-has-anything-changed-15037754gt

Supplemental and Optional ABC News ABC News Network nd Web 01 Apr 2015

httpswwwgooglecomwebhpsourceid=chrome-instantampion=1ampespv=2ampie=UTF-

8q=3Chttp3A2F2Fabcnewsgocom2F20202Fvideo2Finside-costa-concordia-

disaster-154085193E

Johnson Andy ldquoTitanic to Costa Concordia has safety at sea improvedrdquo CTV

News Bell Media 15 Apr 2012 Web 26 Mar 2015

lthttpwwwctvnewscatitanic-to-costa-concordia-has-safety-at-sea-

improved-1795387gt

Levy Megan ldquoCursed Concordia lsquoborn bad ended up worserdquo Traveller Sydney

Morning Herald 16 Jan 2012 Web 26 Apr 2012 lthttpwwwsmhcomau

traveltravel-incidentscursed-concordia-born-bad-ended-up-worse-20120116-

1q1w2htmlgt

Salvaging the Costa Concordia BBC News British Broadcasting Company 1 Dec

2014 Web 26 Mar 2015

lt httpwwwbbccomnewsworld-europe-19962191gt

Revised Spring 2015

Section A Assessment Task 1 Student Name _____________________________________ Class Period ________

Space for Notes

TASK After reading Exploring the Titanic complete a RACE graphic organizer that develop an

argument including three reasons that analyze why so many people lost their lives in this tragedy

Follow the conventions of standard English including a variety of sentence structures and correct

spelling Use formal style and effective transitions when appropriate Cited evidence should include

both an indirect (paraphrased) and a direct quote

Revised Spring 2015




spelling Use formal style and effective transitions when appropriate Cited evidence should include both

an indirect (paraphrased) and a direct quote

R Restate or Reword- the question and make it into a statement as a part of the answer

A Answer the question- include all parts of the question _____ because _____

C Cite the evidence to prove your claim (R and A) Do not forget the author and page number

Direct quotes ldquo___rdquo said __ Indirect quotes __ states __

The author says The text states For example

1st evidence 2

nd evidence 3

rd evidence

E Explain - how the evidence supports your claim Connect the evidence from C to the claim (R and A) This shows This is because This meanshellip The evidence proveshellip This illustrates

Revised Spring 2015

StepBack Questions Please answer the following questions in the space below Your responses will be collected but not graded

What did you do to complete the Performance-Based Assessment task List the steps that you took to complete the task

What did you find easy about the Performance-Based Assessment task

What did you find difficult about the Performance-Based Assessment task

Revised Spring 2015

Section B Scoring Guides for Assessment Task 1

Score Point Description

4

Argument states and develops a claim with convincing evidence and

clarifying explanations The ideas are organized using transitions that are

appropriate to the content and help to clarify the relationship among ideas

3

Argument states and develops a claim with adequate evidence and relevant

explanations The ideas are organized using transitions that are appropriate to

the content and help to clarify the relationship among ideas

2

Argument states and develops a claim with evidence and limited explanations

The ideas may be somewhat organized or transitions may not be used

effectively

1

Argument does not state a claim or is developed with information and details

that are not relevant There are no transitions that help to clarify relationships

among ideas

Examples of possible transitions

First second third

Initially to begin with next then finally in conclusion

Although instead of because of

In this way

Therefore as a consequence

Whilehellip

Unlikehellip as opposed to

Primary Trait of Assessment Task 1

W71 Write arguments to support claims with clear reasons and relevant evidence

Develop the topic with relevant facts definitions concrete details quotations or other

information and examples

Scoring Guide

Revised Spring 2015


4

Consistently uses standard English grammar and usage including accepted

use of simple and compound sentences and spelling

3

Generally uses standard English grammar and usage including accepted use

of simple and compound sentences and spelling

2

Only sometimes uses standard grammar and usage including accepted use of

simple and compound sentences and spelling

1

Little evidence of use of standard English grammar and usage including

accepted use of simple and compound sentences and spelling

Conversion from Rubric to Grade

Score 4 = 1010 points




Scoring Guide

Secondary Trait of Assessment Task 1

Student argument demonstrates use of standard English focusing on punctuation

simple and compound sentences and spelling when writing

Revised Spring 2015

Assessment Task 1

Explicit Statements about What Will Be Expected As Evidence of a Score Point 4

Score Point 4

Argument text states and develops a claim with three pieces of convincing evidence and clarifying explanations

The ideas are organized using transitions that are appropriate to the content and help to clarify the relationship

among ideas

Examples of possible reasons why so many lost their lives

Poor communication on board the ship

Reluctance of the passengers to get on the lifeboats

First and second class evacuation allowed while third class locked behind barriers

Reluctance to believe the ship was capable of sinking

Poor communication between the Californian and the Titanic prevented the rescue of passengers on the Titanic

Not enough life boats

Social norms woman and children first third class citizens not equal

Speed of the ship

Calm sea made it difficult to see the iceberg

The theory of ldquounsinkablerdquo

Water-tight compartments

Inexperience of crew

Primary Trait

Write arguments to support claims with clear reasons and relevant evidence

Develop the topic with relevant facts definitions concrete details quotations or other information and

examples

Revised Spring 2015

Example of Score Point 4 RACE Organizer


Many people lost their lives when the tragic crash of the Titanic occurred


Many lives were lost because of poor communication and because there were not enough lifeboats on the ship




No one on the Titanic really knew the dangers of the incident Even when they collided with the iceberg the radio operators didnrsquot communicate the accident clearly with the passengers ldquoOn board the Titanic almost an hour after the crash most of the passengers still did not realize the seriousness of the situationrdquo says Ballard on page 111

After the crash with the iceberg occurred passengers were alarmed thinking something went wrong However attendants on board said nothing unusual had happened and to go back to your cabin (Ballard 113)

On page 111 the text states ldquoCaptain Smith was a very worried man He knew the Titanic only carried lifeboats for half the estimated twenty-two hundred people on boardrdquo


Because of the poor communication passengers didnrsquot have time to be prepared for the sinking If the radio operators had shared the news and warnings with other passengers they might have had more time to make sure everyone was wearing their life jackets and that everyone was safe

This evidence proves if the stewards would have informed the passengers about the crash and what happened there wouldnrsquot have been as much commotion when the Titanic began to sink which led to lives being lost

This illustrates that more people could have been saved if the Titanic had the appropriate amount of lifeboats on board Instead lives were lost because passengers were left with two choices go down with the ship or jump

Revised Spring 2015


Task 2 You will read four articles about the sinking of the Costa Concordia ldquoCosta Concordia Disasterrdquo --- BBC

ldquoCosta Concordia vs Titanic Do they Comparerdquo --- Pappas

ldquoOne Year After the Costa Concordia Has Anything Changedrdquo --- Peterson

ldquoCosta Concordia Captain Convicted on 32 Counts of Manslaughterrdquo --- Nadeau

Based on a careful reading of these articles complete the table by marking which articles contain the specific facts or information listed in the left hand column If an article contains the fact mark an X in that box Next cite where you found the information by listing the paragraph number

Teacher Notes Each teacher will determine the best approach to use for reading the material in these four articles Some teachers may want to read these aloud together or in a guided manner with students Other students may be expected to read the articles individually and independently To complete the table students may be allowed to work in pairs or small groups Other students may be expected to complete the table alone Teacher discretion is encouraged Depending on how students complete this task grading is optional This task may be implemented as a practice activity that provides a supporting scaffold for the final task which is an essay that incorporates in part these articles and the information they contain Teachers certainly may grade this activity but it is not a requirement

Revised Spring 2015







Costa Concordia

Disaster --- BBC News

Costa Concordia vs Titanic Do They Compare ---Pappas

One Year After Costa Concordia Has Anything Changed --- Peterson

Costa Concordia Captain Convicted on 32 Counts of Manslaughter --- Nadeau

The captain did not call for assistance in a timely manner

Captain Schettino left the ship when passengers were still on board

The captain hit rocks when he did not follow the charted course that stays far from Giglio

Captain Schettino claims he ldquofellrdquo into a lifeboat

Captain claims the wreck is not completely his fault

The total number of people killed was 32

ldquoThe captain must go down with the shiprdquo is a standard procedure

Since the Costa Concordia sank at least 10 rules or reforms have been adopted to ensure safety of cruise ship passengers

Revised Spring 2015

Section A Assessment Task 2 Answer Key






Costa Concordia






X Para 4

X

Para 2


X Para 7

X Para 18

X Para 4

X Para 12


X Para 1210

X Para 8

X Para 4

X Para 2


X

Para 18

X Para 2


X Para 9

X

Para 457


X

Para 1


X

Para 19


X

Para 5

Revised Spring 2015

Section A Assessment Task 3 Student Name _____________________________________ Class Period ________ Space for Notes

TASK 3 You read Exploring the Titanic Then you viewed the video (ldquoA Ship That Sailed Under a Black

Cloudrdquo) and read four articles about the sinking of the Costa Concordia

ldquoCosta Concordia Disasterrdquo --- BBC




Consider this question Based on a careful comparison and analysis of the information you have viewed and read which man is

the more honorable captain Captain Schettino of the Costa Condordia or Captain Smith of the Titanic

Argue which captain is more honorable based on the evidence Compare and contrast their leadership actions in handling the situation Cite specific examples of the actions of each captain that reveal his

level of integrity

Your essay should include a clear thesis statement as part of an engaging introduction

at least two specific situations in which the captains acted differently

evidence that explains how BOTH captains acted in response to the events

comparingcontrasting their response

a satisfying conclusion

transitions to effectively guide the reader to an understanding of the ideas

formal style and correct conventions

correct citations of evidence including both direct and indirect

Revised Spring 2015

Compose Your Essay in the Space Below

Compose Your Essay in the Space Below Compose Your Essay in the Space Below

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________









Argue which captain is more honorable based on the evidence Compare and contrast their leadership actions in handling the situation Cite specific examples of the actions of each captain that reveal his level

of integrity



evidence that explains how BOTH captains acted in response to the events comparingcontrasting

their response





Revised Spring 2015

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Revised Spring 2015





Revised Spring 2015

Assessment Task 3---Written Response


4

Student writing shows evidence of detailed critical analysis and deep consideration of ideas

and concepts presented Student cites and explains specific examples of the captainsrsquo words

and actions in these tragedies Student compares and contrasts the actions of each captain

demonstrating thoughtful and detailed examination of personal honor responsibility for

actions andor leadership

3

Student writing shows evidence of critical analysis and general consideration of ideas and

concepts presented Student cites and explains specific examples of the captainsrsquo words and

actions in these tragedies Student compares and contrasts the actions of each captain

demonstrating an examination of personal honor responsibility for actions andor leadership

2

Student writing shows evidence of limited analysis or consideration of ideas and concepts

presented Student cites and explains few or limited specific examples of the captainsrsquo words

and actions in these tragedies Studentrsquos comparisons of the actions of each captain

demonstrate a minimal examination of personal honor responsibility for actions andor

leadership

1

Student writing shows no evidence of analysis or consideration of ideas and concepts

presented Studentrsquos examples and explanations are vague and disconnected Examples if

present do not demonstrate comparisons or examination of personal honor responsibility for







Primary Trait

Draw evidence from informational text to support analysis reflection and research

SCORING GUIDE

Revised Spring 2015

Score Point 4

Example Essay of a Score Point 4

EXAMPLE

Both Captain Smith (of the Titanic) and Captain Schettino (of the Costa Concordia) faced a

dire situation when the ship they commanded met with an unfortunate end However the way each

captain handled the tragedy speaks volumes about the character of the man entrusted with the lives

of so many After careful consideration of the words and actions of these ship captains Smith was

clearly the more honorable man

The causes of the shipsrsquo sinking were very different The Titanic sank due to natural causes

it hit an iceberg Captain Smith had been warned of the threat of icebergs he posted the

information on a bulletin board for crew members to read and he did warn his crew to be on the

lookout While he did not seem to be overly worried about the icebergs that may not have been his

fault after all the ship had been touted by its designers and builders as ldquounsinkablerdquo and he

believed their assertion (Ballard 107)

On the other hand the Costa Concordia sank when it was deliberately sailed off-course at the

direction of Captain Schettino Schettino did not follow the approved route and ran the ship

aground into rocks (Nadeau 1) This ship sank due to human error displaying a lack of leadership

poor judgement and questionable character on the part of the Costa Concordiarsquos captain

Once the two ships were damaged in each accident the captainsrsquo actions reveal more about

their character The Titanic hit the iceberg at about 1140 PM Within 20 minutes of the collision

Captain Smith and the shiprsquos builder Thomas Andrews were already below deck investigating the

damage (Ballard 109) Smith immediately went to the radio room to order the operator to start

sending out SOS messages to get help and a few minutes after midnight Captain Smith ordered his

crew to prepare the lifeboats (Ballard 110) At 1230 he ordered the crew to start loading the

lifeboats women and children first (Ballard 112) When the Titanic sank over 1500 people died---

including Captain Smith who followed the maritime tradition that ldquoThe captain goes down with the

shiprdquo

When the Costa Concordia sank Captain Schettinorsquos actions were very different from

Smithrsquos Schettinorsquos orders were responsible for the ship sinking in the first place but his actions

after the crash are even more troubling ldquoBy his own admission he left the ship before all of the

passengers were safely rescued--- though he says he accidentally fell into a lifeboat and couldnrsquot get

back on boardrdquo (Nadeau 1) In an interview Schettino is quoted as saying ldquoSince the beginning

they have searched for a way to put all the blame on mehelliprdquo (Nadeau 1) Clearly this captain not

only did not have the character and sense of honor to follow the maritime tradition to ldquogo down

with the shiprdquo he continues to ignore his responsibility

Captain Smith according to all reports saved as many lives as he could when he went down

with his ship on that icy disastrous night in April of 1912 Captain Schettino in contrast saved

himself and left 32 people to die on the ship he captained in January of 2012 (Peterson) Clearly the

man of honor and strong moral character is Captain Smith

Revised Spring 2015


4

Consistently uses standard English grammar and usage including accepted use of simple and

compound sentences and spelling

3

Generally uses standard English grammar and usage including accepted use of simple and


2

Only sometimes uses standard English grammar and usage including accepted use of simple

and compound sentences and spelling

1

Little evidence of use of standard English grammar and usage including accepted use of simple



Student explanation demonstrates use of standard English focusing on punctuation simple and

compound sentences and spelling when writing

Scoring Guide

Revised Spring 2015

Costa Concordia Disaster

BBC NewsEUROPE

24 January 2012

At least 28 people died after the Costa Concordia cruise ship ran aground

with more than 4000 passengers and crew on 13 January only hours after

leaving the Italian port of Civitavecchia The maps and graphics below reveal

details about the vessel and its ill-fated journey

The Costa Concordia left Civitavecchia at about 733pm local time (1833 GMT) Automatic

positioning data from Dutch firm QPS shows how the ship sails towards the island of Giglio -

and what happens next

Revised Spring 2015

QPS reconstruction of the Concordias final minutes

At about 940pm nearly three hours after leaving port the Costa Concordia hit a rocky

outcrop as it sailed past the island of Giglio The ship was holed on the left-hand side and

began to tilt as it started taking on water

Costa Concordia crew member tells coastguard we have a blackout

The positioning data shows the captain tried to turn the Costa Concordia back towards the

islands port soon after 1000pm It seems the ship then began to list in the opposite direction

possibly caused by water in the damaged hull rushing to the far side during the turn

At 1012pm the coastguard called the crew after passengers contacted police on land to say

the ship had experienced problems In a recording of the conversation the crew member can

be heard saying We have a blackout and we are checking the conditions on board

As the ship lay sideways on the islands rocks the abandon ship order was given at 1058pm

according to the official charge sheet

Revised Spring 2015

Most passengers escaped in lifeboats but evacuation efforts were hampered by the angle of

the tilting ship The coastguard launched boats and helicopters to carry stranded passengers

to safety

The captain is reported to have left the ship in a lifeboat before all the passengers had been

rescued In another conversation recorded at 1242am a coastguard commander ordered

the captain to get back on board He did not and went ashore

The rescue continued over the weekend with the ships safety officer Marrico Giampietroni

being discovered and evacuated with a broken leg at 1200pm on Sunday A South Korean

couple were also rescued

A recording has been released in which the coastguard is heard ordering the captain to get back on board

Captain Francesco Schettino now under arrest on suspicion of manslaughter said the rocks

were not marked on maps and were not detected by navigation systems He later admitted

making a navigational error and told investigators he had ordered the turn too late as the

ship sailed close to the island

The ships owners Costa Cruises said the captain had made an unapproved unauthorised

deviation in course sailing too close to the island in order to show the ship to locals

Crash investigation

Automatic tracking systems show the route of the Costa Concordia until it ran aground on 13

January Data from 14 August last year shows the ship followed a similar course close to the

shoreline according to Lloyds List Intelligence On 6 January this year it passed through the

same strait but sailed much further from the island

Investigators have recovered the black box system similar to those used by aircraft that

record voices on the bridge as well as radar position and other data which they hope will

explain how the incident happened

Revised Spring 2015

Divers have been searching the ship as it rests on the seabed in about 20m of water The

operation has been suspended a number of times as the ship has shifted position The sea

floor eventually drops to about 100m

Removing the oil

Before salvage work can begin to refloat or remove the Costa Concordia there are 2400

tonnes of fuel in its tanks which need to be extracted

How oil will be pumped out

Revised Spring 2015

Revised Spring 2015

previous slide next slide 16

The Dutch salvage firm Smit has brought a barge alongside the ship as divers install external

tanks that will collect the diesel Work to remove the oil is expected to start soon and could

take up to four weeks

Revised Spring 2015

There are between 15-20 oil tanks that need draining They are located against the outer wall

which means salvage teams can attach a valve to the outside of the ship and drill in to reach

the oil without the oil escaping - a process known as hot-tapping

As the ship is no longer functioning the heavy fuel oil can get thick and viscous making it

harder to pump

To remedy this a steam-heated element is put through the pipeline to warm the oil making

pumping much faster The oil will be pumped to a barge and then to a larger offloading

vessel

Sucking out the oil creates a vacuum so another hole is made lower down the tank to allow

seawater to be pumped in replacing the oil This also ensures extracting the oil does not

cause the ship to shift position on the seabed

Revised Spring 2015

The surreal sight of the Costa Concordia on Jan 14 2012 crippled and capsized off the Italian coast the morning after the accident became an iconic image worldwide

One Year After Costa Concordia Has Anything Changed

BY BARBARA PETERSON January 29 2013

More than a year has passed since the Costa Concordia cruise ship disaster We investigate what the cruise

industry has done to prevent it from happening again

The wreck of the Costa Concordia still lists in the waters

off Giglio more than a year after the crash Commercial

pilots flying overhead are known to point it out to

passengers Itrsquos been photographed from space Recently

the doomed vessel demanded a second rescue after a group

of thrill-seeking tourists got too close to the wreck and

their dinghy nearly overturned in the frigid waters

It was an unfortunate reminder of how little of substance

has been accomplished since the tragedy last January

which killed 32 of the 4200 people aboard and ranks

among the worst cruise ship disasters in memory The next

12 months will determine how long the Costa Concordia

remains a disaster tourism spectacle and whether the ship

itself and the questions about what caused it to sink are

finally put to rest

The salvage operation said to be the largest such project in

maritime history is turning out to be more complex than

expected Foul weather and some technical difficulties have pushed back the plan to refloat the vessel first

planned for this spring to September The two companies handling the $400 million job Floridarsquos Titan and its

Italian partner Micoperi plan to tow the wreck to a shipyard where it will be dismantled

As for the investigation the legal process in Italy moves at a notoriously creep Capt Francesco Schettino who

infamously left the ship after having run it into the rocks might go on trial later this year along with seven

others and this week the Italian authorities said they would also charge the cruise shiprsquos owner Costa Crociere

with gross negligence The US Coast Guard is joining the investigation of the accident along with the National

Transportation Safety Board But the full evidence including the black box recordings wonrsquot be fully analyzed

or released until the probe is further along and the criminal proceeding will trump the civil investigation into

what caused the accident

In the meantime a consortium of 26 major cruise lines the Cruise Lines International Assn has voluntarily

adopted a series of 10 reforms and the International Maritime Organization is considering whether to make

them mandatory for all cruise ships Most of the 10 stem from the confusion that followed the Concordiarsquos

grounding on the reef when passengers couldnrsquot get to lifeboats and received little direction from the crew

Key changes include briefing of all passengers before or right after departure not within 24 hours as before (or

in some cases days after sailing designating that passage planning like filing a flight plan must not only be

done in advance but must be adhered to by the crew and that the ship must carry excess lifejackets

Perhaps the biggest change in culture would be to severely restrict access to the bridge during maneuvers or

times of increased vigilance But enforcement largely would rely on an honor system which might not stop a

rogue captain (right before the Concordia crashed her captain was entertaining a guest and talking on his cell

Revised Spring 2015

phone) What this rule proposes would be akin to the sterile cockpit protocols aboard airliners under 10000

feet In aviation though its an official policy thats enforced by a government entity

The new rules also grow out of an increasing recognition that communication among the crew is critical during

an emergency Similar to the airlines crew resource management the shipping industry is moving to change

the idea that the captain calls the shots and canrsquot be challenged As one Coast Guard veteran told me I have

had unlicensed seamen save my butt recalling that early on as a captain I was going too fast in a channel and

my second mate told me Hey arenrsquot you going too fast I quickly changed course I always tell me crew If

you see something tell me

Revised Spring 2015

Costa Concordia Captain Convicted on 32 Counts of Manslaughter By Barbie Latza Nadeau The Daily Beast

February 11 2015

Capt Schettino was sentenced to 16 years for crashing his ship He escaped much heavier penalties Has he learned his lesson Probably Has the cruise industry Maybe GROSSETO Italy mdash Captain Francesco Schettino was found guilty Wednesday of causing a maritime disaster

guilty of abandoning ship and guilty of 32 counts of manslaughter in the sinking of the cruise ship he

commanded the Costa Concordia He was sentenced to 16 years and one month in prison

Schettinorsquos trial never really was about guilt or innocence After all the facts were hard to dispute Schettino

ordered the ship off course and then negligently albeit accidentally crashed it into shallow rocks off the Tuscan

island of Giglio in January 2012 By his own admission he left the ship before all of the passengers were safely

rescuedmdashthough he says he accidentally fell into a life boat and couldnrsquot get back on board No one died on

impact but 32 of the 4229 people on board lost their lives during the evacuation which the captain had failed

to call for nearly an hour after the accident

According to Schettino the real question has always been about money and how Costa and its parent company

Carnival could make sure their insurance companies would pay for the hefty salvage operation which will have

cost $15 billion by the time the wreck is dismantled The Concordia was parbuckled to an upright position in

September 2013 and then towed to Genoa last July where it is being stripped down and recycled and sold for

scrap

In an exclusive interview with The Daily Beast last March Schettino said he was a scapegoat ldquoSince the

beginning they have searched for a way to put all the blame on me saying the captain went crazy for a

moment [so as] not to forfeit the insurance moneyrdquo Schettino told us ldquoIt didnrsquot take long to figure out that it

would all be better if the responsibility rested with just one person rather than the whole companyrdquo

ldquoI died with those 32 passengersrdquo he said then broke down in tears

This week as his trial wound down Schettinorsquos lawyers repeated the claims telling the panel of three judges

that ldquothe cards were stacked against Schettinordquo from the beginning They claimed he was vilified criminalized

and made the laughing stock of Italy ldquoThe personality that was created is not in line with realityrdquo Domenico

Pepe told the court ldquoHe has been massacredrdquo

Pepe also argued that the court refused to accept requests to analyze various functions of the ship which

Schettino claims malfunctioned and led to the deaths Because none of the victims died on impact the defense

tried to prove that had the shiprsquos watertight doors and emergency generators worked lives could have been

saved

Revised Spring 2015

Schettinorsquos defense team also blamed the crew for not being better trained which he said was the responsibility

of the company not him He blamed his helmsman Indonesian national Jacob Rusli Bin for misinterpreting his

order to turn the ship away from the coast before the rocks were hit None of those factors proved his innocence

certainly but they may have played a role in his sentence which could have been still heavier

The captain has clearly learned his lesson He will be able to appeal his verdict and given Italyrsquos court system

has a good chance to get a few years knocked off his sentence Before the judges retired to deliberate Schettino

spoke ldquoOn January 13 I died with those 32 passengersrdquo he said then broke down in tears

What is less clear is whether the cruise ship industry has learned its lesson

Schettinorsquos lawyer told the court that he had an opportunity to go on a Costa cruise which he said he did to help

better understand how to defend his client He said that when Schettino worked for Costa the Concordia only

had two muster stations where passengers meet when there is an emergency Pepe told the court that the cruise

he was on had ten He also said that the members of the staff were attentive and well trained and that they

spoke a number of languages which he was able to test with his multi-lingual wifersquos help

Pepe said there were crew members near the meeting areas on the ship he took which was not the case the night

the Concordia went down Pepe also surmised that proper checks had been made to ensure the watertight doors

and emergency generators functioned too

ldquoThis trial has served a purpose to correct the industryrdquo said Schettinorsquos lawyer ldquoAnd who knows how many

lives could have been lost in the future if not for thatrdquo

Source

httpwwwthedailybeastcomarticles20150211costa-concordia-captain-convicted-on-32-counts-of-manslaughterhtml

Revised Spring 2015

Costa Concordia Captain Convicted on 32 Counts of Manslaughter

Suggested discussion questions

Objective I can analyze language and evaluate arguments

1 Reread the quote by Domenico Pepe in the fifth paragraph Make an inference and explain what Pepe

means by this

2 There are multiple similarities to the tragedy of the Titanic Compare at least two

3 In paragraph eight use context clues to determine the meaning of deliberate What do you think it means

Explain how you came to that understanding

4 Schettino spoke ldquoOn January 13 I died with those 32 passengersrdquo Explain what Schettino means by this

5 From the article what do you think were Schettinorsquos lawyerrsquos two strongest arguments Why

6 Do you agree or disagree that Schettino was used as a scapegoat Why

7 Do you think Schettino deserves the punishment he got Why or why not

8 To aid in your understanding of the whole situation what two search phrases would

you research using the internet

9 How do we know Barbie Latza Nadeau is a credible source How did you find out

10 Is The Daily Beast a credible source Do some research and explain what you found out and HOW you

found out

Revised Spring 2015

Costa Concordia vs Titanic Do They Compare By Stephanie Pappas Live Science Contributor

January 18 2012

The hectic evacuation of the sinking cruise liner Costa Concordia has been compared with the likes of

the disastrous Titanic disaster In fact Swiss survivors even told the newspaper La Tribune de

Genegraveve that Celine Dions My Heart Will Go On the theme song to the 1997 film Titanic was playing

in their dining room as the ship hit the rocks

So how do the two shipwrecks match up While the loss of life on the Titanic was much worse than

on the Costa Concordia even the Titanics poorly planned evacuation may have been less chaotic

than the one off the Tuscan coast By the numbers heres a side-by-side look at the two cruise ship

disasters

Date of wrecks The Titanic went down on April 15 1912 The Costa Concordia capsized on Jan13

2012

Size of ships The Titanic was 882 feet and 8 inches long (268 meters) and had a tonnage of

46000 The Costa Concordia was larger with a tonnage of 114500 and a length of 951 feet and 5

inches (290 m) The width of the Titanic was 925 feet (28 m) compared with 118 feet (36 m) for the

Costa Concordia

Bragging rights The Titanic was the largest ship of her day The Costa Concordia had the largest

spa center ever built on a cruise ship

The sinking cruise ship Costa Concordia

Credit copy Lupoalb68 | Dreamstimecom

Revised Spring 2015

People on board 2201 people were aboard the Titanic when it sunk and 4200 were aboard the

Costa Concordia

Cause of wreck The Titanic famously hit an iceberg on its starboard side in the middle of the North

Atlantic while the Costa Concordia struck a rock on its port side when the captain brought the ship in

close to the Tuscan island of Giglio in the Mediterranean Sea

Lifeboat capacity The Titanics lifeboats could have carried no more than 1178 people Nowadays

according to the International Maritime Organization ships are required to have plenty of lifeboat

space with enough lifeboats hanging off the port side to accommodate half of the passengers

enough on the starboard side to accommodate the other half and room for 25 percent more of the

ships passengers in inflatable rafts stored onboard [Titanic Quiz Fact or Fiction]

The Costa Concordia had sufficient lifeboat space as far as we know by the regulations she

operates under said Charles Weeks an emeritus professor of marine transportation at the Maine

Maritime Academy and a member of the Titanic International Society Unlike the Titanic which

lacked sufficient staff at lifeboat muster points the Costa Concordia seemed to have crew supervision

at the lifeboat stations he said The delay in lowering the lifeboats which occurred about 45 minutes

to an hour after the ship hit the rocks may have been the captains call he said

There may have been a perfectly valid reason why he waited so long Weeks told LiveScience You

dont want to put lifeboats in the water while the ship is still making way That can be very hazardous

Time it took to sink The Titanic went down over a period of two hours and 40 minutes The Costa

Concordia began listing about 20 minutes after it hit a rock near Giglio Island and was completely on

its side within about three hours

Depth of the wreck The Titanic lay on the seafloor 12460 feet (3798 m) below the surface The

Costa Concordia essentially ran aground and is now half-submerged mdash the ship is unable to float in

water less than 26 feet (8 m) deep

Temperature of water The passengers of the Titanic unlucky enough to end up in the water likely

perished in a few short minutes as the water temperature was just 28 degrees Fahrenheit (minus 2

degrees Celsius)

According to Accuweather the air temperature when the Costa Concordia crashed was in the mid-to-

low 40s Fahrenheit The water temperature was in the mid- to upper-50s In 50-degree

waterhypothermia sets in quickly boating guides put the time at about 60 minutes until exhaustion or

unconsciousness with death following within three hours

Loss of life Only 711 of the passengers aboard the Titanic were rescued resulting in a death toll of

1514 according to the British Wreck Commissioners Inquiry As of today (Jan 18) an estimated 11

Costa Concordia passengers were confirmed dead with 23 still missing

Revised Spring 2015

Fate of the captain Edward J Smith the captain of the Titanic went down with his ship His body

was never found

The Costa Concordia captain Francesco Schettino allegedly left the ship with passengers still

onboard He claims he tripped and fell into a lifeboat while coordinating the evacuation and could not

get back on the ship A transcript of a phone conversation between Schettino and a coast guard

officer reveals the officer insisting Schettino return to the ship and the captain refusing Schettino is

now under house arrest and is being investigated for manslaughter

The standard of the captain being the last person to leave a crippled ship serves two purposes

Weeks said First its the captains job to take care of everyone else on the boat Second if a captain

stays with adamaged ship he can protect the ship owners interests If the captain is still on the boat

the owners can arrange a towing contract to get the vessel back to port Weeks said If the ship is

abandoned it must be salvaged which can be a more complicated and costly process for the

owners

Big evacuation foul-ups

Hundreds of Titanic passengers never had a chance at survival given the lack of lifeboat space

available Not only that but a US inquiry into the disaster found that the evacuation process was a

mess There was no system for loading the boats and many of the boats went down partially filled

(though there was space for 1176 people on the boats only about 700 made it onto one)

Additionally the loss of life would have been much worse had the weather have been rough the

panel found With the lifeboats suspended 70 feet (21 m) above the ocean rough waters would have

made lowering them without smashing them against the ship impossible

On the other hand all reports indicate very little panic during the Titanic evacuation at least not until

the very end This is likely because most passengers didnt realize the seriousness of the situation

Weeks said There are reports of passengers refusing to get on the lifeboats choosing instead to stay

in the warmth and light of the doomed ship

The same cannot be said of the Costa Concordia evacuation which survivors describe as chaotic It

was every man for himself one survivor told French News outlet France 24 Crew members

reportedly panicked and jumped aboard lifeboats before passengers

The Costa Concordia listed to one side in contrast with the Titanic which tilted forward her bow in

the water That may have made the Concordia sinking seem more dramatic than the sinking of the

Titanic at least from the perspective of those onboard

A ship that lists to one side is far more dramatic than a ship that trims down by the head Weeks

said

Revised Spring 2015

The evacuation of the Costa Concordia was delayed with passengers initially informed that the ship

was having a minor electrical problem There had been no evacuation drill onboard mdash it was

scheduled for Saturday mdash so passengers were confused Many of the crew did not speak Italian and

could not communicate with their charges Some cruise-goers reported being on lifeboats captained

by waiters and other support staff

Weeks said reports of the crews behavior still needed confirmation but said that such a situation is

not without precedent The cruise ship Oceanus for example sank off the South African Coast in

1991

The social director wound up overseeing the evacuation of the passengers Weeks said The

captain and certain members of the crew went off in the first lifeboatrdquo

Source httpwwwlivesciencecom18004-costa-concordia-titanic-comparisonhtml

Revised Spring 2015

Cursed Concordia born bad ended up worse

By Megan Levy

January 16 2012 The Sydney Morning Herald

If maritime superstitions are to be believed the Costa Concordia was doomed from the moment it was launched

When a grand christening ceremony was held in July 2006 in the port of Civitavecchia the ceremonial champagne bottle failed to smash against the hull of the luxury liner - now on its side in the sea as rescue workers hunt for missing passengers - and wet the bow

In a video capturing the moment some among the crowd - which included supermodel Eva Herzigovaacute - can be heard gasping as the bottle is hurled from a height and bounces unbroken off the side

It is a sign some seafarers consider to be a harbinger of bad luck Ominously the Titanic was never christened

It was born bad and ended up worse the Italian newspaper Il Giornale pronounced in a headline about Fridays tragedy

Just two years later on November 22 2008 the Costa Concordia suffered a second stroke of bad luck

The ship was attempting to enter the post of Palermo Sicily in a storm when it hit the dock and was damaged

The latest accident occurred on Friday the 13th a day some consider unlucky

On Sunday two South Korean honeymooners and an Italian crewman were rescued from the wreckage of the cruise ship wreck in Italy as emergency services found another two bodies bringing the death toll to five

Divers found two elderly men wearing lifejackets in a cabin in the rear of the submerged part of the 17-deck Costa Concordia said the coastguard

Im afraid that we could find others Angelo Scarpa one of the divers who recovered the bodies said as one Australian diving expert suggested it was highly likely that other passengers are trapped alive in air pockets on the vessel

They had to break the glass roof over one of the ships dining rooms to get to them said Scarpa One victim was wearing a chain and the other had a wallet which would help with identification he added

The divers would now focus on the dining areas in the search for more bodies he added as many passengers were eating when the boat hit the rocks

Fire brigade spokesman Luca Cari said the rescued South Korean honeymooners had been evacuated by helicopter and were in perfect condition

Rescuers said the search in the half-submerged ship was highly dangerous because the decks were at almost a 90-degree angle and there was a risk the ship could slip off the rocks it had struck and sink altogether

Two French passengers and one Peruvian crew member were confirmed as dead on Saturday apparently after jumping into the chilly Mediterranean waters with dozens of others in a chaotic evacuation

Revised Spring 2015

Resources and Materials Required Park Andy A Ship That Sailed Under a Black Cloud Traveller Sydney Morning

Herald 16 Jan 2012 Web 26 Apr 2012 lthttpmediasmhcomaunews

world-newsa-ship-that-sailed-under-a-black-cloud-2895378htmlgt

Ballard Robert D Exploring the Titanic Literature 2008 ed Evanston

McDougall Littel 2008 100-14 Print

ldquoCosta Concordia Disasterrdquo News Europe BBC 24 Jan 2012 Web 26 Apr 2012

lthttpwwwbbccouknewsworld-europe-16563562gt

Nadeau Barbie L Costa Concordia Captain Convicted on 32 Counts of

Manslaughter The Daily Beast The Daily Beast Company LLC 11 Feb 2015

Web 26 Mar 2015

lthttpwwwthedailybeastcomarticles20150211costa-concordia-captain-

convicted-on-32-counts-of-manslaughterhtmlgt

Pappas Stephanie ldquoCosta Concordia vs Titanic Do they Comparerdquo Live Science

TechMediaNetwork 18 Jan 2012 Web 26 Apr 2012

lthttpwwwlivesciencecom18004-costa-concordia-titanic-comparisonhtmlgt

Peterson Barbara One Year After Costa Concordia Has Anything Changed

Popular Mechanics Hearst Communication 29 Jan 2013 Web 23 Apr 2013

lthttpwwwpopularmechanicscomadventureoutdoorsa11921one-year-after-

costa-concordia-has-anything-changed-15037754gt

Supplemental and Optional ABC News ABC News Network nd Web 01 Apr 2015

httpswwwgooglecomwebhpsourceid=chrome-instantampion=1ampespv=2ampie=UTF-

8q=3Chttp3A2F2Fabcnewsgocom2F20202Fvideo2Finside-costa-concordia-

disaster-154085193E

Johnson Andy ldquoTitanic to Costa Concordia has safety at sea improvedrdquo CTV

News Bell Media 15 Apr 2012 Web 26 Mar 2015

lthttpwwwctvnewscatitanic-to-costa-concordia-has-safety-at-sea-

improved-1795387gt

Levy Megan ldquoCursed Concordia lsquoborn bad ended up worserdquo Traveller Sydney

Morning Herald 16 Jan 2012 Web 26 Apr 2012 lthttpwwwsmhcomau

traveltravel-incidentscursed-concordia-born-bad-ended-up-worse-20120116-

1q1w2htmlgt

Salvaging the Costa Concordia BBC News British Broadcasting Company 1 Dec

2014 Web 26 Mar 2015

lt httpwwwbbccomnewsworld-europe-19962191gt

Revised Spring 2015


Space for Notes






Revised Spring 2015











1st evidence 2

nd evidence 3

rd evidence


Revised Spring 2015





Revised Spring 2015



4




3




2



effectively

1



among ideas


First second third



In this way


Whilehellip






Scoring Guide

Revised Spring 2015


4



3



2



1








Scoring Guide




Revised Spring 2015

Assessment Task 1


Score Point 4



among ideas









Speed of the ship





Primary Trait



examples

Revised Spring 2015
















Revised Spring 2015








Revised Spring 2015







Costa Concordia













Revised Spring 2015







Costa Concordia






X Para 4

X

Para 2


X Para 7

X Para 18

X Para 4

X Para 12


X Para 1210

X Para 8

X Para 4

X Para 2


X

Para 18

X Para 2


X Para 9

X

Para 457


X

Para 1


X

Para 19


X

Para 5

Revised Spring 2015











level of integrity









Revised Spring 2015



_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________










of integrity




their response





Revised Spring 2015

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Revised Spring 2015





Revised Spring 2015



4






3





2





leadership

1










Primary Trait


SCORING GUIDE

Revised Spring 2015

Score Point 4


EXAMPLE
























shiprdquo













Revised Spring 2015


4



3



2



1






Scoring Guide

Revised Spring 2015


BBC NewsEUROPE

24 January 2012








Revised Spring 2015














Revised Spring 2015



to safety














Crash investigation








Revised Spring 2015




Removing the oil




Revised Spring 2015

Revised Spring 2015





Revised Spring 2015





harder to pump



vessel




Revised Spring 2015




















finally put to rest























Revised Spring 2015









Revised Spring 2015


February 11 2015














scrap













saved

Revised Spring 2015



















Source


Revised Spring 2015





means by this












found out

Revised Spring 2015


January 18 2012








disasters


2012




Costa Concordia





Revised Spring 2015


Costa Concordia

























degrees Celsius)








Revised Spring 2015


was never found











owners




















said

Revised Spring 2015








1991




Revised Spring 2015


By Megan Levy


















Revised Spring 2015


Space for Notes






Revised Spring 2015











1st evidence 2

nd evidence 3

rd evidence


Revised Spring 2015





Revised Spring 2015



4




3




2



effectively

1



among ideas


First second third



In this way


Whilehellip






Scoring Guide

Revised Spring 2015


4



3



2



1








Scoring Guide




Revised Spring 2015

Assessment Task 1


Score Point 4



among ideas









Speed of the ship





Primary Trait



examples

Revised Spring 2015
















Revised Spring 2015








Revised Spring 2015







Costa Concordia













Revised Spring 2015







Costa Concordia






X Para 4

X

Para 2


X Para 7

X Para 18

X Para 4

X Para 12


X Para 1210

X Para 8

X Para 4

X Para 2


X

Para 18

X Para 2


X Para 9

X

Para 457


X

Para 1


X

Para 19


X

Para 5

Revised Spring 2015











level of integrity









Revised Spring 2015



_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________










of integrity




their response





Revised Spring 2015

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Revised Spring 2015





Revised Spring 2015



4






3





2





leadership

1










Primary Trait


SCORING GUIDE

Revised Spring 2015

Score Point 4


EXAMPLE
























shiprdquo













Revised Spring 2015


4



3



2



1






Scoring Guide

Revised Spring 2015


BBC NewsEUROPE

24 January 2012








Revised Spring 2015














Revised Spring 2015



to safety














Crash investigation








Revised Spring 2015




Removing the oil




Revised Spring 2015

Revised Spring 2015





Revised Spring 2015





harder to pump



vessel




Revised Spring 2015




















finally put to rest























Revised Spring 2015









Revised Spring 2015


February 11 2015














scrap













saved

Revised Spring 2015



















Source


Revised Spring 2015





means by this












found out

Revised Spring 2015


January 18 2012








disasters


2012




Costa Concordia





Revised Spring 2015


Costa Concordia

























degrees Celsius)








Revised Spring 2015


was never found











owners




















said

Revised Spring 2015








1991




Revised Spring 2015


By Megan Levy


















Revised Spring 2015











1st evidence 2

nd evidence 3

rd evidence


Revised Spring 2015





Revised Spring 2015



4




3




2



effectively

1



among ideas


First second third



In this way


Whilehellip






Scoring Guide

Revised Spring 2015


4



3



2



1








Scoring Guide




Revised Spring 2015

Assessment Task 1


Score Point 4



among ideas









Speed of the ship





Primary Trait



examples

Revised Spring 2015
















Revised Spring 2015








Revised Spring 2015







Costa Concordia













Revised Spring 2015







Costa Concordia






X Para 4

X

Para 2


X Para 7

X Para 18

X Para 4

X Para 12


X Para 1210

X Para 8

X Para 4

X Para 2


X

Para 18

X Para 2


X Para 9

X

Para 457


X

Para 1


X

Para 19


X

Para 5

Revised Spring 2015











level of integrity









Revised Spring 2015



_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________










of integrity




their response





Revised Spring 2015

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Revised Spring 2015





Revised Spring 2015



4






3





2





leadership

1










Primary Trait


SCORING GUIDE

Revised Spring 2015

Score Point 4


EXAMPLE
























shiprdquo













Revised Spring 2015


4



3



2



1






Scoring Guide

Revised Spring 2015


BBC NewsEUROPE

24 January 2012








Revised Spring 2015














Revised Spring 2015



to safety














Crash investigation








Revised Spring 2015




Removing the oil




Revised Spring 2015

Revised Spring 2015





Revised Spring 2015





harder to pump



vessel




Revised Spring 2015




















finally put to rest























Revised Spring 2015









Revised Spring 2015


February 11 2015














scrap













saved

Revised Spring 2015



















Source


Revised Spring 2015





means by this












found out

Revised Spring 2015


January 18 2012








disasters


2012




Costa Concordia





Revised Spring 2015


Costa Concordia

























degrees Celsius)








Revised Spring 2015


was never found











owners




















said

Revised Spring 2015








1991




Revised Spring 2015


By Megan Levy


















Revised Spring 2015





Revised Spring 2015



4




3




2



effectively

1



among ideas


First second third



In this way


Whilehellip






Scoring Guide

Revised Spring 2015


4



3



2



1








Scoring Guide




Revised Spring 2015

Assessment Task 1


Score Point 4



among ideas









Speed of the ship





Primary Trait



examples

Revised Spring 2015
















Revised Spring 2015








Revised Spring 2015







Costa Concordia













Revised Spring 2015







Costa Concordia






X Para 4

X

Para 2


X Para 7

X Para 18

X Para 4

X Para 12


X Para 1210

X Para 8

X Para 4

X Para 2


X

Para 18

X Para 2


X Para 9

X

Para 457


X

Para 1


X

Para 19


X

Para 5

Revised Spring 2015











level of integrity









Revised Spring 2015



_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________










of integrity




their response





Revised Spring 2015

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Revised Spring 2015





Revised Spring 2015



4






3





2





leadership

1










Primary Trait


SCORING GUIDE

Revised Spring 2015

Score Point 4


EXAMPLE
























shiprdquo













Revised Spring 2015


4



3



2



1






Scoring Guide

Revised Spring 2015


BBC NewsEUROPE

24 January 2012








Revised Spring 2015














Revised Spring 2015



to safety














Crash investigation








Revised Spring 2015




Removing the oil




Revised Spring 2015

Revised Spring 2015





Revised Spring 2015





harder to pump



vessel




Revised Spring 2015




















finally put to rest























Revised Spring 2015









Revised Spring 2015


February 11 2015














scrap













saved

Revised Spring 2015



















Source


Revised Spring 2015





means by this












found out

Revised Spring 2015


January 18 2012








disasters


2012




Costa Concordia





Revised Spring 2015


Costa Concordia

























degrees Celsius)








Revised Spring 2015


was never found











owners




















said

Revised Spring 2015








1991




Revised Spring 2015


By Megan Levy


















Revised Spring 2015



4




3




2



effectively

1



among ideas


First second third



In this way


Whilehellip






Scoring Guide

Revised Spring 2015


4



3



2



1








Scoring Guide




Revised Spring 2015

Assessment Task 1


Score Point 4



among ideas









Speed of the ship





Primary Trait



examples

Revised Spring 2015
















Revised Spring 2015








Revised Spring 2015







Costa Concordia













Revised Spring 2015







Costa Concordia






X Para 4

X

Para 2


X Para 7

X Para 18

X Para 4

X Para 12


X Para 1210

X Para 8

X Para 4

X Para 2


X

Para 18

X Para 2


X Para 9

X

Para 457


X

Para 1


X

Para 19


X

Para 5

Revised Spring 2015











level of integrity









Revised Spring 2015



_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________










of integrity




their response





Revised Spring 2015

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Revised Spring 2015





Revised Spring 2015



4






3





2





leadership

1










Primary Trait


SCORING GUIDE

Revised Spring 2015

Score Point 4


EXAMPLE
























shiprdquo













Revised Spring 2015


4



3



2



1






Scoring Guide

Revised Spring 2015


BBC NewsEUROPE

24 January 2012








Revised Spring 2015














Revised Spring 2015



to safety














Crash investigation








Revised Spring 2015




Removing the oil




Revised Spring 2015

Revised Spring 2015





Revised Spring 2015





harder to pump



vessel




Revised Spring 2015




















finally put to rest























Revised Spring 2015









Revised Spring 2015


February 11 2015














scrap













saved

Revised Spring 2015



















Source


Revised Spring 2015





means by this












found out

Revised Spring 2015


January 18 2012








disasters


2012




Costa Concordia





Revised Spring 2015


Costa Concordia

























degrees Celsius)








Revised Spring 2015


was never found











owners




















said

Revised Spring 2015








1991




Revised Spring 2015


By Megan Levy


















Revised Spring 2015


4



3



2



1








Scoring Guide




Revised Spring 2015

Assessment Task 1


Score Point 4



among ideas









Speed of the ship





Primary Trait



examples

Revised Spring 2015
















Revised Spring 2015








Revised Spring 2015







Costa Concordia













Revised Spring 2015







Costa Concordia






X Para 4

X

Para 2


X Para 7

X Para 18

X Para 4

X Para 12


X Para 1210

X Para 8

X Para 4

X Para 2


X

Para 18

X Para 2


X Para 9

X

Para 457


X

Para 1


X

Para 19


X

Para 5

Revised Spring 2015











level of integrity









Revised Spring 2015



_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________










of integrity




their response





Revised Spring 2015

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Revised Spring 2015





Revised Spring 2015



4






3





2





leadership

1










Primary Trait


SCORING GUIDE

Revised Spring 2015

Score Point 4


EXAMPLE
























shiprdquo













Revised Spring 2015


4



3



2



1






Scoring Guide

Revised Spring 2015


BBC NewsEUROPE

24 January 2012








Revised Spring 2015














Revised Spring 2015



to safety














Crash investigation








Revised Spring 2015




Removing the oil




Revised Spring 2015

Revised Spring 2015





Revised Spring 2015





harder to pump



vessel




Revised Spring 2015




















finally put to rest























Revised Spring 2015









Revised Spring 2015


February 11 2015














scrap













saved

Revised Spring 2015



















Source


Revised Spring 2015





means by this












found out

Revised Spring 2015


January 18 2012








disasters


2012




Costa Concordia





Revised Spring 2015


Costa Concordia

























degrees Celsius)








Revised Spring 2015


was never found











owners




















said

Revised Spring 2015








1991




Revised Spring 2015


By Megan Levy


















Revised Spring 2015

Assessment Task 1


Score Point 4



among ideas









Speed of the ship





Primary Trait



examples

Revised Spring 2015
















Revised Spring 2015








Revised Spring 2015







Costa Concordia













Revised Spring 2015







Costa Concordia






X Para 4

X

Para 2


X Para 7

X Para 18

X Para 4

X Para 12


X Para 1210

X Para 8

X Para 4

X Para 2


X

Para 18

X Para 2


X Para 9

X

Para 457


X

Para 1


X

Para 19


X

Para 5

Revised Spring 2015











level of integrity









Revised Spring 2015



_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________










of integrity




their response





Revised Spring 2015

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Revised Spring 2015





Revised Spring 2015



4






3





2





leadership

1










Primary Trait


SCORING GUIDE

Revised Spring 2015

Score Point 4


EXAMPLE
























shiprdquo













Revised Spring 2015


4



3



2



1






Scoring Guide

Revised Spring 2015


BBC NewsEUROPE

24 January 2012








Revised Spring 2015














Revised Spring 2015



to safety














Crash investigation








Revised Spring 2015




Removing the oil




Revised Spring 2015

Revised Spring 2015





Revised Spring 2015





harder to pump



vessel




Revised Spring 2015




















finally put to rest























Revised Spring 2015









Revised Spring 2015


February 11 2015














scrap













saved

Revised Spring 2015



















Source


Revised Spring 2015





means by this












found out

Revised Spring 2015


January 18 2012








disasters


2012




Costa Concordia





Revised Spring 2015


Costa Concordia

























degrees Celsius)








Revised Spring 2015


was never found











owners




















said

Revised Spring 2015








1991




Revised Spring 2015


By Megan Levy


















Revised Spring 2015
















Revised Spring 2015








Revised Spring 2015







Costa Concordia













Revised Spring 2015







Costa Concordia






X Para 4

X

Para 2


X Para 7

X Para 18

X Para 4

X Para 12


X Para 1210

X Para 8

X Para 4

X Para 2


X

Para 18

X Para 2


X Para 9

X

Para 457


X

Para 1


X

Para 19


X

Para 5

Revised Spring 2015











level of integrity









Revised Spring 2015



_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________










of integrity




their response





Revised Spring 2015

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Revised Spring 2015





Revised Spring 2015



4






3





2





leadership

1










Primary Trait


SCORING GUIDE

Revised Spring 2015

Score Point 4


EXAMPLE
























shiprdquo













Revised Spring 2015


4



3



2



1






Scoring Guide

Revised Spring 2015


BBC NewsEUROPE

24 January 2012








Revised Spring 2015














Revised Spring 2015



to safety














Crash investigation








Revised Spring 2015




Removing the oil




Revised Spring 2015

Revised Spring 2015





Revised Spring 2015





harder to pump



vessel




Revised Spring 2015




















finally put to rest























Revised Spring 2015









Revised Spring 2015


February 11 2015














scrap













saved

Revised Spring 2015



















Source


Revised Spring 2015





means by this












found out

Revised Spring 2015


January 18 2012








disasters


2012




Costa Concordia





Revised Spring 2015


Costa Concordia

























degrees Celsius)








Revised Spring 2015


was never found











owners




















said

Revised Spring 2015








1991




Revised Spring 2015


By Megan Levy


















Revised Spring 2015








Revised Spring 2015







Costa Concordia













Revised Spring 2015







Costa Concordia






X Para 4

X

Para 2


X Para 7

X Para 18

X Para 4

X Para 12


X Para 1210

X Para 8

X Para 4

X Para 2


X

Para 18

X Para 2


X Para 9

X

Para 457


X

Para 1


X

Para 19


X

Para 5

Revised Spring 2015











level of integrity









Revised Spring 2015



_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________










of integrity




their response





Revised Spring 2015

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Revised Spring 2015





Revised Spring 2015



4






3





2





leadership

1










Primary Trait


SCORING GUIDE

Revised Spring 2015

Score Point 4


EXAMPLE
























shiprdquo













Revised Spring 2015


4



3



2



1






Scoring Guide

Revised Spring 2015


BBC NewsEUROPE

24 January 2012








Revised Spring 2015














Revised Spring 2015



to safety














Crash investigation








Revised Spring 2015




Removing the oil




Revised Spring 2015

Revised Spring 2015





Revised Spring 2015





harder to pump



vessel




Revised Spring 2015




















finally put to rest























Revised Spring 2015









Revised Spring 2015


February 11 2015














scrap













saved

Revised Spring 2015



















Source


Revised Spring 2015





means by this












found out

Revised Spring 2015


January 18 2012








disasters


2012




Costa Concordia





Revised Spring 2015


Costa Concordia

























degrees Celsius)








Revised Spring 2015


was never found











owners




















said

Revised Spring 2015








1991




Revised Spring 2015


By Megan Levy


















Revised Spring 2015







Costa Concordia













Revised Spring 2015







Costa Concordia






X Para 4

X

Para 2


X Para 7

X Para 18

X Para 4

X Para 12


X Para 1210

X Para 8

X Para 4

X Para 2


X

Para 18

X Para 2


X Para 9

X

Para 457


X

Para 1


X

Para 19


X

Para 5

Revised Spring 2015











level of integrity









Revised Spring 2015



_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________










of integrity




their response





Revised Spring 2015

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Revised Spring 2015





Revised Spring 2015



4






3





2





leadership

1










Primary Trait


SCORING GUIDE

Revised Spring 2015

Score Point 4


EXAMPLE
























shiprdquo













Revised Spring 2015


4



3



2



1






Scoring Guide

Revised Spring 2015


BBC NewsEUROPE

24 January 2012








Revised Spring 2015














Revised Spring 2015



to safety














Crash investigation








Revised Spring 2015




Removing the oil




Revised Spring 2015

Revised Spring 2015





Revised Spring 2015





harder to pump



vessel




Revised Spring 2015




















finally put to rest























Revised Spring 2015









Revised Spring 2015


February 11 2015














scrap













saved

Revised Spring 2015



















Source


Revised Spring 2015





means by this












found out

Revised Spring 2015


January 18 2012








disasters


2012




Costa Concordia





Revised Spring 2015


Costa Concordia

























degrees Celsius)








Revised Spring 2015


was never found











owners




















said

Revised Spring 2015








1991




Revised Spring 2015


By Megan Levy


















Revised Spring 2015







Costa Concordia






X Para 4

X

Para 2


X Para 7

X Para 18

X Para 4

X Para 12


X Para 1210

X Para 8

X Para 4

X Para 2


X

Para 18

X Para 2


X Para 9

X

Para 457


X

Para 1


X

Para 19


X

Para 5

Revised Spring 2015











level of integrity









Revised Spring 2015



_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________










of integrity




their response





Revised Spring 2015

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Revised Spring 2015





Revised Spring 2015



4






3





2





leadership

1










Primary Trait


SCORING GUIDE

Revised Spring 2015

Score Point 4


EXAMPLE
























shiprdquo













Revised Spring 2015


4



3



2



1






Scoring Guide

Revised Spring 2015


BBC NewsEUROPE

24 January 2012








Revised Spring 2015














Revised Spring 2015



to safety














Crash investigation








Revised Spring 2015




Removing the oil




Revised Spring 2015

Revised Spring 2015





Revised Spring 2015





harder to pump



vessel




Revised Spring 2015




















finally put to rest























Revised Spring 2015









Revised Spring 2015


February 11 2015














scrap













saved

Revised Spring 2015



















Source


Revised Spring 2015





means by this












found out

Revised Spring 2015


January 18 2012








disasters


2012




Costa Concordia





Revised Spring 2015


Costa Concordia

























degrees Celsius)








Revised Spring 2015


was never found











owners




















said

Revised Spring 2015








1991




Revised Spring 2015


By Megan Levy


















Revised Spring 2015











level of integrity









Revised Spring 2015



_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________










of integrity




their response





Revised Spring 2015

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Revised Spring 2015





Revised Spring 2015



4






3





2





leadership

1










Primary Trait


SCORING GUIDE

Revised Spring 2015

Score Point 4


EXAMPLE
























shiprdquo













Revised Spring 2015


4



3



2



1






Scoring Guide

Revised Spring 2015


BBC NewsEUROPE

24 January 2012








Revised Spring 2015














Revised Spring 2015



to safety














Crash investigation








Revised Spring 2015




Removing the oil




Revised Spring 2015

Revised Spring 2015





Revised Spring 2015





harder to pump



vessel




Revised Spring 2015




















finally put to rest























Revised Spring 2015









Revised Spring 2015


February 11 2015














scrap













saved

Revised Spring 2015



















Source


Revised Spring 2015





means by this












found out

Revised Spring 2015


January 18 2012








disasters


2012




Costa Concordia





Revised Spring 2015


Costa Concordia

























degrees Celsius)








Revised Spring 2015


was never found











owners




















said

Revised Spring 2015








1991




Revised Spring 2015


By Megan Levy


















Revised Spring 2015



_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________










of integrity




their response





Revised Spring 2015

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Revised Spring 2015





Revised Spring 2015



4






3





2





leadership

1










Primary Trait


SCORING GUIDE

Revised Spring 2015

Score Point 4


EXAMPLE
























shiprdquo













Revised Spring 2015


4



3



2



1






Scoring Guide

Revised Spring 2015


BBC NewsEUROPE

24 January 2012








Revised Spring 2015














Revised Spring 2015



to safety














Crash investigation








Revised Spring 2015




Removing the oil




Revised Spring 2015

Revised Spring 2015





Revised Spring 2015





harder to pump



vessel




Revised Spring 2015




















finally put to rest























Revised Spring 2015









Revised Spring 2015


February 11 2015














scrap













saved

Revised Spring 2015



















Source


Revised Spring 2015





means by this












found out

Revised Spring 2015


January 18 2012








disasters


2012




Costa Concordia





Revised Spring 2015


Costa Concordia

























degrees Celsius)








Revised Spring 2015


was never found











owners




















said

Revised Spring 2015








1991




Revised Spring 2015


By Megan Levy


















Revised Spring 2015

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Revised Spring 2015





Revised Spring 2015



4






3





2





leadership

1










Primary Trait


SCORING GUIDE

Revised Spring 2015

Score Point 4


EXAMPLE
























shiprdquo













Revised Spring 2015


4



3



2



1






Scoring Guide

Revised Spring 2015


BBC NewsEUROPE

24 January 2012








Revised Spring 2015














Revised Spring 2015



to safety














Crash investigation








Revised Spring 2015




Removing the oil




Revised Spring 2015

Revised Spring 2015





Revised Spring 2015





harder to pump



vessel




Revised Spring 2015




















finally put to rest























Revised Spring 2015









Revised Spring 2015


February 11 2015














scrap













saved

Revised Spring 2015



















Source


Revised Spring 2015





means by this












found out

Revised Spring 2015


January 18 2012








disasters


2012




Costa Concordia





Revised Spring 2015


Costa Concordia

























degrees Celsius)








Revised Spring 2015


was never found











owners




















said

Revised Spring 2015








1991




Revised Spring 2015


By Megan Levy


















Revised Spring 2015





Revised Spring 2015



4






3





2





leadership

1










Primary Trait


SCORING GUIDE

Revised Spring 2015

Score Point 4


EXAMPLE
























shiprdquo













Revised Spring 2015


4



3



2



1






Scoring Guide

Revised Spring 2015


BBC NewsEUROPE

24 January 2012








Revised Spring 2015














Revised Spring 2015



to safety














Crash investigation








Revised Spring 2015




Removing the oil




Revised Spring 2015

Revised Spring 2015





Revised Spring 2015





harder to pump



vessel




Revised Spring 2015




















finally put to rest























Revised Spring 2015









Revised Spring 2015


February 11 2015














scrap













saved

Revised Spring 2015



















Source


Revised Spring 2015





means by this












found out

Revised Spring 2015


January 18 2012








disasters


2012




Costa Concordia





Revised Spring 2015


Costa Concordia

























degrees Celsius)








Revised Spring 2015


was never found











owners




















said

Revised Spring 2015








1991




Revised Spring 2015


By Megan Levy


















Revised Spring 2015



4






3





2





leadership

1










Primary Trait


SCORING GUIDE

Revised Spring 2015

Score Point 4


EXAMPLE
























shiprdquo













Revised Spring 2015


4



3



2



1






Scoring Guide

Revised Spring 2015


BBC NewsEUROPE

24 January 2012








Revised Spring 2015














Revised Spring 2015



to safety














Crash investigation








Revised Spring 2015




Removing the oil




Revised Spring 2015

Revised Spring 2015





Revised Spring 2015





harder to pump



vessel




Revised Spring 2015




















finally put to rest























Revised Spring 2015









Revised Spring 2015


February 11 2015














scrap













saved

Revised Spring 2015



















Source


Revised Spring 2015





means by this












found out

Revised Spring 2015


January 18 2012








disasters


2012




Costa Concordia





Revised Spring 2015


Costa Concordia

























degrees Celsius)








Revised Spring 2015


was never found











owners




















said

Revised Spring 2015








1991




Revised Spring 2015


By Megan Levy


















Revised Spring 2015

Score Point 4


EXAMPLE
























shiprdquo













Revised Spring 2015


4



3



2



1






Scoring Guide

Revised Spring 2015


BBC NewsEUROPE

24 January 2012








Revised Spring 2015














Revised Spring 2015



to safety














Crash investigation








Revised Spring 2015




Removing the oil




Revised Spring 2015

Revised Spring 2015





Revised Spring 2015





harder to pump



vessel




Revised Spring 2015




















finally put to rest























Revised Spring 2015









Revised Spring 2015


February 11 2015














scrap













saved

Revised Spring 2015



















Source


Revised Spring 2015





means by this












found out

Revised Spring 2015


January 18 2012








disasters


2012




Costa Concordia





Revised Spring 2015


Costa Concordia

























degrees Celsius)








Revised Spring 2015


was never found











owners




















said

Revised Spring 2015








1991




Revised Spring 2015


By Megan Levy


















Revised Spring 2015


4



3



2



1






Scoring Guide

Revised Spring 2015


BBC NewsEUROPE

24 January 2012








Revised Spring 2015














Revised Spring 2015



to safety














Crash investigation








Revised Spring 2015




Removing the oil




Revised Spring 2015

Revised Spring 2015





Revised Spring 2015





harder to pump



vessel




Revised Spring 2015




















finally put to rest























Revised Spring 2015









Revised Spring 2015


February 11 2015














scrap













saved

Revised Spring 2015



















Source


Revised Spring 2015





means by this












found out

Revised Spring 2015


January 18 2012








disasters


2012




Costa Concordia





Revised Spring 2015


Costa Concordia

























degrees Celsius)








Revised Spring 2015


was never found











owners




















said

Revised Spring 2015








1991




Revised Spring 2015


By Megan Levy


















Revised Spring 2015


BBC NewsEUROPE

24 January 2012








Revised Spring 2015














Revised Spring 2015



to safety














Crash investigation








Revised Spring 2015




Removing the oil




Revised Spring 2015

Revised Spring 2015





Revised Spring 2015





harder to pump



vessel




Revised Spring 2015




















finally put to rest























Revised Spring 2015









Revised Spring 2015


February 11 2015














scrap













saved

Revised Spring 2015



















Source


Revised Spring 2015





means by this












found out

Revised Spring 2015


January 18 2012








disasters


2012




Costa Concordia





Revised Spring 2015


Costa Concordia

























degrees Celsius)








Revised Spring 2015


was never found











owners




















said

Revised Spring 2015








1991




Revised Spring 2015


By Megan Levy


















Revised Spring 2015














Revised Spring 2015



to safety














Crash investigation








Revised Spring 2015




Removing the oil




Revised Spring 2015

Revised Spring 2015





Revised Spring 2015





harder to pump



vessel




Revised Spring 2015




















finally put to rest























Revised Spring 2015









Revised Spring 2015


February 11 2015














scrap













saved

Revised Spring 2015



















Source


Revised Spring 2015





means by this












found out

Revised Spring 2015


January 18 2012








disasters


2012




Costa Concordia





Revised Spring 2015


Costa Concordia

























degrees Celsius)








Revised Spring 2015


was never found











owners




















said

Revised Spring 2015








1991




Revised Spring 2015


By Megan Levy


















Revised Spring 2015



to safety














Crash investigation








Revised Spring 2015




Removing the oil




Revised Spring 2015

Revised Spring 2015





Revised Spring 2015





harder to pump



vessel




Revised Spring 2015




















finally put to rest























Revised Spring 2015









Revised Spring 2015


February 11 2015














scrap













saved

Revised Spring 2015



















Source


Revised Spring 2015





means by this












found out

Revised Spring 2015


January 18 2012








disasters


2012




Costa Concordia





Revised Spring 2015


Costa Concordia

























degrees Celsius)








Revised Spring 2015


was never found











owners




















said

Revised Spring 2015








1991




Revised Spring 2015


By Megan Levy


















Revised Spring 2015




Removing the oil




Revised Spring 2015

Revised Spring 2015





Revised Spring 2015





harder to pump



vessel




Revised Spring 2015




















finally put to rest























Revised Spring 2015









Revised Spring 2015


February 11 2015














scrap













saved

Revised Spring 2015



















Source


Revised Spring 2015





means by this












found out

Revised Spring 2015


January 18 2012








disasters


2012




Costa Concordia





Revised Spring 2015


Costa Concordia

























degrees Celsius)








Revised Spring 2015


was never found











owners




















said

Revised Spring 2015








1991




Revised Spring 2015


By Megan Levy


















Revised Spring 2015

Revised Spring 2015





Revised Spring 2015





harder to pump



vessel




Revised Spring 2015




















finally put to rest























Revised Spring 2015









Revised Spring 2015


February 11 2015














scrap













saved

Revised Spring 2015



















Source


Revised Spring 2015





means by this












found out

Revised Spring 2015


January 18 2012








disasters


2012




Costa Concordia





Revised Spring 2015


Costa Concordia

























degrees Celsius)








Revised Spring 2015


was never found











owners




















said

Revised Spring 2015








1991




Revised Spring 2015


By Megan Levy


















Revised Spring 2015





Revised Spring 2015





harder to pump



vessel




Revised Spring 2015




















finally put to rest























Revised Spring 2015









Revised Spring 2015


February 11 2015














scrap













saved

Revised Spring 2015



















Source


Revised Spring 2015





means by this












found out

Revised Spring 2015


January 18 2012








disasters


2012




Costa Concordia





Revised Spring 2015


Costa Concordia

























degrees Celsius)








Revised Spring 2015


was never found











owners




















said

Revised Spring 2015








1991




Revised Spring 2015


By Megan Levy


















Revised Spring 2015





harder to pump



vessel




Revised Spring 2015




















finally put to rest























Revised Spring 2015









Revised Spring 2015


February 11 2015














scrap













saved

Revised Spring 2015



















Source


Revised Spring 2015





means by this












found out

Revised Spring 2015


January 18 2012








disasters


2012




Costa Concordia





Revised Spring 2015


Costa Concordia

























degrees Celsius)








Revised Spring 2015


was never found











owners




















said

Revised Spring 2015








1991




Revised Spring 2015


By Megan Levy


















Revised Spring 2015




















finally put to rest























Revised Spring 2015









Revised Spring 2015


February 11 2015














scrap













saved

Revised Spring 2015



















Source


Revised Spring 2015





means by this












found out

Revised Spring 2015


January 18 2012








disasters


2012




Costa Concordia





Revised Spring 2015


Costa Concordia

























degrees Celsius)








Revised Spring 2015


was never found











owners




















said

Revised Spring 2015








1991




Revised Spring 2015


By Megan Levy


















Revised Spring 2015









Revised Spring 2015


February 11 2015














scrap













saved

Revised Spring 2015



















Source


Revised Spring 2015





means by this












found out

Revised Spring 2015


January 18 2012








disasters


2012




Costa Concordia





Revised Spring 2015


Costa Concordia

























degrees Celsius)








Revised Spring 2015


was never found











owners




















said

Revised Spring 2015








1991




Revised Spring 2015


By Megan Levy


















Revised Spring 2015


February 11 2015














scrap













saved

Revised Spring 2015



















Source


Revised Spring 2015





means by this












found out

Revised Spring 2015


January 18 2012








disasters


2012




Costa Concordia





Revised Spring 2015


Costa Concordia

























degrees Celsius)








Revised Spring 2015


was never found











owners




















said

Revised Spring 2015








1991




Revised Spring 2015


By Megan Levy


















Revised Spring 2015



















Source


Revised Spring 2015





means by this












found out

Revised Spring 2015


January 18 2012








disasters


2012




Costa Concordia





Revised Spring 2015


Costa Concordia

























degrees Celsius)








Revised Spring 2015


was never found











owners




















said

Revised Spring 2015








1991




Revised Spring 2015


By Megan Levy


















Revised Spring 2015





means by this












found out

Revised Spring 2015


January 18 2012








disasters


2012




Costa Concordia





Revised Spring 2015


Costa Concordia

























degrees Celsius)








Revised Spring 2015


was never found











owners




















said

Revised Spring 2015








1991




Revised Spring 2015


By Megan Levy


















Revised Spring 2015


January 18 2012








disasters


2012




Costa Concordia





Revised Spring 2015


Costa Concordia

























degrees Celsius)








Revised Spring 2015


was never found











owners




















said

Revised Spring 2015








1991




Revised Spring 2015


By Megan Levy


















Revised Spring 2015


Costa Concordia

























degrees Celsius)








Revised Spring 2015


was never found











owners




















said

Revised Spring 2015








1991




Revised Spring 2015


By Megan Levy


















Revised Spring 2015


was never found











owners




















said

Revised Spring 2015








1991




Revised Spring 2015


By Megan Levy


















Revised Spring 2015








1991




Revised Spring 2015


By Megan Levy


















Revised Spring 2015


By Megan Levy


















Documents

Literacy Performance Taskessentialsguides.sfinstructionalresources.wikispaces.net/file/view...Literacy Performance Task 7th Grade: Learning from Tragedy ... “Titanic to Costa Concordia,