Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
!"#$%&'"()&#(*+((,&-.,")"%&%,/&01$2*3&*4(&*+5&).66())&)*57"()3&%*& '(%)*&857&
,5+3&58&*4(&97%#&9+%:(,",1;&<.*&*4(&!"#$%,&)*57$&4%)&#((,&=.64&/%7:(7;&&
>
>
"%,&)*%#"'"*$3&*4(&65.,*7$?)&8.*.7(&")&.,6'(%7;&@(%7)&*4%*&!"#$%&+"''&#(65=(&*4(&
>
275*7%6*(/&%,/&87%1"'(;&
Gadha!’s legacy and Libyan identity A57(&*4%,&%&=5,*4&%8*(7&@7%,6(3&<7"*%",&%,/&*4(&B,"*(/&C*%*()&/(6"/(/3&+"*4&
>
",6(& 58&D$7(,%"6%3& *4(& E.()*"5,& 58& F+4%*& *4(& 7(#(')&+%,*?& 7(=%",)& 52(,;G&
C('8>2756'%"=(/& 7(#('& '(%/(7)& *7$& *5& 27()(,*& %& .,"*(/& 875,*3& #.*& *4(7(& %7(&
H5.,")3& 857=(7& ",*(7"57&=",")*(7& %,/&=",")*(7& 58&2.#'"6& )(6.7"*$;&9,5*4(7&
%=5,1& *4(& 7(#(');I
Libya after Gadha!
Saskia van Genugten
Saskia van Genugten is a PhD candidate at the School of Advanced International Studies (SAIS), Johns Hopkins University, Bologna/Washington DC. Her dissertation focuses on Italian and British relations with Libya.
Survival | vol. 53 no. 3 | June–July 2011 | pp. 61–74 DOI 10.1080/00396338.2011.586190
Dow
nloa
ded
by [V
UB
Vrij
e U
nive
rsity
Bru
ssel
s] a
t 08:
01 0
6 Ju
ly 2
011
Saskia van Genugten
#(&=%71",%'3& "*& ")&,5,(*4('())&7(%';J&9=5,1&*45)(&*7%",",1&*4(&7(#('&8576()&
9814%,&+%73&",6'./",1&857=(7&K.%,*%,%=5&<%$&",=%*()&).64&%)&C.8$%,&<",&
*4(&=5=(,*3&.,:,5+,;
-4(&!"#$%,&5225)"*"5,&")3&",&8%6*3&%,&%''"%,6(&58&)*7%,1(&#(/8(''5+)&#."'*&
4%)&%/75"*'$&()*%#'")4(/&"*)('8&%)&*4(&27"=(&",*(7'56.*57&%#75%/&%7(&7('"1"5.)&
>
65==5,&4")*57$3&27()(,*&%,/&/()*",$;&
>
E G Y P T
TUNIS IA
N I G E R C H A D
MisurataBenghazi
Tripoli
Derna
T R I P O L I T A N I A
C Y R E N A I C AF E Z Z A N
L I B Y A
Sirte
Al-Bayda
© IISS
Jebel el-Akhdar
500Miles
500Km
Dow
nloa
ded
by [V
UB
Vrij
e U
nive
rsity
Bru
ssel
s] a
t 08:
01 0
6 Ju
ly 2
011
Libya after Gadha!
*4(&65==5,&64%7%6*(7")*"6)&58&!"#$%,)&4%/&*5&#(;L&<($5,/&*4%*3&4(&+%,*(/&
4")&5+,&25'"*"6%'3&(65,5="6&%,/&)56"%'&*4(57"()&%)&(M25.,/(/&",&4")&.#"E>
."*5.)&!"##$% &''(
())(,*"%''$&.,",4%#"*(/&4",*(7'%,/;!*4(&<(,('.M&65.,*7"()&65=#",(/3&#.*&"*)&5,'$&*+5&7(%'&.7#%,&6(,*7()3&-7"25'"&
2(7"5/3&.,/(7&*4(&K7((:)3&D%7*4%1","%,)&%,/&N5=%,)3&*4($&7(=%",(/&)(2%>
7%*(;&-4(&97%#&65,E.()*K.14*&*+5&=%",&*7"#()&*5&=5/(7,&!"#$%O&*4(&<(,"&
>
.,/(7)*%,/%#'$&52*(/&857&%&)*75,1&8(/(7%'&=5/(';P
Q&R.7",1&*4(&
Dow
nloa
ded
by [V
UB
Vrij
e U
nive
rsity
Bru
ssel
s] a
t 08:
01 0
6 Ju
ly 2
011
Saskia van Genugten
S&
-4")&+%)&*4(&)((/&58&!"#$%,&",/(2(,/(,6(T&*4(&:",1&%17((/&5,'$&7('.6*%,*'$&
>
,(,*'$&8(%*.7(/&*4(&67()6(,*&%,/&*4(&)*%73&)$=#5')&58&D$7(,%"6%3&#.*&=%/(&U >
>
*4(&.).%'&7(+7"*",1&58&4")*57$&*(M*#55:)3&*4(&('"=",%*"5,&58&
65,*7%/"6*57$& "/(%)& 875=& 2.#'"6& '"8(& %,/& *4(&+"/(& .)(& 58&
,(+&=())%1(&%675));&-4(&<(7#(7&=",57"*$&+%)&/"7(6*'$&5227())(/3&#.*&=57(&
%&,(+3&=5/(7,&2.725)(>#."'*&*5+,;&-4")&(75/(/3&%=5,1&5*4(7&*4",1)3&*4(&
2%$75'';&-4")&+%)&%,&(M*7(=('$&25+(78.'&=(64%,")=&857&65,*75'&%,/&=%,"2>
.'%*"5,3&2.,")4=(,*&%,/&7(+%7/;&
Gadha! despised the monarchy
Dow
nloa
ded
by [V
UB
Vrij
e U
nive
rsity
Bru
ssel
s] a
t 08:
01 0
6 Ju
ly 2
011
Libya after Gadha!
Uncivil society
<.*& %./"#'(& %,/& %*& '(%)*& )(=">571%,")(/!
!+45&4%/&#((,&%))56"%*(/&+"*4& "*3&%,/& *7"#%'& '(%/(7);&-5&#(&).7(3&,(+&('(>
>
4%)& %'+%$)&#((,&=57(&5.*)25:(,&%1%",)*& %,$& 6(,*7%'& %.*457"*$;&-4")& '())&
.7#%,")(/&7(1"5,&+%)&=57(&6'5)('$& *"(/&+"*4& *4(&=5,%764$&%,/&7('"1"5.)&
()*%#'")4=(,*;&
)$% *+,#$-)*& %,/&
>
V
Dow
nloa
ded
by [V
UB
Vrij
e U
nive
rsity
Bru
ssel
s] a
t 08:
01 0
6 Ju
ly 2
011
Saskia van Genugten
7.*4'())&67%6:/5+,3&",6'./",1&%"7&)*7":()&%,/&2.#'"6&4%,1",1);&C.64&5227()>
% >
).66())&)*57$;&-4(&7(1"=(&+%)&)*75,1(73&%,/&=57(&65'/>#'55/(/3&*4%,&*4($&
%,*"6"2%*(/;GW
).2257*&*5&65=#%*&*(7757")=;GG
65>52*(/&#$& *4(&7(1"=(& ",&(M64%,1(& 857&(65,5="6&65=>
>
'(,6(;GI&A57(&7(6(,*'$3&+"*4&27517%==()&*%71(*",1&$5.*4&.,(=2'5$=(,*&",&
>
A%,$&5225,(,*)&(,/(/&.2&",&27")5,3&+(7(&:"''(/&57&)"=2'$&/")%22(%7(/3&
%)&",&*4(&6%)(&58&A%,).7&N%64"/&('>X":4"%&58&*4(&!"#$%,&Y%*"5,%'&9''"%,6(&",&
>
F)*7%$& /51)?& %#75%/;&A.)%& X.)%3& 4(%/& 58& *4(& !"#$%,& ",*(''"1(,6(& %1(,6$&
The regime was stronger and more cold-blooded
Dow
nloa
ded
by [V
UB
Vrij
e U
nive
rsity
Bru
ssel
s] a
t 08:
01 0
6 Ju
ly 2
011
Libya after Gadha!
>
571%,")%*"5,)&Z5",(/&8576()&",&!5,/5,3&857=",1&*4(&Y%*"5,%'&D5,8(7(,6(&857&
>
(,6(&%,/&")).(/&)(2%7%*(&)*%*(=(,*)&5,&*4(&6.77(,*&7(#(''"5,3&=5)*&175.2)&
/(=5,)*7%*"5,);
4("7& *5& *4(& *475,(3& [7",6(& A.4%==(/& ('>C%,.))"3& +45& ")& %')5& #%)(/& ",&
>
*"5,)&+"*4&*4(&-7%,)"*"5,%'&D5.,6"'3&4(&)*7())()&"*)&*7%,)"*"5,%'&,%*.7(&+4"'(&GJ
7(27())"5,&")&%&64%''(,1(;&9&#%'%,6(&4%)&*5&#(&)*7.6:&#(*+((,&2'.7%'")=&%,/&
GL
#$&*4(&'(1%6$&58&=(,*%'&%,/&24$)"6%'&7(27())"5,3&4.=%,>7"14*)&%#.)(&%,/&
>
Dow
nloa
ded
by [V
UB
Vrij
e U
nive
rsity
Bru
ssel
s] a
t 08:
01 0
6 Ju
ly 2
011
Saskia van Genugten
Institutional shortcomings@7((/&875=&%.*457"*%7"%,")=&%,/&"*)&).2257*",1&)*7.6*.7()3&!"#$%,)&+"''&#(&
(M25)(/&*5&%,&.,27(6(/(,*(/&25'"*"6%'&87((/5=;&-4(7(&")&,5&65,)*"*.*"5,&",&
>
65=2'"6%*"5,&5,& *4(&75%/&*5&/(=567%*")%*"5,&%,/&7(,(+(/&)*%#"'"*$3&()2(>
65,)"/(7(/&=57(&'(1"*"=%*(;
('%#57%*(/&.25,&",&4")&.*52"%,&"/(%)&%75.,/&%&F)*%*(&58&*4(&=%))()?;&C*%*(&
571%,")%*"5,)&4%/&*5&#(&#%)(/&5,&*4(&F%.*457"*$&58&*4(&2(52'(?&*5&#(&%)&6'5)(&
%)&25))"#'(&*5&%&2.7(&857=&58&/(=567%6$;&[%7'"%=(,*)3&25'"*"6%'&2%7*"()&%,/&
>
4(7/(/& '":(& )4((2& #$& ).'*%,)3& (=2(757)& %,/& 65,E.(757)& \& 98*(7& *4(&
*7".=24&58&7(2.#'"6%,")=&%,/&*4(&#(1",,",1&58&*4(&(7%&58&*4(&=%))()3& "*&
")&.,*4",:%#'(&\&%,&5#)5'(*(&(M2(7"=(,*;&[5+(7&)45.'/&#(&(,*"7('$&857&%''&
*4(&2(52'(;GP
>
Dow
nloa
ded
by [V
UB
Vrij
e U
nive
rsity
Bru
ssel
s] a
t 08:
01 0
6 Ju
ly 2
011
Libya after Gadha!
*4(& 67(%*"5,& 58& 252.'%7& 65,17())()& *4%*&+5.'/& ('(6*& *4(& 65.,*7$?)& '(%/(7&
>
>
>GQ
",)*"*.*"5,)&%22(%7(/&*5&=%:(&=5,"*57&%,/&/(,5.,6(&*4(&5225)"*"5,;GS&
>
>
*4%*&*4(&/$,%="6)&58&65,*75''(/&64%5)&7(%64(/&%)&8%7&%)&*4(&/(8(,6(&65==.>
Dow
nloa
ded
by [V
UB
Vrij
e U
nive
rsity
Bru
ssel
s] a
t 08:
01 0
6 Ju
ly 2
011
Saskia van Genugten
>
>
>
*5& 7(175.2& ",& *"=()&58&67")")3&+4(,& *45)(&+45)(& '5$%'*$&+%)&E.()*"5,%#'(&
*./%*/0
1.#)2*
-4(& %#)(,6(& 58& '(1"*"=%*(& %,/& )*%#'(& )*%*(& ",)*"*.*"5,)&+"''& #(& %&=%Z57&
International involvement
%6*57)&%17((&*4%*&!"#$%,)&)45.'/&/(6"/(&!"#$%?)&8%*(3&*4(&8.*.7(&58&!"#$%&+"''&
!"#$%&6%=(&.,/(7&*4(&%.*457"*$&58&*4(&<7"*")4&A"'"*%7$&9/=",")*7%*"5,T&*4(&
Dow
nloa
ded
by [V
UB
Vrij
e U
nive
rsity
Bru
ssel
s] a
t 08:
01 0
6 Ju
ly 2
011
Libya after Gadha!
K(,(7%'&9))(=#'$&/(6"/(/&*5&()*%#'")4&%,&",/(2(,/(,*&:",1/5=3&%'#("*&5,(&
>
!"#$%&*7.(&",/(2(,/(,6(3&#.*&/()2"*(&4")&%,*">65'5,"%'&%,/&%,*">"=2(7"%'")*&
>
="'"*%7$&#%)()&5,&!"#$%,&*(77"*57$&]*4(&=5,%764$&4%/&
857=)& 58& 6552(7%*"5,&+(7(& )*(22(/& .2& ).#)*%,*"%''$3&GU
(M257*)3&,5&!"#$%,&'(%/(7&+"''&#(&%#'(&*5&+"*4)*%,/&5.*)"/(&27()).7(&857&'5,1;&
>
%#"'"*$&*5&2'%$&5,(&)*%*(&%1%",)*&%,5*4(7&4%)&=(%,*&*4%*&(=#%715)&%,/&)%,6>
K55/& 7('%*"5,)& +"*4& *4(& !"#$%,& '(%/(7)4"2& 6%,& #7",1& (M*(7,%'& %6*57)&
GV
Libya was the subject of great-power
bargaining
Dow
nloa
ded
by [V
UB
Vrij
e U
nive
rsity
Bru
ssel
s] a
t 08:
01 0
6 Ju
ly 2
011
Saskia van Genugten
&-4(&<7"*")4&'5##"(/&
>
>
=(76"%'&52257*.,"*"()3&",6'./",1&)%'()&58&*4("7&3)"*4#&+%72'%,();
>
*5/%$?)&=57(&2'.7%'&+57'/3&%&,(+&!"#$%,&7(1"=(&65.'/&#(&(%)"'$&*(=2*(/&
* * *
857&*4(&,(+&!"#$%,&)*%*(&65,6'./(/&*4%*&*4(&65.,*7$&65=#",(/&F%''&*4(&5#)*%>
&-4(&)%=(&
65.'/&#(&)%"/&*5/%$&%#5.*&275)2(6*)&857&%&!"#$%,&*7%,)"*"5,&*5&/(=567%6$&
>
>
6%'&.,6(7*%",*$&%,/&",)*"*.*"5,%'&(M2(7"=(,*%*"5,;&!"#$%&4%)&7(%'&25*(,*"%'&
%7(&.)(/&+")('$;&<.*&*45)(&+45&*%:(&7()25,)"#"'"*$&857&*4(&,(6())%7$&,%*"5,>
#."'/",13&)*%*(>#."'/",1&%,/&*7.)*>#."'/",1&,((/&*5&#(&%+%7(&*4%*&*4($&%7(&
#."'/",1&5,&)%,/;
Dow
nloa
ded
by [V
UB
Vrij
e U
nive
rsity
Bru
ssel
s] a
t 08:
01 0
6 Ju
ly 2
011
Libya after Gadha!
G& -4)&E.()*"5,&4%)&#((,&%):(/&",&=%,$&"=257*%,*&857.=)3&#.*&*4(7(&")&,5&6'(%7&%,)+(7;&@57&(M%=2'(3&%*&*4(&(,/&58&A%7643&BC&R(2.*$&C(67(*%7$&58&C*%*(&
>*"5,&%,/&*4%*&*4(&B,"*(/&C*%*()&+%)&",&*4(&2756())&58&F175+",1&*5&:,5+&
*4(&0B&)(,*&%&/('(1%*"5,&%)&%&F'")*(,>
/"7(6*(/;&C((&F9))())",1&*4(&C"*.%*"5,&
I
J
%,/&*4(&)5>6%''(/&C",Z%7&7(657/)3&%&65'>
)45+(/&*4%*&(%)*(7,&!"#$%&+%)&%&=%",&
)."6"/(=#(7);&@57&%,&%))())=(,*&58%Z"4%/")*&8%6*"5,)&%=5,1)*&*4(&7(#(')&
<7"%,&@")4=%,3&F-4(&0,(="()&58&5.7&0,(=$?3&5'"#)4$%6'/)17
L 8.#%!"##$%&''(3&
D(,*(7&857&*4(&C*./$&%,/&N()(%764&58&
P
/(=%,/)&#$&",*(7,%*"5,%'&5"'&65=2%>,"()&857&4%7=5,")%*"5,&58&7(1.'%*57$&%,/&*%M%*"5,&'%+);
Q
>*"()&25'"*"E.()&(,&!"#$(?3&9#:;#%<#,%2'$<#,%2;,;/2*$,%#-%<#%/*%3!<)-#""*$!#3&
S
X4%//.7"3&3'<#"$%=)+7*>%*%,-;<7%)$%?'/)-)1*/%<#:#/'?2#$-
U& -4(&/5=",%,*&65'5.7)&%,/&)$=#5')&58&
17((,3&'"14*&#'.(&+"*4&%&2%'=&*7((3&%,/&%&)*%7&57&*47((&4%'8&=55,);
V
@*,.)$4-'$%A;*-#"/7
GW >)"*"5,&%,/&*4(&7(1"=(?)&)*7%*(1$&*5&
8.#%=)+7*$%6*"*<'B
GG& -4(&BC&Y%*"5,%'&C(6.7"*$&C*7%*(1$&58&
Notes
Dow
nloa
ded
by [V
UB
Vrij
e U
nive
rsity
Bru
ssel
s] a
t 08:
01 0
6 Ju
ly 2
011
Saskia van Genugten
2%7*,(7)&+(7(&(,65.7%1(/&",&*4("7&
*47(%*&+%)&'56%'")(/3&*4(&B,"*(/&C*%*()&+5.'/&F4('2&(,).7(&*4%*&%&)*%*(&4%)&*4(&="'"*%7$3&'%+&(,8576(=(,*3&25'"*"6%'&
*4(&*%):?;&C*-)'$*/%D#1;")-7%D-"*-#47%'E%-.#%F$)-#<%D-*-#,%'E%G2#")1*3&C(2*(=#(7&
GI& BC&R(2%7*=(,*&58&C*%*(3&F<%6:175.,/&
GJ
&
.,/(7&<7.))(')&C25*'"14*?3&&H;"*1-):
4("7>'"#$%,>*475,(>#7.))(')>)25*'"14*>
GL
>
)=%''&",&,.=#(73&)5&4")&7(1"=(&+%)&27522(/&.2&#$&*7"#%'&%''"%,6()3&2%7>*"6.'%7'$&+"*4&*4(&A%1%7"4%&%,/&*4(&
*4(&(%)*&")&*4(&A").7%*%3&()2(6"%''$&
58&!5$%'*"()&*4%*&+"''&R(*(7=",(&G,.*"I%G/*J,*-
GP 8.#%!"##$%&''(F-4(&C5'.*"5,&*5&*4(&[75#'(=&58&
GQ
G$$;*)"#%<#%/KGE")I;#%<;%$'"<
GS& -4(7(&+%)&)"="'%7&.,6(7*%",*$&",&*4(&
/")*7"6*)&]+*/*<)7*-
>*7"6*)&],.*+)7*-
%=.,"6"2%'"*"()&]2*.*//*-+(7(&*5&#(&7.,&#$&*4(&<%)"6&[(52'(?)&D5,17())();
GU
58&%22%7(,*&45)*"'"*$3&)((&857&(M%=2'(&
GV
L/%?#-"'/)'%<#)%D#$;,,)>%D-*-)%F$)-)%#%!"*$%&"#-*4$*%)$%=)+)*%<*//K)$<)?#$<#$M*%*%
IW
*4(&<7"*")4&%17((/&*5&).22'$&,(+&
(=24%)")(/&*4%*&*4(&675+,&27",6(&+%)&,5*&*5&#(&",857=(/&%#5.*&*4(&/(%'&
%17((=(,*&+%)&*5&#(&/"7(6*'$&+"*4&*4(&
IG
G%N),-'"7%'E%3'<#"$%=)+7*&]D%=#7"/1(O&
Dow
nloa
ded
by [V
UB
Vrij
e U
nive
rsity
Bru
ssel
s] a
t 08:
01 0
6 Ju
ly 2
011
