96
-07,829879.8 4.03-07,82 O ,.74:3/314 4 473435:75480 4 474:8#0;4:943 ;079744190,94.,2089080.43/-,-09 3,908385,7,2039,7/4.:2039,7 O !,7,2039,7809902039 4 290/243,7. 4 -07,4;0732039 O %70,9808,,389,-84:982 O 43899:943,43,7. 4 408,,389;30#9 ;308,3.9431477:08-,80/;,  5,79.,, 99,.88:..0884374490/3,;30 ,:9479 O 4--08 4 0;0458,80.:,7147549.8 4 #4490/3903,9:7041:2,3-038-,80/3, .4397,.9 4 #994801570807;,943 4257808,:3;078,-,88941472,89,90 O  ,9:7,, 4 ,,825479,39/:9,825479,39,90 430/949084.093494:780;08 4 #4490/3.438.304:88 4 !72,.41/:94;0779 O -07,82.42081742,789,397,/9434.08:-;07983,9:7,,90,.3942,0 3,9:7,79890,.3 4 41907010703.0-3/4.094 4/  00/9490394 4/ 4--08 O 34;07320398-099079,34;0732039

Liberalism and Critics

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 1/96

-07,829879.8

4.03-07,82

O ,.74:3/314

4 473435:75480

4 474:8#0;4:943

;079744190,94.,2089080.43/-,-09

3,908385,7,2039,7/4.:2039,7

O !,7,2039,7809902039

4 290/243,7.

4 -07,4;0732039

O %70,9808,,389,-84:982

O 43899:943,43,7.4 408,,389;30#9

;308,3.9431477:08-,80/;,

 5,79.,,

99,.88:..0884374490/3,;30

,:9479

O 4--08

4 0;0458,80.:,7147549.8

4 #4490/3903,9:7041:2,3-038-,80/3,

.4397,.9

4 #994801570807;,943

4257808,:3;078,-,88941472,89,90

O  ,9:7,,

4 ,,825479,39/:9,825479,39,90

430/949084.093494:780;08

4 #4490/3.438.304:88

4 !72,.41/:94;0779

O -07,82.42081742,789,397,/9434.08:-;07983,9:7,,90,.3942,03,9:7,79890,.3

4 41907010703.0-3/4.0944/

 00/94903944/

4--08

O 34;07320398-099079,34;0732039

Page 2: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 2/96

4 :2,38-03894:9.42243,:9479-0.4208,89,9041,7

$4:943884.,.4397,.9;,/0854982038:708907941570807;,943

O 0;,9,3$9,90

4 -07,/0854982

7:20399,9300/8,8924/1.,94394-0.420-07,82

-07,:3/0789,3/34190740419,93

4 4-

4 2479,4/

70,90/-3,9:7,2,3147908,0419078,109,3/80.:79

4 %044/41,84.0989,99,48504509414:78-:94390-,8.0;00

84:/-07,901:1479089,90-0.,:809,4894-0,;0-07,82407890

 -,743,994050.91742549.8408,,389.,88.,549.,54845

4 %341,34;07320399,3344;073203939072841 7,6

%077-0938,55030384.09081,,5,79

!,:8-0,7:2039

4 44/,3/0;,708:-0.9;0

#0,9;82

%,9.,550,7844/844/

 00/,-4/94034904-0.9841/0870

%070834.4224344/

:990708,.42243-,/

O 0,741/0,9

4  00/4:7-4/0894034,9844/

4  0,9;0-,88419089,90

4 ;4/,3.041/0,9

!40734--08-0.4208243034.0

,804-9,3909380,39

43081:3/,2039,944.0

O 4.0,8.431.93;084389,90413,9:70

4 $9,9041 ,9:70,8,89,9041,7

0,089.,39089743089

,81479,9,5503

;072,31472801

4 #05708039,9;04;0732039

25479,396:,1.,943

!49.,705708039,9438,0

Page 3: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 3/96

O 0,..059,84:74390,.943841,34907-0.,:80047

8084:7,039

O :7807;,39807;08:8--034:72,8907

O 4:8,3.9430/9077:0

4 4::89,700/949077:0

O 0/4391009,87:0-0.,:800,700/949

%7,39889,705708039,9;04;0732039

O ,9

0.,:80010344:71:3/,2039,

390708970,09,90478057490.984:7

;08

$01570807;,943

O #94170;4:94334.0

4 %7,398,.9:,,970,994801570807;,943

O 408939,9,3858570107,-0-0.,:809,82470

0110.9;0,9570;0393.;,78

4.0

O $9,90413,9:70,3/455708843412,33,.;84.09-,97,39,7094-089574-028

4 %0.,0304:710-079,3/89,90

4  00/8,.43889039:891.,94314789,909,957490.985745079

O 8:8088/0-9944--08--03-473

4 #.,7/4407,3/90-0

4 ,390/94/08/0399

4 39070890/32,3549.8/1107039,390/90790,.3894-0.420549.,

:801:,3/8:..0881:

0;080,.

O 10-0795745079

4 4/,85745079,3/,-4717429,9-4/,85745079

4 4198/07;081742570807;,943

O -079,8,103.0942570807;,943

4 ,289,988890282470.438890394390-,884390 4--08,31:3/,2039,

 5702809,34--088

$0.43/%70,980414;0732039

Page 4: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 4/96

O #98,89014:3/,9434190549.,47/07419089,90

O 448,,389207

4 89,347801479057024/07397,/943

;307984138

4 $9,3/314790/423,39548943

O 5489;0/4.97309,9144830,9;0.796:041 207

O ,5907

4 %05:75480894,79.:,9090-,88147:89.0549.,5407

!49.,540785,7,209078,704:930/

#9412,3,89503,90841/0,9,3/08807503,90894

 570807;0574507910-079,3/89,90

!745079,3/2430570.0/04;0732039

44,9:2,3570549.,89:,9431474942,0,549.,430

O 0300/945,,990394394901443

4 #0,84383,9:7,,

4 #0,843874490/34:77994570807;,9430,,;0,7994570807;,943

,94:/-09020,3841/4384

4 74:533/;/:,801570807;,94394.70,909089,90

:99449078,780817424:77994801570807;,943

4 #0,8438:80/94801570807;,943

4 :77341,97:82

$01847349

O ,5907

4 $0.943

73,3,89,904150710.91700/42,3/06:,

 4430,8247054079,34907

!:75480414;07320399457490.94:71700/42

4 $0.943,;06:089438

$9,9041-0798349,89,9041.0380

,8,,413,9:70944;0739

O #0,8438,413,9:70

0.,30549078039/4083909390,4:743

 570807;,943

4:.,39;0:5

4 390473,89,900,;0,300.:9;0540794,.9,..47/39498,,3/

 5:38;4,9478

Page 5: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 5/96

%0,70574-028925,79,939089,90413,9:70039.420894

 :/3

,989089,903,9:7001474.0

703/075.9:7093.43;0303.08

%0147.0:894.420940907,3/1472,89,90

$0.943

4:.,370897,3,349071742,7234:,3/0993,705,7,9438

 574543,909490.720

O 41988-,884170,843

4:/0-070897,30/10070,:/0834:743.,808

O  4$0.943

397,387088390,413,9:70

O ;08-,349077:034990,3,9:70

90,413,9:709097,38708847.,3/0103/2801,80

 5:89949089,9041,74--08,3

$9,903,9:709,989:,9430709070834.42243:/0

40839,39948,9,9,34;07320398-099079,334

4;0732039

3901,.0,97,390,703,89,9041,7-.9097,398,970,994

4:7570807;,94380.943

$9,9041,7070147.08:80/94:970,843

#:078413,9438,703,89,90413,9:70

 44308,-4;09029480990279

 490;07.425,.989003/41,89,90413,9:70-:9349,419020,/394

,4;0732039

430880,250

4 $9,9041,7

408-,.94801570807;,943

$9,90413,9:70.,39703/9489,9041,7

%023:900350450,99,.:88039958

%0;08

O 39070890/357450793,3,77480380

$9,90413,9:703,84.090334.42243,:947985708039

4:30;07;0:5907994570807;04:7801

470.42243389,90413,9:709,33.;.84.09

Page 6: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 6/96

O !745079

4 $42050450,;024709,349078

4 4/40:891:306:,5745079

O  550,940,;03

Page 7: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 7/96

4.04393:0/

 550,940,;03

O 0390708,89:,94394:9,.422438:50747430,7994:/039089,9041

3,9:7089,9041,790708,3,550,940,;03,70947.,,550,4.0/40839-00;0

9,9947220/,90

,5907

O :891.,943415745079/11:80890903843-090037.,3/544707

O 430570.0.0/08.;,3/549.,84.09

O !,,9903943944/8740,3/13,9:70850391:47349

O :2,3-03,857450793843507843

4 !7450793.:/0890,-474198-4/

4 10,3/90-07994/85480414:7-4/,84:.4480

4 ,-47904741

30349230230

4 4:.,303.4809381742:3/07,9.43/9438

190708034:1470;07430080

$ 54,0574;8480.9435

O ,3841548808843-,80/43,3473,,.941,-47

O 14:,89090807084:7.04:,70,901,3/70202-074:.,3,901

O #:08940,903.43;03.08 9089,90413,9:70849/40839/0;4;03949089,9041,7

O $0.9434/,;09047/907,943,,3/3/:8974:8

4 %0-033341:306:,57;,905745079

4 %4:9047/,8-003;03:83.4224383.04:7-4/08,704:7574507908

90,70/11070390;08417,943,93/:89:74:83088.2942:.,-47

0.,3574/:.0

O !48808438070-4:3/:59907,943,:80

O 430098417/41854,0574;84

4 3;039434124303.70,80/90;,:041938

4

O :2,3,-47058:82574;0,93,9:70574;/08

O &3.:9;,90/,3/,8,,890854,0**29:891907,943,,3/3/:897,

O :2,3-0389,.9.43803994:306:,5745079039089,790/:832430

O 4.08570;039370;4:948395745079,3/

O 99,.397,/943,03/0774080394.20894,-47

O 430,484:944,7/938 094:941854,0574;84

4 4089094:4:9419044/034:574;84

Page 8: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 8/96

O %0:80414:7-7,38,3/,3/8942,0:2,310-09907:2,3030754079,9-738

14791742900,79147:2,3-038

O ,3/9,3-0.42088.,7.0-0.,:8092430:,;070,90754880438,3/

O $94741306:,9,3/57;,905745079

O !:754808414;073203914757490.943415745079

4 290/4;0732039

290/-1:3/,2039,5:7547809457490.94:7798

O #94170;4:943

4 .,997,33

,5907

O !,9073,!407

4 4.:8084370,9438-090035,70398,3/./703:8-,3/8,3/;08

25,808798.438039,3/.425,.9831,2,70,943858,3//:9

7;3.470573.5083941,210

039489457,83/80390/8,;070,843

4 !

4 70.94334929,943

4 ,8290/-98807;.049.4224344/

4 4;03209303,3.08-079-7024;3903.43;03.08419089,90413,9:70

,5907

O $4.09,3/4;0732039

4 !440/5407-09907,48:894;0,3/00.:09090,413,9:70

O !49.,84.09

4 #0833,9:7,540794.422:39,3/90.422:39-2,479/0./043,

1472414;0732039

O ;84.09

4  4989,90413,9:70-0.,:8090708842043094:/0

4

O 08,9;054078572,7,3/:92,90708/083202-0784184.09

O 901472,9434184.0907084;094/0./0-2,479

O 0,3/;/:,,;08420847941540739089,90413,9:70,3/;09:59403907

84.09,3/45089,984.09.,3-089.44809008,9;0

Page 9: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 9/96

O 43899:943,243,7.

4  3,85407-0.,:8090504505:999070

5

O 0990757490.957450799409079,:/0

570;0

.0:09;0540788:-47/3,909408,9;0

O 4.00;0743084:9419089,90413,9:70

O 4--080.:09;08389,90413,9:70,3/907014704:94190,

5

O 08,9;05407

4 3010472,3

 5

O 89,.98089,-8308,9;05407

O 3899:943,3897:20398

O 08,9;05407.,394;078905-4:3/84795:9898013,89,9041,7

4 4;0732039870-03,,3899050450

O !74507983,03,-0

4  4430.,39,04:7574507947-079

O %40;8

4 $9,90413,9:703.43;03.08

4 %733,7

47809,389,90413,9:70

O 50.9438

4 $4/078

4 %,08

092,90

4309457490.94:75745079

5

O 013943

O .:09;094-,,3.00;0793

O ,7,3/!0,.00,:08,3/,3.00.:09;0,3/10/07,5407

Page 10: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 10/96

5

O 089,9;088:57020

O #0508039850450974:.,39047

O 4;0372093480897:89-0.,:8090/43902

,9,550389470;4:9438

O !407408945045043423,90/902

O

5

O !0747,9;0794100.:9;094,.9

4 !:-.44/94:9,7:0

O $4209208,30.:09;0,894,.9,,38990,47070890,88039 %0,8

0307,43080198,

4 079,3242039807030.08892,-0,70,93

O 8:08989,99070,70242039807090708,99:/01470.0:09;094,.9

4  -47/073439733,784209208

5

039054079,9-0,78308,9;0/4083957490.95745079-0385:950450389,9041,79

 50450 42470:/0,3/.42243,89,0413,9:70,3/89,9041,7

808,330;9,-,550347,94:994,5503

O 4.08;3,/;.0947:078

4 43949441,74:78,2,47941902/010.93

O #99470;4:943

Page 11: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 11/96

,3970,/3

390.422438,3982,-097:039047-:99/408349,55357,.9.0

#:08,70.438/070/,904703907:08,700307,,3/.,3/08.7-0,89:,943,3/.,3570992:.

8,980,/894984784209309

!7,.9.0,.94389,919:3/079047082,-0

 00/,90729439047,3/57,.9.0300/94-0,-094:/0,3/:3/0789,3/03907:08,55,3/

0390/439

%0472,-03.425090,3/.,3-0.425090/-1:9:70050720398,3/050703.081742504504

.43/:.9902,3/050703.0902

039047839,55.,-0980390708349034:9047.,3:80050703.094,//94904734

4308,3050794:.,39,;0050703.08,3/3499794.,90470902479794.420:59,

9047

04:/2,01:3415045048,8420932,088038039047-:99/40839474:9370,

10

9047..43.07384-0.9841507.094386:90/11070391742430.8:.4-0.98,70

7057080390/43974:.43.05989080.43/74:52,088038043,4.,2039,0;0-:992,-0

25488-014790294-0;03$420920089,80259/0,89,9,70.425090:3:801:475,79,

,55.,-0

%04714:3/0/43,.43.05941/:9,347708,-4:9900259/0,94190.43.059.425090

/8,550,74:/392,080380942,0147:894897;0147,3050703.09,90.,39.70,9010,70

43-90/0,9,9947839047-:93493,.9:,57,.9.0 0;09442:..70/9147

050703.0/8574;3,9047,3074:810/49839070,2841,,3/247,9-.39080

,70,8,57,.9.08;,:08/0503/0394398,55745,9030889490904798-,80/43

%700/1107039,999:/0854;

O ,341,11,78

O $9,908203

O ,3419047/

&390/3,99,.390,.,/02.35:993390.,88874442,3/7024;32174270,9

#0,943854190479457,.9.0

O 47,930307,

4 #0,7/949001,70410,.3/;/:,2,3

Page 12: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 12/96

O !49.8

4 #0,7/949001,70419089,90

O 4824549.,85070

4 #0,7/949001,704190:2,37,.0

4 01,70412,33/3.70,833,8070841/0;045203980903/3394,

1:9:70,08

,38 1700/42,8,:2,3-03,8,573.5014790.43899:94341,.422430,9.,3-00570880/

39014431472:, 4430.,3.42502094-0,553,..47/,3.098.43.059434190

01,7041490781470,.2,8008,5530883,90;07,08008198443,80/408349

31730:543901700/424149078945:78:0,82,703/..,3-070.43.0/9901700/4241

0;0743008093,47,-00307,,002:89,..47/9449078908,2079,800348

28014;073203929-0089,-80/4390573.5041-030;403.094,7/8905045009,9

41,1,90794,7/88./703&3/078:., 5,9073,4;0732039 908:-0.98,822,9:70./703

4.,3349/893:8,9897::801:47,721:9490280;084:/-04-0/94-0,;05:70

 5,88;0,3/9470:54390:/203941900,/4189,90,8944904:994-0,55,3/:543

83/308833907,553088,9, $:.,4;073203989070,9089.43.0;,-0/0854982

0,.43899:943.8:8503/890039701700/4241988:-0.984903.01479,;034798

,9840;07%043.43.0;,-04;07320391472034,70.,5,-041548808837980;03190

7:078-030;40398349, 5,9073, -:9, 5,9749.4;0732039 5,9749.,999:/08430070

0;0743039089,903490.0593980,/70,7/890.422430,9,8,2,9073,42-4790,3/

,8905,9073,74:3/1742.02801857,3,3/.02:890,;0948/08.03/,398,8,

970,8:70/50/0,.70,7/82801,8,:9470/9457490.9907984190.422430,9-,841

900307,-:9349948:-299948507843,:80,9843,-84:9050,8:70 %87941

1700/42-0438940,.202-074190.422430,9,8,:2,3-033841,7,80,.8,-03

.,5,-04154880883798

7890843,,3894--08

4397,.9708:933,.;.4389:943,707,70 %070,7082,73147294490784.,.4397,.98390

803809,990,;0,,4.422430,989043:3430709003/89801,3/070,

70,943858,702,70/-98/:9

#941203,:3/07,89,990.,3-0;03,990,70/:0,3/-080.:70/,,839,99,.#98

,709389,9203098174283907,.94394907:2,3-038,3/,8349394/499003/

.,203,;0-3,9:70,.0;3,553088#98,70897.943430;0743081700/42849.,3

,7243090;074300808,82,0985488-0944;.4389:9430;07430.407.;0,8

Page 13: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 13/96

 -:9709,30307,1700/42,5530888/11070391470;07430,3/8:.907.,3349-05:9:3/07

,47,72430/90;07430

5747573.508

%0 1700/42410;07202-074184.09,8, :2,3-03

%006:,9410,.9,9049078,8, 8:-0.9

%03/0503/03.0410,.202-0741,.422430,9,8, .903

,88:-0.9

O $:-0.98,;079841.407.434;070,.4907-:9907:07800259-0.,:80900,/1

0,88:-0.994.407.43414907890304:/344307-00,/4189,90

O 0,70,806:,,80,70:306:,34:70,308808,3/8970398-:90,70,:306:,

3174394190,

O  4430.,3;0:5907798:308890.4229,.720

O ! 584:/,;006:,455749:390894/4907-089

O !:-.79808,9439,9.4317289490/0,9,91700/428.,3.4089,3/8-,.0/:5

 -55

4 ;89,90

O  4,8070/957;0003,.422430,9-.34430,8.439744;07907-79

O  40,97,38,.9434385,79479,941,3430080.,32,02.0,8094-0843

2,3

O ,558,574/:.941.7.:289,3.04:743249;,943

O 3490;07430.,32,0,8-:90;07430,894144902

O ,798/0503/43/:9

O  5:-.574-9438,82

O ,33//;/:,.,3908,90,.422430,9-.907088,,8,9903:89.0307039

39070-.55-031,;474190280;08/013904.031:03.0

4 300/06:,9:3941,202-0784184.09

O  -,8.,.42081742,:390/50450

4 473,.4397,.9

O  554.,3;490

4 4:300/94-04:7432,8907

4 2,479;493

 -038,9810/92,479;493802-0//0/390473,.4397,.9

O 0.,39,88:209,9983,9430898,5503-.8947,8398439,809

O  -:90.,389:80900307,/0,894.70,90,-099074;0732039

O 908941791:3088

O .903801,708901789,2414;9

Page 14: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 14/96

O ,553088.,39-090-,88414;0732039

O 1700/421700/42945:78:0,5530883,0,,

O ,899/4,2147,553088,70,20,3841038:739008903.0419089,90,3/,7043

:59490/8.7094341900,/4189,90

O //39:3/0789,3/,39317429008,947439477005038-0

O .422430,92:89,;0147.094-,.:5907:08

O 70;4:9438349,799,99050450,;0408,,3894.0

4 989024895:38,-0.720390.422430,9

O 0;0310,/4189,908,97,3990.,39709,,90

O 90/439,;0,37994:/0490.4389:94384:/-0,/289070/

O 794130.0889839,55.,-0

%0435488-0,380789,990.,3/43493-:94-0 470,70349.43.0730/0709,3

,553088.908:-0.929050.994/07;01742903899:943847,/23897,9434190

.422430,9-:9572,7990798.4:/9070--080.:70/1470;07430 3/988

90089573.501742.,2,2870,939490.422430,92:89-03,3/..,3349

 -06:,10/-,34907573.508 40307,;,/573.504108,943.,3-0-,80/43,553088

47-4990.:77039.7.:289,3.08,3/90.431.93,3/;,7,-0:8438,894,9,553088

8,3/34430.,35708.7-0944907849084:/,99,392,0,10/573.50825488-084

9,9,553088,430.,330;07-0,8:9,-0573.504108,943 :950450,70170094/4,990

,8439/40839;4,90901700/4241490755

#:078.,32,0,89,9,70-,80/43,553088190,70.43/:.;09008903.0419084.094;9

09.3490747/8905407419089,90 $9,,90(945:990,3940110.98,84 770889-0,3/34

791:089,-80/.422430,9.,308994:9,147.041983/948:557088,39073,

70889,3.0478:.70889,3.04:/-0/.9,90/-,2,2.19-0.,200307,4://08974

9040.;.43899:943,3/5:9,303/94904389,90 :89,3/(3.203.,35488088798

%070834.,8:830.0889,980.059070/:9080,3,-84:90/:9,3/,34907.40;07

 570883830;0790088 70,9;0.420394.431.947389,3.0929-030.088,7147842043094

 -097,84204300800;03190770,943850709,9411,907,3/843347/0794570807;09089,90

1742.,9,897450%8570807;,943419089,9017420;8,3,-84:90/:9090570807;,9434190

3/;/:,82070,70,9;0/:909,550843108349:941,.720,,3899089,90 %0

178950784329/034:3.09080.43/9490,:947908990:92489:333088.42500/43

 -247,30.0889

08,89,9504509,9,/;4.,9014750450949,070;03043907:070390;4,9090.4397,.9

,70743-.,900990573.5041,5530889431:03.0:/02039-9070834574419,984.,

.4397,.908988434147.0.,3-0,550/94907:07-.04:/344307-00,/4189,90  4

.43899:9434:/9050450944;07974904;0732039-0.,:80904;9-,888390.4389:94384

Page 15: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 15/96

4;079743904;07320394:/-04;07974390.43899:943,849088:04144:/-0,

1,7:/040;070/4088,9,9.9038/4,;0.079,3:3,03,-0798;80,/84189,908 408

;84--0848,89,98:-0.98/439,;09080798

08,89,9901700/42419050394.796:0907:0794/38:.31472,9438:79390

0,/4189,90-:908,8990,5574;,41907:0784/408399,94,,389,90:898,/

 ,90;07,50450.,334925480:5439801.,3349-025480/:5439-9008,9470907

98.0,79,9,3473,.4397,.9419050450.089,-80/8:.,,4:/39801-03:,3/

;4/14794:/.431.9990,554390/,2,3/5:75480 08922:3:3/0.0(412,33/

%:8,,41983/.,3349-070,7/0/,890,.9:,4190243,7.9442.4:3907

705708039,94382,,..47/3-02,/0 3,.,80840;07070908:5702008,943//

30;0790088,/4598:.20,8:70894:/-0507288-0945,880307,,3/5:-.:/020398:543

902-:930;079441107,3;07-,47,.9;070889,3.0

 -0/03.0,3/1700/424,3/3,3/ !0450,70170094/4,990,70-:9,844-0/03.0

 -.90300/94800.407.43,8,1:30.088,7

,98300/0/147,549.,.43899:94357,.9.0903/894-5,88904739889:,943 %070,843

1479889,9,0, 0809.0(.43899:943414389,3/37,/:,2,089050450,..:89420/

94:/3-49907,553088,3/907798390728419050,.01:  89,9:86:443;07809/408349

03.4:7,090294;,:090089389,9041,11,783909419480.43.059841,553088,3/79

.70,843574;/08 97,9072,08902570107985,88;089,90 :89,3/(9490/,3074:89,841

443147,-099074309:8-0,734:9908,3. 554.7,90894/58.,389470202-07

:/.:2,3.05805072039:2507.:48:2 %:8,.43899:9438.,;0,890/147,8:11.039

43920,90;079073,/06:,.08,3/;,7,9438574/:.0908,20708:99050450702,3.439039

9,990,;01090701470.438/079001,704190504509047834931,.9;,/147

0;0793/0503/8:54357,.9.0/07;0/1742050703.0

:970,843574;/08,.43.059.0057088-9047/8  549.,79$9,,9870.9(3/98

.43.059,8-3/3147.0147:2,3-0384.40893,89,9041,39,4382574/:.0/-907

3,9:7,1700/42849,99,8,34-0.9;057,.9.,70,9770850.9;0419044/4792,574/:.0

1479080.,343-0343-050703.0 %:898-,80/43,5747 573.508147050703.0.,3349

 574;/0340/041,9879,3/90708, 904741549.,7994.57,.9.02:89.431472

 -014709.,3-0;,/

%0434-0.943..,3-07,80/,,3899889,9,94:203,;0390723/890/0,41

9079894.90,7003990/907397,.9,-988:.9,990,703.,5,-0,3/:347941

 -03970,90/,8907798/02,3/849,990.,3,3/4:994-0059:3/07.43974-,8:57020

 5407,.935:701742050/03.:998.4:38041/08507,943 8,942479,020,389,983.0

9070834,550,9479-:94394147.090504502,90280;0870847994147.0,3/9:82,0

0;070,0809.0(.43899:943380.:70 1907083493..422,3/8220/,9070850.9

Page 16: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 16/96

974:70,8438:.,890-,8.798412,3,8038.0370.9(3431:03.0.,3570;,:543

2,38,7-97,7,3/70897,38(1700/42 :91-49-030;403.0,3/79850,4:934:/

94308:2,33,9:70349574;0944/0-,80/94890394907;4.0970850.9

 ,3982,3/0,8

!4845,8796:0

O  ,39897002,47;4:208,7003990/ .796:08,3/8039705484514.:80843

,5538.79.,2094/9454845.,574-028 %0.4770.92094/354845

,..47/394 ,39834994850.:,9043903,9:70419047/,74:3/:8-:9945071472,

.796:0414:72039,1,.:9083;089,93,90.,334/01339029841

340/0,3//09072334902039,574.08808-.02,080380419047/

,110.9,9034%8.,3032094/7057080398,9 ,39.,8,45073.,3

70;4:943354845:89,845073.:89:730/,897434243980,/390890039

.039:7-,7:39,9908:3349900,79890.03907419084,788902  ,399:738

 5484543980,/-,7:39,9013/90,38078944:754845.,574-028

3,30,23,943414:72039,1,.:9087,9079,33209,58.,850.:,943,-4:990

:3;0780,74:3/:8305,79419870;4:9438908:089439,99023/8349,5,88;0

70.05947-:99,99,.9;08,5084:7507.059434170,9 349078,0307,819.

702,389498/,1742209,58.894,7/05890244 %,98906:0894341,9

70,9,.9:,.43889841,8-0.420088.0397,9,3906:0894341,90.,334

,-4:970,9,3/40.,3349

%0!484541%7,38.03/039,/0,82

O  ,398025,8843907404:72039,1,.:9085,38,534:7050703.02508,

8,75/893.943-09003 5034203,,3/34:203, 4:203,,70938390280;08

9070,99,908983/0503/039414:723/070,85034203,,70,550,7,3.0870,9

,84:723/2,0880380419..47/394 ,390.,330;07349.079,39,98

4:99070$3.0,4:7340/0419009073,47/819070/974:4:72039,

1,.:9080.,334439047/9,94:723/5708039894:8 %,98,4:7340/0

843340/0415034203,,3/02:89,..0599,934:203,,701:3/,2039,

:334,-0 /0,828903,20;039490;,74:8897,3/841548459,9.,290

47/82,/0:5572,7412039,/0,83494158.,938  ,39/1107817422,3

/0,89839,90/408349/039008903.041,309073,70,9,3//4083490;0393

9,9/0,8,7024701:3/,2039,9,393840;070,7:089,90.,330;0797,38.03/

9029,9438,3/90.43909:,,943574;/0/-4:723/8849,9904370,90

0;073489070,9415034203,

Page 17: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 17/96

%0,90474190$3909.!747

O  ,39307981742:2090574-024140.,3310730.088,7,3/:3;078,97:98

1742050703.003,050703.08-983,9:70.4393039,3/5,79.:,7 0,.9:,

050703.03/;/:,898,3/84:3/8,3/84430.,3349050703.0,58.,,47

,70,94341.,:80,3/0110.9$410.,3349800820470,7.,:8,9434.,303107

9,984200;0398.,:8049078 ,3957,808986:0894324700307,,8906:0894341

483909.,5747340/085488-0 %,984.,30349389,9,70

30.088,7,3/:3;078,-:93498010;/03947/013943,  ,3983034:884:94389,9

83909.,5747340/085488-0-0.,:804:72039,1,.:90847,30050703.0

,..47/394.079,3.,904708849,99080.,904708-0.42030.088,7,3/:3;078,

10,9:708414:7050703.047389,3.00/434913/.,:8,94333,9:70842:.,80

.,3349349 13/.,:8,94333,9:70 98,10,9:704190,4:723/82,0803804170,9

9,90507.0;0.,:808,3/0110.980;07070,947 47 ,3990390.,90474190

83909.,574789009405,3340,38:-89,39;0340/0,-4:990

47/

043944.,9.8

O 9.,9047898.,3-074:/;/0/39494.,25894804.438/07,3,.943247,

472247,/0503/34390249;0-03/9,3/94804.438/07,3,.943247,47

2247,/0503/34390.43806:03.089574/:.08  ,398172390147207.,25

2,32,/043944897,9079,3,.43806:039,89039.42089409.8 %047/

/043944/07;0817429070074498/043/:9,3/4488.03.0 ,39,7:089,9

0,708:-0.994247,:/2039-0.,:800,70,-094/0-07,90,3/;070,84381474:7

,.943884247,:/203984:/-0/70.90/,94:770,8438147,.93 00.,3,3/

84:/9,08420.,7094038:709,94:7,.9438574/:.044/.43806:03.0890

.43806:03.08414:7,.9438,7034990280;088:-0.9944:770,843844:770,8438349

1:7085438-014790.43806:03.084190,.9438903/47808#0,843.,343-00/

7085438-014703/4783.079,3,.9438,3/84984390,.9438,3/90249;08-03/

9029,9,70450394247,:/2039

%09.841:94342

O ;0790474109.82:89;0,3,380794906:08943 7080,9%,9802:89

 -0,-09405,344/844/,3/-,/8-,/789,38,380790 7080,9

6:08943990970,94109073,/,23,9430 &99,7,38,38079,983.0,553088

89070,908944/-,/,.9438574/:.0:3,553088,3/:3,5530888-,/3,3/419801

Page 18: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 18/96

 ,39-.4397,89,7:089,983.070,84389084:7.041247,944/3088,3/-,/3088

84:/-0/.9,90/-70,843%4,.9-,/,..47/394 ,39894;4,90902,28,/

4:9-430870,84347941472:,902,289,9430.4:/349.43889039,8:3;078,

,83490747/82247,98,14724177,943,9-,/3088708:981742;4,9390

,84170,843..47/394 ,394:77,943,98,92,08:8:2,384-,.93

77,943,,3/03.02247,0,84.425742804:7:2,39  ,398,38079490

6:089437080,989,90/2384:780;08,87,943,:2,3-038-,.93

2247,3--0,;37,943,/40844:780;0894-0,:943424:8-0383

.4397441905,88438,3/,55099089,9290,/:894,.9,,3894:7-09907:/2039

Page 19: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 19/96

,39

$059

4389:943,243,7..,3-.438890399-07,9  ,39870,954850741:3;078,:2,3

/39,3//339,8,17,204741798 $8902,9. ,39843/0103/904.03,3889020

8,89,990788902-,80/43207.073,7247,9  ,398439400;,901700/423949084:7.041

:2,3/39,9/408020,3-:2,3/39

7014;07;041 ,39,354845

O !704..:5,94399908:11.03970,843

O $8902,9.,7.090.943.

O ,-,80/:3/0789,3/341903,9:7,47/,3/5599490:2,347/

%70070,9.796:08

O !:7070,843

4 45073.,370;4:943419023/

O !7,9.,70,843

O :/02039

O 3903,9:7,47/90708341700-0.,:8098/0907230/-:90-00;0831700

O 09,58.841247,8

4 3,9902594905,3/90.,9074.,2507,9;0394,8890241,,3/09.8

O 47,,.9/4304:941/:9,3//430147,573.50

4 4:09842093174243089

4 ,9844/14720207.03,7247,9-:998349,,890.,809  ,399

83494,94/4.079,3938-0.,:8090,70743349.43806:03.08-,80/

O :891,82,788902944.043,/1107039-,88

O  -84:90247,9

O $,89,94.08207.,7307247,9

4 $018308884:4:/03907,,.425,.9

47,98,.93,..47/39490573.5041/:9

O 04:994970,94907:2,38,803/834920,38

4 0.,:8090,70.,5,-014247,-0,;47

4 0-.4201700-,.93247,

4 17003,/09072389.3,9:7,47/

O 31:03.0/-74880,:30307,

O -07,904789419047

4 :7084394,99,.9047,3/9031:03.041904743549.,938

%077-00110.943,98904743549.8

Page 20: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 20/96

O #05:-.,34;0732039,3/0;0347/4;0732039

4 0,70;350,.0974:,

,,2438989,9088

8,55033,804

4  ,39,3989389,94;07320398,303/

O %0/0,41:39;078,89478799033,,9039,9;0,

O :2,38

4 0;045:2,3.,5,.908974:,574.08841749

O $ 50.08,;0,303/94,7/898/0;0453

4 3/8:3;078,039032039

4 4;394,7/8:2,33/3,9:7,03/42039

O $01570807;,9438,3,23,25:80

O 700/427,943,9,3/247,9,708-9700

O 0050/.70,909080/0,8

4 024.7,9.50,.09047

4 !7;0341798

O %03843-090039079,3/44/57;008794;079044/

O 9.039:7025,80/70,843

O %07088,44/9,9870,90/94247,573.5089,9,7090/944:7/005/39,8:2,38

O ,:8,943,3/70,843

4 0/09072304:703/8

O 0,70.7,394,7/8,-07,17,2047417994;01700/42894559,9,7003/8

4 4;073203984:/053/;/:,8/0;04590770,843

O 47 ,399003/84:/-003:2,38,70170094/0;0459072039,1,.:9,908

O 47,,8.,31700:8174258.,,

O 110703.0-247,9,3/549.843904907-4941908013/907:891.,943398

.,9047.,2507,9;0

O 11070308-09003247,9,3/549.8

4 !49.8

4 80,1700/4225479,39147 ,39

%497:-017004:.,39-0.4078.0/

,970,9038.407843

O /439.,70,-4:970,843.,70,-4:990,.943

O /40839.,70,-4:9908:-0.9;074:3/

47,9/028,3/89,94:,.9147908,01474144/

4709.,-0,;47706:70843094,.9433903943

Page 21: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 21/96

O .,39.407.0247,-0,;47

O 4;91700/42942,0504505488-0942,09070

/0.8438

$2,7094.04:.,39.4070.01700/42

O 47,9,8,;,:0394419801

O 700/42247,9,3/39902039

4 &3;07808/09072389.

4 00;0831700

4 #0,843058:8,..088903,9:7041247,,

4 3.0013/90,7017007,943,

4 3903203980893,4;07320399,9,4890294-0247,1700

O #989070897.943410;0743083/;/:,1700/429457490.90;07430806:,

17,20471700/42

O #94170;4:943/0243897,908,.4170850.9147,

4 89400;,908420934;078420939,9,8247,4-,943

4 47,/:9944-0,

O  ,3974498888902370850.9147247,,

O %0,0,70,3/90,084:/-0

O 3939,90058:8174290,730,.071422-942-85407 4--08

O :2,38,70-4984.,,3/,84.,

4 84.,-9.,30,/9484.,,-9,8,0

4 071,.:908/0;0454;7920,3/,48:8940;039:,-003902039

O ,34:805,7,90907917429044/

4 084:.,3

O ,7/94/8574;098/0,41,5747088;084.09

4  ,399389,99070,70842070,8438944509,90,7024;3940907

,3.4397-:9094-733-,-4:9,70:,784.09

4 &945,3-:9834989:5/

O 390320394:/-09014:783414:72039,.,5,.9908

4  4939039032039,0-:9,3,041039032039

O #0.4;073904/07;041907008

Page 22: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 22/96

,394393:0/

$059

O 3/;/:,,398,553088-:998/11070391742/:9.25479,39147  ,39190708,

/110703.0-09003/:9,3/,5530880,70-4:3/94.4480/:9-,.93247,0

,7047941,553088

O #0,7/147,.93247,

4 :9,9,-4:9050.9438

.9247,70,7/088

O 700/42890908903/41:2,3-038

!7,.9.0,8706:739047

:/2039

O 8,-7/0-090039047,3/57,.9.0

4 %341,:/0

O $00,9,.7.:289,3.0/02,3/847800491983940307,573.508

O !,0

4 ;/08088,3949700088,8

4 #010703.094-:70

$,8549.,/0.8438,702,/017425,79.:,78

O ,341,11,7889,908203,3/2,3419047/

4 11070390;0841,3,88

O ":0894341,55.,-9

4  ,39.,3-09907,79.:,9090573.508.549.,38,.9

O !7,.9.03147239047904731472357,.9.0

O $9084:/-099079,3908

4 /0,8233070393/43907993

4 439044/93;87993

,/,/:07,,71,70

O ,30;07430,700439079093

4 ,9047.,2507,9;0

&3;078,573.50

O 47,.,793 ,39

O 9949047/

O !73.508,7090-,8841904708

O 47,941,.9438-,80/4390/0,41:3;078,9

4 04190334,94:7/:98

4 42243247,17,20479,9034

Page 23: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 23/96

O ,39.407.0842043094/4842093

4 4:.,39147.0247,9

.93,..47/3949,9/:94:/9,04:941700/42(1700/428-,80/

43,:94342

%4-0,:943424:84:/-0,.93:5439080247,8

O 4:,;0901700/4294-0,,7-:99/4083920,34:,70247,30,9;01700/42

4 8420,389,94:,703997:1700

O !,948,850450,70,8,;094907/08708

4 %07088420933:2,389,9.,370:,904070;0/08708147908,041

0747/075:754808

4 0,701700030,.9,..47/39490800747/075:754808

0.4201700-2,890739029484200703/

4 4.0,70,,-4:9/0870,3/8,9813902

43/9438418,981,.943841/0870

O  ,39703974/:.0890800744/8

4 700/4220,3890,-994.4480247,94;07,553088471003

O !74-02,9.9805,7,94341,553088,3//:9

O 4:84:/3905-0.,:804:,39944:84:/05902-0.,:809890799394

/4

4 $,;094/:981700/42147 ,39

4 700/428,/0703.094,7,943,,94;04:7801

O 70394:7897430898038041/:90894504500/434

O ,.:,9438094/090723090-0894:9.420

O 3,97:247,84.09504504:/39,44:71,294-08:11073

4 %70,9349078,803/8349,820,38

O #94170;4:94334.0,3/:9944-03  ,39

4 #0,84381479809394900,79147907:891.,9438147908,2017,2047

4.00,;0,8018390708939089,909044/0039070/9089,90

147,70349-0370,0/9030,;0907944;07974902

1:3/,2039,44/390708979

 ,399070,8430.420940907384.09834914757490.9434144/85

349942,050450902,55-:994038:7090708903.05

70850.9147247,,.,3000;,90394,247,573.5090;4,94341

,

,890/940744/3:874490/34:7,-994,.088,247,70,2

 -0.4201700,3/,:943424:889,9084:/-0,-4:970,39007

Page 24: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 24/96

.:2,3.,5,.930,9;01700/42894,44:94,.9247,0/:.,943

,3/03903203984:/.4397-:90944:-0.4232470247,

17,20478051:1479803/

;07933 ,398-,80/43,840.,3900;,9090;4,94341,

4:/:8919089,90413,9:70

":08943,98 ,398.70,94389474/4080903/3994984093

O

Page 25: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 25/96

:70

$05989

&83,494170947.,3/5402.8

,8089:/08

'072:.,574503941-07970:,90/-,34984204304:80890:370897,30/:80415407

870,9.796:041-07,8289,990,/894549.,,-:80-4

,890747,947:2,3.,33434,/0/94905803,0/3549.8974:94:990.4:78041810'072:.

,,38990,.,/02.2,3,3/209,58.,850.:,9438,84,904789;078:85.4:8,-4:94908034;08

/4.973084179843.0900390790549.,47/,3/49025,.99

O 782,3

4 ,8.,94.908

4 ,7/943410,8,.,94.825,9078

!49.,57:/039849,82:90

4  49:3825,909.9445570880/74:58

O 08590901,.99,908,,3899070;4:94308,,3890,-:8054070,8825,909.94

90.443898

O :704:/,7009 ,399,957,.9.08314720/-9047-:9349.431/039,-4:990478

0110.9

4 0.,3.43/023,-4:99070;4:943317,3.0-,80/43/09,8

O !7,.9.,549.,2,3

O 8570/.9438,70-4:7304:94190703.#0;4:9:43

4 080089047800.088084190703.70;-0147090,55030/

&36:0,-994800070938,7043

43909

O 4898:-89,39;0549.,88:08418/,

4 443080707:3-3803902038490,/,79949,90280;08

470:2,30;843,-4:9,938.4430884:/-0

.:9:70411700/429490.44308940903/.443,,03.08

O $:5:780/2,3-700.9390703.70;

O 3/,

4 ,390/94250,.,7703,8938-0.,:800,8,-:8385407

O ,89070;4:943,708:94190039032039,8039203925.9370;

O !73.5089,970;4:943,7081440/070.47748;04189,-0549.,47/078/089748.0.894

,-:8;05407

4 !7;0341,.079,33/41-079:3/07230890490744/8

Page 26: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 26/96

O %4,9090398,4.0303

O 43807;341-0793;4;08:835,79.:,7549.,2094/8

O %,8,-4:9382,3-0.,:804:.,399,,-4:99080938

O 7/07,3/97,36:9,70:2,344/8

4 %7:89,3/-079,70944

O $059.,417034;,94384.0943,3/0,82

O 494150450,7:09,9083.43889039

O ..:80/43-03908/041904/0,9090

4 !49.,5484507410390203

O 0103/397430,3/,9,7

4 4389:943,243,7.

O %0/0;8390/09,8

O ,9,70900110.983,.9:,549.,1041.079,3549.,/4.97308

O #982,-0/089740/-90703.70;4:9439/089748-079,80,80;07490744/

4 ,9/408-:70-00;03798-07908

4 ,9,709057,.9.,90470843549.8

4  3;,00.90/

47748;041,397,/943,1472417:0

%38,704,,8,43,890,703,..47/,3.0990,

907092,90,841/43938

34724:870;0703.04197,/943

O #0;4:943,8,7084797,9;0349,-,389,90

4 84:/070850.9842093:89-0.,:8098

%7,/943825479,39

O %90825479,39

O ,974:3/80/0103/39038.43899:943

O 472825479,39

4 09907

4 79394,4:3703.203

4 ,9,7090,/;,39,0841:83099071472,9

4 380/:.,94341,4:3703.203

4  49,.933,1472,.425,.9

4 03.0,79,90/40839850,,,38990384;0732039

4 4;9,90/-,80380415745079

O !,00570/.98 ,540,3

4 0,308841,:9479

Page 27: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 27/96

-0790,/397,331742,72-0.,:800.43974890147.0

O $ 50.:,9;0,3/04209070.933,70-,/

4 08974,347,3.3088

O !

4 7.:289,3.08;0370,9940;07549.,573.5098/89::83.447,3/980110.9

O !7,9.,0110.98,92,0893844/

4 11070391742,39-0.,:809044/8,99047908:88

O !70:/.0/70,9089445343

4 #014:3/45343,3/5:9437,943,17,204737,3.0

O ,391,39497,5415,79.:,78-0.,:8090,70573.5089,9.,3,559424709,343089:,943

4  ,39

O !49.,57:/030,3/:/02039890-089549.,8147-:70

4 50703.0,890-,88

O ,98,55033317,3.0890574/:.9419080/0,80390737,3.0

O %038349092,901903834900.90/

4 0897:.9;041,34;07320399,98349,300.9;04;0732039

4 %,9,..:80890341-03,97,39

O :705

4 8-079,44/93147,.723,

4 -0793,.9438,89743573.50

,3989434495,84:937,3.0

4,704:439457490.9-079

4/4,.9438:314/1742/0,8

O 4:.,3.,3047-09907904;073203994:9:3/43904093

4 0.425483473,84.,,3/549.,47/07834990-089/0,

O 0;,943174290573.50890573.50

O !

4 $40,1:84:7.041,:9479

4 ;30243,7./40839,;0/;308,3.94324709,3,349074;0732039

33,3/98349

O 4/408.,304..:73:70

4 7,3.749,3/.,30

O ,714:3/,9438418947300/,;0948420,003.0944:797,/9438-0.,:8090,704:78

O 808,,-897,.943

Page 28: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 28/96

:704393:0/

$059

!04504,;0,4957490.99093890,;0 :708455480/9490/0,41/08974357490.94341

 5745079:708/0103/3,3/0/09083,4.03;0357450798,,41,3.47384.0990

/439,3984.,47/0794.,309457490.9907574507940;070/40839,397/7:08938

207949,7.825479,39-:9;79:70825479,39349,7:314707/07957;00

%0/0,4170;4:943/11078147-:705,.7.:289,3.089,03940907:3570.0/0390/0;039

70,908944.079,3/0,84147,7/39484.099.,9,89745.0110.98

8:7014790207.,3#0;4:943

O 1147/3.079,379894382033207.,

O 38203070253390798,3/1700/42841.44308

4 %380,8147,;094/4970;493174290382507,.0390794

 57490.99038.443898

703.#0;4:943

O 39070890/34.41:708.796:041#0;4:943

O ,7,3/.;,741903494090738947

4 ,00,.490724700

O .4342..7883,908

4 439,;0034:9,70;03:0

9902598,702,/094.422990703.243,7.94701472390

 -0:,7,.088,-84:982

,8-09003,3/0/,7897.47.,,3/903

450940549908013,3.,88:0894.,304;9897:.9:70

4 89,9080307,5,2509,7

7,3.0847,30/43306:,9

422430789,900307,.,8980190 ,943,8802-

08,9;0-4/

O ;07974250/.4250907047,3,94341389:9438

4 !49.,/024.7,.

&306:,/897:-943415745079

 3970894.425742480

4 :9,890

3;,843413,9:7,06:,9

0.,7,94341#98,3/,3903

Page 29: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 29/96

43899:43-:/3

4 24707,/.,#4-0850770

4  ,540,3.17,3.0

796:380053,,,9044/938990-,/

80,4.033,3390803809,90,700899003/841549.,84.0908-:99003/8

O !

4 .,302:897010703.0980194905,89

793,47/0709070,87.0784.,.4330.9438

2574;3349/089743

,302:89-020/,90/974:97,/943

43806:03.0803.,30834974490/3905,89

O $,890,/949024-.74/2039,9

,.,7/3443

3.0;08/4080/8,7004390573.508479020,38

O !49.,47,3829,98-4:3/:53905,895708039,3/1:9:70

4 409,98,7079,3:89,90300/9470850.99,90,70,5,7941

4 !414:784589078

!74708885488-0,904:,7043,-4:994,99,390,/94

/08974390934:,7097394574/:.070,9

4 -0798349803.0147:70

4 700/428349/43,94:,39

0,3884209343390.439094170897,39

4 ,,3.0-09003.42509031,.9438.,3574/:.044/54.

431.9038:70824/07,943

14:,7097394.70,90,17.94308884.094:/08974

,984.098.8,347,3.749

!

O %4,909039,3/3,9,8031:03.0/--:7033,31:03.08

O 8,9844/14750450,990,39

4 110703.0-0900344/4;9,3/00.9;04;9

,282,/0-703.70;4:943898

4728414;07320399,9/439,7009907904708,70

.438/070/092,90

:99,97:084:9901,.990804;07320398.4:/-044/

 4/893.943-032,/0

Page 30: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 30/96

O %0798412,3

4 ,7,2

4 !70903/0/798/0897470,798

4 3985,7930785,203,;006:,798-:934906:,938

4 ,9/408.;84.09/403914728,4;0732039

:708947.0890473,.425,.9491472,.;84.09,3/.,2898

/430-.425,.9

4;073203914728/0907230/30350450.70,90,.425,.9147

.;84.09

O 0,7008939339817,2047

4 $4208:089439,917,3008/089743907;07

70,843,.;84.09,814:3/0/39017895,.0

89-:708;09,9317,3.0-,5539080904708,0/08974390

.43;0394389,97057080390/90703.,4109934:9419089,90

3,9:70-:95:993902-,.39089,90413,9:700897439389,9

,7057490.93703.798-:990.,294/499457490.99080798

 42,384:/-0:/03843.,806:4901742 :70

O $42044/3,;34;90;03198-,/

O 08974347,3.749

O 4:.,32574;0174220.,3828;03944:

O #,/.,82,884.,90/998

O $0941/0,89,9/439,4147.42574280

4 !4;073203983492,/033,9:7,798

4;98:2,38/42574;/3147:2,3,398

,394:941.;84.09

#0897,3415,88438

O 700/42,3/,3:,0411700/42574/:.088.30.03

 57,9.0-:94:797:03907089,3/97:0,398300/,

O ,3:,08.47748;09417,20474184.099,9,.9:,

 57490.98909380,39

Page 31: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 31/96

:70439/

$059

!70:/.0,3/49.4397-:908949038549.,47/07

O ,41,0;0/34:80,3/,8:-:7-,34:8014720719890504504;09070

$42093,-4:9549.89,98098147 :7038549.8199038.4393:08

941990504500;072470,3/24708455480/9484209324700307.,3/2470

424034:8-,80/4370,8433882470,-4:947,3.749,3//0;0452039

O 079,34507,943574.0/:70837,943,829478-0.,:804:89,3/,7/0,3/8099:5

0;07070-:9:2,339003.0/4083950720,90701077394,550-0088038041

39003.09,90;0.079,3;08,3/300/949389,9199,9

O %,3,-4:9,47/9,98891:415,79.:77,7938

O :709380,70.4330.90/9484.,.,880807,7.3,94309.4:743349/;0890/

17424:739070898

4 44708,-98,3/4543438

,9/4089820,3

,3:04179889758,,908047,3.-0018,3/4534389,9

2,084.094:743

O $01/010,93,990259370;4:9439,9/089749389,9

,7043

O :9,8572,7349794:40/84209394905,7930785842093,7079,3

2801-,.390/,

4 $4.098147;3034920701078940

013/4:71:1203994907:2,3-038

:70408-,.9498/0,-:943,30-,88

O %739470089,-89,90,7024709,3:89,9428

O $:-89,3.041.;84.09,3/4;0732039,70

4 30790/-,3.089478704:8-0018,3/453438

40/49380/4902,3/,90,80/4902

70,9098,4110

O %070,7070,843834:710038570:/.08453438,3/

10038

O 703.70;4:,70/08974398 9.7..4330.94389,97050803984.09,3/

,.0;020398

4 #0;4:94332,3307,3/80392039

4 !48433,,

O $:8.54:841,39,3.4824549,382

Page 32: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 32/96

4 :9941,22,99078.,3,-897,.998,, :70

4;0414308434.087389894801

O 408:70939,94/830.088,7147901:3.9434184.09

4 40839-00;0390794138

..420817897043474;0732039

#0438-4:3/:5,3/30..08,784-4:3/:53549.89298

,.9438

O 703.70;8147,;0349808974089347/07-0.,:809

 -030198,;08908-,.947043,3/89,90.4330.9433

7,3.0

O !

O 0897439389,92,/07,3.070,9,3//089743

9389,957490.9-079.3.:/0704380392039

,3/0,79

O 25,8843.422435:75480

O 89070744214739073,/0-,903:70

4 4:,;094/499390-4:3/8419088902,/;4.,93.42509943,3/

/08974.:9388905534:98/041-4:3/8

O 70/0,898/,3074:8

4 !:7941907/0,823903,2041985:70/0,90/089740;0793

9,90898-:70

4 99,38420939,983495488-0

!7,2,989,..4224/,908280194,3549.,47/07342,99074-,/

4  507,933,549.,;,..:243-0,1419080549.,798

#0-,7-,943

 56:490

',:3.079,3-079084;074907829-0/,3074:8

4 ,3:894:9,3/4:99733,7:895

3,0390,938,70

40839,4147948092084170;4:943,81706:039

O :70/4083970,,;0,305.9,;0,799470;4:943

4 :990708,34/9470,97,398

4 40839,399009702020/.30942,/03472,

%0,7070,24203989,930.0889/.9,9089444:98/090-4:3/8

#03/0784.09:389,-0-973942,090050.943907:0

4 0300/94,;070;0703.0147,:947997,/943

Page 33: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 33/96

O $0392039,3/7043

4 ,925,.9/4908093,;043/0;045203941:7450

#043,8,-,8.4507,9388902

84:8,7006:,-014704/,55,7006:,3174394190,

;0398,3:0417989,9908070;4:943,708,70:83.420

17428420070-:914:805,7,904:78011742905,894:,70

/0334:770,93088

#0432,/0:7450,99,8,99,9920

-07,828--.,247,9309.0

4 %7,3341902,479

$,20088

0.,:804:.,3/03902,479-0.,:800,70,7085438-0

343041:8,707085438-0

 499025070/-,393,-4;09

O  ,0/5407

O 254075045094939,990,;0,7994,;0

,90;0790,3994,;098,70-,7-,943415407

0,70431789573.50

 0/0,8,70/0897438,2070850.909.

O $9,90824709,34:7902547,7,398,3/300/824709,3,5,7930785807;34:7

39070898

4 %7:084.,.4397,.9013/,247034-00907390,7090574/:.9,3/.70,9:70

,3/0741.079,384.09

O 40839:70:891,90;07549.,50450,;0#,/.,:891.,9431479089,9:86:4

,90;078844/-0.,:8098

Page 34: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 34/96

:70439/

44:/-:7070,.9947,5/.:9:7,.,30

O ,59,828,7,943,8241549.8

4 ,7098,7,943,24/0

!7470888570/34:784.09

$059.,41803804124/0735747088

3.70,83:2,35407-:9-099073:2,310

:70703974/:.0

O 0;,39,3/44/14728414;0732039

4 $07;0890.4224344/349507843,3907089

#0107894903,0/5407419050450,890973,774124-

:89-0.,:80982,3/4083920,39834997,33

%0,70/08507,9024203989,9.,147/08507,9020,8:708-:9988349,98,5503337,3.0

70,908948.796:084170;4:93,708,8/0,89440/-2470,708949,35,88,08

8574507957490.90/37,3.0

O  450-0.,:80,3/8,0249;,947398

4  49/43,94.08

$41,7174257490.93574507998/4.973041-07904547,/05745079390

3,774803802470,-4:9548808438

/4083920,39,9:708,4.003

O 82,7908,3//110703.08

4  :89-0.,:8008,89,94;984:/57490.95745079

/4083920,39,908,4.03

O -07983498,10

4 !

4 !4077,--03/9047/841-079,3/.42243,/;,39,0

4;020391479057;,90,34190504500,/39070;4:943

4 4:.,370147290549.,47/07-:9334,4:.,3.0,79

%4/49,9897,33

#043380307,9438940907;08:8,8038041770850.91473899:9438

024,:0

,307841/0247,9454.

4 !:80854.949024707,/.,8/0

Page 35: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 35/96

!:850450940970208

!49.888:55480/943;4;0.42574280

4 ,39.79.09070;4:943,70894:9-03,..:80/41-03,97,39

4 ;0793/0503/843900110.9

98,7/948,842093844/47-,/:30884:34,-4:9,5,79.:,70110.9

09.

8:70455480/94/024.7,.

O ,3895:70/024.7,.

O 470,-4:9,.0.,3/-,,3.0888902

O  494394,-897,.9.79.014728414;0732039

4 7,3.0570580398900.08808415:70/0424.7,.

#0,84381474;0732039,3/14728414;073203984201472829-0-099079,34907814757490.9390

.4224344/

:70/408399390243,7.,850710.99,/,-:8083498,390703.4;0732039,850710.91742

 :25

O 4/44:.,30,-,/89,90

4 439/08974:3088,-84:9030.088,7

O !

4 $90/,8,97,33-70;4:943,708-,80/439000.947,.,:80

O #08947,943,8455480/9470;4:943

4 //074:3/

O !

4 44/5,9749

 49,4,39942574;0,;090,-9942574;0

O 4:80,3,4

,98.;,943

O  5548904170-,7-,943

4.03-07,82-:703-07,825:75480,3/1472414;0732039

 -994-739094940907

O !439841.439,.9

4 ":4908,3/,7:203981742909

4  -,80,7:2039843909349.,880.9:70

Page 36: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 36/96

94.6:0;0

$4190548982

O 0-44854041,322038057490.9;05407.944,7085438-91470;074308

,553088:898443,8985407702,30/840,039,3/:/0419%85407%4.6:0;0

74904:/70802-05,7039,,:9479-:94:/9794005504503507509:,./44/-

700;3504501742,90974:-041933,3/,90.,70841;3

O 1/024.7,.85747088,8,..425,30/-/02,3/8147,0;034184.,.43/9438%0/,307

,89,9,34-808843906:,9,8;07.425,9-093.70,83.0397,0/89,905407

0;0384.,.43/9438%4.6:0;04-807;0/:8:,3;4;0/:839089,90948:-;0799480

390720/,90,884.,94389,97010.90/84.,/110703.08-:9,84290/4;07320395407

O 04-807;089,9908974374070435,0/390&390/$9,908,8/:09498805,7,943174290

4;0732039,805,7,943,5,790814:3/,700,-00.4397,89898947,3.00709070,8,9

0507.0;0/94-0,3:30,9,39,4382-09003/024.7,98,3/90704:8.070,90894

90.4330.943-09003.:7.,3/89,90

O 4.6:0;0.4770.9,39.5,90890549039,4190/0-,904;0790,-4943418,;079490,7,5,7990

&390/$9,908,893/00///390207.,3;,7 3904907,3/0570/.989,9,35,79

4190&3434:/-0,-094/0.,703/0503/03.00,84570/.98907804190&390/$9,908,3/

#:88,,87;,8:50754078.90//-0.420,190747/,79#:88,,890.0397,

.425430394190$4;09&343

O 207.,3/024.7,.,8800394,;098549039,/438/090/0854982415:-.4534390

97,3341902,479.4314729147908,0412,907,80.:7990,-803.0413900.9:,

1700/42.08,94/07,/0,/23897,943,3/-7389,9082,3850,733,3/907,9:7094

900;041904089 024.7,.3207.,570/.90/90;403.0415,798579,3/90:/2039

4190808:-47/3,90/9490570:/.084190347,39

O ,/8574547943,9054794341540739008,9;0-7,3.,3,-:804147,.414;0147

1700/42,30.088;0/7;014706:,93/;/:,82,3/2,907,82%000203989,9

%4.6:0;0-00;08.,324898:..0881:.42-,99080/,3074:8/024.7,9.903/03.08,70,3

3/0503/039,3/31:039,:/.,7,8974300.:9;0-7,3.4.,8014;0732039,/23897,9;0

/0.0397,,943704300/:.,90/42031700/4241,884.,943,3/1700/42419057088

O %01789419080890570543/07,3.04108,9;054070.,:809008,9:7082489/70.9

705708039,9;04190419050450/024.7,.08903/94;09902489540741,90

4;0732039,-7,3.080919070,703498:11.039.0.8439854079.,30,8-0.420

97,33.,

O %0574-0289,9190!708/039,8450841-037000.90/04802:.418,-994

2,03/0503/039/0.8438-,80/438:/203983890,/0,;094-49490284190

 50450.4389,39973942,0902,55,94:902,349,;090340/094:/0

Page 37: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 37/96

,990-089,.94314790.4:397,8,4029-03/70.990701470,4390!708/03994

7:31477000.9433.70,80890/,307419097,3341902,47

O %080574;8438708:9390800.94341,20/4.70-4/41705708039,9;08,80,83903,-9

41705708039,9;0894,.9,..47/394907-089:/203983.0902:89.4389,39-04773,-4:9

 5:-.45343

O 31,.90;03903899:943,574-028,7070,4382594284198/0050723/809.,

/024.7,9.504508903/94,;0%0/4.9730419084;07039419050450,3/905407415:-.

45343,70.474,7089490/0,4106:,91,,7006:,90334430507843,8,3-,8894.,2

9079947:04;07,34907%043:89,947:3,84.0990701470894-,80/0.84384390

41902,4790990574-02998/0,89,99.,36:900,80,/94/0854982

O 19070,7034.0.84390540741902,4799431:03.0904;07320399039,;0

,-84:905407,3/948039023479-0050889470889!07,580;03247038/4:8890

8007247,147.09,99,9904534341902,479,84384.0989,8,70,/-0033490/1

,,7006:,9033443045343,870,907099,3,34907%04.,.43.:84389,990

453430/-902,4792:89-090-0894308,708:990708,903/03.94,-,3/431700/42

4194:93/024.7,9.84.090843,,389904534341902,47988003,8,33/70.9

.,294908:5074794143084345343.8/70.9.4397,/.9479490573.5041

06:,9

O 3/;/:,82841/024.7,9.473,3/970,90389474,8.43/943809247006:,%070,843

1479850342034389,906:,9903/8942,05045083907089814.:834390280;08%070,70

3484.09,-43/847/:908,89070,703,3,7894.7,..350450940907,3/147.090294

70,0907/0503/03.043430,349073/;/:,82.,3.4397-:90949074941/0854982

 -0.,:801.9038-0.4209443/;/:,89.90349-4907941:1907.;./:90847007.80

9071700/42

O 00110.9412,907,8289,9504502,-084,-847-0/3907507843,5:78:9410,99,990

300.994:80907549.,1700/42:7907504502,,.9:,3,-,3/439071700/423

47/0794,;0,-030;4039/0854982..,3574;/0,347/0784.09,3/038:702,907,

 57485079

O 43899:943,903/0503/039:/.,7990540741:/.,70;0809702025479,39

0.,:809.,3574.,2.079,3,8:3.43899:943,90$:570204:79574;/0857,.9.,9043

.0.439097,3341902,479:/08,70,554390/34900.90/,3/90807;01090728

;3902,70,9/0,413/0503/03.0942,090/0.84389,99093-08994:9300/394

4770.088;0,-4:95:-.4534370,90/-0301.,3899:943390207.,388902890

 :70:7082,349,,8-090-08920,3841,99,33:89.090807;0,;075489;0

 549.,1:3.94341147.390.90389493,-4:94907504508,11,78,3/0/:.,93902390

:80419071700/42

Page 38: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 38/96

O .,481474.,8014;07320398,-84:90.7:.,,8,20,3894005-079,;0-

,4390.903894007.8091706:039

O 70907941,884.,943901700/42419057088,3/248925479,397043884.,9438,70,3

0.003994494.42-,93/;/:,82,3/94,45045094007.809071700/42-9,3,5,793

 549.8%0570888392,90.4330.90/94,884.,943839,9,884.,9438300/,20,3841

.422:3.,939907202-078,3/,84,20,38418570,/39072088,094905:-.,8,

403207.,704382:.24709,3,3490795041,884.,943,3/8-0301.,-49

 549.,,3/84.09,#04390,.0850450494:809071700/420

O -733504509409073,.422:3941.42243-0017043,84.42-,983/;/:,82

:790724707043857,.9.,904320,3841.4:3907,.93902,907,89.903/03.0841

/024.7,9.504508

O  -4;0,%4.6:0;0,8,5,8843,904;0147-079,3/8.43.0730/9454394:990/,3074:8

9703/89,9970,90394/089749,80,89020,38-.9.,3-0570807;0/

Page 39: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 39/96

%4.6:0;0

$42093,2489:70,3,-4:9%4.6:0;0

,9/408020,3-/024.7,.

O 8545:,784;073990939,9574/:.08/024.7,.

O 6:,941.43/9438

207.,705708039890.0,70890,2504190,9047/843

78947.,7,.8,84.,89,90905,899,9:7450,3824;3,,1742 7090701:3/,2039,

,9073,9;08 4419047/8-0.423207.,%0708,8038090,207.,8,3/0,,3/

349/0,%4.6:0;089,3,-4:9,70201,.9,7894.7,.8349,5,:8-088902;0390

.:7703984.,89,90%8890,938,70300/,30549.,47/07

47:70,/024.7,9.70;4:943834903;9,-08947,3/97,/943

4/408%4.6:0;0;09080.,308

O 024.7,.,830;9,-0:389455,-0

O 9024/0841549.83:7450,7024;394,7/8/024.7,.:33903943,47

3903943,

4 $4203/414.9,984.09824;394,7/806:,9

O %,8,-4:9789,33,9438

4 :7450,3/0,8,3//0,8

408-,.94:7450,3079,09,9802-0//0/37043 :70

$00870;4:943411:12039419480573.508 %4.

,9890/110703.0-09003-07,82,3//024.7,.

8%4.6:0;0,/024.7,.9.,-04080800,3,9073,9;03/024.7,.110703.0-09003

8,;,0/,3/3:9:70/3,9:7041/024.7,.

0397,,9430,/894,5,9;07990803809,94:,701700347/071479080.0397,0/5,.0894

1:3.94390708,300/940053/;/:,5,79.5,943 %0,207.,38570807;09073/;/:,

-0798974:904.,4;07320394.,.,3308

6:,941.43/9438

O #.803804114728414;0732039,3/57,.9.0

O 0397,5439

O 024.7,.8.4230907:7450089349

4 %48945/024.7,.4:/-0,897:0,,3894/2801

O $4.,89,909,9574;/03.0254808432

O  00/94:3/0789,3/9084.,89,909705,.0/

4 !43941.425,7,843349,;0507850.9;0

,0890.,88.,,7:20394390574-0241-4;9

O ,0850450/0503/039434;0732039

4 !70;0398504501742:3/0789,3/39,907:04:780;08

Page 40: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 40/96

O 4/44:570;03990574-0289545:,784;07396:,941.43/9438

024.7,.8,1,.993,/024.7,9.47/079070,7044/,3/-,/,8410.:0939

024.7,..,30,/948.03.0-:99.,3,840,/9497,33 3/0,9,90,70,.,5,-041

.4397434:7;08-:989897:0 %01,.941/024.7,9.06:,9,3/.0397,,943-097,84:743

3/;/:,0,3088084/4009-,.394:.990/0,0/4,;0.439744.,4;9

 0058,;0,803804190.933/;/:,4/44:709,3,8038041705:-.,37:0 0/07,82,8

,3,3807

O ,3/4207.,385799,90.,3/4,393 870,9147.4330.933/;/:,89490

4;0732039

39080,707549.,47/0784:034-050450-;390284205,79.5,94338017:0

%43850058,;090803920399,90,70904;0732039 $008983/;/:,82,8.7:/0,3/

.4,780,99208$008,-00703.0412798-4:3/:59 207.,,3/,9207.,8!0450

/490300/,89,9,4:894807;04:7438013907089 !72,.41549.,57,.9.0,0;0

31:03.0840/4549.80100,803804154073.44507,93390804.,889028

%070,997.3,70549.,47/078894,4504501005407-;3902,290/5,.094

,;054073

%094/,3074:8,7097,33,3/803.0

O 4;984:/-0.0397,0/

O /2384:/-0/0.0397,0/

%,3,-4:9,4.0389,90413,9:70-:90,;4/903.43;03.08 0100,894:0,7090

 :/034:743.,8080;03030,70349448,9,9,4.03549.,47/0720,33 207.,

4,705450:/08390743.,80

Page 41: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 41/96

!,507434.0,3/:70

8:70,4.0,3

4.0

,9890478993

O $9,90413,9:709,9/0;4;08394,89,9041,7

4

#994/0103/5745079,3/430801.,34190392083907,.995,39074041

 :/034:74397,

034:979400794:743147.0439484204300809,98,89,9041

,734:/094894598

O

O ,413,9:708801507807;,943

4 8,990.470414;0732039

4

48925479,39938

O 10-079,3/5488088438

!745079

O $3.00,7043078414:7-4/08,902,084:78

4 4399,024709,330.088,7

O ;079205745079,8-0.42090-,884184.09

O 430,8,20,384170:,93

0,70/7;0394.70,9084.094:94130.0889

O ,3,289457490.95745079

O %4804,70:390/394430-4/,3/,;0,.42243089,-80/,,3/:/.,9:7094,550,94

9,:947994/0./0.43974;078908-09003902,703,.;84.099430,34907

4  -84:90243,7./4083970,2,9.:59498/01394341.;84.09

 42,33.;84.09.,3-00025917429

;3:54:77994:/0941472,.;84.094:,70.70,93,34-,9439904907504504:

039070/.;84.099

O 43,7.08070,9430543900.90/

4 :9,84-0898:90/94907570803989,90,3/.43/943.8944/24703300/41/0103.0

,,389147033;,8438,3/3:708

O  00/940,2304;0732039942,08:709,9983494;0790945047-9,39

O !0,.01:-03338414;0732039,;0-0032,/0990504508.438039

O 3,.941901,907.,3349-3/8843

O 0.420,,5,794184.09034:;0-907,8

,9,709003/8414;0732039

Page 42: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 42/96

O !70807;05745079

4 309:7,:/0

O  50,.08,109,3/905:-.44/

,39508414;0732039807;09803/

,9,709020,38414;0732039

O  00/,089,9;0-7,3..1448903,9:7,,570807;,9434184.09

O 290/54071479044/4184.09

O :89.0

O  -84:9828349,84:943-0.,:809070300/94-010/,81470;0743094144470809070

4:/-034543930,;39089,90413,9:70

O ,399,05745079,,

O ,395:94:78013,/11070390,85070

O ,395,8843540744907-4/08

O 0/07,9;0/0,3949073,9438,3/0.:8;05407

O .:09;084:/-0,..4:39,-09408,9;0

O 0.8,3/-,,3.0888902

!0450507509:,709,38:570205407418,;390280;08174290,9902598,3//083841,3-4/

!0450,;0,7994.4;94:90390,7039/439074-

O .:09;029,;0907994/884;09008,9;0-:99/4083920,3088:5074949

.:09;0,85704,9;0

O 4,9830.088,794570807;09050450

4 %070300/894-0298439893

,08,/893.9/110703.0-0900384.09,3/4;0732039

O $4.09.,3-0/884;0/0314703540783;,/0

4 0384.09/84;0844/.,3.0904;0732039944

O 4;07320398,70/884;0/174293

4 0308,9;08,9070/

4 0308,9;0,.98,,38990797:89

855745079

O !0450.,3:/014790280;0809074734990,399403907,30.4397,.9

4 ,39/4981470;0793

%070,894-0,0970,843

O $9,90.477:59435:9850450394,89,9041,7

O $970970;0703.0

O 030;074:,-:8090504504:7,:947989458

Page 43: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 43/96

:70

O 430,8,347039,94394,7/870432574;02039,3/549.8

O %0,241900/:.,943,090.98,70/984204190549.,.,88,82574;020393

90-74,/089803809,98948,9.4330.90/8012574;02039974:9031:03.04190,798

8.03.08,3/974:90/0;0452039413900.9:,889247,.:9:70,3/90.4342.

/0;0452039%0,-941900/:.,90/90549.,38,3/907.949,0.43897:.9;039,9;08

.4397,890/89,79903,-9419050,8,3979405980150,8,398700;0/9072807

 573.5,974:85,828418,;,07,,389907,3/47/8705708039,9;08-:98:.;403.0,8

70570880/89073,3/050/34-4/%0

O :70709,30/,810,8038041907085438-941900/:.,90/7.,3/54071:942574;090

494194804290/70.90/,803809,90893,77,3020398070;,:,-03841,7,890070

9030.088,7570.43/94381472574;02039,3/,8974380380419025479,3.0410/:.,90/50450

,8,0398147.43897:.9;0.,30.,30.041903.4397,890/990:8041147.00907,8

2094/47,8708:9

O 07008,34,/;,39,0832574507,-897,.943473,29.,4/03,0%:8:708

:33308894:/03899:9438,3/57,.9.0894:91789.4330.93902949079388

/83.3,94394;057,8047-,2094,393.70,90894:2,3,.9438,3/:2,3

.43.073843,8250;041904-0.93,903,0/3088,3/849:/041209,58.,,-897,.943

## $;8,

O %023/,/,54079470.0;08250/0,8174290803808,3/174298437010.94343902

,3/942,04:941982,907,1:7907/0,89,9,/347010703939047/418038,943:708

3907089//3490903/9490.039,:789,94.0,/2039430/-:990,-9942,0.4250/0,8

,3/94,8802-0902330,8,8.0397,94:708,41574.00/3854845.,

2094/3;4;0/93339072841.4250/0,8,-4:9,.4330.90/7,30412,990782,99078

.4330.90/-9075,.03,5747,22041:2,32574;02039#0,843,81:3/,2039,9498

2094/-:934970,843,430,808003:70884047/0;490/49454845.

2,/0:80414.04390,94,3473,/0893,943

O 90.42-3,94341897433899:94389.;-079

O ;07,0,898432,33078,3/98549.8/0503/039:543902%$

O 4723,3:3/0789,3/341549.8.,857,.9.,390;075,79.:,78038041.,3147

,.9;93430/70.94394.4:3907-,,3.0147.08.4231742,349079,8,8457,.9.,370,943

94,/;,3.3;07850.1.39070898

O :08989,990703.3907039:8,8214790/0,41-079,/1,0/94:3/0789,3/9,9-079

,843430,24389,7,3041-030198, 41.070706:70/32:9:,.433043147,10

:3/07.;4;07320399,9,8.;0/39057450780380%0708:98.140/174298

/01.03.41:3/0789,3/33.:/0/.43899:943,,77,3020398.-0.,:8090//3497010.9

Page 44: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 44/96

,3:3/0789,3/341-0799,9,88:-90034:947,859,990-07941902,3,85407//

3496:,1545:,784;070393,,9,94:/70897,390/02480110.9;081,3

:370897,30/545:,.0,8349-,/034:,3:3/0789,3/341104339072841-0798059

,,570.0/30,-47,9438414:7/0,8%82,99070/-0.,:809070130203941/0,8,/-003,

 570.43/9434170130203941.43/:.9,3/90701470419057470884184.0932,370850.98

O %07097470884341:2,39980194,32,9,83491,73901:9:709,8382:99:/0

%0708:9,8504504:/344307-024;0/-45343.,/02-4/0/70130//0,84:/

 -09,9904:/300/94-04;0730/-147.047.0944,890:92,90/0893,943419080.43/

 54794341 #010.9438%88:0890/9,990/0,4106:,9,/-003.4330.90/43944507;,8;0

9903899:943,,77,30203984190:/.,79008,9;0,3/9000.:9;05407,3/

90701470,/574/:.0/34990,:947941.422,3/34;0732039-:93899:943,80/100-03088

9908,2092090507;0780708:984106:,9318.,,77,3020398,/.,:80/545:,7/8.439039

,3/13,3.,389,-9%0708:9,8,89:,943..4:/-0.439740/43-90147.04190

29,713/00/29,747/07,88:89,3,-00384/078,/,-847-0/90/0,4106:,9

7,3.0980020/903/0/94,7/80907907:041147.04790/83907,9434147/07

O %03,9903943419070;4:943,708949070,94389,9300/0/94-0.425780/3,24/073

4;07320390850.,3.4330439-079,82,9.0/-903,557457,90308894,84;0703

702041897:.9:73983899:9438,74:3/06:,97,9079,3,74:3/0110.9;0.422,3/%080

38988:0890/9,9,28897:.9:73419030.43899:9439,9574.00/0/1742,33,/06:,90

 54845.,7,85$:.28:3/0789,3/3,82,9.0/-,1,:7094:3/0789,3/908947.

,/574/:.0/900,-47,94341/0,8,-4:9.43/:.99,9,/:3/07799034;0732039-45343,3/

981,:708:0890/9,990#0;4:9434:/.,:8070974708843174298.;0/.43/943

94,7/8,0880390,41574.00/3,80,8,0880110.9;0430

O :7057010770/94025,809,93:2074:8573.508,3/57,.9.,93394.42-30902070

30.088,79420099080300/8,3/84948:89,32574;02039,3/025,809449,98:.

,..4224/,9433;4;0/2:.247057,.9.,,.9;99,3850.:,9;0/083

O 30.0889418390883/0,8,3/3.:/3343.43.059:,00203983,3,/06:,90970,9203941

 549.8

,9,709003/8,3/20,38414;07320393:70

O %457490.990.4224344/

4 :9,90,.9890.4224344/

O !7490.95745079

O %4038:70,247020,8:70/.43897,30/8038041-079

4 -079834944/

O $01507807;,943

,98799470;4:9433:70

Page 45: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 45/96

O %0050.94384:/349-0.420907:0

8:708.796:04190703.#0;4:9434.03

,9,709020,38

O 3.702039,823,14729,988:90/9420094:75,79.:,7300/83,9:7,0;4:943414;0732039

:808-798.743,8,30,250

O 4397,.99,98-090035,895708039,3/1:9:700307,9438

#4041570:/.0

O 013905,84390,/0703.0945,89

%7,3341902,479

47,841907:078,7025479,39

 005-079,,1742.477:5943

,8,5704..:5,9439/0,8,3/490,70/88023,90/3949047/903843-090039047,3/57,.9.0

,9,7090.4224390208

O 438,70.4803

O 25,8843.4393:9

O ;074308.42500/942,39,3908,2089,3/,7/8

O ,;089/1107039;0843904738415745079

O :89-0.,:809,8.4803-902,479/4803920,39,890-08970,908-,.944.08.08

,3/-,,3.0888902

O #0.43090,938,70

4 4.0.43147284;073203994199050450

4 :70/0,895,79.:,78

O :7084.09-02,/014790,/;,39,0412,3,4190,/;,39,08147.982,/0-0.420

87998,33899:94341-031,3.0,3/,9801843-03103.0,.93-,7:0

4 40843948,9,990,;0,7994;0

O ;0:5907994801/010380:/0034:03907.;84.09

O 4;07320398,.4397;,3.041:2,38/4294574;/0147:2,3,398:708

4 $42014724170897,39830...08,7

:708,4.03,390803809,90,700894.03,99003/8414;0732039,709457490.990.42243

44/5745079-07940;070883494.0,339020,38974:.98.70,90/3,//9439,90

,7008990

%01472414;0732039

O $00/5,39

3/;/:,;8507843

%7394.70,90,:3;078,-881479089,909794.,2901:3/,92039,39708099,90;07-4/

Page 46: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 46/96

Page 47: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 47/96

%4.6:0;0439/

%070;4:94389030;9,-0708:94190,938,7043  48945539-:990708,,94

9025079$008207.,,89070,90890,25041/024.7,.,990920

O 0895488-0/024.7,9.7020

4 '07,,70490300/94199050450

O ,0782,39,3,8,:9,7.43807;,9;0573.509,9-70,890549039,0.0880841

207.,3/024.7,.

O 02039841/11070394;07320399508,7002-0//0/3/024.7,.47,90,89 207.,3

/024.7,.

O 024.7,.,894459438

4 %7,3341902,479

&3570..0/0393/41/08548982

%4:9.43974

O 4/073/024.7,.,8903.3,9439486:,8170094:9

4 ,090234709,99070,7093894-094:9

4170084:794:970,

4 !49.,0,9

O 207.,38,;02079-:99077:078/43970,

4 !:3;078,039032039825488-0

207.,38/439,;090920940/:.,9090280;08

024.7,.8907:04190:380-:990:380/4393490

,703980

207.,38,;0,574-023:/39020,3,894,.0;09003/

4 !748507941902489

O 03903/0/-:93.4389,39

4 $:8.0859-0945045041,9907:8

O !024.7,.9.389:9438/0;04503;-0.,:80908020,3894-0.42006:,419031,

,31,9907905,884314706:,9-:93498,981903970

4 3;,90410908

3.04:70,09,9306:,90894:,3906:,091470;0743094

 -73902/4343908,200;0

O 089/439807;0904;0732039

4 %070884209394-08,/9,9504504,704,-:97010.9:8,704,

O 0.,708,-4:9:2,370,93088

4 $.,70/-4:9900110.941/024.7,.43:2,370,93088

%040/0,4174:593

O 25,8843904.,-0.,:80988070,207.,3810090743,:94342

Page 48: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 48/96

O 30741207.,38

4 .9;941207.,387010.990;07941207.,38

O 494/44:709,3,8038041-030254070/

4 8003,94:,70/43,8,325,.9

4:8009,934.,80993

O 389,-941207.,3,8

4 98,3/89,798,70-:93949088902

%703/8949070,908944/14790248950450

O 207.,382,0705,7,-0289,08

4 !74/:.98414:73899:9438

O !

4 !,79841908070209508,708957080393 207.,3/024.7,.

0-03419070,90893:2-076:490

O 024.7,.,700110.9;03807;390300/84902489-0.,:800,70247000,.4907

9,30,;00;07-003-01470

O 0300/940984209317424:7.4:397347/07147:8944;093/024.7,.

O $03834:7540734.,809938

4 #0,90/949884,207.,38.43.0;041798,3/9084:/

O 4/408207.,2,0,4.0,3.422430,9357,.9.0

4 #985,,325479,39740398

#404170.574.9

9890/0.70,837404170433 207.,

O  00/94,550,945045088013907089

4 #0,0/324704.,809938

4/037:0390728414-0390,

O !,3/

O 4/408430034-0/024.7,.;034/024.7,.570;03990/0;045203941:2,3

70,93088

%7,33,479

O 4081479084:

4 %7,334194:9

089970,994207.,38

/4393441,3.4:397070890700883/0503/03.04123/

10/43934,90703499330/43934494939

%0:3.,030/-0.420890:36:089430/-0.420890:394:9

Page 49: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 49/96

O %0708,3490797,33944

4  470.4:7801473:89.034-70,439041902,4793.437090,

&$,8/,3074:8903/083.079,3.7.:289,3.09,9.4:/0,/9497,33

4 ,3989,3/,,38902,479

O 907549.,14728,470,9071700/42394:9-:906:,941.43/9438408394

9023/0;07-4/938908,20,-0.,:8098/0,05,3/8-:99805,3843

.70,908,42403,94341933

4 3;8-094:954.03207.,

O !,88439:738394,.9433,/024.7,.

4 $:8.059-094/0247:,7,3/1,9907

O 3;8-097,33,83408.,50

O 3/;/:,0,3088083/024.7,.08

Page 50: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 50/96

%4.6:0;0

.99

884.,9438,70,3,39/490943/;/:,824/024.7,9.4;006:,924709,31700/42

O 907.4593/024.7,97.504508,;0,9,8901471700/42-:914706:,9

4 3-09003,3//0854982,3/1700549.,.422:3908

422:389.4:39708408,439/0548982-,80/43,.079,33/41

06:,9

O 6:,98,6:08943412,39,3.0390:2,30,7998901,.941938,3/901,.9

9,998,1,.93.70,8084:74;014790870100/870,9

4 %0708,,9,9981,.9:,06:,9.4397-:90894904;0

%01,.99,9908982,08:84;09,3/4:74;0147989,-0890/0870

1479

O !6:490

4 ;07.039:79070898/0,9,9.,9.0843,3/50450-0.4205,8843,90,-4:9

98806:,9

0,,;057/0,3/4:757/0806:,8,9810/03344308-09907

4:780;08

09,006:,9,8,;031,.9

O 4/024.7,.,942083/;/:,8

4 09703/94,7/3/;/:,829/024.7,.,3/06:,90,70088.4330.90/

4:,70,430940907

4 ,30780-0.420,03,90/,3,5,909.

4 !045010090743540732,8824;020398

3/;/:,8,700,

30419070,9.4397,/.94380-00;04:780;0894-0

3/;/:,54071:-:90,70,.9:,5407088

%070,9,39/49094988,884.,9438

O 010000,70/43842093030,703,74:5

4 709070/,3078,884.,90/90883907,.943

,30788419/0854982

04805:-.;7:9:08

40885:78:9414

4 390,-803.041704389,90/439,;0,4390724,8290,/94,

 5:78:941280/8013907089

$2,220/,9050,8:7085,;0905,994-,/938

 -803.041430790728,484:941,394,2420399,98

.,7,.9070/-,84799072/897,.943

Page 51: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 51/96

220/,90:70841-4/,3//897,.9438419023/

884.,94830/:.,904:78013907089,3/,4:8941449.4770.9

10/439

O 0,-,804:784:8

O 3/05:78:0389,397,91.,943

O :780380414:74354903.3/;/:,88-,80/4370,9

4 3899:943,0/57010703.08295488-908.43/94382,9907;8-:94:300/94

,;0,5489;023/809

!0450/4300/944714790280;08

O 3/0139050710.9,-984;0702344/,3/-,/930,70,,897394

2574;04:780;08

4 0,70,,85:78:3,553088-:90,7030;07433,099070034907

 50450,;089:110,39

4 ,7/147:894-0,7,80380412470,3/2470

38,9,-034:75:78:94182,/08708

,8.,3099070-:90,7006:,840.,39070

%70,/24110.,7749

4 #0438,:801:-70,174298..0-0.,:809574;/08:8,43079204,

89458:817421,33940,90382

,:80:89414.:8431007010.9434:7;081742,07570850.9;0

%4.06:0;08,89-70,8902,907,824190,0

!3907-44,,207.,38,703/0503/039,3/0,1,394

254903.0

1,79894.7,..4208-,.9.420-,.974:99,38413/:8978

 570/.943

4 0397,,943.,:808088,884.,943,2438950450

4 1107039950841,884.,94334247090.470390/

4 ,709970894.,59:70902547,7,884.,9438974:9703/8,884.,9430,70

8:8.059-094-0384.,0/3.079,3,8944/.079,3453438

,307412,907,82

,9,704:75:574808

%008854074:10090088/08704:10094349,;0,94:,39

 45489;070,843349944:,704394/49

O 03/44:1004:754073,74:5

Page 52: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 52/96

%4.6:0;0439/

4708,8/0130/-%4.6:0;0540247,,3/3900.9:,89,904190504505:-.

4534380307,90/4:94124708$07;0942,39,3,/024.7,9.705:-.

47043,3/549.8300/94-0805,7,90/

O 35:-.45343549.8,3/7043,703907930/-:9390,890300/94-0

805,7,90/024.7,.,8,70:389,-0,3/7043824705072,3039034:31:80

 -494:549.070433,,9,99/089748905489;00110.989,97043.,3

,;04324708

O # 0439025078504508/7;0

O %,8,-:93899:94389,931472-00188890287043843041902

$0.:,7549.,-03019841# 0435321789;078435

O 49.,38,50549.8

O /0,9,990708,.47708543/03.0-0900390.482.,3/549.,47/07

4 !,7,08206:,9-01470,

4 # 0,94385-0900390.482.47/07,3/549.,47/07

O !49.8,3/7043,724303207.,

O !549.,38570903/394-07043

4

0.,:80419009038;0805,7,94341.:7.,3/89,90

:89,48994-03504508;083499549.8

O 42403,94341704390,70/110703.08-:990782,79082,0902,;0

82,77403,8

O # 043/70.9824708

O 00180/39057;,908507034:7857;,90107043839057;,9085070

O !5# 0439025078/024.7,9.334;,943

4 %:8090,,4890207.,35045094/40;07937043570;039

9072,330;0793,3/147-/89021742/430;0793

448,99389,9902507900.0880841/024.7,.

,0787043

# 0.574.9

O :2,3-038,7047941,.079,33/4170850.9408-,.94970,930,.49070

O ,-989,98:55479,8

%3,-4:924943,3/7089842084:7.0417089942,39,3549.,47/07,549.,702082:89

,;08420,41570807;390702000/84203/41,3.47147,8-0.,:8090,70,,8

Page 53: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 53/96

Page 54: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 54/96

43$9:,79

,72!73.50

O %0,72573.504/89,90,.3/;/:,,8907994,.9,80,3988443,89080

,.9438/4349,7249078 190,.943880170,7/39,981943/70.9,110.9890

 507843:3/079,390,.94390384.09,83479943907;0300;0319100890,.947

8,72328010/408,7:040;079,93/;/:,8,70570;0390/1742/43

,8938074:8,729490280;08479075745079-90,72573.50 0.,:8034430

0898384,943,72/43094430801,84,72849078,3//0897435745079/057;08

90.422:39,80,8430801 (0.:80894804,70 3.,5,-041801

4;0732039174298573.508:.,84:3./703479480;33  -,.,7/89,908

4184.09

%7,3341902,479

O %0708348,10:,7/17429

4;0732039

O  00/894-09025070/--079419050450134990/9442:.5407

4 84-,.43899:943,.0.2,/09457490.99039070898419050450

0854982

O 147948084.09089,9,70  -,.,7/,843,890/08549,890-089390708984190

 50450,90,79-0.,:804190-,770789485439,304:85747088 (%4:98573.50

80028.0,79070,70,3:2-0741.425.,9438 470,25005.989,9089,9

,7282,3.:/0,.9841428843,80,8,.9841.4228843

700$ 500.

O ,7:089,91700/8.4:7808,30.088,7.43/9431473900.9:,,3/84.,5747088

0.,330;07-08:700.43903/89,9,803.0/45343/408349.439,3842000203941

9097:90,84,7:089,9,435045094,71,804534388574/:.9;014794

70,84387893/;/:,8,702470094,-,3/430774304:8-0018190,7003,0/3

,345030.,3041/0,8$0.43/-147.349073/;/:,894700,230,3/70,1172

907-0018390574.08841/0-,909080-0018,700591742/0.333942070 /42,

98349034:1479,9430825,8,3:30,230/-0019,9,5503894-097:0

4302:89:3/0789,3/90-00136:0894389097:0430

$4.,-079

O 490747/85045084:/,;0907994,;0,8,3904;07320398/0.8438 0

8,/9,984.,-079,8903,9:70,3/29841905407..,3-0092,90

007.80/-84.094;07903/;/:, 9,8,9902590/394,81789-4-9,33

70.4394341.079,322:3908.,0/549.,-079084779880.43/-089,-82039

41,8890241.43899:943,.0.8

3/;/:,-079

Page 55: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 55/96

O 3/;/:,8,707,943,034:942,0/0.8438,-4:990744/-03,3/.4480,3

704390,39944;073203984:/3907107003981479057490.9434184.09

05,38

O %,990435:75480147.5407.,3-0791:007.80/4;07,3202-0741,

.;0/.422:39,,3898894570;039,729449078

O ,392,08420430/444/-:94:.,3570;0399021742,72

&99,7382

O 70,9089,553088573.5094/89,94302:89,,8,.984,894574/:.09070,9089

,5530881479070,90893:2-0741504509370,843

O 8:554790/08,9439,94:/,;07,390/097,;493540794:3;07897,/:,908

439074:3/89,9900703,-0990754894394:/0,94:/-0-08914784.09 9

84:/-03490/9,93980,250//3493903/94/0;,:0:30/:.,90/50450,3/

4:/.079,3,;0,/;4.,90/803/3905447-:99,0390/94:3;0789080-00;0/9,9

0/:.,943,3/3499039738.3,9:7041900/:.,90/6:,10/90294,;0247031:03.0

34;0732039

O 9,91034:50450,90/,349075078438:11.0399,982570/:.390,55308841

904-0.941907,970/4:/.,:8090250,8:7094:/-03.:2-039:543,:99,7,3

84.0994,/9023,723903/;/:,,7:0/9,9347/0794,;08:.,3

,999:/0412,.00,..9034:/,;094;,:084350,8:704;079,941,34907

$4.09907014708334,4-,90/943/:024390.4397,7981:5072990/

948:5570888,.9438

O %0700.94341.0384785,3/5,9073,8283903/0/94574;/09030.088,784.,

.43/943814790,.0;0203941340/0,3/9070,9089,-91479070,90893:2-07

94/0;045,3/007.80907/0-07,9;0,3/7,943,.,5,.908

O 0850.1.:891.,94380;081470,.41901700/428890/,-4;07089834943,31472

413,9:7,798-:97,90743901,.99,90-00;0/90801700/4284:/-735489;0

.43806:03.0814784.09%:8-49,/;4.,908,3/.79.8418;08,;0,7:0/9,90

/4083499,0-079,8,3,-84:9089,3/,7/41;,:0573,-4;09/;078906:,9,3/

84.,5747088

O 9985439/;/08:2,3 -07903357;,9039498.425430398472,31089,9438

%01700/429493,8430808,3/94100,8430/408 %83.:/08901700/429445343,3/

3.:/08901700/42945:-8453438343,890 1700/42418500.

%01700/42945:78:09,8908,3/5:78:980;03190,70/0020/ 2247,,3/438443,890

/4349.,:80,72

%01700/4294:39047200994907841903343,890 1700/4241,8802-

94:9,4190801700/42838;0430.,3349-0.438/070/94-097:1700

Page 56: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 56/96

$4.,97,338/,3074:8

Page 57: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 57/96

Page 58: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 58/96

4 2984384.,5407

O

4 47/9,98783

O

4 09270,7/,3/074;079833:2-07,-0.74/

08

O !:78:941,5530889,3,/11070395,91742901,907

O 700/4241,884.,943

4 !7088

4.,89:118247025479,39

,7/940,79025479,399389,903480

079,31,.94789,925,74:7308

O #0.4394341;,:0837043.42-3098057,94341.:7.,3/89,90

O 024.7,.80507,90890507843,1742907089419084.0909903390-43/89390

 507843,

O -00;00,7006:,03031,.9,7039

808

O 0/8,700/990349439,9:3;078,:3147298.,:8384.0994.0,8094089

O 0/8,7009905488-941097020704:842403,943

O 0/8,7009%4.6:0;08570/.94381479070,94385-09003907,.08390&$

O 470,884.,94380885,79.5,943

O 408349,//708830,9;025.,9438410/,3085,5078

Page 59: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 59/96

.99

14:/439344:93,94:/44:,;03444/74:3/89493,94:/4  00/94

:3/0789,3/45548908/09497:-0,574503/41,3,7:2039 ,;094-0450394-03743.,39

 570903/-0.,:804:934:348420939,94:,7031,,-0

%74:,72573.500-0892,20:999:99412,3,3/:2,3,8,5747088;0-039,9

20,380.,32574;04:780;08

;0394:0-00;0842093,897:09834997:97:0-0.,:800-00;094:941,89,0,-9

..F8,70,30,250

O ,9/408920,39470,;0,/4.9730

O  005323/97,334194:9/4080;070307,943,;094340;0793-9801

,3/3/;/:,

,72573.50

O '089,9093,70-,/,7057490.90/-0.,:80,910,70743

4 ,9,-4:97,.82

O ,3074:8/4.97308

4 ,30794:2,38500.10.,3.:79,

408:3/070892,90905407415745,,3/,40804;070892,9090

,-9415045094-07,943,

O /0,4174--390:2,37,.0

4 034:570;039,345343-030,7/

743.0,7507.05943,3/;0074197:9

%7:9.,3.4770.9743

O $420497:9.436:0707747039094.4/0

4 08,,709,9077475075:,908

,994/4,-4:99

&808789,39,8,30

!6:4909070,,/;,39,04197:9

O #9941700/4241057088438,83415747088-0.,:80

98400,73

4 #0,90894 ,39-,80/430257.,24/0

4

O %4.6:0;,3.796:04198;0

4 80,84501:9,907747705,.097:9-:90

,;0341700/424194:9

O %389044/8411700057088434:9090-,/8

Page 60: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 60/96

O ,3.43.07389,90;07430-093908,20939733,419094:9-:90

88081700/424105708843,8,3,39/490

O 090747349,3453438-0301.,47/,3074:88,84,2,99074145343  4-001

.8.4397,79497:9.,3-0-0;07:801:89,940:/09097:9 3807890

6:08943897:944/

O 408.079,395041,3:,03.90,72

4 390-,8841,72573.50.,308:9/431700/424105708843

O ,9/40857479097:947:801:3088 %7:9478,109

O 4/457490.94:780;084/457490.99017000.,3041/0,84/4034

,9070,0;0393.43.0594107747

4 408-,.940;070307,943300/3940,739381479801

84/0-0,17,/4107747

700,17,/41,3,7:2039

4 $9743,99,.43,:94793/;/:,:2,3-038.,30,7314790280;08

O 4080,88:2050450:80340/014744/,3/3491475407

4 84203/411,93239079:8041:99

005/8.:883289,080.,32574;0902

O ,30570;039:2,-038174207747,3/748807747

4 089.,3.00,;0894,;0842043024394730;07-4/0889058

O  00/94,86:089438,-4:9:2,3574708803289,08.420:5

O 4081700/424105708843570;039:817422,30;302470077478

O ,709,997:9,8,0,4/41:2,3-038

Page 61: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 61/96

;03470

%4419070,9089/0103/078414:7-07,88902,7094419870,9089.79.078

%3,-4:9187980/08.7-3

O 39:994382834930..08,779300/946:,14:7399438974:050703.0

O :943424,9/408920,394-0,:943424:8,3/,9,7090.43/943841,:943424:8.4.0

2,3,984:7.079,33,9:7093:8347/0794/0;0454:7:36:0883/;/:,82

,:9039.9,34907939,92,-0,.43/94341,:94342

O 700/4280.:798,.43/94341,:94342

4 0470073,7/$,6:490

/408399305:78:04:7,553088/70.90/4,90932,99078

,3/10/49,9,5530881448

70.95:78:941,5530888801/010,93-0.420,55-/43938

9,9850,94,990,70

O 8,70:020398-,80/4347,58.4441504509047

8450394.796:04109074734998897:0

O 42243574-028/110703984:9438

O 8.:88434194:9830/943/;/:,9

O 4/40,5590,72573.50941700/42418500.

4 &3290/:308890708,.0,78500.9,93.908;403.0

4 ,98,72

7090702:9:,/01394341,72

709070;,74:80;0841,72

4 0390,72573.50897550/920,389,970897,398:891,-0349:8910/

,914://292470/,2,09,344/370897,3390,72

4 47,573.50,3/573.50419089,90/893.9438

,984:/:/04:7-0,;47

4 4:,7034957490.90/1742,72349078

4 4:,;03479945:38,343014790710890.4.08-0.,:8098349:793434:

4 4:,70349,40/94;4,90,1700/42-0.,:8092,208842044/89897:0

O &99.,.::8

4 %42,0,/0.8434:2,20,553088

 4,.94389,9,70/0-,770/

O 9389,91700/42,:94342,:9039.9.,3,.0;024709,3:894;0732039/024.7,9.

,708949,3

4 347/07942,209007,5530880300/94-0.420,:943424:894,.9:,090

07,553088

4 0,;094-0.4202470414:780;089,30,703494-0.420,5507

Page 62: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 62/96

4 10,;0349,50710.90/4:780;08398,0,70:3/07:90/

4 ,7081479084:-0.,:80900714:78341:2,3-038870,90/94,553088

4 %0-08910/0503/843,9,3/44:,70

O ,38989,9041,7-0.,:809/40839,4:894,..08870,843,3/0/:.94394,.9,..47/394

70,843

4 :7,:94342803,3.0/030,70147.0/94.4317439.4:3907,7:0203984:7549039,

147,55308883.70,80/0307010.943938

408340/0,,80,/94,553088

O 83498,39,90/439,;0,/:9

O ,3895,9073,82

O %38473,988910/3/024.7,.

4 48950450/490.:8942,79394:9343

4 43,,38998484::832039,2:8.0

O $42093,-4:998,7:20398.47748;04197,/9438

4 9,/;4.,90,5074/4170-0431470,.507843

O 4080.,70,-4:920/4.70203477,7010

4 !083

4 3,78947.7,9.903/03.

%080:2,38.,3.4397-:9070,907949070,907,553088,3/9057470884190

850.9080/408939844/147,419497

O 0854982890/0897:.94341473,9

O %,98.830.088,71473/;/:,50450

O ,721:.43/:.9573.50

4 !74-,-941,72

O 40-0.420,5507974:340/0

O 0.,3,,8-0743848945

O 9-08420-0301994.407.350450-:970,907,728/430

O 7090800257.,.,28

Page 63: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 63/96

439/

 4;

,5907

O :3.4397484840,39894,494-:938-:9,;08,10,:7/8

O :/3914784.,,3/0,70897,398-,80/43,72

4 07-,71470,70897,39

O  00/94:/0900110.941,5,79.:,754.0/7:3-0,93810

O ,72573.5083/41,97570097,/0030/439389,90110.9490750450

842054.082,-0,721:-:99/4083920,3084:/3907;0730:99.,.:,943

O 4:84:/5:3850450574;/3.47748;057,.9.08988250/390,2-3

0,250

4 $4.,3907893570;039384.,;.08

4 40898/839.434/:5

O $905035

4 ,4:0990525

4 10938420938-,/84:/390/43842093,-4:99

4 !,9073,89.;0414;9;.0,3/

4;9,70,-4:9.079,344/938,3/.407.;0

,39894/08974247,9247,98,444/93

O 40870,,39948:0899,924700;89,;0.420

7043,3/247,9

O $9050384394,99,.147.477:5943247,9

O 8,2/74339072841494/0;04590

3/;/:,

O /408,;0842039070893247,9,984200;090041/7:3

4 070/484.908798-03,3/4:7/;/:,79803/

O &3;078,0,9.,704:/3909,99,82,3/,90/-:9090,..08

O 8,147314,/2897,9;0.0397,,943-,/2:.0 %4.6:0;0-:990

4;0792039.,3/88020,9031472,943

4 40821,;478.0391.31472,943 -739-,.94,72573.50,9/408

,7220,34/01308,789070,309:7,8.0391.89,3/,7/147,72

O 701,.98;,:0309:7,

4 ,94:/904;0732039.4480

O ,98097394/498/4.973003:30-00;088/4.973048793

147%7394.70,90,247,994-70,97,33412,4795,.01475594/0;0453,

 5,.00703/;/:,984390/0.30

Page 64: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 64/96

O $0.:798,44/342,9907,93/415078430,709070,70.43/94381474:7

 5747088

$90503

O !,234990,/;4.,90

O 40803.4:7,0,8,43/;/:,824080:891803.0349801/0;0452039

O 408$90503

O 4082,;0,74:3/14781,93:2,370,8435190708, 4/30,;038

9,9349,3317302039438904741-079,..47/3944390/,:/02039

948,50,8/2801,3/:7934430

4 247,93;4;08574-94384828/4.793.03.4:7,39047803/41

2247,98970,8.439039439,9,247,98-,/

4 82,4374421472:950247,90847432,3247,9

80,/;4.,93147,247,8890288-099079,3843247,88902

O $905038349455480/94-079

O %38.407.43844/9344/3,9:708.4201742/8.530

O $0380415747088384.0932,83984.092574;0/974:147.0,3/247,80

%0701472,943,3/90703.#0;

O %389,98573.5081,:3/0784309

O 4083,;02,0,2508

O 888902831,.9,247,9

4 39407,3941247,99,9/43970802-09

O 47748;0944907247,99,9839,3

Page 65: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 65/96

,7,3/9008":08943

3708543/394,:07,72,084304190248903/:73,7:20398174280,77938-20,3841

3974/:.3,/893.943-09003549.,02,3.5,943088039,907,3941-07,798,3/-07908,3/

:2,302,3.5,943,7870594,:0789,9549.,02,3.5,943850710.9.425,9-0990.4393:0/

08903.0417043,890.43902547,70,2504190&390/$9,908/0243897,90840;075:832,99078

/005073,3,7:2039703;0390/-33:207,-0.79.841-07,82,7,7:089,9349438549.,

02,3.5,94338:11.03994-73,-4:9:2,302,3.5,943983842080380,84,-,7707-07,798,3/

/0,841:89.0,70570280/4390/0,9,90,.41:8300/857490.94317424907:2,3-038%0701470-07,

798,7079841805,7,943/0830/9457490.9:817428:.507.0;0/970,98700/42438:.,;08

1700/421742390710703.0,998;04;074488905488-9147,7901,.99,970,1700/428

94-014:3/5489;034:770,943894907504509894-014:3/3:2,3.422:39349384,943$4

3889343,70204179803.4:7,08:894;00,.49073,8.:3/07230905488-9419070,

1700/4202,13/3:2,302,3.5,943 4084:/-0.0,79,9,7/408349455480549.,

02,3.5,943147080089,9-07,828,70,92574;02039439088902841570:/.0,3//8.723,943

.0890/390072,3418/, 0;07900888:.549.,02,3.5,90/-07,822:89-097,38.03/0/

439074:909403:30:2,302,3.5,943&31479:3,90,730;07908:8,9:2,302,3.5,9438

,94:98.0,79,998.48070,90/9490/0,41343,03,90/,-4:7.005470-04

;84.093,78-4:708084.09,,389-07,89,90,3/.43.059438415:-.,3/57;,909,90

/8.:880/,7,3,38998/;843-09003549.,,3/.;84.094:78084.0957424908/;843

,3/89,3,943408,,38990/0,9,9:2,3-0381:190280;0890,.4907079,3:3/0789,3/341

 574708884.0908,70743147,7/3,.079,35,99073!747088,3/8947,884.,90/92,907,

/0;045203984184.09,7,7:089,9:2,3-038-0.420:2,3025,3.,5,943,70,9070;041

:2,314:78324;084:941908057;,903907,.9438!49.,02,3.5,943803,89,9089,3/8,-4;0

.079,3/;8438384.0970,9089079850450,33.;84.09%03843-09003901700,3/06:,

70,9438,8.9038,3//;843893.;84.09%00330418947.,.,30890.,88897:090

0330419,984:7300/94574/:.0-07,/024.7,9.47/0787057080395747088-:9,709003/415747088

!49.,02,3.5,94381700/421742704357450796:,1.,943809.

,7870,973949,,-4:990,84.09847,30/,3/4970,894/8.4;07904.-03/9

,7,8,574-029,:07-0.,:800/408392,08,7:2039850.1.034:39072841,93/41

02,3.5,943,3/,998:3/073.43/9438

O %044.,6:08943949,9/85:903072,3

4 0.4208,6:08943417043,3/89,90

4 %7,38,90,9034394,78290728

O !74;089,97043.4393:08940890389,90805,7,9089801174270438

4 &808&$,8,30,250.43.0730/9493870,,70

Page 66: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 66/96

O !49.,02,3.5,943;08:8-079:2,302,3.5,9438,0747/0793

O $97438038041:2,35488-9

4 40;078349:3,,7041903/;/:,829,90898384.09.79.083903,2041,

07:2,3840.9.43/94382,0:8.425099;03493,9:7,40,70

:2,302,3.5,9437024;09080.43/94380300/9402,3.5,90/1742

4:7/;/0/3088

,9570;0398:8174202,3.5,943,59,8200203989,9147.0:894

 -0/;/0/

O %4.6:0;0,398949025079

O 903843-09003,89,909,9/40839.,70,-4:970435745079,3/,.;84.099,989.,708,-4:9

9080938

4 ,8,.9034:70,90944907.9038

O 89,90,8,889,908309:7,908989457490.99017,204741798-:984.098-4:3/:59,

41908057;,90.422920398

O ,78:8389072894/08.7-0,84.099,9,8-003/807.-0/-,3/%4.6:0;0

4 $0993:5,.796:0419884.0939850.0

4 4.9,910,701700,3/06:,549.,9,3084:/-084:2,3

4.0897:.9:7,250/02398174298,55033

O !6:490

4 #0,,3/14720/08903.83.;84.09,3/4:7/0,08903.0390728414:7798,8,

.903

4 #9841.903,3/798412,3:897,90984343/893.943

Page 67: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 67/96

,7,3/8947.,,907,82

,9898/0,41903;8-0,3/

O /0,9,990708,,72434139070898

4 ,7570803989,9.,88,71,70,8,.,0304198/0,

8.,88,710,708003,8,-,/93

/0,412097974.7,.

O ,.41,7/47-449897,553548943

O 4/408,74,,38998/0,4120794.7,.

4 0,703491700-0.,:804:75,.0384.098.444803147:8897:.9:702,99078

8894741,9.,7,.90708897:.9:70,894/490.4342.8

4 !045040;0.,70841.,88,71,70/48494/090724700549,9;0

 5,79.5,94341.,88,71,70080,98458

,7839070890/3,9870,,55033034:1449,92430

97,

,28088039,9,99047078,03,90/072,347/147

0897,302039,90574/:.0,3/40574/:.02,99078-0.,:80

:2,38,702,078%03:2,384.098.,7,.90/-49574/:.08

#0/:.9;00;0793/0503/84390800.4342.70,943858

/0,81:3.94394:8910.4342.70,9438582,09028002

24703,9:7,/0504501742800340.4342.70,943858

0110.902807;0903907089417:3.,88 -449897,5538,3

/044

#0;4:9438389474..:7,8,.,3041,30.4342.88902

O 207.,35,7908,70-490549,9;0

4 ,9,-4:9,2//0.,88

4:.,38,4:,;0,;03498-:990,703902//0

O ..4330.943-09003,0,3/8:7;;,

4  00/9409,,0,9,.489940054:-,70,;094005473

4 10,7084.,.70,9:708,9,70900110.9841-03470390/94,7/89057;,90

3,03,94341504501742490750450

!0450/439,;094.70,9070,9438

03,943,8,20,3841349-0384.,

10,703,9:70384.,-0389,30,7043,,3894:73,9:70

:2,314:7838703/070/25488-0174284.,897:.9:70

Page 68: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 68/96

O 408-,.94

4 %01:3/,2039,4-89,.09414:7838

03:3045570880/-,47/9,984:9414:7

.43974

4 8903.08349807;34:710890-089

 574-02

&809147-,8.8:-89,3.04707

4 $:7;;,85,.0/4;0714:783

4  00/9444,990,50450,70,3/90,9070,10

,78:945,80350450.,3,.0;098

O 0.42-4308,70,89..796:041847/,3/.43438989,4501:308841,98

 5488-0%084:7.08410;,703493:2,3-038.,487442147504509474

,3//0;045

O 4707/40839;04-0.99,902,08843

O ,-4789008803.041:2,3105/0130-:9,90/470,9;094,90,3994

/410,8,7084:7.04397-:93944:743807;9:9/0053940307,90,47/9,9

8,,3892801

O ,7:2,382,03,34:7801147243/;3006:,9084394 4/1,80.43.3

O !:993411;394473494;0,907

O 4707890207.490574.088,3/9834944/147904707

O !

072,3/04

4 :2,30307083944-0.9

4 03,943

4 422:382

4 8947.,2,907,82

%,98-0147050450.4:/7035,7943 ,9:709801147983,9:7,300/8324/07384.091430

,398940,94302:89479843974: 24309,94302,8:7;;0%:8190,03,9434190

4707.4388983-03, 8,;094,7/984-0.99047078/4:-,03,90/ 1789070.0;08,3

4-0.941,-4:79,98013/847,84308,8 13,14:3/47(,3/80.43/070.0;0820,38

418:-88903.009070-408994,-4:7(905488-9940891789,8,470780.43/,8,

 58.,8:-0.9%0,89897,4198807;9:/0478071/42(89,9984386:,9,8,47079,9

 507298294.4393:094.43807;02801,8,58.,8:-0.9,3/9843,8,58.,8:-0.99,9

Page 69: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 69/96

0.,3-0,4707 3490747/8904707700843,-4:79413/243094-0,-094;0-:90

/40839825;00,.9:,438:7;;08,8,4707,-4:7843:80/94.70,9024700,9

3890,/41,.0;3901:1203941 :2,33,9:70%83907;039434190.43.05941 :2,3

3,9:70,8,84-00343041904389,3/31,.94783989098-03,703470/,8980020/944

:2,389,3/90701470,394 -07,82,3/-4:7048548453,907,80380,54845

14:3/0/4390-4:704879841,3574.,20/390 0.,7,9434190#9841,3,3/41

90903

0,7:089,99047078,03,90/314:7,8

03,943174290574/:.90574/:.08

%0,-4:7-0.42082507843,

03,943174290:2,37,.0

03,94317424907:2,3-038

Page 70: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 70/96

,7

,7,8,84.,8.03989

O 408-,.944.0,3/8,82430,82,/09489,3/,7/097,38,.9438-:92,/0

306:,908

O %03,033:08947.,8947390,.,8870,943858 !74/:.943

4 700894.034938-0.42094.4224/10//4080,/947488

306:,9

4.08054:3/3-4:7800247,9

4 :70/0103/810:/,/044

0:/,828,34/24/041574/:.943

4 ,08:893,-4:990897:.9:704184.09

O 306:,93.,59,8283,9:7,

4 70,90504504,;0349301994480

,3074:80390,70,494150450098

30;9,-04:9.4204;07974-9005490/

O ,289,9902//0.,880;039:,-02574;80/

4 #0,943858-09003.,8808

4 89897:0

O !,7908/4392,990757490.932430/3907089889,90.,3-017004190800.4342.

70,943858

O 4330.94394%4.6:0;0

4 024.7,.8,,8324943,,8.,33

4 ,59,82890/9.70,9;0/08.97:.943-4994241

O !90574/:.9;0147.08,990/8548,4184.09

O 4:/.,59,82-73/43.,59,82

O 4;0732039829349-0.,5,-041570807;39907:084190,20

O !5099-4:7080

O ,3.,303908890241.,59,82

O 0.4:5310,3/-07917429089,90

4 4.082,83.,88/110703.0838:891.,94341.422430,9

,398,80.:,7:891.,9431479089,90,39894979424/07,904;07320398,8

9070,90949074350450

4.08,84:300/94-,804:7:891.,9434390-08974:5

O 3.82,-4:90700,7034,3/4501:3088,4-:90700.4:/-0897.9:700983

90,,7

4 4.088.059.,,-4:9074041897.9:705:98943:2,33,9:70

Page 71: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 71/96

82,7908-090034.0,3/,7

O .,7,.90704306:,98/0;0450/3,82,7,.4330943-090032430,3/

306:,9

O 80.:,75.9:7084184.09

110703.08

O ,74:/8004.0,857490.93-4:708089,90-0.,:800,/;4.,90814757490.94341

9089,90

O ;079334.08,.4397,.90,708018-038

O 472,7,9/408920,394-0,942039047/

4  5548908,03,94303:2,38-0.4202,.308

4330.94341 ,39

O !747088;0;0419047/

O  ,395708247,,-84:9089,9,7.79.08,8:33..088,714.:808432,907,82

O ,757;0857,.9.0

:70

O 7,3.938947

4 $420,550,94905,89

O ,98,789,..:4:39418947.,.,30#0;4:943

4 #0;49438,7030;9,-0

O :709389,90,7038947,3/.,3909,,174298,20147,7 0,70

8947.,-038!485.,39,79.:,905072,303984:/-:9.,3/03910700,70

,3/0700,7043

%4.6:0;0

O %,8,-4:906:,941.43/943070,82,79,8-4:9306:,941.43/9438

842093,-4:9/024.7,.8,9810890:2,304

O ,79,09006:,9.43/9438349,8,0307,9;01,.9

4 #0,306:,908

O 49,70.438/070/9:2,314:783

4 110703.084904,-4:99

$4.,39080380

$420939,98970880843003

Page 72: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 72/96

4 ,7,8,2477,/.,8038041,9:2,3-038706:709

796:0434:708084.098430418-0894890

422:382470724;020399,9570..0/9057409,7,9.439744189,90

44/549.,5489;0,9:2,3-038,70,-4:9,93/41.70,9:708,70:2,38

700/428002894705,.0;79:70407341549.,,28-,8..43/943841:2,384.,-9

 574;/08,8244917,2047070:2,3-038.,314:78 700/42,3/14:783,7030/47

,7700/425:91479--4:07808,0,73.79389:7.:97087,/.,4501:,-4:9

:2,33,9:70/0,9,9:2,3-038,7044/4;07459289.3:2,33,9:704.0247070,89.

.796:0412,7439074:3/841:2,33,9:70

Page 73: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 73/96

09.0-043/44/,3/0;

,7/94805,7,9054845,3/70947.

%889070;03041,7894.7,.3,7,/.,147279.,414:7450,3843 894:9,8

90-,88147,4941/8.723,943,94788:08549.,224/07,943 %044/,7:89108,3.,:80

3025,8841.431.9.7:09

99,.90089347/07

 82

$0982801,,3895,94.79.17429079

%7,38;,:9439489,3/,,389,570.0/3970;07804:7,8841247,9.796:04124/0739

/0,41,78947.7,9.7,/.,700.94341906:,941.43/9438303/41-0330950412,3

!701,.0

O ,985,79.,0/

4 390570:/.084154845078

!07850.9;82

507850.9;08,70;0890/5489438

%,9..,2894-04-0.9;0.,294-097:08,2,894,;0

349-00314:3/-:92,/0

439344,7094,5574,.9097:9

42,9.548458,89097:9843093

O 3,99,.43/42,9.82408,3/3,3/97,/.,

 507850.9;,82

 343430801,8-00343041905704..:59,9438415485078

941789,39

,8.70,90/,903843419085798490380,-40.,38449147

902489/89,394,8

O 789,39,870-03:2,38579

O ,39894,7308898903843147854845

4 4:/ 09.0-0,,389/024.7,.

:2,370,93088/084:9

%7,33414147241:2,3-034;07073/

0907230840/893:808,3/4:2,38974:/7;0

/090723,94309.

,2,3:7450,3857999038439,98/1107039174290.:77039

97,0.9479,9:7450,38,7043

#,/.,,3984.,.43.0594341903/;/:,5488-9

:2,3-038.,3-0.42004/2,-0

Page 74: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 74/96

330908/0,8

4 0,705:7,

;07/7;03:8,398949,04;07-:95484507.,397,330902

%038432,085488-084201:9:704,

4 $:57,549.,4,70334;,94341:2,3850.08,830,9;0549.,

.43349,94388:-47/3,908549.,.438/07,94389497,38549.,4,8549.82,

 574;0902489/,3074:8549.8343

O $0.94341!,79

4 /40,3997:97,9079,3:397:9

,98901:,3/,2039,570:/.08415485078939097:9844/

349:397:9

5483570:/9.08-431,79079054845.74,/

4 ,9890;,:04197:9

4 !70;4:85485078//393490280;084,413054845

4 10/09743097:9,890:92,90;,:09,3,994705,.09

8910;347/0,9;3

O 0,7039,39070,702:95041:8

O $0.943

4 #00.91,9,3/4554890;,:08

,8.1472411,9:8:,2508/:,82

39247,

40839939070247,8

%38025,98,897,3093;072:.-00;083.7:09

00;089,92489504508-0018147290710

O $0.943

4 !54583490;0317004:723/82,349-01700-:90-0.420170085798

 548545,83893.9;0

O $0.943

4 %01,8089:/0203982,-090248930.088,7147:8

4 %470430/:397:9,8.43/9434110

4 $420497:9807;0810906:0894341979:9-0.420808825479,39

O 47,82147908,041850..08

O #0,94385-0900397,33.,/7;041973,39,3/44/41490750450

O ,39894-030199480402801 :9:701703/85,39745.25:8083 0980

O $4.0908981479014:7834190089:2,38

O ,9,40/900,94/423,90

Page 75: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 75/96

4 0,8,8947,-4:949,55030/,3/4:/094:3/4990,3.

9,9,55030/,48147994-0/430

4 %03093.42084:94190/0897:.94341904/93

O 3/41,88443,854845-00;08980199708942,09047/47/82,/04390

 -,8841/0,8.,702,/01742147.0

4 %09-,.94309.0

O 945407

O !,79%0700$ 579

4 89885791700-0.,:8090344307//03

!1098018945407

%38,550334.,:8:,70,9438583484:/8:89,9,55030/

!

Page 76: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 76/96

470098.0

!,79

,389-07,/024.7,9.47/07824/07330244330;03/0,8

!4845,3/549.8,8807;0//4239,3974:58-:9370/:.0899458.4,80;070890

70,94385-0900397:0,3/44/ !07850.9;,82

110703.0-0900304907.08947.,;,,-0147/110703950450079,3147284110,7089743079,3

49078,/;4.,901478974307147284110 %34194.6:0;08.796:0410;039030/03.0841

/024.7,.08,3/5:994389074/8309.0,3994/893:8-090039017008579,3/90

 548507841901:9:70,98 098.08/0139434189743:/020398,702:/020398

,3/4:7:/0203984,,3892147284110907014709,98, 300/944,,3894:

O 78980.943,99,.854845.,/42,982507850.9;,82443,9;,74:8;08

/42,898-00;089,9907:020398,7099043:/020398,3/,70,99,.0/949023

,/42,9. 8,84:.,3-00;0,90;074:,39-:9:89-0.,:804:.,398,98

 -,/-0.,:80-00;09,3/.,20:59989743,;0,79944;07.420900,

,3074:8147549.8309.0,8,074,938/024.7,9.8,70.4397-:9394

4073:2,33,9:70,0308/0;04555

!,79

50450/0;045-9,3788,3/.,0303430801

O 9454073499410

4 3/4,83498:7;;,

O 7001742/42,9821,934554890;,:08700;,:9,943414:7;,:08

O $0.9433974

O $0.94370,94385949017008579948.439025,790880.943

O 4:941901700857980.943

O $0.94317008579097,247,

O !07805.9;82

O 25.,9438419080,7:02398147:3/0789,3/39047/,3/,4110

O 17008579,3/548450741901:9:70

$8902418:5547994/0;0451:9:70548450790805485078800294-0430

O 9497:98088039,,941,8044/93841938,8-0343,.4393::2

$0.943

O ,797/42-3/8902,797/4294908097:98,3//0103/890280;08/42,9., %0

30548450784://028011742897:92,09800200843,,389

789834198/0,41902,8,70,9-44.,343-0:3/078944/-70,9:2,3

 -03870,923/8-0440/,9-,/844:84://8:804:7801,3:,43

 570807;,943,3/.:9;,9434190548450741901:9:70 !4850783/0.30,;0,3

:30,970,94385-0900347/

Page 77: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 77/96

44/,3/-,/849:/0

4197,0/,3/.420/

$0.943

O 4.0:2,3-038390/024.7,9.47/8008499:/094,;4/.439,.9994804

,7034990706:,8:308890,;0050.943,:2,3-0388002944/9073480

,,38970:,7504502:894,24389:8940,73.079,3938

O 890050.94394:9,370,94394907:0

4 %0050.9438314720/-907:0302:89:3/0789,3/907:094:3/0789,3/

90280;0814:,7090050.943

O !6:490

4 -04194706:702938,3/23/41430

4  -00;089,9247,3/3,94384304190-089,78

$0.943

O ,7/0794-0:3/078944/

O #0;078008490782

4 548082470/,3074:8.,28

4 /0884209397:07,3/24708:-90-03/9080.,28

$0.943

O %0254

O !8.444190254

$420803809090.42.830.088,794,0;,909097,.84209397,.,3/5,31:,-4:997:

933

$0.943

O 3/0503/03.081479010

O ":08943383498,109070,70/,3074:86:089438

$0.943

O 700893898

O 4907.,3/084907.5439

O ,9844/1470795088-,/1474079508

$0.943

O %04:94117008579

Page 78: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 78/96

$0.943

O 7341,.943349.43806:03.08/0907230247,941,.943

O $4204,9,703903943,3,.9438,70247025479,399,3903903943,

$0.943

O 47,3,09;0981,98,89:5/9-0.,:8090708990434743:8

O !07850.9;,5485078-08:85.4:8

4 $42093,-4:990572,.4190,55,703947/

4 47/9,9.43.0738:8.,3-0,1.94347/839075709,943

$0.943

O  4/893.943-09003902,97,47/,3/4:747/41/7;08,3/5,88438

4 ,907,47/824705729;0

!70147241;0

 4/893943-0900310,3/34310

O 34/893.943413/-09003902

O %0.4384380412094//02,3/895

4 ;07.4234154845-4393914439949024893,9:7,

0903843,3/.43.:843!484598010,/8949814:3/,943-031,9390

807;.04110%,38.0391.2094/,3/0903/3994901:790785439

O  4994,88:20

O ;07938945407

O $:5548013,9,908:..00/0/5

4  4/893.943-090038579,3/5407,,70.,.9070/-

4 ,741147.08

O 548450,/894945407

0.,3-00;09,9,99807;0810,19070700.94554890;,:088420933989,92,08

 5484570430-0.,:809807;0810 197:9834430725479,39,984503147

 5845078

3,97,93

O 70085790/58407

O ;0757414:3/8579300/8,2,8

90894308019413/3/0503/03.0

Page 79: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 79/96

9739403.4:7,0892:,903/;/:,8474:5

70,9938147907,9

$0.943

O 700;07857989080584507841901:9:70 !79.3/423,39;041,9

,170085798#070,/

Page 80: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 80/96

098.08:22,708

 043/44/,3/; 8,.42570038;04;07;041 098.082,9:7054845%0-44.438898

41,5478287,3330391742,10803903.0894,105,08 %080,547828,7074:50/

902,9.,394330/1107039.,59078,3/,70-4403/0/-,5701,.0,3/,5402 00,.

,54782.,389,3/43984390708,8484209341,30,7574708843-09003,54782893

.,59078,3/1742430.,590794,34907 430900880,.,5478257080398,/893.9;0543941;0

,3/0;03903/;/:,.,59078:22,708429,70,9/0,

%05701,.0,..:8085484507841/42,982,3/901789.,590705470898.,2;0770,9

 54845 098.0,880798899024709,390507843,.43108843 !4845078-:/:5.4250

8890284194:994:89190743,88:259438,3/570:/.08 10.,3/90804:90.,3800

,9908054845078;,:02489/005,3/84,3389394907.,7,.907

 098.0.4397,898907/42,982990 170085799,98349.,:9:53,5,79.:,7543941

;004508905484507841901:9:70-0.,7,.9070/-8:.,305072039,2094/

394974:9,3549088,3/144,3,7:2039,90,9498.43.:843

1907,/8.:88434190704:88579.0.,288,3/41/42,982  098.002-,7843,

8070841057,28248941.94:7-,77058.44.,2,0:5  090448,99043

894741247,889028,8,80941/1107039,9902598,98014;07.423 0850,84:989743,,389

90247,9419007/9,903.4:7,08,/:20/4.793,013/88:.,20/4.79324/073

8.4,785.84;07.43.0730/9/3:5/7/:1,.98  098.08/0,5484507

.70,90820,33,3/;,:08,3//408349825/0,902591,.98

 098.0,8807989,990708,3 47/07417,3 ,..47/394.908579:,89703941,50450.,3

 -020,8:70/0.,:804198/110703.0-090035045094:/-0,-8:7/94,55430247,.4/094,

 50450 098.08:08989,9908974308950450,702,70/-,.7:099490280;08,..47/394

.90207.088054809070;07570:/.0,3/,88:25943347/0794/2470/005394

90280;089-4994240;070;07430,8570:/.08 %4574;0985439 098.0,:3.08,3

095,097,/0,,3894203

 090,//708808906:08943413,943,908,3/3,943,82/7,343,3/41,2,7.829,9

8008/11070393,943,90847 7,.08,8307039,;3.079,3.,7,.90789.8 2434907938

 098.0,99,.8,39$02982.79.089038,3/,/;,3.0890.43.0594190 44/

:7450,347808,-4;03,943,89803920399413/97:03/;/:,9

%013,.,590757080398 098.08.43.0594341,9834-0,849,78:1107384:4,8

7803841,7,-4;090.422437,--0,894-0:370.43,-0,3/949,28:3/078944/-902 0

.480890-449,0,5402,-4:98:.,34-084:899343,24:39,3945830,/2470

1703/8

3:3/0789,3/341 098.0847,8,40700843,84/7,85418;084397:9,3/

,3:,0,3/8209,58.8,3/.43.059434190945407 990;07-4994241 098.08

 548450890.43;.9439,990:3;078083,.4389,3989,9041.,30,3/8,970/,3/

Page 81: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 81/96

/85,7,0203941,2489,3548943.,3-097,.0/-,.949,9548943890259,9439444,990

:3;0780,810/34305,.0 098.088059.,41-49,3:,0,3/ 97:9-0.,:8090,70,-0

94,/459,10/507850.9;094,7/938

47/8:3094:98,7010/:794:98.,314,3/.,30:89,8938390:3;078014

,3/.,30-:9,47/43.0:99070/.,3349-0.,30/ 0.,:80,3:,0,898903/03.94,7/

199057088089047/390728411,.98,3/938.,80/548450789493419047/

,810/7,9079,31:/47/417/1,.98.,3-085403,-4:9/0139;0.89084:7.041

4:7.43.059434197:9,3/4907,-84:9088:.,8 4/,3/247,9

 098.08008901,.98,3/9384197,/943,54845,81,717427/,3/8:-0.994,8479841

8198,3/.,308085,79.:,7-7,393,3,3247,984344:7.43.05941 44/

147389,3.0,8,/455489020,338,9/11070399208 %0:3/073147.0/7;3,.,308

,..47/394 098.03850.1.,/7;08-4/4394,945407,/7;01471700/42,3/

/423,9434;074907938%0.43.0594144/,8,//110703920,3384;07920-0.,:80

/11070398,;0.42094,557457,9090.43.0590,33,3/39075709,943,7020708389,9,

84507,9343,.43.059

0.,:801,.98,3/938/0503/14790720,33430;078193,3/897:3890708348:.

93,8430.4770.947,-84:90;05439;07;0543989005708843418420474907

#,9079,397949,,-4:990 97:9084:/9794702,3,810-0,85488-0443,92,99078

1742,82,3/1107039507850.9;08,85488-0  098.08/0, 5484541901:9:7084309,98

1700034:94819507850.9;08,3/4;079:7390 97:98,3/4907/42,8417/933$:.

 548454:/800247,.43.05988:.,8 44/,3/0;,820708:71,.089,9,;034307039

20,338:.548454:/9:824;0  -043/44/,3/0; 098.08/0,54845078

4:/,849:739079454073,7/897:3.4389,39,,38990280;08944;07.420907

43570:/.08,3/,88:259438

 098.08:34794/4;084397:9.,3059405,38:3:8:,890 %4:0.,314497,38

4194:9,3/2,0.4330.9438,4390,907083483030,7,7:20399,97:38974:90

 -440.,:80 098.0/4083498009097:9,8,825094/203843,5.9:700.,3349705708039

9,..:7,909,825030,7809. 098.080089047/,8.4250,3/9700/203843,

24700,447,29,3,94/203843,5.9:70 3/:89,8,447,28,9700/203843,

2,02,/0:5413139082,94/203843,17,203980,.,55742,939040  098.0

 57080398847/;03,807084194/203843,,5478280,.,55742,93,2470.4250

47/;0 043/44/,3/; 8 098.08507850.9;82357,.9.00.,370,/0;07,54782

,8430/1107039507850.9;01742.9444,9  098.0854845%07088420847941300

.,397,.024;31742507850.9;094507850.9;0-:9088039,003/:59  098.0854845

3-50.08,3/82,0717,20398 398, 098.0,99025989413/9005708843418

94:983,3:,09,9-089570807;089071:/9,3/9700/203843,9

Page 82: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 82/96

!,79

 098.0.438/07890/02,3/89,9789,392,08147703:3.,943411700/4257/0801

.431/03.0418579,3/2:.080-08/08 %8789,38,3930888-089002510/-9057089

9504/03080;079344/310,3/8:-29828019484,943:29,3/.,899 %8

,8.09./0,,80/,70,91,8.3,9433,5,.08,3/9208,8908,399030110.98,70;078,

070-08,-0942,08801/0-,802039,550,7,89008914724144/ %054074190

8,39 098.08,808570.80390289074190;,:041,98801/03, $4204303

8:-29932801948:.9479:702:893484209390708941:8/43934 %08,390025108,

301472415407,30945407

 098.0.,7,.90708:894/,,8-03,9089.-:989704:8 %0/0,8414/,81,907:/0

4770,7/07,70344307;,/4//4083498002940,7:834794708543/4/07354845,8

 -003,70,905949074941,9082 36:089433908:-0.9570/.,901472417,22,79,8

6:089430/0907907070,8,3 /893.9174298570/.,908 3/4:-939084;070394198

0/4:-99008903.0419084:847043/02,3/8,08:70.,889,9.,344/434347

80039,8,/897,.94317428579:,2,99078 984:/.420,8348:757809,9983/:8974:8,08

9:733,,17427043

0 098.08:08989,99024/073,08,9089.0938982,70/-,30;078974307

704:88579,-094309,9,80;4;0/-043/9082#043/02,3/88,.71.0,3/35729;0

70438988,.71.0,841,4;0/43047,1789-473430,8,80/948,.71.0430830,7089,3/

/0,7089%88579418,.71.0,870130/849,903443078,.71.0/49078-:98,.71.0/4:780;08

3890,/08:7703/070/4:74:71700/42,3/4:7897039944:7 4/,;3.4250908,.71.0/

4:780;08903094.,8905,89,99,03-789,3908,.71.0/4:7 4/90430933

.0,/5,.0/,4:74508,3/1,9,;38,.71.0/4:74/0,703401993493

,3/478574.87,;9 9034930,;097,/0/4/31478.03.0,3/47859,93890,/

10/0;0/005034:394985088282,3/38240;07  098.08:089802913/90

248910,11723857941,905078439,983494370.43.0/9,9,98-:94:/89

7050,90/394,090739

#043.,320,3/1107039938147/110703950450 %4907:3.,880898,20,389470,9094

9078:-0.98,3/94005902330%4,783.,88990,.08801/8.530,3/5705,7089147

1:9:707:0%4902,8808990,.08902947089.43903939074548943 :97043/408349

43807;0490785:754808789,39,85:754808419843 !72,79800894570807;0,3/.,70

14790:2,3850.08%820,38570807;3902,4794,708.,3/0,418579 8,708:99

.420894;,:0908:11073,3/900,3088394809.,708147 90110.98,949,70;078,34:7247,

;,:,9438849,90,3088,3/8:11073,70.438/070/ 44/,3/0,9,3/897039,70.438/070/

0;00.,3,/270908579:,20341:7450 098.0.43.:/089,998/0;,:,94341

,4:734-03893.98,8-70/,:74504120/4.79,3/-,3,9

Page 83: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 83/96

422039,7

&3/0732:.41,9 098.08,807089025479,39.4397,89-090032,8907247,9,3/8,;0

247,9..47/394 098.0247,9,8473,,2,9907418,39,90,9897039

1700/42,3/90007044/,3/9,9907:3/087,-045548908070-,/ %8247,9,8

70;0780/-90:/04789,3 8,;070;4941247,9 07094804070309070,989743

3471700.,2094708039905045035489438415407,3//03910/902,8 0;%0903.,2094

/039190280;080,8.,3/5447,8 44/%8890702,7,-070;078,4190,8.09.57089

478,39413/854073,9:7333,7/41,,7088;03893.98

 098.0.,7,.90708902,47941:2,39,8 0, ,3/8. -0.,:8090,.90540794

/70.9907,7088;03893.984:9,7/ 54478,;0.,334913/,34:9091478,32,3893.98,3/

849:7388,7088433,7//0;0453708039203994,7/9480445570882 0.,:8090

2,47941:8,7082,73.,5,-0414:9,7/,708843789,395,3/07894982,479,3/

.70,908,0,;039,970,7/854;079.,899,3/:29 %4804,;034540739810,70

.43;3.0/9,990,;054073,3490710

%:8789,3903.4:7,08,3/70,7/8908.308808,3/0,3088089,9  098.0938084:/

97944;07.42095078:,/08:8947089.43903934:70,30887,9079,39497947489743 0.,:80

90789,33893.9,87438454071:3:74509,8/0;0450/,:74509,9800898

20/4.79,8,4,4795:78:3

981,843,-0948008.03.0,890,399088417043,8,30025,74170,843193,,3891,9

,3/8:5078994340;07 098.0/4083498008.03.0,8,147.0455480/947043842:.,80

80089,870438,9089/0;0452039 098.0;083,3,09,9,8-0.4203.70,83,9089.

 -:93.0-00;0890789,33893.994,7/0,3088,3/20/4.79889743079,30;07

$.03.0,8-0.4208:5702054071:398,0-0.,:809570,.089,9907083420,33,9,

9070,70:8990,84158.8,3/903907,.9438412,9907 38.03.0,8.09.82,87438489743

9,99,87034:3.0/349438970390,9,3/,553088-:90;03 4/4,8570;4:89043

 :891.,943147,8.09.82 098.0.,7,.9070898,.415489;01,9,8 382,3/80089,8

,70,9/,3070300/84209394,21478420074,470;0:5431003970 3

,3490747 098.0574509.,3989,990382418,01019:3.0.0/0,/94

,78:30,3980,79,80;078003

 098.043,:/08-701380.9439490147.09,904508455480382 10.,3800

,:3;07804120,330880;03981443430,1907904907,3//093988334932470

9,398.4389,39705099430,;014:3/,1172,943570.803900259308841903829,9

970,9038:8 098.03974/:.0898/0,.,0/90 09073,70.:7703.0,990.2,41% :8$540

 ,7,9:897,,3/.438/0789890.:23,94341,854845 &31479:3,9034-4/8002894

,70043,99009073,70.:7703.0847,9920,38

Page 84: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 84/96

304190-099071472:,9438.420817420800:04/8.:88089009073,70.:7703.0,890

 -0341-0.4231070., 098.08209,58.8708984390,88079439,9901:3/,2039,

3,9:704190:3;07808.,30,3/349.4389,3. 1014.:843,98.,337,9079,3,98

702,33908,20080090:3;0780,8-033,507509:,574.08841-0.423 54845

,3/704344814784203/415072,303.03.9474:3/938-09 4/247,9!,948

47284790,8418.03.040;0710.,3,.340/09,93493810/3493897:0,3/

09.00-7,90983.4389,3.0.00-7,9090  -0341-0.423 ,3/,;01700/4:780;08

1742,/42,982,3/1,9

00:088:8943039075709,943419009073,70.:7703.0 ,907 ,:12,33574;/08,088

,/;039:74:8,..4:390308:08989,99009073,70.:7703.082520,389070.:7703.04190

8,200;03984;07,3/4;0794:9.,30 38590412,3/110703.08339075709,943890708002894

 -0,.438038:89,998.:23,94341 098.085484570898390,-9948, 0894,4110

9044/,3/90-,/,3/94,..0599147,99894:9,3-001347450147,393-043/98

10

":089438,;0,-4:9 09.0

O ,980,,9889743

O ,98945407

4 %0945407/08.7-08,9 098.0-00;0/94-0902,3/7;3147.03

2,3,.0;02039,2-94390897;39470,.900895488-0548943310

9080,70,2,31089,94384190945407

O ,989840-:83088

!,79

O 47,98,84/,8:2,39,3/9070,;0-0032,3/11070393/841247,9,.7488

902033,47,5484507894/,,.988947.,507850.9;0,3/380,7.3147,

7,943,14:3/,943147247,9,9070,/489794:89190743247,9

&3,-0948004:98/090507850.9;04190743247,990,70:3,-09480090.43.059

41247,99801,8574-02,9.,3/300/394-06:089430/,3/:8910/

O 39370,99,90,;0,.0;0/47-0.420,8-00390708:941,897.94-0/03.03

4305,79.:,7/70.9434;07,435074/41920 70,9,79933,3/8579:,9,8

4..:770/974:.4389,39,3/,78/8.530 3974:,3/41038,;02039,3/

,7/85.,30701304:780;08

O  098.0,8807989,90,.9:,7089071,70889,30930/4 47389,3.003

0800,97000/43980090/09,410;07-7,3.,3/0,1-:943,3.0,99074:

8,50419040,3/17429,9.43897:.9,9082,07/09,834:70,/ $2,703

070,/,-44070,9,0343,1047/8,3/90319948047/8394,90

Page 85: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 85/96

,70,/93034 39880380 098.08:08980,70,3;039478,79898,3/

,784:784.,0/340/084:7432,0-00;0

O !0450/1107349433,9909384795:78:3-:9,843,9909,094-0

 54880884341,9905:78:0302,32,1000 548808808,42,310.,3,;0

809070,34907100898548808843843479019042,38394

;0:50;07931472%880.43/3/4154880884382,/0902470;,:,-090

2470/0059042,3348902,384902,32:89-0,-0942,0280134394

07,8-0890.,3 098.0,84:8080,250841.,79,3/0/:.,943,820,3841

 54880884347389,3.030/:.,939090,.072,0890./8009047/,..47/394

9090,.078507850.9;09090,.079:8.4208945488088,3490784:

O  098.0-024,38908,;070;493247,9 ..438/070/907.;4039,3/

8038:,94-00;0.438/07390544740,;0.420948000;07930,9

/,3074:8,3/5,8843,90,-4:94:780;08,85,944., %8247,9419007/.,28

3903,2041,5530889,9084:/,;4/4:7/,7073893.98 %82,-097:0147

8420-:9 098.0/085808247,078570.80-0.,:80900307,0432,990789,9

/0503/70,943903/;/:,%070,;0,,8-0032470504504-039,3

.422,3/3-:9825-0.,:80902,47988:90/948:-288;03088084:/349

.43.:/09,9988,0307,573.509,9,84:/4-0  4,/,894804.422,3/

,70,2489,8,20/419,3//,7043/484190/493903,2041 4/90,4790

 50450

 098.08:08989,94:7247,;,:,9438,70-,80/,704310,7 3,.422:399,988,101742

09073,970,98,3,7088;0202-078419,9.422:39.42094-08003,8,970,9 %:84:7

247,9.43/0238,9,98;057010773908,10941,9,20/20/4.702,88 %8247,94190

07/903574.,289801,8904397:0247,94907247,908,70 2247,,3/,8908,;4741

9007/

 098.047708/024.7,9.8039203982,9,20:8,3/703/07:8,06:,320/4.79934,

4:90.,8147,850.0841305484507894,780,3/0,/90,4:9419843314750,.0

,3/20/4.79

422039,7

80,;0/8.:880/0,707 098.08008,/7;08,870893:92,904390945407

 -0,93:5230-47,3/2;3230-47,19,70-4905708843841294540790

,70-49,83..,3,3,10034154074;07230-47 :94899,994949,

4554890/00/8.,3:92,90-4/4394908,20  098.08:08989,900,73948:-2,90

4:79454070.,3309,3/70/70.99347/0794;09,70130/24708:-90,3/07

057088430,93:5230-478,-4:9,8:38:-90,305708843415407,890708 09,8250

,3/220/,907,91.,94340;0717088990:7094-0,9:5230-47,3/3890,/;02,

Page 86: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 86/96

19,;08:-2,90/2945407 4100230-47832/0-9,3/,;0,

70,9074307,893,3/24708:-2010034154079,31 ,/:89-0,9032:5

 098.0.,71089025479,3.0418:-2,943388:089439,970130203983,79933,3/

8579:,9/0503/:543,3/414-0/03.0 14308:3,-094.422,3/430-0,8,;0-:91430

8:3,-0944-0430-0,23/088-,7-,7,3 %7:0,798988:-2990280;0894,3/8417474:8

,8347/0794/8.53090280;08,3/907,79  -0/03.0,3/8:-2,9434,3/3,3/90

4-0/03.041,7989890,.08902948:-2,90907945407849,9907100341540770,.08,

.2,390,.941.70,94348941:8,.909,039,3/90/8.53014797:70,9,79-:91479480

4.,3.70,90,970,9071003415407890709,394349,943089084:7.041842093

97:-0,:91:

0,8480090.43.059418:-2,94357080393 098.08/8.:88434154880884380,25041

902,34 548808808,42,3-,;380907,84390-,8.3438:-2,90/,32,

3893.9841:89%02,34,3989042,394;0:50;07931472,398,247070130/

10034154074;079042,3%82,3,8470.43089,90.,343-0.079,39,99042,38

;3:50;07931472,3/34984201,80.43.059434121803482/005 347/07147

29470;0,2801/005949042,302:891789342801/005 %:8,70130/94

 5407,243490793803.4:7,08801340/0

0,;03414:3/,1472:,147,9 098.0.438/07894-044/8:-2,90/945407 %0

8,;0854070889024/073:7450,3,834,3/90-,7-,7,3,.88:-2,943 0

 098.0,/2708900,954074190;4039-,7-,7,30,/270898540743,8,3

,9073,9;09490254903.419024/073:7450,3

10.4397,89,9 098.0.438/0784795:78:394907247,9080.,3:3/0789,3/0

84-9907/085808:99,7,382/024.7,.,3/4907 9,23147.08%0789,309..8

34904309.,39894850,1470;07430 ;0743084:/4;08470730-47 0;07430

84:/,.9990,553088419070,90893:2-07323/  098.0.,89807/247,9-0.,:80

9850,8944:707/3893.98 9,88:2089,90,70,908,20,3/84:/,144908,207:08

3:73:8948:-2,904:7945407  098.0/408349570903/94-0850,3940;07-4/

$42041:8070825-47394-023/0888,;08,..47/394  098.0,3/948050450,703498

.43.073,947708 098.089,990234799,98549039,70,9,8-00380/:.0/-90

 570,.3419007/,3/,8,9902590/94144908,207:08,80;07430080 %0807:08 098.0

.,280893,705,79570.80940059080170072470/,3074:885798330024.7,.8:89

4302470,99025994147.0:8,94-006:,

0980,8147,3,908970,/0741 098.09434/5,88;0,98.79.82841789,39

247,94720/4.799297,80,1000-748030;108/024.7,. 1907,248941:8

,;0-003-74:9:5949341/024.7,.,8,70,993 %8.422039,7349,990259,

83908841 098.0,3/90/024.7,9.8579,3/93499,0,8/03890,/97089.4390393

Page 87: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 87/96

,;390/:89430,3. 098.08-4/47/;0829,94//890;0793

057080399,01477,390/ 1,39390-07,/024.7,.084194/,4:/80021,7478094

 098.09,3843072,3:7.438:207/7;0384.0981:0,70/94,7/2,310,8

0,8,85488-01470;074308:-2,90/9454078,708:941,897:09,9/02,3/89,90

2,010,8/11.:9,85488-0

Page 88: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 88/96

098.0!,799700

3,,0/3,5740.99,98,20/,9901:9:70

4/408 098.0:3/0723084354845

O 00;0838014;07.4239,0854845.25:801:79079,3570;4:854850708

,;09,0390298404;07.420890570:/.08419054850786:08943890

44/30884197:94354845.74:3/030099490744941548450.,30994

 507850.9;,82

O  09.0.,289,9,90828,704:825:807057080398,50710.94341704:8

25:80

O ,8.,14435484594987449890:3/072334154845

,9890.4330.943-0900354845,3/7043

O 49,7090708:941905407

O !484589024898579:,0/147241,945407

4 5484514738,-4:947/.70,943

O !4845,3/7043,70-49,3,7989.2,33491:/893.9-:98420470,90/

O #04370,908945844

O ;079380110.9

O 0,70/0.33,8850.08-0343/00;0

O ,98,30570884341945407

O :2,3-038,7090.,9,9,;0-0038,50/-704:8,3/548450783,39894

:3/49

4 7:09.43897,39/8.530,70450450,78,50/

024.7,.:3/408.7:09

 -00;089,90,70349.7:0034:.7:098,834194

 540747,20,3841/0;04539

O 5072039,39,3,4

4 !742490807,7.-,80/43897039

O 8947419084:9058.4.,/005033419084:,7094938080089405,3

4 789,3983;44:94341:2,3/087084302:8997,3304;072801

4 %0:2,384:,3/985488-9088,5,0990147  098.0

O  4104:3907808,430300/940307,901703/8,3/807;,398-:9,7/94.420-

03,0/398:39,430

O %0789,31,98,8,.71.0

4 789,398,70,90;-:9,/0050334190:2,384:

4 $,;0247,9-0.,:809

4 3;4:9434184:97,38;,:94341;,:08/1107039174290,3.0947/

4 ;07.42341789,394974:789,39

Page 89: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 89/96

#04:825:8013/8,981.,9433,9082

4 $420789,3504505:38907-4/08,08.2

3057088434190945407

4  4/893.943-0900358.,,3/8579:,

4 97,388943174270094789,39

700802-7,.0100;03901,.0418:11073

.789,397057080398,708030293,,38910100317429047/

 -0.,:800834989743034:941,.010

4 $,39

%089390743,,389908970394190743/08708

803809,9.7893,9870,90/94039032039

7893,98,7043-,80/4306:,941,84:831743941 4/

7,/.,0;037043 -00;089,906:,941.43/9438830;9,-0

024.7,..42081742.789,391473

789,392,0850450,3994-03.0940,.490778890

4.3/943899,950450300/9414:78

O !,79

4 #04:83893.98743-:9909089.8,981.9439701:8089/0058:58.43

#04:83893.980;4;394:9, 4/

0-00;089,9704:8,3/,9082,7070,90/-0.,:800/40839-00;0

34554890;,:0%4/110703939075709,943419047/

,29,9,90828,8905-043/789,39

#,/.,090:2,389

00;04:98/041:89,334939,334:780;08

O !,79

4 3-0900324/07354845,3/789,39

4 ;07.42341789,39

O !,79

4 ;4:943,3//0;045203941704:8.7:09

;4:943418,.71.04:98/017424: 4/147903493,3,.941

.7:095088282,3/382398700.943.,38:089,302-7,.041

8420930800,/9489,00700.70,904:74320,335705,708

:2,3-038743,703901,.041:2,3-0387057080398,3

,1172,9434110#09:7394900,79

789,39100817429070,941105088282

4:/0/498

Page 90: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 90/96

4 3,974:3/83700.935407

#043980187010.94341909454070.,3344307-00;09

43.000;4;0,704308994:780;08

4 3,,3/089748,14:3/,9438-:9/4089,90,/:894,3829,90.,39

094:9414070,-00;03938103402,/0902:5 4/4081,7

 507850.9;,820903/0,3994-00;03,90-00;03-0,:809897:0

349-0.,:800.48094-00;039 83799,90.,3/4,,99097:941

93

$42093574-02,9.93414:3/,9438

4 $42093,-4:93,48:8948,.71.0903414790,907

O %047/,8,89474190945407

O 14:08.09097:9,3/8,90850.088/00307,93,9-,88,70:2,398

,7:2039

O 08973944-043/9044/,3/0;41884.09700.939,99,-041;,:081478

439,-014;,:0874490/390945407

!,79

O %47:985088282417043430,77;094,345928284204 :9,98

9884204

Page 91: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 91/96

Page 92: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 92/96

O

4 ,90938479897;31478,708:9414:73,9:708

O 0850450

4 3;0784341;,:08902,790-033341908,;0247,9

4 70,94385-09003!,943/:/,829,90,/8948,;0247,9

O 247,9,892/9

O 97,3341902,479974:84303840839,39,8,1047/

O 0://09409070/498944-0,,307/247,93;908,.079,33/41

/0854982,93/41/0854982

O ,9,3/70,843,;0-003,/.492,70,8438,.9343-,88413893.984890507843

4,.98431,9

O

4 07/247,98,8.03/,39

4 70,94385-09003903/;/:,,3/,707545:,943

8003983,7243-090033/;/:,,3/84.09

O ,33;0784341789,3247,99389,9902,384:/8,.71.0147901082,79

4308

O ,7/3088,3/80;079,7030.088,7147:2,3/0;0452039

O /40100591474:7030208

O 3/024.7,.0,70908,20/408399803,3.059,3/.425,8843

O 89,,8-08994,;4/,19 09.04:/8,34 8,7030888,44/93

O 40,3990703499394-0,17,/41 4:/8,9,9984:/-090/0.3041

:2,3-03810.,39-0,7/94,7/849078.,30-0,7/94,7/84:780;08

O #070,/94,43

O ,9834-0

Page 93: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 93/96

098.0

070,;00.4201742

070,700%0/024.7,9.039032039.796:08-07,82

070,70043

%08,58.4.,8947:2,3/0;0452039

024.7,.,3/78974.7,.

O 8.03/.04107/247,9.8,9,79,7894.7,9.9508

O #,/.,.796:041-07,/024.7,.

O %46:;04389074/8

O 4,70905484507841901:9:70

O 50.943,3/;:/,8,70349,40/3.43902547,7/024.7,9.84.0908

O ,98;041024.7,.042.7,9.,307/,3

O ,988,..4:39419097,3341902,479

,8280190,39789-0.,:80045548090;,:089,900854:808 098.0839070890/307408

$,89,908807,7.974:23417,.08..,3/00307,90:2,39472,0970,907

',:08,7030/94,93/4147,38280,70#,3041:2,3/0;04520398-0.4233,77407!7;0008

90050.943,93/41:2,3-038743,99504184024.7,.82,39884,7/0794

.:9;,909079504509/408391,;47.7:09#,3825479,3994.70,909007:2,3-0389,9

0/0870880089,998/;0789,8,44/9380089,85747088

#0;090,899470,/3,88320398.480

$947410;4:943

,8,3,7894.7,9.;843410700,7043,9/0130890,7894.7,9..,88

4.07057080398-4:78084.09

 ,39/1107039,..4:3941-07,82-,80/43:2,3798

%4.6:0;0825,909..79.41-07,82#88410/4382

:70.79.390,-07,8241,9.,30884.09

,7.79.314720/-90/0,841-07,8293890.43/943841,-07,84.09/4083492,05488-090

/0,857428089,9-07,84.095742808

 ,7894.7,9..796:04:/8,,78,3910-0.,:8008,3,/;4.,904107/2,3

 5,-,.

O $420938,550335844.,3:7450

Page 94: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 94/96

O !488-9418:-:2,39,3/8:507:2,39

4 $0089,905488-941/0548982307/2,3-0.,:809.,30,/90,9470,70,93088

O $,;07/09072308;79:094-05705,70/94.422,3/4:75045029,;0-003.422,3/0/

$479,38076:089438

700/42,894-00,730/3 ;0

Page 95: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 95/96

Page 96: Liberalism and Critics

8/8/2019 Liberalism and Critics

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberalism-and-critics 96/96