36
Managing from Ridge to Reef: Lessons from Seachange – Tai Timu Tai Pari www.eds.org.nz 1 Raewyn Peart, Policy Director Environmental Defence Society

Lessons from Seachange Tai Timu Tai Pari - EDS Home events/2015 Conference Presentations... · Lessons from Seachange ... • Liane Ngamane ... mauri, is increasingly productive and

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Lessons from Seachange Tai Timu Tai Pari - EDS Home events/2015 Conference Presentations... · Lessons from Seachange ... • Liane Ngamane ... mauri, is increasingly productive and

Managing from Ridge to Reef:Lessons from Seachange – Tai Timu Tai Pari

www.eds.org.nz1Raewyn Peart, Policy DirectorEnvironmental Defence Society

Page 2: Lessons from Seachange Tai Timu Tai Pari - EDS Home events/2015 Conference Presentations... · Lessons from Seachange ... • Liane Ngamane ... mauri, is increasingly productive and

A place of many names: Te Moananui o Toi, Tīkapa Moana,

Hauraki Gulf

www.eds.org.nz2

Page 3: Lessons from Seachange Tai Timu Tai Pari - EDS Home events/2015 Conference Presentations... · Lessons from Seachange ... • Liane Ngamane ... mauri, is increasingly productive and

A place of many peoples

www.eds.org.nz3

Page 4: Lessons from Seachange Tai Timu Tai Pari - EDS Home events/2015 Conference Presentations... · Lessons from Seachange ... • Liane Ngamane ... mauri, is increasingly productive and

One of the earliest that was settled

www.eds.org.nz4

Ahuahu (Great Mercury Island) Ōpito

Sunde site, Motutapu Pig Bay, Motutapu

Page 5: Lessons from Seachange Tai Timu Tai Pari - EDS Home events/2015 Conference Presentations... · Lessons from Seachange ... • Liane Ngamane ... mauri, is increasingly productive and

… and by far the most heavily settled

www.eds.org.nz5

Page 6: Lessons from Seachange Tai Timu Tai Pari - EDS Home events/2015 Conference Presentations... · Lessons from Seachange ... • Liane Ngamane ... mauri, is increasingly productive and

Enormously productive in the sea

www.eds.org.nz6

“They were sometimes acres in extent, vast areas of seething water churned up by trevalli, underneath them kahawai, beneath them kingfish and beneath them again snapper –great pyramids of fish (1958, Peter Taylor, Lighthouse

Keeper, Burgess Island, Mokohinau)

Page 7: Lessons from Seachange Tai Timu Tai Pari - EDS Home events/2015 Conference Presentations... · Lessons from Seachange ... • Liane Ngamane ... mauri, is increasingly productive and

… and on the land

www.eds.org.nz7

Cows per hectare

Page 8: Lessons from Seachange Tai Timu Tai Pari - EDS Home events/2015 Conference Presentations... · Lessons from Seachange ... • Liane Ngamane ... mauri, is increasingly productive and

A global seabird hotspot

>70 seabird species sighted in Gulf (20% of global species), 23 breed here

www.eds.org.nz8

Page 9: Lessons from Seachange Tai Timu Tai Pari - EDS Home events/2015 Conference Presentations... · Lessons from Seachange ... • Liane Ngamane ... mauri, is increasingly productive and

Home to threatened marine

mammals

www.eds.org.nz9

Brydes whale

Bottlenose dolphin

Orca

Page 10: Lessons from Seachange Tai Timu Tai Pari - EDS Home events/2015 Conference Presentations... · Lessons from Seachange ... • Liane Ngamane ... mauri, is increasingly productive and

A vast fish nursery ground

www.eds.org.nz10 Graphic courtesy: John Zeldis

Page 11: Lessons from Seachange Tai Timu Tai Pari - EDS Home events/2015 Conference Presentations... · Lessons from Seachange ... • Liane Ngamane ... mauri, is increasingly productive and

But now ecologically, a shadow of its former self

“Crayfish in those days, you could see them on the bottom”

“Trevally have disappeared”

“We used to gather pīpī and tuatua here 40 years ago but then all the shellfish was gone“

“We used to see the tails of the snapper feeding on pīpī beds”

“The whole bay echoed with the sound of kahawai … there seem to be a lot less now”

“Paua: there were areas where they were so thick you couldn’t put your feet on the ground without hitting them”

Voices from the Gulf

www.eds.org.nz11

Page 12: Lessons from Seachange Tai Timu Tai Pari - EDS Home events/2015 Conference Presentations... · Lessons from Seachange ... • Liane Ngamane ... mauri, is increasingly productive and

Plethora of agencies were failing to reverse the decline

www.eds.org.nz12

Page 13: Lessons from Seachange Tai Timu Tai Pari - EDS Home events/2015 Conference Presentations... · Lessons from Seachange ... • Liane Ngamane ... mauri, is increasingly productive and

Despite the Hauraki Gulf Forum being in operation for 15 years

Recent review (Dr Nigel Bradley, June 2015) concluded Forum not fit for purpose:

“The Hauraki Gulf Forum is failing to adequately promote the objectives of the Act, and will not do so without significant change.”

“The root cause of failure is governance, and in particular the inability or unwillingness of members to collectively act as a ‘political peer group’ to provide the leadership envisaged by the legislation.”

www.eds.org.nz13

Page 14: Lessons from Seachange Tai Timu Tai Pari - EDS Home events/2015 Conference Presentations... · Lessons from Seachange ... • Liane Ngamane ... mauri, is increasingly productive and

So it was decided to try a new approach

www.eds.org.nz14

Page 15: Lessons from Seachange Tai Timu Tai Pari - EDS Home events/2015 Conference Presentations... · Lessons from Seachange ... • Liane Ngamane ... mauri, is increasingly productive and

Seachange Project StructureDecember 2013

www.eds.org.nz15

Project Steering GroupMana Whenua and statutory

agencies

Independent ChairPlus Executive Facilitator

Stakeholder Working Group

10 members chosen by sector groups, 4 by MW

Project BoardTechnical support

Independent scientistsAs required

Prepares the plan through a

collaborative process

Sets the Terms of Reference for the SWG

Adopts the plan and agencies then

implement

Page 16: Lessons from Seachange Tai Timu Tai Pari - EDS Home events/2015 Conference Presentations... · Lessons from Seachange ... • Liane Ngamane ... mauri, is increasingly productive and

Project Steering Group8-8 Co-Governance

Mana Whenua

• Paul Majurey (co-chair)

• Liane Ngamane

• Pirihira Kaio

• Shane Ashby

• Terrence Hohneck

• Jodi-ann Warbrick

• Nicholas Manukau

• Karen Wilson

www.eds.org.nz16

Statutory agencies

• Cr Penny Webster (co-chair): Auckland Council

• Mayor John Tregidga: Hauraki Gulf Forum

• Cr Mike Lee: Auckland Council

• Cr Peter Buckley: Waikato Regional Council

• Cr Timoti Bramley: Waikato Regional Council

• Cr Peter French: Territorial authorities

• Kathy Mansell: Ministry for Primary Industries

• Meg Poutasi: Department of Conservation

Page 17: Lessons from Seachange Tai Timu Tai Pari - EDS Home events/2015 Conference Presentations... · Lessons from Seachange ... • Liane Ngamane ... mauri, is increasingly productive and

Role of Independent Chair

www.eds.org.nz17

• Liaison (go-between) between the SWG and the PSG

• Provide independent advice and counsel the SWG members

• Maintain oversight of the SWG throughout the plan development process

• Assist in resolving disputes

• Develop and set agendas for meetings of the SWG and chair them

• Recommend the draft plan to the PSG for approval

• Deal with media

OVERALL CREATE A SAFE SPACE FOR THE SWG TO DO ITS

COLLABORATIVE WORK

Page 18: Lessons from Seachange Tai Timu Tai Pari - EDS Home events/2015 Conference Presentations... · Lessons from Seachange ... • Liane Ngamane ... mauri, is increasingly productive and

Stakeholder Working Group

www.eds.org.nz18

How do you represent the Gulf’s ManaWhenua and 1.5 million plus stakeholders?Unusual selection process resulted in good constructive people BUT: Some key gaps

Page 19: Lessons from Seachange Tai Timu Tai Pari - EDS Home events/2015 Conference Presentations... · Lessons from Seachange ... • Liane Ngamane ... mauri, is increasingly productive and

What is the SWG tasked with achieving?

Purpose of the project in SWG Terms of Reference:

“To develop a spatial plan that will achieve a Hauraki Gulf that is vibrant with life and healthy mauri, is increasingly productive and supports

healthy and prosperous communities”

Much more than just spatial allocation!

Consensus model for decision-making:

“Consensus for this purpose means that every member either supports or does not actively

oppose (can live with) the decision”

Timeframe to deliver plan: 18 months!

www.eds.org.nz19

Page 20: Lessons from Seachange Tai Timu Tai Pari - EDS Home events/2015 Conference Presentations... · Lessons from Seachange ... • Liane Ngamane ... mauri, is increasingly productive and

Key gaps in SWG representation AND short time frame to address complex issues resulted

in establishment of 6 “Roundtables”:

www.eds.org.nz20

Water quality and catchmentsFish stocksBiodiversity and biosecurityInfrastructureAquacultureAccessible Gulf

Page 21: Lessons from Seachange Tai Timu Tai Pari - EDS Home events/2015 Conference Presentations... · Lessons from Seachange ... • Liane Ngamane ... mauri, is increasingly productive and

Operation of Roundtables

www.eds.org.nz21

• Co-chaired by SWG members

• Involve a wider range of stakeholders

• Plug some important gaps: eg fisheries quota owners, forestry

• Draw on additional skills and experience

• Drill into issues in more detail re science and solutions

• Report back to SWG with recommendations

• Key issue: timeframe too tight to achieve agreement on detail (6 months)

• May be used to test ideas going forward

Page 22: Lessons from Seachange Tai Timu Tai Pari - EDS Home events/2015 Conference Presentations... · Lessons from Seachange ... • Liane Ngamane ... mauri, is increasingly productive and

Role of independent scientists

• SWG members agreed plan would be science-based (as well as MātaurangaMāori)

• Scientists presented work directly to SWG and Roundtables

• Plan based on existing science (not time or budget to do new stuff)

• Difficulties when science not definitive (which is often the case)

• Not all areas covered eg weak economic input

www.eds.org.nz22

Page 23: Lessons from Seachange Tai Timu Tai Pari - EDS Home events/2015 Conference Presentations... · Lessons from Seachange ... • Liane Ngamane ... mauri, is increasingly productive and

Public input

• 25 Listening Posts

• ‘Love our Gulf’ message boards

• 2 web-based surveys

www.eds.org.nz23

Page 24: Lessons from Seachange Tai Timu Tai Pari - EDS Home events/2015 Conference Presentations... · Lessons from Seachange ... • Liane Ngamane ... mauri, is increasingly productive and

The key issue which emerged based on science: Loss of habitat to support juvenile

fish. NOT something on the public or agency radar!!

Based on snapper science:

• Lots of eggs produced

• Lots of food for adult snapper – which eat almost anything

• But life cycle bottleneck at juvenile stage – lack of suitable juvenile habitat providing a good food source and refuge from predation

Widescale historical loss of suitable habitat for juveniles due to ….

www.eds.org.nz24

Page 25: Lessons from Seachange Tai Timu Tai Pari - EDS Home events/2015 Conference Presentations... · Lessons from Seachange ... • Liane Ngamane ... mauri, is increasingly productive and

Dredging and loss of historical dense mussel beds

www.eds.org.nz25

Restoration will require

reduction in sediment and

active provision of hard

substrate:Revive Our Gulf

Page 26: Lessons from Seachange Tai Timu Tai Pari - EDS Home events/2015 Conference Presentations... · Lessons from Seachange ... • Liane Ngamane ... mauri, is increasingly productive and

Trawling and widespread destruction of horse

mussel, coral and sponge beds

Trawling continuing in outer Gulf

Bottom trawls 2011-2014Blue: untrawled

Green: low trawl nosOrange and red: high number of trawls

If trawling stops recovery may still be slow and require active

intervention

www.eds.org.nz26

Page 27: Lessons from Seachange Tai Timu Tai Pari - EDS Home events/2015 Conference Presentations... · Lessons from Seachange ... • Liane Ngamane ... mauri, is increasingly productive and

High levels of sediment blanketing estuaries and most of inner Gulf

www.eds.org.nz27

Major sources:• Waihou/Piako Rivers• Wairoa – estuary filled up• Mahurangi River

Also much historical sediment from early land clearances being resuspended

Page 28: Lessons from Seachange Tai Timu Tai Pari - EDS Home events/2015 Conference Presentations... · Lessons from Seachange ... • Liane Ngamane ... mauri, is increasingly productive and

But science doesn’t provide all the answers: Another significant issue was loss of vulnerable

reef species: Based on anecdotal evidence

• Depletion accelerated over past 20 years or so

• Accessible inter-tidal reefs being stripped

• Offshore reef systems fished much more often

• Largely function of:• Growing Auckland population

• New ethnicities

• Improved technology (larger recreational vessels and GPS chart plotters/fish finders)

www.eds.org.nz28

Page 29: Lessons from Seachange Tai Timu Tai Pari - EDS Home events/2015 Conference Presentations... · Lessons from Seachange ... • Liane Ngamane ... mauri, is increasingly productive and

Evolving structures for ManaWhenua

At the start:

• Project Steering Group: 50% Mana Whenua50% statutory agencies

• Stakeholder Working Group: 4 ManaWhenua members (out of 14)

Need for more support soon evident:

• Mātauranga Māori Representative Table: Mana Whenua members of PSG and SWG with specialist technical support

• Plan Writing Team: Mana Whenua writers and technical support people

• Complicated by ongoing Treaty settlements

www.eds.org.nz29

Page 30: Lessons from Seachange Tai Timu Tai Pari - EDS Home events/2015 Conference Presentations... · Lessons from Seachange ... • Liane Ngamane ... mauri, is increasingly productive and

Evolving structures for PSGIndependent Review Panel

Membership

• Paul Beverley (chair): Partner, Buddle Findlay lawyers

• Professor Charles Ehler: marine spatial planning consultant to UNESCO

• Dr Chris Battershill: Professor and Chair of Coastal Science, University of Waikato

• Dr Dan Hikuroa: Research Director, Ngā Pae o te Māramatanga

• Dr Rick Boven: Director, Stakeholder Strategies

Role: Report to the PSG; 2 reports so far

Issue: Arguably expertise would be better used contributing to the project rather than critiquing it

www.eds.org.nz30

Page 31: Lessons from Seachange Tai Timu Tai Pari - EDS Home events/2015 Conference Presentations... · Lessons from Seachange ... • Liane Ngamane ... mauri, is increasingly productive and

Seachange Project Structure currently: now too complex?

www.eds.org.nz31

Project Steering GroupMana Whenua and statutory

agencies

Independent ChairPlus Executive Facilitator

Stakeholder Working Group

10 members chosen by sector groups, 4 by MW

6 RoundtablesWater quality and catchments,

Fish stocks, Biodiversity and biosecurity, Infrastructure,

Aquaculture, Accessible Gulf

Project BoardTechnical support

Independent Review Panel

5 members

Independent scientistsAs required

MātaurangaMāori

Representative Table

4 MW SWG members

8 MW PSG members (6 also TW reps on HGF)

Page 32: Lessons from Seachange Tai Timu Tai Pari - EDS Home events/2015 Conference Presentations... · Lessons from Seachange ... • Liane Ngamane ... mauri, is increasingly productive and

Power of Collaboration

• Hear each other’s views

• Build up trust

• Learn new information

• Shifts positions

• Creates social capital which can be applied in a wider setting

• Makes things possible that previously were not

BUT: Very time consuming and emotionally sapping

www.eds.org.nz32

Page 33: Lessons from Seachange Tai Timu Tai Pari - EDS Home events/2015 Conference Presentations... · Lessons from Seachange ... • Liane Ngamane ... mauri, is increasingly productive and

Many inherent tensions in the process: Requires strong leadership to resolve

• Co-governance versus collaboration

• Agency-led versus collaboration

• Mana whenua and Pākehā world views

• Extraction values versus conservation values (esp. marine reserves)

• Catchment users versus marine users

• Non-statutory versus statutory

• High level versus detail (directly related to time and resources)

www.eds.org.nz33

Page 34: Lessons from Seachange Tai Timu Tai Pari - EDS Home events/2015 Conference Presentations... · Lessons from Seachange ... • Liane Ngamane ... mauri, is increasingly productive and

Content of Spatial Plan?

• Will identify what it will take to reverse the degradation of the past 175 years during the next generation

• Focus is on big Gulf-wide moves (strategies and actions) not local management

• Spatial element likely to include location of priority areas for action, areas requiring more fine-grained management, and provision for aquaculture and marine-related infrastructure

• Will contain a package of statutory and non-statutory measures

www.eds.org.nz34

Page 35: Lessons from Seachange Tai Timu Tai Pari - EDS Home events/2015 Conference Presentations... · Lessons from Seachange ... • Liane Ngamane ... mauri, is increasingly productive and

How will the Plan be implemented?

Key question we’ve been grappling with:

“If stakeholders develop a non-statutory Gulf-wide plan, and then hand implementation over to agencies which didn’t develop the plan, and which still operate within a fragmented institutional framework, will it work?”

Concluded PROBABLY NOT. So the plan will potentially drive institutional change

www.eds.org.nz35

Page 36: Lessons from Seachange Tai Timu Tai Pari - EDS Home events/2015 Conference Presentations... · Lessons from Seachange ... • Liane Ngamane ... mauri, is increasingly productive and

Lessons learnt for scaling up

• Taking a catchment-to-the-sea system approach enables systemic issues to be addressed (which can otherwise fall through the cracks)

• Collaboration is a powerful, and potentially effective approach to deal with complex and intractable issues

• But for collaboration to work agencies and Mana Whenua need to be willing to give up power

• Development of novel solutions can challenge ‘business-as-usual’ thinking

• Effective implementation of scaled-up planning may require institutional change

www.eds.org.nz36