46
Lecture Overview ... Modern Problems in Nuclear Physics II D. Blaschke (U Wroclaw, JINR, MEPhI) G. Röpke (U Rostock) A. Sedrakian (FIAS Frankfurt, Yerevan SU) 1. Physics of Neutron Stars I Phenomenology, EoS and Structure (3) 2. Statistical Model and HIC I RHIC and CERN Experiments, Chemical Freeze-out (2) 3. Physics of Neutron Stars II – Color superconductivity (2) 4. Statistical Model and HIC II NSE, Clusters in Nuclei, HIC & Femto-Nova (3) 5. Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter I BEC-BCS Crossover. NSR Theory (2) 6. Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter II – Nuclear vs. Quark Matter, NS Cooling (3)

Lecture Overview - Uniwersytet Wrocławskiblaschke/vorles/MEPhI_MPNP_Blaschke... · 2019. 3. 9. · Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter II – Nuclear vs. Quark Matter, NS Cooling (3)

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    2

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Lecture Overview - Uniwersytet Wrocławskiblaschke/vorles/MEPhI_MPNP_Blaschke... · 2019. 3. 9. · Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter II – Nuclear vs. Quark Matter, NS Cooling (3)

Lecture Overview ...

Modern Problems in Nuclear Physics II

D. Blaschke (U Wroclaw, JINR, MEPhI)G. Röpke (U Rostock)A. Sedrakian (FIAS Frankfurt, Yerevan SU)

1. Physics of Neutron Stars I Phenomenology, EoS and Structure (3)2. Statistical Model and HIC I RHIC and CERN Experiments, Chemical Freeze-out (2)3. Physics of Neutron Stars II – Color superconductivity (2) 4. Statistical Model and HIC II NSE, Clusters in Nuclei, HIC & Femto-Nova (3)5. Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter I BEC-BCS Crossover. NSR Theory (2)6. Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter II – Nuclear vs. Quark Matter, NS Cooling (3)

Page 2: Lecture Overview - Uniwersytet Wrocławskiblaschke/vorles/MEPhI_MPNP_Blaschke... · 2019. 3. 9. · Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter II – Nuclear vs. Quark Matter, NS Cooling (3)

Name, First name email address

Akhmetov, Fedor f.o.akhmetov (at) gmail.comChulkoov, Ilya chulkov.ilya96 (at) gmail.comDevyatyarov, Kyrill xxccnn55 (at) gmail.comGallyamov, Renat pehat96 (at) yandex.ruKhusnutdinov, Radmir hatach (at) mail.ruKoptev, Ivan ivanforlife9 (at) gmail.comLukianov, Pavel p.d.lukianov (at) yandex.ruMatveevski, Konstantin matveevskiy.konstantin (at) gmail.comPostnikov, Valentin postnikov.valentin (at) yandex.ruShatalov, Nazar satalov.nazar (at) gmail.com

Kolomiytsev, Georgy flight160 (at) gmail.com

Schedule for the Summer Semester 2019

05.02., 14:30 – 17:00 Lectures David Blaschke 12.02., 14:30 – 17:00 Lectures David Blaschke12.03., 14:30 – 18:00 Lectures David Blaschke09.04., 14:30 – 18:00 Lectures Gerd Roepke14.05., 14:30 – 18:00 Lectures Gerd Roepke04.06., 14:30 – 18:00 Lectures Armen Sedrakian

DRAFT

Page 3: Lecture Overview - Uniwersytet Wrocławskiblaschke/vorles/MEPhI_MPNP_Blaschke... · 2019. 3. 9. · Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter II – Nuclear vs. Quark Matter, NS Cooling (3)

Pair condensation – color superconducting quark matter in compact stars?

Cooper instability Quark condensates Symmetries and pairing patterns Two-flavor color superconductors → 2SC phase Three-flavor color superconductors → CFL phase NJL model and Nambu-Gorkov formalism Mean field gap equations and solutions Thermodynamic potential Phase diagram EoS and TOV equations – Hybrid stars with CC

Topics:

[email protected] (Wroclaw University & JINR Dubna & MEPhI Moscow)

See also lectures by M. Buballa at HISS Dubna 2006; http://theor.jinr.ru/~dm2006/talks/buballa_3.pdf

Page 4: Lecture Overview - Uniwersytet Wrocławskiblaschke/vorles/MEPhI_MPNP_Blaschke... · 2019. 3. 9. · Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter II – Nuclear vs. Quark Matter, NS Cooling (3)

Cooper instabilities

Page 5: Lecture Overview - Uniwersytet Wrocławskiblaschke/vorles/MEPhI_MPNP_Blaschke... · 2019. 3. 9. · Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter II – Nuclear vs. Quark Matter, NS Cooling (3)

Cooper instabilities

Page 6: Lecture Overview - Uniwersytet Wrocławskiblaschke/vorles/MEPhI_MPNP_Blaschke... · 2019. 3. 9. · Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter II – Nuclear vs. Quark Matter, NS Cooling (3)

Field operators

Page 7: Lecture Overview - Uniwersytet Wrocławskiblaschke/vorles/MEPhI_MPNP_Blaschke... · 2019. 3. 9. · Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter II – Nuclear vs. Quark Matter, NS Cooling (3)

Quark-antiquark condensates

Page 8: Lecture Overview - Uniwersytet Wrocławskiblaschke/vorles/MEPhI_MPNP_Blaschke... · 2019. 3. 9. · Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter II – Nuclear vs. Quark Matter, NS Cooling (3)

Diquark condensates

Page 9: Lecture Overview - Uniwersytet Wrocławskiblaschke/vorles/MEPhI_MPNP_Blaschke... · 2019. 3. 9. · Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter II – Nuclear vs. Quark Matter, NS Cooling (3)

Diquark condensates

Page 10: Lecture Overview - Uniwersytet Wrocławskiblaschke/vorles/MEPhI_MPNP_Blaschke... · 2019. 3. 9. · Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter II – Nuclear vs. Quark Matter, NS Cooling (3)

Operators in flavor and color space

Page 11: Lecture Overview - Uniwersytet Wrocławskiblaschke/vorles/MEPhI_MPNP_Blaschke... · 2019. 3. 9. · Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter II – Nuclear vs. Quark Matter, NS Cooling (3)

Operators in Dirac space

Page 12: Lecture Overview - Uniwersytet Wrocławskiblaschke/vorles/MEPhI_MPNP_Blaschke... · 2019. 3. 9. · Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter II – Nuclear vs. Quark Matter, NS Cooling (3)

Combined operators

Page 13: Lecture Overview - Uniwersytet Wrocławskiblaschke/vorles/MEPhI_MPNP_Blaschke... · 2019. 3. 9. · Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter II – Nuclear vs. Quark Matter, NS Cooling (3)

Two-flavor color superconductors

Page 14: Lecture Overview - Uniwersytet Wrocławskiblaschke/vorles/MEPhI_MPNP_Blaschke... · 2019. 3. 9. · Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter II – Nuclear vs. Quark Matter, NS Cooling (3)

Symmetry properties: color

Page 15: Lecture Overview - Uniwersytet Wrocławskiblaschke/vorles/MEPhI_MPNP_Blaschke... · 2019. 3. 9. · Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter II – Nuclear vs. Quark Matter, NS Cooling (3)

Symmetry properties: global symmetries

Page 16: Lecture Overview - Uniwersytet Wrocławskiblaschke/vorles/MEPhI_MPNP_Blaschke... · 2019. 3. 9. · Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter II – Nuclear vs. Quark Matter, NS Cooling (3)

Three-flavor color superconductors

Page 17: Lecture Overview - Uniwersytet Wrocławskiblaschke/vorles/MEPhI_MPNP_Blaschke... · 2019. 3. 9. · Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter II – Nuclear vs. Quark Matter, NS Cooling (3)

Three-flavor color superconductors

Page 18: Lecture Overview - Uniwersytet Wrocławskiblaschke/vorles/MEPhI_MPNP_Blaschke... · 2019. 3. 9. · Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter II – Nuclear vs. Quark Matter, NS Cooling (3)

Pairing patterns

Page 19: Lecture Overview - Uniwersytet Wrocławskiblaschke/vorles/MEPhI_MPNP_Blaschke... · 2019. 3. 9. · Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter II – Nuclear vs. Quark Matter, NS Cooling (3)

Color-flavor locking

Page 20: Lecture Overview - Uniwersytet Wrocławskiblaschke/vorles/MEPhI_MPNP_Blaschke... · 2019. 3. 9. · Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter II – Nuclear vs. Quark Matter, NS Cooling (3)

NJL model for color superconductivity

Page 21: Lecture Overview - Uniwersytet Wrocławskiblaschke/vorles/MEPhI_MPNP_Blaschke... · 2019. 3. 9. · Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter II – Nuclear vs. Quark Matter, NS Cooling (3)

Nambu-Gorkov formalism

Page 22: Lecture Overview - Uniwersytet Wrocławskiblaschke/vorles/MEPhI_MPNP_Blaschke... · 2019. 3. 9. · Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter II – Nuclear vs. Quark Matter, NS Cooling (3)

Nambu-Gorkov propagator

Page 23: Lecture Overview - Uniwersytet Wrocławskiblaschke/vorles/MEPhI_MPNP_Blaschke... · 2019. 3. 9. · Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter II – Nuclear vs. Quark Matter, NS Cooling (3)

Selfconsistency problem

Page 24: Lecture Overview - Uniwersytet Wrocławskiblaschke/vorles/MEPhI_MPNP_Blaschke... · 2019. 3. 9. · Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter II – Nuclear vs. Quark Matter, NS Cooling (3)

Gap equation

Page 25: Lecture Overview - Uniwersytet Wrocławskiblaschke/vorles/MEPhI_MPNP_Blaschke... · 2019. 3. 9. · Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter II – Nuclear vs. Quark Matter, NS Cooling (3)

Propagator

Page 26: Lecture Overview - Uniwersytet Wrocławskiblaschke/vorles/MEPhI_MPNP_Blaschke... · 2019. 3. 9. · Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter II – Nuclear vs. Quark Matter, NS Cooling (3)

Dispersion relations

Page 27: Lecture Overview - Uniwersytet Wrocławskiblaschke/vorles/MEPhI_MPNP_Blaschke... · 2019. 3. 9. · Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter II – Nuclear vs. Quark Matter, NS Cooling (3)

Dispersion relations (CFL)

Page 28: Lecture Overview - Uniwersytet Wrocławskiblaschke/vorles/MEPhI_MPNP_Blaschke... · 2019. 3. 9. · Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter II – Nuclear vs. Quark Matter, NS Cooling (3)

Gap equation: solutions

Page 29: Lecture Overview - Uniwersytet Wrocławskiblaschke/vorles/MEPhI_MPNP_Blaschke... · 2019. 3. 9. · Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter II – Nuclear vs. Quark Matter, NS Cooling (3)

Gap equation: solutions

Page 30: Lecture Overview - Uniwersytet Wrocławskiblaschke/vorles/MEPhI_MPNP_Blaschke... · 2019. 3. 9. · Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter II – Nuclear vs. Quark Matter, NS Cooling (3)

Gap equation: solutions

Page 31: Lecture Overview - Uniwersytet Wrocławskiblaschke/vorles/MEPhI_MPNP_Blaschke... · 2019. 3. 9. · Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter II – Nuclear vs. Quark Matter, NS Cooling (3)

Thermodynamic potential

Page 32: Lecture Overview - Uniwersytet Wrocławskiblaschke/vorles/MEPhI_MPNP_Blaschke... · 2019. 3. 9. · Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter II – Nuclear vs. Quark Matter, NS Cooling (3)

Thermodynamic potential

Page 33: Lecture Overview - Uniwersytet Wrocławskiblaschke/vorles/MEPhI_MPNP_Blaschke... · 2019. 3. 9. · Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter II – Nuclear vs. Quark Matter, NS Cooling (3)

Thermodynamic quantities

Page 34: Lecture Overview - Uniwersytet Wrocławskiblaschke/vorles/MEPhI_MPNP_Blaschke... · 2019. 3. 9. · Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter II – Nuclear vs. Quark Matter, NS Cooling (3)

Minima

Page 35: Lecture Overview - Uniwersytet Wrocławskiblaschke/vorles/MEPhI_MPNP_Blaschke... · 2019. 3. 9. · Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter II – Nuclear vs. Quark Matter, NS Cooling (3)

Condensation energy

Page 36: Lecture Overview - Uniwersytet Wrocławskiblaschke/vorles/MEPhI_MPNP_Blaschke... · 2019. 3. 9. · Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter II – Nuclear vs. Quark Matter, NS Cooling (3)

CFL pairing in the bag model

Page 37: Lecture Overview - Uniwersytet Wrocławskiblaschke/vorles/MEPhI_MPNP_Blaschke... · 2019. 3. 9. · Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter II – Nuclear vs. Quark Matter, NS Cooling (3)

Realistic masses

Page 38: Lecture Overview - Uniwersytet Wrocławskiblaschke/vorles/MEPhI_MPNP_Blaschke... · 2019. 3. 9. · Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter II – Nuclear vs. Quark Matter, NS Cooling (3)

Realistic masses

Page 39: Lecture Overview - Uniwersytet Wrocławskiblaschke/vorles/MEPhI_MPNP_Blaschke... · 2019. 3. 9. · Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter II – Nuclear vs. Quark Matter, NS Cooling (3)

Which phase is favored ?

Page 40: Lecture Overview - Uniwersytet Wrocławskiblaschke/vorles/MEPhI_MPNP_Blaschke... · 2019. 3. 9. · Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter II – Nuclear vs. Quark Matter, NS Cooling (3)

Which phase is favored ?

Page 41: Lecture Overview - Uniwersytet Wrocławskiblaschke/vorles/MEPhI_MPNP_Blaschke... · 2019. 3. 9. · Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter II – Nuclear vs. Quark Matter, NS Cooling (3)

3-flavor NJL model

Page 42: Lecture Overview - Uniwersytet Wrocławskiblaschke/vorles/MEPhI_MPNP_Blaschke... · 2019. 3. 9. · Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter II – Nuclear vs. Quark Matter, NS Cooling (3)

Results for T=0

Page 43: Lecture Overview - Uniwersytet Wrocławskiblaschke/vorles/MEPhI_MPNP_Blaschke... · 2019. 3. 9. · Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter II – Nuclear vs. Quark Matter, NS Cooling (3)

Phase diagram

S. Ruester et al. Phys. Rev. D 72 (2005) 034004D. Blaschke et al. Phys. Rev. D 72 (2005) 065020

Page 44: Lecture Overview - Uniwersytet Wrocławskiblaschke/vorles/MEPhI_MPNP_Blaschke... · 2019. 3. 9. · Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter II – Nuclear vs. Quark Matter, NS Cooling (3)

Exploring hybrid star matter at NICAT.Klähn (1), D.Blaschke (1,2), F.Weber (3)(1) Institute for Theoretical Physics, University of Wroclaw, Poland

(2) Joint Institute for Nuclear Research, Dubna(3) Department of Physics, San Diego State University, USA

Heavy-Ion Collisions Compact Stars

„The CBM Physics Book“, Springer LNP 841 (2011), pp.158-181NICA White Paper, http://theor.jinr.ru → BLTP TWikipages

Proposal: 1. Measure transverse and elliptic flow for a wide range of energies (densities) at NICA and perform Danielewicz's flow data analysis ---> constrain stiffness of high density EoS2. Provide lower bound for onset of mixed phase ---> constrain QM onset in hybrid stars

- stiff EoS(at flow limit)

- low ncrit

(at NICA fixT)

- soft EoS (dashed line)

- high Mmax

(J1614-2230)

- low Monset

(all NS hybrid)

- excluded(J1614-2230)

Page 45: Lecture Overview - Uniwersytet Wrocławskiblaschke/vorles/MEPhI_MPNP_Blaschke... · 2019. 3. 9. · Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter II – Nuclear vs. Quark Matter, NS Cooling (3)

Quark matter in 2Msun

neutron stars?→ only color superconducting + vector int.

T. Klahn et al., PRD 88 (2013) 085001; arxiv:1307.696

Page 46: Lecture Overview - Uniwersytet Wrocławskiblaschke/vorles/MEPhI_MPNP_Blaschke... · 2019. 3. 9. · Superfluidity in Nuclear Matter II – Nuclear vs. Quark Matter, NS Cooling (3)

29 membercountries

!New

!

Kick-off: Brussels, November 25, 2013

by Feb. 16, 2016:

MP1304