Upload
others
View
4
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
ME5286 – Lecture 6
#2
Review From Last Lecture
• Definition of an Edge• First Order Derivative Approximation as
Edge Detector
ME5286 – Lecture 6
#3
This Lecture
• Examples of Edge Detection with first order derivative approximation
• Edge Detection with Second order derivative
• Combining Smoothing and Edge Detection with Laplacian of Gaussian
ME5286 – Lecture 6
#4
Summary: Edge Definition• Edge is a boundary between two regions with relatively distinct gray level
properties. • Edges are pixels where the brightness function changes abruptly. • Edge detectors are a collection of very important local image pre-
processing methods used to locate (sharp) changes in the intensity function.
ME5286 – Lecture 6
Criteria for Optimal Edge Detection
• (1) Good detection– Minimize the probability of false positives (i.e., spurious edges).– Minimize the probability of false negatives (i.e., missing real
edges).
• (2) Good localization– Detected edges must be as close as possible to the true edges.
• (3) Single response– Minimize the number of local maxima around the true edge.
ME5286 – Lecture 6
Edge Detection Using Derivatives
• Often, points that lie on an edge are detected by:
(1) Detecting the local maxima or minima of the first derivative.
(2) Detecting the zero-crossingsof the second derivative. 2nd derivative
1st derivative
ME5286 – Lecture 6
Edge Detection Using First Derivative
sensitive to vertical edges!
sensitive to horizontal edges!
ME5286 – Lecture 6
• We can implement and using the following masks:
(x+1/2,y)
(x,y+1/2) **
good approximationat (x+1/2,y)
good approximationat (x,y+1/2)
Edge Detection Using First Derivative
ME5286 – Lecture 6
Approximation of First Derivative ( Gradient )
• Consider the arrangement of pixels about the pixel (i, j):
• The partial derivatives can be computed by:
• The constant c implies the emphasis given to pixels closer to the center of the mask.
3 x 3 neighborhood:
ME5286 – Lecture 6
Prewitt Operator
• the Prewitt operator:
ME5286 – Lecture 6
Sobel Operator
• the Sobel operator:
ME5286 – Lecture 6
#12
Robert Edge Detection• The Roberts edge detector
• This approximation can be implemented by the following masks:
Note: Mx and My are approximations at (i + 1/2, j + 1/2)
ME5286 – Lecture 6
#13
Roberts Edge Detector
There are two forms of the Roberts Edge Detector:
The second form of the equation is often used in practice due to its computational efficiency
ME5286 – Lecture 6
#14
Roberts Edge Detector• A simple approximation to the first
derivative • Marks edge points only; it does not return
any information about the edge orientation
• Simplest of the edge detection operators and will work best with binary images
ME5286 – Lecture 6
Example
Idxd
Idyd
ME5286 – Lecture 6
#16
Edge Detection Using Derivative• Image derivatives:
11* II x
11
*II y
Image I
ME5286 – Lecture 6
#17
Edge Detection Using the Gradient• Example – cont.:
22
I
dydI
dxd
ME5286 – Lecture 6
#18
Edge Detection Using the Gradient• Example – cont.:
100 Threshold
ME5286 – Lecture 6
#19
Derivatives and Noise• Derivatives are strongly affected by noise
– obvious reason: image noise results in pixels that look very different from their neighbors
– The larger the noise - the stronger the response• What is to be done?
– Neighboring pixels look alike– Pixel along an edge look alike– Image smoothing should help – Force pixels different to their neighbors (possibly noise) to
look like neighbors
ME5286 – Lecture 6
#20
Derivatives and Noise
Increasing noise
– Need to perform image smoothing as a preliminary step– Generally – use Gaussian smoothing
ME5286 – Lecture 6
#21
Edge Detection & Image Noisei.i.d ),0(~)( )()(ˆ)( NxNxNxIxI
)()('ˆ
))1( - )1(())1(ˆ)1(ˆ(
))1()1(ˆ( - )1()1(ˆ)('
xNxI d
xNxNxIxI
xNxIxNxIxI
))(( xNE d 0
Taking differences:
Output noise:
))(( 2 xNE d ))1()1(2)1()1(( 22 xNxNxNxNE222 20
Increases noise !!
ME5286 – Lecture 6
#22
Effects of noise• Consider a single row or column of the image
– Plotting intensity as a function of position gives a signal
• Where is the edge?
ME5286 – Lecture 6
#23
Noise in Edge Detection• Practical issues:– Differential masks act as high-pass filters – tend to amplify noise.– Reduce the effects of noise - first smooth with a low-pass filter.
1) The noise suppression-localization tradeoff– a larger filter reduces noise, but worsens localization (i.e., it
adds uncertainty to the location of the edge) and vice-versa.
ME5286 – Lecture 6
#24• Where is the edge?
Solution: smooth first
ME5286 – Lecture 6
#25
Derivative theorem of convolution
• This saves us one operation:
ME5286 – Lecture 6
11 0.0030 0.0133 0.0219 0.0133 0.00300.0133 0.0596 0.0983 0.0596 0.01330.0219 0.0983 0.1621 0.0983 0.02190.0133 0.0596 0.0983 0.0596 0.01330.0030 0.0133 0.0219 0.0133 0.0030
)()( hgIhgI
Derivative of Gaussian filters
ME5286 – Lecture 6
Derivative of Gaussian filters
x-direction y-direction
Source: L. Lazebnik
ME5286 – Lecture 6
Smoothing with a GaussianRecall: parameter σ is the “scale” / “width” / “spread” of the Gaussian kernel, and controls the amount of smoothing.
…
ME5286 – Lecture 6
Effect of σ on derivatives
The apparent structures differ depending on Gaussian’s scale parameter.
Larger values: larger scale edges detectedSmaller values: finer features detected
σ = 1 pixel σ = 3 pixels
ME5286 – Lecture 6
Edge Detection Steps Using Gradient
(i.e., sqrt is costly!)
ME5286 – Lecture 6
Edge Direction Implementation• Typically quantize the gradient orientation to a
fixed number of orientations• You can identify the edges based on
magnitude and direction
How Many Directions or Levels ?
ME5286 – Lecture 6
#32
ME5286 – Lecture 6
Isotropy#33
ME5286 – Lecture 6
Isotropic property of gradient magnitude
• The magnitude of the gradient detects edges in all directions.
22d dI Idx dy
Idxd I
dyd
ME5286 – Lecture 6
#35
Edge Detection Using the Gradient• Isotropic property of gradient magnitude:
– The magnitude of gradient is an isotropic operator (it detects edges in any direction !!)
ME5286 – Lecture 6
Anisotropic Filtering (i.e., edge preserving smoothing)
• Symmetric Gaussian smoothing tends to blur out edges rather aggressively.
• An “oriented” smoothing operator would work better:(i) Smooth aggressively perpendicular to the gradient(ii) Smooth little along the gradient
ME5286 – Lecture 6
Anisotropic filtering - Example
result using anisotropic filtering
ME5286 – Lecture 6
#38
ME5286 – Lecture 6
#39
Edge Detection Using the 2nd Derivative• Edge points can be detected by finding the zero-
crossings of the second derivative.
• There are two approaches that uses the second derivative to identify the edge presence• Smoothing then apply Gradient• Combine smoothing and Gradient Opertations
ME5286 – Lecture 6
Edge Detection Using SecondDerivative
• Approximate finding maxima/minima of gradient magnitude by finding places where:
• Can’t always find discrete pixels where the second derivative is zero – look for zero-crossing instead.
ME5286 – Lecture 6
#41
Edge Detection Using Second Derivative• Computing the 2nd derivative:
– This approximation is centered about x + 1– By replacing x + 1 by x we obtain:
ME5286 – Lecture 6
Image Derivatives
• 1st order
• 2nd order
ME5286 – Lecture 6
Edge Detection Using Second Derivative (cont’d)
ME5286 – Lecture 6
#44
Edge Detection Using Second Derivative (cont’d)
• Computing the 2nd derivative – cont.– Examples using the edge models:
ME5286 – Lecture 6
Edge Detection Using Second Derivative (cont’d)
(upward) step edge
(downward) step edge
ramp edge
roof edge
ME5286 – Lecture 6
Edge Detection Using Second Derivative (cont’d)
• Four cases of zero-crossings:
{+,-}, {+,0,-},{-,+}, {-,0,+}
• Slope of zero-crossing {a, -b} is: |a+b|.
• To detect “strong” zero-crossing, threshold the slope.
ME5286 – Lecture 6
Second Derivative in 2D: Laplacian
ME5286 – Lecture 6
Second Derivative in 2D: Laplacian
ME5286 – Lecture 6
Variations of Laplacian
ME5286 – Lecture 6
Laplacian - Example
detect zero-crossings
ME5286 – Lecture 6
Properties of Laplacian
• It is cheaper to implement than the gradient (i.e., one mask only).
• It does not provide information about edge direction.
• It is more sensitive to noise (i.e., differentiates twice).
• It is an isotropic operator ( equal weights in all directions )
ME5286 – Lecture 6
Noise Effect on Derivates
Where is the edge??
ME5286 – Lecture 6
Solution: smooth first
ME5286 – Lecture 6
Effect of Smoothing on Derivatives (cont’d)
ME5286 – Lecture 6
Combine Smoothing with Differentiation
(i.e., saves one operation)
ME5286 – Lecture 6
Laplacian of GaussianConsider
Laplacian of Gaussianoperator
Where is the edge? Zero-crossings of bottom graphSlide credit: Steve Seitz
ME5286 – Lecture 6
2D edge detection filters
• is the Laplacian operator:
Laplacian of Gaussian
Gaussian derivative of Gaussian
Slide credit: Steve Seitz
ME5286 – Lecture 6
Laplacian of Gaussian (LoG)(Marr-Hildreth operator)
• To reduce the noise effect, the image is first smoothed. • When the filter chosen is a Gaussian, we call it the LoG
edge detector.
• It can be shown that:
σ controls smoothing
2σ2
(inverted LoG)
ME5286 – Lecture 6
Laplacian of Gaussian (LoG)(Marr-Hildreth operator)
• The 2-D Laplacian of Gaussian (LoG) function centered on zero and with Gaussian standard deviation has the form:
where σ is the standard deviation
• The amount of smoothing can be controlled by varying the value of the standard deviation.
ME5286 – Lecture 6
Laplacian of Gaussian (LoG) -Example
filtering zero-crossings
(inverted LoG)(inverted LoG)
ME5286 – Lecture 6
Decomposition of LoG• It can be shown than LoG can be written as
follows:
• 2D LoG convolution can be implemented using 4, 1D convolutions.
2 ( , )g x y
2 ( , )* ( , )g x y I x y
ME5286 – Lecture 6
#62
Edge Detection Using the 2nd Derivative• Separability
Image
gxx(x) g(x)
gyy(y) g(y)
+ gI 2*
Image g(x) g(y) + gI
Gaussian Filtering
Laplacian-of-Gaussian Filtering
ME5286 – Lecture 6
#63
Edge Detection Using the 2nd Derivative• Separability
– Gaussian:• A 2-D Gaussian can be separated into two 1-D Gaussians• Perform 2 convolutions with 1-D Gaussians
),(*),(),( yxgyxIyxh
)(*)(*),(),( 21 ygxgyxIyxh
n2 multiplications per pixel
2n multiplications per pixel
011.13.6.16.13.011.1 g
011.13.6.16.13.011.
2g
ME5286 – Lecture 6
Decomposition of LoG (cont’d)
Steps
ME5286 – Lecture 6
#65
Edge Detection Using LOG• Marr-Hildteth (LOG) Algorithm:
– Compute LoG• Use one 2D filter:• Use four 1D filters:
– Find zero-crossings from each row and column– Find slope of zero-crossings– Apply threshold to slope and mark edges
),(2 yxg)(),(),(),( ygygxgxg yyxx
ME5286 – Lecture 6
#66
Laplacian of Gaussian (LoG) - Example• The Laplacian-of-Gaussian (LOG) – cont.
GI 2* I
)(*I of crossings Zero 2G
ME5286 – Lecture 6
#67
Laplacian of Gaussian (LoG) - Example• The Laplacian-of-Gaussian (LOG) – cont.
1
6
3
ME5286 – Lecture 6
Difference of Gaussians (DoG)• The Laplacian of Gaussian can be approximated by the
difference between two Gaussian functions:
approximationactual LoG
ME5286 – Lecture 6
Difference of Gaussians (DoG) (cont’d)
(a) (b) (b)‐(a)
ME5286 – Lecture 6
#70
Gradient vs LoG (cont’d)• Disadvantage of LOG edge detection:
– Does not handle corners well
ME5286 – Lecture 6
Gradient vs LoG• Gradient works well when the image contains sharp
intensity transitions and low noise.• Zero-crossings of LOG offer better localization, especially
when the edges are not very sharp.step edge
ramp edge
ME5286 – Lecture 6
Practical Issues
• Noise suppression-localization tradeoff.– Smoothing depends on mask size (e.g., depends
on σ for Gaussian filters).– Larger mask sizes reduce noise, but worsen
localization (i.e., add uncertainty to the location of the edge) and vice versa.
larger masksmaller mask
ME5286 – Lecture 6
Choice of Threshold• Trade off of threshold value.
gradient magnitude
low threshold high threshold
ME5286 – Lecture 6
Standard thresholding• Standard thresholding:
- Can only select “strong” edges.- Does not guarantee “continuity”.
gradient magnitude low threshold high threshold
ME5286 – Lecture 6
Hysteresis thresholding
• Hysteresis thresholding uses two thresholds:
• For “maybe” edges, decide on the edge if neighboringpixel is a strong edge.
- low threshold tl- high threshold th (usually, th = 2tl)
tltl
th
th
ME5286 – Lecture 6
Hysteresis Thresholding Example#76
ME5286 – Lecture 6
#77
Edge Detection Review
• Edge detection operators are based on the idea that edge information in an image is found by looking at the relationship a pixel has with its neighbors
• If a pixel's gray level value is similar to those around it, there is probably not an edge at that point
ME5286 – Lecture 6
#78
Edge Detection Review
• Edge detection operators are often implemented with convolution masks and most are based on discrete approximations to differential operators
• Differential operations measure the rate of change in a function, in this case, the image brightness function
ME5286 – Lecture 6
#79
Edge Detection Review• Preprocessing of image is required to eliminate or
at least minimize noise effects• There is tradeoff between sensitivity and accuracy
in edge detection • The parameters that we can set so that edge
detector is sensitive include the size of the edge detection mask and the value of the gray level threshold
• A larger mask or a higher gray level threshold will tend to reduce noise effects, but may result in a loss of valid edge points