86
LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for Monitoring Instrument Health PHILIP SOBOLESKY, PH.D. UC SAN DIEGO HEALTH SYSTEM Center for Advanced Laboratory Medicine

LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    16

  • Download
    3

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System

Suitability Testing for Monitoring Instrument Health

P H I L I P S OBOLESKY, P H . D.

U C SAN D I EGO H EALT H SYSTEM

Center for Advanced Laboratory Medicine

Page 2: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

MSACL Website Resources

Page 3: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

What is a System Suitability Test (SST)?

• Tool for monitoring LC and MS health status– General

– Assay Specific

• Sample injected onto LC-MS instrument before submitting patient sample batch

Page 4: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Acceptable SST Provides Assurance

Page 5: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

SST Does Not Assure Everything

Ordering Errors

Collection Errors

Labeling Errors

Transport Issues

Processing & Handling

Storage

Reporting ErrorsPre- and Post-Analytical

Errors Still Apply

Page 6: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

What Should be Monitored During a SST Run?

Peak Symmetry

Background Noise

Peak HeightSignal

Retention Time

Signal

Noise

1. 2.Retention

TimetR (± 0.2 min)

3.Peak Area

4.Peak Symmetry

tR

± 0.2 min

Page 7: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Example of SST Tracking Data

Page 8: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Why Develop and Run a SST

• Increased Efficiency by Avoiding• Re-extractions

• Re-injections

• QNS reports

• Identify Problems sooner

• Tracking records help to identify• Proper maintenance (column or guard replacement, MS

cleaning etc.)

• Convincing vendor to perform PM when MSMS infusion is “within spec”

Page 9: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

SST Troubleshooting Cases

PROBLEM ANALYSIS SOLUTION

Page 10: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Case 1: Importance of Tracking Assay Specific SST Data

• 25-OH Vitamin D SST passes after annual PM (service rep leaves)

• Benzodiazepine SST ran next day and FAILS.

Normal Benzo SST

Benzo SST after PM25-OH VitDSST after PM

?

Page 11: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Case 1: Important Differences Between the Assays

25-OH Vitamin D Benzodiazepine

1. Column 2.1x75 mm, 2.7 μm particle size, C18, HSS T3, 35°C

2. Isocratic LC method

3. Average Column Pressure ~5000 psi

1. Column 2.1x50 mm, 1.7 μm particle size, C18, BEH, 40°C

2. Gradient LC method

3. Average Column Pressure ~7500 psi

Mobile Phases Identical

Page 12: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Case 1: Resolution & Lessons Learned

• Problem: Leaky Check valve at pressures >7000 psi

• Solution: Replace check valve

• Lessons Learned:1. A single SST on a “within spec” instrument does not mean its okay

for all assays.

2. Run all assay SSTs on an instrument after a PM before letting engineer leave.

Page 13: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Case 2: Spotting Column Degradation using SST Data

Normal Conditions >50 Injections

Page 14: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Case 2: Developing a SST to Assure Acceptable Chromatographic Resolution

1. Make Neat SST solution containing more Oxazepam than Desalkylflurazepam

2. If unacceptable – Change the guard and/or column

Unacceptable Resolution

Overlay 289>140 MRM QC 10ng/mL Desalkylflurazepam detecting the Desalkylflurazepam peak

Acceptable Resolution

289>140 MRM Desalkylflurazepam detecting Oxazepam

289>140 MRM Desalkylflurazepam detecting Desalkylflurazepam

Page 15: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Case 2: Resolution & Lessons Learned

• Problem: Poor chromatographic resolution due to sample buildup

• Solution: Run SST that assures peak resolution acceptable

• Lessons Learned:1. Some post-validation issues can be addressed with SST preventing

revalidation

Page 16: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Case 3: Troubleshooting Blank SST TIC• Blank SST Chromatogram Empty vial?

Was the vial pierced?

Run errors?

Page 17: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Key Points to Remember about SST

1. A single SST on a “within spec” instrument does not mean its okay for all assays.

2. Run all assay SSTs on an instrument after a PM before letting engineer leave.

3. Some post-validation issues can be addressed with SST preventing revalidation

4. Start by checking the obvious when troubleshooting

Page 18: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

AcknowledgementsThanks to the staff of the UCSD Toxicology/Mass Spectrometry Laboratory who solved and documented this troubleshooting case:• Judy Stone, MT(ASCP), Ph.D., DABCC

• Josh Akin

•Heather Hochrein

•Dawn Francisco

•Robert Fitzgerald, Ph.D., DABCC

•UCSD Clinical Chemistry Fellows• Imir Metushi, Ph.D., ABCC

• Jacqueline Hubbard, Ph.D.

Page 19: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

https://www.surveymonkey.com/r/7WQPWJC

Please let us know what training resources you need

[email protected] [email protected]

Speaker and Presentation Evaluations for Sobolesky/Akin/ Metushi Survey Monkey

Page 20: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Zen and the Art of LC-MS/MS Maintenance Assuring Optimal Instrument Performance

Joshua AkinUC San Diego Health

Page 21: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

DisclaimerThis talk should in no way be associated with that great body of factual information relating to orthodox Zen Buddhist practice,

though it is very factual in chromatography and mass spectrometry.

Page 22: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Overview and ObjectivesGoal: Assure optimal and reliable performance of your LC-MS/MS instrument

Understanding the importance of regular maintenance

Develop a checklist to aide in the tasks and intervals required of instrument maintenance

Page 23: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for
Page 24: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Why is Maintenance so ImportantIrv Gordon’s 1966 Volvo 1800S w/ 3,039,122 miles

"Just follow the owner's manual; it's a piece of machinery and can't take care of itself. Have its scheduled maintenance

completed… and when it makes a funny noise, listen to it."

Page 25: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Monitor gauges

Change oil

Check pressure

Clean Intake

Top-off fluids

Why is Maintenance so Important

Page 26: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

LC-MS/MS instruments are no exception

Monitor gauges

Change oil

Top-off fluids

Check pressure

Clean Intake

Page 27: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Maintenance Checklists –A Roadmap to Success

Page 28: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

LC-MS/MS instruments are no exception

Page 29: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Where to Begin?CLSI Document C50-A “Mass Spectrometry in the Clinical Laboratory: General Principles and Guidance - Approved Guidelines”

CLSI Document C62-A – “Liquid Chromatography-Mass Spectrometry Methods - Approved Guidelines” No Guidance on

Maintenance!

Page 30: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Where to Begin?CLSI Document GP31-A – “Laboratory Instrument Implementation, Verification, and Maintenance; Approved Guidelines”

◦Provides guidelines on:

◦Establishing procedures

◦Proper documentation

◦Responsibilities

Not Specific to LC-MS/MS Instrumentation!

Page 31: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Where to Begin?Manufacturer Documentation

◦Maintenance schedules

◦Procedures

◦Troubleshooting

For use only as GUIDANCE to prepare a procedure

SPECIFIC to your laboratory

READ

THE

MANUAL!

Page 32: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Before Moving ForwardAdequate source of power/backup (UPS)

Data repository/server

Gases (i.e., nitrogen, argon) are properly supplied

LC-MS/MS grade reagents and ultrapure H20

Service contract – more extensive service

Page 33: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Start with the Basics

Page 34: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Start with the Basics

Page 35: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Start with the Basics

1) Month and Year2) Day of the Month3) Frequency4) Tech Initials

1

2

3

4

Page 36: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Maintenance intervalsDaily

Weekly

Monthly

Yearly

As needed

Page 37: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Daily Maintenance

Is there enough mobile phase for start-up and analysis?

Page 38: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Assure adequate volume for duration of analysis

Can be approximated:

◦ flow rate (ml/min) X length of run (min)= volume needed

• “Drying up” fluidics system can damage pumps

Mobile Phase Reagents

Page 39: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Daily Maintenance

Are the instrument vacuum readings within acceptable range?

Are the turbo pumps operating as expected?

Page 40: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Vacuum Monitoring

0.00E+00

5.00E-05

1.00E-04

1.50E-04

2.00E-04

2.50E-04

1 4 7 1013161922252831 3 6 9 12151821242730

Vac

uu

m (

torr

)

Collision Cell Vacuum

0.00E+00

5.00E-04

1.00E-03

1.50E-03

2.00E-03

1 5 9 13 17 21 25 29 33 37 41 45 49 53 57 61

Vac

uu

m (

torr

)

Ion Source Vacuum

Tracking longitudinally can give insight into problems

Leak coming from source enclosure

Interruption in the argon supply

Date

Date

Page 41: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Daily Maintenance

Was system suitability performed on this instrument?What column/method was used?

See Phil’s Lecture!

Page 42: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Weekly Maintenance

Were the interface cones properly cleaned?

Page 43: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Cleaning Sample ConesDepends on the degree of contamination

• Regular use:

1:1 MeOH/H20

• Grossly contaminated: 45:45:10 MeOH/H20/ Formic Acid

• 10 min sonication• Blow dry

Page 44: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Weekly Maintenance

Was the computer rebooted and disk cleanup performed?

Page 45: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Reboot removes “Operating Footprint”

◦ Background processes◦ Hoards valuable system resources (usually

RAM)

• Disk Cleanup frees disk space on HD

– Consult with IT for specific files

Reboot and Disk Cleanup

Page 46: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Weekly Maintenance• Was the oil level

checked on the roughing pumps

• Were the pumps ballasted?

Page 47: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Pump Ballast and OilBallast Valve: purging pump oil of condensate (water/solvent vapors)

◦ Recommended: 15-30 minutes at operating temperature

Ballast Valve

Page 48: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Pump Ballast and OilCheck oil level and note color

◦ Change every 6 months or sooner

Page 49: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Weekly Maintenance

Were LC guard columns replaced?

Page 50: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Guard columnsChange at regular time or injection intervals

Inspect ferrule and replace if needed

Minimize dead-volume by assuring tight connections

Page 51: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Column Guard column

Flow Path

Page 52: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Monthly Maintenance• Is data backed-up

properly?• Are security

updates current?

Page 53: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Data Back-upReal-time Server-based (LIS Intranet, LAN)

PeriodicScope? (full vs. incremental)

Frequency?

Backup media (tape, floppy, disk, etc.)

Page 54: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Windows Security Updates

• Security or Critical updates: malware and security exploits.

• Other updates: typically unrelated to security or enhance functionality.

Page 55: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Friday May 12th, 2017

Page 56: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Key PointsRoutine maintenance is the cornerstone of a happy, healthy LC-MS/MS

Craft a checklist that is suited for your particular lab

Implement a maintenance procedure that assures the reliability and longevity of your instrument.

Page 57: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

AcknowledgementsUCSD Toxicology/Mass Spectrometry Laboratory

◦ Rob Fitzgerald, Ph. D., DABCC◦ Judy Stone, MT (ASCP), Ph. D., DABCC◦ Heather Hochrein, MT (ASCP)◦ Dawn Francisco, MT (ASCP)

Questions? Need help?

[email protected]

Page 58: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Thank you!

Page 59: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Choosing the right internal standard for LC-MS/MS

Imir G. Metushi (PhD, DABCC, FAACC)

Director, LabCorp (Endocrine Sciences)

Calabasas CA

Page 60: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

2

Disclosures

None

Page 61: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

3

Acknowledgments

The following slides include troubleshooting cases documented by LabCorp, Burlington and RTP

Slides are courtesy of Russ Grant and Brian Rappold (LabCorp, Burlington and RTP).

Page 62: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

4

Outline

What is the value of an internal standard in LC-MS/MS

How do we use it

What can go wrong

Page 63: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

External Calibration

“known” amounts of analyte

1 5

10 50

? ?

?

External Calibration Samples

Unknown Test Samples ?

1 5 10 50

External Calibration curve

Unknown Samples

? ? ? ?

Total Efficiency

Total Efficiency

Analyte must have identical matrix effects and extraction efficiency (i.e., total efficiency) between calibrators and samples for accuracy

Page 64: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

External Calibration can demonstrate recovery differences

Hydrolysis (100% Efficiency)

Hydrolysis (50% Efficiency)

CA

LIB

RA

TO

RS

S

AM

PL

ES

-50% Bias

Page 65: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

What is an Internal Standard

An internal standard in analytical chemistry is a chemical substance that is added in a constant amount to samples, the blank and calibration standards in a chemical analysis. This is done to correct for the loss of analyte during sample preparation, injection and ionization.

Source: wikipedia

Page 66: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

S L I D E

8

Internal Standards

UTILITY:

Normalization of recovery differences

Injection variance

Identification of analyte retention time shift

• And peak shape

Normalization of ionization effects between calibrators and samples

One of the most valuable components in LC-MS/MS analytical quality

Page 67: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Retinol D4 Retinol

0.05 0.15 0.25 Time, min

5.0e4

1.0e5

1.5e5

2.0e5

Inten

sity, cps

0.35

1.0e5

2.0e5

3.0e5

Inten

sity, cps

0.05 0.15 0.25 Time, min

0.35

5.0e4

1.0e5

1.5e5

2.0e5

2.5e5

Inten

sity, cps

0.05 0.15 0.25 Time, min

0.35

5.0e4

1.0e5

1.5e5

2.0e5

Inten

sity, cps

0.05 0.15 0.25 Time, min

0.35

Retinol D4 Retinol

Good IS informs what the analyte retention time and peak shape should be Allows diagnosis of problems

9

What Does the IS Tell You Qualitatively

Qc1 (injection #12) Qc1 (injection #94)

Page 68: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

10

IS Peak Area Trend: Outliers and Drift

Tecan Liquid handler IS addition Using same 8 tips with aqueous D4-Cortisol

Drift across run observed

IS peak area precision enables outlier detection

With 0.1% BSA (aq) D4-Cortisol solution and Pre-wetted tips (x3) prior to dispensing

IS peak area CV = 8.6%

Page 69: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

External Calibration with Internal Standardization “known” amounts

of analyte

1 5

10 50

? ?

?

External Calibration Samples

Unknown Test Samples ?

External Calibration Samples

Unknown Samples

Total Efficiency

Total Efficiency

1 5 10 50

? ? ? ?

D[A/IS] = 0

Difference in the matrix effects and extraction efficiency (total efficiency) incurred by the Analyte between calibrators should be identical to the difference incurred by the Internal Standard

DA=DIS

DA=DIS

Page 70: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

External Calibration with Poor Internal Standardization

Hydrolysis (100% Efficiency)

Hydrolysis (50% Efficiency)

CA

LIB

RA

TOR

S SA

MP

LES

+Labeled-IS

50% Bias

Page 71: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

External Calibration with Good Internal Standardization

Hydrolysis (100% Efficiency)

Hydrolysis (50% Efficiency)

CA

LIB

RA

TO

RS

S

AM

PL

ES

0% Bias

+Labeled-IS

Page 72: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Internal Standards: Needs and issues

NATURE:

Structurally unique (exogenous) – Not observed in samples

Resolved (separated) from analyte(s) by MS, but Co-elutes

Stable labeled isotope (2H, 13C, 15N, 18O) - +3 amu*, pure

Structurally similar (analog) – No recovery or matrix effect correction

Structurally dissimilar - injection check at best?

Page 73: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

XIC of +MRM (77 pairs): 150.1/87.1 Da ID: Lysine D3 from Sample 1 (Plasma Mid QC_) of SpecChemQC 030211NPExt.wiff (Turbo Spra... Max. 9.4e5 cps.

2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 26Time, min

0.0

5.0e4

1.0e5

1.5e5

2.0e5

2.5e5

3.0e5

3.5e5

4.0e5

4.5e5

5.0e5

5.5e5

6.0e5

6.5e5

7.0e5

7.5e5

8.0e5

8.5e5

9.0e5

9.4e5

Inte

ns

ity

, c

ps

12.57

19.03

D3-Lysine (m/z): 150-87 Tr = 18.97

XIC of +MRM (77 pairs): 150.1/104.1 Da ID: Methionine from Sample 1 (Plasma Mid QC_) of SpecChemQC 030211NPExt.wiff (Turbo Sp... Max. 3.8e5 cps.

2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 26Time, min

0.0

2.0e4

4.0e4

6.0e4

8.0e4

1.0e5

1.2e5

1.4e5

1.6e5

1.8e5

2.0e5

2.2e5

2.4e5

2.6e5

2.8e5

3.0e5

3.2e5

3.4e5

3.6e5

3.8e5

Inte

ns

ity

, c

ps

12.57

15.95

15.43

Methionine (m/z): 150 – 104 Tr = 12.57

XIC of +MRM (77 pairs): 153.1/107.1 Da ID: Methionine D3 from Sample 1 (Plasma Mid QC_) of SpecChemQC 030211NPExt.wiff (Turb... Max. 1.6e5 cps.

2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 26Time, min

0.0

1.0e4

2.0e4

3.0e4

4.0e4

5.0e4

6.0e4

7.0e4

8.0e4

9.0e4

1.0e5

1.1e5

1.2e5

1.3e5

1.4e5

1.5e5

1.6e5

Inte

ns

ity

, c

ps

12.57

13.68

D3-Methionine (m/z): 153 – 107 Tr = 12.57

XIC of +MRM (77 pairs): 153.1/88.1 Da ID: Glutamic Acid D5 from Sample 1 (Plasma Mid QC_) of SpecChemQC 030211NPExt.wiff (Tur... Max. 1.9e5 cps.

2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 26Time, min

0.0

1.0e4

2.0e4

3.0e4

4.0e4

5.0e4

6.0e4

7.0e4

8.0e4

9.0e4

1.0e5

1.1e5

1.2e5

1.3e5

1.4e5

1.5e5

1.6e5

1.7e5

1.8e5

1.9e5

Inte

ns

ity

, c

ps

13.68

13.54

D5-Glutamic Acid (m/z): 153 – 88 Tr = 13.68

XIC of +MRM (77 pairs): 119.1/73.1 Da ID: Proline D3 from Sample 1 (Plasma Mid QC_) of SpecChemQC 030211NPExt.wiff (Turbo Spr... Max. 1.1e6 cps.

2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 26Time, min

0.00

5.00e4

1.00e5

1.50e5

2.00e5

2.50e5

3.00e5

3.50e5

4.00e5

4.50e5

5.00e5

5.50e5

6.00e5

6.50e5

7.00e5

7.50e5

8.00e5

8.50e5

9.00e5

9.50e5

1.00e6

1.05e6

1.10e6

1.15e6

Inte

ns

ity

, c

ps

12.89

13.87 D3-Proline (m/z): 119-73 Tr = 13.84

XIC of +MRM (77 pairs): 118.1/72.1 Da ID: Valine from Sample 1 (Plasma Mid QC_) of SpecChemQC 030211NPExt.wiff (Turbo Spray) Max. 1.3e6 cps.

2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 26Time, min

0.00

5.00e4

1.00e5

1.50e5

2.00e5

2.50e5

3.00e5

3.50e5

4.00e5

4.50e5

5.00e5

5.50e5

6.00e5

6.50e5

7.00e5

7.50e5

8.00e5

8.50e5

9.00e5

9.50e5

1.00e6

1.05e6

1.10e6

1.15e6

1.20e6

1.25e6

Inte

ns

ity

, c

ps

12.89

14.15

Structurally Unique in specimens

Valine (m/z):118-72 Tr = 12.89

Page 74: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Internal Standards

NATURE:

Structurally unique (exogenous) – Not observed in samples

Resolved (separated) from analyte(s) by MS, but Co-elutes

Stable labeled isotope (2H, 13C, 15N, 18O) - +3 amu*, pure

Structurally similar (analog) – Limited recovery or ionization effect correction

Structurally dissimilar - injection check at best?

Page 75: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Too many Deuterons can hurt you

D10-Gabapentin 182.2→147.1

Gabapentin 172.2→137.1

XIC of +MRM (4 pairs): 172.200/137.100 Da ID: Gabapentin 1 from Sample 9 (Blank) of ASMS_Gaba_res5.wiff (Turbo Spray) Max. 4.4e4 cps.

0.69 0.70 0.71 0.72 0.73 0.74 0.75 0.76 0.77 0.78 0.79 0.80 0.81 0.82 0.83 0.84 0.85 0.86 0.87 0.88Time, min

0.0

2000.0

4000.0

6000.0

8000.0

1.0e4

1.2e4

1.4e4

1.6e4

1.8e4

2.0e4

2.2e4

2.4e4

2.6e4

2.8e4

3.0e4

3.2e4

3.4e4

3.6e4

3.8e4

4.0e4

4.2e4

4.4e4

Inte

ns

ity

, c

ps

0.78

Fast LC: Co-elution

XIC of +MRM (4 pairs): 172.200/137.100 Da ID: Gabapentin 1 from Sample 9 (Blank) of ASMS_Gaba_res4.wiff (Turbo Spray) Max. 2.6e4 cps.

1.33 1.34 1.35 1.36 1.37 1.38 1.39 1.40 1.41 1.42 1.43 1.44 1.45 1.46 1.47 1.48 1.49 1.50 1.51 1.52Time, min

0.0

1000.0

2000.0

3000.0

4000.0

5000.0

6000.0

7000.0

8000.0

9000.0

1.0e4

1.1e4

1.2e4

1.3e4

1.4e4

1.5e4

1.6e4

1.7e4

1.8e4

1.9e4

2.0e4

2.1e4

2.2e4

2.3e4

2.4e4

2.5e4

2.6e4

Inte

ns

ity

, c

ps

1.43

Slow LC: Separation

1:1 Gabapentin:D10 IS in Clean Urine

D10-Gabapentin IS not Co-eluting

Page 76: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Under-labelled IS

11-Desoxycortisol Concentration (ng/dL) 400 800 1200 1600 2000

0

5

10

15 An

alyte Area / IS

Area

Calibration curve non-linear 3-log range for 11-Desoxycortisol

IS only 13C2 labelled (*)

Analyte isotopically contributes to IS -

Solutions:

Truncate to linear range assay neat and pre-dilute samples (two analysis!),

Repeat on dilution > mid point

Increase IS concentration or alternate IS

Clinically acceptable as is

* *

No

rmal

Abnormal (>156ng/dL)

Page 77: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

S L I D E

19

Internal Standard

ADDITION:

FIRST step after mixing/pipetting sample (see Glucoronide IS example)

Solution ideally miscible with sample – to correct analyte recovery

Mixed well prior to extraction – Equilibrated identically to analyte

Internal Standard stability to be checked – In solution and H/D exchange in ion source

Reproducibly added (precise!) to samples, calibrators, QC’s except double blanks

Page 78: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Protein Precipitation – Serotonin Blood vs Serum

Spike & Recovery

Mix and Pipet 100uL Sample

Add 300uL D4-Serotonin IS in Acetonitrile

Mix and centrifuge 10 min each

Transfer to 96-well plate and inject

Page 79: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Internal Standard Equilibration in Samples Reverse Timing Study

S L I D E

21

Aliquots of sample pool plus IS equilibrated with mixing Decreasing amounts of time prior to extraction in parallel (i.e., reverse timing)

IS 120 min

IS 60 min

IS 30 min

IS 15 min

IS 5

Equilibration w/ Mixing Extraction

Plateau in A:IS ratio indicates IS has reached binding equilibrium Use double the minimum time!

Page 80: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Serotonin: IS Binding and RBC’s

S L I D E

22

Equilibration/Mixing Time (min)

An

alyt

e:IS

Rat

io

Page 81: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

S L I D E

23

Internal Standard

ADDITION:

FIRST step after mixing/pipetting sample (see Glucoronide IS example)

Solution ideally miscible with sample – to correct analyte recovery

Mixed well prior to extraction – Equilibrated identically to analyte

Internal Standard stability to be checked – In solution and H/D exchange in ion source

Reproducibly added (precise!) samples, calibrators QC’s except double blanks – Hard to know with manual pipetting

Page 82: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Analyte observed in IS solution: H/D Exchange

Neat Dopamine D4 solution appeared to contain mostly Dopamine

Labelling is in an active region of the molecule

Deuteriums exchange with Protons in the APCI source

Solution: Used ESI

XIC of +MRM (6 pairs): 154.1/91.1 Da from Sample 12 (IS APCI) of H-D exchange.wiff (Heated Nebulizer) Max. 1.0e5 cps.

0.05 0.10 0.15 0.20 0.25 0.30 0.35 0.40 0.45 0.50 0.55 0.60 0.65 0.70Time, min

0.00

5000.00

1.00e4

1.50e4

2.00e4

2.50e4

3.00e4

3.50e4

4.00e4

4.50e4

5.00e4

5.50e4

6.00e4

6.50e4

7.00e4

7.50e4

8.00e4

8.50e4

9.00e4

9.50e4

1.00e5

Inte

ns

ity

, c

ps

0.56

XIC of +MRM (6 pairs): 158.2/139.0 Da from Sample 10 (IS ESI) of H-D exchange.wiff (Turbo Spray) Max. 3.7e5 cps.

0.05 0.10 0.15 0.20 0.25 0.30 0.35 0.40 0.45 0.50 0.55 0.60 0.65 0.70Time, min

0.0

2.0e4

4.0e4

6.0e4

8.0e4

1.0e5

1.2e5

1.4e5

1.6e5

1.8e5

2.0e5

2.2e5

2.4e5

2.6e5

2.8e5

3.0e5

3.2e5

3.4e5

3.6e5

3.7e5

Inte

ns

ity

, c

ps

0.55

XIC of +MRM (6 pairs): 154.1/91.1 Da from Sample 10 (IS ESI) of H-D exchange.wiff (Turbo Spray) Max. 1133.3 cps.

0.05 0.10 0.15 0.20 0.25 0.30 0.35 0.40 0.45 0.50 0.55 0.60 0.65 0.70Time, min

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

450

500

550

600

650

700

750

800

850

900

950

1000

1050

1100

1133

Inte

ns

ity

, c

ps

0.00

0.02

0.69

0.29

0.190.09

0.10

0.14 0.21 0.30

0.110.05 0.08 0.17 0.56

0.12 0.34 0.58

0.31 0.590.51

0.670.36 0.52 0.71

0.61 0.63 0.660.430.400.38 0.72

XIC of +MRM (6 pairs): 158.2/139.0 Da from Sample 12 (IS APCI) of H-D exchange.wiff (Heated Nebulizer) Max. 2.5e6 cps.

0.05 0.10 0.15 0.20 0.25 0.30 0.35 0.40 0.45 0.50 0.55 0.60 0.65 0.70Time, min

0.0

1.0e5

2.0e5

3.0e5

4.0e5

5.0e5

6.0e5

7.0e5

8.0e5

9.0e5

1.0e6

1.1e6

1.2e6

1.3e6

1.4e6

1.5e6

1.6e6

1.7e6

1.8e6

1.9e6

2.0e6

2.1e6

2.2e6

2.3e6

2.4e6

2.5e6

Inte

ns

ity

, c

ps

0.55

D4-Dopamine IS

1e5 cps

Dopamine

2e6 cps

D4-Dopamine IS

4e5 cps

Dopamine, 1100 cps

IS in Water APCI Source IS in Water ESI source

Page 83: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

It can get more complicated: just ask Russ

IS Peak Area vs Index (004102 DHEA)- "Mean" Regression ("No" weighting): mean = 8.11e+004 x (std. dev. = 1.44e+004)

5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60 65 70 75 80 85 90 95Index

0.00

5000.00

1.00e4

1.50e4

2.00e4

2.50e4

3.00e4

3.50e4

4.00e4

4.50e4

5.00e4

5.50e4

6.00e4

6.50e4

7.00e4

7.50e4

8.00e4

8.50e4

9.00e4

9.50e4

1.00e5IS

Pe

ak

Are

a,

co

un

ts

D5-Phenylalanine Peak Area Response in a run

Page 84: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

Final thoughts

S L I D E

26

Rule 1: Internal standards are NOT a universal accuracy fix.

Rule 2: Ensure adequate binding/equilibration for analyte and IS prior to extraction (time, pH, temperature, mixing)

Rule 3: IS stability during extraction relative to analyte will impact accuracy (e.g., H/D exchange).

Rule 4: IS recovery (and matrix effect for D-labeling) should be identical between calibrators and samples

Rule 5: Don’t abuse the IS – it is literally your best friend

Page 85: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

27

Acknowledgments

Philip Sobolesky at UC San Diego

MSACL Committee

Russ Grant and Brian Rappold (LabCorp Burlington and RTP) for the slides

Page 86: LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track ...€¦ · LC-MS/MS Practical Mass Spectrometry Training Track: Understanding the Importance of System Suitability Testing for

28