4
LAX Electric Power Vulnerabilities & Possible Mitigations action plan status report for 4th Quarter 2018 Trend Current Quarterly Status Agency Progress Next Qtr Steps Immediate Actions currently in progress Both Update LAX Airport Response Coordination Center emergency communication protocol Plan is being developed. Meeting will be scheduled to review with Managers of both sides. 1 Ensure continued monthly testing and exercise of all back-up generators & UPS The test report for the back-up generators will be submitted monthly and for the UPS system will be submitted according to the manufacture recommendation. Continue testing monthly or according to manufacture recommendation. 2 LAWA Testing and Maintenance of LADWP transmission protection system LADWP Completed. Nothing unusual to report. No additional actions are planned at this time. 3 ESM performed annual inspection on 11 Industrial Stations (IS) and 2 Customer Stations (CS) within LAX. LADWP usually Survey , Inspect, Repair (SIR) as necessary. See Attachment 1 for details and completion dates. Validate maintenance and inspection routines of LADWP's equipment ESM will inspect and perform routine maintenance on approximately 10 Industrial Stations during the next quarter. 4 LADWP 34.5 KV cable assessment and replacement Reliability Group has initiated reliability assessment of the LAX area. Normalized SAIFI and SAIDI performance compared to the West LA district and overall system Number of recorded/reported sustained and momentary outages Breakdown of outage causes for both sustained and momentary incidents Possibly recommend remedial work The July-September reliability assessment will be reported by October 31, 2018. 5 LADWP Electrical Power and Energy Consulting (EPEC) Study Report from EPEC (Electric Power and Energy Consulting ) has been completed.________________________________________________ Review EPEC (Electric Power and Energy Consulting ) Study. Implement design changes into designs for RS-X.__________________________________________ 6 o LADWP On-going preparation to identify the scope of work for consultant team to perform the study. LAX Back-up Generator assessment Preparation of contract to perform the study. 7 LAWA Substructures inspection, assessment and action plan The Inspection and Maintenance group performed visual inspection of overhead and underground facilities within LAX area during the past 12 month. Underground inspections were limited due to accessibility to runway/taxiway/CTA area. A total of 840 overhead and underground facilities were inspected between 7/1/17 and 6/30/18. See Attachment 2 for details and completion dates.________________________________________________ The EPRI (Electric Power Research Institute )report recommends moving forward with RS-X. Visual inspections of overhead facilities are on a 12 month cycle, limited underground visual inspection due to accessibility. Detailed inspections are on a 3-year cycle for underground facilities and five-year cycle for overhead facilities. 8 LADWP Evaluate risks and propose action plan based upon study by EPRI No additional actions are planned or required at this time. 9 LADWP Short Term Actions for consideration and if worthwhile to be completed by January 2020 Preparation to identify emergency scenarios , stakeholders , available options and coordinate with LADWP. Develop emergency response procedure for load shedding during a large power outage Evaluate the options and coordinate with LADWP. 1 LAWA The implementation of the standard was included in CONRAC request for proposal and will be added to LAWA's DCH (Design and Construction Handbook ) on October 2018. Include standard to other future LAX projects in LAWA's DCH (Design and Construction Handbook ). Implement IEEE 1686 standard for new equipment as recommended by EPRI 2 o LAWA LAWA shall implement the standard to new project under planning. Implement existing equipment modifications per EPRI Power Quality study LAWA Continue on going implementation to all existing equipment. 3 LAWA needs to sign an Interconnection Agreement for the CUP (Central Utility Coordinate with LADWP to enable Central Utility Plant cogeneration islanding Prepare scope of work for consultant to analyze existing conditions and provide recommendation. 4 o LAWA Plant). LADOT (Los Angeles Department of Transportation) has programed in their Provide LADOT (Los Angeles Department of Transportation) installation schedule. Provide back-up power to parking structures and traffic signals at the CTA 5 o capital project to add UPS (uninterpretable power supply) to LAX traffic signals to be installed. LAWA LongTermMjtjgItjonjjorconjjderatjonandjfworthwhNetobecompJetedbybeyondJOZO As improvements are made to the CTA (Central Terminal Area ), circuits will be rearranged. Investigate feasibility of rearranging RS-N circuits to eliminate single point of failure Investigation is complete. 1 LADWP Consider new RS-X and corresponding micro-grid dedicated to LAX 2 MOU approved on 6/26/18. Both Planning and Design is on-going. a. MOU to construct a new RS-X b. RS-X to be supplied by four 230-kV cables LAWA Part of the Design criteria for RS-X. Part of the Design criteria for RS-X c. All RS-X cables divided into two redundant/separate duct banks LAWA Part of the Design criteria for RS-X. Part of the Design criteria for RS-X Copy of LADWP_LAWA_Joint Quarterly Report_BoninCouncil Motion_Fourth Quarter 2018 (2).xlsx 1 OF 2

LAX Electric Power Vulnerabilities & Possible Mitigations ...clkrep.lacity.org/onlinedocs/2017/17-0971-S2_misc_08-30-2019.pdfAug 30, 2019  · d. All equipment and cable new LAWA Part

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: LAX Electric Power Vulnerabilities & Possible Mitigations ...clkrep.lacity.org/onlinedocs/2017/17-0971-S2_misc_08-30-2019.pdfAug 30, 2019  · d. All equipment and cable new LAWA Part

LAX Electric Power Vulnerabilities & Possible Mitigations action plan status report for 4th Quarter 2018Trend Current

Quarterly StatusAgency Progress Next Qtr StepsImmediate Actions currently in progress

BothUpdate LAX Airport Response Coordination Center emergency communication protocol Plan is being developed. Meeting will be scheduled to review with Managers of both sides.1Ensure continued monthly testing and exercise of all back-up generators & UPS The test report for the back-up generators will be submitted monthly and for

the UPS system will be submitted according to the manufacture recommendation.

Continue testing monthly or according to manufacture recommendation.2LAWA

Testing and Maintenance of LADWP transmission protection system LADWP Completed. Nothing unusual to report. No additional actions are planned at this time.3ESM performed annual inspection on 11 Industrial Stations (IS) and 2 Customer Stations (CS) within LAX. LADWP usually Survey , Inspect, Repair (SIR) as necessary. See Attachment 1 for details and completion dates.

Validate maintenance and inspection routines of LADWP's equipment ESM will inspect and perform routine maintenance on approximately 10 Industrial Stations during the next quarter.

4

LADWP

34.5 KV cable assessment and replacement Reliability Group has initiated reliability assessment of the LAX area.• Normalized SAIFI and SAIDI performance compared to the West LA district and overall system• Number of recorded/reported sustained and momentary outages• Breakdown of outage causes for both sustained and momentary incidents• Possibly recommend remedial work

The July-September reliability assessment will be reported by October 31, 2018.5

LADWP

Electrical Power and Energy Consulting (EPEC) Study Report from EPEC (Electric Power and Energy Consulting ) has been completed.________________________________________________

Review EPEC (Electric Power and Energy Consulting ) Study. Implement design changes into designs for RS-X.__________________________________________

6 oLADWP

On-going preparation to identify the scope of work for consultant team to perform the study.

LAX Back-up Generator assessment Preparation of contract to perform the study.7LAWA

Substructures inspection, assessment and action plan The Inspection and Maintenance group performed visual inspection of overhead and underground facilities within LAX area during the past 12 month. Underground inspections were limited due to accessibility to runway/taxiway/CTA area. A total of 840 overhead and underground facilities were inspected between 7/1/17 and 6/30/18. See Attachment 2 for detailsand completion dates.________________________________________________The EPRI (Electric Power Research Institute )report recommends moving forward with RS-X.

Visual inspections of overhead facilities are on a 12 month cycle, limited underground visual inspection due to accessibility. Detailed inspections are on a 3-year cycle for underground facilities and five-year cycle for overhead facilities.

8

LADWP

Evaluate risks and propose action plan based upon study by EPRI No additional actions are planned or required at this time.9LADWP

Short Term Actions for consideration and if worthwhile to be completed by January 2020Preparation to identify emergency scenarios , stakeholders , available options and coordinate with LADWP.

Develop emergency response procedure for load shedding during a large power outage Evaluate the options and coordinate with LADWP.1LAWA

The implementation of the standard was included in CONRAC request for proposal and will be added to LAWA's DCH (Design and Construction Handbook ) on October 2018.

Include standard to other future LAX projects in LAWA's DCH (Design and Construction Handbook ).

Implement IEEE 1686 standard for new equipment as recommended by EPRI2 oLAWA

LAWA shall implement the standard to new project under planning.Implement existing equipment modifications per EPRI Power Quality study LAWA Continue on going implementation to all existing equipment.3LAWA needs to sign an Interconnection Agreement for the CUP (Central UtilityCoordinate with LADWP to enable Central Utility Plant cogeneration islanding Prepare scope of work for consultant to analyze existing conditions and provide

recommendation.4 oLAWA

Plant).LADOT (Los Angeles Department of Transportation) has programed in their Provide LADOT (Los Angeles Department of Transportation) installation schedule.Provide back-up power to parking structures and traffic signals at the CTA5 o capital project to add UPS (uninterpretable power supply) to LAX traffic signals to be installed.

LAWA

LongTermMjtjgItjonjjorconjjderatjonandjfworthwhNetobecompJetedbybeyondJOZOAs improvements are made to the CTA (Central Terminal Area ), circuits will be rearranged.

Investigate feasibility of rearranging RS-N circuits to eliminate single point of failure Investigation is complete.1LADWP

Consider new RS-X and corresponding micro-grid dedicated to LAX2MOU approved on 6/26/18.Both Planning and Design is on-going.a. MOU to construct a new RS-X

b. RS-X to be supplied by four 230-kV cables LAWA Part of the Design criteria for RS-X. Part of the Design criteria for RS-Xc. All RS-X cables divided into two redundant/separate duct banks LAWA Part of the Design criteria for RS-X. Part of the Design criteria for RS-X

Copy of LADWP_LAWA_Joint Quarterly Report_BoninCouncil Motion_Fourth Quarter 2018 (2).xlsx1 OF 2

Page 2: LAX Electric Power Vulnerabilities & Possible Mitigations ...clkrep.lacity.org/onlinedocs/2017/17-0971-S2_misc_08-30-2019.pdfAug 30, 2019  · d. All equipment and cable new LAWA Part

Trend CurrentQuarterly StatusAgency Progress Next Qtr Steps

d. All equipment and cable new LAWA Part of the Design criteria for RS-X. Part of the Design criteria for RS-Xe. Share power from CUP cogeneration, solar, etc.. Within micro-grid back-up LAWA Part of the Design criteria for RS-X. Preparation of contract to perform the study.

Bothf. Develop back-up plan in case RS-X catastrophe to switch over to RS-N LADWP is evaluating options. Present options to LAWA .Additional considerations3a. Provide additional back-up generators for partial terminal operations LAWA is assessing the need and evaluating options. Evaluation the need pending LAX back-up generator assessment study.LAWAb. Expand mobile generator inventory for operation back-up LAWA is assessing the need and evaluating options. Evaluation the need pending LAX back-up generator assessment study.LAWA

LAWA is assessing the need and evaluating options. Evaluation the need pending LAX back-up generator assessment study.c. Designate additional emergency terminal LAWA

LegendNo Issue

Warning/Notification

Concern/IssuesO

Copy of LADWP_LAWA_Joint Quarterly Report_BoninCouncil Motion_Fourth Quarter 2018 (2).xlsx2 OF 2

Page 3: LAX Electric Power Vulnerabilities & Possible Mitigations ...clkrep.lacity.org/onlinedocs/2017/17-0971-S2_misc_08-30-2019.pdfAug 30, 2019  · d. All equipment and cable new LAWA Part

LAX Electric Power Vulnerabilities Possible Mitigations action plan status report 1st Quarter 2019

Trend Quarterly Status Next Qtr StepsAgency Progress

JmmedjateActjonscurrentjyjnprogresS-Update LAX Airport Response Coordination Center emergency communication protocol On Feb 26, 2019, managers of both sides met and discussed a need for a proper communication protocol .

LADWP is updating their ONP (Outage Notification Protocol) software to include LAWA's designated email addresses.

LADWP to convey proper communication protocol to LAWA.1

Formalize the communication protocol in writing.Both

LAWA and LADWP are working to update a spreadsheet to identify all industrial stations on the LAX and VNY footprints.

Plan for follow-up meeting in August 2019.

Ensure continued monthly testing and exercise of all back-up generators & uninterruptable power supplies (UPS)

LAWA excercise generators monthly as part of their maintenance program. LAWA has an on-going maintenance contract to test Uninterruptable Power Supplies (UPS) quarterly. Facilities Maintenance and Utilities Group is setting Up Maximo to access test reports.

Generator testing is continuing on a monthly basis. UPS units and inverter units are tested and batteries inspected on a quarterly basis. Any defect found with applicable systems is repaired as soon as practical.

2

LAWA

Testing and Maintenance of LADWP transmission protection system Completed last quarter. Nothing unusual to report. No additional actions are planned at this time.LADWP3Validate maintenance and inspection routines of LADWP's equipment ESM performed annual inspection on 21 Industrial Stations (IS) within LAX. LADWP usually performs Survey,

Inspect, Repair (SIR) as necessary. See Attachment 1 for details and completion dates.ESM will inspect and perform routine maintenance on approximately 10 Industrial Stations during the next quarter.

4LADWP

34.5 KV cable assessment and replacement Reliability Group has completed the Q4 2018 quarterly reliability assessment of the LAX area, submitted to LAWA as Attachment 2. The report contains:• SAIFI and SAIDI performance compared to the West LA district and overall system• Number of recorded/reported sustained and momentary outages• Breakdown of outage causes for both sustained and momentary incidents No incidents were reported in Q4 2018.

The Q2 2019 quarterly and 2018 annual reliability assessment will be reported by 2nd Quarter 2019

5

LADWP

Electrical Power and Energy Consulting (EPEC) Study Report from EPEC (Electric Power and Energy Consulting ) has been completed. CompletedLADWP6LAX Back-up Generator assessment LAWA Facilities Maintenance & Utilities Group has performed an initial assessment of the back-up generators

and conducted tests on September 12, 2018 for Terminal 1, 2 and 3 and on October 31, 2018 for Tom Bradley International Terminal. Both tests went well.

LAWA will prepare a draft scope of work and meet with prospective consultant firms to seek proposals. Estimated Assessment study to begin in 3rd quarter 2019.

7

LAWA

Substructures inspection, assessment and action plan The Inspection and Maintenance group performed visual inspection of overhead and underground facilities within LAX area during the past 12 months. Undergound inspections were limited due to accessibility to runway/taxiway/CTA area. A total of 1,680 overhead and underground facilities were inspected between 01/01/18 and 12/31/18.DWP submitted to LAWA as Attachment 3 for details and completion dates.

Visual inspections of overhead facilities are on a 12 month cycle, limited underground visual inspection due to accessibility. Detailed inspections are on a 3- year cycle for underground facilities and five-year cycle for overhead facilities.

8

LADWP

Evaluate risks and propose action plan based upon study by EPRI LADWP is developing RS-X design requirements. Continue working on RS-X design requirements.LADWP9

ShortTermAtjons;for;consjderatjon;andJfworthwhHe;to;be=comp]eted=byJanuary=202£Develop emergency response procedure for load shedding during a large power outage LAWA and DWP are finalizing a draft MOU named "Sustainble Water and Power Services " where this task will

be addressed.Estimated time to complete this task according to the MOU is 18 months.1 LAWA

Implement IEEE 1668 standard for new equipment as recommended by EPRI The implementation of the standard was included in CONRAC request for proposal and has been added to LAWA's DCH (Design and Construction Handbook )

Follow-up that the IEEE 1668 standard is being included in the project design requirements for future LAX projects. Continue to monitor manufacturers adopting of the standard. Evaluate other options offered by the manufacturers.

2

LAWACoordinating with projects to estimate cost to implement (T1.5, T3, TBIT/T5.5/T7 APM Cores, T4 Renovation,T0, T9, APF)_________________________________________________________________________________LAWA has started the implementation of the standard and removed 47 of 56 phase monitors in existing "OTIS' escalators. LAWA is in continuous dialog with manufacturers to implement an acceptable fix to existing systems.

o Continue coordination w/ OTIS to implement recommendations for all existing conveyance equipment.

Implement existing equipment modifications per EPRI Power Quality study3

LAWATBIT & T6 BHS consortiums (TBITec & LAX6) have declined to approve or assist in modification to equipment that will modify equipment lisitng. LAWA will continue to seek a solution.Coordinating SOW for conveyances (TBIT/T6) w/ OTIS

Coordinate with LADWP to enable Central Utility Plant cogeneration islanding LAWA and DWP 's staff have not agreed on all articles of the agreement. The matters is being reviewed by both departments general counsel. this Interconnection Agreement for the CUP (Central Utility Plant) will facilitate methods of operating the CUP in islanding mode.

Both agencies BIRDI and NREL will provide scope of Work to LAWA to generate a task order to enable the CUP cogeneration islanding. Cogeneration Islanding will enable the CUP to continue operation during a power outage.

4 oLAWA

Copy of LADWP_LAWA_Joint Quarterly Report_BoninCouncilMotion_ First Quarter 2019 revision 3.xlsx1 OF 2

Page 4: LAX Electric Power Vulnerabilities & Possible Mitigations ...clkrep.lacity.org/onlinedocs/2017/17-0971-S2_misc_08-30-2019.pdfAug 30, 2019  · d. All equipment and cable new LAWA Part

LAX Electric Power Vulnerabilities Possible Mitigations action plan status report 1st Quarter 2019

Trend Quarterly Status Next Qtr StepsAgency Progress

Provide back-up power to parking structures and traffic signals at the CTA LADOT (Los Angeles Department of Transportation) has upgraded in 3rd quarter 2018 the LAX traffic signal cabinets that will allow the traffic signals to automatically reset when power is restored after a power outage.

Provide LADOT (Los Angeles Department of T ransportation) complete traffic signal cabinet equipment list.Continue to monitor that the upgraded traffic signal cabinets are able to automatically reset after a power outage.Assess loads needed for back-up power at each parking structure and provide recommendation.

5

LAWA

Long;TermM!tji^^!fls:JOLconsjder|tjon=and=ifworthwhHe;to=becomB]eted=by=beyond=202£Investigate feasibility of rearranging RS-N circuits to eliminate single point of failure As improvements are made to the CTA, circuits will be rearranged. As improvements are made to the CTA, circuits will be rearranged.LADWP1Consider new RS-X and corresponding micro-grid dedicated to LAX2

Both Included in design requirements Included in design requirementsa. MOU to construct a new RS-Xb. RS-X to be supplied by four 230-kV cables Included in design requirements Included in design requirementsLAWAc. All RS-X cables divided into two redundant/separate duct banks Included in design requirements Included in design requirementsLAWAd. All equipment and cable new Included in design requirements Included in design requirementsLAWA

Included as task in LAWA/LADWP sustainable Water & Power Services MOU "Memorandum of understanding' Included as task in LAWA/LADWP sustainable Water & Power Services MOU "Memorandum of understanding"__________________________________

e. Share power from CUP cogeneration, solar, etc.. Within micro-grid back-up LAWA

Included as task in LAWA/LADWP sustainable Water & Power Services MOU "Memorandum of understanding' Included as task in LAWA/LADWP sustainable Water & Power Services MOU "Memorandum of understanding"__________________________________

f. Develop back-up plan in case RS-X catastrophe to switch over to RS-NBoth

Additional considerations3LAWA is assessing the need and evaluating options. LAWA has included in the design requirements additional back-up generator capacity at Terminal 1, Terminal 3 head house and Midfield Satellite Concourse.

Evaluation the need pending LAX back-up generator assessment study.LAWA

a. Provide additional back-up generators for partial terminal operationsb. Expand mobile generator inventory for operation back-up LAWA has no plan to expand mobile generators Evaluation the need pending LAX back-up generator assessment study.LAWAc. Designate additional emergency terminal There is no immediate plan to designate an emergency terminal There is no immediate plan to designate an emergency terminalLAWA

LegendNo Issue

Warnini/Notification/Slow Progress

Concern/IssuesO

Copy of LADWP_LAWA_Joint Quarterly Report_BoninCouncilMotion_ First Quarter 2019 revision 3.xlsx2 OF 2