Law and Public Administration in Ireland - Clarus Press MATERIAL viii Law and Public Administration in Ireland and Public Administration in Ireland looks to connect judicial and non-judicial

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

Law and Public Administration in Ireland

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L


By

Dr Fiona DonsonLLB, LLM, PhD

Dr Darren O’DonovanBCL, PhD

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

Published byClarus Press Ltd,Griffi th Campus,

South Circular Road,Dublin 8.

Typeset byDeanta Global Publishing Services

Printed byClondalkin Print Group,

Dublin

ISBN978-1-905536-70-2

All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, or transmitted in any form or by any means, including recording and photocopying, without

the written permission of the copyright holder, application for which should be addressed to the publisher. Written permission should also be obtained before any

part of the publication is stored in a retrieval system of any nature.

DisclaimerWhilst every effort has been made to ensure that the contents of this book are

accurate, neither the publisher, nor authors can accept responsibility for any errors or omissions or loss occasioned to any person acting or refraining from acting as

result of any material in this publication.

Copyright © Donson and O’Donovan 2015

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

LFiona would like to dedicate this book to Aoife and Oisín

Darren would like to dedicate this book to Aoibheann

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

Preface

It is often said that administrative law is notoriously difficult to study and to teach because its doctrines are abstract and nuanced, moving across a wide array of statutes and aspects of legal practice. This book is an attempt to defend administrative law as an exciting and dynamic subject which is central to meeting the future challenges facing Irish public governance.

Law and Public Administration in Ireland inevitably focuses heavily upon judicial review, as the central aspect of the legal regulation of governance, providing a firm backstop against government abuse of power. In our account of the grounds of judicial review, we have sought to track the movement within the case-law, rather than simply overview existing precedents. Administrative law is a deeply contextual subject, one in which formal doctrinal language obscures the competing principles of public policy and the role played by the complicated fact patterns of cases. This underlying connection with purpose and pragmatic sensitivity to context are essential for any student, practitioner or decision-maker dealing with judicial review cases, and we have sought to anchor our text in this emphasis.

Alongside this formal legal analysis, this book also seeks to engage with broader issues concerning the reform of Irish public administration and the availability of non-judicial forms of review. A distinct focus is upon the crucial role of Parliament in administrative law. It will be obvious to the reader that administrative law has direct implications for citizens, the executive and the courts, with each usually constituting the applicant, the respondent and the adjudicator respectively. Yet, outside the narrow confines of individual cases, it is the Oireachtas which is the primary actor in our administrative justice system. This book stresses the fact that in discharging its legislative mandate, the Oireachtas must create consistent frameworks for resolving disputes between citizen and government. In our discussion of the Office of the Ombudsman, public inquiries in Ireland and parliamentary review generally, we argue that a greater commitment to improving the machinery of administrative justice is key to disentangling the Oireachtas from executive dominance, and ensuring that the executive is answerable to the public. Thus, Law

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

viii


and Public Administration in Ireland looks to connect judicial and non-judicial mechanisms to the broader goal of accountability.

Ultimately, the core question which this book poses is, simply put, what do we want from administrative law? This, to us, is the fundamental question of the subject. Rather than a focus upon inherited principles, it is important to locate the ongoing value judgments shaping judicial decisions and the design of our institutions. For the courts and practicing lawyers, we would submit that this question was central to recent refinements to judicial review principles such as occurred in Meadows v Minister for Justice. Such cases, and broader debates regarding the reform of the Irish administrative state, reflect the fact that Irish legal scholarship continues to question which administrative structures and approaches best reflect, and practically secure, the values of Bunreacht na hÈireann. We hope that this book contributes to this vital conversation.

Fiona Donson and Darren O‘Donovan, 23rd February 2015

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

Acknowledgements

We are very proud of this book as combining both traditional and newer themes in administrative law scholarship. This book was a truly collective endeavor, in which we attempted to draw out our best strengths, in both substance and process. Thanks must go to David McCartney at Clarus Press, who has proved remarkably patient with the book, willing us freedom to pursue a work with the broadest coverage. We would also like to thank Danielle Fleming and Samantha Williams for their research assistance during the initial stages of the book.

Darren would like to thank all the staff at Bond University. While acknowledgements cannot be exhaustive, in particular, I would like to thank Professor Gerard Carney, for having provided me with my first start in Australia. I am also grateful to Professor Patrick Keyzer for his continuing support and for having helped my integration in the Australian legal context. This book strongly benefitted from discussions with my fellow teacher of administrative law, Narelle Bedford, whose knowledge and affection for the subject has been a wonderful resource. Thanks to Linsday Stevenson Graf for providing me with a forum, in her clinical legal placement subject, for the discussion of access to justice themes. Thanks Professor Laurence Boulle, Professor John Farrar and other members of our faculty book club, for our discussions on Lord Bingham’s The Rule of Law. I am grateful also to the editors and members of the Human Rights in Ireland website for providing a testing ground for critical themes on the Irish administrative state, and for their patience with my infrequent blogging over the course of writing this book. I would also like to pay tribute to the staff of the law faculty, University College Cork. It is impossible to single out each individual, as every member of staff seems to have provided me with support or inspiration over my four years on staff there and beyond. Thanks as always, to Professor Siobhan Mullally, who, as my PhD supervisor, laid the foundations of my academic career. Thanks also to all my fellow graduates of the PhD programme at UCC, which has produced so many new scholars over the past decade. To my parents, Alfred and Nuala, and my siblings Adrian, Ronan and Eimear. To Iresha, thank you for your love and patience throughout this process. And finally, to my new

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

x


daughter Aoibheann, in the hope you will grow up with a passion for improving Irish society.

Fiona would like to thank her colleagues at University College Cork. Specific mention should go to Professor Maeve McDonagh for generously sharing her thoughts on Freedom of Information, particularly the 2014 Act and Dr Maria Cahill for invaluable discussions around Parliamentary oversight under the Irish Constitution. Thanks should also be extended to those who tutored Administrative Law in UCC over the past years and shared discussions around both administrative law concepts and the challenges of teaching the subject. Generally I would like to express my appreciation for friends and family for all their support and encouragement. Particular thanks are extended to my parents, Ted and Cathy, who have always encouraged my intellectual and personal efforts, no matter what direction they have taken; and my sister Mary for her ever present voice of reason and support. Finally, and most significantly, I would like to thank Niall, Aoife and Oisín for sharing your home life with this book — your patience, energy and love has supported me through this project.

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

Contents

Preface ..................................................................................................................viiAcknowledgements ............................................................................................... ix

Table of Cases .....................................................................................................xvii

Table of Legislation ..............................................................................................xli

1. Administrative Law: Values and Tensions ................................................1

Introduction ..............................................................................................................3Administrative Law as a Branch of Law ..............................................................3Traditional or Red Light Values ..........................................................................10Imbalances and Tensions in the Red Light Understanding of

Administrative Law ........................................................................................15Administrative Law Viewed From Below: Green Light Values ....................21Law and Regulation ...............................................................................................25Imbalances and Tensions in the Green Light Understanding ......................29The Era of Rights: Building a Culture of Justification.....................................31Criticisms of the Culture of Justification...........................................................40Conclusion ...............................................................................................................47

2. Parliamentary Oversight of Public Administration ..............................49

Introduction ............................................................................................................51Mapping Parliamentary Oversight in Ireland ..................................................53The Constitutional Ideal of Dáil Éireann as an

Accountability Mechanism ...........................................................................57Collective Ministerial Responsibility..................................................................59Individual Ministerial Responsibility .................................................................60Individual Responsibility in Operation ..............................................................68The Comptroller and Auditor General and the Public

Accounts Committee .....................................................................................81Oireachtas Committees ........................................................................................82Conclusion ............................................................................................................ 104

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

xii


3. Freedom of Information and its Role as an Accountability Mechanism .............................................................................................. 107

Introduction ......................................................................................................... 109Governance Justifications for FOI ................................................................... 112Is there a Right to Freedom of Information? ................................................. 117International and Regional Freedom of Information Standards ............... 119A Brief History of Freedom of Information ................................................... 125The Development of Freedom of Information

Legislation in Ireland ................................................................................... 127A Rights of Access to Records .......................................................................... 130Publication of Information on the Operation of Public Bodies ................. 142Right to Reasons .................................................................................................. 144A Right to Amend Personal Information ....................................................... 144The Role of Information Commissioner — Review and

Enforcement .................................................................................................. 144Fees and Their Impact on Freedom of Information .................................... 155Conclusion ............................................................................................................ 160

4. The Ombudsman and Administrative Justice ..................................... 163

Introduction ......................................................................................................... 165The Ombudsman in Ireland: Legislative Underpinnings

and History .................................................................................................... 167Reviewing Maladministration .......................................................................... 170Can the Ombudsman Review Law? ................................................................. 175Bodies Subject to Review ................................................................................... 178The Powers of the Office .................................................................................. 182Ombudsman Investigations and Public Body

Compliance ................................................................................................... 187The Ombudsman, the Constitution and the

Separation of Powers ................................................................................... 200Future Reforms .................................................................................................... 206Conclusion ............................................................................................................ 208

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

Contents

xiii

5. Public Inquiries ...................................................................................... 211

Introduction ......................................................................................................... 213The Public Inquiry As An Accountability Mechanism —

Overarching Purposes ................................................................................. 215Characteristics of Public Inquiries (Tribunals of Inquiry and

Commissions of Investigation) .................................................................. 220The History of the Modern Public Inquiry .................................................... 229Tribunals of Inquiry in Operation ................................................................... 232Commissions of Investigation .......................................................................... 250Conclusion ............................................................................................................ 261

6. Local Government in Ireland ................................................................ 263

Introduction ......................................................................................................... 265Local Government in Ireland: Its Heritage, Status and Fundamentals ...... 267Democracy Versus Administration: The Executive-Elected Council

Relationship ................................................................................................... 275New Municipal and Regional Bodies .............................................................. 280Supervision of Local Government under the 2014 Act ............................... 285Community and Local Development as a Core Policy Area ...................... 290Planning and Development and Local Government .................................... 296Enforcement and Oversight of Development Plans ..................................... 301The Failure of the Irish Planning System: Lessons for Governance ......... 321Conclusion ............................................................................................................ 326

7. Narrow Ultra Vires: Unauthorised Decision-Making ........................ 327

Introduction ......................................................................................................... 329The Need for Legislation: Executive Power as

a Source of Legal Authority ....................................................................... 330Construing the Power: Relevant Principles of Statutory Construction ..... 336Improper Delegation of Decision-Making Powers....................................... 342Elusive Principles: Identifying Jurisdictional Errors..................................... 349Errors of Fact, Mixed Questions of Fact and Law ........................................ 361Conclusion ............................................................................................................ 370

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

xiv


8. Legislative Purpose, Discretion and the Reasoning Process .............. 373

Introduction ......................................................................................................... 375Bad Faith/Improper Purpose ............................................................................ 376Uncertainty ........................................................................................................... 378Taking Irrelevant Considerations into Account/Failure to

Take Relevant Considerations into Account .......................................... 380Identifying Relevant and Irrelevant Considerations .................................... 381Inflexible Application of a Policy/Fettering a Discretion ............................ 387Unwritten Policy and Organisational Cultures ............................................. 392What Does it Mean to Consider? Issues of Weight and Depth ................. 394The Displacement of “Failure to take into Account a Relevant

Consideration” as a Ground of Review .................................................... 405Conclusion ............................................................................................................ 406

9. Unreasonableness, Proportionality and Administrative Decisions ................................................................................................. 407

Introduction ......................................................................................................... 409The Test for Unreasonableness ........................................................................ 410Meadows: Restatement or Evolution? ............................................................. 416Refinement or Revolution? A Survey of Post-Meadows Case-Law ........... 428Conclusion ............................................................................................................ 442

10. Audi Alteram Partem ............................................................................. 445

Introduction ......................................................................................................... 447Flexibility and Specificity: The Interactions of Context

and Content ................................................................................................... 449The Right to Reasons .......................................................................................... 460How Extensive Should Reasons Be? ................................................................ 475The Right to Adequate Notice of a Decision ................................................. 481Decision-Making Steps: How Early is it Before Fair

Hearing Rights Apply? ................................................................................ 484The Obligation to Hear the Other Side .......................................................... 492Conclusion: The Values and Goals of Procedural Justice ........................... 504

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

Contents

xv

11. Bias and Decision-Making ..................................................................... 507

Introduction ......................................................................................................... 509Material Interest .................................................................................................. 510Personal Attitudes, Family and Social Relationships ................................... 512Prior Involvement and Pre-Judgment ............................................................. 516The Test for Bias: Reasonable Apprehension in the Eyes of

the Reasonable Observer ............................................................................ 522Defences ................................................................................................................ 525Reflecting on the Institutional Elements of Bias Analysis .......................... 528Conclusion: The Principle Against Bias and

Institutional Design ..................................................................................... 534

12. Legitimate Expectation .......................................................................... 537

Introduction ......................................................................................................... 539Legitimate Expectation: Prerequisites for its Invocation ............................ 541Substantive Legitimate Expectations and the Statutory/

Non-Statutory Discretion Distinction ..................................................... 545Conclusion ............................................................................................................ 551

13. Judicial Review: Procedures and Remedies ......................................... 553

Introduction ......................................................................................................... 555Applying for Judicial Review ............................................................................. 557Application for Leave ......................................................................................... 563Time Limits .......................................................................................................... 572Availability of Alternative Remedies ............................................................... 579Remedies ............................................................................................................... 585Conclusion ............................................................................................................ 593

14. The Impact of European Union Law on Irish Judicial Review ........... 599

Introduction ......................................................................................................... 601Reviewing Actions in Contravention of the EU Treaties

or Legislation................................................................................................. 602General Principles of EU Law ........................................................................... 607

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

xvi


Proportionality Under EU Law ........................................................................ 615EU Law Remedies and Judicial Review ........................................................... 619The Charter of Fundamental Rights ............................................................... 624

15. The European Convention on Human Rights and Government Decision-Making .............................................................. 639

Introduction ......................................................................................................... 641How Does the ECHR Enter the Irish Legal System? .................................... 643The Interpretive Obligation .............................................................................. 645Performative Obligation (Section 3) ............................................................... 648Judicial Notice of ECHR Case-Law (Section 4) ............................................. 652Declarations of Incompatibility (Section 5) ................................................... 653Administrative Law and the European Convention on

Human Rights ............................................................................................... 654The Standard of Review in Domestic ECHR Actions .................................. 686Conclusion ............................................................................................................ 695

16. Into the Future: Reforming Irish Administrative Law ....................... 697

Introduction ........................................................................................................ 699Alleviating the Rigidity of the Separation of Powers Through

Institutional Innovations and the Recalibration of Judicial Review Principles ......................................................................................... 701

Reinvigorating Parliament as an Accountability Mechanism .................... 702The Need for a Renewed Focus Upon First Instance

Justice in Ireland ........................................................................................... 702Into the Future ..................................................................................................... 704

Index ...................................................................................................................... 705

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

xvii

Table of Cases

A, B, C v Ireland (2011) 53 EHRR 13 ....................................15-06, 15-26, 15-62, 15-82, 15-86

AIB v Collins [2011] MR 4 - 2010 1035 S (1) ..................................15-52n, 15-53Abrahamson v Law Society of Ireland [1996] 1 IR 403 ..................... 12-03, 12-10,

12-15, 12-20Abuissa v Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform

[2011] 1 IR 123 ......................................................................................... 10-31nACF Chemiefarma v Commission of the European Communities

(Case 41/69) [1970] ECR 661 ................................................................. 14-17nAdams v DPP [2001] 2 ILRM 401 ..................................................13-21n, 13-24Aer Rianta v Commissioner for Aviation Regulation

[2003] IEHC 707 ............................................................ 7-70, 7-72, 9-11, 9-55nAfolabi v Minister for Justice and Equality & Ors, unreported,

High Court, 17 May 2012 .................................................................. 7-34, 9-62Agbonlahor v Minister for Justice [2006] IEHC 56, [2007] 4 IR 309. ........ 15-19nAGOSI v United Kingdom App No 9118/80, [1986] ECHR 13 .............. 15-60nAirey v Ireland [1979] 2 EHRR 305 .............................................................. 15-55Akerman-Livingstone v Aster Communities Ltd (formerly Flourish

Homes Ltd) [2014] EWCA Civ 1081 (30 July 2014) .............................. 15-100Aklagaren v Fransson (Case C-617/10) [2013] 2 CMLR 46. ......................14-50,

14-52, 14-55Albert and Le Compte v Belgium (1991) 13 EHRR 415 ................................ 15-33Ali v Birmingham City Council [2010] 2 AC 39........................................... 15-31Ali v Minister for Justice, Equality & Law Reform [2011] IEHC 115 ............ 8-09Alli (a minor) v Minister for Justice [2009] IEHC 595 ................................... 9-44Amann v Switzerland [2000] ECHR 88 ....................................................... 15-90American Cyanamid Company v Ethicon Ltd. [1975] 1 All ER 504 .......... 13-86nAmministrazione delle Finanze v San Giogio [1983] ECR 3595 .................. 14-64AMSJ (Somalia) [No 2] v Minister for Justice, Equality and Defence &

Ors [2012] IEHC 453 ................................................................................... 8-24AMT v Refugee Appeals Tribunal [2004] 2 IR 607 ......................................... 7-72Anisminic v Foreign Compensation Tribunal [1969] 2 AC 147 ........... 7-45, 7-57,

7-58, 7-60, 7-61, 7-63Antonio Munoz y Cia SA and Superior Fruiticola SA v Frumar Ltd

(Case C-253/00) [2002] ECR I-7289 ........................................................ 14-46

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

xviii


AO v Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform [2010] IEHC 89 .......... 8-44 AO & DL v Minister for Justice [2003] 1 IR 1 ..............................9-34, 9-48, 9-51AP v Director of Public Prosecutions [2011] 1 IR 729 ................................ 13-26nArklow Homes Ltd v An Bord Pleanála [2011] IESC 29 ............................... 13-49Associated Provincial Picture Houses Ltd v Wednesbury Corporation

[1948] 1 KB 223 ....................... 1-41, 8-47, 9-04, 9-07, 9-08, 9-20, 15-93, 15-96Atlantean Ltd v Minister for Communications & Natural Resources

[2007] IEHC 233 ........................................................................................ 10-67Atlantic Marine Supplies Ltd v Minister for Transport

[2010] IEHC 104 ............................................................................. 12-14, 12-20Attorney General (McGarry) v Sligo County Council [1991] 1 IR 99 ........ 6-57nAttorney General v Great Eastern Railway Company

(1880) 5 App Cas 473 .................................................................................. 7-14Attorney General v Hamilton (No 1) [1993] 2 IR 250 ........................... 3-44, 3-73Arcelor Atlantique and Lorraine and Others (Case C-127/07)

[2008] ECR I-9895 ....................... ............................................................ 14-15nArdagh v McGuire [2002] IR 385 ..................................... 2-49n, 2-86, 2-88, 2-89,

2-90, 2-91, 2-95, 2-97, 2-98, 2-105, 2-113Ashbourne Holdings Ltd v An Bord Pleanála [2003] 2 IR 114 .....6-92, 8-08, 9-16Ashford Castle Ltd v SIPTU [2007] 4 IR 70 .................................................... 7-77Asibor (a minor) v Minister for Justice & Ors [2009] IEHC 594 ................... 9-44Assenov v Bulgaria 28 October 1998, (1999) 28 EHRR 652 ...................... 5-16nAssurances du crédit v Council and Commission (Case C-63/89)

[1991] ECR I-1799 .................................................................................... 14-15nAW v The Office of the Refugee Applications Commissioner

[2013] IEHC 71 ........................................................................................ 10-96n

B and L v The United Kingdom (2006) 42 EHRR 11 .................................. 15-22nB v Minister for Social Protection [2014] IEHC 186 ...................................... 8-34Babington v Minister for Justice [2012] IESC 65 ........................................ 13-28nBaker v Canada (Minister of Citizenship & Immigration)

[1999] 2 SCR 817 .......................................................................................... 1-10Balaz v His Honour Judge Kennedy & Anor [2009] IEHC 110 .................... 11-38Bane v Garda Representative Association [1997] 2 IR 449 ......................... 13-51nBannon v EAT [1993] 1 IR 500 ..................................................................... 7-55nBarry v Sentence Review Group [2001] 4 IR 167 ...................................... 10-102nBegum v Tower Hamlets LBC [2003] 2 AC 430 .............................15-28, 15-30n,

15-31, 15-35

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

Table of Cases

xix

Beirne v Commissioner of An Garda Siochana [1993] ILRM 1 ..................... 10-11Belilos v Switzerland [1988] ECHR 4 ........................................................... 15-46Bjedov v Croatia, Application No 42150/09, 29 May 2012 ........... 15-71, 15-72,

15-73, 15-74Bloxham v Irish Stock Exchange plc [2013] IEHC 301 ................................. 10-14Board of Education v Rice 1911 AC 179 ........................................................ 10-07Bode v Minister for Justice & Law Reform [2008] 3 IR 663 ............................7-08,

7-11n, 15-19Boland v An Taoiseach [1974] IR 338 ............................................................ 7-08nBorges v Fitness to Practice Committee [2004] 1 IR 103 ................ 10-110, 10-111Bowes v Director of Public Prosecutions & McGrath v Director of

Public Prosecutions [2003] 2 IR 25 .......................................................... 13-77nBoyhan v Beef Tribunal [1993] 1 IR 210 ...............................................5-51n, 5-59Braddish v Director of Public Prosecutions [2001] 3 IR 127 ......................... 10-66Brady v Donegal County Council [1989] ILRM 282 .................................... 13-42Brady v Haughton [2006] IR 1 ..................................................................... 10-26nBrasserie du Pecheur SA v Germany and R v Secretary of State

for Transport, ex parte Factortame (Cases C-46 and 48/93) [1996] ECR I-1029 ..................................................................................... 14-43

Brennan v Attorney General [1984] ILRM 355 ............................................ 6-41nBrennan v Donnellan & Ors [2003] IEHC 58 .............................................. 7-26nBS Levez v TH Jennings (Harlow Pools) Ltd (Case C-326/96)

[1998] ECR I-7835 .................................................................................... 14-39nBuckland v United Kingdom (2013) 56 EHRR 16 .................15-71, 15-73, 15-74Bugdacay v Secretary of State for the Home Department

[1987] 1 AC 514 ......................................................................................... 9-24nBula Ltd v Tara Mines Ltd (No 6) [2000] 4 IR 412 .......... 5-53n, 11-14, 11-28, 11-30Bupa Ireland v Health Insurance Authority (No 2) [2009] 1 ILRM 81 .......... 7-16Burns & Hartigan v Governor of Castlerea Prison [2009] 3 IR 682 ........... 10-103Burns v Australian National University (1982) 40 ALR 707 ...................... 1-05nButcher v The Minister for Justice and Equality [2012] IEHC 347 ....... 8-39, 8-40Byrne v Ireland [1972] IR 241.......................................................................... 7-05

Cahill v Sutton [1980] IR 269 ............................................................. 13-09, 13-11Callely v Moylan & Ors [2011] IEHC 2 ...................................................... 2-101nCampus Oil v The Minister for Energy [1983] 1 IR 88 ....................13-30, 13-86nCape Brandy Syndicate v Commissioners of Inland Revenue

[1921] 1 KB 64 .............................................................................................. 7-18

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

xx


Carltona Ltd v Commissioner of Works [1943] 2 All ER 560 .............2-23n, 2-38, 2-39, 2-40, 7-29, 7-30, 7-31, 7-32, 7-35, 7-36

Carmody v Minister for Justice [2010] 1 IR 635 ................................. 14-65, 15-03Carr v Financial Services Ombudsman [2013] IEHC 182 ............................ 10-98Carrigaline Community Television Broadcasting Company Ltd v

Minister for Transport, Energy and Communications [1997] 1 ILRM 241 ..................................................................................... 8-27n

Cassidy v Minister for Industry and Commerce [1978] IR 297 ........... 8-07, 10-25CC v Ireland (No 1) [2006] 4 IR 1 ................................................................. 13-45CE v Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform, [2012] IEHC 3 ............ 7-63Chaulk v R [1990] 3 SCR 1303 ........................................................................ 9-30City of Yonkers v United States 320 US 685 [1944] ..................................... 7-44nCityview Press Ltd v An Comhairle Oiliúna [1980] IR 381.......................... 4-24nClaude Reyes v Chile Inter-Am Ct Hum Rts (ser C) No 151

(19 Sep 2006) .............................................................................................. 3-26nClinton v An Bord Pleanála (No.2) [2007] 4 IR 701 .............................. 9-55, 9-57Clune v Director of Public Prosecutions [1981] ILRM 17 .......................... 13-77nCommission v French Republic (Case 167/173)

[1974] ECR 359 ........................................................................................ 14-38nCommission v France (Case C-197/96) [1997] ECR I-1489 ........................ 14-17Commission v Ireland (Case C-45/89) [1988] ECR 4929 .......................... 14-16nCommission v Ireland (Case C-418/04) [2007] ECR I-10947 ..... 14-22n, 14-23nCommission v Ireland (Case C-215/06) [2008] ECR I-4911 ..................... 6-101nCommission v Ireland (Case C-66/06) [2008] ECR I-158 ......................... 6-101nCommission v Ireland (C-456/08) [2010] ECR I-859 340 .......................... 13-46Commission v Ireland (Case C-50/09) [2011] ECR I-873 ......................... 6-101nCondon v Minister for Labour [1981] IR 62 ................................................ 13-82nConnors v UK (2004) 40 EHRR 189 ............................................................. 15-41Construction Industry Federation v Dublin City Council

[2005] 2 IR 496 ..............................................................................13-14, 14-64nCork County Council v Shackleton [2007] IEHC 241 ............................ 7-64, 7-65Cork Opera House Plc v The Revenue Commissioners

[2007] IEHC 388 ...................................................................................... 12-18nCorporation of the City of Enfield v Development Assessment Commission

(2000) 199 CLR 135 ................................................................................... 1-13nCouncil of Civil Service Unions v Minister for the Civil Service

[1985] AC 374 .............................................................................................. 9-07Council v Bamba (Case C-417/11) [2013] 1 CMLR 53 ............................ 10-39n

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

Table of Cases

xxi

Creedon v Dublin Corporation [1984] IR 428 ............................................. 13-82nCrilly v Farrington [2001] 3 IR 251 .............................................................. 7-13nCrofton v Minister for the Environment, Heritage and

Local Government [2009] IEHC 114 ............................................................ 8-33Cromane Seafoods Limited and O’Sullivan McCarthy Mussel

Development Ltd v The Minister for Agriculture, Fisheries and Food [2013] IEHC 338 ...........................................................................14-22, 14-24n

Crompton v United Kingdom (2010) 50 EHRR 36 ..........................15-39, 15-40nCullen v Wicklow County Council [2011] 1 IR 152 ........................................ 6-22Curran v Minister for Education and Science [2009] IR 300 ............. 12-06, 12-10

Daniele Annibaldi v Sindaco del Comune di Guidonia & Presidente Regione Lazio (Case C-309/96) [1997] ECR I-7493 .............................. 14-53n

Dauti v Albania Application No 19206/05, 3 February 2009 .................. 15-46Davy v Financial Services Ombudsman [2008] IEHC 256 ..............10-82n, 10-97DEB Deutsche Energiehandels v Bundesrepublik Deutschland

(Case C-279/09) [2010] ECR I-13849 ...................................................... 14-65De Roiste v Minister for Defence [2001] 1 IR 190 ....................................... 13-50nDeely v The Information Commissioner [2001] 3 IR 439 .....................3-68n, 3-96Deerland Construction v Aquatic Licensing Appeals Board

[2009] 1 IR 673 ................................................................................ 10-56, 10-59Delaney v Central Bank of Ireland [2011] IEHC 212 .................................... 10-68Delaney v Judge John Coughlan & Others [2012] IESC 40 ............................ 7-24Dellway Investments Ltd v National Asset Management Agency

[2011] 4 IR 1 ...................................................... 1-27, 8-17, 10-19, 10-24, 10-70Dekra Éireann Teo v Minister for the Environment [2003] 2 IR 270 ........ 13-47nDevanney v District Judge Shields & Ors [1998] 1 ILRM 81 .....2-39, 2-40, 7-29,

7-30, 7-33 Denny v Minister for Social Welfare [1998] IR 34 ................................ 9-11, 9-13Deutsche Milchkontor v Germany (Joined Cases 205- 215182)

[1983] ECR 2633 ........................................................................................ 14-21Diaz-Marroquin v Immigration and Naturalisation Service

(2001) US App Lexis 2352 ........................................................................ 10-59Digital Rights Ireland and Seitlinger and Others (Joined cases C-293/12

and C-594/12), 8 April 2014 ............ ..................................................... 14-58nDigital Rights Ireland Ltd v Minister for Communications & Ors

[2010] IECH 221 ............................................................. 13-17n, 14-02n, 14-58Digital Rights Ireland Ltd v Minister for Communications Marine & Natural

Resources [2010] 3 IR 251 .......................................................................... 14-64

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

xxii


Dimbo v Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform [2008] 2 ILRM 481 ..................................................................................... 10-63

Director of Public Prosecution v Doyle [1994] 2 IR 286 ............................... 10-65DK v Crowley [2002] IR 744.......................................................................... 10-23Doherty v Birmingham [2009] 1 AC 367 ........................................... 15-95, 15-96Dombo Beheer v The Netherlands (1994) 18 EHRR 213 .................... 15-50, 15-51Donegan v Dublin City Council [2012] IESC 18. ..................15-25, 15-41, 15-63,

15-64, 15-65, 15-70Doupe v Limerick County Council [1981] ILRM 456 ................................... 10-93Doyle v Croke, unreported, High Court, 6 May 1988 ............................... 11-05DPP v Cormack [1999] 1 ILRM 398 ............................................................... 7-23DPP v Moorehouse [2006] 1 IR 421 ................................................................ 7-20DPP v O’Donnell [1995] 2 IR 294............................................................... 11-38nDPP v Tivoli Cinema Ltd [1999] 2 IR 260 ...................................................... 7-20Dublin and County Broadcasting Ltd v Independent Radio and

Television Commission, unreported, High Court, 12 May 1989 .................................................. 11-06, 11-07, 11-11, 11-23, 11-32

Dublin City Council v Fennell [2005] IESC 33 ........................................... 15-63nDublin City Council v Gallagher [2008] IEHC 354 ........................... 15-09, 15-64Dublin Corporation v Hamilton [1999] 2 IR 486 ........................................ 15-63nDublin Corporation v McGowan [1993] 1 IR 405 ......................................... 6-90nDublin Wellwoman Centre Ltd & Ors v Ireland & Ors.

[1995] 1 ILRM 408 ...............................................................11-02, 11-03, 11-12Duff v Minister for Agriculture and Food, Ireland (Case C-63/93)

[1996] ECR I-569 ........................................................................................ 14-18Duff v Minister for Agriculture (No 2) [1997] 2 IR 22 ...................... 14-19, 14-25Duggan v An Taoiseach [1989] ILRM 710 .................................................. 13-09nDundalk Town Council v Lawlor [2005] IEHC 73 ...... ......................... 6-80, 6-82Dunne v Donohoe [2002] IESC 35 ................................................................... 7-27Dunnes Stores v Director of Consumer Affairs [2006] 1 IR 355 ................... 7-20nDunnes Stores v Holtglen Ltd [2012] IEHC 93 .............................................. 7-55Dunnes Stores Ireland Company v Maloney [1999] 3 IR 542 ..........10-26n, 10-57Dunraven Estates Ltd v Commissioners of Public Works [1974] IR 113 ...... 7-17nDVTS v Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform [2008] 3 IR 476 ...... 8-22

E v Home Secretary [2004] QB 1044 ...................................................... 7-80, 7-82East Donegal Co-operative Livestock Marts Ltd v Attorney General

[1970] IR 317 ................................................................ 8-14, 8-16, 8-21, 10-17nEbner v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy (2001) 176 ALR 644 ...................... 11-07

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

Table of Cases

xxiii

Edilizia Industriale Sidergurgica Srl (Edis) v Ministero delle Finanze (Case C-231/96) [1998] ECR I-4951 ................................................................. 14-39n

Efe v Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform [2011] 2 IR 798 ............9-52, 9-54n, 9-55n, 9-56n, 9-57n, 15-101

El Corte Ingles SA v Rivero (Case C-192/94) [1996] ECR I-1281.............. 14-08Eogan v University College Dublin [1996] IR 390 ...................................... 10-10nEMI v Data Protection Commissioner [2013] IESC 34 ........ 10-48, 10-51n, 13-61Ezenwaka v Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform,

[2011] IEHC 328 ........................................................................................ 8-30n

FA v Refugee Appeals Tribunal, unreported, High Court, 27 July 2007 .... 13-53Fajujonu v Minister for Justice [1992] IR 151 ............................................... 9-47nFakih v Minister for Justice 1993 2 IR 406 .................................................. 12-10nFaulkner v Minister for Industry and Commerce

[1997] ELR 107 ........................................................................................... 10-55Feldbrugge v The Netherlands [1986] 8 EHRR 425 ...................................... 15-31Findlay v United Kingdom (1997) 24 EHRR 221 ......................................... 15-47Flanagan v Galway County Council [1990] 2 IR 66 ....................................... 8-23Flanagan v University College Dublin [1988] IR 724 .............7-28, 10-66, 10-107Flood v Lawlor, unreported, Supreme Court,

24 November 2000 ........................................................................ 5-27n, 5-50nFlynn Machine & Crane Hire Ltd v Wicklow County Council

[2009] IEHC 285 .......................................................................................... 6-80Fogarty v Judge O’Donnell [2008] IEHC 198 ............................................... 11-26Foley v Judge Murphy [2005] 3 IR 574............................................................ 7-50Foster & Ors v British Gas (Case C-188/89) [1990] ECR I-3313 ............... 14-08Foy v An t-Ard Chlaraitheoir [2012] 2 IR 1 ............................15-10, 15-11, 15-25FP v Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform [2002] 1 IR 164 .......... 10-58Francovich & Ors v Italy (Cases C-6 and 9/90) [1991] ECR I-5357 ......... 14-42

G v Director of Public Prosecutions [1994] 1 IR 374 ..............13-18, 13-23, 13-31Gallagher v Corrigan, unreported, High Court, 1 February 1988............ 10-64Galvin v Chief Appeals Officer [1997] 3 IR 240 .......................................... 10-97nGarvey v Ireland [1979] IR 266.................................................................... 13-78nGaskin v UK [1989] 12 EHRR 36 .................................................................. 3-26nGenmark Pharma v Minister for Health [1998] 3 IR 111 ................................ 7-28Geoghegan v Institute of Chartered Accountants [1995] 3 IR 86 ........ 7-05, 10-13,

10-14, 10-15Georgopoulous v Beaumont Hospital Board [1998] 3 IR 132 ........................ 10-83

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

xxiv


Gerardo Ruiz Zambrano v Office national de l’emploi (Case C-26089) ERT [1991] ECR I-2925 ................................................ 14-51n

Germany v Parliament and Council (Case C-233/94) [1997] ECR I-2405 .................................................................................... 14-15n

Glencar Explorations plc v Mayo County Council (No 2) [2002] 1 IR 84 ................ 8-27, 12-04, 12-06, 12-07, 12-08, 12-09, 12-12, 13-89

Glenkirren Homes v Dun Laoghaire Rathdown County Council [2007] IEHC 298 ........................................................................................ 12-19

Glenkirren Homes v The Revenue Commissioners [2007] ITR 119 ................ 7-18Goodman International v Hamilton (No1) [1991] 2 IR 542 ..... 5-07n, 5-23, 5-43nGoodwin v United Kingdom [2002] 35 EHRR 447 ....................................... 15-10Greenstar Ltd v Dublin City Council & Ors [2009] IEHC 589......... 11-41, 11-49Griffin v Galway County Manager, unreported, High Court,

31st October 1990.... .................................................................................... 8-23Guerra v Italy (1988) 26 EHRR 357 ................................................................ 3-27

Hamblin v Duffy (No 1) (1981) 34 ALR 333 ................................................ 1-05nHaralambie v Romania [2009] ECHR 21737/03 ............................................ 3-29Harding v Cork County Council [2008] 4 IR 318 ......................................... 6-95nHarris v Quigley [2006] 1 IR 165 .................................................................. 7-18nHarrow v Qazi [2004] 1 AC 983 ................................................................... 15-94Health Service Executive v Commissioner of Valuation [2010] 4 IR 23 ......... 1-07Health Service Executive v OA [2013] IEHC 172 ....................................... 10-108Health Service Executive v SC and another (Case C-92/12 PPU)

[2012] 2 FLR 1040 ............ ....................................................................... 14-57nHeaney v Ireland [1994] 3 IR 593 ............................................. 1-63n, 9-31, 9-39nHegarty v Governor of Limerick Prison [1998] 1 IR 412 ............................... 2-45nHempenstall v Minister for Environment [1994] 2 IR 20 ............................. 12-19Henderson v Henderson (1843) 3 Hare ......................................................... 13-49Heneghan v Western Regional Fisheries Board [1986] ILRM 225 ................ 11-08Herbert Karner Industrie Auktionen GmbH v Troostwijk GmnH

[2004] ECR I-3025. ..................................................................................... 14-13Hirst v UK (No 2) (2006) 42 EHRR 849 ......................................................... 8-40Hoey v Minister for Justice [1994] 1 ILRM 334 .............................................. 8-06Holland v Governor of Portlaoise Prison [2004] 2 IR 573 ............................... 9-55Hounslow v Powell; Leeds v Hall; Birmingham v Frisby

[2011] UKSC 8. .......................................................................................... 15-97Howard v Commissioner for Public Works [1994] 1 IR101 ............................ 7-06HR v Refugee Appeals Tribunal [2011] IEHC 151 ........................................ 7-73

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

Table of Cases

xxv

Huang v Secretary of State for the Home Department; Kashmiri v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2007] UKHL 11, [2007] All ER (D) 338 (Mar) ..................................................................... 15-97

Hussain v Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform [2011] IEHC 171 ........................................................................ 10-31n, 10-34n

Hyde v Financial Services Ombudsman [2011] IEHC 422 ........................... 10-97

IATA and ELFAA (Case C-344/04) [2006] ECR I-403 ........................... 14-15nISOF v Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform (No. 2)

[2010] IEHC 457 ...................................................................................... 15-101Impact v Minister for Agriculture and Food and Others

(Case C-268/06) [2008] ECR I-2483. ....................................................... 14-41Inter Envirounmenient Wallonie ASBL v Region Wallonie

(Case C-129/9) [1997] ECR I-7411 .......................................................... 14-07Interfaith Community Org v Honeywell Intl inc 399 F3d 248

United State Court of Appeals, Third Circuit ........................................ 7-76International Fishing Vessels Ltd v Minister for the Marine

[1989] IR 149 ................................................................................... 10-29, 10-57International Fishing Vessels Ltd v Minister for the Marine

[1991] 2 IR 93 ............................................................................................. 10-69Internationale Handelsgesellschaft Gmb v EInfuhr- und Vorratsstelle fur

Getreide and Futtermittel (Case 11/70) [1970] ECR 1125 .................... 14-27nInternational Transport Roth v Secretary of State for the Home

Department [2002] EWCA Civ 158; [2003] QB 728 .................................. 1-57IR v Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform [2009] IEHC 3 ............ 10-59

J & E Davy v Financial Services Ombudsman & anor [2010] IESC 30 .......... 4-44JA v Refugee Applications Commissioner [2009] 2 IR 231 ........................... 13-53Jiad v Minister for Justice [2010] IR 187 ..................................................... 10-31nJJ Rhatigan & Company Ltd v Paragon Contracting Ltd & Anor

[2009] IEHC 117 ........................................................................................ 11-20Johnson v Johnson (2000) 174 ALR 655 ........................................................ 11-33Jones (by Caldwell) v First-tier Tribunal [2013] UKSC 19 ............................. 7-77Jordan v UK (2001) 31 EHRR 6 ...................................................................... 5-16Julian Hernandez v Spain (C-198/13) [2014] All ER (EC) 971

(ECJ (5th Chamber)) ............................................................................... 14-52n

Kadri v Governor of Wheatfield Prison [2012] IESC 27 .................................. 7-21Kay v Lambeth [2006] 2 AC 465 .................................................................... 15-95

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

xxvi


Kay v The United Kingdom, App No 37341/06, September 21, 2010, European Court of Human Rights (Fourth Section), [2012] 54 EHRR 30 .................................................................................... 15-96

Keane v An Bord Pleanala [1997] IR 184 ........................................................ 7-14Keane v An Bord Pleanála [2012] IEHC 324 ................................................ 14-35Keegan v District Judge Kilrane [2011] IEHC 516 ....................................... 11-16Kelly v An Bord Pleanála [2014] IEHC 400 .................................................... 1-53Kelly v Leitrim County Council [2005] 2 IR 404 .......................................... 13-53Kennedy v Law Society [2005] IESC 23 ........................................................ 13-30Kennedy v Law Society of Ireland (No 3) [2002] 2 IR 458 .............................. 8-07Kelly v National University of Ireland (UCD) [2012] IEHC 169 ................. 11-18Kelly v Visitors of Trinity College Dublin [2007] IESC 61 ..............11-30n, 11-39Kennedy v The Charity Commission [2014] UKSC 20 ....................9-20, 15-100nKenny v An Bord Pleanála (No 1) [2001] 1 IR 565 ........................... 8-54n, 8-54nKenny v An Bord Pleanála (No 2) [2001] 1 IR 407 ....................................... 8-46nKenny v Trinity College Dublin [2008] 2 IR 40 ......................11-10, 11-14, 11-32Keogh v Criminal Assets Bureau [2004] 2 IR 159 ................................ 7-19, 10-66Keogh v Galway Corporation [1995] 3 IR 457 ............................................... 6-57nKhan v Health Service Executive [2008] IEHC 234 .................................... 10-18nKiely v Minister for Social Welfare (No 2) [1977] IR 267 .................5-53n, 10-84,

10-109, 10-111Kildare County Council v An Bord Pleanála [2006] IEHC 173............. 8-46, 8-54Killeen v DPP [1998] 1 ILRM 1 ............................................................. 7-51, 7-52Kikumbi v The Office of the Refugee Applications Commissioner et al

[2007] IEHC 11 .......................................................................................... 10-57Kirwan v Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform

[1994] 2 IR 417 ....................................................................................... 10-108nKlohn v An Bord Pleanála [2009] 1 IR 59 ..................................................... 14-34Kobler v Austria (Case C-224/01) [2003] ECR I-10239 .............................. 14-44Konstantinious Adeneler et al v Ellinikos Organismos Galaktos (ELOG)

(Case C-212/04) [2006] ECR 1-6057 ..................................................... 14-07nKremzow v Austria (Case C-299/95) [1997] ECR I-2405 ......................... 14-53nKrombach v Bamberski (Case C-7/98) [2000] ECR I-1935 ....................... 14-66nKruslin v France (1990) 12 EHRR 547 ......................................................... 15-89

L v Refugee Appeals Tribunal [2010] IEHC 362 ............................................. 7-55L v Minister for Justice and Equality [2012] IEHC 189 ............................... 7-30nLGH v Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform,

unreported, 31 January 2009 ................................................... 10-31n, 10-35n

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

Table of Cases

xxvii

Lab Tests Auckland Ltd v Auckland District Health Board [2009] 1 NZLR 776 .................................................................................... 1-31n

Lancefort Ltd v An Bord Pleanála [1999] 2 IR 270 ............................ 13-12, 13-19LAT v Minister for Justice [2011] IEHC 404 .................................................. 7-32Lattimore v Dublin City Council [2014] IEHC 233 .......................... 15-76, 15-77,

15-79, 15-80Law Society of Ireland v Competition Authority [2006] 2 IR 262 ............. 10-108nLawlor v Flood [1999] 3 IR 107 ............................................................... 5-47, 5-54Lawlor v Members of the Tribunal of Inquiry into certain planning

matters and payments [2009] IESC 50 ................................................ 5-63, 5-64Leander v Sweden [1987] 9 EHRR 433 ......................................................... 3-27nLeonard v District Judge John Garavan, unreported, High Court,

30 April 2002................................................................................................ 7-62Leonard v Dublin City Council [2008] IEHC 288 ...................................... 15-63nLett & Co Ltd v Wexford Borough Council [2012] 2 IR 198 .........................12-03,

12-11n, 12-20Leyla Sahin v Turkey (2007) 44 EHRR 5 ...................................................... 15-84Li v Department of Immigration and Citizenship [2013] HCA 18 ............... 9-68nLindqvist (Approximation of laws) (Case C-101/01)

[2003] ECR I-12971 .................................................................................. 14-57nLivesey v New South Wales Bar Association (1983) 151 CLR 288............. 11-30nLocabail Ltd v Bayfield Properties Ltd [2000] QB 451 ............11-10, 11-15, 11-33Lofinmakin v Minister for Justice and Law Reform

[2011] IEHC 38 .......................................................................................... 13-26Louise O’Keefe v Ireland, Application No 35810/09,

Grand Chamber judgment of 28 January 2014 ..................................... 15-06Lumba v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2012] 1 AC 245 ........ 7-58Lyons v Financial Services Ombudsman [2011] IEHC 454 ............................ 4-44

M & J Gleeson Ltd v Competition Authority [1999] 1 ILRM 401 ................ 9-57nME v Refugee Applications Commissioner (Case C-493/10)

[2012] 2 CMLR 9 ........................................................................................ 14-57MacFarlane v DPP [2008] 4 IR 117 .............................................................. 15-19Magee v Farrell, unreported, High Court, 26 October 2005 ................ 10-108nMagee v Murray & Anor [2008] IEHC 371 .................................................... 7-14Magee v Murray & anor, McVeigh v Minister for Justice Equality and

Law, McCarron v Kearney [2011] 1 ILRM 237 .......................................... 7-14Maguire v Ardagh [2002] 1 IR 385 ......................................5-04n, 5-61n, 10-34n,

10-101n, 11-01, 11-40

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

xxviii


Maguire v South Eastern Health Board [2001] 3 IR 26 .............................. 13-82nMallak v Minister for Justice [2012] 3 IR 297 ..........................1-27, 10-27, 10-30,

10-31, 10-32n, 10-33n, 10-34n, 10-35n, 10-36n, 10-38n, 10-39n, 10-42, 10-43, 10-44,

10-45, 10-46, 10-47, 10-49, 10-51, 10-53, 10-54Malone v UK (1984) 7 EHRR 14 ................................................................... 15-88Manchester City Council v Pinnock [2010] UKSC 45 .................................. 15-97Marks and Spencer plc v Commrs for Customs & Excise

(Case C-62/00) [2002] ECR 1-6325 ........................................................ 14-07Marleasing SA v La Comerical Internacional de Alimentacion SA

[1990] ECR I-4135 ...................................................................................... 14-09Marshall v Arklow Town Council [2004] 4 IR 92 ....................................... 13-53nMarshall v Southampton and South-West HampshireAHA

(Case C-06/89) [1986] ECR 723 (Marshall (No 1)). .................... 14-08, 14-40Matthews v Irish Coursing Club [1993] 1 IR 346 ........................................... 9-17Maurin (Case C-144/95) [1996] ECR I-2909 ............................................ 14-53nMcAlister v Minister for Justice and Law Reform [2003] 4 IR 35 ................ 10-53McB v LE [2010] IESC 123 .......................................................................... 15-12nMcBrearty v Morris [2003] IEHC 154 ............................................................ 5-65McBride v Galway Corporation [1998] 1 IR 458 ........................................... 14-06McCallig v An Bord Pleanála [2013] IEHC 60 .............................8-50, 8-51, 8-54McCann v The Judges of Monaghan District Court and Others

[2009] IEHC 276 ........................................................................................ 15-22McCann v United Kingdom (App no 19009/04), 13 May 2008

(2008) 47 EHRR 40 .......................................................................15-94, 15-97nMcCann v UK (1996) 21 EHRR 97 ....................................................5-16n, 15-94McCarthy v Irish Prison Service [2009] IEHC 331 .................................... 13-51nMcCarthy v Minister for Education and Skills

[2012] IEHC 200 ............................................................................. 12-07, 12-10McCarron v Kearney [2008] IEHC 195, High Court .................................. 8-29nMcD v L and ors [2010] 2 IR 199 ............................................15-03, 15-12, 15-13McDonnell v Ireland [1998] 1 IR 134. ......................................................... 15-19nMcEvoy v Meath County Council [2003] 1 ILRM 431 ................................. 6-11nMcGoldrick v An Bord Pleanála [1997] 1 IR 497 .............................13-56n, 13-66McGrath v Minister for Defence [2010] 1 IR 5670. ...................................... 12-20McGrath v Trustees of Maynooth College [1979] ILRM 166 ........................ 11-25McKernan v Employment Appeals Tribunal, [2008] IEHC 40 .............. 7-64, 7-65McManus v Fitness to Practice Committee [2012] IEHC 350 ...................... 10-83

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

Table of Cases

xxix

McMichael v United Kingdom (1995) 20 EHRR 205 ................................... 15-54McSorley v Minister for Education [2012] IEHC 201 .................................... 9-41McVeigh v Minister for Justice, Equality & Law Reform

[2011] 1 ILRM 237 .............................................................................. 7-14, 8-29 Meadows v Minister of Justice [2010] 2 IR 701 ...................1-27, 1-31, 1-40, 1-42,

1-52, 1-53n, 1-54, 1-63, 7-31, 7-32, 8-11, 8-45, 8-46, 8-48, 8-50, 9-03, 9-12, 9-14, 9-15, 9-19, 9-19n, 9-21, 9-22, 9-28, 9-29,

9-31n, 9-35, 9-37n, 9-38, 9-39, 9-41, 9-42, 9-43, 9-44, 9-45, 9-46, 9-47, 9-48, 9-49n, 9-50, 9-51, 9-51, 9-52, 9-53, 9-55,

9-56, 9-57, 9-60, 9-61, 9-62, 9-63, 9-66, 9-67, 9-68, 9-69, 10-57n, 14-12, 14-34, 14-36, 15-76, 15-81, 15-83,

15-87, 15-91, 15-92, 15-93n, 15-101, 15-102, 15-102, 15-103Melloni v Ministerio Fiscal (Case C-399/11) [2013] QB 1067

(ECJ (Grand Chamber)) ....................................... 14-54, 14-60, 14-61n, 14-62Memishi v The Refugee Appeals Tribunal, unreported,

High Court, 25 June 2003 ......................................................................... 10-59MEO (Nigeria) v Minister for Justice, Equality & Law Reform

[2012] IEHC 394 .......................................................................................... 9-60Michel v European Parliament (Case C- 195/80) [1981] ECR 2861 .......... 10-53Minister for Agriculture and Food v Barry and Others

[2008] IEHC 216 .......................................................................................... 7-78Minister for Justice and Law Reform v McGuiness [2011] IEHC 313 ......... 11-27Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform v Josef Adam

[2011] IEHC 68 .......................................................................................... 14-51Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform v Ostrowski

[2013] IESC 24. ............................................................................................. 9-63Minister of Justice, Equality and Law Reform v Dolny [2009] IESC 48 ......... 7-22Minnock v Casing Co Ltd and Stewart [2007] ELR 229 ............................... 10-76Mishra v The Minister for Justice [1996] 1 IR 189 .............................8-28, 10-31nMiss Behavin’ Ltd v Belfast City Council [2007] UKHL 19;

[2007] 1 WLR 1420 ...................................................................................... 1-49Mistretta v United States 488 US 348 ........................................................... 5-20nMM v Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform (Case C-277/11)

(22 November 2012), judgment not yet reported ................................. 14-66MM v Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform [2013] IEHC 9 ........ 14-67Mobil Oil Australia Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation

[1963] 113 CLR 475 ................................................................................... 10-07

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

xxx


Molloy v Financial Services Ombudsman, unreported, High Court, 15 April, 2011............................................................................................. 10-98

Mooney v An Post [1998] 4 IR 288.............................................................. 10-93nMorris v Garvey [1983] IR 319 ...................................................................... 6-88nMorrison and Anor v AWG Group and Anor [2006] EWCA Civ 6 ........... 11-34Mosley et al v St Louis Sough Western Railway (1981) 634 F.2d 942 ..... 10-101nMoyosola v Refugee Applications Commissioner [2005] IEHC 218 ............. 10-94Mulcreevy v Minister for the Environment [2004] 1 IR 72 .......................... 13-13Murphy v District Justice Wallace [1993] 2 IR 138 .................................... 13-51nMurphy v Dublin Corporation (No. 2) [1972] IR 215 .............................................Murphy v Ireland, The Attorney General and the Director of Public

Prosecutions [2014] IESC 19 .................................... 10-43, 10-44, 10-45, 10-46Murphy v Flood [2010] IESC 21 ...................................... 5-68, 5-69, 5-75n, 13-48Murphy v Wicklow County Council [1999] IEHC 22 ................................ 13-17n

Nash v Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform [2004] 3 IR 296 ..................................................................................8-39n, 8-40

National Maternity Hospital v The Information Commissioner and Parents for Justice [2007] IEHC 113 ............................................................ 3-97

National Asset Management Agency v Commissioner for Environmental Information [2013] IEHC 86 ............................................. 3-52n

National University of Ireland Cork v Ahern [2005] 2 IR 577 ........................ 7-78Nestor v Murphy [1979] IR 326 .................................................................... 7-13nNeurendale Ltd (t/a Panda Waste Services) v Dublin City Council

[2009] IEHC 588 ...............................................................................9-11n, 9-55Ní Éili v The Environmental Protection Agency, unreported,

Supreme Court, 30 July 1999 ................................................... 10-56n, 10-99n NM (Togo) v Lenihan [2013] IEHC 436 ......................................................... 8-59Nold v Commission (Case 4/73) [1974] ECR 491 ..................................... 14-11nNorth Wall Developments v Dublin Docklands Development Authority

[2008] IEHC 305 ............................................................... 11-48, 11-49n, 11-50NS v Secretary of State for the Home Department (Case C-411/10)

[2013] QB 102 ........................................................................................... 14-57nNurendale Ltd t/a Panda Waste v Dublin City Council

[2009] IEHC 588 ...................................................................................... 11-41nNyembo v Refugee Appeals Tribunal [2006] IEHC 388 .............................. 11-50n

O(O) & A(O) v Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform [2011] IEHC 78 ................................................ 9-44, 9-47n, 9-49n, 9-50n, 9-51

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

Table of Cases

xxxi

O’Brien v AON Insurance Managers [2005] IEHC 3 .................................. 10-76O’Brien v Financial Services Ombudsman [2014] IEHC 268 ........................ 4-99O’Brien v Moriarty [2005] IESC 32 .............................................................. 5-30nO’Brien v Personal Injuries Assessment Board

[2009] 3 IR 243 ..........................................................................10-100, 10-101nO’Callaghan v Commissioners of Public Works [1985] ILRM 364 ............... 10-23O’Callaghan v Judge Alan Mahon & Others [2012] IEHC 603 ................... 10-86O’Callaghan v Mahon & Ors [2006] IEHC 311 ........................................... 11-37O’Callaghan v Mahon (No 2) [2008] 2 IR 514 ...................................5-52n, 11-31O’Callaghan v Mahon [2009] IEHC 428 ....................................................... 10-86O’Callaghan v Mahon (No 1) [2006] 2 IR 32 ................................................ 10-77O’Ceallaigh v An Bord Altranais [2000] 4 IR 54 ............................... 10-23, 10-91O’Connell v Environmental Protection Agency [2003] 1 IR 530 ............... 6-100nO’Connor v Environmental Protection Agency [2012] IEHC 370 ............... 14-44O’Connor v Kerry County Council [1988] ILRM 660 .................................. 6-78nO’Connor v Private Residential Tenancies Board and another

[2008] IEHC 205 ........................................................................................ 13-59O’Donnell v Corporation of Dun Laoghaire [1991] ILRM 301........13-48, 13-51nO’Donnell v South Dublin County Council [2007] IEHC 204 .......15-18, 15-23nO’Donnell v Tipperary (South Riding) County Council

[2005] 2 IR 483 ................................................................................................ 10-11O’Donogue v An Bord Pleanála [1991] ILRM 751 ..................................... 10-57nO’Driscoll v Law Society & Anor [2007] IEHC 352 ..................................... 11-21Oguekwe v Minister for Justice [2008] 3 IR 795 ............................................. 8-42O’Keeffe v An Bord Pleanála [1993] 1 IR 39 ..................1-46n, 6-81n, 8-45, 8-48,

8-50, 8-54n, 9-10, 9-11, 9-12, 9-35, 9-47n, 9-51, 9-53, 9-54, 9-55, 9-69, 10-52, 14-30,

14-31, 14-32, 14-33, 14-34, 14-35O’Kelly and others v Trusthouse Forte PLC [1983] ICR 728 ........................ 7-78nOkunade v Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform

[2012] IESC 49 ............................................................................................ 13-30O’Neill v Beaumont Hospital Board [1990] ILRM 419 ....................... 7-26, 11-25,

11-30, 11-36O’Neill v Irish Hereford Breed Society Ltd [1992] 1 IR 431 ........................ 11-35nOOC v The Minister for Justice Equality and Law Reform

[2013] IEHC 278. ....................................................................................... 10-80O’Reilly v His Honour Judge Cassidy and Others [1995] 1 ILRM 306........ 11-01O’Reilly v Cassidy (No.2) [1995] 1 ILRM 311 .............................................. 11-09

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

xxxii


O’Reilly v Lee [2008] 4 IR 269 ..................................................................... 11-30nO’Reilly v Mackman [1982] 2 AC 237 ............................................................ 7-57Orange v Director of Telecoms (No 2) [2000] 4 IR 159 ..................... 10-52, 11-02,

11-07, 11-17, 11-29, 11-30Ordre des barreaux francophones et germanophone and Others v

Conseil des ministres (Case C-305/05) [2007] ECR I-5305 ................... 14-57nO’Shea v Ireland [2007] 2 IR 313................................................................. 15-22n

P & F Sharpe Ltd v Dublin Corporation [1989] IR 701 .....................6-22n, 13-57Paul and Others v Bundesrepublik Deutschland ( Case C-222/02)

[2004] ECR I-9425 ...................................................................................... 14-43Pearce v Westmeath County Council [2012] IEHC 300 ............................... 13-44Persey and others v Secretary of State for the Environment

[2002] EWHC 371 ........................................................................................ 5-28Persimmon Homes Teeside Ltd. v R (Kevin Paul Lewis)

[2008] EWCA Civ 746 ............................................................................. 11-45nPfleger v Austria C-390/12 Pfleger Case E-16/11,

April 30 2014.............................................................................. 14-51n, 14-52nPhiladelphia Storage Battery Co v Controller of Industrial and

Commercial Property [1935] IR 575 ........................................................... 9-55nPhillips v Medical Council [1991] 2 IR 115 ................................................. 12-10nPI & EI v Minister for Justice and Law Reform

[2012] IEHC 7 ............................................................................................ 13-30Pigs and Bacon Commission v McCarren [1978] JISEL 109......................... 14-05Pine Valley Developments Ltd v Minister for the Environment

[1988] IR 23 ................................................................................................ 13-89Pinnock and Walker v the United Kingdom [2013]

(Application no 31673/11) (Fourth Section) Decision of 24 September 2013 .....................................15-98, 15-100, 15-102

Pok Sun Shum v Ireland [1986] ILRM 593 ......................................10-35n, 10-36Powell v Alabama (1932) 287 US 45 ......................................................... 10-101nPower v The Minister for Social and Family Affairs

[2007] 1 IR 543 ................................................................................ 12-13, 12-15PPA v Refugee Appeals Tribunal [2007] 4 IR 94 .......................................... 10-78Prendergast v Higher Education Authority & Ors

[2009] 1 ILRM 47 ............................................................. 1-23, 6-07, 7-09, 7-11Prendiville v Medical Council [2008] 3 IR 122 ................................10-09n, 10-83Produtores de Musica de Espana (Promusicae) v Telefonica de Espana SAU

(Case C-275/06) [2008] ECR I-271 ........................................................ 14-56n

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

Table of Cases

xxxiii

Pullen v Dublin City Council (no 1) [2008] IEHC 379 ......................9-21, 9-34n, 15-91, 15-97n

Pullen v Dublin City Council (No 2) [2009] IEHC 452 ................... 15-18, 15-19, 15-21, 15-63n

PUO v Minister for Justice [2012] IEHC 458 (McDermott J, 6 November 2012). ...................................................................................... 7-35

Queensland v Rauber [1983] 47 ALR 55 ..................................................... 11-35nQuinlivan v Governor of Portlaoise Prison [1998] 1 IR 456 ......................... 2-45nQuinn v The Honourable Society of Kings Inns [2004] 4 IR 344 ....... 10-15, 10-16Quirke v Bord Lúthchleas na hÉireann [1988] IR 83 .................... 10-17n, 10-92n

R (A) v Croydon LBC [2009] UKSC 8 .......................................................... 15-31R (Alconbury Developments) v Secretary of State for the Environment,

Transport and the Regions [2003] 2 AC 295 .......................15-34, 15-42, 15-44R (Alconbury Ltd) v Environment Secretary [2003] AC 295 ....................... 11-45R (Begum) v Head Teacher and Governors of Denbigh High School

[2007] 1 AC 100 .................................................................... 1-50, 1-55, 15-87nR (Bibi) v Newham London Borough Council [2002] 1 WLR 237 .............. 12-17nR (Birmingham and Solihull Taxi Association) v Birmingham

International Airport [2009] EWHC 1913 (Admin) ................................ 10-12R (Butler) v Navan UDC [1926] IR 466...................................................... 13-74nR (Countryside Alliance) v Attorney General [2008] 1 AC 719 ................... 14-12R (Huang) v Secretary of State for the Home Department

[2011] EWHC 2069 (Admin), [2011] All ER (D) 87 ....................... 1-49, 1-51R (International Air Transport Association) v Department for

Transport (Case C-344/04) [2006] ECR I-403 ......................................... 14-17R (Jackson) v Sligo County Council (1990) 34 ............................................ 13-73nR (Martin) v Mahoney [1910] 2 IR 695 ............................... 7-45, 7-46, 7-47, 7-48R (Negassi) v Secretary of State for the Home Department

[2011] EWHC 386 (Admin) ..................................................................... 14-45R (on the app of Friends Provident Life Office) v Secretary of

State for the Environment, Transport and the Regions [2001] EWHC Admin 820 ........................................................................ 15-34

R (on the application of Bonhoeffer) v General Medical Council [2012] IRLR 37 ..........................................................................10-109n, 10-111

R (Tipperary North Riding and South Riding County Councils) v Considine [1917] 2 IR 1 ............................................................................ 13-75n

R v Birmingham Juvenile Court, ex parte G [1989] 3 WLR 1024. ............. 13-72n

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

xxxiv


R v HM Treasury, ex parte British Telecommunications Plc Case C-392/93 [1996] ECR I-1631 .................................................................................... 14-44n

R v Hull University Visitor, ex parte Page [1993] AC 682 ............................ 7-57R v Immigration Appeal Tribunal, ex parte Singh

[1987] 1 WLR 1394 .................................................................................. 13-72nR v Inland Revenue Commissioners, ex parte National Federation of

Self-Employed and Small Businesses Ltd [1982] AC 617 .......................... 13-18R v Inland Revenue Commissioners, ex parte Preston [1985] AC .............. 13-54nR v Lippe [1991] 2 SCR 114 ........................................................................... 11-33R v London Borough of Harrow, ex parte Collymore [1995] ELR 217 ............ 8-34R v Minister for Agriculture, Fisheries and Food, ex parte Fedesa

[1990] ECR I-4023 .........................................................................14-27n, 14-28R v Ministry of Defence, ex parte Smith [1996] QB 517 ............................... 9-24nR v Northumberland Compensation Appeal Tribunal, ex parte Shaw

[1952] 1 KB 338 .......................................................................................... 7-54nR v Port of London Authority, ex parte Kynoch [1919] 1 KB 176 .................. 8-31R v Rochdale Metropolitan Borough Council, ex parte Millne

[2001] 81 P & CR 27 .................................................................................. 8-46nR v Secretary of State, ex parte Fayed [1998] 1 WLR 763 ............ 10-35n, 10-39nR v Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs, ex parte

World Development Movement Ltd [1995] 1 WLR 386 ............................ 13-17R v Secretary of State for Health, ex parte Eastside Cheese Co

[1999] 3 CMLR 123 ................................................................................ 15-100nR v Secretary of State for Trade and Industry, ex parte Trades Union

Congress [2001] CMLR 8 ......................................................................... 13-83nR v Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex parte Tarrant

[1985] 1 QB 251 ........................................................................... 10-105, 10-109R v Secretary of State for Transport, ex parte Factortame

[1996] ECR I-1029 .................................................................................... 14-43nR (Sinclair Collis Ltd) v Secretary of State for Health

[2011] EWCA Civ 437, [2012] QB 394 ................................................ 15-100nR (Wagstaff) v Secretary of State for Health

[2001] 1 WLR 292 ........................................................................................ 5-28R (Zagorski) v Secretary of State for Business, Innovation and Skills

[2010] EWHC 3110 (Admin) ................................................................... 14-13Radio Limerick One Limited v IRTC [1997] 2 IR 291 .............. 9-26n, 9-62, 11-19Rafferty v Bus Eireann [1997] 2 IR 424 ....................................................... 10-13nRahill v Brady [1971] IR 69 ........................................................................... 7-13n

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

Table of Cases

xxxv

Rajah v The Royal College of Surgeons [1994] 1 1R 384 .................... 10-15, 10-16Ramsever v Mahon [2006] 1 IR 216............................................................... 10-17Rawson v Minister for Defence [2012] IESC 26 .......................................... 10-49nRe British Columbia Development Corp v Friedmann (1984),

14 DLR (4th) 129 ......................................................................................... 4-89Re Haughey [1971] IR 217 ..............................2-117, 5-54, 5-55, 5-56, 5-58, 5-59,

10-87, 10-90, 10-101n, 10-114Re JP Lenihan [1943] 138F (2d) 650 ............................................................. 11-17Re Malone’s Application [1988] NI 67 ........................................................ 10-15nRe Medicaments and Related Classes of Goods (No. 2)

[2001] 1 WLR 700 ............................................................................................. 11-13Re Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs, ex parte Epeabaka

[2001] HCA 23; 206 CLR 128 ................................................................... 11-13Re National Irish Bank (No 2) [1999] 3 IR 190 ............................................. 10-90Re Refugee Review Tribunal, ex parte Aala (2000) 204 CLR 82 ..................... 7-43 Re South Western Fisheries Region (No 7), Kerry District Conservation of

Salmon and Sea Trout Bye-Law, Teahen v Minister for Communications, Energy and Natural Resources (No 1) [2008] IEHC 194 (Laffoy J)....... 10-25n

Redmond v Flood [1999] 3 IR 79 ...................................................................... 5-29Reid v Industrial Development Authority

[2013] IEHC 433 ..................................................................15-42, 15-43, 15-81Rewe-Handelsgesellschaft Nord mbH v Hauptzollamt Kiel

(Case 158/80) [1981] ECR 1805 ............................................................. 14-37nRewe-Zentral AG v Direktor der Landwirtschaftskammer Rheinland

(Case 37/83) [1984] ECR 1229 ............................................................... 14-15nReyners v Belgium (Case 2/74) [1974] ECR 631 ...................................... 14-06nRichardson v Judge Alan Mahon & Ors [2013] IEHC 118 ............................. 7-82Richardson v Mahon [2013] IEHC 118 .................................................. 5-78, 5-80Ridge v Baldwin [1964] AC 40 ...................................................................... 1-03nRing v Attorney General [2004] 1 IR 185...................................................... 6-15nRiordan v Government of Ireland [2009] 3 IR ............................................. 13-15nRMK v Refugee Appeals Tribunal & Anor [2010] IEHC 367 ........................ 8-55RO v Minister for Justice [2012] IEHC 573 ....................................... 10-59, 10-60Rooney v Minister for Agriculture, Unreported, Supreme Court,

23 October 2000 ......................................................................................... 11-12Rottmann v Freistaat Bayern [2010] ECR I-01449 C-135/08 ................... 10-33nRoughan v Clare County Council, unreported, High Court,

18 December 1996 .............................................................................. 6-70, 6-71

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

xxxvi


Ryan v Compensation Tribunal [1997] 1 ILRM 194 ....................................... 7-55Ryanair v Flynn [2000] IEHC 36 ............................... 7-69, 7-72, 7-73, 7-82, 7-83Ryanair v Labour Court [2007] 4 IR 199 ......................................................... 7-50

S (P) & E (B) v Minister for Justice [2011] IEHC 1...................................... 9-43nS v Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform, unreported,

Supreme Court, 5 March 2002 ................................................................ 13-53S v RAC [2008] IEHC 399 .......................................................................... 10-96nSalesi v Italy (1993) Series A no.257-E (1998) 26 EHRR 187 .................... 15-57Salomonsson v Sweden (App 38978/97), Judgment of

12 November 2002 .................................................................................... 15-51Sandymount and Merrion Residents Association v An Bord Pleanála &

Others [2013] IESC 51. ................................................................................ 6-97Scanlon v Sligo County Council [2011] IEHC 143 ....................................... 14-34Schaible v Land Baden-Württemberg (Case C-101/12)

EU:C:2013:661 .......................................................................................... 14-15nSdruzeni Jiboceske v Czech Republic (App 19101/03),

Eur CtHR (2006). ......................................................................................... 3-28Shannon v McGuiness [1999] 3 IR 274 ....................................................... 13-82nShell E & P Ireland Ltd v McGrath [2013] IESC ............................... 13-39, 13-48Short v Poole Corporation [1926] Ch 66 .......................................................... 9-04SIA (Sudan) v Refugee Appeals Tribunal [2012] IEHC 488........................... 8-56SIAC Construction v Mayo County Council [2002] 3 IR 148 ........... 14-31, 14-35Simmenthal SpA v Amminstrazione delle Finanze dello Stato

(Case 106/77) [1978] ECR 629 ........................................ 14-04, 14-05, 14-38nSinnott v Minister for Education [2001] 2 IR 545 .......................................... 7-11Siragusa v Regione Sicilia - Soprintendenza Beni Culturali e Ambientali di

Palermo (Case C-206/13) [2014] 3 CMLR 13............................14-52, 14-53n, 14-54n, 14-55, 14-62

Sister Mary Christian v Dublin City Council [2012] IEHC 163 ............................................................................. 10-50, 10-51

SK (Ethiopia) v Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform [2011] IEHC 301 ................................................................................. 7-74, 7-75

SK v Minister for Justice [2011] IEHC 371 ..................................................... 7-55Slatterys Limited v Commissioner of Valuation [2001] 4 IR 91 ...................... 7-52Smith and Grady v United Kingdom Smith v United Kingdom [2000]

29 EHRR 493 .............................................................................................. 15-92

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

Table of Cases

xxxvii

Societe Arcelor Atlantique et Lorraine v Premier Ministre (Case C-127/07) [2008] ECR I-9895 ........................................................ 14-15

Sopropé - Organizações de Calçado Lda v Fazenda Pública, (Case C-349/07) [2008] ECR I-10369 .......................................................................10-21, 14-66n

South Bucks County Council v Porter [2004] 1 WLR 1953 .............. 10-56, 10-62South West Area Health Board v Information Commissioner

[2005] 2 IR 547 ........................................................................................... 3-97nSR [Pakistan] v Refugee Appeals Tribunal [2013] IEHC 26........................... 8-58Sramek v Austria (1985) 7 EHRR 351 .......................................................... 15-48State (Abenglen Property) v Dublin Corporation [1984] IR 381 ........ 7-61, 13-55,

13-56n, 13-57, 13-64State (Boyle) v General Medical Services (Payment) Board

[1981] ILRM 242 ...................................................................................... 10-110State (C) v Minister for Justice [1967] IR 106 ............................................... 7-04nState (Creedon) v Criminal Injuries Compensation Tribunal

[1988] IR 51 ....................................................................................... 9-15, 10-37State (Daly) v Minister for Agriculture [1987] IR 165 ................................. 10-28State (Davidson) v Farrell [1960] IR 438.......................................7-49, 7-51, 7-60State (Furey) v Minister for Defence [1988] ILRM 89 ................................ 13-50nState (Gleeson) v Minister for Defence [1976] IR 280 ........................ 10-08, 10-64State (Holland) v Kennedy [1977] IR 193 ........................................................ 7-60State (Hughes) v O’Hanrahan [1986] ILRM 218 ........................................ 13-21nState (Keegan) v Stardust Compensation Tribunal

[1986] IR 642 .............................. 1-46n, 5-80, 7-47n, 7-71n, 8-45, 8-50, 8-54n, 9-08, 9-12, 9-15, 9-19, 9-26, 9-35, 9-36, 9-46,

9-47, 9-51, 9-53, 9-55, 9-56, 10-34n, 14-30, 14-31, 14-36, 15-81State (Lynch) v Cooney [1982] IR 337 ................8-13, 9-54, 13-08n, 13-11, 13-19State (O’Connell) v Fawsitt [1986] IR 362 .................................................. 13-77nState (O’Mahony) v South Cork Board of Public Health

[1941] Ir Jur Rep 79 ..................................................................................... 8-05State (O’Rourke) v Kelly [1983] IR 58 ......................................................... 15-63nState (McFadden) v The Governor of Mountjoy Prison (No. 1)

[1981] ILRM 113 ...................................................................................... 10-01nState (Modern Homes (Ireland) Ltd) v Dublin Corporation

[1953] IR 202 .............................................................................. 13-73n, 13-75nState (Murphy) v Kielt [1984] 1 IR 458 ......................................................... 10-91State (Plunkett) v Registrar of Building Societies [1998] 4 IR 1 ................... 5-69nState (Polymark Ltd) v ITGWU [1987] ILRM 357 ....................................... 10-83

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

xxxviii


State (Sheehan) v Government of Ireland [1987] IR 550 ............................ 13-09nSteel and Morris v United Kingdom [2005] 41 EHRR 403 .......................... 15-56Steeples v Derbyshire Borough Council [1984] 3 All ER 468 ............ 11-44, 11-46Stefan v Minister for Justice [2001] 4 IR 203 ........................... 7-63n, 7-67, 13-60Stevenson v Laney, unreported, High Court, 10 February 1993 .......... 10-108nStretch v United Kingdom (2004) 38 EHRR 12 ............................................ 12-18SUN v Refugee Applications Commissioner [2012] IEHC 338 ........ 10-94, 10-95,

10-96, 10-96nSuperwood Holdings plc v Ireland Application No 7812/04,

8 September 2011 ...................................................................................... 15-58Sweden v Commission 21 July [2011] ECR I-nyr (Case C-506/08) P ....... 3-35nSweetman v An Bord Pleanála [2008] 1 IR 277 ................................. 14-32, 14-35

Tang v Minister for Justice [1996] 2 ILRM 46 .....................................2-39, 2-40nTara Prospecting Ltd v Minister for Energy [1993] ILRM 770 .................. 12-15nTársaság a Szabadságjogokért v Hungary [2009] ECHR 37374/05 .............. 3-28Teahen v Minister for Communications, Energy and Natural

Resources (No 2) [2009] IEHC 399 .......................................................... 10-25nTES & Ors v Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform & Ors

[2012] IEHC 554 ........................................................................................ 10-96Tesco Stores Limited v Secretary of State for the Environment

[1995] 1 WLR 759 ........................................................................................ 8-47Test Claimants in the FII Group Litigation v Commissioners of Inland

Revenue Case C-466/04 [2006] ECR I-11753 ........................................ 14-44nTest Claimants in the Franked Investment Income Group Litigation v Inland

Revenue [2012] 2 WLR 1149, [2012] UKSC 19 (23 May 2012) ............ 14-17nThe Queen v. Secretary of State for Transport, ex parte

Factortame Ltd & Ors. [1990] ECR I-2433 ................................................ 14-64The State of West Bengal v Calcutta Corporation 1967 AIR 997 .........7-06n, 3-68Timmins v Gormley [2000] 1 All ER 65 ........................................................ 11-13Tomlinson v Criminal Injuries Compensation Tribunal [2006] 4 IR 321 ..... 13-57Transocean Marine Paint Association v Commission Case 17/74

[1974] ECR 1063 ...................................................................................... 14-66nTransport Salaried Staffs’ Association v Córas Iompair Éireann

[1965] IR 180 .............................................................................. 13-81n, 13-82nTreasury Holdings v National Asset Management Agency [2012] IEHC 297 ... 10-12Triatic Ltd v Cork County Council [2007] 3 IR 57 ........................................ 12-11

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

Table of Cases

xxxix

Tristor Ltd v Minister for the Environment, Heritage and Local Government and ors [2010] IEHC 397 .........................................................6-63, 6-67, 6-101

Tsfayo v UK [2009] 48 EHRR 18 ................................ 15-36, 15-38, 15-41, 15-42Tuohy v Courtney [1994] 3 IR 1 .................................................................... 9-33n

Unibet (London) Ltd and Unibet (International) Ltd v Justitiekanslern (Case C-432/05) [2007] ECR I-2271 ...................................................... 14-64n

Vakauta v Kelly (1989) 167 CLR 568 ............................................................ 11-38Van Duyn v Home Office (Case 41/74) [1974] ECR 1337 .......................... 14-06Van Schijnel v SPF [1995] ECR I-4705 ........................................................ 14-64Veolia Water UK Plc v Fingal County Council [2007] 1 ILRM 216 .......... 13-43nVM v Refugee Appeal Tribunal & anor [2013] IEHC 24............................ 10-96nVP and Another v Refugee Appeals Tribunal [2007] IEHC 415 .................... 7-71

W v United Kingdom, App. No. 9749/82 Eur Ct HR (1987) .................... 15-60Wachauf v Federal Republic of Germany (Case 5/88) [1989] ECR 2609 .. 14-12nWebb v Ireland [1988] 1 IR 353 ............................................................ 7-05, 12-03Webster v Dun Laoighaire Rathdown County Council

[2013] IEHC 118 .................................................... 15-70, 15-72, 15-73n, 15-75Whelan v Fitzpatrick & Anor [2008] 2 IR 678 ................................................ 8-32White v Dublin City Council [2004] 1 IR 545 ................................................. 9-18Wicklow County Council v Fortune [2012] IEHC 406 .......................... 6-84, 6-87Wicklow County Council v Fortune (No. 2) [2013] 255 ......................6-84n, 6-86Wicklow County Council v Fortune (No. 3) [2013] IEHC 397 .................... 6-84nWicklow County Council v Fortune (No. 4) [2014] IEHC 267 .................... 6-84nWicklow County Council v Jessup and Smith [2011] IEHC 81 ...................... 6-88Wicklow Heritage Trust v Wicklow County Council [1994] 4 IR 571 .......... 6-71nWiley v the Revenue Commissioners [1994] 2 IR ........................................ 12-18nWilliam Bailey v Kilvinane Wind Farm [2013] IEHC 509 ............................. 6-89WWF European Policy Programme v Council [2007] ECR II-911 ................. 3-34

X(R) v Minister for Justice and Law Reform [2010] IEHC 446 .................... 15-03

Zhang v Athlone Institute of Technology [2013] IEHC 390 .............. 10-16, 10-72Zimmerman and Steiner v Switzerland (1983) 6 EHRR 17 ......................... 15-57Zuckerfabrik Suderdithmarchen & Zuckerfabrik Soest (Joined Cases C-143/88

and C-92/89) [1991] ECR I-415 ............................................................... 14-47

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

xli

Table of Legislation

Constitutional ProvisionsConstitution of Ireland 1922 ................................................................7-06, 7-10Bunreacht na hÉireann .............. 1-41, 2-01, 2-14, 2-15, 2-19, 2-21, 2-92, 2-102,

3-44n, 4-24n, 4-81, 5-23n, 5-29, 7-06, 7-11n, 8-44, 9-09, 9-20, 9-26, 9-46, 10-22, 10-29, 10-34, 11-40, 13-17n, 14-05, 14-26, 14-59, 15-03, 15-04,

15-05, 15-07, 15-13, 15-14, 15-19, 15-26, 16-05Art. 5 .........................................................................................................10-34nArt. 6 ...........................................................................................................2-01nArt. 12 .......................................................................................................11-40nArt. 13.1 ........................................................................................................ 2-15Art. 15.2.1˚ ................................................................................ 1-15, 1-27, 4-24Art. 15.10 ............................................................................. 2-101, 2-102, 3-59nArt. 15.10.4˚ ................................................................................................. 2-93Art. 28 ...................................................................................... 2-05, 2-14, 7-10nArt. 28A ..............................................................................................6-06, 6-07Art. 28.2 ........................................................................................................ 7-04Art. 28.4 ..................................................................................... 2-15, 2-87, 3-44Art. 28.4.1˚ ..........................................................................................2-01, 2-15Art. 28.4.2˚ ..........................................................................................2-18, 3-72Art. 28.4.3˚ ................................................................................................. 2-110Art. 28.7.2˚ .................................................................................................2-19nArt. 28.9.4˚ .................................................................................................2-01nArt. 28.10 ...................................................................................................... 2-15Art. 28.11.1˚ ................................................................................................. 2-15Art. 29.4.10˚ .............................................................................................14-02nArt. 29.6 ...................................................................................................... 15-03Art. 33 ........................................................................................................... 2-66Art. 33.5 ........................................................................................................ 2-99Art. 34.1 ................................................................................... 5-23, 5-27n, 5-69Art. 34.4.3˚ ...............................................................................................13-21nArt. 35 ............................................................................................. 2-99, 11-40nArt. 40.3 .............................................................................................5-66, 10-95Art. 40.3.1˚ ......................................................................................10-01, 11-01Art. 40.3.2˚ ................................................................................................... 5-29

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

xlii


Art. 40.4.3˚ ................................................................................................. 15.62Art. 40.5 ...............................................................................................6-84, 6-78Art. 41 ......................................................................................................... 15-05Art. 45 .........................................................................................................7-11n

Pre-1922 StatuteCivil Bill Courts (Ireland) Act 1851

s.31 ................................................................................................................ 8-06Conveyancing Act 1881 ............................................................................. 15-75s

s.14 ............................................................................................................15-19ns.154 ............................................................................................................ 15-72

Exchequer and Audit Departments Act 1866 ............................................ 2-66Local Government (Ireland) Act 1898 ......................................................... 6-13Merchant Shipping Act 1894

s.465 ............................................................................................................5-02nOffences against the Person Act 1861........................................................ 15-26Official Secrets Act 1911 ................................................................................ 3-38

s.2 .................................................................................................................. 3-38Special Commission Act 1888....................................................................... 5-38

s.2 ................................................................................................................5-38nSupreme Court of Judicature Act (Ireland) 1877

s.21 .............................................................................................................. 13-02s.28(8) ......................................................................................................... 13-84

Tribunals of Inquiry (Evidence) Act 1921 .................... 5-02, 5-17n, 5-28, 5-38, 5-39, 5-40, 5-41, 5-43, 5-47, 5-81n

s.1 .................................................................................................................. 5-43s.1(1) ....................................................................................................5-45, 5-47s.1(2) ............................................................................................................. 5-48s.1(3) ............................................................................................................. 5-49s.2 .................................................................................................................. 5-27s.2(a) ........................................................................................ 5-25, 5-50n, 5-61s.2(b) ............................................................................................................. 5-57

Acts of the OireachtasCentral Bank Act 1942 .................................................................................3-59nCentral Bank and Financial Services

Authority of Ireland Act 2004 .............................................................4-02ns.16 ..............................................................................................................4-02n

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L


xliii

s.57 CI(9) ....................................................................................................4-45nSchedule 6 .................................................................................................4-02nSchedule 7 .................................................................................................4-02n

Children Act 1908 ........................................................................................... 7-60City and County Management Act 1940 ..................................................6-41nCivil Registration Act 2004 ......................................................................... 15-10Commissions of Investigation Act 2004 .................................5-02, 5-17n, 5-84,

5-89, 5-90, 5-98, 5-103s.3(1) ....................................................................................................5-89, 5-91s.3(2) ................................................................................................. 5-89n, 5-91s.4 .................................................................................................................. 5-91s.4(3) ...........................................................................................................5-91ns.5(1) ...........................................................................................................5-91ns.5(2)(i) .......................................................................................................5-91ns.5(2)(ii) ......................................................................................................5-91ns.6 .................................................................................................................. 5-91s.10 ................................................................................................................ 5-92s.10(2) .........................................................................................................5-92ns.11 .................................................................................................... 5-26n, 5-93s.11(1)(a).....................................................................................................5-93ns.11(1)(b) ....................................................................................................5-93ns.12 ................................................................................................................ 5-95s.12(1) .........................................................................................................5-95ns.12(1)(a).....................................................................................................5-95ns.12(1)(b) ....................................................................................................5-95ns.12(1)(c) .....................................................................................................5-95ns.12(2) .........................................................................................................5-95ns.12(3) .........................................................................................................5-95ns.14 ................................................................................................................ 5-96s.14(1)(a).....................................................................................................5-96ns.14(1)(b) ....................................................................................................5-96ns.14(1)(c) .....................................................................................................5-96ns.14(2)(a).....................................................................................................5-96ns.14(2)(b) ....................................................................................................5-96ns.14(2)(c) .....................................................................................................5-96ns.15 ................................................................................................................ 5-97s.15(1) .........................................................................................................5-97ns.16 .............................................................................................................. 5-100

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

xliv


s.16(1)(a).....................................................................................................5-99ns.16(1)(d) ....................................................................................................5-99ns.16(1)(e) .....................................................................................................5-99ns.16(3) ......................................................................................................... 5-101s.16(6)(a)...................................................................................................5-100ns.16(7) .......................................................................................................5-100ns.16(8) .......................................................................................................5-100ns.16(9) .......................................................................................................5-100ns.16(10) .....................................................................................................5-101ns.17 .............................................................................................................. 5-100s.17(1) .......................................................................................................5-100ns.17(2) .......................................................................................................5-100ns.17(3) .......................................................................................................5-100ns,17(4) .......................................................................................................5-100ns.18 ................................................................................................................ 5-99s.19 .............................................................................................................. 5-104s.19(2) ......................................................................................................... 5-104s.21 .............................................................................................................. 5-103s.21(4) ......................................................................................................... 5-103s.32(2) ........................................................................................................... 5-88s.44 ................................................................................................................ 5-87s.45 .....................................................................................................5-87, 5-104s.45(1) .........................................................................................................5-87ns.46 ................................................................................................................ 5-87Part 3 ............................................................................................................ 5-92

Committees of the Houses of the Oireachtas (Compellability, Privileges and Immunities of Witnesses) Act 1997 .................. 2-49, 2-51,

2-55, 2-60, 2-83, 2-84, 2-88, 2-108, 3-41ns.3 ................................................................................................................2-83ns. 3(7) ............................................................................................................ 2-83s.3 (8) ............................................................................................................ 2-83s.10 .................................................................................................. 2-49n, 2-83ns.15(1) ........................................................................................................... 2-49

Companies Acts ............................................................................................ 10-13Companies Act 1990 .................................................................................... 10-90

s.197 ............................................................................................................2-89nComptroller and Auditor General Act 1993 ................................... 2-66, 3-41n

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L


xlv

Comptroller and Auditor General and Committees of the Houses of the Oireachtas (Special Provisions) Act 1998............. 2-68

Consumer Information Act 1978 ................................................................ 11-24County Enterprise Board (Dissolution) Act 2014 ....................................6-51nCounty Management Act 1940 ...................................................................6-14nCourts of Justice Act 1924 .........................................................................13-02nCourts (Supplemental Provisions) Act 1961 ..........................................13-02n

s.8(2) .........................................................................................................13-84nCriminal Justice (Community Service) Act 1983

s.2 ................................................................................................................7-50nData Protection Act 1988

s.6 .................................................................................................................. 3-82s.10(4)(a)..................................................................................................... 10-49

Domestic Violence Act, 1996s.4(3) ........................................................................................................... 10-23

Dublin Docklands Development Authority Act 1997s.25 .............................................................................................................. 11-48

Electricity Supply Board Act 1927 ...........................................................15-16nElectoral Reform Act 1997 ...........................................................................3-41nEnforcement of Courts Orders Act 1940 ................................................... 15-22Environment (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 2011

s.27(b) .........................................................................................................6-73nEqual Status Act 2000 ............................................................... 4-13, 4-57, 7-11n

s.3(d)(i) .......................................................................................................7-11nEquality Act 2010 .....................................................................................15-100nEthics in Public Office Act 1995 .................................................................3-41n

s.8 ................................................................................................................ 2-100s.3 ................................................................................................................4-21n

European Communities Act 1972 .............................................................. 14-47s.2 .....................................................................................................14-04, 14-05

European Convention on Human Rights Act 2003 ................8-12, 9-20, 9-21, 9-26, 14-09, 14-38, 14-65, 14-68, 15-01, 15-02,

15-03, 15-04, 15-05, 15-06, 15-07, 15-14, 15-19, 15-21, 15-22, 15-23, 15-26, 15-63, 15-91, 15-103, 15-105

s.1(1) ................................................................................................15-15, 15-16s.2 .................................................................. 14-57, 14-59, 15-08, 15-09, 15-10,

15-11, 15-12, 15-13, 15-14, 15-17, 15-24s.2(1) .........................................................................................................15-07n

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

xlvi


s.3 ..............................................................................15-15, 15-16, 15-17, 15-18, 15-19, 15-20, 15-21, 15-24, 15-53

s.3(1) .................................................................................. 15-07n, 15-18, 15-20s.3(2) .................................................................................. 15-07n, 15-19, 15-20s.4 ......................................................................................... 15-07, 15-22, 15-23s.5 .....................................................................................................15-24, 15-26

Family Home Protection Act 1976 .............................................................7-13nFirearms Act 1925 ........................................................................................... 7-14

s.2(2) ...........................................................................................................7-14ns.5(d) ...........................................................................................................7-14n

Finance Local Property Tax Act 2012s.20 ..............................................................................................................6-28n

Freedom of Information Act 1997 .......................... 3-46, 3-51, 3-56, 3-68, 3-74, 3-78n, 3-79, 3-81, 3-89, 3-96, 3-106, 3-116, 4-33, 10-31

s.2 .................................................................................................................. 3-49s.2(1) ............................................................................................... 3-15n, 3-50ns.15 ................................................................................................................ 3-79s.15(6) ........................................................................................................... 3-58s.16 .........................................................................................4-33, 4-37n, 4-40ns.18 .....................................................................................................3-81, 10-40s.18(1) ................................................................................ 10-31, 10-39, 10-54ns.18(2)(b) .................................................................................................... 10-31s.19 ................................................................................................................ 3-74s.19(3)(b) ....................................................................................................3-74ns.20 ..............................................................................................................3-68ns.22(1A) ......................................................................................................3-68ns.34 ................................................................................................................ 3-96s.36 ................................................................................................................ 3-96s.37 .................................................................................................. 3-96n, 3-100s.37(6) ........................................................................................................... 3-96s.37(7) ......................................................................................................... 3-106

Freedom of Information Act 2014 .......................... 3-48, 3-50, 3-51, 3-53, 3-54, 3-75, 3-76, 3-78n, 3-80, 3-85, 3-91, 3-95n, 3-96, 3-102,3-106

s.2(1) ...........................................................................................................3-15ns.6 ................................................................................................................3-51ns.6(3) ...........................................................................................................3-52ns.7 ...................................................................................................... 3-51n, 3-55s.7(1)(b) ......................................................................................................3-57n

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L


xlvii

s.8 .................................................................................................................. 3-80s.8(2)(d) ......................................................................................................3-86ns.8(5) ............................................................................................................. 3-80s.10 .....................................................................................................3-81, 10-54s.10(1) ......................................................................................................... 10-54s.11 ................................................................................................................ 3-48s.11(2) .........................................................................................................3-76ns.11(3) ........................................................................................................... 3-76s.12 ................................................................................................................ 3-76s.12(2) .........................................................................................................3-77ns.13(1) .........................................................................................................3-77ns.13(2)(d)(i) .................................................................................................. 3-78s.13(2)(d)(ii) ................................................................................................. 3-78s.15 ................................................................................................................ 3-57s.15(1)(a).....................................................................................................3-57ns.15(1)(b) ....................................................................................................3-57ns.15(1)(c) .....................................................................................................3-57ns.17 ................................................................................................................ 3-82s.21 ..............................................................................................................3-85ns.21(1)(a).....................................................................................................3-85ns.21(1)(b) ....................................................................................................3-85ns.21(1)(g) ....................................................................................................3-85ns.21(2) .........................................................................................................3-85ns.21(2)(b) ....................................................................................................3-85ns.22(1) ............................................................................................... 3-85n, 3-90s.22(1)(i) .....................................................................................................3-90ns.22(1)(ii) ....................................................................................................3-90ns.22(3) .........................................................................................................3-99ns.22(9)(a)(i) .................................................................................................3-91ns.22(9)(a)(ii)................................................................................................3-91ns.22(9)(a)(iii) ..............................................................................................3-91ns.22(9)(a)(vii) .............................................................................................3-91ns.22(10) .......................................................................................................3-99ns.22(12)(b) .................................................................................................... 3-94s.22(14)(b) ..................................................................................................3-89ns.23 ............................................................................................................3-100ns.23(1)(b) ...................................................................................................... 3-78s.24(1) ......................................................................................................... 3-107

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

xlviii


s.24(1)(b) .................................................................................................... 3-107s.24(2) ............................................................................................. 3-70n, 3-90ns.27(3) .......................................................................................................3-115ns.27(12) .....................................................................................................3-115ns.28 ............................................................................... 3-61, 3-65n, 3-67n, 3-72s.28(3)(b) ....................................................................................................3-75ns.29 .......................................................................................................3-61, 3-66s.30 .................................................................................................... 3-61, 3-66ns.30(1) .........................................................................................................3-63ns.31 ................................................................................................................ 3-61s.31(1)(a).....................................................................................................3-65ns.32 .................................................................................................... 3-61, 3-70ns.32(1)(a).....................................................................................................3-63ns.33 .........................................................................................3-61, 3-67n, 3-70ns.33(1) .........................................................................................................3-63ns.34(1)(ii) ....................................................................................................3-70ns.34(2) ........................................................................................................... 3-92s.34(3)(b) ....................................................................................................3-90ns.34(7) ........................................................................................................... 3-92s.34(7)(a).....................................................................................................3-70ns.34(13) .......................................................................................................3-70ns.35 .........................................................................................3-61, 3-66n, 3-69ns.36 ........................................................................................... 3-61, 3-66, 3-69ns.36(1)(b) ....................................................................................................3-63ns.37 .................................................................................................... 3-61, 3-69ns.38 ................................................................................................................ 3-69s.39 .................................................................................................... 3-61, 3-66ns.40 .................................................................................................... 3-61, 3-66ns.40(1)(a)....................................................................................................... 3-63s.41 ................................................................................................................ 3-61s.42 ................................................................................................................ 3-59s.43 ..............................................................................................................3-89ns.45 ..............................................................................................................3-96ns.45(6) ..................................................................................................3-95, 3-96s.45(7) .........................................................................................................3-95ns.45(8) ......................................................................................................... 3-106s.47(7) .......................................................................................................3-108ns.52 ..............................................................................................................3-95n

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L


xlix

Part 2 ................................................................................................ 3-51n, 3-61Part 4 ............................................................................................................ 3-60Schedule 1 ..................................................................................... 3-51n, 3-53nSchedule 1, Part 2 ........................................................................... 3-52n, 3-54

Freedom of Information (Amendment) Act 2003 ............. 3-108, 3-109, 10-31s.14 ................................................................................................ 3-74n, 3-108n

Greyhound Industry Act 1958 ...................................................................... 9-17Health Act 1970

s.53 ..............................................................................................................2-56nHealth Act 2004 .............................................................................................. 6-13

s.54(1) .........................................................................................................4-28nPart 9 ..........................................................................................................4-28n

Houses of the Oireachtas (Inquiries, Privileges and Procedures) Act 2013 .............................................2-49n, 2-83n, 2-90, 2-94,

2-106, 2-107, 2-118, 2-119s.7 ................................................................................................................2-96ns.8 (2)(c) ........................................................................................................ 2-98s.9 .................................................................................................................. 2-99s.10 ...................................................................................................2-100, 2-101s.10(2)(c) ..................................................................................................... 2-100s.12 .............................................................................................................. 2-106s.13 ...................................................................................................2-106, 2-119s.14 .............................................................................................................. 2-111s.17 .............................................................................................................. 2-113s.17(2)(b) ..................................................................................................2-113ns.17 (3)(a)..................................................................................................2-113ns.17 (3)(b) .................................................................................................2-113ns.17 (3)(c) ..................................................................................................2-113ns.18 ............................................................................................................2-114ns.19 ............................................................................................................2-115ns.20 .............................................................................................................. 2-115s.21 ............................................................................................................2-116ns.22 ...................................................................................................2-114, 2-119s.24 .............................................................................................................. 2-117s.29 .............................................................................................................. 2-118s.30 .............................................................................................................. 2-109s.31 .............................................................................................................. 2-118s.31(1)(a)...................................................................................................2-118n

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

l


s.32 ...................................................................................................2-109, 2-112s.32(3)(a)...................................................................................................2-109ns.32(3)(b) ..................................................................................................2-109ns.43 .............................................................................................................. 2-119s.46 .............................................................................................................. 2-119s.46(1) .......................................................................................................2-119ns.47 .............................................................................................................. 2-119s.53 .............................................................................................................. 2-119s.67 .................................................................................................. 2-83n, 2-112s.67(1) ......................................................................................................... 2-108s.67(6) .......................................................................................................2-108ns.67(7) .......................................................................................................2-108ns.71 .............................................................................................................. 2-110s.71(1)(a)..................................................................................................... 2-110s.71(1)(c) ..................................................................................................... 2-110s.75 ............................................................................................................2-112ns.75(1) ......................................................................................................... 2-112s.75(3) .......................................................................................................2-112ns.76 ............................................................................................................2-110ns.77(3) ......................................................................................................... 2-110s.83 .............................................................................................. 2-108n, 2-110ns.86 ............................................................................................................2-110ns.93(1)(b) ...................................................................................................... 2-49s.94 ............................................................................................................2-117ns.95 ................................................................................................ 2-117n, 2-120s.99 .............................................................................................................. 2-112Part 2 ..................................................................................... 2-95, 2-106, 2-108Part 3 .......................................................................................................... 2-113Part 6 .............................................................................................. 2-94n, 2-108Part 7 ..........................................................................................................2-94nPart 8 ..........................................................................................................2-94nPart 9 ........................................................................................................2-117n

Houses of the Oireachtas (Laying of Documents) Act 1966 ..................4-24nHousing Act 1966s.62 ..............................................................15-19n, 15-25, 15-63, 15-64, 15-66,

15-70, 15-72, 15-75, 15-80, 15-81Housing (Traveller Accommodation) Act 1998 ......................................... 6-72Housing (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 2014 ........................................ 15-80

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L


li

s.12(9) .......................................................................................................15-80ns.12(9)(a)..................................................................................................... 15-63

Illegal Immigrants (Trafficking) Act 2000s.5 ..............................................................................................................13-94n

Illegal Immigrants (Trafficking) Act 2004s.5 .................................................................................................................. 7-32

Immigration Act 1999 .........................................................................7-32, 10-63s.3 ............................................................................................... 7-31, 7-34, 8-42s.3(3) ........................................................................................................... 10-63s.3(6) ............................................................................................................. 9-19

Industrial Development Act 1986s.16 .............................................................................................................. 15-81

Industrial Development Act 1995 ..............................................................6-51nInterpretation Act 2005 .........................................................................7-11, 7-13

s.5 .........................................................................................................7-13, 7-21Intoxicating Liquor Act 1927

s.1(1) ............................................................................................................. 7-20s.20 ................................................................................................................ 7-20

Irish Nationality and Citizenship Acts 1956 .................................10-31, 10-32s.15 ...................................................................................................10-32, 10-34

Irish Nationality and Citizenship Acts 1986 ............................................ 10-31Livestock Marts Act 1967 .....................................................................8-14, 8-15

s.3 .................................................................................................................. 8-15Local Authorities (Higher Education Grants) Acts 1968-1992 ............12-07nLocal Government Act 1991 ...................................................... 6-08, 6-09, 6-38

s.43 .................................................................................................... 6-34n, 6-39Local Government Act 2001 ............ 6-09, 6-13, 6-15n, 6-21, 6-24n, 6-41, 6-43

s.13A ...........................................................................................................6-15ns.37(2)(b)(iv) ................................................................................................ 6-87s.48 ................................................................................................................ 6-51s.48(1A) ......................................................................................................6-51ns.49A ...........................................................................................................6-48ns.49A(3) ......................................................................................................6-48ns.63(1)(a).....................................................................................................6-06ns.65(1) .........................................................................................................6-09ns.66B ...........................................................................................................6-52ns.66(B)(2) ....................................................................................................6-52ns.66C(1) ........................................................................................................ 6-52

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

lii


s.66H...........................................................................................................6-53ns.66(H)(1) ...................................................................................................6-53ns.66H(2) ......................................................................................................6-53ns.66(3) ........................................................................................................... 6-09s.66(3)(e) .....................................................................................................6-50ns.66(4) .........................................................................................................6-09ns.69 ................................................................................................................ 6-10s.103A .........................................................................................................6-31ns.117 .............................................................................................................. 6-47s.118 .............................................................................................................. 6-47s.128B ........................................................................................................... 6-48s.132(3) .......................................................................................................6-24ns.132(5) .......................................................................................................6-24ns.132(6) .......................................................................................................6-24ns.132(7) .......................................................................................................6-24ns.132(8) .......................................................................................................6-24ns.134 .....................................................................................................6-25, 6-27s.134(6)(e) ...................................................................................................6-25ns.136 ............................................................................................................6-24ns.140 ................................................................................6-21, 6-23n, 6-29, 6-56 s.145(1) .......................................................................................................6-26ns.146 .............................................................................................................. 6-24s.147 ............................................................................................................6-27ns.147(4) .......................................................................................................6-26ns.149(4) .......................................................................................................6-21ns.152 ............................................................................................................6-24ns.199(8a) ....................................................................................................... 6-44s.216(1) ......................................................................................................... 6-43s.222 ............................................................................................................6-43nSchedule 14 ...............................................................................................6-21n

Local Government Act 2014 ................................... 6-01, 6-03, 6-13, 6-14, 6-16, 6-19, 6-20, 6-23n, 6-24, 6-25, 6-27, 6-28,

6-29, 6-30, 6-34, 6-36n, 6-40, 6-47, 6-48, 6-51, 6-52, 6-54, 6-56, 6-60

s.35 ..............................................................................................................6-48ns.36 ..............................................................................................................6-48ns.41 ..............................................................................................................6-51ns.43(3) ........................................................................................................... 6-35

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L


liii

s.43(4)(a)....................................................................................................... 6-36s.44 ..............................................................................................................6-53ns.47 ..............................................................................................................6-24ns.49(c) .........................................................................................................6-25ns.51 ..............................................................................................................6-24ns.58(i) ............................................................................................................ 6-31s.61 ................................................................................................................ 6-45s.62 ..............................................................................................................6-34ns.102(4A)(a) ...............................................................................................6-30ns.102(4A)(c) ................................................................................................6-30ns.103A(1) ....................................................................................................6-30ns.126B ........................................................................................................... 6-45s.126C(1) ...................................................................................................... 6-45s.134A ........................................................................................................... 6-27s.136(3) .......................................................................................................6-24ns.136(4) .......................................................................................................6-24ns.136(5) .......................................................................................................6-24ns.144 ............................................................................................................6-14nPart 3 ..........................................................................................................6-16nPart 7 ............................................................................................................ 6-29Schedule 3 ................................................................................................... 6-32

Local Government (Financial Provisions) Act 1978 .................................. 6-41Local Government (Financial Provisions) Act 1997 .................................. 6-41

s.14(4) .........................................................................................................6-47nLocal Government (No 2) Act 2003 ...........................................................6-15nLocal Government (Temporary Provisions) Act 1923

s.12 ................................................................................................................ 6-41Ministers and Secretaries Act 1924 .....................................................2-21, 2-48National Asset Management Agency Act 2009 ................................8-17, 8-18

s.84 .....................................................................................................8-17, 10-70s.84(1) ........................................................................................................... 8-17s.84(4) ........................................................................................................... 8-19s.84(4)(n) ...................................................................................................... 8-20

National Treasury Management Agency (Amendment) Act 2000s.9(3)(f) ......................................................................................................... 7-37

Non- Fatal Offences against the Person Act 1997 ...................................... 7-22s.2 .................................................................................................................. 7-22s.3 .................................................................................................................. 7-22

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

liv


Nursing Homes Support Scheme Act 2009 ................................................ 7-16s.52 ................................................................................................................ 7-16s.53 ................................................................................................................ 7-16

Official Secrets Act 1963 ............................................................. 3-39, 3-45, 5-49s.4 .................................................................................................................. 3-39s.13 ................................................................................................................ 3-39s.48(1) .........................................................................................................3-39n

Oireachtas (Allowances To Members) and Ministerial, Parliamentary, Judicial and Court Offices (Amendment) Act 1998

s.4 ................................................................................................................2-79nOmudsman Act 1980 ...................................................... 4-08, 4-22, 4-24, 4-28n,

4-31, 4-33, 4-37, 4-38, 4-41s.2 ................................................................................................................4-90ns.2(2) ............................................................................................... 3-89n, 4-10ns.2(2A) ........................................................................................................4-12ns.2(3)(b) ......................................................................................................4-11ns.2(7) ...........................................................................................................4-10ns.4 .................................................................................................................. 4-22s.4(1) ............................................................................................................. 4-11s.4(2) ........................................................................................ 4-13, 4-23, 4-36ns.4(3) ............................................................................................................. 4-35s.4(3)(a)......................................................................................................... 4-36s.5 .................................................................................................................. 4-31s.5(1)(a)(i) ...................................................................................................4-27ns.5(1)(a)(ii)..................................................................................................4-27ns.5(1)(a)(iii) ...................................................................................... 4-27n, 4-31s.5(1)(b) ......................................................................................................4-28ns.5(1)(c) .......................................................................................................4-28ns.5(1)(d)(i) ..................................................................................................4-28ns.5(1)(d)(ii) .................................................................................................4-28ns.5(1)(e)(i) ...................................................................................................4-28ns.5(1)(e)(ii) ..................................................................................................4-28ns.5(1)(f) .......................................................................................................4-28ns.5(3) ............................................................................................................. 4-32s.6(2) ............................................................................................................. 4-42s.6(3) ............................................................................................................. 4-46s.6(4) ...........................................................................................................4-42ns.6(5) ................................................................................................. 4-46, 4-59n

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L


lv

s.6(6) ............................................................................................................. 4-42s.6(7) .............................................................. 4-10n, 4-32n, 4-46, 4-59n, 4-65ns.7(1) ............................................................................................................. 4-38s.7(1)(a)......................................................................................................... 4-38s.7(2) ...........................................................................................................4-39ns.7(3) ...........................................................................................................4-39ns.7(6) ...........................................................................................................4-39ns.8(1) ...........................................................................................................4-41ns.8(2) ...........................................................................................................4-41ns.8(3) ............................................................................................................. 4-41s.8(4) ...........................................................................................................4-41n

Ombudsman (Amendment) Act 2012 .......... 4-12, 4-26, 4-29, 4-38, 4-42, 4-73s.9(3A)(b) ...................................................................................................4-42n

PIAB Act 2003 ............................................................................................. 10-101s.7 ............................................................................................................10-101ns.54(2) .....................................................................................................10-101n

Planning and Development Act 2000 ..............................6-57, 6-63, 6-65, 6-66, 6-91, 6-95, 6-105, 15-81

s.5 .........................................................................................................6-89, 6-90s.5(1) ............................................................................................................. 6-77s.10 .......................................................................................................6-57, 6-65s.10(2) .........................................................................................................6-57ns.10(2)(a).....................................................................................................6-57ns.10(2)(b) ....................................................................................................6-57ns.10(2)(c) .....................................................................................................6-57ns.10(2)(d) ....................................................................................................6-57ns.10(2)(e) .....................................................................................................6-57ns.10(2)(f) .....................................................................................................6-57ns.10(2)(g) ....................................................................................................6-57ns.10(2)(h) ....................................................................................................6-57ns.10(2)(i) .....................................................................................................6-57ns.10(2)(j) ......................................................................................................6-57ns.10(2)(k) ....................................................................................................6-57ns.10(2)(l) .....................................................................................................6-57ns.10(2)(m) ...................................................................................................6-57ns.10(2)(n) ....................................................................................................6-57ns.10(2)(o) ....................................................................................................6-57ns.27(2) ........................................................................................................... 6-66

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

lvi


s.28 ................................................................................................................ 6-62s.29 .....................................................................................................6-62, 6-101s.31 ...................................................................... 6-61, 6-63, 6-65, 6-66n, 6-101s.31(1) ........................................................................................................... 6-65s.34(1) ........................................................................................................... 6-91s.34(2)(a)....................................................................................................... 6-91s.34(4) ........................................................................................................... 6-91s.34(4)(a)....................................................................................................... 6-92s.34(7) .........................................................................................................6-21ns.50 ................................................................................................................ 6-94s.50A ............................................................................................................. 6-97s.50A(3)(b) .................................................................................................6-96ns.50(4)(b)(iv) ............................................................................................13-12ns.81 ..............................................................................................................6-57ns.94 ..............................................................................................................6-57ns.94(1) .........................................................................................................6-57ns.95 ..............................................................................................................6-57ns.95(1) .........................................................................................................6-57ns.96 .................................................................................................... 6-57n, 7-64s.126 .............................................................................................................. 6-94s.132 .............................................................................................................. 8-53s.134 .............................................................................................................. 6-94s.151 .............................................................................................................. 6-74s.152(1)(a)...................................................................................................6-75ns.152(1)(b) ..................................................................................................6-75ns.152(4) ......................................................................................................... 6-75s.153(8) .......................................................................................................6-73ns.154(5)(b) .................................................................................................... 6-79s.157(4)(a)...................................................................................................6-75ns.160 ...............................................................6-73, 6-75, 6-84, 6-85, 6-86, 6-87,

6-88, 6-89, 6-90, 6-95s.160(1) ......................................................................................................... 6-83s.169(9) .......................................................................................................6-57nSchedule 1 ................................................................................................... 6-57Part 2, Chapter IV .....................................................................................6-61nPart 9 ..........................................................................................................6-57n

Planning and Development Acts 2000-2011 ....................................6-97, 6-100s.15(1) ........................................................................................................... 6-69

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L


lvii

s.34(10) ....................................................................................................... 10-62s.50(3)(b)(i) .................................................................................................. 6-95s.50(4) ........................................................................................................... 6-95s.153(7) ......................................................................................................... 6-73s.178 .............................................................................................................. 6-71s.178(1) ......................................................................................................... 6-70

Planning and Development (Amendment) Act 2010...................... 6-58, 6-60, 6-67, 6-100

s.10(1A) ...............................................................................................6-58, 6-59s.10(1B) ......................................................................................................... 6-59s.10(1)D ......................................................................................................6-59ns.10(2)(A)(a) ................................................................................................. 6-59s.10(2)B .......................................................................................................6-59n

Planning and Development (Strategic Infrastructure) Act 2006 ................................................................................. 6-94, 6-96, 6-96

s.8 .................................................................................................................. 6-92 s.13 ..............................................................................................................6-94ns.34(3)(b)(i) .................................................................................................. 6-95s.34(4) ........................................................................................................... 6-95s.37(4)(d)(iii) ................................................................................................ 6-96s.37(4)9c ....................................................................................................... 6-96

Protection of Life During Pregnancy Act 2013 ........................................2-08nProvident Societies (Am) Act 1978 ............................................................5-69nPublic Service Management Act 1997 ................. 1-08, 2-21, 2-48, 2-61, 3-41n

s.3 ................................................................................................................1-08ns.4 ...................................................................................................... 1-08n, 2-48s.4(1) ............................................................................................................. 1-08s.6 ................................................................................................................1-08ns.7 ................................................................................................................1-08n

Public Service Management (Recruitments and Appointments Act) 2004 ........................................................................ 1-07

Railway Safety Act 2005s.64 ..............................................................................................................5-02n

Refugee Act 1996 .................................................................................7-32, 10-94s.5 ............................................................................................. 7-31, 7-32, 9-19ns.8 .................................................................................................................. 7-73s.11 ............................................................................................. 7-73, 8-59, 8-60s.11A(1) ....................................................................................................10-94n

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

lviii


s.11A(1)(a) ................................................................................................. 10-95s.11B .........................................................................................................10-94ns.11(6) ......................................................................................................... 10-80s.12 ............................................................................................................10-94ns.12(1)(m) .................................................................................................10-94ns.13 ......................................................................................... 7-73n, 8-59, 10-95s.13(5) ......................................................................................................... 10-94s.13(6) .......................................................................................................10-96ns.13(6)(e) ....................................................................................... 10-94, 10-96ns.13(8)(a)...................................................................................................10-94ns.13(10) ......................................................................................................... 7-63s.17(2) ......................................................................................................... 10-41s.18(6) ......................................................................................................... 10-80s.91 .............................................................................................................. 11-50

Regional Technical Colleges Act 1992 ....................................................... 10-16Rent Restrictions Act 1946 ............................................................................ 7-49Restrictive Practices Act 1972

s.5 ................................................................................................................7-20ns.8(1) ...........................................................................................................7-20n

Roads Act 1993s.11(3) .........................................................................................................6-57ns.22 ..............................................................................................................6-57n

Social Welfare Consolidation Act 2005s.186C(1) ....................................................................................................8-34ns.186C(3) ....................................................................................................8-34ns.300 ............................................................................................................8-34n

Social Welfare (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 2010s.186C(1)(a) ................................................................................................8-34n

Stamp Duties Consolidation Act 1999s.40(2) ........................................................................................................... 7-18

Standards in Public Office Act 2001s.4 ................................................................................................................ 2-101

State Property Act 1954s.11(2) ........................................................................................................... 8-33

Statute of Limitations 1957s.11(2)(b) .................................................................................................... 13-09

Student Support Act 2011s.6 ................................................................................................................ 12-07

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L


lix

Taxes Consolidation Act 1997 ...................................................................... 7-19s.849 .............................................................................................................. 4-19

Transport (Reorganisation of Coras Iompair Eireann) Act 1986 ................................................................................................10-13n

s.14 ............................................................................................................10-13nTribunals of Inquiry (Evidence) (Amendment) Act 1979 ........... 5-43n, 5-81n

s.4 .........................................................................................................5-47, 5-48s.6 .........................................................................................................5-67, 5-69s.6(1) ...........................................................................................................5-60n

Tribunals of Inquiry (Evidence) (Amendment) Act 1997 .......................5-81nTribunals of Inquiry (Evidence) (Amendment) Act 1998 .......................5-81nTribunals of Inquiry (Evidence) (Amendment) (No. 2) Act 1998 .........5-81nTribunals of Inquiry (Evidence) (Amendment) Act 2002 .......................5-81nTribunals of Inquiry (Evidence) (Amendment) Act 2004 .......................5-81nUrban Renewal Act 1986 (Remission of Rates) Scheme 2011

Art.5(b) ......................................................................................................... 7-52Valuation Act 2001 ............................................................................. 1-07, 6-41n

s.15 ................................................................................................................ 1-07s.39 ..............................................................................................................6-41n

Waste Management Act 1996 ....................................................................... 6-72s.22(10A) ...................................................................................................... 6-57

Waste Management Acts 1996-2003 ..........................................................6-57nWaste Management Acts 1996-2007 .......................................................... 11-41Waste Management (Amendment) Act 2001

s.4 ................................................................................................................6-57n

Secondary LegislationAccess to Environmental Information Directive 1990 ............................3-46nAir Navigation (Notification and Investigation of Accidents,

Serious Incidents and Incidents) Regulations 2009 (SI No 460 of 2009) ................................................................................5-02n

Council Directive 97/11/EC ........................................................................ 8-52Data Retention Directive ............................................................................. 14-58Directive 85/33/EEC ................................................................................... 14-35

Art.10a ........................................................................................................ 14-32Directive 2009/22/EC .................................................................................4-95nDirective 2011/92/EU

Art.11(4) ..................................................................................................... 14-44

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

lx


EC (Access to Information on the Environment) Regulations 2007 (SI No 133 of 2007) ................................................................................3-52n

EC (Eligibility for Protection) Regulations 2006 (S.I. No. 518 of 2006) Regulation 7(1) ........................................................................................ 8-57

EC Habitats Directive Council Directive 92/43/EEC ..... 6-57n, 14-22, 14-24Art.6(3) ....................................................................................................... 14-22Art.6(4) ....................................................................................................... 14-22

Environmental Impact Assessment Directive ...............................14-35, 14-52EU Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) Directive

(Directive 2013/11/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council, 21 May 2013) ........................................................4-95, 4-97

EU Council Directive 85/337/E.E.C ........................................................... 8-52EU Equal Treatment Directive ................................................................... 14-40EU Public Participation Directive ................................................................ 6-98European Communities (Safeguarding of Employees’ Rights on

Transfer of Undertakings) Regulations 1980 ....................................7-55nFreedom of Information Act 1997 (Fees) Regulations 2003

(SI No 264 of 2003) ..............................................................................3-108nFreedom of Information Act 1997 (Prescribed Bodies)

Regulations, 1999 (SI No 329 of 1999) ................................................3-51nFreedom of Information Act, 1997 (Prescribed Bodies) (No. 4)

Regulations,2001 (SI No 475 of 2001) .................................................3-51nHabitats Directive: Council Directive 92/43/EEC of 21 May 1992 ......6-86nHealth (Charges for In-Patient Services) Regulations 1976 ...................2-56nLocal Government Act 1991 (Regional Authorities) (Amendment)

Order 2014 (SI No 228 of 2014) .................................................. 6-34n, 6-37s.6(a) ...........................................................................................................6-38ns.6(b) ...........................................................................................................6-38ns.43 ................................................................................................................ 6-39

Local Government Act, 1991 (Regional Authorities)(Establishment) Order 1999, (SI No 226 of 1999) ...........................................................6-34n

Major Accidents Directive ..........................................................................6-57nPlanning and Development Regulations 2001 ......................................... 14-35

Art.94 ............................................................................................................ 8-53Art. 111(i) ..................................................................................................... 8-53Schedule 6 .................................................................................................8-53nSchedule 6, Para 1(c) ................................................................................8-53nSchedule 6, Para 2(b) ................................................................................8-53n

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L


lxi

Procurement Remedies Directive (Directive 89/665/EEC of 21 December 1989) ................................................................................ 14-31

Refugee Act 1996 (Safe Countries of Origin) Order 2004 (SI No 714 of 2004) ..............................................................................10-94n

Regulation (EC) No. 742/2006 of the 17th May, 2006 ...........................10-67nRegulation (EC) No 2006/2004 ..................................................................4-95nRules of the Superior Courts (Judicial Review)

(SI No 691 of 2011) .................................................. 13-21n, 13-41n, 13-88nAppendix T .............................................................................................13-21n

Rules of the Superior Courts 1986 (SI No 15/1986) ................................ 13-05Transparency Regulation/ Regulation 1049/2001 ...........................3-34, 3-36

Art. 4 ............................................................................................................. 3-35Art. 4(1)(a) ................................................................................................... 3-35Art. 4(1)(b) ................................................................................................... 3-35Art. 4(2) ........................................................................................................ 3-35Art. 4(3) ......................................................................................................3-35n

Rules of CourtRules of the Superior Courts 1962 ...........................................................13-07nOrder 84 .......................................................................................................13-02nRules of the Superior Courts 1986 ........................................................... 13-07nOrder 18, rule 24(1) ....................................................................................13-22nOrder 18, rule 24(2) ....................................................................................13-22nOrder 19, rule 5 ...........................................................................................13-89nOrder 19, rule 7 ...........................................................................................13-89nOrder 19, rule 29 ........................................................................................... 13-81Order 40, rule 4 ...........................................................................................13-21nOrder 58, rule 13 .........................................................................................13-21nOrder 84 ............................................................................................. 13-06, 13-07,

13-20, 13-26, 13-41, 13-44, 13-46, 13-47, 13-67, 13-69, 13-78

Order 84, rule 18(1) ...................................................................................... 13-79Order 84, rule 18(2) ...................................................................................... 13-79Order 84, rule 20 ........................................................................................... 13-23Order 84, rule 20(1) ...................................................................................... 13-21Order 84, rule 20(2)(a) ................................................................................. 13-25Order 84, rule 20(2)(a)(iii) ........................................................................... 13-29Order 84, rule 20(2)(1)(iii) .........................................................................13-21n

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

lxii


Order 84, rule 20(3) ...........................................................................13-27, 13-28Order 84, rule 20(4) .........................................13-07, 13-13, 13-18, 13-23, 13-28Order 84, rule 20(7) ...................................................................................... 13-83Order 84, rule 20(8) ...........................................................................13-29, 13-30Order 84, rule 21 ......................................................... 13-41, 13-43, 13-48, 13-49Order 84, rule 21(1) ............................................................... 13-24, 13-40, 13-51Order 84, rule 21(3) ...................................................................................... 13-52Order 84, rule 25 .........................................................................................13-88nOrder 84, rule 25(1)(1) ................................................................................. 12-20Order 84, rule 26(4) ...................................................................................... 13-72

International ConventionsAarhus Convention ........................................................................................ 6-98

Art.2(2) .......................................................................................................6-98nArt.2(4) .......................................................................................................6-98nArt.2(5) .......................................................................................................6-98nArt.9 ............................................................................................................6-98n

American Convention on Human RightsArt. 13 .........................................................................................................3-26n

Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union .....1-41, 8-12, 14-13, 14-14, 14-48, 14-49, 14-50, 14-51,

14-54, 14-58, 14-62, 14-63, 14-65, 14-68, 15-02

Art. 11 ........................................................................................................... 3-32Art.17 ........................................................................................................14-52nArt.41 ........................................................................... 3-33,10-39, 14-63, 14-66Art. 41(1) ...................................................................................................... 3-33Art.41(2) ..................................................................................................... 14-66Art. 42 ........................................................................................................... 3-33Art.47 ................................................................................... 14-63, 14-64, 14-65Art.51 .......................................................................................................... 14-49Art.51(1) ..........................................................................................14-50, 14-53Art.52(3) ..................................................................................................... 14-14Art. 53 .................................................................................. 14-59, 14-60, 14-61

Council of Europe Convention on Access to Official DocumentsArt. 7 ........................................................................................................... 3-112Art. 7(1) ....................................................................................................3-112n

Council of Europe Landscape Convention ..............................................6-57n

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L


lxiii

European Convention on Human Rights .......................1-34, 1-41, 1-42, 1-49, 1-61, 1-63, 3-26, 5-16, 7-08, 8-40, 9-02, 9-20, 9-21, 9-34, 9-46, 9-69, 11-51, 14-03, 14-14, 14-26, 14-48,

14-63, 14-68, 15-01, 15-02, 15-03, 15-04, 15-05, 15-06, 15-07, 15-09, 15-14, 15-15, 15-17, 15-18, 15-20, 15-22, 15-23, 15-27, 15-40, 15-42, 15-44, 15-51, 15-52, 15-59,

15-65, 15-69, 15-75, 15-82, 15-88n, 15-90, 15-91, 15-92, 15-94, 15-100n, 15-101n, 15-102

Art. 1 ...........................................................................................................5-16nArt. 2 ............................................................................................................. 5-16Art. 3 ............................................................................................................. 5-16Art. 6 ..............................................10-01, 10-89, 10-112, 14-64n, 15-02, 15-20,

15-27, 15-30, 15-31, 15-32, 15-33, 15-34, 15-37, 15-41, 15-42, 15-44, 15-45, 15-49, 15-50, 15-52, 15-55, 15-56, 15-57, 15-60

Art. 6(1) ..................................15-19, 15-28, 15-33, 15-35, 15-38, 15-39, 15-40, 15-44, 15-45, 15-46, 15-48, 15-52, 15-57, 15-58, 15-59

Art. 8 .................................................3-26, 3-29, 8-39, 8-40, 8-41, 15-05, 15-10, 15-19n, 15-41, 15-42, 15-60, 15-62, 15-63,

15-67, 15-68, 15-69, 15-71, 15-72, 15-81, 15-88n, 15-90, 15-92, 15-94, 15-96, 15-98, 15-100

Art. 9 ........................................................................................................... 15-85Art. 10 ..................................................................................................3-26, 3-28Art. 10(2) ...................................................................................................... 3-27Art. 13 ........................................................................................... 14-64n, 15-92Art. 52(30 .................................................................................................14-63nFirst Protocol to the ECHRArt.1 ..........................................................................................................15-60n

European Communities (Markets in Financial Instruments) Regulations 2007 (SI No 60 of 2007) ................................................... 10-14

International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights Art. 19 ........................................................................................................... 3-25

Lisbon Treaty ................................................................................................ 14-68Prison Rules 2007 (SI No 11 of 2013)

Rule 57A ....................................................................................................4-29nRule 57B .....................................................................................................4-29n

Treaty of the European Union ...................................................................... 3-30Art. 3(2) ......................................................................................................3-30n

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L

lxiv


Treaty on the Functioning of the EU ..............................................14-12, 14-37Art. 4(2) ...................................................................................................... 14-62Art. 5(4) ...................................................................................................... 14-27Art. 6 ........................................................................................................... 14-14Art. 6(3) ...................................................................................................... 14-14Art. 15(1) ...................................................................................................... 3-32Art. 16(1) ...................................................................................................... 3-32Art. 16(2) ....................................................................................................3-32nArt. 18 ......................................................................................................... 14-15Art. 19 ......................................................................................................... 14-15Art. 45(3) .................................................................................................... 14-06Art. 267 ............................................................................................14-47, 14-64Art. 288 ....................................................................................................... 14-06Art. 296 ....................................................................................................... 10-39

UN Convention against Torture .................................................................. 7-36

Other Jurisdictions

AustraliaAdministrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth). .................................... 1-35

DenmarkDanish Constitution 1953 ............................................................................4-05n

MaltaMaltese Civil Code

Second Schedule .......................................................................................6-98n

New ZealandParliamentary Commission (Ombudsman) Act 1962 .............................4-05n

SpainSpanish Constitution

Art.24 ........................................................................................................14-62nSwedenAct of Succession ..........................................................................................3-38nFreedom of the Press and Right of Access to

Public Records Act 1766 ......................................................................... 3-38Fundamental Law on Freedom of Expression .........................................3-38nInstrument of Government .........................................................................3-38n

SAMPLE M

ATERIA

L


lxv

United KingdomFreedom of Information Act 2000 ..............................................................3-18n

s.19 ..............................................................................................................3-80nHuman Rights Act 1998 ..................... 8-47, 9-24, 15-08, 15-23, 15-44n, 15-105

s.3(1) ............................................................................................. 15-08n, 15-09Hunting Act 2004 ......................................................................................... 14-12Inquiries Act 2005..................................................................................5-40, 5-81

s.14 ..............................................................................................................5-40ns.19 ..............................................................................................................5-40ns.25 ..............................................................................................................5-40n

National Health Service Act 1977s.2 ................................................................................................................5-28n

Parliamentary Commissioner Act 1967 .......................................... 4-05n, 4-15s.5(1) ............................................................................................................. 4-15

United Kingdom Secondary LegislationCivil Procedure Rules

Rule 25(1)(b) ............................................................................................13-83nInquiry Rules 2006 (SI No 1838) .................................................................5-55n

s.13(1) .........................................................................................................5-55n