53
All rights reserved • Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review • Hart Energy Consulting • CABI www.hartenergyconsulting.com October 2010 Prepared By: Hart Energy Consulting CABI Hart Energy Consulting 1616 S. Voss, Suite 1000 Houston, Texas 77057, USA CABI Head Office Nosworthy Way Wallingford, Oxfordshire OX10 8DE, United Kingdom Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review

Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

All rights reserved • Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review • Hart Energy Consulting • CABI

www.hartenergyconsulting.com

October 2010

Prepared By:

Hart Energy ConsultingCABI

Hart Energy Consulting1616 S. Voss, Suite 1000Houston, Texas 77057, USA

CABI Head OfficeNosworthy WayWallingford, OxfordshireOX10 8DE, United Kingdom

Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review

Page 2: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32
Page 3: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

1 Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010

Table of ConTenTsI. ExecutiveSummary...........................................................................................................2

Introduction:.Why.Is.Biofuels.LUC.Important?........................................................................3

2. LandUseImplicationsofIncreasedBiofuelProduction............................................6Bringing.Land.That.Is.Not.in.Agricultural.Use.into.Production.................................................7Replacing.Existing.Crops.with.Biofuels...................................................................................8Cultivating.Degraded,.Abandoned.Land.or.Land.That.Is.Considered.Marginal.......................8Intensifying.Land.Use.without.Reducing.Crop.Production......................................................9Conclusion.............................................................................................................................11

3. BiofuelsFeedstockLCAs,EnergyBalanceandCarbonFootprint:HowItRelatestoILUC..................................................................11Biofuels.LCAs........................................................................................................................11Energy.Balance......................................................................................................................13Carbon.Footprint....................................................................................................................13Conclusion.............................................................................................................................16

4. AdditionalEnvironmentalImpactsLinkedtoILUC..................................................17Biodiversity.Concerns............................................................................................................17Potential.Impacts.on.Water.Resources.................................................................................18Conclusion.............................................................................................................................19

5. ExamplesofSelectBiofuelsILUCStudies..................................................................19The.Many.Approaches.to.Modelling.ILUC.............................................................................19The.Searchinger.Analysis.of.Biofuels.ILUC...........................................................................21Conclusion.............................................................................................................................23

6. RegulatoryandLegislativeActionsUndertakentoControlILUCfromBiofuels.......................................................................................23European.Union:.Renewable.Energy.Directive......................................................................23United.Kingdom:.Renewable.Transport.Fuel.Obligation........................................................25United.States:.Renewable.Fuels.Standard.Program.............................................................26California:.Low-Carbon.Fuels.Standard..................................................................................27Conclusion.............................................................................................................................28

7. OtherPolicyApproachesthatAddressBiofuelsILUCConcerns...........................29Brazil......................................................................................................................................29China......................................................................................................................................30India.......................................................................................................................................31Malaysia.................................................................................................................................31The.Philippines......................................................................................................................32Conclusion.............................................................................................................................33

8. ILUCandPotentialImplicationsfortheEmergingGlobalBiofuelsMarket.......34Ethanol.Outlook.to.2020........................................................................................................34Biodiesel.Outlook.to.2020.....................................................................................................35

9. Conclusion:BalancingtheRisksandUncertainties.................................................38

10.Acknowledgement...........................................................................................................41

Page 4: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010 2

I. exeCuTIve summaryNever.before.has.humanity.had.to.think.so.carefully.about.how.it.uses.land..Until.recent.times,.there.has.been.a.widespread.assumption.that.there.are.always.new.lands.available,.with.no.long.term.global.consequences.for.exploiting.them...This.era.has.now.ended...As.the.world’s.popula-tion.and.consequently,.food.and.energy.needs,.increases,.so.does.the.pressure.on.land.to.meet.these.needs...With.specific.respect.to.biofuels,.as.production.continues.to.grow.in.response.to.demand,.the.pressure.to.expand.feedstock.crop-growing.areas.continues.to.grow.as.well...This.in.turn.leads.to.the.possibility.of.land.use.changes.

It.is.the.purpose.of.this.paper.to.provide.a.concise.review.and.summary.of.land.use.change.(LUC).issues.specifically.as.it.relates.to.the.increasing.production.and.consumption.of.biofuels..This.paper.attempts.to.summarise,.add.insight.and.provide.understanding.of.the.complexities.of.these.issues.from.a.scientific.and.policy.standpoint.in.a.very.brief.manner.

This.paper. is.not.a.scientific.study.and.does.not.provide.a.comprehensive.overview.of.all.the.mounting.analyses.that.have.been.conducted.in.this.area..It.does not.advocate.a.particular.position.be.taken.on.the.issue...In.addition,.this.paper.does.not.address.other.issues.that.have.been.raised.in.the.context.of.the.current.discussions.surrounding.LUC.though.we.acknowledge.them.here..For.example,.the.question.has.been.raised.about.properly.allocating.LUC.to.biofuels.feedstock.crops.versus.non-biofuels.crops...Stakeholders.have.questioned.why.LUC.should.be.addressed.for.biofuels.and.not.other.economic.activities,.including.fossil.fuels..

Rather,.we.have.selected.key.studies.and.analyses.that.have.been.peer reviewed.to.present.examples.and.highlight.the.biofuels.LUC.issues.at.hand..This.paper.has.been.peer.reviewed.by.a.diverse.and.select.group.of.experts.and.we.are.most.grateful.to.them.for.their.time,.feedback.and.assistance.in.developing.this.paper...For.those.readers.interested.in.further.study.of.biofuels.LUC,.a.comprehensive.bibliography.of.sources.is.available.both.at.the.back.of.this.paper.and.further.documentation.can.be.found.online.through.the.Biofuels.Information.Exchange,.located.on.the.web.at:.http://biofuelexperts.ning.com/...A.forum.for.discussion.is.available.on.the.same.site...As.the.current.body.of.work.on.biofuels.LUC.expands,.we.invite.authors.to.contribute.their.work.there.

LUC.is.a.complex.process.caused.by.the.interaction.of.natural.and.social.systems.at.different.temporal.and.spatial.scales.(Rindfuss.et.al.2004).and.large.numbers.of.variables.are.required.to.be.input;.for.example,.landholders’.experience,.family.structure,.economic.and.technical.resources.and.the.socioeconomic.context...LUC.and.LUC.patterns.are.created.by.actors.and.they.interact.and.collaborate.in.a.variety.of.contexts.(as.individuals,.families,.communities,.or.corporations).(Robiglio.et.al.2003)..LUC.can.be.sub-divided.into:

n. Direct.LUC.(DLUC),.which.occurs.in situ.which.results.from.a.commercial.decision.as.part.of.a.specific.supply.chain.for.a.specific.product.e.g..if.a.field.is.changed.from.growing.wheat.to.oil.seed.rape,.and

n. Indirect.LUC.(ILUC),.where.other.land.is.changed.as.a.consequence.of.the.direct.change..For.example,.if.less.wheat.is.grown,.other.lands.may.be.pressed.into.service.to.supply.the.shortfall..This.could.include.LUC.in.another.country.or.continent.

Figure.1.presents.a.diagrammatic.view.of.DLUC.and.ILUC.

If.there.are.unutilized.agricultural.lands.available.then.ILUC.may.be.mostly.uncontroversial..Another.uncontroversial.option.is.to.increase.output.on.the.same.land.by.increasing.crops.yields.and/or.using.lands.in.new.ways.(e.g..double-cropping,.pasture.intensification,.etc.)...The.problem.arises.when.other.lands,.including.forest.and.savannah,.are.pressed.into.service.which.may.re-sult.in.increase.in.greenhouse.gas.(GHG).emissions,.as.well.as.ecosystem.service.losses..The.

Page 5: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

3 Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010

concern.about.ILUC.is.fundamentally.about.the.sheer.scale.of.production.that.may.be.expected.of.the.biofuel.industry.if.it.is.to.contribute.significantly.to.reducing.GHG.

Serious.consideration.of.biofuel-related.ILUC.is.a.new.phenomenon.that.was.spurred.by.a.paper.by.Searchinger.et.al.(2008)..Before.that,.LCAs.of.the.“well-to-wheel”.type.were.mostly.attributional,.i.e.,.consisting.of.a.linear.chain-like.series.of.analytical.steps,.which.did.not.carry.out.a.consequential.analysis,.i.e.,.an.assessment.of.nonlinear.feedback-like.effects..The.Searchinger.paper.suggested.that.when.including.ILUC,.the.previously.favourable.GHG-saving.crops.of.maize.and.cellulosic.ethanol.systems.turned.into.net.producers.of.GHG.emissions...For.those.govern-ments.looking.to.biofuels.as.a.strategy.(among.others).to.reduce.GHG.emissions,.the.Searchinger.paper.raised.serious.concerns.and.new.efforts.were.launched,.particularly.in.the.U.S..and.Europe,.to.study.biofuels.LUC.

Introduction: Why Is biofuels luC Important?

Biofuels.can.be.solid,.liquid,.or.gaseous.and.are.derived.from.biomass.that.can.be.combusted.to.produce.heat.or.power...The.current.focus.on.biofuels.is.on.those.that.can.be.used.as.trans-portation.fuel.in.internal.combustion.engines..These.include.bioethanol.from.starch.and.sugar.crops.such.as.sugar.cane,.maize,.sorghum,.cassava,.sweet.potato;.biodiesels.from.soy.oil,.palm.oil,.jatropha,.pongamia,.oil.seed.rape.(canola),.and.waste.oils;.sources.of.lignin-cellulose.such.as.switch.grass,.miscanthus,.crop.residues,.tree.prunings;.algal.fuels...

The.majority.of.biofuels.currently.produced.are.from.maize,.sugar.cane,.soy.oil,.palm.oil.and.oil.seed.rape...Lignin-cellulosic.feedstocks.must.undergo.further.processing.as.they.need.to.be.first.processed.to.sugars,.either.by.heating.with.acid.or.converted.using.cellulase.enzymes.extracted.from.fungi..Algal.biofuels,.at.an.earlier.developmental.stage.than.cellulosics,.may.have.promise.since.they.could.be.grown.on.waste.land,.using.waste.carbon.dioxide.and.waste.water..Into.the.future,.more.investments.in.cellulosic.and.algal.biofuels.are.expected.(DBCCA.2009)..

figure 1: a diagrammatic explanation of IluC (after bauen and Howes in Woods, 2009).

Direct land use change

Indirect land use change

Page 6: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010 4

Biofuels.feedstocks.are.highly.diverse.in.their.input.requirements,.alternative.uses.and.climatic.requirements.and.are.grown.in.many.different.contexts.globally..LCAs.of.different.biofuel.crops.reveal.large.differences.in.yields,.climatic.requirements,.energy.balances,.and.water.and.carbon.footprints...This.review.will.focus.on.the.production.of.agricultural.crops.or.feedstocks.suitable.for.bioethanol.and.biodiesel.production.because.these.compete.with.land,.energy.and.water.use.for.food.production...Crops.that.can.be.used.as.biofuels.are.listed.in.Table.1,.with.the.temperature.and.water.requirements.as.well.as.their.alternate.food.values...It.should.be.noted.that.the.figures.in.the.table.do.not.indicate.optimal.conditions,.which.may.be.more.restricted..

Common name Genus sp biofuel

type

max temp (oC)

min temp (oC)

max rainfall (mm/annum)

min rainfall (mm/annum)

protein value

edible oil value

edible carbohydrate

Oilseed rape Brassica napus D 40 6 1500 400 high

Linseed Linum usitatissimum D 32 4 1300 250 medium

Field mustard Sinapis alba D 27 7 1200 600

Hemp Cannabis sativa D,S 28 5 1500 600

Sunflower Helianthus annus D 39 15 1500 350 high

Safflower Carthamus tintorius D 45 20 1300 400 high

Castor Ricinus communis D 38 17 2000 500

Olive Olea europea D 42 7 1300 200 low high

Groundnut Arachis hypogaea D 45 19 2000 450 high high

Sweet potato

Ipomoea batatas E 45 17 1400 750 low high

Cassava Manihot esculenta E 45 18 5000 500 low (leaves) high

Barley Hordeum vulgare E,S 35 8 2000 250 high high high

Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high

Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high highRye Secale cereale E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high

Potato Solanun tuberosum E 25 5 1500 500 medium high

Sugar beet Beta vulgaris E 25 5 1500 500 high

Sugarcane Saccharum officinarun E 41 16 > 4000 1000 high

Sorghum Sorghum bicolor S,E 40 16 700 300 medium high

Maize Zea mays S,E 40 9 2000 450 high highReed canary

grassPhalaris

arundinacea S 38 1 2000 600

Miscanthus Miscanthus spp. S 40 11 1500 600

Eucalyptus Eucalyptus globulus S,D 36 6 2500 400

Eucalyptus Eucalyptus camaldulensis S 36 7 2500 400

Eucalyptus Eucalyptus grandis S 36 10 2500 400

Jatropha Jatropha curcas D 2000 300African oil

palmElaeis

guineensis D 3000 1000 high

Pongamia Pongamia pinnata D 2000 300

Table 1: Climatic requirements of crops that can be used as biofuels, noting values as foodstuffs (adapted from Tuck et al 2006) Key: D biodiesel; s solid biofuel; e, bioethanol.

Page 7: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

5 Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010

As.it.pertains.specifically.to.biofuels,.an.ILUC.impact.may.be.triggered.when.an.increase.in.the.demand.for.a.crop-based.biofuel.begins.to.drive.up.prices.for.the.necessary.feedstock.crop...This.price.increase.causes.farmers.to.devote.a.larger.proportion.of.their.cultivated.acreage.to.that.feed-stock.crop..Supplies.of.the.displaced.food.and.feed.commodities.subsequently.decline,.leading.to.higher.prices.for.those.commodities..In.the.past,.many.farmers.have.brought.non-agricultural.lands.into.production.as.a.low-cost,.high-benefit.option.to.take.advantage.of.higher.commodity.prices..These.land.use.conversions.release.the.carbon.sequestered.in.soils.and.vegetation..The.resulting.carbon.emissions.constitute.the.ILUC.impact.of.increased.biofuel.production...The.land.use.conversions.may.also.lead.to.a.loss.of.ecosystem.functions.(e.g..biodiversity.loss).

Based.on.the.work.done.to.date,.and.in.particular.the.last.two.to.three.years,.crop-based.bio-fuels.may.contribute.to.some.ILUC.impacts...It.is.not.clear.what.the.magnitude.of.the.impact.actually.is.due.to.the.complexity.of.the.issues.involved.in.assessing.LUC.generally.and.ILUC.spe-cifically...The.tools.for.estimating.and.analysing.ILUC.impacts.from.biofuels.are.few.and.relatively.new...And,.the.ranges.of.analyses.conducted.have.produced.varying.results.that.are.dependent.on.the.assumptions.used...Because.of.this.evident.complexity,.it.is.worth.noting.some.of.the.uncertainties,.even.though.they.are.difficult.to.rank.and.quantify,.and.though.some.are.more.important.than.others:.

n. Much.of.the.biofuel.yields.data.is.too.inaccurate.to.calculate.potential.GHG.effects,.energy.ratios.and.profits.

n. Energy.return.on.energy.invested.(EROI),.a.fundamental.issue.that.has.been.insufficiently.researched.

n. Marginal.and.abandoned.lands.and.the.extent.to.which.they.can.both.be.identified.and.re-habilitated...In.fact,.a.common.definition.for.marginal.land.does.not.currently.exist.(UNEP.2009).

n. The.extent.to.which.any.newly.exploited.land.will.be.needed.for.food.and.the.extent.to.which.old.land.can.be.made.more.productive.

n. The.use.of.fertilizers.and.the.optimal.amount.to.use.to.minimize.GHG.releases,.especially.of.nitrous.oxide?

n. Uncertainties.about.indirect.effects..The.Searchinger.et.al.(2008).paper,.despite.numerous.criticisms,.revealed.a.potential.flaw.in.our.understanding.of.biofuels.LUC.and.created.new.discussion.about.the.importance.of.carefully.considering.biofuels.DLUC.and.ILUC..As.this.may.include.cross-border.effects,.the.complexities.of.estimating.the.effects.are.obvious.

n. Soil.carbon.loss.and.sequestration,.which.depends.greatly.on.the.soils.in.question.and.how.the.land.is.farmed.

n. Uncertainties.in.the.science.itself.which.has.been.outpaced.by.biofuels.commercialization.and.scale-up.over.the.last.several.years.

n. A.lack.of.a.broad.interdisciplinary.approach.to.the.subject..We.understand.for.instance.that.LCA.scientists.had.recognized.the.ILUC.problem,.but.avoided.it.because.of.the.problems.of.indeterminacy.

As.the.biofuels.LUC.issue.has.come.to.the.fore,.governments.have.pressed.forward.with.set-ting.and.implementing.mandatory.biofuels.programs..By.end.of.2010,.approximately.39.countries.have.already. implemented.or.are.preparing.to. implement.mandatory.biofuels.programs.(Hart.2010).and.most.do.not.address.biofuels.LUC...Several.governments.have.attempted.to.address.LUC.concerns.in.their.biofuels.programs,.and.have.undertaken.their.own.biofuels.LUC.analyses...They.have.ultimately.concluded.that.the.uncertainties.involved.should.not.prevent.the.develop-ment.and.implementation.of.policy.that.“factors.in”.biofuels.ILUC...

Some.governments.have.instituted.an.“ILUC.penalty”.or.“ILUC.factor”.in.their.biofuels.pro-grams.to.account.for.the.GHG.emissions.caused.by.ILUC.of.certain.biofuels.feedstocks...The.introduction.of.an.ILUC.factor.is.meant.to.disincentivise.the.use.of.biofuels.that.may.cause.ILUC.such.as.deforestation.and.allocate.poorer.GHG.savings.to.these.specific.biofuels..Notably,.some.governments.in.structuring.their.biofuels.programs.have.not.implemented.an.“ILUC.factor”.but.

Page 8: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010 6

have.set.policies.that.address.land.use.management.and.best.agricultural.practice.for.biofuels.feedstock.crops...Notably,.many.of.these.governments.set.these.policies.in.conjunction.with.their.biofuels.programs.and.began.to.address.issues.related.to.LUC.and.biofuels.before.ILUC.became.a.significant.topic.of.discussion.in.the.biofuels.world.

As.most.of.the.biofuels.policies.that.include.an.“ILUC.factor”.are.currently.being.implemented,.it.is.not.clear.at.this.time.whether.such.factor.will.actually.result.in.reducing.ILUC...As.an.example,.an.ILUC.factor.that.disfavours.the.use.of.palm.oil.as.a.biodiesel.feedstock.will.not.necessarily.curtail.the.use.of.palm.oil.globally.nor.prevent.the.effects.that.have.been.associated.to.palm.oil.production.growth.(e.g..deforestation.and.biodiversity.loss)...The.palm.oil.may.not.be.used.for.biofuels.production.and.consumption.in.the.country.with.the.ILUC.factor.policy.in.place,.but.could.be.used.in.a.country.that.does.not.have.such.a.policy...Moreover,.such.a.policy.would.not.likely.curtail.the.use.of.palm.oil.as.an.important.global.food.commodity.

Even.so,.the.way.in.which.land.is.allocated.and.used.has.become.important.as.never.before.especially.as.population,.income.and.consequently,.food.and.energy.demand,.increases.in.the.coming.years...Note.that.while.biofuels.provided.just.1.8%.of.the.world’s.transport.fuel.in.2007.(UNEP.2009),.this.is.expected.to.increase...According.to.the.International.Energy.Agency.(IEA),.biofuels.are.projected.to.represent.9%.of.total.transport.fuel.demand.in.2030.(IEA.2009)...De-mand.for.petroleum.products.is.expected.to.grow.1.6%.per.year.through.2030.(Hart.2009)...For.many.stakeholders.and.policymakers,.this.is.why.biofuels.LUC.is.important.to.consider...

This.paper.is.structured.to.address.in.brief.the.following.topics:n. Land.use.implications.of.increased.biofuel.productionn. Biofuels.feedstock.LCAs,.energy.balance.and.carbon.footprint:.how.it.relates.to.ILUCn. Additional.environmental.impacts.related.to.ILUCn. Examples.of.select.biofuels.ILUC.studiesn. Regulatory.and.legislative.actions.undertaken.to.control.ILUC.from.biofuelsn. Other.legislative.and.regulatory.approaches.that.address.ILUCn. ILUC.and.the.emerging.global.biofuels.market

The.review.concludes.with.some.recommendations.for.next.steps...These.recommendations.include.more.experimentation.and.modelling,.which.is.already.occurring;.the.establishment.of.standard.methodologies.to.evaluate.LUC.from.biofuels;.quantifying.available.marginal.land;.and,.establishing.effective.land.use.management.and.best.agriculture.practice.policies.for.biofuels.feedstock.crops...We.also.suggest.the.development.of.a.knowledge.product.or.tool.kit.to.help.interested.countries.plan.rationally.for.the.future.as.they.develop.their.biofuels.programs...

2. lanD use ImplICaTIons of InCreaseD bIofuel proDuCTIonLand.use.implications.of.increased.biofuel.production.will.depend.on.the.crop.grown.and.the.context.in.which.it.is.grown...With.specific.respect.to.biofuels,.as.production.continues.to.grow.in.response.to.demand,.the.pressure.to.expand.feedstock.crop-growing.areas.continues.to.grow.as.well...This.in.turn.leads.to.the.possibility.of.LUC.(both.DLUC.and.ILUC).that.in.the.biofuels.context.may.include.the.following.scenarios...Biofuel.feedstock.crops.may.be.grown.by:

n. Bringing.land.that.is.not.in.agricultural.use.into.production;.n. Replacing.existing.food.and.fibre.crops.with.biofuels.feedstock.crops;n. Cultivating.degraded,.abandoned.land.or.land.that.is.considered.marginal;n. Intensifying.land.use.without.reducing.crop.production,.including.improving.yields,.technolo-

gies.and.integrating.agriculture.and.livestock.production.

None.of.these.scenarios.present.easy.solutions.to.the.complex.issue.of.LUC,.even.for.the.last.two.scenarios.concerning.new,.non-food.feedstocks.and.increasing.yields.on.existing.lands....

Page 9: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

7 Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010

According.to.the.Millennium.Ecosystem.Assessment.(MEA.2005).nearly.all.of.the.world’s.suitable.land.is.already.under.cultivation:.“Although.Africa.and.Latin.America.contain.the.majority.of.the.world’s.remaining.stock.of.potentially.cultivatable.lands,.most.of.this.currently.supports.rain.forest.and.grassland.savannas.that.provide.many.other.ecosystem.services.and.are.crucial.habitats.for.fauna.and.flora.in.natural.ecosystems”.(Bruinsma.2003).

bringing land That Is not in agricultural use into production

Campbell.et.al.(2008).estimated.the.global.potential.for.bioenergy.on.abandoned.agriculture.lands.to.be.less.than.8%.of.current.primary.energy.demand..In.the.case.of.developing.countries,.Young.(1999).concluded.that.the.major.assessments.by.international.bodies.and.research.organizations.greatly.over-estimate.the.extent.of.spare.land,.that.is,.land.available.for.cultivation.but.presently.uncultivated..The.reasons.given.are:

n. An.over-estimation.of.the.extent.of.cultivable.land,.through.inclusion.of.hills.and.other.un-cultivable.areas,.that.are.individually.small.but.of.substantial.total.extent;

n. An.under-estimation.of.land.already.cultivated,.statistics.for.which.are.demonstrably.of.great.unreliability;

n. Failure.to.take.sufficient.notice.of.the.considerable.requirements.of.other.land.uses,.notably.water.supply,.nature.conservation,.human.settlements,.and.forest.

Making.speculative.adjustments.to.allow.for.each.of.these.causes,.Young.found.that.a.sup-posed.land.balance.of.50%.is.reduced.to.one.of.between.3%.and.25%.of.the.present.cultivable.land..If.this.is.correct,.as.an.order.of.magnitude,.then.estimates.of.the.total.spare.land.in.the.developing.world,.and.those.for.individual.countries,.should.be.reduced.to.half.or.less.the.values.given.by.current.estimates...We.note,.however,.this.is.still.a.significant.area.

The.MEA.notes.that.in.many.parts.of.North.America,.Europe,.Japan.and.China,.where.produc-tivity.has.grown.faster.than.demand,.land.is.increasingly.being.withdrawn.from.cultivation...On.a.global.basis,.there.has.been.a.steady.decrease.in.area.devoted.to.the.major.cereal.crops,.maize,.rice.and.wheat,.which.account.for.the.majority.of.calories.in.human.diets,.amounting.to.2.4.mil-lion.ha/year.(Mha).since.1980...Kampman.et.al.(2008).concur,.estimating.there.is.a.large.potential.of.idle.land,.especially.in.Russia,.Ukraine.and.Kazakhstan.where.over.the.last.15.years.almost.23.Mha.of.arable.land.became.idle.as.a.result.of.the.breakup.of.the.Soviet.Union..Also.in.the.United.States.(9.Mha).and.Europe,.idle.land.increased,.aimed.at.limiting.production.or.ensuring.more.sustainable.land.use.

Using.an.agro-ecological.zones.approach.on.the.other.hand,.Fischer.et.al.(2002)..found.that,.at.the.global.level,.the.Earth’s.land,.climate,.and.biological.resources.are.ample.to.meet.food,.pasture,.fodder.and.fibre.needs.of.future.generations,.in.particular,.for.a.world.population.of.9.3.billion,.as.projected.in.the.United.Nations.medium.variant.for.the.year.2050..Despite.this.positive.aggregate.global.picture.though,.they.discovered.reasons.for.profound.concern.in.several.regions.and.coun-tries.with.limited.land.and.water.resources..However,.Haugen.(2010).strongly.argues.that.these.estimates,.as.well.as.the.figures.produced.in.a.United.Nations.Food.and.Agriculture.Organization.(FAO).study.(FAO,.1995).cannot.be.considered.to.be.sufficiently.accurate.or.ecologically.justifiable.to.be.applied.as.a.basis.for.national.strategies.on.land.policies,.either.in.agriculture.or.forestry.

Smeets.et.al.(2007).estimated.that.between.730.Mha.up.to.3.6.Gha.of.agricultural.land.might.become.available.in.2050,.as.a.result.of.advancement.of.agricultural.technology.for.food.produc-tion,.representing.the.technical.potential.to.increase.the.efficiency.of.food.production..But.achiev-ing.the.high.side.of.this.range.would.require.a.very.drastic.change.of.global.agriculture,.including.for.example. landless.animal.production,.genetically.modified.organisms.and. implementation..of.the.best.available.technologies.as.well.as.very.high.levels.of.irrigation..In.addition,.there.is.uncertainty.about.future.impacts.of.climate.change.and.need.for.adaptation..

Page 10: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010 8

It.is.also.worth.noting.that.in.recent.years.there.already.are.increasing.claims.on.tropical.land.for.widespread.biofuels.plantations..In.a.review.by.FAO.and.the.International.Institute.for.Environ-ment.and.Development,.Cotula.et.al.(2009).report.that.GEM.Biofuels.plc.gained.exclusive.rights.for.50.years.over.453.Mha.in.Southern.Madagascar.to.plant.jatropha.for.biodiesel.production.whilst.UK.energy.company.CAMS.Group.have.acquired.a.lease.over.45.Mha.of.land.in.Tanzania.for.investments.in.sweet.sorghum.production.for.biofuels,.whether.these.are.”new”.or.exist-ing.agricultural.lands.is.far.from.clear,.nor.who.is.presently.occupying.them.or.what.ecosystem.services.they.provide...

replacing existing Crops with biofuels

If.biofuel.feedstock.production.becomes.profitable.for.farmers.they.may.switch.their.produc-tion.from.their.current.cropping.regime..This.potential.scenario.has.raised.international.concern.given.that.one.billion.people.are.still.food-insecure.(FAO.2009),.global.consumption.of.grains.and.oilseeds.has.exceeded.production.in.seven.out.of.the.first.eight.years.of.the.21st.century.and.the.global.stocks-to-use.ratio.has.reduced.from.30%.to.less.than.15%,.the.lowest.since.1970.(Trostle.2008)..

However,.the.impact.on.food.security.would.depend.on.the.crop.replaced..For.example,.coffee.is.grown.on.more.than.11.Mha.in.the.tropics,.often.by.smallholder.farmers.(Waller.et.al.2007),.coffee.at.the.lower.altitude.margins.will.be.replaced.as.climate.change.induced.temperature.rise.continues.and.some.of.this.could.be.turned.over.to.biofuels,.which.could.be.a.more.sustainable.alternative.than.beef.pasture..Nevertheless,.demand.for.coffee.remains.strong,.and.substitution.would.result.in.increasing.levels.of.deforestation.elsewhere,.especially.in.Southeast.Asia.(e.g..Vietnam,. Indonesia,.Laos),.which.means.that.direct.replacement.of.one.crop.by.another.still.causes.ILUC..

Cultivating Degraded, abandoned land or land That Is Considered marginal

It.has.been.claimed.that.some.biofuel.crops.can.be.grown.on.marginal.land,.under.low.rainfall.conditions,.otherwise.unsuitable.for.arable.production,.and.may.have.the.potential.to.improve.soil.properties..Two.examples.often.cited.of.this.potential.are.Pongamia pinnata, native.to.India,.and.Jatropha curcas, native.to.Central.America...Both.are.being.investigated.as.potential.biodiesel.feedstocks. .An.appealing.possibility.for.these.biofuels.feedstocks.is.that.as.hardy.species,.they.might.grow.extensively.on.marginal.or.degraded.land,.with.poor.soils,.low.rainfall.and.with.low.agronomic.inputs.yet.still.yield.enough.to.turn.a.profit.from.those.picking.it...

For.example,.much.of.the.interest.in.jatropha.stems.from.early.work.on.the.crop.in.Mali,.India.and.a.few.other.semi-arid.regions,.where.the.plant.is.common.and.habitually.used.for.hedges.to.protect.farm.plots.from.intrusion.by.wildlife.and.cattle.(Heller.1996;.Francis.et.al.2005)..However,.some.recent.reports.of.the.plant’s.ability.to.yield.well.in.such.conditions.are.disappointing.(Brit-taine.and.Lutaladio.2010)..It.appears.that.jatropha.will.survive.in.marginal.conditions,.but.data.are.lacking.to.prove.that.it.can.be.commercially.successful.under.such.conditions,.particularly.in.large-scale.plantations.(Sanderson.2009)..

In.reality,.jatropha.may.be.more.economically.and.environmentally.viable.in.small-scale,.com-munity-based.jatropha.plantations,.agroforestry.systems.with.jatropha.intercropping,.and.agro-silvo-pastoral.systems.(Achten.et.al.2010)..Rural.communities.relying.on.fuel.wood.and.expensive.fossil.fuel.as.energy.source.can.substitute.these.with.jatropha.oil,.which.is.easily.and.locally.extractable.with.cheap.technology.(Achten.et.al.2008)..The.use.of.jatropha.in.low.input.systems.for.small-scale.Jatropha.oil.production.offers.additional.advantages,.such.as.a.diversification.of.the.farmers’.income.sources,.the.reduction.of.soil.erosion,.the.use.of.woody.by-products.and.

Page 11: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

9 Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010

seed.cakes.as.combustible.or.soil.amendment.and.the.use.of.jatropha.hedges.as.living.fences.(Achten.et.al.2010)...

Other.feedstock.crops.suitable.for.bioethanol.production.that.can.be.grown.on.marginal.land.include.sweet.cassava.and.sweet.potato.(Ziska.et.al.2009.and.Ou.et.al.2010)..These.crops.are.grown.in.the.U.S..and.China.and.are.also.staple.foods.in.many.parts.of.the.tropics..However,.growing.root.crops.on.marginal.land.implies.substantial.soil.disturbance,.which.leads.to.greater.risk.of.soil.erosion.and.release.of.soil.carbon;.modern.zero.tillage.methods.are.preferable.but.not.applicable.in.the.case.of.root.crops..Otherwise,.perennial.crops.with.established.root.systems.and.low.soil.disturbance.may.be.more.appropriate.for.marginal.conditions.where.soils.will.often.be.poor.and.loose.

Intensifying land use without reducing Crop production

In.many.parts.of.the.world,.agricultural.systems.are.extensive.with.low.crop.densities,.no.external.inputs,.fallows.and.low.crop.yields.–.this.especially.is.the.case.for.poor.farmers..When.population.pressure.increases.and.market.access.improves,.these.drivers.motivate.people.to.change.their.production.systems.(Boserup.1965;.Binswanger.and.McIntire.1987),.particularly.when.pressure.is.so.high.that.there.is.no.available.uncultivated.area.to.expand.into.or.farmers.do.not.have.access.to.it.because.of.ownership.issues..Studies.have.shown.that.intensification.is.the.outcome.with.a.transition.to.greater.resource.use.and.higher.yields.(Demont.et.al.2007)..

Methods.include.using.innovations.such.as.animal.traction,.integration.of.crops.and.livestock,.improved.cropping.techniques,.and.use.of.external.inputs.(pesticides.and.fertilisers)..Other.tech-niques.not.reliant.on.purchased.inputs.include.live.mulch.systems,.i.e..rapidly.growing.herba-ceous.Leguminosae,.which.are.regularly.slashed,.and.grown.in.synchrony.with.the.crop..The.legumes.fix.nitrogen,.maintain.ground.cover,.control.weeds.and.increase.soil.phosphorus.avail-ability.(Lathwell.1990)..Examples.are.different.varieties.of.Mucuna pruriens.subsp..utilis, Pueraria phaseloides.and.Psophocarpus palustris...Systems.achieve.increased.nutrient.recycling.and.use-efficiency.through.N-fixation,.a.deep-reaching.root.system.and.by.producing.biomass.during.the.dry.season..When.such.legumes.are.incorporated,.fallow.lengths.can.be.reduced.so.yields.also.increase.over.time..In.some.cases,.intensification.has.led.to.improved.natural.resource.use.fertil-ity.(Tiffen.and.Mortimore.1994)..

Under.these.circumstances,.biofuel.production.could,.hypothetically,.make.complementary.use.of.land,.water.and.labour.resources,.increasing.overall.efficiency.(Ziska.et.al.2009)...For.example,.smallholder.farmers.could.grow.biofuel.crops.alongside.food.crops..This.could.increase.cash.flow,.thus.permitting.input.purchase,.agricultural.intensification.and.higher.yields..The.fuel,.if.locally.processed,.could.create.an.affordable.source.of.energy.to.semi-mechanize.crop.systems,.reduc-ing.labour.requirements.in.systems.where.labour.is.a.limiting.factor..

Thus.intercropping.biofuel.crops.with.food.crops.or.integrating.perennial.biofuels.into.existing.cultivation.systems.might.allow.the.development.of.fuel-food.systems.that.increase.resource.use.efficiency.through.spatial.or.temporal.integration,.but.data.on.this.are.lacking..Work.on.intercrop-ping.systems.can.exploit.a.greater.amount.of.limited.growth.factors.when.grown.together.than.when.apart,.particularly.if.components.have.different.architectures.and./.or.resource.demand.peaks.at.different.times.in.the.growing.season.(Midmore.1993)..Furthermore,.if.farmers.intercrop.a.biofuel.with.a.crop.where.they.commonly.apply.fertilizers,.or.use.land.fertilized.during.the.last.cycle,.the.biofuel.may.inadvertently.benefit.through.a.residual.fertilizer.effect.

Problems.lie.in.commercialization.and.this.includes.the.difficulty.of.assessing.quality.of.feed-stock. from.so.many.small. farms.as.well. as. the.collection.problem,.especially. for.bulky. raw.material.where.considerable.energy.has.to.be.expended.to.gather.enough.together.to.make.it.

Page 12: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010 10

profitable.to.process..These.and.other.problems.(e.g..the.implied.shift.to.a.more.knowledge-intensive.production.mode).lie.in.the.path.of.intensification.for.most.smallholders..For.plantations.on.the.other.hand,.gains.in.productivity.can.be.expected..There.is.a.lack.of.data.that.quantify.this.gain,.so.further.data.collection.is.needed.to.assess.the.potential.impact.of.land.intensification.on.food.crop.vs..biofuel.feedstock.crop.production.

Potentially.the.most.likely.biofuel.feedstock.for.a.low.input.system.could.be.those.derived.from.low-input.high-diversity.(LIHD).mixtures.of.native.grassland.perennials...According.to.Til-man.et.al.(2006).such.a.system.can.provide.more.usable.energy,.greater.GHG.reductions,.and.less.agrichemical.pollution.per.hectare.than.can.maize.grain.ethanol.or.soybean.biodiesel..They.found.that.high-diversity.grasslands.developed.increasingly.higher.bioenergy.yields.that.were.238%.greater.than.monoculture.yields.after.a.decade..Moreover,.LIHD.biofuels.can.be.produced.on.agriculturally.degraded.lands.and.thus.need.to.neither.displace.food.production.nor.cause.loss.of.biodiversity.via.habitat.destruction...An.important.caveat.here.is.to.determine.and.define.the.nature.of.degraded.lands,.since.many.lands.of.this.type.are.still.a.wildlife.refuge.and.in.developing.countries,.used.by.nomadic.pastoralists,.for.example.

In.temperate.areas,.high. input.agriculture. is.the.norm.using. inorganic.fertilizer,.pesticides,.mechanisation.and.thus.energy..Comprehensive.statistics.on.comparative.yields.by.crop.are.avail-able.from.FAO..Bondeau.et.al.(2007).assessed.FAO.data.on.country.average.maize.grain.yields,.divided.by.climatic.zone..They.found.that.yields.were.highest.in.warm.temperate.areas,.depend-ing.on.input.level,.ranging.from.3.5.Mg.ha-1.in.Turkey.to.approximately.9.Mg.ha-1.in.Greece...For.cool.temperate.areas,.yields.presented.were.from.4.Mg.ha-1.in.China.to.more.than.7.5.Mg.ha-1.in.Switzerland..Yields.in.tropical.areas.varied.from.0.75.Mg.ha-1.in.the.Democratic.Republic.of.Congo.to.2.5.Mg.ha-1.in.Thailand.

Notably,.yields.and.requirements.for.biofuel.crops.vary.widely.over.different.production.sys-tems.and.regions..But.mere.data.about.yields.is.of.little.use.when.considering.biofuels,.what.we.now.need.to.know.is.the.maximal.yield.per.unit.of.GHG.produced..A.recent.paper.by.Melillo.et.al.(2009).indicates.that.nitrous.oxide.release.from.fertilizer.use.is.the.most.serious.problem.of.GHG.balance..Data.are.lacking.on.rates.of.release,.number.of.applications,.formulation.and.other.factors.and.hence.experiments.will.need.to.be.carried.out.to.assess.optimal.applications...Moreover,.Johnston.et.al.(2009).questioned.the.data.frequently.presented.in.biofuels.journals.and.decided.to.compare.this.data.with.their.own.calculations,.based.on.the.best.available.global.agricultural.census.data..They.found.that.biofuel.yield.data.are.often.taken.from.a.single.location,.sometimes.a.yield.trial.and.are.frequently.overestimated.by.100%.or.more..They.conclude.that.”a.more.detailed,.geographically-specific.analysis.of.(actual.and.potential).yields.is.necessary.”..

The.difficulties.of.accurately.estimating.yields.are. further.exacerbated.by. the. likely. future.changes.due.to.climate.change..In.tropical.regions.especially,.many.crop.yields.are.expected.to.decline.due.to.increased.temperature,.increased.pests.and.disease,.more.chaotic.rainfall.and.even.sea.level.rise.(Contribution.of.Working.Group.II.to.the.Fourth.Assessment.Report.of.the.IPCC,.2007)..Indeed,.some.evidence.already.exists.that.yields.have.been.negatively.affected.by.increased.temperatures..Lobell.and.Field.(2007).estimate.that.warming.since.1981.has.resulted.in.annual.combined.losses.in.wheat,.maize.and.barley.crops.representing.roughly.40.million.tons.(Mt).or.$5.billion.per.year.by.2002...A.model.developed.by.Schlenker.and.Roberts.(2009).without.ILUC.effects.suggests.that.area-weighted.average.yields.of.soy.and.maize.will.decrease.by.30–46%.before.the.end.of.the.century.under.the.slowest.(B1).IPCC.warming.scenario.and.decrease.by.63–82%.under.the.most.rapid.warming.scenario.(A1FI,..under.the.Hadley.III.model).

More.generally,.a.recent.report.estimates.that.in.developing.countries,.climate.change.will.cause.yield.declines.for.the.most.important.crops..South.Asia.will.be.particularly.hard.hit...Climate.change.will.have.varying.effects.on.irrigated.yields.across.regions,.but.irrigated.yields.for.all.crops.in.South.Asia.will.experience.large.declines.(Nelson.2009)...Climate.change.will.therefore.cause.

Page 13: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

11 Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010

its.own.ILUC.and.how.this.would.relate.to.biofuel.ILUC.is.difficult.to.imagine.and.is.something.that.is,.as.far.as.we.have.been.able.to.ascertain,.unresearched.

Two.very.recent.papers.highlight.the.potential.and.the.reality:.on.the.one.hand.Burney.et.al.(2010).estimate.that.each.dollar.invested.in.agricultural.yields.has.resulted.in.68.fewer.kgC.(249.kgCO2e).emissions.relative.to.1961.technology.($14.74/tC,.or.$4/tCO2e),.avoiding.3.6.GtC.(13.1.GtCO2e).per.year..Their.analysis.indicates.that.investment.in.yield.improvements.compares.fa-vourably.with.other.commonly.proposed.mitigation.strategies.and.recommend.that.further.yield.improvements.should.be.prominent.among.efforts.to.reduce.future.GHG.emissions..

On.the.other.hand.Gibbs.et.al.(2010).analyze.FAO’s.pan-tropical.Landsat.database.to.exam-ine.pathways.of.agricultural.expansion.across.the.major.tropical.forest.regions.in.the.1980s.and.1990s..Over.that.period,.across.the.tropics,.they.find.that.more.than.55%of.new.agricultural.land.came.at.the.expense.of.intact.forests,.and.another.28%.came.from.disturbed.forests..It.is.therefore.highly.likely.that.considerable.GHG.savings.could.be.made.by.judicious.investment.in.research.and.implementation,.but.equally.likely.that.this.may.not.happen.in.many.places.

Conclusion

There.are.multiple.uncertainties.with.biofuel.land.use,.both.direct.and.indirect..There.are.major.doubts.about.official.estimates.of.available.land,.including.those.classed.as.unused,.abandoned,.degraded.and.marginal..Current.estimates.of.the.land.that.might.be.pressed.into.service.in.the.next.40.years.vary.widely,.by.half.an.order.of.magnitude.and.more..Until.these.discrepancies.are.resolved,.the.various.attempts.to.calculate.and.model.what.will.happen.as.biofuel.production.expands.should.be.regarded.as.extremely.tentative,.otherwise.such.estimates.run.the.risk.of.becoming.accepted.as.the.truth.by.policy.makers..In.such.a.case.as.this,.perhaps.the.lower.range.of.estimates.of.available.land.should.be.adopted.until.more.convincing.data.is.available..

At.the.same.time.it.seems.possible.that.there.would.be.substantial.habitat.destruction,.espe-cially.tropical.rainforest.and.savannah..Leading.environmental.scientists.and.international.organi-zations.such.as.UNEP.all.agree.that.further.destruction.of.these.systems.is.a.major.risk.for.climate.change,.biodiversity.and.ecosystem.services...These.issues.will.be.covered.further.in.Section.5...Substantial.yield.increase.of.existing.agricultural.lands.is.clearly.desirable,.but.in.many.cases.is.by.no.means.a.foregone.conclusion.because.of.the.various.economic,.cultural.and.infrastructure.difficulties.that.lie.in.the.way.of.scaling.up.such.an.outcome,.especially.with.resource-poor.farm-ers.in.developing.countries..On.top.of.this.are.the.uncertainties.of.our.future.climate,.where.more.extremes.(high.temperatures,.droughts,.floods).are.predicted.

3. bIofuels feeDsToCK lCas, energy balanCe anD Carbon fooTprInT: HoW IT relaTes To IluC

biofuels lCas

A.recent.review.by.van.der.Voet.et.al.(2010).of.no.less.than.67.biofuel.LCAs.found.a.range.of.problems..The.studies.do.not.adopt.the.same.functional.units;.some.express.results.in.terms.of.amount.of.energy.contained.in.the.fuel,.others.the.weight.of.the.fuel.or.the.yield.per.unit.area.(e.g..hectare).or.even.a.composite.measure..Such.differences.make.comparison.between.stud-ies.difficult.and.lead.to.major.differences.in.conclusions...Different.allocation.methods.employed.in.the.studies.caused.percentage.GHG.reductions.compared.to.fossil.fuels.to.vary.from.negative.to.above.100%.

Page 14: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010 12

The.authors.also.found.that.the.system.boundaries.vary.between.studies,.reflecting.their.dif-ferent.purposes..Hence.some.are.well-to-wheel,.others.are.well-to-tank,.cradle-to-gate.(where.‘gate’.means.the.final.product.less.costs.of.delivery.to.the.tank).and.even.cradle-to-grave.where.the.whole.transport.system.is.evaluated,.including.the.car.and.the.road..The.latter.is.the.most.complete.and.indeed.is.surely.needed.if.society.is.to.evaluate.the.full.costs.of.our.current.free-wheeling.life.styles..But.by.so.doing,.these.most.comprehensive.studies.tend.to.reduce.the.overall.differences.between.fuel.stocks,.which.is.often.the.centre.of.interest.

At.the.heart.of.this.is.a.fundamental.problem:.LCAs.were.never.designed.to.cover.wide-ranging.questions.of.such.global.concern..LCAs.are,.by.concept,.a.way.of.determining.costs.and.impacts.of.a.particular.process.–.they.are.especially.useful.for.firms.looking.to.reduce.costs.of.energy.and.materials.for.a.particular.supply.chain,.or.of.reducing.environmental.pollution;.Coca-Cola.and.Mobil.Oil.were.early.adopters..It.is.easy.for.a.company.to.use.LCAs,.because.they.can.be.reduced.to.a.bottom.line.expressed.in.terms.of.money.saved..

As.Finnveden.et.al.(2009).point.out,.not.all.types.of.impacts.are.equally.well.covered.in.a.typi-cal.LCA..For.example,.the.methods.for.the.impact.assessment.of.land.use,.including.impacts.on.biodiversity,.and.resource.aspects,.including.freshwater.resources,.are.problematic.and.need.to.be.improved..They.also.believe.that.there.is.a.growing.realization.of.the.need.to.match.the.aims.of.the.study,.the.questions.being.asked.and.the.choices.made..For.example,.if.the.aim.of.a.study.is.to.assess.the.consequences.of.a.choice,.the.data.used.and.the.system.boundaries.chosen.should.reflect.these.consequences..The.data.and.system.boundaries.used.can.then.be.discussed.and.assessed.in.relation.to.their.appropriateness.for.this.specific.aim.

In.the.simplest.analysis,.biofuels.are.considered.to.be.carbon.neutral.because.CO2.released.during.biofuel.combustion.is.offset.by.carbon.fixation.during.plant.growth..However,.GHGs.can.be.produced.during.production.and.carbon.balance.can.only.be.determined.by.a.LCA.(Koh.and.Ghazoul.2008)..LCAs.follow.the.impact.of.a.product.on.the.environment.throughout.its.life.span,.through.extraction.of.raw.materials,.conversion,.manufacture,.transport.and.use,.to.disposal.of.the.product.at.the.end.of.its.useful.life.and.management.of.the.waste.(Berg.1997)..Using.this.approach,.land,.water,.carbon.footprints.and.energy.balances.can.be.calculated.

Another.method.to.evaluate.the.effects.of.LUC.(DLUC.and.ILUC).developed.by.García-Quijano.et.al.(2007).uses.17.quantitative.indicators.to.describe.impacts.on.water,.soil,.vegetation.cover.and.biodiversity..This.method.calculates.impact.of.LUC.and.occupation.relative.to.the.potential.natural.vegetation.of.a.certain. location..Ecological. impacts.are.evaluated.specifically. for.soil,.biomass,.vegetation.structure.and.water.per.functional.unit..By.expressing.the.impacts.in.a.rela-tive.way.(generally.by.percentage),.the.land.use.impacts.become.site-independent.and.globally.applicable.and.comparable..The.application.of.different.versions.of.this.methodology.in.different.environments.and.on.different.production.systems.have.proven.to.result.in.understandable.and.realistic.outcomes.

Nevertheless,.the.LCA.process.is.by.no.means.straightforward..Gnansounou.et.al.(2008).for.example,.found.significant.biases.stemming.from.a.range.of.factors..They.found.that.the.esti-mated.GHG.balance.of.wheat-based.ethanol.was.highly.sensitive.to.the.method.used.to.allocate.impacts.between.co-products,. type.of.reference.system,.type.of. land-use.change,.choice.of.functional.unit.and.type.of.fuel.blend..Depending.on.the.methodological.choices.made,.variation.of.life-cycle.GHG.emissions.with.respect.to.gasoline.ranged.from.-107%.to.+120%..They.con-clude.that.several.LCA.studies.are.not.transparent.enough.and.methodological.choices.can.easily.turn.a.positive.GHG.balance.into.a.negative.one..It.is.therefore.very.important.to.establish.agreed.evaluation.methods.

Cherubini.(2010).has.just.reviewed.a.wide.range.of.methodological.concerns.and.identifies.several.areas.that.lead.to.diverging.results..These.include.type.of.biomass.source,.conversion.

Page 15: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

13 Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010

technologies,.input.data,.end-use.technologies,.allocation.method,.system.boundaries,.reference.energy.system.and.other.assumptions.such.as.land-use.change.effects,.soil.N2O.emissions,.data.quality.and.age..He.lists.18.guidelines.and.recommendations.which.are.too.numerous.to.detail.here,.so.we.mention.just.one..

When.agricultural.residues.are.used.as.raw.materials.for.energy.generation.(e.g..in.the.case.of.sugar.cane),.best.management.practices.and.above-ground.residue.harvest.rates.need.to.be.established.for.minimum.amount.of.crop.residue.that.must.be.retained.on.the.soil.to.maintain.soil.organic.carbon,.minimizing.erosion.and.protecting.soil.quality.and.productivity..He.suggests.that.this.very.complex.issue.(which.is.ignored.in.some.studies).should.be.addressed.regionally.if.not.on.a.field.or.even.subfield.basis..Rotation,.tillage.and.fertilization.management,.soil.properties.and.climate.will.all.play.major.roles.in.determining.the.amount.of.crop.residue.that.can.be.removed.in.a.sustainable.system..

energy balance

A.cardinal.requirement.of.any.energy.generation.business.is.that.it.should.generate.more.energy.than.is.consumed.by.the.generation.process..This.balance.is.called.the.Energy.Return.On.Invest-ment.(EROI).and.has.been.the.subject.of.much.recent.debate.and.confusion..With.fossil.fuels.it.was.never.an.issue.since,.as.Solomon.(2010).points.out,.in.the.1930s,.the.US.production.ratio.was.about.100:1..Latterly.though.the.ratio.has.fallen.to.at.best.20:1.Hall.et.al.(2009);.and.the.ratios.calculated.for.biofuels.are.always.lower.than.this..

A.review.of.10.papers.on.corn.and.cellulosic.energetics.by.Hammerschlag.(2006).concluded.that.for.cellulosic.ethanol.EROI,.three.of.four.studies.estimated.the.range.as.4.4:1.to.6.6:1,.whilst.Farrell.et.al.(2006).reported.values.as.high.as.11:1..For.existing.corn.based.ethanol.operations.on.the.other.hand,.EROI.ranged.from.1.3:1.to.1.65:1.in.five.of.six.studies,.with.Pimentel.and.Patzek’s.(2005).estimations.being.an.exception,.showing.negative.gain.of.0.7:1...Pimentel.and.Patzek’s.estimates.did.not..account.for.the.use.of.co-products..

This.highlights.a.significant.issue.raised.in.detail.by.Giampietro.and.Mayumi.(2009):.there.is.no.standard.way.to.calculate.EROI..It.depends.on.a.range.of.indirect.factors.and.hence.has.parallels.to.the.ILUC.problem..For.instance,.for.a.simple.system.such.as.a.smallholder.farmer.growing.a.biofuel.crop,.what.counts.towards.energy.inputs?.Is.it.just.the.farmer’s.direct.energy.inputs.to.produce.the.crop?.Or.does.it.include.his/her.family’s.energy.costs,.since.the.family.is.the.over-head.that.ensures.a.sustainable.farming.future?.And.what.about.the.sunken.fossil.fuel.energy.costs.in.the.equipment.he.uses,.and.how.much.more.energy.expensive.will.they.be.in.a.future.when.they.too.have.to.be.produced.by.burning.biofuels?.Hall.et.al.(2009).state.that.since.most.biofuels.have.EROI’s.of.less.than.3:1.they.must.be.subsidized.by.fossil.fuels.to.be.useful.

Additionally,.Giampietro.and.Mayumi.point.out.that.the.conventional.analysis.of.EROI.misses.out.the.implications.of.the.power.level.of.the.system..Differences.in.scale.imply.completely.dif-ferent.sets.of.internal.and.external.constraints..What.is.clear,.is.that.with.the.very.high.historical.gains.of.fossil.fuel.energy.production,.human.society.has.never.needed.to.seriously.consider.EROI;.now.however,.with.the.much.lower.energy.gains.of.biofuel.systems,.the.way.we.evaluate.a.system’s.energy.gain.needs.very.careful.consideration..

Carbon footprint

There.are.significant.differences.between.biofuel.crops.in.their.GHG.balances..Figure.2.demon-strates.the.wide.estimated.ranges.from.the.available.data.(Menichetti.and.Otto.2009)..Palm.oil.is.not.included.because.its.full.range.includes.a.value.of.-868%.for.GHG.savings.when.grown.on.

Page 16: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010 14

peat..Overall,.sugar.cane.and.sunflower.display.the.most.favourable.balances,.though.all.these.must.be.regarded.as.tentative,.given.the.almost.universal.tendency.to.over-estimate.yields.as.mentioned.above..

figure 2: ranges of estimated fossil fuel and gHg savings for maize (ma), soybean (so), wheat (Wh), sugarbeet (sb), sugar cane (sc), rape seed (rs) and sunflower (sf). % fossil fuel savings refers to the reduction in fossil fuel use that would be achieved by adopting the biofuel in question. The ideal biofuel would be a short line located in the top right of the graph. Data from menichetti and otto (2009).

Globally,.most.of.the.discussion.of.biofuels.LUC.has.focussed.on.impacts.on.carbon.cycling.or.carbon.footprint..Koh.and.Ghazoul.(2008).analysed.studies.conducted.during.the.last.15.years..They.demonstrated.that.the.replacement.of.petrol.or.diesel.by.biofuels.can.reduce.GHG.emis-sions.by.31%.for.bioethanol,.54%.for.biodiesel,.and.71%.for.cellulosic.ethanol..Sugarcane.bio-ethanol.had.the.greatest.GHG.savings,.and.this.has.been.reflected.in.analyses.conducted.in.the.U.S..for.the.federal.Renewable.Fuels.Standard.program.(RFS2)..

According.to.the.Intergovernmental.Panel.on.Climate.Change.(2000),.LUC.generally.(primarily.deforestation).was.responsible.for.20%.of.global.CO2.release.from.1989.to.1998..If.remaining.forested.lands.are.also.converted.to.biofuels,.carbon.dioxide.emissions.will.increase..Recently.Gibbs.et.al.(2010).provide.new.evidence.that.expansion.of.farming.is.a.major.cause.of.forest.loss.

In.many.cases,.conversion.will. result. in.significant.above-.and.belowground.carbon.losses.(Figure.3),.creating.carbon.payback.times.of.decades.or.even.centuries.(Fargione.et.al.2008)..However,.this.is.mainly.dependent.on.the.carbon.stocks.of.the.previous.land.use,.plus.the.land.management.patterns.post.conversion,.rather.than.the.biofuel.crop.per se..

Yet,.these.analyses.use.general.figures.that.need.to.be.put.into.context..While.it.is.relatively.easy.to.estimate.changes.in.above-ground.carbon.stock,.as.these.are.proportional.to.biomass,.carbon.changes.in.soils.are.more.complex..The.carbon.balances.of.terrestrial.ecosystems.are.uncertain.and.there.are.errors.in.measurements,.but.perhaps.most.importantly.due.to.method-ological.problems.resulting.in.incomplete.accounting.(Houghton.2003)..There.is.a.lack.of.data.on.carbon.dynamics,.particularly.in.tropical.systems,.from.where.the.greater.part.of.carbon.emis-sions.is.expected...

Page 17: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

15 Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010

There.is.also.much.uncertainty.regarding.the.various.sinks.of.CO2.in.natural.ecosystems..Bon-deau.et.al.(2007).summarise.ranges.in.estimated.agriculture.related.carbon.fluxes.listed.in.recent.papers..Estimates.varied.over.an.enormous.range,.from.0.6.to.3.0.megatonnes.C.yr-1,.(Schimel.et.al.2001,.House.et.al.2003)..This.huge.uncertainty.reflects.large.differences.in.estimates.of.deforestation.rates.and.in.the.size.of.the.terrestrial.carbon.sink.

Generally. it. is. assumed. that. converting.native. systems. to. cultivation. reduces.soil. carbon.through.increased.soil.respiration.and.loss.of.soil.organic.carbon.(SOC)..In.North.America,.for.example,.there.were.large.decreases.in.soil.carbon.when.prairies.were.ploughed.for.the.first.time.in.the.latter.part.of.the.19th.Century.(Tiessen.and.Stewart.1983),.estimated.by.Wilson.(1978).to.have.been.3.7.Pg.carbon.p.a..between.1860.and.1890..Nevertheless.there.are.many.manage-ment.factors.affecting.this.dynamic..These.include.nitrogen.status,.tillage,.and.the.crop.selected...

For.example,.it.is.suggested.that.nitrogen.fertilization.can.increase.carbon.mineralization.of.recalcitrant.soil.carbon.pools.(Dijkstra.et.al.2005).by.inducing.changes.in.the.activity.of.ligninase.enzymes.(Zech.et.al.1994,.Dijkstra.et.al.2004)..In.this.case,.carbon.storage.in.soils.would.be.greater.in.the.long.run.under.N-amended.agricultural.soils.than.under.native.vegetation..Yet,.this.hypothesis.has.been.challenged.by.Cadisch.and.Giller.(2001).who.found.evidence.against.a.direct.lignin.pathway.to.soil.organic.matter.(SOM).formation:.a.fertilization.experiment.they.performed.found.that.only.the.labile.fractions.of.soil.carbon.increased.rather.than.the.recalcitrant.fractions.

Additionally,.Melillo.et.al.(2009).using.linked.economic.and.terrestrial.biogeochemistry.models,.predict.that.in.a.global.cellulosic.bioenergy.program,.ILUC.will.be.responsible.for.substantially.more.carbon.loss.(up.to.twice.as.much).than.direct.land.use;.finding.that.through.predicted.in-creases.in.fertilizer.use,.nitrous.oxide.emissions.will.eventually.be.more.important.than.carbon.losses.themselves.in.terms.of.warming.potential..Their.analysis,.the.most.comprehensive.to.date,.therefore.shows.that.DLUC.and.ILUC.associated.with.expanding.global.biofuels.programs.have.the.potential.to.release.large.quantities.of.GHGs.into.the.atmosphere.

Melillo.and.his.colleagues.simulated.two.global.land-use.scenarios.in.their.study..In.Case.1,.natural.areas.are.converted.to.meet.increased.demand.for.biofuels.production.land..In.Case.2,.there.is.less.willingness.to.convert.land.and.existing.managed.land.is.used.more.intensely..The.model.predicts.that,.in.both.scenarios,.land.devoted.to.biofuels.will.become.greater.than.the.total.area.currently.devoted.to.crops.by.the.end.of.the.21st.century..Case.1.will.result.in.more.carbon.loss.than.Case.2,.especially.at.mid-century..In.addition,.indirect.land.use.will.be.responsible.for.substantially.greater.carbon.losses.(up.to.twice.as.much).than.direct.land.use.

Balesdent.et.al.(2000).compiled.a.review.on.the.effects.of.tillage.on.soil.carbon.dynamics..They.

figure 3: above and below-ground carbon (C expressed in megagrams = tonnes) debts created in land use conver-sion to selected biofuel crops (norgrove 2010, adapted after fargione et al 2008).

Page 18: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010 16

concluded.that.no.general.relationships.could.be.discerned.as.tillage.effects.interact.strongly.with.local.climate,.soil.physical.properties,.and.microbial.populations..Tillage.disrupts.soil.structure.by.breaking.macroaggregates..Microaggregates.are.dispersed.and.this.alters.SOM.decomposition.but.the.extent.of.change.depends.on.the.previous.land.use.and.the.time.lag.since.conversion..To.predict.better.the.consequences.of.tillage.on.SOM.turnover,.more.quantitative.studies.are.needed.

Solomon.et.al.(2002),.working.in.the.humid.zone.of.Southeast.Ethiopia.reported.that.topsoil.SOC.reduced.from.58-63.Mg.ha-1.under.humid.forest.to.34-40.Mg.ha-1.in.maize.fields..Tchienkoua.and.Zech.(2004).looked.at.SOC.under.intercropped.food.crop.systems.and.compared.this.with.areas.that.had.been.converted.to.Eucalyptus and.tea.plantations..Conversion.led.to.significant.increases.in.SOC.(by.a.factor.of.approximately.2.for.both.trajectories)..Tchienkoua.and.Zech.(2004).stated.that.this.was.favoured.by.low.temperature.fluctuations.and.by.allophone,.a.substance.that.reduces.decomposition.rate.of.polysaccharides.and.glucose..Other.authors.have.found.increases.in.SOC.when.rainforest.is.converted.to.improved.pasture..For.example,.Boddey.et.al.(2002).report.that.SOC.under.improved.pasture.of.Brachiaria.in.South.America.increased.compared.with.the.previous.rainforest...Such.mechanisms.involve.the.deposition.of.recalcitrant.root.residues.high.in.lignin.and.tannin.at.deeper.soil.layers.due.to.root.turnover.by.deep.rooting.grasses..

There.are.many.methodological.problems.associated.with.the.measurement.of.soil.carbon..For.example,.to.obtain.an.accurate.estimate.of.soil.carbon.in.Mg.ha-1,.it.is.necessary.to.simultaneously.analyse.soil.carbon.concentrations.and.soil.bulk.density.to.a.depth.where.the.total.carbon.con-tribution.of.that.depth.fraction.to.total.soil.is.insignificant...Yet,.often.soil.bulk.density.estimates.are.not.done,.they.are.inherently.difficult.to.do.on.ploughed.soil,.and.methods.used.vary.(core.method.versus.clod.method)..Below.20cm,.bulk.density.measures.are.increasingly.destructive...Many.authors.have.only.estimated.soil.bulk.density.in.the.topsoil.although.bulk.density.at.deeper.layers.is.difficult.to.predict.from.this.parameter.

Second,.different.authors.have.used.different.extraction.techniques.for.soil.carbon..For.ex-ample,.the.use.of.the.Heanes.(1984).method.will.give.different.results.to.the.Walkley.and.Black.method.(Walkley.and.Black.1934)..Furthermore,.the.temperature.used.in.the.Walkley.and.Black.extraction.affects.the.results.with.greater.carbon.extracted.at.higher.temperatures..Method.stan-dardization.is.therefore.essential..Regarding.measurements.of.carbon.fluxes,.the.least.labour.intensive.and.most.capital.intensive.measurement.of.soil.respiration.is.by.using.an.infrared.gas.analyzer..

Nonetheless,.this.gives.only.a.spot.value.and.requires.simultaneous.measurement.of.soil.tem-perature.and.water.content..As.respiration.rate.will.vary.greatly.diurnally,.repeated.measures.over.a.representative.24-hour.period.are.required..Other.methods.include.the.use.of.soda.lime,.left.in.an.enclosed.container.over.a.fixed.area.of.soil.for.24.hours.and.weighed.before.and.after.to.deter-mine.carbon.uptake..This.gives.an.integral.measure.of.soil.respiration.and.making.measurements.at.different.times.of.year.allows.an.estimation.of.yearly.fluxes..This.method.requires.numerous.titrations.or,.if.solid.soda.lime.is.used,.precise.weighing.of.the.material.before.and.after....

Conclusion

The.uncertainties.associated.with.ILUC.are.compounded.by.methodological.problems.with.the.LCA.process.itself..The.issues.are.multiple.and.complex.and.would.require.a.separate.study.to.cover.adequately..As.things.stand,.it.would.seem.that.little.confidence.can.be.placed.in.any.one.LCA.study.unless.every.assumption.is.transparently.listed.and.sufficient.emphasis.is.placed.on.any.remaining.uncertainties..At.the.root.of.this.problem.is.that.current.commercial.biofuels.have.much.lower.EROI.ratios.than.fossil.fuels,.so.that.there.is.little.or.no.safety.factor.to.allow.for,.say,.local.differences.in.yields.or.energy.costs.of.irrigation.for.example..Much.clearer.guidelines.are.

Page 19: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

17 Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010

needed.for.field.operators.and.the.implications.for.standard-setting.are.possibly.very.onerous..Furthermore,.it.would.seem.that.the.energy.expended.in.ILUC.activities.are.currently.not.factored.into.EROI.calculations,.which.could.further.add.to.the.doubts.surrounding.the.true.sustainable.energy.gains.accrued.through.biofuels.to.society....

4. aDDITIonal envIronmenTal ImpaCTs lInKeD To IluCAdditional.environmental.impacts.that.have.been.linked.to.ILUC.include.biodiversity.and.water.footprint..This.section.briefly.details.these.concerns.and.their.link.to.biofuels.ILUC.

biodiversity Concerns

Attempts.to.halt.biodiversity.decline.by.2010.as.stated.in.the.Convention.on.Biodiversity.are.now.widely.agreed.to.have.failed..It.is.also.generally.acknowledged.that.further.losses.of.natural.habitats.is.extremely.ill-advised,.because.of.risk.of.extinction.and.the.loss.of.ecosystem.services.that.this.will.entail...Forest.losses.in.Southeast.Asia.for.example.have.accelerated.in.recent.years..Koh.(2007).points.out.that.the.rate.of.loss.of.old.growth.forests.in.Indonesia.has.increased.from.2.3%.per.year.in.the.period.1990–2000.to.2.7%.per.year.in.2000–2005..Old.growth.forests.are.also.being.lost.at.increasing.rates.in.Cambodia.(1.0.to.6.7%).and.Vietnam.(6.9.to14.6%).between.the.two.time.periods..Much.of.the.forest.loss.is.due.to.expansion.of.agricultural.land.(Gibbs.et.al.2010),.for.commodity.crops.including.biofuels.feedstocks...This.will.either.directly.or.indirectly.only.tend.to.further.increase.natural.habitat.loss.

A.study.on.biodiversity.in.oil.palm.plantations.(Fitzherbert.et.al.2008).concludes.that.they.are.a.poor.substitute.for.native.tropical.forests.and.support.few.species.of.conservation.importance,.and.affect.biodiversity.in.adjacent.habitats.through.fragmentation,.edge.effects.and.pollution..The.authors.suggest.that.there.is.enough.non-forested.land.suitable.for.plantation.development.to.allow.large.increases.in.production.without.further.deforestation,.but.political.inertia,.competing.priorities.and.lack.of.capacity.and.understanding,.not.to.mention.high.levels.of.demand.for.timber.and.palm.oil,.often.make.it.attractive.to.clear.forests..

Moreover,.some.biofuel.plant.species.may.become.invasive.in.non-native.ecosystems.and.hence,.affect.biodiversity.and.ecosystem.services..For.example,.jatropha.is.considered.as.an.invasive.weed.in.South.Africa.and.Australia.although.studies.on.its.actual.or.potential.ecological.impact.are.as.yet.unavailable..A.further.and.serious.problem.with.greatly.expanding.biofuel.pro-duction.is.that.optimal.yields.and.efficiencies.are.gained.with.large.monocropped.systems..As.with.all.monocultures,.such.large.expanses.are.inherently.susceptible.to.attack.by.pests..History.is.full.of.grandiose.schemes.for.major.production.schemes.that.have.faltered.or.been.serious.curbed.by.these.factors.(e.g..Grandin.2009)..

Pests.frequently.account.for.40+%.crop.losses.(Oerke.and.Dehne.1997).and.biofuel.crops.are.no.different.but.so.far.little.studied...We.know.though.that.pests.can.cause.major.losses.to.crops.that.can.be.used.as.biofuels..For.example,.basal.stem.rot.(BSR).is.the.most.serious.constraint.of.oil.palm.in.South.East.Asia...After.10.or.more.years,.yields.may.be.reduced.by.25%.or.more.(Ariffin.et.al.2000).but.importantly,.the.disease.appears.earlier.in.replanted.areas..Therefore.suc-cessful.management.of.BSR.is.essential.to.allow.replanting.on.currently.cultivated.land.and.to.reduce.further.deforestation..

Theoretically.at.least,.cellulosic.biofuels.based.on.a.mix.of.grass.species.might.experience.fewer.pest.and.disease.losses.since.this.could.provide.a.stable.combination.of.species.likely.to.possess.a.relatively.high.level.of.overall.genetic.resistance.with,.if.managed.effectively,.a.reason-able.balance.of.pests.and.natural.enemies..Currently.though,.this.subject.seems.to.be.completely.

Page 20: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010 18

unstudied...Theoretically.too,.biofuel.plants.introduced.to.non-indigenous.areas.may.be.preferred.because.they.would.be.considered.likely.to.be.attacked.by.a.smaller.guild.of.pests.and.diseases.but.there.is.always.a.risk.of.pests.and.diseases.from.closely.related.crops.spreading.to.the.intro-duced.crop..Also.there.are.potential.problems.with.invasiveness.–.the.ideal.biofuel.plant.would.be.one.that.grows.vigorously.in.marginal.conditions.and.this.is.precisely.the.characteristic.of.many.invasive.plant.species..Invasives.have.the.potential.to.cause.significant.economic.loss:.In.the.US.alone,.annual.losses.of.over.$120.billion.have.been.documented.from.the.effects.and.control.of.introductions.of.invasive.species.

potential Impacts on Water resources

Currently.food.and.fibre.production.systems.use.86%.of.worldwide.freshwater.(Hoekstra.and.Chapagain.2007)..Table.2.details.water.footprints.for.some.common.biofuels..Sugarbeet,.maize,.sugar.cane.and.potato.bioethanol.have.low.water.footprints..The.biodiesel.crops,.soy.and.rape.have.very.high.water.footprints..Some.of.these.values.(for.example,.for.jatropha).have.been.dis-puted.by.others.however.(Pfister.and.Hellweg.2009).

Crop Total water footprint(m3 per GJ electricity)

Sugar beet 46Maize 50

Sugar cane 50Barley 70Rye 77

Paddy rice 85Wheat 93Potato 105

Cassava 148Soybean 173Sorghum 180Rapeseed 383Jatropha 396

Table 2: Total weighted global average water footprint for 13 crops (from gerbens-leenes et al 2009).

The.International.Water.Management.Institute.(IWMI.2008).suggests.that.globally,.there.is.enough.water.to.produce.both.food.and.biofuel..But,.in.countries.where.water.is.already.scarce,.such.as.India,.growing.biofuel.crops.will.aggravate.existing.problems...Difference.in.requirements.are.highly.site-specific,.for.example.producing.one.litre.of.ethanol.from.sugarcane.takes.nearly.3,500.litres.of.irrigation.water.in.India,.but.just.90.litres.of.irrigation.water.in.Brazil..

The.Committee.on.Water.Implications.of.Biofuels.Production.in.the.United.States.(National.Research.Council,.2007).also.concluded.that.there.are.many.uncertainties.in.estimating.consump-tive.water.use.of.the.biofuel.feedstocks.of.the.future..Water.data.are.less.available.for.some.of.the.proposed.cellulosic.feedstocks,.for.example,.native.grasses.on.marginal.lands,.than.for.widespread.and.common.crops.such.as.corn,.soybeans,.sorghum,.and.others..Neither.the.cur-rent.consumptive.water.use.of.the.marginal.lands.nor.the.potential.water.demand.of.the.native.grasses.is.well.known..Further,.while.irrigation.of.native.grass.today.would.be.unusual,.this.could.easily.change.as.production.of.cellulosic.ethanol.gets.underway..In.the.next.5.to.10.years,.in-creased.agricultural.production.for.biofuels.will.probably.not.alter.the.US.national-aggregate.view.of.water.use..However,.there.are.likely.to.be.significant.regional.and.local.impacts.where.water.resources.are.already.stressed.

Page 21: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

19 Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010

Conclusion

Compounding.the.uncertainties.revealed.in.previous.sections,.we.see.that.a.broad.range.of.other.environmental.effects.add.further.difficulties.in.accurately.predicting.the.effects.of.biofuel.produc-tion.in.a.given.location.at.some.point.in.the.future...The.main.problem.resides.in.the.magnitude.of.localized.effects,.including.climatic.variables,.availability.and.therefore.cost.of.water.as.well.as.the.various.pests.and.diseases.present..This.strongly.suggests.therefore.that.extensive.pre-testing.at.the.pilot.stage.is.required.for.all.prospective.biofuel.projects.in.every.new.setting..The.problem.is.that.ILUC.effects.will.only.truly.be.understood.in.retrospect.after.major.programs.are.carried.through..For.this.reason,.ILUC.modelling.becomes.the.only.way.to.judge.the.possible.impacts.and.this.is.covered.in.the.following.section.

5. examples of seleCT bIofuels IluC sTuDIesIn.this.section,.we.will.discuss.examples.of.different.models.used.to.quantify.ILUC.as.well.as.their.shortcomings,.followed.by.some.examples.of.biofuels.ILUC.findings.in.recent.studies..Most.authors.expect.that.an.increase.in.biofuel.production.will.lead.to.LUC,.either.directly.or.indirectly.(for.example,.see.Righelato.and.Spracklen.2007)..Permutations.and.combinations.of.LUC.are.endless..For.example,.for.a.land.use.trajectory.where.the.initial.land.use.system.is.tropical.forest,.three.classes.of.conversion.were.distinguished.by.Coulter.(1992):

n. High.input-high.output.systems.(tree.crops.such.as.rubber,.oil.palm)..This.is.common.in.South.East.Asia,.where.farmers.clear.land.that.has.been.logged.(Moad.and.Whitmore.1994);.

n. Pasture.production.for.cattle.farming.usually.after.one.upland.rice.cycle..This.is.the.major.type.land.conversion.in.Honduras.(Sunderlin.and.Rodriguez.1996),.Puerto.Rico.(Aide.et.al.1996),.and.Latin.America.(FAO.1997).and.is.the.dominant.option.for.smallholders;

n. Low.input-low.output.slash.and.burn.agriculture..This.is.the.most.common.cause.of.defor-estation.in.Africa.(FAO.1997).and.is.frequent.in.Asia.

The many approaches to modelling IluC

Attempts.to.quantify.LUC.rely.on.models,.and.there.are.many.approaches,.which.we.present.but.in.brief.here...Pontius.and.Neeti.(2010).identified.the.following.categories:

n. Models.containing.calibration.algorithms;n. Statistical.models.creating.a.probability.function.as.an.output.that.require.calibration.using.

historic.data,.such.as.CLUE.(http://www.cluemodel.nl/),.used.together.with.scenario.model-ling.(Verburg.et.al.2002);

n. Agent-based.models.simulate.decision-making.by.human.actors.who.influence.land.change,.and.tend.to.have.many.input.parameters.(Manson.and.Evans.2007)..

Other.models.combine.the.above.techniques.(Pontius.et.al.2007)..All.models.have.parameters.where.values.need.to.be.assigned.to.run.the.model...For.example,.the.Forest.Land.Orientated.Resources.Envisioning.System.(FLORES).has.been.used.and.adapted.to.understand.LUC.at.the.humid.forest.margins.of.South.East.Asia.and.Central.Africa.(Robiglio.et.al.2003,.Vanclay.2003)..The.assumptions.of.FLORES.include.that.land-use.decisions.are.complex.and.that.actors.consider.all.of.their.options.within.the.constraints.of.the.financial,.labour.and.technical.resources.available.as.well.as.within.their.knowledge.and.perception.limitations.(Vanclay.2003)...

Bondeau.et.al.(2007).described.the.Lund–Potsdam–Jena.model.of.managed.Land.(LPJmL).developed.by.Sitch.et.al.(2003)..This.model.looks.at.the.changing.area.of.croplands..According.to.their.assumptions,.total.cropland.area.increased.rapidly.until.the.1950s..It.then.slowed.and.reached.an.equilibrium.position.in.the.1980s.when.tropical.deforestation.rate.was.balanced.by.

Page 22: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010 20

temperate.afforestation.(Ramankutty.and.Foley.1999).data.set...Results.therefore.disagree.with.those.of.Houghton.(2003).from.1970.onwards..

As.another.example,.regulators.in.the.U.S..have.used.a.combination.of.modelling.tools.to.analyse.lifecycle.GHG.emissions.and.biofuel.ILUC.impacts...They.are.not.limited.to.but.include:

n. The.Forestry.and.Agricultural.Sector.Optimization.Model. (FASOM):.A.partial.equilibrium.economic.model.of.the.U.S..forest.and.agricultural.sectors.that.tracks.over.2,000.production.inputs.for.field.crops,.livestock.and.biofuels.and.accounts.for.GHG.emissions.changes.from.most.agricultural.activities...Regulators.selected.the.FASOM.model.because.comprehensive.forestry.and.agricultural.sector.model.that.tracks.over.2,000.production.possibilities.for.field.crops,.livestock,.and.biofuels.for.private.lands.in.the.contiguous.U.S.

n. Greenhouse.gases,.Regulated.Emissions,.and.Energy.use. in.Transportation. (GREET):.A.spreadsheet.analysis.tool.developed.by.Argonne.National.Laboratories:.GREET.includes.the.GHG.emissions.associated.with.the.production.and.combustion.of.fossil.fuels..GREET.also.estimates.the.GHG.emissions.associated.with.electricity.production.required.for.agriculture.and.biofuel.production...

n. Integrated.Food.and.Agricultural.Policy.and.Research-Center.for.Agricultural.and.Rural.De-velopment.(FAPRI-CARD).at.Iowa.State.University:.These.models.capture.the.biological,.technical,.and.economic.relationships.among.key.variables.within.a.particular.commodity.and.across.commodities.....

n. The.Global.Trade.Analysis.Project.(GTAP).This.model.was.developed.to.estimate.global.flows.in.agricultural.commodities.in.response.to.prices.and.policy.changes.

Sources.of.uncertainty.and.error.in.the.outcome.of.model.runs.may.derive.from:n. The.input.data,.digital.maps.and.remote.sensing.interpretation;n. How.well.algorithms.included.in.the.model.express.important.processes.and.simulate.domi-

nant.LUCs;n. Uncertainty.in.predicting.future.LUC.processes..Decision.making.involves.human.free.will,.

which.is.difficult.to.model.and.maybe.illogical.(Pontius.and.Neeti.2010).

Some.examples.of.errors.in.LUC.assessments.and.models.are.below..They.include:n. Misinterpretation.of.the.extent.of.the.original.vegetation;n. Difficulty.in.distinguishing.between.certain.land.uses;n. Treating.LUC.as.linear.and.ignoring.cyclical.processes.such.as.shifting.cultivation.(Mertens.

and.Lambin.2000).

Deforestation.in.West.Africa.is.given.as.an.example.to.illustrate.these.error.types...According.to.estimated.deforestation.rates.in.West.Africa,.90%.of.the.‘original’.moist.forest.has.been.lost.(Bry-ant.et.al.1997)..Slash.and.burn.agriculture.is.cited.as.the.major.cause.of.forest.loss.(FAO.1997)..However,.the.extent.of.the.so-called.original.forest.is.unclear..Researchers.and.early.explorers.during.the.colonial.era.who.observed.forest.patches.with.tall.trees.in.the.savannah.or.in.bush.land.assumed.that.these.indicated.the.past.presence.of.a.more.extensive.closed.canopy.forest.of.which.they.were.mere.relicts.(Chevalier.1909;.Aubréville1938,.1949).and.thus.the.entire.area.of.the.surrounding.savannah.was.assumed.to.be.previously.forest..

This.conclusion.has.been.challenged.by.researchers.in.fields.as.disparate.as.anthropology.(Fair-head.and.Leach.1994,.1996;.Bassett.and.Koli.Bi.2000,.Ickowitz.2006),.botany.(Goetze.et.al.2006,.Hennenberg.et.al.2005).and.palynology.(Maley.and.Brenac.1998,.Vincens.et.al.2000)..Fairhead.and.Leach.(1994,.1996),.have.analysed.reports.in.West.Africa.and.concluded.that.forest.cover.has.increased.in.the.last.century..Tree.cover.has.been.enhanced.by.cultivation.along.the.forest.savannah.boundaries.by.promoting.forest.succession.after.removal.of.grasses.through.hoeing..Other.evidence.has.attributed.major.changes.in.vegetation.cover.to.climate.changes.(Maley.and.Brenac.1998)..

Page 23: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

21 Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010

Remote.sensing.interpretations.of.land.use.cover.are.prone.to.error,.if.not.backed.up.with.extensive.ground.truthing,.due.to.the.difficulty.of.distinguishing.certain.land.use.types..For.ex-ample,.Thenkabail.(1999),.analysed.HRV.SPOT.data.of.central.Cameroon.from.March.1995..He.concluded.that.Imperata cylindrica.(spear.grass),.an.aggressive.weed.that.spreads.after.cultivation.and.can.cause.farmers.to.abandon.land,.occupied.more.than.10%.of.the.land.area..This.area.was.subsequently.classified.by.the.Global.Alternatives.to.Slash.and.Burn.Programme.(Kotto.Same.et.al.2000).as.having.a.high.human.population.density,.high.intensity.and.consequently.“only.4%.of.land.remains.covered.by.primary.forest’.and.‘the.stock.of.forest.resources.has.been.seriously.degraded”..

Yet,.more.recent.work.revealed.that. Imperata cylindrica.coverage.is. low..According.to.the.reports.of.villagers,.most.of.this.land.has.not.been.cultivated.recently.(Gockowski.personal.com-munication,.Norgrove.2006)..This.misinterpretation.of.remote.sensing.data.is.understandable;.Mertens.and.Lambin.(2000).working.near.Bertoua.in.East.Cameroon.looked.at.land.cover.trajec-tories.from.1973.to.1991.and.found.that.nearly.10%.of.land.was.classified.as.stable.savannah.or.permanent.agriculture,.and.these.two.land.use.types.were.indistinguishable..Doumenge.et.al.(2001),.also.working.in.Cameroon,.stated.that.it.was.not.possible.to.distinguish.natural.forest-.savannah.mosaics.from.cultivated.areas..

Grieg-Gran.(2006).reported.that.deforestation.in.the.Congo.Basin.is.driven.by.smallholder.shift-ing.cultivation..Certainly,.smallholders.clear.land.for.agriculture,.however,.net.clearance.requires.subtracting.the.amount.of. land.that. is.returning.to.forest.fallow.and.this. is.often.overlooked..Robiglio.and.Sinclair.(2007).compared.the.aerial.photos.from.the.1950s,.and.satellite.imageries.of.1980s.and.2001.and.demonstrated.that.in.some.parts.of.southern.Cameroon.the.area.of.land.previously.in.agriculture.but.currently.in.fallow.was.greater.than.the.area.of.land.previously.in.for-est.and.currently.under.agriculture,.in.both.the.1980s.and.2001..

The searchinger analysis of biofuels IluC

Recent.studies.on.biofuels.and.ILUC.have.been.greatly.influenced.by.the.paper.of.Searchinger.et.al.(2008).that.discusses.the.hypothetical.ILUC.impacts.of.increased.biofuel.production..Their.paper.looked.at.what.impact.increasing.maize.bioethanol.production.in.the.U.S..by.75%,.an.ad-ditional.56.billion.litres,.by.2016.would.have.on.land.use..These.figures.were.input.to.the.FAPRI-CARD.model..This.would.mean.that.12.8.million.ha.of.existing.cropland.in.the.U.S..would.be.diverted.to.maize.production,.achieved.by.changing.the.land.use.of.areas.currently.under.soy.and.wheat.and.U.S..exports.of.wheat.and.soy.would.decrease.(wheat.by.31%)..

The.model.predicted.that.price.increases.would.be.40%,.17%.and.20%.for.maize,.wheat.and.soy,.respectively..They.hypothesised.that.this.would.lead.to.more.than.10.million.hectares.being.brought.into.production.elsewhere.in.the.world,.particularly.Brazil.for.soy.and.China.for.wheat.and.maize.and.particularly.from.forest.clearance..This.would.result.in.the.release.of.3.8.billion.mega-tons.of.CO2-equivalent.GHGs.–.a.carbon.debt.that.would.take.more.than.150.years.to.repay.(Searchinger.et.al.2008)...While.the.Searchinger.paper.has.been.widely.quoted,.there.have.been.many.papers.criticizing.the.assumptions.made,.its.conclusions.and.their.general.application.

According.to.Mathews.and.Tan.(2009),.the.Searchinger.paper.has.the.following.flaws..First,.the.expected.ethanol.consumption.of.56.billion.litres.by.2016.is.a.weak.assumption.as.is.the.concept.that.this.would.be.obtained.exclusively.from.maize.grown.in.the.U.S..It.has.been.shown.in.the.cur-rent.paper.that.bioethanol.production.is.more.efficiently.produced.from.other.crops,.even.within.the.U.S...It.would.therefore.be.more.realistic.to.look.at.other.domestic.sources.of.bioethanol.or.to.suggest.that.bioethanol.from.sugar.cane.is.imported.from.Brazil,.but.this.idea.is.not.explored..So.it.is.assumed.that.needs.are.met.entirely.within.the.U.S..Furthermore,.the.supply.and.demand.elasticities.used.are.based.on.historical.figures.

Page 24: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010 22

The.calculations.of.the.extra.hectarage.needed.in.other.countries.to.make.up.for.diversion.of.maize.to.ethanol.specify.locations.(Brazil,.India,.China).and.assume.that.this.production.will.come.from.land.conversion.from.forest..Figures.are.based.on.observations.from.the.1990s.in.countries.such.as.China.and.India.(Houghton.2003)..They.do.not.consider.intensification,.yield.increases,.crop.switching.or.use.of.degraded.land.as.options...They.do.not.consider.the.complexity.of.fac-tors.and.drivers.in.LUC.and.uncertainty.in.the.models.and.there.is.much.literature.showing.that.LUC.is.not.driven.only.by.agricultural.expansion.but.that.timber.extraction.and.road.building.are.major.interacting.factors..

Also,.as.discussed.earlier,.carbon.emission.figures.presented.by.Houghton.(2003).are.larger.than.those.from.other.authors.(Bondeau.et.al.2007.and.others).who.highlight.the.uncertainty.in.global.carbon.dynamics..The.figures.presented.on.carbon.losses.also.do.not.take.into.account.cropping.management.(Kim.et.al.2009).although.the.importance.of.considering.tillage.regimes.and.nitrogen.usage.is.highlighted.earlier.in.this.paper...Instead.there.is.an.arbitrary.assumption.that.when.land.is.cultivated.there.is.a.25%.loss.in.SOC,.although.in.the.previous.section.of.this.paper.it.is.demonstrated.that.SOC.can.increase.in.certain.contexts..Other.problems.are.that.there.are.no.margins.of.error.quoted.in.the.paper.and.no.discussion.of.the.assumptions.used...

Searchinger.(2008).rebutted.these.technical.objections.and.recent.work.by.Yan.et.al.(2010).has.provided.further.support.for.his.position.on.ILUC..They.conclude,.from.both.U.S..and.Chinese.data,.that.soybean,.rapeseed.and.jatropha.biodiesel.all.appear.at.first.sight.to.have.favourably.low.GHG.emissions.in.relation.to.diesel,.but.that.their.“well.to.wheel”.GHG.releases.are.increased.significantly.when.land-use.change.is.taken.into.account..Hence.biodiesel.from.soybean,.rape-seed.or.jatropha.could.cut.emissions.but.by.very.little.if.carbon-storing.forests.and.grasslands.are.cleared.to.grow.these.crops..Only.cellulosic.biomass.has.significant.potential.for.cutting.transport.emissions,.because.it.has.minimal.land-use.impacts..They.warn.that.converting.grasslands.in.the.U.S..to.maize.fields.for.bioethanol.production.could.cause.a.huge.carbon.debt.through.direct.land-use.change..Diverting.U.S..maize.exports.to.bioethanol.production.could.potentially.cause.an.even.greater.carbon.debt.through.ILUC.

Finally,.and.most.recently,.further.support.for.Searchinger.comes.from.Lapola.et.al.(2010).who.looked.at.potential.land-use.changes.from.biofuel.expansion.in.Brazil.which.almost.certainly.will.continue.to.be.a.major.source.of.global.biofuels..“To fill the biofuel production targets for 2020, sugarcane would require an additional 57,200 sq km and soybean an additional 108,100 sq km of land. Roughly 88% of this expansion (145,700 sq km) would take place in areas previously used as rangeland,”.say.the.authors..Their.simulations.suggest.that.direct.deforestation.would.mean.de-struction.of.a.fairly.modest.1,800.sq.km.of.forest.and.2,000.sq.km.of.woody.savannah.in.the.case.of.soybean..However,.their.models.also.suggest.that.large.areas.of.rainforest.and.cerrado.(savannah).would.be.indirectly.impacted.as.displaced.cattle.ranchers.find.such.new.lands.to.exploit..

When.it.came.to.carbon.payback.times,.the.authors.found.that.four.years.would.be.needed.to.compensate.for.direct.emissions.from.conversion.for.cane.relative.to.emissions.from.fossil.fuels.and.35.years.for.soy.biodiesel..But.factoring.in.ILUC.–.in.this.case.cattle.ranching.displaced.to.forest. lands.by.cropland.expansion.–.dramatically.extends.the.amount.of.time.needed.for.emissions.savings.from.biofuel.production.to.compensate.for.emissions.from.deforestation:.by.40.years.for.sugarcane.ethanol.and.211.years.for.soy.biodiesel...“Indirect land-use change could considerably compromise the GHG savings from growing biofuels, mainly by pushing rangeland frontier into the Amazon forest and Brazilian Cerrado savanna,”.Lapola.and.colleagues.write..The.authors.suggest.that.planting.oil.palm.instead.of.sugarcane.or.soy.on.pasture.lands.would.result.in.some.direct.deforestation.(300.sq.km).but.significantly.reduce.emissions.from.ILUC.due.to.the.crop’s.substantially.higher.oil.yield.

Page 25: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

23 Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010

Conclusion

To.estimate.the.effects.of.ILUC.into.the.future,.modelling.is.required,.but.there.is.no.standard.and.agreed.method.to.do.it,.and.no.sign.that.a.consensus.is.near..Indeed.the.current.debate.about.ILUC.between.scientists.is.intense,.as.may.be.expected.from.a.field.of.study.that.only.opened.up.two.years.ago..Whatever.the.objections.to.the.assumptions.and.methods.employed.by.Search-inger.et.al.(2008).it.is.surely.undeniable.that.if.the.biofuel.industry.expands.to.the.point.where.it.is.making.a.global.impact.on.GHG.emissions,.then.indirect.effects.will.exist.and.become.more.important.and.possibly.self-defeating...

As.in.previous.sections,.uncertainties.abound,.with.doubts.about.fundamental.measurements.such.as.the.availability.of.unassigned.land,.the.extent.to.which.marginal.land.can.be.utilized.and.the.yields.that.can.be.expected.in.a.future.where.availability.of.sufficient.water.is.increasingly.uncertain..All.these.factors.and.others.lead.to.the.inevitable.conclusion.that.the.outputs.of.models.must.be.treated.with.considerable.caution.and,.because.of.the.global.gravity.of.land.use.issues.in.a.crowded.world,.that.ILUC.effects.must.be.considered.plausible.and.substantial.until.strong.evidence.to.the.contrary.is.provided.

In.the.concluding.section.we.will.elaborate.on.the.multiple.categories.of.uncertainty.that.need.very.careful.definition.and.delimitation.as.first.steps.towards.clarification.of.these.complex.is-sues..The.situation.is.seemingly.much.more.difficult.than.with.climate.change.modelling,.which.at.least.can.rely.on.one.hundred.years.of.accurate.weather.recordings,.so.that.models.can.be.back-casted..Hence.the.accuracy.with.which.climate.models.reproduce.past.climate.variations.gives.considerable.confidence.that.modellers.are.on.the.right.track..No.such.possibility.exists.for.ILUC.and.associated.biofuels.issues..

6. regulaTory anD legIslaTIve aCTIons unDerTaKen To ConTrol IluC from bIofuelsSeveral.regions.or.individual.countries.have.incorporated.ILUC.estimations.into.LCAs.of.GHG.emissions.resulting.from.the.production.of.renewable.biofuels...Estimation.of.such.unintended.consequences.of.carbon.emissions.from.LUC.is.an.evolving.scientific.process.with.substantial.data.gaps.and.uncertainties...Nonetheless,.legislative.and.regulatory.action.to.address.carbon.emissions.broadly,.and.the.contribution.of.ILUC.induced.by.mandated.biofuels.use.specifically,.is.proceeding.in.parallel.to.the.advancing.science...Currently,.there.is.no.internationally.agreed.policy.or.methodology.for.addressing.ILUC.impacts.for.biofuels.production.and.use...This.section.briefly.describes.the.major.regulatory.and.legislative.actions.taken.to.require.ILUC.considerations.in.the.development.of.biofuels.programs.

european union: renewable energy Directive

On.17.December.2008,.the.European.Parliament.approved.the.Renewable.Energy.Sources.Di-rective.(COM/2008/19).(RED).and.amendments.to.the.existing.Fuel.Quality.Directive.(Directive.2009/30/EC).(FQD),.which.include.sustainability.criteria.for.the.production.and.use.of.biofuels.and.requires.ILUC.to.be.considered.in.the.development.of.these.criteria...The.Renewable.Energy.Directive.(Directive.2009/28/EC).set.the.EU.target.of.10%.for.biofuel.use.in.transportation.fuels,.whereas.the.Fuel.Quality.Directive.established.a.Low.Carbon.Fuel.Standard.(LCFS).to.achieve.a.6%.reduction.in.GHG.emissions.of.transport.fuels.by.2020...

As.part.of.the.implementation.of.the.increased.biofuels.production.and.use,.the.EU.directed.that.calculation.of.GHG.emissions.include.all.main.contributions,.including.the.indirect.effects..The.directive.did.not.specify.the.approach.(methods.for.determining.ILUC).or.the.defined.limits.

Page 26: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010 24

for.such.determination,.instead.it.directed.the.European.Commission.to.develop.the.factors.for.ILUC.impacts.on.GHG.emissions.based.on.the.best.available.science,.and.to.make.proposals.on.how.to.address.the.issue.of.ILUC...Under.the.mandate,.the.Commission.is.to.deliver.its.report.on.methodology.and.limits.by.31.December.2010...

Directive.2009/28/EC.on the promotion of the use of energy from renewable sources and amending and subsequently repealing Directives 2001/77/EC and 2003/30/EC,.also.known.as.the.Renewable.Energy.Directive.or.RED, .presents.several.clauses.on.the.need.to.carefully.establish.the.sustainability.criteria.to.monitor.and.reduce.GHG.emissions.from.transport.fuels.and.biofuels...The.directive.text.clearly.indicates.that.emissions.from.domestic.and.international.LUCs.resulting.from.biofuels.need.to.be.incorporated.into.the.calculations;.however,.it.recognizes.that.the.sci-ence.needs.to.continue.to.develop.to.do.so...The.RED.further.recognizes.that:

n. Biofuel.production.should.be.sustainable.and.national.programmes.fulfil.sustainability.criteria;n. Biofuels.and.bioliquids.should.avoid.destruction.of.biodiverse.lands;n. GHG.emissions.should.attempt.to.use.actual.values.for.carbon.stocks.associated.with.land.

use.and.conversions;n. Concrete.methodology.should.be.developed.to.minimize.GHG.emissions.caused.by.ILUC.

and.the.best.available.scientific.information.should.be.analyzed.

As.a.legislative.action.by.the.EU,.the.RED.has.spelled.out.the.requirements.for.implementing.sustainability.criteria.that.incorporate.consideration.of.ILUC...Annex.V.of.the.RED.provides.for.the.rules.for.calculating.the.GHG.impacts.of.biofuels,.bioliquids.and.their.fossil.fuel.comparators...The.Annex.V.includes.the.following.rules:..

n. Typical.and.default.values.for.biofuels.if.produced.with.no.net.carbon.emissions.from.land-use.change;

n. Estimated.typical.and.default.values.for.future.biofuels.that.were.not.on.the.market.or.were.on.the.market.only.in.negligible.quantities.in.January.2008,.if.produced.with.no.net.carbon.emissions.from.land-use.change;

n. Specific.methodology.for.calculation.of.GHG.emissions.from.the.production.and.use.of.transport.fuels,.biofuels.and.bioliquids;.and

n. Disaggregate.default.values.for.biofuels.and.bioliquids,.and.for.processing,.transport.and.distribution.of.fuels.

The.EU.recognized.that.increased.demand.for.biofuels.would.result.in.increased.agricultural.land.use.and.potentially.this.could.include.conversion.of.carbon-rich.land.areas.into.agricultural.land.that.could.cause.adverse.carbon.emissions.impacts...The.RED.includes.provisions.to.prevent.the.risks.of.emissions.from.direct.LUCs.in.the.production.of.biofuels.by.defining.lands.that.are.not.eligible.to.be.used.for.producing.feedstocks.for.biofuels.under.the.Directive...Included.in.this.restriction.are.high.carbon.stock.lands.such.as.wetlands.and.forested.areas.having.canopy.cover.of.30%.or.more...Forested.areas.with.a.canopy.cover.between.10%.and.30%.must.be.included.in.the.restriction.unless.it.can.be.demonstrated.that.their.carbon.stock.is.low.enough.to.justify.conversion.to.biomass-feedstock.within.the.rules.set.by.the.Directive...The.European.Commis-sion.has.conducted.a.consultation.to.establish.the.definition.for.“highly.diverse.grasslands”.to.establish.the.criteria.and.geographic.ranges.that.should.be.covered.within.the.RED...The.final.conclusions.from.this.consultation.on.grasslands.definition.are.pending.

In.March.2010,.the.European.Commission.released.a.large.number.of.documents.relating.to.its.work.on.ILUC.under.the.Directive.2009/28/EC,.including.available.results.from.the.Partial.Equilibrium.Modelling...These.results.indicate.that.a.1.25%.increase.in.EU.biofuel.consumption.would.require.around.5.million.additional.hectares.of.land.globally...Results.of.a.General.Equilibrium.Model.were.also.released.that.analyzed.different.scenarios.for.biofuel.use.varying.from.5.6%.to.8.6%.of.road.transport.fuels...These.results.also.showed.that.ILUC.effects.off-set.part.of.the.emissions.benefits.from.the.use.of.biofuels.above.5.6%.level...Furthermore,.above.this.threshold,.ILUC.emissions.increase.at.greater.rate.that.can.erode.the.environmental.sustainability.of.biofuels.

Page 27: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

25 Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010

The.RED.identified.ILUC.as.an.issue.that.needed.further.investigation.and.study...In.response.to.this.directive.and.timeline,.the.Commission.published.Terms.of.Reference.for.the.Indirect.LUC.Impact.of.Biofuels...This.reference.builds.on.earlier.work.that.examined.overall.economic.and.environmental.impacts.of.the.EU.biofuels.policy.and.specific.trade.issues.associated.with.the.policy...The.subsequent.reference.establishes.three.modelling.exercises.on.ILUC:

n. Using.a.general.equilibrium.model;n. Using.a.partial.equilibrium.model;n. Comparing.other.global.modelling.approaches.

The.purposes.of.this.second.phase.of.biofuels.and.ILUC.study.are.to.address.questions.raised.in.the.earlier.effort.and.to.produce.a.more.detailed.and.reliable.estimate.of.ILUC.impacts.from.improvements.in.databases.and.modelling...The.outcome.of.this.study.is.a.report.that.analyses.the.global.agricultural.production,.trade.and.environmental.impact.of.the.EU.biofuels.policy.within.the.RED...Focus.is.on.the.ILUC.effects.of.the.main.feedstocks.used.for.biofuels.production...The.objective.is.to.contribute.to.the.impact.assessment.and.report.on.ILUC.and.possible.Commission.proposals.on.how.to.best.deal.with.ILUC.under.the.RED...

To.support.this.additional.work.and.the.possible.proposals.for.dealing.with.ILUC,.the.Commis-sion.carried.out.a.consultation.(governmental.and.private.inputs).on.a.defined.range.of.options.for.addressing.ILUC..Responses.to.the.consultation.were.received.from.17.countries.and.59.organizations...Even.though.the.deadline.for.the.report.on.ILUC.impacts.on.GHG.emissions.from.the.biofuels.policy.is.not.due.until.December.2010,.the.Commission.is.using.the.results.of.this.consultation.to.help.prepare.a.report.(March.2010).for.use.by.Member.States.in.preparing.their.national.Renewable.Energy.Action.Plans,.which.must.be.submitted.by.the.end.of.June.2010...The.consultation.demonstrated.that:

n. Member.states.are.widely.divided.on.the.issue.of.ILUC,.and.no.single.policy.option.is.fa-voured;

n. No.agreement.exists.either.on.the.issue.of.ILUC.outside.the.EU;n. Many.commenters.indicated.that.issues.on.ILUC.are.not.well.enough.defined.to.determine.

the.best.policy.options;n. Further.scientific.analysis.and.discussions.are.needed.before.ILUC.policy.can.be.established.

A.more.recent.issue.being.discussed.within.the.RED.implementation.is.waste.oils/residues,.tallow,.black.liquor.and.tall.oil.traditionally.used.for.feedstock.to.make.soaps,.detergents.and.other.related.chemicals,.and.now.being.more.often.used.as.substitutes.for.food-based.(grains).feed-stocks.for.biofuels.production...The.consequence.of.this.substitution.would.be.soaps/detergents/chemicals.producers.seeking.out.other.economic.feedstocks,.such.as.palm.oil.that.could.result.in.ILUC.impacts...Feedstocks.that.would.go.into.production.of.next-generation.renewable.fuels.will.need.to.consider.ILUC.effects.

united Kingdom: renewable Transport fuel obligation

The.UK.Renewable.Transport.Fuel.Obligation.(RTFO).program.requires.transport.fuel.suppliers.provide.5%.of.their.fuels.from.renewable.sources.by.2010...The.requirement.was.authorized.by.the.Energy.Act.of.2004,.which.came.into.effect.in.April.2008,.and.is.intended.to.help.the.UK.achieve.the.EU.biofuels.directive.targets...Although.not.mandated.by.the.legislation,.the.Renew-able.Fuels.Agency.(RFA).was.asked.to.conduct.a.review.of.the.impacts.from.this.requirement.and.increased.biofuels.production,.including.consideration.of.ILUC.and.changes.in.food.and.other.commodity.supplies.and.pricing...

The.RFA.study,.referred.to.as.the.Gallagher.Review,.was.published.in.July.2008.and.concluded.that.risks.exist.from.increasing.biofuels.production.and.demand,.and.that.although.uncertainties.exist.in.the.estimations,.feedstock.production.should.avoid.lands.otherwise.used.for.food.crops...

Page 28: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010 26

The.review.also.concluded.that.“quantification.of.GHG.emissions.from.indirect.land-use.change.requires.subjective.assumptions.and.contains.considerable.uncertainty.”..Because.of.this,.the.report.recommended.further.investigation.and.study.to.better.understand.the.impacts.of.indirect.effects,.including.ILUC.and.other.factors...The.UK.regulators.are.working.closely.with.the.EU.offi-cials.on.development.of.appropriate.methodologies.to.take.ILUC.into.account.for.GHG.emissions.from.biofuels.production.and.use.

united states: renewable fuels standard program

On.3.February.2010,.the.U.S..Environmental.Protection.Agency.(EPA).issued.the.final.regulations.for.the.federal.Renewable.Fuels.Standard.Program.(RFS2)...This.regulation.makes.changes.to.the.program.as.required.by.the.Energy Independence and Security Act of 2007.(EISA;.P.L..110-140)...The.statute.requires.increased.annual.use.of.renewable.fuels.in.transportation.fuel,.modi-fies.definitions.and.criteria.for.feedstocks.and.renewable.fuels.made.from.them,.and.establishes.GHG.emissions.reductions.thresholds.as.determined.by.LCAs.for.these.fuels...The.LCAs.must.take.into.account.the.direct.and.indirect.emissions.impacts.of.the.production.and.use.of.the.re-newable.fuels...

The.final.regulations.issued.by.EPA.for.the.RFS2.program.does.not.directly.include.provisions.on.ILUC.or.specific.requirements.for.conducting.LCA.on.biofuels..The.EPA.used.the.LCA.(with.incorporated.ILUC.impacts).process.to.help.identify.the.renewable.fuel.pathways.that.meet.the.statutory.GHG.reduction.thresholds,.and.thereby.qualify.for.compliance.under.the.RFS2.program...The.final.regulations.include.provisions.for.biofuel.producers.to.petition.the.EPA.for.evaluation.of.new.renewable.fuel.pathways...The.RFS2.regulations.require.that.biofuels.producers.con-duct.a.certified.engineering.assessment.and.attest.engagement.for.production.processes.and.feedstock(s).used...The.biofuels.producer.(either.domestic.or.foreign).must.also.register.into.the.program.and.maintain.documentation.and.recordkeeping.to.ensure.that.the.renewable.fuel.meets.the.requirements.to.qualify.for.use.under.the.RFS2.program...This.documentation.must.also.indi-cate.the.renewable.fuel.feedstock.source.thereby.allowing.EPA.to.monitor.land.use.

Obligated.parties.for.the.RFS2.regulations.include.domestic.and.foreign.producers.and.import-ers.of.transportation.fuels.used.in.the.U.S...This.regulation.also.establishes.the.2010.RFS.volume.standard.for.each.obligated.party.within.the.four.categories.of.renewable.fuels.set.in.the.EISA:.conventional.renewable.fuel;.advanced.biofuel;.biomass-based.diesel.fuel.and.cellulosic-based.biofuel...This.final.regulation.is.effective.on.July.1,.2010,.and.the.percentage.standards.apply.to.all.gasoline.and.diesel.fuel.produced.or.imported.in.2010...It.must.be.emphasized.that.ILUC.are.incorporated.into.the.LCA.for.biofuels.to.determine.whether.or.not.they.qualify.for.the.GHG.emissions.reductions.required.by.the.four.biofuel.categories.under.EISA.–.there.are.no.specific.standards.on.ILUC.in.the.RFS2.regulation..

The.EISA.legislation.established.the.general.requirements.for.considering.the.lifecycle.GHG.emissions.of.renewable.fuels.and.incorporation.of.direct.and.significant.indirect.emissions...The.legislation.also.provides.for.definitions.for.renewable.fuel.and.advanced.biofuel.as.those.produced.from.renewable.biomass.(also.defined).that.is.used.to.replace.or.reduce.fossil.fuel...The.provi-sions.further.provide.definitions.for.each.of.the.categories.of.qualified.biofuels.under.the.program,.namely,.renewable.fuel.(including.conventional.biofuel),.advanced.biofuel,.cellulosic.biofuel.and.biomass-based.diesel...

It.also.established.the.meaning.for.baseline.lifecycle.GHG.emissions...One.of.the.most.sig-nificant.provisions.in.the.statute.is.the.setting.of.GHG.emissions.reductions.thresholds.for.the.renewable.fuels.to.quality.for.compliance.purposes.under.the.RFS2.program...EPA.was.required.to.conduct.a.LCA.of.each.biofuel.type.to.determine.whether.or.not.it.can.meet.the.thresholds..The.statute.allows.for.EPA.to.consider.flexibility.for.these.reduction.thresholds;.however,.in.the.

Page 29: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

27 Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010

final.regulation.the.agency.retained.those.specified.by.the.law...EPA.followed.the.mandate.of.the.statute.in.considering.the.full.lifecycle.GHG.emissions.impacts.of.fuel.production.from.both.direct.and.indirect.emissions,.including.significant.emissions.from.LUCs...The.EPA.analyses.attempted.to.incorporate.the.“most.up-to-date”.science.and.methodologies.during.the.rulemaking.effort...The.agency.recognized.that.LCA.is.an.evolving.discipline.and.plans.to.re-evaluate.their.analyses.as.new.information.becomes.available...The.EPA.also.intends.to.ask.the.National.Academy.of.Sciences.for.assistance.and.input.to.the.process...

Throughout.the.regulatory.process.for.the.RFS2,.EPA.solicited.expert.input.to.evaluate.key.components.of.EPA’s.methodology.on.LCA.and.LUC:..

n. Land.use.modelling,.specifically.the.use.of.satellite.data.and.land.conversion.GHG.emission.factors;

n. Methods.to.account.for.the.variable.timing.of.GHG.emissions.associated.with.land.use;n. GHG.emissions.from.foreign.crop.production.(both.the.modelling.and.data.used);.and.n. How.the.models.are.used.together.to.provide.overall.lifecycle.estimates.

Based.on.public.comments.and.scientific.peer.review,.EPA.agreed.that.it.was.important.to.take.into.account.indirect.emissions.when.conducting.lifecycle.emissions.from.biofuels...It.was.also.clear.that.there.were.significant.uncertainties.associated.with.these.analyses,.particularly.with.regard.to.ILUC.and.the.use.of.economic.models.to.project.future.commodity.market.interactions.that.involve.biofuels,.feedstocks.and.agricultural.products...Working.closely.with.experts,.other.government.agencies.and.industry,.EPA.quantified,.to.the.extent.possible,.the.uncertainty.as-sociated.with.indirect.LUC.emissions,.including.international.changes,.associated.with.increased.biofuel.production...

To.manage.the.uncertainty.around.those.international.and.indirect.LUCs,.EPA.focused.on.three.approaches:

n. Getting.the.best.information.possible.and.updating.analyses.to.narrow.the.uncertainty;.n. Performing.sensitivity.analyses.around.key.factors.to.test.the.impact.on.the.results;.and.n. Establishing.reasonable.ranges.of.uncertainty.and.using.probability.distributions.within.these.

ranges.in.threshold.assessment.

From.its.assessments,.EPA.concludes.that.the.modelled.indirect.emissions.from.LUC,.includ-ing.international.changes,.were.“significant”.in.terms.of.their.relationship.to.total.GHG.emissions.for.given.fuel.pathways,.as.consistent.with.the.mandate.under.EISA...The.findings.in.these.analy-ses.were.incorporated.into.the.LCA.for.biofuels.to.determine.whether.or.not.they.qualify.for.the.GHG.emissions.reductions.required.by.the.four.biofuel.categories.under.EISA

California: low-Carbon fuels standard

On.1.January.2010,.the.California.Low.Carbon.Fuels.Standard.(LCFS).regulation.became.effective...The.regulation.is.designed.to.reduce.the.state’s.GHG.emissions.from.fuels.used.in.the.state.by.reducing.the.carbon.intensity.of.the.fuel.supplied.to.the.marketplace...This.reduction.in.carbon.intensity.(CI).is.being.phased-in.beginning.in.2011.and.will.achieve.a.10%.reduction.by.2020...In.determining.carbon.intensity.of.fuels,.the.California.Air.Resources.Board.(CARB).conducted.fuel.LCAs.that.incorporated.both.direct.and.indirect.impacts,.including.LUCs...The.regulations.were.adopted.on.23.April.2009,.and.final.administrative.approval.issued.on.12.January.2010..In.developing.the.LCFS,.the.CARB.established.a.process.to.evaluate.the.LCA,.including.direct.and.indirect.effects,.of.GHG.emissions.of.various.fuel.pathways...CARB.modified.available.models.to.incorporate.land.use.impacts.for.production.of.feedstocks.used.to.make.biofuels.for.the.LCFS.

CARB.calculates.fuel.CIs.under.the.LCFS.on.a.full.lifecycle.basis..This.means.that.the.CI.value.assigned.to.each.fuel.reflects.the.GHG.emissions.associated.with.that.fuel’s.production,.trans-

Page 30: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010 28

port,.storage,.and.use...Based.on.its.work.with.university.LUC.researchers,.CARB.staff.has.con-cluded.that.the.land.use.impacts.of.crop-based.biofuels.are.significant,.and.must.be.included.in.LCFS.fuel.CIs....CARB.believes.that.to.exclude.them.would.allow.fuels.with.CIs.that.are.similar.to.gasoline.and.diesel.fuel.to.function.as.low-carbon.fuels.under.the.LCFS...CARB.further.believes.this.would.delay.the.development.of.truly.low-carbon.fuels,.and.jeopardize.the.achievement.of.a.10%.reduction.in.fuel.CI.by.2020.

The.general.process.used.by.CARB.to.quantify.the.GHG.emissions.from.LUC.and.to.convert.those.emissions.to.a.CI.value.that.can.be.added.to.a.fuel’s.direct.CI.value.is.illustrated.in.Figure.4.

figure 4: luC Impact estimation process (Carb 2009).

Estimating.how.much.non-agricultural.land.is.converted.to.agricultural.uses.in.response.to.in-creased.demand.for.biofuels.requires.a.model.capable.of.simulating.the.multiple.economic.forces.driving.the.LUC.process..Models.of.the.international.agricultural.system.have.been.adapted.to.estimate.the.magnitude.of.biofuel-driven.LUC.impacts..The.GHG.emissions.generated.by.the.conversion.of.land.to.agricultural.uses.are.estimated.by.applying.emission.factors.to.the.acreage.of.land.converted..

Emission.factors.are.estimates.of.the.GHGs.released.from.each.converted.unit.of.land.area..GHGs.are.released.from.burned.or.decomposing.cover.vegetation.and.disturbed.soils..LUC.emis-sions.vary.substantially.with.time.and.emission.flows.are.converted.to.LUC.carbon.intensity.using.a.time.accounting.method..Large.initial.releases.of.GHGs.from.clearing.native.vegetation.are.followed.by.slower.releases.from.below-ground.materials..The.time-varying.emission.flows.are.converted.to.a.LUC.carbon.intensity.value.using.a.time.accounting.model.

.CARB.has.established.two.main.approaches.for.determining.the.CI.of.fuels.under.the.LCFS,.

both.of.which.consider.ILUC.impacts...The.first.method.is.CARB.“lookup.tables”.which.include.carbon.intensity.values.for.fuels.as.determined.by.the.agency.using.its.California-modified.GREET.model.(with.LUC.modifiers.when.applicable)...The.other.is.“customized.lookup.tables”.by.which.regulated.parties.may.propose.modifications.to.California-GREET.model.inputs,.including.new.fuel.pathways,.to.determine.fuel.specific.carbon.intensity.values...The.customized.approach.must.be.approved.by.CARB.and.meet.necessary.scientific.criteria.

Conclusion

As.noted.previously,.there.are.no.existing.internationally.agreed.methodologies.or.policy.struc-tures.for.dealing.with.ILUC.impacts.on.GHG.emissions.from.biofuels.production.and.use...The.need.to.improve.datasets.and.modelling.systems.to.more.reliable.determine.ILUC.and.sustain-ability.is.recognized.and.work.continues.to.effect.these.improvements...A.global.consensus.on.certification.and.sustainability.criteria.for.biofuels.would.address.many.issues.related.to.ILUC...

Page 31: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

29 Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010

Other.regions.and.countries.are.beginning.to.consider.ILUC.impacts.within.their.own.biofuels.polices.either.already.implemented.or.under.development...For.the.most.part,.none.of.these.countries.has.established.specific.legislative.or.regulatory.requirements.to.include.sustainability.criteria.and.ILUC.impacts.within.their.biofuels.programs...China,.India,.Malaysia.and.Philippines.have.established.land.use-related.policies.(detailed.in.Section.7).that.provide.guidance.on.how.their.lands.can.be.developed.for.biofuel.feedstock.production,.however.these.guidances.are.not.build.in.relation.to.ILUC.for.biofuels.use...As.the.expansion.of.formal.legislative.and.regulatory.programs.on.biofuels.production.and.use.occurs,.more.of.these.countries.will.incorporate.ILUC.impacts.into.their.policy.determinations.and.GHG.emissions.

7. oTHer polICy approaCHes THaT aDDress bIofuels IluC ConCernsAs.noted,.policies.that.serve.to.address.ILUC.concerns.are.being.or.have.been.included.in.bio-fuels.policies.in.the.U.S..and.the.EU...Other.countries.have.already.taken.or.are.taking.different.approaches.that.focus.on.land.use.management.and.promoting.or.requiring.best.agricultural.prac-tices...As.noted,.a.number.of.countries.have.instituted.specific.land.management.policies.to.help.ensure.that.biofuel.development.takes.place.on.land.which.will.not.impact.on.biodiversity,.social.and.economic.needs,.soil.erosion,.water.conservation,.labour.rights.and.land.rights...Moreover,.governments.have.also.taken.steps.to.promote.best.agricultural.practices.which.are.environ-mentally.sustainable.as.well.as.socially.accepted.and.promote.an.efficient.use.of.energy.should.negate.the.need.for.an.ILUC.factor..Best.agricultural.practices.would.include.such.practices.as.no-till.farming,.improving.integration.between.agriculture.and.cattle.operations,.and.phasing.out.pre-harvest.field.burning,.which.is.currently.practiced.in.some.sugar.cane.growing.countries...

This.section.provides.examples.of.such.policies.set.in.countries.such.as.Brazil,.China,.India,.Ma-laysia.and.the.Philippines...For.these.countries,.biofuels.are.not.only.seen.as.a.means.to.reduce.en-ergy.dependence,.but.as.a.key.mechanism.to.improve.farmers’.income.and.in.some.cases,.improve.remote.communities’.access.to.liquid.fuels...While.it.is.true.that.the.setting.of.a.particular.policy.is.much.different.than.ensuring.that.policy.is.implemented.through.an.appropriate.monitoring.and/or.enforcement.scheme,.it.is.important.to.note.that.countries.are.recognizing.that.there.may.be.LUC.issues.related.to.biofuels.production.and.use.and.that.they.are.taking.steps.to.address.those.issues...Many.of.these.countries.began.addressing.these.issues.before.biofuels.ILUC.came.to.the.fore.

At.the.outset,.consider.that.there.is.a.very.different.concept.of.land.use.between.the.western.context.and.Asian.context..In.the.Asian.context,.any.land.that.is.not.used.for.food.plantations.will.be.considered.as.“safe”.land.to.be.used.for.biofuels..Although.there.is.often.no.clear.policy.by.Asian.governments.on.their.land.use.policies.for.biofuels,.the.Asian.countries.do.not.intend.to.use.land.that.is.still.suitable.for.agricultural.use.to.be.converted.to.producing.crops.for.fuel...Many.stakeholders.in.Asia.have.difficulty.accepting.the.concept.of.ILUC.as.they.are.dealing.with.very.high.population.increase.rate..Hence.they.will.use.any.land.they.have.for.human.settlement.and.food.production.which.in.the.end.contribute.to.the.clearing.of.forests.and.peat.lands.

brazil

Brazilian.President.Lula.announced.a.proposal.in.September.2009.to.ensure.sustainable.expan-sion.of.sugar.cane.harvesting.in.Brazil.while.addressing.sustainability.and.ILUC.issues.in.the.Bra-zilian.sugar.cane.industry..In.addition,.the.Brazilian.Research.Center.for.Agriculture.(EMBRAPA).took.over.coordination.of.the.Agro-Ecologic.Zoning.Program.for.sugar.cane.nationally...The.results.of.the.Zoning.Program.should.be.used.as.guidelines.for.licensing.and.financing.decisions..The.following.aspects.of.the.program.are.being.considered.in.order.to.define.adequate.areas:.

n. Soil.and.weather.adequacy;.n. Topography;.

Page 32: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010 30

n. Water.availability;.n. Water.requirements;.n. Sugarcane.cannot.be.planted.in.areas.with.sensible.ecosystems;.n. Areas.where.other.crops.have.been.produced..

Approximately.35.Mha.would.be.declared.adequate.for.sugar.cane.cropping..These.areas.are.highly.concentrated.in.the.states.where.most.sugar.cane.production.already.occurs,.for.example.the.states.of.São.Paulo,.Paraná.and.Minas.Gerais...Another.such.program.adopted.in.Brazil.is.the.Verified.Sustainable.Ethanol.Initiative..In.May.2008,.the.Swedish.company.SEKAB.together.with.Brazilian.ethanol.producers.developed.this.program.and.verified.and.traceable.ethanol.has.been.available.in.Sweden.since.August.2008..The.sustainability.criteria.put.in.place.to.meet.EU.and.Swedish.National.law.include,.among.other.things,.a.specific.provision.concerning.zero.tolerance.for.felling.rainforest.and.continuous.monitoring.provisions.

The.Green.Protocol.of.the.State.of.São.Paulo.in.2007.establishes.an.early.phase-out.of.sugar.cane.pre-harvest.field.burning.(an.old.practice.utilized.to.facilitate.the.manual.sugar.cane.cutting):.from.2012.to.2014.for.mechanized.areas.and.from.2013.to.2017.for.steeper.slopes..This.protocol.is.a.voluntary.scheme.with.the.goal.of.promoting.best.practices.within.the.sugar.cane.industry..The.São.Paulo’s.government.future.target.is.to.issue.a.Certificate.of.Conformity.to.producers.adhering.to.this.program...

According.to.the.Association.of.Sugarcane.Producers.(UNICA),.the.elimination.of.straw.burn-ing.will.help.reduce.CO2.emissions.in.8.5.million.tons.over.the.10-year.period.that.the.protocol.is.scheduled.to.last..It.is.important.to.note.that.more.than.150.mills.(approximately.85%.of.produc-ers).and.13,000.suppliers.have.already.committed.to.meet.the.goals.established.by.the.protocol..Mechanized.areas. in. the.state. increased.from.34%.in.2007.to.53.8%.during. the.2009-2010.harvest,.scheduled.to.end.in.May.2010..That.means.that.more.than.half.of.the.cane.harvested.in.Brazil.takes.place.without.burning..By.the.2010-2011.harvest,.the.state.government.expects.to.reach.70%.of.conformity....

In.addition,.there.other.initiatives.currently.being.undertaken.in.Brazil.to.promote.best.agricul-tural.practices,.which.are.part.of.the.Agro-Environmental.Protocol,.such.as.protection.of.riparian.forests.in.sugar.cane.areas,.soil.conservation,.implementation.of.water.conservation.programs,.and.recycling.of.solid.wastes.among.others...Following.the.Green.Protocol.adopted.by.São.Paulo,.there.are.current.discussions.among.other.producing.states,.which.are.also.willing.to.phase.out.sugar.cane.field.burning.before.harvesting.in.their.regions...

China

In.China,.the.Ministry.of.Agriculture.in.2007.released.an.Agricultural.Biofuel.Industry.Plan.(2007-2015),.which.aims.to.develop.a.number.of.new.crop.bases.by.2010.to.provide.sufficient.biomass.resources.to.meet.the.country’s.growing.demand.for.ethanol.and.biodiesel..The.plan.expected.the.new.crop.bases.to.mostly.grow.non-grain.feedstock.such.as.sugar.cane,.sweet.sorghum,.cassava.and.sweet.potatoes.as.feedstock.for.ethanol.production.since.they.can.be.grown.on.non-arable.land..Sweet.sorghum.was.recommended.to.be.cultivated.on.10.million.hectares.of.unused.saline.land.located.in.the.provinces.of.Heilongjiang,.Shandong,.Inner.Mongolia,.Xinjiang.and.Hebei..The.plan.estimated.that.an.additional.13.million.hectares.of.unused.land.is.suitable.for.developing.new.cassava.plantations.in.the.provinces.of.Guangxi,.Guangdong,.Hainan,.Fujian.and.Yunnan..The.plan.also.recommended.the.expansion.of.sweet.potato.plantations.in.the.provinces.of.Guangxi,.Chongqing.and.Sichuan.

Some.governments.have.put.into.place.specific.policies.requiring.or.promoting.the.use.of.the.use.of.idle,.degraded,.marginal,.and/or.waste.land...Again,.however,.note.there.are.no.commonly.

Page 33: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

31 Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010

accepted.definitions.of.these.terms...Nevertheless,.the.Chinese.government.have.taken.steps.in.this.area...China’s.land.use.policy.restricts.biofuels.production.on.crop.land,.and.focuses.on.mar-ginal.or.wasteland.for.growing.feedstocks.for.producing.bioethanol.and.biodiesel..For.instance,.in.Southwest.China,.provincial.governments.have.plans.to.plant.jatropha.on.“barren.land”,.i.e.,.land.that.is.not.suitable.for.agricultural.use,.in.provinces.such.as.Sichuan,.Guizhou.and.Yunnan..The.governments.own.some.barren.land.which.would.be.managed.by.government.agencies.if.put.to.use;.a.significant.amount.of.barren.land.is.owned.by.village.collectives,.with.use.rights.granted.to.individual.households..In.China,.there.are.nearly.0.1.billion.ha.of.marginal.lands.including.saline,.sandy,.mining.lands,.etc.,.which.can.be.used.to.plant.energy.crops.

India

India.has.also.taken.steps.in.this.area...The.National.Policy.on.Biofuels.was.announced.in.Septem-ber.2008.which.was.subsequently.approved.in.December.2009..The.policy.aims.to.facilitate.and.bring.about.optimal.development.and.utilization.of.indigenous.biomass.feedstocks.for.production.of.biofuels..The.government’s.approach.to.biofuels.is.based.solely.on.non-food.feedstocks.to.be.raised.on.degraded.or.wastelands.that.are.not.suited.to.agriculture..The.focus.for.the.develop-ment.of.biofuels.in.India.will.be.to.utilize.waste.and.degraded.forest.and.non-forest.lands.only.for.cultivation.of.shrubs.and.trees.bearing.non-edible.oilseeds.for.production.of.biodiesel.

Plantations.of.trees.bearing.non-edible.oilseeds.in.India.will.be.taken.up.on.government/com-munity.wasteland,.degraded.or.fallow.land.in.forest.and.non-forest.areas..Contract.farming.on.private.wasteland.could.also.be.taken.up.and.plantations.on.agricultural.lands.will.be.discouraged..In.all.cases.pertaining.to.land.use.for.the.plantations,.consultations.would.be.undertaken.with.the.local.communities.through.Gram.Panchayats/Gram.Sabhas,.and.with.Intermediate.Panchayats.and.District.Panchayat.where.plantations.of.non-edible.oilseed.bearing.trees.and.shrubs.are.spread.over.more.than.one.village.or.more.than.one.block..State.governments.would.also.be.required.to.decide.on.land.use.for.plantation.of.non-edible.oilseed.bearing.plants.or.other.feedstocks.of.biofuels,.and.on.allotment.of.government.wasteland,.degraded.land.for.raising.such.plantations..

Jatropha.is.one.of.the.most.popular.non-edible.oilseeds.used.for.biodiesel.production.in.India..As.India.has.nearly.60.million.hectares.of.wasteland,.the.government.has.indicated.that.about.30.million.hectares.could.be.made.available.for.plantations.with.an.aim.to.producing.a.minimum.of.2.tons.(8,602.gallons).of.biodiesel.per.year.per.hectare..This.can.be.achieved.through.research.on.improving.the.productivity.of.jatropha.oilseeds,.mastering.extraction.and.esterification.technol-ogy,.and.finding.profitable.by.products..According.to.the.Ministry.of.New.and.Renewable.Energy,.930,000.ha.of.wastelands.were.covered.with.jatropha.and.pongamia.plantations.in.eight.states.as.of.February.2010.

Access.to.land.is.a.fundamental.importance.in.India.especially.in.rural.areas..It.remains.the.principal.determinant.of.rural.income.distribution..In.the.Indian.context,.in.which.a.large.and.rising.share.of.the.rural.poor.derive.livelihoods.principally.from.their.own.labour,.a.powerful.case.can.be.made.in.favour.of.more.equitable.land.distribution.on.the.grounds.that.such.a.strategy.would.generate.more.employment.than.the.alternative..In.general,.with.the.main.objectives.being.to.reduce.poverty,.raising.agricultural.productivity.and.promoting.social.inclusion,.there.are.strong.arguments.for.seeking.ways.to.improve.access.to.land.for.the.poor.and.other.socially.excluded.groups.in.rural.India1..This.will.“eliminate”.the.need.to.follow.ILUC.concept.

malaysia

The.government.of.Malaysia.has.set.a.combination.of.policies.described.above.that.attempt.to.address.sustainability.concerns,.including.biofuels.LUC,.though.there.has.been.criticism.of.the..

1 T. Haque, national Centre for agricultural economics and policy research, “land use planning in India – retrospect and prospect.”

Page 34: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010 32

government’s. lax.enforcement.of. these.policies..There. is.already.a. legislation.regulating.the.sustainable.development.of.the.palm.oil.industry.including.the.Land.Acquisition.Act.1960,.Land.Conservation.Act.1960.(revised.in.1989).and.National.Land.Code.1965,.Quality.Act.1974.(Environ-mental.Quality).(Prescribed.Premises).(Crude.Palm.Oil).Regulation.1977...

The.government.has.set.a.number.of.new.initiatives.to.ensure.sustainability.and.competitive-ness.of.the.oil.palm.industry..In.August.2007,.the.Ministry.of.Plantation,.Industries.and.Com-modities.launched.the.“Codes.of.Practices.&.Sustainability.Manual.”..In.addition.to.preparing.a.sustainability.manual.for.the.oil.palm.industry,.the.following.five.codes.of.practices.were.set:

n. Good.agricultural.practice.for.oil.palm.estates.and.smallholdings;.n. Good.milling.practice.for.palm.oil.mills;n. Good.crushing.practice.for.palm.kernel.crushers;.n. Good.refining.practice.for.palm.oil.refineries;n. Good.practice.for.the.handling,.transport.and.storage.of.products.from.the.oil.palm.

According.to.the.Malaysian.Palm.Oil.Council.(MPOC),.the.Malaysian.palm.oil.industry.is.sup-portive.of.addressing.biofuels.ILUC,.but.remains.concerned.about.the.issues.such.as.the.method-ologies.to.analyse.ILUC.and.the.potential.impact.to.developing.rural.economies...Though.a.diverse.group.of.stakeholders.have.formed.the.Roundtable.on.Sustainable.Palm.Oil.(RSPO).and.adopted.“Principles.and.Criteria.for.Sustainable.Palm.Oil.Production”.which.in.part.addresses.biofuels.ILUC.concerns,.there.has.been.public.criticism.of.the.lack.of.“teeth”.in.the.RSPO.principles.

The philippines

The.Biofuels.Act.of.2006.(Republic.Act.9637).was.formally.signed.into.law.on.Jan..17,.2007...The.enactment.of.the.Biofuels.Act,.which.mandates.the.utilization.of.idle.lands.for.feedstock.production.in.the.Philippines,.led.to.the.commissioning.of.the.Department.of.Agriculture.to.formulate.the.Bio-fuels.Feedstock.Program..It.has.two.subprograms.including.the.Biodiesel.Feedstock.Program.and.the.Bioethanol.Feedstock.Program,.with.implementation.targeted.within.five.years.starting.in.2007..

Through.the.Philippine.Agricultural.Development.and.Commercial.Corporation.(PADCC),.the.Department.of.Agriculture.provides.information.on.assistance.in.selecting.ideal.investment.loca-tions;.joint.venture.matching;.and.facilitation.of.surveys,.permits,.and.clearances.to.biofuel.inves-tors..As.of.2008,.49.biofuel.projects.generated.a.total.of.11,539.ha.planted.with.various.crops.(8,887.ha.for.biodiesel.and.2,652.ha.for.bioethanol)..The.program.supports.feedstock.production.through.R&D.such.as.varietal.improvement.of.potential.feedstock.sources.including.seed.produc-tion,.planting.materials,.plantation.development.and.postharvest.technologies.

In.December.2008,.a.Joint.Administrative.Order.(JAO).No..2008-1.was.signed.by.various.Philip-pine.government.agencies.on.the.“Guidelines.Governing.the.Biofuel.Feedstocks.Production,.and.Biofuels.and.Biofuel.Blends.Production,.Distribution.and.Sale.under.Republic.Act.No..9637.”.Also.known.as.the.Omnibus.Guidelines.on.Biofuels,.they.basically.provide.guidance.on.screening.and.processing.applications.for.certifications,.licenses.and.permits.to.operate.as.a.biofuel.feedstock.producer,.biofuel.and.biofuel.blend.producer,.distributor.and.reseller..One.of.the.land.use.guidelines.ensures.that.lands.devoted.to.food.crops.shall.not.be.utilized.for.biofuel.feedstocks.production..

The.JAO.specifies.requirements.for.biofuel.feedstock.producers,.where.applicants.are.required.to.secure.certification.from.the.Department.of.Agriculture.that.the.feedstock.or.the.proposed.biofuel.feedstock.area.may.be.utilized.for.the.production.of.biofuel.feedstock..Certification.is.not.required.if.the.feedstock.to.be.used.(e.g..molasses).does.not.involve.land.utilization..The.following.are.the.criteria.for.the.issuance.of.certification:.

n. Cereals.that.can.be.used.both.for.food.and.for.biofuel.production.such.as,.but.not.limited.to,.maize.and.wheat.shall.not.be.used.for.biofuel.production;

Page 35: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

33 Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010

n. The.land.to.be.used.shall.be.consistent.with.the.natural.expansion.of.the.municipality.or.lo-cality,.as.contained.in.the.approved.physical.framework.and.land.use.plan.by.the.concerned.municipality.or.locality;.

n. The.area.that.will.be.used.is.not.the.only.remaining.food.production.area.of.the.community;n. All.agricultural.areas.classified.hereunder.shall.not.be.utilized.for.biofuel.feedstock.production:

•. All.areas.covered.by.government-funded.irrigation.facilities,.either.national.agency.or.LGU,.designed.to.support.rice.and.other.crop.production,.and.all.irrigated.lands.where.water.is.not.available.for.rice.and.other.crop.production.but.are.within.areas.programmed.for.irrigation.facility.rehabilitation.by.the.department.of.agriculture.and.the.national.irriga-tion.administration.(NIA);

•. All.irrigable.lands.already.covered.by.irrigation.projects.with.firm.funding.commitments.as.certified.by.NIA.at.the.time.of.the.application.for.land.use.conversion;

•. All.privately.irrigated.alluvial.plain.lands.utilized.for.rice.and.maize.production;.and•. All.agricultural.lands.that.are.ecologically.fragile,.the.utilization.of.which.will.result.in.seri-

ous.environmental.degradation.

The.Department.of.Agriculture.has.listed.in.one.of.its.conditions.to.evaluate.that.the.areas.are.underutilized.and.marginal.before.issuing.the.certification..Independent.biofuel.feedstock.produc-ers.(i.e..has.no.marketing.or.supply.agreement.with.a.biofuel.producer).with.effective.areas.of.less.than.25.hectares.are.exempted.from.securing.the.certification..On.the.other.hand,.biofuel.producers.which.hold.agricultural.lands.as.biofuels.are.required.to.apply.to.the.Department.of.Agriculture’s.National.Technical.Committee.on.Land.Use.Matters.(NTECLUM).to.secure.the.Cer-tification.of.Eligibility.for.Reclassification.of.Agricultural.Lands.

Conclusion

A.number.of.countries.are.sensitive.to.biofuels.LUC...While.these.countries.have.not.followed.the.lead.of.the.U.S..and.EU.in.biofuels.ILUC.policy.setting,.these.countries.have.been.addressing.LUC.by.putting.into.place.legislation.and/or.regulations.that.require.specific.land.use.manage-ment.practices.for.biofuels.feedstocks...Moreover,.they.have.taken.steps.to.address.the.issue.by.promoting.and/or.requiring.best.agricultural.practice...Notably,.many.of.these.countries.began.to.consider.these.issues.before.they.became.a.popular.point.of.discussion.in.the.biofuels.realm.and.before.some.industry-lead.initiatives.gained.popularity.and.focus...Some.countries.have.put.into.place.ambitious.policies.in.this.area.but.effective.enforcement.of.these.policies.is.lacking.

We.note.also.that.a.number.of.voluntary.initiatives.have.emerged.in.addition.to.the.RSPO,.high-lighted.above...Many.of.the.sustainability.criteria.and.principles.contained.within.other.voluntary.initiatives.such.as.the.Roundtable.for.Sustainable.Biofuels.(RSB),.Roundtable.on.Responsible.Soy.Association.(RTRS),.Better.Sugar.Cane.Initiative.(BSI).include.concepts.that.in.effect.address.bio-fuels.LUC.as.well...However,.with.the.exception.of.the.BSI.none.of.the.schemes.have.addressed.directly.biofuels.ILUC,.preferring.instead.to.concentrate.among.other.things.on.best.practice.within.land.management,.biodiversity,.water.resources.and.human.social.and.economic.rights

The.BSI.has.applied.to.the.EU.Commission.for.voluntary.scheme.recognition..To.qualify.for.EU.recognition.under.RED.section.6,.the.basis.for.the.calculation.of.GHG.emissions.and.the.protec-tion.of.land.with.high.biodiversity.value.must.be.presented..Section.6.does.not.currently.allow.for.actual.values.to.be.used.when.calculating.the.greenhouse.gas.emissions.from.the.production.and.use.of.sugarcane.ethanol..This.may.be.changed.in.future.revisions..To.calculate.emissions.the.default.values.in.annex.V.of.the.RED.must.be.used..GHG.emissions.resulting.from.changes.in.land.carbon.stocks.must.be.added.to.the.default.values..

The.RSB.recognizes.the.effect.of.both.biofuels.DLUC.and.ILUC,.and.Principle.3.of.the.standard.–.Greenhouse.Gas.Emissions.–.makes.reference.to.this.when.calculating.the.lifecycle.GHG.emis-sions.of.the.feedstock.or.biofuel..In.June.2010.at.a.RSB.workshop.held.in.Rio.de.Janeiro.it.was.

Page 36: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010 34

agreed.by.the.majority.of.participants.that.the.RSB.should.continue.to.review.indirect.impacts.of.biofuels,.however.no.consensus.was.reached.as.to.how.this.should.be.reflected.in.its.Standards..When.discussing.indirect.impacts.at.the.project.level,.the.majority.opinion.was.that.an.ILUC.factor.was.not.a.good.option.and.that.more.emphasis.should.be.placed.on.“qualitative.approaches”..It.was.suggested.that.a.differentiation.be.made.among.feedstocks.based.on.regional.differences.and.that.feedstocks.be.classified.according.to.their.risk.level.for.indirect.impacts.

8. IluC anD poTenTIal ImplICaTIons for THe emergIng global bIofuels marKeT

Biofuels.supply.and.demand.is.expected.to.grow.in.the.coming.years...By.2020,.total.demand.for.biofuels.in.the.four.major.producing.and.consuming.regions.of.North.America,.Latin.America.&.Caribbean,.EU.and.Asia-Pacific.may.reach.249.4.billion.liters.(65.8.billion.gallons)..Ethanol.demand.will.represent.the.overwhelming.majority.of.this.demand.at.73%,.representing.184.billion.liters.(48.6.billion.gallons).and.may.represent.13%.by.volume.of.the.global.gasoline.pool.by.2020.(Hart.2010)...Biodiesel.demand.will.continue.to.increase,.but.more.modestly,.representing.6%.of.the.on-road.diesel.pool.comprising.the.aforementioned.four.regions,.or.65.3.billion.liters.(17.25.billion.gallons),.by.2020.(Hart.2010)...Africa.is.expected.to.contribute.very.modestly.to.both.biofuels.supply.and.demand.through.this.time.period.

The.effect.of.ILUC.on.the.emerging.global.biofuels.market.is.potentially.expected.to.be.two-fold:.first.as.ILUC.policies.may.prevent.the.use.of.some.feedstocks.in.large.markets.and..demand.for.other,.more.sustainable.biofuels.will.rise...The.biofuels.that.are.linked.to.ILUC.concerns.may.find.markets.in.other.countries.that.are.now.only.starting.their.biofuels.policies.but.are.not.as.concerned.by.biofuels.ILUC.issues...More.than.39.countries.either.have.or.are.scheduled.to.imple-ment.biofuels.mandates.in.2010.and.the.majority.of.those.are.in.developing.countries.which.have.not.expressed.concerns.about.biofuels.ILUC...This.section.will.first.review.the.expected.supply.and.demand.of.ethanol.and.biodiesel.until.2020.with.some.ILUC.considerations,.and.then,.the.impact.of.ILUC.on.the.expected.biofuels.trade.flows.both.to.countries.which.have.ILUC.policies.in.place,.and.those.which.do.not..

ethanol outlook to 2020

Ethanol.is.the.main.biofuel.currently.used.worldwide.with.the.two.main.producers.and.consumers.being.Brazil.and.the.U.S...Ethanol.is.expected.to.remain.the.main.biofuel.used.and.the.main.sup-plier.of.ethanol.on.the.international.market.until.2020.is.expected.to.be.Brazil.by.an.overwhelm-ing.margin...The.main.parameter.expected.to.affect.ethanol.trade.flows.in.the.near.future.is.the.sustainability.criteria.that.have.been.used.in.biofuels.policies.in.the.U.S..(RFS2).and.California.(LCFS).and.in.the.EU.(RED.and.FQD)...By.attributing.high.GHG-saving.potential.to.Brazilian.etha-nol.specifically,.these.policies.are.expected.to.create.high.demand.for.this.product,.which.in.turn.could.affect.other.ethanol.and.sugar-producing.countries,.thus.leading.to.potential.ILUC.concerns...The.analysis.hereafter.shows.the.expected.trends.in.the.ethanol.market.worldwide.considering.four.main.biofuel-producing.regions:.Asia.Pacific,.EU27,.Latin.America.and.North.America..Ethanol.supply.and.demand.projection.until.2015.by.region.is.presented.in.Figure.5...It.shows.that.the.Western.Hemisphere,.lead.by.the.U.S..and.Brazil,.will.continue.to.represent.about.86%.of.global.ethanol.production.and.nearly.80%.of.consumption.through.2020.

As.figure.5.shows,.there.will.be.some.supply.growth.in.the.Asia-Pacific.region.by.2020,.which.will.represent.10%.of.global.ethanol.production.by.then...EU-27.supply.growth.over.by.2020.is.quite.modest.as.traditionally.only.50%.of.capacity.has.been.used.and.is.reported.in.this.forecast..On.the.demand.side,.the.EU.currently.imports.around.1.5.billion.litres.of.ethanol.mainly.from.Brazil.(2009.and.2010)..This.figure.is.expected.to.double.by.2020.to.nearly.4.billion.litres..

Page 37: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

35 Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010

On.the.supply.side,.ethanol.is.expected.to.be.only.first.generation.ethanol.until.at.least.2015,.in.spite.of.research.efforts.and.funds.being.allocated.to.cellulosic.ethanol.so.as.to.allow.the.use.on.non-food,.non-ILUC.and.high.GHG.emission.savings.ethanol.(Hart.2009)...Cellulosic.ethanol.proj-ects.are.not.expected.to.produce.large.enough.commercial.volumes.by.2015.to.satisfy.require-ments.in.countries.such.as.the.U.S..This.is.one.of.the.main.drivers.for.Brazilian.ethanol.imports,.as.the.GHG.saving.potential.associated.with.it.is.high.and.Brazilian.ethanol.is.even.considered.an.advanced.biofuel.in.the.U.S..under.the.RFS2.program...Demand.for.Brazilian.ethanol.is.expected.to.grow.substantially.in.the.U.S..and.in.particular.in.the.state.of.California..

Essentially,.sugar.cane.ethanol.from.Brazil.is.the.only.commercially.available,.economical.bio-fuel.available.to.meet.RFS2.advanced.biofuel.requirements..In.California,.it.has.been.estimated.that.at.least.50%.of.the.state’s.ethanol.demand.could.be.satisfied.with.Brazilian.ethanol.(Hart.2009)..The.growth.in.sugarcane.ethanol.demand.is.directly.due.to.the.LCFS.which.takes.effect.in.2011..Total.Brazilian.ethanol.demand.in.the.U.S..could.reach.5.7.billion.litres.(1.5.billion.gallons).by.2015..By.2020,.Brazil.will.be.in.position.to.export.a.minimum.11.billion.litres.(approximately.3.billion.gallons).to.the.world.market,.in.particular,.the.U.S.,.Europe,.Japan.and.possibly.China...Meantime,.internal.ethanol.demand.in.Brazil.is.expected.to.continue.to.climb.as.well.

biodiesel outlook to 2020

Biodiesel.is.a.distant.second.after.ethanol.in.terms.of.global.biofuels.supply.and.demand..Never-theless,.palm.oil.cultivation.in.South.East.Asia.linked.to.biodiesel.production.has.helped.to.trigger.the.debate.on.ILUC.when.it.was.shown.that.new.plantations.were.started.on.cleared.tropical.forest.land.even.if.forest.clearing.has.been.mainly.linked.to.timber.production...A.similar.situation.has.been.found.in.Latin.America,.in.particular.in.Brazil,.where.it.was.charged.that.soy.oil.planta-tions.were.encroaching.on.the.Amazon.forest.and.then.led.to.the.soy.moratorium.in.Brazil...As.a.result,.an.ILUC.factor.in.biofuels.policies.around.the.world.may.well.affect.biodiesel.feedstocks.and.the.biodiesel.market.perhaps.more.than.it.is.expected.to.affect.the.ethanol.market..

Figure.6.shows.the.expected.biodiesel.market.evolution.until.2020.in.four.regions:.Asia.Pacific,.EU27,.Latin.America.and.North.America..The.analysis.does.not.take.directly.ILUC.into.consideration.and.the.impact.of.ILUC.is.discussed.following.the.business.as.usual.case.presented.hereafter.

figure 5: ethanol supply and Demand by region, 2010-2020 (Hart 2010).

-10,000.0020,000.0030,000.0040,000.0050,000.0060,000.0070,000.0080,000.0090,000.00

Supply Demand Supply Demand Supply Demand Supply Demand

Asia Pacific EU 27 Latin America North America

Mill

ion

Lite

rs

2010 2015 2020

Page 38: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010 36

-

5,000

10,000

15,000

20,000

25,000

30,000

Supply Demand Supply Demand Supply Demand

2010 2015 2020

Mill

ion

Lite

rs

Asia Pacific EU 27 Latin America North America

figure 6: biodiesel supply and Demand by region, 2010-2020 (Hart 2010).

As.can.be.seen.in.Figure.6,.with.respect.to.biodiesel,.Europe.currently.dominates.consumption.representing.about.61%.of.global.consumption.in.2010..The.region.also.represents.50%.of.sup-ply...However,.significant.growth.in.supply.and.demand.is.expected.to.come.from.the.Asia-Pacific.and.Latin.American.regions..Combined,.these.two.regions.are.projected.to.overtake.Europe.by.2020.and.represent.about.51%.of.global.biodiesel.demand...

For.2010.and.even.2015,.the.increase.in.capacity.will.lead.to.similar.utilization.rates.even.if.con-sumption.actually.increases.because.of.higher.mandate.levels..The.EU.relies.mainly.on.rapeseed.as.biodiesel.feedstock,.although.high.prices.have.led.the.region.to.look.at.cheaper.oils.such.as.soy.and.palm.oils.as.biodiesel.feedstocks..Should.the.RED.include.an.ILUC.factor.it.would.therefore.affect.the.potential.of.the.region.to.import.these.oils.or.biodiesel.

Global.biodiesel.supply.will.have.to.double.over.the.2010-2020.timeframe.to.accommodate.de-mand.requirements.that.governments.around.the.world.are.aiming.to.implement..With.biodiesel.overcapacity.an.issue.globally,.producers.in.other.countries.complaining.about.cheap.imports.and.with.policies.structured.that.tend.to.disfavor.imports.altogether,.many.countries.will.focus.on.their.own.internal.markets..For.example,.the.governments.of.Brazil.and.Argentina.are.likely.to.increase.biodiesel.blending.limits.to.absorb.excess.capacity.and.will.supply.their.respective.internal.mar-kets...Many.of.these.countries.do.not.address.biofuels.ILUC.in.their.biodiesel.policies.at.this.time...

As.previously.discussed,.palm.oil.is.the.feedstock.most.closely.associated.with.potential.ILUC.issues..Recent.studies.give.ILUC.values.for.palm.oil.of.74.kg/GJ.to.153.kg/GJ.for.20.years.of.depreciation,.compared.to.lower.or.negative.values.for.rapeseed,.wheat,.corn.or.sugar.beet..Soy.however.has.been.attributed.a.very.high.ILUC.factor.in.one.study.of.166.kg/GJ..The.ILUC.values.should.not.hide.the.fact.that.palm.is.a.very.efficient.plant.with.a.very.high.oil.yield..Should.ILUC.factors.lead.palm.oil.and.palm.oil.based.biodiesel.from.Indonesia.and.Malaysia.to.fail.the.EU.and.U.S..sustainability.criteria.after.2011,.then.the.2015.biodiesel.supply.and.demand.scenario.would.be.severely.affected..By.then,.potentially.20.1.billion.litres.(5.3.billion.gallons).oversupply.of.biodiesel.from.Indonesia.and.Malaysia.would.be.without.value.for.the.EU.and.U.S..biofuels.targets..As.mentioned.earlier,.the.U.S..is.not.expected.to.need.large.quantities.of.feedstock.or.biodiesel.imports.from.outside.since.the.soybean.biodiesel.GHG.factor.has.been.found.to.meet.the.minimum.GHG.criteria.under.the.RFS2.program..

In.the.EU,.the.expected.biodiesel.demand.in.2015.is.close.to.18.8.billion.litres.(5.billion.gallons).and.the.EU.biodiesel.capacity.should.exceed.that.demand.at.26.5.billion.litres.(7.billion.gallons)..In.

Page 39: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

37Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010

spite.of.the.fact.that.the.EU.has.enough.capacity.to.meet.its.demand,.biodiesel.is.imported.into.the.EU..Biodiesel.from.the.U.S.,.Argentina.and.South.East.Asia.has.been.imported.into.Europe.due.to.economic.considerations.as.local.rapeseed.oil.or.rapeseed.biodiesel.was.more.expensive.than.imports..By.2015.supply.of.biodiesel.from.the.EU.should.be.around.15.billion.litres.(4.billion.gallons).therefore.leading.to.3.8.billion.litres.(1.billion.gallon).of.imports..However.by.2015.the.38%.GHG.saving.default.value.achieved.by.rapeseed.biodiesel.will.be.struggling.to.meet.the.2017.target.of.50%.minimum.GHG.reduction.under.the.RED.unless.the.value.has.been.improved.through.advances.in.rapeseed.LCA.or.the.FAME.from.rapeseed.production.process..

The.EU.biodiesel.producers.could.therefore.have.to.look.at.alternative.feedstocks..However.as.the.GHG.saving.default.values.stand.now,.both.palm.oil.and.soybean.oil.appear.to.have.worse.GHG.savings.than.rapeseed.oil,.unless.there.is.methane.capture.at.the.oil.mill.in.the.case.of.palm.oil..The.fact.that.the.palm.oil.GHG.saving.factor.has.been.revised.in.the.U.S..could.lead.to.a.revision.in.the.EU.too..Considering.the.existing.GHG.saving.factors,.the.potential.biodiesel.feedstocks.meeting.the.50%.cut.would.be.sunflower.oil,.palm.oil.with.methane.capture.at.the.oil.mill.and.tallow.or.other.wastes..The.fact.that.palm.oil.could.face.ILUC.issues.and.not.be.available.to.the.EU.could.therefore.severely.affect.the.potential.of.the.EU.to.meet.its.biofuels.mandate.under.the.RED.

A.side.effect.of.the.ILUC.factor.preventing.or.limiting.palm.oil.from.being.used.in.the.EU.bi-odiesel.industry.could.be.the.increase.in.the.use.of.ethanol.in.the.EU..As.the.mandate.for.biofuels.would.still.be.in.place.for.2020.Member.States.could.meet.their.obligation.with.more.ethanol.and.less.biodiesel..This.in.turn.would.put.pressure.on.the.ethanol.producing.countries.and.could.potentially.lead.to.ILUC.in.ethanol.exporting.countries...In.addition,.Hart.sees.as.highly.probable.the.creation.of.a.biofuels.market.between.developing.countries,.thus.by-passing.the.EU.and.U.S..where.ILUC.factors.would.be.implemented..Palm.biodiesel.from.Malaysia.and.Indonesia.could.be.used.in.the.countries.where.it.is.produced,.with.no.ILUC.limitation,.but.could.also.be.exported.to.other.large.markets.where.there.are.no.ILUC.considerations.such.as.China..In.that.case,.the.introduction.of.ILUC.factors.in.the.EU.and.U.S..would.fail.to.meet.its.purpose.

Another.region.which.could.be.affected.by.the.introduction.of.ILUC.factors.applied.to.biofuels.is.Africa..There.are.for.now.over.27.African.countries.where.biofuels.projects.have.been.launched.or.announced.and.the.targets.are.both.the.internal.and.exports.markets.as.shown.in.Figure.7..The.countries.that.plan.on.exporting.biofuels.are.generally.looking.at.the.EU.as.an.export.market..

figure 7: biofuels projects in africa (Hart 2010).

Page 40: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010 38

This.is.because.of.historical.links.as.well.as.tax.benefits..The.restriction.of.exports.in.other.biofuel.producing.regions.could.potentially.affect.biofuels.projects.in.Africa.by.creating.more.demand.for.biofuels.from.the.region..However.there.are.also.reports.of.unsustainable.land.developments.associated.with.biofuels.plantations.in.Africa.and.ILUC.issues.too..It.is.therefore.quite.unsure.whether.the.continent.would.be.able.to.supply.the.shortfall.of.biodiesel.demand.or.extra.etha-nol.demand.from.the.EU.should.other.regions.be.unsuitable.feedstock.providers.due.to.ILUC.concerns..As.in.Asia,.African.countries.could.look.for.other.biofuels.markets.where.to.sell.their.production,.thus.bypassing.ILUC.issues.

9. ConClusIon: balanCIng THe rIsKs anD unCerTaInTIesIt. is.clear. from.this. review.that.multiple.uncertainties.exist.about.a.wide. range.of. factors. in.assessing.biofuels.ILUC:.true.land.availability,.yields,.GHG.savings,.net.energy.savings,.direct.environmental.effects.and.potential.market.impacts.and.unintended.consequences.of.biofuels.ILUC.penalties.or.factors...All.these.affect.the.amount.of.DLUC.and.ILUC.and.make.accurate.projections.extremely.unlikely.and.hence.any.economic.decisions.extremely.risky..Permutations.and.combinations.of.LUC.are.endless.and.their.drivers.are.many.and.interrelated...Given.high.uncertainty,.there.is.much.variation.in.outputs.between.different.models.due.to.errors.and.dif-ferences.in.input.data,.digital.maps.and.remote.sensing.interpretation.and.how.well.algorithms.included.in.the.model.express.important.processes.and.simulate.dominant.LUC..There.is.even.

general.uncertainty.in.predicting.future.LUC.decisions.involving.human.free.will.and.behaviour..Lohmann.(2006).raised.some.important.points.about.risk.and.uncertainty.by.recalling.the.seminal.

work.of.the.great.20th.century.economist.Frank.Knight’s.Risk, Uncertainty and Profit.(1921)..Knight.is.famous.for.his.distinction.between.risk.and.uncertainty,.which.Lohmann.expands.as.follows:

Risk.in.Knight’s.sense.refers.to.situations.where.the.probability.is.well.known,.e.g..flipping.a.coin..Such.known.risk.factors.in.biofuels,.we.suggest.are.currently.few.

Uncertainty.is.different:.you.know.the.things.that.can.go.wrong,.but.cannot.calculate.the.prob-ability,.e.g..the.effects.of.weather.on.yields.over.the.next.few.years.

Ignorance.is.again.different:.these.are.the.unknown.unknowns,.and.ILUC.is.a.case.in.point,.of.something.that.was.largely.unknown.and.is.now.perhaps.in.the.process.of.becoming.“uncertain”.

Finally.there.is.indeterminacy.where.the.probability.of.a.result.cannot.be.calculated.because.it.is.not.a.matter.of.science,.modelling.and.prediction,.but.of.decision..Hence.future.political.decisions.cannot.be.easily.guessed.and.so.not.factored.into.calculations..Currently.this.is.a.major.problem.for.the.private.sector,.which.requires.clear.signals.about.government.direction.on.climate.change,.carbon.prices.and.much.else,.in.order.to.make.important.investment.decisions..In.such.cases,.Lohmann.suggests.that.even.trying.to.assign.a.probability.to.an.outcome.can.affect.the.likelihood.of.the.outcome.itself...Risk.fits.easily.into.economic.thinking,.because.it.can.be.easily.measured..Uncertainty,.ignorance.and.indeterminacy.however.call.for.a.more.precautionary.and.flexible,.less.numerical.approach..To.date.in.the.case.of.biofuels,.the.subject.has.not.been.noted.for.a.precau-tionary.approach...Lohmann.cautions.that.by.mixing.up.the.analytically.distinct.concepts.outlined.above,.risks.blundering.into.what.Knight.would.call.a.‘fatal.ambiguity’.

The.complexities.of.biofuels.ILUC.can.be.appreciated.from.the.flow.diagram.(Figure.8).as.well.as.the.centrality.of.land.use.issues..To.each.of.the.boxes.can.or.should.be.attached.estimates.of.risk,.uncertainty.and.indeterminacy,.which.we.believe.are.largely.lacking.and.need.to.be.assessed.if.we.are.to.truly.assess.the.future.of.biofuels.and.their.indirect.effects..

Quite.simply,.the.policy.and.market.development.of.biofuels.have.proceeded.so.quickly.over.the.last.decade.that.the.science.needed.to.untangle.the.complexities.of.biofuels.ILUC.and.ad-dress.the.uncertainties.pointed.out.above.has.been.outpaced..Biofuels.will.be.an.important.tool.for.many.countries.as.they.begin.to.diversify.their.energy.portfolios.in.this.century.and.it.is.important.

Page 41: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

39 Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010

to.note.that.not.all.biofuels.and.biofuels.feedstocks.are.created.equally...We.hope.that.the.many.uncertainties.raised.in.this.paper.do.not.detract.the.reader.from.contemplating.the.serious.issues.that.biofuels.LUC.present..The.switch.away.from.fossil.fuels.to.renewable.alternatives.will.have.unforeseen.consequences,.especially.for.highly.populated.resource-poor.countries.and.presently.the.role.of.biofuels.in.this.process.is.very.unclear.

We.end.this.review.with.a.list.of.knowledge.gaps.that.need.addressing.and.some.suggestions.for.stakeholders:

1..Moreexperimentationandmodelling:It.is.clear.that.there.are.several.aspects.of.biofuel.production.that.work.against.the.very.goals.policies.are.trying.to.achieve.–.reduction.of.GHGs.and.protection.of.scarce.and.valuable.natural.resources..These.need.to.be.very.carefully.elu-cidated.by.monitoring,.experimenting.and.modelling.in.many.locations.around.the.planet.

figure 8: analytical framework for the analysis of the cause and effect relations of land use competition (from rathmann et al 2010).

Page 42: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010 40

2..EstablishstandardmethodologiestoevaluateLUCfrombiofuels:It.is.very.clear.that.there.are.major.site-specific.effects.of.biofuel-related.agriculture.which.may.explain.some.of.the.differences.between.different.published.papers,.but.even.so,.the.extent.of.ranges.displayed.(Figure.9).suggests.major.methodological.differences..There.should.now.be.a.major.effort.to.establish.reliable.standard.methodologies.to.be.followed.at.the.experimental.and.pilot.scale.to.fully.evaluate.the.wide.range.of.effects,.direct.and.indirect,.that.ensue.from.growing.biofuels..This.would.enable.much.greater.confidence.when.comparing.future.studies.and.greatly.enable.decision.makers.to.make.more.informed.judgments..

3..Quantifyavailablemarginalland:Marginal,.abandoned,.degraded.and.unused.lands.are.really.the.only.possible.sources.of.significant. land.for.biofuel.expansion..They.are.often.invoked.but.rarely.quantified..How.much.of.each.exists.in.each.region?..What.are.the.prob-lems.to.be.overcome.to.bring.these.lands.into.production?.

4..Establisheffectivelandusemanagementandbestagriculturepracticepoliciesforbio-fuelsfeedstockcrops:.It.is.not.clear.whether.ILUC.factors.or.penalties.in.biofuels.programs.will.ultimately.be.successful...More.useful.may.be.establishing.land.use.management.and.best.agricultural.practice.policies.in.conjunction.with.biofuels.programs.which.some.coun-tries.are.already.doing.and.as.described.in.Section.7.

We.also.suggest.that.experts.continue.to.convene.to.discuss.these.issues.and.work.toward.establishing.methodologies.that.will.further.help.illuminate.the.complex.issues.surrounding.bio-fuels.ILUC...The.development.of.a.knowledge.product.or.tool.kit.to.help.regulators.in.countries.plan.rationally.for.the.future.may.be.advisable.as.well.

We.conclude.with.a.final.thought:

“Upon this handful of soil our survival depends. Husband it and it will grow our food, our fuel, and our shelter and surround us with beauty. Abuse it and the soil will collapse and die, taking humanity with it”..[The.Vedas.Sanskrit.Scripture.1500.BC]

figure 9: The two extremes of the IluC debate (after bauen and Howes in Woods, 2009).

ILUC optimist

ILUC pessimist

Page 43: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

41 Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010

10. aCKnoWleDgemenT:Hart.Energy.Consulting.and.CABI.gratefully.acknowledge.the.financial.contributions.by.Packard.Foundation.and.Energy.Foundation.that.supported.the.production.of.this.paper.

Hart.Energy.Consulting.and.CABI.felt.that.peer.review.was.extremely.important.to.ensure.that.we.presented.this.subject.in.a.balanced.and.fair.manner,.and.that.the.most.important.and.relevant.literature.was.included..Therefore.this.paper.has.been.peer-reviewed.by.a.select.but.balanced.group.of.relevant.experts..Although.the.views.expressed.by.peer-reviewers.are.not.necessarily.represented.in.the.published.paper,.we.have.been.grateful.to.all.peer-reviewers.who.provided.valuable.comments..We.acknowledge.among.others:

•. Bliss.Baker,.President,.Global.Renewable.Fuels.Alliance.•. Bruce.Dale,.Professor,.Department.of.Chemical.Engineering.and.Materials.Science./.DOE.

Great.Lakes.Bioenergy.Research.Center,.University.of.Michigan•. Sandrine.Dixson-Declève,.Director,.University.of.Cambridge.Programme.for.Sustainability.

Leadership•. Victoria.Junquera,.Manager.of.Science.and.Technology,.Roundtable.on.Sustainable.Biofuels•. Lian.Pin.Koh,.Senior.Research.Fellow,.Institute.of.Terrestrial.Ecosystems,.Swiss.Federal.

Institute.of.Technology•. Robert.Larson,.Associate.Director,.Transportation.and.Climate.Division,.United.States.Envi-

ronmental.Protection.Agency•. Marcelo.Moreira,.Professor.Econometrics,.Economics.Department,.Columbia.University.and.

Researcher,.Instituto.de.Estudos.do.Comércio.e.Negociações.Internacionais.(ICONE)•. Martina.Otto,.Head,.Energy.Unit,.United.Nations.Environment.Program

The.following.HEC.and.CABI.staff.contributed.to.this.paper:

HEC:•. Denise.Green.([email protected]),.manager,.Europe.&.Africa•. Tammy.Klein.([email protected]),.assistant.vice.president•. John.Kneiss.([email protected]),.director,.government.affairs.&.U.S..policy•. Huiming.Li.([email protected]),.director,.Asia•. Lucky.Nurafiatin.([email protected]),.research.manager,.Middle.East.&.Asia•. Maelle.Soares-Pinto.([email protected]),.director,.biofuels,.Europe

CABI:•. Peter.Baker.([email protected]),.senior.scientist.commodity.crops•. Julie.Flood.([email protected]),.global.director.commodity.crops•. Lindsey.Norgrove.([email protected]),.global.director.invasive.species.management•. Alexis.Rendell-Dunn.([email protected]),.content.manager.plant.sciences•. Janny.Vos.([email protected]),.head.business.development,.Europe

Page 44: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010 42

referenCesAchten. W. M. J,. Verchot. L,. Franken. Y. J,. Mathijs. E,. Singh. V. P,. Aerts. R,. Muys. B. (2008).Jatropha. bio-diesel. production. and. use.. Biomass and Bioenergy. 32,. 1063-1084.

Achten.W,.Maes.W,.Aerts.R,.Verchot.L,.Trabucco.A,.Mathijs.E,.Singh.V,.Muys.B.(2010).Jatropha:.From.global.hype.to.local.opportunity...Journal of Arid Environments.In.Press..

Aide.T.M,.Zimmerman.J.K,.Rosario.M,.Marcano.H,.Walker.L.R,.Silver.W.L,.Willig.M.R,.Zimmer-man.J.K.(1996).Land-use.dynamics.in.a.post-agricultural.Puerto.Rican.landscape.(1936-1988)..Biotropica.4A,.525-536.

Ariffin.D,.Idris.A.S,.Singh.G.(2000).Status.of.Ganoderma.in.Oil.Palm..In.‘Ganoderma.Diseases.of.Perennial.Crops’.(eds.J.Flood,.P.D.Bridge.and.M.Holderness).CABI.Publishing,.Wallingford,.UK..http://bookshop.cabi.org/

Aubréville.A.(1938).La.forêt.coloniale:.Les.forêts.de.l’Afrique.Occidentale.Française,.Annales.d’Académie.des.Sciences.Coloniales,.IX..Société.d’Editions.Géographiques,.Maritimes.et.Colo-niales,.Paris.

Aubréville.A.(1949).Climats,.Forets.et.Desertification.de.l’Afrique.Tropicale;.Geographie.Maritime.et.Coloniale..Paris,.351.

Balesdent.J,.Chenu.C,.Balabane.M.(2000).Relationship.of.soil.organic.matter.dynamics.to.physical.protection.and.tillage..Soil and Tillage Research.53,.215-230.

Bassett.T,.Koli.Bi.Z.(2000).Environmental.discourses.and.the.Ivorian.savanna..Annals of the As-sociation of American Geographers 90,.67-95..Berg.S.(1997).Some.aspects.of.LCA.in.the.analysis.of.forestry.operations..Journal of Cleaner Production.5,.211-217..

Binswanger.H.P.and.McIntire.J.(1987).Behavioral.and.material.determinants.of.production.rela-tions.in.land.abundant.tropical.agriculture..Economic Development and Cultural Change.36,.73-99..

Boddey.R.M,.Aves.B.J.R,.Urquiaga.S,.Fisher.M.(2002).Potential.for.carbon.accumulation.under.Brachiaria.pastures.in.Brazil..In.Kimble.J,.Lal.R,.Follet.R.(eds).Agriculture practices and policies for carbon sequestration in soil..Advances.in.Soil.Science.Series,.CRC.Press,.Boca.Raton,.Florida...http://www.crcpress.com/

Bondeau.A,.Smith.P.C,.,.Zaehle.S,.Schaphoff.S,.Lucht.W,.Cramer.W,.Gerten.D,.Lotze-Campen.H,.Müller.C,.Reichstein.M,.Smith.W.B.(2007).Modelling.the.role.of.agriculture.for.the.20th.century.global.terrestrial.carbon.balance..Global Change Biology.13,.679-706..

Boserup.E.(1965)..The.conditions.of.agricultural.growth..The.economics.of.agrarian.change.under.population.pressure..George.Allen.and.Unwin,.London..http://www.routledge.com

Brittaine.R,.Lutaladio.N.(2010).Jatropha:.A.smallholder.bioenergy.crop.-.the.potential.for.pro-poor.development..Integrated.Crop.Management.Vol..8..1-114,.FAO..http://www.fao.org/docrep/012/i1219e/i1219e00.htm.Bruinsma,.J.(2003).World.agriculture:.towards.2015/2030..An.FAO.perspective..Earthscan,.Lon-don..http://www.fao.org/docrep/005/y4252e/y4252e00.htm

Page 45: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

43 Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010

Bryant.D,.Nielsen.D,.Tangley.L.(1997).The.last.frontier.forests:.ecosystems.and.economies.on.the.edge..World.Resources.Institute,.Washington.DC..http://www.globalforestwatch.org/english/pdfs/Last_Frontier_Forests.pdf

Burney.J.A,.Davis.S.J,.Lobell,.D.B.(2010).Greenhouse.gas.mitigation.by.agricultural.intensification..Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 107,.12052-12057..

Cadisch.G,.Giller.K.(2001).Soil.organic.matter.management:.The.role.of.residue.quality.in.C.se-questration.and.N.supply..In:.Sustainable Management of Soil Organic Matter..Eds.R.M.Rees,.B.C.Ball,.C.D.Campbell.and.B.A.Watson...97-111...CAB.International,.Wallingford,.UK..http://bookshop.cabi.org/

California.Code.of.Regulations,.Title.17,.Chapter.1,.Subchapter.10,.Article.4,.Subarticle.7.–.Low.Carbon.Fuel.Standard,.1.January.2010,.http://www.arb.ca.gov/regact/2009/lcfs09/finalfro.pdf..

Campbell.J.E,.Lobell.D.B,.Genova.R.C,.Field.C.B.(2008).The.global.potential.of.bioenergy.on.aban-doned.agricultural.lands..Environmental Science & Technology.42,.5791-5794..

Cherubini.F.(2010).GHG.balances.of.bioenergy.systems.–.Overview.of.key.steps.in.the.production.chain.and.methodological.concerns..Renewable Energy.35,1565–1573.

Chevalier.A.(1909).Les.massifs.montagneux.du.nord-ouest.de.la.Côte.d’Ivoire..La Géographie 20,.207-224.

Contribution.of.Working.Group.II.to.the.Fourth.Assessment.Report.of.the.Intergovernmental.Panel.on.Climate.Change.(2007).Climate.change.2007.–.impacts,.adaptation.and.vulnerability..M.L..Parry,.O.F..Canziani,.J.P..Palutikof,.P.J..van.der.Linden.and.C.E..Hanson,.Eds..Cambridge.University.Press,.Cambridge,.UK,.976.pp.http://www.cambridge.org/

Cotula.L,.Vermeulen.S,.Leonard.R,.Keeley.J.(2009).Land.grab.or.development.opportunity?.Ag-ricultural.investment.and.international.land.deals.in.Africa.IIED/FAO/IFAD,.London/Rome..ISBN:.978-1-84369-741-1.http://www.fao.org/docrep/011/ak241e/ak241e00.htm

Coulter.J.K.(1992).Population.pressures,.deforestation.and.land.in.the.wet.tropical.forest.zones:.the.technical.dimension..In:.Gregerson.H,.Gram.P,.Spears.J.(eds).Priorities.for.forestry.&.agro-forestry.policy.research..pp.33-53..International.Food.Policy.Research.Institute,.New.York,.USA..http://www.ifpri.org/publication/priorities-forestry-and-agroforestry-policy-research

DBCCA.(2009).DB.Climate.Change.Advisors..Investing.in.agriculture:.far-reaching.challenge,.sig-nificant.opportunity..http://www.dbcca.com/research.

Demont.M,.Jouve.P,..Stessens.J,.Tollens.E..(2007).Boserup.versus.Malthus.revisited:.Evolution.of.farming.systems.in.northern.Côte.d’Ivoire..Agricultural Systems.93,.215–228.

Dijkstra.F.A,.Hobbie.S.E,.Knops.J.M,.Reich.P.B.(2004).Nitrogen.deposition.and.plant.species.interact.to.influence.soil.carbon.stabilization..Ecology Letters.7,.1192–1198..

Dijkstra.F.A,.Hobbie.S.E,.Reich..P.B,.Knops.J.M..(2005).Divergent.effects.of.elevated.CO2,.N.fertilization,.and.plant.diversity.on.soil.C.and.N.dynamics.in.a.grassland.field.experiment..Plant and Soil 272,.41–52..

Page 46: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010 44

Doumenge.C,.Garcia.Yuste.J-E,.Gartlan.S,.Langrand.O,..Ndinga.A..(2001).Conservation.de.la.bio-diversité.forestière.en.Afrique.Centrale.Atlantique.:.Le.réseau.d’aires.protégées.est-il.adéquat.?.Bois et Forêts des Tropiques.268,.5-27.. http://bft.revuesonline.com/

European.Commission,.Environment.Directorate-General.(2009).Terms.of.Reference.for.the.Indi-rect.LUC.Impact.of.Biofuels.http://ec.europa.eu/environment/air/transport/pdf/DG%20TRADE%20GEM.pdf..

Fairhead.J,.Leach.M.(1994).Contested.forests:.modern.conservation.and.historical.land.use.in.Guin-ea’s.Ziama.reserve..African Affairs.93,.481-512..http://afraf.oxfordjournals.org/content/93/373.toc

Fairhead.J,.Leach.M.(1996).Misreading.the.African.landscape:.society.and.ecology.in.a.forest-savanna.mosaic..Cambridge.University.Press,.Cambridge/New.York..http://www.cambridge.org/

FAO.(1995).World.Agriculture:.Towards.2010..An.FAO.Study..Rome..http://www.fao.org/docrep/v4200e/v4200e00.htm

FAO. (1997). State. of. the. World’s. Forests.. Oxford,. UK.. http://www.fao.org/docrep/w4345e/w4345e00.htm

FAO. (2009).The state of food insecurity in the world. Economic crises: impacts and lessons learned; Rome, FAO, 56 pp.http://www.fao.org/publications/sofi/en/

Fargione.J.E,.Hill.J,.Tilman.D,.Polasky.S,.Hawthorne.P.(2008).Land.clearing.and.the.biofuel.carbon.debt..Science.319,.1235-1238..

Farrell..A.E,.Plevin.R.J,.Turner.B.T,.Jones.A.D,.O’Hare.M,.Kammen.D.M (2006).Ethanol.can.con-tribute.to.energy.and.environmental.goals..Science.311,.506-508..

Finnveden.G,.Hauschild.M.Z,.Ekvall.T,.Guinée.J,.Heijungs.R,.Hellweg.S,.Koehler.A,.Pennington.D,.Suh,.S.W.(2009).Recent.developments.in.Life.Cycle.Assessment..Journal of Environmental Management 91, 1-21.

Fischer.G,.van.Velthuizen.H.T,.Shah.M.M.(2002)..Global.Agro-ecological.Assessment.for.Agricul-ture.in.the.21st.Century:.Methodology.and.Results..International.Institute.for.Applied.Systems.Analysis,.Laxenburg,.Austria.and.FAO,.Rome..http://www.iiasa.ac.at/Admin/PUB/Documents/RR-02-002.pdf

Fitzherbert.E.B,.Struebig.M.J,.Morel.A,.Danielsen.F,..Bruehl.C.A,.Donald.P.F,..Phalan.B.(2008).How.will.oil.palm.expansion.affect.biodiversity?.Trends in Ecology and Evolution.23,.538-545..

Francis.G,.Edinger.R,.Becker.K.(2005).A.concept.for.simultaneous.wasteland.reclamation,.fuel.production,.and.socio-economic.development.in.degradedareas.in.India:.need,.potential.and.perspectives.of.Jatropha.plantations..Natural Resources Forum.29,.12–24..

Garcia-Quijano.J,.Peters.J,.Cockx.L,.van.Wyk.G,.Rosanov.A,.Deckmyn.G,.Ceulemans.R,.Ward.S,.Holden.N,.Van.Orshoven.J,.Muys.B.(2007).Carbon.sequestration.and.environmental.effects.of.afforestation.with..Pinus radiata.D..Don.in.the.Western.Cape,.South.Africa..Climatic Change.83,.323-355..

Gerbens-Leenes.W,..Hoekstra.A.Y,.Meer.van.der.T.H.(2009).The.water.footprint.of.bioenergy..Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.106,.10219–10223..

Page 47: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

45 Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010

Giampietro.M,.Mayumi.K.(2009).The.Biofuel.Delusion..Earthscan,.London,.Sterling.V..A.http://www.earthscan.co.uk/

Gibbs.H.K;.Ruesch.A.S;.Achard.F;.Clayton.M.K;.Holmgren.P;.Ramankutty.N;.Foley.J.A.(2010).Trop-ical.forests.were.the.primary.sources.of.new.agricultural.land.in.the.1980s.and.1990s..Proceed-ings.of.the.National.Academy.of.Sciences.107,.16732–16737..doi:.10.1073/pnas.0910275107

Gnansounou.E,.Dauriat.A,.Panichelli.L,.Villegas.J.(2008)..Energy.and.greenhouse.gas.balances:.biases.induced.by.LCA.modelling.choices..Journal of Scientific & Industrial Research.67,.885-897.http://nopr.niscair.res.in/bitstream/123456789/2418/1/JSIR%2067%2811%29%20885-897.pdf

Goetze.D,.Hoersch.B,.Porembski.S.(2006).Dynamics.of.forest–savanna.mosaics.in.north-eastern.Ivory.Coast.from.1954.to.2002..Journal of Biogeography 33,.653–664..

Grandin.G.(2009).Fordlandia:.The.Rise.and.Fall.of.Henry.Ford’s.Forgotten.Jungle.City,.Metropoli-tan.Books..http://us.macmillan.com/metropolitan.aspx.Green.D.(2010).Sustainability.Criteria.Initiatives,.Global.Biofuels.Center..http://www.globalbiofu-elscenter.com/

Grieg-Gran.M.(2006).The.cost.of.avoiding.deforestation..Report.prepared.for.the.Stern.Review.of.the.Economics.of.Climate.Change..International.Institute.for.Environment.and.Development,.London,.UK..http://www.iied.org/pubs/pdfs/G02489.pdf

Hall.C.A.S,.Balogh.S,.Murphy.D.J.R.(2009).What.is.the.minimum.EROI.that.a.sustainable.society.must.have?.Energies.2,.25-47..

Hammerschlag.R.(2006).Ethanol’s.return.on.investment:.a.survey.of.the.literature.1990–present..Environmental Science & Technology 40,.1744–1750..

Haugen.H.M.(2010)..Biofuel.potential.and.FAO’s.estimates.of.available.land:.The.case.of.Tanzania.Journal of Ecology and the Natural Environment..2,.30-37.http://www.academicjournals.org/jene/PDF/Pdf2010/March/Haugen.pdf

Heanes.D.L.(1984).Determination.of.organic.C.in.soils.by.an.improved.chromic.acid.digestion.and.spectro-photometric.procedure..Communications in Soil Science and Plant Analysis.15,.1191-1213..

Heller.J.(1996).Physic.Nut.–.Jatropha.curcas.L..–.Promoting.the.Conservation.and.Use.of.Underuti-lized.and.Neglected.Crops..PhD.dissertation,.Institute.of.Plant.Genetic.and.Crop.Plant.Research,.Gatersleben,.Germany.&.International.Plant.Genetic.Resource.Institute,.Rome,.Italy..http://tinyurl.com/cg2pw8.

Hennenberg.K.J,.Goetze.D,.Minden.V,.Traoré.D,.Porembski.S.(2005).Size-class.distribution.of.Anogeissus leiocarpus (Combretaceae).along.forest–savanna.ecotones.in.northern.Ivory.Coast..Journal of Tropical Ecology.21,.273-281..

Hoekstra.A.Y,.Chapagain.A.K.(2007).Water.footprints.of.nations:.water.use.by.people.as.a.function.of.their.consumption.pattern..Water Resources Management.21,.35–48..

Houghton.R.A.(2003).Revised.estimates.of.the.annual.net.flux.of.carbon.to.the.atmosphere.from.changes.in.land.use.and.land.management..Tellus B.55,.378–390..

House.J.I,.Prentice.I.C,.Ramankutty.N.(2003).Reconciling.apparent.inconsistencies.in.estimates.of.terrestrial.CO2.sources.and.sinks..Tellus Series B, Chemical and Physical Meteorology.55,.345–363.

Page 48: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010 46

Ickowitz.A.(2006).Shifting.cultivation.and.deforestation.in.tropical.Africa:.critical.reflections..De-velopment and Change.37,.599–626..

Intergovernmental.Panel.on.Climate.Change.(2000).Special.Report.on.Land.Use,.LUC,.and.For-estry..Intergovernmental.Panel.on.Climate.Change..Geneva,.Switzerland..Cambridge.University.Press..http://www.cambridge.org/

IEA. Bioenergy. (2009). Bioenergy. –. The. Impact. of. Indirect. LUC.. Summary. and. conclusions.from. the. IEA. Bioenergy. ExCo63. Workshop.. Website. http://www.ieabioenergy.com/DocSet.aspx?id=6214&ret=lib.

IEA.World.Energy.Outlook.(2009)..http://www.worldenergyoutlook.org/.IEA.Bioenergy.task38.(2009).Workshop.Report:.LUCs.due.to.Bioenergy:.Quantifying.and.Manag-ing.Climate.Change.and.Other.Environmental.Impacts,.http://ieabioenergy-task38.org/workshops/helsink09/Task38_Helsinki_workshop_summary_final.pdf.

International.Water.Management.Institute.(2008)..Water.implications.of.biofuel.crops:.under-standing.tradeoff.and.identifying.options..IWMI.Water.Policy.Brief.30,.4.pp..http://www.iwmi.cgiar.org/Publications/Water_Policy_Briefs/PDF/WPB30.pdf

Johnston.M,.Foley.J.A,.Holloway.T,.Kucharik.C,.Monfreda.C.(2009).Resetting.global.expectations.from.agricultural.biofuels..Environmental Research Letters.4,.1-9..http://iopscience.iop.org/1748-9326/4/1/014004/pdf/erl9_1_014004.pdf

Kampman.B,.Brouwer.F,.Schepers.B.(2008).Agricultural.land.availability.and.demand.in.2020..A.global.analysis.of.drivers.and.demand.for.feedstock,.and.agricultural.land.availability..CE-Publica-tions.No..08.4723.29,.CE.Delft,.Netherlands.

Kim.H,.Kim.S,.Dale.B.E.(2009).Biofuels,.land.use.change,.and.greenhouse.gas.emissions:.some.unexplored.variables..Environmental Science & Technology.43,.961-996.

Klein.T,.Soares-Pinto.M,.Li.H,.Kosaka.L,.Steiner.P,.Higgins.T,.Potter.F,.Warren.M.(2009).Global.Biofuels.Outlook.2009-2015:.Projecting.Market.Demand.by.Country,.Region.and.Globally..http://www.globalbiofuelscenter.com/

Knight.F.H.(1921).Risk,.Uncertainty.and.Profit,.Houghton.Mifflin,.Boston,.USA

Koh.L.P.(2007).Impending.disaster.or.sliver.of.hope.for.Southeast.Asian.forests?.The.devil.may.lie.in.the.details..Biodiversity Conservation.16,.3935–3938..

Koh.L.P,.Ghazoul.J.(2008).Biofuels,.biodiversity,.and.people:.understanding.the.conflicts.and.find-ing.opportunities..Biological Conservation.141,.2450–2460..

Kotto-Same.J,.Moukam.A,.Njomgang.R,.Tiki-Manga.T,.Tonye.J,.Diaw.C,.Gockowski.J,.Hauser.S,.Weise.S,.Nwaga.D,.Zapfack.L,.Palm.C,.Woomer.P,.Gillison.A,.Bignell.D,.Tondoh.J.(2000).Alterna-tives.to.Slash-and-Burn.Summary.Report.and.Synthesis.of.Phase.II.in.Cameroon..Nairobi,.ICRAF..72.pp.http://www.worldagroforestry.org/downloads/publications/PDFs/B14791.pdf

Lapola.D.M,.Schaldach.R,.Alcamo.J,.Bondeau.A,.Koch.J,.Koelking.C,.Priess.J.A,.(2010).Indirect.land-use.changes.can.overcome.carbon.savings.from.biofuels.in.Brazil..Published.online.before.print.on.February.8,.2010,.doi:.10.1073/pnas.0907318107.

Page 49: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

47 Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010

Lathwell.D.J.(1990).Legume.green.manures..Principles.for.management.based.on.recent.re-search..TropSoils Bulletin.90-01..Soil.Management.Collaborative.Research.Support.Program,.North.Carolina.State.University,.Raleigh,.USA.

Lobell.D.B,.Field.C.B.(2007).Global.scale.climate–crop.yield.relationships.and.the.impacts.of.recent.warming..Environmental Research Letters.2,.014002..

Lohmann.L.(2006).Carbon.Trading,.a.critical.conversation.on.climate.change,privatisation. and. power.. Development Dialogue. 48,. 362. pp.. http://www.dhf.uu.se/pdffiler/DD2006_48_carbon_trading/carbon_trading_web.pdf

Maley.J,.Brenac.P.(1998).Vegetation.dynamics,.palaeoenvironments.and.climatic.changes.in.the.forests.of.western.Cameroon.during.the.last.28000.years.BP..Review of Palaeobotany and Paly-nology.99,.157-187..

Manson.S,.Evans.T.(2007).Agent-based.modeling.of.deforestation.in.southern.Yucatan,.Mexico,.and.reforestation.in.the.Midwest.United.States..Proceedings of the National Academy of Sci-ences.104,.20678-20683..

Mathews.J.A,.Tan.H.(2009).Biofuels.and.indirect.LUC.effects:.the.debate.continues..Biofuels, Bioproducts & Biorefining 3,.305-317..

Melillo.J.M,.Reilly.J.M,.Kicklighter.D.K,.Gurgel.A.C,.Cronin.T.W,.Paltsev.S,..Felzer.B.S,.Wang.X,.Sokolov.A.P,.Schlosser.C.A.(2009).Indirect.emissions.from.biofuels:.how.important?..Science...326,.1397.–.1399..

Menichetti.E,.Otto.M.(2009).Energy.Balance.&.Greenhouse.Gas.Emissions.of.Biofuels.from.a.Life-.Cycle.Perspective..Biofuels:.Environmental.Consequences.and.Interactions.with.Changing.Land.Use..In:.Howarth.RW,.Bringezu.S,.eds.,.Proceedings.of.the.Scientific.Committee.on.Problems.of.the.Environment.(SCOPE).International.Biofuels.Project.Rapid.Assessment,.22-25.September.2008,.Gummersbach,.Germany,.81-109..

Mertens.B,.Lambin.E.F.(2000).Land.cover.change.trajectories.in.southern.Cameroon..Annals of the Association of American Geographers.90,.467-494..

Midmore.D.J.(1993).Agronomic.modification.of.resource.use.and.intercrop.productivity..Field Crops Research.34,.357-380..

Moad.A.S,.Whitmore.J.L.(1994).Tropical.forest.management.in.the.Asia-Pacific.region..Journal of Sustainable Forestry.1,.25-63..

National.Research.Council.(2007).Water.Implications.of.Biofuels.Production.in.the.United.States...Committee.on.Water.Implications.of.Biofuels.Production.in.the.United.States,.ISBN:.0-309-11360-1,.86.pp..http://www.nap.edu/catalog.php?record_id=12039

Nelson.G.C,.Rosegrant.M.W,.Koo.J,.Robertson.R,.Sulser.T,.Zhu.T,.Ringler.C,..Msangi.S,.Palazzo.A,.Batka.M,.Magalhaes.M,.Valmonte-Santos.R,.Ewing.M,..Lee.D.(2009).Climate.Change.Impact.on.Agriculture.and.Costs.of.Adaptation..International.Food.Policy.Research.Institute,.Washington,.D.C...30.pp..http://www.ifpri.org/publication/climate-change-impact-agriculture-and-costs-adaptation

Norgrove.L.(2006).Conflicting.views.of.changes.in.forest.cover.in.the.forest.savannah.transition.zone.in.central.Cameroon..International Workshop for Afrikanists in Germany..Centre.for.Interdis-ciplinary.Africa.Research,.Frankfurt.am.Main,.Germany..

Page 50: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010 48

Norgrove.L.(2010).Impacts.of.biofuel.production.on.food.security..IUFoST.Scientific.Information.Bulletin,.March.2010..21.pp.http://iufost.org/sites/default/files/docs/IUF.SIB.BiofuelProduction.pdf

Oerke.E.C,.Dehne.H.W.(1997).Global.crop.production.and.the.efficacy.of.crop.protection.–.current.situation.and.future.trends..European Journal of Plant Pathology.103,.203–215..

Ou.Xunmin,.Zhang.Xiliang,.Chang.Shiyan,.Guo.Qingfang.(2009).Energy.consumption.and.GHG.emissions.of.six.biofuel.pathways.by.LCA.in.(the).People’s.Republic.of.China...Applied Energy.86,.S197–S208..

Pfister.S,.Hellweg.S,.(2009).The.water.‘‘shoesize’’.vs..footprint.of.bioenergy..Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 106,.E93–E94..

Pimentel.D,.Patzek.T.W.(2005).Ethanol.production.using.corn,.switchgrass,.and.wood;.biodiesel.production.using.soybean.and.sunflower..Natural Resources Research.14,.65-76..

Pontius.R.G,.Neeti.N.(2010).Uncertainty.in.the.difference.between.maps.of.future.land.change.scenarios..Sustainability Science.5,.39-50..

Pontius.R.G,.Walker.R,.Yao-Kumah.R,.Arima.E,.Aldrich.S,.Caldas,.M,.Vergara.D.(2007).Accuracy.assessment.for.a.simulation.model.of.Amazonian.deforestation..Annals of the Association of American Geographers.97,.677-695.

Ramankutty.N,.Foley.J.A.(1999).Estimating.historical.changes.in.global.land.cover;.croplands.from.1700.to.1992..Global Biogeochemical Cycles.13,.997–1028..

Rathmann.R,.Szklo.A,.Schaeffer.R..(2010).Land.use.competition.for.production.of.food.and.liquid.biofuels:.an.analysis.of.the.arguments.in.the.current.debate..Renewable.Energy.35,.14–22..

Renewable.Fuels.Agency.(2008).The.Gallagher.Review.of.the.Indirect.Effects.of.Biofuels.Produc-tion.available.at.http://www.renewablefuelsagency.gov.uk/reportsandpublications/reviewofthein-directeffectsofbiofuels.

Righelato.R,.Spracklen.D.V.(2007).Carbon.mitigation.by.biofuels.or.by.saving.and.restoring.for-ests?.Science.317,.902..

Rindfuss.R.R,.Walsh.S.J,.Turner.II.B.L.Fox.J,.Mishra.V.(2004).Developing.a.science.of.land.change:.challenges.and.methodological.issues..Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.101,.13976-13981..

Robiglio.V,.Mala.W.A,.Diaw.M.C.(2003).Mapping.landscapes:.integrating.GIS.and.social.science.methods.to.model.human-nature.relationships.in.Southern.Cameroon..Small-scale Forest Eco-nomics, Management and Policy.2,.171-184..

Robiglio.V,.Sinclair.F.(2007).One.Step.Back;.One.Step.Forth..Agricultural.Expansion.and.Land-scape.Change.Trajectories.in.Shifting.Cultivation.System.in.Southern.Cameroon..Proceedings.of.International.Association.of.Landscape.Ecology.World.Congress.8-12.July.2007,.Wageningen,.the.Netherlands..http://www.landscape-ecology.org

Sanderson.K.(2009).Wonder.weed.fails.to.flourish..Nature 461,.328-329..

Schimel.D.S,.House.J.I,.Hibbard.K.A.(2001).Recent.patterns.and.mechanisms.of.carbon.exchange.by.terrestrial.ecosystems..Nature.414,.169–172..

Page 51: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

49 Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010

Schlenker.W,.Roberts.M.J.(2009).Nonlinear.temperature.effects. indicate.severe.damages.to.U.S..crop.yields.under.climate.change..Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 106,.15594-15598..

Searchinger.T.(2008).http://www.sciencemag.org/cgi/eletters/319/5867/1238#10977

Searchinger.T,.Heimlich.R,.Houghton.R.A.,.Dong.F,.Elobeid.A,.Fabiosa.J,.Tokgoz.S,.Hayes.D,.Yu.T.H.(2008).Use.of.U.S..croplands.for.biofuels.increases.greenhouse.gases.through.emissions.from.land-use.change..Science.319(5867),.1238-40..

Sitch.S,.Smith.B,.Prentice.I.C.(2003).Evaluation.of.ecosystem.dynamics,.plant.geography.and.terrestrial.carbon.cycling.in.the.LPJ.dynamic.global.vegetation.model..Global Change Biology.9,.161–185..

Smeets.E.M.W,.Faaij.A.P.C,.Lewandowski.I.M,.Turkenburg.W.C.(2007).A.bottom-up.assessment.and.review.of.global.bio-energy.potentials.to.2050..Progress in Energy and Combustion Science.33,.56.–.106..

Solomon.B.D.(2010)...Biofuels.and.sustainability..Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences.1185,.119–134..

Solomon.D,.Fritzsche.F,.Lehmann.J,.Tekalign.M,.Zech.W.(2002).Soil.organic.matter.dynamics.in.the.sub-humid.agro-ecosystems.of.the.Ethiopian.Highlands:.Evidence.from.natural.13C.abun-dance.and.particle.size.fractionation..Soil Science Society of America Journal.66,.969–978..

State.of.California,.Office.of.the.Governor.(2007).Executive.Order.S-1-07.http://gov.ca.gov/exec-utive-order/5172/..

State.of.California,.Air.Resources.Board,.California Global Warming Solutions Act (AB32), 27.Sep-tember.2006,.http://www.arb.ca.gov/cc/cc.htm..

Sunderlin.W.D,.Rodríguez.J.A.(1996).Cattle,.broadleaf.forests.and.the.agricultural.modernization.law.of.Honduras:.the.case.of.Olancho..CIFOR.Occasional.Paper.7,.28.pp..http://www.cifor.cgiar.org/templates/PubPredefined.aspx?NRMODE=Published&NRORIGINALURL=%2fPublications%2fPapers%2f&NRNODEGUID={F534A976-8AC9-4577-B158-734E91ADF063}&NRCACHEHINT=NoModifyGuest

Tchienkoua.M,.Zech.W.(2004).Organic.carbon.and.plant.nutrient.dynamics.under.three.land.uses.in.the.highlands.of.West.Cameroon..Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment 104,.673–679..

Thenkabail.P.S.(1999).Characterization.of.the.alternative.to.slash-and-burn.benchmark.research.area.representing.the.Congolese.rainforests.of.Africa.using.near-real-time.SPOT.HRV.data..Inter-national Journal of Remote Sensing.20,.839-877..

Tiessen.H,.Stewart.J.(1983).Particle.size.fractions.and.their.use.in.studies.of.soil.organic.mat-ter.2..Cultivation.effects.on.organic.matter.composition.in.size.fractions..Soil Science Society of America Journal 47,.509–514..

Tiffen.M,.Mortimore.M.(1994).Malthus.controverted.–.the.role.of.capital.and.technology.in.growth.and.environment.recovery.in.Kenya..World Development.22,.997–1010..

Tilman.D,.Hill.J,.Lehman.C.(2006).Carbon-negative.biofuels.from.low-input.high-diversity.grass-land.biomass..Science.314,.1598-1600..

Page 52: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010 50

Trostle.R.(2008).Global.agricultural.supply.and.demand:.Factors.contributing.to.the.recent.increase.in.food.commodity.prices..Outlook.Report.No..WRS-0801,.Economic.Research.Service,.U.S..De-partment.of.Agriculture,.Washington,.DC,.May..http://www.ers.usda.gov/Publications/WRS0801/

Tuck.G,.Glendining.M.J,.Smith.P,.House.J.I,.Wattenbach.M.(2006).The.potential.distribution.of.bioenergy.crops.in.Europe.under.present.and.future.climate..Biomass and Bioenergy.30,.183–197..

United.Nations.Environment.Programme. (2009).Assessing.Biofuels. http://www.unep.fr/scp/rpanel/pdf/Assessing_Biofuels_Full_Report.pdf.

United.Kingdom,.Office.of.Public.Sector.Information.(2007).Renewable.Transport.Fuel.Obligation.Order.2007,.No..3072,25.http://www.opsi.gov.uk/si/si2007/pdf/uksi_20073072_en.pdf.

U.S..Environmental.Protection.Agency. (2010).40.CFR.Part.80.–.Regulation.of. fuels.and. fuel.additives:.Changes.to.Renewable.Fuel.Standard.Program.http://edocket.access.gpo.gov/2010/pdf/2010-3851.pdf

U.S.. Government. Printing. Office,. Superintendent. of. Documents. (2007). Energy Indepen-dence and Security Act of 2007 (P.L. 110-140) http://frwebgate.access.gpo.gov/cgi-bin/getdoc.cgi?dbname=110_cong_bills&docid=f:h6enr.txt.pdf

Vanclay.J.K.(2003).Why.model.landscapes.at.the.level.of.households.and.fields?,.Small-scale Forest Economics, Management and Policy.2,.121-134..

Verburg..P.H,.Soepboer.S,.Veldkamp.T.A,.Limpiada.R,.Espaldon.V,.Sharifah.Mastura.S.A.(2002).Modeling.the.spatial.dynamics.of.regional.land.use:.the.CLUE-S.Model..Environmental Manage-ment 30,.391-405..

Vincens.A,.Dubois.M.A,.Guillet.B,.Achoundong.G,.Buchet.G,.Kamgang.Kabeyene.Bayala.V,.de.Namur.C,.Riera.B.(2000).Pollen-rain-vegetation.relationships.along.a.forest-savanna.transect.in.Southeastern.Cameroon..Review of Paleobotany and Palynology.110,.191–208..

Voet.E.van.der;.Lifset.R.J;.Luo.L.(2010).Life-cycle.assessment.of.biofuels,.convergence.and.di-vergence..Biofuels.1,.435–449..http://www.future-science.com/doi/abs/10.4155/bfs.10.19

Waller.J.M,.Bigger.M,.Hillocks.R.J.(2007).Coffee.pests,.diseases.and.their.management..CABI,.Wallingford,.UK,.434.pp..http://bookshop.cabi.org/

Walkley.A,.Black.L.A.(1934).An.examination.of.Degtjareff.method.for.determining.soil.organic.matter.and.proposed.modification.of.the.chromic.acid.titration.method..Soil Science.37,.29–38..http://journals.lww.com/soilsci/Citation/1934/01000/An_Examination_of_the_Degtjareff_Method_for.3.aspx

Wilson.A.T.(1978).Pioneer.agriculture.explosion.and.CO2.levels.in.the.atmosphere..Nature.273,.40–1..

Woods.J.(2009).Bioenergy.and.indirect.LUC..IPIECA.Workshop.on.Indirect.LUC.(ILUC).9th.Nov.2009.Hotel.Royal.Savoy,.Lausanne,.Switzerland..

Yan.X,.Inderwildi.O.R,.King.D.A.(2010).Biofuels.and.synthetic.fuels.in.the.US.and.China:.a.review.of.Well-to.Wheel.energy.use.and.greenhouse.gas.emissions.with.the.impact.of.land-use.change..Energy & Environmental Science 3,.190-197..

Page 53: Land Use Change: Science and Policy Review...Wheat Triticum aestivum E,S 32 11 1600 400 high high high Oats Avena sativa E,S 25 6 1200 400 high high high Rye Secale cereale E,S 32

Biofuels and Land Use Change: A Science and Policy Review

51 Hart Energy Consulting | CABI | October 2010

Young.A.(1999).Is.there.really.spare.land?.A.critique.of.estimates.of.available.cultivable.land.in.developing.countries..Environment,.Development.&.Sustainability.1,.3–18..

Zech.W,.Guggenberger.G,.Schulten.H.R.(1994).Budgets.and.chemistry.of.dissolved.organic.car-bon.in.forest.soils:.effects.of.anthropogenic.soil.acidification..Science of the Total Environment.152,.49–62..

Ziska.L.H,.Runion.G.B,.Tomecek.M,.Prior.S.A,.Torbet.H.A,.Sicher.R.(2009).An.evaluation.of.cas-sava,.sweet.potato.and.field.corn.as.potential.carbohydrate.sources.for.bioethanol.production.in.Alabama.and.Maryland..Biomass and Bioenergy.33,.1503-1508..

.