29
! #$%&'( )'*(#+,- $#+ (./#/0*.$,,- 1*$2,( 3!45 67$% 8/&,+ *% 0($# )/' %-9*.$, )$'0: *# ;&,<$'*$= >(2$:%*$# ?$@#(' A B$<+$,(#( C'$99 D#*1(':*%- /) EF%%*#<(# !"#$ &'( )&*+ , #-."/$ 0/1$#234 -#2 $56#6715-334 81-93$ :,; 06/ <"3=-/1- *

Lakner & Trapp 2018 BirdLife model for Bulgaria presentation3 · !"#$%&'()*(%+",-."*/+"+-0&%1-2+-*"&-"3()$,%&, 4+0+)152+-*"16"+751%*8"6%12"3()$,%&, 9:;99:!99: 99:?99:

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    8

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Lakner & Trapp 2018 BirdLife model for Bulgaria presentation3 · !"#$%&'()*(%+",-."*/+"+-0&%1-2+-*"&-"3()$,%&, 4+0+)152+-*"16"+751%*8"6%12"3()$,%&, 9:;99:!99: 99:?99:

!"#$%&'(")'*(#+,-"$#+"(./#/0*.$,,-"1*$2,("3!45"67$%"8/&,+"*%"0($#")/'"%-9*.$,")$'0:"*#";&,<$'*$=

>(2$:%*$#"?$@#('"A"B$<+$,(#("C'$99D#*1(':*%-"/)"EF%%*#<(#

!"#$%&'(%)&*+ ,%#-."/$%0/1$#234%-#2%$56#6715-334%81-93$%:,;%06/%<"3=-/1- *

Page 2: Lakner & Trapp 2018 BirdLife model for Bulgaria presentation3 · !"#$%&'()*(%+",-."*/+"+-0&%1-2+-*"&-"3()$,%&, 4+0+)152+-*"16"+751%*8"6%12"3()$,%&, 9:;99:!99: 99:?99:

!"#$%&'

() *&#+,-".#%,&/) 01+%."$#"+2$34'.#,+32&-3#5'36&7%+,&8'&#3%&39"$12+%2:) ;0<3/=(>?/=/=3*8@$'8'&#2#%,&>) A5'39%+-B%C' D,-'$E) F'G"$#GH) I%G."GG%,&3J3;,&.$"G%,&G

!"#$%&'(%)&*+ ,%#-."/$%0/1$#234%-#2%$56#6715-334%81-93$%:,;%06/%<"3=-/1- )

Page 3: Lakner & Trapp 2018 BirdLife model for Bulgaria presentation3 · !"#$%&'()*(%+",-."*/+"+-0&%1-2+-*"&-"3()$,%&, 4+0+)152+-*"16"+751%*8"6%12"3()$,%&, 9:;99:!99: 99:?99:

!""#$%&'()*%+'$

! ,-."/01"23!4"+5"6%"6"*&'55&'6(! /01"+5"5%+77"%-."76&8.5%"6$("9'5%"+$%.8&6%.(":;"<'7+*=! ,-."/01"-65"(+>.&5."+9<6*%5! :$>+&'$9.$%"6$("*7+96%.?"/-677.$8.5"@'&"%-."/01! ,-."A+&(B+@. 9'(.7"<&'>+(.5"5'9."5'7)%+'$5!C6+$"%65D5"@'&"6$"+9<&'>.("<'7+*=?! E'F"('.5"%-."6*%)67"<'7+*="6@@.*%"%-.".$>+&'$9.$%! E'F"%'"%6&8.%"%-."<'7+*+.5"'$"<)G7+*"8''(5"HG+'(+>.&5+%=I! E'F"%'"9'%+>6%."@6&9.&5"@'&"<6&%+*+<6%+'$! E'F"%'"('*)9.$%"%-."<.&@'&96$*."'@"%-."<'7+*=

! E'F"F')7("@6&9"+$*'9.5"G."6@@.*%.("G="%-."6<<7+*6%+'$"'@"6$"67%.&$6%+>."&.@'&9"9'(.7"6@%.&"2323J

!"#$%&'(%)&*+ ,%#-."/$%0/1$#234%-#2%$56#6715-334%81-93$%:,;%06/%<"3=-/1- >

!"#$%&'()'$*+%,+-+.-&)/$0+'12*$+)3*+,405+63*0+7.-$8*$,9+-$*+:*$0+8'&3+2*;*12*1)+/1+1-)'$*<+-12+;$/=-=(0+=*&-',*+/.+)3*+>*-)3*$+&/12%)%/1,+%)+8%#3)+=*+)3-)+)3*0+7.-$8*$,9+2/1?)+3-:*+;$/2'&)%/1+)3%,+0*-$+7@9A+HK6&9.&"LI

Page 4: Lakner & Trapp 2018 BirdLife model for Bulgaria presentation3 · !"#$%&'()*(%+",-."*/+"+-0&%1-2+-*"&-"3()$,%&, 4+0+)152+-*"16"+751%*8"6%12"3()$,%&, 9:;99:!99: 99:?99:

!""#$%&'()*%+'$

!"#$%&'($)*+,*&-$*)&./0!, -'."+/"%01"/%2%)/"'3"%01"24&+*)5%)&25"/1*%'&"

2$("%01"1$6+&'$71$%"83'*)/"'$"9+'(+61&/+%:;<, -'."('1/"%01"=>?"+7@5171$%2%+'$"+$"A)542&+2".'&BC"

D02%"2&1"@2&%+*)52&"*02551$41/"2$("'@@'&%)$+%+1/CE, -'."+/"%01"=>?"2331*%+$4"+$*'71/"'3"%:@+*25"32&7/"+$"A)542&+2"

2%"@&1/1$%CF, -'.".')5("32&7"+$*'71/"91"2331*%1("9:"%01"2@@5+*2%+'$"'3"

2$"25%1&$2%+61"&13'&7"7'(15"23%1&"<G<GC

1.2$*345*6378 9*2:&.;$*,;'$2/<0*:2/*$%+2+='%:<<0*(':"<$*>9?*,+;*@.<A:;': 4

Page 5: Lakner & Trapp 2018 BirdLife model for Bulgaria presentation3 · !"#$%&'()*(%+",-."*/+"+-0&%1-2+-*"&-"3()$,%&, 4+0+)152+-*"16"+751%*8"6%12"3()$,%&, 9:;99:!99: 99:?99:

!"#$%&'()*(%+",-."*/+"+-0&%1-2+-*"&-"3()$,%&,

!" #$%&'()*+,-./%*+.'00*'(*.%$(+1/%&$.'/(! 4,%2"-(25+%6"7,%2"8&9+8! :+21$%,;/&'"8*%('*(%+

2" 34,*+,-./%*5%/1'.,6*1%/&*78*$--,++'/(! 3%$6,*$(6*,95/%.+*/,0+"&-'%+,8+.! :(5;.+ /,0+"&-'%+,8+."<=>"-&*%1$+-?6"0$(6*5%'-,+*/,0+"&-'%+,8+.! 3+**+%".,-4(/0/)<*$(6*=(/>0,6),*,0,&),5)+! ?',06+ ,%+"),$$&-$"5+/&-."<=>";%1.('*&0&*@";%15)+2?

@" A/-'/B,-/(/&'-*-4$00,(),+! A2,))"7,%2&-$"8+'*1%"&-*+%)&-B+."*1"5&1.&0+%8&*@! :+0+)1;2+-*"17"%(%,)",%+,8! 4&-.&-$"C(,)&7&+."D1%B"71%'+8

C;(,*DEF*2D!G H*($.;%,*1%',(60<*$(6*,-/(/&'-$00<*I'$J0,*KHL*1/%*M;0)$%'$ N

Page 6: Lakner & Trapp 2018 BirdLife model for Bulgaria presentation3 · !"#$%&'()*(%+",-."*/+"+-0&%1-2+-*"&-"3()$,%&, 4+0+)152+-*"16"+751%*8"6%12"3()$,%&, 9:;99:!99: 99:?99:

!"#$%&'()*(%+",-."*/+"+-0&%1-2+-*"&-"3()$,%&,

!" #$%&'()*+,-./%*+.'00*'(*.%$(+1/%&$.'/(! 4,%2"-(25+%6"7,%2"8&9+86"! :+21$%,;/&'"8*%('*(%+

2" 34,*+,-./%*5%/1'.,6*1%/&*78*$--,++'/(! 3%$6,*$(6*,95/%.+*/,0+"&-'%+,8+.! :(5;.+ /,0+"&-'%+,8+."<=>"-&*%1$+-?6"0$(6*5%'-,+*/,0+"&-'%+,8+.! 3+**+%".,-4(/0/)<*$(6*=(/>0,6),*,0,&),5)+! ?',06+ ,%+"),$$&-$"5+/&-."<=>";%1.('*&0&*@";%15)+2?

@" A/-'/B,-/(/&'-*-4$00,(),+! A2,))"7,%2&-$"8+'*1%"&-*+%)&-B+."*1"5&1.&0+%8&*@! :+0+)1;2+-*"17"%(%,)",%+,8! 4&-.&-$"C(,)&7&+."D1%B"71%'+8

C;(,*DEF*2D!G H*($.;%,*1%',(60<*$(6*,-/(/&'-$00<*I'$J0,*KHL*1/%*M;0)$%'$ N

E!"#$%$&'()*(+%,(-.*%/(%$#01(%,(0,2%3"(43-1"3$013#,()5*,(31(+#6*-(1#(15*(-37*(#2(%(."#8*+19(:5*"*(%"*(;*"'($3<(."#8*+1-(15%1(*%1(0.($3<(%6#0,1-(#2(15*(6#,*'(%&&#+%1*4(2#"(15%1($"%,+5(%,4(15*,(15*(-6%&&*"(2%"6*"-(15*'(4#,=1(<*1(31F"<4,%2+%"G?

>(?@A(B&&(15*-*(."#8*+1-(5*&.*4(2%"6*"-(1#(<*1(6#"*(*C03.6*,1D(6#"*(6%+53,*"'D(1#(+"*%1*(6#"*(6#4*",(2%"6-9E(<4,%2+%"H?

>?@A(F1=-(;*"'(5%"4(1#(23,4(C0%&323*4(.*#.&*(2#"(15*(;3,*'%"4-D(15%1=-(%()#"/(0-0%&&'(4#,*($'(#&4*"(.*#.&*D(%,4()315(15*('*%"-()*(&#-*(15*6(+#,-1%,1&'(?@AE(<4,%2+%"G?

I:5*(3,2"%-1"0+10"*(3-(;*"'($%4(5*"*D(%(.%"1(#2(15*("#%4-D(15*"*(3-(,#(+%,%&37%13#,(-'-1*6D(15*(*&*+1"3+31'(3-(,#1()315(<##4(C0%&31'E"<4,%2+%"J?K

Page 7: Lakner & Trapp 2018 BirdLife model for Bulgaria presentation3 · !"#$%&'()*(%+",-."*/+"+-0&%1-2+-*"&-"3()$,%&, 4+0+)152+-*"16"+751%*8"6%12"3()$,%&, 9:;99:!99: 99:?99:

!"#$%&'()*(%+",-."*/+"+-0&%1-2+-*"&-"3()$,%&,4+0+)152+-*"16"+751%*8"6%12"3()$,%&,

9:

;99:

!99:

<99:

=99:

>99:

?99:

;@@<

;@@=

;@@>

;@@?

;@@A

;@@B

;@@@

!999

!99;

!99!

!99<

!99=

!99>

!99?

!99A

!99B

!99@

!9;9

!9;;

!9;!

!9;<

!9;=

!9;>

!9;?

C751%*8"6%12"3()$,%&,C751%*8"6%12"3()$,%&,D%1E*/";@@<F!99?D%1E*/"!99AF!9;?

!"#$%%&''()*+,-'(*.#(*#/$+ 0 1#23456#7 4348

9:#1#23;<=>

0 1#232=?6#@#23;A9:#1#23>54;

B&C&D)EF&*G#)H#&6E)IG'#G)#G,&#J&IF-*#F-IK&G#5;;8L<25AM)NI%&G"1E-"'125&),*&1-H"D+%2,-"I&-&8*%J"61%"K11.",-."#$%&'()*(%+L"M*,*&8*&',)"N+,%O11P"!99;L!99?L!9;=L!9;A

ON*&#24P#<25? $#*-GNI&#HI(&*QD0#-*Q#&%)*)F(%-DD0#C(-RD&#/$+#H)I#SND.-I(- A

Page 8: Lakner & Trapp 2018 BirdLife model for Bulgaria presentation3 · !"#$%&'()*(%+",-."*/+"+-0&%1-2+-*"&-"3()$,%&, 4+0+)152+-*"16"+751%*8"6%12"3()$,%&, 9:;99:!99: 99:?99:

!"#$%&'()*(%+",-."*/+"+-0&%1-2+-*"&-"3()$,%&,4+0+)152+-*"16"7,-."8%&'+9

!""#$#

%&%""#$#

'&"()#$#

:

;::

<=:::

<=;::

!=:::

!=;::

>=:::

>=;::

?=:::

?=;::

!:::

!::<

!::!

!::>

!::?

!::;

!::@

!::A

!::B

!::C

!:<:

!:<<

!:<!

!:<>

!:<?

!:<;

!:<@

*+,-

#./012#34

567

8+9

8%&'+",%,D)+"),-."EFGHI/,J8%&'+",%,D)+"),-."EFGHI/,JK%1L*/"!::AM!:<@K%1L*/"!:::M!::A

:2;2<=.>2,?#=@#<+,-#./012A#@=/#+/+B<2#<+,-#0,#CD<E+/0+#(FFFG(F%!H=D/12N"1L-"'125&),*&1-O"F(%19*,*"61%"!:::M!::CO"3()$,%&,-"P66&'+"61%"Q*,*&9*&'9"61%"!:<:M!:<@R.+,"6%12"#),-"S,**/+L9

45#I112AA0=,J8+A0,E#0,#KIJ

L#M#!'&(%N#O#PQ(RP#6S#M#F&!")

L#M#'QP&)#N#T %)"Q&"###6S#M#F&"'PP

UD,2#FQR#(F%V I#,+?D/2#@/02,-<W#+,-#21=,=>01+<<W#;0+B<2#KIJ#@=/#CD<E+/0+ V

Page 9: Lakner & Trapp 2018 BirdLife model for Bulgaria presentation3 · !"#$%&'()*(%+",-."*/+"+-0&%1-2+-*"&-"3()$,%&, 4+0+)152+-*"16"+751%*8"6%12"3()$,%&, 9:;99:!99: 99:?99:

!"#$%&'()*(%+",-."*/+"+-0&%1-2+-*"&-"3()$,%&,4+0+)152+-*"16"7,-."8%&'+9

!""#$#

%&%""#$#

'&"()#$#

:

;::

<=:::

<=;::

!=:::

!=;::

>=:::

>=;::

?=:::

?=;::

!:::

!::<

!::!

!::>

!::?

!::;

!::@

!::A

!::B

!::C

!:<:

!:<<

!:<!

!:<>

!:<?

!:<;

!:<@

*+,-

#./012#34

567

8+9

8%&'+",%,D)+"),-."EFGHI/,J8%&'+",%,D)+"),-."EFGHI/,JK%1L*/"!::AM!:<@K%1L*/"!:::M!::A

:2;2<=.>2,?#=@#<+,-#./012A#@=/#+/+B<2#<+,-#0,#CD<E+/0+#(FFFG(F%!H=D/12N"1L-"'125&),*&1-O"F(%19*,*"61%"!:::M!::CO"3()$,%&,-"P66&'+"61%"Q*,*&9*&'9"61%"!:<:M!:<@R.+,"6%12"#),-"S,**/+L9

45#I112AA0=,J8+A0,E#0,#KIJ

L#M#!'&(%N#O#PQ(RP#6S#M#F&!")

L#M#'QP&)#N#T %)"Q&"###6S#M#F&"'PP

UD,2#FQR#(F%V I#,+?D/2#@/02,-<W#+,-#21=,=>01+<<W#;0+B<2#KIJ#@=/#CD<E+/0+ "

T!"#$%&$'(#$)*++#,'$-.%)/#0,$*,$'(1'$1/.#123$456$%&$'(#$/1"2$(#.#7$*"$81).9:(17$*,$,%/2$'%$-#%-/#$;(%$2%$"%'$/*<#$*"$81).9:(1 1'$1//$=>?$'(#3$,137$3%9$.#@#*<#$,9),*2*#,$&.%0$'(#$AB7$,%$C$;1"'$'(*,$.#"'D$=>?$E"2$/%@1/$-#%-/#$1.#$-9,(#2$'%$,#//$'(#*.$/1"2$'%$(1<#$.#-1.1'*%"$%&$'(#$(%9,#,DU EV,%2+%"<J=

Page 10: Lakner & Trapp 2018 BirdLife model for Bulgaria presentation3 · !"#$%&'()*(%+",-."*/+"+-0&%1-2+-*"&-"3()$,%&, 4+0+)152+-*"16"+751%*8"6%12"3()$,%&, 9:;99:!99: 99:?99:

!"#$%&'()*(%+",-."*/+"+-0&%1-2+-*"&-"3()$,%&,4*,*(5"16"*/+"+-0&%1-2+-*

!"#$%&'&(#$)%$*+),+-#(.+'/$+.$01'$.'12#3$+4$*&561(+1! 3()$,%&,"/,5"(+7"$8+),+-#(.+'/$789:";,*(%,"!<<<=

! *+(,$4&98#(.$,%+".+')&-&-$

! :18+'1'$(#6&51'+)4>"1-)?"@@:"&-"6,01(%,A)+"5*,*(5

! ;(1..514, &5".+')&-&-$"&-",%+,",-."B(,)&*?C"D,%*)?".%&0+-"A?"E#F"7GFH"IFJ4=

! KL"5(5*,&-,A)+"D%1.('*&0&*?"D%1A)+2

<&4#$=>?$@=AB C$41'&(#$%(+#4,5/$14,$#7)4)9+7155/$-+185#$DCE$%)($*&561(+1 A=

Page 11: Lakner & Trapp 2018 BirdLife model for Bulgaria presentation3 · !"#$%&'()*(%+",-."*/+"+-0&%1-2+-*"&-"3()$,%&, 4+0+)152+-*"16"+751%*8"6%12"3()$,%&, 9:;99:!99: 99:?99:

!"#$%&'()*(%+",-."*/+"+-0&%1-2+-*"&-"3()$,%&,

4+0+)152+-*"16 7,%2),-."3&%.8

!"#

$%# &!#

'((#

!)#

'(*#

!%#

9:;

<:;

=:;

>:;

?:;

@::;

@@:;

!::9 !::< !::= !::> !::? !:@: !:@@ !:@! !:@A

3&%

."B-

.+C"D

!:

:9

"E"@

::

;F

G1221-"3&%."B-.+C"D!::9E@::;FH"A>"85+'&+8

7,%2),-."3&%."B-.+C"D!::9E@::;FH"@="85+'&+8

71%+8*"3&%.8"B-.+C"D!::9E@::;FH"@:"85+'&+8

+,-./,01234-15

+6-758234-15

97:7/6;.70826<28=72>4-15?4017@2<6-2<6-758A2<,-./,0125;7B47524023C/D,-4,E6C-B7I"JK- 5%+8+-*,*&1- L,8+. 1-".,*, 6%12 3MN3"!:@A

FC072()A2%('$ G20,8C-72<-4701/H2,0127B606.4B,//H2:4,>/72IGJ2<6-23C/D,-4, ''

Page 12: Lakner & Trapp 2018 BirdLife model for Bulgaria presentation3 · !"#$%&'()*(%+",-."*/+"+-0&%1-2+-*"&-"3()$,%&, 4+0+)152+-*"16"+751%*8"6%12"3()$,%&, 9:;99:!99: 99:?99:

!"#$%&'()*(%+",-."*/+"+-0&%1-2+-*"&-"3()$,%&,4*,*(5"16"7%1*+'*+."/,8&*,*5",-."57+'&+5

!"#$%&'(%)&*+ ,%#-."/$%0/1$#234%-#2%$56#6715-334%81-93$%:,;%06/%<"3=-/1- *)

!"#

!#$%#

%%#&'#

!(#

&)#

$$#$(#

*&#)!#

$# '# %#$'#

"#

)"#

&"#

("#

%"#

$""#

+,-./01203456-.1-07#8 +,-./01209,/0:;07#8 +,-./01203456-.1-07#8 +,-./01209,/0:;07#8

+<-<4=0>?0@-A1<-<=0)"$! +<-<4=0>?0+B/C1/=0)"$!

;)D0;2?-E>4.-A5/0A-F ;$D0;2?-E>4.-A5/012-F/G4-</ HID0H-E>4.-A5/ JJD0;2K2>L2

:6#>$/8-.16#%>.-.">%60%>?$51$>%-#2%@-91.-.>%?/6.$5.$2%94%.@$%AB%C-91.-.%D1/$5.18$E6"/5$9":,*,"8; <=>?"@!ABCD",-. >E"@!ABFD

Page 13: Lakner & Trapp 2018 BirdLife model for Bulgaria presentation3 · !"#$%&'()*(%+",-."*/+"+-0&%1-2+-*"&-"3()$,%&, 4+0+)152+-*"16"+751%*8"6%12"3()$,%&, 9:;99:!99: 99:?99:

!""#$%"&'()*&'&'"+,-./,/0121340!"#$%&'()*+,)-#(./.0&)&11&2/(

(5 #$%"64/7"041"78--491"1:/"7/;1497"6/</.4-,/01! =39/;1"%2>,/0173)4.(/#"/)1*"'&"(),&2.(.#+)56)4!)"&,72&)1*"'()&11.2.&+28! #48-./6"%2>,/0173)9#/.0*/&)/#)%#$$8.+:)*+,);"&+/)(&&<.+:=! ?/@2."3778/73)>"*7,7%&+/)$&?*0.#7")*+,)2".'&

&5 A0<3940,/012."62,2@/7! #40</97340"4B"@9277.206@)?&*/.+:)/?&)%*+,)'*"<&/A7%:*".*)*'#+:)/?&)"&:.#+()B./?)%#((&()6)CDE)#1)FG! ?%+CD"G&*,()/#)*)"&'#0*%)#1)%*+,(2*-&)&%&'&+/(! $A#ED"H#'-%&I./8)*+,)'.((.+:).+1#"'*/.#+)56)%#B)-*"/.2.-*/.#+

!5 %47313</"/BB/;17F! G9//030@ .()*)$./)$&//&")JKLE)1*%%#B)%*+,M@)/?#7:?)(/.%%).+&11.2.&+/! N.:?)(?*"&)#1)H21892"&'''*B8067".+)O4!)JPQREM

I80/"')J"&'(K $"02189/"B93/06.>"206"/;404,3;2..>"<32L./"#$%"B49"M8.@2932 (!

Page 14: Lakner & Trapp 2018 BirdLife model for Bulgaria presentation3 · !"#$%&'()*(%+",-."*/+"+-0&%1-2+-*"&-"3()$,%&, 4+0+)152+-*"16"+751%*8"6%12"3()$,%&, 9:;99:!99: 99:?99:

!""#$%"&'()*&'&'"+,-./,/0121340!"#$%&'()*+,)-#(./.0&)&11&2/(

(5 #$%"64/7"041"78--491"1:/"7/;1497"6/</.4-,/01! =39/;1"%2>,/0173)4.(/#"/)1*"'&"(),&2.(.#+)56)4!)"&,72&)1*"'()&11.2.&+28! #48-./6"%2>,/0173)9#/.0*/&)/#)%#$$8.+:)*+,);"&+/)(&&<.+:=! ?/@2."3778/73)>"*7,7%&+/)$&?*0.#7")*+,)2".'&

&5 A0<3940,/012."62,2@/7! #40</97340"4B"@9277.206@)?&*/.+:)/?&)%*+,)'*"<&/A7%:*".*)*'#+:)/?&)"&:.#+()B./?)%#((&()6)CDE)#1)FG! ?%+CD"G&*,()/#)*)"&'#0*%)#1)%*+,(2*-&)&%&'&+/(! $A#ED"H#'-%&I./8)*+,)'.((.+:).+1#"'*/.#+)56)%#B)-*"/.2.-*/.#+

!5 %47313</"/BB/;17F! G9//030@ .()*)$./)$&//&")JKLE)1*%%#B)%*+,M@)/?#7:?)(/.%%).+&11.2.&+/! N.:?)(?*"&)#1)H21892"&'''*B8067".+)O4!)JPQREM

I80/"')J"&'(K $"02189/"B93/06.>"206"/;404,3;2..>"<32L./"#$%"B49"M8.@2932 ()

N!"#$%&'$"%"(%)("%*+$,%",'-%./01-'1$2%"(%34'01%",'%&+$,'$%0)5%",'%"1''$%/1(-%",'%*0$"+1'$%&'30+$'%,'1'%",'1'%01'%)("%$(%-0)6%0)5%7-*(1"0)"%"(%$"06%.82 9)%0)6%*403'%:,'1'%",'6%3+"%",'%&+$,'$%(1%"1''$;%044%",'%$(74%7$%<(7)<%5(:)S)J>*"'&")TM

Page 15: Lakner & Trapp 2018 BirdLife model for Bulgaria presentation3 · !"#$%&'()*(%+",-."*/+"+-0&%1-2+-*"&-"3()$,%&, 4+0+)152+-*"16"+751%*8"6%12"3()$,%&, 9:;99:!99: 99:?99:

!""#$%"&'()*&'&'"+,-./,/0121340!"#$#%"$&'$&&(%$)"(#*'+,-./+,+,'"#'01&2$3"$

-

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

I. Pillar

In M

io. E

UR

Decoupled Payments Redistributive PaymentsGreening Payment Young FarmersVoluntary coupled Payments Small farmers schemeMarket measures

II. Pillar1) Knowledge transfer/innovation2) Competitiveness3) Food chain organisation4) Preserving Ecosystems5) Resource efficiency, Climate6) Social inclusion, Rural AreasTechnical Assistance

54678/9":;0"#2.86.21340<=">#"&'(?="@$AB"&'(?4()56'785'9:';"&&$3';$<=5#)*'35>53')(')85'$%)1$&'*?5#@"#2'+,-AB')85'99:';"&&$3';$<=5#)*'$35'$C53$25'?$<=5#)*'+,-./+,+,

5$%5")'C

D7//030E"!(D

A/F3<1G"%2HG"?C

I#59"(JC

E$3F5)6'GDH=$&&'!$3=536'-D

KL"#.3,21/9"(KC

)L">84<H<1/,<9"!)C

M60/"')="&'(N $"02167/"O73/0F.H"20F"/8404,382..H"P32Q./"#$%"O47"R6.E2732 15

Page 16: Lakner & Trapp 2018 BirdLife model for Bulgaria presentation3 · !"#$%&'()*(%+",-."*/+"+-0&%1-2+-*"&-"3()$,%&, 4+0+)152+-*"16"+751%*8"6%12"3()$,%&, 9:;99:!99: 99:?99:

!""#$%"&'()*&'&'"+,-./,/0121340!"#$%&'()*+"$,#-.*/$,,"(&*0123

103,0

64,075,0

26,0

85,8 78,9 77,7

11,623,0 18,1

97,2

171,8

020406080

100120140160180200

Dire

ct P

aym

ents

Gree

ning

Firs

t Hec

tare

s

Youn

g fa

rmer

Mea

t Cow

s / H

eife

rs

Dairy

Cow

s

Dairy

(Mou

ntai

n Ar

eas)

Goat

s (m

ount

ain

area

s)

Ewes

and

goa

ts

Ewes

& g

oats

Cattl

e

Buffa

loes

Decoupled Payments Coupled payments (VCS) Trans. NationalPayments (TNP)

!/ha, !/LU

155,0

591,3

511,2

333,8

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

Prot

ein

Crop

s

Frui

t

Vege

tabl

es

Vege

tabl

es (G

H)

Frui

t (Pl

ums

& Gr

apes

)

Vol. Coupled support (VCS)

!/ha 3.799,9

54678/4*"5%*,(-6-%&'&7"%8*9'&'*:)*;<=9*012>*

960/"'):"&'(; $"02167/"<73/0=.>"20="/8404,382..>"?32@./"#$%"<47"A6.B2732 23

Page 17: Lakner & Trapp 2018 BirdLife model for Bulgaria presentation3 · !"#$%&'()*(%+",-."*/+"+-0&%1-2+-*"&-"3()$,%&, 4+0+)152+-*"16"+751%*8"6%12"3()$,%&, 9:;99:!99: 99:?99:

!"#$%"&'()*'+%,-)%.!"##$%&'(%)*+&,)&"%,'$-'&*,'.,-$%/'/$0,1

/01%"2!3"4256 7"1890(%"+('%1).:"81)"%;-1-<';8..:"='8>.%"?7@"+-("&0.A8('8 23

Greening

Direct Payments

AECM + Organic farming

Conservation

Space for Nature Instrument

Transition Instrument for sustainability

Nature and Biodiversity InstrumentRural

Development

Rural Development

I. Pillar II. Pillar CAP Reform modelBy NABU & Birdlife

?-<B8('C-1"D9890C"E0-"425F"81)"9$%"G7&H"I"&'()*'+%J(%+-(<"<-)%.

Status Quo of the CAP-Reform 2013

Redist. Payments

Coupled Support

Page 18: Lakner & Trapp 2018 BirdLife model for Bulgaria presentation3 · !"#$%&'()*(%+",-."*/+"+-0&%1-2+-*"&-"3()$,%&, 4+0+)152+-*"16"+751%*8"6%12"3()$,%&, 9:;99:!99: 99:?99:

!"#$%&'(%#$%$)*+,"-&$%(./0%123 4/5".%"(,$"678")99$+(.0:".0+/;$%"/9"(<=.+)'"9)*;%".0">&':)*.)"

)("=*$%$0(?1@3 4/5"5/&'A"9)*;".0+/;$%"B$")99$+($A"B<"(,$")=='.+)(./0"/9"

)0")'($*0)(.C$"*$9/*;";/A$'")9($*"DEDE?

!"#$%&'(%)&*+ ,%#-."/$%0/1$#234%-#2%$56#6715-334%81-93$%:,;%06/%<"3=-/1- *+

Page 19: Lakner & Trapp 2018 BirdLife model for Bulgaria presentation3 · !"#$%&'()*(%+",-."*/+"+-0&%1-2+-*"&-"3()$,%&, 4+0+)152+-*"16"+751%*8"6%12"3()$,%&, 9:;99:!99: 99:?99:

!"#$%&'(%)*'+&'*(,-. /*%,+%! 01-%% 2*13,.% 4025"6$1"7*"8-1 $*+7 +1-6 ,."$*+7 1$3,-.! 9&(6&(": ;6$+,8,+ +-%(%

! <*1="61-8,(%! >-(*'"02": 9?$17$*@"+-%(% A";&/%,@,$%

! 966-1(&.,(B +-%(% (- +-.%$1?*(,-. 4C,.+-=$ 8-13-.$D5! E=6'$=$.(*(,-."+-%(% -8 =$*%&1$%

!"#$%&'(%)&*+ ,%#-."/$%0/1$#234%-#2%$56#6715-334%81-93$%:,;%06/%<"3=-/1- *>

Page 20: Lakner & Trapp 2018 BirdLife model for Bulgaria presentation3 · !"#$%&'()*(%+",-."*/+"+-0&%1-2+-*"&-"3()$,%&, 4+0+)152+-*"16"+751%*8"6%12"3()$,%&, 9:;99:!99: 99:?99:

!"#$%&'()*+

,"#$%!-.)*+

."#$%,.()*+

/"#$%0-()*+

0"#$%'(()*+

&"#$%/!()*+

-")12345)627*+28 9)*+

9"$2:+;47)<=:=5+>?=@

')*+

ABC47+? D+2E@ @=?=75=8 D62 5*= 7+?73?+546;@!"#$%&' 6F; C2=@=;5+546;G)H4;:)I+C@ +=24+?

(#)&*+,-*.+/0 1*)23#$&*4$5&)678*2)6*&%")"95%2778*:52;7&*<1=*4"$*>#7?2$52 &(

Page 21: Lakner & Trapp 2018 BirdLife model for Bulgaria presentation3 · !"#$%&'()*(%+",-."*/+"+-0&%1-2+-*"&-"3()$,%&, 4+0+)152+-*"16"+751%*8"6%12"3()$,%&, 9:;99:!99: 99:?99:

!"#$%&# '()*+,-"+./0%$"/1" 20 1$33"/& 456+2/+0738 ./128"#

!"#$ !"#$ %&'( )*"+,-."/0

1"2$(3.%

!"#$01#-4&. )56#-+ 7#-4&. 1(#0*"0

)56#-+

8*"#(0%69%&:&(%0

-301#-4&.%

);<

=0>?70@-#.*0

A(%.9:; <;=>?; @9@=:(9A@9+++ ?9;A?B+++ ?9C

B0>?70@-#.*0

>(3.#"/B@; @;?=@D; (?B=;:DAD@+++ <B>A(D+++ (;C

C0>?70@-#.*0

5"%.:;; @<:=:<(A@; <9@=DD;AB>+++ <>:AD>+++ (@C

D0>?708-6.*0

A(%.@D< ((=9;< ?>=@(;A:(+++ 9<?A>B+++ >;C

E0>?708-6.*0

>(3.#"/?<; >>=?B; @?@=BB9A<<+++ (@?AD@+++ <<C

F0>?708-6.*0

5"%.(D; B<=>>; @DD=?B(A:<+++ ?:<A:B+++ (<C

G0?#H"3&I0

J(H(."9/(%: ?=>?B @>=<;<A;;+++ @=:?<A;;+++ 9>C

K0?#I*"#: > @=>;D B=;@>A<>+++ D<:AB<+++ 9DC

8-6#I(L 2E/ 17%1$%7&.2/#

M63(0NDO0BN=K P03".6#(04#&(3:/20"3:0(I-3-$&I"//20Q&"9/(0>P704-#0R6/H"#&" 9@

Page 22: Lakner & Trapp 2018 BirdLife model for Bulgaria presentation3 · !"#$%&'()*(%+",-."*/+"+-0&%1-2+-*"&-"3()$,%&, 4+0+)152+-*"16"+751%*8"6%12"3()$,%&, 9:;99:!99: 99:?99:

!"#$%&%$'(%)*+)&+(,#+-%./0%&#1)/#2+&).+(,#+$'2$32'(%)*4

! 5.'*4%(%)*+6*4(.31#*(+&).+!34('%*'72#+8'.1%*9! :;;+<=,'>+

! !"'$#+&).+?'(3.#! @A;+<=,'+&'22)B+2'*/

! ?'(3.#+'*/+-%)/%C#.4%(D+6*4(.31#*(! E%C#*+&).+1#'43.#4+(,'(+".)1)(#+7%)/%C#.4%(D+F#G9G+&2)B#.+4(.%"4>+#H(#*4%C#+B,#'(>+2'*/4$'"#+#2#1#*(4I

! JA;+<=,'! K/C%4).D+".#1%31! LA;+<=,'+34#/+&).+$)*4#.C'(%)*>+%&+$)*4#.C'(%)*+'$(%C%(%#4+('M#+"2'$#+)*+N:;O+)&+&'.1+'.#'

!"#$%&'(%)&*+ ,%#-."/$%0/1$#234%-#2%$56#6715-334%81-93$%:,;%06/%<"3=-/1- ))

Page 23: Lakner & Trapp 2018 BirdLife model for Bulgaria presentation3 · !"#$%&'()*(%+",-."*/+"+-0&%1-2+-*"&-"3()$,%&, 4+0+)152+-*"16"+751%*8"6%12"3()$,%&, 9:;99:!99: 99:?99:

!"#$%&'(%)*'+&'*(,-."-/"%,0"%+$.*1,-%

!"#$%&'( !)#"'*'"%+'($23"4-")56780,( 80,("9 .-":*;<$.(%"*("*''

=3">1*.%,(,-."(-"%&%(*,.*?'$"/*1<,.@7".-"+-.%$1A*(,-.

>1*.%,(,-."B.%(1&<$.("/-1"C&%(*,.*?'$"D*1<,.@"E>CDF

G3"H$1;"'-I"'$A$'"-/"+-.%$1A*(,-." >CDC:*+$"/-1"4*(&1$"E!JF

K3"L-I"'$A$'"-/"+-.%$1A*(,-.">CDC:*+$"/-1"4*(&1$"E2MJF5NA,%-1;"O"<*.*@$<$.(":1$<,&<

!3"P$N,&<"'$A$'"-/"+-.%$1A*(,-."

>CDC:*+$"/-1"4*(&1$"E!JF4*(&1$"*.N"Q,-N,A$1%,(;"B.%(1&<$.("E!JF5NA,%-1;"O"<*.*@$<$.(":1$<,&<

R3"S,@T"'$A$'"-/"+-.%$1A*(,-.>CD4*(&1$"O"Q,-N,A$1%,(;"E2!JF5NA,%-1;"O"<*.*@$<$.(":1$<,&<

,-$#./01.2/34 5.$%+-&#.*&'#$678.%$6.#"($(9'"%778.:'%;7#.<5=.*(&.>-7?%&'% 2@

Page 24: Lakner & Trapp 2018 BirdLife model for Bulgaria presentation3 · !"#$%&'()*(%+",-."*/+"+-0&%1-2+-*"&-"3()$,%&, 4+0+)152+-*"16"+751%*8"6%12"3()$,%&, 9:;99:!99: 99:?99:

!"#$%&#'()*+',-"'./0%$"/1"'20'345'6/7'8.97:.0";27"%'2/'2/"'"<6;=%"'069;>#'./12;"

?45?'@ABCDEFEE'G H9""/./I

JCBKLEFEE'G

,2&6%'069; =920.&J@JBAM@FJ@ G

!"#"$%&'$(&)*+, !"7.#&9.N$&.O"

=6P;"/&@BMJEFEE''G

-./(01&2(3.4&)*)+&51.36$1&4.7.4

8(9%.07#"6(9:

,96/#.&.2/'Q/#&9$;"/&'029

?$#&6./6N%" R69;./I'@ABEEEFEE'G

?=61"'029 S6&$9"'(KT*

KBCEEFEE''G

S6&$9"'6/7'8.27.O"9#.&P

Q/#&9$;"/&'(KT*J@BM@KFEE'G

,2&6%'069; =920.&J@@BAAEFMD' G

,2&6%'#$==29&+'KEBD)EFEE'G'

,2&6%'#$==29&+''K)BMDKFEE''G'

;$9.&*<=&)*+, >&9#"$0.&/06.934?&#93&.8(9(168#44?&76#@4.&A>B&/(0&C$4D#06# @)

Page 25: Lakner & Trapp 2018 BirdLife model for Bulgaria presentation3 · !"#$%&'()*(%+",-."*/+"+-0&%1-2+-*"&-"3()$,%&, 4+0+)152+-*"16"+751%*8"6%12"3()$,%&, 9:;99:!99: 99:?99:

-70%

-60%

-50%

-40%

-30%

-20%

-10%

0%

10%

20%

30%1 Exit

2 Noconservation

3 Very lowconsrevation

4 Lowconservation

5 Mediumconservation

6 Highconservation

Chan

ge in

farm

s inc

ome (

%)

1 COP farm in NW Bulgaria (intensive)2 COP farm in NC Bulgaria (intensive)3 COP in NE Bulgaria (intensive)4 COP in SW Bulgaria (less intensive)5 COP in SC Bulgaria (less intensive)6 COP in SE Bulgaria (medium intensity)7 Organic vegetable farm in SW Bulgaria8 Mixed fruit orchard in SC Bulgaria

!"#$%&#'()*+',-"'./0%$"/1"'20'&-"'3.456.0"725"%'2/'0847'./127"#'20'&9:.18%'0847#

!"#$%&' 2;/'18%1$%8&.2/#

(#)&*+,-*.+/0 1*)23#$&*4$5&)678*2)6*&%")"95%2778*:52;7&*<1=*4"$*>#7?2$52 .@

-40.2% -15.2% -13.8% -13.8%0.7%

13.4%(Note: %-figures are the average change of all COP-farms)

Page 26: Lakner & Trapp 2018 BirdLife model for Bulgaria presentation3 · !"#$%&'()*(%+",-."*/+"+-0&%1-2+-*"&-"3()$,%&, 4+0+)152+-*"16"+751%*8"6%12"3()$,%&, 9:;99:!99: 99:?99:

!"#$%&#'()*+',-"'./0%$"/1"'20'&-"'3.456.0"725"%'2/'0847'./127"#'20'&9:.18%'0847#

!"#$%&'()*++),%&-. /01),%&-.

2,%&-)34567&8'9):);#<=),%&-.

2,%&-)>?@6

!"#$%&'#$("%)$%)$&*+",%-./

;'<=.& >?@A;B >)CADB >D@A@B

D'E2'12/#"4F8&.2/ >;?AGB >;HADB >GAGB

?'I"49'%2J'12/#"4F8&.2/ >;?ACB >;?AKB >;CA@B

)'62J'12/#"4F8&.2/ >LAGB >LACB >GA?B

H'M"5.$7'12/#"4F8&.2/ >;A)B CA@B >@ALB

L'N.O-'12/#"4F8&.2/ GA;B ;?A)B >?A@B

A8$#)BCD)EB3@ *)$%98&#),&'#$F+G)%$F)#"($(-'"%++G);'%H+#)/*1),(&)I8+<%&'% E5

J%H+# 3KL *;#&%<# "M%$<# '$ '$"(-#. '$ 9M# F',,#&#$9 ."#$%&'(.

!(8&"#+'2J/'18%1$%8&.2/#P'QRS'T'Q"4"8%#'2.%#""5'8/5':42&"./'142:#P

Page 27: Lakner & Trapp 2018 BirdLife model for Bulgaria presentation3 · !"#$%&'()*(%+",-."*/+"+-0&%1-2+-*"&-"3()$,%&, 4+0+)152+-*"16"+751%*8"6%12"3()$,%&, 9:;99:!99: 99:?99:

!""#$%&'%%$()"*"+()&,'%$()%

! !"#$%&'%()*+,-./"0$&1&$2+%#+03%))*'4*! 53*+#.0&.6*0.'.7&0+03%))*'4*#+.8+%4-&0")$"-*+&'+9:! !"#$%&'/&#$-&("$&.'+.8+#"(#&/&*#+-./0/1&(233$&$2)4%5! 53*+%4-&6*'1&-.'7*'$%)+03%))*'4*#! ;'#$&$"$&.'#+6)7 ,-.,*-$2+-&43$#+-&(88()"9:6%%,6)7;5! <(("86)="&>6)92%"$)"$*-7&'.).42+&'+<=>?+-?@"8$%4:'%45! ;'8.-7%$&.' 6)7"2A42)%$()"%2:B$&2%"-?@",(C"D6:4$&$D64$();5

! 9&-/@&8* 7./*)+%#+%'+.,,.-$"'&$2+8.-+*'1&-.'7*'$+A+&'0.7*#! <6:92427"826%':2%E">$9>2:"$)&2)4$B2%"-:$%F"*"B6,'2"677275! G6:8%"D:(7'&2"3((7"6)7"D'H,$&"9((7%! +()%2:B64$()"6%"$)429:64$B2"D6:4"(3"6"36:8! +>6,,2)92"&('D,27"D6=82)4%"*"%'%46$)6H,2"36:8"%=%428%

B"'*+CDE+FCGH <+'%$"-*+8-&*'/)2+%'/+*0.'.7&0%))2+1&%()*+><I+8.-+9")4%-&% FJ

Page 28: Lakner & Trapp 2018 BirdLife model for Bulgaria presentation3 · !"#$%&'()*(%+",-."*/+"+-0&%1-2+-*"&-"3()$,%&, 4+0+)152+-*"16"+751%*8"6%12"3()$,%&, 9:;99:!99: 99:?99:

!""#$%&'%%$()"*"+()&,'%$()%

-. /01'&0""2)1"342%0"('5"!"#$%&'()*+$,&-'6. 742%0"('5"./01,&)#*'2/130$4'5133/#&'6.257

742%0"('5"8#),-"&"/,)0'9)&"/,)0'()*+$,&-':; !$+/<#)3="%'>'-/%")0'%=)00$,<$-8"9(&$2,"2)1"52:25$()"3(,$&$0%;. <1='%5"540"?),4'()#%$0'@4$,&"A"%)&"/,'5*-&$+'6?(@57!. 95>0)?540)"0$<)0'$,A/#%$+$,&'),4'%/,&#/0-@. 95>0)?540)"2)1"$A3>(B0"B<#"CD,E"#/,+$,&)0'F$)-1#$-C. D2E0"'%0"(F"540"G"#4?"A$ +/4$0')-')'3/--"H0$')0&$#,)&"E$G. <,$?)"<H+D"5("540"9)&1#)'IJJJ'(I=0&5$B0%J. KA3>(B0")4E"-/#*'-$#E"%$-K'",A/#+)&"/,'>'$41%)&"/,

L1,$'JMK'IJNO B',)&1#$'A#"$,40*'),4'$%/,/+"%)00*'E")H0$'2B('A/#'G10<)#") IO

Page 29: Lakner & Trapp 2018 BirdLife model for Bulgaria presentation3 · !"#$%&'()*(%+",-."*/+"+-0&%1-2+-*"&-"3()$,%&, 4+0+)152+-*"16"+751%*8"6%12"3()$,%&, 9:;99:!99: 99:?99:

!"#$%&'()&*(+&'()+&,$-.+./-01)./-,($/&(+&2(33.$-/4

5.6#/-,#$&7#%$.+&8&9#:;#<.$.&!+#==>.(+:?@):)/-?A$,B.+/,-'&(*&>C--,$:.$D&>.+3#$'E.=-F&@:+,G)<-)+#<&HG($(3,G/&8&I)+#<&E.B.<(=3.$-

J5.6#/-,#$7#%$.+

"--=/KLL/<#%$.+FM(+;=+.//FG(3

"--=KLLMMMF)$,?:(.--,$:.$F;.L;.LNOPQRF"-3<