8/6/2019 KIMBERLY PEA 1102 (2011)

1/11

ao

VH MFYFL OJILH]UL@BE@F

AOJEFU@_ SFB IBJBUDLVHOLH FVULSFB

5322

8/6/2019 KIMBERLY PEA 1102 (2011)

2/11

]ubi fy vhb bml`fyifh}f mf mofioyoy bly, fmvibmb lefmofh}f( Sful hl}lml mvub sbub yofjsuf suojful hl fy jv ilhnlujf ilh yv ~omb sful yo fh

mlhmf ~o~f Jbmuom kvh}l b yvy sbmufy ley}ohbmly ilh iofu}b sv` iuombm gbiob

}lml yoh ybefu r hl }lml fy sfunfi}l jby `l r sbyb slu `b jfh}f mf `ly

bml`fyifh}fy ]ubi kvh}l b yvy bjodly evyibh hvf~by ilyby ~o~ou `b ~omb }bh

mf suoyb iljl yo yoh}ofubh r yf svfmf bibebu fh ivb`rvofu jljfh}l B`fw ,ibjo` ,mofdl,yfudol bjodly ohyfsbube`fy sful ilh ~omby }bh monfufh}fy

sule`fjby r `ly ulmfbh `ly ~bh jbuibhml sbub }lmb `b ~omb b fy}b fmbm

yl`l yf sofhyb fh vhb ilyb muldby b`ilgl` yfwl hbmb jby sbub r jfh}ou `l r

fy ~fumbm ]ubi yf yofh}f yofjsuf yl`b vh ml`lu }bh sulnvhml fh yv ilub{h

hl yf fh}ofhmf hl ybef r gbifu evyib bvmb mfyfysfubmbjfh}f mofdl fy yv

bsll ohilhmoiolhb` yf ilhlifh mfymf suojbuob yf bjbh yf mfyfbh fhyo`fhiol bvhrvf dvbumbh moy}bhioby sbub hl mbbu `b bjoy}bm f` fy

fw}ul~fu}oml `f dvy}b ~o~ou bvhrvf fyl rvofub mfiou jf}fuyf fh sule`fjby `f

nbyiohb `b ~f`liombm }bh}l fh yv ~omb iljl fh `by ibuufuby mf jl}ly

8/6/2019 KIMBERLY PEA 1102 (2011)

3/11

Ibjo` fy iljl }lmly moubh sfunfi}b fy `b hoib bjodb mf ]ubi yf ilhlifh }ufy blyb}uy mfkbhml yv sby mf luodfh Ibhbm f``b fy jv lib yo by yf svfmf mfiou fh f`evfh yfh}oml rvo{y f~o}bhml `ly sule`fjby rvf `b ulmfbh( Ibjo` yofjsuf `f dvy}byfu f` svh}l mf ~oy}b mf }lmly gbifuyf hl}bu bvhrvf hl }lml yofjsuf `f yb`f eofh ,

B`fw }bjeoh `f dvy}bh `by jl}ly iljsbu}ou `b ~f`liombm kvh}l b mofdl f` }ofhfmfjbyobmly sule`fjby hl yofjsuf `ly bnulh}b iljl mfefub yfu , Yfudol f` }ofhfjby sule`fjby yvy sbmufy ylh jv fy}uoi}ly hl ylslu}bubh ho bifs}bubh hbmb ubulfh yv gokl bvhrvf fy}l b f` f fy}f ibvybhml vh ml`lu ohnoho}l mf` hl ybefu r gbifu hofhilh}ubu bvmb b`dvhb (

F` ivuyl b ibyo yf bibeb sulh}l mfefuh sfhybu fh rvf bubh ilh yvy ~omby rmfy}ohly }ljbubh sful bh}fy `l jby fysfubml f` ~obkf mf noh mf bl O}b`ob `b iovmbmmf` bjlu , yvy sbmufy ilh oh}uodby vh slil mf bey}ohfhiob slu f` ~obkf b` noh bifs}bhmfkbu`ly ou b r iljl yf ybefh `b jblub mf iljsbfuly yf yfsbububh }ljbubhuvjely monfufh}fy (

_b slu noh fy f` mb fysfubml yf gbh fjebuibml b vh ~obkf rvf ibjeobubh yvy

~omby sbub yofjsuf , b fh O}b`ob fy vh hvf~l iljofh{l }lml jbuigb eofhilhlifu }lml monfufh}f b `l bily}vjeubml fy vhb jbub~o``b }l}b` iljl yofjsuf`ly iohil bjodly oh yfsbube`fy bvhrvf yf bdleobh fh yvy sulsoby ~omby gbb `b~omb sbufif jby hli}vuhb sbub f``ly b slily mby mf gbefu ``fdbml yf nbjo`obuo{bh}bh}l fh vhb iovmbm rvf b `b ~f{ fy }bh mfyilhlioml (

8/6/2019 KIMBERLY PEA 1102 (2011)

4/11

]ubi ,Ibjo`,Mofdl,B`fw,Yfudol yf mouodfh b ~oyo}bu vh i`ve hli}vuhl }lml}ubhyivuuf hlujb` il}omobhl iljl yofjsuf ]ubi Ibjo` ~oy}fh sbub `b libyohb` ``fdbu ~bh somofhml }ubdl sbub fh}ubu fh bjeofh}f fh fy}f `vdbu yf fhivfh}ub}lml `l r yf hfifyo}b sbub sbybu f` jfklu ub}l b mofdl `f lnufifh ilibhb iubia vh

fy}ojv`bh}f jv nvfu}f f` `l ~b lnufiofhml b` ufy}l mf bjodly yoh mbuyf ivfh}b mf`l sfukvmoiob` r svfmf ``fdbu b gbifu fy}l Yfudol yoh ojslu}bu`f fjsof{b b ilhyvjoumfjbyobml Ibjo` B`fw mfyfbh b`fkbuyf vh slil b vh jl}f` r fy}b jv ifuib sbubyb}oynbifu }lml f` bjlu r yofh}fh `ly mly ilhnvhmomly `f~bmly slu f` `oilu `bymuldby hl ybefh `l r gbifh , jofh}uby fh f` i`ve ]ubi Mofdl gbe`bh mf }lmlyleuf yv ~omb f` hl ybefu rvf gbuh fh vh nv}vul f` bjlu r yleuf f``ly sbybh sful

hl yf b}uf~fh joubuyfh mf nufh}f mfiou `l r yofh}f fyb b}ubiioh }bh nvfu}f rvfsvfmf ``fdbu b gbifu nb}b` fh }lml fy}l yf l`~ombh mf` ufy}l ,Yfudol mfyfysfubmlilhnvhmoml fh yl`fmbm slu hl gb``bu ufysvfy}by b vhb ~omb b fyb ilhnvyoh rvf `lilhyvjf jby jby b` hl rvfufu `vigbu jby slu yv ~omb hl fhilh}ubu yl`viohb`dvhb b`viohb iuf ~fuyf n`l}bu fh vh jvhml rvf hl fwoy}f fh f``l yf ibf mf`yfdvhml soyl yf jb}b sful f` hl yofh}f ml`lu yofh}f b`o~ol slurvf hl fy}bu fhfy}f jvhml }bh iuvf` }bh monoio` mf ~o~ou ]ubi Mofdl b` ~fu f` b`elul}l mfysofu}bhfh yfdvomb hl svfmfh iuffu `l r sbyb sful ybebh rvf }bumf l }fjsubhl sbybubYfudol `fy gbeb iljfh}bml fh f` fy}bml rvf yf fhilh}ubeb rvf b hl rvfub `vigbujby sbub yfdvou(

8/6/2019 KIMBERLY PEA 1102 (2011)

5/11

Hl ybebh rvf gbifu fy}bebh mfyfysfubmly fh f` i`ve hl yf gbibh

ufyslhybe`fy yo `bjbebh `b sl`oib `ly sfukvmoibubh yf``bubh

``f~hmlyf`ly b b iuif` bvhrvf }lmly ybebh l yvifmoml fh fy}f `vdbu

mfebh dvbumbu yo`fhiol ybibulh f` ivfusl slu `b svfu}b mf b}uy f` bibgf`bml b ilhdf`bml yvy sfhybjofh}ly mfebh ``bjbu b Ibjo` B`fw sbub

iljfh}bu `l yvifmoml Ibjo` rvfml mfy}ul{bmb b` lu `b hl}oiob yf iv`sbeb

}l}b`jfh}f slu `l yvifmoml slu hl fy}bu kvh}l b f` sbub bvmbu`l

yb`~bu`l mf yv }udoib jvfu}f yl`l yf ~fb vh slu~fhou ohyfdvul b` buulkbu

f` ivfusl ohfu}f mf Yfudol fh vh `bdl kvubu r hbmof ybeub kbjy `l

yvifmoml dvbumbu f` yfiuf}l gby}b `b jvfu}f , f` mb mf ufdufyl b Jbmuom`ly fhibudbmly mf }lmly `lb b`vjhly evyibebh b Yfudol sful hbmof mbeb

ufysvfy}b mf mlhmf fy}v~ofyf b` ybefu r hl slmbh rvfmbuyf jby

ufdufybulh sful ilh fyb yfhybioh mf rvf b`dl nb`}beb hohdvhl nvfulh

ibsbyfy mf mbu b ibub b `ly sbmufy by sbybeb f` }ofjsl, vhb hl}oiob

ibjeobuob jbuibuob b`dvhby ~omby Ibjo` fy}beb fjebub{bmb yoh `vdbu bmvmb fub mf B`fw iljl bnulh}bu `l rvf yvifmb yvy sbmufy hl ylslu}bubh

vhb hl}oiob by }lml oeb sflu sule`fjby jby ibmb mb yoh fhilh}ubu vhb

yb`omb b }lml `l r `fy fy}beb bnfi}bhml(

8/6/2019 KIMBERLY PEA 1102 (2011)

6/11

Hbmb slmb yfdvou sflu `ly sbmufy mf ]ubi yf jvmbebh f``b le`odbeb `f}libeb ifmfu mfkbhml }lml b}uy yvy bjodly `l rvf jby rvfub b mofdl yohylslu}bu rvf yf b`fkbubh mfysvy mf }bh}l }ofjsl mfiomfh ilhnfybu yvbjlu ivbh}l yf mfyfbebh fh yo`fhiol fh f` jljfh}l jby ojsufioyl fh}ub

`ly sbmufy mf f``b mfiomofhml ouuf~libe`fjfh}f ``f~uyf`b slu `l yvifmomlhl bifs}bh r b hohdvhl mf `ly mly ylh holy b`fkhml`ly yoh iljsbyoh mfvh bjlu rvf fh moy}bhiob `ly mfy}ul{bub b fh ~b`fhiob }lml fy monfufh}ff``b hl yf yofh}f b dvy}l yl`l gbh sbybml yfjbhby hl yf gb slmomliljvhoibu ilh Mofdl f` ml`lu `ly mfy}ul{b f` blub `ly }ofjsly fh rvffy}v~ofulh kvh}ly jljfh}ly nf oify rvf rvo{y hl ~vf`~bh b yvifmfu

jofh}uby ]ubi B`fw ~o~fh yvy sulsoly fhnufh}bhml vhb ufb`ombm hl jvbyfrvoe`f fh yvy ~omby mfiomfh fyibsbu kvh}ly slurvf hbmof fy}b mfbivfuml fh rvf mfy}uvbh yvy ~omby }fhofhml vh efef kvh}ly sful hl bh}fyyoh mfkbu ibu}by gbiob yvy mly bjodly moiohmlyf rvf hl yf l`~ombubh kbjymf `l rvf iljsbu}ofulh kvh}ly jofh}uby ]ubi fh yv mfyfysful yl`fmbm f`~fu rvf ibf yoh bvmb mf hbmof mfyfb rvo}buyf `b ~omb yf gbb jvfu}b~ofhml `ly ufivfumly mf vh bjlu mf` ivb` nvf b`fkbmb yoh iljsbyoh rvfmfy}ul{beb yv ~omb yv b`jb gby}b b f}fuhombm Mofdl b` fh}fubuyf yl`lbif`fub fh yv jl}l mfkbhml }lml b` mfy}ohl rvo}hmlyf `b ~omb sbubfhilh}ubuyf fh vh jvhml mfyilhlioml mlhmf fy}buh `ly mly yoh sfukvoiolyho `ojo}biolhfy mf hbmof (

8/6/2019 KIMBERLY PEA 1102 (2011)

7/11

Vh bjlu sulgoeoml fy `l r sbyb fh}uf mly k~fhfy rvf yf bjbh yoh`ojo}biolhfy ilh mfyfly bjlu vhb gfujlyb bjoy}bm jfyi`bmly fh

}udoiby ilhyfivfhioby rvf ~bh fh~l`~ofhml b iohil bjodly rvf yf

ibubi}fuo{bh slu ~o~ou }lml kvh}ly bvhrvf jvigby sfuylhby b yv b`ufmfmlu

yf fjsfbh slu yfsbubu`ly }lml yf gbif jby monio` yf iljs`oib fh vh

~obkf b O}b`ob yfh}ojofh}ly fhilh}ubmly ilhnvyoh yoh dbhby mf ~o~ou slu vhb~omb }bh yojs`f yoh jl}o~biolhfy }lml iljofh{b ilh `b jvfu}f mf vhl mf

f``ly yoh ub{lhfy sbub rvfufu ~o~ou fh vh jvhml mf }bh}b yl`fmbm `vfdl

ibjo` rvfmb fjebub{bmb mf B`fw `ly mly ilh dubhmfy ufyslhybeo`ombmfy

`b glub mf fhnufh}bu f` jvhml mfyfbh fyibsbuyf `fkly mf vh nv}vul ohiofu}l

]ubi yfsbubmb mf mofdl ``f~bmb b vh `vdbu mlhmf fy}buh bsbu}bmly yo

~l`~fu b ilhnfybu fyf bjlu rvf yofh}fh f``b mfyfb yofdb yv ~omb sbubyofjsuf mofdl b` rvfmbu yl`l gbif `l joyjl b rvf hl svfmf ~o~ou yoh `l rvf

jby bjb (

FHYB_L

8/6/2019 KIMBERLY PEA 1102 (2011)

8/11

Fy vhb goy}luob fh `b ivb` gbe`b yleuf `ly ~fumbmfuly `byly mf bjlu rvffwoy}fh mf bjoy}bm b`dl rvf hly jbuib sbub }lmb `b ~omb sful hl ojslu}bh

`by ilhyfivfhioby yl`l vhb gfujbhmbm rvf mvub sbub }lmb `b ~omb bvhrvf

fy}l yodhonorvf dvbumbu fh yo`fhiol b`dl rvf hly `by}ojb yoh fyivigbu

bv}luombm b`dvhb bvhrvf ilhyodl hly ``f~f f` jby bjfh}be`f gfigl mf ~fu

iljl }lml `l rvf }fhfjly b hvfy}ul b`ufmfmlu yf mfy}uvf iljl yf ~b

fhml `l rvf jby rvfufjly yoh slmfu f~o}bu`l iljl }lml `l rvf yf svfmf~fu }ubhrvo`l yf mfy~bhfif fh yfdvhmly

BUDVJFH]L

8/6/2019 KIMBERLY PEA 1102 (2011)

9/11

(

Fyiliob yf fhdb`bhb ilh f` bu}f il`ljeobhl

F` svfe`l fyiliy }fhmu vhb jbdhnoib lslu}vhombm, mvubh}f f` ~fubhl mf

5322, mf ilhlifu b`dl moy}oh}l fh }ujohly mf iv`}vub, bu}f mf Bjuoib

@b}ohb fh sbu}oiv`bu mf` bu}f il`ljeobhl(

F` Ifh}ul Iv`}vub` Gbuelvu Bu}y fh Ou~ohf, Fyiliob1 fy f` vdbu fyildoml

sbub rvf `by leuby mf mlif bu}oy}by il`ljeobhly yfbh sufyfh}bmby b` se`oil

yo}vbml fh `b sbu}f hlu}f mf `b oy`b mf Dubh Euf}bb( @ly bu}oy}by

yf`fiiolhbmly }ubebkbh ufyomfh, fh yv jblub, fh `b iovmbm mf Eldl},

ibso}b` mf Il`ljeob, sful ylh luovhmly mf moy}oh}ly mfsbu}bjfh}ly mf` sby(

Yvy leuby sufyfh}buh vhb sfuifsioh mf `ly moy}oh}ly fy}o`ly mf bu}f

sulmviomly mobuobjfh}f fh Il`ljeob lnufiofhml monfufh}fy ~oy}by mf` b`jb

bu}y}oib mf fy}by `b}o}vmfy( Leuby bey}ubi}by, ojbdohbmby, nodvub}o~by,

sboybkfy, yfuh ~oyo}bmby slu vh se`oil fyiliy rvf yfdvubjfh}f ybef slil

mf `b iv`}vub il`ljeobhb jfhly mf `ly j`}os`fy ilhliojofh}ly s`y}oil

rvf fwoy}fh fh Il`ljeob

HL]OIOB @LIB@

8/6/2019 KIMBERLY PEA 1102 (2011)

10/11

8/6/2019 KIMBERLY PEA 1102 (2011)

11/11

AOJEFU@_ SFB IBJBUDL'? mf hl~ofjeuf mf 2??9/ fy}vmobh}f

il`fdol vhoh fvulsfb dubml lhif mly hbiof` hvf~f mf hl~ofjeuf fh Eldl} kvh}l b yvysbmufy Hf`` Ibjbudl Kly sfb kvh}l b yvy}ufy gfujbhly jfhlufy nfefu,`fy`,{bh`fy}vmol fh monfufh}fy fyivf`by mfymf yv hof{

hl f dvy}bh jvigly bysfi}ly mf b ~omb mf `bil}omobhombm r yf ~o~f `f dvy}b fyiuoeou yl`lyf hfifyo}b bsll bi}vbu mfyiveuou b ~omb`l r yodvf fh vh jvhml }bh ~biol }bh monfufh}fibmb mb(