Upload
juliana-elinor-marshall
View
217
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
kghfhfhf
Bertelsmann AG Presentation
March 2002
Bertelsmann’s Strategic Positioning IN THE MEDIA & ENTERTAINMENT INDUSTRY
University of Illinois Executive MBA
kghfhfhf
Bertelsmann AG Presentation
Donna AcklinJay BartlettDan Becker
Brad ComincioliAnne Jennings
Christine MajersRadha Nandkumar
Paulo OliveiraTroy Scott
Vanisha TaylorFaculty Advisor: Professor Joe Mahoney
Bertelsmann’s Strategic Positioning IN THE MEDIA & ENTERTAINMENT INDUSTRY
kghfhfhf
Bertelsmann AG Presentation
Defining the Business: The Starting Point of Strategy
For the purposes of our presentation, we define the
Media & Entertainment Industry as encompassing
companies dedicated to the creation and/or
aggregation and/or distribution of intellectual property
aimed at providing leisure to users, through any
available media outlet.
kghfhfhf
Bertelsmann AG Presentation
Key Industry Participants
AOL Time Warner
Bertelsmann
News Corporation / Fox
Walt Disney
Viacom
Vivendi Universal
kghfhfhf
Bertelsmann AG Presentation
What are the key strategic factors shaping the
Media & Entertainment industry?
What strategies will enhance Bertelsmann’s
future positioning within the industry?
Strategic Focus of the Presentation
kghfhfhf
Bertelsmann AG Presentation
Bertelsmann’s Strategic Positioning in the Media & Entertainment Industry
Industry Analysis
Value Chain Analysis
Recommendations
….……….….Jay Bartlett
…… Anne Jennings
….……. Paulo Oliveira
kghfhfhf
Bertelsmann AG Presentation
Industry Analysis Using Porter’s Five Forces Model
Buyer Power
RivalryThreat of
SubstitutesThreat of Entry
Supplier Power
Complementors
kghfhfhf
Bertelsmann AG Presentation
Supplier Power (Moderate to High)
New Talent
• Difficult to find
• Expensive to cultivate
Existing content
• High price transparency
• May not be for sale
News / General interest
• Expensive to produce
Impact - Moderate
Stars / Popular Production
• Concentrated supplier group
• Star brand more powerful than media firm brand
• Ability for supplier to sell direct via the Internet
Impact - High
Threats to Content Development
kghfhfhf
Bertelsmann AG Presentation
Consumer Power (Moderate)
Advertisers
• Excess capacity/space
• Evolving distribution channels
• Threat of access barriers by owners of distribution
• Demand for coordinated media campaigns
• Highly price conscious
• Advertising budgets often discretionary
Consumers• Increasing number of choices
• Access to media is increasingly via the Internet
• Increasing consumer control (VOD, iTV, Pay-Per-View, PVR)
• Little or no cost to switch
Threats from Customers
kghfhfhf
Bertelsmann AG Presentation
Threat of Entry (Low)
• Branding is critical• Capital requirements are high• Cost advantages to industry
leaders – economies of scale• High costs due to dynamics of
digital mediums • Economies of scope to diversified
companies• Difficult to secure new capital
- Dot.Com crash- Cyclical nature of advertising
spending
Threats from New Firms Entering the Market
kghfhfhf
Bertelsmann AG Presentation
Threat of Substitutes (Low)
• Very few substitutes for content
• Variety of advertising mediums
• Free basic services
• Companies must advertise
From the Perspective of Advertisers
kghfhfhf
Bertelsmann AG Presentation
Rivalry (High)
• Evolving industry• High fixed costs• Excess advertising capacity• Short product life cycles• High entry and exit costs• Large number of competitors
Propensity for Strong Price-based Competition
kghfhfhf
Bertelsmann AG Presentation
Sixth Force – Complementors (High)
• Broadband• Digital Content• Enabling Technologies• New Revenue Models
- Tiered charging models
- Copyright protection
Unique Technological Factors
Results • Adds to competitive forces • Rewards first-movers
kghfhfhf
Bertelsmann AG Presentation
Industry Structure 2002 High Levels of Competition
Buyer Power Moderate
RivalryHigh
Threat of Substitutes
Low
Threat of Entry Low
Supplier Power Moderate/High
ComplementorsHigh
kghfhfhf
Bertelsmann AG Presentation
Anticipated Industry Structure 2007 Consolidation & Maturing Technologies Improve Industry Conditions
Buyer Power
RivalryThreat of
Substitutes Threat of
Entry
Supplier Power
Complementors
kghfhfhf
Bertelsmann AG Presentation
Vertical Coordination
From the industry analysis we conclude that a key element to improving industry conditions is vertical integration.
• Cost reduction
• Distribution channel risks
• Wide-scope advertising campaigns
Therefore, we turn our focus towards the firm using the tool value-chain analysis.
kghfhfhf
Bertelsmann AG Presentation
Media Value Chain
DISTRIBUTION• Radio• Television/Theater• Magazines• Newspapers• Books• Internet• Theme Parks/Stadiums• Stores/Outlets• Personal Digital
Assistants• Cellular phones• Personal Computers• Kiosks/Pin Walls• Phone/Fax• Billboards
CONTENT• Information• Creative talents• Archives• Intellectual Property
- Copyrights- Trademarks
AGGREGATION• Audio• Video• Print• Virtual
kghfhfhf
Bertelsmann AG Presentation
Global Media Landscape
Movies/Home VideoTV ProductionSportsChildren's EntertainmentNewsMusicMagazine PublishingInteractive SoftwareBroadcast Network
Local TV StationsBasic Cable Network Moderate Presence
Premium Cable NetworkCable SystemsSatellites Little or No Presence
RadioConsumer Products, RetailTheme ParksMovie TheatersE-Commerce/Direct Mkt.Internet-Narrowband
Internet-Broadband
Strong Presence
Salomon Smith Barney, 12/01
kghfhfhf
Bertelsmann AG Presentation
Geographic Diversity of Revenue Streams in 2000
0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%
Viacom
AOL Time Warner
Disney
News Corp.
MGM
Vivendi
Bertelsmann
U.S. Europe/Asia/Latin America
kghfhfhf
Bertelsmann AG Presentation
What are the key strategic factors shaping the Media & Entertainment Industry?
• Convergence of technologies
• Consolidation of creators, aggregators and distributors
• Governmental regulations
kghfhfhf
Bertelsmann AG Presentation
What strategies will enhance Bertelsmann’s strategic positioning within the industry?
Critical Success Factors
1. Become a dominant global player
2. Control the customer interface
3. Leverage intellectual property from publishing
Horizontal and vertical coordination to control the key links of M&E’s value chain, namely content, aggregation and distribution, on a global basis.
kghfhfhf
Bertelsmann AG Presentation
Recommendations
1. Become a dominant global player • Be a catalyst for non-integrated companies• Utilize M&A, Co-opetition, JV’s, strategic alliances
2. Control the customer interface • Expand electronic distribution capability • Explore unique position in the U.S.A.
3. Leverage intellectual property from publishing • Expand into filmed entertainment production• Lead e-book development
kghfhfhf
Bertelsmann AG Presentation
Possible Scenarios: Integrating Complementary Businesses
“Lone stars” in the U.S.A.
• MGM
• NBC
• AT&T Comcast
kghfhfhf
Bertelsmann AG Presentation
Bertelsmann 2001: # 1 in Publishing & # 6 overall in the Media & Entertainment Industry
Vivendi Universal
AOL Time Warner
Walt Disney
Viacom News
Corp. & Fox
Bertelsmann
Revenue $ 48.2$ 38.5$ 25.3$ 23.3$ 22.4$ 18.4$
Pay TV Network 6.7$ 6.9$ 3.8$ 4.2$ 6.0$
Broadcasting 0.4$ 5.8$ 6.8$ 3.3$ 2.4$
Filmed Entertnmnt 7.2$ 8.1$ 6.3$ 2.8$ 7.2$ 1.1$
Publishing 6.7$ 5.0$ 0.7$ 6.0$ 8.5$
Music 14.5$ 4.2$ 3.5$
Cable Systems 6.5$
Radio 3.7$ 0.2$
Consumer Products 2.3$ 2.0$
Theme Parks 1.9$ 6.8$
Video Rental 5.1$
Telecom 11.1$
Online 7.3$ 0.3$ 0.7$
Salomon Smith Barney, 12/01
kghfhfhf
Bertelsmann AG Presentation
MGM acquisition would double Bertelsmann’s film business, but with a minor impact in world positioning
Vivendi Universal
AOL Time Warner
Walt Disney
Viacom News
Corp. & Fox
Bert-MGM
Revenue $ 48.2$ 38.5$ 25.3$ 23.3$ 22.4$ 19.9$
Pay TV Network 6.7$ 6.9$ 3.8$ 4.2$ 6.0$ 0.2$
Broadcasting 0.4$ 5.8$ 6.8$ 3.3$ 2.4$
Filmed Entertnmnt 7.2$ 8.1$ 6.3$ 2.8$ 7.2$ 2.4$
Publishing 6.7$ 5.0$ 0.7$ 6.0$ 8.5$
Music 14.5$ 4.2$ 3.5$
Cable Systems 6.5$
Radio 3.7$ 0.2$
Consumer Products 2.3$ 2.0$
Theme Parks 1.9$ 6.8$
Video Rental 5.1$
Telecom 11.1$
Online 7.3$ 0.3$ 0.7$
Salomon Smith Barney, 12/01
kghfhfhf
Bertelsmann AG Presentation
An alliance with NBC would make Bertelsmann the leading broadcaster in the world
Vivendi Universal
AOL Time Warner
Bert-MGM-NBC
Walt Disney
Viacom News
Corp. & Fox
Revenue $ 48.2$ 38.5$ 26.4$ 25.3$ 23.3$ 22.4$
Pay TV Network 6.7$ 6.9$ 0.2$ 3.8$ 4.2$ 6.0$
Broadcasting 0.4$ 8.9$ 5.8$ 6.8$ 3.3$
Filmed Entertnmnt 7.2$ 8.1$ 2.4$ 6.3$ 2.8$ 7.2$
Publishing 6.7$ 5.0$ 8.5$ 0.7$ 6.0$
Music 14.5$ 4.2$ 3.5$
Cable Systems 6.5$
Radio 0.2$ 3.7$
Consumer Products 2.0$ 2.3$
Theme Parks 1.9$ 6.8$
Video Rental 5.1$
Telecom 11.1$
Online 7.3$ 0.7$ 0.3$
Salomon Smith Barney 12/01 & Company Reports
kghfhfhf
Bertelsmann AG Presentation
ATT Comcast: Merger of the decade creates the second largest Media & Entertainment company in the world!
Vivendi Universal
Bert-MGM-NBC- ATT-Comcast
AOL Time Warner
Walt Disney
Viacom News
Corp. & Fox
Revenue $ 48.2$ 45.4$ 38.5$ 25.3$ 23.3$ 22.4$
Pay TV Network 6.7$ ? 6.9$ 3.8$ 4.2$ 6.0$
Broadcasting 8.9$ 0.4$ 5.8$ 6.8$ 3.3$
Filmed Entertnmnt 7.2$ 2.4$ 8.1$ 6.3$ 2.8$ 7.2$
Publishing 6.7$ 8.5$ 5.0$ 0.7$ 6.0$
Music 14.5$ 3.5$ 4.2$
Cable Systems ? 6.5$
Radio 0.2$ 3.7$
Consumer Products 2.0$ 2.3$
Theme Parks 1.9$ 6.8$
Video Rental 5.1$
Telecom 11.1$ ?
Online ? 7.3$ 0.3$
Salomon Smith Barney 12/01 & Company Reports