27
Corn Processing Options Kevin Lager Dairy Field Specialist ISU Extension and Outreach

Kevin Lager Dairy Field Specialist ISU Extension and Outreach · Kernel Processor. . ... * ** * P < 0.10 ** P < 0.01 Ferraretto and Shaver. Ferraretto and Shaver. NDF Digestibility

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Kevin Lager Dairy Field Specialist ISU Extension and Outreach · Kernel Processor. . ... * ** * P < 0.10 ** P < 0.01 Ferraretto and Shaver. Ferraretto and Shaver. NDF Digestibility

Corn Processing Options

Kevin LagerDairy Field Specialist

ISU Extension and Outreach

Page 2: Kevin Lager Dairy Field Specialist ISU Extension and Outreach · Kernel Processor. . ... * ** * P < 0.10 ** P < 0.01 Ferraretto and Shaver. Ferraretto and Shaver. NDF Digestibility

Overview

• Corn grain – large focus of processing

• What about whole plant corn or corn stover?

Page 3: Kevin Lager Dairy Field Specialist ISU Extension and Outreach · Kernel Processor. . ... * ** * P < 0.10 ** P < 0.01 Ferraretto and Shaver. Ferraretto and Shaver. NDF Digestibility

Outline

• Alkaline treatment of corn stover

• Corn silage processing – shredlage

Page 4: Kevin Lager Dairy Field Specialist ISU Extension and Outreach · Kernel Processor. . ... * ** * P < 0.10 ** P < 0.01 Ferraretto and Shaver. Ferraretto and Shaver. NDF Digestibility

Alkali Treatment

• Not new - alkali treatment processes: – NaOH– NaOH + CaO– Ammonia

• Latest – calcium hydroxide

Page 5: Kevin Lager Dairy Field Specialist ISU Extension and Outreach · Kernel Processor. . ... * ** * P < 0.10 ** P < 0.01 Ferraretto and Shaver. Ferraretto and Shaver. NDF Digestibility

How does it work?

Electron micrographs courtesy of MS Lime

Page 6: Kevin Lager Dairy Field Specialist ISU Extension and Outreach · Kernel Processor. . ... * ** * P < 0.10 ** P < 0.01 Ferraretto and Shaver. Ferraretto and Shaver. NDF Digestibility

Treatment Process• Reduce particle size – increase surface area (3 to 6”

screen)

• Add 5% wt:wt dry CaO and water to create Ca(OH)2, or add Ca(OH)2 directly.

• pH increase to 10-12; above 8 for storage

• Hold 5-7 days before feeding

• Long term storage – oxygen exclusion; not fermentation process

Page 7: Kevin Lager Dairy Field Specialist ISU Extension and Outreach · Kernel Processor. . ... * ** * P < 0.10 ** P < 0.01 Ferraretto and Shaver. Ferraretto and Shaver. NDF Digestibility

Processing

*ADM Commercial Demonstration Trials

* *

Page 8: Kevin Lager Dairy Field Specialist ISU Extension and Outreach · Kernel Processor. . ... * ** * P < 0.10 ** P < 0.01 Ferraretto and Shaver. Ferraretto and Shaver. NDF Digestibility

Feeding Corn Stover

Diets

Item Baled Stover Untreated Stover Silage CaO-Treated Silage

Digestion coefficients, %

DM 75.9a 75.5a 83.2b

NDF 70.8 68.7 81.7

ADF 62.5 62.7 75.9

ISU Animal Industry Report, 2011 (R2586)

Page 9: Kevin Lager Dairy Field Specialist ISU Extension and Outreach · Kernel Processor. . ... * ** * P < 0.10 ** P < 0.01 Ferraretto and Shaver. Ferraretto and Shaver. NDF Digestibility

Hydrated Lime – Stover

Digestibility

Page 10: Kevin Lager Dairy Field Specialist ISU Extension and Outreach · Kernel Processor. . ... * ** * P < 0.10 ** P < 0.01 Ferraretto and Shaver. Ferraretto and Shaver. NDF Digestibility

Lactating Cows

• Purdue University– Mid lactation cows– Replaced corn silage– Short term – 21d

Page 11: Kevin Lager Dairy Field Specialist ISU Extension and Outreach · Kernel Processor. . ... * ** * P < 0.10 ** P < 0.01 Ferraretto and Shaver. Ferraretto and Shaver. NDF Digestibility

Purdue University

Control On-farm Extruded

Treated stover% of dry ration wt.

0 12.5 25 12.5 25

DMI, lbs/d 52.9 49.3 47.7 48.9 49.3

Milk, lbs/d 64.5 61.0 63.6 65.1 67.1

Efficiency 1.22 1.24 1.33 1.33 1.36

% Milk Fat 3.92 3.64 4.0 3.89 3.98

% Milk Protein 2.99 3.06 3.06 3.13 2.96

% Milk Lactose 4.71 4.62 4.63 4.63 4.5

Page 12: Kevin Lager Dairy Field Specialist ISU Extension and Outreach · Kernel Processor. . ... * ** * P < 0.10 ** P < 0.01 Ferraretto and Shaver. Ferraretto and Shaver. NDF Digestibility

Stover vs Grain

Cook, Combs and Hall, 2013

Page 13: Kevin Lager Dairy Field Specialist ISU Extension and Outreach · Kernel Processor. . ... * ** * P < 0.10 ** P < 0.01 Ferraretto and Shaver. Ferraretto and Shaver. NDF Digestibility

Treatment Recipe

• The Recipe to make 50% DM treated stover Water 1000 lbStover DM 950 lbLime 50 lb

2000 lb (as fed) treated stover

• Dry baled stover (90% DM) As fed stover (950 ÷ 0.90) 1055 lbAdded water 1000 lb – (1055-950) 895 lb (112 gallons) Lime 50 lb

2000 lb (treated stover)

• To treat 50 tons of 90% DM Stover you need 10,600 gallons of water!

Combs, UW-Madison

Page 14: Kevin Lager Dairy Field Specialist ISU Extension and Outreach · Kernel Processor. . ... * ** * P < 0.10 ** P < 0.01 Ferraretto and Shaver. Ferraretto and Shaver. NDF Digestibility

Costs• CaO - $350/t

• Labor and machinery = $10/t minimum

• Cost of corn stover: $80/t

• Cost of Grinding: $140-400/hr– Instances of over $400/hr

• Additional costs– Packing tractor, loader, storage: bagger, or plastic cover

Page 15: Kevin Lager Dairy Field Specialist ISU Extension and Outreach · Kernel Processor. . ... * ** * P < 0.10 ** P < 0.01 Ferraretto and Shaver. Ferraretto and Shaver. NDF Digestibility

Summary

• CaO digestibility 8-15%

• Feeding rate – 20% in feeding studies

• Short term work in lactating dairy cattle– Caution for dry, transition cows

• What are the costs

Page 16: Kevin Lager Dairy Field Specialist ISU Extension and Outreach · Kernel Processor. . ... * ** * P < 0.10 ** P < 0.01 Ferraretto and Shaver. Ferraretto and Shaver. NDF Digestibility

Corn Silage

Page 17: Kevin Lager Dairy Field Specialist ISU Extension and Outreach · Kernel Processor. . ... * ** * P < 0.10 ** P < 0.01 Ferraretto and Shaver. Ferraretto and Shaver. NDF Digestibility

Shredlage

• Missouri dairy farmer

• Built prototype in shop

• Prototype in less than 60-days

• Development to today

Page 18: Kevin Lager Dairy Field Specialist ISU Extension and Outreach · Kernel Processor. . ... * ** * P < 0.10 ** P < 0.01 Ferraretto and Shaver. Ferraretto and Shaver. NDF Digestibility

Kernel Processor

Page 19: Kevin Lager Dairy Field Specialist ISU Extension and Outreach · Kernel Processor. . ... * ** * P < 0.10 ** P < 0.01 Ferraretto and Shaver. Ferraretto and Shaver. NDF Digestibility

www.shredlage.com

Page 20: Kevin Lager Dairy Field Specialist ISU Extension and Outreach · Kernel Processor. . ... * ** * P < 0.10 ** P < 0.01 Ferraretto and Shaver. Ferraretto and Shaver. NDF Digestibility

Feeding

• Shredlage vs KP

• 50% of ration

• Cow ~ 114 - 117 DIM

• 8 wks

Page 21: Kevin Lager Dairy Field Specialist ISU Extension and Outreach · Kernel Processor. . ... * ** * P < 0.10 ** P < 0.01 Ferraretto and Shaver. Ferraretto and Shaver. NDF Digestibility

3.5% FCM Yield by Week

*

* ** * P < 0.10

** P < 0.01

Ferraretto and Shaver

Page 22: Kevin Lager Dairy Field Specialist ISU Extension and Outreach · Kernel Processor. . ... * ** * P < 0.10 ** P < 0.01 Ferraretto and Shaver. Ferraretto and Shaver. NDF Digestibility

Ferraretto and Shaver

Page 23: Kevin Lager Dairy Field Specialist ISU Extension and Outreach · Kernel Processor. . ... * ** * P < 0.10 ** P < 0.01 Ferraretto and Shaver. Ferraretto and Shaver. NDF Digestibility

NDF Digestibility

Treatment P < 0.04

Ferraretto and Shaver

Page 24: Kevin Lager Dairy Field Specialist ISU Extension and Outreach · Kernel Processor. . ... * ** * P < 0.10 ** P < 0.01 Ferraretto and Shaver. Ferraretto and Shaver. NDF Digestibility

Settings

Shredlage• 26-30 mm (1-1.2 in.)

TLOC; 2-3 mm roll gap

• Reduce knife numbers

Kernal Processing• 19 mm (3/4 in) TLOC;

2-3 mm roll gap

Page 25: Kevin Lager Dairy Field Specialist ISU Extension and Outreach · Kernel Processor. . ... * ** * P < 0.10 ** P < 0.01 Ferraretto and Shaver. Ferraretto and Shaver. NDF Digestibility

Questions

• Availability and price

• Impact on drought stressed corn

• Long term storage

• High corn silage diet – reduce/eliminate hay

Page 26: Kevin Lager Dairy Field Specialist ISU Extension and Outreach · Kernel Processor. . ... * ** * P < 0.10 ** P < 0.01 Ferraretto and Shaver. Ferraretto and Shaver. NDF Digestibility

Summary

• New technology

• Positive response when fed to cows

• Availability and price

Page 27: Kevin Lager Dairy Field Specialist ISU Extension and Outreach · Kernel Processor. . ... * ** * P < 0.10 ** P < 0.01 Ferraretto and Shaver. Ferraretto and Shaver. NDF Digestibility

Kevin Lager

[email protected]

http://www.extension.iastate.edu/dairyteam/