Upload
vuongtruc
View
221
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Kenyon Mill Dam FishPassage ProjectKenyon Mill Dam FishPassage Project
Richmond/Charlestown, RIRichmond/Charlestown, RI
April 12, 20117:00 P.M. – 9:00 P.M.April 12, 20117:00 P.M. – 9:00 P.M.
Public Informational MeetingPublic Informational Meeting
AgendaKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
AgendaKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
• Introduction (5 min.)
• Project Background (5 min.)
• Project Description (50 min.)– Site Description
– Previous Dam Assessments and Current Condition
– Feasibility Study Alternatives Evaluations
– Data Collection and Assessments
– Fish Passage Alternatives Analyses
– Next Steps
• Questions and Discussion
• Introduction (5 min.)
• Project Background (5 min.)
• Project Description (50 min.)– Site Description
– Previous Dam Assessments and Current Condition
– Feasibility Study Alternatives Evaluations
– Data Collection and Assessments
– Fish Passage Alternatives Analyses
– Next Steps
• Questions and Discussion
AgendaKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectAgendaKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
Site DescriptionSite Description
Site DescriptionKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectSite DescriptionKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
Source: August 2007 Malone and MacBroom Feasibility StudySource: August 2007 Malone and MacBroom Feasibility Study
Watershed and River Continuity MapWatershed and River Continuity Map
Site DescriptionKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectSite DescriptionKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
Upper Pawcatuck River Project Site LocationsUpper Pawcatuck River Project Site Locations
Site DescriptionKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectSite DescriptionKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
• Alewife• Blueback Herring• American Shad• Atlantic Salmon• American Eel• Resident Fish Species
– Brown Trout– Brook Trout
• Alewife• Blueback Herring• American Shad• Atlantic Salmon• American Eel• Resident Fish Species
– Brown Trout– Brook Trout
Target Fish SpeciesTarget Fish Species
Site DescriptionKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectSite DescriptionKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
• 1772 – Iron Works Mill• 1820 – Sold by T. Holburton to Lewis Kenyon, Became
Cotton/Woolen Mill• 1844 – Lewis Kenyon’s Sons Expanded Mill• 1857 – Elijah Kenyon, Sole Owner of Mill (Woolen Mill)• 1881 - Expanded Mill Complex (E. Kenyon & Son)• 1894 – Expanded Mill Complex Including Rerouting River
Through Mill (First Date When Dam is Referenced)• 1911 – Mill and Equipment Sold to F.P. Smith of Boston• 1936 – Mill Bought by Kenyon Piece Dye Works, Large
Scale Improvements• 1996 – Mill Operating as Kenyon Industries
• 1772 – Iron Works Mill• 1820 – Sold by T. Holburton to Lewis Kenyon, Became
Cotton/Woolen Mill• 1844 – Lewis Kenyon’s Sons Expanded Mill• 1857 – Elijah Kenyon, Sole Owner of Mill (Woolen Mill)• 1881 - Expanded Mill Complex (E. Kenyon & Son)• 1894 – Expanded Mill Complex Including Rerouting River
Through Mill (First Date When Dam is Referenced)• 1911 – Mill and Equipment Sold to F.P. Smith of Boston• 1936 – Mill Bought by Kenyon Piece Dye Works, Large
Scale Improvements• 1996 – Mill Operating as Kenyon Industries
Site DescriptionKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectSite DescriptionKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
Site DescriptionKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectSite DescriptionKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
Site DescriptionKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectSite DescriptionKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
Source: RIGIS/URISource: RIGIS/URI
1939 Site Aerial1939 Site Aerial
Site DescriptionKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectSite DescriptionKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
Existing Dam at Kenyon IndustriesExisting Dam at Kenyon Industries
AgendaKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectAgendaKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
Previous Dam Assessmentsand Current Condition
Previous Dam Assessmentsand Current Condition
Current Dam ConditionKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectCurrent Dam ConditionKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
Current Site PhotographsCurrent Site Photographs
Existing Spillway – August 2009Existing Spillway – August 2009
Current Dam ConditionKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectCurrent Dam ConditionKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
Current Site PhotographsCurrent Site Photographs
Existing Spillway – October 2010Existing Spillway – October 2010
Current Dam ConditionKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectCurrent Dam ConditionKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
Current Site PhotographsCurrent Site Photographs
Mill Fire Suppression System Intake - March 2009Mill Fire Suppression System Intake - March 2009
Current Dam ConditionKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectCurrent Dam ConditionKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
Current Site PhotographsCurrent Site Photographs
Mill Fire Suppression System Intake - August 2009Mill Fire Suppression System Intake - August 2009
Fish Passage Alternatives AnalysesKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectFish Passage Alternatives AnalysesKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
Kenyon Industries Fire Suppression Pump Intake SystemKenyon Industries Fire Suppression Pump Intake System
Current Dam ConditionKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectCurrent Dam ConditionKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
Current Condition of Dam– Partial Breach at End of Spillway on
River-Left (Charlestown side)
– Spillway Section in Need of Repair
– No Low-level Discharge Outlet
– Current Visual Assessment of SpillwayReflects POOR Condition
Current Condition of Dam– Partial Breach at End of Spillway on
River-Left (Charlestown side)
– Spillway Section in Need of Repair
– No Low-level Discharge Outlet
– Current Visual Assessment of SpillwayReflects POOR Condition
AgendaKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectAgendaKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
2007 Feasibility StudyAlternatives Evaluation2007 Feasibility StudyAlternatives Evaluation
2007 Feasibility Study Alternatives EvaluationKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project2007 Feasibility Study Alternatives EvaluationKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
Feasibility Study AlternativesFeasibility Study Alternatives
Source: August 2007
Malone and MacBroom Feasibility Study
Source: August 2007
Malone and MacBroom Feasibility Study
Source: August 2007
Malone and MacBroom Feasibility Study
Source: August 2007
Malone and MacBroom Feasibility Study
2007 Feasibility Study Alternatives EvaluationKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project2007 Feasibility Study Alternatives EvaluationKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
Alternatives Evaluation Summary TableAlternatives Evaluation Summary Table
AgendaKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectAgendaKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
Data Collection and AssessmentsData Collection and Assessments
Data Collection and AssessmentsKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectData Collection and AssessmentsKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
Site Survey and Topographic MappingSite Survey and Topographic Mapping
Data Collection and AssessmentsKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectData Collection and AssessmentsKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
Site Survey and Topographic MappingSite Survey and Topographic Mapping
Data Collection and AssessmentsKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectData Collection and AssessmentsKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
Existing Wetland ResourcesExisting Wetland Resources
Data Collection and AssessmentsKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectData Collection and AssessmentsKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
Physical Sediment SamplingPhysical Sediment Sampling
Data Collection and AssessmentsKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectData Collection and AssessmentsKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
Chemical Sediment SamplingChemical Sediment Sampling
Data Collection and AssessmentsKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectData Collection and AssessmentsKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
Data Collection and AssessmentsKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectData Collection and AssessmentsKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
Summary of Chemical Sediment SamplingSummary of Chemical Sediment Sampling
• Only one parameter in onesample exceeded RI DirectExposure Criteria
• All results consistent withprior/historical use at thesite and along the river
• Sediment ManagementPlan to be developed andimplemented for theproject
• Only one parameter in onesample exceeded RI DirectExposure Criteria
• All results consistent withprior/historical use at thesite and along the river
• Sediment ManagementPlan to be developed andimplemented for theproject
AgendaKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectAgendaKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
Fish PassageAlternatives Analyses
Fish PassageAlternatives Analyses
Fish Passage Alternatives AnalysesKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectFish Passage Alternatives AnalysesKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
Fish Passage Design Alternatives• Rock Ramp Construction
– Replaces Dam Spillway with a Rock Ramp (approx. 160-feet long)
– Minimal Water Level Change or Effect on Upstream Wetland Resources
– Continued Use of River by Kenyon Industries’ Fire Suppression System
– Portage Path Planned for Recreational Boaters
• Full Dam Removal– Spillway Removed, Potential Modifications to River Channel to Optimize Fish
Passage
– Water Level Lowered to Pre-Dam Levels, Some Effect on Upstream WetlandResources
– River Likely No Longer Used for Kenyon Industries’ Fire Suppression System
• Neither Alternative Will Have an Effect on Worden PondWater Levels
Fish Passage Design Alternatives• Rock Ramp Construction
– Replaces Dam Spillway with a Rock Ramp (approx. 160-feet long)
– Minimal Water Level Change or Effect on Upstream Wetland Resources
– Continued Use of River by Kenyon Industries’ Fire Suppression System
– Portage Path Planned for Recreational Boaters
• Full Dam Removal– Spillway Removed, Potential Modifications to River Channel to Optimize Fish
Passage
– Water Level Lowered to Pre-Dam Levels, Some Effect on Upstream WetlandResources
– River Likely No Longer Used for Kenyon Industries’ Fire Suppression System
• Neither Alternative Will Have an Effect on Worden PondWater Levels
Fish Passage Alternatives AnalysesKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectFish Passage Alternatives AnalysesKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
Rock Ramp Alternative– Replaces Dam Spillway with a Rock Ramp (approx. 160-
feet long, length determined in final design)
– Minimal Water Level Change and Sediment Migration
– Minimal Effect on Upstream Wetland Resources
– No Effect on Upstream Shallow Groundwater Supply Wells
– No Potential for Scour at Upstream Bridges
– Continued Use of River by Kenyon Industries’ FireSuppression System, Two Dry Hydrants Installed
– Requires Continued Maintenance
– Less than Optimal Fish Passage Efficiency
Rock Ramp Alternative– Replaces Dam Spillway with a Rock Ramp (approx. 160-
feet long, length determined in final design)
– Minimal Water Level Change and Sediment Migration
– Minimal Effect on Upstream Wetland Resources
– No Effect on Upstream Shallow Groundwater Supply Wells
– No Potential for Scour at Upstream Bridges
– Continued Use of River by Kenyon Industries’ FireSuppression System, Two Dry Hydrants Installed
– Requires Continued Maintenance
– Less than Optimal Fish Passage Efficiency
El. 85.8 (for New 1,500 GPM Pump)El. 85.8 (for New 1,500 GPM Pump)
El. 85.1 (for New 2,000 GPM Pump)El. 85.1 (for New 2,000 GPM Pump)
El. 85.4 (for Exist. 1,000 GPM Pump)El. 85.4 (for Exist. 1,000 GPM Pump)
Fish Passage Alternatives AnalysesKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectFish Passage Alternatives AnalysesKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
Rock Ramp – Kenyon Fire Suppression SystemRock Ramp – Kenyon Fire Suppression System
Fish Passage Alternatives AnalysesKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectFish Passage Alternatives AnalysesKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
Potential Local Fire Department Dry Hydrant LocationsPotential Local Fire Department Dry Hydrant Locations
Additional Dry Hydrantfor Full Dam Removal
Scenario
Planned Dry Hydrantsfor Both Scenarios
Fish Passage Alternatives AnalysesKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectFish Passage Alternatives AnalysesKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
Preliminary Rock Ramp Layout - Plan ViewPreliminary Rock Ramp Layout - Plan View
Fish Passage Alternatives AnalysesKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectFish Passage Alternatives AnalysesKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
Rock Ramp - Profile ViewRock Ramp - Profile View
Grade Control Structure With6’ Wide Low-Level Notch
Inv. El.=84.48
Raised Arched Weirs SpacedEvery 20’ (Typ.)
Rock Ramp – El. 84.48 To El. 80.32 (-3%-5% Longitudinal Slope)
Tailout – El. 80.32 To El. 77.5(20% Longitudinal Slope)
Geotextile or Bentonite WaterproofingSheet/Membrane
TailwaterElevation
Fish Passage Alternatives AnalysesKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectFish Passage Alternatives AnalysesKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
Full Dam Removal Alternative– Removes Dam Spillway – No Replacement Structure
– Potential Water Level Change and Sediment Migration
– Potential Effect on Upstream Wetland Resources
– Potential Effect on Upstream Shallow Groundwater Supply Wells
– Potential Scour Protection Needed at Upstream Bridges
– River Likely No Longer Used for Kenyon Industries’ FireSuppression System
– Three Dry Hydrants Installed Along River Channel for Local FireDepartment Use
– No Future Maintenance
– Optimal Fish Passage Efficiency
Full Dam Removal Alternative– Removes Dam Spillway – No Replacement Structure
– Potential Water Level Change and Sediment Migration
– Potential Effect on Upstream Wetland Resources
– Potential Effect on Upstream Shallow Groundwater Supply Wells
– Potential Scour Protection Needed at Upstream Bridges
– River Likely No Longer Used for Kenyon Industries’ FireSuppression System
– Three Dry Hydrants Installed Along River Channel for Local FireDepartment Use
– No Future Maintenance
– Optimal Fish Passage Efficiency
Fish Passage Alternatives AnalysesKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectFish Passage Alternatives AnalysesKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
Base Flow Water Surface Elevation ModelingBase Flow Water Surface Elevation Modeling
Fish Passage Alternatives AnalysesKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectFish Passage Alternatives AnalysesKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
Rock Ramp – Water Surface Change PlanRock Ramp – Water Surface Change Plan
Fish Passage Alternatives AnalysesKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectFish Passage Alternatives AnalysesKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
Full Dam Removal – Water Surface Change PlanFull Dam Removal – Water Surface Change Plan
Fish Passage Alternatives AnalysesKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectFish Passage Alternatives AnalysesKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
Rock Ramp – Seasonal Water Surface Change PlanRock Ramp – Seasonal Water Surface Change Plan
Fish Passage Alternatives AnalysesKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectFish Passage Alternatives AnalysesKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
Full Dam Removal – Seasonal Water Surface Change PlanFull Dam Removal – Seasonal Water Surface Change Plan
Fish Passage Alternatives AnalysesKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectFish Passage Alternatives AnalysesKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
Existing Conditions – Water Surface ProfileExisting Conditions – Water Surface Profile
Amtrak OverpassAmtrak OverpassKenyon DamKenyon DamRoute 2 BridgeRoute 2 Bridge
Biscuit City Rd BridgeBiscuit City Rd BridgeWorden Pond OutletWorden Pond Outlet
Fish Passage Alternatives AnalysesKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectFish Passage Alternatives AnalysesKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
Rock Ramp – Water Surface ProfileRock Ramp – Water Surface Profile
Amtrak OverpassAmtrak OverpassKenyon DamKenyon DamRoute 2 BridgeRoute 2 Bridge
Biscuit City Rd BridgeBiscuit City Rd BridgeWorden Pond OutletWorden Pond Outlet
Fish Passage Alternatives AnalysesKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectFish Passage Alternatives AnalysesKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
Full Dam Removal – Water Surface ProfileFull Dam Removal – Water Surface Profile
Amtrak OverpassAmtrak OverpassKenyon DamKenyon Dam
Route 2 BridgeRoute 2 Bridge
Biscuit City Rd BridgeBiscuit City Rd Bridge
Worden Pond OutletWorden Pond Outlet
Fish Passage Alternatives AnalysesKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectFish Passage Alternatives AnalysesKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
Rock Ramp – Wetland Assessment PlanRock Ramp – Wetland Assessment Plan
Fish Passage Alternatives AnalysesKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectFish Passage Alternatives AnalysesKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
Full Dam Removal – Wetland Assessment PlanFull Dam Removal – Wetland Assessment Plan
Fish Passage Alternatives AnalysesKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectFish Passage Alternatives AnalysesKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
Rock Ramp - Natural History DatabaseRock Ramp - Natural History Database
Fish Passage Alternatives AnalysesKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectFish Passage Alternatives AnalysesKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
Full Dam Removal –Natural History DatabaseFull Dam Removal –Natural History Database
Fish Passage Alternatives AnalysesKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectFish Passage Alternatives AnalysesKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
Evaluation of Potential Shallow Groundwater Well ImpactsEvaluation of Potential Shallow Groundwater Well Impacts
Fish Passage Alternatives AnalysesKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectFish Passage Alternatives AnalysesKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
Alternatives Evaluation Criteria• Kenyon Industries Fire Suppression System and Local Fire
Water Supply
• Potential Effects on Wetland Resource Alterations,Rare/Endangered Species and Habitat, Historic Resources
• Potential Effects on Shallow Groundwater Wells
• Potential Sediment Migration (transitional)
• Potential Bridge and River Channel Scour/Instability
• Potential Effects on Recreational Users (boaters, hunters)
• Potential Flood Impacts/Benefits
• Construction Costs / Post-Construction Maintenance Costs
Alternatives Evaluation Criteria• Kenyon Industries Fire Suppression System and Local Fire
Water Supply
• Potential Effects on Wetland Resource Alterations,Rare/Endangered Species and Habitat, Historic Resources
• Potential Effects on Shallow Groundwater Wells
• Potential Sediment Migration (transitional)
• Potential Bridge and River Channel Scour/Instability
• Potential Effects on Recreational Users (boaters, hunters)
• Potential Flood Impacts/Benefits
• Construction Costs / Post-Construction Maintenance Costs
AgendaKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectAgendaKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
Next StepsNext Steps
Next StepsKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectNext StepsKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
• State Historic Commission / Narragansett TribeCoordination (ongoing)
• Potential Wetland Studies/Evaluations
• Continued Negotiations with Kenyon Industries
• Prepare/Transmit Permit Applications
• Public Review Period and Public Workshop
• Final Design
• Bidding and Construction
• State Historic Commission / Narragansett TribeCoordination (ongoing)
• Potential Wetland Studies/Evaluations
• Continued Negotiations with Kenyon Industries
• Prepare/Transmit Permit Applications
• Public Review Period and Public Workshop
• Final Design
• Bidding and Construction
AgendaKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage ProjectAgendaKenyon Mill Dam Fish Passage Project
Questions and DiscussionQuestions and Discussion