8/3/2019 Kaufmann, EP. 2011. Review of Robert Putnam and David Campbell, 'American Grace,' Literary Review, May 2011

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kaufmann-ep-2011-review-of-robert-putnam-and-david-campbell-american 1/2

¯nf°fn

@¾¾f°n°fnf°�¾°¾°��°°¯nfn¯¯°

f½�½°½f°¾°f¯°f¾¾¯½°fD¾f°

°n��¾n°f¾°��°f¯°f¾n@�fnf½f�¾¾f¾nfff°n¯°¾¾°�½f°�9°f¯¯

@¯¾nf¯¾°�°ffnf¯n°f½°�½fn½f¾

fn¯°¾¾°¾¯f�f�9°f¯¾�°�½��°nf¾¯f¾¾

�¯f°n°�¾nfnf½ff°¾n°½f°¾�nf°�¾

f°n¾½¾¾¾¾nf�¾9°f¯f¾ff�f¾�

�f°�°f9¾°¾°°f°¾f°9¯,°¾f¾°°�n

½n¯f¾9°f¯f¾f¾¯f°f��½ff°n��°ff¾@¾¾f

ffn¯°�°nf°n�¯¾ff¾°°¾�½

¾°¾f¯¾�¾f°f°°¯fn°�°¾�f¾¯fff¾¯°f¯

°nf9°f¯¯f©°f¾°°½��ff@f¾fD°

½½¾n��f,fn¯f9°f¯¾°¾fn�n¾��¯ff

f°¾¾f�f¾°�

@��¾°9°f ̄¾f°¾9°f ̄�°¾¯°¾f°n°f½f°f

f¾f¾¯nf°9nfn°n¾¾nf°¯°�¾¾¾f�n½f°

nfff¯½-¾¾f¯½�¾¯¾9°f¯�¯

½ff°n°�¾f f̄�¾¾f¾nff°f¾¾f¾nf½¾½nf°

½½°�f��f°½¯¾nf°�°n¯¯°9°f¯¾½¾��°�¾

f¾n¯½nf¾n¾°f�°f°�¾nfn°°�°n

°¯nfnf°�ff¾n¯¾¾½n½°�¾�¾fn

f°f¾�°¾@¾nf½¾f¾°f�f¾n°�nn¾fn

f°f°ff°�°f¯°f¾Jnf¾n½°�nnff¾¯¾n

½f¾°¾f°½f¾¾½¾°¾¾½n¾¾f°�ff��¾¾f¾n¾

@f¾°n¾̄ ¯f¾f¾½nf¾¾°¯¾f¾°¾

¯nf°¾f�¾¯ff¾n�°¾�¯¾f°f�

°n°�fn¾f°¾¯f@½n°n°¾¯¾°¯nf°

�¾¯f½fnf¾½�°°f°�¯°f¾¾f°n¾

�f°��¾nff°¾¯f¾n¯ff½nf¾f°¾�ff°°f¾¯�

°�¾�f�f¾f°¾nf@¾nf°�f°�¾¾

f�¯f½¾°½f¾f°°�½nf°f°¯nfn

@°f¾¾f¾½¾°n°°°f¾̄ @fn°°

�¾ffn¯°f¯°�°�¯nf°¾9°f¯f°f¯½½°f½½°

�¯nf°¾½f°�°�°f¾¾ff¯°�n°�f¯¾

¯°�¾f�¾�½¾°f½f°�½n°@¾¾°f°

f�fn�f�½½°��¾°°¾f¯°�°¾°f°¾¾f½n°°

¯¾¾f°½nn°°¾f°f¾�°°�

¾f½n°¾¾°fnf¾�nf°°�°�°¯°@

f¾ff¾��¾�°¾f°¾f¾ffn°¾f

8/3/2019 Kaufmann, EP. 2011. Review of Robert Putnam and David Campbell, 'American Grace,' Literary Review, May 2011

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/kaufmann-ep-2011-review-of-robert-putnam-and-david-campbell-american 2/2

°¯f°�¾°f�°°°��°f¯°�nf°�½½°f

½½f½n½°f°�¾nf¾°f°�f¾¾��°f¾

¾½ffn�nf°½n�f°½n½n@¾f¯n°°

�°°�¾�¾¾°n¯½°���¾¾f°nf¯°�½¾¯

�°f°¾@¾¾�°����f�½f°¾ff�°�nf¾¾¯°�

°¾nf�¾f��f°f¾°¯¾f°�f¾n°©nf°¾n°nf½½fnf½f°¯nf°�¾°n¯¾fn¾¾f¾¾°n

��

@¾¯n¾@f¾�°ffnn¾f¯½nff°

n°¾f°¾@n°�¯ff¯�°¾f°nn¯°f°¾nf¾

�°��¾°°°�f°�°�¾°¾½ff°��¾�¯¾nf

f¾@fn°�ff¾�f°f½¾n½ff°¾f¾¾°�½n

�¯�¾½nf°¾nff¾9°�¾nf¾n°nf°¯f°

f°�¾�f½f¾n¯nf¾fn½n�nf¯nf°¾���°

�f¾f°¯ff�f°�°¾½n½°¾¯�¯½f¾¾°�©�¯°°¾

nf¾¯f©�¯nf°¾f°¾f°°¾f°¾nf°�f°¾½½¾¾�¯°f°n½

@¾½fnf¾°°��¾f°½n½°¾�¾@¯nf°fn

nn�°¾f°n¾ff°¯f©°¾°f¯°�¾°fn9¾f°¾f

fnf¯�°f¯°f¾f°f°�nf¾¾½°�¯nfn°°f

°n¯¾fnf¾°�f°½f¾f°¾½½ff°�n¯½¯½¾¾

9f°nf°n°�°n½f°¾ff¾°f¾�½¾n½ff°¾

n¯f,¯°f¾nf¯n½°f°½f�f�f�nn

n¾°°¾nf°f¾½°nn°¾¾f¾nnf¯¾n

°�n½nf½¾½¾°¾���f°¯f¾°°°f°©¾@¾¾°�½n¾¾

f¾ffn¾nfn°¾f¾�f½°��¾f¾�¯½¾°ff°n¯¾�ff¾°�¾f½f�f°¾�°f¾°�f¾f¾f°�ff°

¾nf¾°f½½°°°¾°�°�¾¾

@¾°�n¾¾¾½¾°¾f°f¯nf°¾nf¾¯f

�nf°�n°°�ff�¯°�°¾ff��nf°°¾¾°

n¾½°°n9°f¯°¾¾fn°°½¾°¾nf¾f°@f½°¾¾�

½f°�fnf¯f°�¾°nf°¾°f°�¾f¾¾��¾¾

°��°°�°¾¾f°ff�°¾¾f°�f¾

f�¾¾½½9°f¯f°f¯½f°°¾°°n¯nf¾

�¾°½°¾nf¯@f°°¯nf°¾½½¾f�¾

�°�¯�f¾½¯½¾°�f�f¾f°f°¯n¾½°¾°¯¯°¾°f°�nf�¯nf°½¯¾¯�f¾�f�°

°°¾f¾�¾�ff°�°°�¾nf¾f°f¾f�ff¾nf

½n¾¾°�n½�½n¾°©n¾¾°¾nf¾¯¾°¾f¾f¾f

°°°n°f°½¾f°n½f°¾°ff°¯nf°

f°n¾ffnf°°�¯nf°¾f½f¾¾©�¯°°nn¾