Upload
others
View
0
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
DPCA: DIABETES PREVENTION AND CONTROL ALLIANCETM
JW TERRILL SEMINAR SERIES
Presentation to
DIABETES PREVENTION AND CONTROL ALLIANCE April 25, 2012
AGENDA The Epidemic Trio: Diabetes, Prediabetes and Obesity Introduction to the Diabetes Prevention and Control Alliance (DPCA) Diabetes Prevention Program (DPP) for Prediabetes Diabetes Control Program for Diabetes Management The NOT ME DPCA Brand Testing Event Overview: DPCA Critical Success Component
PAGE 2
AGENDA
3
Diabetes Prevention and Control Alliance Not Business as Usual
Diabetes & Prediabetes US Adult Prevalence
1. Division of Diabetes Translation, www.cdc.gov 2. American Diabetes Association 3. Huang, Diabetes Care 32.12 Dec 2009 4
Missouri Adult Diabetes
5
Overweight in the Show-Me State Diabetes problems follow closely behind
Missouri Adult Obesity / Overweight
Since 1990, the obesity rate has more than doubled1
As of 2010, 30.5% of Missouri adults were obese
25% percent of Missourians engage in no leisure time physical activity
1CDC's Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System 2 Reidhead, M. The Economic Burden of Diabetes Mellitus Among Missouri Adults, 2006. Part One: Direct Costs. Missouri Department of Health and Senior Services. Diabetes Prevention and Control Program, Jefferson City, MO, 2008. 3“Combined State Sheets”. Juvenile Diabetes Research Foundation.
Diabetes Prevalence 1995: 4.1% of Missouri adults had diabetes 2012: Prevalence more than doubled to 9.4%1
Annual Cost of Diabetes: Estimated direct costs (medical care) for diabetes = $2.72 billion2
Estimated indirect costs (inability to work, death) > $850 million3
Total direct and indirect costs = $3.57 billion
Diabetes has a firm grip on Missouri: For the last 16 years it has remained the 6th or 7th leading cause of death
6 1. UnitedHealth Group’s commercial book of business, 2008 / 2. UnitedHealthcare 2008 analysis for Diabetes Health Plan for several large employers; Medical only (no Rx) / 3. American Diabetes Association
Increased treatment costs: • $6,663 PMPY average cost increase for diabetes • $889 PMPY average cost increase for prediabetes
Costs directly related to progression in severity; a non-compliant individual with diabetes and related complications has potential to cost 9Xs more than a non-diabetic individual 1
10 year NPV of avoiding diabetic conversion - $55K Progressive Cost of Diabetes Per Member Per Year2
$2,784 $3,673
$4,592 $5,595
$6,195
$13,093
$17,762
$0
$2,000
$4,000
$6,000
$8,000
$10,000
$12,000
$14,000
$16,000
$18,000
$20,000
No diabetes Diabetes / no complications
Diabetes non-compliant w/hypertension
Diabetes non-compliant w/CVD
Prediabetes Diabetes compliant w/hypertension
Diabetes compliant w/CVD
The Toll of Diabetes on US Health Care Potential to Bankrupt the Heath Care System
7
9
What is Prediabetes?
A medical condition, impaired glucose tolerance, in which your blood glucose (sugar) is higher than normal but not yet at the level of diabetes (Fasting Blood Glucose = 100 – 125 mg/dl / A1c = 5.7% – 6.4%)
The primary causes of this condition are obesity and inactivity There are no symptoms for prediabetes; 90% of individuals with
prediabetes do not know they have the condition If healthy lifestyle changes are made, the condition can be reversible Annually, 10% of individuals with prediabetes will convert to diabetes
predia betes n. pree-dahy-uh-bee-tis. Noun - pathology
10
DPP Target Population
U.S. Prediabetes Overview Diabetes Prevention Program Challenge
Definition: Blood glucose levels are higher than normal, but not high enough to be irreversible
Culprit: Obesity and Inactivity
Goals: Modify participant behavior, affect lifestyle change, help participants lose weight
Ideal: Reduce diabetes conversion
1. Diabetes Prevention Program Research Group: Reduction in the incidence of type 2 diabetes with lifestyle intervention or metformin. N Engl J Med 346:393-403, 2002 2. Ackermann and Marrero. Adapting the Diabetes Prevention Program Lifestyle Intervention for Delivery in the Community. AADE 2007.
Diabetes Prevention Program (DPP) Evidenced-based Intervention for Prediabetes
Study Diabetes Prevention Program Deploy2
Sponsor(s) National Institutes of Health Centers for Disease Control & National YMCA
Methodology Randomized Control Trial
(Lifestyle/drug/control) 27 sites, 3,234 prediabetics ages (>25) and various ethnicities
Pilot-cluster Randomized Trial (Lifestyle / Control)
Interaction 1:1 PhD-level Clinician (long-term maintenance, consistent training)
Group YMCA Lifestyle Coach (long-term maintenance, consistent training)
Frequency 16 Sessions (with optional year-long monthly follow-up)
Content
Welcome & Getting Started ▪ Be a Fat & Calorie Detective ▪ Ways to Eat Less Fat & Fewer Calories ▪ Healthy Eating ▪ Move Those Muscles ▪ Being Active: A Way of Life ▪ Tip the Calorie Balance ▪
Take Charge of What’s Around You ▪ Problem Solving ▪ Four Keys to Healthy Eating Out ▪ Talk Back to Negative Thoughts ▪ The Slippery Slope of Lifestyle Change ▪ Jump Start Your Activity Plan ▪
Make Social Cues Work for You ▪ You Can Manage Stress ▪ Ways to Stay Motivated
Goals 7% weight loss <25% fat calories 1200-1800 calories/day >150 minutes weekly physical activity
Results 5% weight loss 58% reduction in diabetes conversion 6% weight loss
11
DIABETES PREVENTION PROGRAM (DPP) Lifestyle Management and Weight Loss
People diagnosed with prediabetes can slow and even prevent the onset of type 2 diabetes through weight loss and lifestyle management. Participants are guided in group sessions by specially-trained health coaches. DPP Overview
16 core 1-hour small group sessions, then monthly follow-up for one year Recognized by Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) Preventive benefit; no copayment for participants Sustained weight loss in 40 % of participants at 10 year follow up Adult risk of developing type 2 diabetes reduced by nearly 60%; in adults
age 60+, the reduction is 70% Program lifestyle changes proven to be more effective than medication Regular communication provided to physicians
Diabetes Prevention Program (DPP) Delivered via Local Health Coaches
12
13
DPP at a Glance
14
DPP Member Experience
15
Current St. Louis Locations Y-USA Listings & Map
We will continue to add locations based on enrollment growth
West County Branch YMCA 16464 Burkhardt Place Chesterfield Jefferson County YMCA 1303 YMCA Dr Festus Wildwood Family YMCA 2641 Hwy 109 Wildwood Four Rivers Area Branch YMCA 400 Grand Ave Washington Marquette Branch YMCA 304 N Broadway St. Louis Downtown Branch YMCA 1528 Locust St St. Louis Carondelet Park Rec Complex 930 Holly Hills St. Louis Monsanto Branch YMCA 5555 Page Blvd St. Louis Webster Groves Branch YMCA 226 E Lockwood Ave Webster Groves Kirkwood Branch YMCA 325 North Taylor Avenue Kirkwood South County Branch YMCA 12736 Southfork Rd St. Louis Emerson Family YMCA 3390 Pershall Rd St. Louis South City Family YMCA 3150 Sublette Ave St. Louis Mid-County Branch YMCA 1900 Urban Dr Brentwood Edward Jones Family Branch YMCA 12521 Marine Ave St. Louis O'Fallon Family YMCA 3451 Pheasant Meadows Dr O'Fallon St. Charles Branch YMCA 3900 Shady Springs Lane St. Peters Tri-County YMCA 5293 Quail Ridge Pkwy Wentzville
16
Diabetes Prevention Program Current Pricing
Average payer cost per participant = $450 Claim payment is progressive and based on outcomes (not a PMPM) Expected ROI estimated at 3.0 : 1
Metric Definition Claim Payment
Cumulative Payment
Engagement Enrolls in DPP and attends at least one of the 16 sessions $50 $50
Participation Enrolls in DPP and attends at least four of the 16 sessions $100 $150
Completion Enrolls in DPP and attends at least nine of the 16 sessions $235 $385
Performance 1 Enrolls in DPP and attends at least nine of the 16 sessions and loses >= 5% within 60 days of class completion $165 $550
– OR –
Performance 2 Enrolls in DPP and attends at least nine of the 16 sessions and loses >= 9% within 60 days of class completion $205 $590*
18
DCP Target Population
U.S. Diabetes Overview Diabetes Control Program Challenge
Number: 26 million individuals / 1 in 10 adults
Definition: Can’t process glucose (blood sugar) normally
Culprit: Lack of control for BP, LDL, glucose, weight
Goals: Increase ADA standards compliance, monitor medications and control BP, cholesterol, HbA1c
Ideal: Avoid complications, delay disease progression
1. Diabetes Prevention Program Research Group: Reduction in the incidence of type 2 diabetes with lifestyle intervention or metformin. N Engl J Med 346:393-403, 2002 2. Ackermann and Marrero. Adapting the Diabetes Prevention Program Lifestyle Intervention for Delivery in the Community. AADE 2007.
Diabetes Control Program (DCP) Evidenced-based Intervention for Diabetes
Study The Pharmacy Care Program The Diabetes Ten City Challenge
Sponsor(s) City of Asheville NC & NC Association of Pharmacists
HealthMapRx & American Pharmacists Association
Methodology Ashville city employee diabetes management
program to demonstrate the value of pharmacist-directed care management
Duplication of the Pharmacy Care Program by observational analysis & pre/post comparison
with 573 employees at 10 US locations
Interaction 1:1 ▪ Individual & Pharmacist (health care education and compliance)
Frequency 4 Quarterly Consultations
Content
Baseline Diabetes Assessment (height, weight, waist circumference, BP, diabetes medical history ) ▪ HbA1C, Total cholesterol, LDL, HDL, TG lab reviews ▪ Medication Review ▪ Goal Setting ▪ ADA Exam Schedule ▪ Flu and pneumonia shots ▪ Participant Reminder Calls ▪ Primary Care Provider Updates ▪ Diabetes Self-management Education: Understanding Diabetes ◦ Nutrition & Meal Planning ◦ Medications ◦ Physical Activity ◦ Acute Complications ◦ Chronic Complications ◦ Monitoring Blood Glucose ◦ Health & Behavior Change ◦ Psychosocial Issues & Concerns)
Goals A1c < 7.5% LDL < 100 Systolic Blood Pressure < 130 Weight/BMI < 25
Results > 50% participants’ A1c level
Annual direct medical costs $1,200 - $1,872 Estimated annual productivity of $18,000
Influenza vaccination rate 33% Eye exam rate 24% ▪ Foot exam rate 40%
7.2% annual total health care costs
19
DIABETES CONTROL PROGRAM (DCP) Medication Management and Disease Control
Less than 2% of individuals diagnosed with diabetes are in control of their disease.1 The four additional annual touch points with a specially trained pharmacist supports the PCP’s treatment plan and provides participants with additional health resources. DCP Overview
4 quarterly core 1:1 consultations in a private setting No copayment for program services Convenient pharmacist-monitored care includes meds, BP, weight, labs Proven to identify early signs of debilitating complications & improve outcomes Coordination with participant’s primary care physician Every % in A1C = 40% risk of eye, kidney, nerve disease complications Every 10 mm Hg in SBP = diabetes-related complications by 12% Improved LDL control may reduce cardiovascular complications by 20-50%
Diabetes Control Program (DCP) Delivered via Local Pharmacists
1 Source: National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey, National Center for Health Statistics, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Beckles et.al. Population-based assessment of the level of care among adults with diabetes. Diabetes Care 1998 Sep;21(9):1432-8.
20
21
DCP at a Glance
Current St. Louis Locations Shop N Save Pharmacy Listings & Map
We will continue to add locations based
on enrollment growth
Address City 1253 Watertower Place Arnold 7909 Highway N Dardenne Prairie 15446 Manchester Road Ellisville 45 Gravoi Bluffs Plaza Drive Fenton 49 N Florissant Road Ferguson 1275 N Truman Blvd Festus 175 Flower Valley Shopping Center Florissant 196 Mayfair Plaza Shopping Center Florissant 2183 Charbonier Road Florissant 1023 Crossroads Place High Ridge 10461 Manchester Road Kirkwood 7355 Manchester Road Maplewood 9521 Lewis and Clark Blvd. Moline Acres 1421 Mexico Loop Road East O'Fallon 4447 Natural Bridge Ave Saint Louis 10634 St Charles Rock Rd St Ann 9070 St Charles Rock Rd St John 3865 Gravois Ave St Louis 7057 Chippewa St St Louis 100 Jungermann Road St Peters 3740 Monticello Plaza Drive St. Charles 60 Harvester Square St. Charles 1032 Lemay Ferry Road St. Louis 10805 Old Halls Ferry Rd St. Louis 4660 Chippewa St St. Louis 500 Highway 50 W Union
23
Average payer charge per participant for all claims is ~ $750 – First visit = $125 cost of entire intervention / Subsequent visits = $89 cost of entire intervention – Labs = $60/quarter (includes mailing, test, phys order, results review and data transfer) – Performance metrics = $90 each:
Pricing and underlying reimbursement tied to participant outcomes (not PMPM) Reduction in specialist referrals (expected but not included in ROI) Reduction in trend tied to improved compliance Expected ROI estimated at 3.5 : 1
Metric Definition Additional Requirements
Claim Payment
A1c < 7.5%
If < 7.5%, participant must maintain – OR– If > 7.5%, a reduction of at least 10% – OR– final A1c < 7.5%.
1. At least three measurements within the participant’s program year
2. Two of those measurements at least 180 days apart must be in control per guidelines
3. All measurements match a visit date
$ 90
LDL < 100
If < 100, participant must maintain – OR– If > 100, a reduction of at least 50% – OR– final LDL < 100
$ 90
SBP < 130
If < 130, participant must maintain – OR– If > 130, a reduction of at least 20% – OR– final SBP < 130
$ 90
BMI < 25
If < 25, participant must maintain – OR– If > 25, a reduction of at least 10% – OR– BMI < 25
$ 90
Diabetes Control Program Current Pricing
Current & Scheduled DPCA Markets * Indicates a 2012 Market
24
Market Rollout Schedule through 2013
PAGE 25
DPCA ACTIVE MARKETS Albuquerque NM DCP Mid-Atlantic market
+ Baltimore & DC metro + Northern & Fairfax VA + Suburban Maryland
BOTH Annandale NJ DPP
Atlanta GA BOTH
Birmingham AL DPP Milwaukee WI BOTH
Bloomington IN DPP Minneapolis & St Paul MN BOTH
Boise ID DPP New York City Metro + Surrounding Boroughs + Northern NJ + Fairfield County CT
BOTH Boston MA DPP
Buffalo NY DPP
Cincinnati OH & No KY BOTH Oklahoma City OK DCP
Columbus OH BOTH Orlando FL BOTH
Dallas/Ft Worth/Arlington TX BOTH Phoenix AZ BOTH
Dayton OH BOTH Pittsburgh PA DPP
Eugene OR DPP Providence RI (entire state) DPP
Fort Wayne IN DPP Rochester NY DPP
Houston TX BOTH Savannah GA DPP
Indianapolis IN BOTH Seattle WA DPP
Jacksonville FL BOTH Spokane WA DPP
LaCrosse WI DPP St. Louis MO BOTH
Las Vegas NV BOTH Tampa FL BOTH
Lexington KY DPP Tucson AZ BOTH
Louisville KY DPP Venice FL DPP
Marshalltown IA DPP Wilmington DE (entire state) DPP
DPCA SCHEDULED 2012 MARKETS Albany NY May-Aug Philadelphia PA Jul
Asheville NC May-Aug Plattsburgh, NY May-Aug
Binghamton, NY May-Aug Salem OR Mar
Burlington VT May-Aug Springfield MO May-Aug
Charlotte, NC May-Aug St. Petersburg FL May
Clearwater FL May Stevens Point WI Apr
Cleveland OH Jul Sycamore IL May-Aug
DeLand FL May-Aug Syracuse NY May-Aug
Evansville IN May-Aug Tacoma, WA May-Aug
Itasca MN May-Aug Watertown NY May-Aug
Las Vegas NV Mar Wenatchee WA May-Aug
Marquette MI May-Aug Wichita, KS Jan
Middletown, NY May-Aug
DPCA PENDING MARKETS San Antonio TX TBD 2012
Austin TX TBD 2012
Denver CO TBD 2012-2013
Providence RI (entire state – add DCP) TBD 2013
San Diego CA 2013 Q1
Greensboro NC 2013 Q1
Orange/Ventura Counties CA 2013 Q1
New Orleans LA 2013 Q1
Chicago IL 2013 Q1
Diabetes Prevention and Control Alliance (DPCA)NOT ME Brand
27
DPCA Consumer Brand
Bold and engaging with a strong call-to-action Mindset transition from “It can’t happen to me” to “I won’t let it happen to me” Relevant across full concern / hope / pride spectrum; meets people where they are
28
Employee Communication Tools
Comprehensive view of employee population – demographics, psychographics, lifestyle and behaviors Communication plan for diabetics (DCP)
and prediabetics (DPP) – Direct mail letters – Outbound phone calls by a
DPCA representative – Newsletter articles – Internal communications – Employer campaign kit
Ongoing support for continued maintenance and improvement
DPCA will work with you to reach your members through multiple touch-points to maximize enrollment
29
Sales & Marketing Tools
Proposal template with strong visuals and descriptive tables
Presentation template to customize to your needs
Employer kit tools to ensure successful testing event / health fair / etc.
– Program brochures describing each condition and program success credentials
– Vivid, descriptive and challenging posters that issue calls to action
– Email series to educate members and inform of program or event details
– Newsletter template to provide a comprehensive overview for employer internal communications
A proprietary – and unique – model for diabetes risk identification
Uses the industry’s largest database of medical facts and demographics to provide unparalleled accuracy
OptumInsight Impact Suite Reveals Members Who Need Testing, Enrollment
31
32
What They Don’t Know Can Hurt Them
Why are testing events so critical?
26 million (11.5%) US adult diabetic individuals 1; 7 million (27%) are undiagnosed 79 million (35% )US adult prediabetic individuals1; 67 million (85%) are undiagnosed
and have NO symptoms2
The extra step to “go get tested” is a behavior change barrier that an onsite event could overcome
Traditional “you may be at risk” letters with follow-up phone calls has proven to be ineffective
The cost of waiting is conversion to diabetes
Almost 10% of prediabetic individuals will convert to diabetes annually
Increased average annual medical spend $5,7743 – $3,673 PMPY increase for prediabetes – $9,447 PMPY increase for diabetes with/without complications – The 10 year NPV of an individual converting to type 2
diabetes is $55K
1. American Diabetes Association Source for statistics 2. The Lewin Group 3. UnitedHealthcare 2008 analysis for Diabetes Health Plan for several large employers; Medical only (no Rx)
33
Testing Event Member Benefits
Instant results “Teachable moment” that is hopeful Excellent on the spot enrollment results Most had no idea Some have been told since they were
not diabetic “everything was fine” Most health fairs don’t see prediabetes
as a red flag
Facts about identification and testing: – Results are immediate – Only 1-2% will show up as already diagnosed prediabetic – Approximately 30% of adult members appear in “undiagnosed but at risk” – Over 40% of “at-risk” will test positive for either prediabetes or diabetes – Over 80% of those who test positive will enroll immediately following
the screening event
This is the population we
need to get tested!
Testing Event Member Experience
Member arrives for their appointment at a given time and is checked in by staff from DPCA or Wellness Inc.
Member fills out release forms for Wellness Inc. A1c or Fasting Blood Glucose test is administered
– Test usually takes five minutes for results – Tester hands results to member with no consultation
Member checks out and based on results is either free to leave or is directed to Y table for consultation
– A1c results 5.7 – 6.4 of FBG 100 – 124 = DPP – A1c results 6.5+ or FBG 125+ = DCP
Typical consultation should take 5-10 minutes DPP members will leave feeling “signed up”
for a class while DCP members will leave with doctor referral form
34
35
Event Details Finalized
DPCA Contacts Identified Employees
Additional Participant Employees
Employees Register
STEP WEEK 4 WEEK 5 WEEK 3 WEEK 1 WEEK 2 WEEK 6
SCREENING EVENT
DPCA Screening Event Value of DPCA logistics expertise
Location, date and time established Event data loaded into MYnetico At-risk participants identified
Employers promote event attendance DPCA Supplies the email blast Engagement Specialists begin outbound calls
Participants call to RSVP and ask questions
Fulfillment file loaded and sent to RR Donnelley Participant letters mailed Auto-dialer file prepared and sent
• Event Coordination • Identifying only at Risk participants •Outreach via Mail and Call Center outbound calls •Web link for participants to choose an exact time •DPCA will be onsite during the event to discuss the programs and enroll participants • Call Center to handle incoming calls
DPCA’s Turnkey Testing Event
Solution:
Employees that Test Positive
Enroll
36
DPCA TIMELINE QUICKLY REACHING YOUR AT-RISK EMPLOYEES
Program Confirmed
Benefit Confirmed
Contract Executed
Content Provided
Participants Identified
Participants Entered
Communications Sent
Telephonic Outreach
Client eligibility and claim data collected/sent through DPI process to identify known / at-risk employees
Identified known and at-risk employees loaded into MYnetico
DPCA sends targeted letters to identified employees to begin
Confirm that CPT codes used for DPCA services are covered under client's preventive benefits.
client reviews, signs and returns
documents and member communication samples to client
Client agrees to move forward with DPCA; determines effective date, markets, applicable employee population and chosen programs
DPCA sends administrative
Contract delivered to client;
STEP WEEK 4 WEEK 5 WEEK 3 WEEK 1 WEEK 2 . . .
DPCA call center begins calling campaign to engage identified employees
QUESTIONS?
37