Upload
others
View
3
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Last update 3/15/2016
Judicial Redistricting Proposals
For Discussion by the Judicial Redistricting Commission on April 6, 2016
Proposal 1 – Proposed by Representative Nate McConnell • Create a single-judge 23rd Judicial District by moving Mineral County from the 4th Judicial
District and moving Sanders County and a judge position from the 20th Judicial District. o Lake County would comprise the revised 20th Judicial District with one judge
instead of two. o Missoula County would comprise the revised 4th Judicial District with four judges.
Proposal 2 – Proposed by Senator Kristin Hansen
• Revise four judicial district boundaries. o Move Garfield County to the 10th Judicial District to join Petroleum, Judith Basin,
and Fergus Counties. The 10th Judicial District would remain a single-judge district.
o Move Meagher County from the 14th Judicial District to the 6th Judicial District to join Park and Sweet Grass Counties. The 6th Judicial District would remain a single-judge district.
o Move Treasure and Rosebud Counties to the 14th Judicial District to join Musselshell, Golden Valley, and Wheatland Counties. The 14th Judicial District would remain a single-judge district.
o The 16th Judicial District would be comprised of Custer, Fallon, Powder River, and Carter Counties with one judge instead of two.
• A judge position would be shifted to the 13th Judicial District. Proposal 3 – Proposed by District Court Judge Greg Todd
• Move Broadwater County from the 1st Judicial District to the 14th Judicial District. o Lewis & Clark County would comprise the revised 1st Judicial District with four
judges. o The 14th Judicial District would remain a single-judge district.
Proposal 4 – Proposed by District Court Judge Greg Todd
• Eliminate the 14th Judicial District. o Move Musselshell and Golden Valley Counties to the 10th Judicial District o Move Wheatland and Meagher Counties to the 6th Judicial District o One judge position would be available to shift to another judicial district after
2018.
Over
Last update 3/15/2016
Proposal 5 – Proposed by Representative Nate McConnell • Combine the 6th and 14th Judicial Districts with Carbon and Stillwater Counties from the
22nd Judicial District to create a two-judge district. o Move Big Horn County from the 22nd Judicial District to the existing two-judge
16th Judicial District. o One judge position would be available to shift to another judicial district after
2018. Proposal 6 – Proposed by Representative Nate McConnell
• Revise four judicial district boundaries. o Move Garfield County from the 16th Judicial District and Chouteau County from
the 12th Judicial District to the 10th Judicial District to join Petroleum, Judith Basin, and Fergus Counties. The 10th Judicial District would remain a single-judge district.
o Move Blaine County from the 17th Judicial District to the 12th Judicial District to join Hill and Liberty Counties. The 12th Judicial District would remain single-judge district.
o Combine Phillips and Valley Counties from the 17th Judicial District with Daniels, Sheridan, and Roosevelt Counties from the 15th Judicial District to form a single-judge district.
• One judge position would be available to shift to another judicial district after 2018.
!.
!.
!.
!(
!(
23 (new)
23 (new)
20
4
LAKE
SANDERS
FLATHEAD
MISSOULA
MINERAL
POWELL
LINCOLN
GRANITE
PONDERA
GLACIER
LEWIS & CLARK
RAVALLI
LINCOLN
TETON
Polson
Superior
Missoula
Kalispell
Thompson Falls
Proposal 1
LegendCounty Seats!( Judge Travels!. Judge Location
Main RoadCounty
!(
!(!.
!.
!(
!.
!(
!.
!(
!(
!.
!.
!(
!(
!(
!(
!.
!.
!.
!.
!(
!.
!(
!.
!(
!(
!(
!(
!(
!(
!(
!(
1010
10 10
6
6
6
14
141414
14 16
1616
16
FERGUS
PARK
ROSEBUD
BIG HORN
GARFIELD
CUSTER
CARTER
CHOUTEAUPHILLIPS
MCCONE
VALLEY
DAWSON
GALLATIN
MEAGHER
CARBON
BLAINE
CASCADE
PRAIRIE
POWDER RIVER
FALLON
RICHLAND
YELLOWSTONE
STILLWATER
PETROLEUM
JUDITH BASIN
SWEET GRASS
MUSSELSHELL
WIBAUX
WHEATLAND
TREASURE
ROOSEVELT
GOLDEN VALLEY
HILL
TETON
LIBERTYTOOLE
MADISON
BROADWATER
PONDERA
LEWIS & CLARKTerry
Baker
Circle
Wibaux
Sidney
Jordan
Hysham
Hardin
Winnett
Ryegate
Roundup
Glasgow
Forsyth
Ekalaka
Broadus
Bozeman
Townsend
StanfordGlendive
Columbus
Billings
Red Lodge
Lewistown
Harlowton
Wolf Point
Miles City
LivingstonBig Timber
Great Falls
Fort Benton
White Sulphur Springs
Proposal 2LegendCounty Seats
!( Judge Travels!. Judge Location
Main RoadCounty
!.
!(!.
!(
!.
!.
!.
!(
!(
!(
!.
!(
!.
!.
!.
!(!.
!(
!(
!(
!(
!(
!(
CARBONMADISONBEAVERHEAD
BIGHORN
STILLWATERPARK
GALLATIN
SWEETGRASS
SILVERBOW
DEERLODGE
TREASURE
YELLOWSTONE
JEFFERSON
GOLDENVALLEYWHEATLAND MUSSELSHELL
BROADWATER
ROSEBUD
GRANITE
MEAGHER
JUDITHBASIN
PETROLEUM
POWELL
MISSOULA
CASCADEFERGUS
LEWIS &CLARK
GARFIELD
TETON
CHOUTEAU
PONDERAPONDERA
HILL
BLAINE
LIBERTY
PHILLIPS
FLATHEAD
141414
1414
1
Anaconda
BigTimber
Billings
Boulder
Bozeman
Butte
Columbus
Conrad
DeerLodge
FortBenton
GreatFalls
Harlowton
Helena
Lewistown
Livingston
Roundup
Ryegate
Stanford
Townsend
WhiteSulphurSprings
Winnett
Choteau
Proposal 3
LegendJudge Location!( Judge Travels!. Judge Location
Main RoadCounty
!(
!.
!.!.
!.
!.
!(
!(
!.
!(
!.
!.
!(
!.
!(
!(
!(
!(
!(
10
10
1010
10
6
6
6
6
FERGUS
PARK BIG HORN
CASCADE
MEAGHER
GALLATIN
GARFIELD
CARBON
YELLOWSTONE
STILLWATER
PETROLEUM
JUDITH BASIN
SWEET GRASS
MUSSELSHELL
MADISON
WHEATLAND
ROSEBUD
BROADWATER
CHOUTEAU
GOLDEN VALLEY
TREASURE
PHILLIPSTETON
JEFFERSON
LEWIS & CLARK
VALLEY
Hysham
Hardin
Winnett
Ryegate
Roundup
Bozeman
Townsend
Stanford
Columbus
Billings
Red Lodge
Lewistown
Harlowton
Livingston
Big Timber
Great Falls
White Sulphur Springs
Proposal 4
LegendCounty Seats
!( Judge Travels!. Judge Location
Main RoadCounty
!(
!(!.
!(
!.
!(
!(!(
!.
!(
!(
!.
!.
!(
!(
!.
!.
!(
!(
!.
!.
!(
!(
!.
!.
!.
!.
!(
!.
!(
!(
!.
!(
!(
!(
!(
!(!(
!(
!(
!(
6
6
6
6
6 6
6 616
16
16
16
1616
16
16
Terry
Malta
Baker
Circle
Wibaux
Sidney
Jordan
Hysham
Helena
Hardin
Conrad
Winnett
Ryegate
Roundup
Glasgow
Forsyth
Ekalaka
Broadus
Bozeman
Townsend
Stanford Glendive
Columbus
Billings
Red Lodge
Lewistown
Harlowton
Wolf Point
Miles City
Livingston
Big Timber
Great Falls
Fort Benton
Virginia City
White Sulphur Springs
FERGUS
PARK
ROSEBUD
BIG HORN
GARFIELD
CUSTER
CARTER
VALLEYPHILLIPS
CHOUTEAU
BLAINE
MCCONE
CASCADE DAWSON
GALLATIN
MEAGHER
CARBONMADISON
PRAIRIE
POWDER RIVER
FALLON
RICHLAND
HILL
YELLOWSTONE
ROOSEVELT
STILLWATER
PETROLEUM
JUDITH BASIN
MUSSELSHELL
TETON
WIBAUX
WHEATLAND
TREASURE
BROADWATER
PONDERA
LIBERTY
GOLDEN VALLEY
TOOLE
SWEET GRASS
LEWIS & CLARK
BEAVERHEAD
Proposal 5 LegendCounty Seats!( Judge Travels!. Judge Location
Main RoadCounty
!(
!(!.
!.
!(
!(!(
!.
!(
!.
!(
!(
!.
!.
!(
!(
!.
!(
!(
!.
!.
!.
!.
!.
!(
!.
!(
!(
!.
!(
!(
!(
!(
!(
!(
!(
!(
1010
10
10 10
16 16
1616
16
16
12
1212
1515 15
1515
Terry
Malta
Havre
Baker
Circle
Wibaux
Sidney
Scobey
Jordan
Hysham
Hardin
Winnett
Ryegate
Roundup
Glasgow
Forsyth
Ekalaka
ChinookChester
Broadus
Bozeman
Stanford Glendive
Columbus
Billings
Red Lodge
Lewistown
Harlowton
Wolf Point
Plentywood
Miles City
Livingston
Big Timber
Great Falls
Fort Benton
White Sulphur Springs
VALLEY
HILL
PHILLIPSBLAINE
FERGUS
ROSEBUD
GARFIELD
BIG HORNPARK
CUSTER
CARTER
CHOUTEAU
MCCONE
DAWSON
MEAGHER
PRAIRIE
POWDER RIVER
FALLON
RICHLAND
CARBON
ROOSEVELT
GALLATIN
YELLOWSTONE
LIBERTY
CASCADE
DANIELS
STILLWATER
SHERIDAN
PETROLEUM
JUDITH BASIN
MUSSELSHELL
WIBAUX
WHEATLAND
TREASUREGOLDEN VALLEY
SWEET GRASS
BROADWATER
TETON
PONDERA
MADISON
Proposal 6
LegendCounty Seats!( Judge Travels!. Judge Location
Main RoadCounty