Jose Lomeli-Becerra, A092 122 323 (BIA May 20, 2011)

7/27/2019 Jose Lomeli-Becerra, A092 122 323 (BIA May 20, 2011)

1/9

XAVIER ROSAS, ESQUIRELaw Oices of Elsa Mainez PLC523 6th Street. Suite 633Los Angeles CA 90014

Name: LOMELI-BECERRA JOSE

U.S. epartment o Jutce

Executive Oce r Iiaion Review

Board ofImmigration AppealsOce of the Clerk

/7 leesb1rg Pike. S1ite Fas Chch, Vina

HS/ICE Oice of Chief Conse OS606 S Oive Stree, 8th FoorLos Angeles, CA 90014

A092122323

Date of is notce 5/20/2011

Enclosed is a copy of the Boad's decision and ode in the above-reenced case.

Encosue

Pane Members:Guendelsbege, John

Sinceel

Donna CarChief Cerk

Cite as: Jose Lomeli-Becerra, A092 122 323 (BIA May 20, 2011)


2/9

LOMELIBECEA, JOSE50 THE CI DIVE SOUTH09222323OANGE, CA 92868

Name LOMELIBECEA, JOSE

U.S epartment o utce

Excu Oc aion Rw

Boad ofImmiation AppealsOce ofthe Clek

7 lebu Pke Sue as Chuch nia

HS/ICE Oce of Chef Counse LOS606 S Ove Street, 8th FooLos Angees, CA 9004

A09222-323

Date of ths notice 52020

Enclosed is a copy of the Board's decsion the above-efeenced case. This copy s begpovided o you as a couesy You attorney o epeseatve as bee seed wih hisdecso pusuant o .. 12925(a) f the atached decison orders ha you be emovedfom e Ued Saes o aims an Immigraton Judges decson orderig ha you beremoved, ay peio or revew of te aaced decso mus be iled w ad eceived by heappopiae cout o appeals wh days o he dae o he decsion.

Enclosu

Pan mbs:Gundsbg ohn

D c

Donna CaChf Ck



3/9

epae o JuceExcutive Oc Iigation Rviw

Dcision of Board of Imigaon Appals

Fas Chrch. irginia

Fe: A092 122 323 - Los Angeles, CA

re JOSE LOMEBECEA BOD PROCEEDGS

APPEA

Dat

ON BEHA OF RESPONDENT Xavie oss, Esquire

PPCAON Rdetnation of custody staus

Y Z

his case ws st be ths Bod on by 22, 20, whn we eman the cord to hemmiation Judg t pocdings Th igation Judg eafe hs rvious dcisiondenying te spondnt's rqust r custoy dtination Te miation udge issued amnute order nd no ond mmorndum ws issud sting r t esons r hs ond decisionsinc e mely rafd his prvious cision Te cord wi again b emnde r a newindviuaizd ond heing

he Bo eviews an igration Judg's ndings of ct, incuding ndings s to thecredbiity of tstimony, und the "cly onous stnd 8 CF R 1003 ( d)(3)(i); Me S-H- 23 &N Dc 462, 46465 (BA 2002) (stating tat he Bo must dr to the ctuadetinations of an migation udg in t absce of c o) T Board reviews questionsofaw, disction, and judent d a oter issues in appals om dcisions ofiation udgesde nv 8 CFR 003I(d)(3)(ii)

According to he igita audo rcodg of th bond g on Mach 5, 20, the miationudge concudd that he woud not consir th rspondent's custody deteation requst unesstere was some evidnce that the spondnt ws igbe r som of reief om mova orif e esponnt ws ed r n "gegious pod of time simi to t respondent i CC/n v Dep. melnd Secu 53 3d 942 (9 Cr 2008) W nd no such requirement

or stndd pusunt to th Cou's dcision i C-Cl/n in whic he Nin Circuit hed thatn alin detain in immigration custody wi an appa of a na mova oder is pndg bree Ninth Cicuit is ntitd to a bond eig unde sction 236(a) of the Act

Pursunt to e prcdent auhoity of int Cicuit Cort of Appeas in CC/nder whose jsdiction this cse ss, th espondent is eigib r a heg on the issue of theespondent's suitaiity custody rdtination undr section 236(a) of the Act he Courtconcued in C-Cln that t govnt brs e budn of proving at the respondntis usuitabe rse because is ite a dgr to the communty or a ght rsk See, ege Gue 24 &N Dc 27 (BA 2006) (appropate ctos to consider i deteig therspondnt's suitabiity r eease om custody)



4/9

A09122 32

The record is emanded to the igaton Judge to conduc a dvdalzed cstodyeeteaon heng nder secton 236(a) of the Act.

2Cite as: Jose Lomeli-Becerra, A092 122 323 (BIA May 20, 2011)


5/9

:._)

IT STATS DPE OF TCXC OFFIC R G RV

GTON O SOH OL ST., 15TH F

9004

W OFFI OF TIZ PC

Q53 W U 6OS G 0

N M OI-BEE JOSE

A 0923 DT: Dec 0 010

L! RWD - NO V

COY O DESON O MGRTION J HS lS SS APP IS FIL WI BO O GION PPTHN DAY OF TH ? O T ILING R SON. ! CLOD O UN R PPY PIG U PY NT F PP AHD S, EE OR EE W QMST L : B IGIN S

O O E RKP OX 8S , 24

TTC CO O DECO O TH N JG S T SO O A T PP AT YO SD OA Ol lMV HIT DSO US ON T P I I CCCT 22(} 3) O E ION TOAITY A B U.SCTN ( IN DPTTIN P O ECO 4) 8 S IN RMOV RON F YOU A TN P N S Fit T S T

l O O S H O G7 001.t O rf ( < . . -'

C:

I / -, ACT GTN


6/9

LOMElBC, Joe

ID STAS DPN F USXUV R TIO W

NTD SS IGN ROS S O

Fe No.: 02 122

I he Maer of:

C s

Resode.

}}

OC

RESPNDNTX Ros Eqrew Oces of Elsa Maiez West Sixth St, u 63Lo Angeles Caifi 9014

N BHALF H NT:A Chef uelDpnt o Homeland Seci6 Sou v 8 Floor gles, Caoia 4

C T IMGOND .Staemen ofc

Rd i a f-ghty ma ntive d tizen f Mxco. who admied he Uid e a a WJ peaen ide on o 989 Rnde placd ino mov poedig o b h I r i ,Ci beng sd w Nc o Appe ri TA) g beg ovble om e U S W o IA 237(28i w, m r son hs b v oa ime vg a lled uc dfn n 2 U.SC 02. Je 8, 20 I ra Jud Rendn he ted S. pone apped the deco Bo oImmgAal (ree od upel e C' e o eo o O md po's a

O Oober 9 1 o e Boad dc o em d Repo d to Rv b h U Appe Cu (rea h cu). Repoe culy be hed e cusodyo e Deme H Sc (heea De) Je A. MusikDt acl n Ie Cfa end e ome o etitio w Nu e be e p' uody e Feb .

Z


7/9

0 1

Rone' t o w U.S immigon as n ccou fhs cmal o. o h ufed nmr covico se iigtg

'D

pm

nt ss

eg :

O Decembr J, 200 Po Coo Subtce r Se, violo of C.H&S Cod J r whch e w sentc o 365 das ojl 36 monof pbatn

O Dcember 2 l 200 D_i: uc o AloD, violn oC Veh Ce 315 whh wa o one ay j 6hs o. ,1

g 5, 1999 - u va o C Pe Co 4 r w wteced to m o probaon

See genraly, Bo Exbt #O Novbr 8 2010 Respode col bmid moo r cdy

a hig u Cir ces Po-Rom v. C 5 Fd03 (9 i 208) comon c o v D.HS 55 F 942 (9 r08 beaus pod n e Dp' cody wle h o rew eng be e Ni C

O ovbr 4, 00 pe pped befo mii C LoAgee C. he Resnde sse hs lby on ps o aundr Cas-tJlon d PretoRom a, ddi h sod t bdee e s ie d cmmuty nr a fgh sk d ng amiy s lnhy sdenc i Une Se Te pt sled R"od ib orusto reee i ont oe o bt e at e s h m,gv s cma cod d snct i s e i y eaae to h o e he t ohs NCiutpeio. e deiedReoe'sq r d rao e oon e

Alyi LwT N n wo c, s-atllon. d omo ce Prito

Romo . Clk h ld a p r eew rc co ofpea cv jdl y o moval al s entled o oy dio i o mme. Ito C w ven dcn v e e he Nnt Ciu d e o i w a o e , bt a to or v i g comed by y o i i in he emov peod" de 21a}. e e e s ody isgoved y A 3a nd c) PdoRomero 534 F3 a 0589 S C aslon.5 947. IA 236() gove when t Imign Cour h jusdt ovecn cm b 36c} des ot ppy to oog tos n wc

zd

.


8/9

A

LMB

n atgjudcia eiew o hs iaon cae. T IA 236() ppls da ien tiled to a indivd cusody do n t rton udgeCas-Con. 535 F.3d at 948- At sc cutody i is ove b 1i e n's dnon pndg vJ. ouf Mulacy 5 F3d222 3 35 9 C 008)

J applygCa-Ctrlon it is imptve he holding s itat dic e hodi n C3astilon.alows fr a cutod o sol o waentsidn, who hv ben n h Dm csody fr extnd ped msc sv y or mor, d who drlyi pedig ee t pp b elt c cou d re e Bod onidion. oeein a sondent i ene a d einon de Cas tUon inve cc i s ot Rspondns s

U C.Ctlon, inhch e Respod w hl dno vn de has een n h Den's cd for 10 mon. Bh mmion d he Bod a dudicd hs me n epi d i-n mn, dRe to fr reiewef Nn Cu only een ndng e omo e N rcuit h no da t Rpondn l y mteuse o s the u does n ele Rone nd o ctdytimao accce CsCon.

En hd th Co e t A 36) appled i Resndenf prced Co nd reea o he pos a subsal it isk n cg coco Ch lacd hh o bieves Respondn cat ouhg ik o ju h n keepng n s vlue lc onpea be. IfA 6) w apy, ept b ofuiig o Reo cued detenion g o fr moal. o ndhe Dep jie spndent tn cuse th o fn Rdecrimil co ds hm eiib f eie, d ac levb o - d ofh otcome os tin o -mes hm ct gt rk.

IMater ofGu r1 24l&NDec. 27 (BIA2006), theBod made cleaat, und NA 26(a) a Jd "Ixmly a dt dcing ee t tee aien on Ma Gu ra a 9 Rg n Csn v Ld 42 US (1952)(ldg th denofbail o alien withbe overrled only wher it

s sh "wthou a rsoable uda'} t Bodsatd here sn limiton onth discretionfar ht my considerd bya Imigaton Judgewh lingon cuo bod iseandthe Boprvided exe, but not eauive list of fco to wcha ImgrnJu mayokwen deering whera Respndn m his sto b. Mar o t 39, 40. e a o Merf Sa l ,22l&N Dec. 1258 (BI 2000);Ma of dls,0 & 85 BIA 9) ese ato icld:

A0'


9/9

6 Y

-' -.

091 3 EEE

(I) if aen a xed ddss;(2) aJien lgth si Untd Stes ;

t". I

3 l tes hy ge peant rsen 4) elont htoS) e n s crd appac co6) 's c cod, lun ve y. aos o ac;(7 so of imon ol(8) y tte by 'o e roecton (9 mr e o Untd Ss" M ofGr 40

Adoy. "[t]h Ig g my oos o gv et o o fo ov

lg a th decision a" M oGu at 4 mps adedT t Jdge ond o nne wen deid

dey n Spefcly mon Jg os Iss of endenmlor Supo 9 C e Cu lso cnsded eesf , xd drs ad emmt so

A in fac9r. den ae ofdson a

eonn o uba ik Rspondn s wros o u of kg conod bs efd 21 SC 802, m Rpelo n o favailabl o lck of vlbe fonns C Ron i a ia fht ri ad he Den a o s k m cuody I f o eee t Rsonde h lo o n o

y f s o xo oa o oe gv sev o on aos oh dg o.

A, owi odwll be n:

Rod equst o e Dpn' o s DEE

D:

RF OF RV THl CUMENWASERVDBY : ,\1r'AIL(M) I J PERSONAL SERVC: I ) o o l rs/ (HDAT } l SYCOURSTAFAchments.( )EOIR-3 ( ] EOIR-28 Lgl i ( Othr

Documents

Jose Lomeli-Becerra, A092 122 323 (BIA May 20, 2011)