Jose Cristian Argueta-Martinez, A200 117 964 (BIA Mar. 14, 2014)

8/12/2019 Jose Cristian Argueta-Martinez, A200 117 964 (BIA Mar. 14, 2014)

1/9

Godberg JieGodbeg ssociaes314 Wes 23st Sree, Suite 447ronx, NY 0463

U.S. eartmet of tce

Executive Ofce r Iigraon Reiew

ad Immiai AppealOe he Cek

5 J 07 lesb1rg Pike, Suit 2000Fa Churc Vrginia 2050

S/ICE Oice o Chie Consel O26 Nooint Dre Suie 2020oson X 706

Nae RGUETMRINZ JOSE CR . A 20-7-964

Date o his oice 3/14/24

nclosed s copy of the Boad's decision and oder in the aboe-reenced case.

nclosure

Sinceely,

D cDonna Ca

Chie Cek

For more unpublished BIA decisions, visit www.irac.net/unpublished

Cite as: Jose Cristian Argueta-Martinez, A200 117 964 (BIA Mar. 14, 2014)


2/9

ARGUETAMARTINZ, JOSE CRSTANA200794BOWARD ANSIONAL CN3900 NOTH POWEN OADOMANO BAC FL 33073

Name: ARGEAARTINEZ OSE CR..

U.S eatmet of tce

xecue Oce Immgti eiew

ad Immga AppeaOe e Cle

5 J 07Lsbug Pik. Su 2000 Crch rg

2050

HSIC Oice of Chie Counsel O2 Nohpoint Drve Ste 2020Houston X 7700

A 2001794

ate o this notce: 3/4204

cse is a c f he Bs ecisin in the ererece case This c s beige as ctes Y te reesentae has been see t ecsn usuat 8 CF 1292() I he che ecis es h beeme the Une Stes r as ig Jges ecis erg ha e ree etin r eew he ache ecisn st be le wih ecee e arae cut f eals whin 30 s f he e e ecis

ncsure

Sncere

D cDna CrCef Cer

yg



3/9

US of i Decso of e Bod o mgt Appeal. Exec'tive Oce r Immiaon Revew

Fls Chuh, Vg 00

Fle: A00 17 964 - Hoson, X

n re JSE CSTA ARGTAMARINEZ

I EMVAL POCDNGS

AEA AD MOO

Date

ON BEHAL F RESPODENT uie Goldbeg Esqre

PICAI Reopeng

e esponden, a native d ctizen of E Savado, apals the ecson of he mmaonuge, me ecember 1 en his moon o reopen he responent has also eda motn o rmd.

Due o e respodent's cms of neecte assstanc of counsel, w conclude ha herecod shold be eanded o he Imgraion Judge r her consderaon of hs cams oeoenng Se Maer ofLozda, 19 I& Dec 637 (BIA 98 8) In arcua, upon reman, heImigraion d sould he cnsider whee the esponnt has now estabishe arscisson of the asenta ore o emov, enteed o Deceber 1 200 is waaned onaccont of ack of notice, heth he ha now estabishe tha cange count contons in Salvadr want eopening ore to allo hm o prse a Appcato Asm an r

Witoldin o Removal (o 589), d whether he has now etbished at sua sontereopnn is waated Se sections 0)(5)(C)(i), (c)(7)()(i) of te mgraion andNatonat Act, 8 U.SC 129a(b)(5)(C)() (c)(7)(C)(); aer ofJJ 1 &N Dec 97(BIA 997) Whe e conclude hat he espondet has esabishd ha the migaton geshod have a aiona opporun o consd his claims o eopening, we epress no opnonregarding he unelng meits of hs clams to eopenig at he presnt m e lngoe s enteed

ORDER The respondet's moton o remnd s grned an he record s reaned o heImmraton Judge r frher conseraon of he esponent's moton to ropen and te ntof a ne decisio

e esont eais suject t e orer of reoval whc as eneed absetia b eIiaton de on Decemer 4, 2005 Howeve, as the respoent ha presente a cla toreoenng on he bais of lac of notc, hs roval shal be saed pendng dispositon of the

moon b the Immgation Jdge Secon 24(b)(5)(C) of the Ac



4/9

NITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF USTICEEXECTIE OFFICE FOR IMMIGRATION REVIEW

IMMIGTION COURT600 EFFERSON, SUITE 900

Garcia & Qayum Law Group, P.AGrcia Kenia3191 Coral Way Sute 601Coa Gbes F 345

HOUSTON TX 77002

E E -964Z JOS

BLE TO FORWR - O DDESS POIDED

: 13,

TTCHED IS COPY OF THE DECISION OF TE IMIGTION UDGE HIS DECISONIS L L S LED TH E O O GO ESIN 3 CLE D E E OF TH NG OF I W E YU A A V QM B MD BD MM

' CK Pik ut FLS CHH 050

TTCHED IS A COP OF THE DECISION OF THE IMIGRTION DGE AS THE RESULTOF U FAILUE TO PPEA AT OR SCHEDULED DEPORTTION OR REO HERIGTHIS DECISION IS FINAL NLESS MOTION TO REOPEN IS FILED IN ACCORDCEWITH SECTION 242(c) (3) OF THE IMMIGTION D NATIONAL IT ACT 8 USCSECTIO 125B(c) (3) IN DEPORTATION PROCEEDIGS OR SECTION 40(c) (6)8 .. SECTION 229a(c) {6) IN EMOL PROCEEDINGS IF OU FILE MOTIONTO EOPEN, OU MOTION MUST E FILED WITH THI COURT:

ER-1

IMMIGRATION COURT600 EFFERSON SITE 900HOUSTON TX 7700

IIGATION COURTCC ES E NING A.CC

6 NORTHPOINT D ROOM 20HOUSTON TX, 7060000

FF


5/9

\J

UNITED STATS DEPARMNT OF JUSTICEECUIVE OFFCE OR IMMGATION EVW

MMAIO COURT

HUSTON, EXS

e ae

e GUE EZ

APPON M

B PKe aa sqcia & Qay La r 9 Cra ay Se 6ral abes rda 5

6

O DS: a sDee ead Secriy26 Nh Dre# 22s exas 776

ORERS MOTON

edg bere Crt is espdes Mi epe le Neer 7, 23esde, hgh csel aks he C ree hs real prcedigs r lack f ic esci is in bset real rder he Depe Heland Secriy DS r ee) le a iy psii esde ed a iey resse. Fr he reasssaed bel he Curt eies espes reqess

actua roceura Histor

espe s a ae d ce l Sad ee xh He e i e UedSaes i beig aded r ple by a iga cer r ab Ocber 2 5I. On ha dae Brder Parl areheed espde d persly seed hi a Nce pe chargg h as rale der sec 212a6))i f he Igaia Naialiy c IN r he c) ; see xh 2 The NT icaed a t dae d ief hs hearg ld be se by the Crt ee xh Respde as ried h ral icei he Saish agage he cseqeces f lig ae r is ia heing adas ased f s bligai pride a al adress r cge f aress a eleheber E 2


6/9

_A 00-7964

On Ocbe 3 2005 e Cu aled a earing nce Respndens eed ddeia egu a advisng h is Deceme 2005 heig dae. See Noce f Heaing n

Removal Prceedings (Oc 26 2005) espode ed apea a hs scheded eang das deed eved o l Savado in absenta. ee Ode e Imgran Jdge (Dec 4,005) n ovee 7 2013 Resnden led a Moo Repen w e , gung ac nice in e alenave eqesing sua pone eie. See Resnde's ion o Repend Say erain (N 203). Fo e easos saed elow e enesesden eess

n :) en 0 as ae he de o e e ev i e a e aa as xceal csnces; o ( an ee ed a ay e e e ses a ey id eeve e cce a ) aen densaes pp thrug uJ 5; F 4 i i e j 8 F l 032b)(4i. n

Whn aie fas o ae a eva ceeings wch nce f e eg asserved by l n n abena de may l be eneed ee e aie has eceved, c ecarged h eceivng e chgng dcen nmng e aen o e say addessgains asscaed eval pceedings and f e cnseqeces ilg pvide a

cren adess, pusuan o seco 239(a))(F) e Ac. ee Mater of G-Y-, 23 I& ec.8 BIA 2001) esn o ecep e eing nice s eker whe e docmen ssen y egula ma nsead o ceied al aer o-RA, 24 & ec 665 BA 2008

ee akojya Goale 32 3d 58 590 5h C 2005 Facos eigng v ovecng he weak pesn f delvery incde e vs adavi afdavs e dvdas kwedgeabe abou e eevan cs, e vas acins n eang e eval de any po appcai eie indcang an inceve e mva oape and ny p aendce a heaings. aer oM--- 24 & ec a 64

Al nnUS cizens esen in e Uned Saes e nde an igain i eAoey Genea he addess a wic ey can e caced, ad updae he addess hn

en das ay cage esdence. ee A 265(a 8 CR 2651 The egulains saea ile le sch change o addess cld esl in a ne of ealies, icdg nessen and ssily, reva e ed Saes See A 66) n eeova ode sd be evked e e ale dd no eceve aca nce ecase enegeced hs bligan pvde e imigan cou wh s ce aing addess eeomezPaaco Hoder 560 3d 35, 360 (5 C 20) ndg ha ie eceveaca nce f emva eangs de o esndes egec f s gan ee he apased of s cen alg addess did no mea he ale "dd o eceve noce puses seci 240 )ii

-2-


7/9

A 0017964

)

aien may also le a motion o eopen hat s based on changed couny coditosn acompanied by an appiato r asylm under section 208 o e Ac witon oreoval nder seton 4(b)(3) of the A, or wthholdin of removal uner the ConentoAgains Torure NA 40(c)(7)(C)(i); 8 C.F. 100323(b)(4)(). Tere s no tie limit o

sch a oion. . Chane ontry contons r the prposes o ths secon are dened as"conions arisig in he coy of aonaliy or he cor o wc reoa s beeordered, suc eence is ateria and was not avalabe an od no ae been isoereo presete at e peos proceegs 8 CF. 10032(b)(4)() Such a oton s notsje to e me o umea to eie ner son 00(b)J. ofJG, 2 &N 16, 9 (B 203) He on t e ct e ea .b T t a epen ate o sreo a e Co a a moto o eopen eve the movng pay aseabed a r ce cs

- L

c exetoa msan we the oa o he aes s osdee. oo oReopen. Te Co nds that sh a moton s mebared. esponens oer of eoal wasisse on Deember 14, 2005 and s moto o reopen was led alos eigt years later. TeCort, therere, ns espondes moon o be nmey INA 40(b)(5)(C) 8 CF.R.100 .23(b)(4)(i)

B. N

Responent arges at e was no gien proper noice o s reoval proeeingbease he did no reee the Note o Heang maile o hm by e Cour Moton toReopen. e opines that his was because the unit nber was le out of is adress on e NT A, and rer arges that wt he amount o docens wih whch esonents n simiarsituaons ae seve upon release an he me ey are ven o sign an ove on, t nlkeyResponen was aored n opporunity or encourage to ceck te work o he Deprent raccuacy. esponent's esponse to e Depaent's Oppostion to Responents Moion toReopen (Dec. 4 2013)

An a oder ay be entere wen e alen has receved, or an e cage whreeving, he hang ocue inmng te alen of he satoy aress oblgaonsasoae remoa proceegs a he onseuenes o ng to proie a curentaddress pursuat to secon 239(a)()(F) o he Act. a G-YR 23 I&N Dec 181(BIA 2001) n hs ase Responen was personally seved with e NTA, as evidence by hissgnare d ngerin. Ex 1 e was provided ora noie in te Spanish anuage at

theme nd pae of hs hearng wold be se by the Co and o te consequences of ailure toapper . e reor ndicaes tha he wa also nforme of is obligation o in e Cour

-3-


8/9

A 20964

of ay cage rss so at h Cot cou oti m of ay egs o cgs ete Se x 2 Tese dals e lso cdd i wn on t NA See Ex

Respoe oud hae cecked teNTA accac at n time. H ew e hd aogo o ese e Co a ld adess o e d was aso o te iporco apeig is ai e so, e aie os eit years o noi Co of iace ess s a es e Cou s t Respodet's r to no t Cou o

vad dess s o eect on eer he reciv poper otce of is mro pocedns GomzPalcis v Hdr, 56 d 360. s espon ec oe o then o A 239{; GY- 23 & 89

C

Roe ses at e ow ia eiie o p A Wog ofeoa lg Remoa sa o sT e ws ke i a or l 2012 H a u c n k t Rsp

poen s nd vdnce y s ec acte yh codtos lvaor e has sbie o eec te codions n El Sldovech ee FR 02(b)4( her e d o sumt a apicao rrlif a te te to o so is o IA 2(c(C)i) s a rst te Cor ns aResoes c does o w t open ed o cg cout conos

V i

he Co s dscreton de ts pont oiy to ope n cas n wc teo hs d ecsio, uss jsdito i t cs is est i Bo. ee 8 C. 0 2b spe auhoiy s o b invokd spang, o s g y asps cetd y rcent o e ube Jms n th moos' regtons us extaori remey eeved y co sitions. M GD 22 &Dc. 2 1134 BIA 9) o pe a m chge t w, ot mrely nceel delen wol qli excptol suatio t merts t use of ot ory 15 It s soets e to ed e C tha s

crcscs e tu cet e en at 3; M Becrd 22I& De 12 6 18 BA 200)

he os dcso n e XGW 2 &N ec 71 BI s he onycoolln cae tt lusraes the y o siuato i whch su spne acon is arorate SGD- I&N ec a 5 I a case, asylsees moo o reop was ted whe

t Bo excpiol crcstaes d o a namenl cng t o frge" brog bou y e Ieg gatio Re d Immgrat ResposyAct o996 See W 22 I&N a 71 Swepin cas to th maio lws were

-4-


9/9

A 2017964

enated onl ur onts aer te oard dsmssed he repondents appeal Id at 7 Terespondent's moton to reopen was led e monts later Id

espondents stuaton s not as omelg as te one resented n XW e argesat e dd not attend s mmaton hearng beause e d no reee te Notce o Hearngmaed to m b te Court S oton to Reopen Te Cot nds howeer tat he dd notreee ts ote beause e gnore s ogato to keep te Co aprased o a admalng adress e Court also notes tat esondent led o not the Court o s hange nadress e he moe o Floda

Resdent argus that he arants u ee euse e s retg to soe o v year old Unite Ss ciz w eed o h b d Rp. We s y s arsp ts s oeetoa ards; any dometed grats wo hae resded te Uted tates r log as Respondet ae a Ute es ze Fe, ay ats ro

aador the oee ta otr Resde has ot ade s o are o y h wol e h ane me eetoal ost or rs o a wh h b d v. WH C l , m ' gr r aws a x"

e Cogess asses as and agees romugate rules as dreted y tse lastese ats are meat t ae rea and subsatal eet M f JJ- 2 I&N De 97 984IA 997). ese rles are eant to rng al to mmgraton proeedngs ad to redress theproem o abuses resultng om he ng o sesse or olous motons Id S reopeng s t met to sere as a genera ure r lng dets or to otese rmen te

reguatons were erng em ght reslt ardsp d It would e napprorate r tsCour to expanse emo ts s st autorty a maner that otraened te tentono Coness or led to ge eet to te omrehense reguatory strcture n t estsS GD- 22 I&N De at 3334

Based upon the regong the llowng sal e entered:

ORDER

I IS E OERED tat espondets Moton to eopen e EID

-5-

Documents

Jose Cristian Argueta-Martinez, A200 117 964 (BIA Mar. 14, 2014)