60
Does my Bus look big in this? Keynote Session Martin Fowler and Jim Webber

JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

Does my Bus look big in this?Keynote Session

Martin Fowler and Jim Webber

Page 2: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

Integration: A Retrospective(Save Ferris)

Page 3: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

Back in the day

Page 4: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

Application silos were normal

Page 5: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

Some smart people spotted a niche

Page 6: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

And they built integration software

Page 7: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

And it sort of worked

Page 8: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

And silos were bridged(and yes, it was that ugly)

Page 9: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

Over the years

Page 10: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

Competitors came along

Page 11: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

Integration experts grew powerful

Page 12: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

And integration software grew…

Page 13: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

… the wrong way

Page 14: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

On a rich diet

BPM

GUI Tools

Transformations

Security

Reliability

Rules Engine

Low Latency

Adapters

Reliability

Page 15: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

And more silos were bridged(it doesn’t get any prettier)

Page 16: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

SOA to the rescue!

Page 17: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

Same Old Architecture?

BPM Services

Business Service

Business Service

Business Service

Basic Service

Basic Service

Basic Service

Basic Service

Basic Service

Page 18: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

Same old atrocity

Accounting Marketing

SupportProduct Development

Page 19: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

ESB – Enterprise Service Bus? Or…

BPM Service

Business Service

Business Service

Business Service

ESB

Basic Service

Basic Service

Basic Service

Basic Service

Basic Service

Page 20: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

ESB - Erroneous Spaghetti Box?

Enterprise Service Bus

Page 21: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

Architectural Fantasy

Page 22: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

Ungovernable

Page 23: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

Doesn’t Scale

Page 24: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

Big SOA gets political

Your cunning co-worker

You and your boss

Page 25: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

Mainstream SOA Today

++++

Page 26: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

But resistance is not futile

Page 27: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

Agility(Meanwhile, back in Gotham City...)

Page 28: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

The beauty of traditional process

Page 29: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

Time for a group hug!

Page 30: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

We got tools and techniques...

Page 31: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

Learning to grow, incrementally

Page 32: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

Frameworks got better at agile too

Page 33: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

T’Interweb(Surprisingly isn’t just great big Rails app)

Page 34: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

Why the Web was inevitable...

Tim Berners-Lee is a physicist

(Sir Tim is also a knight, but that’s not important right now)

Page 35: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

Why the Web was inevitable...

He lived in a hole in the ground

Underneath a big mountain

Page 36: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

Why the Web was inevitable...

And because he was a physicist (and not yet a knight)...

...he only had a big atom-smashing thing for company

Page 37: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

Why the Web was inevitable...

And for a lonesome physicist stuck underground with smashed up atoms for company...

...gopher just wasn’t going to cut it!

Page 38: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

The Web broke the rules

Page 39: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

The Web is protocol-centric

Page 40: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

Dumb network, good idea!

Page 41: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

Innovation at the edges, heavy lifting in the cloud

Page 42: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

It has a serendipitous architecture

Page 43: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

La lucha continua!(Guerrilla SOA, slight return)

Page 44: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

Traditional SOA

Them

Us

Page 45: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

Guerrilla SOA

Page 46: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

Service Infrastructure (Endpointware)

Services Host Business Processes

Page 47: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

Business people own those processes

Page 48: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

Business folks own services

Service Infrastructure (Endpointware)

Page 49: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

Prioritise and deliver incrementally

Page 50: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

Then re-prioritise and keep delivering

Page 51: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

Web-based Services(The browser is your granddad’s Web)

Page 52: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

The Web is middleware

Page 53: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

Ubiquitous on-ramp

Page 54: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

Incremental

Page 55: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

Low risk

Page 56: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

Middleware optional

Page 57: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

We still don’t like ESBs(with one or two exceptions)

Page 58: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

Proxy server is your ESB

Service Service Service Service

Big, Big Proxy Server

Service Service Service Service Service

Page 59: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

A brilliant flash of hindsight

•Proprietary middleware

–BUFD

–Lengthy death-marches

–Expensive

–Risky

•Web-centric techniques

–Evolutionary design

–Constant delivery

–Inexpensive

–Incremental

–Enterprise scale

–Specialised

–Integration separate activity

–Not very sensible

–Internet scale

–Commoditised

–Integration by-product of delivering business value

–Quite sensible

Page 60: JimWebber MartinFowler Does my Bus look big in thisxjaoo.dk/dl/...MartinFowler_DoesMyBusLookBigInThis.pdf · Martin Fowler and Jim Webber. Integration: A Retrospective (Save Ferris)

Martin Fowlerhttp://martinfowler.com

Jim Webberhttp://jim.webber.name