Upload
glenna
View
93
Download
0
Tags:
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
J.C. Penney. Riley Coy Chris Wahl Jon Lambert. Agenda. Recommendation Industry Analysis Capital Analysis Financial Statement Analysis. New Pricing Strategy. Distinguish company More loyal, frequent customers “Everyday low prices” Apparel is 57% of Sales. Renovations. - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Citation preview
The Future of OilMike Lee, Roy Ju, Christine Chen, Jon Stein
Introduction• Recommendation• Industry Analysis
• Price Increase Drives• Additional Considerations
• Rise of Natural Gas• Interest Rate Impact
• Company Analysis• Strategies• Financial Ratios• Valuation and Projection
• Conclusion
Recommendation• Invest in ConocoPhillips
• Industry Analysis: Future Oil Price Increase• Favorable Company Analysis• Favorable Ratio Analysis• Relatively High NPV and Intrinsic Value Analysis
Industry Analysis: Price Increase Drivers• Spike Potential
• Geopolitical Turmoil• Natural Disasters• War• Depletion of Low-Cost Crude Oil Sources
• Weakening U.S. dollar• Emerging Markets Surge• Saudi Arabia
Industry Analysis: Additional Considerations • Sustainability
• Political Risk• Government restrictions in favor of environmentally friend sources
• Growth in Alternative Energy Sources• Nuclear Power• Wind Power• Solar Power
• Technological Improvements• Increase industry margins increase market supply• Pushes prices down• Expedite rise of natural gas
Industry Analysis: Additional Considerations • Rise of natural gas
• 3 themes in historical energy consumption• Regular energy transition• Diversification of fuel sources• De-carbonization as time passes
• Trend• Dominance for 50-80 years• Surpass oil as soon as 2030
Industry Analysis: Additional Considerations• Impact on CP and AR
• Comparable business mix• Extremely strong correlation between natural gas and oil prices
Crude Oil Natural Gas
Industry Analysis: Additional Considerations• Interest Rates
• Offsetting impacts on crude oil prices• Increase in rates
• Increase cost, driving down demand• Stronger U.S. dollar applies upward pressure on prices
• Minimal impact on oil
Company Analysis• CP
• First mover• High margins• Efficient operations• Intent to finish active projects• Shorter asset life cycles-capital flexibility
Company Analysis• AR
• Cutting production – higher break-even point• Reliance on fracking• Idle capacity• Recent downsizing
Ratio Analysis
Value Factor Desired Value Company Mean Range Acceptable/Poor/BadDebt to Assets < 1.10 Antero 33.81 16.21 Bad
ConocoPhillips 17.05 7.16 PoorCurrent Ratio > 1.5 Antero 0.87 0.85 Poor
ConocoPhillips 1.13 0.48 AcceptableEarnings per Share Consistent Antero 2.57 5.29 Acceptable
ConocoPhillips 3.56 20.20 BadPrice to Earnings < 9 Antero 50.04 3.86 Bad
ConocoPhillips 11.21 10.65 PoorPrice to Book < 1.2 Antero 2.71 3.54 Bad
ConocoPhillips 1.48 0.44 Poor
Regression Analysis• High correlations between oil prices and GDP, consumption, and production
• Utilized regression coefficient to predict future oil prices
Sensitivity Analysis
Probability of a Large Price Change
Model Assumptions• Projected Revenue
• Oil Prices• Natural Gas Price
• Growth Assumptions• ConocoPhillips – 4%• Antero- Initially massive, regression toward the mean
Model Assumptions• Price elasticity of demand -0.2• Terminal Growth is 4%
Commodity Prices Per Share Intrinsic Value
Oil Natural Gas CP AR
Optimistic $359.26 $51.42 $1,125.51 $347.77
Semi-Optimistic $233.35 $30.59 $613.47 $240.38
Base $118.29 $11.53 $145.23 $13.10
Semi-Pessimistic $61.45 $10.18 $(0.08) $(304.45)
Pessimistic $33.78 $5.60 $(112.67) $(3,372.07)
Optimistic Semi-Optimistic Base Semi-Pessimistic Pessimistic
$(200.00)
$-
$200.00
$400.00
$600.00
$800.00
$1,000.00
$1,200.00
Intrinsic Value of ConocoPhillips
Oil Natural Gas COP
Optimistic $359.26 $51.42 $1,125.51
Semi-Optimistic $233.35 $30.59 $613.47
Base $118.29 $11.53 $145.23
Semi-Pessimistic $61.45 $10.18 ($0.08)
Pessimistic $33.78 $5.60 ($112.67)
Optimistic Semi-Optimistic Base Semi-Pessimistic Pessimistic
$(4,000.00)
$(3,500.00)
$(3,000.00)
$(2,500.00)
$(2,000.00)
$(1,500.00)
$(1,000.00)
$(500.00)
$-
$500.00
$1,000.00
Intrinsic Value of Antero Resources
Oil Natural Gas AROptimistic $359.26 $51.42 $347.77 Semi-Optimistic $233.35 $30.59 $240.38 Base $118.29 $11.53 $13.10 Semi-Pessimistic $61.45 $10.18 ($304.45)Pessimistic $33.78 $5.60 ($3,372.07)
Model Shortcomings• Extreme Intrinsic Value
• Price elasticity of demand increases at higher prices• Managers slow growth when prices fall
Qualitative Analysis• ConocoPhillips
• Established• Slow growth-mature firm• Dividend
• Antero Resources• Young firm• Obsessed with growth
Conclusion• CP has favorable long-term viability• Crude oil price recovery will enhance company performance