35
Introduction to Judicial Review and Case Law Update 11 th December 2014 Jonathan Butler - Geldards Trevor Griffiths - Sharpe Pritchard Andrew Hogan - Ropewalk Chambers

Introduction to Judicial Review and Case Law Update 11 th December 2014 Jonathan Butler - Geldards Trevor Griffiths - Sharpe Pritchard Andrew Hogan - Ropewalk

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Introduction to Judicial Review and Case Law Update 11 th December 2014 Jonathan Butler - Geldards Trevor Griffiths - Sharpe Pritchard Andrew Hogan - Ropewalk

Introduction to Judicial Review and Case Law Update11th December 2014

Jonathan Butler - Geldards

Trevor Griffiths - Sharpe Pritchard

Andrew Hogan - Ropewalk Chambers

Page 2: Introduction to Judicial Review and Case Law Update 11 th December 2014 Jonathan Butler - Geldards Trevor Griffiths - Sharpe Pritchard Andrew Hogan - Ropewalk

www.emlawshare.co.uk

Introduction

Jonathan Butler, Partner, Geldards LLP

Tel: +44 (0)1332 378321

Email: [email protected]

Page 3: Introduction to Judicial Review and Case Law Update 11 th December 2014 Jonathan Butler - Geldards Trevor Griffiths - Sharpe Pritchard Andrew Hogan - Ropewalk

www.emlawshare.co.uk

A Practical Guide to Judicial ReviewTrevor Griffiths – Sharpe Prichard LLP

Page 4: Introduction to Judicial Review and Case Law Update 11 th December 2014 Jonathan Butler - Geldards Trevor Griffiths - Sharpe Pritchard Andrew Hogan - Ropewalk
Page 5: Introduction to Judicial Review and Case Law Update 11 th December 2014 Jonathan Butler - Geldards Trevor Griffiths - Sharpe Pritchard Andrew Hogan - Ropewalk

www.emlawshare.co.uk

Judicial Review

• Public nature• Orders• Procedure last resort/Alternative remedy• Time limit 3 months/6 weeks promptly• 2 Stage – Permission/substantive

Page 6: Introduction to Judicial Review and Case Law Update 11 th December 2014 Jonathan Butler - Geldards Trevor Griffiths - Sharpe Pritchard Andrew Hogan - Ropewalk

www.emlawshare.co.uk

Protocol

• History• Code good practice – Generally used• Limitation – Time Limit/Functus• Sanctions

Page 7: Introduction to Judicial Review and Case Law Update 11 th December 2014 Jonathan Butler - Geldards Trevor Griffiths - Sharpe Pritchard Andrew Hogan - Ropewalk

www.emlawshare.co.uk

Letter- Claimant/Annex A

• Defendant• Claimant• Basis Claim/Details• Action to be taken• Legal Advisers• Interested Parties• Information/Documents/Disclosure• Service details• Reply date

Page 8: Introduction to Judicial Review and Case Law Update 11 th December 2014 Jonathan Butler - Geldards Trevor Griffiths - Sharpe Pritchard Andrew Hogan - Ropewalk

www.emlawshare.co.uk

Letter – Defendant/Annex B

• Details of matter challenged/Response• Other Interested Parties• Service details

Page 9: Introduction to Judicial Review and Case Law Update 11 th December 2014 Jonathan Butler - Geldards Trevor Griffiths - Sharpe Pritchard Andrew Hogan - Ropewalk

www.emlawshare.co.uk

Urgent Applications

• Form N463• Paper consideration• Urgency• Directions on paper

Page 10: Introduction to Judicial Review and Case Law Update 11 th December 2014 Jonathan Butler - Geldards Trevor Griffiths - Sharpe Pritchard Andrew Hogan - Ropewalk

www.emlawshare.co.uk

Claim Form

• Form N461• Service 7 days after issue• Administrative Court/Venue/Regions

Page 11: Introduction to Judicial Review and Case Law Update 11 th December 2014 Jonathan Butler - Geldards Trevor Griffiths - Sharpe Pritchard Andrew Hogan - Ropewalk

www.emlawshare.co.uk

Planning Court

• Practice Direction 54E• Significant cases• Listing

Page 12: Introduction to Judicial Review and Case Law Update 11 th December 2014 Jonathan Butler - Geldards Trevor Griffiths - Sharpe Pritchard Andrew Hogan - Ropewalk

www.emlawshare.co.uk

Acknowledgment

• Form N462 – 21 Days• Summary/Outline grounds• Sanction in not filing• Reply

Page 13: Introduction to Judicial Review and Case Law Update 11 th December 2014 Jonathan Butler - Geldards Trevor Griffiths - Sharpe Pritchard Andrew Hogan - Ropewalk

www.emlawshare.co.uk

Permission

• Order/Paper• Costs of Acknowledgment• Oral Hearing• Order 54(12) 7 CPR

Page 14: Introduction to Judicial Review and Case Law Update 11 th December 2014 Jonathan Butler - Geldards Trevor Griffiths - Sharpe Pritchard Andrew Hogan - Ropewalk

www.emlawshare.co.uk

Defence

• Detailed grounds/Evidence• Service 35 days• Reply• Disclosure

Page 15: Introduction to Judicial Review and Case Law Update 11 th December 2014 Jonathan Butler - Geldards Trevor Griffiths - Sharpe Pritchard Andrew Hogan - Ropewalk

www.emlawshare.co.uk

Hearing

• Skeleton• Bundle• Hearing/Attendance• Listing• Judgments

Page 16: Introduction to Judicial Review and Case Law Update 11 th December 2014 Jonathan Butler - Geldards Trevor Griffiths - Sharpe Pritchard Andrew Hogan - Ropewalk

www.emlawshare.co.uk

Costs

• Summary Assessment• In-house recovery

Page 17: Introduction to Judicial Review and Case Law Update 11 th December 2014 Jonathan Butler - Geldards Trevor Griffiths - Sharpe Pritchard Andrew Hogan - Ropewalk

www.emlawshare.co.uk

Protective Costs Orders

• Corner House Research• Compton/Buglife• Environmental/Aarhus• CPR 45.44 CPR• Bahta – v – Secretary of State• M – v – Croydon

Page 18: Introduction to Judicial Review and Case Law Update 11 th December 2014 Jonathan Butler - Geldards Trevor Griffiths - Sharpe Pritchard Andrew Hogan - Ropewalk

www.emlawshare.co.uk

Appeal

• Renewal/Permission 7 days• Substantive 14 days• Extensions

Page 19: Introduction to Judicial Review and Case Law Update 11 th December 2014 Jonathan Butler - Geldards Trevor Griffiths - Sharpe Pritchard Andrew Hogan - Ropewalk

www.emlawshare.co.uk

Criminal

• Divisional Court/Single Judge• Limited Appeal/Renewal

Page 20: Introduction to Judicial Review and Case Law Update 11 th December 2014 Jonathan Butler - Geldards Trevor Griffiths - Sharpe Pritchard Andrew Hogan - Ropewalk

www.emlawshare.co.uk

Contact

Trevor Griffiths, Partner, Sharpe Pritchard LLP

Tel: +44(0)20 7405 4600

Email: [email protected]

Page 21: Introduction to Judicial Review and Case Law Update 11 th December 2014 Jonathan Butler - Geldards Trevor Griffiths - Sharpe Pritchard Andrew Hogan - Ropewalk

www.emlawshare.co.uk

Refreshments & Break

Page 22: Introduction to Judicial Review and Case Law Update 11 th December 2014 Jonathan Butler - Geldards Trevor Griffiths - Sharpe Pritchard Andrew Hogan - Ropewalk

A Year in Judicial Review 2014

Andrew Hogan, Ropewalk Chambers

Page 23: Introduction to Judicial Review and Case Law Update 11 th December 2014 Jonathan Butler - Geldards Trevor Griffiths - Sharpe Pritchard Andrew Hogan - Ropewalk

www.emlawshare.co.uk

PD Peach

Page 24: Introduction to Judicial Review and Case Law Update 11 th December 2014 Jonathan Butler - Geldards Trevor Griffiths - Sharpe Pritchard Andrew Hogan - Ropewalk

www.emlawshare.co.uk

More interesting than PI

Page 25: Introduction to Judicial Review and Case Law Update 11 th December 2014 Jonathan Butler - Geldards Trevor Griffiths - Sharpe Pritchard Andrew Hogan - Ropewalk

www.emlawshare.co.uk

Let Us Go Forward Together

Page 26: Introduction to Judicial Review and Case Law Update 11 th December 2014 Jonathan Butler - Geldards Trevor Griffiths - Sharpe Pritchard Andrew Hogan - Ropewalk

www.emlawshare.co.uk

Parole

Page 27: Introduction to Judicial Review and Case Law Update 11 th December 2014 Jonathan Butler - Geldards Trevor Griffiths - Sharpe Pritchard Andrew Hogan - Ropewalk

www.emlawshare.co.uk

Costs

Page 28: Introduction to Judicial Review and Case Law Update 11 th December 2014 Jonathan Butler - Geldards Trevor Griffiths - Sharpe Pritchard Andrew Hogan - Ropewalk

www.emlawshare.co.uk

Rugby in Plume

Page 29: Introduction to Judicial Review and Case Law Update 11 th December 2014 Jonathan Butler - Geldards Trevor Griffiths - Sharpe Pritchard Andrew Hogan - Ropewalk

www.emlawshare.co.uk

The Greatest Living Scientologist

Page 30: Introduction to Judicial Review and Case Law Update 11 th December 2014 Jonathan Butler - Geldards Trevor Griffiths - Sharpe Pritchard Andrew Hogan - Ropewalk

www.emlawshare.co.uk

High Speed 2

Page 31: Introduction to Judicial Review and Case Law Update 11 th December 2014 Jonathan Butler - Geldards Trevor Griffiths - Sharpe Pritchard Andrew Hogan - Ropewalk

www.emlawshare.co.uk

Yeah, right

Page 32: Introduction to Judicial Review and Case Law Update 11 th December 2014 Jonathan Butler - Geldards Trevor Griffiths - Sharpe Pritchard Andrew Hogan - Ropewalk

www.emlawshare.co.uk

An age old problem

Page 33: Introduction to Judicial Review and Case Law Update 11 th December 2014 Jonathan Butler - Geldards Trevor Griffiths - Sharpe Pritchard Andrew Hogan - Ropewalk

www.emlawshare.co.uk

www.catsthatlooklikehitler.com

Page 34: Introduction to Judicial Review and Case Law Update 11 th December 2014 Jonathan Butler - Geldards Trevor Griffiths - Sharpe Pritchard Andrew Hogan - Ropewalk

www.emlawshare.co.uk

Contact

Andrew Hogan, Barrister, Ropewalk Chambers

Tel: +44 (0) 115 947 2581

Email: [email protected]

Page 35: Introduction to Judicial Review and Case Law Update 11 th December 2014 Jonathan Butler - Geldards Trevor Griffiths - Sharpe Pritchard Andrew Hogan - Ropewalk

www.emlawshare.co.uk

Thank you & questions