INTR

OD

UC

TIO

N T

O C

arbo

n fo

otpr

ints

Mik

eBe

rner

sLe

e

An

Asso

ciat

e C

ompa

ny o

f La

ncas

ter U

nive

rsity

QU

ICK

LY A

BO

UT

ME

An

Ass

ocia

te C

ompa

ny o

f La

ncas

ter U

nive

rsity

Carb

onM

anag

emen

twit

hBT

,M

anch

este

rCity

Coun

cil,

Vari

ous

Loca

lA

utho

ritie

s,La

ncas

ter

Uni

vers

ity,,

Tayl

orW

impe

y,Bo

oths

supe

rmar

kets

,Lak

eD

istr

ictN

atio

nalP

ark

Aut

hori

ty,E

den

Proj

ect,

Gua

rdia

n,et

c...

WH

AT’

S C

OM

MIN

G U

P

•Con

text

•Car

bon

Foot

prin

ts

•Met

hods

•Exa

mpl

es

•IT

Carb

on

A T

RIC

KY

CH

ALL

EN

GE

FO

R

GLO

BA

L S

OC

IETY

We

are

OK

atm

anag

ing

this

kind

ofim

pact

…

…bu

tnow

we

have

tom

anag

eth

iski

ndto

o

TYP

ES

OF

EM

ISS

ION

S A

ND

IM

PA

CTS

Dir

ect

(Sco

pe1)

Indi

rect

(Sco

pe3)

Elec

tric

ityge

nera

tion

(Sco

pe2)

WE

NE

ED

A C

AR

BO

N IN

STI

NC

T LI

KE

WE

HA

VE

A M

ON

EY

IN

STI

NC

T

A B

IT A

BO

UT

CA

RB

ON

FO

OTP

RIN

TS

An

Asso

ciat

e C

ompa

ny o

f La

ncas

ter U

nive

rsity

A C

HO

ICE

OF

ME

AS

UR

ES

•D

irec

tcar

bon

emis

sion

s

•D

irec

tgre

enho

use

gase

s(C

O2e

)•

CO2

•M

etha

ne

•N

itrou

sox

ide

•Re

frig

eran

tgas

ses

•O

ther

s

•CO

2efo

otpr

int:

incl

udin

gsu

pply

chai

ns

•O

ther

envi

ronm

enta

land

sust

aina

bilit

ycr

iteri

a

SU

PP

LY C

HA

INS

AR

E C

OM

PLI

CA

TED

CA

RB

ON

FOO

TPR

INT

S A

RE

LIK

E

THE

FIR

ST

MA

PS

–A

ND

D

ON

’T L

ET

AN

YO

NE

TELL

YO

U

OTH

ER

WIS

E!

Proc

ess

Bas

ed L

ife C

ycle

A

naly

sis

Proc

ess

Bas

ed L

ife C

ycle

A

naly

sis

•Bot

tom

up:O

nyo

urha

nds

and

knee

sgr

opin

gar

ound

•Har

dw

ork

•Diff

eren

tass

umpt

ions

yiel

ddi

ffer

entr

esul

ts•A

lway

sha

sar

bitr

ary

boun

dari

es•H

ard

tokn

owth

esi

gnifi

canc

eof

omis

sion

s•T

ends

toun

dere

stim

ate

•Acc

urac

yof

ten

over

stat

ed.

•Has

pote

ntia

lfor

spec

ifici

tybu

tin

real

ityen

dsup

rely

ing

onge

neri

cda

tase

ts

•Can

bepo

wer

fulf

orid

entif

ying

spec

ific

hot

spot

sin

asu

pply

chai

n.•I

nfer

ence

sca

nal

sobe

mad

eab

outo

ther

sim

ilar

supp

lych

ains

.•R

equi

res

huge

reso

urce

sto

dopr

oper

ly.

PAS

2050

is a

sta

ndar

d fo

r Pr

oces

s ba

sed

life

cycl

e an

alys

is

of p

rodu

cts

PA

S 2

050

–R

evie

w o

f met

hods

“Exp

erts

high

light

edpa

rtic

ular

lytw

ow

eakn

esse

sof

PLCA

:cos

tand

labo

urin

tens

ityof

carr

ying

outa

PLCA

and

the

syst

embo

unda

rypr

oble

m…

“sys

tem

cut

off”

isun

avoi

dabl

ein

PLCA

…Th

ecu

tof

fcr

iteri

asu

gges

ted

byIS

Oca

nbe

mis

lead

ing

and

dono

tpro

vide

asa

tisfa

ctor

yba

sis

for

atr

ansp

aren

tsys

tem

boun

dary

sele

ctio

n….

The

(res

ultin

g)tr

unca

tion

erro

ris

pote

ntia

llyve

ryla

rge.

…

“…Th

isis

furt

hera

ggra

vate

dw

hen

rest

rict

ions

are

impo

sed

onth

ebu

dget

asty

pica

lin

sim

plifi

edPL

CAap

proa

ches

.Suc

hsi

mpl

ified

appr

oach

esus

ually

fail

tore

liabl

yre

prod

uce

resu

ltsfr

omde

taile

dPL

CA.H

owev

er,o

nly

sim

plifi

edPL

CAs

wor

kun

der

tight

budg

etco

nstr

aint

sre

quir

edfo

rth

ePA

Sto

beap

plic

able

toor

gani

satio

nsof

alls

izes

.Thi

sse

riou

sly

limits

the

usef

ulne

ssof

PLCA

for

the

PAS

deve

lopm

ent.

”

INPU

T O

UTP

UT

AN

ALY

SIS

Look

sat

the

who

leec

onom

ydi

vide

din

toin

dust

ryse

ctor

s.

INPU

T O

UTP

UT

AN

ALY

SIS

Dem

and

for

prod

ucts

stim

ulat

esou

tput

acro

ssth

eec

onom

y….

INPU

T O

UTP

UT

AN

ALY

SIS

…. c

ausi

ng b

oth

dire

ct a

nd in

dire

ct e

mis

sion

s…

INPU

T O

UTP

UT

AN

ALY

SIS

…. t

he ri

pple

effe

cts

are

endl

ess…

INPU

T O

UTP

UT

AN

ALY

SIS

…w

ithou

t sys

tem

atic

und

eres

timat

ion

…. t

he ri

pple

effe

cts

are

endl

ess…

but c

an b

e m

odel

led

as a

com

plet

e sy

stem

…

DIF

FER

ENT

MET

HO

DO

LOG

IES

GIV

E D

IFFE

REN

T R

ESU

LTS

SO

ME

FO

OTP

RIN

TS ..

.

MA

NK

IND

: 50

BIL

LIO

N

TON

NE

S C

O2E

PE

R Y

EA

R

HO

NG

KO

NG

RE

TUR

N:

4.6

TO

NN

ES

Low

3.4

tonn

esH

igh

13.4

tonn

esA

vera

ge4.

6to

nnes

Econ

omy

Firs

tcla

ss

DR

YIN

G Y

OU

R H

AN

DS

:10

G Low

0g

20g

typi

cal

hand

drie

r

Ave

rage

10g

Let

them

drip

Pape

rto

wel

s

TYP

ICA

L M

AN

CH

ES

TER

RE

SID

EN

T:

15.7

TO

NN

ES

CO

2E P

ER

YE

AR

AV

ER

AG

E G

RE

ATE

R M

AN

CH

ES

TER

RE

SID

EN

T: 1

5.7

T P

ER

PE

RS

ON

…O

F W

HIC

H D

IRE

CT

PLU

S E

LEC

TRIC

ITY

MIG

HT

AC

CO

UN

T FO

R

AB

OU

T 30

%

LON

DO

N T

O G

LAS

GO

W

RE

TUR

N12

0kg

CO2e

53kg

CO2e

(by

Bana

napo

wer

)to

2.3

tonn

es(P

eruv

ian

aspa

ragu

spo

wer

)

330

kgCO

2e

500

kgCO

2e

CA

RS

6to

nnes

CO2e

17to

nnes

CO2e

35to

nnes

CO2e

Basi

cCi

troe

nC1

Ford

Mon

deo

Top

Spec

Land

rove

r

AS

PA

RA

GU

S (2

50G

PA

CK

):2K

G Low

125

g

Air

frei

ghte

dfr

omPe

ru

Ave

rage

2kg

Loca

lIn

seas

on

Hig

h3.

5kg

A R

ED

RO

SE

:Ze

ro

Hot

hous

edin

Hol

land

350g

:Flo

wn

from

Keny

a

From

your

gard

en

Hig

h2.

1kg

RIC

E

Effic

ient

lypr

oduc

ed:

2.5k

gCO

2e

Ave

rage

:4

kgCO

2e

Inef

ficie

ntly

prod

uced

with

exce

ssiv

efe

rtili

ser:

6.1

kgCO

2e

BR

EA

KD

OW

N O

F TO

TAL

FOO

TPR

INT

OF

BO

OTH

S S

UP

ER

MA

RK

ETS

HA

VIN

G A

CH

ILD

: 37

3 TO

NN

ES

Low

100

tonn

es

2000

tonn

esA

vera

ge

A B

UR

GE

R:

2.5K

GLo

w1k

g

Hig

h3.

5kg

Ave

rage

2.5

kg

Vegg

ieBu

rger

4O

zCh

eese

burg

er

A C

OU

NTR

Y

LAP

TOP

:

400K

G E

MB

OD

IED

Low

~100

Kg

Hig

h~1

tonn

eA

vera

ge40

0Kg

2010

21.5

inch

iMac

Asi

mpl

elo

wco

stla

ptop

LAP

TOP

: ~50

G /

HO

UR

O

PE

RA

TIO

NA

L12

g15

0g63

Kg

Old

desk

top

Ener

gyef

ficie

ntla

ptop

Pow

erhu

ngry

iMac

orsi

mila

r

TEX

T M

ES

SA

GE

: 0.0

14G

PE

R

ME

SS

AG

E0.

014g

32,0

00to

nnes

All

the

wor

lds

text

spe

rye

ar

One

mes

sage

US

ING

A M

OB

ILE

:57

G P

ER

M

INU

TE47

kg

125

mill

ion

tonn

esA

vera

ge12

50Kg

Glo

bal

mob

ileus

age

1ye

ars

usag

eat

unde

r2m

ins

per

day

1ye

ars

usag

eat

1ho

urpe

rda

y

US

ING

MO

BIL

ES

•So

1ho

urpe

rda

y=

1to

nnes

per

year

.

•O

nees

timat

efo

ra

sim

ple

phon

eis

16kg

(sa

me

as1

kgfb

eef)

–Sm

artp

hone

sar

ea

loth

ighe

r.

TEX

T S

TATS

•2.

5Tr

illio

npe

rye

ar–

(25%

inCh

ina,

20%

inPh

ilipi

nes

whe

reea

chph

one

send

s15

per

day)

–W

ese

nd6

per

day,

inth

eU

Sit’

s2

per

pay)

(Gar

tner

2007

Pred

ictio

nfo

r20

08)

•G

loba

lly,3

2,00

0to

nne

foot

prin

tper

year

•Is

that

alo

t?

DA

TA C

EN

TRE

S

2010

:130

mill

ion

tonn

esCO

2e

Pred

ictio

nfo

r20

20:

250

–34

0m

illio

nto

nnes

CO2e

WE

B S

EA

RC

H: ~

1–5G

FO

R 3

0SE

CO

ND

S

EA

RC

H0.

2g4.

5g

0.7g

Ener

gyus

edfr

oma

pow

erhu

ngry

mac

hine

and

high

eres

timat

esfo

rth

ene

twor

k

Ener

gyus

edat

goog

le’s

end

Incl

udin

gen

ergy

used

inan

effic

ient

lapt

op

WE

B S

EA

RC

HE

S

•A

ccou

nts

for

1.3

mill

ion

tonn

esCO

2e

•Is

that

alo

t?

AN

EM

AIL

: ~4-

50G

PE

R M

ES

SA

GE

0.3g

Tode

lete

asp

amm

essa

ge

50g

Ave

rage

4g

Alo

ngem

ailw

itha

big

atta

chm

entt

ore

ad

Topr

oper

mes

sage

SP

AM

STA

TS•

62tr

illio

nsp

ams

pery

earr

equi

ring

33bi

llion

KWh

ofel

ectr

icity

and

20m

illio

nto

nnes

ofCO

2e

•78

%of

emai

linc

omin

gem

ails

are

spam

,res

ultin

gin

22%

ofth

efo

otpr

into

fyou

rem

ail(

beca

use

they

are

quic

kto

deal

with

)

•W

hati

fthe

cost

ofan

emai

lwas

1p?

EM

AIL

CO

NTI

NU

ED

…

•60

emai

ls(p

rope

ron

es)h

asth

esa

me

foot

prin

tas

1le

tter

•So

does

emai

lgiv

eus

aca

rbon

savi

ng?

The

Glo

balE

cono

my

Can

Hid

eO

urIm

pact

SO

ME

GR

EE

N IT

QU

ES

TIO

NS

•Is

itbe

tter

tore

plac

eor

keep

old

kit?

•D

oIT

impa

cts

outw

eigh

the

savi

ngs?

ordo

the

bene

fits

outw

eigh

the

impa

cts?

–e.

g.D

oes

itre

plac

epa

per

and

fligh

ts?

•A

reef

ficie

ncy

impr

ovem

ents

usef

ul?

–or

dow

eju

stta

keup

the

slac

kw

ithin

crea

sed

appe

tite?

THA

NK

YO

U F

OR

LI

STE

NIN

G

Mik

eBe

rner

sLe

eM

ike@

swco

nsul

ting.

co.u

k

An

Ass

ocia

te C

ompa

ny o

f La

ncas

ter U

nive

rsity

A B

IG P

ER

SP

EC

TIV

E O

N

CLI

MA

TE C

HA

NG

E•

Expo

nent

iale

mis

sion

ssi

nce

1850

•Th

ere

are

othe

rsi

mila

ren

viro

nmen

tali

mpa

ctcu

rves

•So

Effic

ienc

yim

prov

emen

tsha

ven’

tm

anag

edto

redu

ceim

pact

•Th

ere

isa

need

tora

ise

the

gam

e.