Upload
bijuajithesh
View
215
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
1/125
CHAPTER 1CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION TO RESEARCHINTRODUCTION TO RESEARCH
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
2/125
TOPICS DISCUSSEDTOPICS DISCUSSED
Defnition o ResearchDefnition o Research
Hierarchy o inormation-Based DecisionHierarchy o inormation-Based Decisionmaers!maers!
"hy #ana$ers Sho%&d 'no( A)o%t"hy #ana$ers Sho%&d 'no( A)o%tResearchResearch
*actors stim%&atin$ interest in research*actors stim%&atin$ interest in research
*eat%res o Research*eat%res o Research
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
3/125
Research
The word ‘Research’ can be bifurcated in to two
words: Research = Re + Search. The word ‘Re’
means again and again and ‘Search’ means to findout something.
Research is a process by which one observes a fact
or situation repeatedly from different aspect andcollects the data and on the basis of data derives
some conclusions.
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
4/125
! "eep si# honest serving men$ %they
taught me all ! "new&$ their names are
what, and why$ and when$ and how$
and where and who'.(Rudyard )ipling
The use of the words what, why, when, howwhere and who essentially summari*es what
research is?
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
5/125
Research is the process of finding
solutions to a problem after a thoroughstudy and analysis of the situational
factors.
hat is Research,
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
6/125
Base Tier
Middle Tier
Top Tier
-ierarchy of !nformation/ased 0ecision 1a"ers
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
7/125
The managers encounter big and small
problems on a daily basis$ which they have to
solve by ma"ing the right decisions.
!n business$ research is usually conducted toresolve problematic issues in the areas of
management.
hy 1anagers should "now
Research,
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
8/125
hy 1anagers should "now
Research,
1anagers in organi*ations constantly engage
themselves in studying and analy*ing issuesand hence are involved in some form of
research activity as they ma"e decisions at the
wor"place.
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
9/125
2ood decision ma"ing fetches a yes' answer tothe following 3uestions:
4s a manager are you in a position to identifywhere e#actly the problem lies,
hat are the relevant factors in the situationneeding investigation,
0o you "now what types of information are to be
gathered and how,
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
10/125
0o you "now how to ma"e use of the
information so collected and draw appropriateconclusions to ma"e the right decisions,
0o you "now how to implement the results ofthis process to solve the problem,
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
11/125
This is the essence of research and to be
successful manager it is important for you to"now how to go about ma"ing the right
decisions by being "nowledgeable about the
various steps involved in finding solutions to
problematic issues.
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
12/125
Factors stimulating interest in
research 5roblems in 4ccounting
5roblems in 6inance
5roblems in 1anagement
5roblems in 1ar"eting
5roblems in -ealth 7are
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
13/125
6eatures of Research
!t means the discovery of new "nowledge.
!t is essentially an investigation.
!t is related with the solution of a problem.
!t is based on observation or e#perimental
evidences.
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
14/125
!t demands accurate observation or
e#perimentation.
!n research$ the researchers try to find out
answers for unsolved 3uestions.
!t should be carefully recorded and reported.
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
15/125
4ssume for the moment that you are the -ealth
4dministrator of a hospital. 8ou are e#periencing
significant turnover in your doctors pool and some long
time patients have committed that the friendlyatmosphere$ which has historically drawn them to your
door$ is changing. here will you begin to try to solve
this problem, !s this a problem for which research
should be used,
!s Research always problemsolving based,
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
16/125
INTERNET EXERCISES
Use the Web search enines
+oo$&e and ,ahoo! Search "sinthe #e$ %ords “b"sinessresearch”! &repare a brie' report
tellin %hat $o" 'o"nd and ho% itdi(ered on the di(erent searchenines!
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
17/125
Topics for self study
5urpose. 4ims or 9bectives of Research
;imitations of Research
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
18/125
Research methods include all those
techni3ues
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
19/125
vidence based research
hat is important in -ealthcare Service
delivery,
-ow healthcare practitioners ustify the care
they provide to the patient,
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
20/125
6actors to be considered for evidence
based research
Ade)"ate research *"st ha+e beenp"blished in the area bein researched!
The researcher *"st ha+e the s#ill o'accessin and anal$sin the p"blishedliterat"re in his,her area o' research!
The researcher *"st be able toi*ple*ent the chanes based on EBN inhis area o' practice!
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
21/125
#ample of /R
>urse wor"related inury
hat are the evidence to be considered,
The integration of the best research evidence with
clinical e#pertise and patient values?
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
22/125
hat is ethnography,
thnography is the study of social interactions$
behaviours$ and perceptions that occur within
groups$ teams$ organisations$ and communities.
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
23/125
7ostello’s e#amination of death and dying in elderly
care wards@
9sterlund’s wor" on doctors’ and nurses’ use of
traditional and digital information systems in their
clinical communications.
/ec"er and colleagues’ /oys in hite$ an
ethnographic study of medical education
#amples of ethnographic research within the
health services literature
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
24/125
Airtual thnography
Airtual ethnography is a 3ualitative and interpretive
methodology approach that is carried out in the online
setting %the !nternet& to study the online communities
and culture. !t is a research conducted on the orld
ide eb.
Example: 0esigning and implementing mobilevirtual communities for cancer patients
https://sites.google.com/site/virtualethnography/glossaryhttps://sites.google.com/site/virtualethnography/glossary
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
25/125
Triangulation
Triangulation is an approach to research that uses a
combination of more than one research strategy in a
single investigation.
4 phenomenon under study in a 3ualitative research
proect is much li"e a ship at sea. The e#act
description of the phenomenon is unclear !
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
26/125
Why o we conuct Triangulation!
Types of Triangulation
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
27/125
hy choose triangulation as a research
strategy,
Bualitative investigators may choose triangulation as a
research strategy to assure completeness of findings
or to con"irm "inings#
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
28/125
Ass"re co*pleteness
The most accurate description of the elephant
comes from where,
4 combination of all three individualsC descriptions
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
29/125
7onfirm findings
Researchers might also choose triangulation to confirmfindings and conclusions. 4ny single 3ualitative researchstrategy has its limitations.
/y combining different strategies$ researchers confirm findings by overcoming the limitations of a single strategy.
Dncovering the same information from more than one vantage
point helps researchers describe how the findings occurredunder different circumstances and assists them to confirm thevalidity of the findings.
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
30/125
hy do we conduct Triangulation,
Types o" Triangulation
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
31/125
Types of Triangulation
$% &ata TriangulationTime, space, person
E& 1ethod Triangulation0esign0ata collection
F& !nvestigator Triangulation
G& Theory Triangulation
6ifth type$ multiple triangulation$ which uses acombination of two or more triangulation techni3ues in onestudy.
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
32/125
04T4 TR!4>2D!4T!9>
0en*in %HIJI& described three types of data
triangulation: %H& time$ %E& space$ and %F& person.
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
33/125
Time triangulation
Time triangulation$ researchers collect data about
a phenomenon at different points in time.
Studies based on longitudinal designs are not
considered e#amples of data triangulation for time
because they are intended to document changesover time.
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
34/125
Space triangulation
Space triangulation consists of collecting data at more
than one site.
4t the outset$ the researcher must identify how time or
space relate to the study and ma"e an argument
supporting the use of different time or space collection points in the study.
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
35/125
/y collecting data at different points in time and in
different spaces$ the researcher gains a clearer and
more complete description of decision ma"ing and
is able to i""erentiate characteristics that span
time perios an spaces "rom characteristics
speci"ic to certain times an spaces
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
36/125
5erson triangulation
Dsing person triangulation$ researchers collect data
from more than one level of person$ that is$ a set of
individuals$ groups$ or collectives.
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
37/125
Types of Triangulation
$% &ata TriangulationTime, space, person
'% (etho Triangulation&esign&ata collection
F& !nvestigator Triangulation
G& Theory Triangulation
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
38/125
1T-90S TR!4>2D;4T!9>
1ethods triangulation can occur at the level of design
or data collection.
1ethods triangulation at the design level has also been called )etween*metho triangulation and
methods triangulation at the data collection level has
been called within*metho triangulation#
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
39/125
0esign ;evel
0esign methods triangulation most often uses+uantitatie methods combined with 3ualitative
methods in the study design.simultaneous implementationse3uential implementation
Theory should emerge from the 3ualitative findings
and should not be forced by researchers into thetheory they are using for the 3uantitative portion ofthe study.
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
40/125
The blending of 3ualitative and 3uantitative
approaches does not occur during either data
generation or analysis.
Rather$ researchers blend these approaches at the
leel o" interpretation, merging findings from each
techni3ue to derive a consistent outcome.
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
41/125
The process of merging findings ?is an informed
thought process$ involving -ugment, wisom,
creatiity, an insight and includes the privilege ofcreating or modifying theory.
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
42/125
Sometimes triangulation design method might usetwo different 3ualitative research methods.
hen researchers combine methods at the designlevel$ they should consider the purpose of theresearch and ma"e a logical argument for using
each method.
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
43/125
1ethods triangulation at the level of data
collection
Dsing methods triangulation at the level of data collection$researchers use two different techni3ues of data collection$
but each techni3ue is within the same research tradition.
The purpose of combining the data collection methods isto provide a more holistic an )etter unerstaning o"the phenomenon uner stuy#
!t is not an easy tas" to use method triangulation@ it is oftenmore time consuming an expensie to complete astuy using methos triangulation.
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
44/125
Types of Triangulation
$% &ata TriangulationTime, space, person
E& 1ethod Triangulation0esign0ata collection
.% Inestigator Triangulation
G& Theory Triangulation
6ifth type$ multiple triangulation$ which uses acombination of two or more triangulation techni3ues in onestudy.
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
45/125
!>AST!24T9R TR!4>2D;4T!9>
!nvestigator triangulation occurs when two or moreresearchers with iergent )ac/grouns and e#pertise wor"together on the same study. To achieve investigatortriangulation$ multiple investigators each must have
prominent roles in the stuy and their areas of e#pertisemust be complementary.
4ll the investigators discuss their individual findings andreach a conclusion$ which includes all findings.
-aving a second research e#pert e#amine a data set is notconsidered investigator triangulation.
Dse of methos triangulation usually re3uires investigatortriangulation because few investigators are e#pert in morethan one research method.
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
46/125
Types of Triangulation
$% &ata TriangulationTime, space, person
E& 1ethod Triangulation0esign0ata collection
F& !nvestigator Triangulation
0% Theory Triangulation
6ifth type$ multiple triangulation$ which uses acombination of two or more triangulation techni3ues in onestudy.
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
47/125
T-9R8 TR!4>2D;4T!9>
Theory triangulation incorporates the use of morethan one lens or theory in the analysis of the same
data set.
!n 3ualitative research$ more than one theoreticale#planation emerges from the data.
Researchers investigate the utility and power ofthese emerging theories by cycling between datageneration and data analysis until they reach a
conclusion.
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
48/125
Ded"ction and Ind"ction
&euction: reasoning from general premises$ whichare "nown or presumed to be "nown$ to morespecific$ certain conclusions.
Inuction: reasoning from specific cases to moregeneral$ but uncertain$ conclusions.
/oth deductive and inductive arguments occurfre3uently and naturallyKboth forms of reasoningcan be e3ually compelling and persuasive$ andneither form is preferred over the other %-ollihan L
/as"e$ HIIG&.
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
49/125
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
50/125
!nductive Reasoning
O)ser.ation
Pattern
Tentati.e Hyothesis
Theory
1sing inuctie reasoning, one
starts with a speci"ic o)seration
as the )asis "or which we
eelop a general pattern antentatie hypothesis as the
"ounation o" a theory
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
51/125
Sample 0eductive and !nductive 4rguments
Example o" &euction
ma-or premise: 4ll
tortoises are vegetarians
minor premise: /essie
is a tortoise
conclusion: Therefore$
/essie is a vegetarian
Example o" Inuction
/oss to employee: /iff
has a tattoo of
an anchor on his arm.
-e probably
served in the >avy!-
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
52/125
&euction theory and hypothesis are developed and
tested
Inuction M data are collected and a theory developed
from the data analysis
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
53/125
#ample of !nductive Reasoning
;incoln is on a penny %;incoln is a specific instanceof a 5resident&.
Nefferson is on a nic"el %4 nic"el is a specific
instance of a coin&.
Roosevelt is on a dime.
ashington is on a 3uarter.
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
54/125
In each o' the 'ollo%in e.plain i' ind"cti+e or ded"cti+e reasonin isbein "sed!
a!An e*plo$ee has %orn a bl"e shirt e+er$ /rida$ the$ ha+e %or#edat a co*pan$! A person concl"des the$ %ill %ear a bl"e shirt this
/rida$ to %or#!
b!An e*plo$ee at a co*pan$ *"st %ear a "ni'or* that has a bl"eshirt! A person concl"des the$ %ill %ear a bl"e shirt this /rida$ to%or#!
c!I a* eatin at a +eetarian resta"rant! I concl"de all the dishes onthe *en" are *eatless!
d!A'ter readin the entire *en" I concl"de all o' the dishes on the
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
55/125
&heno*enolo$
5henomenological Research is a strategy of in3uiry inwhich the researcher identifies the essence of human
e#periences about a phenomenon as described by participants. Dnderstanding the lived e#periencesmar"s phenomenology as a philosophy as well as amethod$ and the procedure involves studying a smallnumber of subects through e#tensive and prolongedengagement to develop patterns and relationships ofmeaning %1ousta"as$ HIIG&.
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
56/125
5henomenology %con’t&
5henomenologists attempt to understand those whom
they observe from the subects’ perspective.
This outloo" is especially pertinent in social wor" and
research where empathy and perspective become the
"eys to success.
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
57/125
The 5rocedures of 5henomenological !n3uiry
0!Deter*ine i' pheno*enoloical approach is best0!Do se+eral people share a co**on e.perience?1!Can $o" de+elop policies2 practices or de+elop deeper"nderstandin o' the 'eat"res o' the pheno*enon?
1! De3ne the pheno*enon o' interest to be st"died
4! Reconi5e and "nderstand the philosoph$ behindpheno*enolo$ incl"din brac#etin2 ob6ecti+e realit$ andindi+id"al e.perience
7! Collect data thro"h *"ltiple in8depth inter+ie%s or other 'or*so' collection
9! Bein %ith the broad :What- and :Ho%- )"estions! &roceed
%ith broader open8ended )"estions to ather te.t"ral andstr"ct"ral data
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
58/125
5henomenological 0ata 7ollection
!nterview!n depth interview5articipation observation7onversation
4ction research6ocus 1eeting4nalysis of 5ersonal Te#ts % 0iary riting&!nterpretive %-ermeneutic& 5henomenology
To interpret the phenomena beingobserved
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
59/125
RS4R7- 5-!;9S95-8
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
60/125
Research is about the search "or /nowlege$ but the
3uestion is$ what is "nowledge and can that
"nowledge be in any sense true or "alse!
!t is a branch of philosophy that deals with "nowledge
and tries to answer the 3uestion as to whether a given
body of "nowledge is ade3uate or inade3uate
Epistemology
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
61/125
Epistemology cont3
pistemology as a branch of philosophy deals with
the sources of "nowledge. Specifically$ epistemology
is concerned with possibilities$ nature$ sources and
limitations of "nowledge.
!ntuitive "nowledge
4uthoritarian "nowledge
;ogical "nowledge
mpirical "nowledge
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
62/125
Research process may integrate all of these sources
of "nowledge within a single study.
8ou want to select a specific problem to be e#plored
within a selected research area. hich "nowledge is
used,
hen you gain authoritative "nowledge,
logical "nowledge is generated as a result of
analysing primary data findings$ and conclusions of
the research can be perceived as empirical
"nowledge.
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
63/125
4 Simple #ample
O Suppose ! as" the 3uestion: are your friends
trustworthy,O 1ost of us would answer 8es
O !s it that the "nowledge ‘8S’ is true or false$
accepted or unaccepted$ or even valid,
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
64/125
The 9bectivism vs Subectivism
pistemological Stance
O)/ecti.ism
&ositi+ist;s belie+e thatonl$pheno*ena %hich areobser+able and*eas"rablecan be rearded as +alid
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
65/125
4#iological 4ssumption
4ositiist5s‐ believe that science and the process is
alue "ree i.e. the researcher is etache from
what they are researching and regard the
phenomena as an obect.
O 4henomenologist6s‐ considers that researchers
hae alues. These values help to determine whatare recogni*ed as facts and the interpretation. The
researcher is inole with that which is being
researched
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
66/125
:9>T9;928 is concerned with the nature ofrealityKK and assumptions researchers have about
the way the world operates and the commitment held
to a particular view'.
!n this conte#t we are thin"ing of ‘"nowledge’ or
perhaps more correctly the particular body of"nowledge that is embedded in your research proect
What is 7ntology!
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
67/125
!s that description of Reality is e#ternal to or
within the mind of the individual,
hat 0o you thin" ,
The body of "nowledge on the phenomena%reality& isexternal to social actors# 9bjectivism or
whether the phenomena can and should be considered
social constructions )uilt up "rom perceptions andactions of social actors. Constructivism
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
68/125
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
69/125
5ositivism
9bectivism
5henomenology
Subectivism<
7onstructivism
f h i di
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
70/125
6eatures of the two main 5aradigms
Positi.istic
Tends to prod"ce )"antitati+edata!
Uses lare sa*ples
Concerned %ith h$pothesis Testin
Data is hihl$ speci3c and
&recise
Reliabilit$ is hih
>alidit$ is lo%
enerali5es 'ro* sa*ple
Phenomeno&o$ica&
Tends to be )"alitati+e data
Uses s*all sa*ples!
Concerned %ith eneratin Theories!
Data is rich and s"b6ecti+e!
Reliabilit$ is lo%
>alidit$ is hih!
enerali5es 'ro* one settin
to another!
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
71/125
hat is a concept,
7oncepts are:
/uilding bloc"s of theory
Concept 4 generali*ed idea about a class of obects$attributes$ occurrences$ or processes.Examples: 9ener, 8ge, Eucation, )ran loyalty,
satis"action, attitue, mar/et orientation
;
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
72/125
Synta#
Aocabulary
Spelling
1anuscript
errors
Typing
speed
6ormat
4ccuracy
anguage S/ill Construct
2Components un/nown )y analyst%
; 4resentation >uality
Construct =
a)stract
(ost
concrete
: e , e l o " a ) s t r a c t i o n
ConstructsCompose o"
Concepts in a
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
73/125
7oncepts are useful for:
5roviding an e#planation of a certain aspect of
the social world
Standing for things we want to e#plain
2iving a basis for measuring variation
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
74/125
Construct 4 concept that is measured with multiplevariables.
Examples: ?ran loyalty, satis"action,
attitue, mar/et orientation, socio*economicstatus#
@aria)le 4nything that varies or changes fromone instance to another@ can e#hibit differences
in value$ usually in magnitude or strength$ or indirection.
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
75/125
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
76/125
9perational 0efinition
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
77/125
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
78/125
Rules of 1easurement
2uidelines established by the researcher for assigning numbers or scores to
different levels of the concept %or attribute& that different individuals %or
obects& possess
The process is facilitated by the operational definition.6or e#ample$ if you operationali*ed brand loyalty as purchase se3uences'
%conceptual definition H&$ then you may establish the following rules for
assigning scores:
!f consumer purchased brand 4: IU or more MV loyalty for brand 4 = H %#tremely loyal&
J JIU MV loyalty for brand 4 = E %Aery loyal&
Q QIU MV loyalty for brand 4 = F %;oyal&
tc.
4utting Relia)ility an @aliity Together4utting Relia)ility an @aliity Together
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
79/125
4utting Relia)ility an @aliity Together4utting Relia)ility an @aliity Together
very instrument can be evaluated on two
dimensions:
Relia)ility-ow consistent it is given the same
conditions
@aliity
!f it measures what it is supposed to and
how accurate it is
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
80/125
Re&ia)i&ity and 0a&idityRe&ia)i&ity and 0a&idity
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
81/125
"hat is Re&ia)i&ity"hat is Re&ia)i&ity??
Reliability isReliability is::
the consistency of your measurementthe consistency of your measurement
instrumentinstrument
the degree to which an instrument measures thethe degree to which an instrument measures the
same way each time it is used under the samesame way each time it is used under the same
condition with the same subectscondition with the same subects
i iWh t i th l i t
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
82/125
What in the worl is a measurementWhat in the worl is a measurement
instrumentinstrument!!
4ny tool that you use to measure with
What :instr"*ent- *iht $o" "se to *eas"re the 'ollo%in ite*s?
Ho% hea+$ the apples are
Ho% tall the %all is
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
83/125
(ore on Instruments(ore on Instruments
hat would the following instruments measurehat would the following instruments measure,,
The size of
someone’s foot
Eyesight
(ore on Instruments(ore on Instruments
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
84/125
(ore on Instruments(ore on Instruments
O'ten there are *an$ di(erent instr"*ents thatO'ten there are *an$ di(erent instr"*ents that
co"ld be "sed to *eas"re the sa*e thinco"ld be "sed to *eas"re the sa*e thin..
Ta#e Ta#e distancedistance 'or e.a*ple'or e.a*ple……
Or an odo*eter
@o" co"ld "se a *eas"rin tape
Measure it out on a map
Or (a& it(ith aedometer
Use a distance
h t i t t h d d
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
85/125
hat instrument you choose depends on
several factors
ase of Dse
4ccess
4ppropriateness
4ccuracy
7ost
Reliability
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
86/125
Reliability
!magine that you are using a ruler measure a boo".
hat do you thin" would happen if you waited H
minutes and measured the boo" again$ how long would
it be then,
34ro)a)ly still inches
hat if you spun the ruler aroundP
4nd shoo" it up really good,P
R li bilit
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
87/125
Reliability
8our rulerK
was consistent
measured the same way each time it was used underthe same condition with the same obect
The boo" did not change and therefore the ruler
reported bac" the same measurement
8our ruler is R;!4/;
Reliability
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
88/125
y
very time the water begins to
boil the "ettle whistles
very time it is :F my alarm
cloc" goes off
4ll of these tools of measurement are reliablereliable given the same
temperature$ time and volume$ they measure the same
consistentlyconsistently
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
89/125
Relia)ilityRelia)ility
Reliability alone does not mean that you have a good instrumentReliability alone does not mean that you have a good instrument
however however ..
!magine the following reliable instrument!magine the following reliable instrument::
09Every morning I get on the
scale and every morning it
reads 165 lbs.
It seems pretty reliable
since I haven’t gained or
lost any weight.
One day an elephant goton the weighing scale and
it still read 165 lbs.!
ow is this scale reliable?
It does measre the same
way nder the sameconditions !mine" # bt a
lot o$ other conditions too
!the elephant".
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
90/125
A! Ta$lor A! Ta$lor
Do not d"plicate %itho"tDo not d"plicate %itho"ta"thor;s per*issiona"thor;s per*ission
Relia)le )ut not @aliRelia)le )ut not @ali
Remember our reliable ruler Remember our reliable ruler ,,
%an it measre howlod the radio is&
how $ll the
glass is&
how smart
the girl is&
The ruler may )e relia)le 2an perhaps een
ali% )ut not in these situationsD
It is only ali "or measuring length#
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
91/125
This brings us to @aliity
5utting Reliability and Aalidity Together
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
92/125
g y y g
very instrument can be evaluated on two
dimensions:
Relia)ility
-ow consistent it is given the sameconditions
@aliity
!f it measures what it is supposed to and
how accurate it is
4utting Relia)ility an @aliity Together4utting Relia)ility an @aliity Together
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
93/125
g y y gg y y g
!magine that ! have F fish tan" thermometers$ a blue
one$ a red one$ and a green one.
The )lue one always reas the same temperatureno matter how hot or col the water is#
The re one shows a i""erent temperature eery
time een i" I -ust measure it secons earlier#The green one seems to rea accurately, warm
when the water is warm an col when the water is
cool#
Complete the chart )elowComplete the chart )elow
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
94/125
pp
s it consistent?
s it meas"ringwhat it is
s"pposed to?
s it reliable?
s it #alid?
$l"e always reads
the sametemperatre nomatter what
%ed di$$erenttemperatre everytime even i$
nothing haschanged
&reen warm whenthe water is warmand cold when thewater is cool
hat can be said of the reliability and validity
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
95/125
hat can be said of the reliability and validity
of the following,
8 spelling test with the "ollowing item: ' G HHHH
5robably reliable$ if you get it wrong once you will probably get
it wrong again %assuming no new learning& M same with getting it
right.;ac"s validity$ this is more appropriate for a math test$ not a
spelling test.
8n elastic ruler 2eery time you use it is stretches to a
i""erent length%
;ac" reliability
8ou can’t have validity without reliability
Thi "i 1 b t A lidit
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
96/125
Thin"ing 1ore about Aalidity
Aalidity is whether or not the instrument measures what it is
designed to measure.
/elow are three constructs that you can use to evaluate thevalidity of a measure:
6ace Aalidity
5redictive Aalidity
7oncurrent Aalidity
6 A lidi
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
97/125
6ace Aalidity
0o the 3uestions loo" li"e they measure what they are supposed
to,
hat does the 3uestion below loo" li"e it would measure ,
Choose the ite* that best describes$o"F I do not 'eel sad!0F I 'eel sad!
1F I a* sad all the ti*e and I canGtsnap o"t o' it!4F I a* so sad or "nhapp$ that IcanGt stand it!
I' $o" said deression $o"%o"ld be correct! It loo#sli#e an ite* 'ro* adepression scale and it is
It has ace .a&idity!
I' so*eone said this %as'ro* a parental attach*entscale2 then $o" co"ld sa$that it lac#s 'ace +alidit$!
5 di i A lidi W
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
98/125
5redictive AalidityW
0oes the measure predict something that it logically should,
The 74T
4ccording to their website$ the 74T is the one test that shows
colleges what you "now'. 7ollege admissions officers use this
test to determine who will do well in college.
hat future measures do you e#pect that the 74T would be
correlated with,
!f you said grades in college you would be right$ and the 74T
is correlated with thatP M somewhatK
!t has predictive validity
7oncurrent Aalidity
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
99/125
7oncurrent Aalidity
0oes this measure correlate strongly with something that
it logically should right now,
Dnli"e predictive validity$ concurrent validity compares
measures ta"en at the same time.hat current measures do you imagine that 254 should
correlate with,
!f you said current test scores and teacher ratings you would
be correct.
254 has some concurrent validity
5 iti
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
100/125
5roposition
Statements concerned with the relationships among concepts.
The logical lin"age among concepts.
4ssert a universal connection between properties.
e define a proposition as a statement about concepts which
may be udged as true or false if it refers to observable
phenomena 7ooper L Schindler.
hen a proposition is formulated for empirical testing$ we call
it a hypothesis.
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
101/125
Aariable M 4ny factor that
can change in a scientific
investigation or e#periment.
T$pes o' >ariables
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
102/125
$p
Dichoto*o"sMale,/e*ale
E*plo$ed, Une*plo$ed
DiscreteEthnic bac#ro"ndEd"cational le+el
Reliio"s aJliation
Contin%o%sInco*e
Te*perat"reAe
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
103/125
!ndependent Aariable
%also called the manipulated variable$
predictor variable&
The condition that is intentionally change
by the investigator in an e#periment.
There can be only one independent variable in
an e#periment.
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
104/125
0ependent Aariable
%also called the responding variable$ criterion
variable& The factors or conditions that will change as a
result o" the inepenent aria)le#
The factors that you measure or o)sere as
data.
There can be one or more dependent variables
in an e#periment.
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
105/125
!ndependent and 0ependent Aariable Synonyms
Inepenent
@aria)le 2I@%
4reictor
4resume cause Stimulus
4reicte "rom3
8nteceent
(anipulate
&epenent @aria)le 2&@%
Criterion
4resume e""ect
Response
4reicte to3#
Conse+uence
(easure outcome
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
106/125
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
107/125
/or e.a*ple2 i' $o" are researchin %hether lac# o' e.ercise leads to%eiht ain2 lac# o' e.ercise is $o"r independent +ariable and %eihtain is $o"r dependent +ariable! Con'o"ndin +ariables are an$ other+ariable that also has an e(ect on $o"r dependent +ariable! The$ areli#e e.tra independent +ariables that are ha+in a hidden e(ect on$o"r dependent +ariables! Con'o"ndin +ariables can ca"se t%o *a6orproble*sIncrease +ariance
Introd"ce bias!
http://www.statisticshowto.com/variance/http://www.statisticshowto.com/what-is-bias/http://www.statisticshowto.com/what-is-bias/http://www.statisticshowto.com/variance/
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
108/125
The s%itch to co**ission 'ro* a salar$co*pensation s$ste* %ill lead to increased
sales per %or#er2 especiall$ *oree.perienced %or#ers !
The loss o' *inin 6obs leads to acceptance
o' hiher8ris# beha+iors to earn a 'a*il$8s"pportin inco*e partic"larl$ a*on those%ith a li*ited ed"cation!
d i i bl i h i fl h h
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
109/125
1oderating variable is one that influences the strength
of a relationship between two other variables$ and
a mediator %intervening& variable is one that e#plainsthe relationship between the two other variables
;etCs consider the relation between social class %SS&
and fre3uency of breast selfe#ams %/S&. 4ge might be a moderator variable$ in that the relation between
SS and /S coul )e stronger for older women and
less strong or non e#istent for younger women.
ducation might be a mediator variable in that ite#plains why there is a relation between SS and /S.
hen you remove the effect of education$ the relation
between SS and /S disappears.
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
110/125
f h i
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
111/125
Types of -ypothesis
0escriptive hypotheses: 0escribing the characteristics of
a variable %may be an obect$ person$ organisation$ event$
and situation&.
g. mployment opportunity of 1/4 graduates is more
than the arts students.
The current unemployment rate in Ddupi e#ceeds percent of the labor force
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
112/125
Researchers will often use a research 3uestion rather
than a descriptive hypothesis.
hat is the unemployment rate in Ddupi,
Relational -ypotheses
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
113/125
Relational -ypotheses
stablishes relationship between two variables. !t may
be positive$ negative or nil relationship.
Example
6oreign cars are perceived by !ndian consumers to beof better 3uality than domestic cars.
Correctional relationships
8oung machinists are less productive than those who
are FX years or older Explanatory, or causal relationships 2Causal
ypothesis%
4n increase in family income leads to an increase in
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
114/125
>ull -ypothesis M it points out there is no difference
between two populations in respect of same property.
o di2erences )et(een the $ro%s )ein$st%died 3e!$!4 e5erimenta& .s! contro&$ro%6 oro re&ationshi )et(een the .aria)&es)ein$ st%died
E.a*ple :There is no sini3cant di(erence inthe an.iet$ le+el o' children o' Hih IL andthose o' lo% IL!
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
115/125
4lternative -ypothesis when we reect the null
hypothesis$ we accept another hypothesis "nown as
alternate hypothesis.
4lternate -ypothesis can further be classified as
0irectional -ypothesis and >ondirectional
-ypothesis.
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
116/125
0irectional -ypothesis
!s a type of alternative hypothesis that specifies thedirection of e#pected findings.
Sometimes directional hypothesis are created to
e#amine the relationship among variables rather than
to compare groups.
0irectional hypothesis may read$'Kis more than..'$
Kwill be lesser..'
E.a*ple : Children %ith hih IL (i&&e5hi)it more an.iet$ than children %ith
lo% IL-
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
117/125
I i & i h 2ThI ti & ti th 2Th
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
118/125
Inuctie an &euctie ypotheses2TheoryInuctie an &euctie ypotheses2Theory
?uiling an Theory Testing%?uiling an Theory Testing%7lassified in terms of how7lassified in terms of how they were derived: !nductive hypothesis they were derived: !nductive hypothesis aa
generali*ation based on observationgenerali*ation based on observation
0eductive hypothesis derived from theory0eductive hypothesis derived from theory
ypotheses 8re the Empirical Counterparts o"
4 i i
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
119/125
4ropositions
7oncept 4%Reinforcement&
7oncept /%-abit&
8)stract
eel
Rupee )onus"or sales
olume oer
+uota
8lwaysma/es "our
sales call a
ay
Empirical
eel
The Role of -ypothesis
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
120/125
The Role of -ypothesis
!t guides the direction of the study
!t limits what shall be studied and what shall not
!t suggests which form of research design is li"ely to
be most appropriate!t provides a framewor" for organi*ing the conclusions
that result.
E.a*pleH"sbands and %i+es%ho sho"ld be st"diedFaree in their perceptions o' their respecti+eroles%hat shall be st"diedF in p"rchasindecisions%hat conte.t shall be st"diedF
Theory
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
121/125
4 theory is a set of interrelated constructs %concepts&$
definitions$ and propositions that present a systematic
view of phenomena by specifying relations among
variables$ with the purpose e#plaining and predictingthe phenomena )erlinger
A theory is a statement or set o
statements a)o%t the re&ationshisamon$ .aria)&es
Theory
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
122/125
The role of theory
9rgani*ing "nowledge and e#plaining laws
5redicting new laws
2uiding research
E5am&e o a Theory< 0o&%ntary ;o)T%rno.er
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
123/125
M
o b & e r ' o r * a n c
e
7a)o%r maret conditions4 n%m)er oor$ani8ations4 ersona& characteristics4
And other artia& determinantso ease o mo.ement
Percei.ed ease o mo.ement 3e!$!E5ectation o fndin$ a&ternati.es4
%nso&icited oort%nities6
Percei.ed desira)i&ity o mo.ement3e!$! /o) satisaction6
E9%ity o ay4 /o) com&e5ity4 articiationIn decision-main$4 and other artia&
Determinants o desira)i&ity o mo.ement
IntentionTo
:%it
0o&%ntary ;o)
T%rno.er
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
124/125
1odel
8/18/2019 Introduction c i
125/125
1odel
4 model is defined here as a representation of a system which is
constructed for the purpose of studying some aspect of that
system or the system as a whole
1odels differ from theories in that a theory‘s role is e#planation
whereas a model’s role is representation
4 model is not an e#planation@ it is only the result of ta"ing the
structure or function of one obect or process and using that as amodel for the second 7ooperLSchindler