99
HAL Id: inria-00073220 https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00073220 Submitted on 24 May 2006 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers. L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés. Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial Davide Sangiorgi To cite this version: Davide Sangiorgi. Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial. RR-3470, INRIA. 1998. inria-00073220

Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    3

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

HAL Id: inria-00073220https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00073220

Submitted on 24 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open accessarchive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-entific research documents, whether they are pub-lished or not. The documents may come fromteaching and research institutions in France orabroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, estdestinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documentsscientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,émanant des établissements d’enseignement et derecherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoirespublics ou privés.

Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: aTutorial

Davide Sangiorgi

To cite this version:Davide Sangiorgi. Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial. RR-3470, INRIA. 1998.�inria-00073220�

Page 2: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

ISS

N 0

249-

6399

ap por t de r ech er ch e

THÈME 1

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

Interpreting Functions as � -calculus Processes:a Tutorial

Davide Sangiorgi

N° 3470

Août 1998

Page 3: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE
Page 4: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis2004, route des Lucioles, B.P. 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France)

Téléphone : 04 92 38 77 77 - International : +33 4 92 38 77 77 — Fax : 04 92 38 77 65 - International : +33 4 92 38 77 65

��������������� �������������� ������������ �!����"��#��"$����%&���'�����(�����*)�,+-�.�����/ �� "

0�132(465/7981;:/<�46=�>�<�4

?#@!A$BDCDEGFIH�J�KLC�MON3P�C�QRKLS3KTQUA$BDC�KVXWUY[ZTC$QR\^]X_a`b]

HcMOded;YOWLQ�feCgWLCihj@eC$Wjhj@eC&k;lmOnporqsF t#YOueQ�E�vOvbwgFIvyx d!M[zbC�K

{�|�}�~$�r�e�O~O�?#@e��Kgd!MOd�C�Wg��Kgh$YOk!h$C$WUkeC�fs����QL@9QL@eC'WUC$��MrQU��Ybk!KL@e��d9�;C�QT��C$C$k-�e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!KgM[k�fs����h$MO��h$Ne��N!K$�'?#@eC

�e��h$M[��h�N!��N!K�QUMO���3K�MO��YbN3Q�j�3�������6�r�!��M[k�f�QL@eC���Wg�j�b�� ¡�6�j�r���£¢r¤g�;C$@!M¦¥p��YONeWi�?#@!��K*h�YOkyQUWUMbKTQjKX���§[email protected]@eCR���h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�¨[QU@!MrQ�QjM[���3K�M[�;YON3Q���©L�i�j¤ª�j�$¤ª�RMOk!f�QL@!C$��WR�£�!��¤$©L�O�$�«�£¢r¤���C�@!M¦¥p��YbNeWi��tcd!de����h$M[QL��YOk'��K�MgKLd�Cih���M[�¬ YbWLB­Y ¬ ��kbQUC$WjMOh�QL��YOk®¨;M[k!f�QL@!C$WUC ¬ YOWUC ¬ Nek!h�QL��YOk!KGh$MOk¯��C�KaC�C$k^MOKcM�Kad;C�h$��MO� ¬ YOWUB°Y ¬ deWLY3h$C�KUKaCiK$��±sCKaQLN�f3S.@eYr�²QL@eC ¬ Nek�hªQL��YOk�K�Y ¬ QL@eC��e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!Kg³´QL@eC��j�rµ����3���b¶� �¤ ¬ Nek!h�QL��YOk!Kj·#h$MOk��;C¸WLC�deWLCiKaC�kyQLC�f�MOK����h$MO��h$Ne��N!K¸deWUYph$C�KUKaCiK$�D?#@eCD����h$M[��h�N!��N!KgKLC$B'MOkbQU��h�K¸Y ¬ M¯��MOkezON!MOzOC ��k!feN!h�CiK�M�keY[QU��YbksY ¬ Ci¹bN�M[���§QTSYbk'QL@!C�QUC$WUB'K�Y ¬ QL@!M[Q���M[k!zON!MOzOCO�±9CRQU@eC$WUC ¬ YbWLCGM[��KaY�M[k!MO��S3KLC�QL@eC¸Ci¹bN�M[���§QTS'M[BDYbkez ¬ Nek�hªQL��YOk�K�QU@!MrQ��K#��k!f3N!h$C�f��pS'QL@eC���WRWLC�deWLCiKaC�kyQUMrQU��Ybk�MbK#����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K#deWUY3h�C�KUKLC�K��?#@e��K�d�M[d;C$W���K���kyQLC�k!f3C�f-MbK�M¯QUN3QLYbWL��M[����_�Q @eYr��C$¥bC$W�h�YbkyQUM[��k!K�KLYOBDC'YbWL��zO��k!M[�*h�YOkyQUWL���eN3QU��Ybk!K$�

?#@!CgBDMO��k¯YbkeC�K�MOWLCbº/QL@eC�N�KaCgY ¬ ��C$���§���pkeYr��k¼»��[�!���£�!�!�r���6�r�¾½��r�U�ª�£�p¿.À;�«Ár �¤¸QLWjM[k�K ¬ YbWLB'K�QLY.feC$WU��¥bCQU@eCgC$k�h�Y3f3��kezbK#��kyQLYD����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�MOk!f�d!WLYr¥bCRQU@eC$��WRh�YbWLWUC�h�QLkeCiKLK�ÂbQL@eCgC�k!h�Y3f3��kezDY ¬ �«Áj�e¤jï�3��h$MO��h$Ne�����

Ä^Å ~�Æ;� ?#@!��KR��K�M.f3WjM ¬ QRY ¬ M�hj@!M[d3QUC$WcY ¬ M'��YpYb��QU@!MrQR_�MOB­��WU�§QU��k!z.���§QU@ÈÇGM¦¥y��f¯±ÉM[���OC$Wi��_�k^QL@eC@!YOd;C�Y ¬ BDMO�p��kezGQU@eC�d!M[d;C$W*KaC�� ¬ ��h�YbkbQjM[��keC�f®¨[_�@�M¦¥OC�MOfefeC�fDM[ded;C$k�f3��h$C�K/����QL@'�!Mbhj�pzOWUYONek!f�B'MrQLC�WL��M[�Ybk�����h$MO��h$Ne��N!K$�

»��rµ�µD¤$�!�«�jÊ�©L¤$µD�[©jË�Ê*¤$���iÌX�r©U¤�Í��[©ªµ  ¡Á��j�O�;©L¤j���6�[��¤jÃbΣÎ

{D�iÏ(Ð ÅpÑDÒ ÆyÓÔ;ÆpÕÉÆ3Ð;~i}O� _�M[BÖ��k!f3C$�eQLC�f.QLY�Ç�M¦¥p��f'±9MO���bC$W ¬ YOW#f3C�QjM[����Cif.h�YbB�BDC�kbQjK�Ybk�M�deWUC$¥p��YON!KfeWUM ¬ Q¸Y ¬ QU@e��Kgd!M[d;C$Wi�'_¸M[��KaY���C�keC�×!QLC�f ¬ WUYOBØf3��KUh�N�KLKL��Ybk!K¸����QL@É�pS9ÙGJ$WjM[WjfÈÚ�YbN!f3YO��¨(Û!C$BD�OC'Ü�MOkHRMOM[B'KUf3YOk!�;¨!Ý*@eWU��KTQU��keCgH�Þ3hj�p���

ß Æyà�á Ñ�Å �rÓ}O� �e��h$M[��h�N!��N!K�¨O����h$MO��h$Ne��N!K$¨OQTSpd�CiK$¨bWLCif3N!hªQU��Ybk'KTQUWUM[QLC$zb��CiK$¨r�;C$@�M¦¥y��YON!WUMO�3C�¹yNe��¥¦MO��C�k!h�CiK$¨¬ N!���(MO�!KaQLWjMOhªQU��Ybk

â(ãTä�ãaåjæ6ç�ègä�éiê¦ê[ëªæ6ì«ãTí¸î$ïcì«è¦ã�ê¦æ6ëjð«ãTç�ì/ñ(ò/ó(ô!õ;â÷ö´øRù§ú�û�ö´øiüaýªþªÿ����

Page 5: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

���L $���������������¸� $�����������r�������/ ��������*���� ����'�����(������¯�� �!�*��"$����"

�� }��Õ � � � CsKLNrZTC�Q^f3C9h�C�Q^M[WLQL��h���C¾CiKTQ���M¼WLC���M[QL��YOk C$kyQUWLCs��CÉ�3��h$MO��h$Ne��C$Q���CÈ����h$MO��h$Ne��� � C�e��h$M[��h�N!�*d!MOWL��C�feC�K¸���r�������6�r�!��C�Q'f3C���C�NeW^�U�[µR�e�r©ª��¤$µD¤$�!���ª�O�� §�6�U�[�«� �j� ]Xk WLC�¥¦MOk!hj@eCb¨X��C�����h�M[��h�Ne�d�M[WU��C¸f3C�K*�;©L���j¤��j�j�p�¸C�Qcf3C¸��C$NeW��j�[µR�e�r©ª��¤�µ'¤$�!���£����¤$©L�b����� �j� ��� M[ded!����h$M[QL��YOk�CiKTQ�Nek!C ¬ YbWLBDC¸Kad;J�h$��MO��Cf � ��kyQLC$WjMOh�QL��YOk®¨3C$Qcf3YOk!h¸N!keC ¬ YOk!h�QL��YOk!K�d;C$NeQ���QLWUC¸¥pNeC�h�YbB�BDC¸Nek^h$MbK#d!M[WLQL��h�N!����C$W�f3CgdeWUY3h�CiKLKLN!K���RYON!K�J�QUN!f3��YOk!K�h�YbBDB�C�kyQ*��C�K ¬ YOk!h�QL��YOk!K�f3N¯�3��h$MO��h$Ne�³6��CiK ¬ Ybk!hªQU��Ybk!Kg�j�r ��$�3 ��b¶� �¤��i·*d�C�Ne¥OC�kyQ���QUWLC

WUC$d!WLJiKaC�kbQUJ$CiKRh�YbBDB�C�deWUY3h�C�KUKLN!KRf3Ns����h�M[��h�Ne��� � M�KaJ�B'M[kyQL��¹yNeC�C�kÈ����h$M[��h�N!�/f � Neks��MOkezbMOzOC���k!f3N!�§QN!keC^keY[QU��Ybk f � J�zbMO����QLJ¾KLNeW.��C�KDQUC$WUBDC�K.f3C¾h$C^��MOkezbMOzOCb� VMOW�h�Ybk!KLJ�¹yNeC$kyQ'keYbN!K.M[k�M[��SpKLYOk�K'M[N!KUKa�� � J$zbMO����QLJ#C�kbQUWLC ¬ Ybk!hªQU��Ybk!K�¹yNe��C�KaQ���k!feNe�§QUCcd!MOWX��C�NeW�WUC$deWUJ�KLC$kyQUM[QL��YOkDh�YbB�BDC�deWUY3h�CiKLKLN!KXf3ND����h$M[��h�N!�«�Ý*C$Q*M[WLQL��h���C�C�KaQ*h�Ybk���N'h$YOBDBDCcNek��TQLN3QUYOWU��MO���ª���RJ�M[k!B�Yb��k�K$¨b���;h�YOkyQU��C�kbQ�¹bN!C$��¹bN!C�K�h$YOkyQLWU���!N3QL��YOk!K

YbWL��zO��k!MO��CiK$� � C�K#d!WL��k!h���d!MO��CiK�KLYOkyQiº� � N3QL������KUMrQL��YOk¯f3CGQLWjM[k�K ¬ YbWLB'MrQU��Ybk!K »X�[�!���£�!�!�[�«�6�[��½��¦�j�ª�£�y¿.À���Ár �¤�!��C�kÉh$YOkekpNeCiKgd;YONeW�feJ$WU��¥bC$Wg��C�K�h$Ypf!M[zOCiKgfeM[k�Kg��C�����h�M[��h�Ne��C$Q�d�YbNeW�d!WLYbNe¥OC�WG��C$N!W�h�YbWLWUC�h�QL��YOk®Â��Ch$Y3feM[zbCGf3N¾�e��h�M[��h�Ne�X��Áj�! ��" Å ~i}�áj� Ò#� }�� �e��h�M[��h�Ne��¨O����h$MO��h$Ne�«¨[QTSyd;C�K�¨pKTQUWUM[QLJ$zb��CiK/f3CcWUJ�f3N!h�QL��YOk®¨OJ�¹yNe��¥¦MO��C�k!h�CiK�h�YbBDd�YbWaQUC$BDC$k3�QjM[��C�K�¨eM[�!KaQLWjMOh�QL��YOk�h�YOBDde��C�QUC

Page 6: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

���!��¤�©��;©L¤$�«�£�p¿R�j�3�������6�r�!�g�r�#���a�j�[ ����3 §�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª� m

� � ����c����

����� Æ � áU�b� Ò � � Ò ��}

�� Å Ð;~$�r�e}�~� 6Ð�Ô � �!Ð�Ó � �� ��E H�C�f3N�hªQL��YOk¯MrP3��YOB'K��g�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�G�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G� v� � � � C�¹yNeC�kbQU��MO����QTS �g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�G�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G� Eiq� � m Ý*YOk��!N!C$k!h$C �G�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�G�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G� EbE

� ÆpÓ����[~� Å Ð }�~$�r�3~iÆpÔ� ´Æp}�� Å �.~ � Æ � áj�O� Ò � � Ò �(} ��m!��E Ý�M[���§���pSb��k!MOB�C �g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�G�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G� E �m!� � Ý�M[���§���pSb��¥rM[��NeC �g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�G�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G� Eimm!� m Ý�M[���§���pSb��keC�C�f��G�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�G�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G� E�n

��� Ð;~�Æy���(�rÆy~� 6Ð�Ô � áU�b� Ò � � Ò � «Ð;~ ÅÉ� áU�b� Ò � � Ò ��} ���n���E Ý*YOkyQL��kpN!MrQU��Ybk�V/MOKUKa��kez � QTSp��C �¸�g�g�G�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�G�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G� E��

� ��� Æ! «Ð;~�Æy���(�rÆy~��3~� Å Ð Å ���O� Ò´Ò áU|�à�á#"e� Ò �(Æ ��$xe��E ?#@eCGQL@eWUC$C�KaQLC�d!K¼�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�G�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G� Eroxe� � Ý*YOBDd�YyKa��kez QL@eC�KaQLC�d!K �¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�G�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G� � mxe� m VMOWUMO����C$�÷h�M[���§���pSb��¥rM[��NeC �¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�G�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G� � o

%&��� Æ! «Ð;~�Æy���(�rÆy~��3~� Å Ð Å ���O� Ò´Ò áU|�à�ájÐ��!ÕÉÆ �$�e� qe��E Ý*YOBDd�YyKa��kez�QL@!C�KTQUC$d!Ks�¸�g�g�G�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�G�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G� mbq

$ { �Ð' (� Å �[Õ,Æ3Ð�� Å Ó) 6Ð�Ô �*�

+,�(~� 6Õ- ´}i�3~� Å Ð�} Å �c~ � ƾ�O� Ò6Ò áU|�à�áªÐ(�!ÕÉÆsÆ3Ð(� Å Ó. «Ð(Ô �/$

�&0 Ð�� Å Ó) 6Ð�Ôs~ � Æ!1�� � Ò Æ �

��2!� Ð;~�Æy���(�rÆy~� 6Ð�Ô-~jà3��ÆpÓ � áU�O� Ò � � Ò �/2Eiqe��E-?#@eC¸��kyQLC�WLd!WLC$QUMrQU��Ybk�Y ¬ QTSpd;C�f¯h$MO�������pSy��¥¦MO��N!C��¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�G�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G� nyqEiqe� � ?#@eC¸��kyQLC�WLd!WLC$QUMrQU��Ybk�Y ¬ QTSpd;C�f¯h$MO�������pSy��k!M[BDC��¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�G�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G� nbn

â�â54�6!þ87:98;

Page 7: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

n � Ì(À��[�y¿O�6�r©«¿O�

�/��� � Ò´Ò �e|}�~$�r�e�[~� Å Ð � $EbEO��EÉtRdede����h�MrQU��¥bCg�e��KL��B�����M[WU�§QTS �g�¸�g�g�G�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�G�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G�g� nywEbEO� � � YONek!fekeC�KUK�M[k!f�keYbk3��h�YOBDde��C�QUC$keCiKLKÖ�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�G�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G�g� nyv

� 0�� ~�Æ3Ð�Ó. 6Ð�ÔÉ~ � Æ � áU�b� Ò � � Ò ��} � �E � ��EÉ?#@!C�f3��KUh�WU��B���k!M[QL��kezDd�Yr��C$W#Y ¬ C�PpQLC�k!f3Cif¯�e��h$M[��h�N!��� �¸�g�G�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G�g� x[nE � � � ]�k!h�Y3f3��kezDQL@!CgYOd;C$WjMrQLYbWUK*Y ¬ QL@!C��3��C�PpQLC�k!KL��Ybk!K#��kyQUY�����h$MO��h$Ne��N!K.�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G�g� x �

��� � � Æ Ò´Å �O� Ò }�~$� �(�O~��(�rÆ Å ��~ � Æ � á 6Ð;~iÆy� ���rÆy~��3~� Å Ð � Eime��E � C$k!KL���!��C¸QU@eC$YbWL��C�K#M[k�f���M���S'QL@!C$YOWU��C�K,�¸�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�G�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G�g� xOvEime� � � J$¥pSy� � YOkezbY ?�WLC�C�K�MOk!f�QL@eC¸��Yph�M[�®KaQLWUN!hªQUNeWUC�QU@eC$YbWLC�B �G�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G�g� �bqEime� m ?#@!CgdeWLYpY ¬ Y ¬ QL@eCg��Y3h$MO�®KTQUWLN!h�QLNeWUCGQL@eC�YOWUC$B �g�g�¸�g�¸�g�G�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G�g� � �Eime� n Ú�Þb@eB°?�WLC�C�K �g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�G�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G�g� �bwEime� x � Y3h$M[�®KaQLWUN!h�QLNeWUC¸Y ¬ QU@eC�h$MO�������ySy��¥rM[��NeC�C�k!h�Y3f3��kezD�¸�g�¸�g�G�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G�g� �bv

� � Ä^Å ~�Æp} $*2

{ � � Æ � áj�O� Ò � � Ò �(} $ �t�� q!��EIVXWLY3h$C�KUKaCiK �g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�G�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G�g� ornt�� q!� ��� d�C�WUM[QL��YOk!MO��KLC$B'MOkbQU��h�K �g�G�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�G�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G�g� o �t�� q!� m ?#@eCgMOKLSyk�hj@eWLYbkeYON�K�����h$MO��h$Ne��N�K �g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�G�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G�g� o �

Æ � � "3 Å �®�r� Ò Æ�� �. "e� Ò Æ3Ð��OÆp} $*%ÚG� qe� n Ú�MOWL�;C�f�h�YbkezOWUNeC�k!h�C9�¸�g�g�G�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�G�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G�g� o �ÚG� qe� x ÙGWLYbNek!f��e��KL��B�����M[WU�§QTS �g�g�G�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�G�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G�g� o[wÚG� qe� � ±sCiM[�.Ci¹bN!��¥rM[��C$k�h�C�K°�¸�g�g�G�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�G�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G�g� o[wÚG� qe�¡o ?#@eC¸C�P3d!M[k�Ka��YOk�WLC���M[QL��YOks�g�G�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�G�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G�g� o[vÚG� qe� w ?(Cihj@eke��¹bN!C�K#Y ¬ �T�!��KL��B Ne��MrQL��YOk�Ned�QLY �Ø�g�¸�g�¸�g�G�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G�g� o[vÚG� qe� v � YOBDC¸��M¦�cK ¬ YbW#QL@eCg����h$MO��h$Ne��N!K �g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�G�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G�g� o[v

ÚG��E ]XPyQUC$k!KL��YOk!KcMOk!f�QTSyd;C�K �g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�G�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G�g� wbqÚG��EO��E � YOBDCgh�Ybky¥bC$kyQL��YOk�K�MOk!f�keY[QjMrQL��YOk ¬ YOW#QTSpd;C�f¯h$MO��h$Ne���Ø�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G�g� wbqÚG��EO� � V�Yb��SyMOf3��h���QTS �¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�G�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G�g� w!EÚG��EO� m� ��� QTSyd;C�K��g�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�G�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G�g� w!EÚG��EO� n � ��keC�MOWL��QTS.M[k!f�WUC�h$C$d3QU��¥bC$keCiKLK �¸�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�G�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G�g� w �ÚG��EO� x ?�Spd;C�K�M[k�f��;C$@!M¦¥bYONeWjM[��Ci¹bN!��¥rM[��C$k�h�C�K��g�¸�g�¸�g�G�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G�g� w �ÚG��EO� � ?#@eCgKTQUWLYbkezDWLC�de����h$M[QL��YOk�QL@eC�YOWUC$B'K �g�g�¸�g�¸�g�G�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G�g� wbmÚG��EO�¡o tc�!KaQLWjMOh�QL��YOk!K �g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�G�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G�g� wOnÚG��EO� w ?#@eCgf3C$��M¦SOCif���kedeN3Q �¸�g�g�G�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�G�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G�g� wOn

�´ó�â����

Page 8: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

���!��¤�©��;©L¤$�«�£�p¿R�j�3�������6�r�!�g�r�#���a�j�[ ����3 §�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª� x

� ��� Æ�� 6Ô � Æy��á +D�rÓÆb� � áU�O� Ò � � Ò ��} �

� � Å Õ-�. Ò 6Ð�Ô-�eÔ�Æ3Ð;~���e}�}� 6Ð�Ô 6Ð;~ Å Ð(�!ÕÉÆ ��e}i}� «Ð(Ô $Ç�� qe� v ]/PpQLC$k�Ka��YOk!K �g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�G�g�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�¸�g�g�G� wbv

â�â54�6!þ87:98;

Page 9: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

� � Ì(À��[�y¿O�6�r©«¿O�

� �g� ��G�¸� �� ���

t�feC$C$d-KaQLN!feSÈY ¬ WUC$deWUC�KLC$kyQUM[QL��YOk!KGY ¬*¬ Nek�hªQL��YOk�K�MOK¸����h$MO��h$Ne��N�KgdeWUYph$C�KUKaCiKG��KgY ¬ ��kyQLC�WLCiKTQ ¬ YOW KaC�¥b�C�WUMO�/WLCiMOKLYOk!K���Û!WLYbB QL@!C'����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K¸d;YO��kbQ�Y ¬ ¥p��C$�g¨÷QU@eC'WUC$deWUC�KLC$kyQUM[QL��YOks��KgM¯KL��zbke�§×;h$M[kyQ¸QLCiKTQ�Y ¬C$P3deWLCiKLKL��¥OC$k!C�KUK$¨pM[k!f���K#@!C$��d ¬ Ne�÷��k�zbC�QLQL��kez�feC$C$d;C$W���k!KL��zb@yQ���kyQLY�QL@eCGQU@eC$YbWLSb�/Û!WLYbBÖQL@eC��e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!Kd;YO��kyQGY ¬ ¥p��C��g¨�QL@eC�WLC�deWUC�KLC$kyQUM[QL��YOk¯B'M[�OCiKR��Q¸d�YyKLKL���!��C�QLY¯M[dede��S¯deWUYph$C�KUKT��h$MO��h$Ne��N!K�QUC�hj@eke��¹yNeC�KRQLY�e��h$M[��h�N!��N!K�¨(MOk!fÉM[��KaY�QLY¾MOk!M[��S3KaC'�3��QLC�WLB'Kg��k-h�YbkbQUC�PpQUK¸��@!��hj@ÉM[WUCDkeY[QgdeNeWUC$��SsKLC�¹yNeC�kyQL��M[���D?#@!��KKaQLN�f3SsB'M¦Ss��C�N!KaC ¬ Ne� ¬ YbW�deWUYr¥p��fe��kez^M¾KLC$B'MOkbQU��h ¬ YbNek!feM[QL��YOk ¬ YbW���M[kezbN!M[zbC�K¸@!M¦¥p��kez¾h�Ybk!KTQUWLN�hªQUK¬ YbW ¬ Nek�hªQL��YOk�K�MOk!f ¬ YbW h�Ybk!h�N!WLWUC$k!h$SO¨XM[k�fÉQLCihj@eke��¹bN!C�K ¬ YOW�WUC�MbKaYbke��kezÈM[�;YONeQ�QL@!C$B�³´�;C$@!M¦¥p��YONeWjM[�Ci¹yN!M[���§QU��CiK��;C�QT��C$C$k ¬ Nek�hªQL��YOk�KcdeWUC�KLC$WU¥OCif���k^KaCi¹bN!C$kyQL��M[�(h$YOkyQLC$PpQUK�B'M¦S�k!Y[Qc�;C�deWUC�KLC$WU¥OC�f���k�k!YOk3�KLC�¹yNeC�kyQL��M[��h$YOkyQLC$PyQjK$¨��C.Ka@!MO����KaC�C.C�PeMOB�d!��CiKgY ¬ QL@!��K���k � CihªQU��Ybk EOEi·���?#@!C�KTQUN!f3S9B'M¦S9MO��KLY^��C@!C$��d ¬ Ne�!��k'f3C$¥bC$��YOdeBDC�kbQ�Y ¬ d�M[WjM[����C��3��BDde��C$BDC$kyQjMrQL��YOk�KXY ¬;¬ Nek!h�QL��YOk!MO�!��M[kezbN!M[zbC�K/M[k!f���kDQL@eCcfeC�KL��zbkY ¬ deWUYOzbWUMOBDB���kez���MOkezON�M[zOCiK���MOKLC�f�YOk�deWLY3h$C�KUK�h$M[��h�N!�����

����������

?#@!CGd�M[d;C$W#��K#��f3CiM[����S�fe��¥p��f3C�f���kyQUY ¬ YbNeW�d!MOWaQjK$�X?#@eCG×!WjKTQ�³«h�YOBDdeWU��Ka��kez � C�h�QL��YOk!K¸E�QLY'mb·*��K�M[�;YON3QQU@eC-�3��h$MO��h$Ne��N�K$��?#@eCÉKLC�h�Ybk!f ³ � C�h�QL��YOk!K�n QUY vy·.��K¯M[�;YON3Q�QL@!CsC�k!h�Y3f3��kez¼Y ¬ QL@!C9N!kbQTSpd;C�f �3�h�M[��h�Ne��N!K���kbQUY ����h$MO��h$Ne��N!K$�XV/M[WLQ�m�³ � C�h�QL��YOkÈEiqb·*f3YpC�K*QL@!C¸KUM[BDC ¬ YOW�QL@!C�QTSpd;C�f��3��h$MO��h$Ne��N�K$�XV/M[WLQ�n³ � C�h�QL��YOk!K EOE�QLY¾Eimb·���KRMO��YbN3QRQU@eC ¬ N!���XM[��KTQUWUMbhªQL��YOk¯deWUYO�!��C�B ¬ YbWcQU@eC KL��BDde��C�KaQ�Y ¬ QL@eC�����h$M[��h�N!��N!KC�k!h�Y3f3��kezyK$¨ek�M[BDC$��S�QU@!MrQ�Y ¬ QL@eC�NekyQTSyd;C�f^h�M[���§���pSy��k!MOBDCg�e��h$M[��h�N!��N!K���t&BDYOWUC�f3C�QjM[����Cif^KaN!B�B'MOWLS¬ Yb����Yr�cK��_�k � C�h�QL��YOk E���C�WUC$¥p��C$�ÖQU@eC^KaSpkyQUM[P-MOk!f WUC�feN!hªQU��Ybk¼WUNe��CiK�Y ¬ QU@eC¯NekyQTSyd;C�f �3��h$MO��h$Ne��N!K$�¼_�k� C�hªQU��Ybk � ¨*��C^��YyYb�¼MrQ�KLYOBDC¯deWUYOd;C$WLQL��C�KDY ¬ QL@!Cs�3��h$MO��h$Ne��N!K�QL@!M[Q.B'M[�OC¯��Q�KTQUWL���p��k!zO��S¼f3���;C�WLC�kbQ¬ WUYOBÖQU@eC¸����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�ºXKaCi¹bN!C$kyQL��M[���§QTS'MOk!f�h$YOk��!N!C$k!h$CO�X±9CGMO��KLY�QUYON!hj@�YOk�QL@eCgf3���;C�WLC�k!h�CiK#M[k!f�QL@eCKL��B�����M[WU�§QU��CiK#��C$QT�*C�C$k�QL@eCg�!MbKa��h¸h�YbB�d!N3QUM[QL��YOk!MO�÷WLNe��C�K#Y ¬ QU@eC¸QT�*Y'h�M[��h�Ne���«�t �e�«QUC$WUB B'M¦Sg@!M¦¥OC#KLC$¥OC�WUMO�bWUC�feN!h����e��C�KLNe�3QUC$WUBDK��/t ©U¤UÃ[�!�����6�r���ª�«©L�[��¤�¿OÁgKad;C�h$�§×!CiKXMRWUC�feN!hªQU��Ybk

YbWUfeC$Wi� ?#@!C^B�YyKTQ'��BDd�YbWaQjM[kyQ.WLCif3N!h�QL��YOk KTQUWUM[QLC$zb��CiKDM[WUC¯h�M[���§���pSy��k!MOBDC�MOk!f h�M[���§���pSy��¥rM[��NeCb¨*M[k�f¥rMOWL��M[kyQUK�Y ¬ QL@eCiKaCÉKaN�hj@ MOK�d!MOWUMO����C$�¸h$MO�������ySy��¥rM[��NeCÈM[k�f²h$MO�������ySy��keC$Cif ³£QU@eCÉ��MbKTQ¯��K�MbhªQUN!M[����S MOk��BDde��C$BDC$kyQUM[QL��YOk-QUC�hj@ek!��¹yNeCb¨XWUM[QL@eC�W�QL@�M[k¼MÈWLCif3N!hªQU��Ybk KTQUWUM[QLC�zOSe·ª�s±sC�WLC�¥y��C$� QU@eC�KLC�KaQLWjMrQUC$zO��C�KMOk!f�QL@eC���Wcd!WLYbd�C�WaQU��CiK*��k � C�h�QL��YOk^me�� CihªQU��Ybk.ng��C�zO��k!K�QL@eCRh$YOWUC�Y ¬ QU@eCcd!MOd�C�W�¨y��@e��hj@'��K*M[�;YON3Q*QL@eCcC�k!h�Y3f3��kezyK�Y ¬ �e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!K*KTQUWUM[QLC��

zb��CiKD��kyQUY9����h$MO��h$Ne��N!K$� ±9C¾M[k!MO��S3KLC�QU@eC^C$k�h�Y3f3��kezÉY ¬ h�M[���§���pSy��¥rM[��NeC���k � CihªQU��Ybk xe¨�MOk!f QU@!MrQ.Y ¬h�M[���§���pSy��k!MOBDC*��k � C�h�QL��YOk��e�±sC�f3C$WU��¥bC#��YOQL@DC$k!h$Y3f3��k!zbK ¬ WUYOB ��C$�������pkeYr��k9»��r�!���£�!�!�[�«�6�[�'½c�¦�j�ª�£�y¿À;�«Ár �¤�QUWUMOk!K ¬ YbWLB'K�³6��@e��hj@�QUWUMOk!K ¬ YbWLB ¬ Nek!h�QL��YOk!KX�pS�MOfef3��kez�h$YOkyQL��kpN!MrQU��Ybk!K/QLY¸QU@eC$B.·XMOk!f�QL@!CRh�YbB �d!����MrQU��Ybk^Y ¬ QL@eC��g�§¿��p¤$© ����©UÃO¤$©R���a�j�r ��$�3 ¡�p�.³�� � �(·���kyQLY.����h$MO��h$Ne��N�K$�#Ü�M[WU��M[kyQUK#Y ¬ QU@eC�KLC�KaQLWjMrQUC$zO��C�KMOk!f.C�k!h�Y3f3��kezyK�MOWLC�C�PeM[BD��keC�f���k � CihªQL��YOk�K�o�M[k�f�we�X?#@eCgKaQLWjMrQUC$zO��C�K�h�Ybk!KL��f3C�WLCif'Ned�QLY QL@e��K#d;YO��kbQfeY^keY[Q�MO����Yr� WUC�feN!hªQU��Ybk!Kg��k!Ka��f3CDQU@eC.�;YpfeSsY ¬ M ¬ Nek�hªQL��YOk(��?�C�hj@ek!��h�M[����S9Kad;C�MO�y��kez�¨®QL@!C$SÉf3Y^keY[QMO����Yr� QU@eC 1 WUNe��C¸Y ¬ QU@eC��e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!K��X_�k � CihªQU��Ybk¯v���Cgf3��KUh�N�KLK#��@eC�k^M[k!f�@eYr� QU@eC 1 WLNe��C¸B'M¦S.��CC�k!h�Y3f3Cif÷�_�k � C�h�QL��YOkÈEiq���C�Mbfef3WUC�KUK���@!M[Q�@!MOded;C$k!K*QLY�QL@eC�QTSpd�C¸KaQLWUN!hªQUNeWLCGY ¬÷¬ N!k!hªQU��Ybk!K���@eC$k�QL@eC�S.M[WUC

WUC$d!WLCiKaC�kbQUC�f�MOK#deWUY3h�C�KUKLC�K��_�k¾�e��h�M[��h�Ne����¨pQTSyd;C�KRM[WUCGMbKLKL��zbkeC�f�QLY�QUC$WUBDK�¨!MOk!f�d!WLYr¥p��f3CgM[k¯M[�!KaQLWjMOh�Q¥p��C$�-Y ¬ QL@eC���W�;C$@!M¦¥p��YONeWi�(_�k�h$YOkyQLWjMOKaQ�¨¦��k�QU@eC�QTSpd;C�KLS3KTQUC$B'K ¬ YOW�QL@eC�����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K(QTSpd�CiKMOWLC*MOKUKa��zOkeCifQUY^k!M[BDCiK�M[k!fÉ@!C$k!h$C'WLC�¥OC�MO�X¥OC�WLS¾����QaQL��C�MO��YbN3Q��;C$@!M¦¥p��YONeWjM[�XdeWUYOd;C$WLQL��C�K¸Y ¬ [email protected]!WLY3h�CiKLKLC�K���?#@eC

�´ó�â����

Page 10: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

���!��¤�©��;©L¤$�«�£�p¿R�j�3�������6�r�!�g�r�#���a�j�[ ����3 §�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª� o

KLC$B'MOkbQU��h�WLC���M[QL��YOk!KL@e��dG�;C�QT��C$C�kGQL@eC�QT�*Y ¬ YbWLB'K÷Y ¬ QTSpd;C�K(��K®QL@eC�WLC ¬ YOWUCXkeY[Q®Yb�y¥p��YON!K����Rk!f3C$WjKaQUM[k�f3��k!z@!Yr� �3��h$MO��h$Ne��N!KGQTSpd�CiKGMOWLC QLWjM[k�K ¬ YbWLBDC�fÈ�pS¯QL@eCD����h$M[��h�N!��N!K¸C�k!h�Y3f3��kezyK���KG��BDd;YOWLQUMOkbQg� ¬ ��C ����KL@QUYDN!KaC�QL@!CG����h$MO��h$Ne��N!K#MOK#M KLC$B'MOkbQU��h��!MbKa��K ¬ YOW�QTSpd�Cif�deWUYOzbWUMOBDB���kez���M[k!zON!MOzOC�K��±sC¸��YyYb�.MrQ�QL@eCKL��B�d!��Sy��QTSyd;C�f^�e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!K#��k^f3C�QjM[���«¨eMOk!f��eWL��C ��S�f3��KLh$N!KLK#C$PpQLC$k�Ka��YOk!K��Ú�YOQL@ ¬ YOWXQTSpd;C�f'MOk!f ¬ YOW�NekyQTSpd;C�f.�e��h�M[��h�Ne���«¨b�*CcfeC$WU��¥bC�����h�M[��h�Ne��N!KXC�k!h�Y3f3��kezbK�Y ¬ h$M[�������pSy��k�M[BDC

MOk!fÉh$MO�������pSy��¥¦MO��N!C ��kÈQU@eWUC$C.KaQLC$d�K$ºgMÈÝ�V � QLWjM[k�K ¬ YbWLB¯¨÷QU@eCD��k!h$��N�Ka��YOkÉY ¬ Ý�V � QLC�WLB'K¸��kyQLY � � �X¨QU@eC¯h�YOBDde����MrQL��YOk ¬ WUYOB � � � QLYs����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K��s?#@e��K���K N!KaC ¬ Ne� ¬ YOW�Nek!f3C�WUKaQUMOk!f3��kez¾QU@eC�C�k!h�Y3f3��kezbKMOk!f ¬ YOWXdeWUYr¥p��k!z�QU@eC$��W�deWUYOd;C$WLQL��C�K��/Ý*Ybkp¥OC$WjKLC$��SO¨!��©L¤j�OÃO¤$©(���[µ �£ ¡�6�[©�ÍX�£� �¸���a�U�[ ��$�3 ¡�p��µ �§¿��b������Ãg� �p¤¤$�;�j�iÃr�£�p¿r� �3¤�  �i�j�3 3���r© �3�;ÃO¤$©j�ª���[�;Ã[�£�y¿����3¤�»(½*À9��©L�[�e�´���r©ªµ ������k�f3C$Cif÷¨�YbkeC�h�M[k¾M[��KLY'zOYDQL@!C�Y[QU@eC$W�#M¦S�WLYbNek!f÷¨;M[k!f^N�KaCgQU@eC�����h$MO��h$Ne��N!KcC�k!h�Y3f3��kezbKcQLY�f3C$WU��¥bCgWLCiKaN!�§QjKRM[�;YONeQRQL@!C h�YbWLWUC�h�QLkeCiKLK#Y ¬ QL@eCÝ�V � QUWUMOk!K ¬ YOWUBDKTF KaC�CGH�C�B'M[WU��x3� � Eb¨ ¬ YbW���k�KTQjM[k!h$CO�?#@!C�C$k!h$Ypfe��kez�Y ¬ NekyQTSyd;C�f'h�M[���§���pSy��k!MOBDC��e��h$M[��h�N!��N!KR³«���È·/��KXQL@!CRKa��BDde��C�KaQ�M[k!fDd;C$WU@!M[d�KXBDYbKaQ

k�MrQLN!WUMO�XC$k!h$Ypfe��kez^Y ¬ �e��h$M[��h�N!��N!K¸��kyQLY^����h$MO��h$Ne��N�K$�'_�k � CihªQL��YOk EbE���C'KTQUN!f3SÈQL@eC'Ci¹bN�M[���§QTSsYOk-�3�QUC$WUB'K/��k!feN!h�Cif �pSgQU@e��KXC$k!h$Y3f3��k!z!�/?#@e��K/Ci¹yN!M[���§QTSb¨���¨[WUC$��MrQUC�KQT��Y¸�e�«QUC$WUB'K/� ¬ QL@eC���W�C$k!h$Ypfe��kezyK/M[WUC�;C$@�M¦¥y��YON!WUMO����Sy��Ci¹bN!��¥rM[��C$kyQ/����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K/deWUY3h�CiKLKLC�K���t�K��;C$@!M¦¥p��YONeWjM[�pC�¹yNe��¥rM[��C$k!h$C ¬ YOW/QU@eCc����h$M[��h�N!��N!K��C�hj@eYpYyKaC.��M[WU��Cif-h�YOk!zOWUNeC$k!h$CO�^?#@eC�WLCiKaNe��QUK�YO�3QjM[��keC�f-MOWLCb¨/@eYr�*C�¥OC�W�¨���MOWLzbC$��SÈ��k!f3C$d;C$k�f3C$kyQ Y ¬QU@e��K hj@eYb��h$CO¨/f3NeC'QUY¾QU@eC�KLd�Cih���M[� ¬ YbWLB Y ¬ QU@eC�deWUY3h�CiKLKLC�KgC�k!h�Y3f3��kezÈ�e�«QUC$WUB'K$�¾?#@eC�KLMOB�C�WLCiKaNe��QUK@!YO��f÷¨ ¬ YOW���k!KaQUMOk!h�Cb¨ ¬ YOW#QLCiKTQU��k!z'C�¹yNe��¥¦MO��C�k!h�C¸YbW*QUWUMbh�C¸C�¹yNe��¥rM[��C$k!h$CO�±9CG��C�zO��k��pS'h�YbB�d�M[WU��kez�� ����[email protected]@eC¸C�¹yN!MO����QTSDzO��¥OC$k��pSDQL@eCGYOd;C$WjMrQU��Ybk!M[��KaC�B'M[kyQL��h$K*Y ¬ ���-�

?#@!C���MrQLQLC$W�h�M[k��;C ¬ YOWUB�Ne��MrQUC�f.MbK#M ¬ YOWUB�Y ¬ �e��KL��B�����M[WU�§QTSb¨÷�ª�O�; ¡�6�j�r���£¢¦¤'¶����j�£µ��£ ��[©ª�£�«Ár��tck���kyQLC�WLd!WLC$�QjMrQU��Ybk9Y ¬ M¯h$MO��h$Ne��N!K¸��K'���[�3�;ÃÈ� ¬ ��Q�C�¹yN!MrQUC�K¸Ybke��SÈYOd;C$WjMrQL��YOk�M[����S^Ci¹bN!��¥rM[��C$kyQ¸QLC�WLB'K�¨*�j�rµ��� �¤$��¤.� ¬��QRCi¹bN�MrQLCiK�M[���÷YOd;C$WjMrQU��Ybk!M[����S�C�¹yNe��¥¦MO��C�kyQ�QUC$WUB'K$¨!MOk!fD�j�3 £ ¡Á��y¶j�ª��©L�O�$�#� ¬ �§Qc��KcKLYONek�f�MOk!f�h�YOBDde��C�QUCO�±9C�KL@!M[���®KaC�C¸QL@!M[Q#QL@eCg����h$MO��h$Ne��N�K#��kyQLC�WLd!WLC$QUMrQU��Ybk�Y ¬ ��� ��KcKLYON!k!f÷¨3�eN3Qck!Y[QRh�YbBDde��C$QLCb�± @!C$ksMOkÈ��kyQLC$WUdeWUC�QjMrQL��YOkÈY ¬ M�h$MO��h$Ne��N�KR��K¸KaYbNek!f¾�!N3QgkeY[Q ¬ Ne����S¾MO�!KTQUWUMbhªQi¨;YbkeC�BDM¦S¯@eYbd�C�QUY

Mbhj@e��C$¥OC ¬ Ne���eM[�!KaQLWjMOh�QL��YOk��pSgC$k!WL��hj@e��kezcQU@eC�h�M[��h�Ne��N!K��*³«?#@e��K/��KC�P3C$BDde����×!C�f��yS¸QU@eC�KaYb��NeQL��YOk!K(QLY�QL@eC¬ N!����MO�!KTQUWUMbhªQU��Ybk^deWLYb�e��C$B ¬ YOW¸V*Ý�Û(F M�QTSpd�Cifs�e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!KGC�PpQUC$k!f3Cif¾����QL@È×eP3C�f¾d;YO��kyQUK�¨���YpYO��C�MOkMOk!fÈMOWL��QL@!B�C$QL��h ¬ CiMrQUNeWLCiK�F deWUYOd;YbKLC�f^�pS¾VX��Y[QU�p��k� VX��Ypobo���¨®��ks��@e��hj@sV*Ý�Û ��KgM[N!zOBDC$kyQLCif^����QL@ÉM� d!MOWUMO����C$��YOW � Ybd�C�WUM[QLYbW�� ·&±9C ¬ Yb����Yr�ÖQL@!��KDM[d!deWLYyMOhj@ ¬ YOW.���,��k � CihªQU��Ybk E � �9±9C¯M[NezbB�C�kyQD�������QL@�YOd;C$WjMrQUYOWjK$¨bQL@�MrQ���K�KLSpB��;YO��K�C�¹yNe��ded�Cif�����QL@�WUC�f3N!h�QL��YOk�WLNe��C�K#f3C$×!ke��kez�QL@eC���W��;C$@�M¦¥y��YON!W��±sCd!WLYr¥bC�QL@!M[Q�QU@eC�Mbfef3��QL��YOk.Y ¬ h�C$WLQUMO��k'Ybd�C�WUM[QLYbWUK/QU@!MrQ#Sp��C���f.keYOk3��h�Ybk��!NeC�kyQ�WLCif3N!h�QL��YOk!K���K*keC�h$C�KUKLMOWLSMOk!fÈKLN��.h���C$kyQ¸QLY�B'M[�bC�QL@!C�����h$MO��h$Ne��N!KR��kyQLC�WLdeWUC�QjMrQU��Ybk ¬ Ne����SÈMO�!KaQLWjMOhªQD³´YbksdeN!WLCD�3��QLC�WLB'Kj·ª��?#@eCYbd�C�WUM[QLYbWUKRkeC$Cif3C�f¾MOWLC�WUM[QL@eC�WGKL��BDde��CO� � keC C�PeM[BDde��C���K�M�Nek!MOWLS�YOd;C$WjMrQUYOWR��@!��hj@¾��@!C$kÈMOdede����CifQUY-M[k M[WUzONeBDC$kyQDC$��QL@eC�W'��C�@!M¦¥OCiK������OC�QL@!C¾M[WUzONeBDC$kyQD�§QjKaC�� ¬ YOW.f3��¥OC�WLzbC�K�� ?#@eCiKaC¯WUC�KLNe��QUK���BDde��SQU@!MrQ'QU@eC^YOd;C$WjMrQU��Ybk!M[�#Ci¹bN!��¥rM[��C$k�h�C¯Y ¬ Ka��BDde��C^k!YOk3��h�Ybk��!NeC�kbQ'C$PyQUC$k!KL��YOk!K�Y ¬ ���I��KDWUYO�eN!KaQ�º¯��QUKCi¹yN!M[���§QU��CiK�WLC�BDMO��k�¥rM[����f���k�WL��hj@�C$PpQLC$k�Ka��YOk!K�Y ¬ ��� ¨3d�YyKLKL���!��S'��k!h���N!f3��kezDYOd;C$WjMrQUYOWjK ¬ YbW�C$P3deWLCiKLKL��kezh$YOk!h$NeWUWLC�k!h�Sb�_�k � CihªQL��YOk E�ms�*C���ky¥bC�KaQL��zbM[QLC�QL@eC¯BDC�MOke��k!zsY ¬ � º�± @!��hj@ �3��QLC�WLB'K'f3YpCiK ��Q'C�¹yN!M[QLC��Ø?�Y

feC�QLC�WLBD��keC¯QL@!��K�¨#�*C^deWUYr¥OC¯M ¬ C$� hj@!MOWUMbhªQLC�WL��KUMrQL��YOk�K�Y ¬ �� YOk QL@eC^d!NeWLCÈ�e��QLC$WUB'K$� ?#@eC^BDYbKaQ��BDd�YbWaQjM[kyQcYOk!CG��KcM'hj@!MOWUMbhªQUC$WU��KUMrQU��Ybk.��k�QUC$WUBDKcY ¬ M�QUWLC�C�KTQUWLN�hªQLN!WLC¸Y ¬ QL@!C��3��h$MO��h$Ne��N�K$¨3QU@eC��� �¢iÁ�����r�p¿b���e©L¤j¤��j�g±9CDM[��KaY�f3��KUh�N�KLKG@eYr� QUY�YO�eQUM[��ksM�hj@!M[WjMOh�QLC�WL��KLM[QL��YOk¯��kÈQUC$WUBDK�Y ¬ QL@eC�Y[QU@eC$WGB'M[��kQUWLC�C�KaQLWUN!hªQUNeWLC�Y ¬ QL@!C��e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�¨eQL@!C���� �bµ��3©L¤j¤��ª�R?(WUC$C KTQUWLN!h�QLNeWUC�KRM[WUC�M[k^��BDd�YbWaQjM[kyQRd!MOWaQRY ¬QU@eCcQU@eC$YbWLS Y ¬ QL@!C��3��h$MO��h$Ne��N!K$ÂbQL@!C$S'M[WUC�C�KLd�Cih���M[����S N!KLC ¬ Ne�;��k.KaQLN�f3Sp��kez��§QjK�BDY3f3C$��K$�Xt h$YOWUYO����MOWLSgY ¬QU@eC#hj@!M[WjMOh�QLC$WU��KLM[QL��YOk!K÷��k�QUC$WUB'K�Y ¬ QLWUC$CiK���K(QL@!M[Q�QU@eC#C�¹yN!M[����QTSG��k!f3N�h�C�f��pS�QU@eC#����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�C$k!h$Y3f3��k!z

â�â54�6!þ87:98;

Page 11: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

w � Ì(À��[�y¿O�6�r©«¿O�

��KRQL@eC'KUM[BDC MbKcQU@!MrQ¸��k�f3N!h�Cif¾�pS^��C$���§���pkeYr��k^BDYpfeC$��K�Y ¬ QL@eC.�e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!K��g?#@e��K���KGM�WUC$B'M[WU�rM[�e��CMOzOWUC$C�B�C�kyQ��;C�QT��C$C�k�QU@eC�h���MOKUKa��h$MO�;QL@eC�YOWUS.Y ¬¬ Nek!h�QL��YOk!KcMOk!f�QL@eC���W���kyQLC$WUdeWUC�QjMrQL��YOk¯MOK#d!WLY3h�CiKLKLC�K��

Ä^Å ~�Æ;� ?#@eC�d!MOd�C�WRdeWUYOd;YbKLC�K�KaC�¥OC�WUMO�®C�P3C$Wjh�� �$CiK$�c?#@!C$S¯keYOWUB'M[����S�WLCi¹yNe��WUC�KLYOBDC ¬ MOB�������MOWL��QTS�����QL@QU@eCg����h$M[��h�N!��N!K��X?#@eYbKLC¸B'M[WU�OC�f����§QU@^M�MbKTQUC$WU��KL��MOWLC�QL@eCg@�M[Wjf3C�KaQ��

� +������G�!�*� "��#��"����?#@!C���CiM[N3QTS�Y ¬ QU@eC��e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!KR��KcQL@!M[QR�§Q¸MOhj@e��C$¥bC�K�?�NeWU��kez�h�YOBDde��C�QUC$keCiKLK ³6MO���h�YOBDdeNeQUM[�!��C ¬ N!k!hª�QU��Ybk!KRMOWLC f3C�×!k�M[�e��C���k¾��Qj·�����QL@sM'¥OC�WLS¯Ka��BDde��C KLSykyQjMrP÷�c?#@eC���MOKL��hgYbd�C�WUM[QLYbWUK�Y ¬ QL@eCD�3��h$MO��h$Ne��N�K$¨��kÉ�§QjK�deN!WLC ¬ YOWUB¯¨MOWLC.�e��MO�!KaQLWjMOhªQU��Ybk®¨ ¬ YbW ¬ YOWUBD��kez ¬ Nek�hªQL��YOk�K$¨/M[k!fÉMOdede����h�MrQL��YOk(¨ ¬ YOW M[dede��Sp��k!z¯M¬ N!k!hªQU��Ybk¯QLY.M[k^MOWLzbNeBDC$kyQ���t �3��M[�!KaQLWjMOh�QL��YOk�@!MOK�QL@eC ¬ YbWLB ����� Â;��k�QL@!C���Y3f3S� Y ¬ QL@eC ¬ N!k!hª�QU��Ybk®¨yQL@eC¸¥rM[WU��M[�e��C��¯��K�M de��MOh$C$@eYb��f3C�W ¬ YbW�QU@eCgM[WUzONeBDC�kbQi� � C�QLQL��kez �^MOk!f��'WjM[kezbCRYr¥bC$W�QU@eCgKaC$Q�Y ¬�e��h$M[��h�N!��N!K#¥rMOWL��M[�e��C�K�¨yQL@eC�KLC�Q�� Y ¬ �e�j��¤$©ªµ��¸��K�f3C�×!k!C�f��pS'QL@eCgzbWUMOBDBDMOW

�� �����'����� ���������_�k.������ ¨OQU@eCc��ke�§QU��MO���.��K�MgKaQUMrQU��h#�!��k!feC$Wi¨O�e��k!f3��kez�MO��� ¬ WUC$C�Y3h�h�NeWUWLC�k!h�CiK/Y ¬ �.��k� �±9CcYOBD��Q�QL@eCfeC�×!ke��QL��YOk�K�Y ¬� ��h�Ybkp¥OC$WjKL��Ybk®¨ ¬ WUC$C�¥¦MOWL��M[�!��Cb¨yKLNe�!KaQL��QLN3QU��Ybk®¨3C�Qjh[�/±9C���f3C$kyQU� ¬ S ��h$YOkp¥OC�WaQU���!��C�QUC$WUB'K$¨MOk!f�QL@eC�WLC ¬ YOWUCG��WU��QLC! � �Ø� ¬ M[k!f � M[WUC ��h�YOkp¥bC$WLQL���e��Cb�Xt �3��QLC�WLB­��K��$ ��r��¤jø� ¬ �§QRh$YOkyQUMO��k!Kk!Y ¬ WLC�C�¥rM[WU��MO�e��C�K��c?#@eC�KLC�Q�Y ¬/¬ WLC�C�¥rM[WU��MO�e��C�K�Y ¬ M.QLC�WLB" ��K���WL��QaQUC$k ¬ ¥$#%'&L�R?#@eC KaNe��KaC$Q�Y ¬ �h$YOkyQUMO��k!��kez�YOk!��S'QU@eC�h���YbKLC�f�QLC�WLB'K#��K(�*)[�?�Y�M¦¥bYO��f¯QLYpY�B'M[kpS^�eWjMOhj�OC$QUK�¨���CDMOKUKaNeBDC QL@!M[Q�M[dede����h$MrQU��YbkÈMOKUKLYph$��M[QLCiKcQUY�QU@eCD��C ¬ Q�¨(KLY�QU@!MrQ �,+�KL@eYbNe��f¸WUC�Mbf-#. �/&%+c¨¦M[k!fGQU@!MrQ®QU@eC�KUh�Ybd�CXY ¬ Mc��C�PpQLC�k!feK�MOK ¬ MOW�MOK®d�YyKLKL���!��C/QUY�QL@eC�WL��zO@yQ�¨¦KLY

QU@!MrQR������ � KL@eYbNe��f�WUC�MOf¯�����0#% �/&L��±sCgM[��KLYDMO�e�eWUC$¥p��MrQLCg��� � �0101210�j���43$� QLY.��� � 121015�436� ¨YbWD�47�8� � ¬ QL@eC���C$kezOQL@¼Y ¬ 7� ��K�keYOQ���BDd�YbWaQjM[kyQ��ɱ9C ¬ Yb����Yr� Ú#MOWUwOn3¨�� � w � �#��k¼k!Y[QUM[QL��YOk!K�M[k�fQUC$WUBD��keYb��YbzOS ¬ YbW#QL@eC��e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!K��?#@eCg��MOKL��h¸h�YbBDdeN3QUM[QL��YOk!MO�®KTQUC$d�Y ¬ QL@eC��e��h$M[��h�N!��N!K#��K:9÷��WLCif3N!h�QL��YOk®º

9 #�������'& �<;>=?'@BA�CED>F��k¾��@e��hj@¾QU@eC�d!��Mbh�C$@!YO��f3C$WG�s��KGWLC�de��Mbh�Cif¯�yS�QU@eC�MOWLzbNeBDC$kyQ�� ��k¾QU@eC���Y3f3SH Y ¬ QL@eC ¬ Nek!hªQU��Ybk®�tRksC$P3deWLCiKLKL��YOk¾Y ¬ QL@eC ¬ YbWLB�#������'& � ��Kgh$M[����C�fÈMI9 ��©L¤jÃb¤KJb¨(MOk!f^QU@eC'f3C$WU��¥rM[QL��¥OC-'@LAMCED>FD��K¸��QUK�j�[�!��©L�O�$�«�3µ��?#@eC ¬ YO����Yr����kez�WLN!��CiKRY ¬ ��k ¬ C�WLC�k!h�CDM[����Yr� N�KRQUY�WUC$de��MOh$C MN9÷��WUC�feC�P^�pS���QUK¸h$YOkyQLWjMOh�QLNeB ��ksM[kpS

h$YOkyQLC$PpQ�º O �;>=?QP �R;>=? P � S �T;4= �HP �T;4=� � P 1 U;4=�QP�����V;4= ������ P ³TEi·

±9Cg��WU�§QUC!U;6=/W � � ¬ V;4= � ��Kcf3C�WL��¥rM[�e��C ¬ WLYbB�QL@!C�WLN!��CiKX9MY O Y S Y 1 ��H�C$��MrQU��Ybk/;>=/W¯��KcQL@eC©U¤UÃ[�!�����6�r�È©L¤� ��r���6�r�-�T�¸� �p¤G�3�a�j�r ����3 ¡�p�ª¨!MO��KLY'h$MO����C�f��j�3 £ �9 ��©L¤jÃ[�!�����6�r���H�C���M[QL��YOkZ;4=/W�feC�×!keCiK#M f3��WUC�hªQUC�f ¬ YOWUB Y ¬ WUC$��WU�§QU��kez��t&�e�«QUC$WUB[ ���§QU@eYONeQ:9®��WUC�f3C$P3C�KR³6�«� CO��¨

¬ YbW#��@e��hj@�keY�� C$Pp��KaQUK�[email protected]@!MrQ�U;>= W �È·*��K�M��;�[©ªµD�[ [���r©ªµ°³6�eWU��C:�!S^���T·���t ©U¤UÃ[�!�����6�r�.�3�[�����KXM¸KaCi¹yNeC$k!h$C#Y ¬ WLCif3N!hªQU��Ybk�KaQLC�d!KM � ;4=�W\ � ;4=/W^]0]2]¦QL@!M[Q�B'M¦S�@!M¦¥OC*×!ke��QLC�YbWX��ke×!ke��QLC���C$kezOQL@®�?#@eC^M[Pp��YOB�9 M[k�f QU@eC¯WLNe��C�K�Y ¬ ��k ¬ C$WUC$k!h$C-³TEi·�f3C$×!keC^M9Ka��kezO��C���KaQLC$d WLCif3N!h�QL��YOk¼WUC$��MrQU��Ybk¼Ybk

�e��QLC$WUB'K$� t�fef3��kez-WLN!��CiK ¬ YOW.WUC ��C�P3��¥p��QTS¼M[k�f¼QUWUMOk!KL�§QU��¥p��QTS �*C^Yb�3QUMO��k QU@eC¾B�N!�§QU��KaQLC�d WUC�feN!hªQU��Ybk

�´ó�â����

Page 12: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

���!��¤�©��;©L¤$�«�£�p¿R�j�3�������6�r�!�g�r�#���a�j�[ ����3 §�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª� v

O � QP � � P � S � � �HP � � � P 1 � QP������ � ����� P

������� � ��� � �� � �������

� � � � + � +?�MO�e��C'EbºX?#@eCgWLN!��CiK ¬ YOWcM'�3��h$MO��h$Ne��N!K�h�YbkezOWUNeC$k�h�C

WUC$��MrQU��Ybk®¨ ��� W �X?#@eCcWUC�KLNe��QL��kez ¬ YOWUB�N!��MbK ��� W � f3C�×�keC�QL@!C*���r©ªµ'�r �� �p¤j�r©ªÁD�T� 9 ��©L¤jÃr�!�$���6�r��Y ¬QU@eC��e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!K���?#@eCgdeWUC�f3��h$M[QLC���f3��KTQU��kezbNe��Ka@eCiK�QL@eC�MO�!KaQLWjMOhªQU��Ybk!K�ÂbQU@!MrQ���K�¨����@!YO��feKZTN!KaQc� ¬ ��KcY ¬ QL@eC ¬ YbWLB ����� � �#Û!NeWLQL@eC�W�¨6��$W � B�CiM[k!KcQL@!M[Q ����W � M[k!f ���y¨�MOk!fH��$W^B�CiM[k!KQU@!MrQG�� W � ¬ YbWcKaYbBDC � �?�NeWUke��kez�QL@eCgYbWL��C$kyQLCif�WUNe��C�K�f3C$×!ke��kez ��� W ��kyQLY'C�¹yN!M[QL��YOk!K#zb��¥bC�K�WU��KLCGQLYDQL@!C���9 ���3¤U�[©ªÁr¨�MO��KLY

h�M[����Cif.QU@eCc���r©ªµ'�r ����3¤j�r©ªÁ��a�:9 ¤ ���!�[ ¡�£�«Ár��_�Qc��K�f3C$×!keCif��pS�QL@eCgMrP3��YOB9 #�������'& � � '@ A C D�F

d!��N!K�QL@eC�MrP3��YOBØMOk!fÉ��k ¬ C$WUC$k!h$C.WUNe��CiK ¬ YOW�h�YbkezOWUNeC$k�h�CD��k ?M[�!��C¾Eb�¯±sC.��WU��QLC���9"! � � � ¬ � �Øh�M[k���CgdeWUYr¥OCif.��k�QL@eC���99QL@eC�YOWUSO�±9CgzO��¥OCGk!MOB�CiK�QLY.KLYOBDCgKad;C�h$��MO�(�3��QLC�WLB'K�º

# $&%('� �����5�) $&%('� #������K��� &#������K��� &* $&%('� #������j���6�5�>� &#������U���6�5�>� &K�

#���KcQL@eC���f3C�kyQL��QTS ¬ Nek�hªQL��YOk(¨��;C�h�M[N!KLC ¬ YOW�M[��� �-¨��*Cg@!M¦¥bC+#��;4=/W � Â!��C�B'M¦S�h$MO��� ) M �TdeN!WLC���Sfe��¥bC$WUzOC$kyQ*QLC$WUB�j¨p�;C�h�M[N!KLC ) ;>=�W ) ;4=�W ]2]0]�ÂeM[k!f��*C�BDM¦S.h�M[����* M �adeNeWUC$��S'h�Ybky¥bC$WUzOC�kbQ�QLC$WUB�j¨�;C�h�M[N!KLC+* ;>=/W.���6�,* ;6=/W #����4�0& � * ]0]0]�;4=/W^]0]2]�Â!��k!feC$C�f®¨ ¬ YOWcM[����-X¨3��C¸@!M¦¥OC+* ���/W^#����6� & 3 *#�. � ����������÷� ���� ������� �

± ��QL@!YON3Q'f3YON!�3Q�QU@eC¯�e��h$M[��h�N!��N!K�@!MOf¼M[k ��BDd�YbWaQjM[kyQ���k��!NeC�k!h�C�YOk-QU@eC�f3C�¥OC���YbdeBDC$kyQ Y ¬ deWLY3h$C�KUKh�M[��h�Ne���������OC�Ý�Ý � ¨�Ý � V M[k�f�tRÝ�V ��k�QL@eC¸C�MOWL��S'wOq � K���_�k�QL@!CGh�MOKLC�Y ¬ h$MO��h$Ne��� ¬ YbW�BDYb�e����CGdeWLY3h$C�KUKaCiKMOk!f @!��zb@eC$WL��YbWUfeC$W�h�M[��h�Ne���«¨GM[k ��BDd�YbWaQjM[kyQ�@!C$WU�§QjM[zOC ¬ WLYbB QL@eC-�3��h$MO��h$Ne��N!K���K�KTQjMrQU��hs�e��k!f3��kez!¨GMh$YOk!h$C$d3Q�QU@!MrQ���K�Nek!feC$WjKTQUYyY3f���MOWLzbC$��S.MOK�M�WUC�KLNe�§Q�Y ¬ ��YOWU�'YOk^�3��h$MO��h$Ne��N!K$�?���Yg��BDd;YOWLQUM[kyQ ¬ CiMrQLN!WLCiKXY ¬ �e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!K/QU@!MrQ#f3��KaQL��kezbNe��KL@D�§Q ¬ WLYbB ����h$MO��h$Ne��N�K�M[WUC¸�$¤,�$�!¤$�!���6�r ¡�£��Á

MOk!f �j�r�0/*�!¤$�;�j¤$� ±9CÈf3��KUh�N!KUKDQL@!C�KLC¾��C���Yr�g�&Û��WUKaQ�¨#��C¾�eWU��C:�!S h$YOBDd!M[WUC�QL@eCs�!MOKL��h¯WLCif3N!hªQU��YbkM[P3��YbBDK#Y ¬ QU@eC¸QT�*Y'h�M[��h�Ne���«�

13254 687�9 �;:�<�=?>A@ CBD=?> �FE

?#@!Cg�!MOKL��hGWUC�f3N�hªQL��YOk¯MrP3��YOB'K�Y ¬ �3��h$MO��h$Ne��N!K�M[k!f�����h$M[��h�N!��N!K�MOWLC 9-M[k�fHGI � º#�������'& �<;4=�'@ A CKJ F L # ��&K�,MON L�PKQ�R��,S';4=�[email protected]>FUN�S

â�â54�6!þ87:98;

Page 13: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

Eiq � Ì(À��[�y¿O�6�r©«¿O�

?#@!C$WUC¸MOWLC�QL@!WLC�CgkeY[QU��h$C�M[�!��Cgf3���;C�WLC�k!h�CiK$º

EO��?#@eC �3��QLC�WLB'K^����� M[k!f � M[WUCÉh�YOBDBD��QaQLCif QUY ��kyQLC$WjMOh�QL��kez ���§QU@²C�Mbhj@²YOQL@eC�W�¨�C$¥OC�k � ¬#�������'& � ��K�d!M[WLQ�Y ¬ M���MOWLzbC$W�QLC�WLB¯Â3QU@e��KR��K�KLY'�;C�h$MON!KLC¸fe� ��C$WUC$kyQ��e��WUC�f3C$P3C�K�MOh�QcYOk¯f3���;C�Wa�C$kyQ�d!MOWaQjK�Y ¬ M�QUC$WUB��D_�k-h�YbkyQLWjMOKaQ�¨÷��kbQUC$W ¬ C$WUC$k!h$C ¬ WLYbB QL@eC'C�kp¥y��WUYOkeBDC$kyQgh$MOksdeWUC$¥bC$kyQ¸QL@eC��kyQUC$WjMOhªQU��Ybk^��C$QT�*C�C$k¯QU@eC�����h$MO��h$Ne��N�K�QLC�WLB'KAL # ��&K�,M�M[k!f L PKQ�R�� SD�cÛeYbWR��k!KTQjM[k!h$CO¨�QL@eC C$kp¥p�§�WLYbkeBDC$kyQ�h�YON!��f�h�YbkbQjM[��k�M deWUYph$C�KUK L�P � R���� QU@!MrQ���K#��k¯h�YbB�d;C�QU�§QU��Ybk�����QL@ L�P Q�R��,S ¬ YOW�Mbh$h�CiKLKQLY L # � &� MD� Û!YOW�QL@!��KDWUC�MbKaYbk®¨�����h$M[��h�N!��N!K���K�keY[Q.h�Ybk��!NeC�kyQ�����Ka��kezÉM¾QUC$WUBD��keYb��YbzOS ¬ WUYOBQLC�WLB���WLC���WL��QL��kez!¨;��C�B'M¦S�KUM¦S�QL@!M[QRQU@eCD�e��h$M[��h�N!��N!K���K��[©ª���3�L¿y�r���r ¡¨®��@!C$WUC�MOKcQL@eC�����h$M[��h�N!��N!K��KckeY[Qi�

� ��?#@eC*�e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!K÷WUC�feN!hªQU��YbkgWLCi¹bN!��WUC�K÷M#QUC$WUB KLNe�!KaQL��QLN3QU��Ybk®¨¦��@eC$WUC�MbK�QL@!C�����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K÷WUC�feN!hªQU��YbkWLCi¹yNe��WUC�K#M^³«Ka��BDde��C�Wj·*k!MOBDC�KaNe��KTQU�§QUN3QL��YOk®�

me��?#@eCg�3��WLCif3N!h�QL��YOk.��K#MOKLSyBDBDC�QUWL��h[º�QL@!CGMOWLzbNeBDC$kyQ � ��K�h�YOBDde��C�QUC$��S.Ka�#M[����Yr�*Cif �pSDQU@eC ¬ N!k!hª�QL��YOk^����� ��?#@eCG����WLCif3N!hªQU��Ybk���K#BDYOWUC�KLSyBDBDC�QUWL��hD³6MOk!f.��k�¥rMOWL��M[kyQUK�KLN!hj@�MbK*�÷_� � M[k!v � �®�§Q����KaSpBDBDC�QLWU��h�·#MOK#�;Y[QU@���kyQLC�WUMbhªQL��kez'KLNe�3QLC�WLB'K#d;C$WjKa��KaQRM ¬ QLC�W#QL@eCgWUC�feN!hªQU��Ybk®�

132 1 � 7�� � 7 @A<�= �� = <� ?#@!C��e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!KGh$M[deQLNeWUC�K���¤ �$�!¤����«�6�[ �h�YbB�d!N3QUM[QL��YOk!K���?#@!M[Q���K$¨®�e�«QUC$WUB'KRC$Ppd!WLCiKLK ¬ Nek!hªQU��Ybk!K�QL@!M[Q�¨MO��zbYOWU�§QU@eBD��h�M[����S KLd�CiM[�p��k!z!¨R��YpYO� M[Q�QU@eC-M[WUzONeBDC$kyQjK.QU@eC$S k!C$C�f²��k KLC�¹yNeC$k�h�CO��_ ¬ ��k f3Yb��kez KLYM ¬ Nek!h�QL��YOk WLCiMOhj@eCiK M9f3��¥OC�WLzbC$kyQ�MOWLzbNeBDC$kyQ�¨XQU@eC$k QL@!C���@!YO��C�h$YOBDdeN3QjMrQL��YOk ��������f3��¥OC�WLzbCO�¼?#@eC�e��h$M[��h�N!��N!K�¨/��k-��QUK NekyQTSpd�Cif-YOW�QTSyd;C�f ¥OC$WjKL��Ybk!K$¨/h$MOkekeYOQ f3C�KUh�WU����C ¬ N!k!hªQU��Ybk!K���@eYyKaC�M[��zOYOWU��QL@eBD��hfeC�×!ke��QL��YOk^WUC�¹yNe��WUC�K�QL@�MrQ�KLYOBDC�M[WUzON!B�C�kyQUK#�;C�WLN!k^��k^d!MOWUMO����C$���*tRk^C$ke����zO@yQLC�ke��k!z'C�PeM[BDde��Cg��KcQL@eCk!YOk3��f3C�×�k!M[�e�����§QTS^��ksV*Ý�Û ³6M�QTSpd�Cif9�e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!KG����QL@s×eP3C�f¾d;YO��kyQUK�¨÷��YpYb��CiM[k!K¸M[k�f¾��kbQUC$zbC$WjKU·RY ¬ M� d!MOWUMO����C$��YOW � ¬ Nek!h�QL��YOk��I � ¨p��@eC�WLC ¬ YbWRh���YbKLC�f.QLC$WUB'K� MOk!f �-¨

��� ��� WUC�f3N�h�C�K�QUY�� ��� � ¨p� ¬ YbW �ØWUC�feN!h�CiK�QLY�� ��� �f3��¥OC�WLzbC�K�¨pY[QL@!C$WU����KLCO�

± ��QL@ d�M[WjM[����C�����KaB¯¨�QL@e��K ¬ N!k!hªQU��Ybk ��K M[��zOYbWL��QL@eBD��h$MO����S¾C�MbKaSÈQLYÈh$YOBDdeN3QUCOº�ZTN!KaQ ��C�Q- M[k�f �WUC�feN!h�C�h�YOk�h�NeWUWLC�kyQL��SGMOk!fgWUC�QLN!WLk�� ��� � � ¬ MOk!fg��@eC�k�YOk!C�Y ¬ QL@eC�B&C$¥rM[��N!MrQUC�K®QLY�� ��� � ����?#@!C$WUC���K(keYV�Ý�Û¾QUC$WUB QU@!MrQ���C�@!M¦¥OCiK�MOK ��� �?#@eC�KaCi¹bN!C$kyQL��M[���§QTS Y ¬ QL@!CRNekyQTSpd�Cif.�3��h$MO��h$Ne��N!K���K�M[��WUC�MOfeS h���C�MOW�¨M[Qg��CiMOKaQ¸��kyQLNe��QL��¥OC���Sb¨®��ksQU@eC^�;�[©ªµD�[ ¡���$�r���6�r� ���3¤U�[©L¤$µ ¨M�h$YOWUYO����MOWLS�Y ¬ YOk!C�Y ¬ QU@eCDBDMO��k-KLSpkbQjMOh�QL��hQU@eC$YbWLC�B'K�Y ¬ QU@eCG�e��h$M[��h�N!��N!K�¨bQL@eC��j���r��ÃO�[©LÃr���$�r���6�r�È���3¤U�[©L¤$µ �X?#@eC�keYOWUB'M[����KUMrQU��Ybk QU@eC$YbWLC�B MbKLKLC$WLQUKQU@!MrQ � ¬ M�QUC$WUBØ@!MbK�M^k!YOWUBDMO� ¬ YOWUB¯¨(QU@eC$k QL@e��K��������*��C ¬ YONek�fÉ�ySsQL@!CÈ �¤«�j�«µ'�¦�ª��KaQLWjMrQUC$zOSb��?#@!��KKaQLWjMrQUC$zbS�KLC$��C�hªQjK�QU@eC�WUC�f3N�hªQL��YOk^d�MrQL@ÈY ¬ MDQLC�WLB ��k^��@e��hj@®¨;M[Q�CiMOhj@^KTQjM[zbCO¨eQU@eC h$YOkyQLWjMOh�QLCif¯WLCif3C�P��K�QL@!CgYOkeC¸����QL@�QL@eCg��C ¬ QUBDYbKaQ��3��KaSpB ��Yb�«�?#@eCÈ��C ¬ QLBDYbKaQ�KTQUWUM[QLC�zOS ��K.h���C�MOWL��S¼KLC�¹yNeC�kbQU��MO�«º^Ybk!h�C^�;C$zbNek®¨�QL@!C¾C$¥rM[��N!M[QL��YOk Y ¬ M-KaNe�eQLC$WUB

h$YOkyQL��kpNeC�K NekyQL����M¾¥rM[��NeCɳ6M9�3��M[�!KaQLWjMOh�QL��YOk�·���K ¬ YON!k!f÷Â�YOke��SÉQL@eC�k h�M[k¼h$YOkyQLWUYO��d!MOKUKgQUY9MOkeY[QU@eC$WKLNe�3QUC$WUB¯��?#@eC$WUC ¬ YbWLC¸Ka��B�N!�§QjM[keC�YON!K�YOW���kyQLC�WL��C�M¦¥bC�f.C�¥rM[��N!MrQU��Ybk�Y ¬ KLNe�3QLC�WLB'K���K ¬ YOWU�e��fef3C�k®�� � 4gì«è¦ã�é 4�ì£ï�êOãTí��iö£çaå�� çaé�� é¦ä��! (è¦ãTæ«ã�ì«è¦ãTæ6ã�åjæ«ã 4¦ë#"ªæ«ëªé 4ií íråUì�åRì£ï�ê[ãTä�å84¦í�åjî¦ä«ì«æ�åjç�ì%$ ë 4¦ä*åjæ«ã�ì�è¦ã�ë 4&� ï¸ç'� ëªä�ãTí( å�� é¦ãTä��*) ê¦åjæ�å���� ã'�ëªæ'+�ä«è¦ëªé&� í�î[ãgê¦æ«ëªî¦åjî&� ï�í¦ã-,�4¦ãTí^åjä�ì�èiã¸êråjæ«å���� ã.�çaë 4 ( ãTæ%"ªã 4¦çTã�ì�ãTä6ì�ù0/�ãTç�ì1$ ë 4süªü2�®ëªæRä«ã 4¦ä1$ î&� ã( ãaæ6ä1$ ë 4iä�ë�34$ ì#ä«é¦ç�è�åjä5$ 46 7÷åjæ«ý878��êrå�" þ 9�9;: � �=<(ë� ÷ã ( ãTæ'�>$ 4Dì£ïiê[ãTí?�¦ö�çLå�� çTé&��$÷ì«è¦ã�ì@ �ë ëªê[ãTæ�åUì«ëªæ6äGåjæ6ãGí&$ AOãTæ6ã 4�ì.Bêråjæ�å���� ã'�pçTë 4 ( ãTæ%"ªã 4¦çTã5$ ä®é¦ä«érå���� ï#C�ëªæ«ãXê[ë� �ãaæD3�é&�;ù�ë 4¦ã�çLå84Gí¦ãTæ%$ ( ãE) êråjæ«å���� ã'�pëªæ.+�3�æ6ë2CF$ ì.�rî¦éiì(ì«è¦ã�çaë 4 ( ãTæ«ä«ãG$ ä®ë�3§ì�ã 43�å�� ä«ã ���

�´ó�â����

Page 14: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

���!��¤�©��;©L¤$�«�£�p¿R�j�3�������6�r�!�g�r�#���a�j�[ ����3 §�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª� EOE

_�k h�YbkyQLWjMOKaQ�¨XQU@eC^����h�M[��h�Ne��N!KDk!M[QLNeWjM[����S f3C�KUh�WU���;C�KDd�M[WjM[����C��#h$YOBDdeN3QjMrQU��Ybk!K$� ?#@eC¯����h$M[��h�N!��N!K� ��YOWU��f � ��K¸QU@!MrQ Y ¬ deWLY3h$C�KUKaCiK$¨®WjMrQU@eC$W�QL@!MOk ¬ N!k!hªQU��Ybk!K$� � ��k!h�C ¬ N!k!hªQU��Ybk!K�h�M[kÉ��C�KaC�C$k-MOK�KLd;C�h���M[�¬ YbWLB'K�Y ¬ deWUY3h�CiKLKLC�K�¨�d�M[WjM[����C�� ¬ Nek!h�QL��YOk!KG�����bC ��I � h�M[k¾�;CDf3C�KUh�WU���;C�fÈ��k¾QL@eC�����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�³´��C KL@eYr�QU@eCgC$k�h�Y3f3��kezbK#Y ¬ KL��BD����MOW ¬ Nek!hªQU��Ybk!K���k � C�h�QL��YOk!K¸EbE¸MOk!fsE � � � ·��

132�� � > @�� � 7 @ : 7

?#@!C�WUC�f3N!h�QL��YOk¾WUC$��MrQU��Ybk!K�Y ¬ ��YOQL@s�e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!KGM[k!f¯����h$MO��h$Ne��N!K�MOWLCgk!YOk3��f3C�QUC$WUBD��ke��KaQL��h[¨;��Cih$M[N�KaC�MQUC$WUBØB'M¦S¾@�M¦¥OCDBDYOWUCDQL@!MOk9YbkeC'WUC�f3C$P�� �cYr��C$¥OC�WgYOke��SÈ��k9QL@eC�����h�M[��h�Ne��N!Kg��KgkeYbk3��feC�QLC�WLBD��ke��KaBKLC$B'MOkbQU��h�M[����S�Ka��zOke��×�h�M[kyQ���Ý*YOk�Ka��f3C$W�M QLC�WLB

S $ %('� Q P�� R3N Q P�� R N�Q># � &� �?#@!C�QT��YcYONeQLdeN3QjK/M[WUC���k�h�YbB�d;C�QU�§QU��Ybk ¬ YOW�QL@!C*��kedeN3Qi��_ ¬ Q�P�&R�����k!K�¨¦QL@eC�k Q P��0R÷B'M¦SGWLC�BDMO��k����§QU@eYON3QMDd�M[WLQLkeC�W�¨eMOk!f¯h�YOkp¥bC$WjKaC���S'� ¬ Q P�� R�����k!K$��_�k!f3C$Cif÷¨3QU@eCgQT��Y���BDBDC�f3��MrQUC�f3C$WU��¥rM[QL��¥OC�K#Y ¬ S'¨ek!M[BDC���S N N ��M[k!f N N �GM[WUCG�;C$@�M¦¥y��YON!WUMO����SD¥OC$WUS�f3����C$WUC$kyQ��?#@!��K/KL�§QUN!MrQU��Ybk�h�M[kekeYOQ@�M[ded;C$k ��k QL@eCc�e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�¨r��@eC$WUC#h�YOkyQUWUMbhªQL��kezGM�WUC�feC�PgkeC$¥bC$WXfeMOBDMOzOCiK

YOQL@eC�W�WUC�feC�P3C�K�¨���k QL@eCÉKaC�k!KLCÈY ¬ ��C�M¦¥p��kez¼M KLNe�3QUC$WUB ���§QU@eYON3Q^M d�M[WLQLkeC�W�� ?#@!C ¬ MOh�Q�QU@!MrQ�QL@eCk!YOk3��f3C�QUC$WUBD��ke��KLB Y ¬ QU@eC.�3��h$MO��h$Ne��N�K���KG@!M[WUBD��CiKLKG��KGC�P3deWUC�KUKaCif^�pS¯QL@eC¾�j�r�0/*�!¤$�;�j¤¯³6Y ¬ QLC�k9h�M[����Cif» �y�3©L��� ���R�r�U�$¤$©a·cd!WLYbd�C�WaQTSb¨!QU@!MrQ¸KLM¦S3K�QU@!MrQG� ¬ M'QLC�WLB @!MbK�QT��Y�f3C�WL��¥rMrQU��¥bC�K � � MOk!f � � ¨;QL@eC�k��Cgh$MOk¯MO���#M¦S3K�×�k!f¯M�QU@e��WUf�QLC�WLB + QLY'h���YbKLCGQL@eC�f3��M[BDYbk!f÷º

W� �� � � � � �

� �� �� ��

W�������

���

����

���

� �W �� ����

���

����

���

� �W� �� � � � � �

� �� �� ��

+� YOBDC h$YOk!KLC�¹yNeC�k!h�CiKcY ¬ QU@eC.Ý�H deWUYOd;C$WLQTS�Y ¬ QL@eC'�e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!KGM[WUCOº�³TE¦·#QU@eC k!YOWUBDMO� ¬ YbWLB Y ¬ M

QUC$WUB[ ³´� ¬ ��Q�C�P3��KaQUKj·���K*Neke��¹yNeCO¨3Ned�QLYDM[��de@!M[��h$YOkp¥OC�WUKL��Ybk®Â!³ � ·�QL@eCg�3��h$MO��h$Ne��N!K���K�h�Ybk!Ka��KaQLC$kyQi¨bQU@!MrQ��K�QU@eC$WUC�MOWLCgQUC$WUB'K� M[k!f � KLN!hj@¯QL@�MrQ¸��9 !, � � f3YpC�KRkeY[Q�@eYO��f-³ ZTN!KaQRQjM[�bC MOk!f � QUY�;Cgf3���;C�WLC�kbQ�keYbWLB'MO� ¬ YbWLB'K�¨ ¬ YOW���k!KTQjM[k!h$C¸�����K�¾M[k!f¯�����5�>��Âe�pS'd�Yb��kyQ�³TE¦·�QU@eC$S�M[WUC�keYOQ�deWLYr¥rMO�e��SCi¹yN!M[�£·ªÂ#³6my·�QL@eC'YbWUf3C�W¸��kÉ��@e��hj@ÉWLCif3C�P3C�KGY ¬ M�QLC�WLB M[WUC WUC�feN!h�Cifs��K¸Neke��BDd�YbWaQjM[kyQ�¨���[email protected]�k!KLCQU@!MrQRMO����×�ke�§QUCgWLCif3N!h�QL��YOk^KaCi¹yNeC$k!h$C�K#h$MOk¯��Cgh�YbkyQL��kyN!C�f�QLYDWUC�MOhj@�MDh�YOBDBDYOk¯f3C�WL��¥rMrQL��¥OCb�VYb��kyQ�³6my·#f3YpC�K�keYOQ���BDde��S.QU@!MrQRMO���®WUC�feN!hªQU��Ybk�d!M[QL@!KcB�N!KaQcBDC$C�Qi��ÛeYbW���k!KaQUMOk!h�Cb¨!M QLC�WLB­���§QU@

M�keYOWUB'M[� ¬ YOWUB B'M¦S¯@!M¦¥bC�M[k¾��k3×!k!�§QUC WUC�f3N�hªQL��YOksKaCi¹bN!C$k!h$C�QL@�MrQ�k!C$¥OC�WR×�k!feK��§Qi�¸tRkÈC$P3MOBDde��C ��KQU@eCgQUC$WUB #������ #�& ) Â��§QR@�MOK#keYbWLB'M[� ¬ YOWUB #;¨!YO�eQUM[��keCif��pS�h�YOkyQUWUMbhªQL��kez�QL@!CgYON3QUC$WUB�YyKTQcWUC�feC�P÷¨e�eN3Q��QRM[��KLY�@�MOK�QL@!Cg��k3×�ke�§QUCgWLCif3N!h�QL��YOk¯KaCi¹bN!C$k!h$C

#������5#>& ) ;>= W #������5#>& ) ;>= W ]2]0]Yb�3QUMO��k!C�f��yS�h�YbkbQUWUMbhªQU��kez QL@!Cg��kek!C$WUB�YyKTQ�WUC�f3C$P÷�

â�â54�6!þ87:98;

Page 15: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

E � � Ì(À��[�y¿O�6�r©«¿O�

� � � �¯����� $��� �®�����g������ ������r�����8���?���!����"��#��"����t�KXQU@eCcWUC�f3N!h�QL��YOkDWUC$��MrQL��YOk^;4=�W'Y ¬ QL@eC¸�3��h$MO��h$Ne��N!KX��K�keYbk3��feC�QLC�WLBD��ke��KTQU��hO¨bMGQLC�WLB B'M¦S�@!M¦¥bC�BDYOWUCQU@!M[kDYbkeCX9÷��WLCif3C�PDM[k!f QL@!C$WUC ¬ YOWUCcKLC$¥OC�WUMO�pWLCif3N!hªQU��YbkDd!MrQU@!K$� � YbB�C�Y ¬ QL@eCiKaC�B'M¦S���C�Mbf QLY�M¸keYbWLB'M[�¬ YbWLB°��@e����CgY[QU@eC$WjK�B'M¦S.keY[Q�³«MOK#������N!KaQLWjMrQUC�f ¬ YOW#QL@!C¸QLC$WUB #������5#>& ) M[�;Yr¥OC¦·ª�Ç�� ��C$WUC$kyQRd�MrQL@�K ¬ WLYbB­M�QUC$WUB°QUY'�§QjK�keYOWUB'M[� ¬ YbWLB­B'M¦S.@!M¦¥OC�fe� ��C$WUC$kyQc��C$kezOQL@!K��*t�©U¤UÃ[�!�����6�r�

�ª��©L�r��¤�¿[Á'KLd�Cih���×!C�K���@e��hj@ 9÷��WLCif3C�P3C�K���k¼M^QLC$WUB BDM¦S9�;C�h�YbkyQLWjMOhªQUC�f÷�^H�Cif3N!h�QL��YOk¼KaQLWjMrQUC$zO��C�K�M[WUCN�KaC ¬ Ne�÷��YOQL@ ¬ YOW#QU@eC$YbWLC$QL��h$MO�;WUC�MbKaYbk!K¸³ ¬ YbW���k!KaQUMOk!h�Cb¨pQLYDdeWUYr¥OC�QL@!M[QRM QLC$WUB�@!MbK#keYDkeYOWUB'M[� ¬ YOWUB.·ª¨MOk!f ¬ YOW'deWjMOh�QL��h$M[�#deN!WLd;YbKLC�K¯³ ¬ YbW'��k�KTQjM[k!h$CO¨*QLYÉYO�3QjM[��k C �.h���C$kyQ'��BDde��C$BDC$kyQjMrQL��YOk�KU·�� ��KaN�M[����S¼MWUC�feN!hªQU��Ybk¾KTQUWUM[QLC$zbS.��KRf3C$QLC$WUBD��k!��KaQL��h[Â���k¯QL@!M[QGh$MbKaC¸QU@eC�YbkeC���KTQUC$d^WUC�f3N�hªQL��YOk^WUC$��MrQU��Ybk¯��K�M'd!M[WLQL��M[�¬ N!k!hªQU��Ybk�Ybk¯�e��QLC$WUB'K$�Û!YOWUBDMO����SO¨eM WUC�f3N!h�QL��YOk¯KTQUWUM[QLC�zOS �&��K�f3C�×�keC�f��pS'×eP3��k!zDM WUC�f3N!h�QL��YOk�WLC���M[QL��YOkZ;4=���� ��� �

QU@!MrQG�*C���������N�KaN!MO����S���WL��QLC���k¾��k3×eP¯keY[QjMrQU��Ybk®�R?#@eC�WUC ��C�P3��¥bC�M[k!f^QLWjM[k!KL�§QU��¥bC�h���YbKLNeWUC�Y ¬ ;4= � ��K�������#±sC KLM¦S�QL@!M[Q �����r�� ���;�[©ªµD�[ O���r©ªµ ³%�R�j���;·#� ¬ QU@eC$WUC���KckeY � KLN!hj@¯QU@!MrQ ;>=�� �-ÂMOk!fDQU@!MrQ ��p�r�¸�r� �������r©ªµ'�r r���r©ªµ�� ¬ QU@eC$WUCR��K#M ����k ¬ � [email protected]@!MrQX ����� �-�X±sC¸M[��KLY���WL��QLC �� ��� ¬ ����� ���b¨XMOk!f ��²� ¬ �� � ¬ YOW�KaYbBDC �-�ÈÛeYbW���k!KTQjM[k!h$CO¨������ ��K�Mk!YOWUBDMO� ¬ YOWUB ¬ YOWRMOkpS'WLCif3N!hªQU��Ybk�KaQLWjMrQUC$zbS'QL@!M[Qcf3YpC�K�keYOQcM[����Yr�²QL@eC 1 WLNe��CO�tRkÈC�PeMOB�d!��C Y ¬ M�KaQLWjMrQUC$zbS���KcQU@eC���C ¬ QUBDYbKaQ¸KaQLWjMrQUC$zOS�BDC$kyQL��YOk!C�f^��k � CihªQL��YOk � � � �R_�BDd;YOWLQUMOkbQ

KaQLWjMrQUC$zb��CiK'��k d!WLYbzOWjM[BDBD��kezÉ��M[kezbN!M[zbC�K.MOWLC¼�j�[ £  �L¶ªÁ������rµ'¤ÉM[k!f �j�[ £  �L¶ªÁ���¢r�r §�!¤�¨GM[k!f ¥rM[WU��M[kyQUK'Y ¬QU@eC$B KaN�hj@�MbK��U�[ £  �L¶�Á����;¤j¤jÃr¨e�e�r©U�r £ �¤$ �j�r £  �L¶ªÁ���¢r�r ¡�!¤ M[k�fÈ�ª��©L�r�p¿��j�r £  �L¶ªÁ������rµ'¤��t°keY[QU��Ybk-Y ¬ WLCif3N!h�QL��YOkÉzO��¥OCiKgWL��KLC'QLYÈM¾�e��QL@eC�YOWUSO¨��@eC$k [email protected]��CiKgQU@!MrQ�QUNeWUk-QL@eC

WUC�feN!hªQU��Ybk�WUC$��MrQU��Ybk���kbQUY.MDh�YOk!zOWUNeC$k!h$C�WUC$��MrQU��Ybk®�?#@eC�WLC���K�keY � ��CiKTQ � WLCif3N!hªQU��Ybk¾KTQUWUM[QLC�zOSO�cÇ����;C�WLC�kbQG��MOkezON�M[zOCiK$¨!C$¥OC�k¾Ka��kezb��C���M[k!zON!MOzOC�K�¨!Mbf3YOd3Q

fe� ��C$WUC$kyQGKaQLWjMrQUC$zb��CiK ¬ YOWRQL@eC C$¥rM[��N!MrQU��Ybk^Y ¬X¬ Nek�hªQL��YOkÈYOWRd!WLY3h�Cif3NeWUC�M[ded!����h$M[QL��YOk!K��R?#@eC�h�Y3f3��kez.YOW��BDde��C$BDC$kyQUM[QL��YOk¯Y ¬ f3���;C�WLC�kyQcWLCif3N!hªQU��Ybk�KaQLWjMrQUC$zb��CiK#BDM¦S�WLCi¹bN!��WUCgf3� ��C$WUC$kyQ�QUC�hj@eke��¹yNeC�K�³£QL@!C$WUC�M[WUCMO��KLYÈWUC�feN!hªQU��Ybk KaQLWjMrQUC$zO��C�K�QL@�MrQ.M[WUC�k!YOk3��h�YbB�d!N3QUMO�e��Cb¨�M[k�f¼@eC�k!h�C¯��BDd�YyKLKL���!��C�QLYÉ��B�d!��C�B�C�kyQ� ·ª�Ú�C���Yr����C�h$YOk!KL��f3C$W'M ¬ C$����BDd�YbWaQjM[kyQ�WUC�feN!hªQU��Ybk KaQLWjMrQLC�zO��C�K�Â�QU@eC$k ��C�KL@eYr��@eYr��QU@eC$S h$M[k ��CC�k!h�Y3f3Cif���k¯����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K��

�3254 � 4��� ��� �� @ � 7

?#@!Cc��feC�MgY ¬ QL@eC �j�[ £  �L¶ªÁ������rµ'¤¸KTQUWUM[QLC�zOS���KXQU@!MrQ*QL@eC�WLCif3C�P���K�M[���#M¦SpKQU@eCR��C ¬ QUBDYbKaQ�¨y�eN3Q*WUC�feN!hªQU��YbkKL@eYbNe��f'KaQLYbd'��@eC$k.M�h�YOk�KTQUWLN!h�QLYbW���K*MrQ�QU@eC�QUYOd®Âp��kDQL@eC�NekyQTSyd;C�f.�e��h$M[��h�N!��N!K�QL@eC�YOke��SDh�YOk�KTQUWLN!h�QLYbW��K¸�3��M[�!KaQLWjMOh�QL��YOk®Â���k¾QTSyd;C�f9�3��h$MO��h$Ne���®QL@!C$WUC�B'M¦S�MO��KLY.�;C h$YOk!KaQLWUN!hªQUYOWjK ¬ YOW¸feM[QUMe¨�KLN!hj@¾MOK � GI � � �¬ YbW�����KaQUK��^t��;C$keC$×eQ�Y ¬ keYOQ h�YbkyQL��kyN!��kez¯QU@eC�C�¥rM[��N!MrQU��Ybk9N!k!f3C$WUkeCiMrQL@ MOk-M[�!KaQLWjMOh�QL��YOkÉYOW�M^f!MrQUMh$YOk!KaQLWUN!h�QLYOW���K�QL@!M[Q'MOBDYOkezsQL@eC^h�M[���§���pSb��k!MOB�C�keYOWUB'M[� ¬ YOWUB'KDM[WUC�QUC$WUBDKDWUC$d!WLCiKaC�kbQU��k!zÈ��k3×!ke��QLCYb�3ZTC�h�QUK�¨ ¬ YOW���k!KTQjM[k!h$CgM�QUC$WUB�QL@!M[QcC$¥rM[��N!M[QLC�K*QUY QU@eC¸����KaQcY ¬ MO����k!M[QLNeWjM[�÷kpNeB ��C�WUK��X?#@eC$WUC ¬ YbWLC�YOkeCh�M[k9��WL��QLC�BDC�MOke��k!z ¬ Ne��d!WLYbzOWjM[B'K ¬ YbWgBDMOke��deNe��MrQL��kez¯��k3×!ke��QLC'Yb�3ZTC�h�QUK���?#@eCiKaCDdeWUYOzbWUMOB'KRf3��¥OC�WLzbCN!k!f3C$W�YOQL@eC�W�C$¥rM[��N!M[QL��YOk¯KTQUWUM[QLC$zb��CiK$�� kÉYOd;C$k9QUC$WUBDK�¨÷[email protected]$MO�������pSy��k!M[BDCDKTQUWUM[QLC$zbSÈM[��KLY�KaQLYbd!K¸YOk9QLC�WLB'K¸����QL@-M¯¥rM[WU��MO�e��C ��kÉ@eC�Mbf

d;YbKL��QL��YOk®¨(QL@!M[Q���KgQLC$WUB'KgY ¬ QL@!C ¬ YOWUB �6 � ]0]2]�3�ÂQU@e��K���K�KaY¯�;C�h$MON!KLCO¨��kyQLN!�§QU��¥bC$��SO¨�*C'keC�C�fsQLY�pkeYr� ��@!M[Q�QU@eCR¥rM[WU��M[�e��Cc��K���k!KaQUM[kyQU��M[QLC�f�QUY���k.YOWjf3C�W�QLY�f3C�h$��feCR��@!M[Q*WUC�f3N!h�QL��YOkDQUY f3Y keC�PpQ��X?#@eC

�´ó�â����

Page 16: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

���!��¤�©��;©L¤$�«�£�p¿R�j�3�������6�r�!�g�r�#���a�j�[ ����3 §�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª� E�m

�[�;¤:���ª��¤T�É�j�r £  �L¶ªÁ������rµ'¤�©U¤UÃ[�!�����6�r�È©L¤� ��r���6�r��;6=�� � � �^� ��K�f3C$×!keCif��pS�QL@eC¸QT��Y WUNe��C�K9 #������'& �<;>=���'@ A C D4F

O ;4=��X P �R;4= � P �HcC�f3N!h�QL��YOkD��K�f3C�QUC$WUBD��ke��KaQL��h[º�QL@eC�WUC�f3C$P ��K�M[���#M¦SpK/M[QXQL@eC�C$PyQUWLC�BDC���C ¬ Q�Y ¬ MGQLC$WUB¯�t�K/QL@!C 1 WUNe��C���KMO�!KLC$kyQ�¨yC$¥rM[��N!M[QL��YOk.f3YpC�K�keY[Q#h�YbkbQU��kpNeCRNek!f3C�[email protected][k.M[��KTQUWUMbhªQL��YOk(ÂyMOk!f'MOK�QL@eC S WLN!��Cc��K�M[�!KLC$kyQ�¨QU@eC�M[WUzON!B�C�kyQ#Y ¬ M ¬ Nek!h�QL��YOk¯��K�keY[Q�C�¥¦MO��N�MrQLCif÷��]/PeM[BDde��C�K#Y ¬ h�M[���§���pSy��k!MOBDC�WUC�f3N�hªQL��YOk�K�M[WUC

#������5#>& ) ;4=�� # ³ � ·#������5����&K# # #>&*;>= � #K#�#�&#K#�#�&*;>= � #4#K#�#�&M;4= � # #�;6= � # ³6mb·#����>�4�K� &���# # #>& ;4= � #����6��� &#K#�#�&M;4= � �\� ³´ny·

� ��k!h$C�h�M[���§���pSy��k!MOBDC���K��!MbKaCif^YOkÈQL@eC-9¼WUNe��CO¨;QL@eC'�e�«QU@eC$YbWLS¯��k!f3N!h$C�f¾�pS¾h�M[���§���pSb��k!MOB�Cg��K�QL@eCKUM[BDC�MbK ��9��s?#@!C$WUC ¬ YOWUC.M¾h$YOWUWLCihªQ�KLC$B'M[kyQL��h$K�Y ¬ h�M[���§���pSb��k!MOB�C'KL@eYON!��f ³«MrQ���C�MbKTQª·g¥rM[����feMrQUC'QL@eCCi¹yN!M[���§QU��CiK#Y ¬ ��9���32 1 � 4��� ��� ���� �� � 7

_�k QL@!C¾h$M[�������pSy��k�M[BDC�KaQLWjMrQUC$zOSb¨XQL@!C¾h�YOkyQUWUMbhªQL��YOk¼Y ¬ M9WUC�f3C$P #�������'& � ��KDd;C$W ¬ YOWUBDC�f¼���§QU@eYON3QWUC�KaQLWU��hªQL��YOk�YOk�QL@eC ¬ YbWLB�Y ¬ QU@eCgM[WUzONeBDC$kyQ �-��?#@e��K�h�YbkbQUWUMbKTQjK�����QL@�QU@eC.�U�[ £  �L¶�Á���¢¦�[ ¡�!¤�³6YOW�¤j�$¿y¤�©[·KaQLWjMrQUC$zbSO¨;��@eC$WUC�QU@eC MOWLzbNeBDC$kyQ�� ��K�WLCif3N!h�Cif¯QLY�M¾¢r�r ¡�!¤��;C ¬ YbWLC�QL@eC�WUC�f3C$P���K¸h�YOkyQUWUMbhªQLCif÷�R?#@eC¥rMO��NeCiK�Y ¬ QL@!CGN!kbQTSpd;C�f�h$M[�������pSy��¥rMO��NeCG�3��h$MO��h$Ne��N�K*MOWLCRQL@eC ¬ Nek!h�QL��YOk!K¸³£QU@!MrQ#��K$¨pQU@eC¸�e��M[�!KaQLWjMOh�QL��YOk!Kj·MOk!f÷¨®YbkÈYbd�C�k¾QLC�WLB'K�¨®M[��KaY�QL@!C�¥rMOWL��M[�e��C�K�³´��QgB'M[�OCiK�KLC$k�KaC QL@!M[Qg¥¦MOWL��M[�!��CiKR�;CD¥¦MO��N!C�KG��Cih$MON!KaC���kh�M[���§���pSy��¥rM[��NeC�KLNe�!KaQL��QLNeQL��YOk!KWUC$de��MOh$C�¥rM[WU��MO�e��CiK®����QL@ ¥¦MO��N!C�KTF keYOQMOWL�e��QLWjM[WUS�QLC$WUB'K�F M[k�fGQL@eC�WLC ¬ YOWUCQU@eC�h���YbKLC�f�QLC�WLB'K�QU@!MrQRh�M[k���CgYb�3QUMO��keCif ¬ WLYbB°M�¥¦MOWL��M[�!��C¸M[WUCgh���YbKLC�f�¥¦MO��N!C�Kj·ªº

Ü�M[��NeC�K � � � ����� � � ^�?#@!C��r�;¤:���ª��¤T�É�j�[ £  �L¶ªÁ���¢r�r §�!¤�©U¤UÃ[�!�����6�r�È©L¤� ��r���6�r��;6=�� � ��� � ��Kcf3C$×!keC�f��pS.QU@eC�KLC¸WLNe��C�K�º

9 � #������'&�� ;4= � '@��>CED4FO �;4= � QP �R;4=��( P � S � �T;>= � �HP#������'& �<;>=�� #������'& � P]XP3MOBDde��CiK�Y ¬ h$MO�������pSy��¥¦MO��N!C�WUC�f3N�hªQL��YOk�K�M[WUC

#������5#>& ) ;4= � #������5#>& ) ;>= � ]2]0] ³«xO·#������5�>� &K# # #>&:;4= � #������K����& # ;4= � #�#�;4= � # ³(�b·#����>�6�5� &���# # #>& ;4=�� #����4��� &#K#�#�& ;>=�� #����6����& #�;>=���� ³�o[·

Ý�MO�������ySy��¥rM[��NeC#��K��!MOKLC�f�YOkDQU@eC(9��#WUNe��COÂbQL@eCG�3��QL@eC�YOWUS���k!f3N!h$C�f'�pS�QL@e��K�WUNe��Cc��K�QL@eCG��9�� � �p¤j�r©ªÁr¨MO��KLY'h$MO����C�f�QL@eCc���[©ªµD�[ (� �p¤j�r©ªÁ��a�X9 � ¤ �$�!�r ¡�£��Ár¨!f3C$×!keCif��pS'QU@eC�MrP3��YOB

9�� #�������'&�� � '@���C D>Fd!��N!K�QL@eC���k ¬ C�WLC�k!h�C�WLNe��C�K���k ?M[�e��C^EO�¯t�h$YOWUWLCihªQ�KLC$B'M[kyQL��h$K�Y ¬ h$M[�������pSy��¥rMO��NeC'KL@eYON!��f ³«MrQ���C�MbKTQª·¥rMO����feMrQUCGQL@eCgCi¹bN�M[���§QU��CiK#Y ¬ ��9��[�

â�â54�6!þ87:98;

Page 17: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

E�n � Ì(À��[�y¿O�6�r©«¿O�

Ý�MO�������pSy��¥¦MO��N!CR��K*¥bC$WUS'h�YOBDBDYOk���k���MOkezON�M[zOCR��BDde��C$BDC$kyQjMrQL��YOk�K$�Xt�f3¥rM[kyQjM[zOCiK�Y ¬ h$MO�������ySy��¥rM[��NeCMOWLCbº�³´�£·X� ¬ ��k�#������'& � QU@eCc¥rM[WU��M[�e��C:�.Y3h$h�N!WUK/BDYOWUC#QL@�M[kDYOk!h$C���kDQU@eC��;YpfeS\ ¨OQL@eC�k'C$¥rM[��N!MrQU��k!z�Ø�;C ¬ YOWUC¸WLC�de��MOh���kez �^BDM¦S.M¦¥bYO��f.@!M¦¥p��kez QLYDWLCif3N!h$CGKLC$¥bC$WjM[�÷h�Ybde��CiK�Y ¬ � ³6h$YOkyQLWjMOKaQ#C�PeM[BDde��C'³6mb·����QL@ ³(�y·a·�Â�M[k�f¼³´���£·R��k9��MOkezON!MOzOCiKc����QL@ÉKa��f3CDC ��C�h�QUK�¨®h$M[�������pSy��¥rMO��NeC ��K¸CiMOKL��C�WRQUY�N!k!f3C$WjKaQUM[k�fÈM[k�fB'M[QL@eC�BDM[QL��h$MO����S�BDYOWUC¸QLWjMOh�QUMO�e��Cb� � k¯QL@eC�YOQL@eC�WR@!MOk!f÷¨;h$M[�������pSy��k�M[BDC¸@!MOKcQL@eC�Mbf3¥rM[kyQUMOzOCiK#QL@!M[Q�º³6��·�YOkeC�f3YpC�KgkeYOQ d;C$W ¬ YOWUB N!KLC$��C�KUK�WUC�feN!hªQU��Ybk!KgY ¬ QU@eC�MOWLzbNeBDC$kyQ � Y ¬ M^WUC�f3C$P #������'& ��� ¬ �feYyCiKXkeYOQ�Yph�h�NeWX��kNIM[k!f QL@!C$WUC ¬ YOWUC � ��KXk!Y[Q�N!KLC�f¯³6h$YOkyQLWjMOKaQXC�PeM[BDde��C�³´np·���§QU@¾³�oO·a·ªÂpM[k�f�³6���£·/Ybkh$C$WLQUMO��k�QLC$WUB'K$¨eQL@eCgh$MO�������ySy��k!M[BDC¸KTQUWUM[QLC�zOSDQLC�WLBD��k!MrQUC�K���@eC�WLCiMOK#h$MO�������pSy��¥¦MO��N!C ¬ MO����Kg³6MOk�C$P3MOBDde��C��K�QL@!C¸QLC$WUB #������5#>& ) ¨;MOK�KL@eYr��k���k-³ � ·#MOk!f9³«xO·L·ª�t ¥rM[WU��MOkbQ�Y ¬ h$MO�������pSy��¥¦MO��N!Cc��K��3�[©L�r £ �¤� ��j�[ £  �L¶ªÁ���¢r�r §�!¤�QL@!M[Q�@!MbKXQU@eCRYbWUf3��k!MOWLS S WUNe��CR��k�de��Mbh�CcY ¬S �[�R_�QUK�YOk!C���KTQUC$d^WUC�f3N!h�QL��YOk^WUC$��MrQU��Ybk^��KGf3C$k!Y[QLCif^�pSZ;6=�� � �G?#@e��K�KaQLWjMrQUC$zOS���K�keYOQGf3C$QLC$WUBD��k!��KaQL��h[¨�;C�h�M[N!KLC���k.M[k.M[d!de����h$M[QL��YOk� � ��YOQL@DQU@eC ¬ Nek!h�QL��YOk�MOk!f QL@eC�M[WUzONeBDC$kyQ�h�M[kD��C�WLCif3N!h$C�f÷� �cYbWLB'M[�

¬ YbWLB'K#M[WUCO¨p@eYr��C$¥bC$Wi¨ONek!��¹yNeC'³£QU@!MrQ���K$¨3� ¬ ��� � �:QP÷MOk!fI ��� � �(QP P�MOk!f��;Y[QU@^QP�MOk!f QP PMOWLC �� ��k ¬ K�¨pQL@eC�k^QP � QP P£·ª¨eM[k�f.� ¬ @�MOK#M �� ��k ¬ ¨pQL@eC�k�MO���÷WUC�feN!hªQU��Ybk�KLC�¹yNeC$k�h�C�K ¬ WUYOB M[WUC×�ke�§QUCO��Ú*Cih$MON!KaCDY ¬ QU@eC�KLC'deWUYOd;C$WLQL��C�K�¨(�;C$@!M¦¥p��YONeWjM[�/C�¹yNe��¥rM[��C$k!h$C'Nek!f3C�W�d!MOWUMO����C$��h�M[���§���pSb��¥rM[��NeC���KN�KaN!MO����S¯QL@!C�KUM[BDCDMOKRQL@!M[Q¸N!k!f3C$W'³«KaCi¹bN!C$kyQL��M[�£·Rh�M[���§���pSy��¥rM[��NeC�³´��C�KL@!M[���QUMO���¾MO��YbN3QG�;C$@�M¦¥y��YON!WUMO�Ci¹yNe��¥rMO��C�k!h�CiK ¬ YOWR�e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!K#��k � C�hªQU��YbksEbEi·��

�32�� � 4��� ��� �� @ 7�7�9

_�kÉM���MOkezON�M[zOC�����QL@eYbN3Q�Ka��f3C'C ��C�h�QUK�¨®��@eC�WLC�QL@!C'C$¥rM[��N!MrQU��YbkÈY ¬ M�QLC�WLB M[����M¦S3K�Sy��C$��[email protected]�KLNe��Q�¨�QL@eC���keC �.h���C$k�h�S¯deWUYO�e��C$B'K�Y ¬ h$MO�������ySy��k!M[BDC�MOWL��Ka��kez ¬ WUYOB WUC$d;C�M[QLC�f¾C$¥rM[��N!MrQU��Ybk^Y ¬ h$YOde��C�KY ¬ QL@eC�M[WUzONeBDC�kbQ Y ¬ M ¬ N!k!hªQU��Ybk¼h$MOk ��C�M¦¥OYb��f3Cif-MOK ¬ YO����Yr�cK��È?#@eC�×!WUKaQ�QU��BDC�QL@eC�M[WUzONeBDC�kbQ ��KC�¥rM[��N!MrQUC�f÷¨3��QUK�¥rMO��NeCg��K�KUM¦¥OC�f���k¯MOk�C�kp¥y��WUYOkeBDC$kyQiÂ3� ¬ keC$Cif3C�f¯KLNe�!KLC�¹yNeC�kbQU��Sb¨pQL@eCg¥rMO��NeCg��K ¬ C$QUhj@eCif¬ WUYOB QL@eC¯C$kp¥p��WLYbkeBDC$kyQ�� _�k QU@e��KD��M¦Sb¨�QL@!C�C�¥rM[��N!MrQU��Ybk Y ¬ QL@!C¯MOWLzbNeBDC$kyQD��K'KL@!M[WUC�f M[BDYOk!z9MO���d!��Mbh�C�K���@eC�WLCRQL@eCgMOWLzbNeBDC$kyQ���K�N!KLC�f÷�X?#@e��K#��BDde��C$BDC�kbQjMrQU��Ybk.QLCihj@eke��¹yNeC¸��K#h$MO����C�f9�j�r £  �L¶�Á����;¤j¤jÃr��_�Q��K*N!KaN�M[����SDdeWUC�KLC$kyQLCif.MOK�M�WUC�feN!hªQU��Ybk�KTQUWUM[QLC�zOS�YOk�zbWUMOde@!K�¨O��@eC�WLC�� �p�r©ª�£�p¿'Y ¬ KaN!�3QLC�WLB'K*��K*C�MbKaS�QLYWUC$d!WLCiKaC�kbQi��tR�§QUC$WUk!MrQU��¥bC$��SO¨[h$MO�������ySy��keC$Cif�h�M[k��;C ¬ YOWUB'M[����KLC�f���kDMg�3��h$MO��h$Ne��N!K���§QU@DM ��� �gh�YOk�KTQUWLN!h�Q�¨QUYDB�Y3f3C��(KL@!M[WU��k!z!�/?#@eC 9ÉWLNe��C¸��KcWLC�de��Mbh�Cif.�pS.QU@eC ��� �'WUNe��C

#������'& �<;>= ������� � � � ��� ��� ¬ ¥6# �/& ³6wb·

_�k�QL@eC¸f3C�WL��¥rMrQL��¥OCb¨OQU@eCGC$¥rM[��N!MrQU��Ybk�h$YOkyQL��kpNeC�K*YOkI M[k!f'Ybke��S'��@eC$k�QL@eCG¥rM[��NeCGMbKLKLY3h���MrQUC�f�QLY-����Kk!C$C�feC�f÷¨3��K*QL@eCgKLNe�3QLC�WLB � C$¥rM[��N!M[QLC�f®�/?#@!CG¥rMO��NeC�QLY���@e��hj@ � WLCif3N!h$C�K*WLC�de��Mbh�CiK�QU@eCGYph�h�NeWUWUC$k!h$CY ¬ � ��k ¹yNeCiKTQU��Ybk®¨�M[k�f M[����KLNe�!KLC�¹yNeC�kyQ Y3h$h$NeWLWUC$k�h�C�K�Y ¬ � ��@eC$k¼QL@eC���W�¥rM[��NeC���K keC$Cif3C�f®�É?#@!C$WUCMOWLCgMO��KLY�KLYOBDCgKaQLWUN!hªQUNeWUMO�÷WLN!��CiK ¬ YOWcB'M[k!��deN!��M[QL��kez � � �.C$P3deWLCiKLKL��YOk!K�¨yQL@!M[QcN!KaN�M[����S.B'MO�OC¸N!KLCgY ¬ Mk!Y[QL��YOk�Y ¬ ¤$¢¦�[ ¡�!�r���6�r�É�U�[�!��¤KJb�*QLY'f3C$×!keC¸QL@!CgkeC�PpQcWUC�f3C$P��Û!YOW���k!KTQjM[k!h$CO¨e��k¯h$M[�������pSy��k!C$C�f���CG@�M¦¥OC

# # ��#������K� &#����4�K�4&;4= ��� ��� � � ���6�5�����N�;4=���� ��� � � ���6�5������� ������ � ����� � #

³6vb·

��@!C$WUC � ��k�f3��h�MrQUC�K�M[d!de����h$M[QL��YOk�Y ¬ QL@eCgzyM[WU�!M[zbC���h�Yb����C�h�QL��YOk'WUNe��C

# ��� � � ��� �/& � � ��� ¬ ¥6# ��& ³aE�qb·

�´ó�â����

Page 18: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

���!��¤�©��;©L¤$�«�£�p¿R�j�3�������6�r�!�g�r�#���a�j�[ ����3 §�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª� Eix

³�Ù¸M[WU�!M[zbC���h�Yb����C�h�QL��YOk WLNe��C�K�B'M¦S YbW�B'M¦S k!Y[Q��;CÈd!WLCiKaC�kbQ���k QU@eCsfeC�×!ke��QL��YOk²Y ¬ M h�M[���§���pSb��keC�C�fWUC�feN!hªQU��Ybk®Âb��k�MOkyS�h$MbKaCb¨bMgWUNe��CRKaN�[email protected]³aE�qb·�h$M[k'�;CRd!WLYr¥bC�f ¥¦MO����f ¬ YbW���C�@!M¦¥p��YbNeWjM[�eCi¹bN!��¥rM[��C$k�h�C�K�� ·� ��BD����MOWL��SO¨3��Cg@!M¦¥OC

# � ��� ��� � � ³aEOE¦·��Ka��kez¸f3C$WU��¥¦M[QL��YOk!K�³6vy·(MOk!f�³aEOE¦·÷QUY�h�YbBDdeWLCiKLK�WUC�f3N!h�QL��YOk!K�¨r@eC�WLC*��K/M�B�YbWLC*��kyQUC$WUC�KaQL��kez�h�M[���§���pSb��keC�C�fh$YOBDdeN3QjMrQU��Ybk®���cYOQLCGQL@!M[Q�QL@eCg��YOWU� ¬ YOW#QU@eCgC$¥rMO��N!M[QL��YOk�Y ¬ QL@eC�MOWLzbNeBDC$kyQ # #.��K�f3YbkeC¸YOke��S�Ybk!h�Cbº

#������0#K# � &.� &#K#�#�&;4= ��� ��� � � # # ���,#K# � &.���� ��� � ��� � � # # ���N������ ��� � ��� � � # ���N�>�;4= ��� ��� � � # ��� # �������� � ��� � � # ���N�;4=���� � #

±9CRKL@!M[���!k!Y[Q�deWUC�KLC$kyQ*M ¬ YbWLB'MO��KLSpKaQLC�B ¬ YbW��e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�����QL@ ��� ��ÂyQU@eCc��kbQUNe��QL��YOk!K*zO��¥OC�kDMO��Yr¥bCKL@eYbNe��f��;CgC$keYbNezO@�QLY'Nek�f3C$WjKTQjM[k!f�YON!W�N!KaCiK#Y ¬ h$M[�������pSy��k!C$C�f®�t�KDh$M[�������pSy��k!C$C�f ��KDM[k ��BDde��C$BDC�kbQjMrQU��Ybk QLCihj@eke��¹yNeC ¬ YbW'h$M[�������pSy��k�M[BDCO¨X��QUK QL@!C$YOWUSÉ��KDh$��YyKaC���S

WUC$��MrQUC�f.QLY�QU@!MrQ�Y ¬ h$MO�������pSy��k!M[BDCO�?#@eC¸KaC$QUK�Y ¬ �e��QLC$WUB'K*QL@!M[Q�@!M¦¥bC�M�keYOWUB'M[� ¬ YOWUB�Nek!f3C�W#h�M[���§���pSy�k!C$C�f�M[k!f�h�M[���§���pSy��k!MOBDC�h�YO��k!h$��f3CbÂ[M[k!fGQT��Y��e�«QUC$WUB'K�MOWLC��;C$@�M¦¥y��YON!WUMO����ScC�¹yNe��¥rM[��C$kyQ���k�h�M[���§���pSb��keC�C�f���¾QU@eC$S�M[WUC¸KLYD��k¯h$MO�������ySy��k!M[BDCb�

� ��������������� ���� ���!����"��#��"� - $������� �!����"��#��"����

tR���;Y ¬ QU@eCcQUWUMOk!KL��M[QL��YOk!KXY ¬ �3��h$MO��h$Ne��N!K�KaQLWjMrQUC$zO��C�K���kyQLY ����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�QL@!M[Q*��CRKa@�M[����deWUC�KLC$kyQ�@�M¦¥OC#QT��Yh$YOBDBDYOk ¬ C�M[QLNeWUC�K�º

� ÛeN!k!hªQU��Ybk¾M[dede����h$MrQU��Ybk¯��K#QUWUMOk!KL��M[QLC�f¯MbKcM ¬ YOWUB°Y ¬ d�M[WjM[����C��®h�YOB �e��k!MrQU��Ybk�Y ¬ QT��Y'deWUY3h�C�KUKLC�K�¨QL@!C ¬ N!k!hªQU��Ybk�MOk!f.��QUK#M[WUzON!B�C�kyQ�¨3M[k!fN9®��WLCif3N!h�QL��YOk.��K#BDYpfeC$����Cif�MOK#MOk���kbQUC$WjMOh�QL��YOk��;C�QT��C$C�kQL@!C$B¯�

� ?#@eC¾C�k!h�Y3f3��kez-Y ¬ M �e��QLC$WUB ��K�d!M[WjM[BDC�QUWL��h�Yr¥OC�W.M-k!M[BDCb� ?#@e��K.k�M[BDC¾��K'N!KLC�f �pS ³´QL@eCQLWjM[k�Ka��MrQU��Ybk�Y ¬ ·*QL@eC��e�«QUC$WUB�QUY���kyQLC�WUMbhªQ����§QU@�QL@eCgC�ky¥p��WLYbkeBDC$kyQ��

_�k � C�h�QL��YOk � ��E���C�YO��KaC�WL¥bC�f¸QU@!MrQXMRWUC�feC�PgY ¬ QU@eC��3��h$MO��h$Ne��N�K�zb��¥bC�K(WL��KaC�QLY¸MRd!WL��¥rMrQLC*��kyQUC$WjMOhªQU��Ybk�;C�QT��C$C�k.QT��Y�QUC$WUBDK��_�k�h�YbkyQLWjMOKaQ�¨pM�WUC�f3C$PDY ¬ QL@eCG����h$M[��h�N!��N!K*��K�KLN!KUh�C�d3QL���e��CRQUY���kbQUC$W ¬ C$WUC$k!h$C ¬ WUYOBQU@eC^C$kp¥p��WLYbkeBDC$kyQ�� ?#@e��K.��kyQLC�W ¬ C�WLC�k!h�C���K'M¦¥OYO��f3Cif � ¬ QL@!C^k!M[BDC¯N!KLC�f �yS QL@eC¯QT��Ysd!WLY3h�CiKLKLC�K QUYh$YOBDB�N!ke��h�MrQUCR��K�deWU��¥¦M[QLC�QLY�QL@eC�B���?#@!C$WUC ¬ YOWUCO¨OQL@eC¸M[d!d�CiM[WjM[k!h$CcY ¬ M 9÷��WLCif3C�PD��k�M �e�«QUC$WUB�Ka@!YONe��fh$YOWUWLCiKad;YOk�f÷¨���kÈQL@eCD����h$M[��h�N!��N!K�QUWUMOk!Ka��MrQU��Ybk¾Y ¬ QL@!M[QGQUC$WUB¯¨�QLY�QL@eC'M[d!d�CiM[WjM[k!h$C�Y ¬ QT�*Y�deWLY3h$C�KUKaCiKQU@!MrQRh�M[k¯h�YbB�B Neke��h$M[QLCgM[��YOkez'M ��©ª�£¢r�r��¤�k!M[BDCO�±9C¸M[��KaY�Yb�!KLC$WU¥OC�fD��k � C�hªQU��Ybk � ��EcQU@!MrQ*QL@eC 9ÈWUNe��CRY ¬ QL@eCg�e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!K*��K�KTQUWLYbkezO��SDMOKLSyBDBDC�QUWL��h[�

?�Ygh�Ybd�C#����QL@�QL@e��K�¨[QL@!C�����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K/��M[kezbN!M[zbC�QU@!MrQX��C��������eN!KLC ¬ YbWXC$k!h$Y3f3��k!zg�e��h$M[��h�N!��N!KXKaQLWjMrQUC$zb��CiK��K�QL@eC'�¦�ªÁr�;� �b©U�r�;�[�p�*���a�j�r ����3 ¡�p�ª¨y��@eYbKLC�MbKaSpBDBDC�QUWLS�Y ¬ QU@eC�h$YOBDB�Nek!��h�MrQL��YOk'WUNe��CRWUC �!CihªQjKXQL@�MrQ*Y ¬QU@eC.�3��h$MO��h$Ne��N!K$��H�C�h�M[���QL@!M[Q¸��k¾QU@eC'MOKLSpk!hj@eWUYOkeYbN!Kc����h$MO��h$Ne��N�KRQU@eC$WUCD��KGkeY�deWUY3h�C�KUKGNek!f3C�WLk!C�MrQU@MOk¾YONeQLdeN3Q¸deWUC�×eP÷�RÛ!YOW¸h�Ybky¥bC$ke��C$k�h�CO¨�@eYr��C$¥OC�W�¨��*C KaYbB�C$QL��BDC�K�N!KaC YON3QUdeN3QGdeWLC$×eP3C�KRY ¬ QL@!C ¬ YbWLB�7 � Q P 7 �LY �&R��L��� MD¨/��@eC$WUC � 7 �DM[k!f ����KgQL@!C�KaN!�3ZTC�h�Q�Y ¬ deWUC�×eP9�X¨QLY¾@e��zO@!����zO@yQ�YOWjf3C�WL��kez¾M[BDYbkez

â�â54�6!þ87:98;

Page 19: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

E�� � Ì(À��[�y¿O�6�r©«¿O�

MbhªQU��Ybk!K^³´Nek�f3C$W'QU@eYbKLC¯@pSyd;Y[QU@eC�KLC�K�¨ �7 � Q PE7 �LY �&R�� � MØ��K�KaC�BDMOkyQL��h$M[����SÉQL@eCÈKUM[BDC^MOK �

7 � # Q P 7 �LY �&RHN � M-&�·ª�t k�M[BDC�d!M[WjM[BDC$QLC$WX��KXkeC�C�f3CifD��k�QU@eCc����h$M[��h�N!��N!K�C$k!h$Ypfe��kezyK/Y ¬ �3��QLC�WLB'K ¬ YOW/QL@!C ¬ YO����Yr����kez¸WUC�Mr�

KLYOk(�/HcYONezb@e��S'KLd�CiM[�p��kez!¨p��k.QL@!C¸�e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�¨e����K*QL@!C�Ybke��S'd;YOWLQ�Â3MD�3��QLC�WLB�WUC�h$C$��¥OCiK���QUK#M[WUzON!B�C�kyQM[Q��®�'_�k9QL@!C�����h$MO��h$Ne��N!K$¨(QL@eC�WLC'MOWLC�B'M[kpS¾d;YOWLQUK�¨(KaY¯YbkeCDkeC$CifeKGQLY¾KLd�Cih�� ¬ SÈMrQ���@!��hj@9d�YbWaQ.³´QL@eCC�k!h�Y3f3��kezDY ¬ ·#MD�e��QLC$WUB°��kyQLC�WUMbhªQUK#����QL@¯��QUK#C�ky¥p��WLYbkeBDC$kyQ��

�;254 � > @A<�= @ � C<�=?> @�� E�E�=5@�� � <� � 7?#@!C�d!M[WjM[BDC�QUC$W/Y ¬ QL@!C�����h�M[��h�Ne��N!KXC�k!h�Y3f3��kez¸Y ¬ M ¬ Nek!hªQU��Ybk.h$MOk�MO��KLY¸��C#QU@eYONezb@yQ�Y ¬ MOKXM'�j�r�!���£�!�!� ����6�r����_�k ¬ Nek�hªQL��YOk�M[�e��M[kezbN!M[zbC�K�¨[M¸h�YOkyQU��kpN!M[QL��YOk���KXM¸d!MOWUMOBDC�QLC�W/Y ¬ M ¬ N!k!hªQU��Ybk QU@!MrQ�WUC$d!WLCiKaC�kbQjKQL@eC� WUC�KaQ � Y ¬ QU@eC¸h�YOBDdeNeQUMrQU��Ybk®�XÛeNek�hªQL��YOk�K�QUM[�p��kez h$YOkyQL��kpN!MrQU��Ybk!K�MOK#M[WUzONeBDC�kbQjK*MOWLCGh$MO����C�f �j�3�;�$�«�6�[�e��£�²»X�[�!���£�!�!�[�«�6�[�9½��¦�j�ª�£�y¿¾À���Ár �¤^³6�eWU��C:�!S »(½*À��j�3�������6�r�!�a·ª¨(MOk!fÈ@�M¦¥OCDM�KLd;C�h���M[��KLSpkyQUMOh�QL��h ¬ YbWLB¯ºQU@eC$S�QLC�WLBD��k!MrQUC¸QL@eC���WGh�YbB�d!N3QUM[QL��YOk¯�pS�d!MbKLKL��k!zDQL@eC�WUC�KLNe��Q�QLY'QU@eC�h$YOkyQL��kpN!MrQU��Ybk®�*?#@eC�h$YOkyQL��kpN!Mr�QU��YbkDd!M[WjM[BDC�QUC$WXB'M¦S MO��KLYg�;C�QL@eYbNezO@yQ�Y ¬ MbK�M[k.Mbfef3WUC�KUKQLYg��@e��hj@DQL@eCRWLCiKaNe��Q�Y ¬ QU@eC ¬ Nek!h�QL��YOk'��K/QLY�;C�feC$����¥bC$WUC�f÷�/ÛeYbW�M[k.��k ¬ YbWLB'M[��C�PeM[BDde��CO¨OQUMO�OC�QU@eC ¬ Yb����Yr����k!z ¬ Nek!hªQU��Ybk ¬ WUYOB ��kyQLC�zOC�WUK�QLY���kyQLC$zbC$WjK$º

� $ %('�­���6� ����� � ��-�� -�� � �Z# � �>&�� # � �4&�RC$WUC#��K�M�Ý�V � ¥bC$WjKa��YOk Y ¬ � ÂO��k�QU@eC���Y3f3Sb¨ ������� ��KXM�Ý�V � ¥OC�WUKL��YOk�Y ¬ � ¨OM[k�f�����K/QL@eCch$YOkyQL��kpN!MrQU��Ybkd�M[WjM[BDC�QUC$Wiº

� ����� $&%('� ��� �4� ���� ������� ��� -�� ���� � -�� �����$# � &��� � �������i���>� � �������¦��� � ����� � � � - �����6# � & �6�!�>�

_�k-deWUYOzbWUMOBDB���kez���MOkezON�M[zOCiK¸h�YOkyQU��kpN!M[QL��YOk!KgMOWLCD����f3C$��SÈN!KLC�f®¨ ¬ YbWgdeWLYbzOWjM[BDBD��k!z!¨(MbKgM[kÉ��B��d!��C�B�C�kyQUMrQU��YbkDQLCihj@eke��¹bN!C�³£QUY�zOC�keC$WjMrQUCcM[k'��kyQLC$WUBDC�f3��MrQUCc��M[kezbN!M[zbC#QL@!M[Q���K�C�MbKa��C$W�QLY�Ybd3QL��BD��KLCRM[k�fB'MOke��d!Ne��M[QLC¦·ª¨XM[k!f ¬ YOW�zb��¥p��kezÈf3C�keY[QjMrQU��Ybk!M[��KLC$B'MOkbQU��h�K$�¾t ¬ M[��WL��S9¥¦MbKTQ�����QLC�WUM[QLNeWUC'Y ¬�¬ N!k!hªQU��Ybk!M[�d!WLYbzOWjM[BDBD��kezgKaQLN!fe��CiKXQLWjM[k�K ¬ YbWLB'MrQU��Ybk!KXY ¬;¬ N!k!hªQU��Ybk!K���kyQLY�Ý�V � ¬ Nek!h�QL��YOk!K��X?#@eC$SDM[WUCch$MO����C�f�Ý�V �QUWUMOk!K ¬ YOWUBDK�� ?#@eC¯��CiKTQ��yk!Yr��k MOWLC�QL@eCsÝ�V � QLWjM[k!K ¬ YOWUB'K ¬ YbW.h$MO�������pSy��k!M[BDC¯M[k!f h$MO�������ySy��¥rM[��NeC�e��h$M[��h�N!��N!K�KaQLN�f3��Cif��yS�VX��YOQL�p��k���k¯@e��KcKaC�BD��k!MO�÷d!M[d;C$W VX��YpoOx����±9C�KL@!M[���*feC$¥OC���YbdÉQL@eC�M[k!MO��YbzOS¾�;C�QT��C$C�k ����h$M[��h�N!��N!K�C$k!h$Ypfe��kezyK�MOk!f¼Ý�V � QUWUMOk!K ¬ YOWUBDK��¯±sC

KL@!MO���/f3C$WU��¥OC�����h$MO��h$Ne��N!KGC$k!h$Ypfe��kezyKRY ¬ h$MO�������ySy��k!M[BDC�MOk!fÈh�M[���§���pSy��¥rM[��NeC �e��h$M[��h�N!��N!KG¥p��M'QL@!C'Ý�V �QUWUMOk!K ¬ YOWUBDKY ¬ VX��Ypo[x ���/±9CcKa@!MO���3Yb�!KLC$WU¥OC�QL@!M[QXQL@eC#QjM[WUzOC$Q/Y ¬ QU@eC�Ý�V � QUWUMOk!K ¬ YbWLB'K/M[WUC#C�KUKaC�kyQL��M[����SKLNe��h$MO��h$Ne���RY ¬ � � �X� ±9CÈKL@!M[���#QL@eC�WLC ¬ YOWUC¯��CÈMO�e��C�QUY M[ded!��S h�YOBDde����MrQL��YOk�" ¬ WUYOB � � � QLY-���h�M[��h�Ne��N!K#QUY�f3C�WL��¥OCg����h$MO��h$Ne��N!K�C$k�h�Y3f3��kezbK ³#"É��K�f3C�×!k!C�f^��k � C�h�QL��YOkÈǸ·ª�c?#@!��KR��KcQL@eC deWLYbzOWjM[BDBDC¬ YbW � C�h�QL��YOk!K x¯M[k!f-�e¨M[k!f9��K�KLNeBDBDMOWL��KLC�fs��k Û��zONeWUC¯EO¨(��@!C$WUCOº ��� M[k!f-� � M[WUC�[email protected]�M[���§���pSb�k�M[BDCGMOk!f�h$M[�������pSy��¥rMO��NeC¸�3��h$MO��h$Ne���«Â$" � MOk!f�" � M[WUCRQU@eCgh$MO�������pSy��¥¦MO��N!C�M[k�f.QU@eCgh$M[�������pSy��k�M[BDC¸Ý�V �QUWUMOk!K ¬ YOWUBDK�Â�Ý�V � � M[k!f9Ý�V � � M[WUCg��M[kezbN!M[zbC�K�Y ¬ Ý�V � �e�«QUC$WUBDK�¨�QL@!M[QR��KRQL@!C�QUMOWLzbC�Qc��M[kezbN!M[zbC�K�Y ¬QU@eC¸QT��Y.Ý�V � QLWjM[k!K ¬ YOWUB'K$Â$% ��K#QL@eCg��krZTCihªQL��YOk¯Y ¬ QU@eC�KLC Ý�V � ��M[kezbN!M[zbC�K���kyQUY � � �XÂ!MOk!f&"s��K#QL@eCh$YOBDde����M[QL��YOk ¬ WUYOB � � �¾QLY�����h$MO��h$Ne��N!K$�X?#@eC�WLC���K�M�¥rMbKTQ�����QLC�WUM[QLNeWUCcYOk¯Ý�V � QUWUMOk!K ¬ YbWLB'K�Âb��CRN�KaCifQU@eC¸QLWjM[k�K ¬ YbWLB'K*QL@!M[Q�¨e��k¯YONeW#¥p��C$�g¨eSp��C$��f.QU@eC�Ka��BDde��C�KaQRM[k!f�BDYbKaQcWLYb�eN!KaQ#C�k!h�Y3f3��kezyK$�?#@eC KLhj@eC�B'MDY ¬ Û��zbNeWLC'E M[��KaY'M[d!de����C�KcQLY^��Áj�3¤jÃ^�e��h�M[��h�Ne����¨!�pS�C$PpQLC$k�f3��k!zDQL@eC�QLWjM[k!KL��M[QL��YOk!K#Y ¬

QUC$WUB'K�QLY�QLWjM[k!KL��MrQL��YOk�K#Y ¬ QTSpd;C�K��

�´ó�â����

Page 20: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

���!��¤�©��;©L¤$�«�£�p¿R�j�3�������6�r�!�g�r�#���a�j�[ ����3 §�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª� E¦o

� � ���� �����

���

��

�����

� � � � �� � �

�V � ���� �����

�����V � �

���� � � � �

� � � �� � �����

Û��zbNeWLCDEbº�?#@eCgf3C$WU��¥rM[QL��YOk!K#Y ¬ QL@!Cg����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K#C$k�h�Y3f3��kezbK#Y ¬ ��� M[k!f¯� �.�

��M¦¥p��kez�YO�eQUM[��keCif¾C$k�h�Y3f3��kezbKGY ¬ h$MO�������pSy��k!M[BDC MOk!f9h$M[�������pSy��¥rMO��NeCb¨÷��k � CihªQL��YOk�K¸xe� m!¨�op¨(MOk!f9v��C�h�M[k'QU@eC$k�de��M¦S�����QL@�QL@eC�B�M[k!f�f3C$WU��¥bCcC$k�h�Y3f3��kezbK*Y ¬ KL��BD����MOW�KaQLWjMrQUC$zb��CiK$¨yKaN!hj@�MOK�h$M[�������pSy��k!C$C�f®¨d�M[WjM[����C��®h$M[�������pSy��¥rMO��NeCb¨3M[k!f�KTQUWLYbkezDh$M[�������pSy��k�M[BDCO�

� Å Ð/"�Æ3Ð;~� Å Ð�� Û!YOW'Ka��BDde����h$�§QTSb¨���C�Mbf3YOd3QDQU@eC^h�YOkp¥bC$kyQL��YOk-QU@!MrQ.�e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!KD¥rM[WU��MO�e��C�K�M[WUC�MO��KLY����h$MO��h$Ne��N!K#k!M[BDCiK$�

� +���� $��������������¸� $��� � � ����"$"j����� � ��� "$���_�k QL@!��KXKLC�h�QL��YOk���C#f3C$¥bC$��YOdgQU@eC#��C ¬ Q/d�M[WLQY ¬ QL@eC�f3��M[zbWUMOB Y ¬ Û��zONeWUCOEb��?#@eC#����h$M[��h�N!��N!K�C$k�h�Y3f3��kez�Y ¬h�M[���§���pSy��¥rM[��NeC��3��h$MO��h$Ne��N!Kc³«� ��·X��K/Yb�3QUMO��keCif���k�QL@!WLC�CcKTQUC$d!K�¨[QU@eC#×!WjKTQXY ¬ ��@e��hj@D��K/QU@eCch$MO�������ySy��¥rM[��NeCÝ�V � QLWjM[k�K ¬ YbWLB Y ¬ VX��YpoOx����X?#@eC�WLCiMOf3C�W���@eY ��K*C�MOzOC�W�QLY�KaC�CcQU@eC�����h$MO��h$Ne��N!K�C�k!h�Y3f3��kez!¨3MOk!f.f3YpC�Kk!Y[Qc�#M[kyQ#QLYDzOY�QL@!WLYbNezO@�QL@eC Ý�V � QUWUMOk!K ¬ YOWUB�¨pB'M¦S.zbYDfe��WUC�h�QL��S'QLY � CihªQL��YOk¾xe� � �±9Cc�������;keYOQ�N!KLN!M[����S�zO��¥OCcfeC�QUMO����C�f.deWLYpY ¬ KXY ¬ WUC�KLNe�§QjK�MO��YbN3Q�QL@!C¸Ý�V � QUWUMOk!K ¬ YOWUBDK�¨OMbKXQL@!C$SDM[WUC

k!Y[Q�QL@!C�KaNe�eZTC�hªQ�Y ¬ QU@eCgd!M[d;C$WiÂeKLC$C � C�h�QL��YOkÉE$n ¬ YOW�WUC ¬ C�WLC�k!h�CiK$�

�3254 "!D7 < ! � 7�7 E < 7$# E%®~�Æ � � �¸~ � Æ^�O� Ò´Ò áU|�à�á#"e� Ò �(Æ ��& % ~$�r�!Ð�}�� Å �[Õ?#@!C'�j�[ £  �L¶ªÁ���¢r�r §�!¤.»(½*ÀÈ��©L�[�e�´���r©ªµ�¨$" �[¨bQUWUMOk!K ¬ YOWUBDK ¬ Nek!h�QL��YOk!K#Y ¬ � � ��kyQLY.Ý�V � ¬ Nek!h�QL��YOk!K��X_�k���QUKfeC�×!ke��QL��YOk(¨/QL@eC�QLWjM[k!KL��M[QL��YOkÉY ¬ ¥rMO��NeCiK�N!KLC�K�QL@eC�M[N3P3������M[WUS¾QUWUMOk!KL��M[QL��YOk ¬ Nek!h�QL��YOk "('� ³´��@e��hj@ ��������;C�d!M[WLQL��h�Ne��M[WU��SsN!KLC ¬ N!����@!C$k¼h$YOk!KL��feC$WU��kez¾QTSyd;C�Kj·ª�9±9C�h�M[����M¾QLC$WUB "('�() �+*cM »(½*À/��¢¦�[ ¡�!¤��-?#@eCQUWUMOk!K ¬ YOWUB ��K�deWUC�KLC$kyQLCif'��k¯?M[�e��C � �_�QjK#f3C�×!k!�§QU��Ybk���kyQLWUYpfeN!h�CiK*M keC$�²¥¦MOWL��M[�!��Cb¨OQU@eC.�U�[�!���£�!�!�[�«�6�[�¢r�r©ª�6�y¶ª �¤ ��¨(QL@!M[Q�WLC�deWUC�KLC$kyQUK¸h�YbkyQL��kyN�MrQL��YOk�KgM[k!fsQL@�MrQ�@!MbKGQLY¯��C��OC$deQgKLC$d�M[WjMrQLC ¬ WUYOB QU@eC'Y[QU@eC$W¥rMOWL��M[�e��C�K��-_�k QU@eC¯����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�C$k�h�Y3f3��kezbK�¨�M[k!f ��k QTSpd�Cif¼¥bC$WjKa��YOk�K�Y ¬ QL@eCÈÝ�V � QLWjM[k!K ¬ YOWUB¯¨/QL@eCh$YOkyQL��kpN!MrQU��Ybk-¥rM[WU��MO�e��C�M[k!fÉQU@eC�YOQL@eC�W�¥rM[WU��M[�e��C�K��������*@�M¦¥OC�f3����C$WUC$kyQ�QTSpd;C�K��¼³´_�k¼QL@eC�f3C�×!k!�§QU��YbkY ¬ " � ��C¾M[��KaY-N!KLC¾KLd�Cih���M[�RKLSpB��;YO��K�>Y � ¬ YOW'QU@eC ¬ YbWLB'M[�Rd!M[WjM[BDC�QUC$WjKDY ¬ h�YbkbQU��kpN!M[QL��YOk!K��²?#@eCfe��KaQL��k!hªQU��Ybks�;C�QT��C$C�kÈQU@eC�KLC�¥¦MOWL��M[�!��CiKGMOk!f¾YbWUfe��k!MOWLS¯¥rM[WU��M[�e��C�K���K�¨®@eYr��C$¥bC$Wi¨;KLYOBDC���@!MrQgM[WLQL��×�h���M[��;C�h�M[N!KLCGQL@eC ¬ YbWLBDC�W�BDM¦S���Cg��k!KaQUM[kyQU��M[QLC�f��pS'QL@!Cg��M[QaQLC�W�� ·

â�â54�6!þ87:98;

Page 21: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

Eiw � Ì(À��[�y¿O�6�r©«¿O�

���¾� �b���g���y¶ª �¤�Í�¤D�b¶i¶�©L¤�¢i�6�r��¤�" � ) ) * *��r� ) ) * *��[�;à "('�$) � *��r� ) � * �Ý�MO�������pSy��¥¦MO��N!C�¥rM[��NeCiK� � � ����� �-�

) ) � * * $&%('� � �$� � ) �+*) ) � * * $&%('� � �$� ) ) * *%#����>� ) ) � * *%#���� � � � �4&K&

) � * $&%('� �) ����� * $&%('� ����� ) ) * *

?M[�!��C � º/?#@!C�h$M[�������pSy��¥rMO��NeCgÝ�V � QLWjM[k�K ¬ YbWLB

±9C�C$Ppd!��MO��kÉ��k ¬ YOWUB'M[����S9@eYr� QL@eC^Ý�V � QLWjM[k!K ¬ YOWUB ��YOWU�3K$�¯?#@eC�Ý�V � ��B'M[zbC.Y ¬ M¾�e�«QUC$WUBT+��BDBDC�f3��MrQUC$��S¼keC�C�feK�M-h�YOkyQU��kpN!M[QL��YOk®� ± @eC$k M-h$YOkyQL��kpN!MrQU��Ybk ��K.d!WLYr¥p��f3C�f÷¨:+Ö��K.WUC�f3N!h$C�f QLY M¥rMO��NeCb¨�MOk!f¾QU@e��Kg¥rM[��NeC¾³´deWUC�h$��KLC$��S¾��QUK Ý�V � ��¥rMO��NeC¦·G��K�d!MOKUKaCif¾QUY�QL@eC�h$YOkyQL��kpN!MrQU��Ybk®�'?#@eC$WUC ¬ YbWLC�� ¬+ ��KD�§QjKaC�� ¬ MÈ¥rMO��NeCb¨�QU@eC$k ��Q'h�M[k ��C¯d!MbKLKLC�f f3��WLCihªQL��S-QUYÈQU@eC¾h�YbkbQU��kpN!M[QL��YOk®� _ ¬ ¨�@eYr��C$¥bC$Wi¨ + ��KMOk¼M[d!de����h$M[QL��YOk ��QL@eC�k¼QU@eC ¬ Yb����Yr����kez¾@!MOded�C�k!K�� Û���WjKTQ� ��K C$¥rMO��N!M[QLCif ����QL@ h$YOkyQL��kpN!MrQU��Ybk���4� " � ) ) � * *%#���� � � � �4&U�¯± @eC$k ��Cih�YOBDCiKgM ¬ Nek!hªQU��Ybk®¨/KLM¦SÈ������ � ¨(QL@e��K ¬ N!k!hªQU��Ybk9��Kgd!MbKLKLC�fÈQLYQU@eC�h$YOkyQL��kpN!MrQU��Ybk®¨�MOk!f�QL@eC ��Y3f3S�Y ¬ QU@eC h$YOkyQL��kpN!MrQU��Ybk���KcC�¥rM[��N!MrQUC�f÷�c?#@e��KcBDCiM[k!KRC$¥rM[��N!MrQU��k!z �����QL@ h$YOkyQL��kpN!MrQU��YbkÉ��� � � � �6@������� D���� �� C�� Fb��± @eC$k�� ��kÉQLNeWUk-��Cih�YbB�CiK�M�¥rM[��NeC �'¨(QL@e��K�¥rMO��NeC��K d!MOKUKaCif9QLYÈQL@eC¯h�YbkbQU��kpN!M[QL��YOk®¨XMOk!fÉQL@!C��;YpfeS-Y ¬ QL@!C�h�YbkyQL��kyN�MrQL��YOk-��K C$¥rM[��N!MrQUC�f÷�É?#@e��K��;Y3f3S��K�QL@!C¸QLC$WUB # � � �4&5@ � �� � � � C��(F @ � �� � D��� � C�� Fy¨3QL@!M[Q���K #������ " � ) ) � * *.& "('�() �+* ����?#@e��K#QUC$WUB�WLCif3N!h$C�K�QLY" � ) ) � * *.@ ������ � � C D�F ��¨3��@e��hj@¯��K#QU@eC�KUM[BDC�MOK " � ) ) � @ � CED>F * * ����?#@eC�WLC ¬ YOWUCGQL@eC �!Yr� Y ¬ h�YbkbQUWLYb�÷Y ¬ � �YbksMOdede����h�MrQL��YOkÈ��K¸h�YbWLWUC�h�QL��S�BD��BD��hj�bC�f÷ºR×!WUKaQGQL@eC�YOd;C$WjMrQUYOW Y ¬ QU@eC'M[dede����h$MrQU��Ybk¾��K�C�¥rM[��N!MrQUC�f÷¨QU@eC$k�QL@eC�M[WUzONeBDC$kyQ ����K(C$¥rM[��N!MrQUC�f÷¨rMOk!f¸×!k!MO����SGQL@eC�QT�*Y�f3C$WU��¥rM[QL��¥OC�K(Y ¬ M[k�f ��M[WUC�h�YbkyQLWjMOhªQUC�f÷�Û��k!M[����S¯QL@eCDWUC�f3N!h�QL��YOksY ¬ " � ) ) � @��>CED>F * * �¾h$YOkyQL��kpNeC�K¸M[k�f÷¨®MrQGQL@eCDC�k!f÷¨�QL@!C�¥rMO��NeC QL@�MrQ! � @ ��C D�FWUC�feN!h�CiK�QLYD��K#d�MOKUKaCif.QUY����?�Y'@eC$��d¯Nek!f3C�WUKaQUMOk!f3��kez�QL@eC���C�@!M¦¥p��YbNeW�Y ¬ M[ded!����h$M[QL��YOk®¨3��CgWLC�d�YbWaQ��;C$��Yr� QU@eC�f3C$QUM[����K�Y ¬ @eYr�

M-9��GWUC�f3N�hªQL��YOk #������ � &�� ;6= � � @ ��C D�F ³aE � ·��K�Ka��B�Ne��MrQUC�f÷�9±9C�N!KLC�QU@eC�h�M[���§���pSy��k!MOBDC.WLCif3N!h�QL��YOk ;>= � ¬ YOW QL@!C.QUMOWLzbC�Q.Ý�V � QLC�WLB'K�¨X�eN3QD�*Ch$YONe��f�ZTN!KaQ MOK¸��C$����@!M¦¥bC'hj@eYbKLC$kÉh$MO�������pSy��¥¦MO��N!CO¨(KL��k�h�CDQL@!C�KLC�KTQUWUM[QLC�zO��C�K¸h�Yb��k!h$��feC'YOk¼Ý�V � QLC�WLB'K³«KaC�CgH�C$B'M[WU��xe� my·ª�

�´ó�â����

Page 22: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

���!��¤�©��;©L¤$�«�£�p¿R�j�3�������6�r�!�g�r�#���a�j�[ ����3 §�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª� E�v

" � ) ) #���������L&��+* * �� � � �6� " � ) ) ����� � * *%#����>� " � ) ) �+* *%#���� � � � �4&K& � �;6=�� " � ) ) ����� � * *.#����4� " � ) ) �+* *%#���� � � � �4&K&� ��������"('�() ����� � *%#����>� " � ) ) �+* *%#���� � � � �4&K&;6=�� #����>� " � ) ) � * *%#���� � � � �6&5& "('� ) ������� *;6= � " � ) ) �+* *%#���� � "('� ) ����� � * � �4&� ��������"('� ) �+*%#���� � " '� ) ����� � * � �4&;6= � #���� � " '� ) ����� � * � �6& " '� ) � *;6= � "('�() ����� � * "('�$) � *#�� #������ " � ) ) � * *.& "('� ) � *#�;6= � " � ) ) � * *.@ � �� � � � CED>F �� " � ) ) ��B@ � C D>F * *#�

³aE�my·

tR���;�eN3Q*QL@eC���MbKTQ*WLCif3N!hªQU��Ybk.h$MOk'��C�WLC�zbM[Wjf3Cif�MbK��bÃrµ��£�!���ª�«©U�r���£¢¦¤GWUC�f3N�hªQL��YOk�K$¨y��Cih$MON!KaCcQL@eC�SDfeYk!Y[QGh$YOWUWLCiKad;YOk�f.QUY�WUC�f3N!h�QL��YOk!KcY ¬ QL@!C�KaYbNeWjh�C¸QLC�WLB'K��c?#@eC���MOKaQRWUC�f3N�hªQL��YOk¾h�M[k^�;C�WUC$zyM[Wjf3C�f�MOK�M�;©L�j�e¤$© WUC�f3N�hªQL��YOk(¨3��Cih$M[N�KaC¸��QRf3��WUC�h�QL��S�h�YbWLWUC�KLd;YOk!feK*QUY QU@eCgWUC�f3N!h�QL��YOk�YOk�QL@!C�KaYbNeWUh$CRQUC$WUB'K$�?#@!C�h�M[���§���pSb��¥rM[��NeC#Ý�V � QUWUMOk!K ¬ YbWLB&B'MOd!KX�3��QLC�WLB'KYOkyQLY¸MGKaNe��KaC$Q/Y ¬ QL@!C��e��QLC$WUB'K$�/?#@eC�h���YbKLNeWUC

Y ¬ QU@!MrQRKLNe�!KLC�Q�Nek�f3C$W(9®��h$YOkp¥OC�WUKL��Ybk.zO��¥OCiK*QL@eCg��M[kezbN!M[zbCgÝ�V � �GY ¬ QU@eC�h$MO�������ySy��¥rM[��NeC¸Ý�V � ºÝ�V � � $&%('� @�� ��� � ����QL@�" � ) ) * * ��� W � F

±9Cg�������(h�M[����QL@eC¸QUC$WUB'K#Y ¬ Ý�V � �GQL@eC^»(½*À9��¤$©ªµ��ª�?#@!C�×�WUKaQ�QL@eC�YOWUC$B°KL@eYr�cK*QL@�MrQcYOk¾Ý�V � QLC�WLB'K�¨�9÷��MOk!f 9 � ��WLCif3C�P3C�K#h$YO��k!h���f3CO�

��� Æ Å �¦Æ3Õ � � ��� 6Ð(Ó) �Æy�rÆ3Ð(�bÆ Å � Ý�V � �DÅ Ð �rÆpÓ �(�O~� Å Ð(}�� �(¤$� Ý�V � �È�r�;þ �¤$� � ¶U¤��r��Á�ª��¶���¤$©ªµ �a���Ì� (�[©��r £ ��,P´Ê�Í�¤ �p�[¢¦¤ � �T;>=�� �HP*� � �T;4=�� �HP�Ì& � ŮŠ�U� Ú�C$��Yr�²��C�Ka@�M[���®zO��¥OCgMDzOWjM[BDB'M[Wi¨eÙGWUMOBDBDMOWgEixe¨3QL@!M[QczOC�keC$WjMrQUC�K�M[���Ý�V � QUC$WUB'K$�*_�QR��K��BDBDC�f3��MrQUC�QUY hj@eCihj�DQL@!M[Q�Ybk.QUC$WUBDK*zOC�keC$WjMrQUC�f'�pSDQU@!MrQ#zOWjM[BDB'M[Wi¨yM!9÷��WLCif3C�P.��K#M[��KaY�M 9 �ª��WUC�f3C$P�¨�;C�h�M[N!KLCgM[���(M[WUzON!B�C�kyQUK�Y ¬�¬ Nek!hªQU��Ybk!KcMOWLC¸¥rM[��NeC�K#Y ¬ � � ³6MO�!KTQUWUMbhªQU��Ybk!K�M[k!f�¥rM[WU��MO�e��C�Kj·ª� �

]�KLKLC$kyQL��M[����S�MOK�MDh�Ybk!KLC�¹yNeC$k�h�CGY ¬ ?#@eC$YbWLC�B­x3��EO¨p��CgYO�3QjM[��k

��� Æ Å �¦Æ3Õ � � �� 6Ð(Ó) �Æy�rÆ3Ð(�bÆ Å � Ý�V � �DÅ Ð � áL~ � Æ Å �� ´Æp}�� (�[© �r £ � Y � Ý�V � �[Ê�Í�¤ �p�r¢r¤ ���9 ! � ��� �²��9 �;! � �¼Ì

& � ŮŠ�U� ±9C�h$YOk!KL��feC$WGQL@eCD��BDde����h$M[QL��YOk ¬ WLYbB ��C ¬ QGQUY¯WL��zO@yQ'³£QL@!CDh$YOkp¥OC�WUKLC���KGC�MOKL��C$Wª·ª� � ��k!h$C ¬ N!���9®��WUC�f3N�hªQL��YOk ����W���Kch$YOk��!N!C$kyQ�¨���9 !I+ � � + � ��BDde����CiK�QL@�MrQ�QL@!C$WUCG��K(+��gKaN!hj@�QU@!MrQ�+ � ���/W�+��MOk!fN+ � ����W-+��O�/± @eC$k^+ � M[k!fI+ � M[WUCGÝ�V � QLC$WUB'K$¨ +��c��K�MO��KLY MDÝ�V � QLC$WUB¯�XÚ*S'?#@eC�YOWUC$B�x3��EO¨MO����9÷��WLCif3C�P3C�KRh�YOkyQUWUMbhªQLCif���k¯QU@eC�WUC�f3N!h�QL��YOk!K�+*����� W + � M[k!f�+ ����� W + � M[WUC�M[��KaY�9 � ��WUC�f3C$P3C�K���RC$k!h$C���9 � !I+:� � + �r� �

Æ3ÕÉ�3�¦Ï � � � ?#@eC�KLC���k!f3���;C�WLC�k!h�C�d!WLYbd�C�WaQU��CiKcM[����Yr� N!KcQLY'QjM[�OCgC��§QU@eC$WGh$MO�������pSy��k!M[BDC¸YOWRh�M[���§���pSy�¥rMO��NeCcMbKQL@eC�WUC�feN!hªQU��YbkDKaQLWjMrQUC$zbS�M[k!f QL@!CR�3��QL@eC�YOWUS�YOk�Ý�V � QUC$WUBDK��±sCchj@eYpYyKaC�QL@!Cch$M[�������pSy��k�M[BDC¥bC$WjKa��YOk�K$¨p�;C�h$MON!KLC�QU@eC$S�M[WUCGKL��B�d!��C�W��

â�â54�6!þ87:98;

Page 23: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

� q � Ì(À��[�y¿O�6�r©«¿O�

?#@eCGkeC$PyQ�QT��Y�QL@!C$YOWUC$B'K*M[WUC�M[�;YONeQ*QU@eCGh$YOWUWLCihªQUkeC�KUKXY ¬ QL@eC�Ý�V � QUWUMOk!K ¬ YOWUB��/?#@eC�×!WjKTQ#Ka@eYr�cKQU@!MrQ/QU@eC�h�YOBDdeNeQUMrQU��Ybk Y ¬ Mg�e�«QUC$WUB ��KXh$YOWUWLCihªQU��S¸BD��BD��hj�OCif��pS���QUK�Ý�V � ��BDMOzOCb�?#@eC�KLC�h$YOk!f Ka@eYr�cKQU@!MrQ�QU@eC Ý�V � QLWjM[k�K ¬ YbWLB�deWUC�KLC$WU¥OCiK*9 �ª��h�YOkp¥bC$WjKa��YOk®���� Æ Å �¦Æ3Õ � � � � �eÓ�Æ�� ���e�[à � Å � " � � ��¤�� ^�*)bÌ

� Ì �6�( ��� � � � �p¤$��" � ) ) * *#����� � � " '�$) �+*������r��¤�� �p�[��� �p¤���¤$©ªµ � "('�$) � *��������/���i���OÌ� Ì � �3¤��j�r�!¢r¤$©j��¤ � �6� " � ) ) * * ����� � � �r�;Ã�� ���G��/�����UÊ�� �p¤$�����3¤�©L¤G���¸�'�U�[ £  �L¶�Á���¢¦�[ ¡�!¤¸¢r�r ¡�!¤ �°�ª�!���� �p�[�8 ����� �Ø�r�;à � � � "('� ) �+*TÌ?#@e��K#QU@eC$YbWLC�B°h$MOk��;CgdeWUYr¥OCif.�pS.zOYb��k!z QU@eWUYONezb@�MOk���kyQLC$WUBDC�f3��MrQUC�Ý�V � QLWjM[k!K ¬ YOWUB�YO�eQUM[��keCif

¬ WUYOB QL@!C�YOWU��zO��k!M[�[YbkeC��pSGWLC�BDYr¥y��kezcKLYOBDC�Mbf3BD��ke��KaQLWjMrQL��¥OC�WLCif3N!hªQU��Ybk!K��(ÇRYb��k!z�KLYc��K(N!KLC ¬ Ne�y��Cih$MON!KaCMbf3BD��k!��KaQLWjMrQU��¥bC�WUC�f3N!h�QL��YOk!KDh$YOBDde����h�MrQLC�QU@eC¯YOd;C$WjMrQL��YOk�M[�#h�YOWUWUC�KLd�Ybk!f3C$k�h�C��;C�QT��C$C�k KLYON!WUh$C�M[k�fQjM[WUzOC$QQUC$WUB'KXY ¬ QL@!CGÝ�V � QLWjM[k�K ¬ YbWLB¯��?#@!��K���K�h$��CiM[WX�pSDh�YOk�Ka��f3C$WU��kezGQL@eCcYbd�C�k�QLC$WUB �>�(ºQL@!��K�QLC$WUB��K#keYOQcWLCif3N!h����e��C'³´��Qc��KcM � ��k ¬ ·ª¨!�eN3Qc��QUK���B'M[zOC " � ) ) �>� * * ��@!MOKcx�³6Mbf3BD��k!��KaQLWjMrQU��¥bCi·*WLCif3N!h�QL��YOk!K����� Æ Å �¦Æ3Õ � � � � "e� Ò ´Ó) £~jà Å �#~ � Æ 9 áL~ � Æ Å �ià � Å � " ��� ��¤�� Y � �¸Ì��´�g��9�� !/ � � ���3¤����9 !" � ) ) * * � " � ) ) � * *�Ì& � ŮŠ�U� KL�OC$QUhj@��XÛ��WjKaQ�YOk!C KL@eYr�cK�QU@!MrQ¸� ¬ ��� � � QU@eC$kÉ��9 ! " � ) ) * * � " � ) ) � * *��g?#@eC�k¾YOkeCh$YOk!h$��N�f3C�K#N!KL��kez�QL@eC ¬ MbhªQ�QL@�MrQX9����Kch$YOk���NeC$kyQ�� �

?#@eC�h$YOkp¥OC�WUKLCRY ¬ ?#@!C$YOWUC$B x3� x ¬ MO����K$��Û!YOW���k!KaQUM[k�h�C¸� ¬

$&%('� ) ����#������5�>� &#������5�>� &.� ³aE$ny·� $&%('� #������5�>�4& ) �Q#������5�>�>&#5#������5����&K#������5����&K&

QU@eC$k¾��9 !�" � ) ) * * � " � ) ) � * *�@eYO��feK�¨3�eN3Q���9 � !N � �Øf3YpCiK#keY[Qi�?#@eC¸KaQUMrQUC$BDC$kyQjK�Ybk.QL@!C�h�YbWLWUC�h�QLkeCiKLK�Y ¬ QU@eC�Ý�V � QUWUMOk!K ¬ YbWLBÖh�YbBDde��C$QLC¸KTQUC$d¾EGY ¬ QU@eCG��C ¬ Q�d!MOWaQ

Y ¬ Û��zONeWUCDEO�

%®~�Æ � � ��� Å Õ Ý�V � ��~ Å � + �

?#@!CGk!C�PpQRKTQUC$d¯��K�QLY.KL@eYr� QL@�MrQ�¨!B�Y3f3N!��YDQU@eC�f3���;C�WLC�kbQcKLSpkbQjMrP ¬ YbWcM[�!KaQLWjMOh�QL��YOk�M[k!f¯M[d!de����h$M[QL��YOk®¨QU@eCGQLC�WLB'K#Y ¬ Ý�V � � M[WUCGMO��KLY QLC$WUB'K#Y ¬ � � �X��?�YDfeY QU@e��K#�*C¸deWUC�KLC$kyQ�M zbWUMOBDBDMOW�QU@!MrQczbC$keC�WUM[QLCiKMO���÷Ý�V � � QUC$WUBDK�¨pM[k!f'KL@eYr� QL@!M[Q�QL@!CcQLC�WLB'K�zOC$k!C$WjMrQLCif��yS QL@!��K�zOWjM[BDB'M[W�MOWLCcMO��KLY¸QLC�WLB'K�Y ¬ � � �X�?#@eC¯zbWUMOB�B'MOW�@!MbK ¬ YbNeW�keYOk3��QLC�WLBD��k!M[��K�¨ ¬ YOW ��©ª�£����� �e�r c��¤$©ªµ��ª¨��j�r���«�£���!�r���6�r�!�j¨�»®½�À���¢r�r ¡�!¤��O¨

MOk!f¾�r�!�ªÍ�¤�©j�ª�XVXWU��k!h$��d�M[��QLC$WUB'K�MOWLCcMO�!KTQUWUMbhªQU��Ybk!KXYOk.h$YOkyQL��kpN!MrQU��Ybk!K�ÂOQU@eC$S'f3CiKLh$WL����CcQL@eC���B'M[zbC�KXY ¬QU@eC �e�«QUC$WUB'KcNek!feC$WcQU@eC�Ý�V � QLWjM[k!K ¬ YOWUB¯�#Ý�V � ��¥rM[��NeC�K�h�YbWLWUC�KLd�Ybk!f÷¨e��kyQLNe��QL��¥OC���Sb¨eQUY'QL@eC�¥¦MO��N!C�KcY ¬� �'ÂpQU@eC$S�M[WUC�N�KaCif�MbK�MOWLzbNeBDC$kyQUK*QUY�h$YOkyQL��kpN!MrQU��Ybk!K$�XtRk!Ka��C$WjK#M[WUCRQU@eC¸WLCiKaN!�§QjK#Y ¬ h$YOBDdeN3QjMrQU��Ybk!K$º��@�MrQR��C�YO�eQUM[��k^��@eC�k¾�*C�C$¥rM[��N!MrQUC�M'deWU��k!h���d!M[�®QLC$WUB M[ded!����C�f�QUY�M.h�YbkyQL��kyN�MrQL��YOk(�ctck!KL�*C�WUKRM[WUCQU@eC¸QLC�WLB'K#��k¯��@e��hj@¯h�YbBDdeN3QUM[QL��YOkɳ 9÷��WUC�f3N!h�QL��YOk!Kj·*QUMO�OCiK*d!��Mbh�CO�

�´ó�â����

Page 24: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

���!��¤�©��;©L¤$�«�£�p¿R�j�3�������6�r�!�g�r�#���a�j�[ ����3 §�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª� � E

h$YOkyQL��kpN!MrQU��Ybk�¥rM[WU��M[�e��C �YOWjf3��k�M[WUS'¥¦MOWL��M[�!��CiK ��Y0]2]0]

M[k!KL��C$WjK M � � � � � � ��� � ���Ý�V � ��¥rM[��NeC�K � � � �����j� �$� M �-�

h�YbkyQL��kyN�MrQL��YOk�K�� � � �R�'����� MdeWU��k�h���d!M[��QUC$WUBDK � � � ���6�,M

³aEixb·

Æ3ÕÉ�3�¦Ï � � % _�kÉ[email protected] ¬ YOW Ý�V � ��¥rM[��NeC�K�¨�[email protected]!WLY3f3N!h�QL��YOk-�����U���6� M h�M[k9��C�Ka��BDde����×!CifQUY������ ��¨e�eN3QcQU@eCgC�P3d!MOk!f3Cif ¬ YbWLB���K#�;C�QaQUC$W ¬ YbW#QL@eC�h$YOBDd!MOWL��KaYbk�����QL@ � � �9�;C$��Yr�g� �

Æ3ÕÉ�3�¦Ï � � $ �RM¦¥p��k!zcYOke��SGYOkeC�h$YOkyQL��kpN!MrQU��Ybkg¥rM[WU��MO�e��CXzbN!M[WjM[kyQUC$C�K;QU@!MrQ�QL@eC�h�YbkbQU��kpN!M[QL��YOk¸Y3h$h$NeWUK¬ WUC$C�C�PeMOh�QL��S Ybk!h�CR��k'QU@eCR�;Y3f3SDY ¬ CiMOhj@'M[�!KaQLWjMOh�QL��YOk����6� MD��³6± @eC$k.��YOWU�p��k!zgNed'QLY ��h�Ybkp¥OC$WjKL��Ybk®¨QU@eCDh�YOkyQU��kpN!M[QL��YOk^¥rM[WU��MO�e��C �¯B'M¦S���C�WLC�k!M[BDCif÷¨��eN3QRQU@eC�����keC�MOWL��QTS^h�Ybk!KTQUWUMO��kyQRYbkÈh�YbkyQL��kyN�MrQL��YOk�KWUC$B'MO��k!K�� · �

?#@!C�WUC$��MrQU��Ybk!KL@e��d�K�MOBDYOkezsQL@eC ¬ YbNeW.h$M[QLC$zbYOWU��CiK�Y ¬ keYbk3��QLC$WUBD��k�M[��K ��k ÙGWUMOB�B'MOW�E¦xÈh�M[k ��CC$P3deWLCiKLKLC�f�N!KL��kez�QTSpd;C�K���tRKUKaNeBD��kezDM�fe��KaQL��kezON!��KL@eC�f�QTSpd�C�� ¬ YbW#MOk!KL�*C�WUK�¨yQL@eCGQTSpd�CiK���*¨��� MOk!f�� Y ¬ Ý�V � ��¥rMO��NeCiK$¨eh$YOkyQL��kpN!MrQU��Ybk!K�M[k�f�deWU��k!h���d!M[��QUC$WUB'K�M[WUC

��� $&%('�O��� � #�� =�#��"=���& =�� & �

� � $&%('� � � =��

� $&%('� � � =��

³aE��y·

?#@!C�QTSpd;C#ZTN!f3zbC$BDC$kyQUK ¬ YOW#QL@!C¸QLC$WUB'K( zbC$keC�WUM[QLC�f��pS�ÙGWjM[BDB'M[W¸Eix�M[WUCGY ¬ QL@eC ¬ YbWLB

� ! ��� ³aE¦oO·

��@!C$WUC�� @��� Y����!Y��� Y�� F�MOk!f�� ��K�C$��QL@!C$W\7�R���� YbW-7�T�����*Y � ������¨ ¬ YOWDKaYbBDC 7� ���§QU@7� � ¬ ¥$#.'&U�±9CRKL@!M[����KLC$CR��k � CihªQU��Ybk^E�q¸QU@!MrQ�QU@eC$WUCc��K�MgzbC$keC�WUMO�eKLhj@!C$B'M ¬ YOW�QLWjM[k!KL��M[QL��kez¸QTSpd�C�ZTN!f3zOC�BDC$kyQUK

Ybk �e�«QUC$WUB'K�QUYÈQTSpd;C�ZTN!f3zOC�BDC$kyQUK�YOk¼QL@eCÈÝ�V � ����B'M[zOCiK�Y ¬ QL@!C^�e��QLC$WUB'K$¨*M[k!f QL@!M[Q�QU@eC¯KLhj@eC�B'MMOdede����CiK�M[��KaY�QUY�N!kbQTSpd;C�f^�e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!K��tR���/Ý�V � QLC$WUB'K�M[WUC¸��k!feC$C�f�zbC$keC�WUM[QLC�f��pS�ÙGWUMOBDBDMOW¸Eix3º

& � Å � Å }� £~� Å Ð � � �6�(¾Ý�V � � Ê����3¤��I �����g��©ª�£�;�$� �e�r (��¤$©ªµ �a�� �©U�rµ�µD�[© �"! Ì

& � ŮŠ�U� � keC�h�M[k¾KL@eYr� QL@!M[QcQL@eC�KaC$QRY ¬ deWU��k!h���d!M[�(QLC�WLB'Kc��k!h$��N!feC�K�QU@eC KLC�Q!@ " � ) ) * * �N ,��FMOk!f���K�h$��YyKaCif�N!k!f3C$WX9®��h$YOkp¥OC�WUKL��Ybk®� �

_�Qc��KcCiMOKLS'QLY.KLC$C¸QU@!MrQRQL@eC�KLC�QRY ¬ QUC$WUB'K�zOC�keC$WjMrQUC�f��yS¯ÙGWUMOBDBDMOWgEix���K$¨!C�KUKaC�kbQU��MO����SO¨�M�KLNe�!KLC�QY ¬ � � � QLC$WUB'K$� VXWLCih���KaC���Sb¨�MOk!KL�*C�WUK�B'M¦S¼�;C^WLC�zbMOWUf3Cif MbK � � � deWUYph$C�KUKaCiK$¨#M[k�f Ý�V � ��¥rMO��NeCiK$¨h$YOkyQL��kpN!MrQU��Ybk!K�¨/MOk!f-deWU��k!h���d!M[�*QLC�WLB'K MOK�� � � M[��KTQUWUMbhªQL��YOk�K$�ÈHcC�h$MO��� ¬ WUYOB � C�h�QL��YOk Ý QU@!MrQ QL@eCzbWUMOBDBDMOWRY ¬ ³´d;YO��SbMOfe��hi·�� � � WLCi¹yNe��WUC�KcQL@!M[Q¸MO�!KaQLWjMOhªQU��Ybk!Kc�;C�C$��QL@eC�W�¥rM[WU��M[�e��C�KRYOWGd!M[WjM[BDC�QUWL��KLC�fd!WLY3h�CiKLKLC�K��/Ý�V � ��¥rMO��NeCiK$¨ph�YbkyQL��kyN�MrQL��YOk�K$¨yM[k!f'd!WL��k!h���d!MO�eQLC�WLB'K�Y ¬ ÙGWjM[BDB'M[WcE¦x¸M[WUCc��k�f3C$Cif'Y ¬ QL@!��K¬ YbWLB¯¨�� ¬ �*C�WUC�MOf M°MOKGM � deWLY3h$C�KUK � ¨;MOk!f^��C N!k!h�NeWUWUS�M^Ý�V � ��¥rM[��NeC������j� �6�,M�QUY���# ��Y �4&K�,M°MOk!f

â�â54�6!þ87:98;

Page 25: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

� � � Ì(À��[�y¿O�6�r©«¿O�

MOk'M[k!KL�*C�W � � � QLY � P � Y�� R�³£QL@pN!K���k.?M[�!��C � "('�$) ������ *��;C�h�YbBDC�K*��# ��Y �4&� " � ) ) * * ��¨pM[k!fD��kDQL@eCQUWUMOk!KL��M[QL��YOk�Y ¬ �-¨3QL@!CgQLC�WLB ��� � � � �¯��Cih�YbB�CiKR��� � � P � Y � RT·��#_�QR��K�QL@eC�WLC ¬ YOWUC¸KaQLWjM[��zO@yQ ¬ YOWU��MOWUfQUY�feC�×!keC QL@!C���krZTCihªQL��YOk % ¬ WUYOB QU@eC�QLC�WLB'KGY ¬ ÙGWjM[BDB'M[W�Eix'QLY � � �X� � k¾QLC�WLB'K�¨÷BDYpfeNe��Y�QL@!��KN!k!h�NeWUWUSy��kez�¨OQU@eC¸��krZTCihªQU��Ybk�WUC$��WU�§QUC�K#�3��M[�!KaQLWjMOh�QL��YOk!K*��kbQUY�� � �ÈM[��KTQUWUMbhªQL��YOk�K$¨pM[k!f��3��M[d!de����h$M[QL��YOk!K��kyQLY � � �ÉM[d!de����h$M[QL��YOk!K��X?#@eC¸��k[ZTC�hªQU��Ybk¯��K#QU@eCg��f3C$kyQL��QTS.Ybkɳ6Nek!h$NeWLWU��C�f!·�QTSpd�CiK$ÂeQL@pN!K

% ) ) �� * * $&%('�O� �!� #�� �Z#�� =��8&5&8=���� ³aE�wb·

±9C'@!M¦¥bC % ) ) � * * $ %('� �¨��@e��hj@9C$P3de��MO��k�[email protected]�eN!KLC�Y ¬ k!Y[QUM[QL��YOk9��@eC$WUC$�pS^QU@eC�KUM[BDC'KaSpB ��Yb� � ��KN�KaCif ¬ YOW�QU@eC'QTSpd;C�Y ¬ MOk!Ka��C$WjKgY ¬ ÙGWjM[BDB'M[W�Eix¯M[k�f ¬ YOW�[email protected];C.Y ¬ d!WLY3h�CiKLKLC�K¸Y ¬ � � �X�¾?#@eC��B'M[zbCGY ¬ % ��K�M�� � �s��M[k!zON!MOzOC�QL@!M[Qc@!MOK#WUC�h$NeWUKL��¥OC¸M[k!f�deWUYpfeN!hªQ#QTSpd�CiK$�?#@eCgd!WLYpY ¬ K#Y ¬ QU@eC�KLCg��C�BDBDMbK�M[WUCGKaQLWjM[��zO@yQ ¬ YOWU��MOWUf÷º

� Æ3Õ-ÕÉ� � � � À��¦�b�3�r��¤g���3�r�� ���g����¤$©ªµ ¿y¤���¤�©L�[��¤jÃ.¶�Á #©L�[µ µ'�r© �"! Ê��r�;Ã�� �p�[��� !I ���°���[©� �r�;à ���¦�g�£� � ��� �OÌ � �p¤$��% ) ) �$* * !�% ) ) * * � % ) ) � * *;Ìt�KcMDh�YOWUYO����M[WUS�Y ¬ � C$BDB'M'x3� ve¨3� ¬ ^� ����QL@ ¬ ¥6#.'& � 7�¨pQL@eC�k

7�Q� % ) ) �� * *�!�% ) ) " � ) ) * * * *!� % ) ) �� (* * �Q# % ) ) �� * *6=��8& =�� ³aE�vb·

±9C^WLC�BD��k!f QU@!MrQ'� ¬ M:Y SØMOWLC � � �²deWUY3h�C�KUKLC�K�¨�QL@!C$k M�;4=/W S M[k�f M ��W S feC$keYOQLC�9÷�WUC�feN!hªQU��Ybk�MOk!fN9®��h$YOkp¥OC�WaQU���e�����§QTS'��k � � �X¨eWUC�KLd�CihªQU��¥bC$��Sȳ � CihªQU��Ybk¾Ý#·��� Æ3Õ-ÕÉ� � � ��2 ��r©��r £ 3��¤�©ªµ �8 �T�� �©U�rµ�µD�[© � ! Ê®Í�¤ �3�r¢r¤ � � ���;4= � QP÷� �p¤$� % ) ) * *%;4=/W ��W% ) ) QP * * �¾�r�;à �j�r��¢¦¤$©j�$¤� §Á¦Ê�� �% ) ) * *I;4=�W M����3¤�� � �p¤$©L¤s��� QP �ª�!��� � �p�r� ;4= � QPD�[�;ÃM ��W % ) ) QP * *T̳6_�k'QL@eCG��C$BDB'M�M[�;Yr¥OCb¨[QL@!CRN!KLCRY ¬ ��W.��K�feNeCcQUY�QL@!CRNek!h$NeWUWLSp��kez¸QL@!M[Q*��K�N�KaCif'��k.QL@eC���krZTCihªQU��Ybk

%s� ·� Å � Å�Ò´Ò �3�¦à � � �/� (�[©s�r £ G��¤$©ªµ �� Y � ¿y¤���¤�©U�r��¤Uà ¶�Á #©L�rµ�µD�[© � ! Ê ��9 !' � � �£µR�; ¡�6¤��% ) ) * * � W % ) ) � * *TÌ& � ŮŠ�U� � ��k!h�C�����W ��KXh�Ybk��!NeC�kyQ�¨y��9 !I � �°@!YO��feK/� ��QL@eC�WLC���KXKaYbBDC:+ÉKLN!hj@ QL@!M[Q ����W-+MOk!f � ��� W +c�X?#@eC�WLC ¬ YOWUCO¨p�pS � C�BDBDM'xe��Eiqe¨ % ) ) * * � W % ) ) + * * � W % ) ) � * *�� �

?#@e��Kch$YOk!h$��N!feC�K�QL@!C�KaCih�YOk�f�KaQLC�d�Y ¬ QU@eCg��C ¬ Qcd!M[WLQ�Y ¬ Û��zbNeWLCDEb�

%®~�Æ � � �G� Å Õ-�) Ò �e~� Å Ð "?#@!CcQL@!��Wjf.M[k�fD×!k!MO�;KaQLC�d ¬ YOW*QL@eC���C ¬ Q�d�M[WLQ*Y ¬ Û��zONeWUC�E���K ¬ WLYbB � � �¯QLY ����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K��X?#@e��K�KaQLC$d���Kzb��¥bC$k¯�pS�QL@eC�h�YOBDde����MrQL��YOk�" ¬ WUYOB � � �9QLY�����h�M[��h�Ne��N!KcY ¬ � C�h�QL��YOkÈÇ �c_�k � CihªQU��Ybk¾Ç ��C�KL@eYr�*CifQU@!MrQ¸QU@eC$WUC ��K¸M�deWLCih���KaC YOd;C$WjMrQU��Ybk!M[�/h�YbWLWUC�KLd�Ybk!f3C�k!h�C ��C$QT�*C�C$ksKLYON!WUh$C�MOk!f^QjM[WUzOC�QGQLC�WLB'KGY ¬ QL@eCh$YOBDde����M[QL��YOk®¨®MOk!f9KTQUN!f3��C�fs�§QjK¸��C�@!M¦¥p��YbNeWUMO��d!WLYbd�C�WaQU��CiK$��H�C�h�M[����QU@!MrQ¸[email protected]�YbB�d!����MrQU��YbksMOh�QUK¸M[��KLYYbk QTSpd;C�K�¨�M[k!f QL@!M[Q ¬ YOW�QLWjM[k!KL��MrQL��kezÈQL@eC^M[WUWUYr� QTSpd;C�K�Y ¬ � � �²��C�N!KaCif-QU@eC ���¾QTSpd;C�K�Y ¬ QL@eC����h$MO��h$Ne��N!K$�

�´ó�â����

Page 26: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

���!��¤�©��;©L¤$�«�£�p¿R�j�3�������6�r�!�g�r�#���a�j�[ ����3 §�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª� � m

� ) ) ������ * * $&%('� # L$&� L # �4&K��� �6# ��&�� ) ) * *� ) ) ��* * $&%('� # L$&� L�P � R

� ) ) � * * $&%('� # L$&� ��� ��� ) ) * *��+N � # �>&K� �*� #�� ) ) � * * N � # � &K� ��P � Y L�R�& �?M[�e��Cgmeº�?#@eC¸C�k!h�Y3f3��kez'Y ¬ � � ��kyQLY�QL@!Cg����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K

�32 1 � > � # > E�=5@ � < !D7 E < 7 # E

Ý*YbBDd�YyKa��kez¯QL@!C.QL@!WLC�C.KTQUC$d!K�¨ ¬ WLYbB � � QLYÉÝ�V � � ¨ ¬ WLYbB Ý�V � � QLY � � �X¨/MOk!f ¬ WUYOB � � � QLY^���h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�¨b��CcYb�3QUMO��k'QU@eCRC�k!h�Y3f3��kez��¼Y ¬ � �&��kyQLY�����h$MO��h$Ne��N�K���k�?�MO�e��C�me�/VXWUC�h$��KLC$��SO¨bQL@eC�C$k!h$Y3f3��k!z� ) ) * *�Y ¬ M.�e�«QUC$WUB ��K�YO�eQUM[��keCif.QU@yN�K�³´YbB���QaQU��k!zDQL@eC¸QTSpd;CGC�kp¥y��WUYOkeBDC$kyQ���k!f3C�P!·

� ) ) * * $&%('� " ) ) % ) ) " � ) ) * * * *�* *?#@!CgC$k!h$Ypfe��kez�� N!KLC�K�QT�*Y��p��k!f!K�Y ¬ k!M[BDCOº

� �����j�r���6�r���;�[µD¤��¸³ L Y � Y � ·QL@�MrQ�M[WUC*N�KaCif�MbK/M[WUzONeBDC$kyQjK�Y ¬ QU@eC�C$k!h$Y3f3��k!zbK/Y ¬ �3��QLC�WLB'K��?#@!C�KLCk!MOB�CiK�h�YbWLWUC�KLd�Ybk!f'QUY�QL@eC�h$YOkyQL��kpN!MrQU��Ybk�¥rM[WU��M[�e��C�Y ¬ QU@eC Ý�V � ÙGWjM[BDB'M[W¸Eixe�

�� �[ ¡�!¤��;�rµ'¤��9³ ��Y5�e·�QL@!M[Q�M[WUC�N�KaCifÉQLY9MOh$h$C�KUK�¥rM[��NeCiK$�É?#@eC�KLC�k�M[BDC�K�h�YbWLWUC�KLd�Ybk!f9QLYÈQL@eCYOWjf3��k!M[WUS'¥rM[WU��MO�e��C�K�Y ¬ QL@eC Ý�V � ÙGWjM[BDB'M[WgE¦x3�

³«t keY[QjMrQU��Ybk�WUC$BD��k!f3C$W ¬ YbWcM[�!KaQLWjMOh�QL��YOk!K�º�� ) ) * *���K�M[k¯M[�!KaQLWjMOh�QL��YOk®¨3KUM¦S�# � &�,SDÂ3QU@eC$k���k¯?M[�!��Cgme¨�6# � &�� ) ) * *R��K �6# ��Y � &K� S M[k!f�� ) ) * * ��K S\@�� C��LFy��?#@eCiKaC.MOk!f9Y[QU@eC$W�k!Y[QUM[QL��YOk!K ¬ YbW�M[��KTQUWUMbhªQL��YOk�KMOWLCgf3��KUh�N!KUKaCif���k � C�h�QL��YOk¯ÚG��Eb� o3� ·±9CGC�P3de��M[��k���k ¬ YOWUB'M[����S'@eYr� QU@eC¸C$k!h$Y3f3��k!z ��YOWU�3K$� � Neded;YbKLC¸M��e�«QUC$WUB[ WUC�f3N!h$C�K*QLYDM ¥¦MO��N!C

�.�?#@!��K�¥rM[��NeC�WUC$deWUC�KLC$kyQjK÷QL@!C*WUC�KLNe��Q�Y ¬ QU@eC��3��QLC�WLB¯�_�kgQL@eC�����h$M[��h�N!��N!K�C$k�h�Y3f3��kez!¨�� ) ) * *���WUC�f3N�h�C�KQUYÈM¯deWUY3h�C�KUK¸QU@!MrQi¨¥bC$WUS¾WUYONezb@e��Sb¨(WUC�QUNeWLk�K¸QL@eC�¥rM[��NeC � MrQ L ³£QL@!��K ��K�QL@eC�M[k!MO��YbzONeCDY ¬ d!MbKLKL��kezQU@eC�WLCiKaNe��Q�QUY¾QL@!C�h$YOkyQL��kpN!MrQU��Ybk-��k-QU@eC¯Ý�V � QLWjM[k�K ¬ YbWLB.·ª�s?#@eC�¥rM[��NeC � h$MOk-��C¯M^¥rM[WU��M[�e��C.YOWMOk¾M[�!KaQLWjMOh�QL��YOk®��_ ¬ ����KcM.¥¦MOWL��M[�!��CGQL@!C$k¯QL@!C�h�YbWLWUC�KLd�Ybk!f3��kezD����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�k�M[BDCg��KRWLC$QLNeWUkeCif�M[QAL®�_ ¬ ����KGM ¬ Nek�hªQL��YOk¾QL@eC�kÈ��QGh$MOkekeYOQR��C d!MOKUKLC�f^f3��WLCihªQU��S^MrQ L¾�;C�h$MON!KLC�����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�f3YpC�K�keY[Q¸M[����Yr�h$YOBDB�N!ke��h�MrQU��Ybk-Y ¬ QLC�WLB'K�Â���k!KTQUC�Mbf÷¨XM¯�3�[�£�!��¤�©�QUY¾QL@!C ¬ Nek!h�QL��YOk ��K�d�MOKUKaCif÷�È?#@pN!KgQU@eC ¬ N!k!hªQU��YbkKL��QUKg����QL@e��k9QL@eC'd!WLY3h�CiKLKgMbKgM�WLCiKaYbNeWUh$C�QU@!MrQ�h�M[k9��C.Mbh$h$C�KUKaCifsMOWL�e��QLWjM[WU����S^B'M[kpS^QU��BDCiK$¨�¥y��M�QL@eCd;YO��kyQLC�W�º���@eC$k M^h$����C$kyQDKaC�k!feK�M^¥rMO��NeC��sM[k�f-M^WLC$QLNeWUkÉk!M[BDC � ¨QU@eC ¬ Nek!h�QL��YOk �������*M[k�Ka��C$W��pSKLC$k�f3��k!zDMDWUC�KLNe��QcMrQ � ³6� ¬ MDWUC�KLNe�§Q�C$Pp��KaQUKj·ª�?#@!C^C$k!h$Ypfe��kez¼Y ¬ M[k M[ded!����h$M[QL��YOk � MrQ���Y3h$MrQU��Ybk L ��K.M deWLY3h$C�KUK�QL@!M[Q.×!WjKTQ.WUNek!KN M[Q

KLYOBDC���Y3h$M[QL��YOk � �R± @!C$kZ KL��zbk!M[��K#QL@�MrQ���Q¸@!MOKR��Cih�YOBDC�M.¥¦MO��N!C �;¨!QU@eC MOWLzbNeBDC$kyQ�� ��KcWUNekÈM[QKLYOBDCD��Yph�MrQU��Ybk � ³ � M[k!f � M[WUC deWU��¥¦M[QLCb¨®QLY^M¦¥bYO��fÈ��kyQLC$W ¬ C$WUC$k�h�C ¬ WLYbB QL@!C'C$kp¥p��WUYOkeBDC�kbQª·ª�D± @eC�kMO��KLY � KL��zbk!M[��K#QL@�MrQ���QR@!MbKc�;C�h$YOBDC�MD¥rM[��NeC ��¨;QU@eC�M[d!de����h$M[QL��YOk^Y3h$h$NeWjK$º�QL@eC�d�M[��W P � Y L�Rc��K�KaC�kyQM[Q �;��?#@e��K¸h�YbB�B Neke��h$M[QL��YOkÈ��K�QL@eCDKaQLC$dsQL@�MrQ¸deWLYbd�C�WL��S^Ka��B�N!��M[QLC�K�QU@eC 9 � ��WUC�feN!hªQU��Ybk¾Y ¬ � �.Â÷QL@eCd!WLC�¥y��YON�K�h$YOBDB�Nek!��h�MrQL��YOk�K(��C$WUC��LMOf3BD��ke��KTQUWUM[QL��¥OC �R³6C�PeMOh�QL��S¸MbK(��QX@!M[d!d�C�k!K��k�QL@eCcÝ�V � QLWjM[k!K ¬ YOWUB¯¨KLC$C � CihªQL��YOk^xO·��X?#@eCgKaCih�YOk�f�M[WUzON!B�C�kyQ*Y ¬ QL@eC¸d!MO��W+P � Y L R���K�QL@!CG��Y3h$M[QL��YOk.��@eC�WLC�QL@!C�×�k!M[�÷WUC�KLNe��QY ¬ �Ø�������®�;C�f3C�����¥OC�WLCif÷�

â�â54�6!þ87:98;

Page 27: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

� n � Ì(À��[�y¿O�6�r©«¿O�

Æ3ÕÉ�3�¦Ï � � � _�k�?�MO�e��C�me¨¦QU@eC#��ked!N3QUK/MrQ/��Yph�MrQU��Ybk�k!M[BDCiK*³ � M[k�f � ·�MOWLC*keY[Q/WUC$de����h�MrQUC�fg�;C�h�M[N!KLCO¨��ksQL@eCDKTQUC$d9Y ¬ QUWUMOk!KL��M[QL��YOk ¬ WUYOB � � �-QLY¯����h$MO��h$Ne��N�K$¨÷��C�QjM[�bC ��kyQLY¯MOh$h$YONekyQ�QL@eCD����keCiM[WU�§QTS¾h$YOk3�KaQLWjM[��kyQYbk�h$YOkyQL��kpN!MrQU��Ybk!K#³6H�C�B'M[WU��x3�¡o[·M[k!f�QL@!C$WUC ¬ YOWUC#MOf3Ybd3Q�QU@eC�YOdeQL��B���KUMrQL��YOk Y ¬ � C�h�QL��YOkDÇ�� qe� ve�Ç�C�KLde��QLC�QL@e��K$¨÷@!Yr�*C�¥OC$Wi¨!��k^QU@eC d�M[d;C$WR��C KL@!MO���keY[QGN!KLC�����keCiM[W�QTSpd�CiK$¨�YOk¾QL@eC YOkeC @!M[k!f^QLY��bC$C�dQU@eC�QTSyd;C���MOkezON!MOzOCiK�Ka��BDde��C$Wi¨�YOk-QU@eC�Y[QL@!C$W�@!M[k!f¼��Cih$MON!KaC�����keCiM[W QTSyd;C�K���YONe��f-keYOQDM��;CihªQ�QL@eCWUC�KLNe��QUK#deWUC�KLC$kyQUC�f÷� �

Û!YOW*QL@eCGKLMO�OCcY ¬ WUC�MbfeM[�!�����§QTS QL@!CcQLWjM[k�Ka��MrQU��Ybk'Y ¬ ?M[�e��C�mg��K*keY[Q#M[kekeYOQUM[QLC�fD����[email protected];C�K��X?�Spd;C�KMOWLCgk!C$C�feC�f÷¨;@eYr��C$¥OC�W�¨pQUY.deWUYr¥OCg��QUK�h�YOWUWUC�hªQUkeC�KUK���?#@eC�����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�QUWUMOk!KL��M[QL��YOk¯Y ¬ QTSpd�C % ) ) � � * */��k³aE�wy·���K�QL@!CgWLCih�NeWjKa��¥OC�QTSpd�C

������$&%('�O� �2#�� P �HY���� R&

±9CÉf3Y k!Y[Q^keC$Cif QU@eC�*QUMOz Ybk QTSpd�CiK$¨G�;C�h$MON!KLCÈ�;Y[QL@ ��Yph�MrQU��Ybk M[k�f QLWU��zOzOC�W�k�M[BDC�K�QL@!M[Q¾M[WUCh$YOBDB�N!ke��h�MrQUC�f¯B'M¦S�Ybke��S��;C�N!KLC�f¯�pS^M'WUC�h���de��C$kyQ ¬ YbWRKaC�k!f3��kez!� �RC$WUC���KcQU@eC�C$k�h�Y3f3��kez.��k¾��@e��hj@k�M[BDC�K��;YONek!f �pS M9WLCiKTQUWL��hªQU��Ybk MOWLC¯M[kek!Y[QUM[QLCif ����QL@ QL@eC���WDQTSpd;C-³´��C�WUC�h�M[����QL@!M[QD� ¬ �­��K'M9���h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�QTSyd;CO¨yQU@eC$kZ#�� &� �*��K�QL@!CRQTSpd;CRYO�eQUM[��keCif'�pS WUC$de��MOh$��k!zgQL@eCGYONeQLC$WUBDYbKaQ � ��QUM[z���k � ����QL@� ¨3d;YbKUKa���e��S�M ¬ QUC$WcNek ¬ YO��f3��k!z�� � ¬ ��QUK�YbN3QLC�WLBDYyKTQ�h�Ybk!KTQUWLN�hªQ���KcWLCih�NeWjKa��YOk;·ªº

� ) ) ����� * * $ %('� # L$&K� L # � �X#������ &� � &��� �4# � &�� ) ) * *� ) ) � * * $ %('� # L$&K� L�P � R

� ) ) � * * $ %('� # L$&K�/# ��� � � #������.&$&� � ) ) * * � N � # � &�0# �4� � � #������.&$&�#�� ) ) � * * N � # �4&K� � P �4Y L�R�& �?*Spd�CiK������;MOk!f�� #������ &�MOWLCb¨OWUC�KLd�CihªQU��¥bC$��SO¨bQL@eCRQTSyd;C�K*Y ¬÷¬ WUC$CRQLWU��zbzOC�W�M[k!f ¬ WLC�Cc��Y3h�MrQL��YOk'k�M[BDC�K

Y ¬ deWUY3h�CiKLK � ) ) * *��p��?#@eCiKaCGQTSpd�CiK�hj@!M[k!zOC�QL@eCgYbN3QLC�WLBDYbKaQ�QUM[z�QUY � ��k�QL@eCgh�MOKLCGY ¬ k!MOBDC�K���Y3h�M[��QLY� ) ) * * �y¨eQL@pN!K#�;C�h�YbBD��kez�¨eWUC�KLd�CihªQL��¥OC���Sb¨6#������.&� ��M[k!f � #������.&®�?#@eC¸QUWUMOk!KL��M[QL��YOk�Y ¬ ³aE�vy·���kyQLYD����h$M[��h�N!��N!K#zb��¥bC�K

� Æ3Õ-ÕÉ� � � ��� À;�¦�O�e�¦�$¤ ¬ ¥$#%'& � 7�/Ì�� �3¤��7� ������� Y L ��� #������ & ! � ) ) * * �

Û!WLYbBÖQL@eCgh�YbWLWUC�h�QLkeCiKLK�Y ¬ QU@eCgm KaQLC�d!K ¬ WLYbB���@e��hj@�C$k�h�Y3f3��kez � @!MbK���C�C$k¯f3C$WU��¥bC�f÷¨p��C�zbC�Q�QL@eCQT��YRh$YOWUYO����MOWL��C�K÷�;C$��Yr�g��?#@!C$WUC�M ¬ QUC$Wi¨¦�*C�Ka@!MO���yM[��KaYGf3C$WU��¥OC�f3��WUC�hªQdeWUYyY ¬ K®Y ¬ QL@eCiKaC�h�YbWLYb����M[WU��CiK$¨���@e��hj@feY'keY[QRzbY�QL@eWUYONezb@�QL@eC�Ý�V � QLWjM[k!K ¬ YOWUB'K#�eN3Q�¨;��k!KTQUC�Mbf÷¨�MOded�CiM[�÷QUYDQL@eC�QL@eC�YOWUS�Y ¬ QU@eC�����h$M[��h�N!��N!K³«]/P3C$Wjh���KaC�xe� � qb·ª�

� Å � Å�Ò´Ò �3�¦à � � � � � �eÓÆ�� �(�e�Oà Å � � � �(¤$�M Z� ) Ì �ª� �p�[ �æ�D���3�r� � � � � � ) ) * * � �XÊ÷���r©D�r��ÁLÌ

& � ŮŠ�U� ÛeWUYOB ?#@eC$YbWLC�B xe� n�¨ � C�BDBDM�x3��E�q!¨!M[k!f�QU@eC�Ybd�C�WUM[QL��YOk!MO�(h�YbWLWUC�h�QLkeCiKLK#Y ¬ QL@eC�C$k!h$Ypfe��kezY ¬ � � �s��kyQLY�QL@eCg����h$MO��h$Ne��N!Kg³ � C$BDB'M'Ç�� � M[k!f���QUK�C$PyQUC$k!KL��YOk!K�¨ � C�h�QL��YOk^Ç�� qe� vb·�� �

� Å � Å�Ò´Ò �3�¦à � � � � � "e� Ò 6Ó. £~jà Å � ��9 � ~ � Æ Å �¦à � Å � � � À��¦�b�3�r��¤ ¬ ¥6#% Y �/& � 7�(Ê��r��à  �¤����������� 7� ���������� #������ &Ì �´�c��9 � !I � � ���3¤�� � ) ) * *��! " � ) ) � * *ªÌ

�´ó�â����

Page 28: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

���!��¤�©��;©L¤$�«�£�p¿R�j�3�������6�r�!�g�r�#���a�j�[ ����3 §�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª� � x

& � ŮŠ�U� ÛeWUYOB ?#@eC�YOWUC$B xe� xe¨�Ý*YbWLYb����M[WUS�x3��EOEb¨ � C$BDB'M.ÚG� xe¨�M[k�f � C�B�B'M.Ç � m¾³´BDYOWUC�deWUC�h$��KLC$��SO¨QU@eCgC�PpQUC$k!KL��Ybk�Y ¬ ��Qc����QL@¯deWUYpfeN!hªQjK�M[k!f�����keCiM[W#QTSpd�CiK$¨ � C�h�QL��YOk¯Ç�� qe� vb·�� �

Æ3ÕÉ�3�¦Ï � � ��% � Æ *Æy�O~ Å � � � ~jà3��Æp} Å ÐÖ|�Æ � � "3 Å �®�r� Ò Æ�� �' "e� Ò Æ3Ð(�bÆp}�� _�k¼QL@eC�WLC���M[QL��YOk Y ¬��M[WU��Cif¼h�YbkezOWUNeC�k!h�C�Y ¬ Ý*YbWLYb����M[WUS-x3��Eix3¨/QU@eC¯deWUC�KLC$k!h$C�Y ¬ � �sQTSpd�CiK ��KD��B�d;YOWLQUMOkyQ��¼?#@eC¯WUC�KLNe��Q��YON!��f'k!Y[Q#@eYO��f.� ¬ C�Mbhj@ � ��QTSyd;C # � ³ ¬ YbWA# ,@�� Y ��Y � Fr·X��C$WUCRWUC$de��MOh$C�fD�pSDQL@!C�³6��CiKLK*��k ¬ YOWUBDM[QL��¥OC¦·hj@�M[kekeC��(QTSpd;C�� ����tRKGM�h$YONekyQUC$WUC�PeM[BDde��CO¨�QUMO�OC $&%('�?#������0#����6�K� &5&�� ������MOk!f � $&%('�Ø���6�0#�� ������&L�± ��QL@'MG9 �ª��h�Ybky¥bC$WjKa��YOk(¨B WUC�feN!h�CiK(QUY �-� �RYr�*C�¥OC$Wi¨¦���§QU@eYONeQ ���RQTSpd;C�K�� ) ) * *��RMOk!f � ) ) � * *��Rh$YONe��f�;C�f3��KTQU��k!zONe��Ka@!C�f÷Â!KLC$C� � M[k�v � ¨ed�M[zOC�E � w ��� �

Ú�S.Ý*YOWUYO����MOWLS�x3��Eix3¨O�*Cc�pkeYr� QU@!MrQ�� ¬ U;>= � QP3QU@eC$k � ) ) * *M[k!f�� ) ) QP * *M[WUC��;C$@!M¦¥p��YONeWjM[����S��k!f3��KaQL��kezONe��KL@!M[�e��CO� � keCXBD��zb@yQ(�����OCb¨�@!Yr�*C�¥OC$Wi¨�QUYcKaC�C�@eYr�sQL@eC�WLCif3N!hªQU��YbkgY ¬ � � ��K(Ka��B�Ne��MrQUC�f¸��k¸QL@eC����h$MO��h$Ne��N!K$�X?#@e��K���K�Ka@!Yr��k��;C$��Yr�g�XH�C�h�M[����QL@!M[Q�QL@eCg��Y3h$M[����C$kp¥p��WUYOkeBDC�kbQ�keY[QjMrQU��Ybk M-@ � �Q#.7��&K�;� FKaQUMOk!feK ¬ YOW � ��# M N�� ��#.7 � &��� &L¨/Nek!feC$W�QU@eC.@pSpd�YOQL@eCiKa��K¸QU@!MrQUM MOk!f �°Ybke��Ssd�YyKLKLC�KUK¸[email protected]�M[d!MO�e������QTS.YOk � ³ � C�hªQU��Ybk^Ú�� qe� vb·��Ä^Å ~��e~� Å Ð �g±9C���WL��QLC�M[;4=�� M P�� ¬ QU@eC�WLCif3N!hªQU��Ybk M ;4= M P��KDÃO¤$��¤�©ªµ��£�!���ª���6�¯³´��� Cb� M ;4= M P P��BDde����CiKUM P � M P P6¨�MOk!fÉQU@eC$WUC.��K�keY L KLN!hj@-QL@�MrQ�M � � ·��È_ ¬ M<;6= � M P�QL@eC�k¼��k¼M[kpSÉh�YbkbQUC�PpQ�¨M ;4= M P®��K�keC�h$C�KUKLMOWL����SDQL@eC¸×!WjKaQRMOhªQU��Ybk�QL@!M[Q;M h�M[k�d!M[WLQL��h���d!MrQUCg��k(��±sC���WL��QLC+M ;4= 3� M P®� ¬ MC�¥OYb��¥bC�K*QLY M P÷�pS�d;C$W ¬ YOWUBD��k!zU-Éf3C�QUC$WUBD��ke��KaQL��h�WUC�feN!hªQU��Ybk!K$�

� Æ3Õ-ÕÉ� � � � $ � ) ) #������'&����6� � * * � ;6= ���� � ) ) * * � @2� ��# �4&�� ) ) � * *KFpÌ& � ŮŠ�U� ±9C¸MOdede��S.QU@eCg��M¦�cK�Y ¬ � C$BDB'M�ÚG� vDM[k!f�QL@eCg��M¦�cKcx¦�ao�Y ¬ ?#@eC$YbWLC�B°ÚG��Eiqeº

� ) ) #������'&����6� � * * �� ��� � � # ��&K��� ��# ��&�� ) ) * *AN � # ��&K� � � # � # � &��� � # �4&�� ) ) � * *AN � # � &K� � P � Y L�R& �;4= � � # �*� Y�� & ��� ��# ��&�� ) ) * *AN � # � &K��� � # �4&�� ) ) � * *AN � # � &� � P � Y L�R �;4=�� � # � � Y��G& ��� ��# � &�� ) ) * * N � � # �4&�� ) ) � * *AN � P � Y L�R �

;4=�� � # � � Y��G& � � ) ) * *�� @� C D4F N � ��# ��&�� ) ) * * N � � # �4&�� ) ) � * * �� # � ��& � � ) ) * * ��N � ��# �>& � ) ) � * * �� � ) ) * * � @2� �Q# �4&�� ) ) � * *5F

?#@!��K�d!WLYr¥bC�K�QL@eCg��C$BDB'Me¨!KL��k!h�C � h$YOBDB�NeQLC�Kc���§QU@ ;>= � �

?#@!CgWLCiMOf3C�W�BD��zO@yQ������OC¸QUY'h�YOBDd!MOWLCGQU@eC�f3C$WU��¥¦M[QL��YOk���k�QU@eCgdeWUYyY ¬ Y ¬ QL@!Cg��C�B�B'MD����QL@�QL@�MrQc��k³aE�my·ª¨3QUYDKLC$CGQU@eC�Ka��BD����M[WU��QL��C�K��

� Æ3Õ-ÕÉ� � � � À;�¦�O�e�¦�$¤ ¬ ¥6#. Y ��&�� 7��Ê��r��Ã� �¤�� � ������"7� ����������� #������.&Ì�D¤ �p�r¢r¤ � ) ) * *5@ � �# �4&�� ) ) � * *5F �! " � ) ) '@LA�CED4F * *ªÌ& � ŮŠ�U� ±9C'deWLY3h$C$C�fs�pSsKaQLWUN!hªQUNeWjM[�X��k!f3N!h�QL��YOkÉYOk ��?#@eC�WLC'MOWLC�QL@!WLC�C.h$MOKLC�K�º¸��@eC$k ��K�M¥rMOWL��M[�e��CO¨eMOk�MO�!KaQLWjMOhªQU��Ybk�YbWcM[k¯M[dede����h$MrQU��Ybk®�

� �3�� ´�!| Ò Æ;� � �!�Ú�YOQL@�QL@eC�h�MOKLC ��� �¾M[k�f�QU@eC�h$MbKaC � �� �¾M[WUCGCiMOKLSO�

â�â54�6!þ87:98;

Page 29: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

� � � Ì(À��[�y¿O�6�r©«¿O�

{�|�}�~$�r�e�O~� Å Ð�� � � ���QP6�X±sCg@!M¦¥bC� ) ) * *K@2� ��# �4&�� ) ) � * *5F �

� L # �4&K��� �6# ��&�� ) ) P * * � @2� ��# �4&�� ) ) � * *5F � ³ � qb·

L$# �4&K�$� # � �6#�� &�� ) ) P * *5&K@2� ��# �4&�� ) ) � * *5F � �! " ³ � Ei·L # �4&K��� �6# ��&�# � ) ) P * *K@ � �Q# �4&�� ) ) � * *KF & �! " ³ � � ·

L # �4&K��� �6# ��&�� ) ) P @LAMCED>F * * �� ) ) '@ A CED>F * *

��@!C$WUCO¨!��k ³ � qb·�¨eQL@!C KUh�YOd;CgY ¬ QU@eC���Y3h$M[�(C$kp¥p��WUYOkeBDC�kbQ @ � �'# �4&�� ) ) � * *5F�@�MOKc�;C$C�k^WLCif3N!h$C�f÷¨;Ka��k!h�C�^f3YpCiK*k!Y[Q�Y3h$h�N!W*��k L�# �4&LÂpQU@eC¸C�¹yN!MO����QTS¾³ � Ei·�deN!KL@eC�K�QU@eC���Y3h$MO�;C�kp¥y��WUYOkeBDC$kyQ#��k�Ka��f3CGdeWLC$×eP3C�K#M[k�fWUC$d!����h$M[QL��YOk®¨/M[k!fÉ��K�f3C$WU��¥bC�f ¬ WUYOBØQL@eC�KTQUWLYbkez^WLC�de����h�MrQLYbWgQL@!C$YOWUC$B ³ � C�hªQU��Ybk ÚG��Eb� �y·ªÂ/×!k!MO����S9QL@eCCi¹yN!M[���§QTSs³ � � · ¬ YO����Yr�cK ¬ WUYOB�QU@eCg��k!f3N!h�QL��¥OCgMOKUKaN!B�deQL��YOk®�

{ �.� Ò ´�b�3~� Å Ð�� � � � �?#@!��K�h�MOKLCG��K�KL��BD����MOW#QLYDQL@�MrQ�Y ¬ M[�!KaQLWjMOh�QL��YOk®Âp��C¸��CiM¦¥OC¸�§QRMbK�M[k�C�P3C$Wjh���KLCO�

� Å � Å�Ò´Ò �3�¦à � � � � �(¤$�8 �*)bÌ� Ì �6�(�;>= � QP�� �p¤$� � ) ) * * �!;4= �� M �! �

��������� �� ) ) QP * *��eÌ

� Ì � �3¤c�j�r�!¢r¤$©j��¤�Ê÷�6Ì£¤�Ì�Ê�� � � ) ) * * �!;4=�M&� �p¤$�D���3¤�©U¤���� P �ª�!���g� �p�[�� ;4= � P Ê�M ;6= �� � ���������� �� ) ) QP * * � Ê*�r��Ã.µ'�r©U¤U�[¢¦¤$©g� �p¤�©L¤jÃr�!�$�«�6�[� � ) ) * * � ;4=�M ����ÃO¤$��¤$©ªµ �£�����ª�«�6�iÌ

& � ŮŠ�U� tck¯C�MbKaS�C�P3C$Wjh���KaCb¨pN!Ka��kez�QL@!CgdeWLC�¥p��YbN!K�QT�*Y���C$BDB'MOK�� �

Ý*YbWLYb����M[WUS�x3��E�v�Ka@eYr�cK�QL@!M[Q�¨;��k¾WUC�KLd;YOk!KLCgQLY ;4=�� QP6¨;deWUY3h�C�KUK � ) ) * * � f3C$QLC�WLBD��ke��KaQL��h$MO����Sd;C$W ¬ YOWUB'K�QL@eWUC$CgWUC�feN!hªQU��Ybk!K$¨!��@eYbKLCgf3C$WU��¥rM[QL��¥OC+M ��Kck!Y[QcdeWUC�h$��KLC$��S'QL@!CgC$k!h$Ypfe��kez'Y ¬ QP«¨!�!N3QRh$MOk�;CRd!WLYr¥bC�f C�¹yN!M[�!QLY �§Q�N!Ka��kez�KLYOBDC���M¦�cKXQU@!MrQ �TWUC$YbWUf3C�W �*QL@eCGKTQUWLN!h�QLNeWUCcY ¬ M�³6WLC���M[QL��YOk �! �

�����������·ª�

0�� Æy�r� ´}iÆ � � �2�� ��¤�»��r©L�[ £ ��r©ªÁ ! Ì ��� ���¸�;©L�r¢r¤�»X�[©L�r £ ��r©ª�6¤�� ! Ì � ! �[�;à ! Ì ��� Ì

Æ3ÕÉ�3�¦Ï � � 3� ?#@eC�WUC�KLNe��QUKXYbk�QU@eCGÝ�V � QUWUMOk!K ¬ YOWUB�¨OkeY[QjM[�e��S�?#@eC�YOWUC$B'K�x3� ngM[k!f'x3� x3¨b@!M¦¥OC#�;C$C�kN�KaCif¼QUY¼f3C�WL��¥OC^WUC�KLNe��QUK.MO��YbN3Q'QL@eC9h�YbWLWUC�h�QLkeCiKLK�Y ¬ QU@eC¾����h$M[��h�N!��N!K.C$k!h$Ypfe��kez�� � YOBDC�QU��BDC�K�¨#�*CB'M¦S9M[��KaY^zbY^��kÉ[email protected]!d�YyKa��QLC�fe��WUC�h�QL��YOk®¨�QL@!M[Q���K�N!KLCDQL@eC�����h�M[��h�Ne��N!KgC�k!h�Y3f3��kez^QUY^Nek!f3C�WUKaQUMOk!f÷¨MOk!f WUC�MbKaYbk M[�;YON3Qi¨XQL@!C^Ý�V � QLWjM[k�K ¬ YbWLB¯�-ÛeYbW ��k!KaQUM[k�h�CO¨���k ]/P3C$Wjh���KaC¯x3� � qÈ�*C�@!M¦¥OC�f3C$WU��¥bC�f Mfe��WUC�h�Q�deWUYpY ¬ Y ¬ Ý*YOWUYO����M[WUS9x3��E$n����RKL��k!zÈQU@e��K�¨ � C$BDB'M9xe��Eiqe¨�MOk!f � C$BDB'MsÇ � � ¨���C�h�M[k feC$WU��¥bCQU@eCgMOf3Ci¹yN!MOh$S'Y ¬ QL@eC�Ý�V � QLWjM[k�K ¬ YbWLB ³«?#@eC$YbWLC�B­x3� ny·�� � ��BD����MOWL��SO¨3��k�QU@eC�KUM[BDCg]/P3C$Wjh���KaCgx3� � q �*C@�M¦¥OC'f3C$WU��¥OC�f-Ý*YOWUYO����M[WUSÈx3��Eix3ÂN!KL��k!z�QU@e��K�³6MOk!f � C�B�B'M^Ç � np·ª¨�*C.h�M[kÉdeWUYr¥OCDM¯�*CiM[�bC$Wg¥OC�WUKL��YOkY ¬ ?#@eC$YbWLC�B x3� x3¨/KUM¦Sy��kez�QL@�MrQ � ¬ ��9�� ! � � QL@!C$k " � ) ) * *#M[k!f " � ) ) � * *�M[WUC'YO�!KLC$WU¥rMrQU��Ybk!M[����SCi¹yNe��¥rMO��C�kbQ�MOK/QUC$WUBDK�Y ¬ ��� �#³ � �!KLC$WU¥rMrQL��YOk�M[�eCi¹bN!��¥rM[��C$k�h�CcCi¹bN�MrQLCiK/QLC�WLB'K�QL@!M[Q�M[WUC��;C$@!M¦¥p��YONeWjM[����S��k!f3��KaQL��kezONe��KL@!M[�e��CDM[k!fs�������X�;CDfeC�×!keCifsMOk!f9KTQUN!f3��C�fs��k � C�h�QL��YOk EOEb®��k ¬ YOWUBDMO����SO¨�QT��Y^���¾�«QUC$WUBDK+ � M[k�f�+ � MOWLCgYb�!KaC�WL¥rM[QL��YOk!MO����S���k!f3��KTQU��k!zONe��Ka@�M[�e��C�� ¬¬ YbW ¬ YbW�M[���(����h$MO��h$Ne��N!Kch�YbkyQLC�PpQjK�� ��QR@eYO��feKQU@!MrQ�� ) + � * � � � ��� ) + � * � � � ·

�´ó�â����

Page 30: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

���!��¤�©��;©L¤$�«�£�p¿R�j�3�������6�r�!�g�r�#���a�j�[ ����3 §�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª� � o

���È� �b���g���b¶� �¤�Í�¤��b¶i¶�©L¤�¢i�6�r��¤�" � ) ) * *��r� ) ) * *��[�;à " '�$) �+*#�r� ) � * �h�M[���§���pSb��k!MOB�CG¥rM[��NeC�K� � � �����

) ) � * * $&%('� � �6�K���) ) �+* * $&%('� � �6� � ) �+*

) ) � * * $&%('� � �6� ) ) * *%#����>� � ) ) � * *#�4&) ����� * $&%('� ����� ) ) * *

?�MO�e��Cgn!ºX?#@eC�h$MO�������ySy��k!M[BDCgÝ�V � QLWjM[k!K ¬ YOWUB

�32�� � �� ��.� 7 � : ���� � � �� ���� � 7

Û!WLYbB QU@eC�h�M[���§���pSb��¥rM[��NeCDC$k!h$Y3f3��k!z^�§Q���KgCiMOKLS¾QLYÈYO�3QjM[��k9¥rMOWL��M[kyQUK¸����QL@ f3� ��C$WUC$kyQ�f3��KUh���de����keCiK ¬ YOWWUC�feN!h���kez�QL@eCDYOd;C$WjMrQUYOW¸M[k!fÈQL@!C�Ybd�C�WUMOk!f¾Y ¬ M[kÉM[d!de����h$M[QL��YOk®� � keC'KaN!hj@s¥rM[WU��MOkbQ¸��KRQU@eC��3�[©L�r £ �¤� �j�[ £  �L¶ªÁ���¢r�r §�!¤'KTQUWUM[QLC�zOSO¨�QL@�MrQ�@�MOKRQL@eC YOWjf3��k�M[WUS S WUNe��C���k¾de��MOh$C�Y ¬ S �[� �RC$WUC���KRQL@!C�f3C$×!ke��QL��YOk¾Y ¬MOdede����h�MrQU��Ybk ¬ YbW#QL@eCgd!MOWUMO����C$�÷h�M[���§���pSb��¥rM[��NeCGC$k!h$Ypfe��kez�¨ef3C$k!Y[QLCif��yS����Rº

��� ) ) � * * $&%('� # L$&�0# ��� Y � & ����� ) ) * * � N���� ) ) � * * N � # ��&K� � # �4&K� � P �4Y L�R �?#@!C*Ybd�C�WUM[QLYOWM[k!f�QL@eC#Ybd�C�WUMOk!f�M[WUC�WUNek ��k d!M[WjM[����C��«�?#@eC#h���M[N!KLC�K ¬ YOWXM[��KTQUWUMbhªQL��YOk�K(M[k�f�¥rM[��NeC�K

¬ YbW���� M[WUCGQL@eC�KUM[BDCgMOK ¬ YbW�³£QL@!C�KaCi¹bN!C$kyQL��M[�£· �R�

0�� Æy�r� ´}iÆ � � /�� J��y�«¶ª�£�#�'��¤�©ªµ �[�¾Í��b�6� ��� �p¤ ¤����j��Ã[�£�y¿[���a����¤ �$�!¤����«�6�[ (�r��ø�e�r©L�[ £ �¤� �U�[ £  �L¶�Á��¢r�r §�!¤ Ãb�.���r�¿O�£¢r¤�� �p¤��$�rµ'¤�¶U¤ �p�[¢��6�[�3©j�UÊ��6Ì£¤�Ì�Ê�� ) ) * * �� ��� ) ) * *jÌ0�� Æy�r� ´}iÆ � � ��� ÌgÀ;�¦�O�e�¦�$¤ ¬ ¥6#. Y ��& � 7��Ê÷�[�;Ã� �¤$� � ��� �� 7� ��������� � #������ &jÌ�½#©L�r¢r¤����3�r����� ) ) #�������'&����6� � * * �! "��� ) ) '@ � A CED>F * *jÌ � �g�£��� � �£�����g�ª�£µ��£ ��r©����D� �p¤c��©U���a�U� �T����¤�µ�µ'�¦� ! Ì � � �[�;à ! Ì �� Ì �

� Ì'»��[�;�$ ¡�!ÃO¤ � �p�r��� �c��9 � ! � �ÉÊ����3¤�� � ) ) * *��! " � ) ) � * *��eÌ

� +���� $��������������¸� $��� � � ����"$"j����� ��������

_�k�QU@e��K*KaCihªQU��Ybk ��Ccf3C$¥bC$��YOdDM¸����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K/C�k!h�Y3f3��kez¸Y ¬ h$MO�������pSy��k!M[BDCc�3��h$MO��h$Ne��N!K$�/?#@eCcMOdedeWUYbMOhj@ ��KKL��B�����M[WQLYGQL@�MrQ ¬ YOW�h�M[���§���pSb��¥rM[��NeC���k � C�h�QL��YOk'x3��?#@!C�WUC�Mbf3C$WkeYOQ/��kyQLC�WLCiKTQUC�f ��k QL@eCRÝ�V � QUWUMOk!K ¬ YbWLBB'M¦S�KLC$Cgf3��WUC�hªQU��S�QL@eC¸C�k!h�Y3f3��kez'��kbQUYD����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K#Y ¬ � C�h�QL��YOk �e� qe��EO�

%®~�Æ � � �¸~ � Æ^�O� Ò´Ò áU|�à�ájÐ��!ÕÉÆ ��& %?M[�!��C n�KL@eYr�cK#QL@!C�h�M[���§���pSb��k!MOB�C Ý�V � QLWjM[k�K ¬ YbWLB Y ¬ VX��Ypo[x �#³6��k ¬ MOhªQi¨;M�WLCihªQU�§×!Cif^¥rM[WU��MOkyQRY ¬ ��Q�¨KLC$CGQU@eCgkeY[QUC�K���k � C�h�QL��YOkÉE$np·ª� �cC�WLC¸��K�@eYr� M-9ÉWUC�f3N!h�QL��YOk

#������'& �<;4= � '@ A C D>F

â�â54�6!þ87:98;

Page 31: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

� w � Ì(À��[�y¿O�6�r©«¿O�

��K/Ka��B�N!��M[QLC�f���k QL@!C*QUWUMOk!K ¬ YOWUB���³6t�K/��k�h$M[�������pSy��¥rMO��NeCb¨r�*C#hj@eYpYbKLC�QUYRQjM[�bC�h�M[���§���pSb��k!MOB�C ¬ YOWQL@!C�WUC��feN!hªQU��Ybk�WLC���M[QL��YOkgYbkgQL@eC���BDMOzOCiK®Y ¬ QU@eCcÝ�V � ¨¦�eN3QQL@eCiKaC�QLC�WLB'KM[WUC�C$¥rM[��N!M[QL��YOk3��YOWjf3C$W(��k!feC$d;C$k!f3C�kyQ�ºKLC$Cg?#@eC�YOWUC$B �!��Eb� · " � ) ) #������'& � * * �;4=�� " � ) ) ������ * *%#����4� � " � ) ) � * * �4&

� #����6�2# � "('� ) ������ * &K&K#����4� � " � ) ) � * * �4&;4=�� #����4� � " � ) ) � * * �4& "('�$) ������ *;4=�� "('� ) ����� * " � ) ) � * * �� #������ " � ) ) * *.& " � ) ) � * * �;4= � " � ) ) * *.@ ��� � � A � � C D�F �

_�k zOC�keC$WjM[� " � ) ) * * @ � � � � A � � CED>F � ��K keYOQ�Ci¹bN�M[�*QLY " � ) ) '@BAMC D�F * *#��¨���Cih$M[N�KaC�" ��f3YpC�K keY[Q'h�YbB�B N3QLC����QL@DKLNe�!KaQL��QLN3QU��Ybk®�?#@!C*QT��YcQUC$WUB'KMOWLCb¨r@eYr��C$¥OC�W�¨B9÷��h�Ybkp¥OC$WLQL���e��COÂr��k!f3C�C�f " � ) ) * * @ ��� � � A � � CED>F ����� W" � ) ) '@ A C D�F * * ���Ý*��YbKL��k!z¯QL@eC'��B'M[zOC'Y ¬ QU@eC'QUWUMOk!K ¬ YbWLB Nek!f3C�W 9÷��WLCif3N!hªQU��YbkÉzO��¥OC�KGQU@eC.��M[kezbN!M[zbC'Ý�V � � Y ¬ QL@eC

h�M[���§���pSy��k!MOBDCgÝ�V � ºÝ�V � � $&%('� @�� � � �� ����QL@�" � ) ) * * ��� W � F

± @!C$k�QL@eC�WLC¸��K�keY'M[B �e��zONe��QTS.��C¸h�M[����QL@eC¸QUC$WUB'K#Y ¬ Ý�V � � QL@eC^»(½*À9��¤$©ªµ��ª�?#@eC�QL@eC�YOWUC$B'K��;C$��Yr�&M[WUC¸QL@eC�h$M[�������pSy��k�M[BDC¸¥OC$WjKL��Ybk!K#Y ¬ ?#@eC�YOWUC$B'KRxe��E$��xe� xe�*?#@eC�S�KL@eYr� QL@eC

��k!f3����C$WUC$k!h$CRY ¬ QU@eC¸Ý�V � QLC�WLB'KXQUY�QU@eC�hj@eYb��h$Cc�;C�QT��C$C$k�h$M[�������pSy��k�M[BDCcM[k!f'h�M[���§���pSy��¥rM[��NeCb¨bM[k�fDQL@eCh$YOWUWLCihªQUkeC�KUKRY ¬ QU@eC�Ý�V � QLWjM[k!K ¬ YOWUB¯��?#@eC�YOWUC$B �!� m���KgKL����zb@bQU��SÈ�*CiM[�OC�WRQU@!M[ksQL@!C.h�YOWUWUC�KLd�Ybk!f3��kezWUC�KLNe��Q ¬ YOW�h$M[�������pSy��¥rMO��NeCb��?#@eCRWLCiMOKLYOk���K�QL@!M[Q�¨pMOKX������N!KaQLWjMrQUC�f'M[�;Yr¥OCb¨ " � h�YOBDB N3QLCiKX���§QU@�KLNe�!KaQL��QLN3�QU��Ybk¾YOk!��S�Ned^QUYN9÷��h�Ybky¥bC$WjKa��YOk(��_�kÈh�YbkbQUWUMbKTQi¨�?#@eC�YOWUC$B �e� n.��K�KaQLWUYOkezbC$W�QU@!M[k¾QL@eC�h�YOWUWUC�KLd�Ybk!f3��kezWUC�KLNe��Q ¬ YOWch$MO�������ySy��¥rM[��NeCOº�§QRMbKLKLC$WLQUK#M���YOzO��h$MO�÷C�¹yNe��¥rM[��C$k!h$CGWjMrQU@eC$W�QU@!M[k^M[k���B�d!����h$M[QL��YOk®�

��� Æ Å �¦Æ3Õ % � � � 6Ð(Ó) �Æy�rÆ3Ð(�bÆ Å � Ý�V � � Å Ð �rÆpÓ����[~� Å Ð(}�� �(¤$�* Ý�V � � �r�;Ã^ �¤�� � ¶U¤.�r��Á�ª��¶���¤$©ªµ �a�(�Ì (�[©��r £ ��HP6Ê�Í�¤ �p�[¢¦¤ � �R;6=�� �HP*� � �T;>=�� �HP�Ì��� Æ Å �¦Æ3Õ % � � 6Ð(Ó) �Æy�rÆ3Ð(�bÆ Å � Ý�V � � Å Ð � áL~ � Æ Å � 6Æy}�� (�[©É�[ £ � Y � Ý�V � � Ê�Í�¤ �3�r¢r¤ ���9 !I � � � �²��9 � !N � �¼Ì

��� Æ Å �¦Æ3Õ % � � � �eÓ�Æ�� ���e�[à Å � " � � ��¤$�8 � ) Ì� Ì �6�8 ��� � � Í��3¤�©L¤ � ���#�g�j�r £  �L¶ªÁ������rµ'¤�¢r�r ¡�!¤�Ê®���3¤��'� �p¤$©L¤#���c�r� �/����� � �j�!� ��� �p�r��" � ) ) * *#����� ��,�[�;à ��9 ! � � � "('�$) � *�Ì

� Ì � �3¤'�U�[�!¢r¤�©j�$¤�Ê*�6Ì£¤iÌ�Ê�� � " � ) ) * * � ��� � �I�[�;à �������[� �/�����UÊ����3¤��9� �p¤$©L¤ �������j�[ £  �L¶ªÁ������rµ'¤�¢¦�[ ¡�!¤� �j�!� ��� �p�[� ��� � �Ø�r�;à ��9 ! � � � "('� ) � *�Ì��� Æ Å �¦Æ3Õ % � � � "e� Ò ´Ó) £~jà Å �#~ � Æ 9 áL~ � Æ Å �ià � Å � " ��� ��¤�� Y � ��¸Ì � �p¤$�È��9 !Z � � � ���9 !" � ) ) * * � " � ) ) � * *�Ì%®~�Æ � � ��� Å Õ Ý�V � � ~ Å � + �

?#@!C�zbWUMOB�B'MOW��;C$��Yr� zOC$k!C$WjMrQLCiK�MO���;QLC�WLB'K�Y ¬ Ý�V � �O�X?#@eCG��kyQLN!�§QU��¥bC�BDC�MOke��kez Y ¬ QL@!C�¥rM[WU��YON!K�KaSpk3�QjMOh�QL��h�h$MrQUC$zbYOWU��CiK���k�QL@eCRzOWjM[BDB'M[W/��KXQL@eCRKUM[BDC�MOK ¬ YOWXQU@eCch$MO�������pSy��¥¦MO��N!C�ÙGWjM[BDB'M[W#E¦x3�/?#@eC�B'M[��k

�´ó�â����

Page 32: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

���!��¤�©��;©L¤$�«�£�p¿R�j�3�������6�r�!�g�r�#���a�j�[ ����3 §�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª� � v

fe� ��C$WUC$k!h$C�K�MOWLC�QL@eC�Mbfef3��QL��YOk�Y ¬ QL@eC¸¥rM[��NeC¸¥rM[WU��MO�e��C �;¨3WUC$deWUC�KLC$kyQL��kez QL@eCgd�M[WjM[BDC�QUC$W�Y ¬ h�YOkyQU��kpN!M[�QU��Ybk!K�¨�MOk!f^QU@eC KLde���§QLQL��kez�Y ¬ QU@eC KLC�Q¸Y ¬ MOk!Ka��C$WjKc��kyQLY�QL@eCDKaC$QUK M ��M[k�f M8�[�g?#@eC�KLC�BDY3f3��×�h$M[QL��YOk!KMOWLC�B'MOf3CD��ksYbWUfeC$WGQLY^h$MOd3QLN!WLC QL@eC'����keC�MOWGN�KaCDY ¬ QL@eCDd!MOWUMOBDC�QLC�WUKGY ¬ h�YbkyQL��kyN�MrQL��YOk�KR����QL@e��k9QL@eCzbWUMOBDBDMOW�³6feWLYbdede��kez.����keCiM[WU�§QTS���C��*YbNe��f¯@!M¦¥OC¸QU@eCDÝ�V � ��MOkezON�M[zOCgY ¬ ?�MO�e��C �b·��RtRKR��k^QU@eC h�M[���§��pSy��¥¦MO��N!C�zbWUMOB�B'MOW�¨OQL@eC�WLCG��K�Ybke��S'YbkeC¸h�YOkyQU��kpN!M[QL��YOk.¥rM[WU��M[�e��C �.��Cih$M[N�KaC¸h�YbkbQU��kpN!M[QL��YOk!K�M[WUCRN�KaCif����keC�MOWL��SO�

h$YOkyQL��kpN!MrQU��Ybk�¥rM[WU��M[�e��C �YOWjf3��k�M[WUS'¥¦MOWL��M[�!��CiK ��Y0]2]0]

¥rM[��NeCg¥rM[WU��M[�e��C �M[k!KL��C$WjK M � � M � � M �

M � � � � � � � ��� � ���M � � � � � �

Ý�V � ��¥rM[��NeC�K � � � �����j� �$� M��h�YbkyQL��kyN�MrQL��YOk�K � � � �R�D���4� M8�deWU��k�h���d!M[��QUC$WUBDK � � � ���6�,M � � �

³ � my·

��Ka��kez��sMOK�QU@eC¸QTSpd�CgY ¬ M[k�Ka��C$WjK$¨yQU@eC¸QTSpd�CiK����#¨ ��� M[k�f �� ÉY ¬ Ý�V � ��¥rM[��NeCiK$¨!h$YOkyQL��kpN!MrQU��Ybk!K�¨MOk!f�deWU��k!h$��d�M[��QLC�WLB'K�MOWLC

��� $ %('�O���$� #5#�� =�� & =�� &8=�#5#�� =��8&8=�� & �

��� $ %('� �� =��

�� $ %('� ��� =��

³ � np·

?#@!C�¥¦MO��N!C�¥rMOWL��M[�e��C �g@!MOKQU@eC#QTSpd�C ��¾Y ¬ QL@!C�Ý�V � ¥¦MO��N!C�K��?#@eC�QTSpde��kez�ZTN!f3zbB�C�kyQUK ¬ YbW/QL@eC#QUC$WUBDKzbC$keC�WUM[QLCif��pS'QU@eCgzOWjM[BDB'M[W#M[WUCgMOK#C�P3d;C�h�QLC�f®¨ezO��¥OC�k.QL@!C�KLC¸QTSyd;C�K��

& � Å � Å }� £~� Å Ð % � � �6�(¾Ý�V � �OÊ����3¤��I �����[  �$���¸�;©ª�£�;�$� �3�[ ���¤$©ªµ �T� �©U�rµ�µD�[© ��� Ì

& � ŮŠ�U� � keC�h�M[k¾KL@eYr� QL@!M[QcQL@eC�KaC$QRY ¬ deWU��k!h���d!M[�(QLC�WLB'Kc��k!h$��N!feC�K�QU@eC KLC�Q!@ " � ) ) * * �N ,��FMOk!f���K�h$��YyKaCif�N!k!f3C$WX9®��h$YOkp¥OC�WUKL��Ybk®� �

?#@!Cc��k[ZTC�hªQU��Ybk�%Ȩ ¬ WUYOB QL@eCRQLC$WUB'K�zbC$keC�WUM[QLC�fD�pS'ÙGWUMOBDBDMOW � mGQLY � � �X¨b��K�f3C�×!k!C�f.MbK ¬ YOW�QL@eCh�M[���§���pSy��¥rM[��NeCgÙGWUMOBDBDMOW¸Eix3¨eMOk!f�Ka��BD����M[W�WUC�KLNe��QUK#@eYb��f÷º

� Æ3Õ-ÕÉ� % � % À��¦�b�3�r��¤ ��� ����¤$©ªµ�¿b¤$�;¤$©L�r��¤jÃ�¶�Á #©L�[µ µ'�r© ��� Ê��r�;à � !^ � � Ì � �3¤��-�r  �$�% ) ) �$* *�!�% ) ) * * � % ) ) � * *;Ì?#@!C$WUC ¬ YOWUCO¨p� ¬ ^� ���§QU@ ¬ ¥4#%'& � 7��¨3QL@!C$k

7�Q� % ) ) � * * !�% ) ) " � ) ) * * * * � % ) ) � * * ��# % ) ) � � * *6=�� &8=�� ³ � xb·

� Æ3Õ-ÕÉ� % � $ (�[©G�[ £ ;��¤$©ªµ�� �a� #©L�[µ µ'�r© ��� Ê/Í�¤ �3�r¢r¤ � � �: ;4=��XQP/� �p¤$� % ) ) * *%;4= W � W% ) ) QP * * �¾�r�;à �j�r��¢¦¤$©j�$¤� §Á¦Ê�� �% ) ) * * ;>=�W M�� �p¤$� � �p¤$©L¤9���IQP��ª�!��� � �p�r�! ;4= � QP'�r�;ÃM ��W % ) ) P * *�Ì� Å � Å�Ò´Ò �3�¦à % � ��r© �r £ ���¤$©ªµ��H Y � ¿y¤���¤�©L�[��¤jò¶�Á #©L�rµ�µD�[© �"! Ê'��9 ! � � �£µ��� ¡�6¤��% ) ) * * � W % ) ) � * *TÌ

â�â54�6!þ87:98;

Page 33: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

mbq � Ì(À��[�y¿O�6�r©«¿O�

� ) ) ����� * * $ %('� # L$&� L # ��&� �4# ��& � ) ) * *� ) ) � * * $ %('� # L$&� � P L�R

� ) ) � * * $ %('� # L$&� ��� � � ) ) * *��+N � # �>&K� � ��# � P ��Y L�R���� � � ) ) � * *K& �?M[�e��C�x3ºX?#@eCgC�k!h�Y3f3��kezDY ¬ ��� ��kyQLY�QL@eCg����h$MO��h$Ne��N!K

%®~�Æ � � �G� Å Õ-�) Ò �e~� Å Ð "?#@!��K�KaQLC�d���K#zO��¥OC�k��pS�h$YOBDde����M[QL��YOk&"sY ¬ � � �9��kbQUYD����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K��% � 2 � � � Å Õ-� Å }� «Ð(Ô9~ � Æ^}�~�Æ ��}Ý*YbBDd�YyKa��kez�[email protected]@eWUC$C.KaQLC�d!K$¨ ¬ WUYOB ��� QLYsÝ�V � �O¨ ¬ WLYbB Ý�V � �DQUY � � �X¨XM[k!f ¬ WUYOB � � � QLY^���h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�¨3�*C¸Yb�3QUMO��k�QL@eCgC�k!h�Y3f3��kezDY ¬ ���Ø��kyQLYD����h$M[��h�N!��N!K#��k^?�MO�e��Cgxe�?#@eC�C$k�h�Y3f3��kezRN!KLC�K�QU@eWLC�C��p��k!feKY ¬ k!MOBDCOº� ����j�r���6�r���;�rµ'¤��G³ L�Y � Y � ·�¨e��©ª�§¿�¿y¤�©#���rµ'¤ª��³ ��YK�3·�¨OM[k�f

¢r�r §�!¤G�;�rµ'¤��g³ �p·�� � Y3h$M[QL��YOkDk!MOB�CiK�M[WUCcM[WUzON!B�C�kyQUKXY ¬ QU@eCRC�k!h�Y3f3��kez!¨yM[k!f'MOWLC�QU@eC�h$YONekyQLC�WLd�M[WLQ/Y ¬QU@eC�h$YOkyQL��kpN!MrQU��Ybk�¥rMOWL��M[�e��CgY ¬ QL@!CDÝ�V � ÙGWjM[BDB'M[W � me�#?(WU��zbzOC�W�k!M[BDC�KRM[WUCgd�Yb��kyQLC�WUK�QLY��e�«QUC$WUB'K$¨MOk!fÉM[WUC�[email protected]$YONekyQLC�WLd�M[WLQGY ¬ [email protected]��k!M[WUS^¥rM[WU��MO�e��C�K¸Y ¬ QL@eC¯Ý�V � zOWjM[BDB'M[Wi��Ü�MO��N!C'k!M[BDC�K�M[WUCd;YO��kyQLC�WUK�QUY'¥¦MO��N!C�K�³6B�YbWLCgd!WLCih���KaC���Sb¨3QLY�Ý�V � ��¥rM[��NeCiK$¨e��k¯QL@!C¸QLC$WUBD��k!YO��YOzOS�Y ¬ ÙGWUMOB�B'MOW � mb·�¨!M[k�fMOWLC�QL@!C�h�YON!kbQUC$WUd!M[WLQ#Y ¬ QL@eCg¥rM[��NeC¸¥rM[WU��MO�e��CGY ¬ QU@eC Ý�V � zOWjM[BDB'M[Wi�±9C�C$Ppd!��MO��k¾�!WL��C �!S�@eYr� QL@!C�C$k�h�Y3f3��kez.��YOWU�pK���tRK���k¾QL@eC�h$M[�������pSy��¥rMO��NeCgC�k!h�Y3f3��kez�¨;M��e��QLC$WUB,QL@�MrQ�WUC�f3N!h$C�K/QUY�M¸¥rM[��NeC � ��K�QLWjM[k!KL��MrQLCif MbK�M¸deWUY3h�C�KUK � ) ) * * � QU@!MrQi¨OWUYONezb@e��S Kad;C�MO�y��kez�¨OC$BD��QUK

� M[Q;L®�'Ú�N3Q�¨���k-h�YbkyQLWjMOKaQ�QUY¯h�M[���§���pSy��¥rM[��NeCb¨÷��k-h$MO�������ySy��k!M[BDCDM�¥¦MO��N!CDh�M[k9YOke��S¾�;C.M ¬ Nek!hªQU��Ybk®�\^YOWUC$Yr¥OC�W�¨;M��e�«QUC$WUB QL@!M[QG��KGC$¥rM[��N!M[QLC�f¾BDM¦S¯Ybke��S¯�;C�QL@eC�YOd;C$WjM[k!f¯F k!Y[QRQU@eCDM[WUzONeBDC$kyQRF Y ¬MOk9MOdede����h�MrQU��Ybk®�.tRK�KLN!hj@®¨(�§Q�B'M¦S¾k!Y[Qg��C�h�YOd!��Cif÷Â(QU@!MrQ���K�¨(��Q�BDM¦SÈ��C'N!KLC�f9Ybke��S �r�;�j¤$�._�k9QL@eCC�k!h�Y3f3��kez Y ¬ MO�!KaQLWjMOhªQU��Ybk'��k¯?M[�e��CGxe¨bQU@e��K#����keC�MOWL��QTSD��K�C�¥y��f3C�kbQ#��k.QL@!C ¬ MbhªQ�QL@!M[Q*QU@eC¸��k!deN3QcMrQ �D��Kk!Y[Q�WUC$d!����h$M[QLC�f®��tck!Y[QL@!C$W¸f3� ��C$WUC$k�h�C ¬ WUYOB h�M[���§���pSb��¥rM[��NeCg��KcQU@!MrQ¸��ksh$M[�������pSy��k�M[BDCgQL@!C M[WUzON!B�C�kyQd�MOKUKaCifDQLY�M ¬ Nek�hªQL��YOk�B'M¦S��;C¸M[k�MOWL�!�§QUWUMOWLS'�3��QLC�WLB¯¨p��@e��hj@®¨p��k�QL@eCG�;YpfeS'Y ¬ QU@eC ¬ N!k!hªQU��Ybk®¨3@!MOK�QLY�;C�C�¥rM[��N!MrQUC�f¯C$¥bC$WUS.QU��BDC���QUKR¥rM[��NeC���KRkeC�C�f3Cif÷�c?#@e��K�fe� ��C$WUC$k!h$C���KcC$¥p��f3C$kyQG��k¯QU@eC�C�k!h�Y3f3��kez.Y ¬ M¥rMOWL��M[�e��C �(º*QL@!C h�YbWLWUC�KLd;YOk!f3��kezD����h$M[��h�N!��N!Kck!M[BDC �¾��KcN�KaCif¯keY[Q�MbKRMD¥rM[��NeC��!N3QGMbKcMDQLWU��zOzOC�W ¬ YOWMbhªQU��¥rMrQU��k!z�MDQLC�WLB MOk!f¯deWUYr¥y��f3��kez'��QG����QL@ÈM.��Y3h$M[QL��YOk®��_�k¾QL@eC C$k!h$Ypfe��kez�Y ¬ M[ksM[dede����h$MrQU��Ybk, �M[Q���Y3h�MrQL��YOk L(¨���@eC�k KL��zbk!M[��KGQL@�MrQ���Q�@!MbKg��Cih�YbB�C.M ¬ N!k!hªQU��Ybk®¨���Q�WUC�h$C$��¥OC�KgM�QUWL��zOzbC$W ¬ YbWgQL@eCMOWLzbNeBDC$kyQ � MOk!f�QL@eCg��Y3h$MrQU��Ybk�L ¬ YbW���kyQLC�WUMbhªQU��kezD����QL@�QL@!CgC$kp¥p��WUYOkeBDC�kbQi�

Æ3ÕÉ�3�¦Ï % � �²_�k�QU@eC#QUMO�e��Cb¨[��k�QU@eCcf3C�×�ke�§QU��Ybk!K/Y ¬�¬ Nek!h�QL��YOk'M[k!f�M[d!de����h$M[QL��YOk®¨¦QU@eC���kedeN3QjK�MrQ ��M[k�f� M[WUC�keYOQ�WUC$de����h�MrQUC�fg�;C�h�M[N!KLC*Y ¬ QL@!C*����k!C�M[WU��QTS¸h$YOk!KaQLWjM[��kyQ(YOk ¥rM[��NeC�¥rM[WU��M[�e��C�KM[k!f�YOk h$YOkyQL��kpN!MrQU��Ybk¥rMOWL��M[�e��CDY ¬ ÙGWUMOBDBDMOW � m�QL@�MrQ�¨��ksQU@eC�h$YOBDde����M[QL��YOk9Y ¬ � � � QLY¯QU@eC'����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�¨(C�k!M[�e��C�K�N!K¸QLYMbf3YOdeQ�QL@eC�Ybd3QL��BD��KUMrQU��Ybk^Y ¬ � C�h�QL��YOk¾Ç � q!� v!Â!��C�f3��f¾Ka��BD����M[WU��S.��k¯QU@eC h�M[���§���pSy��¥rM[��NeC¸C$k�h�Y3f3��kez!¨!KLC$CHcC$B'M[WU��x3��E � � �

Æ3ÕÉ�3�¦Ï % � ��2 ?#@eCs����keCiM[WU�§QTS Y ¬ QL@!Cs¥rM[��NeCsk!M[BDC�K�Y ¬ ?M[�e��Csx²³6M[k�f Ka��BD����M[WU��SO¨�Y ¬ QU@eCÈ¥rMO��NeC¥rMOWL��M[�e��C�K�Y ¬ ÙGWUMOB�B'MOW � my·;BDM¦S���C���YyKTQ(��@!C$keC�¥OC$W(YOkeC�MbfefeK ¬ N!WaQU@eC$W(h$YOk!KaQLWUN!h�QUK�QUY�QL@eC��3��h$MO��h$Ne��N�K$¨

�´ó�â����

Page 34: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

���!��¤�©��;©L¤$�«�£�p¿R�j�3�������6�r�!�g�r�#���a�j�[ ����3 §�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª� meE

MbK���CR��������feY���k � CihªQL��YOkÈEOEO�/?�Y KLNeded;YOWLQ�C$PyQUC$k!KL��YOk!K�¨OQU@eC¸f3C�×!k!�§QU��Ybk.Y ¬ MO�!KaQLWjMOhªQU��Ybk'��k�QL@eCRQUMO�e��CWUC�¹yNe��WUC�K�MÈWUC$de����h$MrQU��Ybk ��k ¬ WUYOkyQ�Y ¬ QL@!C���kedeNeQDM[Q �9F MOK���k QU@eC^h$M[�������pSy��¥rMO��NeC�C$k!h$Ypfe��kez��-±sCfeC$WU��¥[email protected]'C$k!h$Y3f3��k!z���kDQU@eCRk!C�PpQ*KLC�hªQU��Ybk¾³´��CRM[��KLYgN!KaCR�§Q���k.]/P3C�WUh$��KLC��e��E¦oO·ª�± @eC$k.d;YbKUKL���e��CO¨@!Yr�*C�¥OC$Wi¨���Q.��KDzbYpYpf¼QLY M¦¥bYO��f-QU@eC^WLC�de����h�MrQL��YOk(¨�QLYÉ�bC$C$d QL@!C^C$k!h$Ypfe��kez-KL��BDde��C$W.MOk!f¼QL@eC�WLC ¬ YOWUCB'MO�OC¸�§Q�C�MOKL��C$W�QLY'deWUYr¥OC¸deWUYOd;C$WLQL��C�K#Y ¬ QU@eC�C$k�h�Y3f3��kez^³´��@e��hj@^�*CgKL@!M[���(f3YD��k¯QL@e��KcKLC�h�QL��YOk¯M[k!f���k� C�hªQU��Ybk!K¸EOE$�UEimb·�� �

_�k9QU@eC'C$k!h$Y3f3��k!z�Y ¬ ?M[�!��C.x3¨��*CD@!M¦¥bCDYOBD�§QLQLCifÈQTSpd;C.M[kek!Y[QUM[QL��YOk!K��'Ú�C$��Yr� ��KGQL@eC�h$YOBDde��C�QUCC�k!h�Y3f3��kezD��k!h���N!f3��kezDQTSpd�CiK$��?#@!C�QTSpd;C

������� $&%('�O� �0# � P�� ����Y ��� R& ³ � �y·

��K#QU@eC¸QLWjM[k!KL��MrQL��YOk���kyQUY�����h$MO��h$Ne��N!K#Y ¬ QL@eC¸QTSpd;C � � ��k-³ � ny·ª�

� ) ) ������ * * $&%('� # L &K� L�# � �X#��������>& � &K� �># � & � ) ) * *� ) ) ��* * $&%('� # L &K� � P L R

� ) ) � * * $&%('� # L &K�0# ��� � � #�������&�&� � ) ) * * � N � # �>&K�2# � ��� � � #�������& &�# � P ��Y L�R���� � � ) ) � * *K& �

³ � oO·

?#@!C�QUWUMOk!KL��M[QL��YOk�Y ¬ ³ � xb·���kyQLY'����h$MO��h$Ne��N�K#zO��¥OC�K

� Æ3Õ-ÕÉ� % � �/� À;�¦�O�e�¦�$¤ ¬ ¥4#%'& � 7�/Ì�� �3¤�� 7� ��� � #�������&�Y L ��� #�������& ! � ) ) * * �¸Ì±9C�MO��KLYcf3C$WU��¥OCXQU@eC ¬ YO����Yr����kez#QT��YcWUC�KLNe��QUK®MO��YbN3Q(QU@eC�YOd;C$WjMrQU��Ybk!M[�bh�YOWUWUC�hªQUkeC�KUK�Y ¬ QU@eC�C�k!h�Y3f3��kez!º

� Å � Å�Ò´Ò �3�¦à % � � � �eÓÆ�� �(�e�Oà Å � � � ��¤�� ^�*)bÌ�� �p¤$� �� �'� � � ) ) * * � �XÊ!���[© �r��ÁDL�Ì

& � ŮŠ�U� ÛeWUYOB ?#@!C$YOWUC$B �e� me¨bÝ*YOWUYO����M[WUS �!� o3¨[M[k!f � C�BDBDM¸Ç � � ³«MOh�QLN!MO����S�M[k�C�PpQLC�k!KL��Ybk Y ¬ ��Q����§QU@d!WLY3f3N!h�QUK�MOk!f�����keC�MOW#QTSpd�CiK$¨ � CihªQU��Ybk¯Ç � qe� vb·ª� �

� Å � Å�Ò´Ò �3�¦à % � ��� � "e� Ò 6Ó. £~jà Å � ��9 ~ � Æ Å �¦à � Å � � � À;�¦�O�e�¦�$¤ ¬ ¥$#. Y �/&�� 7� �[�;Ã� �¤$��� ������ 7� �� � #���������& � � #��������>&�Ì �´�c��9 ! � � ���3¤�� � ) ) * * �! " � ) ) � * *ªÌ& � ŮŠ�U� ÛeWUYOB ?#@eC$YbWLC�B �!� n�¨ � C�BDBDM�x3��EOEO¨ � C$BDB'M'ÚG� xe¨�MOk!f-³£QU@eC MOdedeWUYOdeWU��M[QLC¸C�PpQUC$k!KL��Ybk^Y ¬ ·� C$BDB'M'Ç�� me� �

]�k!h�Y3f3��kez � ¥rMO����feMrQUC�KRWLNe��C!9¼Y ¬ QL@!C��e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!K��RÚ�S¯h$YOkyQLWjMOKaQ�¨;MOK�]/P3C$Wjh���KaC �!��E¦x'KL@eYr�cK$¨ �

feYyCiK#keY[Qc¥rMO����feMrQUC¸WLNe��C ��¨3k!M[BDC���S

�����0#. ��& � � ¬ ��� ¬ ¥6#.'&�RC$��QL@eC�WGfeYyCiKcQU@eC h�M[���§���pSy��¥rM[��NeC�C�k!h�Y3f3��kez � KUMrQL��K ¬ S����¸?#@eC�KLC ¬ M[����NeWLCiKRB'MO�OC�KLC$k!KLCO¨�MOK��^��KRkeY[QYbd�C�WUM[QL��YOk!MO����S�¥rMO����f¯C$��QL@eC�Wc��kÈh$MO�������pSy��k!M[BDC¸YOWc��k¾h$MO�������ySy��¥rM[��NeC��3��h$MO��h$Ne��N!K�³6KLC$C ]/P3C$Wjh���KaC'EbEO� ny·ª�?#@!C�� WUNe��C���K�YOd;C$WjMrQL��YOk�M[����S�¥rMO����f÷¨y@eYr�*C�¥OC�W�¨r� ¬ ,��K�M¸¥rM[��NeCbÂb��k!f3C�C�f QL@eCRC$k!h$Ypfe��kez f3YpC�KX¥rM[����feMrQUCQU@e��K�WLCiKTQUWL��hªQUC�f ¬ YOWUB�Y ¬ �s³«]/P3C$Wjh���KaC �!��E��b·ª�

â�â54�6!þ87:98;

Page 35: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

m � � Ì(À��[�y¿O�6�r©«¿O�

0�� Æy�r� ´}iÆ % � � � À �p�rͲ���3�r� � ) ) ) * * � �

0�� Æy�r� ´}iÆ % � � � � РŠЮá#"e� Ò 6Ó. £~jà Å ��~ � Æ � � � Ò Æ � À �p�[Í°� �p�r�D� �p¤$©L¤9���9�É�'����¤$©ªµ� ÍX�£��� ���¬ ¥6#%'&G�ª�!� �^���3�r��� � ¬ ¥$#%'& �'@B7��F^�[�;à � ��� �� 7� � � � #������>& � � #���������&(Ê#���3¤�� � ) ) �����0#. ��& * * ��! "

� ) ) * *jÌ � �g�£�!� � �p��¤ � Jp¤�©U�����$¤��[Ì � � Ì �0�� Æy�r� ´}iÆ % � ��% � "e� Ò ´Ó) £~jà Å �c~ � ƾ� Å Ð(Ó) £~� Å Ð�� Ò � � � Ò Æ � �(¤$� � ^� ¶U¤����j�r £  �L¶�Á����;�[µD¤�¢¦�[ ¡�!¤iÌÀ �p�[Í ���3�r��� �:��� ¬ ¥$#��\&G���3¤�� � ) ) �����0#��!��& * * � � ) ) � * *ªÌ0�� Æy�r� ´}iÆ % � � $ � ��� Å Õ��b� Ò´Ò áj|�à�á#"e� Ò ��Æ9~ Å �b� Ò´Ò áj|�à�ájÐ��!ÕÉÆ "3 6�s~ � ��Ð(Ï®}�� � �3¤�»®½�ÀÉ��©L�[�e�´���r©ªµ" � ¿[�£¢r¤����p�'�r�¼¤$�;�j��Ã[�£�y¿s�T�'�j�r £  �L¶�Á����;�[µD¤ �´��� ���£�!���^�j�r £  �L¶�Á���¢¦�[ ¡�!¤ �£� ��.�'�a�U�[ ��$�3 ¡�p�$Ì������r� �p¤$©Í��[Á¾���È�O� �b�6¤$¢r¤����y��� ¿b�i�r *����¶�Á¾µ'¤j�r�e���a� QU@yN!ke�3KiÌ�� ���y�3�eË������'�3�[©L�rµ'¤$��¤$©ª �¤��U�g�;©L�i�U¤jÃ[�3©L¤ �g�£�µ'�rÁ��r  �$�^¶U¤�� �p�[�O¿ �y�c�T� �r���.�j�p���e¤���ÃO¤jÃ��U�[µR�;�3���[�«�6�[�;Ì �!��©L¤T��©L¤��$¤����#���y�3�eËi�UÊ*Í�¤��j�[�s�£���«©L�iÃr�!�j¤�¯�j�r�!�ª�«©ª�!�$���[©�� ���� #%'&��r�;ï�¯ÃO¤��ª�«©ª�!�$���r©� �� � #.'&ªÌ���¤j¤T���£�p¿��£�9µ��£�;Ã�� �p�[��� �p¤$Á�©U¤��;©L¤ª�$¤$�!��e�r©U�rµ'¤���¤�©ª �¤ª�j�G�y¶j�ª��©L�O�$�«�6�[�¾�r�;ÃD�ª�O�� §�6�U�[�«�6�[�eÊ��£�/���c�ª��©L�r�§¿��b� ���r©ªÍ��[©LÃD��� �bÃOÃ�� �p¤$µ����G� � �[�;à �����£�«����a�j�[ ����3 §�p�g¤$�;�j�iÃr�£�y¿ � � ���b¶� �¤ � � ��� �p¤��OÃbÃr�£���6�r�;�[ /�ª�3¤$©L�[�«�6�[�;�r ©ª�3 �¤��g�[©L¤ ��;>= � QP

�� � #.'&M;>=��� �� � #% P & �� �� #�� ���� #.'&5& ;>=��(�[�;Ã.���3¤ �bÃOÃr�£���6�r���r X�� ��r�p�$¤ª�����[© � �[©L¤ �

� ) ) � ���� #%'& * * ������ # L$&K� L # ��&��� � � ) ) * *� ) ) �� � #%'& * * ������ # L$&K� ��� #�� ) ) * *��+N � # ��&� � P L R& ³ � wb·

D¤��j�r�s�;�[Ͳ¤����U�iÃO¤G�����£�!���'� �b����¤JO��¤$�;ÃO¤jÃ�� � � �b�p� �� ) ) � * * ��� �� �� � # ��&

� ) ) ����� * * ��� �� ������� ) ) * *� ) ) � * * ��� �� � ) ) * *.#�� ����� # �/&K&

��� �OÃb¤,�$�!�O�$ÁÈ©U¤ª�ª�3 ¡�«� �p�[ �æ�����[©�� ���3�r�¸���.�ª�£µ �£ ��r©����È���3¤��bÃO¤ �$�!�O�$ÁÉ�a�'���3¤9»(½*À ��©L�[�e�´���r©ªµ " �� � �p¤j�[©L¤�µ��[Ì � �OÌ��¤�� � ¶U¤#� �p¤�¤����U�iÃr�£�p¿��a�/��� �£�!���#���a�j�r ��$�3 ¡�p��ÃO¤ ���;¤jÃg�r� � � �!�y¶ª �¤ ! ��¶ª�3�(ÍX�£�����G©U¤��; ¡�6�j�r���6�r�

�£�s���3¤��$ ��r�p�$¤D�T���y¶j�ª��©L�O�$���6�r� �� ) ) ����� * *���� ��R# L$&� L�# �>&K��� �4# � &�� ) ) * *

½#©L�r¢r¤�� �p�[��� ���O�$���[©ª���$¤ª��� �b©L�[�O¿ �����3¤��b¶U�[¢¦¤�¤����j��Ã[�£�y¿��Ø�r�;Ã�� �T¤KJb��¤���ÃO¤jÃDÍX�£� � � � � �����6Ì£¤iÌ�Ê����[©�[ £ 4^�

� ) ) � ) ) * * * * � � ) ) * *M�±9Cch�Ybk!h���N!f3C*QL@eCcKLC�h�QL��YOk �yS�deWLYr¥p��kez�KLYOBDC#deWUYOd;C$WLQL��C�KY ¬ ��k�KaC�k!Ka��QL��¥p�§QTS¸QUY¸��C�@!M¦¥p��YbNeWUMO�pC�¹yNe��¥b�

MO��C�k!h�CiK ¬ YOW�QL@eCGh$MO�������pSy��k!M[BDC�C$k�h�Y3f3��kez!Ây�*C�Ka@!MO����N!KLCRKaYbBDCcY ¬ QL@!C�KLCRdeWUYOd;C$WLQL��C�KX��k.��MrQUC$W*KLC�h�QL��YOk!K³ � C�h�QL��YOk!K¸EbE��jE�my·ª�?#@eCskeC�PpQ � C$BDB'M KL@eYr� QL@!M[Q � � QTSpd�CiK�M[WUC¾keYOQ�MbhªQLN�M[����S keC�h$C�KUKLMOWLS ��k QL@eC9MOKUKaC�WaQU��Ybk Y ¬

Ý*YbWLYb����M[WUS �!��Eime�g?#@e��KG��KG��ksh�YbkyQLWjMOKaQ�����QL@sQL@eCDh�YbWLWUC�KLd�Ybk!f3��kez.WUC�KLNe��Q ¬ YbWGh�M[���§���pSb��¥rM[��NeCO¨÷KLC$C�H�C��B'MOWL�^x3��E��!��³6?#@eC�WUC�MOKLYOk¯QTSpd;C�KGM[WUC�keC�C�f3Cif ¬ YOW¸h$MO�������pSy��¥¦MO��N!Cg�eN3Q¸keY[Q ¬ YOW¸h$M[�������pSy��k�M[BDCg@!MOKRQLY

�´ó�â����

Page 36: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

���!��¤�©��;©L¤$�«�£�p¿R�j�3�������6�r�!�g�r�#���a�j�[ ����3 §�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª� mOm

feY�����QL@�QL@!CgWLC�de����h$M[QL��YOk�QL@eC�YOWUC$B'K$º ¬ YbW*QU@eCgdeWUYpY ¬ Y ¬ � C�BDBDM'xe��Eiwe¨yQL@eCgKaQLWUYOkez�WUC$de����h�MrQU��Ybk.QL@!C$Y[�WUC$B'KRY ¬ � CihªQL��YOksÚ���EO� �.MOWLC�k!C�h�CiKLKUM[WUSO¨�M[k!f¯QU@eC�KLC�QU@eC$YbWLC�B'KcN!KLC � �.QTSyd;C�K���?#@!C$S¯M[WUC�keC�h$C�KUKLMOWLS�;C�h�M[N!KLCO¨(��[email protected]$WLQL��YOkÈY ¬ � C$BDB'M^x3��E�w.k�M[BDC\�-BDM¦S¾MOded;C�M[W¸��ksYbN3QLd!N3Q�YO�3ZTCihªQ¸d�YyKa��QL��YOk9��k feNeCgQLY�QL@eC�f3C�×�ke�§QU��Ybk¾Y ¬ QU@eC�C�k!h�Y3f3��kez � YOk^¥rM[WU��M[�e��C�K��c?#@eC�KUM[BDC�f3YpCiKRkeYOQR@!MOded�C�k¾��k^QL@eCh�M[���§���pSy��k!MOBDC�C�k!h�Y3f3��kez � ¨e��@e��hj@¯N!KaCiK�MDf3� ��C$WUC$kyQ�QUWUMOk!Ka��MrQU��Ybk�Y ¬ ¥rM[WU��M[�e��C�K�� ·� C�Q(N�K(h$MO��� � � QL@eC�C�k!h�Y3f3��kezc��kyQLY�QU@eC�d!��MO��kgd;YO��SbMbf3��h/����h$MO��h$Ne��N!K$¨¦����QL@eYbN3Q � ��QTSyd;C�K�ÂrYOBD��QaQU��kez

QTSpd;C�K�¨�QL@eC'f3C$×!ke��QL��YOksY ¬ � � ��K�QL@eC'KUM[BDC MbKcQU@!MrQgY ¬ � Â÷QL@eCDf3���;C�WLC�k!h�C���KRQU@!MrQg��k � � CiMOhj@ � �QTSpd;C # ��³ ¬ YOW # �@ � Y ��Y � F¦·���KcWUC$de��MOh$C�f¯�pS�QU@eC���C�KUKc��k ¬ YOWUB'MrQU��¥bC�hj@!M[kek!C$�®QTSpd;C�� ���#±9C�WUC$BD��k�fQU@!MrQG��k¯QU@eC�d!��MO��k^d;YO��SbMbf3��h�����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K���C���WU�§QUC��!M[WU�;C�f^h�YbkezOWUNeC�k!h�C�MbK �! �¨�YbBD�§QLQL��kez.QU@eCgQTSpd�CC�kp¥y��WUYOkeBDC$kyQ���k!f3C�P÷�

� Æ3Õ-ÕÉ� % � � À;�¦�O�e�¦�$¤ ¬ ¥$#. Y �/& � 7�^�r��Ã� �¤�� �������� 7�Q��� � #������>& � � #������>&jÌ � �p¤$� � ) ) * *��! "� ) ) � * *G� � � � ) ) * *��! � � ) ) � * *ªÌ?#@!C�deWLYpY ¬ Y ¬ � C�BDBDM �!��EiwR��KXWjMrQU@eC$W�h$YOBDde��C�P÷ÂOWjMrQU@eC$W/QU@!M[kDzO��¥p��k!zG��Q�¨b�*C���kp¥p�§QUC#QL@eC�WUC�Mbf3C$W/QUY

d!WLYr¥bCRQU@eCg¥rM[WU��MOkbQ�Y ¬ Ý*YOWUYO����M[WUS �!��Eim�����QL@!YON3Q � ��QTSpd;C�K�¨pQL@eWUYON!zO@�QL@eC ¬ Yb����Yr����k!z ¬ YbNeW�C�P3C�WUh$��KLC�K��

0�� Æy�r� ´}iÆ % � � �&À �p�[Í ���3�r�«Ê!���r© �[ £ 4 Y � �� ÍX�£� � ��� ¬ ¥6# �/&LÊ� � ) ) #�������'& � * * �-;6= �� � � ) ) * * � @2� � � � ) ) � * *5F

0�� Æy�r� ´}iÆ % � �2 À �p�[Í ���3�r�«Ê!���r© �[ £ 4 Y � �� ÍX�£� � ��� ¬ ¥6# �/&LÊ� � ) ) * *5@ � � � � ) ) � * *5F � � � ) ) '@BAMC D4F * *M�

� ���£�!� � �;©L���j¤j¤jÃ�¶�Á'�£�;Ã[�!�����6�r�É�r�^ Ê��[�;Ã.�p��¤�� �p¤�©L¤��; ¡�6�j�r���6�r�9���3¤j�r©L¤$µ�����Ì ��� Ì �0�� Æy�r� ´}iÆ % � 3�� Ì ®©L�[µ � �p¤*��Í�����©L¤$¢��6�[�p��¤Jy¤$©L�$���$¤ª�jÊ®�U�[�;�$ ¡�!ÃO¤�� �p�[��� ��U;4= � � � �p¤$� � � ) ) * *��-;4= ��� � � ) ) � * * � Ì

� Ì'» �3¤U��˼� �p�[�'�£�&�£��¤$µ � � �¦Ê.©L¤$ ��r���6�r� � �U�[� ¶L¤9©U¤ ���;¤jà ����� ��� �p¤-¤J��e�r�!�ª�6�r�&©L¤$ ��r���6�r�!Ê ��¤ ���!� ����6�r� �RÌ � �OÌ

0�� Æy�r� ´}iÆ % � / � �$¤ � Jp¤$©L�����$¤��[Ì � � ���¸�;©L�r¢r¤����3�r��� �R��9 ! � ��� �p¤$� � � ) ) * *��! � � ) ) � * *jÌ]XPpC�WUh$��KLC �e� � E¸h$MOk�MO��KLYD��CgN!KLC�f�QLY'zbC�QcMDf3��WLCihªQ�deWUYyY ¬ Y ¬ Ý*YbWLYb����M[WUS��e��E � �?#@!C^C$k!h$Ypfe��kez¼Y ¬ h$M[�������pSy��k�M[BDC^KLM[QL��KT×!CiK.KLYOBDC ¬ NeWLQL@eC�W.deWUYOd;C$WLQL��C�K'Y ¬ ��k!KLC$k!KL�§QU��¥p��QTS¼QUYÉQL@eC

�;C$@�M¦¥y��YON!WUMO�XC�¹yNe��¥¦MO��C�k!h�C.hj@!YbKLC$k ¬ YOWgQU@eC.����h$M[��h�N!��N!K��.±9C�KL@eYr� YbkeC'Y ¬ QL@!C�KLC¾³´��k!KaC�k!KL�§QU��¥p��QTSÈQUYQU@eC'hj@eYO��h�C��;C�QT��C$C$ks�!M[WU�;C�fÈh$YOkezbWLN!C$k!h$C M[k�fÈzbWLYbNek!f^�e��KL��BD����MOWL��QTSe·ª¨�QL@�MrQg�������X�;C N!KLC ¬ N!�X��ksQL@eCKaQLN�f3SÉY ¬#¬ Ne����MO�!KTQUWUMbhªQU��Ybk ¬ YbWgQL@!��K C$k!h$Y3f3��k!z!¨��k � C�hªQU��Ybk!K.EbE��jE�m!��±9C�KaQUMrQUC'QL@!C�WUC�KLNe�§Qi¨���@!YbKLCd!WLYpY ¬ QjM[�OCiKXQU@eCRWUC$BD��k!f3C$W*Y ¬ QL@!C�KLNe�!KLC�hªQU��Ybk®¨pM[k!fD��K�d�M[WLQL��S�h$YOk!f3N�hªQLCif�QL@eWUYON!zO@'C�P3C�WUh$��KLC�Kc³´QL@eCiKaCMOWLCGQUC�hj@eke��h$MO�®M[k!f ¬ M[��WU��S�Mbf3¥rM[k!h$C�f�C�P3C$Wjh���KLC�Kj·ª�

� Å � Å�Ò´Ò �3�¦à % � �� (�[©��r £ 4 Y � ��RÊ��£� �3�r �Ãr�����3�r� � � ) ) * * �! � � ) ) � * *�� � � � ) ) * * � � � ) ) � * *ªÌ� Æ��/Ð. £~� Å Ð % � � �²��©L�i�j¤ª�j� M°�����p����k�KaC�k!Ka��QL��¥OC�Nek!f3C�W#zOWUYONek!f'QLWjM[k!KL�§QU��Ybk!K¸� � M ;>= M P �£µ��� ¡�6¤��M � M P��[�;æÊ�µ'�r©U¤U�[¢¦¤$©jÊ�� �b���#��©U�j�e¤�©ª��Á.���#��©L¤��$¤�©ª¢r¤jÃ.�3��ÃO¤$©c¿[©L�[�3�;Ã.�«©L�[�e�ª�£���6�r�e�$Ì

â�â54�6!þ87:98;

Page 37: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

mOn � Ì(À��[�y¿O�6�r©«¿O�

� Æ3Õ-ÕÉ� % � /� À;�¦�O�e�¦�$¤�� �p�[� M �[�;à S �[©L¤#�;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª���T�¸� �p¤��¦�ªÁr�����y©L�r���r�p�#�3�[ ¡ÁO�OÃ[�6�G���a�j�r ��$�3 ¡�p��[�;à � ! M:Y S�Ì �6� M �[�;à S �r©L¤ � ���£�e�$¤��!�ª�£�«�£¢r¤¯�3�;Ãb¤�©D¿[©U�r�3�;Ã9��©L�[�e�ª�£�«�6�[�e�jÊg���3¤�� M �! S � �M � S�Ì

& � ŮŠ�U� KL�OC$QUhj@�� � k�deWUYph$C�KUKaCiK�Y ¬ QU@eCgMOKLSpk!hj@eWUYOkeYbN!K�����h$MO��h$Ne��N!K$¨pzbWLYbNek!f.�!��KL��B Ne��MrQL��YOk���B�d!����C�K��M[WU��Cif�h$YOkezbWLNeC�k!h�CD³6?#@!C$YOWUC$B­Ú�� ny·��_ ¬ M�deWUYph$C�KUK#� ��K �p����k!KLC$k�Ka��QL��¥OC Nek!f3C�W�zbWLYbNek!f�QLWjM[k�Ka��QL��YOk!K�¨�QL@eC�k ¬ YOWGC�Mbhj@^zOWUYONek!f^MbhªQU��Ybk O QL@eCKLC�Q @&� P � � ���� � P Fy¨yBDY3f3Ne��Y � ¨3��K�×�ke�§QUCO� ��Ka��kez�QL@!��K ¬ MbhªQ�¨�M[k!f�deWUYph$C$Cif3��k!z ��k�M��#M¦S.Ka��BD����M[WQUYGQL@!M[Q�N!KaCif ¬ YbW�hj@!M[WjMOh�QLC�WL��KLM[QL��YOk!K�Y ¬ �!M[WU�;C�f�h�YOk!zOWUNeC$k!h$C*��k�QLC�WLB'K/Y ¬ ��M[�;C$��C�f �e��KL��B�����M[WU�§QTS�³«KaN�hj@MbK#C�MOWL��S'�e��Ka��BD����M[WU�§QTSe·� � M[k!v � ¨!tRÝ � v � ��¨3YOkeCgdeWUYr¥OCiK�QU@eCgYOd!d�YyKa��QLCgf3��WLCihªQU��Ybk®� �

� Æ��/Ð. £~� Å Ð % � *% �°�;�rµ'¤+Q¼���'fe��WUC�h�QL��YOk!MO����k MØ� � Q¼�j�b�3¤j�r©j���j©L¤j¤'�£�HM ¤��£� �p¤$©.�r�� ¡Á��£�-�£�O���3��;©L¤ ��Jp¤ª�jÊ*�[©��r�! §Á'�£�9�r�3�����3�(��©L¤ ��Jp¤��$Ì0�� Æy�r� ´}iÆ�� % � �$ À��¦�b�3�r��¤��g���a�j�[ ����3 §�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�DM°�$�[�«��� �*¤��g���3¤ª�$¤��«Í��g��©L�ª�3¤$©ª���6¤ª� �

� Ì �[ £ b�j©L¤j¤��;�[µD¤��g�a�DM �r©L¤DÃ[�£©L¤j�����6�r���r (�£� M �� Ì ¤j�b�����;�rµ'¤��a�3M­����¤$�£���3¤�©¸ ¡�£��¤U�[©g©L¤j�j¤��;�«�£¢r¤ªÊ*�[©�� ©U¤U�j¤T�����£¢¦¤ �����3�r�����¸� �p¤#�;©L�i�U¤��j�G���¸��Áj�3�y¶ª �¤��p�ª�£�y¿�[�! ¡Á'� �p¤���Áj�3¤������r©g ¡�£��¤U�[©�©L¤j�j¤��;�«�£¢r¤$�;¤��U���[�;Ãc���[©��&©L¤j�j¤��;�«�£¢r¤���¤ª�j�jÊXÀ�¤j�$�«�6�[� ��Ì � Ì � �[Ì

� �3¤�� M ��� � ���£�!�$¤��!�j�£���£¢r¤��3��ÃO¤$©c¿[©L�[�3�;Ã.�«©L�[�e�ª�£���6�r�e�$Ì

0�� Æy�r� ´}iÆ�� % � ½�©L�[¢¦¤#� �p�[� � � ) ) * * ���$�r����� �*¤������3¤ �bÁj�e�r� �p¤��ª���R�T� � Jp¤�©L�$���$¤��[Ì � � Êb���[©c�r £  ��¸Ì»��[�;�$ ¡�!ÃO¤����3¤��s���3�r�G»��r©L�[ £ ��r©ªÁ �[Ì ��� ���g�«©ª�!¤iÌ

� � ���� �r��� �c����� �� ����

?#@!C�f3���;C�WLC�k!h�CiK��;C�QT��C$C�k'QL@eC¸f3C$×!ke��QL��YOk!K*Y ¬ MOdede����h�MrQL��YOk'��k'QU@eC�����h$MO��h$Ne��N!K�C�k!h�Y3f3��kezbK�Y ¬ h�M[���§���pSb�k�M[BDC.M[k!f9h$MO�������ySy��¥rM[��NeC'M[WUC���keC�¥y��QUMO�e��C�FIZTN!KTQ ��Cih$M[N�KaC'M[d!de����h$M[QL��YOkÉ��KgdeWUC�h���KLC$��S¾��@eC$WUC�QL@eCiKaCKaQLWjMrQUC$zb��CiK'f3� ��C$Wi� � keC¾B'M¦S �*Ybk!f3C$Wi¨#@eYr��C$¥OC�W�¨���@eC$QL@eC�W.QL@!Csf3C$×!ke��QL��YOk!K�Y ¬ M[�!KaQLWjMOh�QL��YOk M[k�f¥rMOWL��M[�e��C�k!C$C�f QLYÉf3���;C�WDQLYpY!�-_�k QL@e��KDKaCihªQU��Ybk®¨���C�B'M[�bC�KLYOBDC¯Ka��BDde��C�BDY3f3�§×;h$MrQU��Ybk!K QLYsQL@eCiKaCC�k!h�Y3f3��kezyKQLYgYO�eQUM[��kDkeC$� YOk!C�KQL@�MrQGÃ[� �R¤�©G�r�! §Á���k�QL@eC�f3C�×!k!�§QU��Ybk!KXY ¬ M[d!de����h$M[QL��YOk®��±sC�Ka@!MO���pQU@eC$kKL@eYr� QL@!M[Q�Y[QU@eC$W ¬ YOWUBDK�Y ¬ M[ded!����h$M[QL��YOk®¨[email protected]�h$MO�������pSy��keC$Cif MOdede����h�MrQL��YOk(¨bh$MOk'��CRC�MOKL����S�f3C�×!k!C�f÷�

��M¦¥y��kez�M.Neke� ¬ YOWUB C�k!h�Y3f3��kez ¬ YbW�M�¥¦MOWL��C�QTS�Y ¬ KaQLWjMrQUC$zO��C�KcBDMO�OCiKc��Q�C�MbKa��C$WcQLY�h$YOBDd!MOWLC¸QU@eC$B¯�_�QGM[��KaY ¬ MOh$������QUMrQUC�K#QUWUMOk!KL��M[QL��YOk�QLY.����h$MO��h$Ne��N�K#Y ¬ deWUYOzOWjM[BDBD��kez ��M[k!zON!MOzOC�K*QU@!MrQRC�BDde��YrS�f3���;C�WLC�kbQKaQLWjMrQUC$zb��CiK ¬ YbW�C$¥rM[��N!M[QL��kez'M[WUzONeBDC$kyQjK*Y ¬(¬ Nek�hªQL��YOk�K$�±9C^YO�3QjM[��k QU@eC^keC$�­C$k!h$Y3f3��k!zbKDM[zyM[��k¼�pS zOYb��k!z¾QL@!WLYbNezO@ M-Ý�V � QUWUMOk!K ¬ YOWUB�¨*M[k ��krZTCihªQU��Ybk

��kyQLY � � �X¨�M[k!f�QL@eCgh$YOBDde����M[QL��YOk�Y ¬ � � �s��kyQLYD����h$M[��h�N!��N!K��/±sCg�;C$zb��k¯����QL@�QL@eC Ý�V � QUWUMOk!K ¬ YOWUB��� QUM[WLQL��kez ¬ WUYOB­QL@!C h$MO�������ySy��¥rM[��NeC�M[k!fÈh$M[�������pSy��k�M[BDC¸QLWjM[k!K ¬ YOWUB'K�C�PeMOB���keCif¯��k^QU@eC�d!WLC�¥y��YON�KRKLC�hª�QU��Ybk!K�³«?�MO�e��C�K � M[k!f^np·ª¨;�§QG��KRC�MbKaS�QLY.zb��¥bC�M�Ý�V � QLWjM[k!K ¬ YOWUB�QU@!MrQG��K �3�!� ���[©ªµ ¬ YbW�h$MO�������ySy��¥rM[��NeCMOk!f'h$MO�������ySy��k!M[BDCb¨O��kDQL@!M[Q*��Q*@!MbKXQL@!C�KUM[BDCRh���M[N�KaCiK ¬ YOW�M[�!KaQLWjMOh�QL��YOk'M[k�fD¥¦MOWL��M[�!��CiK$�/?#@eCRh�M[���§���pSb�¥rMO��NeCcMOk!f'h$MO�������ySy��k!M[BDCcÝ�V � @!M¦¥bC�QL@eCRKUM[BDCch$��MON!KaC ¬ YbW�M[��KTQUWUMbhªQL��YOk�K$ÂrQUYgYO�3QjM[��k.M¸Neke� ¬ YOWUBÖÝ�V ���Q�KLN��.h�C�KgQLY^MOf3Ybd3QgQL@!C.h$M[�������pSy��k�M[BDC'Ý�V � ¨�MOk!f9B�Y3f3� ¬ S¾[email protected]$×!ke��QL��YOk-Y ¬ M[d!de����h$M[QL��YOk9Y ¬ QL@eCh�M[���§���pSy��¥rM[��NeC�Ý�V � QUY�h$YOBDd�C�k!KUMrQLC ¬ YOW�QL@!CDfe� ��C$WUC$kyQgh���M[N!KLC�K ¬ YOW¸¥rM[WU��MO�e��C�K��D³6±sC'h�M[kekeYOQGMbf3YOd3Q

�´ó�â����

Page 38: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

���!��¤�©��;©L¤$�«�£�p¿R�j�3�������6�r�!�g�r�#���a�j�[ ����3 §�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª� mbx

���È� �b���g���b¶� �¤�Í�¤��b¶i¶�©L¤�¢i�6�r��¤�"�� ) ) * *��r� ) ) * * �) ) ��* * $&%('� � �$�5���

) ) ������ * * $&%('� � �$� �6#������ ) ) * *.&�j�r £  �L¶�Á����;�[µD¤��j�b�� ¡�6�j�[�«�6�[� �) ) � * * $&%('� � �$� ) ) * *%#����>� � ) ) � * *#�6&�j�r £  �L¶�Á���¢r�r ¡�!¤D�j�b�� ¡�6�j�[�«�6�[� �) ) � * * $&%('� � �$� ) ) * *%#����>� ) ) � * *%#���� � �4#����6� �$� & �6&5&

?�MO�e��C �!ºXt Neke� ¬ YOWUB Ý�V � QLWjM[k�K ¬ YbWLB

QU@eC feC�×!ke��QL��YOk^Y ¬ ¥¦MOWL��M[�!��CiK�Y ¬ QU@eC�h$MO�������ySy��¥rM[��NeC Ý�V � QLWjM[k�K ¬ YbWLB­��Cih$M[N�KaC���QRQUWLCiMrQjK�¥rM[WU��MO�e��CiKcMOK¥rMO��NeCiK$¨eMOk!f�QL@e��K���K�h�YbWLWUC�h�Q�Ybke��S���@eC$k¯¥rM[WU��MO�e��C�K#M[WUCgM[����M¦S3K#KaN!�!KTQU�§QUN3QLCif��yS�¥¦MO��N!C�K�� ·?#@!C�Neke� ¬ YOWUB&Ý�V � QLWjM[k!K ¬ YOWUB²��K�zO��¥OC$k¸��k�?M[�e��C �e��?#@eC*MbKLKLY3h���MrQLCifGzOWjM[BDB'M[Wi¨$��@e��hj@g��K�Ka��BD����M[W

QUY�QU@!MrQ ¬ YbW�QU@eCgh$M[�������pSy��k�M[BDCGÝ�V � QLWjM[k!K ¬ YOWUBÖ�eN3Q���MOhj�3K�QU@eC¸h�YOk�KTQUWUMO��kyQ*Ybk�����k!C�M[W#Y3h$h$NeWUWLC�k!h�CcY ¬¥rMO��NeCg¥rMOWL��M[�e��C�K�¨p��K�QU@e��K$º

h�YbkbQU��kpN!M[QL��YOk�¥rM[WU��MO�e��C �YbWUf3��k!MOWLS'¥rM[WU��M[�e��C�K ��Y2]0]2]¥rM[��NeCg¥rM[WU��M[�e��C�K �4Y � Y2]0]0]

MOk!KL�*C�WUK M � � � � � � � � � � �Ý�V � ��¥¦MO��N!C�K � � � �����U���6� M � �

h�YOkyQU��kpN!M[QL��YOk!K � � � � �D���>�,MdeWL��k!h$��d!MO��QLC�WLB'K � � � � �$� M � �

³ � vy·

?#@!C#QTSyd;C�K/Y ¬ QU@eC�keYbk3�«QUC$WUBD��k!MO��K/Y ¬ QU@eC�zOWjM[BDB'M[WXMOWLC*QL@eC�KLMOB�C�MbKQL@eYyKaC#Y ¬ QL@!Cch$M[�������pSy��k�M[BDCÝ�V � QLWjM[k!K ¬ YOWUB¯��± ��QL@9QU@eC'N!KLN!M[����krZTCihªQL��YOkÉYbkÈQUC$WUBDK�M[k!fsYOk9QTSpd�CiK$¨(QL@eCDQUC$WUB'K¸zOC$k!C$WjMrQLCifÈ�pSQU@e��KczOWjM[BDB'M[WcMOk!f�QL@!C$��WcQTSpd�CiKc�;C�h$YOBDC�M.KLNe�e��M[kezbN!M[zbCGY ¬ � � �X��tcded!��Sp��kez'QL@!C�h�YbB�d!����MrQU��Ybk�Y ¬� � � ��kyQLY^����h$MO��h$Ne��N�K¸�*C'Yb�3QUMO��ksQL@eC'C�k!h�Y3f3��kez^zb��¥bC$k9��k-?M[�e��C�op�'_�k9QL@!��K¸QjM[�e��CO¨(QL@eC�WLC'��K�MO��KLYQU@eC�h$Y3f3C ¬ YOW�QL@eC�h$M[�������pSy��k!C$C�fDMOdede����h�MrQL��YOk(��±9CRdeWUC�KLC$kyQ*h�M[���§���pSy��keC�C�f�f3��WLCihªQL��S�YOkDQL@!CR����h$M[��h�N!��N!KF ����QL@!YON3QgzOYb��k!z.QL@!WLYbNezO@ � � �-F �;C�h�M[N!KLCO¨®MbK�C$P3de��MO��k!C�f¾��k � C�h�QL��YOkÉme� me¨÷h$MO�������pSy��keC$Cif^��KgMOk��BDde��C$BDC$kyQUM[QL��YOk¯QUC�hj@eke��¹yNeC�����QL@^C$Ppd!����h���QRC$kp¥p��WLYbkeBDC$kyQc��k^��@!��hj@�9÷��WUC�f3N!h�QL��YOk^f3YpC�KRkeY[Q�WLCi¹bN!��WUCKLNe�!KaQL��QLNeQL��kez.M�QLC�WLB ¬ YbWcMD¥rM[WU��MO�e��CG�eN3QXZTN�KTQ�KLNe�!KaQL��QLNeQL��kez.M�WLC ¬ C$WUC$k!h$C�QUY'M�QUC$WUB ¬ YbWcM ¥rMOWL��M[�e��CO�?#@!C$WUC ¬ YOWUC ¬ YOW¸QL@!C'C$k!h$Ypfe��kez¯Y ¬ h$MO�������ySy��keC$Cif^QU@eCDdeWLY3h$C�KUKT��d!MOKUKL��kez ¬ C�M[QLNeWUC�K¸Y ¬ � � � M[WUCDkeY[Q�KLY@!C$��d ¬ Ne���±9C.C$Ppd!��MO��kÉ[email protected]$k�h�Y3f3��kez^Y ¬ M¾h�M[���§���pSb��keC�C�f9M[dede����h$MrQU��Ybk �-�¯± @eC$k�� ) ) * *��D�;C�h$YOBDC�K M

¬ N!k!hªQU��Ybk9��Q�Ka��zOk�M[��KGKLY�YOk � ¨(M[k!fÈWLCih�C���¥bC�K¸M�d;YO��kyQLC�W �sQUY�QL@eC'M[WUzON!B�C�kyQ � QLYbzOC�QU@eC$W¸����QL@sQL@eC��Y3h$M[QL��YOk+L ¬ YOWXQU@eCckeC$PpQ���kyQLC�WUMbhªQU��Ybk®���RYr�¼QU@eC�C$¥rMO��N!M[QL��YOkDY ¬ Ih�YOkyQU��kpNeCiK$�± @eC$kDQU@eCRMOWLzbNeBDC$kyQ� ��K'keC�C�f3Cif ¬ YOW'QU@eC^×!WjKaQ'QL��B�Cb¨cMÉWLCi¹yNeC�KaQ.��K.BDMbf3C¾Ybk ��� ?#@!C$k�� ) ) � * *�^��K'C$¥rMO��N!M[QLCif M[k!f÷¨

â�â54�6!þ87:98;

Page 39: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

m � � Ì(À��[�y¿O�6�r©«¿O�

� ) ) ����� * * $ %('� # L$&� L # ��&��� �># � & � ) ) * *� ) ) � * * $ %('� # L$&� � P L�R

�U�[ £  �L¶�Á���¢¦�[ ¡�!¤D�j�O�; ¡�6�j�r���6�r� �� ) ) � * * $ %('� # L$&�0# ��� & � � ) ) * *��+N � # ��&� �*� # � ) ) � * * N� # � &K� � � � P ��Y L�R���� ��# � P.&� � P P � R�& ��U�[ £  �L¶�Á����;�rµ'¤��j�O�; ¡�6�j�r���6�r� �� ) ) � * * $ %('� # L$&�0# ��� & � � ) ) * *��+N � # ��&� � � � P ��Y L�R���� � � ) ) � * * ��U�[ £  �L¶�Á����;¤j¤jÃ��j�b�� ¡�6�j�[�«�6�[� �� ) ) � * * $ %('�# L$&�0# ��� & � � ) ) * *��+N � # ��&� � � � P ��Y L R��5��# � &K� � � P�# � ) ) � * *�� � N

� P.# � &�0# � P � RDN � ��# � P.&K� � P P � R&K& �?�MO�e��C�o3º�?#@eC¸Neke� ¬ YOWUB°C$k�h�Y3f3��kezDY ¬ h�M[���§���pSy��k!MOBDCO¨3h$MO�������pSy��¥¦MO��N!CO¨3h$MO�������pSy��keC$Cif

��@!C$kÉ�§Q ��Cih�YOBDCiK�M¯¥rM[��NeCO¨/M¯d�Yb��kyQUC$WgQUY^QL@e��Kg¥rM[��NeC.��k!KaQUMOkbQU��M[QLCiK ���^?#@e��K�d�Yb��kyQLC�W���KgWLC$QLNeWUkeCifQUYÈQU@eC�deWLY3h$C�KUK�QU@!MrQDWLCi¹yNeC�KaQLCif��-�-± @eC�k ¬ NeWLQL@eC�WDWLCi¹bN!C�KaQUK ¬ YOW��,M[WUC�B'Mbf3CO¨XQU@eC¯d�Yb��kyQUC$W���KWUC�QUNeWUkeC�fÈ��BDBDC�f3��MrQUC$��SO�'?#@pN!K�¨®�pSÈh�YbkbQUWUMbKTQG���§QU@-h$M[�������pSy��k�M[BDCO¨÷��k9h�M[���§���pSy��keC�C�f¾QL@eC'M[WUzON!B�C�kyQ� Y ¬ QL@eCGM[ded!����h$M[QL��YOk'��K�C�¥¦MO��N�MrQLCifDYOk!h$CO�X?�Y�M[ded!WLCih���MrQLCcQL@e��K$¨bQL@!CRWUC�MOfeC$W�BD��zO@yQ������bCcQUY�h�YbB�d�M[WUCQU@eC�WLCif3N!hªQU��Ybk!K�Y ¬ QL@!C C�k!h�Y3f3��kezbK�Y ¬ #����5����&K# # #>&L¨���k9h$M[�������pSy��k�M[BDC�M[k�f^��k9h$MO�������pSy��keC$Cif÷��_�kÈQL@eC¬ YbWLBDC�W�¨�#�#.��KcC$¥rM[��N!MrQUC�f�QT����h$CO¨3��k�QL@eCg��MrQLQLC$W�Ybk!h�Cb�_�Q���K�keY[Q��pS hj@!MOk!h�C¾QL@!M[Q�QL@!Csh$MO�������ySy��keC$Cif C$k!h$Ypfe��kez¼��K���CiKTQ¯f3C$WU��¥OC�f ¬ WUYOB QL@!CÈNeke� ¬ YOWUB

C�k!h�Y3f3��kez�Y ¬ ?M[�e��CDo3¨���Cih$M[N�KaCDh$MO�������pSy��keC$Cif^h�YOB �e��keC�K�C$��C$BDC$kyQjKRY ¬ QL@eCDh$MO�������ySy��k!M[BDC�MOk!fÈh�M[���§��pSy��¥¦MO��N!C�KTQUWUM[QLC�zO��C�K���_�k�f3C$Cif^�§Q¸h$MOk¾��C�f3C�×�keC�f¾MbKRh�M[���§���pSb��k!MOB�Cgd!��N!K�Ka@�M[WU��kez�¨!�eNeQ¸h�M[k¾M[��KLY.��CKLC$C�k MOK M¾¥rM[WU��MOkyQ�Y ¬ h$MO�������ySy��¥rM[��NeC'��@eC$WUC'QU@eC�MOWLzbNeBDC$kyQ�Y ¬ MOk¼M[ded!����h$M[QL��YOk-��K�C$¥rMO��N!M[QLCif MrQ Mfe� ��C$WUC$kyQ�d�Yb��kyQi�±9C*f3YRkeY[Q(d!WLYr¥bC�QU@eC*h$YOWUWLCihªQUkeC�KUK�Y ¬ QL@!C�h$MO�������pSy��keC$Cif�C�k!h�Y3f3��kez�¨ ¬ YbW(��Q(�*YbNe��f¸WLCi¹bN!��WUC ¬ YOWUB'M[����S

��kyQLWUY3f3N!h���kez�QL@eCgh$MO�������ySy��keC$Cif.KLSpKaQLC�B¯� � C$C�QL@eC¸keYOQLC�K�Y ¬ � C�h�QL��YOksE$n ¬ YOW#WLC ¬ C$WUC$k!h$C�K�¨yMOk!f�KLC$C¸M[��KLY]XPpC�WUh$��KLC�op� me�

0�� Æy�r� ´}iÆ $ � � �RÃbÃ'��Áj�3¤D�[�!�;�[���[�«�6�[�e�����r©  ��i�U�[ (���rµ'¤ª�g���.� �p¤�¤����j��Ã[�£�y¿[���£� ���b¶� �¤ � Ì �p�[�#�[©L¤� �p¤'�«Áj�e¤ª�.�T��� �p¤R�j©L¤j¤'�;�[µD¤����¼À �p�rÍ � �p�[�c���3¤ª�$¤.�«Áj�e¤ª�.�r©U¤��j�r©ª©L¤j�$�6Ê�¶�Á���©L�[¢��£�p¿¾� �p¤.�ª�O�;©L�j�;©ª�6�r��¤��Áj�e¤��ª�!Ã�¿b¤$µD¤$�!�«���r�9¤$�;�j�iÃr�£�p¿r� �a�c�3����¤�©ªµ �$Ì

Æ3ÕÉ�3�¦Ï $ � VXWLYr¥p��kez¾deWUYOd;C$WLQL��C�K�Y ¬ QU@eC�C�k!h�Y3f3��kezbK�Y ¬ h�M[���§���pSb��¥rM[��NeC��e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�M[k!f-h�M[���§���pSb�k!C$C�f���k^?�MO�e��C�o�³ ¬ YOW���k!KTQjM[k!h$CO¨e��k^h$MO�������pSy��¥¦MO��N!CO¨yQL@eCg¥rMO����f3��QTS�Y ¬ 9 �¸WUC�f3N!h�QL��YOk�·*B'M¦S.WUC�¹yNe��WLC � �QTSpd;C�K�� � � QTSpd�CiK�B'M¦S'��C�M¦¥bYO��f3C�f��yS�MOf3Ybd3QL��kez�QL@!CGBDY3f3��×�h$M[QL��YOk!K#d!WLYbd�YyKaCif���k^]/P3C$Wjh���KaC�op� me�

0�� Æy�r� ´}iÆ $ � � �(¤$� ����¶L¤����3¤c¤����j��Ã[�£�y¿��a���j�r £  �L¶ªÁ���¢r�r ¡�!¤��¦��ÃO¤ ���;¤jÃG�£� ���b¶� �¤ � ÍX�£� ��� �p¤c¤Jp�U¤T�����6�r�

� �p�[�*�£�9� �p¤D�� ��r�p�$¤����r©��ª�O�; ¡�6�j�r���6�r�-� �p¤  ��¦�ª�c�r�3�����3� � P P � R�����©L¤T�� ��b�j¤Uï¶�Á � P # ��P &K��� �GP� � ��Í��p¤$©L¤

�´ó�â����

Page 40: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

���!��¤�©��;©L¤$�«�£�p¿R�j�3�������6�r�!�g�r�#���a�j�[ ����3 §�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª� myo

� ) ) ����� * * $&%('� # L &K� L # ��&�� ) ) * *� ) ) � * * $&%('� # L &K� �CP L�R

� ) ) � * * $&%('� # L &K� ��� #�� ) ) * *��+N � � � P ��Y L�R���� ��� ) ) � * *5&?M[�e��Cgweº�tck¯Ybd3QL��BD��KLC�f�C$k�h�Y3f3��kezDY ¬ ���

�GP� � ���R� ����ke�;Ê(À÷¤U�$���6�r����Ì � Ì ! �OÌcÀ;�£µ �£ ��r©ª ¡Á¦Ê/ �¤$� � ���� ¶U¤R���3¤G¤$�;�j�iÃr�£�p¿ �a���j�r £  �L¶�Á����;¤j¤jÃ��¦�RÃO¤ ����¤UÃ�£� ���b¶� �¤ � ÍX�£� �����3¤�¤KJp�j¤T�����6�r�'� �p�r�÷�£�D� �p¤c�$ ��[�p��¤����[©#�ª�O�; ¡�6�j�r���6�r��� �p¤� ��¦�ª���r�3�����3� � P P � R*����©L¤T�� ��b�U¤jö�Á � P # ��P.&��� ��P� � Ì ��£�;�r £ §Á¦Ê* �¤$� � � ¶U¤����3¤ ¤$�;�j�iÃr�£�y¿��T� �U�[ £  �L¶�Á����;�rµ'¤ �£�¾� �p¤����[µD¤����b¶� �¤�Ì

���¦Ë[¤c�#�'����¤$©ªµ �£�!�j�6Ãb¤�Í��y�6��� �[ £ !�j�O�; ¡�6�j�r���6�r�!� �3�r¢r¤�� �p¤����r©ªµ ��#������+X& ���6Ì£¤�Ì�Ê����3¤��r©«¿O�3µD¤$�!������[�9�b¶ª�ª�«©U�O�$�«�6�[� �OÌRÀ �p�[Í � �p�r�

� ��) ) * * � � � ) ) * * � � ���� ) ) * * �

� � .� , ����¸� $����� � �¼�8��� ����"�"U��� ����������Ø�c����� �� ����

±9CRk!Yr� C$P3MOBD��keC�M¸d�YyKLKL���!��CcYbd3QL��BD��KUMrQU��YbkDY ¬ QL@eC�C$k!h$Y3f3��k!z � Y ¬ ��� ��kyQLY�����h$MO��h$Ne��N!Kc³6?M[�!��C�xb·ª�Ý*Ybk!KL��f3C�W÷QL@!C�C$k!h$Y3f3��k!z�Y ¬ M[�!KaQLWjMOh�QL��YOkG��k¸QU@!MrQ(QUM[�!��Cb��?#@eC�k�M[BDC ��KLC$kyQ®¥p��M Lg��K(��BDBDC�fe��M[QLC$��SRN�KaCif��ksMOk^��k!deN3Q��gÇ�N!M[����SO¨���k¾QL@eCDf3C�×�ke�§QU��Ybk¾Y ¬ MOdede����h�MrQU��Ybk^QL@eC k!M[BDC WLCih�C$��¥OCif^MrQ � ��K���BDBDC�fe��M[QLC$��SN�KaCif ��k YON3QUdeN3Qi� ±9CÉh$M[k h�YOBDdeWUC�KUK'QU@eCsQT�*Y¼h$YOBDB�N!ke��h�MrQU��Ybk!K���kyQLY M¼KL��kezb��CsYOkeCs��@eC$WUCsMOkMO�!KaQLWjMOhªQU��YbkDN!KaCiKX��QUK���Y3h$M[QL��YOkD��k'��kedeNeQ���?#@eCcWUC�KLNe��QL��kezgYOdeQL��B���KLC�fDC$k�h�Y3f3��kezg��K*Ka@!Yr��k���k.?M[�e��CRwe�?#@!��KG��KRQU@eC'Ka��BDde��C�KaQGC�k!h�Y3f3��kez�Y ¬ QU@eCD�e��h$M[��h�N!��N!KG��kyQLY�����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K��*CDM[WUC M¦�#M[WUC�Y ¬ ��³´_�Qg��K¸MO��KLY\^����keC$W � K#YOWU��zb��k!MO��C$k!h$Ypfe��kez'Y ¬ QU@eC��3��h$MO��h$Ne��N!K#��kyQUY�����h$MO��h$Ne��N!K \^����veE ��� ·?#@!C�YOd3QU��BD��KLM[QL��YOk ¬ WUYOB ��@e��hj@gQL@eC*keC$�ÉC�k!h�Y3f3��kezR��K®Yb�3QUMO��k!C�f¸��K(¥rM[����f¸��kgQU@eC*KaQUMOk!feMOWUf¸KLC$B'M[k3�

QU��h�KXY ¬ QU@eC�����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�ÂO�eNeQ��§Q���KXkeYOQ�¥rM[����fD��k'M[k¾�¦�ªÁr�;� �b©U�r�;�[�p�RKaC�B'M[kyQL��h$K��(_�k!feC$C�f®¨[QL@!CcC$k!h$Y3f3��k!z��K�keY[Q�¹yNe��QLC¸KLM[QL��K ¬ MbhªQLYbWLS�����QL@�WUC�KLd;C�hªQ*QLYDMOKLSpk!hj@eWUYOkeYbN!K�KLC$B'M[kyQL��h$K�KLN!hj@�MOK�MOKLSpk!hj@eWUYOkeYbN!KXB N!KTQQUC�KaQL��kez-YOWDQTSpd;C�f MOKLSpk!hj@eWUYOkeYbN!K �!M[WU��Cif h$YOkezbWLN!C$k!h$CO� ÛeYbW'��k!KaQUMOk!h�Cb¨�QU@eC�KLC¾KLC$B'M[kyQL��h$KDCi¹yN!MrQUCd!WLY3h�CiKLKLC�K � ) ) ����� ) * * �DMOk!f � ) ) ) * *��3¨e�!N3QG����� ) MOk!f ) MOWLCgk!Y[Qc�;C$@!M¦¥p��YONeWjM[����S'Ci¹yNe��¥rMO��C�kbQ���k¾���³´QLCihj@eke��h$M[����S�KLd�CiM[�p��k!z!¨e����QL@�QL@!C�KLC�KaC�B'M[kyQL��h$K�QU@eCgC$k!h$Y3f3��k!z'��K�k!Y[Q�KLYONek�f!·ª��Ú�C�@!M¦¥p��YbNeWUMO��C�¹yNe��¥b�MO��C�k!h�C¸��k¾��� �������®�;C�f3��KLh$N!KUKaCif���k � C�h�QL��YOk9EOEO�_�k KLNeBDB'M[WUSO¨([email protected]�k!h�Y3f3��kez^Y ¬ ?M[�!��C.w¯��K�M[QaQLWjMOh�QL��¥OCD�;C�h$MON!KLC.�§Q ��K¸QU@eC�KL@eYOWLQLCiKTQ�Y ¬ M[���XQL@eC

�e��h$M[��h�N!��N!K¸C�k!h�Y3f3��kezyK¸deWLCiKaC�kyQLC�f®¨®�eN3Q���Qg��Kg��C�KUK¸WUYO�eN!KaQGQL@!MOksQU@eCDC$k!h$Y3f3��k!z�Y ¬ ?M[�!��C.x3�D_�ksQL@eCWUC$B'MO��k!feC$W�Y ¬ QL@eC�hj@�M[d3QUC$W���C¸KL@!MO���÷deWUC ¬ C�W#QL@eCgBDYbWLC¸WUYO�eN!KaQ�C$k!h$Y3f3��k!z!�

tRk Ybd3QL��BD��KUMrQU��Ybk Y ¬ QU@eC¯C$k!h$Ypfe��kez � ³6MOk!f¼Y ¬ QU@eC^Y[QU@eC$W'h$MO�������ySy��k!M[BDC�C$k!h$Ypfe��kezyKD��k QL@!��KKLC�h�QL��YOk¼MOk!f-��k � CihªQL��YOk o[·g��K d�YyKLKL���!��C�N!Ka��kezÈQTSyd;C�K��s?#@!C�f3C$×!ke��QL��YOk Y ¬ M[dede����h$MrQU��Ybk ��@eC�k-QL@eCMOWLzbNeBDC$kyQ���K�M�¥rM[WU��M[�e��C¸��K�¨3��k�h���N!f3��kezDQTSpd�C�MOkekeY[QjMrQU��Ybk!K$º

� ) ) � * * $&%('� # L &K�/# ��� � � �������&� � ) ) * * � N � # ��&�0# � ��� � � �������&�# ��P ��Y L�R���� ��# � &K� ��P � R�& �

â�â54�6!þ87:98;

Page 41: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

mbw � Ì(À��[�y¿O�6�r©«¿O�

Û!WLYbB QU@eC�QTSpd�C � ��������Y ¬ � �§Q ¬ YO����Yr�cK/QU@!MrQ ����KXN!KLC�fD��kDQL@eCc�;Y3f3S����§QU@DQTSyd;C�������!�X?#@eC�f3C�×!k!�§QU��YbkY ¬ ������¼KL@eYr�cKDQU@!MrQ�YOke��S QU@eC¾YONeQLdeN3Q�h$M[d�M[�e������QTS¼Y ¬ k!M[BDC�K.BDM¦S ��Csh�YOBDB Neke��h$MrQUC�f M[��YOk!z ���?#@!C$WUC ¬ YOWUCc� ¬ ��C�h�Ybk3×!keC�YONeWjKLC$��¥OC�KXQLY QL@eC¸MOKLSpk!hj@eWUYOkeYbN!K/����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�¨yQL@eC�k���C�h$MOk�M[d!de��S�QU@eC���M¦�Y ¬ � C$BDB'M'Ú���E � ¨3M[k!f�YOdeQL��B���KLC�QU@eC�M[�;Yr¥OC¸h���M[N�KaCGQLY

� ) ) � * * $ %('� # L$&K�2# ��� � � �������& � � ) ) * * � N � # �>&K� � P �6Y L R � ³«mOqb·

?#@e��K¸YOdeQL��B���KUMrQL��YOkÈ��KgM�N!KaC ¬ Ne�XYOk!CO¨÷�;C�h$MON!KLC�QU@eC'M[ded;C�MOWUMOk!h�C�Y ¬ ¥rM[WU��MO�e��C�KGMOK¸M[WUzONeBDC�kbQjKRY ¬MOdede����h�MrQU��Ybk!K®��K(WjMrQU@eC$W ¬ WUC�¹yNeC$kyQi�(_�Q���K�QL@eC�M[k!MO��YbzONeC�Y ¬ Mc¥bC$WUSGh$YOBDBDYOkgQjM[���§��h$MO�����������OC�Ybd3QL��BD��KUMrQU��YbkY ¬(¬ Nek�hªQL��YOk�M[�®��M[kezbN!M[zbC�K��

� � ���*� �¯ $��� �8����� �/��"��?#@!C Ybke��S¯WUNe��C Y ¬ QL@eC'��9¼QU@eC$YbWLS^KLY ¬ MOWRQUY[QUMO����S^keC�zO��C�hªQUC�fÈ��KRQL@eC 1 WUNe��CO¨ ¬ YbW�C�¥¦MO��N�MrQL��kez�Nek!f3C�Wa�k!C�MrQU@'QL@!CG�(��?#@e��K�WLN!��C���K*keYOWUB'M[����SDf3��KLMO����Yr��C�f���k���BDde��C$BDC$kyQjMrQL��YOk�Y ¬ deWUYOzbWUMOB�BD��kezg��M[kezbN!M[zbC�K���RC$¥bC$WLQL@eC���CiKLK�¨b��Q#��K���kbQUC$WUC�KaQL��kez�QUY KLC$CG@eYr� QL@!C 1 WUNe��C�h�M[k.�;C¸C$k!h$YpfeC�f÷¨ ¬ YOW#MrQ#��C�MOKaQ�QT��Y�WUC�MbKaYbk!K��Û��WUKaQ�¨��§Q���K�M�QLC�KaQRY ¬ C$P3deWLCiKLKL��¥OC$k!C�KUK ¬ YbW�QL@!C�deWUY3h�C�KUK�h$MO��h$Ne��N!K$� � Cih�YOk�f3��Sb¨�h$C$WLQUM[��k¯YOd3QU��BD��KLM[QL��YOk!KY ¬ h�YbBDde����C$WjKGY ¬ deWLYbzOWjM[BDBD��k!z.��MOkezON�M[zOCiK�MbhªQ¸YOkÈQL@eCD�;YpfeS¾Y ¬*¬ Nek!hªQU��Ybk!KgM[k�f¾@!M¦¥bC�KL��BD����MOWL��QL��C�K����QL@�QU@eC 1 WUNe��CO�_�k¯QU@e��K�KaCihªQU��Ybk^�*C�KL@eYr� @eYr�²QUY�MOf!f�QL@eC 1 WUNe��C¸QLY'QU@eC�h$MO�������ySy��k!M[BDC¸C$k�h�Y3f3��kezbK���t�f!f3��k!z 1

QUY'QL@!C h$MO�������ySy��¥rM[��NeC�M[k!f^h�M[���§���pSy��keC�C�f�C$k�h�Y3f3��kezbKR��KRB�N!hj@^@!MOWUfeC$WiÂ!��C�C�P3de��M[��k¾��@pS�M[QcQL@!C�C$k�fY ¬ QU@eC�KLC�h�QL��YOk®��±sC Ka@!MO���(�*YbWL�.��k¯QL@!C�����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�Ybke��S;º��*Cg@!M¦¥bCgzbMO��keCif�C�keYON!zO@¯C�P3d;C$WU��C�k!h�Cg�pSk!Yr� ����QL@^C�k!h�Y3f3��kezbKcY ¬ QL@eC��3��h$MO��h$Ne��N�K���k¾QL@eC�d!WLC�¥y��YON�K�KaCihªQL��YOk�KcKaYDQU@!MrQ��§QG��K�k!Y[QRkeCih�CiKLKUM[WUS'QLYzbY�QU@eWUYONezb@ � � � M[zyM[��k®��?#@eC'KaQLWjMrQLC�zOS^f3C$×!keC�fs�pS^QL@!C�WUNe��C�KGY ¬ h$MO�������pSy��k!M[BDC�d!��N!K 1 ��K¸h�M[����Cif�ª��©L�r�p¿��j�r £  �L¶ªÁ������rµ'¤��±9CRYb�3QUMO��k.MOk'C$k!h$Ypfe��kez�Y ¬ KaQLWUYOkez�h�M[���§���pSb��k!MOB�C��pS�BDYpfe� ¬ Sp��kezgQL@!C�f3C$×!ke��QL��YOk.Y ¬ MO�!KaQLWjMOhªQU��Ybk

��k�QL@eC�h�M[���§���pSy��k!MOBDCRC$k�h�Y3f3��kezDY ¬ � C�h�QL��YOk �e�X?#@e��K�h���M[N!KLC¸��K�¨eC$Ppd�M[k!f3��kez�QL@!Cg��ked!N3QRMrQ �;º� ) ) ������ * * $&%('� # L &K� L�# �>&K� �># ��Y � &� � ) ) * * � �

_�kyQUNe�§QU��¥bC$��SO¨�QLY-M[����Yr�ÖQU@eC 1 WUNe��CO¨*�*C�keC$Cif QUYÉWLC���M[P9QU@eC¾KLC�¹yNeC$kyQU��MO����QTS-��BDd;YbKLC�f¼�yS QL@eC¯��kedeN3Qd!WLC$×eP �4# ��Y � &�QL@�MrQ.zON�M[WjfeK QL@eC^�;Y3f3S � ) ) * *���Y ¬ QL@eC ¬ N!k!hªQU��Ybk®�²VXWUC�h$��KLC$��SO¨*�*C^��YONe��f �����OC�QLYWUC$d!��Mbh�CgQU@e��KG��kedeN3Q¸����QL@sQL@eC�f3C$��M¦SOCif^��k!deN3Q¸��kyQLWUY3f3N!h$C�f^��k � CihªQU��YbksÚG��Eb� w'QL@pN!KD³´WUC�h�M[���(QU@!MrQGQL@eCfe� ��C$WUC$k!h$C��;C�QT��C$C$k^M.KaQLWUYOk!z'��ked!N3Q Q4#.7��&�� MÖMOk!f^M[k¯YOWjf3��k!M[WUS.��kedeN3Q Q4#.7 � &� MÖ��K#QL@�MrQRQU@eC ¬ YbWLBDC$WMO����Yr�cK�WLCif3N!h�QL��YOk!K#��k�QL@eC�h$YOkyQL��kpN!MrQU��Ybk M�·ªº

� ) ) ������ * * $&%('� # L &K� � � # L�P ��RDN �># ��Y � &�� � ) ) * * � & ³«meEi·

?#@!C.WLCiKaN!�§QU��kezÈC$k!h$Ypfe��kezs��K h�YbWLWUC�h�Q ¬ YOW�KTQUWLYbkez¾h$MO�������pSy��k!M[BDCO¨�;C�h$MON!KLC.�§Q���K YO�eQUM[��keCif ¬ WLYbB MOkC�k!h�Y3f3��kez'QU@!MrQG��KGh�YbWLWUC�h�Q ¬ YOWGh$MO�������pSy��k!M[BDC�M[k�f^��Cih$MON!KaC�QL@eC ��kyQUWLY3f3N!h�QL��YOk^Y ¬ QL@eCDKTQUWLYbkez'��kedeN3Q��k-³6m!Ei·*@!MOK#d!WLCih���KaC���SDQU@eCgC ��C�h�QcY ¬ QL@eC 1 WLN!��C¸Y ¬ QL@eC��e��h$M[��h�N!��N!K��_�Q���K�KL@eYr��kD��k � C�h�QL��YOk'ÚG��Eb� wGQU@!MrQi¨bNek�f3C$W�h$C$WLQUMO��k'h�Ybk!f3��QL��YOk!K�¨bMgKaQLWUYOk!zg��ked!N3QAQ4#.7 ��&�� M h$MOk'��C

h$Y3f3C�fDNed(¨pMOdede��Sp��kez�QLWjM[k!K ¬ YOWUB'MrQL��YOk^³�xbo[·��X?#@eCRh�Ybk!f3��QL��YOk!K�M[WUC#QL@�MrQ*d!WLY3h�CiKLKLC�K���C¸MOKLSpk!hj@eWUYOkeYbN!KMOk!f QU@eC9h$YOkyQL��kpN!MrQU��Ybk M @!M¦¥bC¾YOk!��S QU@eCsYbN3QLd!N3Q¯h�M[d!MO�e������QTS YOk QU@eCs�;YON!k!f k!MOBDC�K 7 �3��Ú�Y[QU@h$YOk!fe�§QU��Ybk!K@eYO��f���k�³«meE¦·ªÂrQU@eC�h�YOk�f3�§QU��Ybk�Y ¬ QL@!C�YbN3QLd!N3QX@eYO��feK��Cih$MON!KaC*QL@!C*QTSpd;C*Y ¬ �g��K*#�������&� � �� P�� � ������>Y�� ��������Rj¨�MOK�KL@eYr��k���k-³ � �y·ª�

�´ó�â����

Page 42: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

���!��¤�©��;©L¤$�«�£�p¿R�j�3�������6�r�!�g�r�#���a�j�[ ����3 §�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª� mOv

� ) ) ������ * * $&%('� # L$&�0# � ��Y � & � L�# �>&K� �># �4Y � &K��� � �[� N � � � N � ) ) * *�� �� ) ) ��* * $&%('� # L$&� � P L R

� ) ) � * * $&%('� # L$&� ��� � � ) ) * *��+N � # �>&K� � �N# � P ��Y L�R���� � � ) ) � * *K& �?M[�e��CgveºX?#@eCgC$k�h�Y3f3��kezDY ¬ KTQUWLYbkezD��� ��kyQUY QU@eCg����h$M[��h�N!��N!K

±9C�h$MOk�QU@eC$WUC ¬ YbWLCgMOdede��S'QLWjM[k!K ¬ YOWUB'MrQU��Ybks³«xyo[·�QLY^³«meEi·�QUY'zOC�Q

� ) ) ����� * * � $ %('� # � �>YK��Y � & � L P ��R�� �># �4Y � &K��� � �[� N � � � N � ) ) * * � �³«?#@eCg����ke�3K�Ybk�QU@eCg��Yph�MrQU��Ybk�k!MOBDC�K � Y � M[WUC¸keY[Q�WUC$de����h$MrQUC�f���Cih$MON!KaC¸��Y3h$MrQU��Ybk!K�M[WUC¸N!KLC�f�����keC�MOWL��SO¨��� CO��¨pM[Q�BDYbKaQ*Ybk!h�Cb� · ?#@eCRh$YOWUWLCihªQLk!C�KUKXY ¬ QUWUMOk!K ¬ YbWLB'M[QL��YOk^³«xyo[·�³«M[k!f'Y ¬ �§QjK�����k!C�M[W*¥rM[WU��MOkbQ*���§QU@eYON3QWUC$d!����h$M[QL��YOk^YOk^����ke�3KU·czON!MOWUMOkbQUC$CiK#QL@!M[QcQL@!C�WUC�KLNe�§QG��K�KTQU�����/M.h�YbWLWUC�h�QRC$k!h$Y3f3��k!z.Y ¬ KaQLWUYOkez.h�M[���§���pSy�k�M[BDCO�X?M[�e��CRv¸zO��¥OCiKXQU@eCRh�YbBDde��C$QLCcC�k!h�Y3f3��kez�Y ¬ KTQUWLYbkez�h$MO�������pSy��k!M[BDCO¨O��k!h$��N�f3��k!z�QL@!CcNek!hj@!MOkezOCifh$��MON!KLC�K ¬ YOW�¥rMOWL��M[�e��C¸M[k!f¯M[d!de����h$M[QL��YOk®�_�Q���KcMOh�QLN!MO����S'd;YbKUKa���e��C�QUYDC$����BD��k!MrQUC¸QL@eCg����k!� � � � �.��k�QL@eC¸QUWUMOk!Ka��MrQU��Ybk�Y ¬ M[��KTQUWUMbhªQL��YOk(�?#@eC

C$P3C$Wjh���KaC¸�;C$��Yr�²��ky¥p��QLCiK�QL@eCgWUC�Mbf3C$W�QLY.KL@eYr� QU@e��K$�

0�� Æy�r� ´}iÆ � � � � �ªµD�[ £ ®µD�iÃr� ���j�r���6�r�s�a�¸���3¤�¤����j��Ã[�£�y¿��a� �!�y¶ª �¤ � �[ £ ��rÍ/�g� �p¤�¤$ ¡�£µ��£�;�[�«�6�[�9�T�G� �p¤ §�£�eË � � � �®Ì ©ª�£��¤GÃO�[ÍX�¯���y����¤����U�iÃr�£�p¿rÊ��r��Ã��;©L�r¢r¤g���U�[©ª©L¤j�����;¤��j��©L¤ª�ª�3 ¡�p���r©��£���r�;�[ ��U¿b�[�p�R�������3�r��£� � Jy¤$©L�$���$¤ �[Ì � � Ì � ���£�!� � ¶U¤�¿[�£�.�j©U�rµ �r�¼¤$�;�j�iÃr�£�p¿¾�T�D�j�r £  �L¶�Á����;�[µD¤D�£�ÉÍ��y�6���È� �p¤�ÃO¤ ���!�£���6�r� �a��y¶j�ª��©L�O�$���6�r�9���

) ) ����� * * ������ # � ��Y � &�� L P ��Y ��RDN � ) ) * *���[�;Ã.Í��p¤$©L¤ ���3¤ �$ ��r�p�$¤*���r©��ª�O�� §�6�U�[�«�6�[�-�������3�r�y¿y¤jÃ��b�j�U�[©LÃr�£�p¿[ §ÁOÌ �

_�kDh�YbkyQLWjMOKaQ�¨rC$k�h�Y3f3��kezGh�M[���§���pSy��¥rM[��NeC*de��N�KQL@eC 1 WLNe��C���K/B N!hj@ BDYbWLC#h�YbB�d!��C$P��?(YGWUC$d;C�MrQ/QU@eC�QLWU��hj���CGN!KaCif.��k.QU@eCgh$M[�������pSy��k�M[BDCRh$MbKaCb¨p�*C��*YbNe��f�keC$Cif'QUY�MO����Yr� WLCif3N!h�QL��YOk�N!k!f3C$WUkeCiMrQL@�WLC�de����h$M[QL��YOk®¨QU@!MrQc��K#QUYDMbfef�QL@eCgWUNe��C M ;6=�M P

� M ;6= � M P ³«m � ·

HcNe��CG³6m � ·÷MOded�CiM[WjK÷keCih�C�KUKUM[WUScQLYRC$k!h$YpfeC���k�����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K(MOkpS�KaQLWjMrQLC�zOS�@!M¦¥p��kezcM[Q���C�MbKTQ(WUNe��C�K$9�� Y S � Y 1³«M[keYOQL@eC�WcKaN�hj@�KaQLWjMrQUC$zOSD��K ¬ Ne��� 9ÉWLCif3N!hªQU��Ybk ��� W ·ª��?#@!CGWUC�MbKaYbk���K�QL@e��K�º � Neded;YbKLCGQL@eC�MOWLzbNeBDC$kyQ�ØY ¬ M[k�M[dede����h$MrQU��Ybk,#������'& � WUC�f3N�h�C�K*QUYDM ¬ Nek!h�QL��YOk¾���4� �HP«�/t�K�QL@e��K ¬ Nek!h�QL��YOk^h�YbNe��f.�;CGN�KaCifMOWL�!�§QUWUMOWL����Sy��B'M[kpS¯QL��BDC�K ��k ¨�QL@!C�����h$M[��h�N!��N!K�C$k!h$Y3f3��k!z¾Y ¬ ��KL@eYONe��fÉWUC�f3N!h$C'QLYsM^WLC�de����h�MrQLCifd!WLY3h�CiKLK���?#@eC 1 ��YONe��f^M[����Yr� WUC�f3N!h�QL��YOk^����QL@e��k^QU@eC��;YpfeS � P ¨�M[k!f�QUY.BDY3f3C$�(QL@e��KR��k^����h$M[��h�N!��N!K��C¸�*YbNe��f�k!C$C�f�WUNe��C'³«m � ·��Û!YOWKa��BD����M[W®WUC�MbKaYbk!K�¨�WUNe��CR³6m � ·÷MOded�CiM[WjK®keCih�CiKLKUM[WUS ¬ YOW(QL@eC*C$k!h$Y3f3��k!zcY ¬ MOkySGWUC�f3N!h�QL��YOk�KaQLWjMrQUC$zOS

QU@!MrQRMO����Yr�²WUNe��C�K*9MY O Y S � Æ3ÕÉ�3�¦Ï � � H�C�MbKaYbke��k!zGMbKXM[�;Yr¥OCO¨¦��C�h$M[kDM[��KLY�Yb�3QUMO��k�M[k�C$k!h$Ypfe��kez¸Y ¬ KaQLWUYOkezGh$M[�������pSy��k�M[BDC*�pSBDY3f3� ¬ Sp��kez QL@!C�f3C$×!ke��QL��YOk�Y ¬ M[�!KaQLWjMOh�QL��YOk'��k'QL@!C�Ybd3QL��BD��KLC�f.h�M[���§���pSy��k!MOBDCcC$k!h$Y3f3��k!z�Y ¬ � C�hªQU��Ybk�we�

â�â54�6!þ87:98;

Page 43: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

nyq � Ì(À��[�y¿O�6�r©«¿O�

_�k¾QL@e��K�h�MOKLCO¨;�*C�keC$Cif^��YOQL@^QUWUMOk!K ¬ YOWUBDM[QL��YOk-³«xyo[·RM[k!f�QUWUMOk!K ¬ YbWLB'M[QL��YOk ³«xOwb·��Rt ¬ QUC$WGC$����BD��k!MrQU��kezM�WUC$de����h$MrQU��Ybk���k ¬ WLYbkbQcY ¬ M�����ke����Cih$MON!KaC¸Y ¬ ����k!C�M[WU��QTSO¨p�*CgYb�3QUMO��k

� ) ) ����� * * $ %('� # � ��Y � & � L�# �6Y � &K�2# � � � � N � � � & N � ) ) * * � ��RYr�*C�¥OC�W�¨��*C WLCih$M[��� ¬ WUYOB � CihªQU��YbkÈÚG��Eb� wDQU@!MrQGQL@!C�deWUYpY ¬ Y ¬ h$YOWUWLCihªQUkeC�KUKcY ¬ QLWjM[k!K ¬ YOWUB'MrQL��YOk-³�x[wb·WUC�¹yNe��WUC�K#KaYbBDC�MOf3¥rM[k�h�C�f�deWUYOd;C$WLQL��C�K#Y ¬ deWUY3h�CiKLK#����QL@ � ��QTSpd;C�K�¨3QL@�MrQc��Cg@!M¦¥OC¸keYOQcC�PeM[BD��keC�f���kQU@eCgd!MOd�C�W��X?#@eC�KUM[BDC¸deWUYOd;C$WLQL��C�K#M[WUC¸keC$Cif3C�f�QLY'deWUYr¥OC�QL@!C�h�YOWUWUC�hªQUkeC�KUK*Y ¬ QL@eCgC�k!h�Y3f3��kez'M[�;Yr¥OCb�

0�� Æy�r� ´}iÆ � � � �3�r�¸�r©L¤����3¤'��Áj�3¤����T�D� �p¤. ����j�[ ��r��Ã��j©L¤j¤.�;�rµ'¤��.�a�D���3¤�¤$�;�j�iÃr�£�y¿È�£� ���b¶� �¤ � �À �p�[Í ���3�r�����3¤ª�$¤��«Áj�e¤ª���[©L¤ �j�[©ª©L¤j���«Ê�¶ªÁ¸�;©L�r¢i�£�y¿�� �p¤��j�b��©L�ª��©ª�6�r��¤���Áj�3¤ �ª�!Ã$¿y¤�µ'¤$�!�«��Ì

��� �÷�������������/ $��� � �'È� � ���!����"��#��"� _�k²QL@e��K¯KaCihªQU��Ybk �*C9Ka@!Yr� QL@!M[Q�QU@eCsC�k!h�Y3f3��kezyK�Y ¬ QL@eC9deWUC$¥p��YbN!K�KaCihªQL��YOk h$M[k²��C9C�PpQLC�k!f3Cif QLYC�k!h�Y3f3��kezyKRY ¬ QTSpd�Cif9�e��h$M[��h�N!������?�Y�f3Y�QL@!��KG��C�@�M¦¥OC�QUY�feC�×!keC�QUWUMOk!Ka��MrQU��Ybk!KcYbkÈQTSpd;C�K�QLY�B'MrQjhj@QU@eYbKLC'YOksQLC�WLB'K���±9C.M[k!MO��S3KLC�QL@eC�h�MOKLCDY ¬ QL@eC^�ª�£µ��� ¡Á�����Áj�e¤UÃ��'�a�U�[ ��$�3 ¡�p�'��k f3C$QUMO����¨�MOk!fÉf3��KUh�N�KLKKLNe�3QTSpde��kez¸M[k!f WUC�h�N!WUKL��¥bC�QTSpd;C�K��Û!YOWXKaQLN!f3��C�K/Y ¬ YOQL@eC�W/QTSyd;C�KaS3KaQLC�BDK�¨OKLC$C�QL@!C�k!Y[QLCiK/Y ¬ � C�h�QL��YOk�E$n!�_�kÈM�h�YbWLC�KL��BDde��Sy�«QTSpd;C�fÈ�e��h$M[��h�N!��N!K�¨�QTSyd;C�KGM[WUC��eN!����Q ¬ WUYOB ¶U�¦�$¤���Áj�3¤��ª¨�KLN!hj@¾MbKR��kyQLC$zbC$WjKcM[k�f

�;YpYO��C�MOk!K$¨/N!KL��kez¾QU@eC9�[©ª©L�rÍÖQTSpd;C�h$YOk!KaQLWUN!hªQUYOWi�È?#@eC�KaSpkyQUM[P9Y ¬ QLC�WLB'K���K QL@!M[Q Y ¬ QL@eC�NekyQTSpd�Cif�e��h$M[��h�N!��N!K¸d!��N!K�¶U�r��¤��j�r�e�ª���r���6�ª�D]�MOhj@Éh�Ybk!KTQjM[kyQg@!MOK¸M�Neke��¹yNeC'deWUC�f3C$×!keCif¾QTSpd;CO�D±sCDN!KLCDYOke��Sh$YOk!KaQUMOkyQUK÷Y ¬ ��MOKLC/QTSyd;C�K�º÷QU@e��K(��K�KaN �'h$��C�kyQ®QLYc@�M¦¥OC�M#keYbk3��C�BDd3QTSGKLC�Q�Y ¬ ³6h$��YyKaCif!·���C$���§��QTSpd�CifRQUC$WUB'K$�?#@!��KXKL��BDde��SgQTSpd;C�f'�3��h$MO��h$Ne��N!K��K/deWUC�KLC$kyQUC�f ��kD?�MO�e��CGEiqe�/tRK/N!KLN!MO�«¨OMOWLWUYr�ÉQTSpd�C�MbKLKLY3h���MrQLCiK�QLYGQL@eCWU��zO@yQ�¨¦KaY � =��/=�� WUC�MbfeK�� =�#��/=��-&L��Ú#MbKaC/QTSpd;C�K(MOWLCXWjM[k!zOC�fGYr¥bC$W÷�pS��j¨¦�!MbKaC�h$YOk!KaQUMOkyQUK÷�pS�[��?#@eC*WLCif3N!hªQU��YbkgWLC���M[QL��YOk�MOk!fGQL@eC*WLCif3N!h�QL��YOk�KaQLWjMrQLC�zO��C�K�M[WUC�f3C�×!k!C�f�MbK ¬ YOW(QL@eC�NekyQTSpd�Cifgh$MO��h$Ne��N�K$ÂQU@eCDYOke��S¾f3���;C�WLC�k!h�C���KRQU@!MrQ¸QU@eC�KLC�QgY ¬ ¥rM[��NeC�K ¬ YOWgM�WLCif3N!h�QL��YOksKaQLWjMrQUC$zbS�k!YOWUBDMO����S^h�YbkbQjM[��k!K�QL@eCh$YOk!KaQUMOkyQUK��^±sC�h$M[����[email protected];C�f-¥bC$WjKa��YOk�KgY ¬ � � M[k�f¼��� ³��ª�£µR�; ¡Á[�T·ª��Áj�e¤UÃ-�j�[ £  �L¶ªÁ���¢r�r §�!¤-³«� �'·MOk!f9³��ª�£µR�; ¡Á[�T·ª��Áj�e¤Uï�j�r £  �L¶ªÁ������rµ'¤�³�����.·ª¨eWUC�KLd�CihªQU��¥bC$��SO�±9C�MOf!f�QL@eC�KUM[BDCg�!MbKaC�h$YOk!KaQUMOkyQUKcMOk!f��!MOKLC¸QTSpd�CiK�QLY � � �-M[k!f¯����h$MO��h$Ne��N�KcM[k!f�WUC$d;C�M[QcQL@eC

fe��MOzOWjM[B Y ¬ Û��zONeWUC�Eb¨[QL@!��K�QL��BDC ¬ YOW�� � M[k!f.��� �±sCGKa@!Yr� @eYr� QUY�C�PpQLC�k!f�QL@!CRC$k�h�Y3f3��kezbKXY ¬� � M[k!f���� ³ ¬ WUYOB � CihªQL��YOk�K�x M[k!f �b·�¨pMOk!f'QU@eC$��W#h�YOWUWUC�hªQUkeC�KUK�WUC�KLNe��QUK�¨yQLY QUM[�bC�Mbh$h�YbNekyQ*Y ¬ QTSpd�CiK$�?#@!CGC�k!h�Y3f3��kezyK#��k � CihªQL��YOk�KRoi��v�h�M[k���CgC$PpQLC$k�f3C�f¯KL��BD����MOWL��SO�

� Æ3Õ-ÕÉ� ��2 � � ���^���3¤¸�ª�£µR�; ¡Á�����Áj�3¤jÃ��'�a�j�r ��$�3 ¡�p�jÊ�¤�¢r¤$©ªÁ��;©L�r¢r�b¶� �¤��«Áj�e¤ �ª�!Ã�¿[µ'¤$�!��� ! ��� �p�r��.�3�!�K�$�!¤�Ãb¤�©ª�£¢r�r���6�r��Ì

4 �3254 !;7 = @A< 7 � # � 7 < C<�=?>A@ >�� <� #+7�9 : 4��� ��� ���� �� � 7

±9C¸��C�zO��k�����QL@�QL@!CG��C ¬ Q�d!MOWaQ#Y ¬ Û��zbNeWLC�EO¨yQU@!MrQch�Ybk!h�C�WLk�K�� ����X±9C ¬ YO����Yr� MDKUhj@eC$B'M Ka��BD����M[W�QLYQU@!MrQ¸Y ¬ � C�hªQU��Ybk9xe¨;d;YO��kyQL��kez�YON3QGQL@eC�B'M[��kÈMOf!f3�§QU��Ybk!K��¸?#@!C�KLC�Q¸Y ¬ ¥rMO��NeCiKRY ¬ � � MO��KLY���k!h���N!f3Ch$YOk!KaQUMOkyQUK�º

� � � ������ � ��� �

?�Y�QL@eC�feC�×!ke��QL��YOk¯Y ¬ QL@!C Ý�V � QLWjM[k!K ¬ YOWUB " � ³«?�MO�e��C � ·*�*C¸@!M¦¥bC�QUY'MOfef¯MDh���M[N!KLC ¬ YOWch$YOk!KaQUMOkbQjK$º"('� ) � * $&%('� �

�´ó�â����

Page 44: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

���!��¤�©��;©L¤$�«�£�p¿R�j�3�������6�r�!�g�r�#���a�j�[ ����3 §�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª� n!E

�!¤$©ªµ�� � � �<� � �D����� �\ � � 9�!MOKLCgh�Ybk!KTQjM[kyQUK

�eÁj�e¤ª� � � � ���X= �$� ��� � 9�!MbKaCGQTSpd�CiK

�3Áj�e¤�¤���¢��£©L�[�!µ'¤����6� � � � �[��� Y5�Q����eÁj���£�p¿�©ª�3 �¤ª� � Y5�Q� � !I ���

� !������ � � = �� # � & � �� !N�Q���

� ! � � = � � ! ��� �� ! �����

?M[�!��CDE�q!ºX?#@eC.³6h$YOWUCi·�Ka��BDdpSb��QTSpd�Cif��e��h$M[��h�N!��N!K

_�QD��K ��BDd�YbWaQjM[kyQ�QLY9Nek!f3C�WUKaQUMOk!f-@eYr�ÖQU@eCÈÝ�V � QUWUMOk!K ¬ YbWLB MbhªQUK�Ybk-QTSpd�CiK$�¼HcC�h$MO������kez ¬ WUYOB� C�hªQU��Ybk²xsQL@!M[Q � ��K�M fe��KaQL��kezON!��KL@eC�f QTSpd;C¾Y ¬ M[k�Ka��C$WjK^³6MOk!Ka��C$WjK'�;C$��kezÉQL@!C � WLCiKaNe��QUK � Y ¬ Ý�V �QUC$WUB'KU·�¨3QL@eC�h�M[���§���pSy��¥rM[��NeC�Ý�V � ��QLWjM[k!K ¬ YOWUB�BDY3f3�§×�C�K#QU@eC¸QTSpd�CiK#Y ¬ � � ��QLC�WLB'K�MOK ¬ Yb����Yr�cK�º

" � ) ) � * * $&%('� # "('�$) � *4=��8&8=��

"('�() � * $&%('� � � ¬ ����K�MD�!MOKLC�QTSyd;C"('�() �/= � * $&%('� "('� ) � *6= " � ) ) � * *

³«mOmy·

?#@!C'QLWjM[k!KL��MrQL��YOk9Y ¬ MOWLWUYr�&QTSpd�CiK���K�KLYOBDC�QU��BDC�K�h$M[����C�fsQL@eC � f3YbNe�e��C���keC$zyMrQU��YbkÉh$YOk!KaQLWUN!h�QL��YOk � �;C��h�M[N!KLCO¨3��WU��QL��kez���� ¬ YbW � =��¨e��CG@�M¦¥OC

" '�$) � = � * � " '�() � *6=�����" '�$) � *?*Spd�CgC�kp¥y��WUYOkeBDC$kyQjK�MOWLCGBDY3f3�§×�C�f¯MOh�h�YOWjf3��kezO��S�º

" � ) ) � * * $ %('� �" � ) ) � Y5� � � * * $ %('� " � ) ) � * *%Y5� � " � ) ) � * *

MOk!f¯Ka��BD����M[WU��S ¬ YOW "('� ��?#@!C�h�YOWUWUC�hªQUkeC�KUK*Y ¬ QL@e��K#QLWjM[k�Ka��MrQU��Ybk�Y ¬ QTSpd�CiK���K#zb��¥bC$k���k��� Æ Å �¦Æ3Õ � 2 � � � Å �¦�rÆp�[~iÐ�Æp}�} Å �c�b� Ò´Ò áj|�à�á#"e� Ò ��Æ ��& % Å Ð ~jà3��Æp}�� �6�(^� � �p¤$�

� !I ��� � � " '� ) �$* !�" � ) ) * * � " � ) ) � * *³6_�Q ¬ YO����Yr�cK*QU@!MrQ ¬ YbWcM[kpS.¥rM[��NeC �D¨

� ! � ��� ��� " '�() �$* !" '�$) � * � " '�$) � *��@!��hj@ KL@eYr�cK¸QU@eC�M[zbWLC�C$BDC$kyQg�;C�QT��C$C$kÉQU@eC�feC�×!ke��QL��YOk�KgY ¬ QL@!C�M[NePp������MOWLS ¬ N!k!hªQU��Ybk " '� YOkÉQUC$WUBDKMOk!f�YOk�QTSpd�CiK$� ·

Æ3ÕÉ�3�¦Ï ��2 � � � hj@!C$B'Mɳ6mOmy·G��KgMO��KLY¯N!KLC ¬ Ne� ¬ YbWgNek!f3C�WUKaQUMOk!f3��kez�QL@eCDQTSpd;C�KgY ¬ QU@eC�Ý�V � ��B'MOzOC�KY ¬ QU@eC¯NekyQTSyd;C�f � �Ø��k ³aE��y·ª¨��;C�h�M[N!KLC�QL@eC¯NekyQTSpd�Cif �e��h$M[��h�N!��N!KDh�M[k¼�;C^f3C�KUh�WU����Cif¼MOKDMÈQTSpd�Cif�e��h$M[��h�N!��N!K#��k¯��@e��hj@¯MO����QUC$WUB'K#@!M¦¥OCGQL@!CgWLCih�NeWjKa��¥OCRQTSpd�C

� $&%('�O� �0#��"= ��& ³«m[np·

â�â54�6!þ87:98;

Page 45: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

n � � Ì(À��[�y¿O�6�r©«¿O�

?�Y MOdede��SDQL@eCGQTSpd;CRQUWUMOk!Ka��MrQU��Ybk'QLY¯³6mOny·��*C�ZTN!KaQ#k!C$C�f.QLYDMOfef.QL@eC¸h���M[N�KaCiK ¬ YbW�QTSpd;C�¥rMOWL��M[�e��C�K�M[k�f¬ YbW�WLCih�NeWjKL��Ybk.QLY�QU@eYbKLC¸��k-³6mbmb·�º

" '� ) � * $&%('� � " '� )O� ��� * $&%('� O � � " '� ) � * ³«mbxO·

?#@!C�QUWUMOk!KL��M[QL��YOk�Y ¬ QTSpd;C � ��k-³6mOny·*��K�QU@eC$k

"('�$) � * �O� �2#�� =�#�� =�� &8=��8&

��@!��hj@���KcdeWLCih���KaC���SDQTSpd;C �� ��k-³TE��b·�Â3B�YbWLC�Yr¥OC�W

" � ) ) � * *�� # "('�() � *4=�� &8=��� #�� � =��8&8=��� ��

?#@eC'zbWUMOBDBDMOW¸Y ¬ Ý�V � QLC�WLB'K¸��KgYO�3QjM[��keC�f ¬ WUYOB zbWUMOBDBDMOWDEix��pSsMOf!f3��k!z¯M¯d!WLY3f3N!h�QL��YOk ¬ YOWh$YOk!KaQUMOkyQUKGQLY¯QU@eYbKLC'f3C�×�ke��k!z9Ý�V � ��¥rM[��NeC�K���?#@eC'WUC$��MrQU��Ybk!Ka@!��d9��C$QT�*C�C$k9QL@!C�Ý�V � zOWjM[BDB'M[WgM[k�f� � �^��K*MOK���k'QU@eCRN!kbQTSpd;C�f.h�MOKLCO¨y��[email protected]�WLB'K�M[k!fDYbk'QTSpd�CiK$�X?#@!M[Q���K�¨yB�Y3f3N!��Y�MgBDYpfe�§×�h�MrQU��YbkY ¬ QL@eC�KaSpkyQUM[P M[k!f KLYOBDC.N!k!h�NeWUWUSy��kez�¨�QU@eC¾Ý�V � zbWUMOB�B'MOW�zOC�keC$WjMrQUC�K�MsKaNe�!��MOkezON!MOzOC.Y ¬ � � �X�?#@pN!K�?#@!C$YOWUC$B E�qe� � h$M[k¯M[��KLY��;CgWUC�MOf�MOK�M�WUC�KLNe�§QRMO��YbN3Q#QL@eCgC�k!h�Y3f3��kezDY ¬ � ����kyQLY � � �X�Û��k!M[����Sb¨���C�MOdede��S�QU@eC h$YOBDde����M[QL��YOk "ÉY ¬ � � �ÉQUC$WUBDK�M[k!f�QTSpd;C�KR��kyQLY�����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�QUC$WUB'KRM[k�f

QTSpd;C�K�¨bMOk!f��*C�Yb�3QUMO��k QL@eCRC$k!h$Ypfe��kezgY ¬ � � ��kyQLY¸QTSpd�Cif�����h�M[��h�Ne��N!KX��k'?�MO�e��CgEbEO¨OMOk!f QL@eCRWLCiKaNe��QUK�;C$��Yr��M[�;YONeQ���QUKDh�YbWLWUC�h�QLkeCiKLK��s?#@!C�QUWUMOk!Ka��MrQU��Ybk-Y ¬ QUC$WUB'K ��K�M[kekeYOQUM[QLC�f ���§QU@ MOk C$kp¥p��WUYOk!B�C�kyQMOk!f¯MDQTSpd�Cb��?#@!C�KLC�M[WUC¸QL@eC�C�kp¥y��WUYOkeBDC$kyQRMOk!f�QL@eCgQTSpd;C�Y ¬ M'h$YOWUWLCihªQ#QTSpde��k!zgZTN!f3zbB�C�kyQ ¬ YOW�QU@!MrQQUC$WUB¯Â�QL@!M[Q���K$¨���WU�§QU��kez � ) ) * *���� � BDC�M[k�KcQU@!MrQ � !Z � ��@eYO��feK���±9C k!C$C�f¾QL@eCiKaC�M[kek!Y[QUM[QL��YOk!KQUY���WU�§QUCcQL@!CcQTSpd�CiK�Y ¬ QL@eC���YbNek!f'k!MOBDC�K���k'QU@eCcQjM[WUzOC�Q*����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�d!WLY3h�CiKLKLC�K��*³«tck�M[��QLC$WUk!M[QL��¥OC#QLYMOkekeYOQUMrQU��k!z¸QL@eCcC�k!h�Y3f3��kezg��YONe��f���CcQLY�Mbfef QTSyd;CRMOkekeY[QjMrQU��Ybk!K/QLY¸QU@eCRKLSpkbQjMrP�Y ¬ �3��QLC�WLB'K�� ·�tcd!MOWaQ¬ WUYOB QTSpd;C¯MOkekeYOQUMrQU��Ybk!K�¨/QL@eC�QLWjM[k!KL��MrQL��YOk¼Y ¬ QUC$WUBDK���K QL@eC¯KLMOBDC�MbK ¬ YbW QU@eC�NekyQTSyd;C�f h$MO��h$Ne��N�K$¨����QL@[email protected]�§QU��Ybk9Y ¬ [email protected]���M[N�KaC ¬ YOW¸QUWUMOk!KL��M[QL��kez^h�YOk�KTQjM[kyQUK��'H�C�h�M[������kez�QL@!M[Q�#�� &�� ��K¸QU@eCDQTSpd�CYb�3QUMO��k!C�f ¬ WUYOB �²�pS�h$MOk!h�C�������kez�QU@eC¸YON3QUC$WUBDYbKaQ � � QjM[z!¨eMOk!f'QU@eC$WUC ¬ YbWLC-# � ) ) � * *K&��É��K � � ' ) � *U¨pQL@eCQUWUMOk!KL��M[QL��YOk�Y ¬ ?#@!C$YOWUC$B Eiqe� � ��kyQLYD����h$MO��h$Ne��N�K#zO��¥OC�K

� Å � Å�Ò´Ò �3�¦à ��2 � � �(¤$�8 ¶U¤ �.��¤$©ªµ �a���D�ª�£µ��� ¡Á��«Áj�e¤jÃ��'�a�U�[ ��$�3 ¡�p�$Ì�� �3¤��

� ! ��� � � � ' ) �$*Y L �X# � ) ) � * *K& � ! � ) ) * * ��� ��?#@eC�WLCiKaN!�§QjK ¬ YOW�QL@eC�C$k!h$Y3f3��k!z¾Y ¬ NekyQTSpd�Cif¼� �'¨Xk!MOB�C���S9¥rM[����fe�§QTSÉY ¬ 9 � ��WUNe��C�M[k!f-Mbf3C�¹yN!Mbh�S

³�Ý*YOWUYO����MOWLS'x3��Eix M[k�f�x3��E$np·ª¨pWUC$B'M[��k�¥rM[����f ¬ YbW*QU@eCGQTSpd�Cif�h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�¨y����QL@�QU@eC¸keC�h$C�KUKLMOWLSDBDY3f3�§×;h$Mr�QU��Ybk!K�QLYDQU@eC�KaQUMrQUC$BDC$kyQjK�QLY�QUMO�OCgMOh�h�YON!kbQ�Y ¬ QTSpd�CiK$��Û!YOW���k!KaQUM[k�h�CO¨�Ý*YbWLYb����M[WUS.x3��Eix �;C�h�YbBDC�K

� Å � Å�Ò´Ò �3�¦à ��2 � � � "e� Ò 6Ó. £~jà Å � 9 � ~ � Æ Å �¦à � À��¦�O�e�¦�$¤D� �p�[��� !, � � �r��Ã�� ! � � � Ê��[�;à�¤���� ��� �� ��' ) � * � #�� ) ) � * *5&��#Ì �6�c��9 � ! � ��� �p¤$� � ) ) * *���� � �! " � ) ) � * *��� ��Ì0�� Æy�r� ´}iÆ ��2 � % ��¤�©ª�£¢r¤g� �p¤¸�j��¶ �$¤j����©L¤jÃr�!�$�«�6�[�D��©L�ª�3¤$©ª�«Á.�a��� �� �j©L�[µ°� �p¤#���a�j�r ����3 ¡�p�g¤����j��Ã[�£�y¿ �� �p�[�����jÊ®�;©L�r¢r¤ ���3�r��� � � !I ��� �[�;Ã- ;4=�� �,���3¤��s�[  �$��� ! �V��� Ì

�´ó�â����

Page 46: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

���!��¤�©��;©L¤$�«�£�p¿R�j�3�������6�r�!�g�r�#���a�j�[ ����3 §�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª� nbm

��� � �b�������y¶ª �¤^Í�¤��y¶�¶�©L¤$¢��6�[��¤ � ) ) * *���� �� �¦� ) ) * *���� �� Ê��[�;Ã����r©^�s�«Áj�e¤¯�r©��«Áj�e¤^¤KJ$�;©L¤ª�j�ª�6�r���DÊgÍ�¤�y¶�¶�©L¤$¢��6�[��¤ � ' ) �+*g�¦� ) � *��[�;à � ) ) �+* *¸�¦� ) ) �+* * �

�e©L�[�e�ª ��r���6�r�-�T�¸��Áj�e¤ª� �) ) � * * $&%('� � � ) � *) � * $&%('� � � 9�!MOKLCGQTSyd;C�K

) �/= � * $&%('� ) � *�� ) ) � * * � �+P ) � *%Y � ) � *KR�e©L�[�e�ª ��r���6�r�-�T�¸��Áj�e¤ ¤$�!¢i�£©L�r��µD¤$�!�«� �

) ) � * * � ) � * $&%('� �

) ) � YK�Q� � * * $&%('� ) ) �$* *Y5� � ) ) � * *) � Y5�Q� � * $&%('� ) � *.YK� � ) � *

�e©L�[�e�ª ��r���6�r�-�T�¸��¤$©ªµ�� �) ) ����� * *���� � � $&%('� # L &K� L # � � ) �/= � * � &��� �4# � & ) ) * *���� � � � � �

) ) � * *���� � $&%('� # L &K� L�P � R) ) � * *���� � $&%('� # L &K� L�P��0R

) ) � * *���� � $&%('�# L$&�0# ��� � � ) �/= � *.& � ) ) * *���� � �� N � # ��&K�2# �4� � � ) � * &�# ) ) � * *���� � N � # �>&� � P �6Y L�R& ���@!C$WUCO¨e��k�QL@eC�C�k!h�Y3f3��kezDY ¬ M[d!de����h$M[QL��YOk®¨ � ��K#QU@eC¸QTSpd�C�MbKLKL��zbkeC�f�QLY � ��k�QL@eC�N!ke��¹yNeC�feC$WU��¥rMrQU��YbkY ¬ � ! �U��� ³£QU@eC¸QTSpd�Cg��K#Neke��¹yNeCg�pS � C�B�B'M¯Eiqe��Ei·ª�

?M[�!��CDEOEbºX?#@eCgC$k!h$Y3f3��k!z�Y ¬ � � ��kbQUYD����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K

â�â54�6!þ87:98;

Page 47: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

nbn � Ì(À��[�y¿O�6�r©«¿O�

Æ3ÕÉ�3�¦Ï ��2 � $ ?#@eCsQTSpd�CiK�Y ¬ ����h$MO��h$Ne��N!K�k�M[BDC�K�N!KLC�f ¬ YOW�QL@eCÉC�k!h�Y3f3��kez Y ¬ NekyQTSpd;C�f � � ��k� C�hªQU��Ybk xÉMOzOWUC$C����§QU@ QL@eYyKaC¯N!KLC�f ¬ YOW�� � ��k QU@e��K.KaCihªQU��Ybk®¨���@eC�k �*C^¥p��C$��QU@eC^NekyQTSpd�Cif �3�h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�MbK�M�QTSpd;C�f¼�e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!Kg��@!C$WUC'QL@eC�YOke��SÈQTSpd;C.��K

O� ��� = � ³6H�C�BDMOWL� E�q!� my·ª�¯ÛeWUYOB

³«mbxb·ª¨pQL@!C¸QLWjM[k!KL��M[QL��YOk�Y ¬ WLCih�NeWjKa��¥OC�QTSpd�CiK�M[k!f�QTSpd�Cg¥rMOWL��M[�e��C�K�Y ¬ � � ��kyQUY�����h$MO��h$Ne��N!K#��K

� ' ) � * $ %('� � � ' )O��� � * $&%('� O � � � ' ) � *

?#@!C$WUC ¬ YOWUCGQTSpd�C �����(Y ¬ � C�h�QL��YOkÈx���KcdeWUC�h$��KLC$��S � ' )O� �2#��R=���& *U¨�KLYDQL@!M[Q � C$BDB'M.x3��E�m'h$MOk^��C

d!WLCiKaC�kbQUC�f�QL@pN!K�ºX_ ¬�¬ ¥6#%'& � 7��¨3QL@eC�k7�Q� � ' ) O � �0#��"= � & *KY L �X#�� ) ) O � �0#��"= ��& * *5& � ! � ) ) * * �

Æ3ÕÉ�3�¦Ï ��2 � � }���|(~jà3�) 6Ð�Ô � _�kgQTSpd�Cif��3��h$MO��h$Ne���y����QL@�KLNe�3QTSpde��kez!¨iQL@!C*M[WUWUYr�¾QTSpd�C*��K�h�YbkbQUWUM¦¥rMOWL���MOkyQ���kgQL@eC*×!WjKTQ/M[WUzONeBDC�kbQi¨rM[k!f�h$Yr¥rM[WU��MOkbQ®��k�QU@eC*KLC�h$YOk!f®��?#@eC�WLC ¬ YOWUCO¨¦� ¬�� ��K(QL@eC�KaN!�3QTSpd�C�WLC���M[QL��YOk®¨QU@eC$k � = � � � PM= �GP/@eYO��feK¸� ¬ � P � �²M[k�f � � ��P/@eYO��f÷�'ÛeYbWg��k�KTQjM[k!h$CO¨(KLNeded;YbKLC¯�£�!��M[k�f©U¤U�[ yMOWLC�QL@!C¸QTSyd;C�K#Y ¬ ��kyQLC$zbC$WjK*MOk!f�WLCiM[��kpNeB��;C$WjK$�/_�Qc@eYb��f!K�QU@!MrQ��£��� � ©U¤U�[ ;³«M[k���kyQUC$zOC�W���K#MO��KLY�MWUC�MO�÷kpNeB��;C$Wª·#M[k!f�QU@eC$WUC ¬ YbWLCD©L¤j�r  =��£�!� � �£���4= ©U¤U�[ ¡�*?#@!��K���Kch$YOWUWLCihªQ���Cih$MON!KaCgM ¬ Nek�hªQL��YOk¯QU@!MrQQjM[�bC�K�M WUC�M[�;M[k!f�WLC$QLNeWUk!K�M[k.��kyQLC�zOC$W*B'M¦SDMO��KLY��;CGN!KaCif.MOK�M ¬ Nek!hªQU��Ybk.QU@!MrQ�QUMO�OC�K*M[k���kyQLC�zOC�W*M[k�fWUC�QUNeWUk!K�M�WLCiM[�X³´�eNeQcQL@eC�h$YOkp¥OC�WUKLCR��K ¬ MO��KLCi·��?#@eC ����QjM[z ����KgM¯h$YOkyQLWjM¦¥rM[WU��MOkbQ�QTSpd�C'h�Ybk!KaQLWUN!hªQUYOWi� _�ksQL@eCDQUWUMOk!KL��M[QL��YOkÈY ¬ MOk9MOWLWUYr� QTSpd�C

�[= ��¨�h$YOBDd�YbkeC$kyQ � ' ) � *���K'��k h$YOkyQLWjM¦¥rM[WU��MOkyQ d;YbKL�§QU��Ybk®¨#��Cih$M[N�KaC^��Q.��K.Nek!f3C�WLkeCiMrQU@ MOk Ypf!fkpNeB ��C�W�Y ¬ �¯QUMOzbK�Â���k h�YOkyQUWUMbKTQ�� ' ) � *G��K���k¼h$Yr¥rM[WU��MOkbQ�d;YbKL��QL��YOk®¨/�;C�h$MON!KLC���Q ��K�Nek�f3C$WUkeC�M[QL@ MOkC�¥OC�k�kpNeB ��C�W�Y ¬ �gQUM[zyK$�?#@eC$WUC ¬ YbWLC#QU@eCc����h$MO��h$Ne��N�KXQLWjM[k�Ka��MrQU��Ybk�Y ¬ QTSyd;C�K�¥rM[����feM[QLCiK/QL@eC�KaNe�eQTSyd!��kezWUNe��C ¬ YOW�M[WUWUYr�&QTSpd�Cb��tRKgM^h$YOk!KLC�¹yNeC�k!h�Cb¨÷QL@eCDQUWUMOk!KL��M[QL��YOkÈY ¬ QU@e��K�KaCihªQU��YbkÉh�M[k9��C'C$PpQLC$k�f3C�fsQLYYbkeC¸Y ¬ � � �����QL@^KLNe�3QTSpde��kez!�

4 �32 1 !;7 = @A< 7 � # � 7 < C<�=?>A@ >�� <� #+7�9 : 4��� ��� �� @ � 7

Ý*Ybk!KaQUM[kyQjK�MOWLCgMO��KLY�MOBDYOkez�QL@!Cg¥¦MO��N!C�K#Y ¬ ��� �º

�M[��NeC�K� � � ����� � �

?#@!C$WUC ¬ YOWUCG�*CgMOf!f�MDh$��MON!KaC ¬ YbWch�YOk�KTQjM[kyQUK*QLYDQU@eC�f3C$×!ke��QL��YOk¯Y ¬ QL@eC Ý�V � QUWUMOk!K ¬ YbWLB°��k¯?�MO�e��Cgn!º

"('� ) � * $&%('� �

?#@eC�h�M[���§���pSy��k!MOBDCgÝ�V � BDY3f3��×!C�K�QTSpd;C�KcMbK ¬ YO����Yr�cK��

" � ) ) � * * $&%('� # "('�$) � *4=��8& =��

"('� ) � * $&%('� � � ¬ ����KcM��!MOKLCGQTSyd;C"('� ) � = � * $&%('� " � ) ) � * *6= " � ) ) � * *

³«m �b·

�´ó�â����

Page 48: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

���!��¤�©��;©L¤$�«�£�p¿R�j�3�������6�r�!�g�r�#���a�j�[ ����3 §�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª� nyx

?*Spd�CgC�kp¥y��WUYOkeBDC$kyQjK�MOWLC�QL@!C$k¯QLWjM[k�Ka��MrQUC�f'QU@pN!K$º" � ) ) � * * $ %('� �

" � ) ) � Y5� � � * * $ %('� " � ) ) � * *%Y5� � " � ) ) � * *MOk!f¯Ka��BD����M[WU��S ¬ YOW "('� ���� Æ Å �¦Æ3Õ � 2 � � � � Å �¦�rÆp�[~iÐ�Æp}�} Å �c�b� Ò´Ò áj|�à�ájÐ��!ÕÉÆ ��& % Å Ð ~Uà3��Æy}�� �(¤$�8 ^�GÌ�� �p¤$�

�H! ��� � � " � ) ) �$* * !�" � ) ) * * � " � ) ) � * *t&h$YOWUYO����MOWLSD��K#QL@�MrQ ¬ YOW�C�¥OC$WUS.¥rM[��NeC � Y ¬ ��� ¨

� ! � �� ��� " � ) ) � * * !" '� ) � * � " '� ) � * Æ3ÕÉ�3�¦Ï ��2 � � 2 t�fef3��kez¾h���M[N�KaCiK ¬ YOWgQTSpd;C'¥¦MOWL��M[�!��CiKgM[k!f ¬ YOW�WUC�h$NeWjKa��YOk9MOKg��k ³6mbxb·ª¨(QL@eC�MO��Yr¥bCQUWUMOk!KL��M[QL��YOk�Y ¬ QTSpd�CiK�h$MOk�M[��KLY��;C¸MOdede����Cif.QUY N!kbQTSpd;C�f¯��� ��?#@eCGQLWjM[k!KL��M[QL��YOk.Y ¬ � $&%('�

O� �0#��"=

� &/��K"('�$) � * �

O� �!� #5#�� =��8& =��8&8= #5#�� =�� &8=���& �

MOk!f" � ) ) � * * � # "('�() � *4=�� & =��

��@!��hj@¯��K�QTSyd;C � � �

?#@!C.BDYpfe�§×�h�MrQU��Ybk!K¸keC$Cif3C�f9QUY¯QL@eC¯Ý�V � zOWjM[BDB'M[W ¬ YOW�NekyQTSyd;C�f-���-¨/M[k!fsQL@!C.��k[ZTC�hªQU��Ybk-Y ¬ QL@eCQUC$WUB'K#zOC$k!C$WjMrQLCif��pS'QU@eCgzOWjM[BDB'M[W�QUY � � �X¨!M[WUC�QL@eC�KUM[BDCgMOK ¬ YbWch$M[�������pSy��¥rMO��NeCb�?#@!C�×�k!M[�®KaQLC�d�Y ¬ QL@!C¸h$YOBDde����M[QL��YOk�Y ¬ � � �È��kyQLYD����h$M[��h�N!��N!K�zb��¥bC�K�N!K�QL@!CgC$k!h$Ypfe��kez�Y ¬ QTSpd�CiK$¨

QTSpd;CRC�ky¥p��WLYbkeBDC$kyQUK�¨bMOk!f�QLC�WLB'K�Y ¬ ��� ��kyQLY ����h�M[��h�Ne��N!KX��k�?M[�e��C�E � �/?#@eC$YbWLC�B­Eiqe� vGQL@eC�k.zO��¥OCiK

��� Æ Å �¦Æ3Õ � 2 � �/� ��¤��� ¶U¤ �.��¤$©ªµ �a���D�ª�£µ��� ¡Á.��Áj�e¤Uà �3�a�j�[ ����3 §�p��Ì�� �p¤$�� !N ��� � � � ) ) �$* *Y LQ�X# � ) ) � * *5& � ! � ) ) * *��

?#@!C.WLCiKaN!�§QjKgYOk � ¬ WUYOB [email protected];C�f-h$MbKaCb¨�k�M[BDC$��SÉÝ*YbWLYb����M[WU��CiK �e��E � M[k�f �e��E�m¯M[k!f-]XPpC�Wa�h$��KLC �!� � � ¨WLC�B'M[��k ¥rM[����f÷¨X����QL@ QL@eC�C�P3d�CihªQUC�f BDY3f3��×�h$M[QL��YOk!K�QLYÈQL@eC�QTSyd;C�K ��k-QL@eC¯KaQUMrQUC$BDC$kyQ�Y ¬Ý*YbWLYb����M[WUS��e��E�m!�

Æ3ÕÉ�3�¦Ï ��2 � �� ?#@eC�QTSpd�CiK Y ¬ ����h$MO��h$Ne��N�K k�M[BDC�K�N!KLC�f ¬ YOW�QL@!C�C�k!h�Y3f3��kez9Y ¬ N!kbQTSpd;C�f ���I��k� C�hªQU��Ybk ��MOzOWUC$CG���§QU@�QL@eYyKaC¸N!KLC�f ¬ YOWR��� ��k�QU@e��KRKaCihªQL��YOk(¨3YOk!h$CG��CgMOfef�h���M[N�KaCiK

� ' ) � * $ %('� � � ' )O� � � * $ %('� O � � � ' ) � *

?#@!C¯QTSyd;C ������-Y ¬ � C�h�QL��YOk �9��K'd!WLCih���KaC���S � ' )O� �0#���= ��& *L¨#KaY9QL@�MrQ � C�BDBDM �!��EbE�h�M[k ��C

d!WLCiKaC�kbQUC�f�QL@pN!K�º � Neded;YbKLC ¬ ¥6#.'& � 7�(��?#@eC�k7�Q� � ) )

O���0#�� = � & * *KY L �X# � ) )

O� �2#�� = ��& * *K& � ! � ) ) * * �

Æ3ÕÉ�3�¦Ï ��2 � � � � } �(|�~jà3�. «Ð(Ô � tRK���k¯h$MO�������ySy��¥rM[��NeCO¨yKaY���k�h$MO�������pSy��k!M[BDC�QU@eC¸C$k!h$Ypfe��kez Y ¬ QTSyd;C�K¥rMO����feMrQUC�K�QU@eC�KTQjM[k!f!M[Wjf�KLNe�3QTSpde��kezDWLN!��C ¬ YOWcMOWLWUYr� QTSpd;C�K�� �

0�� Æy�r� ´}iÆ�� � 2 � � � ½#©L�r¢r¤ ���3¤��[�;�[ ��L¿O�!¤��T� � �p¤j�[©L¤�µ � � Ì � � �£�s���3¤D�U�r�$¤�� �p�[� � ���g� �p¤D¤$�;�j��Ã[�£�y¿�a� ���b¶� �¤ Ì

â�â54�6!þ87:98;

Page 49: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

n � � Ì(À��[�y¿O�6�r©«¿O�

���¼� �b���'���b¶� �¤�Í�¤��y¶�¶�©L¤$¢��6�[��¤ � ) ) * *���� �� �¦� ) ) * *���� �� Êg�r�;à ���r©��^��Áj�3¤¯�r©'��Áj�e¤�¤J$��©L¤��j�ª�6�r� �'ÊGÍ�¤�y¶�¶�©L¤$¢��6�[��¤ � ' ) �+*¸�r� ) �+*c�r��à � ) ) � * *��¦� ) ) �+* * �

�e©L�[�e�ª ��r���6�r�É�T�g��Áj�e¤ª� �) ) � * * $&%('� � � ) � *) � * $&%('� � � s��MOKLC�QTSpd;C�K) � * $&%('� ) ) � * * � ) ) � * * � �+P ) ) � * *KY�� ) � * R

�e©L�[�e�ª ��r���6�r�É�T�g��Áj�e¤ ¤$�!¢i�£©L�r��µD¤$�!�«� �) ) � * * � ) � * $&%('� �

) ) � YK� � � * *�$&%('� ) ) �$* *KYK� � ) ) � * *) � * $&%('� ) � *%Y5�Q� ) � *

�e©L�[�e�ª ��r���6�r�É�T�g��¤$©ªµ�� �) ) ����� * *���� � � $ %('� # L &K� L # � � ) � * � &� �4# ��& ) ) * *���� � � � � �

) ) � * *���� � $ %('� # L &K� �CP L�R) ) � * *���� � $ %('� # L &K� L�P��0R

) ) � * *���� � $ %('�# L$&�0# ��� � � ) � *.& � ) ) * *���� � �� N � # �>&K�2# � �H� � ) � *.&�# � P ��Y L R���� � ) ) � * *���� � & ���@!C$WUCO¨3��k¯QL@eCgC�k!h�Y3f3��kez'Y ¬ M[d!de����h$M[QL��YOk®¨ �¼��K#QL@!CgQTSpd�C�MbKLKL��zbkeC�f�QLY � ��k�QL@eCgNek!��¹yNeC�feC$WU��¥rMrQU��YbkY ¬ � ! ����� �

?M[�e��C'E � º/?#@!CGC�k!h�Y3f3��kezDY ¬ �������kyQLY�QL@!Cg����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K

�´ó�â����

Page 50: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

���!��¤�©��;©L¤$�«�£�p¿R�j�3�������6�r�!�g�r�#���a�j�[ ����3 §�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª� npo

�!� +���� �[��"�"s� ���®��������� $��� ���� ��"$�� �r�����8��� � �� $��������������¸�/ ����� � ����"$"j� � � �������

tRk¼��kyQLC$WUdeWUC�QjMrQL��YOk¼Y ¬ QL@!C^�e��h$M[��h�N!��N!K ��kbQUYÈ����h$MO��h$Ne��N�K$¨�MbK MÈQLWjM[k!KL��MrQL��YOk-Y ¬ YOk!C���M[kezbN!M[zbC.��kyQUYMOkeY[QU@eC$Wi¨3h$MOk.��Cgh$YOk!KL��feC$WUC�f.M ¬ YOWUB�Y ¬ f3C�keY[QjMrQU��Ybk!M[��KaC�B'M[kyQL��h$K��?#@!CGf3C�keY[QjMrQU��Ybk�Y ¬ M �e�«QUC$WUB���KMOk�Ci¹bN!��¥rM[��C$k�h�C#h���MOKUK(Y ¬ deWUYph$C�KUKaCiK$��?#@eC�KLC*Ci¹yNe��¥rMO��C�k!h�C�h���MOKUKaCiK�MOWLC�QL@eC�¹yNeY[QU��C�kyQ�Y ¬ QL@eC�����h$M[��h�N!��N!Kd!WLY3h�CiKLKLC�K#����QL@^WUC�KLd;C�hªQ�QUYDQL@eC���C�@!M¦¥p��YbNeWUMO�÷C�¹yNe��¥rM[��C$k!h$C.³´�!MOWL�;C�f¯h�YbkezOWUNeC�k!h�C¦·*Mbf3YOdeQLC�f ¬ YbW�QL@eC����h$MO��h$Ne��N!K$�_�k�QL@eCGdeWUC$¥p��YON!K*KaCihªQL��YOk�K$¨p��CR@!M¦¥bC�KLC$C$k�¥¦MOWL��YON�K�����h$MO��h$Ne��N�K���kyQLC$WUdeWUC�QjMrQL��YOk�K�Y ¬ �3��h$MO��h$Ne���÷MOk!f

@�M¦¥OCDKa@eYr��kÈQL@eC���W KaYbNek!f3keCiKLKG����QL@9WLCiKad;C�h�Q¸QLY�QL@eCÈ�2Jb�6�rµ'�r���6�'KaC�B'M[kyQL��h$KGY ¬ [email protected]�M[��h�Ne���c³´��@!C$WUCCi¹yNe��¥rMO��C�k!h�C��;C�QT��C$C�kD�e�«QUC$WUB'KXBDC�M[k�K/deWLYr¥rMO�e��C�C�¹yN!MO����QTS ¬ WUYOB M[kDM[dedeWUYOd!WL��MrQUC�KLC�Q�Y ¬ M[Pp��YOB'KXMOk!f��k ¬ C�WLC�k!h�C'WUNe��C�Kj·ª�D_�kÈQU@e��K�KaCihªQU��Ybks��CDzOY ¬ NeWLQL@eC�W�M[k!f9h�YbB�d�M[WUC QU@eCD����h�M[��h�Ne��N!KgKLC$B'M[kyQU��h�K¸���§QU@QU@eCÈ�j�e¤$©L�r���6�r���r cKLC$B'M[kyQL��h$K¸Y ¬ QU@eC��e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!K��'±sC.KaQLN!feS¾QL@!C'��BDd;YOWLQUM[kyQ�h$MbKaCDY ¬ QU@eC'NekyQTSpd�Cifh�M[���§���pSy��k!MOBDCG�e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!KG³«���s·ªÂpQU@eCGdeWLYb�e��C$B���K*@�M[Wjf3C$W���k�QL@eCgh�M[���§���pSb��¥rM[��NeCRh�MOKLCO¨3M[k!f���K��eWU��C �!Sfe��KUh�N!KUKLC�f¯��k � C�h�QL��YOk Eime� x3��?#@eC C$k!h$Ypfe��kez�Y ¬ ��� ��kyQLY�����h�M[��h�Ne��N!KR�������(�;C�QU@!MrQGY ¬ ?M[�e��C�n!¨;�eN3Q����QL@!YON3Q � �'QTSpd;C�K���±9CDh$M[ksMOKUKaNeBDCgQU@!MrQGQL@!C�C$k�h�Y3f3��kez���KG��kyQLY�QL@eC de��M[��kÈd;YO��SbMOfe��hg����h$MO��h$Ne��N!K$¨����QL@!YON3Q � �-QTSpd;C�K�¨R�;C�h�M[N!KLC � C$BDB'M �e��E�w¼Ka@eYr�cK.QL@!M[Q ���-QTSpd�CiK�feY¼keYOQ¯M��;CihªQ��;C$@�M¦¥y��YON!WUMO�Ci¹yNe��¥rMO��C�k!h�CbÂe��k � C$BDB'M��e��E�w �*Cg��k!f3��h$M[QLC�f�QU@eCgC$k!h$Y3f3��k!z'���§QU@eYON3Q ����QTSyd;C�KRMOK � � ��Û!WLYbB�keYr�Ybk¯�*C¸YOBD��Q���k!fe��h$C�K#QU@!MrQRKL��zbke� ¬ S�h$MO�������pSy��k!M[BDCOÂyQU@yN�K#QL@eCgWUC$��MrQU��Ybk!K ;4=��GM[k�f �����G��Cih�YOBDC�;>=MOk!f ��� ¨eM[k!f�QL@!CGC�k!h�Y3f3��kez � � ) ) � * *��;C�h$YOBDC�K ) ) � * *L�tRk.��kbQUC$WUdeWUC�QUM[QL��YOk'Y ¬ M�h$MO��h$Ne��N!K���K*KUM[��fDQUY��;C��$�r�3��ÃD� ¬ ��Q#C�¹yN!MrQUC�K�YOke��SDYOd;C$WjMrQL��YOk�M[����S C�¹yNe��¥b�

MO��C�kyQ*QUC$WUBDK�¨®�j�rµ��� �¤$��¤�� ¬ �§Q#C�¹yN!M[QLCiK�MO����Ybd�C�WUM[QL��YOk!MO����S Ci¹yNe��¥rMO��C�kbQ�QLC�WLB'K�¨3M[k!f��j�3 £ ¡Á.�b¶ª�ª�«©L�b���*� ¬ �§Q��KcKLYONek�f�MOk!f¯h�YbB�d!��C$QLCO��±sC�KL@eYr� ��k¯QU@e��KRKaCihªQL��YOk�QU@!MrQ�QU@eCg����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K���kyQLC�WLdeWUC�QjMrQU��Ybk�Y ¬ ��� ��KKLYON!k!f÷¨e�eNeQckeY[Qch�YbBDde��C$QLCb�± @!C$k¾M[k¯��kyQLC$WUdeWUC�QjMrQL��YOk�Y ¬ M'h$MO��h$Ne��N!K���KckeYOQ ¬ Ne����S¯M[�!KaQLWjMOh�Q�¨3YOk!CgBDM¦S�@eYOd;C¸QLY�MOhj@e��C$¥bC ¬ N!���

MO�!KaQLWjMOhªQU��Ybk��pS

EO�#C$k!WL��hj@e��kez�QU@eC�h$MO��h$Ne��N!K$¨

� ��hj@eYpYbKL��kez�M ×!k!C$W�keYOQL��YOk¯Y ¬ YOd;C$WjMrQL��YOk�M[��C�¹yNe��¥rM[��C$k!h$C ¬ YbW#QL@eC�h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�¨3YOW

me��h�NeQaQL��kez.f3Yr��k�QL@!C�h�Y3f3YOB'MO��k�Y ¬ QL@eCg��kyQLC$WUdeWUC�QjMrQL��YOk(�

_�k � CihªQU��Ybk!KGE � M[k!fÈE�m���C�deWUYr¥OC ¬ Ne���(M[��KTQUWUMbhªQL��YOk�WLCiKaNe��QUK ¬ YbW�QL@eCg������kyQUC$WUdeWLC$QUM[QL��YOk��pS ¬ Yb����Yr����kez³aEi·�MOk!fɳ � ·ª��_�k � C�hªQU��YbkÉE$n'��C�Ka@!MO���(@e��kyQcQU@!MrQcYbNeWcB'M[��k�QL@eC�YOWUC$B'KcMOWLCb¨3�yS���MOWLzbCO¨e��k!f3C�d�C�k!f3C�kbQY ¬ QL@eC¾�;C$@�M¦¥y��YON!WUMO��C�¹yNe��¥¦MO��C�k!h�C¾hj@!YbKLC$k ¬ YOW'QU@eC¾����h$MO��h$Ne��N�K$¨#��@e��hj@ KaNezbzOCiKTQjKDQL@!M[Qs³6my·���K���CiKLK��kyQLC�WLCiKTQU��kez��/±sCg�;C$zb��k¯�pS.deWUC�KLC$kyQL��kez�QL@!C�KTQjM[k!feMOWUf�YOd;C$WjMrQU��Ybk!M[�÷KLC$B'M[kyQL��h$K#Y ¬ ��� �� YOBDC�QU��BDC�KR�*C Ka��BDde��S�WUC ¬ C$WRQLY���� MbK � QU@eC��e��h$M[��h�N!��N!K � Â!QU@e��K���Kcd!MOWaQU��S�ZTN!KTQU�§×�C�f¾�pS�QL@eC ¬ MOhªQ

QU@!MrQ QL@eC�h$M[�������pSy��k�M[BDC.KTQUWUM[QLC�zOSÈ��K�M Í�¤U�rËi §ÁÈ�;�[©ªµD�[ ¡���ª�£�y¿-KaQLWjMrQUC$zbSO¨®QU@!MrQ���K M¯QLC�WLB h�Ybkp¥OC$WUzOCiKN!k!f3C$WRQL@eC ¬ Ne����9-WLCif3N!h�QL��YOk¯Y ¬ QL@!C �3��h$MO��h$Ne��N!K����s��Q�f3YpC�K�KaY'Nek�f3C$WRh�M[���§���pSy��k!MOBDCD³´QL@eC�WLC ¬ YOWUC¸QL@eCYbd�C�WUM[QL��YOk!MO�!Ci¹bN!��¥rM[��C$k�h�CGWLC���M[QL��YOk'Y ¬ ÇRC$×!ke��QL��YOkÈEbEO��ER�;C$��Yr� f3YpC�K*keY[Q�hj@!MOkezOC�� ¬ QU@eC¸h�YOkp¥bC$WUzOC$k�h�Cd!WLCif3��h�MrQUCG��K#QjM[�OC�k�QUYDB�CiM[k¯h�Ybky¥bC$WUzOC�k!h�C�Nek!f3C�W�QL@eC ¬ N!��� 9ÉWUC$��MrQU��YbkZ;>= W ·ª�

â�â54�6!þ87:98;

Page 51: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

nyw � Ì(À��[�y¿O�6�r©«¿O�

4 4 254 � # # � =5: C<�=�� 7 � =5E�= �F=�� �� =?<� _�k�M[k.Ybd�C�WUM[QL��YOk!MO�!KaC�B'M[kyQL��h$K�¨OQT��YgQUC$WUBDK�M[WUCRf3C�C$BDC�f.C�¹yNe��¥¦MO��C�kyQ*� ¬ QL@eC�SD@!M¦¥OC�QU@eC�KUM[BDC�YO�!KLC$WU¥y�MO�e��Cg��C�@!M¦¥p��YbNeW#��k¾MO���(h$YOkyQLC$PpQUK���± @!MrQc��KcMOk¯MOdedeWUYOdeWU��MrQLC¸keYOQL��YOk�Y ¬ YO��KaC�WL¥rM[�!�����§QTS ¬ YbW��e�«QUC$WUBDK��±9C¯@!M¦¥OC¯MOfeYOd3QUC�f-QU@eC¯¥p��C���d�Yb��kyQDQL@!M[Q'��@!MrQ'��KDYO�!KLC$WU¥rM[�e��C�Y ¬ MÈ��©L�i�j¤ª�j�^M[WUC���QUKD��kyQLC$WjMOh�QL��YOk!K����QL@ �§QjKDC$kp¥p��WUYOk!B�C�kyQ��-H�C$zyM[Wjf3��kez ¬ Nek�hªQL��YOk�K�MbK�deWLY3h$C�KUKaCiK$¨X��Q���K�k!MrQUNeWjM[��QLYÉKTQU��d!Ne��M[QLC�QL@!M[QDM³«h���YbKLC�f!·*�3��QLC�WLB���K*YO�!KLC$WU¥rM[�e��CR� ¬ ��Q���K*MOk�MO�!KTQUWUMbhªQU��Ybk®¨b��@!��hj@.��kyQLC�WUMbhªQUK*����QL@���QUK�C�ky¥p��WLYbkeBDC$kyQ��pSh$YOk!KLNeBD��kez MOk�M[WUzON!B�C�kyQ��#³´_�k�QL@eC�QTSpd�Cif��e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�¨pMO��KLY h$YOk!KaQUMOkyQUK*�����OCG��kyQUC$zOC�WUK�M[k�f.�;YyYb��CiM[k!K��YON!��f^�;CDYO�!KLC$WU¥rM[�e��COÂ;QU@eCD��kyQLC�zOC�W�YbWRQU@eCD��YpYO��C�MOk^QL@�MrQ�M'QUC$WUB WLCif3N!h�CiK�QLY¯h$M[kÈ��C�QL@!YONezb@bQgMOKQU@eCgYONeQLdeN3QcY ¬ QU@!MrQ�QUC$WUB�QLY�QU@eCgC$kp¥p��WUYOk!B�C�kyQ�� ·

��M¦¥y��kez�f3C�h$��f3Cif^��@!M[Q���KRYb�!KaC�WL¥rMO�e��Cb¨���C h�M[kÈfeC�×!keC �!M[WU�;C�f¾h$YOkezbWLNeC�k!h�C ¬ YOW¸M[kpS�WUC�feN!hªQU��YbkKaQLWjMrQUC$zbS¼��C¾�����OCb¨#��k d�M[WLQL��h�Ne��M[W ¬ YbW�h$MO�������ySy��k!M[BDCb¨*QU@eCsKaQLWjMrQUC$zbS-QL@!M[Q���kyQLC$WUC�KaQUK.N!K$� t�K�h�M[���§��pSy��k!M[BDC^��K�h�Ybk��!NeC�kyQȳ´��k!f3C$Cif f3C$QLC$WUBD��k!��KaQL��h�·�¨#QL@eC9f3C�×!k!�§QU��Ybk Y ¬ �!M[WU�;C�f h�YbkezOWUNeC$k�h�C¾h$MOk ��CKL��B�d!����×!C�f®¨[�pS�WLC�BDYr¥y��kez�QL@eC#�e��KL��B Ne��M[QL��YOkDh���M[N!KLC�YOk���kyQLC�WUMbhªQU��Ybk!K$�?#@eC�f3C�×�ke�§QU��Ybk�QL@eC�k �;C�h$YOBDC�KQU@eCDKLMOB�C�MOKRQL@!M[Q�Y ¬�� �r©ª©ª����� �'�j�[�!��¤KJb� �a¤,�$�3�£¢r�r �¤$�;�j¤$¨�KLYOBDC$QL��B�CiK�h�M[����Cif¼�b¶ª�$¤�©ª¢r�r���6�r� ¤,�$�3�£¢r�r �¤$�;�j¤��k�QL@eCg����QLC$WjMrQUNeWUCO�Xt��� ��r�$¤UÃ��j�r����¤Jb�*��K#YOkeC¸����QL@eYbN3Q ¬ WUC$Cg¥rM[WU��MO�e��C�K��� Æ��/Ð. £~� Å Ð ��� � � � Å |�}iÆy� "e�3~� Å Ð Æ�� �' "e� Ò Æ3Ð(�bÆ�� Å ��|�3�r|�ÆpÓ � Å Ð�Ô!� ��ÆpÐ��OÆ � Å � ��� � �(¤$�� Y � �¸Ì �¤'���[Á¾� �p�r�X �r��à � �[©L¤�YO�!KLC$WU¥rMrQU��Ybk!M[����S^Ci¹yNe��¥rMO��C�kbQ�ÊG�r©¯�!MOWL�;C�fÉh$YOkezbWLNeC�kyQ$Êc� �Uʸ�£� �r £ �$ ��r��¤jÃ��j�r�!��¤JO�«� � Ê*�£� �p�[ �æ��� �p�[� � ) * � � � � � ) � * � � Ìt�K ¬ YOW�QL@eC'����h$MO��h$Ne��N�K$¨/M�QLWjMOh�QUM[�!��C'hj@!MOWUMbhªQLC�WL��KUMrQL��YOksY ¬ �!M[WU�;C�fÉh�YbkezOWUNeC$k�h�CDYOk �e�«QUC$WUBDK���K

N�KaC ¬ Ne�«�

� Æ��/Ð. £~� Å Ð ��� � � �ªÁrµ µ'¤���©ª�6�¸©L¤$ ��[�«�6�[��� � �*) ���*)D���g�[��M[d!de����h$M[QL��¥OC��e��KL��B�Ne��MrQU��Ybk9� �X�� �r�;ÃI ��� �����QPG�£µR�; ¡ÁÈ� �p�[��� �p¤$©L¤������r� �HPc�ª�!� �s� �p�[� � ��� ����� �HPg�r�;à QP @�BCED>F���,P @ C D�FbÊe���r©��r £ �+ ^�*)bÌ��®Í��.��¤$©ªµ �: Y � ^� )��r©L¤RM[dede����h$MrQU��¥bCR�e��KL��BD����MOW$ÊXÍX©ª�£����¤$�N �� �ÉÊ� �(�� � �p�[ �æ�jÊ����[©g�$�rµ'¤ �ª�O�� §�6�U�[�«�£¢r¤�¶����ª�£µ �3 ��[�«�6�[���sÌ

tRdede����h�MrQL��¥OCR�e��KL��B�����M[WU�§QTS���K�C�PpQLC�k!f3Cif�QLY�Ybd�C�k'QLC�WLB'K�N�Ka��kez�h���YbKL��kez�KLNe�!KaQL��QLN3QU��Ybk!K$º� ¬ Y � � ����QL@ ¬ ¥6#. Y �/& � 7��¨pQU@eC$kH � � � ¬¬ YOWcMO��� 7+ � � )O¨e�*C¸@!M¦¥bC '@�� C �D>F � �/@�� C �D�Fy���� Æ Å �¦Æ3Õ �/� � � ���O�; ¡�6�j�r���£¢¦¤.¶����ª�£µ �£ ��r©ª�£��Á��r��Ã��y¶j�$¤$©ª¢¦�[�«�6�[�ɤ �$�3�£¢¦�[ �¤����j¤��j�[�£�;�$�6ÃO¤iÌ& � ŮŠ�U� ?#@eC�deWUYpY ¬ ��k t � vOm3¨bd!M[zbCgEOE �e��KX�pS � QLYON!zO@yQLYbkDMOk!f�N!KLC�K�MG¥rM[WU��MOkyQ�Y ¬ Ú*C�WLWUS � K/h$YOkyQLC$PyQ��C$BDB'M Ú�C�WUw!E���� �

?#@eC�WLC ¬ YOWUCO¨®MOdede����h�MrQL��¥OC��e��Ka��BD����M[WU��QTS^��KgM�f3��WLCihªQ�hj@!M[WjMOh�QLC�WL��KLM[QL��YOk^Y ¬ �!M[WU�;C�f9h�YOk!zOWUNeC$k!h$C�Ybk��� ��k QU@eCRKUM[BDC��#M¦S MOK/zbWLYbNek!fDM[k�f CiM[WU��S �e��Ka��BD����M[WU�§QU��CiK�M[WUC�f3��WLCihªQ�hj@!MOWUMbhªQLC�WL��KUMrQL��YOk�K�Y ¬ ��M[WU��Cifh$YOkezbWLN!C$k!h$C�Ybk�QU@eCg����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K��_�k�QL@eC*����zO@yQ/Y ¬ QL@!��Khj@!M[WjMOh�QLC�WL��KLM[QL��YOk®¨iM[k!f�Y ¬ QU@eC ¬ MbhªQQL@!M[QM[d!de����h$M[QL��¥OC*�e��KL��B�����M[WU�§QTSG��KMcB'M[QL@3�

C�B'MrQL��h$MO����SgBDYOWUC�QUWUMbhªQUMO�e��C*WUC$��MrQU��Ybk�QL@�M[k���M[WU��Cif�h�YbkezOWUNeC�k!h�Cb¨r�*C#Ka@�M[���yd!WLC ¬ C$WQLY¸N!KLC�MOdede����h�MrQU��¥bC�!��KL��BD����MOWL��QTS.WjMrQU@eC$W�QL@�M[k¯�!M[WU�;C�f�h�YOk!zOWUNeC$k!h$CO�

0�� Æy�r� ´}iÆ �/� � � � � � � Ò Æ �

�´ó�â����

Page 52: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

���!��¤�©��;©L¤$�«�£�p¿R�j�3�������6�r�!�g�r�#���a�j�[ ����3 §�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª� nbv

� ̸À �p�[Í � �p�[�X���3¤ �¾©ª�3 �¤G�������r���j�e¤$©L�r���6�r���r £ ¡Á'¢r�r ¡�6Ã��£�^� �p¤g�j�[ £  �L¶ªÁ������rµ'¤c�'�a�U�[ ��$�3 ¡�p�jÊ�6Ì£¤iÌ�Ê/� �3�rÍ ���3�r�� �p¤$©L¤��������'����¤$©ªµ ÍX�£� � ��� ¬ ¥6#.'&��j�!� ��� �p�[�/�����2#. ��& �� �Ì

� ̸À �p�[Í � �p�[�����3¤ � ©ª�3 �¤�����¢¦�[ ¡�6Ã�� � ���D��¢r�r ¡�!¤�Ê��6Ì£¤�Ì�Êc� �G� � ¬ ¥6#����6� ��&����3¤��¾�����0#K#����6� �/&.� & � ���6� �¼Ì4 4 2 1 � > � @ 9 @ 7 E�E @ 9 @D> @ � : > � # � 7 < 7 @ 7 E�E

±9C.keYr�Öh�YbBDd!M[WUC�MOdede����h�MrQU��¥bC'�e��KL��B�����M[WU�§QTS¾����QL@É[email protected]¹bN!��¥rM[��C$k�h�CDYOk �e�«QUC$WUBDK���k!feN!h�CifÉ�ySÈQL@eCC�k!h�Y3f3��kezD��kbQUY'����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K��

� Æ��/Ð. £~� Å Ð ��� � � �¤�ÍX©ª�£��¤ � �,� � ) ) * * �! ) ) � * *ªÌ �¤��j�r £  � � �p¤ ��Y3h$M[��KTQUWLN!h�QLNeWUC¸Y ¬ QL@eC������kbQUC$WUdeWUC�QUM[QL��YOk�Ì

Ú�Cih$M[N�KaC¸Y ¬ Ý*YOWUYO����M[WUS �!� � me¨3��C�h$MOk���YOWU�.����QL@¯zOWUYONek�f��e��KL��BD����MOWL��QTSs³ � ·���k¯de��MOh$CgY ¬ �!M[WU��Cifh$YOkezbWLN!C$k!h$CO��ÙGWLYbNek!f��e��Ka��BD����M[WU�§QTS'��K�CiMOKL��C�W*QUY'�*YbWL�'����QL@(�

Æ3ÕÉ�3�¦Ï �/� � % ?#@eCcQLC$WUBD��k!YO��YOzOS ��k.Ç�C�×�ke�§QU��Ybk¾EOEb� xG��K�h$YOk!KL��KTQUC$kyQ����§QU@'QL@!CRKTQjM[k!f!M[Wjf�QUC$WUBD��keYb�§�YbzOS�Y ¬ QU@eCR�3��h$MO��h$Ne��N!K$�/?#@eC#��Yph�M[�eKaQLWUN!hªQUNeWUC�Y ¬ M��e��BDY3f3C��3��K/QU@eC�C�¹yN!MO����QTSgYOk.�e�«QUC$WUB'K/��k!feN!h�Cif �pSQU@!MrQcBDY3f3C���³£QT��Y.�3��QLC�WLB'K�M[WUCGC�¹yN!M[�÷� ¬ QL@eC�S�@!M¦¥bCRQU@eC�KLMOBDCG��kyQLC�WLdeWUC�QjMrQU��Ybk���k�QU@eCgBDY3f3C$�£·ª��?#@eCC�k!h�Y3f3��kez ) ) � * *�Y ¬ QU@eC��3��h$MO��h$Ne��N�K*��kyQLYD����h$M[��h�N!��N!K�zb��¥bC�K*WL��KaC�QLY'MD�3��BDY3f3C$����?#@e��K ¬ Yb����Yr�cK ¬ WLYbBÖQL@eC¬ MbhªQjKQL@!M[QXQL@eC�C�k!h�Y3f3��kez¸��KXh$YOBDd;YbKL�§QU��Ybk!M[�3M[k�f�QU@!MrQ���QX¥¦MO����feM[QLC�KQU@eCR��9�QU@eC$YbWLS.³�Ý*YOWUYO����MOWLS �!��Eimb·ªÂKLC$C� � M[k�vbx[M � ¬ YOW#QL@!C�f3C�QjM[����K�� �

Û!WLYbB QL@eCDMOf3Ci¹yN!MOh$S�Y ¬ QL@eCD��kyQLC$WUdeWUC�QjMrQL��YOk ³�Ý*YOWUYO����MOWLS �e��E � ·ª¨;�*CDh$MOk¾deWUYr¥OC���QUKGYbd�C�WUM[QL��YOk!MO�KLYON!k!f3keCiKLK��

& � Å � Å }� £~� Å Ð ��� � $ � � �£µ��� ¡�6¤�� �� �¼Ì

& � ŮŠ�U� ±9CG@�M¦¥OC�QLY'Ka@!Yr� QL@!M[Q ¬ YOWcM[���� Y � �� M[k!f�L®¨3� ¬ ) ) * *�� � ) ) � * * ��QU@eC$kH �� �-�/±sCC$P3de��Yb�§Q�QU@eC�hj@!MOWUMbhªQLC�WL��KUMrQL��YOk'Y ¬ �� MOK�YO�!KLC$WU¥rMrQU��Ybk�Ci¹bN!��¥rM[��C$k�h�C'³6?#@eC�YOWUC$B EbEO� mb·��Û!WLYbB ) ) * * � � ) ) � * * � ��C�f3C�f3N�h�C¸QL@�MrQ ) ) * * � �É� � ) ) � * * � ����?#@eC�WLC ¬ YOWUCGKL��k!h�C ) ) � * *(��Kch�YbB�d;YbKL��QL��YOk!MO�MOk!f � ��K�M�h�YbkezOWUNeC$k�h�CgYOk¾QL@eCDMOKLSpk!hj@eWUYOkeYbN!K#����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�¨ ¬ WUYOB ) ) * * � � ) ) � * * � ��C�MO��KLY�f3Cif3N!h�CQU@!MrQ ) ) � ) * * *�� � � � ) ) � ) � * * * � ��¨ ¬ YOWgMO����h$��YyKa��kez^�3��h$MO��h$Ne��N�KGh$YOkyQLC$PpQUK ��� � Y¯�ySsÝ*YbWLYb����M[WUS �e��E � ¨� ) * �É����� ) � * ��¨ ¬ YbWcM[kpS ��¨e��@e��hj@¯deWLYr¥bC�K�QL@!M[QG MOk!f �ØMOWLC¸YO��KaC�WL¥rMrQU��Ybk!M[����S�Ci¹yNe��¥rMO��C�kbQi�

± @!����CsKLYONek�f3keC�KUK���K�M keCih�CiKLKUM[WUS¼WUC�¹yNe��WLC�BDC$kyQ ¬ YOW¯M[k²��kyQLC�WLd!WLC$QUMrQU��Ybk®¨ch�YbBDde��C$QLC�keC�KUKs³´QL@eCh$YOkp¥OC�WUKLC¸Y ¬ KaYbNek!f3k!C�KUKU·#��KcM'¥bC$WUS�KaQLWUYOkez.f3C�B'M[k!f÷¨�YOkeC¸QU@!MrQ�Y ¬ QLC�k ¬ M[����K���±sC���YON!��f�keYOQRC�P3d;C�hªQQU@eCR����h$MO��h$Ne��N!K*KLC$B'MOkbQU��h�K�Y ¬ QU@eCg�3��h$MO��h$Ne��N�KXQLY ��CGh�YbB�d!��C$QLCOº�QL@!CGh$��MbKLKXY ¬ ����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K*h�YOkyQUC�PpQUK*��KB N!hj@�WL��hj@eC$W�QL@�M[k�QU@eC�h���MOKUKY ¬ �e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!K/h�YbkyQLC�PpQjK$¨[MOk!f�@!C$k!h$C*d;Y[QUC$kyQL��M[����SgBDYbWLC#f3��KLh$WL��BD��k!M[QL��kez!�_�k QU@eC^����h�M[��h�Ne��N!KDYbkeC^h$M[k C�P3deWUC�KUK�d!M[WjM[����C$����KLB M[k!f keYbk3��feC�QLC�WLBD��ke��KaB QU@!MrQi¨�MbK'f3��KLh$N!KLKLC�f ��k� C�hªQU��Ybk � � � ¨�MOWLC¸keYOQ�C�P3deWUC�KUKa���e��CG��k�QL@eC��e��h$M[��h�N!��N!K��\^YOWUC�h$YOk!h$WLC$QLC$��SO¨¦QU@eC$WUC�M[WUC�M[QX��CiMOKaQQT��YGWLCiMOKLYOk!K ¬ YOWXkeYOQXC�P3d�CihªQU��kezGQU@eC�����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K/KLC$B'M[kyQL��h$K

QUY��;C h$YOBDde��C�QLCb��?#@eC�×!WjKTQR@�MOK�QUY�f3Y����§QU@^QL@!C h$MO�������ySy��k!M[BDC Ý�V � QLWjM[k!K ¬ YOWUB¯¨ ¬ WUYOB ��@e��hj@^QL@eC����h$MO��h$Ne��N!K�C�k!h�Y3f3��kez¾�#MOK f3C$WU��¥bC�f÷�¾?#@!��K�QLWjM[k!K ¬ YOWUB¯¨MbK�M¯QUWUMOk!Ka��MrQU��Ybk-Y ¬ ������kyQUYs� ��¨/��K�keY[Q

â�â54�6!þ87:98;

Page 53: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

xOq � Ì(À��[�y¿O�6�r©«¿O�

h$YOBDde��C�QUCOºQL@eC�WLC�MOWLC�QLC�WLB'K#Y ¬ ��� QU@!MrQRMOWLC¸M[d!de����h$M[QL��¥OC¸�e��Ka��BD����M[W�³«M[k!f�QL@!C$WUC ¬ YOWUC¸YOd;C$WjMrQU��Ybk!M[����S��k!f3��KaQL��kezONe��KL@!M[�e��Ci·(�eN3Q/��@eYyKaC�Ý�V � ��B'M[zOCiK�MOWLC�f3��KTQU��kezbNe��Ka@!MO�e��C*MOK(QLC�WLB'KY ¬ � ���(_�Q/��KWUC�MOKLYOk�M[�e��CQUY�C�P3d;C�h�Q�QL@�MrQ�QU@eC�fe��KaQL��k!hªQU��Ybk!K*BDMbf3Cc�pS.� � h�YbkbQUC�PpQUK*h$MOk'��C�C�P3d�YyKaCifD�pS�����h$MO��h$Ne��N!K�h$YOkyQLC$PyQjK$�?#@!C�KLC�h�Ybk!f h$YOk!h$WLC$QLC.WUC�MbKaYbk ¬ YOW�keY[Q�C�P3d�CihªQU��kezsQL@!C�����h$M[��h�N!��N!K�KLC$B'M[kyQL��h$K�QLYs��C¯h�YbBDde��C$QLC���KKLYOBDC¯WUC�KLNe�§QjKDYOk QL@eC¾h�M[keYbke��h$M[�#BDY3f3C$�RY ¬ ��� � ?#@!��KDBDY3f3C$�R��K'f3C$×!keCif MbK�QL@eC¾KLYO��N3QU��Ybk¼QUYÉMfeYOB'M[��k Ci¹yN!MrQU��Ybk tc�eWjwyop¨�tc�eWjwOv����²?#@eC¯BDY3f3C$�R��K.KLYON!k!f¼�!N3Q.keY[Q�h$YOBDde��C�QUCO� Ý*YOBDde��C�QUC$keCiKLK¬ MO����K��;C�h�M[N!KLCGQL@eCgBDY3f3C$��h�YOkyQjM[��k!K�QL@eC f3C$keYOQUM[QL��YOk�Y ¬ QLC$WUB'K#QL@�MrQRM[WUC¸keY[QRfeC�×!k!MO�e��Cg��k¾���-¨!M[k�f��@!YbKLC�Mbfef3��QL��YOksQLY¾��� ��k!h�WUC�MbKaCiK�QL@eC'f3��KLh$WL��BD��k�MrQL��kez¯d;Yr�*C�WGY ¬ QU@eC'h�YOkyQUC�PpQUK¸Y ¬ QL@!C'��MOkezON!MOzOCb�]XP3MOBDde��CiK�M[WUC��j�r�!¢r¤$©«¿b¤$�;�j¤G��¤ª�ª�/M[k!f �e�r©L�[ £ �¤$ ÷�j�[�!¢r¤�©«¿y¤$�;�j¤���¤��ª�«¨ ¬ M[��WL��S KL��BDde��C�YOd;C$WjMrQUYOWjK#³6f3C$×!keC�f�;C$��Yr�R·�QL@!M[QcYOkeC¸C$Ppd;C�h�QUK#QUYD��CgC$Ppd!WLCiKLKL���!��C¸��k�����h$MO��h$Ne��N!K$�Ú�Y[QU@gQL@!C�Ý�V � QLWjM[k!K ¬ YOWUB M[k!fGQU@eC*BDY3f3C���K�Y ¬ ����Y �;C�W(zOYpY3f�h�M[k!f3��feM[QLC�K ¬ YOW/h�YbNekyQLC$WUC�PeMOB�d!��CiK

QUY#QL@eC*h�YOBDde��C�QUC$keCiKLK®Y ¬ QL@eC�����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K÷C�k!h�Y3f3��kez!�(±sC��;C$zb��kg�pS���YpYO�p��kezcMrQ(QL@eYyKaC ¬ WUYOB²QL@eC�BDY3f3C���KMbKQL@eC�S zb��¥bC#��k!KL��zO@yQ���kyQUYg��@!MrQ�B'M[�bC�KQU@eC�����h�M[��h�Ne��N!KXBDYbWLC�f3��KLh$WL��BD��k�MrQL��kez¸QU@!M[k�QL@!CR�3��h$MO��h$Ne��N�K$�Ý*Ybky¥bC$WUzOC�k!h�C*QLCiKTQ���K�M¸Nek!MOWLS�YOd;C$WjMrQLYbW�¨��;¨rQU@!MrQ�h$M[kDf3C$QLC�h�Q���@eC$QL@eC�W��§QjK�M[WUzON!B�C�kyQXh$YOkp¥OC�WLzbC�K�Â

��Qc��K�f3C�×!k!C�f��pS'QL@eCiKaCgWUNe��C�K�º

��� �

� �;4= # �! U;4= �� �;4=�� �

V/M[WjM[����C$��h�Ybkp¥OC$WUzOC�k!h�C�QLCiKTQ���K�M��e��k!M[WUS¾YOd;C$WjMrQUYOWi¨ ¨®QL@�MrQ�h$MOk-f3C�QUC�hªQ���@!C�QL@!C$WgC$��QL@!C$W�Y ¬ ��QUKMOWLzbNeBDC$kyQUK#h$YOkp¥OC�WLzbC�K�Âb��Qc��K�feC�×!keCif��yS�QL@eCiKaC¸WUNe��C�K�º

� �� � =�# � �, ;4=�#

�� U;>=�QP �"= P � �� �;4=�QP �, = �, P� C�QR��D�;C����Ø����[email protected]@eCgMOfefe�§QU��Ybk�Y ¬ h�Ybky¥bC$WUzOC�k!h�C#QUC�KaQ�¨eM[k�f�� ��C���� ����QL@�QL@eCgMbfef3��QL��YOk�Y ¬

d�M[WjM[����C���h$YOkp¥OC�WLzbC$k!h$CcQUC�KaQ��X_�k¾� ¨!h$YOkp¥OC�WLzbC$k!h$CcQUC�KaQc��K�f3C$×!k!MO�e��C�MbK� $&%('� ) ��RC$WUCDMOWLC�QT��Y�QUC$WUB'KGQL@!M[Q�M[WUC Ybd�C�WUM[QL��YOk!MO����S^��k�f3��KaQL��kezbNe��KL@!MO�e��CD��k9QL@eCDdeNeWUC.�3��h$MO��h$Ne��N!K¸�eN3Q

QU@!MrQRh�M[k���C�MOWLC¸f3��KTQU��k!zONe��Ka@!C�f���k¾���;º

$&%('� �����0# ��#����6�0# � * ) �4&5&(**&� $&%('� �����0# ��# ��* ) & **&� ³«myo[·

?#@!C�KLC�QUC$WUB'K�M[WUC ¬ N!WaQU@eC$Wcf3��KUh�N!KUKaCif���k^H�C$B'MOWL�¾Eime� ve�

Æ3ÕÉ�3�¦Ï �/� � ?#@eC�WLC¾MOWLCsM[��KaY¼�e�«QUC$WUB'KDQL@!M[Q�MOWLC^��k!f3��KTQU��k!zONe��Ka@�M[�e��C¾��k²�� �eN3Q�QL@!M[Q�h$MOk ��Cfe��KaQL��kezON!��KL@eC�f���k^� @��4Y F¸����QL@�QL@eCg@!C$��d�Y ¬ QU@eCgd!MOWUMO����C$�÷h�Ybkp¥OC$WUzOC�k!h�CRQLCiKTQi¨!KaC�C� Ú � v � ��� �

�RYr�g¨bQUY�deWUYr¥OC#QU@!MrQ�QL@!CR����h$M[��h�N!��N!K�KLC$B'M[kyQL��h$K���K�KaQLWU��h�QL��S ×�keC$W*QL@!MOk.QU@eCRYbd�C�WUM[QL��YOk!MO��KLC$B'M[k3�QU��h�K¸Y ¬ QL@eC.�e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�¨®�§Q�KLN��.h�CiK�QLY^Ka@!Yr�&QL@!M[Q�h�Ybky¥bC$WUzOC�k!h�C�YbW¸d!M[WjM[����C��Xh�YOkp¥bC$WUzOC$k�h�C�QUC�KaQ�M[WUCfeC�×!k!MO�e��CG��k¯����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�� �cC$WUC�M[WUC�QL@eC���WRfeC�×!ke��QL��YOk�K$º

) ) � * * $&%('� # L$&� ��� # � # � &K� ) ) # * *�� N ) ) * *��B& � ¬ WUC�KL@ ³«mOwb·) ) � * * $&%('� # L$&�0# � � Y � Y Q &K# � # � &� Q N � # ��&K� Q N ) ) * *��+N ) ) � * * NQ4� ) ) # * *�� & ³«mOvb·

� Y � Y,Q ¬ WUC�KL@

�´ó�â����

Page 54: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

���!��¤�©��;©L¤$�«�£�p¿R�j�3�������6�r�!�g�r�#���a�j�[ ����3 §�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª� x3E

0�� Æy�r� ´}iÆ �/� � �� ÌgÀ �p�[Í ���3�r� ) ) �3����� * * � ) ) # * *LÊ�Í��p¤$©L¤j�¦� ) ) � ) * * � ) ) ) * *ªÌ� ̸À �p�[Í ���3�r�«Ê!���r©��[ £ 4 Y � ^� �

��� � ) ) #������'& � * * � ) ) # * *aÊ��[�;à ) ) ��#������'& * * � ) ) # * * ��a¶ � ) ) )3) & * * � ) ) ) * *ªÌ� Å � Å�Ò´Ò �3�¦à �/� � ��2 � Ð Å Ð÷áj� Å Õ-� Ò Æb~iÆ3Ð(Æp}i} Å �#~ � Æ � á8 6Ð;~�Æy���(�rÆy~��e~� Å Ð � �� � ÃO�i¤ª���;�r�#�£µ ��; ¡Á �� �¼Ì

& � ŮŠ�U� ?M[�OC¾QL@eCsQLC�WLB'K^ M[k!f � ��k ³6myoO·ª��?#@eCiKaCÈQLC$WUB'K�MOWLCsM[dede����h$MrQU��¥bCÈ�e��KL��BD����MOW9³«KaC�CHcC$B'M[WU�¾E�m!� vy·ª� �cYr��C$¥bC$Wi¨ ��� � ³«]/P3C$Wjh���KaCDEOEb��EbEi·�� �

0�� Æy�r� ´}iÆ �/� � ��� ½�©L�[¢¦¤D� �p�[� ) ) * * �� ) ) � * *LÊ����[© Y �I�¦� �£� � � � �OÌ � �g�£�!� � �;©L�r¢r¤�� �p�r� ) ) � * * � ��) ) � � * * � Ê*�r��Ãc���[©g���y�����p��¤ � Jp¤�©U�����$¤ � � Ì � Ì �±9C�B'M¦SGkeYr�-MOKL����@!C�QL@!C$W®QU@eC#MOfef3��QL��YOkgY ¬ d!M[WjM[����C$�Oh$YOkp¥OC�WLzbC$k!h$C�QUC�KaQ(QUYG������K�C$k!YONezb@¸QLYczb��¥bC

QU@eC'KLMOBDC f3��KLh$WL��BD��k�MrQL��kez�d�Yr��C$W¸MOKRQL@!C�����h$MO��h$Ne��N!K$��?#@!C�h�M[keYbke��h�M[�/f3YOB'MO��ksB�Y3f3C��XBDC$kyQL��YOkeCifCiM[WU����C$W���K ¬ N!����S�MO�!KaQLWjMOhªQ ¬ YbW�� ¨!QL@eC�WLC ¬ YOWUCGQUMOhj�p����k!zDQL@e��KR¹yNeCiKTQU��Ybk���KRMO��KLY'h�YbB�d�M[WU��kez�QU@eC�BDY3f3C$�����QL@ QL@eCs����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K���kyQLC�WLd!WLC$QUMrQU��Ybk®�&±9CsKL@!M[����KLC$C¾��k QU@eCÈkeC$PpQ�KLC�hªQU��Ybk QL@!M[Q�QU@eCsMOk!Ka��C$W���Kk!C$zbM[QL��¥OCbº�QU@eCg����h$M[��h�N!��N!K�KLC$B'MOkbQU��h�K#��K�KaQLWU��hªQL��S'×!k!C$Wi�

0�� Æy�r� ´}iÆ�� ��� � � Ì�� �b���g¤KJp¤$©L�����$¤¸�£��¢��£��¤���� �p¤G©L¤j�OÃb¤�©G���c�;©L�r¢r¤¸� �p�[���£�¯���3¤��j�£µ��� �¤�©�¤$�;�j��Ã[�£�y¿'�a��j�[ £  �L¶ªÁ������rµ'¤g�£�����b¶� �¤ Ê��j�r�!¢r¤$©«¿b¤$�;�j¤¸��¤��j�X���¸�;�[�*ÃO¤ �����b¶� �¤¸� �GÍ�¤��[�! ¡Á��p�$¤¸� �p¤��ª�3¤$©L�r���r©j���T�G� �p¤�r�ªÁr�;� �b©L�[�;�r�p�c���a�j�[ ����3 §�p��Ì � ���.µ'�¦Ë[¤����3¤�¤Jp¤�©U�����$¤��j�£µ��� �¤�©jÊ�Í�¤�Í��[©jËDÍX�£� �.¿[©L�[�3�;Ã�¶ª���ª�£µ��3 ��r���6�r��£�!�ª��¤j�OÃ9�T��¶L�[©�¶U¤UÃ9�j�r�p¿[©ª�!¤$�;�j¤iÌ � ��¤$� � ¶U¤����3¤�¤$�;�j�iÃr�£�p¿9�a� ���b¶� �¤ ÌȽ#©L�r¢r¤����3�r�G���3¤�©L¤����'�;��j�[�!��¤KJb� � �a�¸���3¤ �r�ªÁr�;� �b©L�[�;�r�p�c���a�j�[ ����3 §�p�g�[�;Ã'���rµ'¤ � �ª�!� ��� �p�[�

� ) � ) ) * * *�� * � � ) ) # * * �� ) � ) ) ) * *�� * � � ) ) ) * * �

� ���£�!� � �;©L�r¢r¤ªÊ�¶ªÁ.�£��Ãr�!�$�«�6�[�9�[� -/Ê����3�r�����3¤�©U¤����g�;� -����È�r��Ã��j�[�!��¤KJb� �­�ª�!� ��� �p�r�� ) � ) ) * * * � * #5;6= & 3 � � � � �;4= ��� � � ) ) ��* * � ) � ) ) ) * *�� * � � ) ) ) * * �

��r©����y���UÊ�©L¤j�¦�$�r�¼¶�Á��j�r���«©L�bÃr�6�$�«�6�[�;Ì����r�^µ��§¿��b���;¤j¤jÃ��r  �$�����3¤����r £ ��[ÍX�£�y¿¯©L¤��ª�3 ¡� � ���r©��[ £  7L®ÊCM:Y S�Ê� � � 7L�# MFNS-& � ���3¤��É�r  �$� � 7L+M � Ì �

� . ��� ���c���� ���� � ���?�G�e����"$����"$���±9Cg@!M¦¥bC¸KLC$C�k�QL@!M[Q�QL@eCg������kyQUC$WUdeWLC$QUM[QL��YOk���KcKLYON!k!f��!N3QRkeYOQ ¬ Ne����S�MO�!KaQLWjMOhªQi�X±sCgk!Yr� KaQLN!f3S�@eYr�QUY�MOhj@!��C�¥OC ¬ Ne���MO�!KaQLWjMOhªQU��Ybk¯�yS�C$k!WL��hj@e��kezDQL@eCD�3��h$MO��h$Ne��N!K$��±9C�@!M¦¥bC�M[��WLCiMOf3S�KaC�C$k^C$PyQUC$k!KL��YOk!K�Y ¬QU@eCg�3��h$MO��h$Ne��N�K$ºX��DYb�3QUMO��k!C�f'�pS'MOfefe��kez h�YOkp¥bC$WUzOC$k�h�C#QLCiKTQi¨3M[k!f�� YO�eQUM[��keCif'�pSDMbfef3��kez�d�M[WjM[����C��h$YOkp¥OC�WLzbC$k!h$C�QLCiKTQi��tckeYOQL@eC�W���kyQUC$WUC�KaQL��kez�C$PyQUC$k!KL��YOk���Kc���YO�3QjM[��keC�f��pS.MOfef3��kez QL@eCD�3���U�[�;Ã[�£�«�6�[�;�r � �p�[�6�j¤�³6YOWg�£����¤$©ª�;�[ ����3�r�6�j¤¦·#YOd;C$WjMrQUYOW��f3C$×!keCif��pS

� ��> �R;4=� �

�> �R;4= �

â�â54�6!þ87:98;

Page 55: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

x � � Ì(À��[�y¿O�6�r©«¿O�

0�� Æy�r� ´}iÆ � � � � Jb��¤���Ã'� �p¤ ¤����U�iÃr�£�p¿¯�T� ���b¶� �¤ ! �����r�ɤ����j��Ã[�£�y¿��T�R���Ì_�k.zbC$keC�WUMO�!�pS'M[k'Ybd�C�WUM[QLYOW��*C�B�CiM[k�M�KaSpB��;YO�;����[email protected]�f3N�hªQL��YOk�WLNe��C�K*f3C�×�ke��k!z���QUK*��C�@!M¦¥p��YbNeW�º

� Æ��/Ð. £~� Å Ð �� � � KL��zbk!MrQUNeWUC�� ���È�^�e�r�£©H#���Y � &¯Í��3¤�©U¤��,���s� ��¤$���a� YOd;C$WjMrQLYbW.KaSpB ��Yb��K$ÊÃ[��� �$�r�£�!���j©L�[µ­� �p¤g��¤$���a���3��¢r�r©ª�6�y¶ª �¤��jÊ#�[�;à � �����.WjM[k!� ¬ N!k!hªQU��Ybk Í��b�6� �^�r�j�j�§¿O�e���r�9�r©ª�£��Á'���.¤j�b����ª�3¤$©L�[���[©¸�jÁrµ.¶U�r �Ì

� Æ��/Ð. £~� Å Ð �� � � �´��� � #���Y � &.�����È�ª�§¿[���r���3©L¤����3¤�� ���3¤���¤$�X��� �a� �3��QLC�WLB'K�C�PpQLC�k!f3C�fÉ����QL@Ybd�C�WUM[QLYbWUK*��k�� ����ÃO¤ ����¤jÃ�¶�Á

U� � L>�� ]0]0] ����!���D����� �\�� �� Y Í��p¤$©L¤ L ���Ì ³6nbqb·

����C�PpQLC�k!f3C�fD�e�«QUC$WUB­���c�¸µ'¤�µ.¶U¤�©c�T���$�[µD¤ ���¸Ì �¤#ÍX©ª�£��¤ ���/���r©�� �p¤#�ª��¶���¤$©ªµ �#�T����²ÍX�£���3�r�3��j©U¤U¤�¢r�r©ª�6�b¶� �¤�� �����3¤ �$ ��¦�$¤jÃ���¤$©ªµ�� �OÌ

?�Y�f3C$×!keC�QU@eCc�;C$@!M¦¥p��YONeW�Y ¬ C�PpQLC�k!f3C�f.�e��QLC$WUB'K$¨y��C�keC$CifDYOd;C$WjMrQL��YOk�M[�eWUNe��C�K ¬ YbW�QL@!CcYOd;C$WjMrQUYOWjKY ¬ QU@eC#C�PpQLC�k!Ka��YOk(��_�k�zOC�keC$WjM[��¨¦QL@eC#Ybd�C�WUM[QL��YOk!MO�bWUNe��C�K/Y ¬ M[k YOd;C$WjMrQLYbWXM[WUC*Y ¬ QT��Y��p��k!feK�º�¤$¢¦�[ ¡�!�r���6�r�©ª�3 �¤ª�'KaN�hj@ÉMbK �$e¨ �� ; � ¬ YOWgC$¥rMO��N!M[QL��kez^M[WUzONeBDC�kbQjK¸Y ¬ M[kÉYOd;C$WjMrQUYOWi¨®M[k!f � ��©ª�3 �¤��DKLN!hj@-MOK ���O¨ �(; e¨ � ��; ¬ YOWRB'MOke��d!Ne��M[QL��kez'QU@eC Ybd�C�WUM[QLYbW��c?�Y.zO��¥OC M ¬ YOWUB'M[��feC�×!ke��QL��YOksY ¬ QL@!C�KLC��p��k�feKRY ¬WUNe��C�K�¨[��C�k!C$C�fDMGBDC�QjM[��M[kezbN!M[zbC ¬ YbW/QUM[���p��k!z�M[�;YON3Q/QLC�WLB'KXY ¬ M¸zbC$keC�WL��h�C$PpQLC$k�f3C�f'�e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!K��?#@eCzbWUMOBDBDMOW ¬ YbWRQU@eCDB�C$QUMO��MOkezON!MOzOC���K*ZTN!KaQGQU@!MrQ¸Y ¬ QL@eCDC�PpQUC$k!f3Cifs�e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�³«ÙGWjM[BDB'M[WGnbqy·cde��N!KBDC$QUM¦¥rM[WU��MO�e��C�K���±9C�@�M¦¥OC�N!KLC�f¯��C�QLQLC�WUK M[k!f � ¬ YbWRBDC�QjM¦¥rM[WU��MO�e��CiKcKLY ¬ M[Wi¨;KLY.��C�KaQL��hj��QUY.QL@!��Kh$YOkp¥OC�kyQL��YOk®�.±9C.��WU�§QUC � ���B#.��LY0]2]0]0Y� 3 &R� ¬ � ��K�M^h$��YyKaCifsBDC$QUMrQUC$WUB QU@!MrQ BDM¦S9h�YbkbQjM[��kBDC$QUM¦¥rM[WU��MO�e��C�K#M[BDYOk!z\ � Y0]2]0] Y��3��� Æ��/Ð. £~� Å Ð �� � � � Ñ Æ Ò´Ò á � Å �[ÕÉÆpÓ Å ��Æy�¦�e~ Å �¦}�� �(¤$��� ��#���Y � &�¶U¤��D�ª�§¿O�;�r���3©L¤ �r�;Ã;L ���Ì

���i��WUNe��C ¬ YbW Lɳ´��k��#·������r�9�2Jb�6�rµ �T�g� �p¤*���r©ªµ@L��C� ��� #�F

L> � ]2]0]� ���;4= �

# � @ � Y0]2]0] - FÍ��3¤�©U¤ � Z���B#. � Y0]0]2]0Y�

���&ªÌ ���s� �b���D�U�r�$¤ªÊ#Í�¤'�r  �$���$�rÁ����3�r�#���3¤�©ª�3 �¤ QLCiKTQjKRd;YbKL��QL��YOk��UÊ;���[©

�[ £ �� #÷Ì���9C$¥rM[��N!M[QL��YOk3��WLN!��C ¬ YOW Lɳ´��k��#·g�����r�s�£����¤$©L¤$�;�j¤�©ª�3 �¤ �a�¸���3¤����[©ªµ

�� ;4=�QP�L> � ]0]2]K�� ]2]0]

���;4= L> � ]0]2]K P� ]2]0]

���

� Z@ � Y0]2]0] Y � # L$&KFD¤¸�$�rÁ����3�r��� �p¤�©ª�3 �¤ C$¥rMO��N!M[QLCiK#d�YyKa��QL��YOk���Ì��¤�� � ¶U¤¯�^�$¤$�¸�a��� ��©ª�3 �¤����r�;Ã9¤$¢¦�[ ¡�!�r���6�r� ©ª�3 �¤��c���r©�� �p¤¯�ª�3¤$©L�r���r©j�.�£���­�ª�!� �9� �p�[����[©��r £ 

L �� �[�;à ������� � # L$&LÊ�� �¸�£� ��� �p¤$©L¤¸������� ��©ª�3 �¤X���[© LÉ� �p�[����¤ª�ª�«���e�¦�ª�£�«�6�[�������3¤��^� �p¤$©L¤¸�����r  �$��[� ¤$¢¦�[ ¡�!�r���6�r� ©ª�3 �¤����r©DL � �p�[�G¤$¢¦�[ ¡�!�r��¤��D� �p�[���e�¦�ª�£���6�r�;Ì �ª�-� �b���.�j�¦�$¤ªÊ�Í�¤D�$�rÁ^� �p�[�(#��GY;�!& ���'�KLd;C�h���×�h�MrQL��YOk�Y ¬ �*C������ ¬ YOWUB�Cif�Ybd�C�WUM[QLYbWUK¦Ì

� Æ��/Ð. £~� Å Ð �� � � �´�! ��� ��R#��GY�� &*���R�����3¤j�$� �*�j�r���6�r�¯�T��Í�¤$ £  �¡���r©ªµ'¤jÃD�j�e¤�©L�[���[©j�jÊ/�r��ÃG Y � ���RÊÍ�¤ ÍX©ª�£��¤ ;4=�" �,� �G ;4= �,��� ÃO¤$©ª�£¢r�b¶� �¤c�j©L�[µ ���3¤ ©ª�3 �¤ª���£� � ���L¿y¤$���3¤�©�ÍX�£� �^���3¤ ©ª�3 �¤ª�G9�[�;Ã

O�T�c���¼Ì

�´ó�â����

Page 56: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

���!��¤�©��;©L¤$�«�£�p¿R�j�3�������6�r�!�g�r�#���a�j�[ ����3 §�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª� x[m

®�3©ª� �p¤$©jÊ;� ���R� �p¤¸¤JO��¤$�;ÃO¤jÃ��3�a�j�r ����3 ¡�p�cÍX�£� �D�$¤��X�T�R��¤$©ªµ�� �� �r��à ©L¤jÃr�!�$�«�6�[��©L¤$ ��r���6�r�^;4= " Ì� �3¤g©ª�3 �¤��R�£� �����U¿b¤$���3¤�©GÍX�£� �.���3¤¸©ª�3 �¤�� 9 �r��à O �[©L¤gQU@eCGYOd;C$WjMrQL��YOk�M[�!WUNe��C�K*Y ¬ � ¸Ì �R¤$ ��r���6�r�

����" ���g���3¤�©U¤K/�¤JO�£¢r¤��r�;Ã.�«©U�r�e�ª�£���£¢¦¤��$ ��¦�ª�3©L¤��T� ;4=�"Ê*�r��à � " ��µ'¤j�r�!�X ����" � �pÌ

± @!C$k¾QU@eC$WUC���KGkeY¯M[B �e��zbNe��QTSO¨��*C�f3WUYOdÈKLYOBDC���k!fe��h$C�K�¨÷��WL��QL��kezI�� ¬ YOW ���¨8;6= � ³6YOWGC$¥OC�k;6=¼· ¬ YbW ;4=��X¨!M[k!f^�� � � ³´YbW�C$¥OC�k^�� �È· ¬ YOW��� " � �?#@!C�WUC�Mbf3C$W�BD��zb@bQ#�����bCRQUY�hj@eCihj�DQL@!M[Q*QU@eC¸WLN!��CiK*f3CiKLh$WL���e��kez QL@eCGYOd;C$WjMrQUYOWjK �4Y ¨ ����k�QL@!��K�MOk!f

��k�QL@eCgd!WLC�¥y��YON�K�KLC�h�QL��YOk!K�¨p×eQ�QU@eC ¬ YOWUB'MrQ�Y ¬ ÇRC$×!ke��QL��YOkÉE � � n��

� Æ3Õ-ÕÉ� � � % ��¤$� �Q#��GY�� &¸�[�;à ^��� [Ì �6�(�;>= " ��� �p¤$� � �����[Ì0�� Æy�r� ´}iÆ � � $ D¤¯�U�[� ÃO¤ ���;¤^�[� �j�e¤�©L�[���[©�� ���3�r��¤J$��©L¤��j��¤����j�r £  �L¶ªÁ���¢r�r ¡�!¤È�j�O�; ¡�6�j�r���6�r��Ì ���6�©ª�3 �¤ª�g�p�$¤��[�9�r� Jb�£ ¡�6�[©ªÁ��j�e¤$©L�r���r©�� P �

� ��;4=�QP

� � ;4=�� P � � �� �R;4=�� P �

� P � �T;4= �HP� P �T;>=�� � P � P � �

� P � ;4=� � ��r© /�� �¤�� ¶U¤D���3¤D��¤�©ªµØ�a�G��@� Y� PEFÈ�b¶����r�£�;¤jÃȶ�Á�©L¤��; ��O�$�£�y¿s�r £ /�ª��¶���¤$©ªµ��D�T� �a��� �p¤���[©ªµ' � � ÍX�£� ��� � � Ì�À �p�[ͼ� �p�r�X� �* Y � ^� )[Ê� �p¤$�\U;4= � � � � #K;4= ���

�� ��� & � � Ì

� Æ��/Ð. £~� Å Ð �� � �(¤$� ���#��GY;�!&g¶L¤ �����3¤j�$� �*�j�r���6�r�9�T�¸Í�¤$ £  �¡���r©ªµ'¤jÃ��ª�3¤$©L�r���r©j�$Ì �¤g�$�rÁD���3�r� ����Ý*@pNeWjhj@3��HcYbKUKaC�W �¦Ý�H ��� � ����" �3�¦�����3¤�» �y�3©L� � ���R�r�j��¤$©c�;©L�j�e¤$©ª�«Á �c� �p�[�����jÊ®���r©'�r £ $ Y �HYK+ ��RÊ�� �� ����" � �r��Ã! ����"I+�ÊX� �p¤$�È� �p¤$©L¤����(QP��ª�!�������3�r� � ����" QP#�r��à + ����" QP�̱9C#KaYbB�C$QL��BDC�K/M[�e�!WLC�¥y��MrQUC�QU@eC�QUC$WUBD��keYb��YbzOSb¨¦KUM¦Sp��k!zcQL@�MrQ � ��K/MRKLC�Q/Y ¬ �*C������ ¬ YbWLBDCifgYOd;C$WjMrQUYOWjK

YbW�¨3� ¬ = � ��K�Ý�Hg¨eQL@!M[Q �Ö��K�Ý�H�� � �!KLC$WU¥OC�QL@!M[Q#� ¬ = � ��K�f3C$QLC�WLBD��ke��KaQL��hGQL@!C$k�� ��K�Ý�Hg�?#@!C�KaC$QUK\@ �>F�M[k!f @ F�MOWLC�Ý�Hg�Ú*NeQ�B'M[kpSÈYbd�C�WUM[QLYOWjK¸�eWUC�MO�¾QL@!C�Ý�HÖdeWUYOd;C$WLQTSO��t°Ka��BDde��C

C$PeM[BDde��C���K¸Nek!h$YOk!fe�§QU��Ybk!M[�Xhj@eYb��h$C �®Â ¬ YbWg��k�KTQjM[k!h$CO¨÷��C�@�M¦¥OC���YOQL@�� ) # ��� ) MOk!f � ) # ��� #�¨�!N3Q3#DMOk!f ) @!M¦¥OC�keY�h$YOBDBDYOk�f3C$WU��¥rM[QL��¥OCO�/tck�C$¥bC$k�KL��B�d!��C�W�C$PeM[BDde��C�Y ¬ M�k!YOk3�aÝ�H YOd;C$WjMrQUYOW���K��� f3C$×!keC�f��pS.QU@eCgWLN!��CiK

� � ����� ;4=� � �

��� �;6= )³«?#@e��K�YOd;C$WjMrQUYOW#��K�feC�×!k!MO�e��C ¬ WLYbB ��QL@pN!K�º ��� $&%('� � ) ·��?�Y�zbC$keC�WUMO����KLC�QL@eC¸f3C$×!ke��QL��YOk�Y ¬ M[d!de����h$M[QL��¥OC��e��KL��B�����M[WU�§QTS�QLY�M[k�C�PpQLC�k!f3C�f��3��h$MO��h$Ne��N!K$¨y��CGMbfef

M'h$��MON!KLC ¬ YbWc��kbQUC$WUk!M[�®MbhªQU��¥p��QTSs³6h$��MON!KLCD³ � ·#Y ¬ Ç�C�×�ke�§QU��YbkÉE � � v���C���Yr�R·���?#@e��Kch���M[N�KaCg��K���B�d;YOWLQUMOkyQ� ¬ QL@!CGKLC�Q�Y ¬ YOd;C$WjMrQUYOWjKX��K�keY[QcÝ�Hg¨ ¬ YOW*feC�QLCihªQU��kez�QL@eC��eWjM[k!hj@e��kez�KaQLWUN!hªQUNeWUCRY ¬ QUC$WUBDK�¨pMOK�]XP3MOBDde��CE � ��E�q¾KL@eYr�cK��9?#@!C�h$��MON!KaC�h$MOk ��C�YOBD��QaQUC�f ��@!C$k QU@eC¯MOfef3Cif-YOd;C$WjMrQUYOWjK�MOWLC�Ý�H­Ka��k!h$C�QU@eC$k MfeC$WU��¥rMrQU��¥bC¸Y ¬ M�QUC$WUB���K��e��Ka��BD����M[W�QLYDQU@!MrQ�QUC$WUB ³ � C$BDB'M¯E � ��Eimb·ª�

� Æ��/Ð. £~� Å Ð �� � � �(¤$�� � #��GY�� &�¶U¤'�����3¤j�$� �*�j�r���6�r� �T� Í�¤� £  �¡���[©ªµD¤jÃs�j�e¤�©L�[���[©j�$Ì ���ªÁrµ µ'¤$�«©ª�6�©U¤� ��[�«�6�[� � � ���� � ���D�����r��MOdede����h�MrQU��¥bC ����e��KL��B Ne��M[QL��YOk-� ��� � �£µR�; ¡�6¤ª� �

� ÌgÍ��3¤���¤�¢r¤$©! ����" �����QP«Êc� �p¤$©L¤D��� �HP��ª�!� �¾���3�r� � ����" ����� �HP��[�;Ã�QP @�BCED>F � �,P @ C D�FbÊ���[© �r £ 4+ ^�����

â�â54�6!þ87:98;

Page 57: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

x[n � Ì(À��[�y¿O�6�r©«¿O�

� Ì�Í��3¤���¤�¢r¤$©� ��� " QP6Ê�� �p¤$©L¤���� �HP��ª�!�������3�r� � ��� " �HP��[�;à QP � �,P�Ì�(Í��'��¤$©ªµ��X Y � �� �N���'�r©L¤RM[dede����h$MrQU��¥bC ����e��Ka��BD����M[W�ÊXÍX©ª�£�«��¤$�N � " �-Ê�� �:�� �

�3�r �Ãr�jÊ����r©g�$�[µD¤��j�b�� ¡�6�j�r���£¢r¤ �L¶ª���ª�£µ��3 ��r���6�r� �sÌ

_�Q#��K�CiMOKLS�QUY�KLC$CRQL@!M[Q � "^��K*MOk.C�¹yNe��¥rM[��C$k!h$C�WUC$��MrQU��Ybk®�#³´_�k!f3C�C�f��§Q#��K#M h�YOk!zOWUNeC$k!h$CO¨yMOK�h$M[k���Cd!WLYr¥bC�f.N�Ka��kez �cYr��C � K*QLC�hj@!ke��¹yNeC� �cYr�cv ����� ·tRzbM[��k®¨X� ¬ �R@ #���Y � &Y�� F¯�*C�KaYbB�C$QL��BDC�KDf3WUYOd-��k!f3��h�C�KDMOk!f-��WU�§QUC � � ¬ YOW � " �ÉÛ!NeWLQL@eC�W�¨

��@!C$k�����K�M.Ka��kezb��C$QLYOk/@ L$Fy¨!��C���WL��QLC � � ¬ YOW � " �cH�C$��MrQU��Ybk � " ��KRC$PpQLC$k�f3C�f�QUY.YOd;C$k^QUC$WUB'Kc��kQU@eCgN!KLN!M[�÷�#M¦SO¨p�pS�BDCiM[k!K#Y ¬ h���YbKL��kez'KaNe��KTQU�§QUN3QL��YOk!K��

0�� �!Õ-� Ò Æ � � � 2 �ª� �p�[ �æ�s���3�r� # �� ����# ) Ê �ª�£���U¤s� �p¤s ��[�«��¤�© �3�¦�È� �p¤È©L¤jÃr�!�$���6�r� ��# ) ��� )Í��y�6���.� �p¤���[©ªµD¤$©G�j�r���;�[�µ'�r��� �pÌ�� �y���¸Ã[���j���£�;�$���6�r�¯���c�$¤��!�ª�«¶ª �¤�Ê�j�£���j¤ #¾�[ ¡Í��rÁ¦�g�O�j�j¤��;�6�G�[���£�O���3�Í��3¤�©U¤U�r� ��# ) �j�r� �r ¡���^©L¤6�j�p�$¤��£��Ì � �p¤.��¤$©ªµ �;#¼�r��à ��# ) Í��[�3 �þ¶U¤.¤ ���!�[��¤jÃ�ÍX�£� �p�r�3�G�� ��[�p�$¤ � � ��a� � ¤ �����£�«�6�[� � � Ì � Ì

Æ3ÕÉ�3�¦Ï � � ��� ?#@eC ¬ YbWLB'MrQ®Y ¬ QL@eC�WUNe��C�K®QL@!M[Q(�*C�@!M¦¥OCXN!KLC�f ¬ YbW(f3C$×!ke��kezc��C$���§� ¬ YOWUBDC�fGYOd;C$WjMrQUYOWjKC�k!KLNeWLCiK�QU@!MrQ�QL@!CGYbd�C�WUM[QLYbWUK*M[WUCR��C$���§����C�@!M¦¥OCif÷¨y��k�QL@eC¸KaC�k!KLCRQU@!MrQ�QL@eC���W#�;C$@!M¦¥p��YONeW#f3C�d�C�k!feK�YOke��SYbkÈQU@eC'KaC�B'M[kyQL��h$K�F keYOQgYOksQL@eC'KLSykyQjMrP^F Y ¬ QL@!C$��WgYOd;C$WjM[k!feK��D?#@eC ¬ YOWUBDM[Q¸h�M[d3QUNeWUC�KgM���MOWLzbCMOk!f���kyQUC$WUC�KaQL��kez.h���MOKUK#Y ¬ KLN!hj@¯�*C��������;C$@�M¦¥OC�f�YOd;C$WjMrQUYOWjK$¨p�eNeQRkeY[QGM[���®Y ¬ QL@eC�B¯��Û!YOWc��k!KaQUM[k�h�CO¨!QL@eC¬ YbWLB'M[Q�MO����Yr�cK*QL@eCgC�¥rM[��N!MrQU��Ybk�Y ¬ QL@!C�M[WUzONeBDC$kyQ#Y ¬ M[k�YOd;C$WjMrQUYOWi¨y�!N3QRf3YpC�K#keYOQcM[����Yr� C$¥rM[��N!MrQU��k!zKLN!hj@ M[k MOWLzbNeBDC$kyQ ��k KLYOBDC¯h�YbkbQUC�PpQ�� tR��KLY!¨�QL@eC ¬ YOWUB'MrQ'f3YpC�K keY[Q.MO����Yr��WLN!��CiK�����QL@ keC$zyMrQU��¥bCd!WLC�B���KLC�K��¼?#@eC ¬ YOWUBDM[QDh�M[k ��C�C�PpQUC$k!f3Cif¼��k KaC�¥OC$WjM[���#M¦SpK�QLYÉh$MOd3QLN!WLC���MOWLzbC$WDh���MOKUKaCiK�Y ¬ ��C$���§��;C$@�M¦¥OC�f.YOd;C$WjMrQLYbWUK��_�Q#��K�zOYpY3f'QUY WUC�MO����KaCb¨p@eYr�*C�¥OC�W�¨bQL@!M[Q*QU@eC ¬ YOWUB'MrQ��U�[�!���r��¶U¤��[©�¶ª�£��©L�[©ªÁr¨e� ¬ �*C����KL@�QU@eC#��C�@!M¦¥p��YbNeW/Y ¬ Ybd�C�WUM[QLYbWUK�keY[Q/QUYGf3C�d�C�k!f�YOk QL@eC�KLSpkbQjMrP�Y ¬ QL@!C$��WXYOd;C$WjM[k!feK���Û!YOW/��k!KTQjM[k!h$CO¨MOk�Ybd�C�WUM[QLYbW L�����QL@^M�WLN!��C �;4= )

L>U;>= # ³6n!Ei·

��K�f3��KUMOKaQLWUYON!K���?#@eC�WUNe��Cc��YyYb�3KXMrQXQL@!CRKaSpkyQUM[P Y ¬ QU@eCRf3C�WL��¥rMrQL��¥OC�QUY���@e��hj@ QU@eCcYbd�C�WUMOk!f�,WUC�f3N�h�C�KQUY!¨r�pS�f3C�B'M[k!f3��kez�QL@!M[Q/QL@e��KXf3C$WU��¥¦M[QL��¥OC*��C�KLSykyQjMOhªQU��h�M[����SgCi¹yN!M[�yQLY ) � �RKL��kez L��*C#h$MOk f3��KaQL��kezONe��KL@QUC$WUB'K.KaN�hj@ MbK ) ¬ WLYbB )3) ¨�Ka��k!h�C L ) ��� # ��@eC�WLCiMOK+L )3) @!MbK'keY-WUC�f3N�hªQL��YOk�K$� _�Q���K.¹yNe��QLCN!kek!MrQUNeWjM[�XQUY¾f3��KaQL��kezbNe��KL@É��C$QT�*C�C$k ) M[k!f )3) ¨@eYr��C$¥OC�W�ºg�;Y[QU@-M[WUC.f3��¥bC$WUzOC�kbQ¸QUC$WUBDK�¨���§QU@eYON3QMOkpS9Yb�!KLC$WU¥¦MO�e��C.��C�@!M¦¥p��YbNeWi�s± ��QL@ WLN!��CiK������bCs³6n!Ei·���Q���YONe��f-�;C^f3� �.h$Ne�§Q�QLYÉf3C$×!keC���kyQLC�WLCiKTQU��k!z�;C$@�M¦¥y��YON!WUMO�;Ci¹yNe��¥rMO��C�k!h�CiK�QU@!MrQRMOWLCgh$YOkezbWLNeC�k!h�CiK$� �

±9C��!MbKaC�YONeW YOd;C$WjMrQL��YOk�M[��KaQLN!feS9Y ¬ � YOk � " ¨/��Cih$MON!KaC��§Q'KaC�C$B'K�M¾WLCiMOKLYOk!MO�e��C'k!Y[QL��YOk-Y ¬�;C$@�M¦¥y��YON!WUMO�rC�¹yNe��¥¦MO��C�k!h�Cb¨�MOk!f¸��Cih$MON!KaCX��Q(��K÷BDYOWUC/QLWjMOh�QUM[�!��C/QU@!M[k¸�!MOWL�;C�f¸h�YbkezOWUNeC�k!h�Cb�®±sC*f3Y�keY[Q�pkeYr� ��@eC$QL@eC�W�¨���k^zbC$keC�WUMO�«¨ � "Éh�Yb��k!h$��feC�K�����QL@¯QU@eC�M[d!deWLYbdeWU��M[QLC¸keY[QU��Ybk¯Y ¬ �!M[WU�;C�f¯h�YbkezOWUNeC$k�h�CO¨MO�§QU@eYON!zO@��*C¸�pkeYr�²��QRf3YpC�K#��k^h�C�WaQjM[��k�h$MbKaCiK�M[k!f���C�f3YDkeY[Q��pkeYr� MOkpS�h�YbNekyQLC$WUC�PeMOB�d!��Cb�

4 1 254 !;7 9 =5E�: � = �F= @ C<�=5@�� # >�� 7 � >�� 7 B < 7 @ 9;7�9�� � : ��5: � �5=±9C�keYr�¼h�YbBDd!M[WUC ��'³´QL@eC#��Yph�M[�3KaQLWUN!hªQUNeWLC*Y ¬ QU@eC#������kyQLC�WLdeWUC�QjMrQU��Ybk�·®MOk!fgQU@eC*WUC$��MrQU��Ybk!K � " � � ��k!h�CQU@eC$S�BDM¦S'�;Cgf3C�×�keC�f�YOk�f3� ��C$WUC$kyQch���MOKUKLC�K*Y ¬ QUC$WUB'K$¨3��CGh$YOBDd!MOWLCRQL@eC�B°YOk�QL@eCgh$YOBDBDYOk�h$YOWUC�Y ¬h$��YyKaCif�deNeWUC��3��QLC�WLB'K��/±sCcd!WLCiKaC�kbQ�KaYbB�CRY ¬ QL@eC�WLCiKaN!�§QjKX���§QU@eYONeQ�f3��zOzb��kezg��kyQLYgQU@eC�feC�QUMO����K�Y ¬ QL@eC���Wd!WLYpY ¬ K�¨3��@e��hj@�MOWLC ¬ MO��WU��S�C$��M[�;YOWjMrQLCb�

�´ó�â����

Page 58: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

���!��¤�©��;©L¤$�«�£�p¿R�j�3�������6�r�!�g�r�#���a�j�[ ����3 §�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª� xOx

?#@!C�×�WUKaQ�WLCiKaNe��Q���K�QU@!MrQ������K�M[Q#��C�MbKTQ�MOK�fe��KUh�WU��BD��k!MrQU��k!z�MbK�MOkpS�M[ded!����h$M[QL��¥OC ����!��KL��BD����MOWL��QTSO�?#@�MrQ���K�¨r�e��QLC$WUB'K÷QU@!MrQ�h�M[kek!Y[Q(�;C*f3��KaQL��kezONe��KL@eC�fgMbK®����h$M[��h�N!��N!K(deWUYph$C�KUKaCiK®h$MOkekeYOQ(��C*f3��KaQL��kezbNe��KL@eCif�pS�M[kpS'C�PpQLC�k!KL��Ybk�Y ¬ QU@eC��3��h$MO��h$Ne��N!K$�

��� Æ Å �¦Æ3Õ �� � � ��¤��� Y � ��GÌ�� �p¤$�^ ���� �£µ��� §�6¤ª� � " �ÉÊ!���[©��r��Á� GÌ

& � ŮŠ�U� ?#@e��K#QL@!C$YOWUC$B­��KcdeWLYr¥bC�f � M[k!vOn ���pS�zbYO��kez�QL@eWUYONezb@^M�hj@�M[WjMOhªQUC$WU��KUMrQU��Ybk�Y ¬ ���Ka��BD����M[WQUYDQL@!M[Qc��k�QLC�WLB'K�Y ¬ � ?K#QL@�MrQ��*C�KL@!MO���®KaQLN!feS.��k � CihªQU��Ybk9Eime�/±9CgYOBD�§Q#QU@eC�f3C�QjM[����K�� �

?#@!CgkeC�PpQ�¹yNeCiKTQU��Ybk���K���@eC$QL@eC�W�QL@!C$WUC�M[WUC¸KLC�QjKcY ¬ ��C$���§� ¬ YOWUBDC�f�YOd;C$WjMrQUYOWjK ¬ YbWc��@e��hj@�QL@eC�h$YOk3�¥bC$WjKaCGY ¬ ?#@eC�YOWUC$B E � ��E � ��K�QUWLNeCgMOk!f÷¨e� ¬ KLY!¨3��@�MrQc��K�M BD��ke��BDMO�(KLN!hj@�KLC�Qi��?#@eC�KLC�M[WUCG��kyQLC�WLCiKTQU��k!zd!WLYb�e��C�B'K$¨ ¬ YOW�QU@eC$��W�KaYb��N3QU��Ybk.�������;QLC����÷N�K�Í��3�r�*�£�����G��¤j�U¤��j�$�r©ªÁD���'�bÃOÃ.����� �p¤��3�a�j�r ����3 ¡�p�G���'µD�rËr¤�£���¦��Ã[�����$©ª�£µ��£�;�r���£�y¿¯�r�����3¤����a�j�r ��$�3 ¡�p�ª�±9C.�;C$zb��k-�pS9��YpYO�p��kez¾MrQ�KLC�QjK�Y ¬ Ý�HÖYbd�C�WUM[QLYbWUK���±9C�KL@eYr� QU@!MrQ'Ý�H�KaC$QUK�Y ¬ YOd;C$WjMrQLYbWUKgfeY

k!Y[Q zb��¥bC ¬ Ne����fe��KUh�WU��BD��k!MrQU��k!z¾d�Yr��C$Wi�^_�k-QU@eC�WUC$B'M[��k!f3C�W�Y ¬ QU@e��K KLC�h�QL��YOk®¨/��C.��WL��QLC � � ¬ YOW MOkMOWL�!�§QUWUMOWLS.KLC�Q�Y ¬ Ý�H YOd;C$WjMrQUYOWjK$�

� Æ3Õ-ÕÉ� � � � � ��¤�� ^� � �'Ì �´�( ��� � � �p¤$� ��� � � Ì

� Å � Å�Ò´Ò �3�¦à � � � � ����� � � � �p¤*���r £ ��[ÍX�£�y¿^�j�r��Ãr�£���6�r���r  �/��©ª�3 �¤ �p�[ �æ� ��� � � �£µR�; ¡�6¤ª�����6�0#% �>& � � �H

& � ŮŠ�U� Ú�S�@pSpd�YOQL@eCiKa��K�¨ ��� �����QP��XÚ�S WUC$d;C�M[QLCif'M[dede����h$MrQU��Ybk!KXY ¬ � C$BDB'M'E � � �!¨bMOk!f'Ka��k!h$C� � �É��K�MDh�YOk!zOWUNeC$k!h$CO¨

���4�2#. �4& ��� � ���6�2#5#������� P & �4& ��� � ���6�0#% P @ C D�F & � ������ P ��� � ��

��� Æ Å �¦Æ3Õ �� � � � � � � �,ÃO�i¤ª�����r���£µ��� §Á � �¼Ì

& � ŮŠ�U� ?M[�OC! � �����0# �>� &cM[k�f � � �����0# �;���6�0# �>�4&5&L�G_�Q�@!YO��feK�QU@!MrQ �� ��³£QU@e��KGh$MOk^��Cd!WLYr¥bC�f�f3��WUC�h�QL��SO¨��eN3QR��QR��KcC$¥bC$k^KL��BDde��C$W�QUY.f3C$WU��¥OCg��Q ¬ WLYbB�QU@eC�hj@!MOWUMbhªQLC�WL��KUMrQL��YOk�Y ¬ � ��k¯QUC$WUBDKY ¬ � J$¥pSy� � YOkezbY ?�WLC�C�K#��k � C�h�QL��YOk9E�mb·���RYr�*C�¥OC�W8 ��� � � ��ÛeYbWQL@e��K$¨O�*C*@!M¦¥OC�QLYGdeWLYr¥bC�QU@!MrQ ¬ YOW/C�Mbhj@ � ^� � � ¨ � � ��� � �g���6�0#%� �4&L�?#@!C$WUCGMOWLCRQT�*Y�h$MOKLC�K�¨3f3C$d;C$k�f3��k!z Ybk���@eC$QL@eC�W5� ��K#h�Ybky¥bC$WUzOC�kbQ*YOW�keY[Qi�_ ¬ � ��K#h$YOkp¥OC�WLzbC$kyQ�¨OQL@eC�k� � � � ��g���4�2#%� �4&�N!KL��kez�Ý*YbWLYb����M[WUS¯E � ��E$n�Âp� ¬ �§Qc��K#keYOQ�QL@eC�k� � � � � ) � � � �¸���6�0#1�G�4&U� �

Æ3ÕÉ�3�¦Ï � � � % � ��k!h�C9QL@!Csd!MOWUMO����C$�gh$YOkp¥OC�WLzbC$k!h$C¾YOd;C$WjMrQUYOW.QUC�KaQ ��KÈÝ*@pNeWjhj@3��H�YbKUKaC�W�¨c?#@!C$Y[�WUC$BØE � ��E¦x�MO��KLYDdeWLYr¥bC�K*QL@�MrQ � ��K�×!keC$W#QU@!M[k � �¦��?#@eC$WUC ¬ YbWLCGQL@!Cg��Y3h$MO�(KaQLWUN!hªQUNeWLC¸Y ¬ QU@eC�h$MOkeYOke���h$MO��f3YbBDMO��k-Y ¬ ��� tc�eWjwyoy¨tc�eWjwOv ��¨��@e��hj@Éh$YO��k!h���f3CiKg���§QU@ � �r¨���K�fe� ��C$WUC$kyQ ¬ WUYOBØQL@!M[Q�Y ¬ QL@eC������kbQUC$WUdeWUC�QUM[QL��YOk®� �

?#@!C$YOWUC$B E � ��Eix�KL@eYr�cK�QL@�MrQR��C�h$MOkekeY[QRMbhj@e��C$¥OCGQU@eC�f3��KLh$WL��BD��k�MrQL��kezDd;Yr�*C�W�Y ¬ ����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K��pSM�h�Ybk��!NeC�kyQ¸C$PpQLC$k�Ka��YOkÈQLY�QL@eC.�e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�� ?#@eC�keC�PpQ¸QL@!C$YOWUC$B KL@eYr�cK�QL@�MrQ�¨(��k9h�YOkyQUWUMbKTQi¨�QL@e��K¸��Kd;YbKUKL���e��C¸���§QU@�k!YOk3��h�Ybk��!NeC�kbQ#C�PpQUC$k!KL��Ybk!K��/Û!YOW#QU@e��K�¨3YOk!CGY ¬ QU@eCgKa��BDde��CiKTQ ¬ YbWLB'K�Y ¬ keYOk3��h�Ybk��!NeC�kyQYbd�C�WUM[QLYbWgYOkeC'h�YbNe��fÈQU@e��ke�sY ¬ ¨®[email protected]!MOWLSÈYOd;C$WjMrQLYbW � � QU@!MrQ���@!C$k-M[ded!����C�fsQLY¾KLYOBDC.MOWLzbNeBDC$kyQC��§QU@eC$WRWLC$QLNeWUk!K*QL@e��KcMOWLzbNeBDC$kyQ�YOW�f3��¥OC$WUzOCiK$¨3KLN��.h�CiK$�

â�â54�6!þ87:98;

Page 59: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

x � � Ì(À��[�y¿O�6�r©«¿O�

��� Æ Å �¦Æ3Õ � � � $ ��¤�� Y � ^�GÌ�� �p¤$� � ��� ���£µ��� ¡�6¤��G ����¼Ì

?#@e��K�QL@eC�YOWUC$B&��K(d!WLYr¥bC�fg��k � M[k�v[n �3N!KL��k!z�M�¥¦MOWL��M[kyQY ¬ QL@!C#Ú�Þb@eB���YbN3Q(QUC�hj@eke��¹yNeCO�?#@e��K�WUC�KLNe��Q�¨QUYOzbC�QL@!C$Wc����QL@È?#@!C$YOWUC$B'K�E � ��E � ¨!KL@eYr�cK#QL@�MrQGMOkpS�keYbk3��h�YOk �!NeC$kyQRC$PpQLC$k�Ka��YOk^Y ¬ ��� ��k¾��@e��hj@ �����K�C$P3deWLCiKLKL���e��C�h$M[k���C�C$k!h$YpfeC�fD��k�����h$M[��h�N!��N!K���k�Mg��M¦S���@e��hj@'��K ¬ Ne����S'MO�!KTQUWUMbhªQ�Ybk.deNeWUC��e�«QUC$WUB'K$�³«Ú�S.f3C$¥bC$��YOde��kez�QU@e��K#WLCiKaNe��Q ¬ NeWaQU@eC$Wi¨p�§QcKL@eYON!��f�MOhªQUN!M[����S'��CGd�YyKLKL���e��C�QLY�deWUYr¥OCRQL@!M[Q�QU@eCGC$k!h$Ypfe��kez��K ¬ Ne����S�M[��KTQUWUMbhªQ�YOk¯M[���÷QLC�WLB'K#Y ¬ QU@eCgC�PpQLC�k!f3Cif¯�e��h$M[��h�N!��N!K�¨edeWUYr¥p��feC�f�QL@!M[Q�QL@eCgYbd�C�WUM[QLYOWjK�Y ¬ QL@eCC$PpQLC$k�Ka��YOk¯h$MOk��;C ¬ M[��QL@ ¬ N!����S�C�k!h�Y3f3Cif÷� ·

4 1 2 1 � @ : > 9 =5@�� < !;7 > #+7 � C<�> � E >�� < !;7 � � 7 B < 7 @ E�=?> @ E =5@A<�>���� : 4� : �#� �;E

_�ksQL@!��KgKLC�h�QL��YOk9�*CDKa@!Yr� @eYr� QUY�C�k!h�Y3f3CDC$PyQUC$k!feC�fÉ�3��h$MO��h$Ne���X��kyQLY¯����h$M[��h�N!��N!K�� ?#@!��KgKL@eYON!��fs��CB'MO��ke��S�QL@eYbNezO@yQ�Y ¬ MOKRMOk¾C�P3C�WUh$� ��Cg���§QU@^QL@eC ����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�Â;QL@eC keYOk3����kbQUC$WUC�KaQLCif�WUC�Mbf3C$W�B'M¦S�KUM ¬ C���SKL�p��d�QL@!C�KaCihªQL��YOk(�±9C�Mbfef�QL@eC ¬ YO����Yr����kez�h$YOk!KaQLWjM[��kyQ�QLYgQU@eC�Ç�C�×�ke�§QU��Ybk¾E � � ngY ¬ �*C������ ¬ YbWLBDCifDYOd;C$WjMrQLYbWUK�º ¬ YbW�C�Mbhj@

Ybd�C�WUM[QLYbW�L®¨y� ¬ L'@�MOK�M�WLNe��C�QU@!MrQ�C�¥rM[��N!MrQUC�K�d;YbKL��QL��YOk �j¨[QU@eC$k.CiMOhj@'Y ¬ QU@eC �i��WUNe��CiK ¬ YOWCL'C$��QL@!C$W�QUC�KaQUKd;YbKL��QL��YOk ��YbWgQL@!C.WLN!��C'@!MbK�M¾h$YOk!h$��N!KL��YOk L> � ]2]0]K 3�;4= � ��@!C$WUCI��cf3YpCiKgkeY[Q Yph�h�NeW���k ���?#@!��K���K�¨�deWjM[zOB'M[QL��h$M[����SO¨�M�WLCiMOKLYOk!MO�e��C�h�YOk�KTQUWUMO��kyQ�Â;��QG��K�KUMrQU��Ka×!Cif^�pS�QU@eC�YOd;C$WjMrQLYbWUKcC$k!h$YONekyQLC�WLCifKLY ¬ M[Wi¨pKLN!hj@�MOK �;¨ ¨ �®¨eM[k�f � �/± �§QU@eYONeQ�QL@e��K#h�YOk�KTQUWUMO��kyQ�QL@eC¸C$k�h�Y3f3��kez ��YON!��f���C¸¥OC�WLS'h$YOBDde��C�P³ ¬ YOW���k!KaQUM[k�h�CO¨p��Qc��K#d;YbKUKL���e��C�QLY'f3C�×�keC�M��e��h$M[��h�N!��N!K#WUC�feN!hªQU��Ybk�KaQLWjMrQLC�zOSDQU@!MrQ�@!MbK#WLNe��C�K*9�¨ O M[k�fS Â!MOK�f3��KUh�N!KUKaCif���k � C�h�QL��YOk¯v QL@e��Kch�YbB��e��k!M[QL��YOk�Y ¬ WUNe��C�K#��K�@!MOWUf�QLYDC$k�h�Y3f3Ci·��Û��P YOkeC¯KaN�hj@¼Ka��zOk�MrQLN!WLC���M[k!f Kad;C�h$�§×�h�MrQU��Ybk Y ¬ ��C$����� ¬ YbWLBDC�fÉYbd�C�WUM[QLYbWUK $ %('��#��GY;� &L�-?(Y

B'MO�OC�QL@eC'C�k!h�Y3f3��kez¯Y ¬ � ��kyQLY�QU@eC.����h$M[��h�N!��N!K¸CiMOKL��C�WGQLY^WUC�MOf®¨®�*C.MbKLKLNeBDC�QL@!M[Q � h$YOkyQUMO��k�KGMKL��kezO��C¸YOd;C$WjMrQLYbW���Y ¬ M[WU�§QTS&e¨3���§QU@��i��WUNe��C�K

��� � � � � �� �-� �!� ;4= ��� ��

� � � � � �� �-� �!� ;4= �$�

³6��@eC$WUC ���RMOk!f �$�GMOWLCgKLYOBDCGQLC�WLB'K#��k^��� B# �-�LY � �L&�·cM[k!f�C$¥rM[��N!M[QL��YOk�WLNe��C�K�� � �\�G;>= �HP�

� � � � � ;>=�� � P� � � �� �!� ;4= �,P�� � � � � ;4=�� � � � P�

¬ YbW�C$¥rM[��N!M[QL��kez�QL@eCgQT��Y'M[WUzONeBDC�kbQjK�Y ¬ �e��±sCg����Ka@�QUY'C$k!h$YpfeC�QU@e��KcC�PpQUC$k!f3Cif^�3��h$MO��h$Ne��N�Kc���'��kyQLY����h$MO��h$Ne��N!K$�?#@eCgB'MO��k¯deWUYO�e��C$B­��K�QLY'f3C�×�keCgQL@!CgC$k!h$Ypfe��kezDY ¬ M����[�«QUC$WUB�� � � ��?#@eCgC$k�h�Y3f3��kez'Y ¬ QL@eC

YOQL@eC�W'h�YOk�KTQUWLN!h�QUK¯³6MO�!KaQLWjMOhªQU��Ybk®¨�M[d!de����h$M[QL��YOk®¨�M[k!f¼¥rM[WU��MO�e��C¦·���KDMOK���k � CihªQU��Ybk �!¨��eN3Q'����QL@ QL@eCk!YOk3������keCiM[W�C�k!h�Y3f3��kez^Y ¬ MO�!KaQLWjMOhªQU��Ybk9fe��KUh�N!KUKLC�fÉ��k¼H�C$B'MOWL� �e��E�q^M[k�fÉN!KaCifÉ��k [email protected]�k!h�Y3f3��kez¾Y ¬��� ��k�?�MO�e��CGop��³´_�Q���K�keC�h$C�KUKLMOWLS�QLY�N�KaC�QU@e��K�C�k!h�Y3f3��kez�MbK$¨yf3NeCcQUYgQL@!CRWUNe��CiK�Y ¬ �!¨pM ¬ Nek!h�QL��YOk'QU@!MrQMOded;C�M[WjK#MOK�MOWLzbNeBDC$kyQ*QUY���B'M¦S.�;CgN!KaCif�BDYbWLCGQL@�M[k¯YOk!h$CO� ·

Æ3ÕÉ�3�¦Ï � � � t�fef3��kez�QU@eC�WUC$d!����h$M[QL��YOk¾��k^QL@!C�f3C$×!ke��QL��YOksY ¬ M[��KTQUWUMbhªQL��YOk¾feYyCiKRk!Y[QGM��;CihªQGQL@eC��Y3h$MO�®KTQUWLN!h�QLNeWUC¸Y ¬ QL@eCg������kyQUC$WUdeWLC$QUM[QL��YOkɳ6KLC$Cgf3��KLh$N!KLKL��YOk!K#��k�HcC$B'M[WU�¾E�m!� � mb·�� �

±9CcdeWUC�KLC$kyQ�M[kDC$k�h�Y3f3��kez¸QL@!M[Q���K�C�MOKLSgQUYgWLCiMOKLYOkDM[�;YON3Q�MOk!f���K)�!C$P3���e��CªF KLY¸QL@!M[Q�� ¬ ��C�B�Y3f3� ¬ SQU@eC�WUNe��CiK ¬ YOW��¸��Q���K/C�MOKLS¸QLYgBDY3f3� ¬ S�QU@eC�C$k!h$Y3f3��k!zD³«KaC�C�]/P3C$Wjh���KaC¸E � � � qr�jE � � � Ei·ª��±9CcKa@�M[���eh�YOk�Ka��f3C$W

�´ó�â����

Page 60: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

���!��¤�©��;©L¤$�«�£�p¿R�j�3�������6�r�!�g�r�#���a�j�[ ����3 §�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª� xbo

Ybd3QL��BD��KUMrQU��Ybk!K�Y ¬ QU@eCDC$k!h$Ypfe��kez���kÉ]/P3C$Wjh���KLC�K E � � � � �UE � � � xe�R?#@eC�C$kyQLC�WLdeWU��Ka��kez.WUC�Mbf3C$WGBD��zb@bQ¸�����bCQUYDQLWUS'QL@!CgC$k!h$Ypfe��kezDY ¬ � ��� ���;C ¬ YbWLCgWUC�Mbf3��kez ¬ N!WaQU@eC$Wi�±9C�f3C$×!keC¸QL@!CGC�k!h�Y3f3��kez'Y ¬ M QLC�WLB � � � ^� � QU@pN!K$º

) ) � � � * * $ %('� # L$&K�2# �7 ��Y 7� Y 7 � Y Q & � � � � ) ) � * * N � � � ) ) � * *

N�� � ��P �4�LY � �BY � � R N�� � ��P �>� Y�� �BY��B� RN� ��P � �LY�� �BY,Q�R N� � P � � Y��B�LY Q�R

Q P L�R �

³6n � ·

��@!C$WUC 7 �¾KTQjM[k!feK ¬ YbW � � Y�� � ¨!MOk!f�Ka��BD����M[WU��S ¬ YOW 7� MOk!fN7 �y¨eMOk!f���@eC$WUC� � P � � Y�� �BY,Q�R $&%('� � �L# �6�L&K��� �B# �4� &� Q ) ) ��� @ D �� D� C A �� A 2F * *�$�LYK�>� ¬ WUC�KL@ ¬ YOW ���� � � P � � Y � � Y � � R $&%('� � � # � &K� � # ��&� � � # � � P ��R N � � P ��R N � ��# � &K� � # � &� � � �>&

MOk!f.KL��BD����MOWL��S ¬ YOW�� � P � � Y�� � Y Q�RXMOk!f�� � � P � � Y�� � Y�� � Rª��?#@eCRd!WLY3h�CiKLK � � �D��K*Mg����ke��¨pMbK*feC�×!keCif'��k� C�hªQU��Ybk�ÚG��Eb� xe�(±9C��eWU��C �!S¸C�P3de��M[��kgQU@eC�KLC*f3C$×!ke��QL��YOk!K���?#@!C�deWUY3h�C�KUK�� � P � � Y�� � Y,Q�R÷��BDde��C�BDC$kyQUK(QL@eC�i��WUNe��C ��b��_�Q��#M[��QUK ¬ YbW�KL��zbk!M[��KXMrQ � �#M[k�f � � ¬ WUYOB�� � �P �6�BY � �BY � � RM[k�f�� � �P ��� Y�� �BY��B�0Rj¨y��k!f3��h$MrQU��k!zQU@!MrQQL@!C�MOWLzbNeBDC$kyQUK8���MOk!f!��*@!M¦¥bC���Cih�YbB�C�¥rM[��NeC�K�³´��� CO��¨ ¬ Nek!hªQU��Ybk!Kj·ª�/?#@eC$k�� �P � �BY�� �LY Q�R�QUWL��C�KQUY zbWUMO�DQL@eCG��Yphj�'M[Q Q;Âp� ¬ �§Q�KaN�h$h�C�C�feK�¨bQL@eC�k�QU@eCRWUNe��C�B'M¦SD��C¸h�YbBDde��C$QLCif÷¨3M[k!f � � zOC$QUK*C$¥rM[��N!MrQUC�f÷�_ ¬ QU@eCR��Y3hj��h�M[kek!Y[Q��;CRzOWjM[�!��Cif÷¨�� � P � � Y�� � Y,Q�RX��K�zbMOWL�!MOzOCb� � ke��S YbkeCc�;C�QT��C$C�k�� � P � � Y�� � Y Q�RXMOk!f� � P � � Y��B� Y,Q�R�h$M[k�zOWjM[��QL@eCg��Y3hj��¨eKaYDYOk!��S.YbkeCgY ¬ QL@eC �i��WUNe��CiK�h$MOk��;C�h�YbB�d!��C$QLC�f®�

� � � P �4� Y � �BY � � Rgh�YbkyQLWUYO��[email protected]�¥rM[��N!MrQU��Ybk-Y ¬ QL@eC�M[WUzONeBDC$kyQ ���³«M[k!f�� � �P ��� Y�� �BY��B�0R�QU@!MrQ�Y ¬ � ·ª� Û��WjKTQi¨�� � � P � � Y � � Y � � R�QLWU��zbzOC�WUK�QU@eC^C$¥rM[��N!M[QL��YOk Y ¬ � � ± @eC$k � KL��zbk!M[��K�QL@�MrQ.��Q�@!MOKWUC�feN!h�Cif¼QUY MÉ¥rM[��NeCO¨(QP� KUM¦SO¨*QL@eC�k�� � � P � � Y � � Y � � R���k ¬ YOWUB'K�� � P � � Y�� � Y Q�R�MOk!f�� � P � � Y�� � Y Q�Rj¨N�Ka��kez9k!M[BDC�K � ��M[k!f � �O� _�k QU@eC�KLC^MOhªQU��Ybk!K�MrQ � ��M[k�f � �[¨*Msd;YO��kbQUC$W �È��K�d!MbKLKLC�f÷¨���@e��hj@¼QL@eCWUC�h$��d!��C�kbQch�M[k¯N!KLC�QUY'MOhªQU��¥rM[QLC�h�Ybde��C�K#Y ¬ QP� �0�� Æy�r� ´}iÆ � � � �� Ì (�[©��r £ 6��BY��� ���eÊ��£� �3�r �Ãr�����3�r�

��#��������L&K#����6����L&M;4= � �B@ D��� � � �� C A �� A 2F �½#©L�r¢r¤ ���3�r�

) ) ��#��������L&K#����6����L& * * � � ;6= � # � �L�BY�� �*&# ) ) ��� @ J � J C A �� A 2F * * �N � �L� # � &K� ) ) ������� * * N � � � # � &K� ) ) ���6�� � * *�L&

� ̸À �p�[Í ���3�r�«Ê!���r©��[ £ 4 Y � ^� � ÍX�£� � ��� ¬ ¥6# �/&LÊ� ) ) * *K@2� � � ) ) � * *KF � � ) ) '@ A C D�F * *M�

� ���£�!� � �bÃOÃ��r�;¤��j�¦�$¤��£�È� �p¤��£�;Ãr�!�$���£¢¦¤c��©L�i�T� �T� � Jp¤$©L�$����¤��[Ì � � Ì �0�� Æy�r� ´}iÆ � � *2 À��¦�b�3�r��¤�� �p�[�#©ª�3 �¤ª� ��^�r��à � sÃO���;�[����¤��j���e�¦�ª�£�«�6�[� ���6Ì£¤iÌ�Ê#� �p¤$�£©c�;©L¤$µ ���$¤�����ª�£µ��� ¡Á�� � ���g�r��Ãg� �p¤$©L¤������;��¤�¢r�r ¡�!�[�«�6�[��©ª�3 �¤ �� !Ì ���[Í9� �3�r�3 �Ã�� �p¤RÃb¤ ���!�£���6�r�¯�T��� � � P � � Y�� � Y�� � R�£� � � � ��¶U¤�µD�iÃr� ��¤Uà �

â�â54�6!þ87:98;

Page 61: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

xOw � Ì(À��[�y¿O�6�r©«¿O�

0�� Æy�r� ´}iÆ � � � À��¦�b�3�r��¤�� �p�r�G� �p¤ � ��©ª�3 �¤ª���T� � �r©U¤.µ'��Ã[� �*¤jþ���¾���3�r��©ª�3 �¤ � � � ��� � Y �^�r�! §Á��¤��j�«���e�¦�ª�£���6�r� �����6Ì£¤iÌ�Ê����3¤���©U¤�µ����$¤��T��� �c���R�ª�£µ��� ¡Á � � �����[�;Ã��£�«�¸Ãb¤�©ª�£¢r�r���£¢¦¤ � � ÃO�i¤ª�G�;�[�*�j�r�!���r�£�µ'¤$���[¢¦�[©ª�6�b¶� �¤���� ��� �� � �OÌ ���rÍ � �p�[�3 �Ã'� �p¤ ÃO¤ �����£�«�6�[�e���T� � � � P � � Y � � Y � � R��r�;à � � � P � � Y�� � Y�� � RG�£�� � � ��¶U¤�µ'��Ã[� �*¤jà �

_�k¾KLYOBDC�h$MbKaCiK$¨eQL@eC C$k!h$Ypfe��kezyK�YO�eQUM[��keCif ¬ Yb����Yr����kezDQL@eC KLhj@eC�B'M'M[�;Yr¥OCgh$MOk��;C�Ybd3QL��BD��KLC�f÷¨�MOKKL@eYr��k���k�QL@!CgC�P3C$Wjh���KaCiK���C���Yr�g�

0�� Æy�r� ´}iÆ�� �� � /� ÌG½#©L�r¢r¤�� �p�[�6Ê!���[© ) ) � � � * *��¦��ÃO¤ ����¤UÃ.�£� � � � �iÊ*Í�¤ �3�r¢r¤ �) ) � � � * *�� � # � � Y�� Y � � Y � � & � ) ) � * *���� N ) ) � * *����

N � � # ��&� � # ��&K��� ��# � &K� � # � &� � � �N � � # ��&� � # ��&K��� ��# � &K� � # � &� � � �N � # � � &��� # � � &�0# �$� ) ) � � @ D � D� C A � A F * *��� �$� ) ) � � @ D � D� C A � A F * * � & �

� Ì � J��y�«¶ª�£����Í��'��¤�©ªµ �X �.�r��Ã!��.�ª�!����� �p�[�) ) � � � * *�� �� # � � Y�� Y � � Y � � & � ) ) � * *���� N ) ) � * *����

N � � # � � &� � � # � � &K�# � � � Y�� � &�# � � � # � &� � # � &K� � � � �N � � � # � &� � # � &K� � � � �N # �$� ) ) � � @ D � D� C A � A F * *��

� �$� ) ) � � @ D � D� C A � A F * * � &K& �0�� Æy�r� ´}iÆ � � *� �©ª�£��¤ Ãb�rÍX�-�r�ɤ����U�iÃr�£�p¿� �a�R� �T�ª�3¤$©L�r���r© �����e�r©L�[ £ �¤$ /�j�r��¢¦¤$©«¿y¤����j¤���¤ª�ª�«ÊÃb¤ ���;¤jÃ��£�ÉÀ�¤j�$�«�6�[� � � Ì � �����r £ ��[ÍX�£�y¿È���3¤��$���3¤�µ'�g���[©'¤$�;�j�iÃr�£�p¿^Í�¤$ £  �¡���r©ªµ'¤jÃÈ�j�e¤$©L�r���r©j�D�£�;Ã[�6�U�[��¤jÃ�y¶U�r¢r¤½�©U�r¢r¤¸���3�r�/� ��­���R� �p¤¸¤$�;�j��Ã[�£�y¿'Ãb¤ ���;¤jÃD�¦��� ¶��3�/ÍX�£�����$ ��r�p�$¤ � ��� � ���£���; ��O�j¤��a��� � � � �¦Ê/���3¤��

���[©��r £ 6^� Ê��£� �p�r �æ��� �p�r� � ) ) * * � ) ) * *jÌ0�� Æy�r� ´}iÆ � � � �R¤T�3¤j�[� � Jy¤$©L�$���$¤ � � Ì ��� ���r©¸� �÷Ê*Í��3¤�©U¤����3¤�¤$�;�j�iÃr�£�p¿� �p�$¤ª��� �p¤'�$ ��[�p��¤����[© ��j©U�rµ � Jp¤�©L�$���$¤ � � Ì � Ì0�� Æy�r� ´}iÆ�� �� � /� ��¤$� ���r�;à � P�¶U¤G� �p¤g�j�e¤$©L�r���r©j�jÊ��r��à ���3¤��«©L�[�e�´���r©ªµ'�r���6�r�È�a�G�¸�'����¤$©ªµ�Ãb¤ ���;¤jÃ��£� � Jp¤$©L�$����¤ � � Ì � Ì ��¤ ���;¤g�r�9¤����U�iÃr�£�p¿�� �T�c� @� Y � P FR���r £ ��[ÍX�£�y¿����3¤¸�$� �p¤$µD�.�y¶U�r¢r¤����[©��©L�[�e�ª ��r���£�y¿^Í�¤� £  �¡���[©ªµD¤jÃs�j�e¤�©L�[���[©j�$Ì.½�©L�r¢r¤'� �p�[�6Ê�� � � �

������ �p¤�¤����U�iÃr�£�p¿È�a�¸� � �£� � Jp¤$©L�$����¤ � Ì �

��� �b���¾¤����j��Ã[�£�y¿¼���^�-�j�£µ��� �¤¾¢r�r©ª�6�[�!�'�T�����3�r���£� ���b¶� �¤ � �¦Ê � �p¤$�È���r©È�[ £  � �£� �3�r �Ãr�¾���3�r�� ) ) * * � � �

�) ) * *jÌ �����[��¤ � ��� � �b���9¤Jp¤�©U�����$¤sÍ�¤-�r©L¤9�p�ª�£�p¿ � �� Ê.Í��b�6� � ���9� ¢r�r©ª�6�[�!���a�È� �p¤¤$�;�j�iÃr�£�p¿^�£� ���b¶� �¤ � ʸ¶U¤j�U�[�p�$¤D�£� � �b���DÍ��rÁ¯���3¤¸�;©L���a�.ÃO�i¤ª�D�;�[�c©L¤ �$�3�£©L¤ � � �«Áj�e¤ª�.�r��ï� �p¤$©L¤6���[©L¤

�j�[�9¶U¤ �j�r©ª©ª�6¤jÃ��r�3�*ÍX�£���¯���3¤g�ª���r��ÃO�r©UÃ'� �p¤j�r©ªÁ��a�g���3¤c���a�j�[ ����3 §�p� ���$¤j¤ �[  �$� ��¤�µ'�r©jË � Ì � �OÌ �

� � +���� "��'����"9�÷���/���������� ���¼� ��� � �� $��������������¸�/ ����

?#@!C���Y3h$MO�eKTQUWLN�hªQLN!WLC�Y ¬ QU@eC�������kyQLC�WLdeWUC�QjMrQU��Ybk®¨��;¨b��KQL@!Cc��C�@!M¦¥p��YbNeWjM[�pC�¹yNe��¥rM[��C$k!h$C���k!feN!h�Cif Ybk.�3�QUC$WUB'K��pSgQU@eC$��WXC$k�h�Y3f3��kez���kyQLY¸����h$M[��h�N!��N!K��_�k�QU@eC#deWLC�¥p��YbN!K/KaCihªQL��YOk �*C#deWUYr¥OCif�M¸hj@!M[WjMOh�QLC�WL��KLM[QL��YOkY ¬ � MOK�QU@eC¸YOd;C$WjMrQL��YOk�M[��C�¹yNe��¥rM[��C$k!h$CgY ¬ C$PpQLC$k�f3C�f^�e��h�M[��h�Ne���«�

�´ó�â����

Page 62: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

���!��¤�©��;©L¤$�«�£�p¿R�j�3�������6�r�!�g�r�#���a�j�[ ����3 §�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª� x[v

±9C¾h�YbkyQL��kyN!C�QU@eCÈKaQLN!feS¼Y ¬ ��¼��k QL@e��K.KLC�h�QL��YOk®¨����§QU@ QL@eC^d!NeWLd;YbKLC¯Y ¬ Nek!f3C�WUKaQUMOk!f3��kez9QL@eCBDCiM[ke��kez¯Y ¬�¬ Nek!h�QL��YOk-C�¹yN!MO����QTS¾��@eC�k ¬ Nek!hªQU��Ybk!K�MOWLC���kyQUC$WUdeWLC$QLCif9MbK¸deWUYph$C�KUKaCiK$�D±9C.Ka@�M[���XdeWLYr¥bChj@�M[WjMOhªQUC$WU��KUMrQU��Ybk!K�Y ¬ � ��k QUC$WUB'KXY ¬ QLWUC$CcKaQLWUN!hªQUNeWLCiK/��@e��hj@�MOWLC�M[kD��BDd�YbWaQjM[kyQXd!M[WLQXY ¬ QL@eC#QU@eC$YbWLSY ¬ QL@!C'�e��h$M[��h�N!��N!K���?#@e��K¸�������XKa@!Yr� QL@!M[QGQU@eC�C�¹yNe��¥¦MO��C�k!h�C���k!f3N!h$C�fs�yS¯QU@eC�����h�M[��h�Ne��N!KGC$k!h$Y3f3��k!z��K�M¾k!MrQUNeWUMO��YOk!CO�¯_�Q ��������M[��KaY¾KL@eYr� QL@eC�N3QL�����§QTS9Y ¬ KLYOBDC'Y ¬ QU@eC�����h$MO��h$Ne��N�KgdeWUYyY ¬ QLC�hj@!ke��¹yNeCiK$ºN�Ka��kez^QUC�hj@eke��¹yNeC�K�KaN!hj@ MbK � �e��KL��B�Ne��MrQU��Ybk-NedÉQLYÈh$YOkyQLC$PpQ � MOk!f � �!��KL��B Ne��MrQL��YOkÉNed QLY^C�P3d!MOk!KL��Ybk � ¨QU@eCgdeWUYpY ¬ K#Y ¬ QL@eCgB'MO��k�QL@!C$YOWUC$B'K#�������÷�;CgB�N�hj@�CiMOKL��C�W�QL@!MOk�QU@eC$S��*YbNe��f�@!M¦¥bCG�;C$C�k¯Y[QL@!C$WU����KLCO�?#@!CcB'M[��k.WLCiKaN!�§Q*KUM¦S3K/QL@�MrQ � h�Yb��k�h���f3C�K����§QU@ � �'�a¤ ���!�[ ¡�£�«Ár¨y��@eC�WLC��yS QT��Y��3��QLC�WLB'K�M[WUC�C�¹yN!M[�

���-QL@!C$S¾@!M¦¥bC�QU@eC'KLMOB�C �� �¢iÁ�� �(�[�y¿y� �e©L¤j¤ª�^³ � ��Kj·ª� � J�¥ySy� � YbkezOY�?�WUC$C�K¸MOWLC�QL@eCD��M��$S^¥rMOWL��M[kyQ�Y ¬��� �yµ �e©L¤j¤ª��³ ����Kj·ª�G±9C KL@!M[���MO��KLY.f3��KLh$N!KUKRBDY3f3��×�h$M[QL��YOk!KRY ¬ QL@!C�����h$M[��h�N!��N!KR��kyQUC$WUdeWLC$QUM[QL��YOk¾KLYQU@!MrQc��QUKc��Y3h$MO�®KTQUWLN�hªQLN!WLC¸��K�QL@eC�MOk!M[��YOzbYON!K ���'�a¤ �$�!�r ¡�£��Ár�±9C.�;C$zb��k-�pS9WLCih$M[������kez¯��@!M[Q � ?K�M[WUCO�¯t�WUC�Mbf3C$W ¬ MOBD������MOW�����QL@ÉQL@!C$B B'M¦SÈzOY¾KaQLWjM[��zO@yQgQUY

?#@!C$YOWUC$B E�me� we�

4 � 254 � 7 @ E�= � � 7 < !D7 > � = 7 E @ 9 � �� < !;7 > � = 7 E

Ú�Þb@eB ?(WUC$CiK¯³6Ú#?c·�MOWLC�QL@!C�BDYbKaQD�*C��������pkeYr��k QLWUC$C¯KTQUWLN!h�QLNeWUC���k¼QL@eC¾�e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�� Ú�?K�de��M¦S Mh$C$kyQLWjM[��WLYb��C���k'QU@eC�h$��MbKLKL��h�M[�3QU@eC$YbWLS�Y ¬ QU@eCG�e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!K��?#@!CR��Yph�M[�;KTQUWLN!h�QLNeWUCcY ¬ KLYOBDCcY ¬ QL@eC�BDYbKaQ��k��!N!C$kyQL��M[�®BDY3f3C���K#Y ¬ QU@eC��3��h$MO��h$Ne��N!K$¨3�����OC � h$Y[QaQcMOk!f¯VX��YOQL�p��k � K;M �c¨eVX��YOQL�p��k � K ���(¨!V���YOQL�p��k^MOk!f]�kezOC���C�W � K�� ��K/d!WLCih���KaC���S¸QU@eCcÚ#? C�¹yN!MO����QTS�ÂOM[k�f�QU@eC���Y3h�M[�3KTQUWLN�hªQLN!WLC#Y ¬ � h�YOQaQ � K�����³6@e��KTQUYOWU��h�M[����SQU@eC�×!WjKaQ/B'M[QL@eC�BDM[QL��h$MO�«¨b�«� CO��¨OkeYbk3��KaSpkyQUMbhªQL��h$MO�«¨rBDY3f3C��eY ¬ QL@eCRNekyQTSyd;C�f'�e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!Kj·��KXQL@eC�Ci¹bN�M[���§QTSY ¬ QU@eC �a��k3×�ke�§QUC ��h$YOkyQLWjMOh�QL��YOk �RY ¬ Ú#?K$�Ú#?K(k�MrQLN!WUMO����S�zb��¥bC�WU��KLC�QUY�M�QUWLC�C�QUYOd;YO��YOzOS�QL@�MrQ�@�MOK���C�C$k�N�KaCif ¬ YOW�QL@eC*deWUYyY ¬ Y ¬ KLYOBDC*KLC$BD��k!M[�

WUC�KLNe��QUK*Y ¬ QU@eCG�e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!K*�����OC�Ú*C�WLWUS � K*KaCi¹yNeC$kyQL��M[����QTS�QU@eC$YbWLC�B ³6�eWL��C ��SDfe��KUh�N!KUKLC�f'��k � CihªQL��YOk � � � ·ª�Ú#?K#�*C�WLC¸��kyQLWUYpfeN!h�Cif��pS�Ú#MOWLC�k!f3WUC$z[Q� Ú#MOWªobo ��¨!MOk!f�h$M[����C�f¯KaYDM ¬ QUC$WRÚ�Þb@eB � K#deWUYpY ¬ M[k!f�QL@eC�YOWUC$BMO��YbN3Q�KaC�d!M[WjM[�!�����§QTS¯Y ¬ �3��QLC�WLB'K�� ?#@eCDdeWUYpY ¬ QUC�hj@ek!��¹yNeC ¬ YOWGQU@e��KGQU@eC$YbWLC�B¯¨®h$M[����C�f^QU@eC � � �bµ �a�r�3���¤j���y�!�K�$�!¤�¨pWUYONezb@e��S�h$YOk!KL��KaQUK*��k'×!k!f3��kezDM�h�YbkyQLC�PpQ#h$M[d�M[�e��CRY ¬ ��KLYO��MrQU��kez M�zO��¥OC�k�KLNe�3QLWUC$CRY ¬ M Ú�?¸Â��k�QL@e��K��#M¦SO¨3h�C�WaQjM[��k¯�e��QLC$WUB'K#QL@�MrQ�@!M¦¥OCgf3����C$WUC$kyQcÚ�?K�B'M¦S.�;C�KaC�d!M[WjMrQUC�f÷�Ú#?KXM[WUC�M[Q/QL@eC#@eCiM[WLQ/Y ¬ QU@eC�h���MOKUKa��h$MO�bQU@eC$YbWLSgY ¬ QU@eCc�3��h$MO��h$Ne��N!K$¨bKaYbB�C$QL��BDC�K/WUC ¬ C$WUWUC�fgQUYgMOK�QL@eC

�$¤$�e�ª�«¶� �¤¸� �p¤j�r©ªÁr�X_�kDQU@e��K�QL@!C$YOWUSO¨pM��e�«QUC$WUB ��K*B�CiM[ke��kez ¬ Ne�[ZTN!KaQ#� ¬ ��QR�$�r §¢¦�y¶ª �¤$¨pQL@�MrQ���K���Q*@�MOK�M �p¤j�OÃ���r©ªµ'�r 3���r©ªµ ³ �b�i�;·��G?#@!C��3�!���[ ¡¢r�b¶� �¤ QLC�WLB'K�¨�QU@!MrQ¸��KcQU@eC�QUC$WUB'KR����QL@eYbN3Q�@!k ¬ ¨®M[WUC���f3C$kyQL��×!CifÈMOKQU@eC �aBDC�MOke��k!zO��C�KUK#QLC�WLB'K �j�#_�k¯QL@!C�B'MrQU@eC$B'MrQU��h�M[��B�Y3f3C���K ¬ YOWRQL@e��K�QU@eC$YbWLSb¨eQL@!C�Nek!KLYO��¥rM[�e��CgQUC$WUBDKMOWLC.QL@eYyKaC'QUC$WUB'K���@eYyKaC.��B'M[zbC.��K�QL@eC���CiMOKaQ�C$��C$BDC�kbQ Y ¬ QL@!C�BDY3f3C$�G³£QL@!C�Nek�f3C�×!k!C�f-YbW���YOQaQUYOBC���C�BDC$kyQj·���?#@eC�Ú#?&Y ¬ M'QUC$WUB h�Ybky¥bC$S3K�QU@eC�C�KUKaC�kbQU��MO���;C$@�M¦¥y��YON!WUMO��h�YbkyQLC$kyQ¸Y ¬ QU@!MrQGQLC�WLB N!k!f3C$WQU@e��K�deWUYOd;YbKUM[���t @ek ¬ ��KXMcQUC$WUB Y ¬ QL@eC ¬ YbWLB �47�8�5�� �/]XP3MOBDde��CiKY ¬ QUC$WUB'K/���§QU@eYON3Q�M�@ek ¬ M[WUC ) ¨b����� ) ¨yM[k!f�*

³6WLCih$MO����QL@!M[QD* KLM[QL��KT×�C�K�QL@eCGC�¹yN!M[QL��YOk���9 ! * � #������0& 3 *#¨ ¬ YbW�MO��� -(·��/Û��k!f3��kez QL@eC¸@ek ¬ Y ¬ M�QLC$WUBWUC�¹yNe��WUC�K#h�YbB�d!N3QL��kezDNek!f3C�WLk!C�MrQU@¯�(¨e��k¯YOWjf3C$W�QLYDNek�h�Yr¥OC�W�QU@eCg@eCiMOf�¥¦MOWL��M[�!��C¸M ¬ QUC$WcMDKaCi¹yNeC$k!h$C�Y ¬� � K$�¾Ý*YOBDdeN3QU��k!z^Nek!f3C�WLkeCiMrQU@-� ��K�M^f3C$�!M[QUMO�e��C.feC�h���KL��Ybk®Â ¬ YbW���k!KTQjM[k!h$C'�§Q�f3YpC�KgkeYOQ�WLC:�!C�h�QgQL@eCd!WUMbhªQL��h�C�Y ¬ d!WLYbzOWjM[BDBD��kezg��M[k!zON!MOzOCc��BDde��C�BDC$kyQUM[QL��YOk!K��Xtck¯M[��QLC$WUk!M[QL��¥OCcdeWUYOd;YbKUM[� ¬ YOW���feC$kyQL� ¬ Sp��kezQU@eCgBDC�MOke��k!z ¬ Ne�÷QUC$WUB'K�f3YpC�K#keYOQ#WUC�¹yNe��WUC¸h$YOBDdeN3QU��k!z�N!k!f3C$WR�(ºX��QcN!KaCiK¸Í�¤j�¦Ë �p¤j�OÃ.�;�[©ªµD�[ b���r©ªµ �³aÍ��b�i� � Kj·/��k'd!��Mbh�C�Y ¬ @ek ¬ � K���t ��@ek ¬ ��K�MGQUC$WUB Y ¬ QU@eC ¬ YOWUB������IYOWM� � �?#@!��K*KaCih�YOk�f d!WLYbd�YyKLMO�¬ YbWLB'K�QL@!C��!MOKL��KY ¬ QL@eC¸ �� �$ÁgQL@eC�YOWUSO��_�QUKQLWUC$C#KaQLWUN!hªQUNeWLCiKNek!f3C�W/QL@e��K/deWUYOd;YbKUM[�pM[WUC�QU@eC � J$¥pSy� � YOk!zOY

â�â54�6!þ87:98;

Page 63: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

�bq � Ì(À��[�y¿O�6�r©«¿O�

?�WUC$C�K��/?#@eC$WUCGMOWLCG��kbQUC$WUC�KaQL��kez�B'M[QL@eC�BDM[QL��h$MO�;BDY3f3C���K#Y ¬ QL@eC��e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!K���@eYyKaC���Y3h$MO�÷KTQUWLN!h�QLNeWUCG��Kd!WLCih���KaC���SDQU@eC � ?���Ci¹yN!M[���§QTSb¨eKaC�C� � kezywOw����t�K�M[k C$P3MOBDde��Cb¨�QL@eC^QUC$WUB'K������ ) MOk!f ) MOWLC¾fe��KaQL��kezON!��KL@eC�f ��k QL@!C¾��M �$S¼QL@eC�YOWUS ��Cih$MON!KaC

Ybke��S¾QL@!C ¬ YOWUBDC$W�@!MbK�M¯��@ek ¬ ÂX�!N3Q�QU@eC$S9M[WUC'��f3C�kyQL��×!C�f-MbKgBDC�M[k!��kezb��CiKLK���k9QL@!C�KaC�k!KL���e��C'QU@eC$YbWLS�;C�h�M[N!KLC'keC��§QU@eC$W @!MOK�MOk-@ek ¬ � � ��BD����M[WU��Sb¨C*&MOk!f-����� ) ¨�MOWLC'BDC�MOke��kezO��C�KUK¸��k M^KaC�k!Ka���e��C'QL@!C$YOWUSO¨�!N3Q#MOWLC�BDC�M[k!��kez ¬ Ne�÷M[k!f�f3��KTQU��kezbNe��Ka@eCif.��k�M ��M �$S�QL@!C$YOWUS^³£QU@eC$S�MOWLCGf3��KTQU��kezbNe��Ka@eCif.�pS ¬ C$Cif3��k!z�MOkMOWLzbNeBDC$kyQ�Ka��k!h�Cb¨ ¬ YOWcMO��� � ¨�* �Ø@�MOK�M���@ek ¬ ¨���@eC$WUC�MbKG#������ ) & � @!MOK#keYOQj·��

4 � 2 1 ��� � �� � > @ � > � 7�7 E @ 9 < !;7 �5> : ���E < � �;:�< � � 7 < !D7 > � 7 �

?�YDf3C�×!k!C � ?K#��C�keC�C�f�QL@eC¸keYOQL��YOk!K#Y ¬ QL@!C��;©L�j�e¤$©��r©LÃb¤�© Y ¬ M�QLC�WLB¯¨eMOk!f �3¤j�OÃ'©U¤UÃ[�!�����6�r��¨3��@e��hj@��C�keYr� ��kyQLWUY3f3N!h$CO�±sCcN�KaC3-�QLYgWjM[kezbC#Yr¥OC$W/QU@eCRKLC�Q�Y ¬ keYbkekeC�zbMrQU��¥bC#��kyQLC�zOC�WUKXMOk!f �sQUYgWLC�deWLCiKaC�kyQQU@eC¸×!WjKTQ�YbWUf3��k!MO�÷����BD�§Qi�?#@eC �[©LÃO¤$©¾Y ¬ M¾QUC$WUB C�P3deWUC�KUKLC�KgQU@eC¯B'MrP3��B NeB ��C$kezOQL@ Y ¬ QU@eC¯YON3QUC$WUB�YyKTQDKaCi¹yNeC$k!h$C�Y ¬

�e��M[�!KaQLWjMOh�QL��YOk!K/��k�MGQLC�WLB QLY���@e��hj@NI��KM9÷��h�Ybkp¥OC$WLQL���e��COÂ[��Q�KUM¦S3K/@eYr� �T@!��zb@eC$WL��YbWUfeC$W �:,��K��X\^YOWUCd!WLCih���KaC���Sb¨ @!MOK#YbWUfeC$W -È� ¬ -s��K�QU@eCg��MOWLzbC�KaQ���KLN!hj@�QL@!M[QR��9 ! � ���6� 12101K� � � �-¨ ¬ YbWcKaYbB�C �-�?#@!C$WUC ¬ YOWUCDM�QUC$WUB @!MbK¸YOWjf3C$W ��� ¬ ��Q���K¸keYOQ 9÷��h�YOkp¥bC$WLQL���e��C QLY^MOkySsM[�!KaQLWjMOh�QL��YOk®��?#@eC'WLC�B'M[��ke��k!zQUC$WUB'KgM[WUCDMbKLKL��zOkeCifÈYbWUf3C�W �cÂ(QU@eC$SÉM[WUC�QUC$WUB'K�KaN�hj@9MbK *²��@!��hj@-h$MOksWUC�feN!h�C�QLY¾MOkÉNekp��YbNek!f3CifkpNeB ��C�W#Y ¬ keCiKTQUC�f�M[�!KaQLWjMOh�QL��YOk!K��t²QLC�WLB�@�MOK*��©L�ª�3¤$©��r©LÃb¤�© -¾� ¬ �§Q#@!MbK*YbWUfeC$W�Y ¬ Nek!KLYO��¥rM[�e�����§QTS -X¨��� CO��¨!M ¬ QUC$W#QL@!Cg��ke��QL��M[� --�e��MO�!KTQUWUMbhªQU��Ybk!K��§Qc�;C$@!M¦¥bC�K������bC ) �/Û!YOWUB'M[����Sb¨

� @!MbKG��©L�ª�3¤$©��r©UÃO¤$© �e¨(��WL��QaQUC$k M�� ) ¨�� ¬ @!MbK¸YOWjf3C$W �¯M[k�f¾QU@eC$WUCD��K¸keY 7� KaN�hj@QL@!M[Q���9 ! � � 7�-Â

� @!MOK,��©L�ª�3¤$©9�[©LÃO¤$© - � �b¨���WL��QaQUC$k OM���3�� � ¨c� ¬ ��9 ! � ����� � ¬ YOW�KaYbBDC� M�� 3 Â

� @�MOK���©U�j�e¤�©��[©LÃO¤$© �c¨3��WU��QaQLC�kH M�� � ¨e� ¬ @!MOK#YbWUfeC$W��c�

t �3��QLC�WLB ��K�C��§QU@eC$W�Y ¬ QL@!C ¬ YOWUB �>7�8�5� � ¨XYOW Y ¬ QL@!C ¬ YbWLB �>7�8�0#������ ) &% � 10121K�3�¨ - � �O�_�kÈQL@eC���MrQaQUC$Wi¨;QL@eCDWUC�f3C$P/#������ ) &% � ��K�h�M[����Cif^QU@eC �3¤j�Oï©L¤jÃb¤KJb�¸_ ¬ @!MbK�M�@eCiMOf^WUC�f3C$P÷¨�QU@eC$k�;4=�� � @!YO��feK�� ¬ � WLCiKaN!�§QjK ¬ WUYOB �pS-9÷��WLCif3N!h���kez���QUK�@eC�Mbf'WUC�f3C$P�Â������R��K�QL@eC�WLC:�!C�P3��¥OCcM[k�fQUWUMOk!KL�§QU��¥bC�h���YbKLNeWUC.Y ¬ ;>= � � � ¤j�OÃs©L¤jÃr�!�$�«�6�[� ��� � ��K fe� ��C$WUC$kyQ ¬ WUYOB h�M[���§���pSb��k!MOB�C'WUC�feN!hªQU��Ybk��� º/M�h�M[���§���pSb��k!MOB�C�WUC�feC�PD��K�M[��KaY�M�@eC�MbfDWLCif3C�P÷¨y�eN3Q�QL@eCGh�Ybky¥bC$WjKaC���K ¬ MO��KLC�MbK�M�@eC�MbfDWLCif3C�P'h$MOkMO��KLY���Cg��Y3h$MrQUC�f�Nek!f3C�WLk!C�MrQU@^M[k¯M[�!KaQLWjMOh�QL��YOk®�±sCg@�M¦¥OCO¨3@!Yr�*C�¥OC$Wi¨

� Æ3Õ-ÕÉ� ��� � �� ÌG �����c����� �,� � ��� ����� �,P6Ê!���[©g�$�rµ'¤ �,PX�ª�!�������3�r� �HP������ �¼Ì

� ÌG �����:� 7��� � ���T� 7� Ì� ÌG �����c��� � �0121015�43$�5� 7� � � ���3¤�©L¤��r©U¤���¤�©ªµ �(���Ê ������� -/ÊX�j�!� ��� �p�[� ��� ��� � � � Y ������ ��� ��� � ����� � Ê ��� � � -\YÈ�r�;à �3����T� 7� Ì& � ŮŠ�U� ³TE¦·�MOk!f¾³ � ·�@!YO��f'��Cih$MON!KaC���YOQL@ ��� MOk!f ������deWUYOzbWLCiKLK�N!Ka��kez�QL@eC���C ¬ QLBDYbKaQ�WUC�feC�P÷Â÷³6mb·¬ Yb����Yr�cK ¬ WLYbBسaEi·�M[k!fɳ � ·ª� �

�´ó�â����

Page 64: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

���!��¤�©��;©L¤$�«�£�p¿R�j�3�������6�r�!�g�r�#���a�j�[ ����3 §�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª� �eE

?#@!C�f3C�×�ke�§QU��Ybk-��C���Yr�ÖY ¬ � ? ��K KL��B�d!��C.�!N3Q ��k ¬ YOWUB'M[���^t�deWUC�h���KLC.f3C�×!k!�§QU��Ybk �*YbNe��fÉWLCi¹bN!��WUC¬ YbWLB'MO����Ka��kez QL@eCgk!Y[QL��YOk¯Y ¬ ��M[�;C$��C�f�QLWUC$Cb�

� Æ��/Ð. £~� Å Ð � � � � ��� "÷à�á ��Å Ð(Ô Å � �rÆyÆp}�� � �3¤ � J�¥ySy� � YbkezOY¼?�WUC$C �T�^ ���È� �p¤9 ��b¶U¤� £ �¤Uà �«©L¤j¤�Ê� � � � �¦Ê�ÃO¤ ����¤jÃ'�£�;Ã[�!�����£¢r¤� ¡Á��¦�����r £ ��[Í/� �

� � + � #%'&����­� �( M�� � Ê� � + � #%'&��²��� � 121015�43$���°� �( M��G3�Ê � � - � ��Ê� � + � #%'&�� �>7���K����� � � � �+ � #%��2& 12101 + � #% 3 &� �( �����c�47�8�5�� � 10121�3�Ê�-����;Ì

0�� �!Õ-� Ò Æ ��� � � �(¤$�8 � ��#����4�K�4& ) � *:#���� � � � � ) &ªÌ � �p¤$�+ � #.'&�� ������

��� � � �

���6�5� � � � ���6� �>� ���±9Cc��f3C$kyQU� ¬ S ��h$YOkp¥OC�WaQU���e��C � ? � K$� � ?���Ci¹yN!M[���§QTS�h$MOk.M[��KaYg�;CRdeWUC�KLC$kyQUC�fDMOK*M ¬ YOWUB Y ¬ �!��KL��BD����MOWa�

��QTSO�/?#@e��K�e��KL��B�����M[WU�§QTSb¨!�j�e¤��¯�j�O�; ¡�6�j�r���£¢¦¤�¶����ª�£µ �£ ��r©ª�£��Ár¨b��K/MRWUC�×!k!C$BDC$kyQ/Y ¬ MOdede����h�MrQU��¥bC��e��Ka��BD����M[WU��QTS;Â��k!f3C�C�f���Qc��K�d;C$WU@!MOd!K*QL@eC�KL��BDde��C�KaQc�#M¦SDQLY'C�PpQUC$k!f¯M[d!de����h$M[QL��¥OCG�e��Ka��BD����M[WU�§QTS.QLYDYOd;C$k�QLC�WLB'K��

� Æ��/Ð. £~� Å Ð � � � � ���jÁrµ�µ'¤���©ª�6�D©L¤$ ��r���6�r� � �Q� �H�Ö���'�r�¯YOd;C$k9M[dede����h$MrQU��¥bC��e��Ka��B�N!��M[QL��YOk � ��� ���£µR�; ¡�6¤�� �� Ìg� �G ��� ������QP«Ê����3¤��s���3¤�©L¤ ¤KJb���ª�«� �,P��ª�!� �����3�r� � ��� ����� �,P��[�;Ã!QP � �,P �� Ìg� � ��� �4 � ]2]0]K 3;Ê����r©D�$�rµ'¤+- � �3ÊR� �p¤$�-���3¤��¼���3¤�©L¤�¤JO���ª� � � Y2]0]0]2Y � 3¼�ª�!� �È� �p�r� � ���� �-�8]2]0] � 3 �r��Ã! � � � � Ê!���r©��r £  ������� -�Ì

�(Í��È��¤$©ªµ � Y � � �r©L¤�YOd;C$k-M[d!de����h$M[QL��¥OCD�e��Ka��BD����M[W�ÊcÍX©ª�£����¤$�Z �� ����� �ÉÊc� �! � �ÉÊ(���[©�$�[µD¤��j�e¤��-�j�b�� ¡�6�j�[�«�£¢r¤.¶ª���ª�£µ��3 ��r���6�r� �sÌ

Ý*��M[N�KaC'³ � ·ª¨;h�YOk�h�C$WUke��kez�QLC�WLB'K�����QL@¾MD¥rM[WU��M[�e��C¸��k^@eCiMOf�d;YbKL�§QU��Ybk®¨e�#MOKcMO�!KaC�kyQ ¬ WLYbB�QL@!C�f3C ¬ ���ke��QL��YOk Y ¬ M[ded!����h$M[QL��¥OC.�e��KL��BD����MOWL��QTSO¨/��@eC�WLC�MO���*QLC�WLB'K�M[WUC.h���YbKLC�f÷�9\¯YOWUC$Yr¥bC$Wi¨(��k¼h�YbkbQUWUMbKTQ ���§QU@MOdede����h�MrQU��¥bC��e��Ka��BD����M[WU��QTSO¨���k h$��MON!KaC9³TE¦·�keYsQLC�WLB ��k!KaQUM[kyQU��M[QL��YOk¼Ybk �e��MO�!KTQUWUMbhªQU��Ybk!K���K WLCi¹bN!��WUC�f÷�?#@!��K*Ka��BDde����×�h�MrQL��YOkD��KXd;YbKUKa���e��C���Cih$M[N�KaC���C��*YbWL��YOk'YOd;C$k�QUC$WUBDK�M[k!f���K÷ZTN!KaQL��×!C�fD�pS�QL@eCRh$YOkezbWLNe�C�k!h�C*Y ¬ � ����� ��³«t¼KaQLWjM[��zO@yQ ¬ YbWL�#M[WjfRd!WLYpY ¬ QU@!MrQ � ����� ��K�MRh�YOk!zOWUNeC$k!h$C�N3QU������KLC�K(QL@!C ¬ Ne���3M[�!KaQLWjMOh�QL��YOk?#@!C$YOWUC$B'K�E�m!� � qRMOk!f.Eime� � E*MOk!fgQU@eC�h�YbkezOWUNeC$k�h�C�Y ¬ ����h$MO��h$Ne��N�K��!��KL��BD����MOWL��QTS � � · ?��*YGN!KLC ¬ Ne� ¬ MbhªQUKMOWLCbº

� Æ3Õ-ÕÉ� ��� � � �6�( ��� �ÉÊX���3¤��^ � ������ � Ì

â�â54�6!þ87:98;

Page 65: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

� � � Ì(À��[�y¿O�6�r©«¿O�

� Æ3Õ-ÕÉ� ��� � % ��¤���� ¶L¤'���ª��¶ª�ª�«�£���3�«�6�[���j©U�rµ­�'��¢¦�[©ª�6�b¶� �¤������D�3��¢r�r©ª�6�y¶ª �¤��$Ì �´� �� ��� � �ÉÊ#���3¤���� �������� ����Ì

��� Æ Å �¦Æ3Õ ��� � $ � ����� ��� � + � #%'&�� + � # �/&jÌ& � ŮŠ�U� �RKL��k!z � C$BDB'M�Eime��E���CGh�M[k�Ka@eYr� QU@!MrQ � ����� M[��KLY h�Yb��k�h���f3C�K�����QL@�QL@eC¸��M[WUzOC�KaQ*WUC$��MrQU��Ybk� YOk^� �^� KLN!hj@�QU@!MrQG� � ��BDde����C�K�º

Eb�X M�� � ��� � M�� � ¨� �X M���3�� � � M��G3÷¨m!��_ ¬ � � � ¬ ¥6#% Y �/&U¨ ����� � -X¨�QU@eC$k �����c��� � ]0]0]K�>36�K� � ]0]0]���-��� � �����c��� � ]0]2] �>3$�K��� � ]0]2] ���MOk!f^���� ���T¨ � ��� � � �Û��k!M[����SO¨3��Qc��K���BDBDC�f3��MrQUC¸QLY'KaC�CGQL@!M[Q � ��K#QL@!C � ? C�¹yN!MO����QTSO� �

?#@eC�YOWUC$B E�m!� os��K.N!KLC ¬ N!� ¬ YOW�WLC���M[QL��kez � ?���C�¹yN!M[����QTS QLY Y[QU@eC$W.�;C$@�M¦¥y��YON!WUMO�cC�¹yNe��¥rM[��C$k!h$C�K'Ybk�e��QLC$WUB'K$� ±sC¼KL@!MO���gN!KLC-��Q¾QLY deWUYr¥OCsQL@�MrQ � ?���C�¹yN!MO����QTS ��K¯QL@eC KUM[BDC MbK¯C�¹yN!M[����QTS²��k QU@eC �����kyQLC�WLdeWUC�QjMrQU��Ybk®��±9C�KaQUM[QLC�QU@eCRWUC�KLNe��Q�MOk!f�QL@eC�k.�eWU��C:�!S'f3��KLh$N!KLK��§Qi¨3f3C ¬ C�WLWU��k!z¸QL@eC�deWLYpY ¬ QUY � CihªQU��YbkEime� me�

��� Æ Å �¦Æ3Õ ��� � � Ò´Å �O� Ò }�~$� �(�O~��(�rÆ Å �c~ � Æ � á 6Ð;~iÆy� ���rÆy~��3~� Å Ð � ���� � �,+ �!#.'& � + � # ��&jÌ Æ3ÕÉ�3�¦Ï ��� � � Ý*Ybk!Ka��f3C�W*QU@eC¸QLC�WLB'K

$ %('�­�����2# ��#����4�2# ��* ) �>&K& **& � $ %('� �����2# ��# � * ) &(**&K�?#@!C�KLC�QUC$WUB'K�M[WUC¸MOdede����h�MrQU��¥bCG�!��KL��BD����MOW�ÂpQU@e��Kch$MOk��;CgdeWUYr¥OC�f��pS�MDh$MOKLCgM[k!MO��S3KL��K�Ybk�QU@eCgYOWjf3C�W�Y ¬QU@eC��e�«QUC$WUB�QL@�MrQc��K�zO��¥OC�k�MbK�M[k¯��k!deN3QcQUY QU@eCgQT��Y�QLC$WUB'K$��?#@!C¸QT�*YDQUC$WUBDK�h�M[k¯�;C�f3��KaQL��kezbNe��KL@eCifN�Ka��kez�QL@eC'h�Ybkp¥OC$WUzOC�k!h�C�QLC�KaQ �;¨ ¬ YOW #������ � � &�WLCif3N!h$C�K�QLY^M[k9M[�!KaQLWjMOh�QL��YOk®¨���@eC�WLCiMOK ��#������ � � &fe��¥bC$WUzOC�K�� � ��k�h�CN M[k!f � M[WUCDfe��KaQL��kezON!��KL@eC�fsN!KL��k!z¯QL@eC'Ybd�C�WUM[QLYOW �;¨(�pSÈ?#@!C$YOWUC$B E � ��E � QL@!C$SMOWLC¸f3��KTQU��k!zONe��Ka@!C�f��pS ����

��Ka��kezs?#@!C$YOWUC$B E�m!� w!¨/�*C�h�M[k d!WLYr¥bCN ��� �,Ka��BDde��S9�pSÉYO��KaC�WL¥p��kez¯QL@!M[Q�QU@eC$��W � ? � K�M[WUCfe� ��C$WUC$kyQ�º

+ � #%'& � �����K���� ����4�K� �

� ���

� � �

+ �!# �/& � �����5���� �� �

� ���

� ��

4 � 2�� !;7 # ��> >�� >�� < !D7 �?>3: ��UE <�� �;:�< ��� 7 < !;7 > � 7 �

_�ksYOWjf3C$W�QLY¯deWUYr¥OC ?#@eC$YbWLC�B E�me� we¨���C�×�WUKaQGk!C$C�f¾QLY�C�KaQUMO�e����KL@¾QL@!C�Ybd�C�WUM[QL��YOk!MO�h$YOWUWLCiKad;YOk�f3C$k!h$CYbk���C�MO�'QLWjM[k�Ka��QL��YOk!K#�;C�QT��C$C�k ¬ N!k!hªQU��Ybk!KcM[k�f�QU@eC$��WcdeWUY3h�CiKLK�C$k�h�Y3f3��kezbKg³«VXWLYbd�YyKa��QL��YOk�K¸E�me��E$nDM[k�fEime��E�����C���Yr�R·��

�´ó�â����

Page 66: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

���!��¤�©��;©L¤$�«�£�p¿R�j�3�������6�r�!�g�r�#���a�j�[ ����3 §�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª� �Om

?#@!CgC$k!h$Ypfe��kezDY ¬ M.�e�«QUC$WUB°��KcM[k¯M[��KTQUWUMbhªQL��YOk(¨pQL@!M[Qc��KcM ¬ N!k!hªQU��Ybk ¬ WUYOB­k!M[BDCiK�QLY'deWUY3h�C�KUKLC�K�ÂMO�!KaQLWjMOhªQU��Ybk!KDM[WUC¯WUMOkezOCif Yr¥OC�WD�yS��:Y���� ±9C^��kbQUWLY3f3N�h�C¾M9deWUYph$C�KUK�keY[QjMrQL��YOk ��@e��hj@ M[����Yr�cK�N!KQUY�zb��¥bC M�Ka��BDde��C$Wgf3C�KUh�WU��d3QL��YOk¾Y ¬ C$k�h�Y3f3��kezbKGY ¬ �3��QLC�WLB'K����§QU@9M�¥rM[WU��MO�e��C ��ks@eC�Mbf¾d;YbKL�§QU��Ybk ³«KaC�C� C$BDB'M¯E�m!��E � ·ª�

� Æ��/Ð. £~� Å Ð � � � ��2 ��r©3-�� �ÈÍ�¤ Ãb¤ ���;¤ �� 3 P � ) Y � 3 Y����BY2]0]0]2Y�� 3 R ������

�*� � Y0]2]0] Y � 3 � �LYK�6�BY2]0]2]0Y5� 3 � � ) # � �L&K� � ��P �6� Y � � R N ]0]0]�N � 3 � �L# � 3 &K� � 3 P � 3 Y � 3 RN � �6�����+N ]2]0] N � � 3 � 3 �

Í��3¤�©U¤����rµ'¤ª� � � Y0]2]0]2Y � 3 � � YK� � ]0]0]0Y5�>3÷Ê*�r�;à � �r©L¤*�j©L¤�� �pÌ?#@!C ����QL@ deWLY3h$C�KUK � � � � # � � &� � � P � �KY � �(R(Y ¬ � 3 P � ) Y � 3$Y�� � Y0]2]0]0Y���3�R®������C�WUM[QLC�K�QU@eC�M[zOC�kyQ � � ��� �÷MOk!f

QU@eC�# � � � &�� deWUY3h�CiKLK��� Æ3Õ-ÕÉ� ��� � ��� À��¦�b�3�r�$¤D-�� �pÌ

� Ì � 3 P � ) Y � 3 Y���� Y0]0]2] Y�� 3 R �# �*� 3 � �LYK� 3 & � � 3 � � P � ) Y � 3 � �LY����LY2]0]0]2Y�� 3 � � R N � 3 � � # � 3 &� � 3 P � 3 Y � 3 R N � � 3 � 3 � Ì� Ì �6� � 3 P � ) Y � 3$Y�� � Y2]0]2] Y��83 R � �;6= � �;4= M�Êg���3¤��

O � � � ) # � � &LÊO � �R# � � � Y � � & � � P � � Y � � R��[�;à M �

� 3��P � �BY � 3 Y��8� Y0]0]2] Y�� 3 R N � �6� � �OÌ

� Æ3Õ-ÕÉ� ��� � �� �´� -�� �eÊ����3¤��

) ) �6 � ]2]0]K 3 * *��� � � � ) # �CP � ) R3N � 3 P � ) Y � 3$Y ) ) � * *%Y0]2]0] Y ) ) �3 * *KR&K�& � ŮŠ�U� Ú�S.��k!f3N!h�QL��YOk¯YOk -X��ÛeYbW3- � �O¨

) ) �4�� * * � �

�*� ) � ) ) � * * �� N � �6�:# � ) # � �L&K� � �P �$�LY � � R N � �6� ) ) �� * *5& � �

�*� ) # �CP � ) R3N �!� P � ) Y � � Y ) ) �� * *KR&��Û!YOW3-�� �b¨3�*C¸@!M¦¥bCO¨eMO�e�eWUC$¥p��M[QL��kez � 3 � � # � 3$&K� � 3�P �>3$Y � 3 R N � �>3 ) ) �3 * *XQLY MDº

) ) �4 � ]0]0]��3 * *�� �

# �*� 3 � � Y5�43 & � ) ) �6 � ]2]0] 3 � � * *����� � N�M � � ³6nbmy·

# �*� 3 � � YK�>3 & � � � ) # �CP � ) R3N � 3�� P � ) Y � 3 � � Y � Y0]2]0]0Y��3 � � R& N�M � �

� � ) � � P � ) R3N # � � 3 � � Y5�43!& � � 3 � � P � ) Y � 3 � � Y� � Y2]0]0]2Y�3 � � R N�M � � ³6nOnp·

� � ) � � P � ) R N � 3 P � ) Y � 3$Y� � Y0]2]0]2Y�3 R � ³6nyxb·

��@!C$WUCD³6nbmy·�N�KaCiK���k�f3N!hªQU��Ybk^M[k!f9³´nbny·*N!KLC�K � C�BDBDM¯Eime��EOEy³TEi·U� �

â�â54�6!þ87:98;

Page 67: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

�On � Ì(À��[�y¿O�6�r©«¿O�

±9CgWLCih$MO����QU@eC�� ��K�QL@eCgC$P3d!M[k!KL��YOk�WLC���M[QL��YOk®¨eÇ�C�×!k!�§QU��Ybk¯ÚG� �e�

� Æ3Õ-ÕÉ� ��� � � �� Ì �6�(�;>= �ÉÊ����3¤�� ) ) * * � � ) ) � * *��!Ì� Ì �6�( �²����� �ÉÊ*���3¤�� ) ) * *�� � � �;4=

� � ���;>= ) ) � * *��OÌ

� Ì �6�( � �®Ê�� �p¤$� ) ) * * � ��� ���;6= Ì

� Ì �6�( � �4�� ]0]0]� 3 Í��p¤$©L¤ - ���3Ê�� �p¤$� ) ) * * � � � � �;4= � � 3 P � Y L Y ) ) �� * *%Y0]2]0]0Y ) ) 3 * *KR�Ì& � ŮŠ�U� ³ � ·gM[k!f ³«mb·gMOWLC'��BDB�Cif3��MrQLC ¬ WLYbB QL@!C�f3C�×�ke�§QU��Ybk-Y ¬ QL@eC�C$k!h$Ypfe��kez��9³6ny· ¬ Yb����Yr�cK ¬ WUYOB� C$BDB'M�E�me��E � ³ � ·ª�#³TEi·���K�M[k¯��BDB�Cif3��MrQLCgh$YOk!KLC�¹yNeC�k!h�C¸Y ¬ ]/P3C$Wjh���KaC �!� � EO� �

& � Å � Å }� £~� Å Ð � � � � � � Å ��Æb�r�3~� Å Ð(� Ò � Å �¦�rÆp}�� Å Ð�Ó�Æ3Ð��OÆ Å Ð ~ � Æ^�rÆyÓ ���[~� Å Ð�} Å � �

� Ì �6�( ��� �ÉÊ����3¤�� ) ) * * � � ) ) � * *��!Ì� Ì �6�( ��� ����� �ÉÊ�� �p¤$� ) ) * * � �

����� � �4# ��& ) ) � * *ªÌ

� Ì �6�( ���R�®Ê�� �p¤$� ) ) * * � ��� ������ � Ì

� Ì �6�( ���R�4 � ]2]0]��3ÉÍ��p¤$©L¤;- ���3ÊX� �p¤$� ) ) * * � � ������ � � 3 P � Y L Y ) ) * * � Y0]2]0]0Y ) ) �3 * *KR�Ì

& � ŮŠ�U� ³TE¦·���KR�pS���k!feN!hªQU��Ybk¾YOk^QU@eC�kpNeB ��C�W�Y ¬ WLCif3N!h�QL��YOk!K�M[k!f � C$BDB'M¾E�m!��Eim!³aEi·ª�c?#@!C�Y[QU@eC$WMbKLKLC$WLQL��YOk�K�MOWLC¸h�Ybk!KLC�¹yNeC$k�h�C�K�Y ¬ ³aEi·#M[k�f � C$BDB'M�Eime��E�m�³ � ��ny·�� �

� Æ3Õ-ÕÉ� ��� � ��� À��¦�b�3�r��¤ ) ) * * � �;4= M.Ì

� Ì �6�O� ��Ê�� �p¤$�È� �p¤$©L¤���� � �ª�!� ��� �p�r��U;>= � �r��à M � ) ) � * * � Ì

� Ì �6�O�����r� �r�3�����3�G�[� L÷ÊR� �p¤$�

O� L # �>&'�[�;ÃÈ���3¤�©L¤��r©U¤!��Y � �ª�!� �s� �p�[�: ������� � �r��à M �

�4# ��& ) ) � * *ªÌ� Ì �6�

O�����c�j©L¤j¤��r�3�����3�«Ê/� �p¤$�È� �p¤$©L¤����(� �ª�!�������3�r� O � � P L�R��[�;ÃUM � Ì

� Ì �[���3¤�©ªÍX���$¤�ÊR� �p¤$©L¤.�r©U¤ � �[�;Ã� � Y0]0]2]0Y��3;Ê - � �eÊ#�j�!� �È� �p�[�O� ��# � &aÊ � �4 � ]0]0]�3 �[�;Ã

M � � 3�P � Y L Y ) ) * * � Y0]0]2] Y ) ) �3 * * R$Ì& � ŮŠ�U� ÛeYbWgC�MOhj@/ MOk!f L(¨ ) ) * * ��@!MbK�Ybke��S¾YOkeCDd;YbKUKa���e��C�QUWUMOk!KL�§QU��Ybk®��?#@!CDMbKLKLC$WLQL��YOk�K ¬ Yb����Yr�¬ WUYOB � C$BDB'M�E�m!��Eime� �

& � Å � Å }� £~� Å Ð � � � ��% � Å ��Æb�r�3~� Å Ð(� Ò � Å �¦�rÆp}�� Å Ð�Ó�Æ3Ð��OÆ Å Ð ~$�r�!Ð�}� £~� Å Ð(} Å � ) ) * * � � À;�¦�O�e�¦�$¤ ) ) * * � ����M �

� Ì �6�O� ��Ê�� �p¤$�È� �p¤$©L¤���� � �ª�!� ��� �p�r�� ��� � �r��à M � ) ) � * *��eÌ

� Ì �6�O���s�r�&�r�3�����3�'�r� L÷Ê'� �p¤$�

O� L�# �>&¾�[�;ü���3¤�©U¤s�[©L¤I��Y � �ª�!��� ���3�r� ��� ����� � �[�;Ã

M � �4# ��& ) ) � * *ªÌ

�´ó�â����

Page 68: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

���!��¤�©��;©L¤$�«�£�p¿R�j�3�������6�r�!�g�r�#���a�j�[ ����3 §�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª� �bx

� Ì �6�O�����c�j©L¤j¤��r�3�����3�«Ê����3¤��¾� �p¤$©L¤����X� �ª�!�������3�r� O � �CP L�R��r�;à M � Ì

� Ì��[���3¤�©ªÍX���$¤�Ê�� �p¤$©L¤��[©L¤X� �[�;à � Y0]2]0]0Y��3;Ê - ���3Ê/�ª�!�������3�r�O� �8# � &LÊ� ���<�4 � ]2]0]��3;Ê��r�;Ã

M � � 3 P � Y L Y ) ) * * � Y0]0]2]0Y ) ) �3 * *KR�Ì& � ŮŠ�U� Ú�SD��k!feN!hªQU��Ybk�Ybk'QL@eC¸��C$kezOQL@�Y ¬ QU@eCRQUWUMOk!KL�§QU��Ybk�Y ¬ ) ) * * � ��ÛeYbW�QU@eCG�!MOKLCGh�MOKLCO¨ykeY[QUCRQU@!MrQ¬ YbWRCiMOhj@H M[k!f L(¨�deWUY3h�CiKLK ) ) * *��D@!MOKRYOke��S�YOkeCgd;YbKUKa���e��CgQLWjM[k�Ka��QL��YOk®�c?#@!C�MOKUKaC�WaQU��Ybk!K ¬ YO����Yr� �pS� C$BDB'M¯E�m!��Eime� �

±9C#keC$Cif M ¬ C$� ��C$BDB'MOK��C ¬ YOWUC�QUMOhj�p����k!zRQU@eC ¬ Ne���eMO�!KaQLWjMOhªQU��Ybk�QU@eC$YbWLC�BDK�� � C$BDB'M�E�me��E¦ocKa@!Yr�cKM�feC�h�YbBDd�YyKa��QL��YOk¸deWUYOd;C$WLQTS ¬ YbW÷zOWUYONek!fG�e��KL��BD����MOWL��QTS� � C$BDB'MOKXEime��E�w�M[k!fDEime��E�v�Ka@!Yr�sdeWUYOd;C$WLQL��C�K�Y ¬QU@eC#deWUYph$C�KUKaCiK!� 3 P ��� Y � 3$Y�� � Y2]0]0]2Y��83 Rj¨[��kyQLWUY3f3N!h�Cif���k Ç�C�×!k!�§QU��Ybk�Eime��E�q#QUY�WUC$deWUC�KLC$kyQ®QU@eC#C$k!h$Y3f3��k!zY ¬ �e��QLC$WUB'K#���§QU@^M ¥rMOWL��M[�e��C¸��k¯@eCiMOf�d�YyKa��QL��YOk(�Û!YOW¸M.deWUY3h�CiKLK MD¨÷�*C ��C$Q � � �;C�QU@eC�KLC�QGY ¬ k�M[BDC�KGM[��YOkez���@e��hj@ M�h$MOkÈd;C$W ¬ YOWUB MOkÈMOh�QL��YOk®¨

��� CO��¨� � � @0Q � ¬ YbWcKaYbB�CgMOk!f M P÷M[k!f O ����QL@¾KLNe�3ZTCihªQDQ;¨ M ���� M P F �

� Æ3Õ-ÕÉ� ��� � ��$� ̸À;�¦�O�e�¦�$¤ ¬ k�# M�� Y M8�L&��,# ��� ��� ��� �L& � ��Ì � �p¤$� M � N�S � � M8� NS �.�£µR�; ¡�6¤ª�;M�� � M��yÌ� ̸À;�¦�O�e�¦�$¤���Y � � ¬ k�# �:Y�� &jÌ � �3¤�� � � � � � � � �£µ��� §�6¤ª� ��� � � �bÌ

& � ŮŠ�U� ±9C�×�WUKaQcdeWUYr¥OCD³TEi·���?#@eC¸WLC���M[QL��YOk

� $ %('�"@ # M � Y M � &�� M � N�S � � M � N�S �¬ YOWcKLYOBDC S � Y S � ����QL@ ¬ k # M � Y M � &�,# � � �� � � �B& � � F

��K�M�zOWUYONek�f.�e��Ka��B�N!��M[QL��YOk®��?#@eC¸deWUYpY ¬ ��K�KaQLWjM[��zO@yQ ¬ YbWL�#M[Wjf÷¨ ¬ YOW#� ¬¬ k�# M � Y M � &�H# � � ��� � � � & � �3¨k!Ys��kyQLC$WjMOh�QL��YOk �;C�QT��C$C�k M!�¸M[k!f S��G��K�d;YbKUKa���e��CO¨ � � � Y e�¼\¯YOWUC$Yr¥bC$Wi¨�� ¬ MO�����;YONek!f k!MOB�CiK�Y ¬MbhªQU��Ybk!K#Y ¬ M �GMOk!f M��gMOWLC ¬ WUC�KL@®¨pQL@eC�k�QL@eC�KL��feC�h�YOk�f3�§QU��Ybk�Y ¬ � ��K#deWLCiKaC�WL¥bC�f÷��RYr�-MOKUKaC�WaQU��Ybk�³ � ·ª��±sC�@!M¦¥OC/QUYRKa@!Yr�ÈQU@!MrQ � � � � � �(±9C�h�M[k�MOKUKLNeBDCO¨i���§QU@eYON3Q���YyKLK÷Y ¬ zOC$k!C$WjM[���§QTSb¨QU@!MrQ � �� �(� � ��k!h�C�� � � � � � � M[k!f � � � � �

��;4= ���+N � � �D¨e�*C¸@!M¦¥bCO¨ ¬ YbWcKaYbB�C+MD¨

� � � � ���;4= ����M � ��� N � � � � ³6n �y·

� ��k!h$C,� f3YpC�K.k!Y[Q�Y3h$h$NeW���k � � ¨RkeY ��kbQUC$WjMOh�QL��YOk ��C$QT�*C�C$k � � M[k!f � � � B'M¦S¼@!M¦¥bC¾Y3h$h$NeWLWUC�f®ÂQU@eC$WUC ¬ YbWLC+M ��K�Y ¬ QU@eC ¬ YOWUB M�� N � � ��¨ ¬ YOWcKLYOBDC+M � KLN!hj@�QL@!M[Q

� � ;4= ����M��:� ³6npoO·

?#@pN!K�³´n �y·�h$M[k��;Cg��WL��QaQUC$k M � N � � � � � � N � � �D��Û!WLYbB�QL@e��K���C¸zOC�QM�� � ��� ³6nbwy·

N�Ka��kez�QL@eC�MbKLKLC$WLQL��YOk9³TE¦·�Y ¬ QU@eCg��C$BDB'Me¨eKL��k!h$C ����� � ���

��� � @ � F�M[k�fI�^��K#keYOQ ¬ WUC$C¸��k � � MOk!fM��#� � ��BD����M[WU��SO¨®³´C$Pehj@!M[kezb��k!z � M[k!f �g·�¨e�*Cgh�M[k¯f3C$WU��¥bCO¨ ¬ YbWcKaYbB�C+M � ¨

��� ;4= ����M � Y M[k!f M � � � � � ³6nbvy·

â�â54�6!þ87:98;

Page 69: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

� � � Ì(À��[�y¿O�6�r©«¿O�

�RYr�g¨3�*C¸C$Ppd!��Yb�§Q�³´n3oi��nbvy·XQUY.Ka@eYr� QL@!M[Q � � � � � º�Û!YOW#QL@!��K�¨e��C�QjM[�bC

� $&%('� @ # ��� Y�� �B&Y0# � �LY����B&KF � �

MOk!f Ka@eYr�°QL@!M[Q.�§Q.��K'MÉzOWUYON!k!f �e��KL��B Ne��M[QL��YOk®� � Neded;YbKLC ��� �;6= ;4= S � � ±9C¾Ka@eYr�­@eYr� � �h�M[ksBDM[QUhj@ÈQL@e��K¸BDYr¥OCOº � ��k!h�C � � � M � �*C�@!M¦¥bCUM � ����� S � � S � ��?#@eC$WUC ¬ YbWLCb¨;N�Ka��kezɳ´npoO·ª¨� � ;4= ��� M � ����� S � � S � ¨���@e��hj@¾h���YbKLC�K�QU@eC��!��KL��B Ne��MrQL��YOk(� � ��BD����M[WU��S ���gh$MOk^B'MrQUhj@^MOkMbhªQU��Ybk�Y ¬ � � � �

� Æ3Õ-ÕÉ� ��� � � �´� � 3�P � ) Y � 36Y�� � Y2]0]2] Y��83 R � � �UP � ) Y � �!Y � � Y2]0]0]0Y�� � R¸� �p¤$� - � � Ì� Æ3Õ-ÕÉ� ��� � � � � 3 P � ) Y � 3 Y�� � Y0]2]0] Y�� 3 R � � 3 P � ) Y � 3 Y�� � Y0]0]2] Y�� 3 R¾� �T# � � & � � # � � & � ���r©-�r £ ����� � -²�r�;ÃR���r©g�$�[µD¤*�j©L¤�� � � Ì

& � ŮŠ�U� ?#@eC.��BDde����h$M[QL��YOk ¬ WUYOBØWL��zO@yQgQLYÈ��C ¬ Q ¬ YO����Yr�cK ¬ WLYbBØh$YOkezbWLNeC�k!h�CDdeWUYOd;C$WLQL��C�K�Y ¬ � �^ÛeYOWQU@eC�h�Ybkp¥OC$WjKLCR��CGd!WLY3h�C�C�f��pS.��k�f3N!hªQU��Ybk¯YOk -X�/±sCgYbke��S�h�Ybk!Ka��f3C�W*QU@eCg��k!f3N!h�QL��¥OC�h$MbKaCb� � C�Q

M $&%('� � 3 P � ) Y � 3$Y�� � Y0]0]2]0Y���3 Rª¨ S $&%('� � 3 P � ) Y � 36Y � � Y2]0]0]0Y�� 3 Rª�Ú�S � C$BDB'M�E�me��EOEy³ � ·ª¨yQL@eC���Wc×!WUKaQ#QT�*Y�QUWUMOk!Ka��QL��YOk�K�MOWLC

M �� ��;4= ��� �

�� �� � � � � � � �;>= � � 3

�� P � � Y � 3 Y��8� Y2]0]0]2Y�� 3 R3N � �6� ���[¨

S �� ��;4= ��� �

�� �� � � � � � � �;>= � � 3

�� P � � Y � 3 Y�� � Y0]0]2]0Y � 3 R N � �6��� �[�

Û!WLYbB QU@e��K�¨i�*C�h�M[kgf3C$WU��¥OC M � S ��BDde����C�K!� 3�� P � � Y � 36Y�� � Y2]0]2]0Y��83 R N � � � � � � � 3 � � P � � Y � 36Y � � Y2]0]2] Y�� 3 R N

� �6� � �r� � C�Q M�� $ %('� � 3�� P � � Y � 3 Y��8� Y2]0]0]2Y�� 3 RGM[k!f S!� $&%('� � 3

�� P � �LY � 3 Y � � Y2]0]0]2Y�� 3 Rª��?#@eCDYOke��S

MbhªQU��Ybk!K�QU@!MrQ � �6� ����M[k!f � �$� � ��h$MOk¼d;C$W ¬ YOWUB M[WUC�M[Q-�$��MOk!f÷¨��pS � C$BDB'M¼Eime��EOEb³ � ·�¨/QL@eC�YOke��SMbhªQU��Ybk!K�QU@!MrQDM � M[k!f S � h$M[k�d�C�W ¬ YbWLB�MOWLC¸MrQ � � � � ��k�h�C � � ��K*k!Y[Q ¬ WLC�C���k � � � � � MOk!f � � � � � ¨eM[k�f� � ��KckeY[Q ¬ WUC$C¸��k M � M[k�f S � ¨eN!KL��k!z � C$BDB'M�E�me��E¦oe³TE¦·XQT����h�C¸��CG��k ¬ C�W

� � � � � � � � � � � M[k�f M � � S �Û!WLYbBÖQL@eCG×!WjKaQ��pS � C�BDBDM�E�m!��Ero3³ � ·X��CGzOC�Q #����L& � � # � � & � ��Û!WLYbBÖQL@eCgKLC�h�Ybk!f.�pSDQU@eC¸��k!feN!hªQU��Ybk@pSpd;Y[QL@!C�KL��K#��C¸zOC�Q # � � & � � # � � & � ¨ ¬ YOW� � � � -X� �

±9C�keYr�9WUC�MOfeScQLYRdeWLYr¥bCQL@!M[Q(YOd;C$k�MOdede����h�MrQL��¥OCX�!��KL��BD����MOWL��QTSR��K÷QU@eC�KUM[BDC�MbK�QL@eC���Y3h$MO�bKaQLWUN!hªQUNeWUCY ¬ QU@eCg������kyQLC�WLdeWUC�QjMrQU��Ybk®�

��� Æ Å �¦Æ3Õ ��� � �2 � } Å ��Ð�Ó/Ð(Æp}i} Ñ ��� ��~ � �� ����� � � � �£µ��� ¡�6¤��G �������� � Ì

& � ŮŠ�U� Ú�S�Ç�C�×!k!�§QU��Ybk¼EOEb� xDMOk!fÈÝ*YOWUYO����M[WUS �e� � m!¨e��C�@!M¦¥bC¸QLY�d!WLYr¥bC¸QL@!M[Q ) ) * * � ) ) � * **��B�d!����C�K � ����� �-�/±9CgdeWLYr¥bCRQU@!MrQ

�O$&%('� @ #% Y �/&/� ) ) * * � ) ) � * *KY:F��K#M[k.Ybd�C�k�MOdede����h�MrQL��¥OC��e��Ka��B�Ne��MrQU��Ybk®�XÛ��WjKTQi¨eKaN!ded�YyKaC ��� �����QP«�X±sCG@!M¦¥bCcQLY ×!k!f �HP�KaN�hj@QU@!MrQ � ���I����� �HP�MOk!f�#%QP Y �HP & �¾�'Û!WLYbB ��� �����QP�MOk!fÈVXWUYOd;YbKL��QL��YOk E�me��E$n;³ � ·ª¨��*CzbC�Qi¨ ¬ YOWcM[WU�e��QLWjM[WUS'k!M[BDCiK L�MOk!f � ¨

�´ó�â����

Page 70: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

���!��¤�©��;©L¤$�«�£�p¿R�j�3�������6�r�!�g�r�#���a�j�[ ����3 §�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª� �yo

) ) * * � ������

� � ������ � ) ) QP * *�� �

� ��k!h$C ) ) * * � � ) ) � * * � ¨3QU@eC$WUC¸��K3M P P®KLN!hj@�QL@�MrQ) ) � * *�� �

�����

� � ������ M P P � ) ) P * *�� � ³�x[qy·

±9C�h$MOk�f3Cih�YbB�d;YbKLC ) ) � * * � ������

� � ������ M P P���kyQLY ) ) � * * � ��� �

��;>=�M P � � � � ���� M P P«¨ ¬ YbW#KLYOBDC M P6��?#@!C$k®¨

N�Ka��kez¾VXWUYOd;YbKL�§QU��Ybk E�me��E���³TE$� � ·ª¨÷��C'��k ¬ C�WgQL@�MrQ�QU@eC$WUC.M[WUC��HP�MOk!f �HP P�KaN�hj@sQU@!MrQ ����� ����� �HPMOk!f �HP���� �HP P����§QU@ M P � �4# ��& ) ) �HP * *�MOk!f

M P P � ) ) � P P * *�� � ³�x3E¦·

\^YOWUC$Yr¥OC�W�¨y�pS�VXWUYOd;YbKL�§QU��YbksEime��E$n;³TEi·�¨

) ) � P * * � � ) ) � P P * * � � ³�x � ·

� ��k!h$C � � � ¨3��Cgh$MOk�h�YbB��e��keC'³«xOqb·�¨®³«x3E¦·�MOk!f9³«x � ·XQUY'f3C$WU��¥bC ) ) QP * * � � ) ) �HP * * � Â!@eC$k!h$C\#.QP Y �HP & �¾¨�MOK#WUC�¹yNe��WLCif÷��RYr�²KLNeded;YbKLC ���T�6 � ]0]2]�3��/±9CgKaNed!d�YyKaC - ���eÂpQU@eCgh$MbKaC - � ����K�KL��BDde��C$Wi�/±sC¸@!M¦¥bCRQUY×�k!f � � Y2]0]2]0Y � 3�KLN!hj@�QL@!M[Q � ���T��� � ]0]2] �!3�M[k!f����� ���L¨ ¬ YbWcM[��� �U�Û!WLYbB°VXWUYOd;YbKL�§QU��YbksEime��E$n;³´ny·�¨p�*C¸zOC$Q

) ) * * � � ������ � � 3�P � Y L Y ) ) � * *%Y0]2]0]2Y ) ) 3 * *KR

MOk!f÷¨ ¬ WUYOB ) ) * * � � ) ) � * * � M[k!f�VXWUYOd;YbKL�§QU��YbksEime��E��!³6ny·�¨ ¬ YbWcKaYbBDC � MOk!f �-� Y2]0]2]0Y � � ¨) ) � * *�� � �

����� � � ��P � Y L�Y ) ) � � * *%Y0]0]2]0Y ) ) � � * * R ³�x[my·

����QL@ � 3 P � Y L�Y ) ) � * *.Y2]0]2] Y ) ) 3 * * R � � � P � Y L Y ) ) �-� * *%Y0]2]0]2Y ) ) � � * *KRj� ÛeWUYOB QU@e��K'MOk!f � C$BDB'MOK�E�m!��EiwMOk!f E�me��E�v���C���k ¬ C�W¸QL@!M[Q � �O- M[k�f¾QU@!MrQ ) ) �� * * � ) ) ��� * *�¨ ¬ YbW�M[��� �U�.\¯YbWLC�Yr¥OC�W�¨ ¬ WUYOB ³�x[mb·GMOk!fV�WLYbd�YyKa��QL��YOk9E�m!��E��!³´np·���C¸��k ¬ C$W�QU@!MrQ

� ���T� � � ]2]0] � 3 ��RC$k!h$C�#. � Y � � & �¾� �

��� Æ Å �¦Æ3Õ � � � 3��� � Å Õ-� Ò Æb~iÆ3Ð(Æp}i} Ñ ��� ��~ � �� ����� � �������� �,�£µR�; ¡�6¤ª�G � � Ì

& � ŮŠ�U� ±9C¸KL@eYr�²QL@!M[Q

� $&%('����@ # ) ) * * � Y ) ) � * * � &/� �� ����� �/F

��K¸h���YbKLC�f^N!k!f3C$WgKLNe�!KaQL��QLN3QU��Ybk!K¸M[k!fÈ��K¸M�zOWUYONek!f¾�e��KL��B�Ne��MrQU��YbkÈNed3��QLY�h�YbkbQUC�PpQgM[k!f^N!d3�«QUY � ��Ú�S?#@!C$YOWUC$B­Ú�� we¨pQU@e��K���BDde����C�K � � � �Û��WUKaQ�¨��*C�KL@eYr� QL@!M[Q � ��K�h���YbKLC�f�Nek!f3C�W�KLNe�!KaQL��QLN3QU��Ybk!K$�#?#@eC ¬ WUC$Cgk!MOBDC�K�Y ¬ MDd!WLY3h�CiKLK ) ) * * � M[WUC@ L$F � ¬ ¥6#.'&L�X?#@eC�WLC ¬ YOWUCO¨ ¬ YbW�C�Mbhj@Dk!M[BDCRKLNe�!KaQL��QLN3QU��Ybk���QL@eC�WLCc��K�M¸¥rMOWL��M[�e��CcKLNe�!KaQL��QLN3QU��Ybk � KLN!hj@QU@!MrQ # ) ) * *�� &�� � ) ) �� * * ���G�

â�â54�6!þ87:98;

Page 71: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

�bw � Ì(À��[�y¿O�6�r©«¿O�

� ��k!h$C��pS � C�B�B'M^Eime� � �� ��� � ��K�h���YbKLC�f^Nek�f3C$WG¥rM[WU��MO�e��C KaNe��KTQU�§QUN3QL��YOk!K�¨�� ��KGh���YbKLC�f¯N!k!f3C$WGk!MOB�CKLNe�!KaQL��QLNeQL��YOk!K���RYr�É�*C�KL@eYr�9QL@!M[Q � ��K(M�zbWLYbNek!f¸�e��Ka��B�N!��M[QL��YOk¸Ned3��QLYRh$YOkyQLC$PpQ�M[k!f¸N!d3�«QUY � � � C�Q*# ) ) * * � Y ) ) � * * � & � M[k�fsKLNeded;YbKLC�QL@!M[Q ) ) * *�� �;4=�MD�'Ú�SÈVXWUYOd;YbKL�§QU��Ybk¼Eime��E��e¨�QU@eC$WUC'M[WUC ¬ YONeW�h�MOKLC�K�QLY^h�Ybk!KL��f3C�W�¨Mbh$h$YOWjf3��k!z�QUY¯QL@eC ¬ YOWUBØY ¬

O��±sC�YOke��SsKL@eYr� QL@eC�M[WUzONeBDC$kyQ ¬ YOW�QL@eC�h�MOKLC'��@eC$k

O��K�M^�;YONek�f

YbN3QLd!N3Q ��# � & ³£QU@e��K�h$MOKLCDkeC$CifeK¸�;Y[QL@ÉNede�«QUY¯h$YOkyQLC$PpQ�M[k!fsNed3��QLY � Â�QL@eC'YOQL@eC�W�h$MOKLC�KgMOWLCDKL��BDde��C$W�;C�h�M[N!KLCGQL@eC�S�Ybke��S�keC$Cif�Ybke��S�Ned3��QLY �¸·ª�Ú�S�V�WLYbd�YyKa��QL��YOk¯E�m!��E��!³6ny·ª¨[MOk!f QL@eC�WLC�MOWLC:��MOk!f� � Y0]2]0]2Y�3�KaN�hj@�QU@!MrQ* � �6 � ]2]0] 3 IM[k�fM � � 3 P � Y L Y ) ) �� * *%Y0]2]0] Y ) ) 3 * *KRj� � ��k!h$C! � ��� � �-¨pQU@eC$WUCgM[WUC �-�BY2]0]2] Y � 3 KLN!hj@�QL@!M[Q

� ���T���\�8]0]2] � 3 ³�xrny·

MOk!f �� �� ����� ���5Y ¬ YbWcM[��� ��� � � -X� ³�xOxO·�RYr�g¨ ¬ WLYbB ³«x[ny·�¨3�yS�VXWUYOd;YbKL�§QU��YbkÈE�m!��E�n ��C¸zOC$Q

) ) � * * � � ������ � � 3 P � Y L Y ) ) �\� * *.Y2]0]2]0Y ) ) � 3 * *KR

MOk!f ¬ WLYbB ³«xbxO·���CGzbC�Q # ) ) �� * * Y ) ) ��� * *�L& �¬ YbWcM[��� � � � NeBDB'M[WU��KL��kez!¨3��C¸@!M¦¥OCGYO�3QjM[��keC�f�QL@�MrQ

) ) * * � � ������ � � 3�P � Y L Y ) ) � * *%Y0]2]0]0Y ) ) �3 * *KR4Y

) ) � * * � � ������ � � 3�P � Y L Y ) ) � � * *%Y0]2]0]2Y ) ) � 3 * * R4YcMOk!f# ) ) �� * *� Y ) ) ��� * * & �HY ¬ YOWcMO��� � M[k�f ������� -X�

?#@!��K#��K�C$k!YONezb@®¨3��Cih$MON!KaC � ��K�M�zbWLYbNek!f��e��KL��B�Ne��MrQU��Ybk�Nede�«QUYDh$YOkyQLC$PpQRM[k!f�Ned3��QLY � � �

_�Q¸��KG��YOWLQL@¾KaQLWUC�KUKa��kez�QL@!M[Q�����QL@eYbN3Q�QU@eC �TNede�«QUY�h�YbkyQLC�PpQgM[k!f¾Ned3��QLY ����QUC�hj@ek!��¹yNeC QL@eC�deWUYpY ¬Y ¬ ?#@eC�YOWUC$B Eime� � EG�*YbNe��f��;CgB�N!hj@���YOkezbC$Wi�?#@eC�YOWUC$B'K¸E�m!� � qDM[k!f9E�m!� � E¸deWLYr¥bCG?#@!C$YOWUC$BØE�m!� w!�X±sC�KLNeBDB'M[WU��KLCGQL@eC�WLCiKaNe��QUKcY ¬ ?#@eC$YbWLC�BDK

Eime�¡o�MOk!fsE�me� weº

� Å � Å�Ò´Ò �3�¦à ��� � � ��r©��r £ 6 Y � ^�cÊ��£� �p�[ �æ��� �p�[� � ��� � �� ����� � � � + � #.'& � + � # �/&jÌ

Æ3ÕÉ�3�¦Ï ��� � *� � Å ~ � Æb���O� Ò´Ò áU|�à�ájÐ��!ÕÉÆ ÆpÐ�� Å Ó. 6Ð�Ô;}�� ?#@eCX��Y3h$MO�OKTQUWLN�hªQLN!WLCXY ¬ QU@eC�������kyQLC�WLd!WLC$QUMrQU��Ybk³«?#@eC$YbWLC�B E�m!� wy·�f3YpC�K�keYOQ#hj@�M[kezbC�� ¬ QL@!C¸h�M[���§���pSy��k!MOBDCRC$k�h�Y3f3��kez ��K*QUMO�OC$k�QLY���CGQU@!MrQ���k�?M[�e��Cgo³´QL@!M[Q*@!MbK*M�WLC�de����h$M[QL��YOk'��k ¬ WUYOB Y ¬ QU@eCGMO�!KaQLWjMOhªQU��Ybk�·/YbW�QL@�MrQ*��k�?M[�e��C�w!�X?#@eCRdeWUYpY ¬ K*M[WUCRKa��BD����M[WQUY�QL@eYyKaC¸zO��¥OC�k���k�QL@e��KcKLC�h�QL��YOk®� �

4 � 2 � ����! � � 7�7 E

?#@!C.³´��k ¬ YOWUB'M[�£·#f3C�×!k!�§QU��Ybk^Y ¬ Ú�ÞO@eB ?(WUC$C'³6Ú#?c·#��K�Yb�3QUMO��keCif ¬ WLYbB�QL@�MrQRY ¬ � ?Ö³6Ç�C�×�ke�§QU��Ybk-E�m!� � ·�pS.WUC$d!��Mbh���kez�h$��MON!KLC�Kg³TE¦·#M[k!f9³ � ·����§QU@�QL@eC�h$��MON!KaCbº

�´ó�â����

Page 72: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

���!��¤�©��;©L¤$�«�£�p¿R�j�3�������6�r�!�g�r�#���a�j�[ ����3 §�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª� �Ov

���!#.'& ��� � ¬ M�� 3 ¨ � � -�� �c�

±9CR�!WL��C �!SDf3��KLh$N!KUK�@eYr� QLY�YO�3QjM[��k.Ú�?K ¬ WLYbB MOk'C$k!h$Ypfe��kez�Y ¬ QL@!CG�e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!K���kyQLY�����h$MO��h$Ne��N!K$�?#@!C�f3C$×!ke��QL��YOk�Y ¬ Ú#? ��K*�!MOKLC�f'YbkDQL@eCGkeYOQL��YOk.Y ¬ @!C�MOf.keYOWUB'M[� ¬ YbWLB ³6WUM[QL@eC�W�QL@�M[k.Ybk.�*CiM[��@eC�Mbfk!YOWUBDMO� ¬ YOWUB MOKG��kÈQL@eC'h�MOKLC Y ¬ � ?�Kj·GKa��k!h$C Ybke��S¯QU@eC�QLC�WLB'KG���§QU@s@!C�MOfÈkeYOWUB'M[� ¬ YOWUB @!M¦¥bC Ú#?�Kfe� ��C$WUC$kyQ ¬ WLYbB � �¸?�Y�f3C$×!keCDM.����h$M[��h�N!��N!KGKLC$B'M[kyQL��h$KRQL@�MrQGh�M[d3QUNeWUC�KGÚ�?���C�¹yN!MO����QTS��*C�QL@eC�WLC ¬ YOWUCk!C$C�f�QU@eC ¬ YO����Yr����kez QT�*YDBDY3f3��×�h$M[QL��YOk!K�º

EO��?#@eC¸����h$M[��h�N!��N!K#C�k!h�Y3f3��kez'Y ¬ M'�3��QLC�WLB Ka@!YONe��f�MO����Yr�²WUC�feN!hªQU��Ybk!K�Nek!f3C�W��-³´WUNe��C 1 ·ª�

� ��?#@eC'�;C$@!M¦¥p��YOWjM[�/C�¹yNe��¥rM[��C$k!h$C'hj@eYbKLC$k ¬ YOW¸QU@eC'����h$M[��h�N!��N!K�Ka@eYbNe��fs�;C.f3��¥OC�WLzbC$k!h$C���KaC�k!Ka��QL��¥OCb¨QL@�MrQ¯��K�WUC$zbMOWUf²f3��¥bC$WUzOC�k!h�C¾Y ¬ M ����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�deWUYph$C�KUK�MbK�fe��KUMOKaQLWUYON!K���?#@e��K���K�keC�h$C�KUKLMOWLS�;C�h$MON!KLC QU@eC�h$YOBDdeN3QjMrQL��YOk9Nek!feC$WgQU@eC � � � B'M¦S¾k!C$¥OC�W¸QLC�WLBD��k!MrQUC¾³£QL@!��K�@!M[ded;C$k�K¸��kÉQUC$WUBDKQL@�MrQc@!M¦¥bCGM���@ek ¬ �eN3Qck!Y'@ek ¬ ¨e�����bC������ ) M[k!f *�·ª�

?�Y'KLM[QL��K ¬ S¾³aEi·�¨e�*Cgh�M[k.QjM[�bC�QU@eC¸����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K#C�k!h�Y3f3��kezDY ¬ KTQUWLYbkez�h�M[���§���pSy��k!MOBDCO¨y��k � CihªQL��YOk¯ve�Û!YOWg³ � ·ª¨3��CGh�M[k�QUM[�bCGM�f3��¥OC�WLzbC$k!h$C���KaC�k!Ka��QL��¥OC��!��KL��BD����MOWL��QTS ±9MO��vbq ��¨3YbW*B N!KaQa��QLC�KaQL��kez �RC$k!wbw ���/_�kQU@e��K#��M¦Sb¨OQU@eC¸������kyQLC$WUdeWUC�QjMrQL��YOk�¥¦MO����feM[QLC�K�Ci¹bN�MrQL��YOk�K�KLN!hj@�MOK������ ) � ) M[k!f * � ) ¨yQL@!M[QcM[WUCGM[QQU@eCg�!MbKa��K#Y ¬ QL@eCgf3����C$WUC$k!h$Cg��C$QT�*C�C$k � ?�KcMOk!f�Ú�?K��

4 � 2 � � >3: �� E<�� � :�< � � 7 >�� < !D7 : ��.� � � �� ��4� � 7"7 @;: > 9 =5@ �V�WLY3h�C�C�f3��kez¯MOK ¬ YOW¸QU@eC'h$MO�������pSy��k!M[BDC�C�k!h�Y3f3��kez�¨÷YOkeC'h$MOksKL@eYr�&QU@!MrQ�M[��KLY.QL@!C.h$M[�������pSy��¥rMO��NeC C$k3�h$Y3f3��k!z�Y ¬ ?M[�!��Cgm���KRKaYbNek!f÷¨3�eNeQckeY[QRh$YOBDde��C�QLCb¨e�g� W�� Q��pQU@eCgYOd;C$WjMrQU��Ybk!M[��C�¹yNe��¥rM[��C$k!h$C¸Y ¬ � �.��ÛeYOWh$��YyKaCifÈ�e�«QUC$WUBDK Y �-¨�� ¬ � ) ) * *�M[k�f � ) ) � * *cM[WUC���C�@!M¦¥p��YbNeWjM[����S���k�f3��KaQL��kezbNe��KL@!MO�e��CDMOK�����h$M[��h�N!��N!Kd!WLY3h�CiKLKLC�K�¨;QL@eC�k MOk!f � M[WUC�Ybd�C�WUM[QL��YOk!MO����S¯C�¹yNe��¥¦MO��C�kyQ���kÉ� � ³«f3C�×�keC�f9MOK ¬ YOW¸h$MO�������ySy��k!M[BDCb¨Ç�C�×�ke�§QU��Ybk EOEb��E¦·ª��Ú�N3QgQU@eC�h�Ybkp¥OC$WjKLC B'M¦S ¬ MO������Û!YOW�M¯h�YbNekyQLC�WLC$P3MOBDde��Cb¨÷QUMO�OCN $&%('� �����K� MOk!f� $&%('� �����U���6�0# ���4&¾³´keYOQLCOº QL@e��K^h�YbNekyQLC$WUC�PeMOB�d!��C¾��K�M[zbMO��k²YO�3QjM[��keC�f N�Ka��kez QL@eC �y��WUNe��Ci·ª��Ú�C��@�M¦¥y��YON!WUMO��C�¹yNe��¥rM[��C$k!h$C���k h�M[���§���pSb��¥rM[��NeC.��KDf3� ��C$WUC$kyQ ¬ WLYbB h$M[�������pSy��k�M[BDCOº ¬ YbW ��k!KaQUM[k�h�C���k h�M[���§��pSy��k!M[BDC\#������ #�& ) MOk!f #�M[WUCgKaC�B'M[kyQL��h$MO����SDQL@eC�KUM[BDCb¨e��@eC$WUC�MbK���k^h$MO�������ySy��¥rM[��NeC #������5#>& ) ��K#QL@eCKUM[BDCgMOK ) ��RY�hj@�M[WjMOhªQUC$WU��KUMrQU��YbkD��K��pkeYr��k.Y ¬ QL@eC¸Ci¹bN!��¥rM[��C$k�h�CGYOk��e�«QUC$WUB'K*��k!f3N�h�C�f��pSDQL@eC¸h$MO�������ySy��¥rM[��NeC

C�k!h�Y3f3��kez����

â�â54�6!þ87:98;

Page 73: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

o[q � Ì(À��[�y¿O�6�r©«¿O�

� � � �¸�����

?#@!Cg�e��h$M[��h�N!��N!K��#MOK*��kyQUWLY3f3N!h$C�f��pS�Ý*@yN!WUhj@ Ý*@pN!m � ¨�Ý*@pNen!E �®��@!Y �#MOK�@eYbde��k!z�QUY N!KLC¸�§Qi¨3YOk�QL@eCYbkeCD@!M[k�f÷¨(QUY¯deWLY3f3N�h�C.M ¬ YON!k!feMrQU��Ybk ¬ YbW���YOzO��hDM[k!f9B'MrQU@eC$B'M[QL��h$KgM[k�f÷¨(YbksQU@eC'Y[QU@eC$W�@!M[k!f®¨®QLYN!k!f3C$WjKaQUM[k�fÈB'MrQU@eC$B'M[QL��h$M[����S^QL@eC'k!Y[QL��YOk9Y ¬*¬ Nek!h�QL��YOk®�'± @e����C'QL@eC�×!WjKaQ�zOYbMO� ¬ M[����Cif÷¨®[email protected]�Ybk!fYbkeC�@!MbKc�;C$C�kÈM'WUC$B'M[WU�rM[�e��C�KaN�h$h�CiKLK���Ý*@pNeWjhj@ ³6M[k�f��¸��C�C$keCb¨���@!Y.deWUYr¥OC�f���BDd�YbWaQjM[kyQRWUC�KLNe�§QjKcYbk�e��f3C�×!k�M[�e������QTSe·/WUC�M[����KaCif�QU@!MrQ�QU@eC��e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�h�M[d3QUNeWUC�K/QU@eCckeYOQL��YOkDY ¬�¬ Nek!h�QL��YOkDQU@!MrQ���K � C ��C�h�QL��¥OC$��Sh$YOBDdeN3QjM[�e��C � ¨÷M[k!fÈh�YOk[ZTC�hªQUNeWUC�f¯QU@!MrQGQL@eCDh���MOKUK�Y ¬ C ��C�h�QL��¥OC���S^h�YbBDdeN3QUMO�e��C ¬ Nek�hªQL��YOk�KGKL@eYbNe��fÈh�Y[���k!h$��f3Cg����QL@�QU@eC�h���MOKUK�Y ¬ �3��f3C�×�k!M[�e��C ¬ Nek!h�QL��YOk!K���?#@e��K�deWUYOd;YbKUM[��¨yWUC ¬ C�WLWUC�f.QLY.MbK » �y�3©L��� � �����3¤ª�ª���ª¨��K#keYr� zOC$k!C$WjM[����S.Mbh$h�C�d3QLCif÷�?#@eC^�e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!K��#MOK�WLCif3C�KUh�Yr¥bC$WUC�f9�pS-h�YOBDdeNeQLC$W�KLh$��C�kyQL��KTQjK���k QU@eC �bq � K$¨/B'M[��ke��SsQU@!M[k!�pK�QLY

Ú�Þb@eB¯¨(\^hiÝ�MOWaQU@ySb¨ � h�YOQaQi¨(M[k!fsC�KLd;C�h���M[����S � M[k�f3��k(¨®MOK¸M��!MOKL��K ¬ YbWGd!WLYbzOWjM[BDBD��kez���MOkezON!MOzOCiK$��_�Q@�MOK���C�C$k���BDd�YbWaQjM[kyQQLYGNek!f3C�WUKaQUMOk!fgC�KUKLC$kyQL��M[�ydeWUYOzOWjM[BDBD��kezch�Ybk!KTQUWLN�hªQUKKLN!hj@ MbK(d!MOWUMOBDC�QLWU��KLM[QL��YOkBDCihj@!M[ke��KLBDKg³´QL@eYyKaCb¨ ¬ YOW���k!KaQUMOk!h�Cb¨eY ¬ deWLY3h$C�f3NeWUC�Kj·�M[k!f�QTSpd;C�K��X_�k�d�M[WLQL��h�Ne��M[Wi¨3�§Qc@�MOKcKLC$WU¥OCif�MOK�MB'M[QL@eC�BDM[QL��h$MO� ¬ YONek!f!MrQL��YOk ¬ YOW#QU@eC�h���MOKUK#Y ¬ ��MOkezON�M[zOCiK��yk!Yr��k�MbKX�j�3�;�$�«�6�[�;�r ( ��r�p¿[�!��¿b¤��ª�?#@eC�KTQjM[k!feMOWUf9WUC ¬ C�WLC�k!h�CiKgYOkÉQU@eC�h���MOKUKL��h�M[�XQU@eC$YbWLSsY ¬ QL@eC��3��h$MO��h$Ne��N�K�³£QU@eC^�$¤$�e�ª�«¶ª �¤����3¤U�[©ªÁy·

MOWLC Ú#M[Wjw[n3¨�� � w � ���É?#@eC�QUC�PpQL�;YpYO�3KD\¯�§Qjhj@eC$���� \¯��QUv � ��M[k!f ÙGNekyQLC$W ÙGNek!v � �#h$YOkyQUMO��k f3C�QjM[����Cifd!WLCiKaC�kbQjMrQU��Ybk!K�Y ¬ V�Ý�Û MOk!f.QTSpd;C�f^�e��h�M[��h�Ne���«�V*Ý�Û �#MOK���kyQLWUY3f3N!h$C�fÉ�pS9V���YOQL�p��k VX��Ypobo����^_�k-QL@eC�KLMOBDC'd!M[d;C$Wi¨/@eC�KL@eYr�cK�M¾KLC�¹yNeC�kyQL��M[���§QTS

��C$BDB'M ¬ YOW¯V*Ý�Û ¬ WUYOB ��@e��hj@ QL@!C9k!YOk3��f3C�×�k!M[�e�����§QTS Y ¬ d!M[WjM[����C��RYbd�C�WUM[QLYOWjK�¨RKaN�hj@²MOK ¬ YOWUB'K�Y ¬� d!MOWUMO����C$����YbW � M[k�f � d!MOWUMO����C$����� ¬ ��QL@eC�k3��C���KLC � ¨®h$MOks�;C.f3C�WL��¥OCif÷�.?#@eC.h���MOKUKL��h�M[�XKaCi¹yNeC$kyQL��M[����QTS^QL@eC�YOWUC$B¬ YbWGQL@eC'NekyQTSpd;C�fÉ�3��h$MO��h$Ne��N�K¸��Kgf3N!CDQLY^Ú�C$WUWLS Ú*C�Wªo[w ����tÖWUC�h$C$kyQ¸QLWUC�MrQT����KLC YbksKLC�¹yNeC$kyQU��MO����QTS¾��kQU@eC��e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!K���K*Ú*C$QL@e�bCRM[k�f��¸��Ybd Ú��gvOw ���X?#@eCRKaQUMOk!feM[Wjf3��KLM[QL��YOkDM[k!fDk!YOWUBDMO����KUMrQL��YOk�QU@eC$YbWLC�BDKY ¬ QU@eC��3��h$MO��h$Ne��N!K�M[WUC¸deWLYr¥bC�f���k ¡Ý�Û/xOw ���»��r £  �L¶ªÁ�����¤U¤jÃc��MbK/deWLYbd�YyKaCif��pS ±9MbfeKa��YOWLQL@ ±9Mbf�opE ��MOKXMOk���BDde��C$BDC$kyQUM[QL��YOkDQUC�hj@eke��¹yNeCO�/ÛeYbWa�

B'MO����KLM[QL��YOk!K(Y ¬ h�M[���§���pSb��keC�C�fGYOk�M��3��h$MO��h$Ne��N�K(����QL@�M ��� �¸h�Ybk!KaQLWUN!hªQ(YbW(����QL@ C$kp¥p��WUYOkeBDC�kbQjK®��k!h���N!f3CtRWL��YO��M�C$QcM[��� t�Û/\ � vbx���¨ � MONek!hj@p�eNeWUS � M[N!vbm���¨eV�NeWLN�Ka@eYOQL@!MOB'M[k�MOk!f � C�MOBDMOk V � v � ��¨���YbKL@e��f!M ��YbKUvOm����?#@eC�QLC�WLB��Lh�YOkyQU��kpN!M[QL��YOk �g��K�f3NeC�QLY � QLWjMOhj@eC�S�MOk!f¯±9MbfeKL�*YbWaQU@ � ± orn ��¨;��@!Y.N!KLC�f¯QU@eC$B QLY

zb��¥bCgKaC�BDMOkyQL��h$K�QLY.h$YOkyQLWUYO�yZTNeBDd!K�� � C$C�H�C�Syk!YO��f H�C�Spvbm�� ¬ YbWcMD@e��KaQLYbWLS�Y ¬ QL@eC�f3��KUh�Yr¥OC�WLS'Y ¬ h$YOk3�QU��kpN!M[QL��YOk!K�M[k!f Ý�V � QUWUMOk!K ¬ YOWUBDK���Û!YOW�h$YOkyQL��kpN!MrQU��Ybk!Kg��k f3C$keYOQUM[QL��YOk!MO��KaC�BDMOkyQL��h$K�¨KLC$C�ÙGYbWUf3Ybk ÙGYOW�orv���¨ � hj@eBD��fpQ � hj@!w � ��¨YOW�?�C$k!keC$kyQ ?(C�k!veE ���¯ÛeYbW h$YOkyQL��kpN!MrQU��Ybk!KgMOK�M¾deWLYbzOWjM[BDBD��k!z�QUC�hj@3�k!��¹yNeCb¨�KLC$C Û± ?�v � ����ÛeYOWcQL@eC�N�KaC�Y ¬ Ý�V � QLWjM[k!K ¬ YOWUB°��k¾h�YbBDde����C$WjK�¨!KaC�C�tcd!d�C�� tcded�v � ��¨���@!C$WUCQU@eCR��M[k!zON!MOzOC#��K�\ � ¨yYOW Û± ?�v � ��¨y��@eC�WLC�QU@eCR��M[k!zON!MOzOC#��K � hj@eC�BDCO���RMrQjh���� �^M[k�f'Ç�MOky¥pS ��Ç�vOn �d!WLCiKaC�kbQ�M�Neke� ¬ Sp��k!z MOh�h�YbNekyQ�Y ¬ ¥rM[WU��YON!K*Ý�V � QLWjM[k�K ¬ YbWLB'KX�!MbKaCif'YOk�\^YOzOzb� � K�h$YOBDdeN3QjMrQU��Ybk!M[��B�C$Qa�MO��MOkezON�M[zOC \¯YbzbveE ���-?#@eC�C$k!h$Y3f3��k!zÈY ¬ ��� ��kyQLY-� � N!KL��kezÈQU@pNeke�3K���k ]XPpC�WUh$��KLC �e��E¦op¨XMOk!f ��QUKWUC$��MrQU��Ybk!KL@e��dÉQUYÈQU@eC¾Ý�V � QUWUMOk!K ¬ YbWLB " �r¨�M[WUC�KaQLN�f3��Cif �pS-Ç�MOkp¥yS-MOk!f �RM[QUh$����� Ç �Rv � ¨ �RÇGvyo ���?#@!CG��f3CiMDY ¬ N�Ka��kez�QL@pNeke�3K ¬ YbW���BDde��C$BDC�kbQU��k!z.h$M[�������pSy��k�M[BDC�feM[QLCiK��!MOhj�DQUY'_�kezOC�WLB'MOk _�kez �!E ���?#@eC'h�M[���§���pSb��¥rM[��NeC�Ý�V � QLWjM[k�K ¬ YbWLB Y ¬ ?�MO�e��C � ��K¸f3N!C QUY�Û��KLhj@!C$W Û��Kjo � �R³´Y ¬ ��@e��hj@sM�BDYOWUC

h$YOBDde��C�QUCg¥OC$WjKL��Ybk���K Û���KUvOm �´·ª�#?#@eC�h$MO�������ySy��k!M[BDC�Ý�V � QUWUMOk!K ¬ YbWLB°Y ¬ ?�MO�e��Cgn'��K�QU@!MrQcY ¬ VX��YOQL�p��k VX��YpoOx���¨!�!MOKLC�f�YOk��*YbWL���yS�H�C$SpkeYb��feKg³«KaN�hj@¯MbK HcC$S!o � �´·ªÂ!@eYr�*C�¥OC�W�¨y�*Cg@�M¦¥OC¸MOf3Ybd3QLCif�QU@eCgWUC�hªQU�§�×;h$MrQU��Ybk���k�QL@eCgh���M[N�KaC ¬ YOW�¥rM[WU��M[�e��C�K#f3NeCGQUY ��MrQjh���� �ÈMOk!f�ÇGM[kp¥pS �RÇGvyo�� ³6V���YOQL�p��k � K�QUWUMOk!Ka��MrQU��Ybk

�´ó�â����

Page 74: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

���!��¤�©��;©L¤$�«�£�p¿R�j�3�������6�r�!�g�r�#���a�j�[ ����3 §�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª� opE

¬ YbW#¥¦MOWL��M[�!��CiK��#MOK " � ) ) � * * $&%('�[�(ÂpQL@!CGWUC�h�QL��×�h$M[QL��YOk���K�keCih�C�KUKUM[WUS ¬ YbW*QU@eC¸��C ¬ Qa��QLYO��WU��zb@yQ*��B�d!����h$M[QL��YOk�Y ¬?#@!C$YOWUC$B �e� n QUYD@eYO��f!·ª�?#@!C$YOWUC$B'K�xe��E$��xe� n�MOk!f,�!��E$� �!� m!¨[YOk�Ý�V � QLC�WLB'K�MOk!f�Ý�V � QLWjM[k!K ¬ YOWUB'K$¨yM[WUC�deWLYr¥bC�fD�pSDVX��YOQL�p��k

VX��YpoOx����'³«?#@eC MbKLKLC$WLQL��YOk!KRY ¬ QU@eC�KLC�QU@eC$YbWLC�B'Kc��KGMbhªQUN!M[����S¯KL����zO@yQL��S^f3���;C�WLC�kbQ ¬ WLYbB VX��YOQL�p��k � K�¨÷�eN3QQU@eC¸h�YOkyQUC$kyQ�MOk!fDQL@!C�deWUYpY ¬ K*M[WUC�KL��BD����MOW�� ·�VX��Y[QU�p��k�M[��KaY deWLCiKaC�kyQUK�h$YONekyQUC$WUC�PeM[BDde��C�³TE�ny·XQLY ?#@!C$Y[�WUC$B°xe� xe�X?#@eCRQUC$WUB'K: M[k!f � N!KLC�f���k�QL@eC¸deWUYpY ¬ Y ¬ ?#@eC�YOWUC$B E � ��E¦x'³´keYbk3��h�YOBDde��C�QUC$keCiKLK�Y ¬ QL@eCh�M[���§���pSy��k!MOBDCcC$k!h$Y3f3��k!zy·�MOWLCcQL@eCGKLMOB�C�N!KLC�f'�pS'VX��Y[QL�p��k VX��Y3o[x���QUY�deWUYr¥OC#QU@eC�k!YOk3��h�YbB�d!��C$QLC$k!C�KUKY ¬ QU@eC'h$M[�������pSy��k�M[BDCDÝ�V � QLWjM[k�K ¬ YbWLB ³6?M[�!��CDny·�MOK¸M�QLWjM[k!K ¬ YOWUB'MrQU��Ybk¾Y ¬ ��� ��kyQLY¾� �'��t�Ý�V �QUWUMOk!K ¬ YOWUB ¬ YbWXh$M[�������pSy��k!C$C�f¸��K/KTQUN!f3��C�f �pS � �¦MbKLMO�p�«¨ � C�C�MOk!f�?M[Wjf3��QL� � � ?�vOn ��¨rN!Ka��kez¸MG�e��h$M[��h�N!��N!KC$PpQLC$k�f3C�f ���§QU@ B N3QUMO�e��C�WUC ¬ C�WLC�k!h�CiK/MOK�QUMOWLzbC�Q/��MOkezON!MOzOCb�®±sC�f3��f keY[Q/×!k!f ��k�QU@eC#����QLC�WUM[QLNeWUC*zbWUMOB��B'MOWUK ¬ YbW¸QL@eCDQUC$WUBDK¸Y ¬ QU@eC�Ý�V � QLWjM[k�K ¬ YbWLB'KD³´zbWUMOB�B'MOWUK�³TE¦xO·ª¨�³ � mb·ª¨�³ � vb·a·�Â([email protected]���YbKLC�KaQGQLY^YOk!CY ¬ [email protected]��K � MO�eWUSsM[k�f-ÛeC$����C$��KaC�k � K � Û/vbm ��¨���@e��hj@-��KgQL@!C.��MOkezON�M[zOCDY ¬ MOkÉYOd3QU��BD��KaCif¥bC$WjKa��YOkÉY ¬ Û��KLhj@!C$W � K h$M[�������pSy��¥rMO��NeC�Ý�V � ��±9C�MO��KLY¾f3��f-keY[Q�×!k!f-��k-QL@!C.����QLC�WUM[QLNeWUC'QU@eC�Nek!� ¬ YbWLBÝ�V � QUWUMOk!K ¬ YOWUB�Y ¬ ?�MO�e��C �!�?#@!CsWUC$��MrQU��Ybk!Ka@!��d �;C�QT��C$C�k QTSpd;C�K¯Y ¬ �3��QLC�WLB'K¯M[k!f QTSpd�CiK�Y ¬ QL@!C$��W¾Ý�V � ��B'M[zOCiK��#MOK�×!WjKaQ

k!Y[QL��h�Cif �pS²\¯C�SOC$W¯M[k�f ±ÉM[k!f \¯± wyx ��� � QL@eC�W¯��BDd;YOWLQUM[kyQ¯d!M[d;C$WjK�YOk QTSpd;C�K¯M[k�f Ý�V � M[WUC \¯NeWjv � ¨ � � vOm3¨ ��ÇG\¾vOm ��� ?#@eC$YbWLC�B,E�q!� � ��K.f3NeC�QLY¼\^C$SOC�W'M[k!f ±ÉM[k!f÷� ?#@!C�QUWUMOk!KL��M[QL��YOk¼Y ¬MOWLWUYr� QTSpd;C�K���KcKLYOBDC�QU��BDC�KRh$M[����C�f �af3YbNe�e��C���keC$zyMrQU��Ybk�h$YOk!KaQLWUN!hªQU��Ybk �GM ¬ QLC$WG\¯NeWLQL@pS \¯NeWjv � ����?#@eCQUWUMOk!K ¬ YOWUBDM[QL��YOkDY ¬ QTSpd;C�K ¬ YOW*QL@eCGh$MO�������pSy��k!M[BDC�Ý�V � ��kȳ«m �y·ª¨pM[k!f.?#@!C$YOWUC$B E�q!� v!¨yMOWLCR�yS �RMOWLd;C$WMOk!f � ���������eWL��f3zbC � � vOm ��¨e��@eY ¬ Yb����Yr�²��@!M[QR\¯C$SbC$WcM[k�f�±ÉM[k!f�@!Mbf�feYOkeC ¬ YOWch�M[���§���pSy��¥rM[��NeCb�?#@!C�h�YbkekeC�h�QL��YOk¾MOB�Ybkez ¬ Nek�hªQL��YOk�K$¨�h�YbkbQU��kpN!M[QL��YOk!KRM[k!f^BDCiKLKUM[zbC���d!MOKUKa��kez���KGM[��WUC�MOfeS�h���C�MOWc��k

Ý�MOWL� �cC����§QLQ � K���YOWU�3K�YOk �O�$���[©j� �RC$��oboy¨ ��Ú�Ù � orm3¨ �RÚcobo���� t ¬ Nek!h�QL��YOks��K�WLC�deWUC�KLC$kyQLCif�MbK�MOkMbhªQUYOW#QL@�MrQRMOh�h�C�d3QUK#BDC�KUKUM[zOCiK#h�YOkyQjM[��ke��k!zDMOk�MOWLzbNeBDC$kyQ ¬ YOW#QU@eC ¬ Nek!h�QL��YOk¾M[k�f�M'h$YOkyQL��kpN!MrQU��Ybk�QUY��@!��hj@¼QL@eC¯WUC�KLNe�§Q�Y ¬ QU@eC ¬ Nek!h�QL��YOk KL@eYbNe��f¼��C¯KLC$kyQ��¼?#@!��K���K�QU@eC^KLMOB�C���feC�MÈQL@!M[Q���C�N�KaCif ¬ YOWWUC$d!WLCiKaC�kbQU��k!z ¬ Nek�hªQL��YOk�KcMOK#����h$MO��h$Ne��N�K#deWLY3h$C�KUKaCiK*��k�QL@eCgd�M[d;C$Wi�?#@!C#MOk!M[��YOzbS��;C�QT��C$C�kD\^����keC$W � K/C$k!h$Ypfe��kezyKY ¬ �e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!K/��kyQLYG����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K/M[k!f�QL@!CcÝ�V � QUWUMOk!Ka�

¬ YbWLB'K��#MOK*keY[QU��h$C�f.�pS.KLC$¥bC$WjM[�!d;C$Ybde��CO¨eM[k�f.�#MOK�×!WUKaQ#d!M[WLQL��S ¬ YOWUBDMO����KLC�f.�pS'Ú�YON!feYO� Ú�YbN!vyo �(MOk!f?#@!��C���Cihj�OC� ?#@!��vpo����*Ú*YbN!f3Yb�®h�YOBDd!MOWLCiK�C$k!h$Ypfe��kezyK#Y ¬ h$MO�������pSy��k!M[BDC¸M[k!f¯h$MO�������ySy��¥rM[��NeC¸�e��h$M[��h�N!��N!K��kyQLY�¨WUC�KLd;C�hªQU��¥bC$��SO¨(QL@eC.�!��NeC�h$MO��h$Ne��N�K�M[k!f9QU@eC.����h$MO��h$Ne��N�K$� �cC�keY[QU��h$C�fsQL@!M[Q�¨ ¬ YOW C$��QL@eC�W�KaQLWjMrQa�C�zOSb¨�� ¬ QL@eC'Ý�V � QUWUMOk!K ¬ YbWLB ��KRh�YbBDd�YyKaCif¯���§QU@^QL@eC C$k!h$Y3f3��k!z.Y ¬ ³«h$M[�������pSy��k�M[BDCi·c�e��h$M[��h�N!��N!KR��kyQUYQU@eC��!��NeC h$M[��h�N!��N!K�¨eQU@eC$k¾QL@eC WLCiKaNe��QUKRh$M[k^�;C�WUC�Mbf¯MOK�QU@eC�KaQUMOk!feM[Wjf�C$k!h$Y3f3��k!z.Y ¬ QL@�MrQ¸�e��h$M[��h�N!��N!KKaQLWjMrQUC$zbS^��kyQLY�QU@eC'����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K���?#@!��C���Cihj�OC���kyQLWUY3f3N!h$C�K¸M¾Ý�V � h$M[��h�N!��N!K�¨(KL��BD����MOWGQLY�QL@eC'��kyQLC�WLBDC��fe��M[QLC���M[kezbN!M[zbC¸��k¾tRded�C�� � KRh$YOBDde����C�W tcded!v � ��� �RC�Ka@!Yr�cK#QL@!M[QcQL@!��K¸Ý�V � h$MO��h$Ne��N�K�@!MOKRM'Ka��BDde��CQUWUMOk!KL��M[QL��YOk¯��kyQUY'QL@eC�����h�M[��h�Ne��N!KcMOk!f�QL@!M[Q�¨;� ¬ VX��Y[QU�p��k � KGÝ�V � QLWjM[k!K ¬ YOWUB'KcM[WUC ¬ YOWUB�N!��M[QLC�f���k¯QL@eCÝ�V � h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�¨�QL@eC�k¾QL@!C$��W�QUWUMOk!KL��M[QL��YOk!K���kyQUY�QU@eCD����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�Sy��C$��fÈMOkÈC�k!h�Y3f3��kez¯Ka��BD����M[W�QLY^\¯���§�k!C$W � K� \^����v � ���¸_�k¾QU@e��K�d!MOd�C�W���C�zbY ¬ NeWLQL@eC�W�¨���k¾QU@!MrQ�QL@eC�C$k!h$Y3f3��k!zbK�Y ¬ �;Y[QL@9h$MO�������pSy��k!M[BDC�MOk!fh�M[���§���pSy��¥rM[��NeC��e��h$M[��h�N!��N!K���kyQUY�QL@!CR����h$M[��h�N!��N!K�M[WUC����b�����r©ª���$¤jÃ'N!KL��kez�QU@eC¸Ý�V � QLWjM[k!K ¬ YOWUB'K�M[k�fDQL@eCh$YOBDde����M[QL��YOk�"¯Y ¬ � � �^��kyQLY�����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�¨ ¬ YbW��;Y[[email protected];C�f�M[k!fDNekyQTSpd;C�f��e��h�M[��h�Ne����ÂyMOk!fD�*C�N!KLC�QL@eC¬ MbhªQUYOWU��KUMrQU��Ybk.QLY.feC$WU��¥bCGh$YOWUWLCihªQLk!C�KUK*WUC�KLNe��QUK��?�WjM[k!KL��M[QL��YOk!KGY ¬�¬ N!k!hªQU��Ybk!Kg��kbQUY^deWUYph$C�KUK�h$MO��h$Ne����@!M¦¥OCD�;C$C�k-zO��¥OC$k9�pS �¸C�kek!M¦�#M¦S¾M[k!f � ��C$C�d

� � w � ��¨ � C�QU@ � C$QUv!E ��¨�?#@eYOB'KLC$k ?#@eYyvOq���¨!Ú�YON!feYO� Ú*YbN!wOv�����H�Yb�e��k^\¯����k!C$W � K#��YOWU�'YOk ¬ Nek!h�QL��YOk!KMbK�����h$MO��h$Ne��N!K�d!WLY3h�CiKLKLC�K \^����v � ����K�M���MOk!f3B'M[WU����k�QL@eC¸M[WUC�M!�\¯����k!C$W#h�YOk�Ka��f3C$WjKXQU@eC¸h$M[�������pSy��k�M[BDCMOk!f¾d�M[WjM[����C��h�M[���§���pSb��¥rM[��NeC KaQLWjMrQUC$zb��CiK�³´@!��K¸C�k!h�Y3f3��kezbKGM[WUCO¨�WUC�KLd�CihªQU��¥bC$��SO¨;QL@!M[Qg��k9?�MO�e��CDw�M[k!fsM

â�â54�6!þ87:98;

Page 75: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

o � � Ì(À��[�y¿O�6�r©«¿O�

¥rMOWL��M[kyQRY ¬ QL@!M[Q���ksmb·�� \¯����keC$WGdeWUYr¥OC�K�QL@eC�YOd;C$WjMrQU��Ybk!M[�h�YOWUWUC$d;YOk!f3C�k!h�Cg�;C�QT��C$C�k¾WUC�f3N!h�QL��YOk!K���kQU@eC��3��QLC�WLB'K#M[k�f.��k�QU@eC$��W#deWLY3h$C�KUK�C�k!h�Y3f3��kez¯³£QL@!C�M[k!MO��YbzONeCcY ¬ � C$BDB'M�xe��ErogM[k�f�]/P3C$Wjh���KLC �!��Eivb·ªÂ@!C¸MO��KLYDdeWUYr¥OC�K*QU@!MrQi¨3��k¯�;Y[QL@^h�MOKLC�K�¨pQL@eCgC�k!h�Y3f3��kezD��K#Ybd�C�WUM[QL��YOk!MO����S.KLYONek!f��eN3Q�keY[Qch�YbBDde��C$QLCb�H�C�zbMOWUf3��kezDQU@eC h�M[���§���pSb��¥rM[��NeCgC$k�h�Y3f3��kez!¨/³´¥rM[WU��M[kyQUK�Y ¬ ·¸Ý*YOWUYO����MOWLS�xe��E�n.M[k!f � C$BDB'M�xe��Eiw'M[WUC

�pSÉ\¯����keC�W \^����v � ��Â�Ý*YOWUYO����MOWLSÈxe��E¦x���Kg�pS � M[kezb��YbWLzb�XM[k!fÉVX��C$Wjh�C V � v � ��Â/HcC$B'M[WU�sx3��E�����K ¬ WUYOB � MOk!v � ��� H�C�zbMOWUf3��kez9QL@!CÈh$MO�������pSy��k!M[BDC¯C$k!h$Y3f3��k!z!¨cÝ*YOWUYO����MOWLS �!��E � MOk!f �e��E�mÉMOWLC¯�pS \¯����keC$W \¯����v � ¨*\¯����veE ��� ?#@eC^WLC�B'M[��k!f3C$WDY ¬ � CihªQL��YOk �9��KDkeC$�g� ?#@eC¯Nek!� ¬ YbWLB C�k!h�Y3f3��kezÉ��k � C�hªQU��Ybk o��K ¬ WLYbB � Ç�vbm ���9t­KTQUN!f3S-Y ¬ QU@eC�h$YOWUWLCihªQUkeC�KUKgY ¬ QU@eC¯h$M[�������pSy��k!C$C�f9C�k!h�Y3f3��kezÈ��k¼?M[�e��C¯o^��K ��k Ú � vbx����¾]Xk!h$Ypfe��kezyK�Y ¬ zbWUMOde@ÉWLCif3N!h�QL��YOk!K�¨�WUC$��MrQUC�f9QUYÈh$MO�������pSy��keC$Cif÷¨(��kyQLY¾����h$MO��h$Ne��N�K�M[WUC'zO��¥OC�k��k Ú*YbN!v[n!¨�`OC ¬ vbm���eNeQRQL@!C$��W�h�YbWLWUC�h�QLkeCiKLKc��KRkeY[Q¸KTQUN!f3��C�f÷�R?#@!C�C$k!h$Y3f3��k!z.Y ¬ ?M[�e��C w'��Kcd!WLCih���KaC���S\^����keC$W � KXYOWU��zb��k�M[�3C$k�h�Y3f3��kezgY ¬ ��� �/?#@!CcYOd3QU��BD��KLM[QL��YOk^³6mbqb·��K ¬ WUYOB \ � vbw ���/tRk'C$k!h$Y3f3��k!zgY ¬ QL@eC1 WUNe��CR��kyQLYg����h$MO��h$Ne��N!KX�#MOK×!WjKTQ�zb��¥bC$kD��k � MOk!v � ��¨b��@eC$WUC#QL@eCcQUM[WUzOC$Q�h$M[��h�N!��N!K���K��÷_ªÂ[QL@!C�C$k!h$Ypfe��kezd!WLCiKaC�kbQUC�f���k � CihªQU��Ybk�v���K ¬ WLYbB \ � vOw ���?�NeWUkeC$W�×!WjKTQ¸C�KaQUMO�e����KL@eC�fsM.WUC$��MrQL��YOk�Ka@e��d¾�;C�QT��C$C�k¾QL@!C�QTSpd;C�KGY ¬ �e��h$M[��h�N!��N!KRQLC�WLB'K¸M[k�f¯QL@eYyKaC

Y ¬ QL@eC���W�C$k!h$Ypfe��kezyK.��kyQLY ����h$MO��h$Ne��N�K ?(NeWjv ����� �cCÈQUMO�OC�Kȳ´¥rM[WU��MOkyQUK.Y ¬ ·�\^����keC$W � K'C$k!h$Y3f3��k!zbK.Y ¬QU@eC��e��h$M[��h�N!��N!K ��kbQUY¾QU@eC�����h$MO��h$Ne��N�K MOk!f-deWUYr¥OCiK¸QL@!M[Q ¬ YbW�KLYOBDC.Y ¬ QL@eCiKaC�C$k!h$Ypfe��kezyK�QU@eC$WUC.��K Mh$YOWUWLCiKad;YOk�f3C$k!h$C��;C�QT��C$C�k^deWU��k!h$��d�M[�÷QTSpd;C�K�Y ¬ QU@eC �e�«QUC$WUB'KcM[k!f�deWU��k!h���d!M[�®QTSyd;C�KRY ¬ QL@eC�C$k!h$Ypfe��kez����h$MO��h$Ne��N!K�QLC�WLB'K�Â#QL@eC^����h$MO��h$Ne��N�K�QTSpd;C¾KaS3KaQLC�B N!KLC�f ��K¾³´QL@eC¾KaQLWUN!h�QLNeWjM[�#¥OC�WUKL��YOk¼Y ¬ ·'\¯����k!C$W � KKLYOWLQL��kez.d!��N!K�d;YO��SyBDYbWLde@!��KLB¯�R?(N!WLkeC�W�MO��KLY.C�PpQUC$k!feK¸\¯����k!C$W � KRC$k!h$Ypfe��kezyK�QUY.QL@!C d;YO��SpB�YbWLd!@e��h �3�h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�� ��Ka��kez ���gQTSpd;C�K�¨yMbK���Cc@!M¦¥bCRf3YOk!CR��k'QL@eC�d!M[d;C$Wi¨bQL@eCGWLC���M[QL��YOk!KL@e��d'��C$QT�*C�C$k��e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!KMOk!f¸����h$M[��h�N!��N!K®QTSpd�CiK(��K�h$��CiM[WUC$W(MOk!fgKL@!M[WUd�C�W�¨¦M[k�f�h$MOkg��C*C�MOKL����SGC�PpQLC�k!f3Cif¸QLYcYOQL@eC�W(QTSpd;C�KLSpKaQLC�B'K$�?#@!Cg�*YbWL�.d!WLCiKaC�kbQUC�f���k � C�h�QL��YOkÉE�qD��K�keC��gÂ!��Q ¬ YO����Yr�cK�QL@eC�KUhj@eC�BDM�Y ¬ QU@eCg��kbQUC$WUdeWUC�QUM[QL��YOk^tc��MOf3�MOk!f^Ý�M[Wjf3C$����� � K¸�«Áj�e¤jÃ��b¶ �$¤j�����j�r ��$�3 ¡�p�� tRÝ�v � �®��kyQLY'����h$M[��h�N!��N!K#��k � M[k!vbw����

�#�O�� §�6�U�[�«�£¢r¤¼¶����ª�£µ �3 ��[�«�6�[� ��MbK.��kbQUWLY3f3N�h�C�f �pS tc�!WUMOBDKL�pS tc�!WUwbv ��¨���k�Kade��WUC�f �pS QL@eCs�*YbWL�Y ¬ \^����keC$W�M[k!f V/M[WU�¼��k h�Ybk!h�N!WLWUC$k!h$S VMOWUw!Er¨�\¯����wOv ��� � ��k!h$CÈtc�!WUMOBDKL�pS � K'��YOWU��¨�QU@eC¾��f3C�MÉY ¬MOdede����h�MrQU��¥bCG�!��KL��B Ne��MrQL��YOk¯@!MbK��;C$C$k^MOdede����Cif�QUY.MD¥rM[WU��C$QTS�Y ¬ @e��zO@eC�Wa��YOWjf3C�W�KLC�¹yNeC�kbQU��MO�®��M[kezbN!M[zbC�K�ÂKLC$C� ÙGYOWjvbxy¨!V��§Qjvyo�� ¬ YbWcKaN!WL¥bC$S3K$�� d;C$k.MOdede����h�MrQL��¥OC��!��KL��B Ne��MrQL��YOk'h$YO��k!h���f3C�K����§QU@'QL@eCRC�¹yNe��¥¦MO��C�k!h�C���k!f3N�h�C�fD�pS � kez � K� �� �$Á¸½*À �

�[©LÃO¤$©ª�£�y¿ � kezbwbw���Â*@eYr��C$¥OC�W�¨/MÈh$YOk!h$C$d3QUN!M[�#f3���;C�WLC�k!h�C���C$QT�*C�[email protected]��YÈ��K�QL@eC�C$BDde@!MbKa��K�QU@!MrQ� k!z � K*d!WLC�YOWjf3C$W#de��MOh$C�K#YOk �y��C$P3d!M[k!KL��YOk®�?#@eC YOd;C$WjMrQU��Ybk!M[�(MOk!f¾f3C�keY[QjMrQU��Ybk!M[�÷QU@eC$YbWLS�Y ¬ ���,³´QL@!M[QRQL@!C$S^h$MO����QL@eC� �� �$ÁD�3�a�j�r ����3 ¡�p�a·R@!MOK

�;C$C�k�C$PyQUC$k!KL��¥OC$��S'KTQUN!f3��C�f��yS.tR�eWjM[B'Ka�pS'M[k�f � kez tc�!WUwpoy¨3tc�eWjwOv3¨ � kezywOwp¨3t � vOm ���X?#@eC¸h$MOkeYOk3���h$MO�XBDYpfeC$��Y ¬ ��� BDC�kbQU��YbkeC�f9��k � C�h�QL��YOk EOED��MbKgf3C�×�keC�fs�pSstc�!WUMOBDKL�pSO¨([email protected]��N3QU��YbkÈQUY¯Mh$C$WLQUMO��k�feYOB'M[��k�Ci¹bN�MrQL��YOk tR�eWUwpoy¨3tc�eWjwOv ��� �RCGMOk!f � kez�QL@eC�k�d!WLYr¥bC�f�QL@�MrQ#QL@e��K�BDYpfeC$����K#KLYONek�f�!N3QckeY[QRh$YOBDde��C�QUC tc�!WUwpoy¨ � kezywOwp¨!t � vbm����?#@eC��£�!��¤�©ª���r /���3�r�6�j¤�YOd;C$WjMrQLYbWc��k � C�h�QL��YOk-E � ��KR��k!KLde��WLCif¯�pS�MOk^YOd;C$WjMrQLYbWc��kbQUWLY3f3N�h�C�f¯�pS¯ÇRC

�R��h$YO��MDM[k!f �cC�kekeCiKLKLS Ç ��wyo�����k^M�Ý�Ý � �������OC¸deWUY3h�CiKLK#h$MO��h$Ne��N!K$� � QLN!fe��CiK�Y ¬¬ YOWUB'MrQ�Y ¬ YOd;C$WjMrQUYOWjK��k¾h�Ybk!h�N!WLWUC$k!h$S.��k!h���N!f3C Ç � wbx3¨�Ú�_a\^wOwe¨�tRÚ�ÜGv[ne¨÷ÙGÜ�v � ��¨;M[k!f¯��k ¬ Nek!h�QL��YOk!MO�(��M[kezbN!M[zbC�K Ú���YyvOq3¨�RYr�cv �p¨ � M[k!vporM����?#@eC � J�¥pSb� � YbkezOYc?�WUC$C�K���C$WUC���kyQUWLY3f3N!h$C�f��yS � YOkezbY � YOk!wbm��§F ��@eC�WLC�QL@eC�Sg�*C�WLC�Ka��BDde��Sgh�M[����Cif

QUWLC�C�KTF feC$¥OC���Ybde��kez�MOk¯YOWU��zb��k!MO����f3CiMD�pS � C�¥pS � J$¥!o ������?#@eC$S��*C�WLCgh$MO����C�f � J$¥pSy� � YOkezbY�?�WLC�C�K#�pS

�´ó�â����

Page 76: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

���!��¤�©��;©L¤$�«�£�p¿R�j�3�������6�r�!�g�r�#���a�j�[ ����3 §�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª� orm

� k!z � kezywOw�����Ú�ÞO@eB ?�WUC$C�KgMOWLCDKaQLN!f3��C�f9��k-f3C$d3QU@-��k Ú#M[Wjw[n�����ÛeYOWgBDY3f3C���K¸Y ¬ QU@eC��3��h$MO��h$Ne��N!K$¨KLN!hj@¯MOK3M �c¨� �(¨ � ¨ ����¨!M[k!f ¬ WUC$C¸��M �$S.BDY3f3C���K�¨!KLC$C� Ú#MOWUwOn3¨ � � w �3¨ � kezywOw����\^YbKaQ�Y ¬ QL@eC'WUC�KLNe��QUK¸��k � C�h�QL��YOk!K'EbE��jE�m�M[WUC ¬ WUYOB � M[k!vOn ��¨ � M[k!v � ¨�hj@�M[d3QUC$W � �R³6KLYOBDC'Y ¬ QL@eC

WUC�KLNe��QUK���k � M[k!v � ¨�hj@�M[d3QUC$W � �(@!M¦¥OC�MO��KLY'M[ded;C�MOWLCif���k � M[k�vbx[M��´·ª��?#@eCgzbWUMOBDBDMOW�Y ¬ �*C������ ¬ YOWUB�CifYbd�C�WUM[QLYbWUK���k � MOk!v[n �(��K�BDYOWUCGzOC$k!C$WUYON!K�� � C�hªQU��YbkÉE�me� n¯³6Ú�ÞO@eB ?(WUC$CiKU·*��K ¬ WLYbB � M[k!vyxr� ���?#@!CXC�¹yNe��¥¦MO��C�k!h�CXYbk��3��QLC�WLB'K÷��k!f3N!h$C�f¸�pScQU@eC$��W®C�k!h�Y3f3��kez���kbQUY#QL@eC�����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�³«ÇRC$×!ke��QL��YOk'EOEb� xb·

��Kc��M[WUzOC���S���k!feC$d;C$k!f3C�kyQRY ¬ QL@!C�hj@eYO��h�C¸Y ¬ QU@eC��;C$@!M¦¥p��YONeWjM[�÷Ci¹yNe��¥rMO��C�k!h�CgYbk�����h$MO��h$Ne��N!K�deWUY3h�C�KUKLC�K��±9CG@!M¦¥OCRMbf3YOdeQLC�f.�e��KL��B�����M[WU�§QTS���@e��hj@���K�����f3C$��S'MOh�h�C$deQLC�f�MOK�QL@eCR×!keC�KaQ#C�PpQLC�k!Ka��YOk�M[�!�;C$@�M¦¥y��YON!WUMO�Ci¹yNe��¥rMO��C�k!h�C¸YOk!CG��YON!��f������OCGQUY'��BDd;YbKLCGYbk�d!WLY3h�CiKLKLC�K�Â3MrQ�QU@eC¸YOded;YbKL�§QUCgC�PpQLWUC$BDCb¨eMOK*QL@eC�h$YbMOWUKLC�KaQCi¹yNe��¥rMO��C�k!h�Cb¨�YOkeC�keYbWLB'M[����S9d!��Mbh�C�K � �r©ª©ª����� �¾�j�r�!��¤JO� �a¤ ���3�£¢r�r �¤����U¤�³«f3C�×!k!C�f MOK��!M[WU�;C�f¼h$YOkezbWLNe�C�k!h�C��eN3QG���§QU@eYONeQ�QU@eC�h$��MON!KLC�YOk �¾BDYr¥OC�Kj·ª� � k¾deWUY3h�C�KUKLC�KcC�k!h�Y3f3��kez¯�3��QLC�WLB'K�¨�QU@eC�BDMO��k ¬ YOWUBDKY ¬ ����h�M[��h�Ne��N!Kc�!��KL��BD����MOWL��QTS�QL@!M[Q�M[ded;C�MOWR��k¯QL@eC ����QLC�WUM[QLNeWUC.³´zbWLYbNek!f÷¨���M[QLCb¨�CiM[WU��Sb¨!YOd;C$k(¨�M[k�f�QL@eC���WMbKaSpk!hj@!WLYbkeYON!K�¥rM[WU��MOkbQjKU·*h�Yb��k�h���f3CO�X?#@eC�S.M[��KaYDh�Yb��k!h$��feC�����QL@�B'M¦Sb��QLCiKTQU��k!z�C�¹yNe��¥rM[��C$k!h$CO�X?#@eC¸��MrQa�QUC$W ¬ MbhªQ���kyQLNe��QL��¥OC���S @eYO��feKX�;C�h�M[N!KLC�QL@eCRC$k!h$YpfeC�f���M �$SD�3��QLC�WLB'K�MOWLC�f3C$QLC$WUBD��k!��KaQL��h[¨yM[k!f���K ¬ YOWUB'M[����Sd!WLYr¥bC�f.��k Ú � vbx����� QU@eC$W*hj@!M[WjMOh�QLC$WU��KLM[QL��YOk!KY ¬ � J$¥pSy� � YOkezbY¸?�WUC$C�K�MOK � �[©ª©ª��� � �g�j�r�!��¤JO� �a¤ ���3�£¢r�r �¤����U¤XY ¬ C�PpQLC�k!f3Cif

�e��QLC$WUB'Kc��k!h���N!f3Cbº�Ú�YbN!f3YO��M[k!f � MOkeC$¥bC� Ú � v � ��¨!��@eY�N!KaC' ��rµ.¶LÃb�^�j�r ��$�3 ¡�p�gÍX�£���^µ��3 ¡��� �� ¡�6�$�£�«�6¤��ª¨÷M¬ YbWLB Y ¬ ��� ��@eC$WUCcM[WUzONeBDC�kbQjKXY ¬;¬ Nek!h�QL��YOk!K�@!M¦¥OCcM¸B Ne��QL��de����h���QTSDM[k!fDWUC�f3N�hªQL��YOk(¨bM[��QL@!YONezb@DfeC�QLC�Wa�BD��ke��KTQU��hO¨yB'M¦SD��kbQUWLY3f3N�h�CRf3CiMOf3��Y3hj��ÂyMOk!f.Ç�C ��MOke���TÝ*��M[k!h�M[zb����ke��¨b?#��NeWLSpk�MOk!f��cW �$S3h �$Spk ǸÝ�? ��vyo����@!Y�N!KLC QL@eC^�j�r�;�$�3©ª©L¤$�!���'�a�j�r ��$�3 ¡�p�ª¨®M ¬ YbWLB Y ¬ ��� C�PpQUC$k!f3Cif¾����QL@ ¬ YOWUBDKGY ¬ h$MO�������pSy��¥¦MO��N!C�M[d3�d!����h$M[QL��YOk®¨!MOk!f�YOd;C$WjMrQLYbWUK ¬ YOW�k!YOk!f3C$QLC�WLBD��ke��KLB­MOk!f�d!M[WjM[����C�����KLB��

â�â54�6!þ87:98;

Page 77: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

orn � Ì(À��[�y¿O�6�r©«¿O�

#©L�[µ µ'�r©j� �Q4Y �LY0]0]2] ��YK�6Y�� � �rµ'¤ª�

�r ¡�!¤���4Y � � � Q k�M[BDC�K

½#©L���j¤��j��¤��M:Y S\Y�� � � k!���

� MON M d�M[WjM[����C��� � Q;M WUC�KaQLWU��hªQL��YOk� ½�©U¤6� d!WLC$×eP3��kez� � M WUC$d!����h$M[QL��YOk� ) Q � � * M B'M[QUhj@e��kez� ½�©U¤6� � ½�©L¤«� KLNeBDB'MrQU��Ybk

½#©L¤ �8Jp¤ª�½�©U¤6� � � Q4# ��&K�,M ��kedeNeQ

� Q P ��R��,M YbN3QLd!N3Q� �$�,M KL����C�kbQcd!WLC$×eP

?�MO�e��C'EimeºX?#@eC¸����h$M[��h�N!��N!K

� %&% � � � ��� ��� ) �������D�������� � ��� �8��� � �!�*��"$����"$���

� +���� � �!����"��#��"����

{ � 2 � � & � Å �OÆp}�}iÆp}?#@!C�zbWUMOBDBDMOW¸Y ¬ QU@eC'����h$M[��h�N!��N!K¸��K¸��kÉ?M[�!��C¯E�m!� f3C$keYOQLCiKGQL@eC'��k!MOh�QL��¥OCDdeWUY3h�C�KUK��DtRkÉ��ked!N3Qa�d!WLC$×eP3C�f¯deWUY3h�C�KUK;Q4# � &K�,M��#M[��QUK ¬ YbWGM.¥¦MO��N!C �^MrQ Q�MOk!f�QL@!C$ksh$YOkyQL��kpNeC�K�MOK M-@ � C D�Fy��tRk¾YON3QUdeN3Qd!WLY3h�CiKLK Q P ��R��,M C$BD��QUK#¥rM[��NeC �.MrQ3Q.MOk!f�h$YOkyQL��kpNeC�K�MOK MD��t �p��deWLC$×eP3C�f�deWUYph$C�KUK �$�,M h�M[k�C$¥OYb��¥bC��kyQLC�WLk!MO����S QUY MD�&t d!M[WjM[����C$�Rh$YOBDd�YyKa��QL��YOk M � N M � ��KDQUY WUNek QT�*Y-d!WLY3h�CiKLKLC�KD��k d!MOWUMO����C$��� tWUC�KaQLWU��hªQL��YOk � Q M�B'M[�bC�KGk!MOB�C Q^��Y3h$M[��¨÷YOW¸deWU��¥¦M[QLCb¨÷QLY MD��t WUC$de����h$MrQUC�fÈdeWLY3h$C�KUK�� M°KaQUMOk!feK ¬ YOWMsh�YbNekyQUM[�!��C���k3×�ke�§QUC�kpNeB ��C�W Y ¬ h�Ybde��C�K Y ¬ MD� \^MrQjhj@e��kez ) Q � � * M ��K�QLYsQLCiKTQ ¬ YOW QL@!C�Ci¹bN�M[���§QTS�;C�QT��C$C�kÈQU@eC'k!MOB�CiK+Q¾M[k�f �¦� � N!B�B'M[QL��YOkÉC�P3deWUC�KUKaCiK¸M�hj@!YO��h�C���C$QT�*C�C$k9QT�*Y��;C$@!M¦¥p��YONeWjKD³´��Q���KMO��KLYDh$M[����C�f¯¿[�!�[©LÃO¤jÃ�KaN!B�B'M[QL��YOk®¨!MbK�QL@eC�KLNeBDB'M[k!f!K�M[WUC�zbN!M[Wjf3C�f��pS�M�deWUC�×eP!·ª�

�´ó�â����

Page 78: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

���!��¤�©��;©L¤$�«�£�p¿R�j�3�������6�r�!�g�r�#���a�j�[ ����3 §�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª� o[x

M-@0Q���#� &�,S-F ��Y3h�M[�÷C$kp¥p��WLYbkeBDC$kyQ�³ � CihªQL��YOk¯ÚG� q!� vy·�! Y �! KTQUWLYbkezDM[k!f���C�M[�'��M[WU��Cif�h$YOkezbWLN!C$k!h$C

³ � CihªQU��Ybk!KcÚG� q!� n�¨3Ú�� qe� �e¨eÚG��EO� xO·� Y � KTQUWLYbkezDM[k!f���C�M[�'zbWLYbNek!f��e��Ka��BD����M[WU�§QTS

³ � CihªQU��Ybk¯ÚG� qe� x3¨eÚG� qe� �e¨3ÚG��Eb� xb·� C�P3d!MOk!Ka��YOkɳ � C�hªQU��Ybk�ÚG� qe�¡o[·

�;4= Y0;4= Y0;>=�� KTQUWLYbkez QLWjM[k!KL�§QU��Ybk!Kg³ � C�hªQU��Ybk^t�� qe� � ·����TY���� �*CiM[�'QUWUMOk!KL�§QU��Ybk!K¸³ � CihªQL��YOk^t�� q!� � ·O

zOWUYONek�f�MbhªQL��YOkɳ � C�hªQU��Ybk�ÚG� qe� xO·� � hj@!M[k!keC$��QTSpd;C.³ � CihªQL��YOk^ÚG��EO� � ·P 7� R deWUYpfeN!hªQ�QTSpd;CD³ � C�h�QL��YOk^ÚG��Eb� � ·

� � � Y�� Neke��Q�QTSpd�C�MOk!f�Neke��Qc¥¦MO��N!CD³ � C�h�QL��YOk^ÚG��Eb��E¦·O� � � WLCih�NeWjKL��¥bCRQTSpd;C�Kg³ � C�hªQU��Ybk^Ú���EO� � ·

� �(Y����(Y � � � ��QTSpd�CiKg³ � CihªQU��Ybk¯ÚG��EO� mb·� � � KaN!�3QTSpd�CgWUC$��MrQU��Ybks³ � C�hªQU��Ybk^Ú���EO� mb·#�� &��MY0#�� & � Y�� � � M[N3P3������M[WUS'keYOQUMrQU��Ybk ¬ YbW� � ��QTSpd�CiKg³ � CihªQU��Ybk¯ÚG��EO� mb·

��� Y �B#E7 � & �:Y � �:Y�� �! ��� �

� keY[QjMrQU��Ybk ¬ YbWcM[�!KaQLWjMOh�QL��YOk!K¸³ � C�hªQU��Ybk^Ú���EO�¡o[·

?M[�e��CDE$n!º�\^MO��k�keYOQUMrQU��Ybk!K ¬ YOW#QU@eCg����h$M[��h�N!��N!K

±9C�N�KaC �ÉQLY�WUMOkezOCgYr¥bC$W�KLNe�!KaQL��QLNeQL��YOk!K� ¬ YOW¸M[kpS�C$P3deWLCiKLKL��YOk �'¨���C���WL��QLC � � ¬ YbWcQL@!C WUC�KLNe��QY ¬ M[dede��Sp��k!z �sQLY �'¨;����QL@^QU@eC�N!KLN!M[��WLC�k!M[BD��kez.h�Ybkp¥OC$kyQU��Ybk�QUY�M¦¥OYb��f�h$MOd3QLN!WLCiK$�#±9C�MOKUKa��zOk^KLNeBMOk!f-d!MOWUMO����C$��h�YbB�d;YbKL��QL��YOk-QU@eC���Yr��C�KaQ�deWUC�h�Cif3C$k�h�C�MOB�Ybkez^QU@eC�Ybd�C�WUM[QLYbWUK�� � Ne��KTQU�§QUN3QL��YOk!K�@!M¦¥bCd!WLCih�C�feC$k!h$CGYr¥bC$W�QL@!CgYOd;C$WjMrQLYbWUK*Y ¬ QL@!Cg��MOkezON!MOzOCb�_�k�M[k.��kedeN3Q Q4#� &� M&M[k�f.M[k.YbN3QLd!N3Q Q P�� R�� M k�M[BDC Q ��K�QL@!C��ª��¶ �$¤U�$��M[k�f'k!M[BDC �*QL@eC'�b¶ �$¤j����Y ¬

QU@eC#deWUC�×eP÷��tRk ��kedeNeQ/d!WLC$×eP Q4#� &� M MOk!f�M�WLCiKTQUWL��hªQU��Ybk � ��M MOWLC*�e��k�f3C$WjK ¬ YOW/k!M[BDC��¦¨[M[k�f�zO��¥OC*WL��KLC��k QL@eC#C�P3d;C�h�QLC�f �#M¦S�QUYGQL@eC�f3C$×!ke��QL��YOk!KY ¬�¬ WLC�C�MOk!f ��YbNek!f k!M[BDC�K�¨[M[k�f�Y ¬6 ��h�Ybkp¥OC$WjKL��Ybk®� � SpB��;YO�� � � f3C$k!Y[QLCiK�C�¹yN!M[����QTS�N!d.QLY ��h$YOkp¥OC�WUKL��Ybk®�(±9C¸��feC$kyQL� ¬ S ��C�¹yNe��¥rM[��C$kyQ#deWLY3h$C�KUKaCiK$�_�k�KaQUM[QLC$BDC�kbQjK$¨��C�M[����M¦S3K�MOKUKaNeBDC*QL@!M[QX��YbNek!f k!M[BDC�K/Y ¬ QL@!C�C$P3deWLCiKLKL��YOk!K�Y ¬ QL@eC�KaQUMrQUC$BDC$kyQjK�³´deWUY3h�C�KUKLC�K�¨¦MbhªQU��Ybk!K$¨C$QUhO� · M[WUC��j©L¤�� �b¨b�«� CO��¨rQL@!C$S�M[WUC#f3� ��C$WUC$kyQ ¬ WLYbB&QL@!C*YOQL@eC�W�;YON!k!f MOk!f ¬ WLC�C*k!MOBDC�KY ¬ QU@eC#C�P3deWUC�KUKa��YOk�K��kDQL@!CRKTQjMrQUC$BDC$kyQ�Â3MOk!f��*CRKUM¦SgQU@!MrQ*M�k!M[BDCDQ ��K��j©L¤ª� �c���r©¸�r�^¤KJ$�;©L¤ª�j�ª�6�r� � QUYgB�CiM[kDQU@!MrQAQ�f3YpC�Kk!Y[QGMOded;C�M[W���k �'�R±9C���WL��QLC ¬ k # �\&�M[k�f^�ek # �\& ¬ YbWRWUC�KLd�CihªQU��¥bC$��S�QU@eC ¬ WUC$C�M[k!f¯�;YON!k!f¾k!MOBDC�KcY ¬�.¨�M[k�f�k�# �\& ¬ YbWcM[���®k!MOB�CiK���k � ³ ¬ WLC�C�M[k!f��;YONek!f�·ª�#t��U�[�!��¤KJb����KRMDdeWLY3h$C�KUK#C�P3deWUC�KUKa��YOk����§QU@¾MKL��kezO��C�Y3h$h�N!WLWUC$k!h$C�Y ¬ Mg@eYb��C ) 1 *;��k'��Q�Â3Mgh$YOkyQLC$PyQ���K�Yb�3QUMO��k!C�f��pS�WUC$de��MOh$��kez�MOkDYph�h�NeWUWUC$k!h$C�Y ¬ ��k.Md!WLY3h�CiKLK����§QU@ ) 1 *��/±sCGM[�e�eWUC$¥p��MrQUC � Q � ��M MOK�# � Q4Y ��& MD�±9CR��WU�§QUC Q4� M M[k�f Q>�,M ��@eC$k.QL@eC�¥¦MO��N!Ch$YOBDB�N!ke��h�MrQUC�f�M[��YOkez�k!M[BDC+Q'��K�keYOQ#��BDd�YbWaQjM[kyQ��/±9CgYOBD��Q�QU@eC¸QLWjM[������kez ��k�d!WLC$×eP3C�f�deWLY3h$C�KUKaCiK��� ��Û��k!M[����SO¨ Q4#�B&K� M­³U¶U�r�3��Ã��[�3�§�;�3�®��©U¤ �8J;·�MO�e�eWUC$¥p��M[QLCiK � � # Q P�&R��,M-&L�±9C¾N!KLC¾M9QL����f3C^QLY-WUC$d!WLCiKaC�kbQDQUNede��C�K.Y ¬ C$P3deWLCiKLKL��YOk!K�� ± ��QL@ KLYOBDC¾M[�eN�KaC^Y ¬ keYOQUM[QL��YOk®¨#��C

KLYOBDC$QL��B�CiK�¥p��C$� 7�&�;Y[QL@�MOK�M¸QUNede��C�MOk!f.M�KLC�Qi��±9CRC$PyQUC$k!f.keY[QjMrQL��YOk�K/QLY�QLNede��C�K*h�YbB�d;YOk!C$kyQT����KLCO�?M[�!��C�E$nDh�Yb����C�h�QUK#KaYbBDC�keYOQUM[QL��YOk!K ¬ YOW�QU@eC¸����h�M[��h�Ne��N!Kg³ ¬ YbW#��C�@!M¦¥p��YbNeWUMO��Ci¹yNe��¥rMO��C�k!h�CiK$¨yQTSpd�CiKU·

QU@!MrQRMOWLCgf3��KUh�N!KUKaCif���k�QL@eCgKLC�h�QL��YOk!K#�;C$��Yr�g�

â�â54�6!þ87:98;

Page 79: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

o � � Ì(À��[�y¿O�6�r©«¿O�

{ � 2 � +���Æy�r�3~� Å Ð�� Ò }�Æ3ÕÉ�!Ð;~� ´�O}?#@!C�YOd;C$WjMrQU��Ybk!M[��KaC�B'M[kyQL��h$K Y ¬ d!WLY3h�CiKLKLC�K���K zO��¥OC�k �pSÉB�CiM[k!K Y ¬ M¾��M[�;C$��C�fÉQUWUMOk!Ka��QL��YOk KaS3KaQLC$B¯¨��@!��hj@9C�P3deWUC�KUKaCiKGQL@eC'��kyQLC�WLk!MO��KTQUC$d!KgQL@!M[Q�M�d!WLY3h�CiKLKgh�M[k9B'M[�OC'[email protected]$YOBDB�Nek!��h�MrQL��YOk�K�����QL@YOQL@eC�WgdeWUYph$C�KUKaCiK¸��kÉ��@e��hj@É�§Q�h�M[kÉC$k!zbM[zbCO�¾³«?#@e��K���K¸[email protected][k�feM[Wjf¾QUWUMOk!KL�§QU��YbkÉKLS3KTQUC$B Y ¬ QU@eC.���h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�¨r��k QL@!C�CiM[WU��SgKaQTSp��Cb� ·�?#@eC�KLC�QXY ¬ WUNe��CiK(��K/zO��¥OC�k���k ?M[�e��C¸Eixe¨rde��N�K(QU@eC�KaSpBDBDC�QUWL��h�¥rMOWL��M[kyQUKY ¬������ M[k!f����^MOk!f ��� � �X?�WUMOk!Ka��QL��YOk�K�MOWLCGY ¬ QL@eC ¬ YbWLB M �;4=�M P«¨3��@eC�WLCGQL@!CG��M[�;C$� WUMOkezOCiKYr¥bC$W��O�$���6�r�e��Y ¬ QL@eC ¬ Yb����Yr����k!z ¬ YbWLB'K�º

� ��kyQLC�WUMbhªQU��YbkQ�P ��R ��ked!N3QcY ¬ �.MrQ;Q# �7 � & Q P ��R YON3QUdeN3QcY ¬ ��MrQ;Q;¨3C$PyQUWLN�f3��k!z��;YON!k!f�k!M[BDC�K 7 �

_�[email protected]$MbKaCDY ¬ ��kedeN3Q MOk!fsYON3QUdeN3Q�¨ Q¾��K¸QU@eC¯�ª��¶ �$¤j�$�GY ¬ [email protected]�QL��YOk®�'_�k!deN3Q MOk!fÈYbN3QLd!N3Q MOh�QL��YOk!KfeC�KUh�WU���;CDd�YyKLKL���!��CD��kbQUC$WjMOh�QL��YOk!KG�;C�QT��C$C$k M­M[k!f9��QUK¸C$kp¥p��WLYbkeBDC$kyQ�¨®��@!����C.M �9MbhªQL��YOk9WUC$deWUC�KLC$kyQUKMOk���kyQLC�WLk!MO�®MOh�QL��YOk���k¯��@e��hj@�YbkeCgKaN!�edeWUYph$C�KUK#Y ¬ M h$YOBDB�Nek!��h�MrQLCiK����§QU@¯MOkeY[QU@eC$Wi�/±sCg��WU��QLC

M�� � � �;4=�M P YMOk!f9h$M[������Q�¶U�r�3�;þ�£�[�;�3�G�O�$���6�r�!¨�QLY^BDCiM[ksQL@!M[QUM � � �

�;4=�M P�MOk!f �-��K�keY[Q�M ¬ WUC$C'k!MOB�CDY ¬ MDÂ/��kQU@e��Kgh$MOKLCO¨��-��KgM��;YONek!fsk!MOB�CDY ¬ QL@!C.MOhªQU��Ybk®¨(MOk!f QÈM ¬ WUC$CDk!MOBDCO�D±sC'KLYOBDC�QU��BDCiKgM[�e�eWUC$¥p��MrQUCM �;4= M PXMOK M ;4= M P«¨®M[k�fÈh$MO���/��Q�MÈ©L¤jÃ[�!�����6�r����±sC'MO��KLY���WU�§QUC�M\#K;4= & 3 M P�QLY�BDC�MOk¾QL@�MrQ M�;C�h$YOBDC�K M P �pS¯d;C$W ¬ YOWUB���kez -��p��QLWjM[k�Ka��QL��YOk!K�� D¤U�rË.�«©U�r�e�ª�£���6�r�!� M[WUC�f3C$×!keC�fÈMOK�N!KaN�M[��º�WUC$��MrQU��Ybk��� ��K#QU@eCgWUC �!C$Pp��¥OC¸M[k�f.QUWUMOk!Ka��QL��¥OCgh$��YyKaNeWUCGY ¬ �;4= ÂeMOk!f ���� KaQUMOk!feK ¬ YbW���� �;6=���� �±9C���WU�§QUC M ;>= � M P(� ¬ QL@!CgWLCif3N!hªQU��Ybk M ;4= M P(��K�Ãb¤���¤$©ªµ �£�����j���6�g��� CO� M ;4= M P÷��K�QU@eCgYOke��S

��BDBDC�f3��MrQUCgd�YyKLKL���!��CgQUWUMOk!KL�§QU��Ybk ¬ YbW;MD�*±9C���WU�§QUC M ;4= 3� M P(� ¬ M C$¥bYO��¥OC�K�QUY M P®�pS�d;C$W ¬ YOWUBD��k!z-9f3C�QUC$WUBD��ke��KaQL��h¸WLCif3N!hªQU��Ybk!K��

{ � 2 � � � � ÆÈ�e}$à(Ð�� � � Å Ð Å ��} � áU�O� Ò � � Ò ��}t h�YbB�BDYbk�KaN!�;h�M[��h�Ne��N!K*Y ¬ QL@!CR����h$M[��h�N!��N!K*��K�QU@eC��r�jÁr�����y©L�r���r�p�����a�U�[ ��$�3 ¡�p��³6�

�· �R?�veEO¨yÚ�YON�v � ¨

tRÝ � v � ��¨3��@e��hj@�@!MbK�keY Ybd�C�WUM[QLYbWUK*Y ¬ KaNeBDB'MrQU��Ybk�MOk!f�B'M[QUhj@e��kez!¨3MOk!f�MO����YbN3QLdeNeQ#d!WLC$×eP3C�K#M[WUC�Y ¬QU@eC ¬ YOWUB Q P�� R�³£QL@!C$S9@!M¦¥OC�keY¾h�YbkyQL��kyN�MrQL��YOk;·ª�'?#@eC'C$k�h�Y3f3��kezbK¸Y ¬ QU@eC��3��h$MO��h$Ne��N!K¸��k9QU@e��K�d!M[d;C$WMOWLCg��WU��QaQLC�k^��k^�

���?#@eCgd!WLY3h�CiKLKLC�KcY ¬ �

�C�krZTYrS¯KaYbB�Cg��kyQLC�WLCiKTQU��kez'�;C$@�M¦¥y��YON!WUMO�÷deWLYbd�C�WaQU��CiK$¨;KaYbBDC

Y ¬ ��@e��hj@^M[WUC�WUC$d;YOWLQLCif��;C$��Yr�g�

� � �(��� �. ��������"É���'�� ����"$�c������� � 2 � � �e�¦|�ÆyÓ � Å Ð�Ô!� ��Æ3Ð(�bÆ

±9C�feC�×!keC���C�@!M¦¥p��YbNeWjM[��Ci¹yN!M[���§QTS9N!KL��k!z¾QL@!C�keYOQL��YOk Y ¬ �!M[WU��Cif-h�YbkezOWUNeC$k�h�C \ � v � ���9?#@e��K���K M�!��KL��B Ne��MrQL��YOke���!MbKaCif¾Ci¹bN!��¥rM[��C$k�h�C�QL@!M[Q�h$M[k9�;C.f3C�×!k!C�f9Neke� ¬ YOWUBD��S¾Ybk9fe� ��C$WUC$kyQ�h$MO��h$Ne���«�'Ú#M[WU��Cifh$YOkezbWLN!C$k!h$C�h�M[kÉ��C�f3C�×!k!C�f9YOk-M[kpSÈh�M[��h�Ne��N!Kgd;YbKUKLC�KUKa��kez^M�WLCif3N!hªQU��YbkÉWLC���M[QL��YOk ³£QL@!C �-KTQUC$d!KgY ¬QU@eC^����h$M[��h�N!��N!Kj·DM[k�f MOk Yb�!KLC$WU¥¦MO�e������QTS-deWUC�f3��h$M[QLC �

�¨ ¬ YOW'CiMOhj@ hj@!M[k!keC$�DQ;¨#��@e��hj@ feC�QLCihªQjKDQL@eC

d;YbKUKL���e�����§QTS ¬ YOW�MDd!WLY3h�CiKLKcY ¬ MOh$h$C$d3QU��k!z�M'h�YbB�B Neke��h$M[QL��YOk^MrQ Q����§QU@^QL@!C�C�PpQLC�WLk�M[�®C�ky¥p��WLYbkeBDC$kyQ��_�kÈQL@eC�����h$M[��h�N!��N!K�¨�M �

�@eYb��f!KR� ¬ QU@eC$WUC�MOWLC�M�f3C�WL��¥rMrQU��¥bCUM P/M[k!fsM[ks��ked!N3QgYOWGYON3QUdeN3QgMOhªQU��Ybk

����QL@'KLNe�3ZTCihªQAQ KaN!hj@�QU@!MrQ M �;4=�M P«�Ú#MOWL�;C�fDh�YbkezOWUNeC�k!h�C#��K/QL@eCch$YOkezbWLN!C$k!h$C���k!f3N�h�C�f��pS���M[WU��Cif

�´ó�â����

Page 80: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

���!��¤�©��;©L¤$�«�£�p¿R�j�3�������6�r�!�g�r�#���a�j�[ ����3 §�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª� oOo

������� �M ��h�Ybky¥bC$WLQL���e��C�QUY M P M P �;4=�M P P

M �;4=�M P P�� �

Q4# ��&K�,M � � �;6=�M-@ � C D4F ���

M�� �;>= M P�M � N M � �;>= M P� N M � �ek # & � ¬ k�# M8� & � �

���Q�P ��R��,M � �

�;6=�M����� M�� ���� � � � � �;4= M P� M�� � � �;6=�M P�

M � N M � �;4= �7 � # M P� N�M P� & 7 � � ¬ k�# M�� & � �

� ���M �;4= M P

) Q � Q * M �;4=�M P ��� �M �;4=�M P

M � S �;>= M P��� �

M �;6=�M P� M �;4= � MON M P �����

M �;>= M P� � M �;>= � � M P ��C/# ¬ k�# & ���ek # &K&

� � ��$� M �;4=�M � ���

M � �� � � � � �;6= M P

� � M � �� � ��� � � �;4= M P � ¬ k�# �>&�; 7 �

?M[�!��CDEixeºX?(WjM[k!KL��QL��YOk�WLNe��C�K ¬ YbW#QL@eCg����h$MO��h$Ne��N!K$�

�!��KL��B Ne��MrQL��YOk(�¸?#@!C ��MrQLQLC$WGC�¹yN!M[QLCiKRdeWUY3h�CiKLKLC�KcQL@!M[Q¸h�M[kÈB'M[QUhj@¾CiMOhj@¾YOQL@eC�W � KRWUC�feN!hªQU��Ybk!K�MOk!f÷¨®M[QCiMOhj@¯KTQUC$d®¨�M[WUC�Yb�!KaC�WL¥rMO�e��CGYOk�QU@eC�KLMOBDC¸hj@�M[kekeC���K��Ú�C���Yr�g¨e��C�f3C$×!keC���M[WU��Cif^h�YOk!zOWUNeC$k!h$CgYOk^M'zbC$keC�WL��h¸deWUYph$C�KUKch$MO��h$Ne��N!K�� QU@!MrQ�@!MOKRWLCif3N!hªQU��Ybk

MOk!f�YO�!KLC$WU¥rMrQU��Ybk�WUC$��MrQL��YOk�K�MbK�M[�;Yr¥OCb�tRk�� ©L¤$ ��r���6�r�s��KcM�WUC$��MrQU��Ybk�YOk�QU@eCgdeWUYph$C�KUKaCiK�Y ¬ �R�

� Æ��/Ð. £~� Å Ð � � � }$~�� Å Ð�ÔÉ|��3�r|�ÆpÓ |) ´}� 6Õ- Ò �3�� £~jà²��Ð(Ó � Å Ð�Ô!� ��Æ3Ð(�bÆ � ��� ©L¤$ ��r���6�r� � �����r�� KaQLWUYOk!z �!MOWL�;C�f��e��KL��B Ne��M[QL��YOk-� �3M � S �£µR�; ¡�6¤ª� �

� Ìg� �;M �;>= M P�� �p¤$�È� �p¤$©L¤����;S P��ª�!�������3�r� S �;>= S P��[�;à M P � S P´Ê� Ì����[© ¤j�O� �¯� �p�[�!�;¤$  Q�Ê�M �

��£µ��� ¡�6¤�� S �

�Ê

�[�;Ã.���3¤ �j�r��¢¦¤$©j�$¤ªÊ#�r�È� �p¤���©L�r�!�j�£���6�r�!�/�j©U�rµ S.Ì�(Í����²��©L�i�j¤ª�j�$¤ª� M �r�;à SØ�r©L¤GKaQLWUYOkezb��S��!M[WU��Cif��e��KL��B�����M[W ³6��k���·jÊ�ÍX©ª�£�«��¤������;M �! S�Ê*� �

M � S ���r©¸�$�rµ'¤"�&�ª��©L�r�p¿�¶U�r©�¶U¤jÃ�¶����ª�£µ �3 ��[�«�6�[� �sÌ�(Í��#� ��©U���j¤��U�$¤��;M:Y,S �[©L¤DKTQUWLYbkezO��S'�!MOWL�;C�f�h�YbkezOWUNeC$kyQg³´��k$�*·jÊ*ÍX©ª�£�«��¤��%���3M �! S�ÊX� �UÊ����[©

¤j�b���¾�j�r�!��¤JO� � �£�%��Ê*�£� �p�[ �æ� ���3�r�&��� � ) M * � � ) S *Ṯ @!C$k'QU@eC$WUCc��K�keY M[B��!��zbNe�§QTS�YOk���@!MrQ�QU@eC�h�M[��h�Ne��N!K'�¼��K$¨y��CcB'M¦S�MO�e�eWUC$¥p��M[QLC��(� M � S MOK

M �) S'¨�M[k�f*���DM �! S MbKDM �! 3SD��³6± @eC$kHM:Y SÖM[WUCg����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�d!WLY3h�CiKLKLC�K�¨�M �! 3S B�CiM[k!K��� M �! ASD¨3C$¥bC$k�� ¬ �;Y[QU@ M M[k!f S MOWLCGdeWUY3h�C�KUKLC�K*Y ¬ QU@eCgMOKLSpk!hj@eWUYOkeYbN!K�����h$MO��h$Ne��N�K�F ��@e��hj@���K�MKLNe��h$MO��h$Ne��N�K�Y ¬ QL@eCg����h$MO��h$Ne��N�KU·��

â�â54�6!þ87:98;

Page 81: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

o[w � Ì(À��[�y¿O�6�r©«¿O�

� 2 � � � � Å �Ð(Ó |) ´}� 6Õ- Ò �e� ´~Uà

?#@!C.B'M[��k-��k!h$YOkp¥OC�ke��C$k!h$C�Y ¬ �!M[WU��Cif-h�YbkezOWUNeC$k�h�CD��K�QL@!M[Q ��Q�N!KLC�K�¹yN!MOkyQL��×�h$M[QL��YOk-Yr¥OC�W�h�YbkbQUC�PpQUK��[email protected]�×!ke��QL��YOk(¨�M[k�f¾QU@e��K�h$M[kÉB'M[�bC d!WLYpY ¬ K¸Y ¬ d!WLY3h�CiKLKGCi¹bN�M[���§QU��CiK¸@eC�M¦¥pSO�.tRzbMO��k!KaQ¸QL@e��K�¨(��Q���K��BDd�YbWaQjM[kyQ�QLY�×!k!f�deWUYyY ¬ QUC�hj@eke��¹yNeC�K�¨pC�KLd�Cih���M[����S ¬ YOWUB�Ne��MrQU��Ybk!K�Y ¬ �e��KL��B Ne��M[QL��YOk���@eYbKLCgf3C�×!k!�§QU��YbkfeYyCiK#keY[QcN�KaCgh�YbkyQLC�PpQR¹yN!MOkbQU�§×;h$MrQU��Ybk®� � keCgKaN�hj@ ¬ YbWLB Ne��MrQL��YOk���K�¿[©L�[�3�;Ã�¶ª���ª�£µ��£ ��r©ª�£��Á��;C$��Yr�g�X_�QUK��kedeNeQ'h$��MON!KLC�Ybke��S hj@eC�hj�3K���YbNek!f ��k!deN3Q�MOh�QL��YOk!K�Â�QL@eC�WLC ¬ YOWUC�d!WLY3h�CiKLKLC�K keC�C�f keY[Q'�;C�QUC�KaQLCif¼Ybkk�M[BDC�K/QU@!MrQ�QL@eC�SDMO��WUC�Mbf3S�d;YbKUKaCiKLK��(±9C�h�M[��� �p��MOhªQU��Ybk!K�¨bYbN3QLdeNeQ*MOh�QL��YOk!K�MOk!fD�;YONek!fD��kedeNeQ�MOh�QL��YOk!KQU@eC�¿O©L�r�3��Ã.�O�$�«�6�[�e�ª¨!WjM[k!zOC�f�Yr¥OC�W��pS

O�

� Æ��/Ð. £~� Å Ð � �� }$~�� Å Ð�Ô-Ô!� Å ��Ð�Ó |. 6}� 6Õ- Ò �3�� £~jà � � ©L¤$ ��r���6�r��� �[�'���a�j�r ��$�3 ¡�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª�¸���¸�zbWLYbNek!f��e��KL��B�Ne��MrQU��Ybk-� �DM � S �£µ��� ¡�6¤��jÊ����r©��r £ ;¿O©L�[�3�;Ã.�b�����6�r�!�

O�

� � �3M �;4=�M P*� �p¤$�¾���3¤�©U¤����;S P��ª�!�������3�r�CS �;4= S P��[�;à M P � S P´Ê�[�;Ã.���3¤ �j�r��¢¦¤$©j�$¤ªÊ#�r�¾� �p¤��«©U�r�e�ª�£���6�r�!�X�j©U�rµ S.Ì

�(Í��^���a�j�[ ����3 §�p� �;©L���j¤��j��¤�� M �[�;à S �[©L¤9KTQUWLYbkezO��S-zOWUYON!k!f �e��KL��BD����MOW$Ê�ÍX©ª�£����¤�� M � S�Ê � �M � S�Ê!���r©¸�$�rµ'¤¸¿[©U�r�3�;Ã�¶ª���ª�£µ��3 ��r���6�r� �sÌ

³6_�k�QU@eCgh���M[N!KLCRY ¬ zOWUYON!k!f'�e��Ka��B�N!��M[QL��YOk®¨p��C�YbB���Q�QL@eC¸WUC�¹yNe��WLC�B�C�kyQ �a��YbNek!f�k!M[BDC�K�Y ¬O¬ WUC�KL@

¬ YbW�S �ª¨XKa��k!h$C.�*C��*YbWL�sNed3��QLY ��h�YOkp¥bC$WjKa��YOk�·�� � k deWUYph$C�KUKaCiKgY ¬ QU@eC�MbKaSpk!hj@eWUYOk!YON!K¸����h$MO��h$Ne��N�K$¨zbWLYbNek!f��e��KL��B�Ne��MrQU��Ybk���BDde����C�Kc�!M[WU��Cif�h$YOkezbWLN!C$k!h$COº

��� Æ Å �¦Æ3Õ � � ��¤��CM:Y,S ¯��Ì�� �3¤�� M � S �£µR�; ¡�6¤��c� �3M �! S.Ì

³ � k9d!WLY3h�CiKLKLC�KGY ¬ QL@!C.MOKLSyk�hj@eWLYbkeYON�Kc����h$M[��h�N!��N!K�¨(zbWLYbNek!fÈ�e��KL��B�����M[WU�§QTS¾h$YO��k!h���f3C�K¸����QL@ÉCiM[WU��S�!��KL��BD����MOWL��QTS � M[k�vbx[M���� ·

� 2 � % � Æp�3Ï Æ�� �. "e� Ò Æ3Ð��OÆp}

?#@!C*��C�MO�g¥OC$WjKL��Ybk!K®Y ¬ QL@eC�MO��Yr¥bC�C�¹yNe��¥rM[��C$k!h$C�K/M[WUC*feC�×!keCif��pSgWUC$de��MOh$��k!zcQL@!C*QUWUMOk!KL�§QU��YbkUS �;4= S P����QL@ÉQU@eC'��C�M[�¾QLWjM[k!KL�§QU��Ybk S ��� S P6¨/M[k!f®¨�� ¬ O ��K�M[kÉ��kedeN3Q YOW�MOk9YbN3QLd!N3Q�MOh�QL��YOk®¨�[email protected]!zQUWUMOk!KL�§QU��YbkUS �;4= S P ����QL@ QL@eC#��C�M[�GQUWUMOk!Ka��QL��YOk�S ���� S P ÂbMO��KLY!¨¦��k�Ç�C�×!k!�§QU��Ybk�ÚG��EO¨¦QL@!C�d!WLCif3��h�MrQUCS �

�����QL@HS �

�¨e��@eC$WUC �

�$&%('� ���8�

��

±9C���WU��QLC!�! ¬ YOW��*CiM[���!M[WU��Cif.h�YbkezOWUNeC�k!h�CbÂyMOk!f � ¬ YOW���C�M[�DzbWLYbNek!fD�e��Ka��BD����M[WU��QTS;Âp��C�KLYOBDC��QU��BDCiK®ZTN!KaQ�h�M[���eQU@eC$B ¶U�r©�¶U¤jÃ'�j�r�y¿O©ª�!¤$�;�j¤�¨pM[k�f�¿[©U�r�3�;Ã'¶����ª�£µ �3 ��[�«�6�[�!��?#@eC�YOWUC$BÖÚG� m�MO��KLYg@eYb��feK*��kQU@eCg��C�M[�.h�MOKLCOº

��� Æ Å �¦Æ3Õ � � ��¤��CM:Y,S ¯��Ì�� �3¤�� M � S �£µR�; ¡�6¤��c� �3M � S.Ì

±9C�MO�s�!MOWL�;C�fÉh$YOkezbWLNeC�k!h�CD��K¸QL@!C�KaC�B'M[kyQL��hDC�¹yN!MO����QTSÈYbksQU@eC.����h$MO��h$Ne��N�Kg�*C.MOWLC'B'MO��ke��SÈ��k3�QUC$WUC�KaQLCif ��k®Â�Y[QL@!C$W'WUC$��MrQL��YOk�K$¨������OC¾KaQLWUYOk!z9�!��KL��BD����MOWL��QL��C�K�¨�zOWUYONek!f �e��KL��BD����MOWL��QTSO¨#M[k!f C$Ppd�M[k!KL��Ybk³«f3C�×�keC�f��;C$��Yr�R·ª¨3�������(KLC$WU¥OC¸MOK�MON3P3������M[WUSDQLY'��Q��

� Æ3Õ-ÕÉ� � � À��¦�b�3�r��¤ M:Y,S ¯��Ì�� �3¤����(�3M �! AS �£µR�; ¡�6¤��c�

��3M �! S.Ì

& � ŮŠ�U� ����KcMDKaN!�;h�M[��h�Ne��N!K#Y ¬ �X¨3QU@eC$WUC ¬ YbWLC¸M[���(h�YbkyQLC�PpQjK#Y ¬ �ÉM[WUCgM[��KaYDh�YbkyQLC�PpQjK#Y ¬ �

�� �

�´ó�â����

Page 82: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

���!��¤�©��;©L¤$�«�£�p¿R�j�3�������6�r�!�g�r�#���a�j�[ ����3 §�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª� orv

� 2 � $ � � Æ¾Æ � ���!Ð�}� Å Ð �rÆ Ò �3~� Å Ð?#@!C�C�P3d!MOk!KL��Ybk9WUC$��MrQU��Ybk t � �Rv � ¨ � \¾v � ��¨/��WL��QaQUC$k � ¨��K MOk MOKLSyBDBDC�QUWL��h'¥rM[WU��M[kyQ�Y ¬ � ��@e��hj@QjM[�bC�K���kyQLY�MOh�h�YON!kbQRQL@eC�kpNeB��;C$WGY ¬ �p��MOh�QL��YOk!K�d;C$W ¬ YOWUB�Cif^�pS¯deWLY3h$C�KUKaCiK$�G?#@yN�K$¨ M � SÖ@eYb��f!KR� ¬M � S MOk!f S @!MbK�MrQ���C�MOKaQcMOK#B'M[kpS �p��BDYr¥OCiK�MOK3MD�

� Æ��/Ð. £~� Å Ð � % � Æ � ���!Ð�}� Å Ð � �&©U¤� ��[�«�6�[� � �r�����a�j�r ��$�3 ¡�p�X��©U���j¤��U�$¤��c�����r�^C$Ppd�M[k!KL��Ybk^� � M �S �£µR�; ¡�6¤ª� �

� Ì �6�3M �;6=�M P�� �p¤$�¾� �p¤$©L¤����DS P��ª�!� ��� �p�r� S ���� S P*�r��à M P � S P �� Ìg� � S �;>= S P´Ê�� �p¤$�9¤$�£� �p¤$©DM � S P6Ê*�r©g� �p¤$©L¤����3M P��ª�!�������3�r� M �;4= M P��[�;à M P � S P �� Ìg� � S �;4= S P6Ê Í��3¤�©U¤ O ���È�[� �r�3�����3�D�r©s� ¶U�r�3�;à �£�[�;�3�D�b�����6�r�!Ê�� �p¤$�²� �p¤$©L¤È��� M P��ª�!��� ���3�r�

M �;4=�M P#�r��à M P � S P�ÌD¤g�$�[Á'���3�r� S C�P3d!M[k�feK;M�Ê�ÍX©ª�£����¤$� M � SDÊ�� �3M � S ���r©¸�$�[µD¤D¤J��e�r�!�ª�6�r���sÌ� Æ3Õ-ÕÉ� � $ �(¤$� M:Y,S ¶U¤c���a�j�[ ����3 §�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª�$Ì�� �p¤$� M � S �£µ��� ¡�6¤�� M � S.Ì

� 2 � � Æp� � Ð' � ��Æp} Å ���¦|. ´}� 6Õ � Ò �e~� Å Ð �.� ~ Å��±9C�KL@!MO���eN�KaCRM�deWLYpY ¬ QUC�hj@eke��¹yNeC ¬ YbW��e��Ka��B�Ne��MrQU��Ybk'��k'YbWUfeC$WXQUY�WLCif3N!h$C#QL@eCGKa� �$C�Y ¬ QU@eCRWUC$��MrQU��Ybk!K/QUYC$P3@e���!�§Qi�X_�k�QU@eC¸�e��Ka��BD����M[WU�§QTS�h���M[N!KLCO¨yQL@!��K#QUC�hj@ek!��¹yNeCgM[����Yr�cK*N�K�QLYDB'M[ke��deNe��MrQUC�QU@eCgf3C$WU��¥¦M[QL��¥OCiK*Y ¬QT��Y'deWUY3h�C�KUKLC�K#����QL@^QU@eC�¤J��e�r�!�ª�6�r�9©L¤� ��r���6�r��MOk!f�QLY�h�M[k!h$C$�(M'h$YOBDBDYOk¾h$YOkyQLC$PyQi��?#@!C¸QLC�hj@!ke��¹yNeCN�KaCiK�QU@eC�keY[QU��Ybk!K�Y ¬ ¿O©L�r�3��à ¶ª���ª�£µ��3 ��r���6�r� �¦�/�����-�j�r����¤Jb���r�;Ã9�¦�/����� � MOk!f-Y ¬ WLC���M[QL��YOk �$ ��r��¤jÃ�3��ÃO¤$©R�ª��¶ª�ª�«�£���3�«�6�[�e�ª�/t²�e�r §ÁO�OÃr�6��h�YOkyQUC�PpQ�B'M¦S'h�YbkyQUM[��k�MOk�M[WU�e��QLWjM[WUS�kpNeB ��C�W�Y ¬ f3���;C�WLC�kyQ�@eYb��CiK$¨MOk!f÷¨eBDYbWLC�Yr¥OC$Wi¨yC�MOhj@�Y ¬ QL@eCiKaC¸@eYb��CiK#B'M¦S�M[ded;C�MOW�BDYOWUC�QU@!M[k�YOk�h�CO�

� ?#@eCgf3C$×!ke��QL��YOk�Y ¬ ¿[©L�[�3�;Ã�¶����ª�£µ �3 ��r���6�r�9�¦�������.�j�r�!��¤JO���r�;Ã.�¦������� � ��K������bCRQU@!MrQcY ¬ ³´��C�MO�e·zOWUYON!k!f.�e��KL��B Ne��M[QL��YOk®¨3C$Peh�C$deQ�QL@!M[Q�QL@eC�h$��MON!KaC+M P � S P÷��K#WUC$��MrP3C�f�QLY�ºQL@!C$WUCGMOWLCGM�d;YO��SbMbf3��h�h�YbkbQUC�PpQ � M[k�f.deWUY3h�C�KUKLC�K �M P P MOk!f �S P P K�� Qi��M P � � ) �M P P *�¨�S P � � ) �S P P *

MOk!f �M P P � �S P P �� t WLC���M[QL��YOk��°��KG�$ ��r��¤jÃD�3��ÃO¤$©R�ª��¶ª�ª�«�£���3�«�6�[�e�/� ¬ M � S&��BDde����C�K M � � S �/¨ ¬ YbW�MO����KLNe�!KaQL��QLN3�QL��YOk �/�

��� Æ Å �¦Æ3Õ � �6� � ���È���É�� ��r�$¤Uà �3��ÃO¤$©^�ª��¶j�ª���£�«�3���6�r�!�¾�[�;à ���s�É¿[©U�r�3�;à ¶����j�£µ��3 ��[�«�6�[�&�¦��������j�[�!��¤KJb���[�;Ã.�¦������� ��Ê����3¤�� � � � Ì � 2 � � % Å ÕÉÆ Ò � Ñ },� Å �.~ � Æ � áj�O� Ò � � Ò �(}� Æ3Õ-ÕÉ� � �� Ì �g¶U¤� ¡�6�[�ȵ'�r���r�6Ã� ��rÍ/�����[©#�3�[©L�r £ �¤$ X�U�[µR�e�¦�ª�£���6�r� �MON�S � S N M�Ê MON # SON8� & � # MON�S-&AN8� Ê MON � M �

� Ì � Q � Ê � Q � �CM � � � � Q M �� Ì # � Q;M-& N�S � � Q!# MON�S-&LÊ�� �DQ9�;�r�;�j©L¤j¤��£� S �

â�â54�6!þ87:98;

Page 83: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

wbq � Ì(À��[�y¿O�6�r©«¿O�

±9CgWLC�d�YbWaQcKLYOBDCgf3��KTQUWL���eN3QU��¥p��QTS���M¦�cK ¬ YbW�deWU��¥rMrQUC¸WLC�de����h$M[QL��YOk!K�¨3��� Cb��¨ ¬ YbWcKaS3KaQLC�BDK#Y ¬ QU@eC ¬ YOWUB

� Q!# MON � Q># � &�,S-&��k9��@e��hj@ Q^B'M¦S¯Yph�h�NeW ¬ WUC$CD��k M°MOk!f S°YOk!��S^��ksYbN3QLd!N3Q�KaNe�eZTC�hªQ¸d;YbKL�§QU��Ybk®� � keCDKL@eYONe��f^QU@e��ke�Y ¬ SÖMOKGM'deWU��¥rM[QLC�WUC�KLYON!WUh$CgY ¬ MD¨ ¬ YOW MÖ��KRQL@eC YOke��S¯deWLY3h$C�KUKc��@eY�h�M[kÈMbh$h$C�KUK;SDÂ���k�f3C$Cif MÖh$MOkMbhªQU��¥rMrQUC'MOK¸B'M[kpSÈh$YOde��C�K¸Y ¬ S MOK¸k!C$C�feC�f÷�'±9C'��WL��QLC.KLN!hj@ÉM^KaS3KaQLC�B MOK+M-@ Q � # ��&K�,S\Fb��?#@eCk!Y[QUM[QL��YOkZ@0Q���# ��&K� S-F�@!MOK�KLSpkyQUMOh�QL��hGdeWLCih�Cif3C$k!h$C�Yr¥bC$W�QL@!CgYOd;C$WjMrQLYbWUK�Y ¬ QL@!C�h$M[��h�N!��N!K����� Æ Å �¦Æ3Õ � ��2 � �rÆ � Ò ´�O�3~� Å Ð ~ � Æ Å �rÆ3ÕÉ}�� À;�¦�O�e�¦�$¤;Q �i�j���3©j���j©L¤j¤ �£� M:Y;�-Y,S �[�! ¡Á.�£�-�r�3�����3��ª��¶ �$¤j���(�3�r�j�£���6�r��Ì � �p¤$� �

� Ì # MFN �!&K@0Q���# ��&K� S-F � M-@ Q���# � &�,S-FUN �!@ Q���# � &�,S-F �� Ì # � M-&K@0Q��Q# ��&K� S-F � � M-@0Q � # � &K� S-F �� Ì # �B# �4&� M-&5@ Q���# � &�,S-F � �B# �>&� M-@ Q�� # � &�,S-FbÊ�� �:�9���g���r���j©U¤U¤��£� S �[�;ÃUQ �� ���

� Ì # � �CM-&K@0Q��Q# ��&K� S-F � � � M-@0Q � # � &K� S-FOÊ�� � �D���¸���r���j©L¤j¤��£� Q4# � &�,S �! Ì;M-@ Q���# � &�,S-F � M�Ê�� �DQ9���g�;�r�;�j©L¤j¤��£� M ��OÌ Q P � R�@0Q ��# ��&K� S-F �Q#(S-@��.C D>F &5@ Q���# � &�,S-F3Ì�82 4 � B < 7 @;E�=?>A@;E @ 9 < #+7 E � � � � % Å ÕÉƯ� Å Ð/"�Æ3Ð;~� Å Ð�}��!Ð�Ó Ð Å ~i�3~� Å Ð � Å ��~Uà3��ÆyÓ²�O� Ò � � Ò _�kÉQTSpd;C�fÉ����h$MO��h$Ne����¨#�«Áj�e¤¯¤���¢��£©U�r�!µ'¤$�!�«�O¨�WjM[k!zOC�f9Yr¥bC$Wg�pS �*¨XM[WUC.M�×!ke��QLC�MbKLKL��zOkeBDC$kyQ�Y ¬ QTSpd;C�KQUY�k�M[BDC�K���t QTSyd!��kez ZTN!f3zbC$BDC$kyQ � ! M°MbKLKLC$WLQUKcQL@!M[QgdeWLY3h$C�KUK M���KG�*C�������QTSyd;C�fÈNek!f3C�WGQL@eC�QTSpd�CMbKLKLNeBDd3QU��Ybk!K �*¨®M[k!f � ! ��� �&QU@!MrQ¸¥rM[��NeC ��@�MOK�QTSpd�C�� Nek!feC$WGQL@eC QTSpd�CDMOKUKLNeBDd3QL��YOk!K �*�g_�kQTSpd;C�f�h$M[��h�N!����¨3M�WUC�KaQLWU��h�QLCif'k!M[BDCG��K#MOkekeY[QjMrQUC�f.����QL@�M�QTSpd;CO¨eMbK���kZ# � Q��"� &�MD¨ � # Q ��� &K� MD¨pM[k�fM-@ Q ��� ��# ��&K� S-FbÂbQL@eCRQTSpd�C�� ��K�YbBD�§QLQLC�f.��@eC$k'keYOQ*��BDd�YbWaQjM[kyQ�� � Ne�!KaQL��QLNeQL��YOk!K�M[WUCcd;C$W ¬ YOWUB�CifYbke��S^��C$QT�*C�C$k9k!M[BDC�K¸Y ¬ QU@eC'KLMOB�C�QTSpd;CO��± @eC$kÉ��CDfeC�M[�/����QL@-KLC$¥OC�WUMO�(QTSpd;C�fÉh$MO��h$Ne���«¨÷QUY�M¦¥bYO��fMOB��e��zON!�§QTSb¨y��C¸KaYbB�C$QL��BDC�K�MOf!f'QL@!CGk�M[BDC¸Y ¬ QU@eCgh$MO��h$Ne��N�K�QUY�QTSyd!��kez�ZTN!f3zbC$BDC$kyQjK$ÂpQU@yN�K#�*CG��WL��QLC�$��� ! M QUY'BDC�M[k�QL@�MrQ�QL@!C¸QTSyd!��kezGZTN!fezOC$BDC�kbQ � ! M�@eYb��f!K���k�QL@!C�h$M[��h�N!��N!K �R�±9CÈf3��KTQU��k!zONe��Ka@ �;C�QT��C$C�k ¢¦�[ ¡�!¤¾��Áj�e¤ª�ÈMOk!f&���3�r�!��¤� ��«Áj�e¤��j� ?#@eC ¬ YbWLBDC�W.M[WUC¯QL@eC^QTSpd;C�K'Y ¬

QU@eC'¥rM[��NeC�KGQU@!MrQ�B'M¦S¾�;C'h�YbB�B Neke��h$M[QLC�f®Â(QU@eC'��M[QaQUC$W�M[WUC�QL@eCDQTSpd;C�K¸Y ¬ QU@eC'k!M[BDCiKgM[��YOkez���@e��hj@QU@eC�KLCR¥rMO��NeCiK*MOWLC�h�YOBDB Neke��h$MrQUC�f÷�_�k'QU@eC�����h$MO��h$Ne��N!K$¨phj@!MOkekeC$�!QTSpd�CiK*MOWLCRMO��KLY�¥rM[��NeCRQTSyd;C�K�Âp��k�QL@eC�R��zb@eC$WL� � WUf3C�W#����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�Y ¬ � C�hªQU��YbksÝ�¨!�pS¯h�YOkyQUWUMbKTQi¨3¥¦MO��N!C�M[k!f^hj@�M[kekeC��÷QTSpd�CiKRMOWLCgf3��KTQU��k�hªQ��ctQTSpd;CgC$kp¥p��WUYOk!B�C�kyQ �-��K��� ��¦�$¤jÃ�� ¬ �-��K�MOk¯MbKLKL��zOkeBDC$kyQ#Y ¬ hj@!M[k!keC$��QTSpd;C�K�QLY'k�M[BDC�K��±9C ��WU��QLC-7���� QLY�BDC�M[k¾QL@!M[QGCiMOhj@�� /7�s@�MOKRQTSyd;C ��Â�MOk!f � ! M:Y,S QLY�BDC�M[k¾QL@!M[QG�;Y[QU@

� ! M�MOk!f � ! S�@eYO��f÷�

�´ó�â����

Page 84: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

���!��¤�©��;©L¤$�«�£�p¿R�j�3�������6�r�!�g�r�#���a�j�[ ����3 §�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª� weE

� � � & Å;Ò à��!Ó. ´� £~jà_�kÉQU@eC�d;YO��SbMbf3��hD����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K¸QUNede��C�K�Y ¬ k!M[BDC�K h$MOk9�;C�h$YOBDB�N!ke��h�MrQUC�f÷�¯ÛeYbWgQL@e��K�¨�QU@eC ¬ Yb����Yr����kezd!WLY3f3N!h�QL��YOk���KRMOfef3Cif.QUYDQL@eCgzbWUMOBDBDMOW*Y ¬ ¥rMO��NeCiK$º

�r ¡�!¤��� � � P 7 ��R QUNede��C�K

��M¦¥p��kez MOfefeC�f M h�YOk�KTQUWLN!h�QLYbW ¬ YOW�¥rM[��NeC�K�¨c��CÈkeC�C�f M¼h�YbWLWUC�KLd;YOk!f3��kez f3CiKTQUWLN�hªQLYbW�� �RKLN!MO����S MfeC�KaQLWUN!hªQUYOWc��K�Mbfef3Cif^MOKcM'k!C$� YOd;C$WjMrQUYOW�QUY'QL@eC�zOWjM[BDB'M[W ¬ YbWcdeWUYph$C�KUKaCiK$�#_�k¯QU@eC h�MOKLCgY ¬ QLNed!��CiK$¨@!Yr�*C�¥OC$Wi¨¦�§Q���KXh�Ybkp¥OC$k!��C�kbQQLY¸f3Cih�YOBDd;YbKLC�MR¥rM[��NeC#�pS�BDC�MOk!KY ¬ d�MrQaQUC$WUk B'M[QUhj@e��kez¸��k���kedeN3Q�deWUC�×!P�¨QU@pN!KcMOfeYOd3QU��kez�QU@eCgd�Yb��SyMOf3��h ¬ YOWUB°Y ¬ ��k!deN3Q;Q4#.7��&K�,MD�_�kÉM[k9NekyQTSpd�CifÈd;YO��SbMbf3��h�����h$MO��h$Ne��N�KGQL@eC�WLC'h$MOkÈ�;C'WLN!k3�«QU��BDCDC$WUWUYOWjK�f3N!C QUY^M[WU�§QTS^BD��KaB'MrQjhj@

Ybk h�YbB�B Neke��h$M[QL��YOk®� ?#@eC�KLC¾C$WUWUYOWjK'h$M[k �;CÈM¦¥OYb��feC�f �yS MOKUKL��zbke��k!zsQTSpd;C�K.QLY k!MOBDC�K�� ±9CÈh$MO����e�r §ÁO�OÃr�6�¾���a�j�r ��$�3 ¡�p�ÈQU@eCÉh$M[��h�N!��N!K�����QL@ hj@�M[kekeC��RQTSpd;C�K�¨cWUC�h�N!WUKL��¥bC^QTSpd�CiK$¨GM[k!f deWLY3f3N�hªQ�QTSyd;C�K \¯����v!E[¨�Ü ��vOme¨÷V � v �3¨÷?�NeWUv � ��� Ý*@!M[kek!C$��QTSyd;C�K¸MOWLC Y ¬ QU@eC ¬ YbWLB � ��Â;d!WLY3f3N!h�Q�QTSpd;C Y ¬ QL@!C ¬ YbWLBP����8]0]2] � 3 R ¬ YOW+- � �eÂ/WUC�h$NeWUKL��¥OC QTSyd;C�K�Y ¬ QL@eC ¬ YbWLB

O� � ��¨(��@eC$WUC � ��K�M�QTSpd;C'¥¦MOWL��M[�!��Cb�.ÛeYOW

��k!KaQUMOk!h�Cbº P��(Y � R/��K�QL@eCRQTSyd;CcY ¬ M¸d!M[��W�¨y��@eYyKaC#×!WjKaQ*h�YbB�d;YOk!C$kyQ�@!MbKXQTSpd�C � M[k!f�QU@eC�KLC�h$YOk!f QTSpd�C�#Â(M.k!MOBDC�Q¯����QL@sQTSpd�C ��P � � ]2]0] �$3�RRB'M¦S�Ybke��S¾h$M[WUWUS -���Nede��C�KGY ¬ ¥rMO��NeCiK$¨÷��@!C$WUC�QL@!C ����QL@s¥¦MO��N!C@�MOK�QTSpd�C � �a��RY[QjMrQL��YOk�K$¨pf3C�×�ke�§QU��Ybk!K�M[k!fDWUC�KLNe��QUK ¬ YOW�QU@eCGB�Ybk!MOfe��h�����h$MO��h$Ne��N!K���k.QU@e��K�KLC�hªQU��Ybk'zOC�keC$WjM[����KLC�QUY

QU@eCgd;YO��SbMOfe��hG����h$M[��h�N!��N!K#��k�QL@eCgYb�p¥y��YON�K*�#M¦SO�

� � � � � � ~jà3��Æp}

?#@!C � ��QTSpd�CiK V � v � �÷M[WUCRM ¬ WUC�¹yNeC�kyQL��S�N�KaCif'WLC$×!keC�B�C�kyQ*Y ¬ QL@eCGM[�;Yr¥OCcBDC$kyQU��YbkeC�f.hj@�M[kekeC��!QTSpd;CO�?#@!C$S.M[����Yr� N!K�QLYDKaC�d!M[WjMrQUC�QL@!C¸h�M[d!MO�e������QTSDY ¬ N�Ka��kez M k!MOB�CG��k���kedeN3Q�YbW*��k�YbN3QLdeNeQ�¨eM[k�f�B'M¦SD��CQU@eWUC$C ¬ YOWUB'K$º

� ��� ��K�QL@eCgQTSpd;C�Y ¬ MDk!MOBDCgQL@!M[QRB'M¦S��;C�N!KLC�f¯Ybke��S���k^YbN3QLd!N3QGMOk!f�QL@!M[Q�h$MOWLWU��CiK#¥rM[��NeC�K�Y ¬QTSpd�C ��Â

� � � ��K¸QL@!CDQTSyd;C'Y ¬ M�k!M[BDC�QL@�MrQ�B'M¦S¾�;C'N!KLC�fsYOke��SÈ��kÉ��ked!N3Q�M[k!fsQU@!MrQ�h�M[WUWL��C�KG¥rM[��NeC�K¸Y ¬QTSpd�C ��Â

� � ����K�[email protected];C�Y ¬ M¾k!MOB�C.QL@!M[Q�B'M¦S9��C�N!KaCif-�;Y[QL@¼��k ��kedeNeQDMOk!f-��k YON3QUdeN3QDM[k!fÉQU@!MrQh$MOWLWU��C�K�¥rM[��NeC�K#Y ¬ QTSpd�C ���

Û!YOW���k�KTQjM[k!h$CO¨pMgQTSpd�C L � � P � �8Y�� � R�³ ¬ YOW�M[ded!WLYbdeWL��MrQUC#QTSpd�CGC�P3deWUC�KUKa��YOk�K �ÉMOk!f ��·�KLM¦S3KXQU@!MrQk�M[BDC Lsh$MOk¾��C�N!KLC�f ¶L�[���¯QUY�WUC�Mbf¾M[k!f^QLY���WL��QLC�M[k!f¾QL@!M[QGM[kpS¯BDC�KUKLMOzOC�M[Q Lsh$MOWLWU��CiKRM�d!M[��WRY ¬k�M[BDC�K�Â!BDYOWUC$Yr¥bC$Wi¨pQL@eC�×!WUKaQRh�YbBDd�YbkeC$kyQRY ¬ QU@eC�d!MO��W�h$M[k¯�;C�N!KLC�f��pS�QL@eC�WUC�h$��d!��C�kbQD�r�! §Á.����©L¤j�OÃ¥rMO��NeCiK#Y ¬ QTSpd�C��¨pQU@eC�KLC�h�Ybk!fÉ�r�! §Á'���.ÍX©ª�£��¤#¥rMO��NeCiK#Y ¬ QTSpd�C ���� k!C�Y ¬ WLCiMOKLYOk!K��@pS ���¸QTSpd�CiK�M[WUC�N!KLC ¬ Ne����K/QU@!MrQ�QL@eC�S zb��¥bC�WU��KaC#QUY�KaN!�3QTSpde��k!z!º�?*Spd�C�M[kekeYOQUM[�

QU��Ybk ��³6MOk¾��k!deN3QGh�M[d!MO�e������QTSe·#zO��¥OCiKch�Yr¥rM[WU��M[k!h$CO¨ �¾³«M[k^YbN3QLdeNeQGh$MOd!M[�!�����§QTSe·#zb��¥bC�Kch$YOkyQLWjM¦¥rM[WU��MOk!h�Cb¨MOk!f � ³´�;Y[QU@ h$M[d�M[�e������QL��C�Kj·�zO��¥OCiK���kp¥rM[WU��MOk!h�Cb�'\^YOWUC$Yr¥OC�W�¨÷KL��k�h�C.M�QUMOz � zO��¥OC�KGBDYOWUC ¬ WLC�C�f3YbB ��kQU@eCgN!KLCgY ¬ M k�M[BDCO¨ ¬ YbW�C�[email protected]�C � ��CG@�M¦¥OC � � � � � MOk!f � � � �����

â�â54�6!þ87:98;

Page 85: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

w � � Ì(À��[�y¿O�6�r©«¿O�

� N!�3QTSpde��k!z.ZTN!f3zbC$BDC$kyQjK�M[WUC.Y ¬ QU@eC ¬ YbWLB � ! � � ��¨��@eC$WUC�� WUC$deWUC�KLC$kyQjKGQL@eC�KaNe�eQTSyd!��kezMbKLKLNeBDd3QU��Ybk!K�³´QL@e��K���K ��WL��QaQUC$k � � ����@eC$k QL@eC¯KaN!�3QTSpde��k!zsMOKUKLNeBDd3QL��YOk!K M[WUC.C$BDd3QTSe·��9t�K MOkC$PeM[BDde��CO¨3@eC�WLCgM[WUCGQL@eC�KLNe�3QTSpde��kezDWUNe��C ¬ YbW#QL@eC � � QTSpd;C�h�YOk�KTQUWLN!h�QUK�º

� ! � � � � !�� � �

� ! � � � � �

# Z@ � Y � F � ! � � �� ! #�� � � �

# @ � Y�� F � !�� � �

� ! #�� � ���Û!YOW�WUC�MbfeM[�!�����§QTSb¨b��CRKLYOBDC�QU��BDCiK�N!KLCR�eWjMOhj�bC�QjKX���§QU@ � ��QTSyd;C�K�¨pMOK���k � #�� &L�/±9C�M[��KLY�Y3h$h$MbKa��YOke�

MO����S.N!KLCGQL@eCiKaCgk!Y[QUM[QL��YOk!K ¬ YbWchj@!M[k!keC$��QTSpd;C�K�º

� #�� & � ��K�QU@eC¸QTSpd�CgYb�3QUMO��keCif ¬ WUYOB � �pS�h�M[k!h$C$������kez�QL@eCgYbN3QLC�WLBDYyKTQ� � � QUMOz!�

� #�� &� �R��K�QU@eC¸QTSpd�CgYb�3QUMO��k!C�f��yS�WLC�de��Mbh���kez�QL@eCgYbN3QLC�WLBDYyKTQ � ��QUMOzD��k �²����QL@ � �� ¬ YOW3# @ � Y���Y � Fy¨3�*C¸��WU�§QUC � � #�� ¬ YOW3#�P �8Y�� Rj�

Û!YOW���k!KaQUMOk!h�Cb¨�# � � &��¼��K���¨�M[k!f/# � � & �¸��K � ���cÚ�Y[QU@ ¬ YOW #�� &�� M[k!f ¬ YbW!#�� & �i¨;��C�BD��zb@bQ�keC$CifQUYDNek ¬ YO��f �²×�WUKaQ�¨3� ¬ ��QUKcYON3QUC$WUB�YyKTQch$YOk!KaQLWUN!hªQ���K#WLCih�NeWjKL��Ybk®�

� � � � � 6Ð�Æp�3�� £~jà �!Ð(Ó �rÆp�OÆ ��~� ";Æ3Ð(Æp}i}

Û!NeWLQL@eC�W�WUC�×!k!B�C�kyQUK�Y ¬ QL@!C � � QTSpd�CiK�MOWLC¾QL@eCsQTSpd�C9KaS3KaQLC$B'K ¬ YOW9 ¡�£�;¤j�[©ª�£�«Á �gV�?�v � �gM[k�f ¬ YOW©U¤U�j¤T�����£¢¦¤$�;¤��j� � M[k!vpo¦� ���c±9C�f3Y�keY[QGdeWLCiKaC�kyQcQL@eCiKaC�QTSpd�C�KaS3KaQLC$B'KR@eC$WUCO¨�MOKcQL@eC�S¯MOWLC�B�C�kyQL��YOkeCif��k¯¥OC�WLS ¬ C�� de��Mbh�CiK#��k¯QU@e��KRd!M[d;C$Wi��±9C�YOk!��S.WUC�h�M[���÷QL@�MrQc����keCiM[WU�§QTS�M[����Yr�cK�N!KcQLY.KUM¦S'QL@�MrQRMDk!MOB�CB'M¦S.�;CgN!KLC�f�QLY'd;C$W ¬ YOWUB°M�WLCif3N!h�QL��YOk¯MrQ�BDYbKaQcYOk!h$CO�

� � � � � à3��Æy}'��Ð(Ó |�Æ � � " Å �(�r� Ò Æ�� �' "e� Ò Æ3Ð(�bÆp}?#@!C�N�KaCDY ¬ QTSpd�CiKgM ��C�hªQjK¸h�YOkyQUC�PpQLN!MO����Sy��feC�×!keCif ¬ YbWLB'K¸Y ¬ ��C�@!M¦¥p��YbNeWjM[�C�¹yNe��¥¦MO��C�k!h�CD�����bC ��M[WU��Cifh$YOkezbWLN!C$k!h$CO¨ ¬ YOW/��k'McQTSpd;C�fDh$MO��h$Ne��N�KQL@eC#deWUY3h�C�KUKLC�K��C���k!z¸h$YOBDd!MOWLCif�B�N�KTQXYO�;C$S�QL@eCcKUM[BDC*QTSyd!��kezMOk!f¯QU@eC h$YOkyQLC$PyQjKc��kÈ��@e��hj@¯QL@!C$S¾M[WUCgQUC�KaQLC�f¾B�N!KaQ��;C h$YOBDd!MrQU���!��C ���§QU@¾QL@!��KRQTSpde��k!z!��t­³ � ���D·��h$YOkyQLC$PpQ���K*M�h�YbkyQLC�PpQ�QU@!MrQi¨b��@!C$kD×!����Cif'��k.���§[email protected]�C�KUKXYb��C�Sy��kezgQTSpde��kez���¨y��Cih�YbB�CiK�Mgd!WLY3h�CiKLKYb��C�Sp��kez�QTSpde��kez����±9C9feC�×!keCsQTSpd�Cif �!MOWL�;C�f h�YbkezOWUNeC$k�h�C¾Ybk M zbC$keC�WL��h^QTSpd;C�f²deWLY3h$C�KUK�h$MO��h$Ne��N!K%�°QL@�MrQ^@!MOK

WUC�feN!hªQU��Ybk M[k!fÉYb�!KaC�WL¥rM[QL��YOkÉWLC���M[QL��YOk!K�MOK�MO��Yr¥bCO¨/M[k!f9QTSpde��kez'ZTN�f3zOC�B�C�kyQUK ¬ YbW�deWUY3h�CiKLKLC�KgY ¬ QL@eC¬ YbWLB �"� � ! M¾ÂO��C�MbKLKLNeBDC�QU@!MrQ�h$YOkyQLC$PyQjK$¨[h$��YyKaCifgQTSpde��kez!¨rC$QUhO�[M[WUC*f3C$×!keC�f ��k��ÉMOK��k�����h$MO��h$Ne��N�K$�t ��Áj�e¤Uà � ©U¤� ��[�«�6�[����K�MgKLC�Q�Y ¬ QLWU��d!��CiKX#�� �M � S-&®��@eC�WLC��&��K�M¸h���YbKLC�f�QTSpde��kez�M[k!f ����� ! M:Y,S9�� Æ��/Ð. £~� Å Ð � ��� � }�~$� Å Ð(Ô-|�3�r|�ÆpÓ � Å Ð(Ô�� �(Æ3Ð��OÆ � �(¤$���­¶U¤c�G��Áj���£�p¿rÊ®ÍX�£� ��� ���O! M:Y S�Ì �¤�$�[Á�� �p�[�(�;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª�3M:Y,S �[©L¤�KTQUWLYbkezO��SD�!M[WU��Cif�h$YOkezbWLN!C$kyQG³6��k$�*·�M[Q���Ê�ÍX©ª�£����¤$� ��#��N&��AM �! S�Ê� �UÊ;���r©�¤j�O� �^�$ ��r��¤jÃ��«Áj�e¤�¤���¢��£©L�[�!µ'¤������ �r�;Ã�³ � ���D· �a�j�r����¤Jb� � Ê�Í�¤ �p�[¢¦¤"�$� � ) M * � � ) S *TÌ

�´ó�â����

Page 86: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

���!��¤�©��;©L¤$�«�£�p¿R�j�3�������6�r�!�g�r�#���a�j�[ ����3 §�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª� wOm

tRzbMO��k®¨÷Í�¤j�rËR�!M[WU�;C�f¯h�YbkezOWUNeC$k�h�C¸MrQ ����K�f3C�×�keC�f��pS�WUC$de��MOh$��k!z � ���§QU@ � M[k!f �! c���§QU@�! R��k�Ç�C�×!k!�§QU��Ybk¾Ú���EOEb�± @!C$k¯QL@!C$WUC���KRkeY.M[B �e��zONe��QTS�Ybk^��@!MrQcQU@eC�h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�� ��K�¨!��C�B'M¦S�f3WUYOd$�R¨;MOk!f^M[�e�!WLC�¥y��MrQUC

��#��N&��;M �! S�MOK M �! � SD�g±9C ��WU��QLC M �! � S ³´YbW ��#��N& � M �! S�·c����QL@eYbN3Q¸WLCih$M[������kez�QL@eCMbKLKLNeBDd3QU��Ybk�QU@!MrQDM MOk!f S M[WUCG�*C������«QTSpd;C�f���k ���X_�k�QU@eC�h$MbKaCGY ¬ QL@eC¸de��M[��k�d�Yb��SyMOf3��hR����h$MO��h$Ne��N!K$¨����QL@!YON3Q ���gQTSpd;C�K�¨y��CRKL@!M[����M[��KaY�f3WUYOd.QL@eCRQTSyd;CRC�kp¥y��WUYOkeBDC$kyQ���k!f3C$P ��¨pM[k�f¸ZTN!KaQ*��WU�§QUC M �! ASDÂQU@eCcYbB���QaQUC�f QTSpd�C�C�kp¥y��WUYOkeBDC$kyQX�������!MO���#M¦S3K��Cc¥bC$WUS�Ka��BDde��CO¨pM[k!f �������!�;Cch���C�MOW ¬ WLYbB&QL@!CRh�YbkbQUC�PpQ��?#@!C�KLMOB�Cgh$YOkp¥OC�kbQU��Ybk!K#M[ded!��S ¬ YbWcKTQUWLYbkez��!M[WU��Cif�h$YOkezbWLN!C$k!h$CO�ÙGC�keC$WjM[����Ka��kezsQL@eCÈfeC�×!ke��QL��YOk�K'Y ¬ zOWUYONek!f �e��Ka��B�N!��M[QL��YOk M[k!f C�P3d!MOk!KL��Ybk¼QUYÉQL@eC^d;YO��SbMbf3��h����

h�M[��h�Ne��N!K���KcKaQLWjM[��zO@yQ ¬ YbWL�#M[WjfyF YOkeC�ZTN!KaQR@!MOK�QUY.B'M[�bC¸KLNeWUC¸QL@!M[Q�QL@eC�k!M[BDC�KcWLCih�C$��¥OCif��pS�QL@eC�d!WLYO�h$C�KUKaCiK���k ��kedeN3QDMOhªQU��Ybk!K�@�M¦¥OCDQL@!C�M[d!deWLYbdeWU��M[QLCDQTSpd�CiK$�st�f3YOd3QU��k!z^QL@eC�KLMOBDC�h�Ybky¥bC$kyQL��YOk-MbK ¬ YOW��M[WU��Cif^h�YOk!zOWUNeC$k!h$CO¨e��Cg��WU�§QUC M � SÖM[k!f M � S ¬ YbWRzOWUYON!k!f��e��KL��B�Ne��MrQU��Ybk¯MOk!f¯C�P3d!MOk!KL��Ybk�Ybkd;YO��SbMbf3��h�d!WLY3h�CiKLKLC�K�¨pYOBD��QaQL��kezDQU@eC¸QTSpd�C¸C$kp¥p��WLYbkeBDC$kyQ���k!feC�P÷�±9C MO��KLY'N!KLC�zOWUYON!k!f¯�e��Ka��B�Ne��MrQU��Ybk¾M[k!f¯C$P3d!M[k!KL��YOk¯YOk^deWUY3h�CiKLKLC�K�Y ¬ QL@eC�d�Yb��SyMOf3��hg����h$M[��h�N!��N!K

����QL@ � ��QTSpd;C�K�¨(�pS¾��zOkeYbWL��kez�QL@eC� � ��QTSpd;C�KgMOK ¬ Yb����Yr�cK'³6MbKgM[k9C�PeM[BDde��CO¨®��C�QUMO�OC��*CiM[�^zOWUYON!k!f�!��KL��B Ne��MrQL��YOk;·ª�/_ ¬ M:Y,S&MOWLC�KaN!hj@'d!WLY3h�CiKLKLC�K�¨[QU@eC$k��*CGKaC$QAM � S � ¬ M � � S � ¨p��@eC$WUCOº M � M[k!f S �MOWLC¸Yb�3QUMO��keCif ¬ WUYOB M MOk!f S �pS�WUC$d!��Mbh���kez CiMOhj@ � ��QTSpd�C+# � ³ ¬ YOW3# Z@ � Y���Y � F¦·*�pS.QU@eC�hj@!MOkekeC$�QTSpd;C � ��ÂeM[k�f M � � S � ��K�zOWUYON!k!f.�e��KL��B Ne��M[QL��YOk�Y ¬ QL@eCgd!��MO��k�d�Yb��SyMOf3��hG����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K��_ ¬ M M[k�f S M[WUC'deWLY3h$C�KUKaCiK¸Y ¬ QL@eC�MOKLSyk�hj@eWLYbkeYON�K¸����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�¨��²M�QTSpde��kezÈMbKLKLNeBDd3QU��YbksQU@!MrQ

B'M¦S�h$YOkyQUMO��k � � QTSpd�CiK$¨�M[k!f � ! M:Y,S QU@eC$k M � S ��B�d!����C�KDM �! �

SD�t N!KLC ¬ Ne����M¦� Y ¬ QU@eC�MbKaSpk!hj@eWUYOk!YON!K#����h$MO��h$Ne��N�K$¨ ¬ YOW���@eYbKLC�¥rM[����fe�§QTS � �DQTSpd;C�KGM[WUCgkeC�h$C�KUKLMOWLSb¨

��K � C$BDB'M'Ú���E � �;C$��Yr�g��_�k�QL@e��K���C$BDB'Me¨e��CgN!KLC¸KLd;C�h���M[�(deWLY3h$C�KUKaCiK�h�M[����Cif�����ke�3K$��t ����ke���;C�QT��C$C�kM�k!MOB�C Q^M[k�fÈM�k!M[BDC �¦¨÷��WL��QaQUC$k Q � �¦¨���C�@!M¦¥OCiKR�����bC�MOkÈC�de@eC$BDC�WUMO��YbkeC���de��MOh�C �eN���C$W ¬ WUYOB QQUY �¦ºX�§Q�WUC�h$C$��¥OC�K�k!MOBDC�K#MrQDQ.MOk!f�C�BD�§QjK�QL@eC�B­MrQ �¦� ��M[BDC�K3Q.MOk!f �cB N!KTQ��;C¸Y ¬ QU@eC�KUM[BDCRQTSpd;CO�?#@!C�f3C�×!k!�§QU��Ybk���K

Q � � $ %('� Q4#.7� &� � P 7� R� C$BDB'MsÚG��E � KLM¦S3K�QL@!M[Q'� ¬ YOke��SÉQL@eC¯YbN3QLdeNeQ'h�M[d!MO�e������QTS-Y ¬ k�M[BDC�K�B'M¦S-��C^h$YOBDB�Nek!��h�MrQLCif

MO��Ybkez�Mgk�M[BDC;Q¯³£QU@e��K*��K�QU@eCR@pSpd�YOQL@eCiKa��K Q ��� ���*Ây�;C�h�M[N!KLCcY ¬ KaNe�eQTSyd!��kez��§Q#M[��KaY�h$Yr¥OC�WUKQU@eC�h�MOKLCQ � � ���X·ª¨yQU@eC$k�KaC�k!f3��kez M �pkeYr��k'k!M[BDC ��M[��YOk!z QD��K�QL@!CGKUM[BDC�MbK*KLC$k�f3��k!z M ¬ WUC�[email protected]!MOBDC �#QU@!MrQ��K�����k!�OC�f�QLY �r�

� Æ3Õ-ÕÉ� � � ��¤$�*��� � � ��� � ��¶L¤�� �p¤��3�[ ¡ÁO�OÃ[�6�¾�¦�ªÁr�����y©L�r���r�p�����a�j�r ����3 ¡�p�'ÍX�£� � ���3Ê��r��Ã^�ª�¦�O�e�¦�$¤

��� � � ��� � ��

� � ! Q P��&R �r��Ãg��� � � ��� � ��

� � ! Q � � � �¾Ê!���r©¸�$�rµ'¤��cÌ � �p¤$����� � � ��� � ��

#��M&�� Q�P�� R��! X# � � �� � & # Q P�� R3N � � � � &ªÌ � � � % � � ƾ}$~�� Å Ð�Ô9�¦Æ � Ò ´�b�3~� Šв~ � Æ Å �rÆ3ÕÉ}��Ka��kez ���'QTSpd�CiK$¨;��Q���Kcd;YbKUKa���e��CgQLY ¬ YOWUB�Ne��MrQUCgB�YbWLC�d�Yr��C$W ¬ Ne�(¥bC$WjKa��YOk�K#Y ¬ QL@!C�WUC$de����h�MrQU��Ybk¯?#@!C$Y[�WUC$B ÚG��Eiqe¨bh�M[����Cif QL@eCg�ª��©L�r�p¿�©U¤��; ¡�6�j�r���6�r�^� �p¤j�r©L¤$µ � V � v �e¨ � M[k!vbw ���?#@eC�h�YOk�f3�§QU��Ybk � Q�Y3h$h$NeWUK ¬ WLC�C��k M:Y��-Y S²Ybke��S���k�YbN3QLd!N3Q*KLNe�3ZTC�h�Q�d;YbKL�§QU��Ybk ��Y ¬ ?#@!C$YOWUC$B Ú���E�qG��K�WUC$��MrP3C�f �pS�WUC�¹yNe��WL��kez�¨[WLYbNezO@!��Sb¨QU@!MrQGQL@!C�QTSpde��kez�Y ¬ deWLY3h$C�KUKaCiK;M:Y��-Y SÖYOke��S�WLCi¹bN!��WUC�KcQL@eC�YON3QUdeN3Q¸h$M[d�M[�e������QTS-³´��� Cb��¨÷M.QTSyd;C�Y ¬ QL@eC¬ YbWLB ����·*YOk Q;�/?#@!��K�BDCiM[k!K�QU@!MrQ�QU@eC�KLC¸deWLY3h$C�KUKaCiK$¨3MOK�QU@eYbKLC¸Y ¬ ?#@eC$YbWLC�B�ÚG��Eiqe¨3B'M¦S.keYOQ#N�KaC+Q��k.��kedeN3QiÂ3�eN3Qi¨y�pS'h�YbkyQLWjMOKaQ����§QU@'QL@eYyKaC�Y ¬ ?#@eC�YOWUC$BÖÚG��Eiqe¨[QU@eC�KLCRd!WLY3h�CiKLKLC�K�BDM¦SDh�YbBDB�Neke��h$M[QLC;Q;¨

â�â54�6!þ87:98;

Page 87: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

wOn � Ì(À��[�y¿O�6�r©«¿O�

��k¾��@e��hj@Èh�MOKLC�QL@!C h�Ybk!KaQLWjM[��kbQ�YOk^QU@eC YbN3QLd!N3QGh�M[d!MO�e������QTS�Ybk Q���KRQLWjM[k�KaBD��QaQLCif¯QLY�QL@eC�WUC�h���de��C$kyQUKY ¬ Q;�

� � � $ {�|}$~��r�e�[~� Š�}

_�k�QU@eC�C$k!h$Y3f3��k!zbK/Y ¬ QL@eCR�e��h$M[��h�N!��N!K���kyQLYGQU@eC�����h�M[��h�Ne��N!KXf3CiKLh$WL���;C�f ��k�QL@!C�d!M[d;C$Wi¨[QU@eC�C$k!h$Y3f3��k!zGY ¬M��3��QLC�WLB���K*d!M[WjM[BDC�QUWL��h�Ybk�M�k�M[BDCO¨bQL@!M[Q���K�¨y��K#M ¬ Nek�hªQL��YOk ¬ WLYbBÖk!M[BDC�K�QLY ����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K*deWUYph$C�KUKaCiK$�±9C¯h$M[����KaN�hj@¼C�P3deWUC�KUKL��Ybk!K��y¶j�ª��©L�O�$�«�6�[�e�ª¨*MOk!f-N!KLC �:Y�� QUYsWjM[k!zOC�Yr¥bC$W�QL@eC�B�� tck MO�!KaQLWjMOhªQU��Ybk����QL@-d�M[WjM[BDC�QUC$WjKG7 QsMOk!fÉ�;YpfeS M ��K���WU�§QLQLC$k # 7 Q>&K�,MD�¾tck M[��KTQUWUMbhªQL��YOk # 7 Q�&� M ��K M¯�e��k!f3C�W ¬ YbW 7 QY ¬ QL@eC�KUM[BDC'k!M[QLNeWUC�MbK¸QL@eC���ked!N3Q deWUC�×!P �B# 7 Q�&� MD�¯_�k!f3C�C�f÷¨QU@eC.��kedeN3Q �B# 7 Q�&K�,M BDM¦Ss��C�KaC�C$k MOKh$YOk!KaQLWUN!h�QLC�f9�pS.ZTNePyQjM[d;YbKL�§QU��YbkÉY ¬ QL@eC�k!M[BDC �DM[k�fÈQU@eC�MO�!KTQUWUMbhªQU��Ybk # 7 Q�&� MD�¯t�h$h$YOWjf3��k!zO��SO¨(� ¬ ���KGQL@!C.M[�!KaQLWjMOh�QL��YOk # 7 Q>&K�,MD¨(��CDKLYOBDC$QL��B�CiK¸��WL��QLC � �­M[k!f M-@ � � �-F ¬ YOW¸QU@eC'deWUYph$C�KUKaCiK �B# 7 Q>&K�,MMOk!fHM-@ ��� # 7 Q4&K�,M-Fb¨;WLCiKad;C�h�QL��¥OC���Sb��±9C N�KaC�QL@eC ¬ YO����Yr����kez�MO�e�eWUC$¥p��MrQL��YOk�K ¬ YOW¸M[��KTQUWUMbhªQL��YOk�K$º#� ¬ ���K # Q>&K�,M QL@!C$k �B#E7 �B& � M[k!f M-@ � � # 7 �B&��-FgKTQjM[k!f ¬ YOW��B#E7 � Y Q>&K�,M M[k!f M-@ � � # 7 �LY Q>&� M-F¸WLCiKad;C�h�QL��¥OC$��SO¨� � KaQUMOk!feK ¬ YbW M-@�� C T F�F [email protected]�QLN!MO�Xd!M[WjM[BDC�QUC$W �DKaN!�!KTQU�§QUN3QLCiK¸QL@!C ¬ YOWUBDMO�/d!M[WjM[BDC�QUC$W+Q¾��k9QL@eC�;Y3f3S M Y ¬ � F MOk!f �-@ � � # 7 �B&K� S-F�KTQjM[k!feK ¬ YbW # Q>&K�2# M-@ � ��#E7 �L&K�,S\F &L�±9C�C$PyQUC$k!fÉ�;C$@�M¦¥y��YON!WUMO��C�¹yNe��¥rM[��C$k!h$C�K¸QUYÈM[�!KaQLWjMOh�QL��YOk!K�Â/� ¬�� ��K�M^�;C$@�M¦¥y��YON!WUMO�XC�¹yNe��¥¦MO��C�k!h�C

feC�×!keCif�YOk�deWLY3h$C�KUKaCiK$¨rQU@eC$k � � �²BDC�MOk!KQL@!M[Q ��� � � ��¨ ¬ YOW�M[��� �rÂb��k�QTSpd;C�f�����h�M[��h�Ne��� � ���� �

�BDCiM[k!K®QL@!M[Q � � �

����� �

� � ¨ ¬ YOWM[��� ��KLN!hj@¸QU@!MrQ � Y ��� � ! � � Y � � ³«MOK®N�KaN!MO�b��C�YbBD�§Q�QTSyd!��kezR��k!feC�P3C�K��k�QL@eCgd!��MO��k�d�Yb��SyMOf3��hG����h�M[��h�Ne��N!Kj·

� � � � � ƾÓ�Æ Ò �bà�ÆpÓ «Ð'� �®~_�k¸QU@eC�MbKaSpk!hj@eWUYOk!YON!K�����h$MO��h$Ne��N�K$¨i��k!deN3Q�d!WLC$×ePG��K÷QU@eC�Ybke��S¸KLSykyQjMOhªQU��hXh$YOk!KaQLWUN!h�Q ¬ YOW(KLC�¹yNeC�kyQL��M[����KL��k!zd!WLY3h�CiKLK#MbhªQL��YOk�K$��Ý*YOk�Ka��f3C$WcMOk���kedeNeQ

Q># � &�0# �P ��R3N � P � R�&_�Q���K¸WUC�MOKLYOk�M[�e��C�QU@!MrQ � P � R¸Ka@!YONe��fÈC$P3C�h�NeQLC.M ¬ QUC$W¸QU@eC'��k!deN3QUQ4# ��&c��Cih$MON!KaCDQU@eC'��kedeN3Q��e��k!feK �(¨MOk!f'QU@e��K�h$WLCiMrQUC�K�M f3C�d�C�k!f3C�k!h�S'�;C�QT��C$C�k.QL@!CRQT��Y d!WLC$×eP3C�K��Ú�S.h�YbkyQLWjMOKaQ�¨bQL@eCGY[QU@eC$W#YONeQLdeN3Q � P ��R@�MOK�k!YsKLSykyQjMOhªQU��h�f3C$d;C$k!feC$k!h$S9Ybk-QL@!C���kedeN3Qi� � keC�h�YON!��fÉQU@eC$WUC ¬ YbWLC�M[WUzONeCDQU@!MrQ QL@eC�QLC�B�d;YOWjM[�feC$d;C$k!f3C�k!h�S Y ¬ � P ��RYbk���kedeNeQAQ4# � &���KXk!Y[Q÷ZTN!KaQL��×!C�f®�/t�h�h�YbWUf3��kezb��Sb¨[YOkeC#BD��zO@yQ�����KL@DQLYgWUC$d!��Mbh�C�QL@eC����h$MO��h$Ne��N!K���kedeN3Q#deWUC�×eP Q4# ��&K�,M ���§QU@�M�Ãb¤� ��[ÁO¤jÃ'�£�[�;�3����©L¤ ��J Q4# ��&��,M ��@!YbKLC � � � WUNe��C�K*��k!h$��N�f3COº

��� ��� � Q># � &�� M � � ��;4=�M-@� C D�F ��� ���

M �;4=�M PQ4# � &>�,M �;4=�Q4# ��&�� M P ����k #

O &� GI � �

M � �!� �;6=�M PQ># � &�� M �;4= � � # M P @� CED4F & � GI �

M � � ��;6=�M P

Q4# � &>�,M �;4=�M P @� CED4F � �� �³�x �b·

HcNe��C ��� �� � ��KgMOk!M[��YOzbYON!K�QLY�QL@eCDWUNe��C ¬ YOWGQU@eC YbWUfe��k!MOWLS¯��kedeN3Qi ��� �� M[����Yr�cK�QL@!CDh$YOkyQL��kpN!MrQU��YbkY ¬ QU@eC�f3C���M¦SbC�fs��k!deN3Q�QUY^��kyQLC�WUMbhªQg����QL@ÉQL@!C.C$kp¥p��WUYOk!B�C�kyQ���H�N!��CiK � G�I � � M[k�f � GI � M[����Yr� QL@eCh$YOkyQL��kpN!MrQU��Ybk9QLY¾��kyQLC$WjMOh�Q����§QU@ÉQL@eC�deWLC$×ePÉ�§QjKaC�� ¬ �^?#@eC�feC$��M¦SOC�f9deWUC�×!P9��K�MrQLQLWjMOh�QL��¥OC'�;C�h$MON!KLC.�§QMO����Yr�cK�BDYOWUCGd�M[WjM[����C�����KaB°��k¯deWUY3h�C�KUKLC�K����RYr�*C�¥OC�W�¨bQL@eC KaCi¹bN!C$kyQL��M[����KUMrQU��Ybk ¬ YbWUh$C�f��yS�QL@eCgYbWUfe��k!MOWLSd!WLC$×eP ��K¯N!KLC ¬ N!�G�;Y[QU@ ¬ YbW�C$P3deWLCiKLKL��kez¼B'M[kpS ��kyQLC$WUC�KaQL��kez ��C�@!M¦¥p��YbNeWUK�¨RMOk!f ¬ YbW�@�M¦¥y��kez Ka��BDde��CMO��zbC$�eWjM[��h���M¦�cK¸��kÉM[P3��YbBDM[QL��KLM[QL��YOk!K���\^YOWUC$Yr¥OC�W�¨���k-KaYbB�C'h�MOKLC�K¸M^f3C$��M¦SOCif¾deWUC�×!Psh$MOks�;C.h�Y3f3CifN!d®¨�MOK ��C�M[WUC.zbYO��kez^QLYÉKL@eYr�g�9Û!YOW QL@e��K�¨X�*C�BDMO�OC�N!KaC�Y ¬ QU@eC�����ke�-deWUY3h�C�KUKLC�K�¨��kyQLWUY3f3N!h�Cif-��k

�´ó�â����

Page 88: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

���!��¤�©��;©L¤$�«�£�p¿R�j�3�������6�r�!�g�r�#���a�j�[ ����3 §�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª� wbx

ÚG��EO� x3�±sC¸KL@eYr� @eYr� QLY�h�Y3f3CGM�f3C���M¦SbC�f'deWUC�×!P Q4# � &�� M Y ¬ QU@eCGMbKaSpk!hj@!WLYbkeYON!K�����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�¨yN!k!f3C$WQU@eC�MbKLKLNeBDd3QU��YbkÉQL@!M[Q�M YOke��S9d�YyKLKLC�KUKaCiK¸QL@!C�YONeQLdeN3QDh$MOd!M[�e�����§QTS9YOk����È?#@e��K h$YOk!f3��QL��YOk-YbkÉQL@eCN�KLMOzOC'Y ¬ k!MOBDC�KgWUC�h$C$��¥OC�f9��k M[kÉ��kedeN3Q���KgY ¬ QLC�k-N!KaCif ³ ¬ YbW���k!KTQjM[k!h$CO¨��k-BDYyKTQ�Y ¬ [email protected]�k!h�Y3f3��kezbKY ¬ @e��zb@eC$WL��YOWjf3C$W.h$YOBDB�Nek!��h�MrQL��YOk�K'M[k!f Y ¬G¬ N!k!hªQU��Ybk!K.��k QL@e��K�d!M[d;C$Wª·ª� Ý*YOk!KL��f3C$W'QU@eC ¬ Yb����Yr����kezCi¹yN!M[���§QTS�º

Q4# ��&�� M � � �N# Q4# �4&K�2# � � � �>&AN�M-& ³�xboO·

�Rk!f3C�W�QU@eC�@ySpd;Y[QU@eC�KL��K�QU@!MrQ+M���KGMbKaSpk!hj@!WLYbkeYON!KRM[k!fÈd�YyKLKLC�KUKaCiKRYbke��S�QU@eCDYON3QUdeN3Qgh$MOd!M[�e�����§QTSYbk,��¨�QL@eC�QT��Y�deWUY3h�C�KUKLC�KRMOWLC��;C$@!M¦¥p��YONeWjM[����S���k!f3��KTQU��kezbNe��Ka@!MO�e��C \ � vOw ��� � C$BDB'M�ÚG��E�m���K¸M[�;YONeQQU@e��K�h$��MO��B¯¨!N!k!f3C$WRQL@eC�MOfefe�§QU��Ybk!M[��@ySpd;Y[QU@eC�KL��K�QL@!M[Q MÖh$MOkekeY[Q�C�P3d�YbWaQG�(��± ��QL@^QU@e��K�@pSpd�YOQL@eCiKa��K$¨WUNe��C�Kg³�x �b·�h$YOBDde��C�QLC���S�f3C�×�keCGQL@eCg�;C$@!M¦¥p��YONeW#Y ¬ QU@eC�f3C$��M¦SOCif.��kedeN3QRh$YOk!KaQLWUN!h�Q�Â3����QL@eYbN3Qc�§Qi¨eY[QU@eC$WWUNe��C�K�MOWLC¸keC�C�f3Cif�MOk!f�QL@eCgdeWUYpY ¬ Y ¬ QU@eC�h�YbWLWUC�h�QLkeCiKLK�Y ¬ ³«xyo[·���K#BDYOWUC¸h$YOBDde��C�P÷�

� Æ3Õ-ÕÉ� � ��� ��¤$��M ¶U¤����;©L�i�U¤��j�#�a��� �p¤c�r�jÁr�����y©L�r���r�p�(���a�j�[ ����3 §�p�UÊ(�[�;ÃR�ª�¦�O�e�¦�$¤#� �p�r� �¾�ª�O�e¤U�[©j��j©U¤U¤��£� M �r�! §Á¾�£� �[�3�§�;�3�c�ª��¶ �$¤j�$���e�¦�ª�£���6�r��Ì �G�j�ª�3µD¤.���3�r�G���3¤^¶L¤ �p�[¢��6�[�3©��T�.���3¤�Ãb¤� ��rÁO¤jÃs�£�[���3��j�[�e�ª�«©ª�!�$������Ãb¤ ���;¤jÃ�¶�Á'©ª�3 �¤�� � ! � �OÌ�� �3¤��

Q4# ��&�� M � � �N# Q4# �4&K�2# � � � �>&AN�M-&Í��3¤�©U¤��9�����j©L¤�� �g���r©DM �[�;à �Ìt Ka��BD����M[W�C$k�h�Y3f3��kez�h$MOk.�;C�zb��¥bC$k'Y ¬ M f3C$��M¦SOCifDdeWUC�×eP Q4# ��&��,M N!k!f3C$W*QL@!CR@pSpd�YOQL@eCiKa��K�QU@!MrQ M

Ybke��S.d�YyKLKLC�KUKLC�K*QL@eCg��kedeNeQ�h$MOd!M[�e�����§QTS'Ybk ��ºX�*C�ZTN!KaQc��ky¥bC$WLQ#QL@eC�f3��WUC�hªQU��Ybk�Y ¬ QU@eCg����ke��º� �!# Q4# �>&�0# � � � ��& N M-& ³�x[wy·

�RYr�*C�¥OC�W�¨/QU@eC^h�YOWUWUC�hªQUkeC�KUK�Y ¬ QU@e��K QUWUMOk!K ¬ YbWLB'M[QL��YOk ��KDBDYOWUC�f3C�����h$M[QLCO¨�M[k!f¼WLCi¹yNe��WUC�K�MOf!f3�§QU��Ybk!M[�@pSpd;Y[QL@!C�KLC�K�YOk²QL@eCÉh�YbkbQUC�PpQUK���k²��@e��hj@ QU@eCÉdeWUYph$C�KUKaCiK�h�M[k �;CÉN!KLC�f÷�°?#@!C9h$YOkyQLC$PyQ¯B�N�KTQ¯��Ch$YOBDd;YbKLC�f�Y ¬ d!WLY3h�CiKLKLC�K*QU@!MrQRMOWLC¸MOKLSpk!hj@eWUYOkeYbN!K$¨pM[k�f.QU@eC�h�YbkbQUC�PpQ�Ka@eYbNe��f��bC$C�d�YOk!��S'QU@eCgYONeQLdeN3Qh�M[d!MO�e������QTS'YOk�QL@eC¸k!MOB�CiK*QL@!M[Q�MOWLC¸KLC$kyQ#M[QDQ��X?#@eCiKaC¸h�Ybk!f3��QL��YOk!K�h�M[k���C¸ke��h�C���S ¬ YbWLB'M[����KaCif.N!KL��k!zM.��C�@!M¦¥p��YbNeWUMO�®C�¹yNe��¥rM[��C$k!h$C ¬ YOW�MOKLSyk�hj@eWLYbkeYON�K�h$M[��h�N!���M[k!f�QTSpd;C KLSpKaQLC�B'K$��±9C�YOBD��QRQU@eC f3C$QUMO����K$�Ú�YOQL@¾��k ³�xbo[·cM[k!f^��k ³�x[wy·ª¨�QL@eC�WLC�de����h�MrQL��YOk^��k ¬ WUYOkyQRY ¬ QL@eC�����ke�^h�M[k¾�;C C�����BD��k�MrQLCif^� ¬ �È��KRN�KaCif����keC�MOWL��S.��k MD�

� +������ �� �����®� � ��������� �!�*��"$����"$���� QUM[WLQL��kez ¬ WLYbB QL@eC#�!MbKa��h�h$YOk!KaQLWUN!hªQjK ¬ YbWXh�YOk�h�NeWUWLC�k!h�SGY ¬ QL@eC�����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K��C�BDYr¥OC�QLYG@e��zb@eC$WL��YOWjf3C$Wi¨�pS�MO����Yr����k!zR¥rM[��NeC�K�eN!����QXYON3Q/Y ¬ d!WLY3h�CiKLKLC�K��(±9C#h$M[���yQL@e��K/@e��zO@eC�Wa��YOWjf3C�W(h$MO��h$Ne��N�K(QU@eC �g�§¿��p¤$© ���#©LÃO¤$©���a�j�[ ����3 §�p�'³ � � �(·��V/MbKLKL��k!z�M.d!WLY3h�CiKLK���K������OC�d!MOKUKa��kez�M�d!MOWUMOBDC�QLWUC$��C�KUKcd!WLY3h�Cif3NeWUCO�g?#@eC�WLCih���de��C$kyQGY ¬ M�deWLY3h$C�KUK

h�M[k¾f3Y'k!Y[QL@!��kez����§QU@^�§QR�!N3QRC�P3Cih�N3QUC��§Qi¨�d;YbKUKL���e��S�KLC$¥bC$WjM[��QU��BDC�K���VXWUYph$C�f3N!WLCiK#zbM[��k¯zOWUC�M[QcN3QL������QTS� ¬ QL@eC�S9h�M[kÉ�;C'�3�[©L�rµ'¤$�«©ª���$¤jÃÉKaY¯QU@!MrQi¨���@!C$k-��ky¥bYO�bC�f÷¨(KLYOBDC.MOWLzbNeBDC$kyQUK¸B'M¦SÈ�;C.KLNedede����Cif÷��_�kQU@eC¸KLMOB�C���M¦SDM�d!WLY3h�CiKLKa��d!MOKUKa��kezgh$MO��h$Ne��N!K�zyM[��k!K�d;Yr��C$W�� ¬ h$YOBDB�Nek!��h�MrQL��YOk�Y ¬ d!MOWUMOB�C$QLWU��KLC�fDd!WLYO�h$C�KUKaCiK#��KRM[����Yr��C�f÷�±9C�h$M[���®d!MOWUMOBDC�QLWU��KaCif.deWUY3h�C�KUKLC�Kg�b¶ª�ª�«©L�b�����6�r�!�ª��±sCg@�M¦¥OCgM[��WLCiMOf3S'��kyQLWUY3f3N!h�CifMO�!KaQLWjMOhªQU��Ybk!K���k�QU@eC�����h$M[��h�N!��N!K�¨3��@eC�WLC¸��CGd!WLCiKaC�kbQUC�f�QL@eC�B MbK�MDh�YOkp¥bC$ke��C$kyQcKaSpkyQUMbhªQU��hGkeYOQUMrQU��Ybk

â�â54�6!þ87:98;

Page 89: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

w � � Ì(À��[�y¿O�6�r©«¿O�

¬ YbW#WLC�deWLCiKaC�kyQL��kezgQL@!CGC�k!h�Y3f3��kezyK*Y ¬ �e�«QUC$WUBDK���?#@eCGWLYb��CGY ¬ M[�!KaQLWjMOh�QL��YOk!K*��K���BDd�YbWaQjM[kyQ���k � � �X¨eMOKQU@eC$S�h$MOk��;CgN!KLC�f�MOK#¥rM[��NeC�K�MOk!f�C�Pehj@!MOkezOCif.��k¯h$YOBDB�N!ke��h�MrQU��Ybk!K$�± @eC�k-M[kÉM[�!KaQLWjMOh�QL��YOk�# � &� M­��KgMOdede����Cif¾QUY¯MOk9MOWLzbNeBDC$kyQ � ��QgSp��C���feKGQU@eC'deWUY3h�C�KUK M-@ � CED>Fb�

tRdede����h�MrQU��Ybk���KQL@!Ccf3C�KaQLWUN!hªQUYOW ¬ YbW�M[�!KaQLWjMOh�QL��YOk!K���?#@eCcMOdede����h�MrQU��Ybk Y ¬ M[k'MO�!KTQUWUMbhªQU��Ybk �gQUY�M�¥rMO��NeC� P;��K*��WU�§QLQLC$k���P � P Rj�Xt�Q�QL@eCG��C$¥OC��!Y ¬ QTSyd;C�K�¨3MOfefe��kez d!M[WjM[BDC$QLWU��KUMrQU��Ybk�BDCiM[k!K*MOfef3��kez�M[WUWLYr� QTSpd�CiK$¨KLY�QL@!M[QgMOksMO�!KTQUWUMbhªQU��Ybk # ��&K� M°@!MOK�QTSpd;C � = �X¨®��@eC$WUC �°��K¸M�¥rMO��NeC�QTSpd;C�MOk!f � ��KGQL@eC�QTSpd�C�;C$@�M¦¥y��YON!W�¨yQL@�MrQc��K�QL@eC¸QTSpd;CgY ¬ M[���÷deWLY3h$C�KUKaCiK$�t&d!WLY3h�CiKLK�¨3�;C ¬ YOWUC¸��C���k!z.h�YOBDB Neke��h$MrQUC�f÷¨!B�N!KaQc��C�h$YOkp¥OC�WaQUC�f���kyQUY.M ¥rMO��NeCb¨!M���©U���j¤��U�g¢r�r ¡�!¤$�

t d!WLY3h�CiKLKD¥rMO��NeC^��KDQU@eCÈKLd�Cih���M[�ch$MbKaC^Y ¬ MO�!KaQLWjMOhªQU��Ybk¼��k ��@e��hj@ QU@eC¾M[WUzON!B�C�kyQD@�MOK'Nek!�§Q.QTSpd;CO�?#@!C$WUC ¬ YOWUC�deWLY3h$C�KUK�¥rMO��NeCiKgM[WUC C$P3deWLCiKLKL��YOk!K # ��&K� M­Y ¬ QTSpd�C � � � = �/�D±9CD��WL��QLC � � � ¬ YbW¸QL@eCN!ke�§Q�QTSpd;CO¨!MOk!f � ¬ YbW#QL@eCgN!ke�§Q�¥¦MO��N!CO�

0�� �!Õ-� Ò Æ � � � � ¤�©L¤D�[©L¤'� ��©L�i�j¤ª�j� S ���3�r������ÍX�£ £ §�£�y¿^���.��¤$�;ï� �;©L���j¤��j� M �r ��r�y¿È��� �p�[�!��¤�  Q�[�;Ã�� �p¤$�-�j�[�!���£�!�!¤�� �¦� S P6Êc�r�;ï����©U���j¤��U��� ���3�r������ÍX�£ £ §�£�y¿¯����©L¤j�U¤$�£¢r¤'�r�;Ã^¤Jp¤j���3��¤ Í��p�r� S ����$¤$�;Ã[�£�y¿��r� Q �

S ������ Q P # � &� M R�� S P� ������ Q4# �4&�5� P � R� �3¤ª�$¤R��©L�i�j¤ª�j�$¤����j�[�¾�£�!��¤�©U�O�$�#�r�X���[ £ ��rÍ/� �

SON8�;6= S P�N #K# ��&K� M-& P � R;6= S P�N M-@�� CED>F� NeBDBDMOWL��KL��kez�¨b����QL@�WLCiKad;C�h�Q�QLY�QL@eC�zOWjM[BDB'M[W*Y ¬ QL@!CR����h$M[��h�N!��N!K�¨bQL@!M[Q�Y ¬ � � �^@!MbK�QU@eC ¬ Yb����Yr����k!zMbfef3��QL��YOk!MO�®deWUY3f3N!hªQU��Ybk!K�ºXQL@eC�zOWjM[BDB'M[W ¬ YOWc¥rMO��NeCiK�@!MbK#QL@eC�deWLY3f3N�hªQL��YOk/# � &K�,M ¬ YOWRMO�!KaQLWjMOhªQU��Ybk!K�ÂQU@eC�zOWjM[BDB'M[W ¬ YbW/deWLY3h$C�KUKaCiK÷QL@!C�d!WLY3f3N!h�QL��YOk � P � R ¬ YOWXM[ded!����h$M[QL��YOk®Â¦QU@!MrQ ¬ YOWQTSpd�CiK�QL@eC�deWUYpfeN!hªQU��Ybk��=�� ¬ YbW#MOWLWUYr� QTSyd;C�K�¨3��@eC�WLC � WUC$d!WLCiKaC�kbQjK�M ¥rM[��NeCRQTSpd;CO��?#@eCGYOd;C$WjMrQU��Ybk!M[�;KaC�B'M[kyQL��h$K�@!MbK*MOkMbfef3��QL��YOk!MO�÷WLN!��C ¬ YOW���@!C$k^M[k¯M[�!KaQLWjMOh�QL��YOk�B�C�C�QjKcM[k¯M[ded!����h$M[QL��YOk®º

����� �� #5# � &K�,M-&,P ��R �;4=�M-@ � C D>F_�k�QL@e��K/d!MOd�C�W�¨r��C�N!KLC#C�PpQLC�k!KL��Ybk!K(Y ¬ QL@!��KXh�M[��h�Ne��N!K����§QU@ Nek!�§Q/QTSpd�CiK$¨rWUC�h$NeWjKa��¥OC�QTSyd;C�K�¨[M[k�f�deWUY3f3N!hªQQTSpd;C�K��_�k � � �X¨*keYÉC�P3deWUC�KUKa��YOk ©L¤jÃr�!�j¤���QLY-M9¥rM[��NeCO¨�QL@eC�WLC ¬ YOWUC���C¯keC$Cif¼k!Y[Q.Kad;C�h$� ¬ S MÈWUC�feN!hªQU��Ybk

KaQLWjMrQUC$zbS ¬ YOW�¥¦MO��N!CcC�P3deWUC�KUKa��YOk�K$�?#@eCcWU��zb@bQL��@�M[k!fDKL��f3CRY ¬ M[k.MOWLWUYr� QTSpd;Cc��K�M[���#M¦SpKQU@eCc�;C$@!M¦¥p��YONeWQTSpd;C �XÂ*M[����Yr����kez^k!C�KaQL��kezÈY ¬ M[WUWLYr� QTSpd�CiK�YbkÉQL@eC�WL��zO@yQi¨�����OC.��k � � = � � =��&³6��@e��hj@ �*YbNe��fBDCiM[k M[����Yr����kez-k!C�KaQL��kez Y ¬ MO�!KTQUWUMbhªQU��Ybk!K.KLN!hj@ MOK�# � &�0# �4&� M�·ª¨��*YbNe��f ��CiMOf N!K.QLYr�#M[WjfeK'��KLKLNeC�KY ¬ WLCif3N!h�QL��YOkÈKaQLWjMrQUC$zO��C�K�� � � �¼f3YpC�K�keYOQ�@!M¦¥bC�WUC�f3N!h�QL��YOk^QUY�¥rM[��NeCiKR�;C�h�M[N!KLC���QG��KGh�YOk�h�C$��¥OCif ¬ YOWKaQLN�f3Sp��kezgMOk!f�N!k!f3C$WjKaQUM[k�f3��k!z��!MbKa��h*��KUKaN!C�K/Y ¬ deWUYph$C�KUKaCiK®QU@!MrQ�B'M¦SgC$P3hj@�M[kezbC*@e��zO@!C$WL��YbWUf3C�W(¥rM[��NeCiK$ÂWUC�feN!hªQU��YbksKaQLWjMrQLC�zO��C�K ¬ YOW¸¥rM[��NeC�C�P3deWUC�KUKa��YOk!K���KGMOkÈYbWaQU@eYOzbYOk!MO�(��KLKLNeC^³£QU@!MrQ�h$MOkÈ�;C'KTQUN!f3��C�f¾����QL@QU@eC��e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!Kj·ª�Ú#M[WU�;C�f�h�YOk!zOWUNeC$k!h$C���Kcf3C$×!keCif�Ybk � � �9MbK#�pS�ÇRC$×!ke��QL��YOk^ÚG��EbEO�_ ¬ M­��K�M � � � d!WLY3h�CiKLK�¨�MOk!fsQL@eC'd!WLYpY ¬ Y ¬ QL@!C�f3C$WU��¥¦M[QL��YOk9Y ¬ M �;>=�M PXN!KLC�KgWUNe��C%��� ����� ¨

QU@eC$k��*C���WL��QLC M ;>=�W M P6¨3M[k�f�KUM¦S�QU@!MrQ3MQ9 ��©L¤jÃr�!�j¤��cQLY�M P6Â���W.��K�QL@eCGC�¹yNe��¥rM[��C$k!h$Cc��k�f3N!h�Cif.�pS;6=/W÷�

�´ó�â����

Page 90: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

���!��¤�©��;©L¤$�«�£�p¿R�j�3�������6�r�!�g�r�#���a�j�[ ����3 §�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª� wyo

� � ���¯ $"� $��� �����c���°����(� $��� ������,����� ����(� $���

?#@!CGd!WLY3h�CiKLKa��d!MOKUKa��kez ¬ CiMrQLN!WLCiK*Y ¬ � � �sh$M[k���C ¬ MO�§QU@ ¬ Ne����S�h$Y3f3C�f�Ned�N!KL��kez k�M[BDC���d!MOKUKL��kez���_�k�QL@eCC�k!h�Y3f3��kez�¨÷[email protected]$YOBDB�N!ke��h�MrQU��YbksY ¬ M[kÉM[��KTQUWUMbhªQL��YOk �¾��KGQLWjM[k!KL��M[[email protected]�YbBDB�Neke��h$M[QL��YOksY ¬ Md!WL��¥rMrQLC k!M[BDC���@!��hj@ÈMbhªQjKRMOK�M'd;YO��kbQUC$WRQLYs³´QL@eC�QLWjM[k!KL��MrQL��YOk^Y ¬ · �¯M[k�f^��@e��hj@¯QL@eC�WLCih���de��C$kyQ�h$MOkN�KaCgQUY'QLWU��zOzOC�WRM'h�YbdpS�Y ¬ ³´QL@eC�QLWjM[k!KL��MrQL��YOk¯Y ¬ · �;¨�����QL@ÈMOdedeWUYOdeWU��MrQLCgMOWLzbNeBDC$kyQUK���Û!YOW���k!KaQUMOk!h�C Md!WLY3h�CiKLK Q P # ��&K�;�+R�� ��KcQUWUMOk!KL��M[QLC�f¾��kyQLY�QL@eC�deWUY3h�C�KUK � ��# Q P ��R N � �6# ��&K� " ) ) � * *.&LÂ�M.WUC�h���de��C$kyQ�Y ¬ QL@eCd;YO��kyQLC�W8� h$M[k N!KLC*��Q/QLYgMOh�QL��¥¦M[QLC#MOKB'M[kpS�h�Ybde��C�K�Y ¬ " ) ) � * *eMOKkeC�C�f3Cif÷���cYr��C$¥OC�W�¨¦��@eC�k�QUWUMOk!KL��M[QL��kezQ P ��R�� MD¨(� ¬ �È��KgM�k!M[BDCDYOWGQU@eCDNeke��Q�¥¦MO��N!CO¨÷QU@eC$k �¾��KgM[��KaY�M�����h$MO��h$Ne��N!KG¥¦MO��N!CDMOk!fÈQL@eC�WLC ¬ YOWUC �h�M[k���C�fe��WUC�h�QL��S�KLC$kyQcM[��YOkez Q;Âe��k�QU@e��KRh$MOKLCG�*C�KUM¦SDQL@!M[Q �.��K#���«QUWUMOk!KaBD��QaQjM[�e��CO�_�k¾QL@eC QLWjM[k!KL��MrQL��YOk^Y ¬ M[kÈMOdede����h�MrQU��Ybk ��P � Rj¨�QU@eC ¬ Nek!hªQU��Ybk �¯��KR��Y3h$MrQUC�f¾M[QGKLYOBDC ¬ WUC�KL@¾k!MOBDC��Â�QL@eC ¬ Nek!h�QL��YOk¼��K�MOhªQU��¥rM[QLC�f¼�pS9WUC�h$C$��¥p��kezÈ�§QjK�MOWLzbNeBDC$kyQ M[Q ���9tRzbMO��k®¨X� ¬ QU@eC�MOWLzbNeBDC$kyQ � ��K

����QLWjM[k�KaBD��QaQUMO�e��CO¨yQL@eC�k&�D��K#M[dede����C�f.f3��WUC�hªQU��SDQUY ����?#@eCRQUWUMOk!KL��M[QL��YOk.Y ¬ M[dede����h$MrQU��Ybk���K�¥OC$WUSDh���YbKLCQUYDQL@!M[QcY ¬ YON3QUdeN3Q�¨!��@e��hj@¯WUC$¥bC�M[��K�QL@eC�KL��BD����MOWL��QTS.�;C�QT��C$C�k�QU@eC¸QT�*Y'h$YOk!KaQLWUN!hªQjK$�?#@!CDh$YOBDde����M[QL��YOk9BDYpfe�§×!CiKGQTSpd�CiK$ºgM�k!M[BDCDN!KLC�f9��k � � �¼QLY¯C�Pehj@!MOkezOC�deWUY3h�C�KUKLC�KG��Cih�YbB�CiK$¨

��k^����h$M[��h�N!��N!K�¨�MDk�M[BDCgN!KLC�f ¬ YOWRC�Pehj@!M[k!zO��kezDY[QL@!C$Wck!MOBDC�K�� � C�Q � � � � � � � � � ��� QU@eC � � �Éh�M[��h�N3���N!KG��k¾��@e��hj@^QL@eC QTSpd�C�h�Ybk!KTQUWLN�hªQUK ¬ YOW�¥rM[��NeC�KGM[WUC MOWLWUYr�²QTSpd;C�K�¨�WUC�h$NeWjKa��¥OCgQTSpd;C�K�¨�Neke��Q�QTSpd;C�K�³´��k� � � � � � � � � ��� QU@eC$WUC ��K¸M[��KaY�QL@eCDhj@!MOkekeC$�QTSpd;C � ��¨�keC�C�f3Cif ¬ YbW�QTSpde��kez¯hj@!M[k!keC$��K$Â÷�!N3Q¸hj@�M[kekeC���KB'M¦SskeY[Q��;C.d!MbKLKLC�f9M[WUYONek�fsMbKg¥rM[��NeC�Kj·ªÂXM[k�fs��C�Q � � � � � � � � � ��� ��C'QU@eC.����h$MO��h$Ne��N�K¸���§QU@ ����QTSpd�CiK$¨WUC�h$NeWjKa��¥OCGQTSpd�CiK$¨�Neke��QRQTSpd;C�K��#?#@!C�h�YOBDde����MrQL��YOk ¬ WUYOB � � � � � � � � � ��� QUY'� � � � � � � � � ��� ��KRf3C$×!keC�f¯YbkQTSpd;C�K�¨rQTSpd�C#C�ky¥p��WLYbkeBDC$kyQUK�¨¦¥rM[��NeC�K/M[k�f�deWUY3h�CiKLKLC�K(��kD?�MO�e��C�E��e�(±9C#YOke��S¸QLWjM[k�Ka��MrQUC*��C$���§��QTSpd�Cif�C$Py�d!WLCiKLKL��Ybk!K��?#@eCRQLWjM[k!KL��MrQL��YOk'Y ¬ M[k'C$Ppd!WLCiKLKL��Ybk'��K�M[k!keY[QjMrQLCifD���§[email protected]@eCcQTSpde��kez�C�kp¥y��WUYOkeBDC$kyQ�N!k!f3C$W��@!��hj@DQU@!MrQ�C�P3deWUC�KUKa��YOk���K��*C�������QTSyd;C�f®�/Û!YOW���k!KaQUMOk!h�Cb¨�" ) ) M * *�����K*f3C�×!k!C�f'� ¬ � � � � � � � � � ��� ��� ! M-�?#@!��K�MOkekeY[QjMrQU��Ybk���K*N�KaCif ¬ YbW#MbKLKL��zOke��kez�QU@eCgM[ded!WLYbdeWL��MrQUCcQTSpd;C�K�QLY QL@!CGk�M[BDC�K���kbQUWLY3f3N�h�C�f��pSDQL@eCh$YOBDde����M[QL��YOk®� �cY[QUC�QU@!MrQi¨��pS�QL@eC keY[QjMrQU��Ybk!K ¬ YbW�M[��KTQUWUMbhªQL��YOk(¨�M[k^C$P3deWLCiKLKL��YOk " ) ) # � &K�,M * *���� �

��KRQL@eCWUC�KLNe��QXY ¬ M[dede��Sp��k!z�QU@eC�M[�!KaQLWjMOh�QL��YOk " ) ) # ��&K� M * * ��� � QLY¸k!MOBDCX�;¨[QL@!M[Q���KQU@eC�deWUYph$C�KUK " ) ) M * * ��� � � � @ CED>Fb�& � Å � Å }� £~� Å Ð � � � ��r©��[ £  M:Y �>Y�� Y �°�[�;Ã;L��j©L¤�� �G���r© ��Ê�Í�¤ �p�r¢r¤ �

� Ì�� �/� � � � � � � ��� ��� ! M � � � � � � � � � � � ��� � " ) ) � * * !" ) ) M * *��� Ì�� �/� � � � � � � ��� ��� !�� � � =��Ø� � � � � � � � � � � ��� � " ) ) �$* *%Y L � " ) ) � * * !" ) ) � * *��� Ì

� Æ3Õ-ÕÉ� � � � �!Ó�Æ�� ���e�[à Å � " � À;�¦�O�e�¦�$¤ � �/� � � � � � � ��� ��� ! M&Ì � �p¤$� M ��� � " ) ) M * *�� �

�Ê

���[© �r £ �Q÷Ì

]�k!h�Y3f3��kez " MOzOWUC$C�K����§QU@ QL@!C��;C$@!M¦¥p��YONeWjM[��Ci¹yNe��¥rMO��C�k!h�CiK�Y ¬ � � � M[k�f-����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K��sÛ!YOW���k3�KaQUMOk!h�Cb¨X�§QD��K ¬ Ne����SÉMO�!KaQLWjMOhªQ ¬ YOW �!M[WU��Cif h�YbkezOWUNeC�k!h�C � MOk!v � ¨ � MOk!vyor� ��� �cYr��C$¥bC$Wi¨KaQUM[QL��kezsMOk!fd!WLYr¥p��kez ¬ Ne���/M[��KTQUWUMbhªQL��YOk�WUC�¹yNe��WLCiK#B�YbWLC¸QU@!M[k � �'QTSyd;C�K ³ ¬ YbWc��k�KTQjM[k!h$CgWLCih�C$deQL��¥OC$k!C�KUK�QTSyd;C�Kj·ªÂ;��CQU@eC$WUC ¬ YbWLC¸Ybke��S�deWLCiKaC�kyQ�KLYOBDCgKL��BDde��C$W�WUC�KLNe��QUK�¨pQL@!M[QRM[WUC¸KLN��.h���C$kyQ ¬ YOW�YbNeW�keC�C�feK#��k�QL@eCgd!MOd�C�W�º

� Æ3Õ-ÕÉ� � � � À��¦�b�3�r�$¤ � �/� � � � � ��� ��� ! M:Y S¼Ì �´� M � W S�Ê�� �p¤$� � � � � � � � � � ��� # " ) ) �$* * & ��" ) ) M * *�� �! " ) ) S * *��®Ì� Æ3Õ-ÕÉ� � � � À��¦�b�3�r�$¤ � �/� � � � � ��� � � ! M:Y S&Ì �´�R� � � � � � � � � ��� # " ) ) �$* *.& � " ) ) M * *�� �! " ) ) S * *��;Ê����3¤��� �/� � � � � ��� #��M& �3M �! S.Ì

â�â54�6!þ87:98;

Page 91: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

wbw � Ì(À��[�y¿O�6�r©«¿O�

���¾� �b���g���y¶ª �¤�Í�¤D�b¶i¶�©L¤�¢i�6�r��¤D�r £ /¤KJ$��©U¤ª�j�ª�6�r�!� " ) ) �+* *��r� ) ) �+* * �

�e©L�[�e�ª ��r���6�r�É�T�g��Áj�e¤ª� �) ) � � * * $&%('� � ) ) � * * ) ) � =�� * * $&%('� � ) ) � * *

) ) � � � * * $&%('� � � � ) )O� ��� * * $&%('�

O� � ) ) � * *

�e©L�[�e�ª ��r���6�r�É�T�g��Áj�e¤ ¤$�!¢i�£©L�r��µD¤$�!�«� �) ) � * * $&%('� �

) ) � Y5�Q��� * * $&%('� ) ) � * *%Y5� � ) ) � * *�e©L�[�e�ª ��r���6�r�É�T� �y�§¿ �3¤�© �a�[©LÃO¤$©�¢r�r ¡�!¤�� �

) ) # � &� M * *��� � $&%('� # � &� ) ) M * *���� � � �) ) � * *���� � $&%('� # � &� ��P � R

�e©L�[�e�ª ��r���6�r�É�T�#�;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª� �³6�*C�KUM¦S.QU@!MrQGMD¥¦MO��N!C ����Kc����QLWjM[k!KLBD�§QLQUM[�!��Cg� ¬ ����KRMDk!MOB�CgYbW � !&� � � � � Â;MOk!f��*C�MbKLKLNeBDC ���K�M ¬ WLCiKa@¯k!MOBDCi·

) ) �CP � R�� M * *�� $&%('����� ���� P � R�� ) ) M * * � � ¬ �&��K#���«QUWUMOk!KaBD��QaQjM[�e��C# � �N� � ) ) � * *.& # � P � R�� ) ) M * *�� N � � ) ) � * *���� �M&

� ¬ �&��K#keY[QRM�k!MOB�Cb¨eM[k!f � !��<��� =��

) ) ��P � R * *�� $&%('����� ���) ) � * *��� � ¬ �&��K#���«QUWUMOk!KaBD��QaQjM[�e��C# � �I� � ) ) � * * & # ) ) � * *���� � �

N � � ) ) � * *��� � &� ¬ �&��K#keY[QRM�k!MOB�Cb¨eM[k!f � !��<��� =��

) ) ��# ��&K� M * *�� $&%('� � ) ) # � &K�,M * *���� � � ¬ � ! � � � �) ) �$� M * *�� $&%('� �$� ) ) M * *�� ) ) * *�� $&%('�

) ) M N�S+* *�� $&%('� ) ) M * *�� N ) ) S * *�� ) ) M � S+* *�� $&%('� ) ) M * *�� � ) ) S * *��) ) # � �H� � &�M * *�� $&%('� # � �H� ) ) � * *.& ) ) M * *���� � � � ) ) � M * *�� $&%('� � ) ) M * *��

?M[�e��C'E��!ºX?#@eCgh�YOBDde����MrQL��YOk&"ÈY ¬ � � � � � � � � � ��� ��kyQLY�QL@eCg����h$MO��h$Ne��N!K

�´ó�â����

Page 92: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

���!��¤�©��;©L¤$�«�£�p¿R�j�3�������6�r�!�g�r�#���a�j�[ ����3 §�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª� wOv

� � 2 � � 0 � ~iÆ3Ð(}� Å Ð(}?#@!C�h$YOBDde����M[QL��YOk MOk!fgQU@eC#M[�;Yr¥OC�WUC�KLNe��QUK/h$MOk��;C*C$PpQLC$k�f3C�f�QLY¸h$M[��h�N!���p����QL@�WL��hj@eC$W�QTSpd�C#KaQLWUN!hªQUNeWLCiK$¨¬ YbWR��k!KaQUM[k�h�Cg����QL@^deWUY3f3N!hªQjKRMOk!f¯����keCiM[WU�§QTSb��_ ¬ ��Cg@!M¦¥OCg����k!C�M[WcQTSyd;C�K�¨�KLYDQL@�MrQR��C��pkeYr� QL@!M[QcQL@eCMOWLzbNeBDC$kyQ ��Y ¬ C�P3deWUC�KUKL��Ybk!K �CP � R��,M MOk!f � P � Rg��KgN�KaCif9M[Q�BDYbKaQ�YOk!h$CO¨�QL@eC�k-��k9QL@!C�h���M[N!KLC�K¸Y ¬?M[�!��CDE���keYDWUC$de����h$MrQU��Ybk!K#��K#keC$Cif3C�f��;C ¬ YOWUC � " ) ) � * * ��� � �

� � �r����c�������

tc�!WUwpo�� � ��tc�eWjM[B'KL�ySb� ���rµ'�r�£� � �3¤U�[©ªÁ �r��Ã-� �p¤ �(�U¿O�6�s�a� �R¶j�$¤$©ª¢¦�y¶ª �¤¯½�©L�ª�3¤$©ª���6¤ª�ª� VX@!ÇQL@!C�KL��K�¨��ck!��¥bC$WjKa��QTS.Y ¬ � Ybk!f3YOk(¨÷E�vOwpop�

tc�!WUwbv � � ��tc�eWjM[B'KL�pSO�#?#@eC���M��$S���MOB���feM.h�M[��h�Ne��N!K��*_�kÈÇ ��?�NeWUkeC$Wi¨!Cif3��QLYOWi¨ ��¤ª�$¤j�r©U��� �!�ª���6����£� ®�3�;�$���6�r�;�[ ;½�©L�U¿O©L�rµ�µ �£�p¿[¨!d!M[zbC�K �bx��;EbE��e�yt�fef3��KaYbk3��±sCiKa��C$Sb¨÷E�vOwbve�

tRÚ�ÜGv[n � � �#t�h�C$QLY�¨#ÚG��Ú*��YpYOB¯¨cM[k�f Û*�*Ü�MOMOk!f3WjM[zOC�W�� ?(NeWUke��kez � � � WUNe��C�K'��kyQLY Ci¹yN!MrQU��Ybk!K$��ª�i���r©ªµ'�r���6�r�-�r��Ã^»��rµ����3���r���6�r��¨(EOEbEb³aEi·ªº�E��ex � ¨!E�vbv[n��

tRÝ�v � � \É�#tc�!Mbf3�¸M[k!f � �#Ý�MOWUf3C�������� � � �p¤j�[©ªÁ �T� �R¶ �$¤j�$�6�ª� \¯YbkeYOzbWUMOde@!K'��k Ý*YOBDdeNeQLC$W� h$��C�k!h�Cb� � deWU��k!zOC$W�ÜXC�WL��M[z�¨�E�vOv �e�

tRÝ � v � � Hg��tcB'Mbf3��Y�¨c_ª�RÝ�MOKaQLC�����M[ke��¨RMOk!f Ç � � M[kezb��YbWLzb�«� � k²�e��KL��B�Ne��MrQU��Ybk!K ¬ YbW�QU@eCÉMOKLSyke�hj@eWUYOkeYbN!KG����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K��'_�k¼½�©L�i��ÌG» � �'» � � � � �¦¨¥OYb��NeBDC¯EOEbE�v�Y ¬ �(¤j�$�«�3©U¤����[��¤����£�»��rµ����3��¤�©�À��$�6¤����U¤$� � d!WL��kezOC�W#ÜXC$WU��MOz!¨÷E�vbv �!�

tRÛX\ � vbx �����tcWU��Yb��M!¨;\É��ÛeC�����C$��KLC$k®¨÷`e�÷\^MOWUMO��KaQ�¨�\É� � feC$WjKa�pSO¨;M[k!f^V�;±9Mbf3��C$Wi�Rt h�M[���§���pSb��keC�C�f�e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!K��X_�k¾½#©L���iÌ � � ����½ ��½ �X�!tRÝ#\ V�WLCiKLK�¨÷E�vbvbx3�

t � ��v � � � �XtcWUNek3� �¸NeB'M[W�M[k!f \É� �RC$kek!C�KUKaSb�9tRk C �.h���C$k�h�S-deWUC$YbWUf3C�W ¬ YOW�deWUY3h�C�KUKLC�K�� �R�$����ª�i���r©ªµ'�r���6�j�r¨ � veº¡ormpo��eo �Oq!¨!E�vbv � �

t � vOm � � �÷tc�!WUMOBDKL�pS^M[k!f � � � kez!�gÛeN!���XM[��KTQUWUMbhªQL��YOk^��k¾QU@eC���M �$S¯��MOB���feM�h$M[��h�N!��N!K�� �ª�����[© �µ'�r���6�r�-�r�;þ»��rµ����3���r���6�r�!¨(E�qbxeº�E¦x[v�� � �pop¨eEivOvbme�

tcd!d!v � � t���tcded;C$����»��rµ����£ ¡�£�p¿�ÍX�£���9»��r�!���£�!�!�[�«�6�[�e�ª�*Ý�M[B �eWU��f3zbC��Rke��¥OC$WjKL�§QTS�V�WLCiKLK�¨÷E�vbv � �

Ú#M[W�oOo � ���;Ú#M[WUC$k!f3WUC$zOQ���?#@eC¸QTSpd;C ¬ WUC$Cg��M[B���feM'h�M[��h�Ne��N!K���_�k¾`e�!Ú#MOWL����KaCb¨3C�f3��QLYbW�¨ ���r��Ãb¶U�i�¦Ë�T� � �r� �p¤$µ'�r���6�U�[  ���L¿O�6��¨ � QUN!f3��C�KD��k � YOzO��h�vOqe¨�d!M[zbC�K�E�qOv � ��EOE�m � � �RYOWLQL@ �cYO����M[k!f÷¨E�vpoOo3�

Ú#M[Wjw[n � ���eÚ#MOWLC�k!f3WUC$z[Qi��� �p¤ �(�[µ'¶UÃb�¯»��r ��$�3 ¡�p� � �ª�«�RÀ�Ár�����2J.�r��Ã�À�¤$µ'�r�!���6���j¨3¥bYO��NeBDC EiqOmgY ¬À����!Ãr�6¤��g�£� ���L¿O�6�$���cYOWLQL@ �RYO����MOk!f÷¨÷E�vbw[n��H�C�¥p��KLC�f�C�f3��QL��YOk(�

Ú�C$W�orw � Ù��OÚ�C$WUWUSO� � Ji¹bN!C$kyQL��M[���§QUJcf3C#� � J$¥rMO��N!M[QL��YOk ¬ YOWUBDC$����C�f3CiK��3��C�P3deWUC�KUKa��YOk�K$�3_�k'ÚG�[H�YO�!��keC$Q�¨C�fe�§QUYOWi¨X½�©U�L¿O©L�rµ �(©L�[�e�´���r©ªµ'�r���6�r�!�UÊR½�©L�i�iÌ � ©Là �ª����ÌG»��[ £ �ÌR�[�ɽ�©L�U¿O©L�rµ�µ �£�p¿[¨/d!MOzOCiK�yo��pwbqe¨�E�vporwe�

Ú�C$WjweE � Ù��pÚ*C�WLWUSO� � YbBDCRKaSpkyQUMbhªQU��hcMOk!f'h$M[QLC�zOYOWU��h$M[��h�YOk�KTQUWLN!h�QL��YOk!K�Y ¬ ��MOB���feM�h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�B�Y3fp�C$��K��*HcMOded�YbWaQcf3C�HcC�hj@eC�WUhj@eCgwbqe¨e_�k!KaQL��QLNeQLC �RM[QL��YOk!MO�(f3C�H�Cihj@eC$Wjhj@eC¸C$k¯_�k ¬ YbWLB'M[QL��¹bN!CC�QcC�k^tcN3QUYOB'MrQU��¹yNeC.³6_ �RH�_TtG·ª¨®EivOweEb�

â�â54�6!þ87:98;

Page 93: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

vbq � Ì(À��[�y¿O�6�r©«¿O�

Ú�_a\^wOw � ÚG�Ú���YpYOB¯¨ � �/_TKTQUWUMO����¨�M[k�f t�� Hg��\¯C$SbC$Wi�sÚ���Ka��B�Ne��MrQU��Ybk h$MOk � QD�;C�QUWUMbh�C�f®º�d!WLC�����BD�§�k!MOWLSDWUC$d;YOWLQ��®_�k »��r����¤$©L¤$�;�j¤ ��¤U�j�[©LÃ'�T�G� �p¤ � ! � ��� » � À;ÁrµR�e�¦�ª�£�3µ �[��½�©ª�£�;�$� �� �¤ �a�½�©L�U¿O©L�rµ�µ �£�p¿ ���r�p¿[�!��¿b¤�� �6½ ��½ � �r¨ed!MOzOCiK � � v�� � mOve�ytRÝ#\ VXWLCiKLK�¨÷E�vbwOw!�

Ú��gvOw � _ª�pÚ*C$QL@e�bCRM[k�f�`e� ±&� �¸��YOd(� � C�¹yNeC�kbQU��MO����QTS���k'QU@eCR��M[B �;f!Mr��h$M[��h�N!��N!K�M[k!f.h$YOB �e��k�MrQLYbWLS��YOzO��h[�XÇ�WUM ¬ Q�¨®EivOvbwe�

Ú � vyx � Ù��!Ú�YON�f3YO�÷M[k�f¯Ý�� � M[keC�¥OCO�X�e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�¨3B�Ne��QL��de����h$�§QU��CiKcM[k!f�QL@!Cg����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K��?�C�hj@ek!�§�h$MO�XH�C$d;YOWLQ�HcH#� � x[w!EO¨�_ �RHc_Tt�� � YOde@!��M¯tckyQU��d;YO����K�¨�EivOvbxe��?�Y�MOded�CiM[W¸��k �¦ÛCiKTQjKLhj@eWU� ¬ Q¥OYb��N!B�C¸��k¯@eYOkeYbW#Y ¬ H�YO�e��k^\¯����keC�W � K �Oq[QL@��e��WLQL@�feM¦S �j¨!\¯_T? VXWUC�KUK$�

Ú � v � � Ù��#Ú*YbN!f3Yb�RM[k!f Ý�� � MOkeC$¥bCO� ?#@eCsf3��KUh�WU��B���k!M[QL��kez d;Yr�*C�W.Y ¬ QU@eCs�e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!K.����QL@B�N!�§QU��de����h���QL��C�K�� �ª�����[©ªµD�[�«�6�[�É�[�;þ»X�[µR�;�3���[�«�6�[�!¨�E � ��³TE¦·ªº wOm���E�q � ¨eEivOv �!�

Ú���YyvOq � ÚG�!Ú���YpYbB���Ý�MOk � Ý�Û �;C¸QLYOd!d�Cif��¾Û��MrQ���M[QaQU��h$CgB�Y3f3C���KcY ¬ QTSpd;C�f^�e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�� �ª�����[© �µ'�r���6�r�9�[�;þ»X�[µR�;�3���[�«�6�[�!¨;wyo3³aE � � ·ªº � �bm��3mOqOq!¨3E�vbvOqe�

Ú � vbx � � �/Ú�WLY3hj�ÉM[k!f¼Ù�� � KaQL@eC���BDC�W��9VXWLY3h$C�KUK�KLC$B'M[kyQL��h$K�Y ¬ zbWUMOde@-WLCif3N!h�QL��YOk®�9_�k _ª� � C$CM[k�f � � t�� � BDYO���rMe¨�C�f3��QLYbWUK�¨®½�©L�i��ÌR» � �.» � � � � ! ¨®¥bYO��NeBDC�v � � Y ¬ �(¤j�$�«�3©L¤�� �r��¤ª���£�»��rµ����3��¤�©�À��$�6¤$�;�j¤�¨�d!M[zbC�K npopE �ynywbx3¨VX@e����Mbf3C$��de@e��Me¨�VC$kek!KLSp��¥rMOke��M!¨�E�vbvbx3� � deWU��k!zOC$WÜXC$WU��M[z!�

Ú�YON!wbv � Ù���Ú*YbN!f3Yb�«�G?(Yr�#M[WjfeKcM'��M[B �;f!M�h$MO��h$Ne��N!K ¬ YbW�h$YOk!h$NeWLWUC$kyQ�MOk!f¾h$YOBDB�Nek!��h�MrQL��kez�KLS3KT�QLC�B'K$� _�k ���R½*À �� �� � �� ¨�¥OYb��NeBDC^mbxeE¯Y ¬ ��¤j�����3©L¤ ���r��¤����£� »��[µR�;�3��¤$©¯À��$�6¤����j¤�¨d!MOzOC�KGE�nbv���E��!EO¨;E�vOwbve�

Ú�YON!v � � Ù��3Ú�YON!f3Yb�«�tRKLSpk!hj@eWUYOkpS�MOk!f'QU@eCG����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K��(?(Cihj@eke��h$MO��HcC$d;YOWLQ�HcH#�jE¦o[q � ¨b_ ��H�_Tt��� Ybde@e��M�tRkyQL��d�Yb����K$¨(E�vOv � �

Ú�YON!vOn � Ù��¯Ú*YbN!f3Yb�«� � YOBDC hj@eC�BD��h�M[�sMO�!KaQLWjMOhªQ BDMbhj@e��keC�K�� _�k ½�©U���iÌ � � � À��3µ�µD¤$©À�� �p�i�r  �!À�Árµ��e�¦�ª�£�3µ ����� � ¨g¥OYb��NeBDCÉwOqbm Y ¬ �(¤j�$�«�3©U¤ � �r��¤ª�9�£��»��rµ����3��¤�©sÀ��$�6¤����j¤��� deWU��kezOC�W�ÜXC�WL��M[z�¨÷E�vbv[n!�

Ú�YON!vpo�� Ù��!Ú�YON�f3YO���X?#@eC¸de�§��h$MO��h$Ne��N!K#��k^f3��WUC�hªQRKaQTSp��Cb�/_�k � � � �'½ ��½ �X�!tRÝ#\ VXWUC�KUK$¨÷EivOvyo3�

¡Ý�ÛXx[w � ��� Ú �[Ý*NeWLWUS¸M[k!f Hg�iÛ!C$S3K���»��rµ.¶��£�;�r���r©ªÁ����U¿[�6� � �r  � �¦� �cYbWaQU@ �cYb����M[k�f÷¨rtcB'KTQUC$WjfeM[B¯¨E�vyx[w!�

¡Ý*@pN!m � � t��#Ý*@yN!WUhj@®� t KaC$Q'Y ¬ d;YbKaQLN!��M[QLC�K ¬ YbWDQL@eC ¬ YbNek!feM[QL��YOk!K�Y ¬ ��YOzO��h[� ���!��Ì��a� � �r� �pÌ�¨mOm!º mOn ���pm � �e¨eEivOm � �

¡Ý*@pNen!E � t���Ý*@pNeWUhj@(� � �p¤¼»X�[ ��$�3 ¡� �T� ���rµ.¶UÃO�²»��r�!¢r¤$©j�j�6�[�!� VXWU��k!h$C�QUYOk �cke��¥OC�WUKL��QTS¼VXWUC�KUK$¨E�vOn!Eb�

ÇgÝ�? �Rvyo ��\É��ÇRC ��MOke�§�aÝ*��M[k!h�M[zO����ke�«¨�`e��?#��NeWLSpk®¨÷MOk!f¾V� �RW ��S3h �$Spk®�GÇR��KUh�WU��BD��k!MrQU��Ybk^�yS¯d!MOWUMO����C$�YO��KaC�WL¥bC$WjK$��_�k ½�©L�i�j¤j¤UÃ[�£�y¿[�jÊ��(Í�¤� §��� �����!�!�[ '� � � � À;ÁrµR�e�¦�ª�£�3µ �r� ���U¿[�6�.�£� »��rµ ����3��¤$© À÷���6¤$�;�j¤$¨�d�M[zOCiK¸mOv ���ynyqyop¨�±ÉM[WjKLM¦�g¨®VYb��MOk!f÷¨�EivOvpop��_T]�]�] Ý*YbB�d!N3QLC�W � Y3h���C�QTSVXWUC�KUK$�

Ç �Rwyo � Hg�;ÇRC �R��h$YO��M'M[k!f^\É� �RC$kek!C�KUKaSb�#Ý�Ý � ���§QU@eYONeQ � � K���_�ks½#©L���iÌ ���j�����a�j��� �� ¨�¥bYO��NeBDC� nyv�Y ¬ ��¤j�����3©L¤ � �r��¤ª�g�£� »X�[µR�;�3��¤$©¸À��$�6¤$�;�j¤�¨!d!M[zbC�KGE�mbw��;E¦x � ¨!E�vbwyo3�

�´ó�â����

Page 94: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

���!��¤�©��;©L¤$�«�£�p¿R�j�3�������6�r�!�g�r�#���a�j�[ ����3 §�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª� veE

Ç �Rv � � � ��ÇGM[kp¥pS�MOk!f¾`!� �RM[QUh��������?#@pNeke�3K�³«h�YOkyQU��kpNeCif!·ª��_�ks½�©L�i�j¤U¤jÃ[�£�y¿[� �T��� �p¤ D�r©jËi� �3�j��r�ÈÀ����r���6� �����r ¡Á¦�ª�����À � � � � ¨!Ú�YbWUf3CiM[N3P÷¨3ÛeWjM[k�h�CO¨÷EivOv � �

Ç � wbx � Hg�;ÇRC � ��BDYOk!CO� �R��zb@eC$W���C$¥bC$�(KLSpk!hj@eWUYOke��KL��kez'f3C�¥p��h$C�K#��kÈ\^]X_a`b]/� � Ý�Ý � ��� �3¤U�[©L¤$�«�6�j�r »��rµ����3��¤�©�À��$�6¤����U¤$¨!mpopº � nyx�� � �yop¨!E�vOwyx3�

Û��Kªo � � \É�c`!��Û��KLhj@eC�W�� � M[B �;f!Mr��h$M[��h�N!��N!K�KLhj@eC�B'MrQUM!� _�k ½�©U���iÌ�� » � �j�r�i��Ì��[� ½�©U�r¢i�£�y¿�G�j�$¤$©ª�«�6�[�e���b¶U�r�3��½�©L�U¿O©L�rµ �ª¨ed!M[zbC�KGE�qOn���E�qOv!¨!Eivyo � �

Û��KUvOm � \É��`e��Û��KUhj@eC$Wi� � M[B �;feM[��h�M[��h�Ne��N!K.KUhj@eC�BDM[QUM!� �/����� �r��ÃÉÀ;Árµ'¶U�r §�6�¼»��[µR�;�3���[�«�6�[�!¨�eº � mbm�� � nbw!¨!EivOvOm!�

Û± ?�v � � Ç �®V��÷Û!WL��C�f3B'MOk®¨(\É��±9MOk!f÷¨÷M[k�f �RM¦SpkeCiK¸Ý��÷?¸� � �j�$¤����«�6�[  �D�a�¸½#©L�L¿O©L�[µ µ��£�y¿ �(�[�*�¿O�!�$¿y¤ª�ª�*\^hiÙGWUM¦�#� �c������Ú�YpYO�¯Ý*Y!��¨!�cC$� ��YOWU��¨!��� � ��¨®E�vbv � �

ÙGYOW�orv � \É� `e�¡Ý��¾ÙGYOWjf3YOk(� � �3¤ Ãb¤����r���r���6�r���r  ÃO¤��$��©ª� �;�«�6�[� �a� �;©L�L¿O©L�[µ µ��£�y¿  ��[�y¿O�!�$¿y¤ª�ª�� deWU��kezOC�W�ÜXC$WU��MOz!¨�E�vporve�

ÙGYOWjvbx � t��3Ç �eÙGYOWjf3YOk®��Ú*��KL��BD����MOWL��QTS�MbK*M�QL@eC�YOWUS Y ¬®¬ Nek!h�QL��YOk!MO��d!WLYbzOWjM[BDBD��kez�º(BD��ke�§��h�YbNeWjKaCb��cYOQLCiK � C$WU��CiK Ú#H�_LÝ � � � � ��vyx¦��me¨/Ú�Hc_LÝ � ¨XÇRC�d!M[WLQLBDC$kyQDY ¬ Ý*YbB�d!N3QLC�W � h���C$k!h$CO¨ �ck!�§�¥OC�WUKL��QTS.Y ¬ tRM[WU@pN!K�¨!`[Ne��S¾EivOvbxe�

ÙGNek!v � � Ý��(t��(ÙGNekyQLC$Wi�.À÷¤�µ'�r���«�6���.�T��½�©L�U¿O©L�rµ�µ �£�p¿ ���r�p¿[�!��¿b¤��ª�D\¯_T? VXWUC�KUK$¨Ý�MOB��eWU��f3zOCb¨\¯YyKLK�¨÷E�vbv � �

ÙGÜ�v � � `!� Û��eÙGWLYpYOQLCRMOk!f.Û�� ±&�pÜ�MbM[k!f3WjM[zbC$Wi� � QLWUN!hªQUNeWLCif.Ybd�C�WUM[QL��YOk!MO�!KaC�B'M[kyQL��h$K�M[k!f.�e��KL��B �Ne��MrQU��Ybk¯MbK�MDh�YOk!zOWUNeC$k!h$CO���ª�i���r©ªµ'�r���6�r�-�r�;þ»��rµ����3���r���6�r�!¨(E�qOq!º � q � � � �bqe¨eEivOv � �

�RÚcobo�� Ý�� �RC$����QaQ�MOk!f ����Ú#MO�OC$Wi� � M¦�cK ¬ YbW�h�YOBDB Neke��h$MrQU��k!z�d�M[WjM[����C��XdeWLY3h$C�KUKaCiK$�D_�k � � � �� )�U½Ö»��r�p¿[©L¤��j��½�©L�i�U¤j¤jÃr�£�p¿r�ª¨ed�M[zOCiK�vOwpo��pvbv � �O_TÛ_TV¨®E�vpoOop�

�RÚ�Ù � o[m ��Ý����cC����§QLQ�¨yV��[Ú���Ka@!YOd®¨[_ª�[ÙGWUC$� ¬ ¨OÚG� � BD�§QU@®¨b?¸�[\^M[QUKLYOk®¨bM[k!f Hg� � QLC���zbC$Wi�et�hªQUYOW��k!feN!hª�QL��YOk MOk!f9BDC�QUM[��C�¥rM[��N!MrQU��Ybk®��_�k � » � À�Árµ��3�r�ª�£�3µ �[�-½�©ª�£����� �; �¤����T� ½#©L�L¿O©L�[µ µ��£�y¿���r�y¿O�!�$¿y¤��j¨�d!M[zbC�KGEixOm���E��Ow!�btRÝ#\ɨ(E�vyo[me�

�RÇGv[n � `!� �RMrQjh���� � MOk!f � �÷ÇGM[kp¥pSO��t zOC�keC$WU��h�MOh�h�YbNekyQ�Y ¬ h�YOkyQU��kpN!M[QL��YOk3��d!MOKUKL��kez�KTQTSp��C�K��g_�k� � �ª��½ ��½ �/¨ed!MOzOCiK*npx[w��ynpo3EO�ytRÝ#\ØV�WLCiKLK�¨÷E�vbv[n!�

�RÇGvyo � `!����MrQjh���� � M[k�f � �/Ç�MOky¥pSb�É?#@pNek!�pKDMOk!fÉQL@!C¯�e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!K����3�[�3©ª�;�[ #�a� ®�3�;�$�«�6�[�;�[ ½�©L�U¿O©L�rµ�µ �£�p¿[¨÷o3³«mb·ªº mOqbm��3meE�v!¨y\^M¦S^EivOvpop�

�RǸ\^vbm � Hg� ��M[WUd�C�W�¨(Û��®ÚG�÷ÇRN!�!Me¨(MOk!f9Ç��(\^Mbh���NeC�C$k®��?�Spde��kez�×!WjKTQL��h$��MbKLKGh�YbkbQU��kpN!M[QL��YOk!K���k\ � ���3�[�3©ª�;�[ ��T� ®�3�;�$�«�6�[�;�[ ;½�©L�U¿[©U�rµ�µ �£�p¿[¨!m�³´np·ªº n �bx��ynyw[n!¨ � hªQUYO�;C$WgE�vbvOm!�

�cC�k!wOw � \É� �cC$k!keC�KUKaSb� ��  ¿y¤¦¶ª©L�[�6��� �3¤j�r©ªÁ��a�*½�©L�i�j¤ª�j�$¤��j��?#@eCR\¯_T? VXWUC�KUK$¨3Ý�M[B �eWL��f3zbCO¨O\^MbKLK���¨E�vbwOw!�

�cC���oOo � Ý�� �RC$����QaQi��ÜR��C$����kez.h$YOkyQLWUYO�®KaQLWUN!hªQUNeWUC�K�MOK#d�MrQaQUC$WUk!K�Y ¬ d!MbKLKL��kezDB�CiKLKUM[zbC�K����3�[�3©ª�;�[ �T� ��©ª�«� �����6�[ ®�£�!��¤� £ §�§¿b¤$�;�j¤$¨�w!³«mb·�º m � m��3m �On!¨!Eivyobop�

� � vOm � Hg� �RMOWLd;C$W/M[k�f \É� � ���������eWL��f3zbCO�pV�Yb��SpBDYOWUde@e��hXQTSpd;C�MbKLKL��zOkeBDC$kyQ�MOk!f�Ý�V � h�Ybkp¥OC$WjKL��Ybk®��/����� �r��ÃDÀ�Árµ.¶U�r ¡�6��»��rµ����3���r���6�r��¨��!º m �eE��3mOwbqe¨eEivOvOm!�

â�â54�6!þ87:98;

Page 95: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

v � � Ì(À��[�y¿O�6�r©«¿O�

�cYr�cv � � Ç �R`e� �cYr��CO��VXWUYr¥p��kez h�YbkezOWUNeC$k�h�C¾Y ¬ �e��Ka��B�Ne��MrQU��Ybk²��k ¬ Nek�hªQL��YOk�M[�¸deWUYOzOWjM[BDBD��kez��M[kezbN!M[zbC�K�� �������r©ªµ'�r���6�r�É�r��þ»��rµ����3���r���6�r��¨®E � n�³ � ·ªº�E�qbm���EOE � ¨eE�vbv �!�

� � w � � `!� Hg� �c��k!f3��C$SDM[k!f'`!� V� � C$��f3��k(� ���!��©L��Ã[�!�����6�r������»��rµ.¶ª�£���r���r©j�G�[�;ø�'�a�U�[ ��$�3 ¡�p�ª�÷Ý�MOB ��eWU��fezOC �cke��¥OC�WUKL��QTS.VXWLCiKLK�¨®EivOw �!�

�R?�v!E � �D���RYOk!feM MOk!f&\É��?�YO�bYOWUY!� tck � �eZTC�hªQ9Ý�MO��h$Ne��N!K ¬ YOWstRKLSyk�hj@eWLYbkeYON�KÈÝ*YOBDB�N3�ke��h$M[QL��YOk!K��­_�k \É�c?�YO�bYOWUY!¨ � ���c��C$WjKTQUWUMbK �b¨�V�R±9C$zbkeC$Wi¨GMOk!f t�� ��YbkeC �iM¦��M!¨RC�fe�§�QLYbWUK�¨ � » � ��½ � � � D�r©jËi� �p�j�È�[� �R¶ �$¤U�$���R�r�$¤UÃ�»��r�����3©ª©L¤$�!�®½�©L�U¿O©L�rµ�µ �£�p¿rÊ®ÙGC$k!C$¥rMe¨� ����Q ��C$WU��MOk!f÷¨REivOv!EȨ�¥bYO��NeBDC¾x3E � Y ¬ �(¤j�$�«�3©L¤ � �r��¤ª���£� »��rµ����3��¤�©�À��$�6¤$�;�j¤�¨�d!MOzOC�KE�mbm���E$npo3� � d!WL��kezOC�W�ÜXC$WU��MOz!¨�E�vbveEb�

_�kez �eE � V� ��(_�kezOC�WLB'M[k(��?#@pNeke�3K$¨/M¯�#M¦S¾Y ¬ h�YbB�d!������k!z^deWLY3h$C�f3NeWUC.KaQUMrQUC$BDC$kyQjKg���§QU@ KaYbBDCh�YbBDB�C�kyQUK�YOk.d!WLY3h�Cif3NeWUC�f3Cih���M[WjMrQU��Ybk!K$�R»X�[µ µ��3�!�6�j�[�«�6�[�e���T�G���3¤�� » � ¨3n�³TE¦·ªº xOx��3x[w!¨E�v �eEb�

`OC ¬ vOm � t���`OC ��WLC�SO�9t°hj@eC�B���h$MO��MO�!KaQLWjMOhªQ BDMbhj@e��keC ¬ YbW zbWUMOde@-WLCif3N!h�QL��YOk®�s_�k ½�©L�i��Ì �g�£������ª����¤$©ª�;�[�«�6�[�;�[ »��[����¤$©L¤����j¤��r�^� �p¤ � �[���3¤�µ'�r���6�j�r  ��r�3��ÃO�[�«�6�[�e���T�c½�©L�U¿[©U�rµ�µ �£�p¿�À�¤:�µ'�r�!���6���� � /½*À � ��� �r¨y¥OYO��NeBDC#wOq � Y ¬ �(¤j�$�«�3©U¤ ���[��¤����£�È»��rµ����3��¤�©#À÷���6¤$�;�j¤$� � deWU��k!zOC$WÜXC$WU��M[z!¨÷EivOvbme�

�gV�?�v � � ��� ��YO�!M¦SyMOKL@e�«¨�Ú��¡Ý���VX��C�WUh$CO¨÷M[k�f^Ç�� ���÷?�NeWLk!C$Wi� � ��keC�MOWL��QTS¯M[k!f¯QU@eC�de�§��h$MO��h$Ne��N!K$�R_�k½�©L�i�iÌ ��� ���.½ ��½ �/�!tRÝ#\ VXWUC�KUK�¨÷E�vOv �e�

� � w � � `!� Hg� �¸C$kek�M¦��M¦S.MOk!f¾\É� Hg� � ��C$C�d®�#]/P3deWLCiKLKL��YOk!KcMbK�deWUY3h�C�KUKLC�K���_�k � » � »��r����¤$©L¤$�;�j¤�r� �3�ªÀ3½&�[�;à ®�3�;�$���6�r�;�[ �½�©L�U¿[©U�rµ�µ �£�p¿[¨�d!M[zbC�K � E � � w!�ytRÝ#\-¨®E�vbw � �

� MON!vOm � `!� � M[N!k!hj@p�eNeWUSO��t k!M[QLNeWjM[�XKLC$B'M[kyQL��h$K ¬ YbWG��M���S¾C$¥rMO��N!M[QL��YOk®��_�k ½#©L���iÌ ��� ���¾½ ��½ �/�tRÝ#\ VXWUC�KUK$¨÷EivOvOm!�

� C$QUv!E � � � � C�QU@®� ®�3�;�$���6�r�;�[ �½�©L�U¿O©L�rµ �È�¦� �R¤j�j�r���¿[�3©U�b¶� �¤ � ¤���Í��r©jËi�È�T�É»��rµ�µ �3���6�j�r���£�y¿½�©L�i�j¤ª�j�$¤��j��V�@®� Ç �eQU@eC�KL��K$¨e_�BDd;C$WU��MO��Ý*YO����C�zOCb¨ �Rke��¥OC$WjKL�§QTS.Y ¬ � YOk!f3Ybk®¨÷E�vbveEb�

� J�¥!o�� � `!� `!� � J$¥pSO�÷tck�M[��zOC$�!WUMO��h���kbQUC$WUdeWUC�QUM[QL��YOkDY ¬ QU@eCG��9��e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�ÂyMOk!f'M[k.MOdede����h�MrQL��YOk'Y ¬M���MO��C�����C�f^�e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�� � �3¤j�r©L¤$�«�6�j�[ *»��rµ����3��¤$©¸À��$�6¤����U¤$¨ � ³TEi·�º vpo���EOE$n�¨!Eivyo��!�

� Ybk!wOm � Ù�� � YOkezbY!� � C�QgQU@eC$YbWLC$QL��h$M[�/BDY3f3C$��KgY ¬ ��M[B���feM¯h$MO��h$Ne��N!K$ºg?#@eC�YOWUSO¨®C$P3d!M[k!KL��YOk!K¸M[k�f��KaYbB�YbWLd!@e��KLB'K$� ���!���r �¤����T�R½��3©U¤ �[�;à �#�O�; ¡�6¤jà ���L¿O�6�$¨ � n�º�E¦x[m��;E�wbwe¨eEivOwbme�

\¯����wbv � Hg��\^����keC$Wi�¸»��rµ�µ �3���6�U�[�«�6�[�É�[�;þ»X�[�;�$�3©ª©L¤$�;�$Ár��VXWLC�kyQL��h�C �RMO����¨÷E�vbwOv!�

\¯����v!E � Hg�r\¯����keC�W��y?#@eC�d;YO��SbMbf3��hX����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K�º®M�QUN3QLYbWL��M[���O?�C�hj@eke��h$MO�bH�C�d�YbWaQ/]*Ý � � � ÛÝ � �pveE �E�wbqe¨ � ÛÝ � ¨!Ç�C$deQ��eY ¬ Ý*YbB�d(� � h�����¨!]�f3��kp�eNeWUzO@ �cke��¥���¨ � hªQLYb��C�WgE�vbveEO�XtR��KLY'��k ���L¿O�6��r��à ��  ¿y¤i¶�©L�.�a��ÀO�e¤U�$� �*�j�[�«�6�[�!¨3C�f®�eÛ*� � �3Ú#M[N!C$Wi¨y±&�3Ú�WjM[NeC�W�MOk!f ��� � hj@p����hj@yQLC�kp��C�WLz�¨� deWU��kezOC�W�ÜXC�WL��M[z�¨÷E�vbvOme�

\¯����v � � Hg�!\¯����keC$Wi�Û!Nek!h�QL��YOk!K�MbK*d!WLY3h�CiKLKLC�K�� �e�r�3©ª���r (�a� � �[���3¤�µ'�r���6�j�r (À���©ª�!�����3©L¤��c�£� »��rµ ����3��¤$©�À÷���6¤$�;�j¤$¨ � ³ � ·�º�EbE�v���E$n�EO¨!EivOv � �

\¯��QUv � � `!�rÝ��r\¯��QUhj@eC������ ��r�3��ÃO�[�«�6�[�e�;���[©�½�©L�U¿[©L�[µ µ��£�y¿��(�[�y¿O�!�$¿y¤ª�ª�3\¯_T?-VXWUC�KUK$¨OÝ�MOB��eWU��fezOCO¨\^t�¨®E�vbv �e�

�´ó�â����

Page 96: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

���!��¤�©��;©L¤$�«�£�p¿R�j�3�������6�r�!�g�r�#���a�j�[ ����3 §�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª� vOm

\¯YbzbveE � ]���\^YOzOzb�«� �cYOQL��YOk!K#Y ¬ h$YOBDdeN3QjMrQU��Ybk�M[k�f�BDYbk!MOfeK����ª�����[©ªµD�[�«�6�[�É�[�;ï»��[µR�;�3���[�«�6�[�!¨vOm�³TE¦·ª¨÷E�vbveEb�

\ � v � � Hg��\¯����k!C$WDM[k!f Ç � � M[k!zO��YOWUzO���ÈÚ#M[WU��CifÉ�e��KL��B�Ne��MrQU��Ybk®�s_�k¼±&� �¸N!��hj@®¨XCif3��QLYOWi¨ � � ����r» ���(½�¨¸¥OYb��N!B�C � � m Y ¬ ��¤U�$���3©L¤ � �r��¤ª�-�£� »��rµ����3��¤�©-À÷���6¤$�;�j¤$¨ d�M[zOCiK �bwbx����Ovyx3�� deWU��kezOC�W�ÜXC$WU��MOz!¨�E�vbv � �

\ � vbw � \É��\^C$WUWLY'M[k�f�Ç � � MOkezO��YOWUzO��� � k^MbKaSpk!hj@eWUYOkpSD��k�k�M[BDC���d!MOKUKL��kezDh$MO��h$Ne���«�X?�YDMOded;C�M[W��k�QU@eC�VXWUY3h[�e_LÝ�t � V � vOw!¨÷E�vOvbwe�

\¯NeWjv � � Ý���\¯NeWLQL@pSO�st­h$YOBDdeN3QjMrQL��YOk�M[�*MOk!M[��S3Ka��K�Y ¬ ÙG��WjM[Wjf � KgQLWjM[k�Ka��MrQU��Ybk M[k!f � Ý��È_�k � ����3�[»À »��r�i��Ì!_T]�]�]²Ý*YOBDdeN3QUC$W � Yph$��C$QTS�VXWUC�KUK$��¨÷E�vbv � �

\¯± wyx � t��XHg��\¯C�SOC�W�MOk!f¼\É�±9MOk!f÷�¼Ý*YOkyQU��kpN!M[QL��YOk KLC$B'M[kyQL��h$K ��k QTSpd�Cif ��M[B �;feM[��h�M[��h�Ne�����_�k H�YO@e��Q'VMOWL���p@®¨�Cif3�§QUYOWi¨�½�©L�i�j¤j¤UÃ[�£�y¿[�¯�a��� �p¤-»X�[����¤$©L¤$�;�j¤¾�r�����U¿[�6�¾�a�.½�©L�U¿[©L�[µ��ª¨¥OYb��N!B�CÉEivOmsY ¬ �(¤j�$�«�3©L¤ ���r��¤����£� »��rµ����3��¤$©¯À��$�6¤����U¤$¨�d!M[zbC�K � Eiv�� � � n�¨�Ú*WUYpYO�p��Syk(¨� ��¨(EivOwbxe� � deWL��kezbC$W�ÜXC$WU��M[z!�

� ÇGvOm � Ù�� �D� � KTQU@eC$��BDC$W�M[k!f�t�� `e� ?¸�eÇGM¦¥y��CO�/VX����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K#hj@!MOWUMbhªQLC�WL� ��M[QL��YOk!K�Y ¬ KLYOBDCGdeWjMOhªQU�§�h$MO�X��MOB���feMr��h$MO��h$Ne��N!KRWUC�feN!hªQU��Ybk9KaQLWjMrQUC$zO��C�K�� Ý � vOm �3E$n�¨ �Rke��¥OC$WjKL�§QTS^Y ¬ � Q�tck�f3WLC��cK$¨� h$Y[QL��M[k�f÷¨ � hªQUYO�;C$W¸E�vbvOm!�

� � ?�v[n � Ý�� � �rMOKUM[�p��¨yV� � C$Cb¨eM[k!f�Ç&?�MOWUfe�§QU�«��Ý�M[�������pSy��k!C$C�f�M[k!f�h�YbkbQU��kpN!M[QL��YOk3��d!MbKLKL��k!z KaQTSy��CO��/����� �r��ÃDÀ�Árµ.¶U�r ¡�6��»��rµ����3���r���6�r��¨�oe³TEi·�º xyo��3w � ¨p`OMOkpN!M[WUS^E�vbv[n!�

� kezywOw � � � � kez!��� �3¤���� �$Á ���rµ.¶UÃO�-»��[ ����3 §�p� � �[� �ª��¢¦¤��ª�«�§¿y�r���6�r� �£�!���¯� �p¤ (�[�3�;Ãb�r���6�r�e���a� ®�3�;�$�«�6�[�;�r /½�©L�U¿[©L�[µ µ��£�y¿O��VX@�ÇÖQL@eCiKa��K�¨ �ck!��¥bC$WjKa��QTS¾Y ¬ � Ybk!f3Ybk®¨�E�vbwOw!��tR��KLY^VXWL� �$CÛeC�����Yr�cKL@e��d^Ç���KUKLC$WLQUMrQU��Ybk®¨3?(WU��ke�§QTS^Ý*YO����C�zOCb¨eÝ�MOB��eWU��f3zOCb¨ � x ��ded®�

V/M[WjweE � Ç � \É�XV/M[WU���ÈÝ*YOk!h$NeWLWUC$k�h�S¾Ybk M[N3QUYOB'MrQjM¾M[k!fÉ��k3×!k!�§QUC�KLC�¹yNeC$k�h�C�K��¯_�k V�Ç�C$N!KUKLC$k®¨C�fe�§QUYOWi¨�»��r�i��Ì*�[� � �p¤j�[©L¤����6�j�r #»��rµ����3��¤�©�À��$�6¤����U¤$¨;¥OYO��NeBDC.Eiq[nDY ¬ ��¤U�$���3©L¤ � �r��¤ª���£�»��rµ����3��¤�©�À��$�6¤����U¤$� � d!WL��kezOC�W#ÜXC$WU��MOz!¨÷E�vbweEb�

VX��QUvpo�� t��;\É�eVX��QaQUK�� � d�C�WUM[QL��YOk!MO����Sy����MOKLC�fDQU@eC$YbWL��C�K*Y ¬ deWLYbzOWjM[BÖC�¹yNe��¥rM[��C$k!h$CO�_�k�V�!Ç�Sp�3ZTC$WM[k�f�t���\É�eVX��QaQjK$¨eCif3��QLYOWjK�¨�À�¤$µD�[�!���6�ª���r��à �(�U¿O�6�ª���T�D»��[µR�;�3���[�«�6�[�!¨!VXN!�e����h$M[QL��YOk!K#Y ¬QL@!C �cC$�#QUYOk¯_�k!KaQL��QLN3QUCO¨�d!M[zbC�K � n�E�� � vOw!�pÝ�M[B �eWU��f3zbC��Rke��¥OC$WjKL�§QTS�V�WLCiKLK�¨÷E�vbvyop�

VX��YpoOx � Ù�� Ç��!V���YOQL�p��k(��Ý�MO�����pS.k!MOBDCO¨eh$MO�����pS.¥rM[��NeC¸M[k!f�QL@!Cg�e��h$M[��h�N!��N!K�� � �3¤j�r©L¤$�«�6�j�[ �»��rµ ����3��¤$©¸À��$�6¤����U¤$¨®Ebº�E � x���EixOve¨!EivyoOx3�

VX��Ypobo�� Ù�� Ç��;VX��YOQL�p��k®� � Ý�Û MOK�M�deWUYOzOWjM[BDBD��kez���M[kezbN!M[zbCO� � �p¤j�r©L¤$���6�U�[ *»��[µR�;�3��¤$©¸À��$�6¤����j¤�¨x3º � � m�� � xOxe¨!EivyoOo3�

V � v � � � �eVXN!WLN!KL@eYOQL@!MOBDMOk�M[k�f�`e� � CiM[B'M[k(�(tck�MOf3Ci¹bN�MrQLC�YOd;C$WjMrQU��Ybk!M[��KaC�B'M[kyQL��h$K ¬ YOW#Ka@�M[WL���kez���k'��M �$S�C�¥rM[��N!MrQU��Ybk®�!_�k.Ú�C$WUk!f �¸WU��C�z[��Ú*W��!hj�pkeC�W�¨¦C�fe�§QUYOWi¨ � À ��½ � � � Ê � ��� � �3©L�ª�3¤j�r�À�Árµ��e�¦�ª�£�3µ°�r�.½�©L�U¿[©U�rµ�µ �£�p¿[¨y¥OYb��NeBDCRxOw � Y ¬ ��¤U�$���3©L¤�� �r��¤ª�c�£�9»��rµ����3��¤�©RÀ��$�6¤����j¤�¨d!MOzOC�K#nymbx��ynyxOqe¨yÛeWjM[k!h$CO¨÷E�vbv � � � deWL��kezbC$W#ÜXC$WU��MOz!�

V � v � � ÚG�÷VX��C�WUh$C MOk!fÈÇ � � M[kezb��YbWLzb�«�G?�Spde��kez�M[k!f¾KLNe�3QTSpde��kez ¬ YOWGB�Yb�e����C�deWUYph$C�KUKaCiK$� �e�r�3© ��;�[ c�T� � �[���3¤�µ'�r���6�j�r #À���©ª�!�$�«�3©L¤��'�£� »X�[µR�;�3��¤$©.À÷���6¤$�;�j¤$¨ �!³�xO·�º nyqOv��pnyx[n!¨�EivOv �e�ÈtRkC�PpQUC$k!f3Cif¯M[�!KaQLWjMOh�Q#��kȽ�©L�i��Ì �'�r»À ��� ¨�_T]�]�]²Ý*YOBDdeNeQLC$W � Yph$��C$QTS�VXWUC�KUK$�

â�â54�6!þ87:98;

Page 97: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

vOn � Ì(À��[�y¿O�6�r©«¿O�

H�C�Seo � � `!�iÝ���H�C�SpkeYO��feK��¦Ç�C�×�ke�§QU��Ybk!M[�b��kyQUC$WUdeWLC$QLC�WUK ¬ YbW®@e��zO@eC�W®YOWjf3C$W÷d!WLYbzOWjM[BDBD��kez���M[kezbN!M[zbC�K��� » � »X�[����¤$©L¤$�;�j¤g½�©L�i�U¤j¤jÃr�£�p¿r�ª¨ed�M[zOCiKcopE¦o��eornbqe¨;E�vpo � �

H�C�Spvbm � `!��Ý���H�C$SpkeYb��feK��c?#@eC�f3��KUh�Yr¥bC$WU��CiK#Y ¬ h$YOkyQL��kpN!MrQU��Ybk!K$� �X����� �[�;Ã�À�Árµ.¶U�r ¡�6�^»X�[µR�;�3��� ����6�r�!¨��eº � mOm�� � nbwe¨�E�vbvOme�

� MOk!v � � Ç � � M[k!zO��YOWUzO��� � J$�;©L¤ª�j�ª�£�y¿ � �b¶��£ ¡�£�«Á��£�¯½�©U���j¤��U����  ¿y¤¦¶ª©L�r� � ��£©j�ª� ����©UÃO¤$©g�[�;à �g�§¿��p¤$© ��#©LÃO¤$©D½c�r©L�bÃr�§¿Oµ��ª�¼VX@�Ç QL@eCiKa��K.Ý � ? �pvbv��pvbme¨/ÇRC�d!M[WLQLBDC�kbQDY ¬ Ý*YOBDdeN3QUC$W � h���C$k!h$CO¨�ck!��¥bC$WjKa��QTS.Y ¬ ]�f3��kp�eNeWUzO@®¨®EivOv � �

� MOk!v[n � Ç � � MOkezO��YOWUzO����?#@eCg��M��$S���MOB���feM'h$MO��h$Ne��N!K#��k¾M'h$YOk!h$NeWUWLC�k!h�S�KUh�C�k!M[WU��Y!� �ª�i���r©ªµ'�r���6�r��r��Ã^»��rµ����3���r���6�r��¨(EbEOEb³aEi·�º�E � q���EixOme¨eEivOv[n��

� MOk!vbxOM � Ç � � MOkezO��YOWUzO��� � M �$S ¬ N!k!hªQU��Ybk!KcM[k�f�BDYb�e����C�deWUY3h�CiKLKLC�K���?(Cihj@eke��h$MO�(H�C$d;YOWLQRHcH#� � xeEixe¨_ �RHc_Tt�� � YOde@!��MÉtckyQU��d;YO����K�¨REivOvyx3� ?�YÉMOded;C�M[WD��k �¦ÛCiKTQjKLhj@eWU� ¬ Q�¥bYO��NeBDC���k @!YOkeYbW�Y ¬H�Yb�e��k¾\¯����keC$W � K �bqrQU@��e��WLQL@!feM¦S �ª¨e\¯_T? V�WLCiKLK��

� MOk!vbx[��� Ç � � M[kezb��YbWLzb�«� � J$¥pSy� � YOkezbY.?#WLC�C�KGM[k!f¾Ú�Þb@eB ?#WLC�C�K ¬ WUYOB C�k!h�Y3f3��kezbKRY ¬ �e��h�M[��h�Ne��N!K��kbQUYD����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K����cY[QUC�K�¨÷E�vbvbx3�

� MOk!v � � Ç � � MOkezO��YOWUzO���e����h$M[��h�N!��N!K�¨O��kyQLC�WLk!MO�eBDYO�e�����§QTSDM[k!fDMOzOC$kyQL��d!MbKLKL��kezGh�M[��h�Ne����� � �p¤j�[©L¤����6�j�r »��rµ����3��¤�©¸À÷���6¤$�;�j¤$¨®E��po3³ � ·ªº � myx�� � o¦n�¨eE�vbv �!�

� MOk!vyo[M � Ç � � M[k�feK$�DÛeWUYOB � � � WUNe��C�KGQLY¯deWUYpY ¬ deWL��k!h$��de��C�K�º¸tckÉYOd;C$WjMrQU��Ybk!M[�BDC�QUM[QL@eC�YOWUS ¬ YOW¬ Nek!h�QL��YOk!MO�®��M[kezbN!M[zbC�K��(_�k � � ����½ ��½ �/¨!d!M[zbC�K�n � w��ynbn!Eb�btRÝ#\ VXWUC�KUK$¨÷EivOvyo3�

� MOk!vyor��� Ç � � M[k!zO��YOWUzO���!?#@eC#k!M[BDCcf3��KUh���de����keC�Y ¬ WUC�h$C$d3QU��¥bC$keCiKLK��e_�k � � ��� �r» � ��½�¨O¥bYO��NeBDC¸E � x �Y ¬ ��¤U�$���3©L¤�� �r��¤ª���£�È»��[µR�;�3��¤$©�À��$�6¤$�;�j¤�� � deWU��kezbC$W/ÜXC$WU��M[z!¨!E�vOvpop�e?�YgM[ded;C�MOWX��k'?RÝ � �

� MOk!vOw � Ç � � M[k!zO��YOWUzO��� tck9��kbQUC$WUdeWUC�QUM[QL��YOksY ¬ QTSyd;C�fsYO�eZTC�hªQjK¸��kyQUY�QTSpd;C�fs����h�M[��h�Ne��N!K��,�ª�����[© �µ'�r���6�r�9�[�;þ»X�[µR�;�3���[�«�6�[�!¨�E$nbm�³TE¦·ªº m[n��!orm!¨!E�vbvOw!�

� hj@!w � � Ç �/t�� � hj@eBD��f3Q�� � ¤$�;�[���[�«�6�[�;�r �À÷¤�µ'�r���«�6����� � µD¤$� �p�iÃO�r ��L¿OÁ'���r©� ��r�y¿O�!�$¿y¤¾Ãb¤�¢r¤� ��j���µ'¤����«�Xtc����Syk^MOk!f¯Ú�Mbh�Ybk®¨�E�vOw �e�

� Û/vOm � t�� � M[�eWUS¾M[k!f9\É�®ÛeC�����C$��KLC$k®��HcC�MOKLYOk!��kez�M[�;YON3QgdeWUYOzbWUMOB'Kc��k9h$YOkyQL��kpN!MrQU��Ybk3��d�MOKUKa��kezKaQTSy��CO� �X����� �r��ÃDÀ;Árµ'¶U�r §�6��»��[µR�;�3���[�«�6�[�!¨*�!º � wOv��3m �bqe¨!EivOvbme�

� \^v � � Ç � � M[kezb��YbWLzb�*MOk!f¼Hg��\^����keC$Wi� ?#@eC�deWUYO�e��C$B Y ¬ �i± C�MO� Ú*��KL��B Ne��M[QL��YOk N!d¼QUY �ª�-_�k±&� Hg�*Ý*��C�¥OC���MOk!f÷¨XC�fe�§QUYOWi¨*½�©L�i��Ì�» � �.» � � � � � ¨�¥OYb��N!B�C �Ombq^Y ¬ ��¤j�����3©L¤ � �r��¤ª���£�»��rµ����3��¤�©¸À÷���6¤$�;�j¤$¨ed!MOzOC�K�m � �pn �e� � deWU��kezOC�W�ÜXC�WL��M[z�¨÷E�vbv � �

� ± orn � Ý�� � QUWUMbhj@eC$S�MOk!f�Ý��[V�r±ÉMOfeKL�*YbWaQU@®��Ý*YOkyQU��kpN!M[QL��YOk!K�º®t BDM[QL@eC�B'MrQL��h$MO�eKaC�B'M[kyQL��h$K ¬ YOW@!MOk!f3����kez ¬ Ne����ZTNeBDd!K��¾?(Cihj@eke��h$MO�*H�C�d�YbWaQ ?�C�hj@!ke��h�M[�#\¯YOkeYbzOWjM[de@ÉV�H�Ù��jEOEO¨ � P ¬ YOWjf�ck!��¥bC$WjKa��QTS�Ý*YOBDdeNeQLC$W � M[�;YOWjMrQUYOWUSO¨;E�vyorn!�

?�C$k!v!E � Hg�yÇ��y?(C�kekeC$kyQi��À÷¤�µ'�r���«�6�����T�#½�©L�U¿[©U�rµ�µ �£�p¿ �(�[�y¿O�!�$¿y¤ª�ª�÷VXWUC$kyQL��h�C���M[���«¨ �cC�� ��YOWU�;¨E�vbveEb�

?#@e��vyo � ���;?#@e��C$��C�hj�OCb� »��[��¤�¿y�r©ª�6�j�r À���©ª�!�$�«�3©L¤ �T��»X�[�!���£�!�!�[�«�6�[�^½��r�j�j�£�p¿�À���Ár �¤$�#V�@!Ç QU@eC�KL��K$¨�ck!��¥bC$WjKa��QTS�Y ¬ ]�f3��kp�eN!WLzb@®¨�EivOvpop��tR��KLY�M¦¥rM[����M[�e��CcMOK/QUC�hj@ek!��h�M[�!WUC$d;YOWLQ*]*Ý � � � ÛÝ � ��vyo¦�myo �e�

�´ó�â����

Page 98: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

���!��¤�©��;©L¤$�«�£�p¿R�j�3�������6�r�!�g�r�#���a�j�[ ����3 §�p���;©L�i�U¤��j�$¤ª� vbx

?#@eYyvOq � ÚG�X?#@eYOB'KLC$k®� »��[ ����3 §����[© ���§¿ �3¤�© �#©LÃO¤$©¾»��rµ�µ �3���6�j�r���£�y¿sÀ�Á¦�ª��¤�µ �ª�sVX@�Ç°QU@eC�KL��K$¨Ç�C$d!MOWaQUB�C�kyQcY ¬ Ý*YOBDdeN3QU��kez�¨3_�BDd�C�WL��M[��Ý*Yb����C$zbCO¨÷E�vbvOq!�

?�NeWUv � � ��� Ç ��?�NeWLk!C$Wi� � �p¤��3�[ ¡Árµ'�r©�� �y�6� ��� �a�j�r ����3 ¡�p� � � �p¤j�[©ªÁs�r��à �ªµ��� �¤�µ'¤������[�«�6�[�!��VX@!ÇQL@!C�KL��K�¨!Ç�C$d!MOWaQUB�C�kyQcY ¬ Ý*YbBDdeN3QLC�W � h���C$k�h�CO¨��cke��¥OC�WUKL�§QTS'Y ¬ ]�f3��kp�eN!WLzb@®¨÷E�vbv �e�

Ü ��vOm � Ü�� ?¸�#Ü�MOKUh�Ybk!h�C���YyK.M[k!f �D� �RYOk!feM!� VXWU��k�h���d!M[��QTSpde��k!z¼KLhj@!C$BDC�K���k M-d�Yb��SyMOf3��h^���h$MO��h$Ne��N!K$��_�ks]��®Ú�C�KaQ�¨÷Cif3��QLYOWi¨�½�©L�i�iÌR» � �'» � � � ��� ¨�¥OYO��NeBDCDo3Eix.Y ¬ ��¤j�����3©L¤�� �r��¤ª��£�¼»��[µR�;�3��¤$©¸À��$�6¤����j¤�� � deWL��kezbC$W�ÜXC$WU��M[z!¨�EivOvOm!�

±ÉMOf�o3E � Ý��bV�y±9MbfeKL�*YbWaQU@®�(À÷¤�µ'�r���«�6�����r��ÃR��©L��¿[µ'�r���6�ª�¸�T�����3¤R ��rµ.¶LÃb�'�j�r ��$�3 ¡�p�ª�;V�@!Ç QU@eC�KL��K$¨�ck!��¥bC$WjKa��QTS.Y ¬ � P ¬ YOWjf÷¨�E�vpopEO�

±ÉM[��vOq � Ç �.±9MO���bC$Wi� Ú���KL��B Ne��MrQL��YOk M[k!f­f3��¥OC$WUzOC�k!h�Cb� �ª�i���r©ªµ'�r���6�r� �r��ð»��[µR�;�3���[�«�6�[�!¨wbx!³ � ·ªº � q � � � n!EO¨�E�vbvOqe�

��YbKUvOm � ��� ��YbKL@e��feMe� � d3QU��B'MO��WUC�f3N!h�QL��YOkÉ��k �*CiM[�s��MOB���feMr��h$MO��h$Ne��N�K¸���§QU@¼Ka@�M[WUC�f9C$kp¥p��WUYOke�BDC$kyQUK��X_�k¾½�©L�i��Ì��a� /½G» � � � � Ê ®�3�;�$�«�6�[�;�[ �½�©L�U¿[©L�[µ µ��£�y¿¯�[�;Ã^»��[µR�;�3��¤$©���©L� �b�£��¤U�:����3©L¤�¨3d�M[zOCiK � nym�� � x � ¨!E�vbvOm!�

â�â54�6!þ87:98;

Page 99: Interpreting Functions as pi-calculus Processes: a Tutorial · 2020-03-11 · ISSN 0249-6399 apport de recherche THÈME 1 INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis2004, route des Lucioles - B.P. 93 - 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France)

Unité de recherche INRIA Lorraine : Technopôle de Nancy-Brabois - Campus scientifique615, rue du Jardin Botanique - B.P. 101 - 54602 Villers lès Nancy Cedex (France)

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes : IRISA, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu - 35042 Rennes Cedex (France)Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes : 655, avenue de l’Europe - 38330 Montbonnot St Martin (France)

Unité de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt : Domaine de Voluceau - Rocquencourt - B.P. 105 - 78153 Le Chesnay Cedex (France)

ÉditeurINRIA - Domaine de Voluceau - Rocquencourt, B.P. 105 - 78153 Le Chesnay Cedex (France)��������� ���� �� ���� � � � �

ISSN 0249-6399