7/31/2019 International School Alliance of Educators vs
Quisumbing
2/4
Wen Lowbha _nonwlr ~yenjg wen y bhw+`f+ebn ojlssbfbolwb h f`wen
gbswbhowb`h bh sljlr lwns=
Wen ybhobyjn #n|~lj ylr f` n|~lj q`d#g`ns h`w fbhg lyyjbolwb h
bh wen ynsnhwolsn( Wen bhwnhlwb`hlj oellown `f wen_oe``j n|~bns wen
ebbha `f f`nbahyns`hhnj w` gnlj qbwe gbffnnhw hlwb`hljbwbnslhg
gbffnnhw o~jw~ns* lk`ha wen sw~gnhwy`y~jlwb`h(
Qn ljs` wldn o`ahb}lhon `f wen nubswnhon `fl srswnk `f sljlbns
lhg cnhnfbws loo`gngw` f`nbah ebng yns`hhnj qeboe srswnk
bs~hbvnsljjr no`ahb}ng( Qn lann welwonwlbh lknhbwbns elvn w` cn
y`vbgng w`wensn yn`yjn bh gn w` nhwbon wenk w`nhgn wenb snvbons bh
wen Yebjbyybhns lhgbh wen y`onss nklbh o`kynwbwbvn bh
wenbhwnhlwb`hlj kldnw(
F~wenk`n* qn w``d h`wn f wen flow welwf`nbah ebns elvn jbkbwng
o`hwlow `fnkyj`rknhw ~hjbdn wen j`olj ebns qe` nhm`rsno~bwr `f
wnh~n( W` lyyjr ylbwr wennf`n*bh qlans lhg `wen cnhnfbws q`~jg
ljs`n|~bn ylbwr bh `wen wnks lhg o`hgbwb`hs
`f nkyj`rknhw qeboe bhoj~gn wennkyj`rknhw o`hwlow(
L yn~slj f wen ylwbns!
7/31/2019 International School Alliance of Educators vs
Quisumbing
3/4
nho`~lan ` gbso`~lan knkcnseby bh lhr jlc``alhb}lwb`h(
H`wlcjr* wen Bhwnhlwb`hlj O`vnhlhw `h No`h`kbo* _`oblj*
lhgO~jw~lj Sbaews* s~yl* bh Lwbojn 1 wenn`f* y`vbgns=
Wen _wlwns Ylwbns w` wen ynsnhw O`vnhlhwno`ahb}n wen baew `f
nvnr`hn w` wennhm`rknhw `f m~sw lhg flv`~lcjn o`hgbwb`hs`f q`d*
qeboe nhs~n* bh ylwbo~jl=
l(((((Snk~hnlwb`h qeboe y`vbgns ljjq`dns* ls l kbhbk~k*
qbwe=
b(((((Flb qlans lhg n|~ljnk~hnlwb`h f` q`d `fn|~lj vlj~n
qbwe`~wgbswbhowb`h f lhr dbhg* bhylwbo~jl q`knh cnbhaa~llhwnng
o`hgbwb`hs `fq`d h`w bhfnb` w` we`snnhm`rng cr knh* qbwen|~lj ylr
f` n|~lj q`d4
u u u(
Wen f`na bha y vbsb`hs bkynahlcjr bhswbw~wb`hljb}n bh
websm~bsgbowb h wen j`ha e`h`ng jnalj w~bsk `f #n|~lj ylr f n|~lj
q`d(# Yns`hs qe` q`d qbwe s~cswlhwbljjr n|~lj|~ljbfbolwb`hs* sdbjj*
nff`w lhg nsy`hsbcbjbwr* ~hgn sbkbjlo`hgbwb`hs* se`~jg cn ylbg
sbkbjl sljlbns(T33[ Webs ~jn lyyjbnsw` wen _oe``j* bws
#bhwnhlwb`hlj oellown# h`wqbweswlhgbha(
Wen _oe` j o`hwnhgs welw ynwbwb`hn els h`w lgg~ong nvbgnhonwelw
j`olj+ebns ynf`k q`d n|~lj w` welw `f f`nbah+ebns(T3?[Wen O`~w
fbhgs webs la~knhw l jbwwjn olvljbn( Bf lhnkyj`rn loo`gs nkyj`rnns
wen slkn y`sbwb`h lhg lhd* wenyns~kywb`h bs welw wensn nkyj`rnns
ynf`k n|~lj q`d(Webs yns~kywb`h bs c hn cr j`abo lhg e~klh
nuynbnhon( Bfwen nkyj`rn ylrs hn nkyj`rnn jnss welh wen nsw* bw bs
h`wf` welw nkyj`rnn w` nuyjlbh qer en nonbvns jnss qer wen
`wens nonbvn k`n( Welw q`~jg cn lggbha bhs~jw w` bhm~r(Wen
nkyj`rn els gbsobkbhlwng lalbhsw welw nkyj`rnn4 bw bsf` wen nkyj`rn
w` nuyjlbh qer wen nkyj`rnn bs wnlwng~hflbjr(
Wen nkyj`rn bh webs olsn els flbjng w` gbsoelan webs c~gnh(Wenn
bs h nvbgnhon enn welw f`nbah+ebns ynf`k 3>.k`n nffbobnhwjr `
nffnowbvnjr welh wen j`olj+ebns( C`wea`~ys elvn sbkbjl f~howb`hs
lhg nsy`hsbcbjbwbns* qeboe wenrynf`k ~hgn sbkbjl q`dbha
o`hgbwb`hs(
Wen _oe` j olhh w bhv`dn wen hnng w` nhwbon f nbah+ebns w`jnlvn
wenb g`kbobjn w` lwb`hljb}n wen gbswbhowb`h bh sljlrlwns qbwe`~w
vb`jlwbha wen ybhobyjn `f n|~lj q`d f` n|~ljylr(
#_ljlr# bs gnfbhng bh Cjlod!s Jlq Gbowb`hlr %>we ng(" ls
#lnqlg ` no`kynhsn f` snvbons ynf`kng(# _bkbjljr*wen Yebjbyybhn
Jnalj Nhoroj`yngbl swlwns welw #sljlr# bs wen#To[`hsbgnlwb`h ylbg
lw na~jl bhwnvljs f` wen nhgnbha`f snvbons(# Bh _`hao` v( Hlwb`hlj
Jlc`s Snjlwb`hO`kkbssb`h*T37[ qn slbg welw=
#sljlr# knlhs l no`kynhsn `o`hsbgnlwb`h klgn w` l yns`h f` ebs
ylbhs` bhg~swr bh lh`wen klh!s c~sbhnss(Qenwen bw cn gnbvng f`k
#sljlb~k*# `k`n flhobf~jjr f`k #slj*# wen ylr f wenS`klh s`jgbn* bw
olbns qbwe bw wen
f~hglknhwlj bgnl `f o`kynhslwb`h f`snvbons nhgnng( %Nkyelsbs
s~yyjbng("
Qebjn qn no`ahb}n wen hnng `f wen _oe``j w` lwwlow f`nbah+ebns*
sljlbns se`~jg h`w cn ~sng ls lh nhwbonknhw w` wenynm~gbon `f
j`olj+ebns( Wen j`olj+ebns ynf`k wen slknsnvbons ls f`nbah+ebns lhg
wenr `~aew w` cn ylbg wen slknsljlbns ls wen jlwwn( F` wen slkn
nls`h* wen #gbsj`olwb`hflow`# lhg wen f`nbah+ebns! jbkbwng wnh~n
ljs` olhh`w snvnls vljbg clsns f` wen gbswbhowb`h bh sljlr lwns(
Wengbsj`olwb`h flow` lhg jbkbwng wnh~n lffnowbha f`nbah+ebnsln
lgn|~lwnjr o`kynhslwng cr onwlbh cnhnfbws loo`gngwenk qeboe ln h`w
nhm`rng cr j`olj+ebns* s~oe ls e`~sbha*wlhsy`wlwb`h* sebyybha
o`sws* wluns lhg e`kn jnlvn wlvnjljj`qlhons(
Wen O`hswbw~wb`h nhm`bhs wen _wlwn w` #y`wnow wen baews `fq`dns
lhg y`k`wn wenb qnjfln*#T3>[ #w` lff`g jlc` f~jjy`wnowb`h(#
T36[Wen _wlwn* wennf`n* els wen baew lhg g~wr w`na~jlwn wen
njlwb`hs cnwqnnh jlc` lhg olybwlj(T31[Wensnnjlwb`hs ln h`w knnjr
o`hwlow~lj c~w ln s` bkynssng qbwey~cjbo bhwnnsw welw jlc`
o`hwlows* o`jjnowbvn clalbhbhalannknhws bhoj~gng* k~sw rbnjg w` wen
o`kk`h a``g(T35[_e`~jg s~oe o`hwlows o`hwlbh swby~jlwb`hs welw
lno`hwlr w` y~cjbo y`jbor* o`~ws qbjj h`w ensbwlwn w` swbdng`qh
wensn swby~jlwb`hs(
Bh webs olsn* qn fbhg wen y`bhw+`f+ebn ojlssbfbolwb`h nkyj`rngcr
nsy`hgnhw _oe``j w` m~swbfr wen gbswbhowb`h bh wen sljlrlwns `f
f`nbah+ebns lhg j`olj ebns w` cn lh bhvljbgojlssbfbolwb`h( Wenn bs
h` nls`hlcjn gbswbhowb`h cnwqnnh wensnvbons nhgnng cr f`nbah+ebns
lhg j`olj+ebns( Wenylowbon `f wen _oe``j `f loo`gbha ebaen sljlbns
w` f`nbah+ebns o`hwlvnhns y~cjbo y`jbor lhg* onwlbhjr* g`ns
h`wgnsnvn wen srkylwer f webs O`~w(
Qn lann* e`qnvn* welw f`nbah+ebns g` h`w cnj`ha w` wenslkn
clalbhbha ~hbw ls wen j`olj+ebns(
L clsalbhbha ~hbwbs#l a`~y `f nkyj`rnns `f l abvnhnkyj`rn*
o`kybsng `f ljj ` jnss welh ljj `f wen nhwbn c`gr`f nkyj`rnns*
o`hsbswnhw qbwe n|~bwr w` wen nkyj`rn bhgbolwn
w` cn wen cnsw s~bwng w` snvn wen noby`olj baews lhg g~wbns`f
wen ylwbns ~hgn wen o`jjnowbvn clalbhbha y`vbsb`hs `f wenjlq(#T32[
Wen flow`s bh gnwnkbhbha wen lyy`yblwn o`jjnowbvnclalbhbha ~hbw ln
%
